✨ DEBRIEF | Ryan & David unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-the-anthony-pompliano-interview
------ Bankless Nation, we’ve finally got him… Anthony Pompliano is on the show. Pomp is an investor and media personality, best known to the crypto community for his relentless bitcoin evangelism.
Expect to learn about the Bitcoin Halving, the state of BTC EwTFs, the consequential institutional adoption and crypto tribalism. We wrap up the episode with a quick lightning round with Pomp and a peek into his 2024 investment portfolio.
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🔐 SAFE | ATTEND SAFE{CON} https://conf.safe.global/
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 6:25 Bitcoin Halving 12:07 Institutional Adoption 24:08 Bitcoin ETF Aftermath 34:02 Institutional Dangers 41:49 Bitcoin Evangelism 49:44 Culture Wars 1:03:47 US vs Crypto 1:13:46 Bear Market Learnings 1:16:35 Pomp’s Focus 1:23:04 Pomp’s Portfolio 1:27:48 Lightning Round 1:31:59 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Anthony Pompliano https://twitter.com/APompliano
The Pomp Letter https://pomp.substack.com/
------ Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets.
See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
And so like if I said to you, like, what is the quintessential Bitcoin, right? It's like, okay, they own Bitcoin, they eat meat, they like sun their balls, right? You can just like go down the line. I don't know. There's this whole thing. Oh, yeah. That's one of real things. Yeah. I mean, you get you get T from doing that. Yeah, you get it higher testosterone. Like this whole thing. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless. Anthony Pompliano on the show today, he's better known to us as pop.
He's an investor, he's a media personality. I think he's probably most known to the crypto community for his relentless Bitcoin evangelism and has certainly been relentless over the years. And that's where David and I first ran across him in 2017. He was preaching the good word of Bitcoin. And sometimes he gave us flak for some of our Ethereum bullishness, I would say. We've recorded this conversation just before the Bitcoin happening. We'll be released just after and that's really where we started the conversation. How is this happening? This Bitcoin happening, different from the rest. We also get into what it's like to talk about Bitcoin to the suits on CNBC.
And then the Bitcoin ETF, where's it going? We also talk about Bitcoin evangelism, who is left to convince here and the bear market of 2022. What did Pompliano learn? Finally, we end with a download on Pompl's crypto portfolio, what that looks like in 2024, his predictions for price and his predictions for the upcoming US election. Pompliano, I remember Ryan washing Pompl kind of rise in 2018 through 2020 and 2021 as the Bitcoin evangelist, right, like really putting out content that was educating about Bitcoin, the Bitcoin narrative, Bitcoin thesis, 21 million hardcap, low time preferences. And this just felt like a flashback to some like very early formative bankless years, I think both you and I were watching Pompl do this media machine that he just figured out this system of just rising on Twitter and then rising as a podcast and rising as a business man, like learning about memes.
And so a lot of it was early flashback to some of the things that I think like bankless was built on, like understanding memes, understanding the importance of virality, importance of accepting ideas and the people's heads. So a lot of this just felt like really old school, like early beginnings for me even getting into the crypto space. I don't know if that's how it felt like for you, but like I was getting like flashbacks during this episode. Yeah, I totally get that. And I guess there's maybe some pomp influence over bankless in some ways, though certainly I think and maybe famously at the time we really departed on his ideas for Ethereum.
He was very bearish at least publicly on Ethereum at that time. And so there's kind of a contrast between like pomp and bankless in those early years. But I think we've put a lot of that behind us and there's actually a refreshing conversation that we asked Pompl about how he evaluates Bitcoin culture right now and what his thoughts are and maybe how he's reformed or moderated some of his views over time. So that's an interesting part of this conversation. There's plenty of material here that I want to talk to you about the debrief. I already have some notes for the debrief so we have to go into that right now.
But first. Let's get into the episode with Pomp a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible whether you're buying Bitcoin or any other token. You should do it on Kraken our preferred crypto change for 2024 if you do not have any kind of Kraken. Consider clicking the links in the channel so you're getting started with Kraken today. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams then head over to Kraken when the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto.
Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles and videos. With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. You've got the simple, secure and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro.
Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, but to trading involves risk of loss. Celo is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon negative blockchain built for the real world. Driving real world use cases like mobile payments and mobile defy, and with opera mini-pay as one of the fastest growing web free wallets, Celo is seeing a meteoric rise with over 300 million transactions and 1.5 million monthly active addresses. And now, Celo is looking to come home to Ethereum as a layer 2, Optimism, Polygon, Matterlabs and Arbitrum have all thrown their hats in their ring for the Celo layer 2 to build upon their stacks.
Why the competition? The Celo layer 2 will bring huge advantages, like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability, secured by Ethereum validators and one block finality. What does that all mean for you? With Celo layer 2, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC20 tokens, sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect. But Celo is a community-governed protocol. This means that Celo needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Celo forums, follow Celo on Twitter and visit celo.org to shape the future of Ethereum.
Picking self-custody of your crypto is one of the most important things you can do on your bank list journey. It's also one of the hardest things to get right, with huge consequences if you don't. If you want help going bank lists, talk to Kasa. Kasa helps you take custody of your crypto assets so you don't have to wonder whether you're doing it right. Kasa is a one-stop shop for doing self-custody the right way. With Kasa vaults, you can hold ether, bitcoin, stablecoins, all with one simple app and multiple keys for the ultimate piece of mind with a support team to help you every step of the way.
But it doesn't stop at self-custody because even though crypto is forever, you are not. We all plan on making life-changing wealth in crypto, but with Kasa's inheritance product, life-changing wealth can elevate to generational wealth. For your kids and your loved ones who don't know anything about crypto. With Kasa, you won't lose your private keys and you won't accidentally take them to the grave either. Click the link in the description to get started securing your generational wealth. Bankless nation, we've got Anthony Pompliano, he is a bitcoin bull, he is an investor, he is a fellow podcaster, he is a media personality, is there anything he is not?
I don't know. Pom, welcome to Bankless. How are you guys doing? Long time coming. I appreciate you guys having me. It has been a long time. Do you know, I think I first got to know you as being like the bitcoin evangelist in 2017, 2018, like the main person that was telling the institutions to get off zero, beating the drum, taking this message to the masses and this is going to come out either shortly before the bitcoin happening or shortly after, which is a big freaking deal. I want to start with this question, what about this happening is different in bitcoin land? Where are we on the trajectory of adoption that you have been beating the drum about this entire time?
Yeah. Well, thank you guys for having me. A lot of people don't know this, but actually started out mining Ethereum in 2016 and I didn't know anything about crypto. There was no pitch of like bitcoin is going to be this great digital gold or gold or currency. Ether, it could have been, you know, I don't know, video game. I little had no clue about any of it, but there was a guy who came to me and he said, hey, you can buy these computers. You can plug them in and it like prints money and I was like, I mean, that sounds ridiculous. Where are the computers? Like how much do they cost? And so like, I think as many people who get into mining, like you either do one or two things either you're very technical and you like go and you set it up, you start hook it up the computers and kind of doing it yourself or you're just like more like capital allocation and you basically like order computers.
You think they kind of got shipped somewhere. Someone's supposed to be hosting it. You have a dashboard and like it looks like, you know, Ether is getting produced every day. So I was in that second camp and at the time, I think Ether was like maybe like eight bucks and we were mining like five a day and I never been like, I'm never going to make back this money. Like we're making 40 months a day. Oh my God. This is like what did I do? And then in 2017, as you guys know, better than most, you know, Ether went from like $10 to 30 to like a hundred by if I remember like April or May of 2017 and I remember being like, oh my God, that $40 is now $400 a day.
We've already made back our money and like most things in life, you know, too good to be true. I sold it all at 150 and was like, you know, I'm a genius, ran to 1400 to prideful to buy back in. But I tell that story because, yeah, I mean, I was like, you know, I made some money. I don't want to be the guy that I know FOMO is back in, but what it allowed me to do was I got the like enthusiasm and I got to see the positive side of like, hey, this stuff can move. There's people buying it, really spend some time learning about it. And then I did like a lot of work, right? My wife always tells a story like she remembers me, like having almost like a textbook right now.
I was like reading a book and she's like, what are you doing? I'm like, I'm like, studying. And she's like, you would never study for anything in your life outside of like something in finance. So, you know, let's see what happens. And by the time 2018 rolled around, I think what I came to the conclusion was that like Bitcoin was going to service this like digital gold thing and it was going to be a store of value and usually stores of value end up being kind of like all or nothing. So you know, I always say that dollars, if you live in the United States, like you don't carry Mexican pesos around, right?
You don't care. Bolivia or anything like you just use dollars. You're paid in dollars. You're saving dollars. You spend in dollars, etc. And then Ethereum, obviously I started mining it, I still, you know, paying a lot of attention to it. But the thing that I was most excited about Ethereum early on was in the mining space. I made the mistake of intellectually going long and idea, but not actually acting on it, which was the world was going to run on GPUs. And so I have this like famous tweet in my head. Nobody else cares about it, but I, it's like the death blow. I tweeted the world is going to run on GPUs.
