On today’s episode we have Bitcoin wizard, David Seroy on the show! He’s an armchair researcher in the Bitcoin rollup ecosystem. He really likes Bitcoin, and he really likes projects that are building on Bitcoin.
We’ve got a lot of questions on Bitcoin today, especially those that revolve around Bitcoin L2s. Are they real? David’s got answers.
------ 📣SUI | Register for Sui Basecamp https://bankless.cc/sui-basecamp
------ 🎧 Listen On Your Favorite Podcast Player: https://bankless.cc/Podcast
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
💸 CRYPTO TAX CALCULATOR | USE CODE BANK30 https://bankless.cc/CTC
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 9:18 Bitcoin L2 Rollup Support? https://twitter.com/david_seroy/status/1749508724274946514 12:56 Bitcoin Renaissance? 19:07 ETH vs. Bitcoin Scalability 21:18 Why The Bitcoin Community 25:34 The Bitcoin Rollup Pitch 30:14 Explaining Bitcoin Rollups 38:39 BitVM 47:03 Are L2s on Bitcoin’s Blockchain? 56:13 Exciting Bitcoin Projects 59:32 Are There More Bitcoin Daves? 1:02:53 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
David Seroy (Bitcoin Dave) https://twitter.com/david_seroy
BitVM whitepaper https://bitvm.org/bitvm.pdf
------ Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
That's kind of how I feel about this whole broader like L2 renaissance and what's possible in the Bitcoin world. Like, I don't care if it sinks or swims. I'm pretty sure it's going to be very successful. But even if it's not like this is ideas worth pursuing, you know, like we are freaking missionaries, not mercenaries. And if people disagree with it, it's like, bring it on. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of Internet money and Internet finance. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more Bitcoiners. Oh, is that what we're doing, David?
Yeah, it's a Bitcoin episode. This is a really simple premise for today's episode. We brought on somebody who could answer the question for us, for me. I had more of the questions, actually, than you, David, coming into this episode. Are Bitcoin Layer 2s real? What do you mean by that question? What does that mean? That's kind of what I was going to ask our guests and did ask our guests. But what I sort of mean is I was under the impression that Bitcoin did not have the expressivity, did not have the virtual machine, was more like a calculator and not a computer at its base layer, and therefore had a very difficult, if impossible, probably impossible time launching what Ethereum calls a roll-up, which is some sort of chain that is secured by the base chain.
And this next guest says, actually, layer twos are possible on Bitcoin. With an asterisk. With an asterisk. And he explains why. So I thought it was a brilliant episode. And it doesn't answer all of my questions, but opens the door to possibility that I didn't know fully existed. And so I've still some research to do on this. This is probably the first episode of several in the future where we explore this topic in more depth. But I don't know, this guest has some legitimacy on this topic. And actually, you know this person, right? And so he came in my Twitter DMs. So I was like, or my, my tweets and I was just like, David, who is this?
This is a good answer. You had already met him in person. Yeah. This is, this is your, basically how your, my relationships is, is like you, who are, who is this person? Oh yeah. I met, I met this person that one time. Um, yeah. Uh, I, I, uh, we'll talk about a little bit of the intro, like how we met David in, in, in the show. Shout out Steven from, uh, Alpha Alpha. Um, one thing I want to say before we go into this episode is that when we talk about like the differences between layer ones, usually there are things that get lost in translation, especially when I do like some of these Solana episodes, like I have to like stop and just like translate for the listeners who I know are like thinking in Ethereum terms.
But across smart contract platforms, that's actually pretty easy to do and not all that complicated. It's just like usually swap out one word, replace it, replace it with a different word. Right. And then there's like the conversation of like learning about Bitcoin versus Ethereum. and if like learning about Solana to Ethereum is like English to Spanish or something, learning about like Ethereum to Bitcoin is like English to Chinese. Like you can translate, it does work, but it's entirely different. And so when we talk about layer twos on Bitcoin and we talk about fraud proofs and we talk about different things, like, yes, we are close, but like we need to actually, some things don't always carry over.
And so I think that's important context for listeners to go in. It's like you don't just swap one thing out with a one word and place it with a Bitcoin word. That's not how it works. And so like layer twos and fraud proofs and ZK rollups and like expressivity on Bitcoin will look different. It's like same, same, but different. And so you can't perfectly translate these things. And you'll listen to me and Ryan like stumble our way into that realization once again as we have this conversation with Bitcoin Dave. Yeah, there were some stumblings in this episode, but it's a pretty like we didn't have an agenda going in.
We just wanted to pick David C. Roy, who's our guest. We call him Bitcoin David because we have two Davids in this episode. Pick his brain. I think hopefully the result is something that can further your knowledge on what Bitcoin is building because there's kind of a renaissance going on a little bit, like some glimmers of it. Bitcoin Dave to Bitcoin David presents a zero to one moment in Bitcoin building that is potentially ahead to us. Super exciting. So, guys, stay tuned for that. But before we get into this episode, we want to thank the sponsors that made it possible, including our recommended exchange, a place where you can buy Bitcoin.
If you're a Bitcoiner, it's Kraken. Go create an account. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive, and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone, everywhere to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos.
With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Kraken.com slash bankless to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice. Crypto trading involves risk of loss. Arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications. Arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions.
Arbitrum has the leading DeFi ecosystem, strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs, and is quickly becoming the Web3 gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.arbitrum.io. Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitrum Orbit chain? Arbitrum Orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own Orbit chain, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput. Whether you're a developer, an enterprise, or a user, Arbitrum Orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum.
Experience Web3 development the way it was always meant to be. secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Visit arbitrum.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities. Elegon, Matterlabs, and Arbitrum have all thrown their hats in the ring for the Celo Layer 2 to build upon their stacks. Why the competition? The Celo Layer 2 will bring huge advantages like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability secured by Ethereum validators, and one-block finality. What does that all mean for you? With Celo Layer 2, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC-20 tokens, sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using Social Connect.
But Celo is a community-governed protocol. This means that Celo needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Celo forums, follow Celo on Twitter and visit Celo.org to shape the future of Ethereum. Bankless Nation, we are super excited to introduce you to David C. Roy. Yes, we have a second David on the podcast today. This is the Bitcoin David. Bitcoin Dave. I guess my co-host may be David. David Hoffman, I should refer to you as Ethereum David. So we've got Bitcoin David here and he is a Bitcoin wizard, I would say. What does that mean? He is definitely an armchair researcher in the Bitcoin roll-up ecosystem.
