September 21, 2020
-----
Tools from our sponsors to go bankless:
🌐 UNSTOPPABLE DOMAINS - GET A HUMAN READABLE CRYPTO DOMAIN
🌈 ZAPPER - ULTIMATE HUB FOR DEFI - ZAP INTO DEFI
💳 MONOLITH - GET THE HOLY GRAIL OF BANKLESS VISA CARDS
💸 AAVE - LEND AND BORROW DEFI ASSETS
----- AMA with Hugh Karp the Founder of Nexus Mutual
Hugh Karp returns to the Bankless Nation to answer some of the question the community has from listening to his recent podcast! ------ Resources: Bankless Podcast with Hugh:
http://podcast.banklesshq.com/31-nexus-mutual-to-billion-hugh-karp
Read: How to assess the risks of a lending protocol? https://bankless.substack.com/p/how-to-assess-the-risk-of-lending
Read: how to protect against hacks with Nexus https://bankless.substack.com/p/how-to-protect-against-hacks-with
Nexus Metrics Tracker: https://nexustracker.io/
DeFi Dad Explainer Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rnzInsKPLR0
Rate the Podcast 5 Stars
----- Subscribe to podcast on iTunes | Spotify | YouTube | RSS Feed
Leave a review on iTunes
Share the episode with someone you know!
----- Don't stop at the podcast!
Subscribe to the Bankless newsletter program
Watch Bankless shows and tutorials on YouTube
Visit official Bankless website for resources
Follow Bankless on Twitter
Follow Ryan on Twitter
Follow David on Twitter
----- Not financial or tax advice. This podcast is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. Do your own research.
No summary for this episode yet.
You You You You You You You You You You You You You You You You We had a fantastic podcast conversation with you that came out on Monday. This conversation is really for the bankless community. So to ask you questions, we do these AMAs twice a month. So the second Thursday and the fourth Thursday of the month, they are broadcast live on YouTube. So you can ask questions on YouTube. Of course, if you are a member of the bankless inner circle in Discord, we will prioritize the questions you ask there as well. But this is our opportunity really as a community to come to you and other protocol builders and interesting people in crypto and ask the questions that no one else asks of them.
So this isn't asking me anything. There are no rules, no questions you can't ask. We will do our best to filter and moderate and get the best ones into you in an order. And we do have about an hour time slot. So this will probably end about five minutes or so after the hour. We'll check in with you every so often with a time update. Okay, those are the ground rules. You ready for this? Go ahead. Let's go. All right, first question. I thought this was an interesting one to start with. So this came from a bankless community member wants to know how you feel about the current yield farming craze.
I mean, to me, it's it's temporary. But well, I like there's some good stuff underlying it. But it's obviously a bit too crazy in some sections for my for my liking. I mean, what's the good stuff and what's the bad stuff? Yeah, I mean, it's like it's hard to draw that line. That's the problem, I think. I think, I think fundamentally it's cool because there's some experimentation going on. And especially about bootstrapping communities and giving ownership to communities and stuff like that. And I think that's really cool. So there's fundamentally some good stuff there. But I also think it's obviously going to fire in some places.
And you know, there's obviously potential for the scams, the road pools and all of that type of stuff. Everyone has to keep an eye out on. So, you know, fundamental experimentation is really cool. I think it will lead to some value. But it's obviously getting a bit too exuberant and crazy in some places. I guess I'm more from a fundamental economic perspective. And so, you know, it kind of jars a bit in some places with me. But I do acknowledge that there's some there is some really cool experimentation going on underneath. So in my mind that this whole yield farming crisis kind of like it taps into that same energy of the ICO mania, right?
But it's like a new, new and improved upgraded ICO 2.0, which I know is like maybe that hits the wrong way because ICOs, the ICO industry or ICO phenomenon kind of has this bad rap. But as an upgrade to the primitive of the ICO, how do you feel about it? I was definitely a lot better. But I still, you know, is that any good? Because ICOs were pretty rubbish. So, you know, you're making something that was not so great, better. Okay, cool. But then look, I mean, I do think there's fundamentally some really good stuff with the Australian communities and giving ownership to communities. And I think if we can learn from it and take the best out of that thing, great.
Let's just not go too far and too crazy. And I think it's up to everyone that is kind of in this community for the longer term to help point out where it's hopefully going a bit too far or, you know, to help people avoid some of the less stuff of it. So, yeah, anyway, that's, that's my view. How to draw a line exactly. I think some of it has value some of it. So here the same community member asked a follow-up question about how you feel about shield mining. So I actually didn't recognize the term shield mining. I guess, you know, unless that's a misspelling of yield. Do you know what shield mining is?
And if you do, could you tell us about it? Yeah, so, well, I guess there's a few things going on. And maybe there's a few of some pieces happening. Nexus is actually releasing something quite soon next week, where basically other protocols can provide additional bonuses to Nexus Stakers that stake on their projects contracts. So basically, to bootstrap cover for a new project or something like that. So like the keep network with TPTC is going to probably be one of the first ones similar to that, which is really great. So that's kind of, you said keep with TBTC? Yeah, that's right. So we're really looking forward to that.