And it's because I was doing the ether mining. I should have written video. Yeah. Like how stupid am I? And so it was this idea that like you could switch with the GPUs theoretically between like maybe you want to mine ether today, but all of a sudden maybe more, you know, kind of economic to go in mind using, you know, DNA sequencing or self-driving cars like all these use cases that now I think are kind of becoming very popular. Now the reason why that mining is really important is obviously the Bitcoin mining side, having really matters to those people and there's a whole thing we could take out.
But also this world changes so fast, the industry changes so fast that actually Ethereum miners are no more. Right. And so if you think like if we had gone and built out data centers and we're going to like switch back and forth between all this stuff, whatever, it may actually not have been a good business because one huge part of that thesis like went away. And so on Bitcoin's having I think maybe the only thing that I really can quantifiably point to that is different is we hit an all time high before the having. But that feels like probably the most important difference. There's a lot of kind of qualitative stuff that maybe people would point to that's like, you know, there's more institutional interest now mainstream media seems to think it's not going to go away.
So they're talking about it more. You could make an argument that like the holder base in general is more educated than they were in the last two, you know, having maybe also like expectations are higher. It's like, hey, every having the price goes up so like it better go up this time and so people change their behavior, which then could actually create it to go higher. Again, qualitative stuff we could debate, but like quantitatively, the only real difference is like maybe hash rate is the highest it's ever been and we hit the all time high before the having and those two things seem to be pretty important.
Remember listening to your podcast and pop back in whenever it started 2018, 2019, you were on this big campaign of get off zero, get the institutions off zero. And it was just like this very measured thing of like if we can just convince a marginal amount of institutions to get 1% of their base, their investments and put it into Bitcoin that has just massive implications to the price of Bitcoin just because we'll 1% as a lot. And now here we are in 2024 and like now 1% is actually like 3% like institutions are now allocating 3% and so for a long time, we could get not get get off zero at all.
Institutions were stuck at zero. Now they're just skipping to 3%, which I think is very related to this fact that Bitcoin is at all time highs before the happening like it's because of the ETF, right? Like it's because the outside world is now like not thinking that Bitcoin is this crazy thing anymore. Bitcoin is now like civilized and just an overall theme of like since the genesis of the bankless podcast has been one part of like crypto is actually moving more towards society. At the same time, society is also moving more towards crypto like these two things are converging and they're kind of seems to be this like hand of Adam God touching Adam fingertip at the Bitcoin ETF and that's that's kind of to me like the way to like kind of define this thing.
But the thing is like you've been you've been advocating for this future. You were the first one. So like what's it like to actually have been like at the beginning of that arc, like leading people here and that now actually is it as powerful as a moment as it seems because it this has been your campaign since genesis. The the God and Adam finger touching that's a fantastic analogy. God is gratifying Adam is Bitcoin. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So first I would say like I don't think I was the first to be like oh these two are going to buy this stuff. Whatever. I think maybe my very small contribution was I have a small enough brain to come up with like memorable one liners that people they could go repeat.
So like the marketing of that idea, but definitely there was people before me that you know we're kind of banging the drum. And what I would say in terms of the institutions at the time, what's the Pablo Picasso I think line is like good artist borrow great artist steel. I heard somewhere else that somebody had said like get off zero as a mantra about a different asset class. And I was like that's amazing. Like I'm just going to repeat that here. And you know hopefully it'll resonate. And so really the thought process was just like schmuck insurance right I think is what like Chimalthus called it or the idea that like I think Satoshi early on wrote and said you know maybe you should get some just in case it catches on like that was really it is just like what is the smallest amount possible that we could get you to break the seal because one should break the seal like then game on.
And so just like it wasn't like do one percent right which like also could have been the like memorable line but it was like just get off zero like literally just buy one Bitcoin it's $3,000 or something right like just one now you're a Bitcoin holder if you're holding it you're going to pay attention to it if you're paying attention to it you can't help but fall down the rabbit hole. And so that was really kind of the idea. Now I will tell you that I went and in 2019 I did a 120 flights around the world going and talking to institutions there was days where I would like fly to a city and I would talk to like three institutions in a single day.
It wasn't just me you know Marcus go Jason Williams we had a team like we were just full court press. There's not that many people who did it like there was some but no I mean like I don't know I'd have to go back and count exactly but it off the top I had maybe we worked with like 10 institutions yeah but like maybe we met with 300 or 400 so like on a percentage conversion basis like not that high and so when I always get reminded of that because to see now what's happening you have to wonder how much of it was timing so like they just needed to get familiar with it and time expiring actually just meant that hey the Lindy effect is here I'm like this isn't going to go away that had some contribution to is there's probably some element of like they needed time to do the work internally.
The third one is you need the people who work in the institutions to become Bitcoiners personally before they then go advocate to convince the institution to be like a Bitcoin holder or an investor and we can talk about many stories where institutions literally there's like one person inside the organization they're the Bitcoin or they convince their buddy their buddy convinces another person and the next you know it's like half the team is holding Bitcoin or crypto in general and then they go and they do it as an institution and then also you need to like a different form factor like go on Coinbase was never going to be a thing for an institution because there's just not what they do.
We early on had a venture fund and we told institutions hey it's a venture fund we're going to invest in the equity of these companies but we're going to buy a little bit of Bitcoin like 15% give or take I think it was the first fund the amount of effort that we had to do in diligence to explain that Coinbase was a qualified custodian that was going to hold the Bitcoin that was like 80% of the diligence conversation. So even though Coinbase it to all of us was like oh of course this is like the safest thing possible like at least we're not on name your external you know international exchange to them they were like I never heard of Coinbase like what is that thing who owns it you know what what who's regulating it etc.
And so I think that that's like really the confluence of why the institutions finally have started to allocate is like you need the ETFs to get approved you needed them to have time you needed people internally to buy Bitcoin and then you also in some weird way needed them to like have career risk removed by time and also Paul Tudor Jones bought it Stanley Druckemiller bought it you know all these people like I don't know if they're wrong then we'll all be wrong together like you know it's kind of like misery loves company type thing that they all got comfortable and finally said yeah let's hit the bid and let's go buy some.
Yeah I think a lot of people are looking at this just it felt like overnight suddenly Larry thinks on like CNBC and he's saying like yeah you know Bitcoin is the future here's our Bitcoin ETF but what they don't realize is there was this confluence of like six years plus of effort and infrastructure that need to be built out in evangelism and like individual brains that had to be like converted and turned onto this and I'm wondering if you could kind of compare and contrast right because you're on sort of the media circuit as well I think in like 20 2017 2018 that time period where I would see you on like CNBC and like Squawk Box and this kind of thing and I that the tone from some of the interviewer sometimes in TragFi was just kind of like what you have what percent of your net worth in crypto like what are you doing like here's this business here's this guy evangelizing about Bitcoin there's almost like kind of a I don't know a smirk in the background of how they used to to approach Bitcoin that is much different now and some of these same anchors that I see in 2024 actually having arguments with Gary with with people like Gary Gensler and people like Jamie Diamond reciting crypto talking points that we used to talk about in 2017 2018 and I know you've kind of revisited some of those similar same shows this cycle what's what's the difference between last time and this time are they taking it more seriously has there been a tone difference as light bulbs clicked on like yeah give us a sense yeah I tell you a couple stories that probably can highlight this so the first time that I got asked to go on television I remember being like bam we did it like like we all made it we convinced them they hear the message and converts of course like we're geniuses like thank you we finally all the work that we've done 2018 I go on television they absolutely rip me a new one price I think we dropped it Bitcoin from 20,000 to like 6,000 right and they're just T and off on me and I remember walking off the set being like oh I was the like punching bag we have not made it guys actually it's the opposite like they we they're laughing at us so does that just make sense as in because like they're not going to report about it on the way up because they're not invested on on the way up and so on the way down they need to be right they need to like take a victory lap yeah on the way up at like late late 2017 I think it's when they really started to cover it there was it's interesting there's a number of people in crypto today I could think of Camila Russo I think also Michael Casey a couple of others like they were working I think maybe both of them worked at Bloomberg and we're actually living or covering currencies in Argentina like 2012 2013 and so they saw Bitcoin earlier there was some of the first people to write about it from like the you know traditional mainstream media whatever and so there were some people who were like kind of looking in and around it but then there was like the talking points and I always like to give Joe wise and Joe wise and thought a hard time because he wrote a piece in 2013 he was like Bitcoin's a joke and the pictures like a clown and then it was that you know a hundred bucks and now it's at 70,000 and so you know you had both sides of it now the second story I'll tell you about 2018 2019 is the second time they invite me on Kevin O'Leary is on the set and on the way there I'm listening to the show and he starts talking about crypto garbage instead of garbage he said garbage at least you guys are a little bit above the garbage but it's still you know nonsense and so to like highlight how these shows sometimes come together as before the shows commercial break I walk out onto the set and him and I have never met before you know he I could be somebody who's super nice I could be a complete asshole he has no clue and we started talking about Bitcoin and he says how how much of your dough is in this and I'm like you know more than 50% and his eyes like fill out of his head the the producer says you know three two one you know we're back to the show Kevin doesn't wait two seconds he just immediately goes how much of your dough is in this right off I say 150% and he just goes on a tirade I forbid you from doing that that is insane and he's like going on and