In today’s episode, we have the creator of Solana and the Co-founder of Solana Labs, Anatoly Yakovenko. We brought on Anatoly to reflect on Solana in 2023 and its future in the New Year and beyond.
-----
🏹 Airdrop Hunter is HERE, join your first HUNT today https://bankless.cc/JoinYourFirstHUNT ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.com/MetaMask
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.com/Arbitrum
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.com/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🌐 Layer Zero V2 Launch https://bankless.cc/LayerZeroLabs
-------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 5:49 FTX’s Effect on Solana 8:03 Solana Lindy? 9:55 Local Fee Markets 17:51 Solana’s Governance 24:58 Important Solana Questions 28:44 Firedancer vs. Jump 37:36 Latency Games 40:20 Are More Users Scary? 43:50 Hyper-Optimism 48:52 What Scares Anatoly 54:59 $BONK & Solana Phone 1:07:58 Breakout Consumer Apps 1:12:37 Solana Economics 1:18:30 ETH vs. SOL 1:34:50 Solana Alignment 1:36:49 Solana Misrepresentation 1:37:53 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Anatoly https://twitter.com/aeyakovenko
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Bankless Nation, welcome to a conversation with Anatoly Yakovenko. Recently, Solana seems to have turned a page in its evolution, with the Jito airdrop putting $200 million in the hands of over 10,000 different addresses. It seems to have really reawakened a part of Solana, as new addresses and new TVL have come online, and new conversations are being had in Solana, mainly conversations around Solana governance and Solana economics. And so this has captured the attention of many across the crypto industry and including my own. And so I decided just to throw Anatoly a Riverside link where we record podcasts here at Bankless and ask them to come on and just chat about things.
This was a pretty unscripted conversation. Usually we have pretty thorough, robust agendas for 95% of all Bankless podcasts, but this is not one of them. And this is just David and Anatoly vibing on a podcast together, talking about Solana, talking about Ethereum, talking about tribal stuff, but not with a tribal tone. So I hope you enjoy that. Before getting to the conversation with Anatoly Yakovenko, first a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. Whether you're in the Ethereum tribe, you're in the Solana tribe, or you're in the Bitcoin tribe, use Kraken to get to whatever preferred destination chain of your choosing.
Kraken is our preferred exchange for crypto in 2023. And if you do not have an account with Kraken, consider clicking the links in the show notes to getting started with Kraken today. Kraken knows crypto. Kraken's been in the crypto game for over a decade. And as one of the largest and most trusted exchanges in the industry, Kraken is on the journey with all of us to see what crypto can be. Human history is a story of progress. It's part of us, hardwired. We're designed to seek change everywhere, to improve, to strive. And if anything can be improved, why not finance? Crypto is a financial system designed with the modern world in mind.
Instant, permissionless, and 24-7. It's not perfect, and nothing ever will be perfect. But crypto is a world-changing technology at a time when the world needs it the most. That's the Kraken mission, to accelerate the global adoption of cryptocurrency so that you and the rest of the world can achieve financial freedom and inclusion. Head on over to kraken.com slash bankless to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice. Crypto trading involves risk of loss. Cryptocurrency services are provided to U.S. and U.S. territory customers by Payward Ventures, Inc., PBI, doing business as Kraken. Introducing USDV, a better type of stablecoin.
Currently, billions of dollars in stablecoin yield each year are paid to Tether, Circle, and other central issuers of major stablecoins. But what if yield could be shared with the protocols that use it? Those protocols, in turn, can decide how to reward their users. USDV shares its yield with a community of apps and developers that mint it. Every USDV is backed one-to-one by U.S. Treasury bills which pay yield. This yield flows out to the community of USDV issuers, so your protocol or app can get paid for helping end users convert other stables into USDV. This works thanks to a breakthrough technology called Color Trace from Layer Zero.
Without it, it was impossible to attribute users of a token with a specific issuer, but now we can. USDV is live on Ethereum, Optimism, Arbitrum, and other chains, and is already available on over 20 exchanges such as Curve, BitGet, Velodrome, and Stargate. Start participating in the yield from treasury-backed stablecoins at bankless.com slash USDV. Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax for providing token awards for your team? Toku simplifies everything about managing token grant compensation, and you can get started with them for free. You'll have access to top-notch legal and tax support to handle the distribution and management of tokens for your team.
Toku caters to every step in the process, from user-friendly legal templates for granting tokens to tracking vesting periods and calculating withholding taxes toku understands every grant structure token purchase agreements restricted token awards restricted token units token options and all the other ones toku is already simplifying this today for leading companies like protocol labs dydx foundation mina foundation and many more you can learn more about how toku can help you streamline your token management and get started for free visit toku at toku.com slash bankless or click the link in the description below what's up up Antoli how's it going it's it's good man good to be here so Solana seems to be going well yeah knock on wood um it's as surprising to me as to anyone else like looking back over the year well like looking back over the year I was like oh man okay this is what this is what it's gonna to look like to fail.
I was like psychologically preparing myself like at the start of this year, like that things were not going to work out. But why is that? I mean, the FTX crash, kind of the sentiment was really, really negatively turned and there was a lot of risk. I kind of forgot that that was how this year started. Yeah. yeah like and and you know uh it was it was like kind of like one no one like left like um in terms of like internally all the core engineers were like okay whatever i'm coding the problems are still like my i still have to finish this my job so that was good and for the vast majority of the companies in the ecosystem you know they got that like fight or flight response and most of them chose fight and like just build better products um but that takes like a while to go from shock to like okay people are actually building stuff um yeah it was like yeah knock on wood man i'm i don't know i don't know i don't know how this happened okay we are like um 13 months past the actual you know ftx incident call us like 12 months past you know being able to actually process what that meant for the crypto industry and especially for solana because solana had to especially process what that would mean for solana and like we could we could go through the gamut of the last 12 months and be like okay well then there was this phase and then there was that phase and then there was this phase but maybe we could just like compress it all into just like what is now the net effect of all of that upon the solana ecosystem because like you said you had some people who just like doubled down some people did leave some people doubled down so like if rather than just like going through the whole like speed running of the 2023 history of solana just like what's the net effect of it the the doubling down like it causes like the people with less conviction to leave and people with more conviction to double down.
And that is the best thing that could happen to an ecosystem. If you can survive it, what had happened, like the result was that you had a really core, super connected, strong group of people that had really deep convictions that just built the whole year. They just saw it as an opportunity. Now I have more space, right? Like there's fewer noise, fewer competitors in my product category. Like it actually is like, turned out to be like a huge win. And like, I don't think Armani would have like did Mad Lads and built the exchange. I don't think the Tensor guys would have been like, oh, we can beat Magic Keaton, even though they have 90% of market share.
Right. Like some people just like go hardcore when they see like, oh, this biggest competitors now like spread across five different ecosystems. There's no way they can keep focused. That's like a once in a lifetime opportunity for some folks that have that kind of energy. And seeing them rewarded for the work that they put in, I think, is like the best thing that can happen in the ecosystem, because it's really, really rewarding the people that put in the work. Like that's that's like the beauty of Bitcoin and proof of work. Right. Is that somehow through game theory, it anonymously does that.
It's magic. And that like doesn't always work out. You know, what would you say was the reason why maybe this answer isn't so like the same for everyone, but why did people stay? What made people stick around Solana versus I mean, there's like other high throughput chains that they could have gone to. Like, so what about Solana kept in there? I think the tech is pretty weird. Like it's very different from everyone else. And it has like some unique properties that obviously is riskier. Right. Like you do a bunch of weird optimizations that people think look at you crazy when you do them. It takes years for them to like mature and like prove themselves out.
And like the folks that are deep in the tech, they kind of get why we made those choices and they appreciated them. And like literally like the mango guy said, OK, we'd have to like create our own chain like DYDX. That was, that's their alternative. Or we use Solana and like, they felt that the being part of an ecosystem is better than being kind of running your own L1. So a lot of people like made the choice, I think for that reason, for the tech reason. And I think when you have like a good group of those, like you kind of have a lot of people around them that want to build simply because I don't know if it's validation or like, you I want to build where a bunch of other smart people build.
I think largely one of the best things about Ethereum is you talk to Dankrad and you're like, wow, actually this guy is super smart. How do I work with him? It's like the best selling point of Ethereum. But we're starting seeing that happen in Solana and it's not the researchers that I think are the cornerstone of Ethereum. It's more like the low-level devs that can grind really cool implementations and stuff. So I think there's something to be said about that. One of my favorite questions to ask Bitcoiners is, and one of the reasons why is because the answer is always the same, mostly the same, depending on which Bitcoin you ask, they always kind of more or less say the same answer.