He loves Bitcoin and loves projects that are building on Bitcoin. He actually had probably the best answer I received to a question about the Bitcoin roll-up community and L2 community I put out and is part of the reason for this podcast. Bitcoin David, welcome to Bankless. Yeah, thanks for having me. I'm excited. I can't believe you guys let a Bitcoiner on here. Oh, we do that from time to time. Yeah, we bring bitcoins a lot we just had Nick Carter is our number one most recurring guest true true true who else who else after Vitalik after Vitalik Buterin then Nick Carter David who am I forgetting being in the spot we've got got Eric Wall Eric Wall like on four or five times you guys had had Lin Alden we had Lin Alden on like five times we just had Robert Breedlove on for his first time Robert Breedlove of course of course okay fair enough Bitcoin represents at least two to three percent of all bankless podcasts that when you put it like that that's very small we gotta pump those numbers up yeah it's undersized as far as uh yeah well that's what we're doing today so bitcoin david i understand actually you guys have met in person yes so this isn't your first meeting we were introduced by steven cesaro of the alfalfa podcast fame uh and david was introduced to me as bitcoin dave and that's how his name is stuck in my brain and once again entering this recording room i was like wait David, are you called Bitcoin Dave or is that just how Stephen introduced you?
And apparently that's just what Stephen introduces him as. Now it's stuck. We actually played pickleball the next day. Yes, then we played pickleball. David told me about a really cool idea. He said he wants to put pickleballs on the blockchain. The supply chain is under duress. Yeah, it needs Ethereum. Yeah, but we're track points so no one can cheat with points. Well, but isn't that the broader question? Like which blockchain? Because now Bitcoin can support some tokens. I'm hopeful Bitcoin, Dave, you'll tell us a little bit about this because maybe I'll start the conversation. We're going to talk about the broader Bitcoin ecosystem.
But my base question in that tweet that you helped answer for me was this. Okay, a question for the unbiased big brains. That's how I couch this. Can Bitcoin have an L2 roll-up that satisfies the five slices of the decentralization pie? I was referring to the L2 beat pie where there's like kind of five slices that demarcate decentralization. I mean, is there an exit window? Do you have some sort of decentralized sequence or a few other things? Or does it lack expressivity? And so, David, I want to throw that question to you, basically. So can Bitcoin now support L2 rollups? And like, what does that even mean in the context of Bitcoin?
Yeah, well, I'm going to give a really clear answer here and say yes, but it depends. and really it kind of depends on, I'd say three general things. First is like, what flavor of roll-up are we talking about? Are we talking about like a fully validating ZK roll-up, a sovereign roll-up that has no proving system or an optimistic roll-up? The second question is, you know, are we saying with the soft fork or without soft fork? And then the third question is like, what level of trust is acceptable? And if we jump all the way to the answer that people probably care about is like, no, we want no soft forks, we want fully trustless and it needs to be a fully validating ZK or validity roll-up.
If that's the exact criteria we need, then technically, no, Bitcoin cannot do that. And that is because Bitcoin does not have the ability to natively verify zero knowledge or validity proofs on the base layer. Where this gets a little bit interesting is BitVM. And BitVM potentially allows us to hack in a ZKP verifier into the Bitcoin L1 without a soft fork. and so BitVM was this white paper that Robin Linus, a developer, an amazing researcher in the Bitcoin community wrote back in mid-December and that was about six weeks ago and so the claim with BitVM is that we can now compute anything on Bitcoin and we can express Turing complete smart contracts on Bitcoin and so if this is true, which it appears to be, then this is kind of the fundamental breakthrough that really changes the paradigm for what is possible on Bitcoin.
The caveat with BitVM is that it's a little bit clunky and it has a trust assumption of one of N, meaning that you can perform this computation where we could have a ZKP verifier on the Bitcoin L1, but the people that are performing that computation could be a group of 10, 100, 1,000 people. You only need one of them to be honest in order to kind of get the crypto economic security there. And, you know... some people would say, well, that's not good enough. But if we can essentially optimistically create a validity prover, then maybe that's good enough to build the bridge. And I mean that technically building a bridge, but also metaphorically building a bridge to cross that chasm that Bitcoin typically can't cross.
And if you can cross that chasm, then you get into the whole world that Ethereum is in. You get into this idea of shared sequencers and cross-composability and pre-confirmations and tons of different execution environments, like some really, truly amazing stuff. So BitVM is the real innovation that this could possibly happen without a soft fork in a little bit of a hacky way. And that may be good enough to kind of build out the rest of this. And maybe down the line, we say, okay, like we want the fully trustless version. We're going to soft fork in, you know, a dedicated ZKP verifier. Okay. So I want to get back to like BitVM as kind of maybe part of the final destination here, But could we zoom out for just a minute before we get into some of these more technical details?
So where is this innovation coming from in Bitcoin? Like, why has Bitcoin just discovered that, oh, wow, we can launch rollups and layer twos on top of Bitcoin? Like, is this some kind of a builder renaissance? Has this always been possible? It's just there wasn't the funding or the projects? Or is this just kind of new novel experimentation? Are they seeing the success of Ethereum? They're just like, hey, we could just do that here. Where is this renaissance coming from? Yeah, I mean, there's a bunch of moving puzzle pieces here. Like, to be clear, like, like a lot of this stuff was kind of discussed like early on in Bitcoin talk forums.
Like there is a post from Greg Maxwell, who's like kind of this like OG, just like amazing Bitcoin developer where he he talks about bringing, you know, ZKPs to Bitcoin. And he specifically references Ellie Ben-Sasson, who is now like, you know, who was the founder and is now the CEO of like Starkware. So so this has always kind of been on Bitcoin's radar. And there's even quotes from Satoshi where he he talks about, you know, like like if the technology has caught up, like this would be, you know, the best way to to to improve and kind of like scale Bitcoin, like all the the evidence is there.
Where this really kind of starts, in my opinion, is like back in 20 or not not starts, but like, you know, is back in 2014 where Blockstream released their their white paper for side chains. And this was like this the scaling vision for Bitcoin, where it's like you're going to have the Bitcoin base layer and then you're going to have all these side chains. You know, maybe you have a big block side chain. Maybe you have a privacy side chain. You know, maybe you have like whatever other specialties. And everybody loved this vision. But it was the one problem is the blocks room white paper said, oh, by the way, like we haven't solved this trustless two way peg.
Like, so for now, you're just going to have this federated model where you bridge your Bitcoin into these other ecosystems. You'll trust us with a multisig. We'll solve the trustless two way peg later. That never happened. And in the interim, Bitcoin went down the path of like lightning network. You know, they got Segwit in. You know, it fixed the transaction malleability, which was an issue that prevented lightning from occurring. All that happened with the block size wars in 2017. And then we said, we're going to go all in on essentially lightning. While that was happening, as you guys know, like the Ethereum community went down this other path where you said, you know, we're going to pursue, you know, plasma and then state channels.
And then you eventually settled on roll ups. What we're now seeing in the Bitcoin community, in my opinion, is that lightning is massively hindered. And I think people drastically overestimate essentially what it can do. And don't get me wrong. I love the Lightning community. I support the builders. But there are some systemic issues, which, in my opinion, are probably going to be insurmountable for it to truly scale Bitcoin. And Ben Carman, he goes by Ben the Carman on Twitter, really wrote this very nice post where he kind of said, he's like, I'm a Lightning lover. He's like, I am one of the developers.