on and on and so I was like oh my god I'm like punching bag number two like this is going to be the difference now today what I will say is if I go on and let's say a crypto kind of skeptic comes on after me I think that the mainstream journalist slash host have gotten really good at is they will actually press me right so like Andrew Ross working in a recent segment he was like look I you know I went to South Africa I talked to a lot of people no one owns this stuff like you guys talk about it being adopted internationally like what do you say and you know I would put folks like that in a camp if they are probably cautiously optimistic like they would like to see it work they actually think it could be a good thing for the world but they're skeptical by nature and they're journalists so their job is to ask you questions that push what you think or what you say and it's not you know it's not an opportunity for you to go and do PR right and so they're doing the job of the journalist but then what happens is if you know let's say Jamie Dimon comes on they then flip around on the table and now all of a sudden they're advocating for the opposite of Jamie Dimon's view so what I think we sometimes as a community get sucked into is like we're all pro these assets and so when they push back or like oh they're so dumb they don't understand but if you actually watch when they're pushing against the critics you have to realize like no they're just doing their job like they're going to play the devil's advocate to whoever's on the show there are some hosts as you guys alluded to that you know they're all in they own it Joe Kernan probably being a great example and so when the host starts to debate each other about it I think we all kind of can you know laugh and say like wow we really maybe maybe we are here now uh where we don't even have to like do the debating which let them debate for us um so so it's night and day difference but um again it's hard to debate against it if Paul Tudor Jones daily drunken Miller Larry Fink you know many well respected smart people I mean part of the cynical view here is um they weren't bullish on it and when I say they I mean tradify and kind of the entire apparatus around traditional finance wasn't bullish on it because they didn't have products to sell they didn't have coin base right yeah and this time they do have products to sell so they've got ETFs the fastest growing ETFs that have like ever been ETFed basically they've got like tokenized treasuries now and uh so like the context for this is in this bull cycle we're in a completely different regime it seems like and what's your perspective on what the Bitcoin ETF did for the legitimacy not only Bitcoin but the entire crypto asset class most people in crypto I think if you would have asked them last year they would have said Bitcoin is a commodity and uh there's not regulatory clarity about these other things so outside of their personal opinion they were like that's how the regulators were looking at it um I don't think traditional finance looked in it that way I think traditional finance and know all these assets don't have regulatory clarity so they kind of put them all together and they didn't have enough information or experience to kind of separate out how the regulators were actually thinking about it or looking at it when the ETFs got approved now everyone walks around and they're like oh the ETFs mean that the regulators have like approved Bitcoin now we all know that's not true it's not like they approved the the asset itself they're not telling people to go buy it but I think that is like a zero to one difference in people's minds so if you work your way down kind of coin market capitalist if a Ethereum ETF gets approved I think tradifiable then say oh the regulators have like blessed this asset etc now one of the questions I think that that comes up in kind of the ETF approvals is Bitcoin has today a lot of unique things some people think those unique things are positive something they're negative so proof of work blockchain there's not that many others that have those specific kind of characters to it so when they approve Bitcoin there's not a long line out the door of people saying well I'm just like Bitcoin I have proof of work I have this I've that whatever you know I should be the next one approved I do think that that is probably one of the headwinds for the ether ETF is that if they approve a proof of stake blockchain there's a lot of other ones like that and they're all going to line up and say hey you know what about me doesn't mean that they have to approve the other ones I think it's just harder now to just decipher between the differences and so then I think lastly is there's a very interesting dynamic of getting exposure to price versus exposure to the asset so most people think of that is like I don't want to have to self-custody this right and so historically it's been like well maybe I can just pay coin base to do custody or whatever but you got to go sign up for a coin base account you got to like figure out is coin base the best one you got to like make sure the assets are still there do reporting whatever but if you go to like the nation states I actually think one of the most interesting parts of the ETF is like now several wealth funds can go and buy Bitcoin price exposure but not have to take custody of the Bitcoin and so what they basically are doing is they're removing the geopolitical conversation because of all of a sudden let's say name your country you know somewhere that maybe is like borderline friend or foe if they start like hoarding Bitcoin I think there's a lot of people going to be asking questions like hey why are you guys like buying the Bitcoin like holding the Bitcoin do you plan to go off the dollar like well like what's up if it centers buying an ETF it's very obvious that you're just getting dollar like like price exposure you're not actually like taking control of the Bitcoin and so the reason why this interesting is like El Salvador is taking self custody of the Bitcoin yeah and like the IMF does not appreciate that right that the central bankers powers that be do not appreciate that fact yeah so like if you think of it from that perspective like the ETFs now have green light uh sovereign wealth funds which I do believe they're buying the ETF and it's just like they're doing it right they put a certain percentage in the S&P they put a certain percentage in QQ they're going to put a certain percentage in gold like it's just an allocation decision they just buy assets yeah I mean if you have a trillion dollars like what are you supposed to buy like you can't just buy a trillion dollars of you know Google right so like you you have to have a different side portfolio whatever but I do think that it now allows for the side stepping of the geopolitical complexity and allows you to get price exposure and so it opens up this conversation of like how much of Wall Street into your point of like now they have a product to sell is they want exposure to the price until like the AUM but they don't give a shit about actual Bitcoin right and so like you know it's kind of like careful what you wish for because yeah you maybe let in the fox in the henhouse um and sure like number goes up but what are the trade-offs and they're probably our trade-offs that we don't yet understand right especially as you get deeper and deeper into some of the complex derivatives and things that can get created on this um I'm sure somebody's going to create a you know two extra three X leverage short Bitcoin ETF like what is the impact of that on price how does rebalancing which tradfi loves like the intellectual you know Olympics for them of like when should you rebalance how often all that kind of stuff like that's new price pressure you know sell pressure in the market so all these things are changing but at least in the beginning price goes up and people are happy yeah we've we've often used the idea that the ETF is the ERC 20 token for tradfi as in it like it makes BTC like a module a money lego for the tradfi world for them to play games with that's their money lego and all of a sudden they can like stack on derivatives and derivatives and derivatives plays the whole like not your keys not your coins thing is like a feature for them it's like please no keys just coins no keys um and so I never heard that but that is fantastic that's the great analogy yeah that's 100% with what the ETF does right yeah so like maybe we can like double click on that for a little bit because I think a bank listeners will totally understand what like money legos are inside of the Ethereum context right you put your token in the protocol and then you put that in a different protocol and now you play your games and you wrap your yield and you optimize your yield uh and now this universe is like being opened up to tradfi with Bitcoin as like the asset and we are just now in like the first inning of Bitcoin getting like introduced into the tradfi world so like what what happens as this whole like ecosystem what does a tradfi money lego ecosystem look like and what was that what would you like the future Bitcoin look like when like they start to like play with their whole like money lego that is Bitcoin the better it is has a like a dark hole the more money they make right so like there's a huge part of uh wall street which is like they actually don't want the retail person to understand the full thing because that means that they can't take fees and all these different components etc but in the most basic sense I think you can think of maybe like three or four examples so like one is like that just buy the ETF so like there's a lego there's not a lego right okay hack about the lego like okay that that's one thing you get price exposure to this asset that is way more asymmetric on the upside in downside than anything else they have and so like that'll be interesting in some components the second thing and I think we're starting to see it now is now I have almost a uh return amplifier so now I could take this ETF thing and I kind of like sprinkle it in all my portfolio so oh I have this like fixed income fund let's put a little bit of Bitcoin let's put three percent of that fund we'll put that in Bitcoin so all my other fixed income like competitors or peers they're all returning eight percent but me at eight percent plus three percent of my fund in Bitcoin I never turned nine and a half percent I'm the better fixed income portfolio I go out and I pitch I outperform everyone look how smart I am you're buying a fixed income but really it's the Bitcoin doing the work to outperform the market versus uh the actual asset so I think we're starting to see some of that happening fatalities doing it black rocks talking about it etc um the third thing that I think is going to start to happen is you are going to start to see all the financial products being built in and around Bitcoin not necessarily because of the ETF explicitly but because now people are going to realize wait a second there is this asset that is now going to get swallowed into the the legacy system and so there's an example of um there's a company called meanwhile uh they are building a Bitcoin life insurance policy and the entire business is based in Bermuda it's a regulated life insurance company just like you would see anywhere else um and I recently met these guys and and I was like man it's so smart the company is uh denominated everything in Bitcoin revenue uh expenses uh their balance sheet assets liabilities uh the amount of the policy like everything is nominated in Bitcoin including when they give reports to people it's such everything's in Bitcoin so that's a good example of like okay well if I'm in the life insurance business in the traditional financial world and somehow I can like again sprinkle Bitcoin in somewhere I could either dive in the deep end or I could just sprinkle uh some of this in maybe I can sell more life insurance policies like that becomes a really interesting you know to use your guys words like a Lego that gets kind of put into the this world and so you can go through every single part of the traditional financial system and I think you're going to see people trying to do this and it's because what ends up occurring is there's this coalition of all the products become the same right there's there's like uh uh lack of uniqueness in these financial products so when you go by the S&P what is the difference between one S&P you know fund versus another maybe the fees are like five basis points difference but at the end of the day like you're just buying the S&P right sure made it some tracking difference but like for the average person there's