But if you ask the Bitcoiners the question, like, what's the most important element of Bitcoin that really like powers the whole system? And like the answer is so incredibly uniform. They're like, well, Bitcoin is really a semblance of many different components and technologies. And it's really about how they all come together to produce Bitcoin. But really, the answer is the difficulty adjustment. Like they love the difficulty adjustment. And it's like this keystone thing that puts Bitcoin together in a way that the other components are more ancillary. So if I ask you the question, like what what is that for Solana?
Is that a fair question or is it just apples to oranges? That's a hard question. different yeah it's a really good question but it's a really hard one because i don't know i don't i don't i don't know if we have like a lynchpin like super clever thing i think maybe the parallelism like that we were able to figure out through like failure and experimentation that like we were able to like get it working all the way up to the economics i think that was a really cool innovation but okay let's listen back then then why is that so important and why was it so hard well like it's really not obvious and um we basically see all these systems now that are getting inscription like the fees blow up because like the inscription locus yeah and like what happened with solana was effectively similar attack not attack but people using the the chain is that instead of seeing inscription locus, we saw like the, everything gets saturated to the point of like, you cannot land a transaction.
It was effectively liveness failures, right? Like for users, like DeFi wouldn't operate when there's an NFT min at the same time, right? Like, so, and that was really obvious in retrospect because it's kind of like, if you worked at a big web company and you have a database, you get these hotspots when everyone wants to order some weird thing all at the same time, but then all your other payments can't go through because there's this massive queue for some random viral thing. Happens in every database system with any traction. But it took me seeing it on chain to kind of unpack it and recognize it that this is a problem that has a similar computer science issue in the real world and tying it to the economics to deal with the economics around making sure that you can isolate only that lock.
And literally, we got lucky with SVM having this idea of access lists that are required with every transaction. We did that for performance reasons because that's the fastest way to build the runtime. but having that information is what allows us to do it now in every part of the stack and the economics of it itself so kind of like it was not planned right like i was like what's the fastest possible virtual machine i copied the designs that i knew worked in dsbs and gpus is that the developer does this very painful process of telling the system this is exactly what memory i'm going to touch. So it wasn't like magic.
I mean, I had the benefit of having that experience or worked in tech for like a decade to know that that's the fastest thing, but I didn't know that this is like the most critical piece for crypto. And then when we saw those failures, we had to solve them. Or I think the idea of a single global public chain that with many shared applications, all using the same state was kind of dead on arrival. If global fees spike, parallelism doesn't matter. You have one use case that saturates the whole thing. No one cares how many TPS it can do. It's just irrelevant. So luckily, we did the right steps, failed the right way, and the solution was kind of obvious.
So I think that's maybe what makes Solana unique is we kind of through a very long path uh we found like i think the right answer of how to build like a shared permissionless system and then that answer what is the technical name name for this so i so i use the right name we call them local fee markets yeah free markets and that that's where like if i'm coding up i'll put this into i actually just did this episode with um lucas from from jito and so i was putting into ethereum terms just because like that's how i i think and that's probably what the listeners are familiar with so like for example if we had local fee markets on the ethereum layer one and you made some arb transaction to balance uniswap and sushi swap you would like your what you're saying is the developers of wherever that transaction is originating from would say okay i need to specify to the solana ecosystem to the solana svm i'm going to go touch the uniswap contract or specifically the usdc ether pool of uniswap and then i would also be touching the ether USCC pool contract address of sushi swap.
And that's the only thing that I'm touching and anything else I don't care about. And that's, that's how we get parallelism, right? As in like other things can specify their things over there. And it's, since they're not overlapping, we get parallelism. So it's, it's local fee markets. It produces parallelism. Is that right? Yeah. What, what, what I, uh, believe the technical term for this in database land is isolation because you have transaction isolation. So one transaction, another one isolated from each other. And when you have isolation, you can execute them in parallel and have the exact same result, regardless what order they're executed in.
So, but what's cool is once you do that, once you specify that in a transaction, that information is available in the mempool, so then your block producer is going to like, be like, okay, I'm going to fill up the block with the highest priority fees. And if the runtime, then the virtual machine says, okay, you've saturated all the USDC, UNI, like transactions that could hit this specific market, you cannot add any more to the block, but you still have block space for other stuff. Then the block producers can skip all the high priority fees and defer them to the next block, but then take all the lower priority ones that don't touch that saturated pool and that's what creates this kind of like isolation and localization of fees because you have this hot spot everyone takes everyone still is greedy right so they fill up the hottest market but then they're like well i still have space so i don't take all this other stuff that is like noise or whatever so that was the you know that's what we figured out had to be done for us to be able to support multiple like payments, NFTs, and DeFi, right?
Like the big three use cases. And so, yeah, as stretching the metaphor, even though this is apples to oranges, this is what you're saying is if the Bitcoin, the difficulty adjustment is to Bitcoin, isolationism parallel is in local fee markets is to Solana. Maybe, I hope. But I feel like smart people, engineers, I think everyone is probably looking at what works for Solana and is like, okay, this is how I can apply it to my technology. So we're going to start seeing, I think, that gap narrow. But crypto, man, shipping software and crypto sucks. So what you think you can do in like six weeks takes six months, no matter what.
So I think Solana has been, I think, entering this new phase for itself, specifically with like the Jito airdrop. There's like this before and after moment in the Jito airdrop where like you kind of had like the Solana diehards, the Solana chew glassers throughout the bear market who stuck around. And now that the Jito airdrop happened, now it's attracted people who weren't previously attracted to Solana for like the economics reasons, for the incentive reasons, for like people understanding that this is kind of where the meta is. and that's one way I would describe the chapter or the phase shift for Solana but another one is happening just like with some of the fundamentals here which is like FireDancer is now a second client.
Jito itself is a second client. Maybe there's another other clients coming online as well and so this is now once you have multiple clients you now have the governance conversation and so there seems to be like a lot of couple turnings of pages all kind of happening at the same time making it seem like there's kind of a before after moment for Solana as it relates to the last six weeks or so. Yeah, that's pretty cool to see. I mean, so FireDancer is a complete rewrite. Jito is another distribution of the Solana Labs client, but it does all the human bus factor kind of problems. You have now multiple points of failure, and that creates the governance problems.
It's like, how do we make sure that changes that Jito makes don't break mainnet, changes that Labs make don't break Jito, and don't break don't delay fire dancer like everyone's gonna talk this is why i'm writing more docs alignment is now a thing how do i get all of these like engineers that like are experts in the deep part of the stack that they're in way deeper than me at this point don't like all spread in different directions and make sure that there is like kind of one one horizon roadmap that we're working towards um that's definitely a new problem but it's a good problem to have it means that like you know people it means you have a lot of people trying to trying to move the ship so like uh coming from ethereum land there's all this like infrastructure set up around ethereum governance right like you have the bi-weekly all core devs call now it's split into two calls the el call and the cl call uh there's like the ethereum magicians forums what does this kind of like coordination infrastructure look like Solana or is that kind of still getting built there's a call Jacob Creech runs there's a validator call to kind of more like dev ops system stuff there's a specific core developer call between all the teams there's a discord with all the different channels for different teams and kind of like there's now a simd process Solana improvement documents he posts on github everyone reviews them um all that stuff is getting that was there before but now people like it was good that we kind of like had set these things up but people are now using them because then there's a necessity to use them like setting this stuff up is easy right like it just takes one person to run them but none of it matters until you have like a critical mass of people that don't know what the hell is going on so then they're forced to talk there's usually smart people therefore they go and be like, well, who do I talk to?
Where do I find? Who do I talk to? And you kind of start seeing that happening. I think the interesting thing that I'm seeing is like Solana, the archetype of Solana is super strong. It's like these low level systems engineers, these database designers like yourself. And now with this like whole phase change of Solana, the evolution of Solana into something greater is now needing a new archetype, which is like the governance archetype. And I like the Solana engineering archetype, I'm not sure, has a lot of just like governance muscle, because I don't think most people to have governance muscles by default.