He goes, but sometimes I look around and be like, what are we doing? Like, is this really the right path for Bitcoin to scale? And he labeled that, he laid out like all these reasons why Lightning, like it has some issues, you know? And, you know, I think a lot of those issues are going to be tough to get past. And even if we do get past them, it's just like, you know, it doesn't have a global state. You're going to have the inbound liquidity issues. It doesn't have very good privacy. you know like it requires massive footprints on the l1 is an issue you know so like if if ryan and i want to open up a channel like that requires an on-chain transaction you know if you want to add more liquidity in this channel that requires an on-chain transaction so david just just to kind of get up to to this point and it sounds like there's been some eras of bitcoin development right so bitcoin had kind of its side chain era let's say and that never manifested into kind of like a true trustless bridge and something that like in ethereum would call more like a roll up and that was one area and then lightning was kind of the thing i mean uh ethereum you rightly pointed out very much had its kind of state channel era where we thought that would be like the holy grail for ethereum and we tried a lot in that era i mean like uh remember amin solomani you know built his entire company's bank chain on like on top of that and we had Raiden and that was sort of like this and it never achieved product market fit it never got the traction I think for the same reasons that the the Bitcoin communities is seeing um like you know its endeavor inside of state channels through lightnings like some of the same uh things still applied right and then we entered kind of this this roll-up era of Ethereum and then so much so that Ethereum essentially pivoted entire its entire roadmap to be like you know Vitalik called it the the roll-up centric roadmap right so you're saying this this similar um trajectory the similar path is happening just like slower and a little delayed but like it's still it's happening in the same way in the the bitcoin community or or is that you know is there something i'm missing here no i mean that's that's exactly right um i think one of the things that that was kind of the breaking point was like a lot of the ordinals and inscription stuff because you know inscriptions They post arbitrary data on chain.
And some people will call that spam and it's not monetary use cases and all that. But bottom line, like they are fee paying customers. And so they are kind of pushing up fees on the Bitcoin L1 chain. And the same way that like Ethereum kind of had like their fee crisis and fees were booming, like fees on Bitcoin, they're not like absurd, but like they're creeping up. And what people are finding is that like the Lightning Network really suffers in a high fee environment. And people are sitting there and looking and saying, like, wait, like, the security budget that Bitcoin has, like, we're relying on fees to be higher long term, but our long term scaling solution, Lightning, doesn't really work in a high fee environment.
And I think that was the catalyst that kind of is making people question, like, okay, like, is this the long term solution? And we have other things like ARK, which is very cool. you know people are working on things kind of like like you know rgb as well and you know uh space chains and all this stuff but like at the end of the day nothing has solved like the trustless two-way peg but rollups potentially do i want to present actually a slightly a different um characterization of the progress of ethereum scalability as it compares to the bitcoin story um because we had we had the ethereum layer one we knew it was always needing to scale beyond that and so that we started with state channels which then grew into like generalized state channels which then grew into like plasma for hyperscale and we were doing like these plasma thing for a really long time we had these plasma implementers calls and then there was like this aha eureka moment which morphed into optimistic roll-ups um and we had like the unipig demo and then that's how we got to like optimistic roll-ups uh and then also we knew that zk roll-ups would ultimately manifest as a result of that.
And it was a very logical progression of thought, of research and development and direction and iteration until it actually landed on where we are today. Would you say, David, it's kind of like an idea maze kind of quest? Like we hit some dead ends and we're like, oh, back up. But smaller dead ends, right? And then we kept on progressing. Each one built on the history of the other. And what I'm seeing in Bitcoin is actually people going down the lightning idea maze, realizing that it's a pretty strong, pretty far, like tons of investment into Lightning Network and realizing it's a pretty strong dead end.
And now we're actually going very far back and picking an entirely new strategy for Bitcoin expressivity and Bitcoin scalability. David, would you, how would you, that's kind of my, how I would kind of change that characterization. Would you agree? I do want to somewhat defend the Lightning community. Like I don't think it's, it's, it's a dead end, but I think that it has like significant limitations that can't be overcome by just like, just give it enough dev time. People are like, oh, the builders are building. It's like, no, like, and Vitalik pointed this out. It's like, like the layer two, like, like lightning is essentially bound by essentially what the L1 is capable of.
And so there's just systemic limitations that that lightning is going to have. Like, could it be something that kind of like connects all these different layers? Like if you have a bunch of roll-ups or, you know, like something like Fediments and can it connect these Fediments? Like, yes, but is it going to be this grand vision that everybody hopes for? like, no, that doesn't mean we abandon it. It just means like, let's let a thousand flowers bloom. David, Bitcoin, David, I should say. So I, you know, I, I'm wondering if the Bitcoin community has kind of like felt this, because I'm not sure if, if you would represent yourself as sort of a minority of folks.
I know there's been kind of like a, the Nick Carter, Udi sort of wizards is sort of side of things. And there's almost been this, like this forking in the social layer of Bitcoin, of kind of builders and those who just want the just the pure gold store of value use case. But it also seems to me like some of the people who were embracing of like some sort of scale scaling of, you know, trustless transactions per second. And they were formerly Bitcoiners, like I count myself, you know, among those already moved to the Ethereum community. I'm wondering if you think that effect is in play too. So like, I consider myself a Bitcoiner.
I love Bitcoin. I still own Bitcoin. I don't know if some Bitcoiners in kind of like the Bitcoin tribe would acknowledge me as a Bitcoiner, but I consider myself a Bitcoiner. That said, I moved over to Ethereum because they had a roadmap that was actually trying to scale this whole trustless compute piece of it. And yes, in the early days, the monetary properties weren't quite as pristine. It doesn't have kind of the anonymous faceless founder, but I saw this potential to build kind of a bankless money system. And that's why I moved over into the Ethereum community because they were pursuing that most aggressively.
But you're saying, I think what you're saying is there are still some Bitcoiners out there who are trying to build this vision on top of Bitcoin. And one of my basic questions is like, but why? Why not? Just why not do it on Ethereum? Or like, why have you stayed? You seem like you're very much the builder mindset. Why have you stayed like inside of the Bitcoin community? And why do you still have hopes and aspirations there? You know, when I talked to a lot of Bitcoiners, like, and it kind of gets into this like implicit discussion of like Bitcoin versus Ethereum, they're like, they're like, well, you know, this is a monetary revolution, like not a technology revolution.
And that used to bother me so much because I'm like, yes, it's a monetary revolution, but, but damn it, like the tech matters, you know? And there were many times where I would listen to Bankless episodes and I'm like, man, this stuff is freaking exciting and it's cool. But I always had this spot in my heart for Bitcoin because that is the use case. It is all about the money. And if we can kind of merge these two worlds, that is the best case scenario. And now that we see some of this technical stuff that Ethereum has pioneered and we could potentially bring it to Bitcoin, that is the vision that I want.