So basically, the idea is that Nexus Stakers that stake on the TBTC contracts will be able to earn some bonus keep rewards. And so we think that's really kind of fundamentally, it's actually doing something for the protocol, rather than just here, stake some tokens and earn some random other governance token that you dump on the market. And maybe it has some value at a future point in time, you know, which is kind of a lot of what the geophonic stuff is. Not all, but some of it. And so anyway, so that's our version of shield mining. I guess it may be confused with some of the, like, safe or cover stuff that's going on at the moment, which I'm not as close to exactly what's going on, but that's also a thing.
So yeah, it can be a bit confusing, but the shield mining stuff where launching, where it actually will be for to be answered. All right, so I just want to make sure I understand what shield mining is then. So basically, it's where Nexus would work with another protocol to provide some protocol rewards to incentivize insurance being taken out on those specific protocols. So with, with keep, what shield mining is doing is it's incenting additional coverage cover for the keep TBTC protocols, that right? Yeah, that's right. So like when there's a new protocol that launches, like we can add on Nexus, but to kind of bootstrap cover or some capacity to start with in a decent price, people have to stake against it.
And so this is kind of a good way of kind of constructing that initial staking, so that provides some additional incentives from the project team, which will open up some cover and allow people to buy some cover at reasonable prices. And then that helps the project because hopefully that gives them more users, because more users are happy to do it if they can buy cover remits. So we think it's a very symbiotic way of working together. It's a, to me, it's there's actually a fundamental, it's actually doing something to help the actual projects, rather than just use another token that could be worth it.
Yeah, for sure. So this seems like a mechanism to help projects like keep to really solve the problem of like the fact that no one kind of wants to be the first through the door, right? Like especially with tokenized Bitcoin, and especially with keep, which had some problems, like getting out the gate previously, right? And, like, and, you know, tip of the hat to the keep team, they're the reason why they've, they've, you know, started and stopped and started and stopped and had trouble like really getting that engine going is because of how conservative they are with their ethos, with their ethos and with their principles, right?
Like they're trying to retain as much Bitcoin maximalist culture as possible in the code of keep, right? And so that, and Bitcoiners are very conservative and probably don't really want to be ready to jump out the gate with getting their Bitcoin onto Ethereum with TPTC, but it seems like this new incentive mechanism, which is a cross protocol collaboration between, between Nexus and the keep project, really allows to have more security for people who are willing to like be ventures, right? Who are really to go and go westward first ahead of everyone else? And Nexus offer is offering this early insurance, this early cover to, to people that are doing that, right?
Which can really help TPTC get a lot of TPTC onto Ethereum quickly, which is really kind of what they need, right? Like, especially projects in their early days, they really need that, that early success to generate that flywheel effect, right? Am I getting everything right here? Yeah, exactly. I mean, a lot of new projects will need early liquidity, whether that's in early years, in terms of the TPTC, or maybe you need a liquidity pool in whatever a new DeFi prop or your building. And so to help attract that, it's often helpful to have some cover on Nexus, but you have to do it straight back cover to start with.
So it's kind of a good way of symbiotically working well with everything else. So hopefully we're, we're hoping for some decent success out of that. On the Nexus protocol, but also helping DeFi more widely, I guess, throughout one ask another question, this one's coming in from DAP Lion, and this is maybe more of fundamentals type question, but the question to you here is, is Nexus Mutual fully solvent? So if all the claims are claimed at the same time, can the system respond? I bet you'll have a good answer for that and kind of clarify how Nexus works and how insurance works in general. What's your take?
So the answer's no, and otherwise you're effectively running a fully classed relies bit at your market. And, and so basically that doesn't work for my perspective. Insurance companies work because they massively under-collect relies and they basically rely on the law of large numbers that not everything's going to claim that once. So the probability of lots of low probability events happening at the same time is very small. And so the idea being that I mean, the example I kind of always give is if you have an event which has a 1% probability of happy, if you fully collateralize that, the most the person on the other side of the bit can make is 1% and the most they can lose is 100.
And so it's very hard to make that. So you can only do that make it work economically if you under-clutch-wise spread the risk, get diversification, and essentially Nexus is operating on that on that basis. So right now we've we are under-clutch-wise and the database sound pad, but I actually think it's cool because it's actually how insurance is supposed to work. Okay, a question from Gabber is about the theoretical risk. Okay, so let me let me make sure I get this question right. So he's asking about the theoretical risk that someone or group purchases a sufficient amount of NXM, that's the Nexus token of course, to approve unreasonable claims for the benefit, for their benefit.
Is there anything Nexus is doing against that? Did you understand the question you put to you as insiders kind of purchase NXM in order to start approving unreasonable claims? Yeah, no, we've that's a definite anti-factor we've considered a lot. So right now that's one of the the way we're handling that is one of the more centralized aspects of the system and though we have ways to actually decentralize this. So right now they're to actually voting claims you have to lock or stake NXM to vote. And so what they say here is you can just buy a chunk of the NXM and then the group that you've wanted to attack the system.
So the way we're dealing with that is there's actually five members of the mutual called the advisory board members may have the power to slash the claims assessors' forms. And so they can get in there and slash the forms before kind of plain payouts or not plain payouts would be made. And so that's that's the the prevention. The reason but that just to be clear those advisory board members don't decide on claim payments but they decide on the punishments of they can decide on the punishments of their claims assessors and the idea here is to prevent malicious attacks. The real idea is that they don't actually ever have to do this but there's a threat.