Like I think Ethereum has attracted the governance nerd snipes because that's kind of what it is. But I don't know if the engineers have a lot of governance muscle about them. So I think, I don't know if this happened in Ethereum, but I think out of necessity, you kind of start building like a constitution or a motto, right? And I think for Ethereum, it was like, cheapest possible hardware, like, how do we make this verifiability as accessible as possible? And everyone that's building always thinking about that. And for me, I'm trying to drill into everyone, how do you make it faster? Like just what is like when you're like have 50 different options and you got to pick one or the other, which one is like more scalable, faster scales and more cores.
And that's forcing all the discussions to kind of like pick out of the set of like permutations of every configuration. Like, OK, we should go down this path. And this is a way I think that like it's like a religious mantra. Right. It's the Solana North Star. it's the one alignment right right exactly um and this is this is not to knock on ethereum in any way i think like once you get to a certain size of the ecosystem i think you kind of have to pick that like what's the core pareto efficient spot that we're staking out and like have everyone aligned towards that um and i think like bitcoin picked its own spot right and it's worked out for them.
Like, you know, despite of all the criticism that everyone throws at Bitcoin core and the community, it's still like pretty successful, right? I wouldn't believe it if Solana got there, right? It would be like crazy in my mind. So wait, what would you say is Bitcoin's North Star? Because I have my answer. I just want to hear yours. I think it's the fossilization of the supply cap, that it's like the immutability of it. Yeah. Yeah, it's just like the whole idea of like you get a piece of something that no one can change and you can like hide in your bunker and like count the bits in your ledger, right?
Like in your air gaps, whatever, cold storage, you can, yeah. I think when it comes to like tribal tribal wars in the crypto space, I think like and honestly, even some Bitcoiners will point at this and be like, yo, that doesn't work in the fullness of time. Right. Like I think Nick Carter and Hazu were famous Bitcoiners and Nick Carter, Nick Carter, still a big corner, you know, but they'll point at the supply cap and be like, yeah, eventually you just that just drives you just drive off the cliff with that. And so like some some North Star is actually, you know, explode, if you will, before before they actually get there.
right not if you have inscriptions and i guess it's good enough man inscriptions break and solve everything yeah god okay so what are some of the more more important conversations going on in salon land these days because there's the governance conversation um but what else is there i think like uh the trade house with like fixing like bugs and improvements versus fire dancer shipping faster those are like real hard questions like because i think we have some obvious flaws that are not that haven't like caused a catastrophic failure yet but like stuff like the um the storage fees are like hard-coded and as the price of soul goes up it becomes more expensive and then impacts developers and at some point like the easy solution is like okay there's a governance effectively hard fork process to lower the hard code number until the actual solution is shipped after fire dancer it's just like engineers don't like that because it's uh we know the bug we want to fix it right so there's like this like right need to like fix the wrinkles and stuff but you also have to coordinate so i think like tons of discussions like that are basically all swirling around like i know what the problem is, like, how do we solve it?
But how do we also make sure that FireDancer ships? Because having, to me, in my mind, that reducing the single points of failure of the code base is the most important thing right now. To really, like, guarantee... How would that thing actually, like, how is that a single point of failure? The storage costs? No, like, the not having, like, the single Solana code base is a single point of failure. Having FireDancer out is the highest priority right so like but fixing problems in the runtime requires both teams to solve them and like us you know like even though we know what the problem is if we're like okay there's a solution it'll only take six weeks to implement but then fire dancer is going to be six six weeks later right yeah and then the worry is that there's in that that six weeks of time is a six weeks longer amount of time in which there's a single solana client with a potential like service area for a catastrophic bug understood yeah okay so my my view is that like we do the alignment conversations now we have the design the north star this is how everything should work but ship fire dancer as fast as possible and then start doing the work and that's okay i think like for like for everything that crypto needs this year i believe solana is scaled to the to meet the demand.
So like my, my view is that like we can delay the improvements until fire dancers out. And then like, but like, it's really good to like have the design discussions now poke all the holes in them. And like, that would actually be awesome if we had like, like did all the work that we're, you know, that we were supposed to do three years ago, but like we can do it now and have like a really good design that everyone agrees on. Wouldn't it be good if you have some of these like updates that are, call it like low hanging fruit that everyone has an agreement on wouldn't be good to like ship firedancer and then like okay we have this agreement on this direction for this smaller code change but now we have two systems that we need to update it can be like kind of a test net for governance across multiple clients yep that's basically like kind of the process that's happening and the firedancer folks are awesome they're developing some of these optimizations on their own because they kind of like see where we only went halfway and they're like why didn't you guys do that and i'm like well we had to ship we wouldn't be talking to you and like and then they're like okay so we'll do the r&d and figure out how fast the difference is so it's cool to see them do all this work okay so let's uh there's there'll be a handful of these throughout the conversation i think so i'll pull out here's an ethereum perspective on fire dancer uh that um maybe you can debunk or provide the alternative opinion or perspective on uh when i see jump crypto making a fired from making a solana client and the solana community is like oh fire dancer is the best thing since sliced bread and jump crypto who is like famously extractive totally probably like the right people for the job because you want the high frequency traders to make the high frequency client.
That makes total sense. But then from like from the alternative side of things is like, I don't want these people who are masters at extraction to build the extraction client that gives me the heebie jeebies. What would you say to this? First of all, in the world of finance, right? The exchanges are the extractors. Somebody like jump pays like an arm and a leg to operate at an exchange um and they put their capital at risk and with their brain power they try to minimize latency of all the world's information all the noise find all the right signals and as quickly as possible get them to the exchange and the exchange has just been there because somebody's uncle traded pork you know a thousand years ago or whatever, right?
They're not doing shit. So in my view, like, there is like value creation happening at the jump level. And I think what these systems that we're building, the permissionless open marketplaces do is they equalize the access. So now me as a hobbyist, I can compete with jump without having to pay the exchange and arm and a leg. So that I think is like cool. And we'll actually both jump, I think wants this because they're competitive. And two, I think it'll actually compress the fees all across finance because there's more competition. The other side of it, I think is that it's all open source code.
Like literally like it is a part of Apache 2.0 code. You can go look at it. There is no magic. If jump to this, right? Like, and then everyone has access to it across the ecosystem and across a crypto. right so all the optimizations they do can actually like if they're interesting apply them to ethereum um like so from my perspective i think it's kind of like silly like it's just like the silliest arguments it's just code right it doesn't matter who wrote the code um i think the more interesting one is there a direction that jump can influence solana to where it creates an environment where there can somehow be more extractive governance yeah like well like i think governance like is not going to be stake-weighted but i think core engineers have a lot of influence right like linus has a lot of influence of on linux even though he's just one dude like he gets to make a lot of big design decisions is there like a directional like place where jump could push solana to where it somehow gives an advantage to incumbents like jump and citadel and like displaces hobbyists or whatever that's a more interesting question and like what is that technology choice what what would that even look like right like so i think this is where like i think the community should be like serious right about like what are we building does it actually improve access and stuff like that i think um i think it's pretty unlikely just talking to the jump folks they're like hardcore engineers i don't i don't think you can like even convince kevin bowers to like okay make guide the architecture towards this place where we will extract more value like dude you're wasting my time they're not like puppet masters they're just yeah yeah i think that's like very far-fetched um but like i think it could accidentally get there and that's like a more interesting discussion and we should like be like constantly thinking about it like is the technology that we're building does it like allow like you know like me when i graduated college i was like trading on all of these dinky exchanges but my connectivity sucked i didn't have access to data everything was terrible Like, I don't want that to happen to like the next Anatoly, right?
Like maybe that guy figures out and like does a better job than jump. Cause like, this is where innovation comes from is people that don't know that they're competing against the best, right? They just, yeah. So like, so I do get, I do get the argument that like, uh, with the appropriate tech platform, the middle ground, the, the arena, if the arena is appropriately like engineered and architected in a way that like junk capital only has so much more of an edge over like the average Joe Schmo. That's great. However, like they will have economies of scale. They employ people to do good work, to do good jobs, to succeed at their jobs.
And so like, it's great that we are taking down the silos of exchanges and we are making those decentralized and open and so uh that centralization force that um power capture extraction venue is eliminated and now like distributed through a more decentralized ecosystem that's great but then it kind of just creates a new kingmaker right it's which is whoever can play those markets the best so now that the markets what the walls around the markets are down but the players are now the new the new leaders if if you will and so it's kind of like but if they're doing real work right if they're like looking at all of the world's information synthesizing it as fast as possible and like picking the highest priority things and pricing it correctly and like if if they're doing the work why shouldn't they earn some of the return like me as a hobbyist i can do that work too right and i can find a and because the world is so big and is massive and it's a very long curve of like of events that happen there's no way jump or anyone else can capture all of it's just too big i would always i always believe like that i could always find an edge if i work hard enough i could i could like compete with them on one particular segment of the market beat them and then grow my own business right and then like eventually get to their level to where i am don't spend time on like the little the edge cases and worry only about the big markets that i care about like i think that's just like normal competition like as long as the access is free and open to everyone globally i think that's fine um at least i don't see like a fundamental problem with it or like one that one that like defeats the purpose of like open permissionless networks yeah i guess the concern is is a point taken for sure i guess the concern is just like increasing the scale of capital begetting capital.