I do not think that Ethereum is as good of money as Bitcoin. I could sit here and kind of stay silent and be like, but damn, like Ethereum has legit scaling solutions. I can honestly say that I do not think it is as good of money. And I think what you guys are starting to realize right now is that like, like, like scaling block space, composability, all that stuff's going to be solved. But where are the apps? Where are the fricking apps? Like what is going to be the use? The use, it's been the same since day one. It's money, it's payments, it's payments to each other, it's payments in privates, it's payments to, you know, like a loan contract, it's payments against, you know, collateral.
It's, you know, payments if you want to send it, you know, using Face ID on Apple Pay. Like, it's always been payments and it's always been money. And like Bitcoin Maximus, for all of their flaws and for all the, frankly, like dumb things they say, what they got right is the monetary revolution. And even after this episode, I think so many of them, like, I hope will listen to this and they'll probably still be blind to roll ups and the power of them. But them holding their ground and having that anchor and understanding that the tech, in my opinion, is kind of irrelevant unless you have the money, like that part, they got right.
And that's why I'm sympathetic to the Bitcoin camp. Like that, in my opinion, is the true revolution. But ultimately, if you want that revolution, you need to have the technical side. Like Bitcoin in its current condition, you know, you really can only scale to like, you know, less than 1% of the world in self-custody. Like that is not viable. You know, we need to like increase the scaling of self-custody. We need to bring some form of expressivity so people can borrow against their Bitcoin. They don't have to sell it so that people can have private transactions. We need it. So, David, I'm going to ask you, because, you know, we've certainly made the case for bankless money systems built on top of Bitcoin.
And it seemed to be a roadblock in the past. I'm wondering if you could kind of like what would you say to the Bitcoin community? I mean, you sell them, sell them, pitch them on roll ups. Why should the Bitcoin community get excited about roll ups? This whole vision that we have about like 21 million, 21 million is thrown out the window. if anybody can't have the optionality to self-custody. Like right now, there is only a certain allotment of block space every single 10 minutes. If Bitcoin gets any modicum of scale, those blocks are essentially going to be full and it's going to price out every single other person from having self-custody.
If everyone is using these custodial solutions, they don't have the option to go into layer one, then that in and of itself leads to massive attack surface for fractional reserve lending, for rehypothecation to kind of like... Basically the BlockFi's and Celsius's of the world. Yeah. I mean, just anything, even putting your funds into a custodial lightning node, it gives this attack vector to implicitly break the 21 million. And that's what essentially people care about. And seeing kind of like the decentralized finance movement, like the DeFi movement in Ethereum, I think Bitcoiners massively underestimate this.
Even if you think you know, finance is the scum of the earth. And you're this kind of like Rothbardian, you know, Austrian economist, like finance is the anchor that money must carry. You know, if we want this perfect world, like you need the ability to audit these kinds of contracts, like people are going to borrow, they're going to lend, there's going to be all this stuff. Like if you can audit all of that and you can, you know, cryptographically like enforce this set of rules, like all of that contributes to this, you know, trustless, you know, hard money world. Mantle, formerly known as BitDAO, is the first DAO-led Web3 ecosystem, all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network, a brand new high-performance Ethereum Layer 2 built using the OP stack, but uses Eigenlayer's data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum Layer 1.
Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest DAO-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has sub-communities from around Web3 onboarded, like Game7 for Web3 gaming and Bybit for TVL and liquidity and on-ramps. So if you want to build on the Mantle network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle.
If you want to get started working with the first DAO-led Layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax obligations for providing token grants to your team? It's no secret that token management gets complicated. Between learning all the legal language and tax obligations in every country that your team is in, token grant management can feel like an obstacle course, but it doesn't have to. That's where Toku steps in. Toku provides practical tools to handle token grants, allowing for effective oversight of token distributions and payroll tax compliance for employees, contractors, advisors, and investors.
They also handle tax withholdings through their real-time tax calculations that can be done by Toku or integrated into any payroll EOR providers in any jurisdiction. Toku is a trusted provider of Protocol Labs, DYDX Foundation, Mina Protocol, and many more. Get started for free and make token compensation simple at toku.com slash bankless. It's everyone's favorite season in crypto, tax season. And crypto tax is always an absolute headache, especially for all you degens out there. But it doesn't have to be a nightmare. That's where Crypto Tax Calculator comes in. The software built for degens by degens.
As Coinbase's official global tax partner, Crypto Tax Calculator focuses on making complex transactions into easy ones, supporting over 300,000 currencies across Ethereum, Arbitrum, Optimism, as well as 1,000 other integrations as well. It's as simple as connecting your wallet, pulling in all your transactions, and following the automated suggestions to quickly and accurately calculate your tax obligations. Plus, for all the airdrop farmers out there, Crypto Tax Calculator has your back as they are consistently adding support for new and upcoming Layer 1s, Layer 2s, and all the airdrops that you're currently farming.
2024 is the year when the degens do their crypto taxes with speed and confidence. Make taxes this year easy and affordable with Crypto Tax Calculator. Sign up at CryptoTaxCalculator.io and get a 30% discount with code BANK30. Click the link in the show notes for more information. Okay, so in the beginning of this episode, I started with kind of like a question that brought us into the weeds really quick. And you started talking about BitVM, right? Which is the question of like, can Bitcoin really, you know, launch roll-ups, completely decentralized Ethereum style roll-ups? And you threw out kind of a few categories and definitions there.
But before the BitVM thing that you're talking about, which we can still get into a little bit more, what has traditionally been possible on top of Bitcoin? Because where I sort of last left things, it seemed to me that Bitcoin did not have the expressivity to sort of do much more than some sort of a sidechain, multi-sig sidechain, right? And it was kind of like the early days where things maybe left off. But you mentioned sovereign rollups. You know, to me, that's kind of like I think that's sort of a side chain type of thing. So what sort of thing has been possible when Bitcoin talks about layer twos, the community talks about roll ups?
What are they describing, I guess, outside of BitVM, which is maybe a special case that we'll get into in a minute? I mean, the main problem with Bitcoin is that it has no concept of the outside world, right? If you are on a sidechain, the sidechain can run a Bitcoin note. It can interpret essentially what's happening on Bitcoin. But Bitcoin cannot interpret what's happening on these other sidechains. So you can bridge Bitcoin out of the ecosystem because those other chains, those other ecosystems can read Bitcoin. But if you're trying to bring Bitcoin back into the ecosystem, Bitcoin has no idea what happened in that outside world.
And so that's the main problem. It's essentially just a trustless two-way peg. Like if you want to peg your Bitcoin, you know, outside into a side chain, you can't do it because of that. And zero knowledge proofs could potentially solve that. So what I could do is kind of give like an overview of, you know, how Bitcoin rollups would work from a Bitcoiner perspective. But I can start using some like Ethereum vernacular and vocabulary. That would be very helpful. And as far as I understand, so like an optimistic rollup would not be possible on Bitcoin, right? because we don't have a smart contract that can kind of enforce the sort of the fraud proof type of game.