And that threat is good enough to deter that attack from happening. We we're working a ways that we can actually decentralize that into a large group of people but we just have to work our way through that and it's kind of like we go back and tell us you what with that specific attack what does the attacker benefit from that like what's the incentive to do it. Yeah so essentially the idea here is that you you buy some I guess you buy some cover then you system it claims even though nothing's happened and then you buy enough tokens and exempt tokens to kind of approve the claims and perhaps approve trying to prove a lot of them and then and then you essentially use take money out of the businesses.
But isn't that going to isn't that going to affect the value of your NXM you say like if you have NXM you own a whole bunch of it and then you're mucking up the system in in a pretty severe way you'd you'd have to think that a lot of that NXM would get sold and you know decrease the the value of your holdings right. Yeah exactly right so you're essentially sacrificing those take the NXM tokens so you have to get to the point where you have to think that the cover that you've taken and that you could approve is going to be greater than the NXM tokens. So then maybe you also short you also short the NXM simultaneously or something to make that attack.
Yeah so I'm not thinking of doing that attack don't worry I just that was just wondering how it works. So we do yeah we do require like many multiples of claim value in the state to NXM tokens actually approve the claim so it is actually we've kind of got we did a lot of work on this one because it's clearly it's a good question that needs to be dealt with and it's how this system actually works. But yeah I don't think this is any different from like many many protocols have this same sort of like security assurance where like the because you own the tokens you're incentivized to not attack the system right and so like this is mainly a proof of state type system and a theorem in proof of state 2.
0 has kind of the same security assurances where like you know you could attack the system but the only way that you attack the system is you have a lot of capital locked up in the system that you're trying to attack right so this isn't this isn't unique to Nexus right. Yeah that's correct and I guess here one of the things that we have to be aware of is that derivative attack where you don't care because you're taking out the short position of it right and sorry like that's that's the thing we have to be careful of and we just the slashing mechanism and there are numerous other ways that we would have dealt with that.
I mean you know it has to be dial tested I'm not saying it's perfect we have to work through it over time and we're willing to adjust it if it needs to. So here's an attack vector that I've been thinking about so like what happens when you know inevitably some contract is going to have a bug because like if that didn't then like you guys wouldn't need to exist so like we're running on the assumption that there will be contracts that Nexus provides cover for that there will be bugs right. So like say someone sees this bug and then they see that Nexus covers it and then they buy a boat load of cover for that bug and then they go and exploit that bug right like have you guys thought about this yeah yeah we have I'm like this good to hear so like so right now it is actually possible we like effectively the cover that Nexus provides is like a credit default right now like you don't actually have to have interest in the underlying to buy the cover so it's kind of like a prediction like that of course obviously so that that attack is is possible we do have KYC so that does provide some soft little benefit.
Right but are they even doing anything bad? Well no like necessarily they're not necessarily doing anything bad. I guess from my point of view and this is one of the things we've discussed in the community right now is we're looking to introduce it like a proof of lost requirement into the claims so that would mean that you have to kind of hear show that you control an account or that has actually lost money as a result of this and then that takes away the the potential attack and I generally I think I always thought that we needed some type of structure like that to make a sustainable product in the long term but we definitely release something simpler just because you know going to get out there go to test the mic and see how it works and then you can adjust from there.
Well so you seem if you do that where like the user has to prove that they actually lost something in the exploit you're kind of taking away what I think is a pretty interesting feature where you don't actually need to have lost in order to express an opinion about a the security of a particular contract so it is what I'm hearing from you just like okay well we have these two products and like one is the the fact that you don't need to have lost and then the other one is like well we also need to make sure that we're safe from exploitation and tack and you're just choosing one over the other is that right?
Yeah so there's definitely a balance I mean if you don't have this proof of lost then it definitely should be priced higher in my mind so there's definitely a balance between like what do we try to achieve but which customer are you really aiming for? Yeah and so in my mind it's sent to make more sense to yourself for a lower price product and be able to make it more useful for people but you know that's definitely something that the community is still discussing so it could go either way. All right the bankless community just keeps firing away awesome questions this one is from Joseph IT about how is the risk of loss the assessment calculated?