Like how fast does the best trader on Solana accrue more rewards faster than the medium trader on Solana? And if that gap is large, then we're concerned. But if that gap isn't that large, then to what you're saying, just like, well, at some point they are doing real work. They are shifting the state of Solana to map the state of the real world, and that is valuable. We'll see, right? I think folks that are trying to think about how do they capture... I mean, this is the problem. How do we capture Mev in the protocol? People trying to find solutions to this. I think it's unsolvable. So you're going to have, I think, the Ethereum approach, which is through crypto economics and auctions and a slow chain that can run this.
And I think you're going to see the Solana approach is like physics. How do we make the chain so fast that it's physically impossible for like information to travel around the world and then like you have localization and and like the physical forces basically kind of force a certain fairness like i can submit my transaction to the block producer that's closest to me and that means that like the amount of information that that thing can evaluate is only local to me and it doesn't have like full control of the of the global state no matter what happens so like can we like cut the latencies that low And if we can, then like, it'll be cool to see which one's better, right?
Like maybe Solana is worse. Maybe Ethereum captures more value for Ethereum, but the prices to the users are worse. Who knows, right? Like, I don't know, right? Like it's, we'll see what happens. I think that is a pretty solid way to kind of differentiate the strategies between Ethereum and Solana, where Ethereum is trying to like maximize in protocol value capture, whereas Solana, maybe this will be my description, correct me if I'm wrong, but Solana is trying to outrace MEV. It's just trying to go faster than it. And the first thing you learn about MEV is that there's actually no eliminating it.
You can only just transfer it elsewhere. And Ethereum is like, well, we're going to be slow and expensive, and we're going to capture all of that value, and it's going to be placed into Ether. and Ether is desired to be this highly decentralized distributed asset that everyone has access to. One of the easiest things you can do in crypto is buy Ether. And all of a sudden you have exposure to Ethereum fees and Ethereum MEV. And Solana on the other side of things is like, well, we're just going to have block times that are so incredibly fast that someone captures it by the time that that information permeates to the other side of the world.
which does one thing i did learn is like small blocks fast block times uh do does is actually a mechanism to lower total mev but doesn't it then it just kind of displaces it into like latency games but that's but i think what the solana theory or a salon of strategy is that like well those latency games will happen in like a local part of the globe and those games won't be global games they'll be local games and those people are doing work they're racing right and then like if the message bus that they're all synchronizing on is the fastest one there, then it's creating value for the whole world.
Because then if I'm on the other side of the world, I get this reference point that's most trusted. And in theory, if the way that it's, this message bus is really valuable, the token that, you know, prevents spam and this message bus should accrue some of the value. But again, I don't know. Let's just pick up notes. we'll see this is like i think the hardest part is like figuring out what happens when the systems scale and like really take over real finance like right now what do we have like dog coins and nfts and inscriptions and it's almost like honestly it's the perfect amount of risk it's like risky but but but like we're not risking the global economy like there's enough skin in the game that everyone's taking it seriously and trying to like do their best job but it's you know it's still humans writing software it's not gonna like doesn't matter if dog money like fails or not yeah it is real capital but at least inside of it it's in a doggy container yeah exactly not a pension container yep yep uh okay so um the what does so the Incoming bull market, which I think everyone has assumed that we're getting.
Salon activity reaching new heights, I think. It's going to be close. Pretty close, yeah. Does the future influx of a bunch of new users scare you? So, like, we had 2 million active accounts with Stepin during its peak. And what I learned is that, like, these kind of, like, hyper-economically incentivized users, have a steep onboarding and then a steep drop off if the activity they're doing is not like creating daily value or something like that and these like economic kind of bursts like you'll have like what's cool is that i think these users are like basically like already crypto users they all have seed phrases and you can see that like once somebody figures out how to deal with any wallet they can switch relatively easily right their mental models already set up for this and this is what i believe is like the key part of like the growth in crypto industry is how many people figure out a seed phrase is like the total number of addressable users and then after that like it's just i think the switching costs of somebody installing an extension one or the other are pretty minimal so i think you can see that like all all the pieces are there and if the only thing that we figured out are speculative like kind of economically incentivized games i don't think it'll last but uh if we figure out some real world use cases that create value for those users they'll be stickier and they'll stick around and i think the latter is still unproven and i hope that this bull cycle is the one where like real world applications kind of get some traction like a payments thing or something right like helium i feel like is infra that i feel like the users that are using it are not gonna like be crypto users they're they're helium network users i think the idea that you can get tokens for creating a quality of the of the map is at least enough to onboard them to a wallet and get a seed phrase But like, I want like a Venmo.
Why can't we have a crypto Venmo that's global? Everyone's sending each other real currencies, euros, dollars, and it works. Like something like that where it's useful. So this is my biggest story. Like I look at the numbers, I'm glad it's happening. And like, I'm glad that the network's not falling over while it's happening even more, that the fees are not spiking. that's like pat myself on good engineering but like we need to see real world use cases that i feel like are sticky to the point that users aren't going to leave yeah i would say that's kind of like the identity crisis that i'm seeing unfold for the entire industry kind of in slow motion is like everyone is realizing that like it was really fun to build insular apps for like almost a decade now and also we've gotten every single person nerd sniped about crypto who would ever be nervous about that and now if we're ever gonna like you know get further reaches it has to take a new kind of app um but that's not even like a solana ethereum you know polka die cosmos conversation that's just like a yo what can we really do with crypto conversations and there's differing differing perspectives as to like how far crypto can go uh in terms of its utility right Are you a reader of Polenya's blogs at all?
You know, Polenya, you know, they're more Ethereum aligned. I've read his blogs. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So they think that like the case for crypto use cases is actually like much smaller than what everyone in like crypto land is giving credit for. Because they're like, OK, look at the utilities. It's Bitcoin and Ether as store values. it's stable coins for payments and that's about it and everything else isn't he arguing for a million l2s as well in the same breath that i don't i can't remember a specific blog writing about that but i i wouldn't be surprised okay i think i think he might be more in the uh one fewer number of larger l2s like one like a power law of layer twos but i think he is i think I think they are definitely like an app chain thesis person, but more for like, I think gaming chains, I'm starting to put words in their mouth.
So like games get their own chains, for example. But beyond that, I think it's like power law distribution for layer twos. Anyways, the conversation I was bringing up is just like, I think like crypto is kind of, and it swings between pendulums of like optimism and pessimism, right? Like on the optimistic side of things, we have like, oh, we can tokenize everything. We can tokenize blockchains and supply chains and we can, you know, map the world and there's going to be a token. Everything's going to be a token, token economy, token economy. And then on the other side of things, it's like, you know, Bitcoin maximalism, extreme conservatism is like, no, there's only one blockchain.
It does one thing, which is produce Bitcoin and Bitcoin is money and all other utilities, just like a complete farce. And I think depending on where you fall in this spectrum, you kind of find yourself in different like ecosystems of crypto. And I would definitely place Solana on the more optimistic version of the crypto utility. Hyper optimistic. Hyper optimistic, yeah. I feel like if the Western world doesn't accept crypto as an industry, Solana is worthless. It's like useless. No one's going to care. like the only reason to have a high throughput low cost chain is if it like is adapted like at the consumer level to like normal voting citizens like use it on a daily basis right like otherwise what's the point so like i feel like yeah i'm hyper optimistic i would say i feel like legally it'll be like basically enshrined and we'll have some some way to operate and launch decentralized systems and all this stuff will happen every bank is going to have a stable coin and yada yada yada but like yeah i think i don't know i think like if i also think in that world uh something like bitcoin or the ultrasound money like narrative where you have like the cockroach chain is really important because it kind of forces the question like if you if it's if if the the cost to shut down bitcoin in the western world is orwellian like it requires massive surveillance and interruption of normal people's lives it's too it's too far politically difficult and that that forces the question for people to be like okay fine here's your box go do it right right right are you saying that like people are realizing that they'll never be able to shut down bitcoin and so therefore like well if we're not going to shut down bitcoin we might as well just like keep ethereum and then we'll keep solana and we'll just keep all the the less uh hardened ones too i think it's uh They can shut it down, but if it requires so much political capital, right, so much, such a huge invasion of privacy and individual liberty, that it's not politically viable.