But maybe there's hope for some sort of a ZK roll up. Is that what you're saying? Well, BitVM potentially could enable both of those in like a kind of like, you know, quasi trust minimized way. And I'll get to that. But let me just grab the the rollers first that we're all we're all on the same page. So in the Ethereum world, you guys have talked a lot about this modular thesis, right? How you have like the data, the computation, and the settlement. And Bitcoin is really no different. When a user submits a Bitcoin transaction, like Alice sends one Bitcoin to Bob, that is data. That goes up into the mempool, which is like the waiting room, right?
The miners mine the block, and then they go up into the waiting room, up into the mempool, they pull it down, they collect the transaction sheet, and then they create the block. They package all of those transactions, that data, into the block. That block then gets propagated out to the rest of the network. It's sent to all the nodes. And if you're being a good little Bitcoiner, you're running your node, you receive that block, and you're going through and you're essentially performing the computation. You're validating all those transactions. You're saying, does Alice actually have one Bitcoin?
Is this a valid signature? Okay, yes. And then they append that block to the rest of the prior blocks in the blockchain. And then now you've essentially audited everything up until that date. And then you settle the transaction. You say, all right, Alice no longer has one Bitcoin. Bob has it. with a roll up in a Bitcoin world, similar to Ethereum, you're abstracting that computation part, that kind of incrementing and decrementing of the balances is no longer being done by your nodes. It's being done in this off-chain environment, right? And, you know, I think an astute Bitcoiner at this point will say, well, hold on a second.
Actually, let me back up really quick. Because you're not doing the computation on Bitcoin anymore, you're doing this off-chain environment, you can use any custom execution environment you want. You're no longer bound by what is called Bitcoin script, which is kind of like the EVM equivalent in the Bitcoin world. You can now use EVM in this off-chain computation world. You could use Kyrode, you could use Rust, you could use Clarity, you could use whatever language you want. At this point, a Bitcoiner would say, well, hold on a second. If this computation, this kind of incrementing of decrementing of these balances is happening off-chain and my node is not validating all of that, then doesn't that defeat the whole purpose of Bitcoin?
And this is where, as you guys know, like the zero knowledge proof comes in, where all of that computation, which it could have been smart contracts and DeFi and NFTs or, you know, fast transactions, small transactions, all of that is essentially compressed into a singular zero knowledge proof, which is like an unforgeable digital receipt. That unforgeable digital receipt is pushed back to Bitcoin L1, along with the updated state saying, hey, Alice no longer has that one Bitcoin. Now Bob has it. Here's the unforgeable digital proof that this actually occurred. And from Bitcoin's perspective, it's essentially saying, well, I have no idea what happened off-chain, but just prove to me, mathematically prove to me that you followed the rules of my consensus, that no more than 21 million coins were created, that Alice actually did have the funds, that all of the signatures were valid.
And if you can mathematically prove that to me, then I will allow you to update the state on the L1, meaning I will allow the kind of now, you know, Bob has the one Bitcoin and Alice no longer does. Functionally, the way this kind of works on Bitcoin is on the L1, you would have what's called like a shared UTXO. This is essentially like the roll-up contract in Ethereum world, where users can pool their funds into the shared UTXO, and then those funds are represented in the L2 where all this computation and the zero-knowledge proof and everything is essentially completed. It was typically assumed that in order to create some sort of shared UTXO structure, you would need a software called recursive covenants.
However, there are proposals to potentially create something like this if you had a ZKP verifier. With BitVM, we now potentially have the ZKP verifier. So hopefully that's making sense where we could potentially create these shared UTXOs on the L1. We can perform all the computation in the ZK proof and submit it back to the L1. And then you can use BitVM to verify that ZK proof. If you have that, then you can build a roll up. All right. So before we get to BitVM, could you just like, so I'm not as familiar with kind of the Bitcoin, I'll call it generally layer two community, but like, I don't know if these are legit layer twos or not.
Right. And what, what you would say. And I'll say first, like we've run across the same problem, of course, in all of crypto and in Ethereum, where everybody wants to be a layer two, but oftentimes they're just side chains with multisigs. And so it's hard to like get past the marketing speak and get to actually the technical details of, is this really a layer two? And then that's even more obscured by the fact that some legitimate layer two projects are still not fully layer two, if that makes sense. Like they still have some training wheels on, some guardrails on, and they're working to decentralize over time.
But the technology is such that they can become kind of fully decentralized or much more decentralized layer twos in the future. So I'm just trying to find out what's real in the Bitcoin kind of quote unquote layer two community. So something like stacks, is that a layer two? Something like rootstock, is that a layer two? Are these kind of like more like sidechain types of networks? I mean, they're more like sidechains. There's kind of multisigs or they don't like necessarily anchor to Bitcoin, like do quasi call them like, like layer twos. And I, I guess they are, but for me personally, it's like, no, like I want like this path towards like fully trustless, like CK rollups.
And the closest thing we could possibly get there is like some sort of integration with, with, with BitVM, you know? Okay. So aside from BitKey, BitVM, are there any sort of layer twos and you know, like in the theorem definition of a layer two is basically, it has to be kind of secured, settled by the base layer or be on a trajectory towards being fully decentralized. Is there anything else besides BitVM? Yeah. I mean, in terms of like the level of trust that you guys would want, the only thing is Lightning Network. Lightning Network from a security assumption standpoint is like very, very strong, but it just comes with like so many other pitfalls.
Okay. Okay. So we've been talking so much, like you've been alluding to this BitVM project, like what is it? Where did it come from? like why are you so excited about it you don't work for the project so I think you're looking at this from a you know a bitcoiner that's very excited about this this building renaissance you're just kind of evaluating this and you're like this is the future but yeah give us some context for this what is it what is it yeah so bitvm is a way to to verify any arbitrarily complex like touring complete uh you know contract on bitcoin and the keyword there is verify not necessarily execute.
And so if you read the BBM white paper, there are two key references in there. The first is optimistic rollups. And the second is Taproot, which was the last Bitcoin soft fork. So as you guys know, an optimistic rollup performs this computation off-chain, and then it submits the results of that computation back on-chain along with the data. And you optimistically assume that it is valid. And if somebody says, hey, I do not believe this is valid, I believe that you lied, then they can use the data that was posted on L1 to create a fraud proof and say, hey, this is incorrect. And then the transactions are essentially rewound.
So worst case, the transaction could get rewound, the fraud gets discovered. But because of the game theory, you assume that it's going to work correctly. BidVM is similar, except it's not actually posting transaction data on L1. Instead, what it's doing is it's committing on-chain in a Bitcoin transaction to perform a certain set of computations, and it will do this off-chain. And it says, you know, I will perform all of this computation, and then it will do it off-chain in kind of a prover-verify setup where there is a prover that's performing this off-chain. And then if they do not perform that computation, then the verifier can take a piece of that and submit it to the Bitcoin L1 and say, hey, here is fraud.