So for something like death liability he says they use actuary tables and that sort of thing it's it's very well known it's a you know actuarial science how about the risk of loss on a smart contract how do you even figure that out? How are the stakers calculating that at the moment? That's a good question I'm not sure how they calculate where basic where that's the that's I guess that's one of the things we're doing quite differently where we're basically saying look what you might know where your mouth is this is prediction market-esque type of approach you can use whatever tools or analysis that you want to do to and analyze how secure or not something is and then you can stake against it and so I think I think that's been done like pretty roughly right out but if we are seeing like more that some the more secure contracts so the contracts that you may think be the most secure are actually attracting most like so okay so this is so fascinating right so the the the actuarial risk assessment is not really part of the nexus protocol itself right you provide the incentive layer to make that risk assessment actually happen but the risk assessment itself is completely decentralized and that's such a fascinating answer that question like you're like I don't know how it happens that's not up to nexus of a protocol that's up to the stakers which is super fascinating so first I want to just dive in on there does that ever happen in traditional insurance companies like all of traditional insurance companies from the limited knowledge that I have my my dad used to be a programmer at one of them like a state farm in the US and they have you know offices a full of actuarial scientists and you know data tracking like car insurance every type of insurance imaginable to like a very precise degree but it's all internal they don't outsource that to a decentralized community of like stakers yeah maybe can you comment on that yeah I think it's one of the fascinating things I used to be a lineman actually I used to do that stuff myself for life insurance and stuff so you know I don't feel well out kind of done but I think the yeah that's that is one of the fundamentals of all by doing what kind of saying look here's a protocol here's an incentive layer do whatever analysis you want to do we'll just take we'll just find the money about how to do state and that that has I mean it's to be proven how well that actually works that's for sure but it seems to be worth getting in the right direction right now the the benefit the big benefit that it has is you can actually enter new markets really really quickly right so insurance companies will often wait until our hotel we need really multiple years of data to do this thing you know I want I want a time series I want statistically significant information I want to like over a many years and then I then will enter but here we can go we don't know but we'll just put it out there and if there's no enough staking then there's no cover offered but but it allows the market to kind of get an early interindication and enter new markets really quickly so I think that's a massive benefit that we have over a very traditional insurance approach so does that mean there's a world where there's these independent actuaries who essentially like quit their job at you know state farm but they're really good at life insurance and they come and they start staking and they make money via nexus I mean yeah actually to see it happening more like what's called MGA's on managing general agents they kind of like there's a group that's an expert in a particular risk type and that's crypto or whether that's something else you know it doesn't really matter and they apply their expertise and they have their models and then they kind of they're own little business that they sell a particular product they distribute it with they also price it and they can use the nexus platform to provide the risk like the risk capital and so essentially what you end up with is a back end of nexus which is like this capital coordination like a risk on the righty coordination man and you have multiple businesses on top that distribute and price the road products and so it's kind of how it works so kind of like a loyades or something like that.
And then then back to that question so first of all that's fascinating and I wanted to dive deeper on that I don't even think we we fully dove into that in our initial podcast so that's just another just fast fascinating point about nexus but but going back to like how smart contract risk is actually is actually calculated do you have any other insight into that here right so like if I were to just use my you know model I feel better about something like make your gal right because it's been formally verified because it's protecting a larger amount of money because it's been out in the wild for a while then I do something like BZX which has had like you know a couple of hacks right so like how how are these things calculated is is it primarily lindy effect really like you know amount of value in and duration and then maybe there's some side things but the bulk of it is just it's just simply that yeah I mean we've we had a bit more of a complicated formula to kind of take account of those types of things in our pricing but we actually just shifted it all to just say the staking that's what we care about and because I mean there are a few technical tellagers with the formula but like it sometimes didn't quite work properly but the point being that now we have staking we don't care like effectively all of those factors are kind of condensed and analyzed just pulled into one number and and so if you actually have a look at our pricing right now you will see something like make it ours kind of at the minimum price but something like BZX is at a lot higher than that and so you know it intuitively it's it's kind of working how you want to get of it should work right now so speaking of BZX we have a a listener asking about the recent most recent BZX attack was did claims go through for that were there any claims outstanding on that is that a governance decision that's pending any update um no sorry um I personally think we would have paid a claim but there was no one win any cover um over that period so yeah there was actually two covers taken out three hours also after the attack happened um sorry but they wouldn't have you know different cover periods so they did went there during the attack so um so basically no claims but I would just because no one had come people buying cover after it was active did they just not understand the system they were trying to like sneak a sneak some cover in yeah maybe I don't know but that's yeah that's yeah no one had cover for the period of the attack so we haven't made claims so what tell us more about like the timing on that like what if somebody had bought cover like five minutes before the attack well I mean your theory that should be paid I mean it's always it's always going to come down to people deciding um what the if it's illegitimate claim or not but I guess one of the beauties of the blockchain world is you can just look at the chain and go when did when did this happen um but the cover was bought here the attack happened here um I mean I cover the regular insurance wealth and there's there's there's many cases where of this person um really sadly committed suicide five minutes of before or after the policy expired like and like you know so what do you do like any time to work out like did it actually happen then or did it happen before or after and there's like it goes to real legal cases and stuff like that so you know this stuff um now we have actual data to really determine exactly what happened but that's really powerful so with nexus is it maybe there isn't any formalized rules because it's up to the nxm holders to determine this but like is it and maybe in your opinion is it like okay you've purchased insurance on this block therefore the next block that insurance is therefore activated is that kind of how you think it works yeah I mean look if the covers purchased before the attacker event started happening before the bug disclosure was made um then um then it should be it should be legit that's that's kind of nice because I recently had to buy a health care and uh I bought it at like noon and it didn't activate until like 12 p.