That means that it's not going to be shut down because we still, I believe, live in like a fairly representative world. and that forces the conversation to be like okay if we if like it's not practical to shut down bitcoin then what what are the green lines right for for all this stuff so like that that's kind of like i don't know solana's cheating right we're like okay bitcoin survives here's a really fast blockchain that gives you trust minimization but requires data centers and all that yeah it's like solana's like the third kid that the two older kids like are watching their parents just treat way nicer than they were ever treated in ethereum and they're both like why aren't you why aren't you bullying the third kid as hard exactly one one like phase change in ethereum land or like uh development milestone of ethereum I always kind of like look at these systems as like literal kids, children, sometimes like Bitcoin, older brother, Bitcoin, Bitcoin is like probably in college, maybe about to graduate from college.
Ethereum is like entering college. Solana is like still middle school, high school somewhere. But Ethereum went through this one like development milestone when it had its whole like Tornado Cash OFAC moment where that was like a big growing up moment for Ethereum. Like it was no longer like dog tokens and Ponzi games. It was like, yo, you are infiltrating the space of the most powerful office in the land, which is like the Department of Defense, Department of Treasury, like threatening the dollar, threatening global security of the United States. And then all of a sudden you saw like the OFAC ruling go out about tornado cash is now you can't touch that.
And then we saw like 85 percent censored blocks on Ethereum inside of a span of a few short months. And all the Bitcoiners are like, oh, told you Ethereum was totally like, you know, not ready to fight nation states. And then the percentage of OFAC censored blocks in Ethereum has now been down only ever since that moment, down to 33%. And now I would call it that. That's in Ethereum's rear view mirror. It's successfully like passed that milestone. And, you know, watching Solana enter its economics and governance phase of its development, which is the part that like really interests me. eventually I'm like well if all of the Solana community wants Solana to have the successes that they want it to have it will one day enter that very big conversation of like threatening nation state powers how close do you think we are and what do you think the Solana system ecosystem is ready for this like what do you think about this I'm not ready for it because I'm just an engineer I bet you are i have no clue how to deal with this i will be like man that's the stuff that like really churns my stomach and that i'm terrified of because i don't know what to do i would like reach out to coin center and be like what do we do help yeah i think like at the same time i have very very strong beliefs that like the west where we live it's a place of freedom like my parents fled the fucking Soviet Union and like, I want to protect it right against bad actors.
I will do everything I can to like stop bad actors from like preventing me to pursue happiness in the United States. It's like a beautiful thing to be able to like work on whatever I want and do like learn whatever I want and say whatever I want right in the U S. So like, I, I, man, yeah, I don't know. Like, these are like the, the really hard questions. I hope it's that those decisions come as far into the future as possible. Well, the, if the trajectory maps on and like Solana is like one cycle behind a theory and Ethereum is one cycle behind Bitcoin, it would, if the trajectory continues, it would generally like if enough stable coins find themselves on Solana and there's enough apps with like holes in them that have high TVL, it's going to attract like the dubious actors such as like the lazarus group which is going to like that's going to happen that's wouldn't that happen at the tail end of this bull market yeah i hope not this is like terrifying we can we can brush that one under the rug and recircle back around that in like two years yep with minimass portfolio swapping tokens on chain has never been easier swap tokens at any time with the most competitive pricing around.
The MetaMask Portfolio swap feature allows you to swap tokens directly by aggregating and comparing various decentralized exchanges to ensure you get competitive prices and low network fees. Choose the token you want to swap from and what you want to swap into and tap into combined liquidity across providers all automatically. Within MetaMask Portfolio, you can easily swap tokens with low fees, fewer approvals, and slippage protection for all of your trades. Manage your Web3 everything at metamask.io slash portfolio. Arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications.
Arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions. Arbitrum has the leading DeFi ecosystem, strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs, and is quickly becoming the web-free gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.arbitrum.io. Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitrum Orbit chain? Arbitrum Orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own Orbit chain, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput. Whether you're a developer, an enterprise, or a user, Arbitrum Orbit lets you take your project to new heights.
All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum. Experience Web3 development the way it was always meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Visit arbitrum.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities. What does all that mean? Rock solid security, a trustless bridge to Ethereum, and more real-world use cases for Ethereum without compromise. And real-world adoption is happening. Active addresses on Celo have grown over 500% in the last six months. With the Celo Layer 2, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas using ERC-20 tokens.
But Celo is a community-governed protocol. This means that Celo needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Celo forum. Follow at Celo org on Twitter and visit Celo.org to shape the future of Ethereum. One thing that I've noticed going on is the Bonk token. Actually, let's start with Bonk. What the hell is Bonk? This was like a project launched by NOM and a bunch of like random ecosystem devs and like participants. right when like kind of the whole narrative storm was happening uh last year like literally one year ago d gods left solana magic key and announcer going multi-chain phantom announcer going multi-chain all like in one week right everything was in the dumpster and these kids lunch bonked and like it was a hit like it's a dog coin i don't i mean like the only purpose is to like send somebody 669 420 bonk and laugh about it like what else it has no other purpose beyond that right so like uh but like for whatever reason i think maybe because it was launched at that like worst possible moment and like people had nothing else to do it like just was kind of like okay i guess we'll do bonk and that became a hit um in response to like people leaving the ecosystem it was like hey i don't know the people sticking around i don't know i honestly don't know the motivation but it felt like it also felt like the bear market was already well underway right like so people were like kind of itching looking for an excuse and like the events like the ftx collapse and everything it was just such a bottom that maybe like i don't know maybe that was the motivating trigger i don't know like i don't fully comprehend how these things work how dog coins work okay so but why did bunk become bunk so they made bunk but like why did it become what it is well i think like everyone was experiencing very shared trauma all at the same time and everyone was plugged in online looking for the next terrible news to drop right and like nobody else had anything else to do like you just have this like dog coin so i guess we're doing like i don't know it's bizarre like how these things catch virality like it's just what what makes something viral i think is like uh i don't know i'm an engineer if i knew i'd be doing something else okay so uh what what how how did bonk like permeate throughout solana like why why do so many solana people have bonk um they did like a big airdrop across all the nft communities and solana like users are pretty nft heavy um like even i like have bought nfts and stuff so like they did a really good job filtering for sibyls and kind of looking at like active people with like nfts incredible communities and stuff and like these did this whole like distribution process and for whatever reason it like just didn't go to zero i don't know why but like that gave people like this influx of like oh this thing is like or something and it's kind of happening and like it caught fire i don't know why or how but like it got a little virality like a year ago and then like everything else like everything was contracting rapidly after that like i think we kind of survived that moment like vitalik saved solana right with that tweet or something like that it was like vitalik and bonk at the same time happened and kind of like breathed some life into us long enough for like devs to go start shipping more products and like they just continued building integrations into like every DeFi marketplace, every NFT project and like kept talking about it.
And like the community just wouldn't die. And I think as MadLads happened and Backpack Launch and like kind of the, all the announcements around Breakpoint, like you just saw that the ecosystem was alive, I don't know if that's the reason why Solana got back in the news or like in the positive cycle, but like that's the only explanation that makes sense to me is like the devs shipped a bunch of products they attracted users and that kind of starts the ball rolling um so yeah the meme was like just meme-y enough with the right amount of fundamental because it seems like bonk has like a lot more of uh the spirit of solana in it than like shibu inu has anything about ethereum like the shibu inu community and the ethereum community are like those venn diagrams don't overlap but the bonk and then solana ecosystems those are like pretty strongly overlapping i think it's because the devs are plugged into the nft developers and like a lot of the developers on solana like like there's like two groups the the jerry's ellipsis people that are like the super defi nerds and mev nerds like cheeto and then there's the nft people that are like metaflex and all these other monkey business and d gods even but like they're all like kind of building web tools and a bunch of stuff that are fun for people to use.
And there's some intersection between them, but there's clearly like two different kinds of devs. And like, I think the Bonk folks were really plugged into both and they were able to just kind of like connect both of these. Like, I don't know. The campfire between the two parties. Yeah, exactly. And then, okay. So, but there's a bunch of Bonk on all the Solana phones. How did that happen? That was like one of the theories that we had is that like we basically get NFT, like everyone gets this phone. It's a pain in the ass to ship apps to the big app stores. But if the phones have like NFT drops and stuff like that, then the kind of people that get the phone will self-select to be the people that care about those things.