buying the S&P but if all of a sudden you can show up and say oh we give you S&P exposure and we outperform by 200 basis points because by the way we sprinkled three to five percent of Bitcoin in here now you have a differentiator and so uh in the short to medium term the differentiator everyone will lean into over the long run everyone's going to sprinkle it everywhere and then it's going to all become not unique again and we're going to kind of be back to square one they're going to find a new shiny thing to try to play this game with this is interesting because this really the institutions coming into into Bitcoin into crypto marks kind of like a new milestone for us and it's sort of like it's interesting that it's happening in the 2020s and kind of like the second decade of this entire experiment I want to double click on on your comment earlier be careful what you wish for and the fox in the henhouse because this is really interesting to me on the one hand having the institutions come into crypto and the big banks and Larry think in black rock and eventually Jamie Diamond will cave you know we will you know like JP Morgan will come in breast them will come in that feels good because it is legitimizing of like all assets will be tokenized this is a real out it and it provides kind of a heat shield against like what I think we in crypto called the final boss which is like eventually nation states and the actual central bankers might wake up and look at this and say do we really want a non sovereign monetary instrument being like free like is that really good for our fiat money system or is that kind of enemy and when we recruit the institutions we get kind of a heat shield against that we get kind of some protection because you know Larry think that their institutions are going to be in their lobbying and say where I'm making money here it's not that bad we can kind of like you know tame the nails off of this off of this tiger and it can be something manageable so on the one hand I see it as good on the other hand I'm kind of worried that it does start to you know a road what has made crypto and what has made Bitcoin very special which is it's a it's a peer-to-peer money system you can own your own keys and have your own private keys you don't have to have it with a third party custodian at all it's not fractionalized so you know exactly how much Bitcoin is out there and that could start to a road in fact like people like Ben Hunt have been on our podcasts and they basically say you know the nation states are never going to let you guys do this peer-to-peer monetary experiment thing okay they're going to like write you into a corner of the script and place you over here and you're not actually going to have the free money that you guys think you're going to have and I worry about that a little bit with the institutions coming in is are they going to say corrupt it or make it much more like the banking system that we just left well what are some of your reflections on that because on the one hand it seems like a nice problem to have because the entire first decade of our existence we were just worried that we would get strangled in the in the crib and now like we're too big for that they can't just shut the whole thing down but on the other hand now I'm more worried about kind of like the the corruption of the system and that we become a bit too tradfy and like too banker and then we lose the things that make Bitcoin and crypto special yeah if you think you know keep your friends close keep your enemies closer right it's kind of like what they're doing and so to some degree yeah Wall Street if they can wrap their hand or their arms around an entire industry that ends up being more beneficial to them what I would say is for the technology platforms the assets etc that are actually decentralized owning a large portion of the coins will not give them any you know new power that the system doesn't give to other people so you know if you use Bitcoin as the example if you own one Bitcoin or you own 60% of the Bitcoin that's in circulation you have the same power right in terms of the system itself now obviously you have more money so there's economic gain but but in terms of being able to change the protocol or anything that that doesn't really matter so I do think that it is kind of this weird thing where decentralization will get put on a pedestal to be more important because you want to be able to have the governance outside of the system regardless of what the system does but yeah any time that you have something of value like the people with the money are going to want the valuable thing right so like naturally you need that now another interesting idea is being a contrarian forever is actually a bad plan you want to be a contrarian and then become the consensus that is where value is right so like for the first 15 years of Bitcoin buying Bitcoin was deemed in you know whatever circles that you kind of went in a contrarian thing but as it becomes more and more consensus you will see a direct overlay with increase in US dollar exchange price so what you actually want if you own a lot of Bitcoin is you want it to become consensus because then that means that it is getting monetized is becoming more valuable in dollar terms now the hard part of this is as you push out on kind of the risk curve or push down you know coin market capitalists or whatever is how many of these assets aspire to be something that Wall Street will find valuable versus they are actually trying to solve something else and so the example I always give is like if you're a technology platform so I would put you know a theory of Solana many other kind of smart contract platforms it's like they are competing in some form or fashion to have cheap fees be fast serve you guys a building blocked for these applications etc Wall Street has usually said well we want to get exposure to a sector right we want to actually buy a couple of these companies etc so like those probably get pulled in as well so you have money in or kind of digital gold you didn't kind of the smart contract platforms but like the meme coins probably don't get pulled in right it's something that is distinct and different and so it's like Wall Street and what they're trying to accomplish is not looking for exposure to those and in between you know Bitcoin and smart contract platforms and then call the meme coins there's a whole bunch of other stuff and right now I think what the industry is going through is we're trying to figure out like well what does the large capital pools find valuable and so if you go to you know kind of like the deep in space I think a lot of us are like etc has pretty cool like you change economic incentives you have these new systems like things are are soon to be working and I've been surprised at times to hear some of the large hedge fund managers mentioned by name things like helium like it's some of the I've seen like annual reports with you know interviews something I'm like wow I did not think you know somebody would would be talking about that on the other hand you start to think to yourself are they aware of it because actually they're huge investors in T mobile or AT&T and in the boardroom they're like how do we you know kill this thing like this is a threat to our business and and I don't know the answer but I do think that it is something that we need to be aware of and where I think you want to allocate capital is to things that have a monopoly of position so for example Bitcoin be having a monopoly on this idea of like digital money or you want to make investments in things where your open your eyes are open to I am headed into a competition and I think that this technology this platform this asset can win that competition right so like today if you're investing in I don't know an e-commerce platform and you don't realize that you're competing against Amazon and Shopify like you're pretty much screwed right but if you think that you're investing in the next great e-commerce platform that can unseat Amazon and Shopify that's a whole different analysis and a different idea and so I think that's really right now where people are still looking at it as like we're competing in the crypto industry but now I actually think you've got to look at it as like winning the crypto industry competition it has to be almost an afterthought it has to be can we win in the free market of ideas crypto and non crypto and that's actually where the majority of the value is going to a crypto yeah you're just saying that the markets are actually starting to blur between the crypto markets and the trademarks now this is just becoming one gigantic playing field where now the world of crypto economics is now entering in the world of like call it like normal startup normal society normal products as we progress like we kind of open up this conversation pop talking about you as like Bitcoin's evangelist back back when Bitcoin was contrarian and now it's consensus now it's entering the world in which like everyone is like not skipping over one and getting into 3% of their portfolio right which you know is a meaningful amount what does the world have in store what does the world need out of a Bitcoin evangelist in the year of 2024 or like is your work a done like what what does being a Bitcoin evangelist in 2024 mean these days yeah I mean the Bitcoiners hated I have the best position of all in all of crypto which is play half of the Bitcoiners hate me because they are not 100% Bitcoin and then most of the other market maybe half of them hate me because I talk too much about Bitcoin and not enough about whatever the thing is that they're excited about or the you know the the bag they want to chill or whatever and so yeah I'm sure right and look and actually a lot of times like that's a good position to be in the example I always give is like when I was talking about Bitcoin a lot of times what I noticed was I would go talk to Wall Street and Wall Street investors would be like Bitcoin is the single most risky thing that I would put my portfolio and then I go talk to like somebody in you know crypto DGN and they're like dude that's boomercoin like what are you talking like nobody owns Bitcoin right and so like sitting in between the like most conservative and the most risky person actually maybe like an interesting spot to sit um and and so when it comes to like Bitcoin evangelist I do think that it is important to kind of have this like passing of the torch and if you said to me today like the most important Bitcoin evangelist is Larry Fink I've joked it like he's the CMO of Bitcoin now right and like him going on national television saying oh people are buying Bitcoin it's a flight to quality the messenger matters so much he can repeat the same things that all of us have been saying for you know a decade nobody cares it's that Larry Fink said when Larry says it yeah of course and he's earned that right because of his track record and his experience and all the things he's done but so I think that's one is like it may not be so much like what is the message as much as who is the messenger at this point and the second thing that I would say is I've always thought that the single greatest evangelist of Bitcoin is the no named kind of you know average Bitcoin user and the reason why I say that is because they have experiences and they have a story that is impossible for anyone to argue with right if I go on Twitter and I tweet something people will just be like oh look it's moron right he owns the Bitcoin he wants it to go higher he's just an asshole you know and he's got a Twitter and like regardless of whether it's true not true whatever it's like easy to yell at the people who are just like talking about it sitting in America etc but if you go to another country and you talked to someone and they're like oh my local currency collapsed and like I own some Bitcoin by the way I also want dollars right but I do own some Bitcoin and that Bitcoin has protected some portion of my economic value from devaluation like you can't argue with that person right it's just like okay like that is your lived experience so I do think that like the beauty of Bitcoin and kind of the node operators and the like network itself being peer-to-peer and decentralized etc that also is true from an evangelist standpoint now I will issue a word of caution which I have said many times before and people you know don't listen I think that you have to be careful not to fall into the religion and what I mean by that is there it's true in Bitcoin it's true in other communities as well but I think part of what ends up happening with Bitcoin is people start to get a very rigid mind and so like I said to you like