They didn't follow this computation. And the prover, just like an optimistic roll-up, essentially gets slashed. The way that this works, because Bitcoin doesn't have any sort of scripting language and it can't verify these kind of complex programming languages is interesting. So most programming languages, I think pretty much all of them, like, for example, like take Python, is built in a hierarchical manner where Python was built on top of C++, which was an extension of C, which was built on assembly. And it goes all the way down to kind of the circuits or the binary bits, where literally, if you have two wires, and they're going into what's called like a gateway, if two of those wires have electricity pulsing through them, maybe the gateway lights up.
Maybe for other types of gateways, if one wire is on, one wire is off, the gateway lights up. The point is, is that these small little electrical signals in these gateways create the basis for like zeros and ones in binary language. And then that binary language, it becomes the basis for, you know, letters and further numbers and then all these codes. So what BitVM is doing is it could take some sort of code, say like a ZKP verifier, and it will break it down to its fundamental components, down to those little binary gates. And then it will commit all those binary gates into what's called like a taproot tree, which this is a Merkle tree.
So if you imagine like, you know, an upside down, yeah, or just kind of like a pyramid structure where you have like the root, And then you have all the binary trees, like you would have this massive tree that has all the different chunks of this essentially code. And you can embed that into a Bitcoin transaction. And so in this situation, again, like the prover is putting money at stake and they're saying, I will compute all of this like the ZKP verifier off chain. And if you feel that I am lying, then you can submit a single small transaction as part of one of these taproot trees or part of this Merkle tree.
and you can identify that as fraud. And if I'm found to be fraudulent, then you can slash and take my funds. So you could have a situation where you have one prover, you have a thousand different verifiers and you yourself could be one of the verifiers. And what this essentially allows is you're optimistically creating a ZK verifier, if that makes sense. I think it does. I think it does. I'm gonna have to like do some, you know, more research on this myself. and ask some other folks. But let me ask you, the BitVM project, how close is it to mainnet? Is this kind of, this is beyond the white paper, but...
Is that even the right question to ask? Yeah. I mean, I follow a lot of the Telegram chats pretty closely. It seems like they're making progress. Like, I don't want to hold them to anything, but like, I think, you know, I think we could be looking at this stuff like within a year or less. Is mainnet like the right phrasing for this? or is there a more precise word? I'm not sure. I'm not sure what we would call it. Well, there would have to be some chain that I can interact with that is some sort of like, you know, virtual machine type chain, whether it's EVM or something else that ultimately settles to Bitcoin.
Or is that not what, like you're describing here, David? So, I mean, all of this computation for BPM, it's happening off chain. It's happening just like, you know, on a server or a computer or anything. Like you don't need any sort of blockchain because, again, you're kind of like optimistically assuming that this stuff stuff is being done. So you're you're saying, look, like here's I want to say it's like here's all this code that I'm essentially going to run. Like before you run it, you say here's all this code that I am promising you I'm going to run. And you're breaking that down all into the binary parts and you're submitting that into the Bitcoin blockchain.
You're committing to it. You're basically saying I am committing, you know, 10 Bitcoin that I'm going to run and operate this code off chain. And so what's happening off chain is the prover is running it and the verifier is simultaneously verifying. All this is outside of a blockchain. This little game that they're playing, there's a lot of kind of interactivity that's happening between these parties. But if the verifier discovers and says, hey, you're being dishonest, they can go through and they can arbitrate that on the Bitcoin chain and be like, hey, do you remember you committed 10 Bitcoin to execute this?
You committed and you promised that you would execute it this way. And I'm now providing a fraud proof to the Bitcoin chain, proving that you did not follow the code. And that's how they essentially punish or slash the off-chain computation. David, does this sound a little bit like Nebra to you? I'm not sure what Nebra is. The Nebra project that we've talked about. That's a proof aggregation layer. No, I don't think so. Like I think what I'm trying to get my head wrapped around is like because with like arbitrage and optimism, you and I are very used to like block like alternative blockchain networks that are blockchains that settle down to Ethereum.
And it's another entire like parallel system. And I don't think that's what's going on here. It's not a blockchain, right? It's like exploring like the world of like expressive layers on top of Bitcoin. You can't really like take your Ethereum frame of mind and apply it to Bitcoin. You can start there, but the outcome is completely different. And so like there's just like some things that don't cross over the chasm in terms of what they look like on Ethereum when they're applied to Bitcoin. It's just like a different construction. like um for example david like the nature of the computation that would occur in a bit vm like layer two it's not going to be like um like nft trading on a layer two or or maybe it maybe it is but even if it is it's going to look different right like maybe you can help uh continue this conversation like what what how is the different nature of like layer two computation going to be like on Bitcoin?
Well, I guess I just want to like to maybe help this. Like I think Ryan's like having trouble thinking that this is like this off-chain computation on blockchain. And I'm thinking like in the context of roll-ups, like like a prover is not a blockchain. Like you have this this you have this blockchain, but then you're taking all that and you're putting in this like hyper centralized, just like like prover computer. And that's kind of what's happening, you know, on the BitVM side. It's not a blockchain whatsoever. You're performing it all off-chain, which just means on a separate computer. Okay, so BitVM is more a prover, it's not an entire chain, but you could just use the prover to validate the entire chain, right?
Are layer twos on Bitcoin's blockchains? Yes, yes. So what BitVM really focuses on is the bridge to get you to this L2 blockchain. So there would really be two different ways that I think people envision using BitVM. One is like that traditional rollup setup that we talked about, where you have the L1 contract, you have the L2 blockchain. It compresses the computation as ZK proof. And then there has to be something to receive and verify that ZK proof. So that little bridge component right there that exists or can be arbitrated by the L1 to verify the ZK proof, like that is one use case of BitVM.
And you could build a true or kind of like a more traditional ZK rollup that way. The other way that people could use BitVM is just to build like a Bitcoin bridge. Like instead of using WBTC or a federation, like you could bridge Bitcoin, say, into some sort of wrapped Ethereum ecosystem or you could bridge it into another side chain. And it has that same trust assumptions where you only need to trust one honest party out of, say, a thousand as opposed to a federation. And you can bridge it into another chain. And maybe that chain, you then build roll ups on top of that. You have a settlement layer.
You have, you know, 20 different roll-ups. They're all using the same ZK circuit. You're getting the cross-composability, you know, all the kind of advanced topics that you guys are talking about. Like that's the potential for it. So to recap that, you could create a ZKP verifier that's arbitrated by Bitcoin and just have a roll-up that settles directly onto the Bitcoin L1. Or you can create a pegged version of Bitcoin with the same trust assumptions. And then in that new ecosystem, you could build roll-ups on top of that. it's not okay so it sounds like the emphasis that you're trying to place on is that this is a bridge primitive but what is on the other side of that bridge you know bitcoin's on one side of the bridge what's on the other side of the bridge what's on the other side of the bridge could be a whole like open field of innovation where it could be a blockchain it could be like a tokenized implementation of bitcoin elsewhere it sounds like like it's up to developers to imagine what could be once on the other side of that bridge once we have that bridge standard developed by the bitvm team.