And that means then developers can ship apps to like a target rich environment, even though it's small, but a target rich one of NFT consumers and folks like that. So we like talk to every NFT project and like Klanos and, you know, we talked to the devs from Bonk, like, can you guys do like a small airdrop? It was like 10 bucks or something at the time. So just as a perk to have the phone. yeah it was not like there's no like master plan there to like oh the price of bonk is gonna pass the price of the phone and okay so how's that happened because okay so like during the bear market yeah during the bear market nobody cared nobody cared about the phone yeah bonk's worth nothing we were selling like 20 it was weird we're selling like 20 to 30 phones a day kind of trickling them out.
And it's like weirdly because it's like, okay, there's traction. Most DeFi protocols are not gaining 20 to 30 users every day. But you need to sell 20,000. That's going to take years to get there. So didn't this Alana phone project like sunset formally and then the bunk token price jumped? No, we had like the team, we didn't sunset the team is there we like kind of went into cockroach mode like how do we like figure out what to do with it and like get people excited about it but like spend the least amount to like extend runway for the for that team so like what happened i think is like right after break point we started sales kind of doubled or tripled so we were like selling 50 to 75 which is great but like it was still pretty slow and then bonk kind of took off and then for like people realize oh man the bunk airdrop is now worth like half the phone i think that's like okay the phone is effectively half price right like or like if you have some bonk you could literally sell it by the phone and get the phone to like equalize right like um so you still had to go like spend money to get this phone so even though like even if it's worth like 10 20 bucks it's gonna take 10 days to deliver rationally i don't think any person would be like i'm gonna get 10 more bonk in 10 days it's not about the bonk yeah i i it never went off like twice as much or 10x as much as the price of the phone to where the arm makes sense it was like maybe 10 to 20 percent more um so like enough people got it like or got excited about it to sell out so in one day we sold like 15 000 units which is bizarro so imagine like what was like the next highest day that you had prior to that yeah like maybe 50 or 75 or something no like i think we sold like at the start we sold like a couple hundred in the first day uh-huh um what was funny is that like literally i was in laurash's podcast earlier was like yeah we only sold 2500 i don't know what we're gonna do next we're trying to figure out so like and then they were like all these articles salonophone is a flop and literally three days later we sell 15 000 of them but like now i don't know what to do either like i think this is this is like the big question like uh people are kind of treating it as an nft like kind of like a club um and there's now devs shipping apps like the interest in terms of shipping apps is like 10x um the amount of airdrops the folks are getting or receiving is like kind of really picked up so that thesis is working but like to compete with apple or google in any meaningful way you need to sell a million phones right um is this enough of a signal to go try to like the next stage would be like 100 to 200 000 like is this enough of a signal to try to do the next stage i mean like honestly prior to this percent chance of us getting to that level was like 0.
1 now it's like five just like pretty good yeah massive improvement so like it's it's it's probably worth it for us to continue, but we still have to like figure out what that looks like, how long it's going to take costs. What's the form factors of shipping hardware is awesome. Like when you get this, do you like work for a year and you like optimize and you build this very complex device and you can hold it in your hands, like a real product. And like, you think it's awesome and you get it out. And there are some reviewers like, ah, it's mediocre. Yeah. The MHKB, the YouTuber. yeah like it's a lot of phone it's bad i remember that so like it's great because it's so much work and it's so intricate and it's like all of human civilization has built out all these technologies for you to like ship this phone um so it's really really cool but like uh you'll always you'll always just like in one like review i'll be like if if the solana phone does take off as a result of this like bonk airdrop that's associated with every single phone and it also like meaningfully disrupts like apple or google it will be the greatest most like facetious crypto story i could ever have you couldn't have written that yep yeah it would be bizarre it's like we live in a simulation then like i think that's definitive proof um okay so wait so how does how does the airdrop per phone work because the airdrop of bonk supply eventually runs out so like some phones won't have bonk in the future or like what's the detail i mean like if we ship another phone it'd be another device like you would have a different genesis token be like a different product there's the 20 000 sagas that get made that that's it like that manufacturing line has been shut down like we can't even ship anymore okay um so like we'd have to build another product and then figure out how that thing's gonna work right but like the goal i think all the salon and genesis phones are sold out yep okay because you said you sold like 50 000 in one day right no 15 15 000 okay yeah and so so oh so the d gens just bought them up to the limit yeah that's all sold out oh amazing all Well, congrats.
Hey, congrats for selling out the Solana phone. Yeah. Bizarre. Bizarre. Yeah. Solana phone is sold out. It was not a flop. But now, like, I think, yeah, now we have to figure out what to do next. Right. Because, like, I think if you're going to make another phone, you have to ask, like, can you get lightning to strike twice? Because, like, you sold the phone because of the bunkyard drop, not because of the phone, right? but the question is like if you have an an app store enough devs will ship to where the probability of lightning is 100 right like that's kind of like the theory um and having an app store that's crypto first is like you own we own our own destiny right like we're not beholden to the apples and googles you can do whatever it's awesome like this this is like the biggest unlock I think we could possibly have.
So if it's possible, if you can get the users to actually like get the phone, use it for crypto stuff and like it'd be really, really cool. I think one of the conversations that I've seen happen in a number of different places. I think the first time I heard this was just getting dinner with John Charbonneau. and he just kind of gave me the thought experiment of like imagine if friend.tech was built on Solana not base and imagine what that would have done to the Solana narrative when when friend tech took off and this this was like two months ago so this was a while ago and like listening to that thought experiment I'm like oh yeah like imagine how loud the Solana community would be on Twitter if it was friend tech on base not on not on Solana like the entire narrative of Solana would have just like pivoted in an absolute heartbeat and that was like you know three months ago two months ago when when frentech was a thing and then i was also having a conversation with chris berniski who's somewhere along those same lines just like the and this was after sole price goes from 20 to 70 something dollars and like the narrative uh shifts the meta shifts towards solana where he goes like oh yeah solana just is a pretty strong bet for like where a breakout consumer crypto app actually lands in this next like wave of adoption like if it's if it's going to be one space where that consumer app is built it the solana is the best like risk to war to place your bets uh and so it would be great and totally if we had a breakout consumer app because we haven't really had one we kind of had one with friend tech and now it's kind of like died uh what are your odds that the crypto industry solana or not the crypto industry produces a breakout consumer app in like say the next like two years i'm an optimist so i'm gonna say like 90 95 i think these like next two years are going to be pivotal and like i think you should see a consumer application that that's like legitimate um it does step in count as a legitimate consumer application if it like stuck around i had this theory that maybe people are like basically like if i'm paying my trainer you know like 50 bucks an hour that i would rather use the the incentives that i'm getting from like the dopamine hook to the kick kickers and trading and stuff for me to run if those are basically equivalent to what i get out of a trainer then some segment of the population would just continuously use step in but I don't know if it feels like that probably didn't like fully land, but there was like a, there was like a theory, right?
Like the value that I'm getting out of it is the exercise and the motivation that I'm getting out of it is the crypto games that I get to play with the NFTs and the tokens and stuff. Cause that's pretty engaging for the brain, right? Like if I wake up and look at the prices and the competitiveness, I spent like countless hours on this, on like ultimate online trading, like random resources that nobody cares about, right? If you could get those same hooks into somebody and force them to work out, it's a value add for the world. But I don't know if that played, it didn't seem like that played out.
So I don't know if that's like the play to earn, learn to earn kind of things. Right. Are the right meta. We'll see. But like, who knows? token inspired consumer apps always kind of like it seems like uh um it seems backwards where like if you you can't inspire human behavior based off of token incentives because then it becomes gamed right so it has to be something else it has to be something a little bit more uh sustainable right random boring cross-border payments like euro usdc like i don't know that would be like great venmo that's international right like that works well um that would be cool okay let's i want to uh turn to solana economics because we've actually seen some like solana fees pick up uh and actually like be pretty sustainable uh where where do you find solana into so like in ethereum when i got into ethereum the monetary policy was we issue five ether per block and then it got changed to three and then it got changed to two and then eip 1559 was introduced and then proof of stake was introduced and that's like the last update that there's been uh if you had to like map solana's uh arc in terms of its like economic sustainability where are we on that arc and like what's ahead of us i think what's different is that like so a bunch of validators compete on commission so for users at stake they pick the lowest commission validator and they basically experience no dilution right like but there is some dilution because a bunch of the tokens are on stakes so those are the folks that are effectively paying this like kind of transfer wealth from everyone that's taking to unstaking and validators take a little cut of that in between um it's hard to tell like how much like users are impacted because the warm and the cool down and warm-up period on solana is really fast so it's like two days um one epoch basically so even if you're like a big fund and you're trading you would probably keep you know 80 of your soul staked and whatever you're using for trading unstaked right so then you're kind of experiencing minimum dilution or effectively like it's for whatever reason 69 of the tokens are staked right now if everyone staked exactly 69 of the tokens you'd be no dilution because you effectively like right like it's all moving from one bucket to the same to every person so like i think that that pain is actually like managed by people pretty effectively because the warmup and cool down period is so fast on Solana.