what is the quintessential Bitcoin right it's like okay they own Bitcoin they eat meat they like sun their balls right you we can just like go down 11 I don't I don't I want a real thing yeah I mean you get you get T from doing that yeah you get higher testosterone like this whole thing right and now I say that you know right I didn't know it's like you got a tan going on there it so like if you think of it from that perspective right it's like okay by the way like living a healthier lifestyle exercising eating healthy like I'm on board right all good but when you start to then say I am going to judge other people for not subscribing to the exact you know regiment and protocol that I have for my life it's dangerous and so what I think is starting to occur to some degree is you get this ossification of a of a philosophy and of a community on one hand that's really good the fact that 21 million Bitcoin will be 21 million Bitcoin forever and if anyone ever tries to change that like there will be a you know a digital eruption of defense from kind of the Bitcoiners is a positive thing the fact that there has been a slowdown and innovation in Bitcoin is probably not a good thing right and so how do you kind of measure these things I don't claim to have the answer right but I do think that it's important to not fall into kind of the religion and so what ends up happening also is if you look at well some of the Bitcoin development Bitcoin are borrowing a lot of ideas from Ethereum Solana L2s NFTs you know stable coins like you go down this whole line and so the most and those always the plan too yeah I mean look for years people have said like hey that's all R&D for Bitcoin right like whether it's true or not I think there's a lot of people who thought that but if you go talk to like the most hardcore Bitcoiners in terms of like the religious fanatics or the zealots they will literally tell you that there will never all these other blockchains will not exist if you look at this maybe softened Bitcoin review it's like look these other blockchains may exist but maybe I don't believe the coins will have long-term value if you then soften a little bit more it's like hey you know what like these other things are like basically tech startups the blockchains will exist the coins may or may not have value but like I'm just focused on Bitcoin and so that spectrum of like how hardcore are you what I found in investing is that actually you want to have deep conviction but you want to have a flexible mind in terms of like a positive some experience so you can be a very hardcore believer like Bitcoin is going to survive I one time on television said if I had to bet my life on one thing it'd be that Bitcoin would remain resilient and the TV host had a blast with that but at the same time it's not so locked in on the high conviction of this one thing that you then think everything else is zero right and so it does crack me up a little bit with kind of the Bitcoin evangelist conversation um there are people who showed up like if you remember like more than half of Bitcoiners showed up in 2020 or later so like everything we're talking about 2016 to 2017 to 2020 like they don't know right they don't have that context so when they hear like oh I mind a theory I'm first shock some of them or the idea of you have the other phrase that I used to say all the time is tokenize the world and they're like oh pop what do you know Larry Fink said tokenization now you're going to start talking about it I'm like I fucking taught Larry Fink about that right right like like like it's just the context isn't there and by the way where did I get that idea from somebody else who was talking about it right so it wasn't my idea I didn't come up with it and so I do think that there's this element of like are you trying to create a religion or are you trying to understand how the world is evolving and you're willing to have kind of a flexibility um I don't have a perfect balance but I try to be more in understanding where the world is going then you know falling into the religion I think that's a good like at some level what's what's great about this and what's great about you know your superpower of being able to simplify communication to like this mimetic one-liner is you can sort of plant the meme and then let it grow somewhere else and you can pass the torch as you say you don't need to be the primary evangelist forever because if Larry Fink adopts the meme of tokenize the world or like get off zero or whatever else that's been implanted then I mean that's already like the programming is done I I I am curious your thoughts because one theme that we've been tracking over the past year or so is sort of this Bitcoin Renaissance theme of all these Bitcoin builders and you are right I mean it does seem to be there's this division in Bitcoin culture around like Bitcoin fundamentalists let's call them that don't want to build anything on the chain you know like what's the purpose of Bitcoin you know 21 million hard cap and like digital gold and get out of my block space you know the block spaces for Bitcoin transactions that's it that's what Satoshi meant there's this other tribe with Bitcoiners who are like F that I'm building stuff I'm doing a layer two's we'll do NFTs this is kind of a Bitcoin Renaissance tribe and we've seen some fracturing in the community of like Bitcoin favorite starlings leaders like Nick Carter for instance you know the Udi's of the world you know even Eric Wall they're kind of shunned by the the fundamentalists it sounds like you come in on the side of like I'm I'm like a pragmatic investor who just loves Bitcoin right and like what do you what do you make of this what do you make of the Bitcoin Renaissance you think that's a good thing do you have any input into these culture wars or just try to stay above them I don't worry so much about the culture war as much as maybe like you know the L2s the side chains the NFTs like all the stuff on top of Bitcoin my default is that they won't work because the probability of new things working is near zero right I mean just look at startup success rates and things like that but I think that the work is important because the only way we're going to know is if somebody tries or not right so like it's not you know a good example is the creation of a theorem or salon or whatever the different architecture like we don't know does it work or not until somebody tries it and so I do think that progress is made through experimentation like innovation is driven through not ideas but actual execution and that is what we want like there is a group of people who believe that we can build things on top of Bitcoin and use it for something other than just money if they are correct that is probably a multi trillion dollar opportunity if they are wrong then what's the worst that happens Bitcoin remains digital gold and you know they wasted some time and money like pretty good trade off right it's a kind of like one x downside you know thousands of x upside um and so yeah I do think the experimentation so I'm like almost like an experimentation maximalist in terms of like if we want innovation we have to keep trying things what I think it ends up being interesting to me is that many of the people who have become kind of the hardened Bitcoin maximalist and kind of really dug their heels in on the culture war many of them go about communication in a very unique way maybe is is one way to put it and so um I always just again learn from history there are very few people who have been able to build highly successful things over a long period of time by being very abrasive to other people there's a time and a place for it right doesn't mean that you can't tell people they're wrong or or whatever but I do think that like that is one component and then the other thing is um I always wonder like the people who are attacking other folks how much have they actually built themselves because in my experience uh there's two things that are true in the world people who are doing more than you one was never attack you right like it like they like they don't punch down people usually only punch up they don't punch down and the second thing is that uh people who build things and have rammed their heads against the wall for a long period of time uh they actually know how hard it is to do this and so they tend to be much more sympathetic to people who are trying things and it's kind of like you know maybe tramos like the man in the arena uh type thing uh without the meme um so when you see all the attacking and the craziness the other thing people in the Bitcoin community don't realize it's like I mean the same thing happens in Ethereum same thing happens in the slotted community same thing happens in these others it's a human nature thing um it's not unique to the Bitcoin community but what I do think is the breakthroughs happened to the people who can kind of tune that stuff out and they just say look I don't care what other people think like it's you know it's science either I get the technology to work or I don't what other people's opinions are don't really matter um and I think that both as a country in the United States as a society and also in these communities of return back to you know people kind of being uh somewhat uh disagreeable and just saying look I'm gonna try what I want to try uh probably would benefit all of us this is definitely something that we've been experiencing I think in in the Ethereum land uh or at least I have seen starting to emerge there there are there's like a tribe of Ethereum people out there who are starting to like just repeat a script that I personally kind of consider outdated just like it's like script players they're just like kind of repeating a script they're not really live players uh and uh and I think like you let's say you said this is likely true for all layer one communities this is like the weird novel thing that crypto is already weird to begin with we have these weird blockchain things we have these weird private keys like all the tech things that make thing that make crypto weird but the really weird thing about it is like the social tribes that come with the entire industry and how incredibly social this this industry is and I don't know if um tradfi really understands that side of things or knows even knows about that and this is something that I don't think as a like human arc of our species has really ever encountered we we never really have had these like very social tribal financial assets that have collided with what is previously just cold hard rigid calculated analysis usually DCF uh you know analysis and and so like there's this world colliding maybe it's not colliding maybe it is colliding I that's kind of what I want your perspective on pomp is we have this this old world of tradfi which does not understand tribes nor do they care yet nonetheless like this new thing that is now emerging and colliding with the tradfi world is this very like social layer based technology where like what what is the final backstop of all of these layer one blockchains the respective social layer the respective tribe that supporting each each system and I think you can't really go to Larry fink and be like Larry fink let me tell you about the layer zero it's the thing that supporting your BT the value of BTC the asset he's not going to know about that is not going to be care about that yet nonetheless these things are like colliding do you have any just any thoughts or reflections on this yeah so I would push back and say that Wall Street definitely understands tribes I would even argue that Wall Street invented the like financial tribes so you know value investors versus like growth investors those guys been arguing for a hundred years right they're still they're still arguing they're still you know which ones better whatever there's this great story of Bill Miller who you know it is a very famous investor owns a lot of Bitcoin at one point he was the largest individual shareholder of Amazon because when the stock dropped after the 2000 kind of tech bust he was buying and bought like 15% of a company or something and there's a book written about Bill and in it he got shunned from the value investor community because he was buying tech stocks and his point was like value investing is not a sector it's just I buy things for less than than what they're worth and so I've evaluated that a company is worth x it's you know x minus whatever is what it's trading at today I'm buying it that is a value investment but the like classical you know value investors were like no dude you didn't buy the textile company or you didn't buy the you know whatever kind of traditional like this p p ratios right