m. that night 12 hours later so I had like 12 hours where I was like well I'm gonna be real drive real slow on my way home anyways no baby we'll be a little bit of a tangent yeah well I'm kept safe yeah it is not fun to be with a hospital bill um when you don't have health insurance in the US that is for sure um okay so a question coming in you from above average Joe so he's asking when will the current expansion phase start to wrap up when do you expect the nxm price appreciation to start growing faster than the network size I'm not gonna come in on price I've no idea um I don't really know but they're going back to the underlying question I guess we we do have this um like floor value on our what's got our MCR minimum level requirement which is kind of like an arbitrary somewhat arbitrary like expansion phase that we're kind of driving to get more color and stuff up and quite recently we shifted a bit earlier than we were thinking it would happen um into kind of like the full long-term growth phase where the actual cover amounts that we're driving that we're writing drive the MCR value and so um I definitely think that probably happens I know six months earlier than I was expecting that to happen um so um we've had quite a lot of growth recently and I think that's definitely a point that we're talking about in the community and working out how we transition into that longer term um so we're kind of we're kind of moving out of the artificial pitch trapping phase then into the more longer term phase and you know it's definitely a spectrum of ways to go there and there's like like clear answer about this is definitely true um it's definitely a judgment call and so I think um we're definitely in the process of working out what what the best approach there is but for now um we we have both the artificial scaling and the cover driven calculation going at the same time we just pick whichever one's the biggest one so they kind of both going right now you know unless the enlistic community decides we should change that very good okay um we are at the halfway point here so you you've hung with us so far doing a great job um we've got more questions for you and this one might be related this is from Matt 7 so when will the current uh no I just asked that one um I've heard the gearing factor has replaced the 1% daily increase in the MCR calculation for some people you might have to explain what that means uh gearing factor um what is the trigger for the change yeah so so basically the gearing factor is kind of what I was just saying before it really is cover amounts divided by gearing factor the gearing factor is 4.
8 so basically our minimum capital of requirement is the maximum of either this floor value which is increasing at 1% per day or a cover amount divided by 4.8 and so we just picked the biggest number and so right now both of those numbers are really close and the gearing factor was ahead I think yesterday the floor value was ahead and so they're really quite close right now um and so um what we want to be in the long term is having the gearing factor driving everything um but it's actually useful to have this floor value in there in the short term so we can keep selling cover on um protocols that are there with us a lot of demand like iron or a compound or um balancer etc etc so um so if there's kind of the I don't know I guess that's what I was alluding to before is we kind of have to work out how to we we should be switching the MCR floor increment off at some point but do we do that now or do we do it in three months time um like when do we do um and so that's definitely the discussion to have okay here is a question coming in from our discord room from emozilla and this is I think a question that um is being asked in the context of other staking protocols particularly in eft 2.
0 it's sort of similar um the question is how is the mutual planning to further incentivize staking on contracts the comment is it seems in the current yield farming craze it's hard to track capital with such a long walkup time 60 days if I recall correctly um this is also a question I think people have asked about eft 2 staking basically with all of the attractive other ways to leverage eith outside of the core ethereum protocol are we going to have enough eith to actually launch eith 2 is kind of the question so um I guess what's your answer for for nexus and nxm how are you planning to incent staking yeah so I think um short a term of the um the shield mining thing I think is uh is a big change um and I think they will help a lot um we do hear the feedback on this stuff um we're taking it on board just for sure um we are actually looking at potentially changing some of the design um and hopefully with the goal of hopefully we're removing the long lockup um so it is currently 90 days which is we recognize as an age in d5 um yeah I think uh yield farming is barely like 90 days old yeah yeah exactly so you know um I mean the challenges you need staking for someone that buys a cover for a year so you need to kind of um but if you have the cup the staking disappear and the cup sits there for a long period of time then you kind of got this mismatch but so we have to work out a way of allowing more fluidity into the staking process um but also dealing with what the mutual needs for an economic perspective in terms of backing the risk um and so working out those two things is going to be the challenge and I think we definitely can get there and I think we can um we can remove that 90 day lockup live more flexibility um with with things like tokeners staking positions and other stuff so but we're definitely um we're looking at it um and we're considering options so you know we're definitely taking the pragmatic iterate learn change it if we need to and and release again that's that's the approach we're taking this is another in the weeds question here coming from someone um but I think it is pretty thoughtful um I don't I don't know if this is kind of the the fall on your own sword option here but the question goes like this uh since NXM insurance is discretionary in paying claims hypothetical would NXM holders ever vote for their own insolvency so if there was ever a large magnitude claim or multiple claims on different protocols would they ever vote to burn their own NXM stake to maintain the credibility of the system interesting thought exercise there yeah I mean it is it is interesting I um so discretionary mutuals in the real world have done this um and so they they I know of facts where that you know they've got um they come in and all the time they've just got massive times and so what what do they do and they sit and and the key here is you have a strong community that is aligned with each other and you can work out you have to work out the best solution it's not a good situation to be in but you have to work out the best solution to the community and and so often often that may be a tradeoff of things like maybe you don't pay the absolute full claim value or maybe you look at other other options or what you need to do in in the future but but basically it's about the community coming together and working out the best way forward so look I mean there's definitely the selfish option of just going low we're not going to pay the claims we're just going to dissolve the whole thing and just split the money between the distinct holders that would be a terrible outcome in my opinion but it could it could be done um I actually think that if that were to happen um Nexus would have by paying the claims in that situation Nexus would have built a massive amount of trust the long term like insurance companies essentially there when ever when the sheet hits the fan right that's that's when you want them to be there you want the reveal and that you you you build that trust and it will pay the whole mutual back like tenfold in the coming period so that's I would hope that that's um what the members would come to to agree one obviously I'm just one member um but that that's I think we have to design the incentive mechanisms so that that is the favourable option um and that's what we're behaving for there's a there's a reference to Molok here where and maybe a lot of the listeners aren't familiar with the the meditations on Molok piece but like if you keep on listening to bankless you will be uh Molok is the god of human coordination failure right and so like if Nexus Mutual decided to like defect and say like you know what effort we're not paying the uh we're not paying the the claims we're just taking our treasury and we're running because we can't do this right and then you know maybe that's a rational thing to do at least in the short term game but he what you're saying is like well you could take that short term hit but like the signal to the community would pay dividend down the line right so long if the commute if the Nexus if the NXM holding community can think long term and not defect from each other well then the the value over the long term is what you think is is that will be just orders a magnitude larger than like the short term game of just saying like effort we'll let's take the treasury and run exactly and like if you actually get into the details of Nexus every single mechanism is designed to push alignment of interest at the long term because that's the only way this whole thing works um and so just because basically it never makes any sense to pay any claim if you just focus on the short term you have to you have to align interest long term and like it's all going to be about trading off short term paying for long term benefit and that's really what this is actually about so yeah if you have a look at if you get into the details of the mechanisms all pushing alignment of interest long term and it's you know it's up still up for the pay if we've got that right but that's definitely what we're trying to do.