So like, but like when I argue with you online, whether that like on Twitter, the poster, like, it was not enough room to like explain the nuance of that, but like, you're not wrong. That inflation is a thing and it is diluting some people, but how much, I think there's a lot of nuance to figure out how much of that is. Uh, what I know is that like a clear cost to the network is the hardware. So like every validator, every RPC note, all of those have to be paid with real money, just like you pay for electricity to mine blocks. But like the difference between Bitcoin, the cost of hash power and the cost to run the Solana computer is like a million X.
But like I think for the network to be sustainable, the fees that you get from running it have to cover the total cost of the hardware. and I think like the fees right now are maybe like 50 million a year and the cost of the hardware depending on the provider and all that stuff is like maybe between 10 to 20 so I think the fees have passed the cost of the hardware so that you can say that it's sustainable global cost of maintaining the Solana network is 10 to 20 million dollars it depends how you count it but like if you took the cheapest possible if you took the cheapest possible like no 350 a month and you multiplied it by 3000 nodes, it actually comes out like to around 10, but like people are not going to take, there's lots of different other infra costs and no one, people will like pay for the more expensive ones.
Right. So you kind of like, maybe it's twice as much, but like, it's also a bunch of nuance there, right? Like, like RPC nodes, uh, like magic Eden uses don't need to be paid for by the network because of a business that makes money off the state and they will pay for those machines and count it as an expense but it is providing some security to the state to have those replicas so like how you count all the stuff is complicated how you like attribute the earnings from mav that jito has is also complicated because effectively any any value that a block producer gets from the network incentivizes them to acquire more stake right right so like that could be like all those incentives combined are like the positive stuff going into the network all the costs are the negatives i think right now the positives outweigh the negatives but again there's a bunch of nuance there but i think like ultimately these networks have to capture a lot more value to be competitive to like profit per market cap with a tech company if we have to actually like like compare those two things unless you believe there's some other reason to value these things higher i don't i think ultimately like there's got to be like value created for the world is sometimes risk-free asset price at the treasury is equals like our like total value of the system i think that fundamental function works for everything um and like where that value capture occurs in the future i think is if the network can handle many different hot spots like thousands of them concurrently And then the economic costs of those hotspots go up and the kind of fees that you're seeing now in the network, if you go to Solana Compass, you see that priority fees on the chart are now the biggest thing.
Base fees you can't even see and vote fees are barely visible. They're still visible, but much, much smaller portion. so like in a world where solana is sustainable and is like valued and capturing value at a higher rate is a world where there is lots of hot spots you know and the network can handle many concurrent hotspots at the same time and those economics capture are captured by the protocol um and by captured by the protocol do you mean payment to validators or burn sold burn this is the big question is i don't know if that matters i don't like i know a lot of folks in ethereum want to do the burn and there's good reasons for that i don't know if it matters over the long term this is like the big unknown like i don't know if it matters i will say that like all of the ethereum people will like say hey do this do this do this and it will be very much in line with like what ethereum is like why should you do the burn well because ethereum does the burn and you know we have ultrasound.
money and we like to look at that website but the thing is like if you keep on listening to the ethereum people they're just going to tell you to become ethereum at the end of the day and at some point like that's not helpful um right like so like the argument that the burn doesn't matter is that like uh within the black box of the whole network right you have the negative externalities you have to pay for to run the computers all that stuff and then you have the positive externalities where i like earned my paycheck from driving an uber and then i used it to pay for the fees on the network. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
But it doesn't matter if that fee is burnt or is distributed to everyone in the box or like what happens in the box, how those numbers move around. Do not change the weight of that box. It's like accounting in the computer. Who cares if you burn it or not or like whatever. I don't think it matters like at the end of the day. I think it doesn't matter at the end of the day to make the box function like whether you give it to validators or you burn it the box can function in both strategies but I mean like what you choose to do does change the output of the system right and so like the whole Ethereum perspective is like you burn it because ETH is money and the Solana perspective is like you want to minimize that because Solana is like an applications platform and it's all about I don't care about the burn of the token.
What I care about is that the fees don't spike without reason. What breaks Solana is that because we don't have a Layer 2, Layer 2s are not on the roadmap. You can build Layer 2s in Solana, but the whole point of a single unified state machine is that you don't need them. and if you have a single if you have like DeFi ARBs increase the cost to access the network to the to have to outbid the cost of the DeFi ARBs it means that payments have to have a separate app chain right and I'm like okay well then just make them all Celestia rollups or whatever I don't care like then like it doesn't matter right like I think if you can't solve the economics the isolation at the economics level, then the premise of Solana doesn't work.
But I think you need some burn to prevent weird spam attacks where validators spam themselves for free and can price out users. A bunch of stuff with 1559 is actually really, really clever ways to prevent that. But I don't know if you need the burn for capturing value. Like, because the burn is very, very different from Apple getting dollars and hoarding those dollars that they can spend later at any given time to like build more products. Right. Like Ethereum doesn't have that like dollar budget. When you burn the ETH, you cannot spend it in the future. It's gone. Well, that's not how I would describe it.
If you save the ETH, you can't, it's pointless to save it or burn it. Like if you like converted to dollars, that would be interesting and different. The idea of the burn is that you burn the ether and then you give yourself tolerance to issue that ether again later. Right. And so in like turn in at a later date, you're in a totally different environment. And if if shit hits the fan and everything is tanking. Right. Versus the dollar. You're not actually hedged to be able to issue more. you're like in a death spiral and if you issue more you die like if the the question on ethereum shouldn't be do we burn the eth or do we give it to some validator or a public goods thing it should be do we convert it to dollars and keep this like other asset that is completely decoupled from ethereum in case shit hits the fan yeah but you can't have that because these are like trustless economic systems why not that's like well that's what like the terra uh foundation the luna a foundation guy was like yeah we're gonna have like bitcoin and whenever we need to defend the peg we're gonna deploy the goal isn't to defend the peg the goal is to pay engineers to like make it better later that's a totally different thing you know you know kevin owaki huh do you know kevin owaki uh don't remember him uh he's the founder of gitcoin in in the ethereum ecosystem and he made this like eip proposal this is like awesome like really awesome ethereum lore he made this like ethereum eip proposal to like have 10 of block rewards go to fund like public goods and like how could you argue with that like we we can we all love public goods in ethereum uh but it actually like created like a pretty big not not like civil war because like one side very one very very quickly but it was all about like the credible neutrality of like where we send the ether that's captured and the idea is like if we send it to gitcoin well then you know gitcoin today wants to fund public goods but what happens when like if you get coin just becomes like a vector for control change it yeah but then you're changing too much right like you know we built we we have cryptography which is the tool that the rest of the world 10 billion people are going to use to coordinate decisions much more difficult than where where the burn goes this is like the magic you guys are too pessimistic no no it's like this is like the whole like uh cockroach chain uh file of gadriel is the metaphor that italic uses which is like yo you don't mess with that because as soon as like you just solve that by changing it again in the future all of a sudden you have like a political and governance system but but the whole point of like cryptography right what we're building is fundamentally is to connect 10 billion people right so they can all coordinate decisions instantly globally and like do much more like powerful things than like funding open source software yeah i think this is like maybe an opportunity for some governance though so like there is like yeah we can all we can find systems that are totally resonant with every single human but like what's that one line is like democracy is the worst form of governance except for all the other ones it's like one of the best forms of governance is like not having any governance yep it's like that that's the ethereum perspective is like you don't mess with the block rewards because that becomes a vector for political capture i don't disagree and i would not recommend anyone try this on solana because i think it's way too complicated too but like i think it's a missed opportunity i think okay so i think this is like one of the big uh dichotomies between like the ethereum perspective and the Solana perspective.