yeah of course so like in a weird way now they all did it with like suits ties Rolexes and Cologne on so you know they're much more cordial they weren't dropping memes on each other's heads and like screaming yelling Twitter spaces so it was like you know a different warfare maybe or competition but I do think that there were tribes the other thing that is unique is they didn't have the communication methods so like I do think a lot about you know in warfare historically there was like the what they called mechanized army so this is like we're gonna show up with tons of soldiers with you all these different army tanks and stuff and we're gonna like invade your country think you know America going into Iraq in 2003 we are amazing at invading countries there is not a country in the world that we can't invade and successfully you know kind of claim victory we're horrible at sticking around and fighting insurgencies because by nature and insurgencies really hard it's like this loose decentralized network of people they don't wear uniform they have all these communication tools that the US can't really fight back etc so it's very difficult to do if you think about what crypto is crypto has a lot of the same similarities in the sense of like we have Twitter this is like this decentralized swarm of people if somebody says something right you know look at the legislation a legislative thing gets proposed and we don't like it people come out of the woodwork I've never seen us coordinate better and go across kind of quote unquote party lines then when there's some sort of legislation that threatens the crypto you have Bitcoiners you have Ethereum folks you have Solana folks you have NFT folks you have everyone they line up and they say how do we work together but it's this weird thing where it's because there's an attack coming from outside and so Michael Aarrington one time told me the story which I thought was great the tech industry he created tech crunch and he would write these articles and you know I'll claim that Michael was writing with a sharp tongue so he didn't mince words if you thought your products like he said it sucks right if you thought it was amazing you'd say it was amazing whatever and at some point somebody attacked him from outside the tech industry and the tech industry basically rallied around him is like hey he might be an asshole but he's our asshole right like he's on our side and I think that crypto is a lot like that now what Wall Street I think is learning is that there's immense power in the coordination and communication of these folks on the internet game stop is kind of an example that I think they really saw first but now all of a sudden they look at Bitcoin and they're like wait a minute 70% of these guys didn't sell when it dropped from 69000 to 15 and went back to 78000 these people are insane and if you ask yourself like why did they not sell it's because we have access to information we have a community like a support group when it went down to 15000 you can get on mine if you be like it's okay like it's gonna come back right like you're not sitting there and the only communication you have was like your telephone right and you'd have to like dial someone's number to like call for support rather than you know sell a stop there's there's Bitcoin church in session every single minute of every single day yeah so so I just think like all these dynamics are like feeding into this idea that like we're more connected than ever we're more educated than ever and if you can build long-term conviction and avoid short-term action being hyper connected and hyper educated is actually an advantage the downside to this is like if you get on Twitter every day and based on sentiment you buy and sell like you're you're gonna lose money right you're gonna get screwed and so it's like use it for the long-term education and conviction and just avoid the like nonsense where you know what what do people say yesterday we're recording and the inflation numbers came out and people like I survived the CPI recession from you know 815 to 1215 yesterday or whatever literally you know we woke up in the morning everyone's happy inflation comes out everyone's like you know down in the dumps for four hours then all of a sudden everyone's back again and it's just like yeah you can talk yourself into doing all kinds of stupid stuff if you pay attention you know too closely mantle formerly known as bit down is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem all built on top of mantle's first core product the mantle network a brand new high-performance Ethereum layer two built using the OP stack but uses eigenlayers data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one not only does this reduce mantle networks gas fees by 80 percent but it also reduces gas fee volatility providing a more stable foundation for mantle's applications the mantle treasury is one of the biggest Dow owned treasuries which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for mantle mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboarded like game 7 for Web3 gaming and buy it for TVL and liquidity and on-rounds so if you want to build on the mantle network mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand secure and decentralized mantle if you want to get started working with the first Dow-led ecosystem check out mantle at mantle.
xyz and follow them on twitter at 0x mantle are you launching a token is it already live how are you managing the legal and tax obligations for providing token grants to your team it's no secret that token management gets complicated between learning all the legal language and tax obligations in every country that your team is in token grant management can feel like an obstacle course but it doesn't have to that's where toku steps in toku provides practical tools to handle token grants allowing for effective oversight of token distributions and payroll tax compliance for employees contractors advisors and investors they also handle tax withholdings through their real-time tax calculations that can be done by toku or integrated into any payroll EOR providers in any jurisdiction toku is a trusted provider of protocol labs dydx foundation mean a protocol and many more get started for free and make token compensation simple at toku.
com slash bankless have you heard about safe they're not just pioneers in crypto custody they're also leading the transition to the world of smart accounts with safe managing your crypto has never been smarter or safer they've recently passed a hundred billion dollars in total value secured and are now deployed everywhere with over 15 supported networks but that's not all safe is revolutionizing the game with their full compatibility with ERC 4337 making embedding wallets super easy to integrate into your daily crypto activities so what are you waiting for head over to safe dot global to join over eight million others into carrying your crypto and while you're there don't forget to check out safe con happening during the burlin blockchain week where the future of smart accounts is unfolding in real life secure your spot today and be a part of the transition to smart accounts click the link in the show notes to learn more and take your first steps towards smarter crypto management palm do you think how do you think the us is doing like with respect to to crypto and i'm talking about kind of our governors our governments like this is us the nation state as a whole like how is it reacting to the rise of crypto because like there's one school of thought where oh my god this is a threat to us dollar like sovereignty and we're worried about disrupt disrupting the banks and all of these things aml k yc all of that right there's another school of thought versus like the us has always been a tech leader i mean built silicon valley led the way in the internet during the 1990s this is a massive opportunity this is a free open permissionless system right this is uh it's something that a democratic country can actually export to the world and and make it better how would you evaluate how the us is doing so far on crypto what do you think they should do because there's also this anti tech backlash i'm starting to see it's not just in crypto it's an a i too i worry about this yeah there's a lot to unpack here so um let me just throw out a couple of ideas the first is the tech backlash uh is really happening for two reasons uh folks who feel like they are falling behind don't like when they see other people succeeding or getting ahead and so in the 80s and 90s they went after wall street and hedge funds and and folks who uh they seems uh to be on the pedestal there being you know celebrated by uh the media and movies and and content etc and so it was like if you were in the hedge fund industry we hate you and that culminated with you know zucati park and occupy wall street and global financial crisis etc there was a shift somewhere between the 2000s and 2010s where the new like boogie monster became tech and some of their complaints or critiques of industry are true like there is suppression of speech there is censorship there is you know tipping of the scale in in some cases etc so i just think that it was like they saw tech people making money i actually think the social network had a positive and negative impact on society in a positive way it inspired an entire generation of people want to go become entrepreneurs and technologists and that's a really good thing on the negative side it basically opened up an entire country's eyes to the fact that tech was making money and then they put the target on their back and everyone said hey let's go attack them so i think that is just a natural thing crypto actually i think will become that thing as prices continue to go up like it's going to go wall street to tech to like crypto will now be the new boogie man when i think of america i'll give you a great example which is i was at an event last night and somebody asked me you know or they asked a panel and they said at what point will the government consider bitcoin mining critical infrastructure and there's a couple of panelists and they had very intelligent answers and i agree with everything that they said but when it became my turn to answer i said you know i want to be careful i think we want this stuff to be critical infrastructure but we don't want it to be recognized as critical infrastructure and i said you know critical infrastructure gets translated inside of the government as infrastructure overseen by communist right critical infrastructure we all think like oh that's amazing but if you think about the Baltimore bridge that just collapsed i don't think it's going to get rebuilt right by the time they get done with the environmental studies they get done with all the DEI stuff when they get done with you know the plans and the procedures and then probably a corruption or two you know investigations like all these like it's never going to get rebuilt but like bridges or critical infrastructure and so in a weird way the closer that you pull what should be entrepreneur or innovative technologies and industries to the government you pull it more into a bureaucracy and so when it's happening is this idea of critical infrastructure the things labeled critical infrastructure are actually our least innovative areas there's the ones that make the least progress and so what we want is we want to create things that are hyper valuable to people but we actually want them to remain as close to the private industry as we can not the public industry and the reason why i use that as kind of a a mental framework is when we think about policy when i see a legislative bill or i talk to a policy maker i a politician a regulator etc i always ask myself the things that they are talking about how much of it is they are trying to pull these things into their apparatus pull these into the bureaucracy versus they are trying to create a box for the private market to play in that is fair safe etc and the truth is nothing is black and white so sometimes they bill or a proposal could be you know 80% you know good-hearted and there's like this 20% piece you're like oh that's gonna pull it into the bureaucracy that's gonna hurt it and so what i think we've seen specific to crypto is most of the politicians who are against it are trying to pull it into the apparatus they're trying to pull into the bureaucracy and what they want to do is pull it close and then kill it right but you got to pull it close to kill it what i think most of the proponents want to do is they're basically standing there they're trying to shield their peers or their colleagues from touching it and like let let this thing grow like