Is that, is that fair? Yeah, exactly. And that's why I think, you know, I started off this conversation describing that, that idea of like the chasm, right? Like you're crossing the chasm and where I mentioned that like bridge that we're building both like a technical bridge and like a metaphorical bridge. And if you, if, if you're willing to, to trust that bridge, this one of end trust assumption, this kind of like optimistic as opposed to validity proof type, type setup. And if you can cross that bridge and you can cross that chasm, then you are into the new frontier, right and and could you build a bridge to ethereum and everybody's like well hey we don't want any of this stuff on on bitcoin like we just want like a trust minimized way to use bitcoin on ethereum like maybe that's the route some people go and maybe some people say no i want true roll up where you're posting the data directly on bitcoin maybe other people say we want this this settlement layer where we have this world of different roll-ups that are all cross-composing with each other yeah like like bitvm and that like enables this kind of design flexibility again with that caveat of the one of n trust assumption yeah i guess more my question was why don't they just attach a chain to it then they're doing the work of creating the bridge like this is essentially what um arbitrum or optimism have like done is they've done the kind of the bridge piece but then they've also just slapped a chain on it too uh is that out of scope for bit vm i think for the bit vm team it's it's probably out of scope but there are a lot of people who are very excited about using BitVM for that exact use case where they want to use it as a bridge to their chain.
And there are some people that are doing the traditional roll-up path and there are other people that are using it for like side chains. But yeah, like I don't think Robin and the BitVM team is building a chain themselves. Like they kind of want to let a thousand flowers bloom. Like Robin is on record saying, you know, a world of like, you know, an arbitrary amount of like side chains all with different experimentations, like a free market of side chains is kind of his vision. Right. Yes. Okay, the bridge, the metaphorical bridge you're talking about is landing way harder for me now. It's like once you get over this, once you build the literal bridge, you get into the land of just like, hey, what's on the other side of that bridge?
What's on that destination is like a startup that can actually raise to build something that they see as like cool and unique and something that they want to see for Bitcoin. Maybe that's not your vibe, but maybe market forces are asking for like a different product or solution on the other side of that potential bridge implementation. Like, well, we can go build that too. I think maybe on net, what's on the other side of this bridge that is being built by the BitVM primitive is expressivity. So like you can have expressivity on the other side and it's up to the Bitcoin builders to like decide what they want to build either by market forces or their own intrinsic curiosity or whatever.
Yeah, and there are, to be clear, there are teams building all the stuff that you're talking about. Like there are teams like building these other environments and these different like design trade-offs. But like once we get over that, that, that bridge, then we get into all the fun stuff that you guys are talking about. Like we talked about data availability layers. You talk about like what different type of execution environment you want. Like maybe somebody wants to build like, like a proof of stake style Bitcoin chain that specializes in NDA. Like all that stuff you can have. One thing that we didn't mention, and just so the audience knows it's like, like a rollup in and of itself is not like a magic bullet, right?
Because you still have to post that data in theory, like onto the Bitcoin L1. And because the blocks are, they're not one megabyte, they're technically four megabyte, you know, like a pure roll up could probably still only get like, I'm going to guess anywhere from like 10 to maybe like 50x improvement in scaling if you're posting all of the data on the L1. So that's still pretty good. It's not bad. It can expand self-custody, can make things a lot cheaper. But eventually Bitcoin is going to have to go down the same path that Ethereum is going down where it's like you're going to have these dedicated data availability layers.
And that gets a little more advanced, a little more nuanced. Okay. So David, you presented this as if people are willing to accept the N of one trust assumption, then we can eventually get to this world of expressivity on Bitcoin. Do you think the Bitcoin set of people, that's a pill to swallow. How big is that pill to swallow? will people swallow that pill yeah i do i think it's going to be absolutely massive i think you think you think people are going to largely as a whole like the laser-eyed maxis aside bitcoin is going to accept this n of one trust assumption yeah i mean i think it's it's good enough to get us there again to cross that chasm and then you can get the the fully zk verified cross-composable you know chains with like you know the beautiful ux and and and the forked Ethereum smart contracts.
Like, I think that's going to be good enough. And I think that there are beginning to be use cases that even the most ardent Bitcoiners are like, oh, like, that's kind of dope. You know, like, I think that's one of the criticisms of like sidechains is sidechains were like a little bit ahead of their time. You know, like none of the good applications really came out until like, you know, DeFi summer. And yeah, there was so much fricking grift and so much scam and so many shitty products. But like the idea of, you know, being able to like borrow against your Bitcoin at 0% interest and like a liquidity style, you know, with like a very small origination fee, provably over collateralized, like that is badass, you know.
Account abstraction wallets is like another great one, you know, obviously sending private payments, you know, being able to earn yield like, like there are, there are teams like I'll give a shout out to like Botanics, you know, they're doing this thing where you can stake Bitcoin, you can earn yield on it. and it would create like a two-way peg to another chain. And so they were thinking about building like an EVM chain. And I was like, guys, look at what EigenDA is doing. Like when you could stake your Bitcoin, you could create this separate layer. You could have a dedicated data availability layer that all of the rollups use and settle to.
It's earning real fees because people are paying to use that blob space and all the ropes can be built on it. Like you can have a decentralized AMM perpetuals platform that, you know, is going, you know, long the proof of stake Bitcoin and, you know, short in the perpetuals and you can create like the inverse perpetual, you know, stablecoin. Like this whole world, it really gives new life to the Bitcoin monetary maximalist. Like right now, all of these people are complaining about, you know, ordinals and inscriptions. And it's like taken away from like, you know, the spam is like increasing fees and it's like pricing out, you know, monetary use cases, it's like, well, you need a scaling solution that aligns with a higher fee environment where we can create economic density, where you could have dedicated rollups that do tons of transactions and tons of DeFi and tons of privacy.
And you could batch all of that. And you're willing to bid way more than any of the inscription people in order to place your rollup transactions onto the L1. That's how you beat out all this kind of arbitrary data on the L1. And I think so many Bitcoiners are just missing that. It's like, all right, guys, chill. like we're going to build it and you know you're going to be happy okay so the world that you're describing kind of i've always thought that building on bitcoin is like building in a wasteland just because the whole entire construction of bitcoin is just like optimizing for simplicity you know it's a philosophy of uh uh subtraction rather than addition make bitcoin simpler make it harder to build on bitcoin just have btc the asset um that's always been like my kind of like philosophy is like how Bitcoin has grown.