And I would actually like camp Ethereum. And I don't speak for all of Solana. This is just my opinion too, right? Of course. I actually think on this part of the spectrum, like Ethereum and Bitcoin are actually closer together than Ethereum is to Solana, where like money is an app. And it's honestly like one of the most important apps. So this is part of like the bankless thesis that we've been like pounding around for a while. We're like, we in crypto are here to make new monies. And so like the Solana idea of, um do you have non-state disagree i think solana folks very much in the same camp uh there was this like again people started talking about like forking off the ftx estate and it was like quickly squashed by everyone there was like a instant immune response that like property rights are sacred whatever happens happens like the state the sacred saying then we do whatever we can to preserve it and that wasn't it didn't come from me i like it literally came from the ecosystem so i think i don't think it would be possible for solana to do this either and i feel like it's a missed opportunity for somebody to think bigger and be like the world is like very complex what we're building is actually to like empower people to do very very complex governance stuff like we can do it it's just going to be hard and we can figure it out but like most people just want to be like back off in property rights because that's like a core tenant of crypto if you don't have property rights in your block space then what is your blockchain even for um but i don't see the same area of emphasis from the solana community as being interested in like money and the concept of money and its role in the world um that i think is like maybe a very nuanced way to look at it but like i don't think i think that the idea of like collecting the fees and then spending them is against at least to me rubs against my idea of like property rights like it feels like i'm being taxed and then somebody else benefits right like it's like uh collecting the fees and then spending them or spending them on on like arbitrary governance decided things doesn't feel true to like being a fully crazy property rights libertarian which we all yeah wait wait so i would agree with that so like uh ethereum ether collecting fees and then burning it and rather than just deciding that like this public institution is better than that public institution feels good in terms of like no one's no one no one's rights are being violated because everyone's being treated equally.
Correct. And I feel like most of the Solana community would agree with that sentiment. Like we all like to LARP as libertarians, right? But I think like reality is that like there's far more complex things in the world and like you want to solve them. And like, I think cryptography offers like a way to like really transform governance and do all these things that we all dream about in the post crypto world. And like, if we are too afraid to do it ourselves, there's no way the world is going to do it so like at the same time like while i like agree hey text don't like don't do this but like i wish somebody would do it because most cosmos people will do it i don't know are you like advocating this as like a thought experiment as like this is worth thinking about or do you actually think like we could make a system of money that has governance as a component of it i think if we did it would be far more powerful than one without it that's very uh very keynesian of you yeah i think like human intelligence i am like very optimistic and human intelligence human goodness their ability to like given enough communication come to the right decision i'm very optimistic i'm not i think it's a very hard problem to solve and like i wish somebody was solving it but it would be a first i would say for humanity to solve that problem no i think we've done it like human governance over money and and and governance is like the meta problem of like the human species right like the world's like us is not too terrible right like most of the places that we choose to live is pretty have pretty decent governance there's definitely places that don't but like a lot of trial and error people have figured out like most of the best practices okay so this is what i was going to bring up with the whole like i think the ethereum again you don't speak for solana you are one member of the solana perhaps a very important one but a member nonetheless uh this is where like if that if that is like a perspective to to apply to like and i do see this in like broader solanas like they're they don't emphasize a role in importance of money in the same way that Bitcoin exclusively does.
And a large part of Ethereum definitely does. And cause like the last time we had you on bank lists, like we asked you like, is soul money and you're like, soul soul's not money. And to us, I'm like, that's, that's the thing. We start there and we expand outwards, but without your base chain becoming money, then you don't have, you can't expand outwards from that. So that I agree with you. I don't think it matters to Solana devs or community. if like if all the volume that was happening on there was going against the wrapped eth pair everyone would be just as happy like holy shit we got it to work everything's like really yeah if eth was the unit of account in solana you think so the salon can be like nice cool great yeah because like the message bus works it's coordinating state everyone is like paying very low low cheap fees and everything's working look as an eth maxi i would love eth to be the unit of account inside of Solana.
That would be awesome. Whatever. Like, who cares? Like, it's like no different than USDC. It's not like I'm like competing with Jeremy Allaire and like money adoption. I want to help them. Is this a minority or majority opinion, would you say, of the Solana community? Ooh, that's a good question. I don't know. This is a good question. I think like people are become token maxis because a lot of the like faith and like kind of all these things and what this technology can accomplish in the future are all wrapped into this like one thing. And then like, it becomes like, I think it's harder to build an NFT marketplace for like, whatever quacks that trade against USDC versus one was sold because you're trying to attract the super Solana maxis that are all like, you have that like, and this is where I think the money meme starts to roll.
is that like once you start building other functions on top and your initial customer base is like all the maxis of that particular like l1 they're all going to use that token but like i don't fundamentally believe that there's anything i can do like as an engineer or programmer to make that happen it's a meme and like right i think like i honestly think that if eth was the biggest trading pair like the whole idea of like solana's blockchain and nasdaq speed That would be the narrative, a meme. Nobody's going to talk about Sol as money. And nobody does, right? I don't think you see that sentiment on crypto Twitter or Sol as money.
So like, I don't think much would change in the community if that was the result, which is cool. I think if like there was more of ETH, if ETH was like the unit of account inside Solana. and when I went to Tensor to go buy another Mad Lad and it was denominated in ETH, that would be the greatest Ethereum Solana handshake moment of all time. They could literally do that and do the trade exchange through Jupyter for zero fees. What's the fastest way to get ETH on Solana these days? Is it Wormhole? It's probably Mayan Bridge is like a wrapper and type of wormhole that has nice UX. Or like, I think Jupiter probably has a kind of a bridge wrap or two.
Cool. All right. As soon as I see a marketplace with ETH denomination, boy is going to go shopping. Okay. Yeah, somebody should like, oh man, I'll ask the Tensor guys if they can detect if you have MetaMask installed. Oh, they can re-denominate to ETH? Yeah, re-denominate to ETH. check check how much madam ask you have like how much heath you have and like pass a certain threshold you re-dominate right right right yeah we do have the tensor guys on in uh january in three weeks so maybe i'll just ask them then anatoly uh when we hang up this phone and uh it's 2 p.m on tuesday december 19th and what are you going to go do inside of solana what are you going to go work on first I'm writing docs alignment docs that sounds awful to be honest it's actually great writing alignment docs actually kind of makes it seem like you're doing some of the stuff that Vitalik does when he writes on Vitalik.
ca which is just like broad vision broad vibes everyone else go implement it kind of strategy it's more specific than that I'm like this is the final state of these specific implementation components and this is how like they should look like and i think this is the effect it'll have and it's not to say that like that's the final state but at least i'm giving people like a north star and a reasoning behind it and they're super smart engineers what's great is that they will hear me out they they will not listen to me just simply because i said something so like that forces that discussion and like people will like comment and like so these are like kind of like What does Solana, like the final state looks like kind of stuff.
And you can go and read all this on like Solink, which is like this one dev built me like a little web platform where I can charge people USDC. I use USDC as money to access my email and my blog. Oh, gosh. Should I have it? I'll ask him to add ETH. I will. it's not very cypherpunk of you to have usdc i'm sorry it's just this is the way that it is yeah i will have access to my block and wormhole rap teeth on solana and it's holy this has been great um one last question for you uh how let's see if there's one thing about solana that you would find is like misrepresented the most by dumb ethereum podcasters, what would it be?
Actually, things have gotten a lot better. I think like the criticisms. Wait, about misrepresentation or dumb Ethereum podcasters? Both. I mean, like, first of all, I think most folks in the space are actually not as dumb. Like, there's really awesome people in the space, right? Like, and I think what's gotten better, and this is like the Ethereum immune response, is that like people will initially reject everything just like Bitcoin people, but then they're smart and curious. And then like you stick around long enough and you kind of tell your story and everyone's like, oh, you got something interesting there.
And then like you start getting this exchange of ideas going. And I think it's the criticisms have gotten way better in the sense that they're like, yeah, we need to fix the stuff. And like, there's a plan to fix it. Cool. Well, Antonio, thanks for coming on Bankless today. I appreciate it, my man. For sure. Thank you. Bankless Nation, you know the deal. Crypto is risky. Ethereum is risky. Solana is risky. Tech stacks of this nature. They're all risky. You can lose what you put in. We are headed west. This is a frontier. It's not for everyone, but we are glad you are with us on the Bankless journey.
Thanks a lot. Thank you.