let the innovation occur these people are smart don't they'll figure it out better than the government will where i think we end up is probably somewhere in the middle and so if you do think about like one of the things the united states government from a structural standpoint over centuries now has been is no one administration or president can have a drastic negative impact for more than eight to ten years so people dove can make stupid decisions they can have a negative impact for you know during their their kind of administration but then another president comes in and if it was a really bad decision usually it's from the other party they kind of roll stuff back they change it whatever the idea of checks and balances kind of the three parts of the government right all those things i think really kind of help and so if you look at like bitcoin bitcoin actually has three parts to the quote unquote governance of bitcoin you have the developers you've got the miners you've got the node operators and so there's a lot of similarities what i do wonder though is do some of the politicians regulators or policy makers believe that they actually have unilateral controller oversight over this stuff and i think what we've found across time is that that unilateral controller oversight is actually really negative and so if i had to give us a grade right now i would say that um we have done things to slow the adoption and innovation of these technologies inside the united states but despite that we still have incredible progress that's been made and one of my favorite data points to share with policy makers and especially the economic folks is crypto may now be too big to fail for the us dollar and when people is looking like what do you mean that's crazy stable coins have extended the reign of the dollar and global adoption of the dollar in a way that the us government and the us dollar kind of in the in you know the electronic form was never going to do also the stablecoin issuers are now like the 14th or 15th largest holder of us treasuries and we're living in a world today where china and japan used to buy 22% of us dead they now buy 7% so who is going to buy our debt well actually in this very weird way the rest of the world is being dollarized by stablecoins it starts off small now we're at over 100 billion it'll eventually be over a trillion and their currencies that they are buying these dollar stablecoins in is being converted to us debt and so if you want to have buyers of us debt in the future stablecoins may be one of the single most important innovations that has come out of the last 15 years and so when you start to talk about it from that perspective all of a sudden everyone kind of you know the knives go away right they say okay hold on a second here I don't want to kill something that's helping me but what I don't want and rightfully so is I don't want criminals I don't want money laundering I don't want terrorist financing I don't want easy and horrible things and so that's the challenge that policymakers have is now they're starting to see positive impact and so they've got to be aware of that and understand we don't want to kill everything but how do you still get at the thing that's kind of metastaticizing on the industry and it's hard and I don't know if they'll figure it out so I totally agree with that take by the way which is like I think this is another sort of idea that we're like talking about right now it's kind of front running I don't think that the US government apparatus really understands how much they actually need stablecoins and they do actually need them because it is the best way to export US debt treasuries the best way to find a buyer like I think people don't realize that you look at something like tether it's basically it's treasuries it's all US debt underneath the covers and if you start to put like the pieces together where black rock just recently launched a middle fund on a theorem for instance and circle has recently integrated with that people can convert directly on chain from treasuries to stablecoins that to me is like just a bandwidth pipeline to get more treasuries into stablecoins and more of this on to crypto the government at some point is going to wake up and realize that crypto is not a threat the US dollar sovereignty it's like the bailout for US dollar sovereignty because this is the way you actually export it to all of the different countries that need it now I do think a byproduct of that though pop is these other countries who want to maintain their own fiat currency sovereignty they're going to start putting walls up right they don't necessarily when you when you talk to kind of like the CEO of tether pop low like his concern is some of these countries even the EU for instance putting up walls against stablecoins against the dollar because they don't want to let the dollar in because it acts as an apex predator for their local currency and so I think we'll see some of that too which is going to make this really interesting I am I'm curious your your perspective on this pop so we're on the other side of a bear market we're all feeling good it's like the middle of a bull run and we all think things are going to to go higher but I feel like sometimes bear markets are actually the best time to learn things as an investor right bear markets make us better what what did you learn in the last bear market the bear market of 2022 2023 there's obviously all of these frauds all these scams we saw algorithmic stablecoins go to zero what were the takeaways for you and the learning lessons it may not be a popular one but my most important lesson was that laser eyes can be incredibly focusing and clarifying but they also can be blinding so some people need laser eyes to focus other people are blinded by them and I think that it goes back to our conversation around you know are you how far into the religion are you and can you actually have the flexibility of mine so I was one of the big lessons the second thing that I would say that I learned is I spent a lot of time understanding the intersection of these technologies and kind of the broader market and I've built some pretty deep conviction you know in terms of where some value will accrue there and then the third thing is I think we now have entered this era where the industry is mature enough that there are certain things that occur in other industries around services or products that we have not had in crypto because it was too small or it didn't really matter then now are becoming kind of key components to help these organizations the organizations are big enough now they have the budgets and the needs and all of that and so we spent a lot of time building companies as well to try to fit those needs and so if you look at those three things it's like my conviction on Bitcoin has never been higher I actually think Bitcoin has been de-risked right it's like price goes higher it gets de-risk which means more people will buy it so the price goes higher and it gets de-risk more it's like a very interesting thing I think that there is this element of the blending between crypto and these other markets and then the last one is we almost are like we're in high school now maybe like we were in elementary school they were in middle school now we're in high school we we're trying to go to college right like I think we'll get to college and then eventually we get to be like a full grown adult and you know Bitcoin's a million bucks and you know all these other assets at value whatever but when you get to you know high school now all of a sudden like you could drive a car you have a cell phone right like like there's things that come along with I think the industry is now at the point where like there's certain things that we need which is good it shows that we're maturing what about your own focus pump because the focus of me and Ryan are as these are our arc in the crypto space actually he's not like terribly off from years as well podcasts in the space also investing in the space how has your focus or your interest changed and adapted over the cycles and because like as we are all navigating and understanding what crypto is we are also all growing as humans so maybe this question is also a little bit more just like selfish I'm a little bit more interested on the personal side of things but like what are your goals as you are now entering like your third cycle you've seen a thing or two you have both interest in crypto but also a life to live so how has your focus changed how has your priorities changed as you've gone throughout your years yeah um I don't know if I have it all figured out why I know I don't have it all figured out I would say that there's maybe two or three things that I know are true for myself one of them is I started my career building companies and I still think that of myself as that's my main focus those companies can be you know what we would think of as traditional companies or they can be an asset management firm but but really spending a lot of time doing that and I enjoy it and find intellectual stimulation from kind of the challenge of trying to build stuff you could also think of a podcast is just like another company right it's just like you got to find what's the product who's going to end up consuming this how do I make money with it all that stuff I think that there's a focus on once you become long term convicted in this is an asset class and you've kind of made your bets um you start to optimize for different things so it's like very weird night and without getting too philosophical I think a lot of people who have had any sort of financial success they start to kind of be like okay like what else do I care about you know and I have a friend who's incredibly wealthy and he one time told me a story where uh I think it was like I don't know half a million bucks or something they make this decision and he basically was like it's not gonna change my life I remember just being like oh okay like that is like a level of a decision I remember I was I don't know like 27 years old when he told me this right now I'm like dude I mean I would do a lot of things for five hundred thousand dollars right now right like I don't have a lot of money so like you know what that that's like I can't fathom that that place in life and as you kind of get older and kind of life changes um I think you start to understand that more right and so that that's been a big piece of it um and then the other thing too is uh that kind of like as an extension of that is I get a lot of enjoyment out of helping other people um and so a lot of the companies that we start we probably give an outsized amount of ownership to the partners that we have and the thought process just being like yeah look you know I have a certain reputation we're bringing capital and distribution like all these things we've done it a bunch of times etc somebody else may ask for you know a very large majority of the business we tend to revert back to like now which be 50 50 right like like that's actually kind of fair and um we could get more but um there's this great Ken Langan quote where he says I never do a deal without making sure that I left more on the table for the other person right and it's kind of just like as long as they feel like they're getting something that there's value there but then what I find is um in helping them be successful we end up being successful and so a lot of that you know it is kind of a mindset change where um as an investor you intuitively know and I put money into a company I want that company to be successful the company is successful I'll make money but then when you start to think about it in all facets of your life you know we have folks who works for some of our businesses especially young folks um it's unclear like why would I spend you know five hours a month with them trying to help them with like career development when I know that they're not going to be here in a year but then what I've learned over time is like well that person ends up being a representation of you as they go out into the world that person ends up you know 20 years from now they send you a deal right or whatever so it's just like just like be a good contributor to kind of the ecosystem and try to help people um and if you do those three things I think that you can end up in a pretty good spot um and then if you said to me like what am I optimizing for at this point um on the professional side I just have this very deeply held belief that capitalism and entrepreneurship can solve our problems so if you look at the problems that the country faces or or our society faces like many of them can be solved through capitalism and entrepreneurship and