So we've got a question from E1 from from the YouTube are there plans to implement easy insurance contracts in popular defi projects like uniswap or zapper um and set wants as thinking of a simple button or warning when adding liquidity for example and so what I think he means is like you're on the obvious site or you're on like the zapper site or on the uniswap site and like you have the option to like deposit assets and then there's another option saying like deposit insured assets right and like that I think what he's saying is buy you buy covers insurance from Nexus when you are also doing that action right and so rather than and it's a little bit cumbersome when you like go to avay and then you deposit your assets and then you go to Nexus to buy cover so like maybe you guys are you guys working on like a business development team or some sort of like way to like just have the Nexus insure with Nexus button like everywhere and across defi.
Yeah exactly that's what we're doing basically we want no one to buy cover on our application that's our goal that everyone basically everyone's buying cover on our app right now but that's not where we want to be long-term so we haven't we haven't prioritized that right now because we're in this situation where we've got massive demand and look quite enough supply so it's not like the top requirement but that's definitely where we're where we're moving on which area basically you know flight insurance click the button at the bottom add it on that's that's the type of thing where very people is that easier to do in in like on Ethereum and DeFi because everything is you know composable money lego's as we've called them yeah exactly it's you know it's really simple compared to um compared to like the traditional world so yeah yeah I mean obviously you need to get the people running the partner sites to add it on but um better step so it's a lot easier there's a very strong protocol sync thesis comment in there somewhere right like just make Nexus invisible but still ensuring all of DeFi right yeah that's exactly it we don't we don't we're we're insurance or Nexus Nexus isn't insurance um let's say there are a few times um but um yeah but basically it's always a security purchase you want to do something else and then like you know have a car you get it you know it's always you always doing it for something else so we want to be there um all of a sudden but we're not the lead sale we're definitely simply repurchase that kind of solves your problem of you know selling cover to people that aren't actually like uh have loss available to them right and so like if you are only able to purchase cover when you are doing something on avay or doing something on maker then like you kind of get it's a little bit easier to ensure that you know everyone who's purchasing cover it always has also has loss a loss event yeah exactly I mean if you want to take that one step further I mean that's just a simple it's like an integration like just a point of purchase right but what we really want to get to is like bundle products um so like he's an interest bearing token that's natively colored um and so you just you just buy that token instead and then you've got it bundled up um so that's the type obviously there's a bit to do to get to that point but um but the whole thing is that you that's what composability really gives you um that's that's the real benefit of the theory nice so with all these interest bearing tokens out there there's the possibility of like the the nexus version of that which bears a little bit less interest but you know is natively insured so like when you buy this token on uniswap like you don't have to worry about like is the do I you know do I now need to go to nexus and get insurance because like you're buying it pre bundled just making it super easy for the consumer that's fantastic yeah that's what that's what you want to get to yeah I think everything that you guys are talking about about nexus being sort of in a long-term um game essentially with multiple iterations right David you're talking about like um slaying mollock it just occurs to me like so much of what we depend on for human civilization are these institutions that we trust the court system is an institution the government is an institution um what what we can start to do with ethereum and some of these these money legoes as we've called them is uh create new institutions that are less centralized and less dependent on a company and a set of like say shareholders in a big corporate office to to kind of set the institutional boundaries so the idea of nexus becoming an institution for um I guess uh safety and risk mitigation across defi protocols is super appealing um I want to ask a question that comes from that's coming from elucus and this is about I think riff and riff off the idea of everything that we're talking about all the advantages of of composability you are I think pretty clear to people who are watching this but there are some disadvantages too right so for example um leucus is asking the question ensuring one we will I use the word insurance it's his words right so I we know what you're really doing non-churance but um ensuring one single contract is simple you've already proven that out but what if something happens that affects many different protocols simultaneously because again they're all woven together so something like affecting avey compound you're in all the same time maybe because they all have one single point of failure maybe there's a chain link oracle problem chain link great in everything it's doing and you price fee to cost across all these protocols but almost the oversaturation of chain link creates a single point of failure for defi this this kind of scary so what do you do if there's kind of a single point of failure cascading event like this how does nexus react yeah I mean this obviously two sides to this nexus has to manage its own risk itself like we're interests that take some and make sure it doesn't accumulate too much in one spot there's diversification there's what will make it work the best but obviously it wants to cover as much risk as possible to provide safety to the wider defi space so I think with Oracle Failure and stuff I think you can we can we can segment it and stuff like that obviously we did limits the probably the biggest risk that nexus probably also exposed to itself is like a silly unique compiler bug that no one knows about yet that basically hits multiple contracts at once and then maybe nexus goes down as well and so you know that's kind of a defi extension level