Bankless Nation, we’ve got the hottest debate in crypto right now: Are L2s extensions of Ethereum?
On one side, we’ve got Kyle Samani and Max Resnick proposing that the current Ethereum Rollup-Centric Roadmap is off-track. On the other side we’ve got David Hoffman and Jill Gunter defending L2s as successful extensions of Ethereum.
------
📣 GET YOUR ALL ACCESS PASS TO THE PODCAST
https://bankless.cc/podshownotes
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦄UNISWAP | BROWSER EXTENSION https://bankless.cc/uniswap
🪄 MAGIC EDEN | HOME OF WEB3 https://bankless.cc/MagicEden
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle 🤖 0G | MAKING THE IMPOSSIBLE, INEVITABLE https://bankless.cc/0G
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/85?referrer=0x077Fe9e96Aa9b20Bd36F1C6290f54F8717C5674E
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 8:54 Defending “Extensions of Ethereum” 16:33 Interoperability Standards 25:36 Are L2s Parasitic to Ethereum? 32:37 ETH Economics & Value Accrual 41:30 Solana vs Ethereum L2s 49:09 Closing Thoughts
------ RESOURCES
Kyle Samani https://x.com/KyleSamani
Max Resnick https://x.com/MaxResnick1
Jill Gunter https://x.com/jillrgunter
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
I think the market demand for producing chains should be just taken as fact. In this day and age, we know that there's going to be many, many, many chains. Some chain is going to figure out how to aggregate all the chains. Some chain is going to figure out how to make these chains have stronger property rights and composability mechanisms between all these chains, and that one chain is going to incentivize the production and aggregation of even further chains, and that chain will become money. Bankless nation, for those of you who did not make it to permissionless this year, there are some pretty hot conversations that were held over those three days at the conference.
The spiciest conversation, or debate, I should say, is what you're going to hear right now. It's a debate as to whether or not layer two's are extensions or ethereum. This debate is between Kyle Salmani and Max Resnick teamed up on the side of no layer two's are not extensions of ethereum versus myself and Jill Gunter. Jill Gunter from espresso on the side of yes, they are extensions of ethereum. Some people said that this was the panel of permissionless, not my words. This was a tweet out of the moderator Westy from blockworks. It was also the last panel on the last day of permissionless about four hours before my fight with King Warwick, and I used this panel to get into war mode in order to prep for the fight, and I definitely think that worked.
There were also lots of other super hot panels and conversations that were held throughout permissionless. Ryan's main stage panel with Chris Dixon was super insightful. I did a DeFi main stage with Kane, Stony, and Sam Kazmanian from Frax, co-moderated by Mike Epolito. And Ryan had an ethereum layer two conversation with Alex from ZK Sync, Harry from Arbitrum, and Rushi from Movement Labs. All of those conversations are getting released on the bankless premium podcast feed. So if you're a bankless citizen, but you're listening to this on the free feed, make sure you go get and download the ad free premium RSS feed, and then get that integrated into your podcast player so you can get all that good juicy content.
If you are not a bankless citizen, but you still want to hear those episodes, you are in luck because we are doing something that we've never done before. We're offering an all-access pass to all the best parts of our podcasts at a price that's kind of a no-brainer for the value that you get. This is a price that includes basically everything. It's the private debrief episodes that Ryan and I record after our guest interviews, where we say things that we wouldn't have necessarily said on the interview itself. It's also the early access to all of our episodes so you can get the early scoop and say ahead of the trends, and it's also the private bonus episodes that we keep exclusive to our paid subscribers, content directly from the best builders that will give you an edge.
So you can scan the QR code for wherever it is on the screen, or you can enter the code podcast at checkout for that exclusive discount that's podcast in all caps, and then from there, you can click the premium feed and add your unique link to your favorite podcast player. And if you're in Spotify, we always ship the ad-free video of every episode as well, so you can watch or listen inside of your shiny new premium feed anywhere anytime. So let's go ahead and get right into the episode, but here first is a word from our sponsors, because you're not on the premium RSS feed yet. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Crackin, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world.