people are always like what do you mean uh how do you solve homelessness well like you get people jobs right you get them off the street you you helped them financially like you put them in a better position people are like well uh you know what about uh income uh inequality well it's like well that is like literally the definition of a financial education problem right is if people invest versus save in dollars like that you close the gap if you look at uh things like housing affordability like we just need to build more houses like that is the answer and it's super simple there's a whole bunch of reasons why we don't do it but like we just got to build more houses if we build more houses like houses will become more affordable and so when when you have that kind of lens um you start to think through like what are the problems that are worth tackling and like how can I uh help the hard part and maybe the the word of caution i you know cost of time remind myself is if you've had any degree of success in building companies and you have this like level of ambition to like go try to help solve these problems you have to be very carefully don't get pulled too thin and you try to do too many of them um and I actually think we see that in crypto a lot right like how many people should have a portfolio of like five assets but they have like 50 how many people are like i'm in 17 dals and you're like yeah how do you possibly you know doing anything um and so i think it's true you know in all facets of life but there's a small top my head that i've uh kind of learned to optimize around you know that life trajectory kind of i have you ever heard uh naval i think he's got a tweet that says this i'm gonna paraphrase it just like when when you're starting out you start out as a mercenary uh and then you become a missionary we get older and you make it you become an artist so it's like mercenary missionary and then artist feels like that's been like part of your true directory as well and um like i feel like that for myself too it's about at first you just got to make it yeah and then you can start to drive more meaning and figure out how to give back and like the causes you care about and maybe at the end i haven't reached this phase you just become a a freaking artist i'm bad i'm bad at art in all forms i don't know if i'll ever make it there i don't need a spire means are yeah it's our good good tweets are um i'm curious what what does this look like from a portfolio perspective you were talking about uh earlier and you know like CNBC was kind of uh or Kevin O'Leary is hassling you for having 50% over 50% bitcoin are you still over 50% crypto and in bitcoin how's that uh you know change for you yeah definitely still over 50% um and like you know i'm actively trying to diversify uh for a whole bunch of different reasons um but i i feel um wrong selling so i so i don't sell so what that means is like i have to somehow make more money and then like deploy it in non crypto uh use cases or or kind of asset classes why why does it feel wrong to sell is that just like an investment case or do you feel like you've got you just actually have some uh attachment so it's just i just have such a conviction it's like you know i'm not the type of person who is smart enough to say uh oh this asset is going to go up but like i've got enough meat off the bone right like it like it went up enough and so like i'm just going to take my profits and go home oh my no like obviously i see what's going to happen for the next 15 20 years so like uh i just i'll kick myself how regret it and so it's like maybe regret minimization i don't want a 20 years and i'd be like why the hell did i talk myself into selling anything uh Ryan talks and gives me these same words every now and then he's like yeah every every once in a while i think about selling but then like selling something means buying something else and what the shit am i gonna buy exactly you buy treasuries and buy the dollar like what do you i'll take it a step further selling something means you're going shorted and like short shorting bitcoin or you know crypto or whatever like it's insane so shivers up the spine so so i don't do that um yeah i try to do other things um and uh inside of crypto um the biggest position is bitcoin uh the second largest position for me personally is salana don't kill me um the uh the thesis there that's a fantastic trade uh especially in the last 12 to 18 months so um i mentioned on another podcast but um i had no exposure to salana um and i had bitcoin and a little bit of eth from years ago and when salana ran up uh through morgan creek our fund there we had been a LP in multi coins fund one and so they obviously had made a great investment in salana gone up a lot you know frankly was like hey great job guys but like don't know that much about it uh that's why we gave you the money is because you guys are the experts and the stuff whatever when it crashed down it felt very similar to kind of me going back and learning about bitcoin and and and stuff like that and i started trying to understand this stuff and so um i started buying it around forty eight dollars double down at fifty five uh and then i actually sold the ethereum to buy salana at seventy three or seventy five something like that and my thought process was purely all price so it's not actually like if you go back to that ETF conversation about like price exposure versus like holding the asset um i don't think that i will be holding any of the portfolio outside of bitcoin ten years from now but i do think i'll still be holding the bitcoin ten years from now right so it's like i kind of know what i'm doing in terms of like bitcoin is this long term thing like i hope to give my grand kids one day these other things are very much like which asset do i think is going to go up in price more and you know short to medium term um and i look at it as like that's part of my job as an investor is to like measure price appreciation uh more so then um i don't need to like get sucked in to be the evangelist of you know name your next asset uh i think i you know i've done my time in uh i'll let somebody else do that stuff i think you're gonna let it get a lot of commenters wanting to figure out how to be your grandkids that kind of confidence uh that's very quite quite the gift you know the time that comes well look what else do you do right like i i think about this all time like yeah okay bitcoin becomes the thing that everyone thinks it's going to be right whether that means like everything becomes you know hyper bitcoinization or just like it's really valuable it it it's like this very weird thing where you can give things away or you just pass them on when you die but like you can't take it with you and so it it's i don't know this is like very uh weird thought process of if you are successful at investing at some point the most important decision you will make is what do you do at the end with the capital and wealth that you've generated um and that is also why like the government is like we'll give us 50% right through the through uh kind of the inheritance tax and stuff like that and so i i don't know the answer i mean it's the hardest problem probably in finance is how do you you know kind of keep wealth over a long period of time but um i think the psychological cop out answers like yeah just go give it to you know the next generation and they'll figure it out pop uh this has been great we've got five minutes left you you ready for a quick lighting round let's do it all right uh bitcoin price by the end of 2024 where are we going higher i i don't know by any 224 i think in this cycle uh i could see over 150 probably not higher than 200 but uh price if you ask me price odds are I'm wrong so who knows what year does the first central bank allocate to bitcoin before 2030 you were talking about financial literacy earlier if you could design the perfect curriculum for high school students what would it be start a business start a business yeah would you teach them about money at all because um start a business one can set them on the path to kind of financial security etc but also if you really think about an individual if you operate like a business then you're acting with fiduciary responsibility so like spend less than you make you know what do you do with your profits how do you reinvest in yourself or invest your business own capital this huge yeah just like i mean most people's problem is they do one of two mistakes uh personal finance they either spend more than they make or they take the money and then they put it in dollars that are devalued away and they don't have any investments so as a business like what do you do like you have to drive profit and then you have to reinvest the capital to be able to grow your business right so like if you teach somebody how to operate a business i actually think they implicitly learn personal finance um and probably some of the best financial advice i ever got was like just treat yourself like a business right and whatever you do for your company do for yourself and you'll you you'll mitigate the downside right i mean that you're going to be the richest person in the world but you'll mitigate the downside that's really what you're trying to do Trump provide in White House by the end of the the election hmm not what you want what you predict yeah not what you want what what you think is most likely i think you got to go with uh Trump right now i i mean that's what the polls say um my guess is that uh it will be closer than people think but yeah the polls age that Trump so far so let's see how about recession i feel like uh the recession is just kind of ever come but will we get one in 2024 or 2025 no because i think that uh they're so scared of the recession that they'll continue to create these inflationary pressures i think the bigger risk is that inflation goes back up towards 10 percent uh more so than a recession but by the way uh trying to predict the macro environment is like uh you know bit basically like trying to read palms or or do tarot cards or something like who knows all right well in contrast this one this last one will be an easy one um aliens do you believe in them or no yeah i mean the odds that the aliens don't exist has to be so small um but the best counter argument to it is then why haven't we seen them right but like yeah and i'm sure you've heard all of the arguments yeah i was going to say this is a question you always used to ask at the the end of your podcast i'm curious what the best response you've you've ever heard was they're already here and i was like what i was like what do you mean and uh they were like um yeah we think they're in the sky but like look in the ocean you know like there's things you see videos on twitter all the time it's like some crazy thing in the ocean like what is that um and so i think uh you know who knows if it's real or not um i don't know if they're like little green men that come down from the sky with a spaceship or whatever but uh in my life i've learned where there's smoke there's fire and there's way too many you know leaks and uh conspiracy theories and i mean you know every time i see an air force commander come out and say something i'm like uh what what is the incentive for that person to be risking their career to come out and say that uh we have saucers or what you know whatever the latest thing is and so yeah probably true how many times did you ask that question on podcasters?
hundred yeah it was a great way to know whether uh people ever listen to the podcast people go listen all the time and i ask them like the two or three questions at the end and they'd be shocked right maybe just never made it to be in the podcast but uh okay pop this has been a long time coming thank you so much for for joining us on bankless uh you have bitcoin bull through and through and um yeah you you've certainly gotten a ton right over the years so it's been a pleasure to have you on bankless what what should um folks look for from you like any interesting projects that people can get involved with i um yeah what what's kind of the latest with the pop media empire and just everything you're doing nothing really i mean just follow me on twitter uh tweet just tweet all kinds of crazy stuff whatever we're doing whether it works or not who knows but uh yeah we're we're trying to uh just have fun at this point nice that's a good place to be all right we'll uh we'll leave it at that uh bankless nation got to end with this of course none of this has been financial advice uh how dare you think that uh crypto is risky you lose what you put in we're headed west this the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a