But what you're showing me is that like, well, maybe that was true with like the Bitcoin base layer. But once you build this Bitcoin VM thing, it goes from like building in a wasteland to just like fish in a barrel. Whereas like, well, there's all this other innovation that so many other ecosystems have already built. So we already have like a lot of the ideas and the research and development like out of the way. Now we just have to build it. So it's just like, you can't, at some point you just can't miss like DA on Bitcoin, somebody's got to go build that, right? Like, I don't know, Optimistic Rollup or ZK Rollup on Bitcoin, somebody just goes and builds that, right?
So a Bitcoin builder's renaissance, we've already seen the culture start to shift this way. What are some of the ideas that are super hot right now? What are people building that's very hyped in Bitcoin world? If Ryan and I were big Bitcoiners, what would we be excited about? Give us the next five episodes, Bitcoin episodes on Bankless. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, I'm a bit biased here. I wrote an article in Bitcoin magazine where I kind of talked about, you know, Bitcoin backed stable coins, you know, and I referenced like, like liquidity, like that is when I even I talked to my most like, you know, hardcore Bitcoin Maximus friends.
I'm like, I'm like, oh, like you call yourself a Bitcoiner, like, like you're never going to sell your Bitcoin until you have to. I'm like, you're selling your Bitcoin. I'm borrowing against it. And I'm doing it like without a custodian and I'm doing a 0% interest. Like, like I'm more of a Bitcoiner than you. You know, I'm holding one longer than you, you know, just like, just, you know, like poke at them. Of course, of course. And, and then, you know, even if you get to this world, like inevitably there are going to people who like, they're just not ready for Bitcoin. They're like, they're like, I'm living in fricking Argentina, you know, off of like $5, you know, like I can't sit here and be having like a crazy volatile asset.
They're like, I need stable coins, you know? And if you can say, well, Hey, look, here's this stable coin. It's, it's, it's decentralized. It's provably backed by Bitcoin. It can't be censored. Like that is a nice little ramp for them to get into this world. And then as they get savings, they can invest into Bitcoin. It's like all this stuff that you guys have been talking about. I just think it's a better fit on Bitcoin and we're going to bring it. That's cool. Yeah. Is there anything else? Like I've heard of restaking protocols on Bitcoin. It's like one's called Babylon that's crossed my desk before.
Obviously, there's kind of like everything that's going on with ordinals and BRC20s and that kind of thing. Anything else that we should keep our eyes open to? I mean, yeah, pretty much just like take off your guys's prior podcasts and things that you're excited about and say like, we can bring them on, on Bitcoin. I think account abstraction wallets, like I'm very excited about. Uh, I'm also really excited about the prospect. I mentioned this in the tweet, like this is pretty far future facing, but like if you could use something like storage proofs to, to kind of trustlessly give an attestation from like a data availability layer, you know, you could use something like Celestia or like a dedicated Bitcoin DA layer, and you could relay that information trustlessly to the Bitcoin L1.
And like that just kind of eliminates like the risk of some of these data availability layers. David, this has been a fascinating conversation. This is exactly what I hoped for when I opened up that tweet and I didn't expect you to reply. And I just want to thank you for replying. I mean, from my perspective, Bitcoin is maybe starting to get interesting again. I sort of left it off as sort of a store of value and it's a uncensorable store of value. And that's great. one part of the bankless journey, but it was missing DeFi, it was missing expressivity, it was missing all of the potential that Ethereum has unleashed.
And if you're telling me that it's starting to get that back again, and there are some ways where it can start to follow more closely something, its own version, but something closer to the Ethereum roadmap, that to me is very exciting and leads to a more bankless future. I guess I got to ask though, David, are there more of you out there, because I think the overwhelming message from what like the social layer, at least that is loudest in Bitcoin, does not talk in the way that you are talking, is not a listener to the Bankless podcast necessarily, is not focused on building, is very focused on kind of like monetary properties and like Robert Breedlove style, which is fantastic, right?
But just like not talking about this sort of thing and is thinking, still thinking that lightning is going to solve everything, all of the Bitcoin scalability problems. And yeah, are there more people like you actually like digging in and coming up with these new roll up style solutions on Bitcoin? How many of you are there? I mean, you probably counted on, you know, one hand, but no, no, no, no. I mean, in all seriousness, like it's a small but but but but growing movement. The problem is, is like there are some projects out there that are trying to like hijack this narrative that really are not the true builders.
It's for sure grifting. It's for sure scams. And I think people need to really have their guard up, not to go full on Bitcoin maximalist, but this stuff is real, but a lot of the stuff you will end up seeing on Twitter is definitely not. And Ryan, kind of what you were saying, I remember, I forget if it was a podcast you guys had many years ago, and somebody came on and just really applauded you guys and said, when you guys were getting into it, nobody gave a shit about Ethereum. It wasn't even like, hey, that was a bad idea. It's like, dude, we don't even want to talk about Ethereum. Like, why are you guys doing this right now?
And you like, you stuck to your guns because like, you understood the potential and the revolution. And you said, I don't care. Like, like, I, you know, will die on this hill because I essentially believe in it. And there is that small contingent of us that feel the same way about what is potentially happening in Bitcoin. And sometimes I look back and I'm like, oh man, like if I found Bitcoin in like, you know, in 2011 or whatever, I've had the conviction to stay on it. And the answer is probably not, who knows. But back then, you don't have the foresight of all of this development work that's already been done, of all of the podcasts, of all of the articles.
But that's kind of how I feel about this whole broader L2 renaissance and what's possible in the Bitcoin world. I don't care if it sinks or swims. I'm pretty sure it's going to be very successful. But even if it's not, like this is ideas worth pursuing, you know, like we are fricking, you know, missionaries, not mercenaries. And if people disagree with it, it's like, bring it on. You know, I'm on Twitter all day, you know? Well, I love that. That level of conviction is going to get you and the small but growing tribe quite far and totally applaud it. I mean, this is very much, you know, bankless aligned, I would say.
Very, very excited to have more bankless money systems built on top of Bitcoin. So, David, I'm going to ask people, including the show notes, a link to your Twitter account, because I was not following you before this, my mistake, but I am now following you. And you, my friend, are going to be my Bitcoin signal, I hope, so I can start to parse out what's real and what's not. You're the go-to now, Bitcoin Dave. So, like, with that power comes great responsibility. Please do not lead us astray. You know, show us where the true decentralized centralized uh roll-ups are building on bitcoin and uh thank you so much for your time today yeah thanks guys i do want to give a quick shout out to people like uh john light you know robin linus uh you know alexi uh orkin like these are like the true builders uh and people if they follow me and see their names like like like those are real deal people there you go and of course satoshi who started it all right right bitcoin dave i can't forget him or them uh yeah the uh The Twitter handle is David underscore C-Roy.
So D-A-V-I-D underscore C-Roy. Got to end with this. Of course, crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. Frontier is not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the Bankless journey. Thanks a lot. Thank you.