Crackin is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive, and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone, everywhere, to trade crypto. Crackin's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks, and there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos. With products and features like Crackin Pro and Crackin NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience.
So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Crackin.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Uniswap wallet is officially the preferred wallet of bank lists, and it's the one we use any time when we want to transact on-chain. Whether you're on your browser or on the go, Uniswap wallet makes it easier than ever to swap anywhere. Use your wallet to transfer funds directly from the top centralized exchange and tap thousands of tokens across a deer, and over 10 other chains like based, arbitrum, and optimism.
Uniswap wallet delivers deep liquidity, fast execution, and reliable quotes with zero gas swaps through Uniswap X. And when it comes to security, you can rest easy knowing it's backed by Uniswap labs, one of the most trusted teams in DeFi. Their code is open-source and independently reviewed, so you know it's protected. So why wait? Download the Uniswap wallet today on Chrome, iOS, and Android, and don't forget to claim your free Unit.e username directly in the mobile wall. Start swapping smarter with Uniswap. Tired of juggling multiple wallets and websites just to navigate Web 3? Meet Magic Eden, the home of Web 3.
It is becoming a super dab where you can do everything cross-chain all in one place. They're solving UX issues by building products across every chain ecosystem, swaps, sparring and lending, NFTs, perps, and more. All seamlessly cross-chain, instead of hopping between countless sites and handling multiple wallets, just use Magic Eden. Save time, and get to the meme-coining faster. Plus, the M.E. token is coming out this quarter from the M.E. Foundation. If you've used any of their protocols like the NFT platform, you can claim some. So check out Magic Eden today and watch them become a super dab and the home of Web 3 in real time.
You can get there at MagicEden.io to get started. As I go on everyone, I've been excited for this conversation for a while. Ever since we said it in stone, I'm Westy. I'm on the Blockworks research team. Most my research has been around Ethereum infrastructure, roll-ups. So this question that we're debating today, I've been talking about for a while and it feels like there have been a ton of conversations on the Twitter verse on podcasts, but I don't think we've ever gotten people with different views in one place at one time. So I think this will definitely be a super fun conversation. Hopefully we get some hot takes as well.
And like I said, in this conference with the bang here. So I guess to start, I'd love to have sort of opening statements, if you will, from everyone on the panel so we can get a quick introduction to everyone. And then if each person also wants to go into, well, I guess their high-level thoughts are what they think of when they hear the question, our L2's extensions of Ethereum. So we'll start with Cal here and make our way down. Sure. Hi everyone, my name is Kyle Simmoni. I'm a co-founder at Multiquin Capital. We are seven years old, and that's for focusing in crypto. And I do not believe L2's are in their current form.
Generally used widely popular L2's such an arbitrary based optimism or non-extensions of Ethereum, although there are other configurations that could be. Hi everyone, I'm Max Reznik. I'm the head of research at Special Mechanisms Group. SMG is a Skunk Works organization within Consensus, which is the parent company at Metamask and Kura. We do special projects. We work with all sorts of things throughout, and we particularly specialize in MEV transaction supply change, transaction landing. We also do a bunch of work on Ethereum Protocol. And I agree with Kyle that L2's in their current form are not.
I love that you guys are already adding some nuance to this debate. My name is Jill. I'm a co-founder at espresso systems. We're working to solve cross-chain composability, starting with L2s on Ethereum, so very relevant. And I believe that L2s are an extension of Ethereum. I think there's two ways to ask the question. One is based on definitions. The other way is to ask it based on the goals of L2s versus the goals of Ethereum. And I think any way you slice it, they're extensions. I am David, one of the two bankless guys, the other ones in this room somewhere. And I think L2s are Ethereum, are extensions of Ethereum naturally.
And I think whether or not that that statement is true or false really depends on, of course, how we define words, all debates are essentially semantic debates. I think Ethereum, all block chains are property rights systems. And whether or not L2s are extensions of Ethereum, is either true or not true based on how strong the L1 can promise a sure your property rights on a L2. And so this is why we have things like L2B, the different stages, fraud proofs, ZK proofs. The whole purpose of L2s is to be a one-to-one extension of your property rights on Ethereum. And I think this debate is being had now because what is not happening or at least what is perceived by the market is not happening is that L2s are not becoming extensions of each value accrual.