event I think yeah I don't know yeah it's kind of like words yeah but I mean fear it's theoretically possible right and I guess from it from my perspective I think nexus is taking on this anyway because it's actually building on a theory so unfortunately we have to kind of just assume that that doesn't happen um the the the best mitigate and I'm going to be completely open and honest to you the best mitigate for that type of thing is actually having it to entirely different protocol if it's traditional insurance totally outside the system because I don't you can't cover something within the system that's like at the base level um so that's that's the challenge that um like we are exposed to that risk so you're exposed to all of the systemic kind of risk that's inherent in a theorem inherent across defi right you can't get away from that without escaping to a different system right but I want to ask you about that extinction level event right so because I think this is somewhat of an interesting topic maybe David was about to do that I see now I'm just shivering from the words extinction level all right so um you know it's interesting because for a system like Bitcoin or even Ethereum the backstop to an extinction level bug is actually the social layer underneath it right so like for Bitcoin Bitcoiners will constantly argue will always argue that hey even if there was some sort of zero-day bug uncovered in Bitcoin that allowed somebody to inflate another 10 million Bitcoin above the 21 million for instance the community would have adhered to the social contract and forked that out and you know they wouldn't gain enough support to actually be a critical threat to Bitcoin an extinction level event to Ethereum I would think would still be backstopped by the social layer where it's all of the essentially the money protocols all of the users all of the validators all of the miners all of the core devs everyone with a vested interest would essentially say oh oops that was not the intent of the social contract of Ethereum yeah there might be a contingent who wants to pump this this you know pre-for but it would essentially be a Dow type scenario where you can recover from such an event I just wanted you to put your your risk hat on for a minute and maybe talk about that because extinction level event is kind of a scary thing to say but could the social layer be a backstop yeah I think that we've thought about this a fair bit I mean the way we're designing Nexus is we want I mean it's not going to work in absolutely all the circumstances but the idea is that if something is big enough that it gets multiple protocols at once that takes down Nexus that's at least in the hard fork discussion territory like so basically if something's big enough to take down Nexus as a whole we hopefully we're designing the system so that there is a decent chance that the social contracts kicks in and and makes everything whole again do you mean do you mean for Nexus or do you mean for Ethereum like I mean so I guess what I'm saying is anything that's big enough to take down Nexus in one go we should we should be managing Nexus for a risk perspective so that if there's anything that's big enough an event that's big enough to take down Nexus from a like multiple claims happening at once then that should be an event which Ethereum as a whole should consider hard for you can I raise the controversial phrase too big to fail because that's what kind of comes to mind and maybe not in a bad way right some things like some failures would cascade it across the system that the failure of a core system maybe like Nexus gets to that level I've often wondered if if Maker or Die is at that level right now where contracts core contracts become too big to fail is that you do you think there's a possibility there yeah I mean I don't I think it's going to be interesting like if one of the really big ones that make it or something goes down if it was just one I I don't think that's going to be a hard for my personal point of view but you know obviously there's a bunch of other different opinions out there but I think if multiple to go down once then it's likely that it's due to some lower level bug and therefore to me that there's a there should be an active discussion about oh hold on this seems this doesn't seem right made we should be hard for this so you know obviously there's no guarantees on any of that stuff at all but the idea of an access is to to manage the risk so that if the the occasion where we failed due to that it's at least a discussion of a hard for me it might happen yeah we're starting to get into pretty existential in conversation territory and it's a good conversation to have and hopefully hopefully it remains existential so we have a question at front from Gonzalo on on YouTube are there any plans to ensure investors in crypto funds like managers running a fund could steal like I'm scond with the funds so investors in that fund would benefit from having insurance covering that event any thoughts on this yes I mean we've built the protocol to be I cover any type of risk so as long as we can design a product that one you can like reasonably determine when a claim should be paid it's not capable but based on what else you know they could just clearly go oh we have full control over this so we'll just make claim so as long as you have the a couple of things like that then yeah we can design it's inside a product that works and so we've had quite a few people are coming to us on on different products related to that it's a little bit different but but those types of things would definitely consider who does that work here to expand into a new market is that somehow governance or is that you know kind of nexus as an entity itself it's kind of a means of its entity yeah so I mean essentially it's governance the idea being that we someone has to come up with a terms and conditions like this is where the claim will be paid and and then it's up to the stakers to stake on it it's basically how it works and so it's really relatively as simple like that so it should like ideally we're not quite there yet but ideally we get to a point where adding a new product should be as easy as adding a new pool one new new swap you go here's a new product now just add it those straps and cover you know add some liquidity kind of that's the comparison and so that's the idea where we want to get to but there is obviously a bit more work in coming up with a terms conditions document that actually just providing a new pool of these but that conceptually that's what we're aiming for so this