I think perhaps that is something that is worth maybe talking about or focusing on, but at the very least that could also only be temporary. Amen. Yeah, there's a lot of threads you mentioned that I definitely want to go off of first. We should certainly define exactly what we're talking about here because I think that's the first question most people have is what doesn't mean to be an extension of Ethereum or to be Ethereum. And it sounds like you you defined it, David. So I'm curious because the people sort of on the anti side here said in their current state, some curious from this side, what would you say like what properties would you say make something an extension that like maybe in their current state they're not, but they could be at some point in the future.
I have a fairly simple image test for this, which is is the extension thing. It's an extension if it's doing something that cannot function on made that. And that doesn't just mean like, hey, increase the throughput of an app by like 10X or 100X, like that's still functionally the same thing, but if you're actually unlocking like new behavior or new use cases, that to me is an extension. And explicitly, therefore, not a replacement. The mainstream L2s that exist on Ethereum today are explicitly replacing a function that L1 did a year or two ago. Would you agree? Yeah, I would agree with that.
I think my test is also about whether these things are their own siloed state with network effects. And when you're your own siloed state with network effects, you naturally compete with Ethereum, which is a siloed state with network effects. So that's another thing that I would add to my definition. And then I would just add like go look at what the things are returned now is spending money on. And it's basically spending money to take away the lifeblood of apps that are currently operating on Ethereum L1. And another thing, go look at the fact that you change just announced that they're launching their own L2.
So that's a hugely popular app. The Uniswap router is one of the most commonly used highest gas usage contracts on mainnet. And they're saying, hey, we're going to go away from mainnet and make our own L2, which again has siloed state, which is not interoperable with anything else today. They explicitly have on their roadmap interoperability and composability as a goal. So are we are we taking unit chain as it exists? Or I'm not even sure the state and it exists that it exists in today? Or are we taking L2s at the word of their roadmap? So like according to your logic, if we put like 1 million TPS on the roadmap, does that mean that Ethereum is scaling?
Like, I just think we live. We have a viable path to get there. We've been saying Ethereum is scaling for years. I think you would agree with that. I would not agree that Ethereum has been scaling for years. I don't think we've done any. I guess because you see L2 is not as an extension with Ethereum. I want to address what Kyle said though. I mean, I think firstly, we can simplify the definitions. What is Ethereum? It's a world computer. It's a platform for innovation. And what are L2s? They're applications. They're specialized form of application, but they're applications. And I would contest the statement that L2s are only extensions of Ethereum.
If you're doing something you fundamentally can't do on the mainnet, I'm not sure that I really understand that, but I would say that regardless of that definition, you are doing something on L2s that you can't do on the mainnet. You have a totally different dynamic around transaction costs, throughput, et cetera. I'm surprised to hear that statement coming from someone who's such a big backer of Solana, because what would be the use case of Solana? What would be the reason for a developer to go over to Solana if that was not by your own definition of fundamentally different experience than you could get on Ethereum?
That's what L2s are offering to developers today. Solana beats explicitly with L2s. So I agree with that. But the frame of the question is not base versus Solana, base versus Ethereum. Yeah, but you're getting a fight. Why would any developer choose between these things? Why wouldn't they just go to the mainnet as of a few years ago, which was where all of the activity, all of the users, all of the liquidity was, because they're getting a fundamentally different experience on Solana. And today, because they get that fundamentally different experience via an L2, which then by your definition is an extension.
How can you have a fundamentally different experience and an extension, those two are contradictory statements? If it is fundamentally different, it is not the same. That's what I'm working off of Kyle's definition. So you'll have to ask him. Well, Kyle is saying that he is not afraid to say that Solana is competing with Ethereum. And I'm not afraid to say that. And I'm also saying that L2s can be competitive with the Ethereum L1 as well. And there are things that I would like to see on the L1 that are only possible on the L1 like censorship resistance and credible neutrality that you cannot expect to see from a US MST centralized sequencer.
And you know, you want to see the Canadian truckers be able to use the chain when they want to get their money out of their account. Then you probably shouldn't rely on a regulated centralized sequencer on US East One, or on some box somewhere in a westernized country. You need more than one box contributing. You need decentralized sequencing. And you cannot basically provide the same guarantees ETH L1 provides without doing a map. I think a large part of this conversation comes down to the competitive competitiveness of L2 chains to the host chain like the L1 chain. When base grows, does it subtract from Ethereum?
Which is yes. Probably the answer is yes. It also subtracts from optimism. It also subtracts from ZK sync. It also subtracts from all chains actually. Actually, there's no really difference between when arbitrum wins. It's pulling away from Solana too. And so there has been this ongoing development architecture in crypto even within without Ethereum. You see this in Cosmos where you have a variety of chains with like no real ropes between them, no real connections. You have polka dot with many, many chains with like very rigid connections between them. And that really didn't take off. And now you have Ethereum with like what I think you guys are saying, very loose connections, but connections nonetheless strong property rights are continued across chains.
And at least when an Ethereum layer two wins, it takes away from Solana more than it takes away from the aggregate of Ethereum because at least it keeps it inside of the Ethereum ecosystem. So when you can keep value inside of Ethereum, yes, the layer two, the role of Central Roadmap is designed to have all chains be competitive with other chains inside of the Ethereum Central Roadmap. But at least there's some aggregate value created that's retained by the net Ethereum ecosystem that is pulled away from the very disconnected layer one landscape. Okay, but let's kind of take this view. So is avalanche, which is an EVM chain L1 part of the Ethereum ecosystem by this logic is monad part of the Ethereum ecosystem.
Do you have to just like do you just automatically become part of the Ethereum ecosystem by posting state reads or do you have to post use use Ethereum for DA? There's no clear line that there's no clear line. It's a set of concentric circles. But I think there is a clear line as to where property rights are given assurances to. And I think where property rights assurances stop is somewhere like avalanche an EVM chain monad. And then way further away is Solana. A lot of great takes going on right now. I'm curious your thoughts on sort of interrupt like let's say Ethereum and then all the relapse agreed on one interrupt standard that there was good UX to basically easily switch assets from one roll up to another to Ethereum L1.
And you have this cohesive ecosystem like you did Solana across these relapse. What that change your guys is my like would that be like what else is in that case like sort of be a theorem and be a part of one ecosystem or would that not matter at all? I mean it's like what does it mean to be a theory? I'm like David you can say our property rights you know functional equivalent and like okay that's one element. Another element is do normal people perceive it as the same. Another would be like is there some general sense of credible neutrality? Another would be if you want to get late like transaction latency for inclusions whether you live in India or the Philippines or in Mexico like what are those guarantees?
So there's like different properties of the systems. Oh and then maybe the other one of like again answering the question is X Ethereum. You know the most obvious one in my opinion is like is it trueing MEV value to the base asset? And so there's different constructions of various roll up looking things whether they're espresso or arbitrum or base or uni chain or base drawlops or whatever and in all of these systems have different versions of some of these properties. I think in maxes and my definition none of the systems by any of these groups are functional equivalents to Ethereum. They may have partial equivalents on some properties but none of them are 100% fundamentally equivalent by definition.
If that was the case then I want to be on stage right now like there would be no date but like very obviously they're not functional equivalent. Yeah and I guess like just to come back to our opening statement it's like in its current form today is exactly what we are talking about. We are not talking about what is on the roadmap because we work in an industry where roadmaps are memes okay. Roadmaps do not exist. Ship code the code that shipped is what the thing is not the code that you promised to ship in the future. Words on a page are not code on the compiler. But Ethereum has had a pretty coherent roadmap.
They had the pivot in like 2019 to the roll up centric roadmap but nonetheless there was some true north star that it kept when it pivoted to the roll up centric roadmap. There was one central north star we just decided to get there a different way and so anyone who's like investing in crypto based on current conditions is not going to make it like the things are going to change in the future. I think Ethereum was on its roll up centric roadmap in 2021 when Solana had it big rise as we realized that the layer one is congested and we really only had polygon as a side chain to Ethereum with no actual strong commitments of property rights connecting there.