is another I think great question from Joseph IT he says first great answers thanks you for that one of the core components of nexus right now is this dispute resolution mechanism right which claim should be covered which claim should we not have you ever looked at alternative dispute resolution mechanisms like arrogant experts or cellarose these kind of Dow type court systems is there any appeal to to those or they too early your general thoughts there yeah I mean we have to we have to be able to have a scalable solution for the claims on an ongoing basis so you don't want to push in all claims to an arrow called or clearer or something like that but they could be potential options for like having a like a higher level dispute resolution in the process there somewhere we haven't done that now various reasons one of the important things is that the members have discretion over which claims are paid rather than then outsourcing it outside the mutual that is what what are important doesn't mean we can't do it but it is it is important conceptually so yeah but there are other assumptions the core the core claims should happen within the mutual but we could do higher level dispute outside so a question came in about memes and this is crypto so we can't get away from memes so synthetics has their Spartans link has their Marines apparently nexus has mutants is can you confirm or deny that no we do we've had a for a little while so that's kind of growing yeah it's it's organic it's pretty fun actually so it's I love it how do that come about community members just in there okay so what is I think is I think it's like I think it's coming from today's we need to tell right yeah yeah so we're not talking like X-Men we're not talking X-Men it's mainly it's mainly um well I think it's it's opening up obviously these things change and morph all the time right um so you know up but I think that's where it's coming from the total things so great um so what have you seen is are there some good memes we should look up after after this AMA here should I mean we want the nexus mutants into Twitter anything fun that you've seen oh yeah there's a few of me fighting around which oh boy it's been kind kind of kind of a kind of amusing but I mean like you know it's a thing I guess but I think the one thing that it's cool is that it it kind of um it's long-term focus and they kind of in there with it fits very well with the nature of what we're trying to do and so you know it's a bit of fun obviously but it is critical okay so I think we've got about three or four more minutes until the conclusion of this AMA when I ask you while we're talking about the community um are you like did you think the community would grow in the way that it did are you are you are you are you proud of it is there anything you would you would change and how do you think it's going to grow into the future yeah it's a it's a good question um like it's definitely your own philosophy we thought it was going to grow um and you know kind of all happened all of a sudden especially I've lost a few months with with things going um I'm surprised by the memes I'm surprised by just how people just get stuck in and have so much passion for the things like you know we've clearly got a bunch of and really solid community members like you know getting into the discord answer questions completely experts but it's like it's I don't know it's it's really amazing to see that you know I've firstly spent so much time building this thing and designing something um building in the dark for a while and then and then putting it out in the community and letting them take control that I yeah I find it amazing to use so yeah really happy with it um I think our challenge is always going to be we're a relatively complex system and because of this long-term nature and trade-offs and stuff like that we have to attract the right type of people and so being able to design incentive mechanisms and also foster our community in the right place um is going to be an interesting challenge um especially as we grow um but yeah that's that's it's definitely um cool and important to it very cool all right we've got time for I think one last question here and so this is maybe harkening back to uh the podcast that we just had you on where you talked about surviving the bear market and that's really where where I think both David and I learned that um you guys were kind of on the break you know of of saying like this thing's not going to work back in 2018-2019 we have just had a 40% drawdown in uh DeFi tokens after an exceptional uh summer of growth right you've you've been a bear market builder are we headed back to the bear market are you are you feeling the bear market again or is this just you know we dust our shoulders off and this is this is just a mere scratch I have no idea don't ask me about that stuff I really don't know I I hope that um honestly the best case for us is just um stability and just steady growth but obviously that's not how good don't markets work we just have to have to go with the extremes in both directions so um managing that's um the biggest challenge from uh from you know a protocol team sported and you know we I guess we've done before so we're confident we can do it again awesome all right uh I said that was the last question but this is the real last question so Hugh uh where are you from in the world um yeah i'm Australian um but i've been in London for about eight nine years now so in when you go home to Australia did they talk about you having sort of an English accent and when you're obviously in London i'm sure they they hear in Australia in one yep love somewhere in the middle now yeah depending on you i talk to that is awesome well Hugh it has been a pleasure thank you so much for being on the hot seat with the bankless nation for this ask me anything David how is youtube looking uh did we get all the questions answered i mean we got all the questions answered and there there's a fun comment from Alex uh i'm gonna read uh Alex says uh keep it up i love how people are imagining things and Hugh and the team just don't have enough time to execute it's still still early and that's exciting i've never been interested in insurance until now so cheers Alex Hugh you got someone interested in insurance yeah got it you got to stand somewhere that's awesome well we really appreciate the work you are doing to um get defy a little bit safer than it was the day before uh so thanks for spending the time with bankless today don't pretend to be able to get us good to all right take care here thanks a lot