But now we have and so this was the era of many independent siloed walled garden chains blossoming out of Ethereum proving the use case of or the idea of a successful roll up centric roadmap. The pocket out model the cosmos model but this time actually working and thriving and so we had the growth of many independent siloed chains. Now we have what is I think the era of the crosshatching between these chains. We have Jill from espresso doing some of that work here. That is one frontier of the composability of networks but this one canonical bridge is the first step to producing composability but then the rest of the shape gets filled in by many different technologies and I think that is going to define the next two to three years of Ethereum.
I just want to build on that to come back to this question of what are the goals of Ethereum and what are the goals of altos. I think we've named three different goals throughout this conversation so far. One would be to create censorship resistance applications. Now that's not the goal of every altos. Certainly the goal of some altos. There are altos that include pernato cache transactions. There are altos building explicitly for even more kind of cipherpunk values than exist on Ethereum today on the Ethereum mainnet and so I would say that on that front the goals are aligned and compatible between the main net and the L1 and the altos at least some of the altos building upon it.
A second goal that we've named now is composability. I think censorship resistance and composability are basically the two reasons that you have as a developer to build in Web 3 or as a user to use Web 3 apps. Composability to me is honestly still a big question mark. That is where I think there is a risk that altos go off to build their own wall gardens. That is why I'm working on espresso to work to solve composability and then there's a third question which you mentioned earlier that I think we've all been skating around which is the question of value accrual and that is the real reason why everyone is sweating over this is because I think Bitcoin, Solana are each up like 40% in the last few months and Ethereum is that meme where you're poking it with a stick saying to something.
I think in the current state of Ethereum we do have kind of this blank step of and then there's a perfectly composable Ethereum and there's like a missing step there. But nonetheless we do see signs of internal composability across what Alasklokowski is calling the clusters, the super chain, the elastic chain. There's a pretty coherent path for having internal composability across these systems and once the super chain, once the elastic chain fixes internal composability of which they are highly motivated to do and they have the war chest to do the R&D to do that, then we learn a bunch of lessons to apply like what worked and what didn't.
We have like five different of these frameworks all tackling this problem. Maybe there's five different solutions, maybe there's one different solution, we're going to find it and we're going to export those lessons learned to fill in the gaps between the frameworks, between the arbitrum orbit chains and the super chain. And that will take time. I'll take a lot of time, but that is the path that we're on and I don't think that that's like a crazy incoherent vision of the future. It's not defined. Yes, anything is possible. Sure, you didn't describe violating laws of physics. It's possible, but that's not helped.
You're just saying I'm not proposing breaking law physics. I mean, there's another thing you said, David, which is that it didn't work for Cosmos. It didn't work for Kolkadeh. This time is different. We have, but we actually have the chains now, like it is currently working. You know that like arrested development meme. I mean, first of all, we'll see what happens when the liquidity rewards dry up on arbitrum and the these war chest front out. We'll see if it actually works. When the tide comes out, we'll see. Max, what would it have to look like for L2s to be an extension of Ethereum? What about, okay, also the other thing, David said was that we've been consistent on the roadmap, but then the first thing he said was actually we shifted the roadmap from sharding.
And if it was basically sharding, I think that would be like pretty, pretty consistent with being Ethereum, but it's not sharding. It's a separate team building a separate system, which is not composable with separate economics as a separate economics and its own token that it's distributing to its team that does not depend on eat at all, and it's making money for itself and for its team members and for its token holders and not for eat. New projects are coming online to the mantle layer two every single week. Why is this happening? Maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer two design architecture since it first started building mantle DA powered by technology from eigen DA.
Maybe it's because users are coming onto the mantle layer two to capture some of the highest yields available in DeFi, and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the $3 billion mantle treasury in the mantle reward station. Maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with, giving you grants, liquidity support, and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application. Maybe it's all of these reasons all put together. So if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto, or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's DeFi apps, click the link in the show notes to getting started with mantle.
Imagine a future where AI and blockchain converge, where decentralized intelligence operates transparently with Web3 infrastructure, unlocking boundless human potential. And that future is here with zero gravity, the first decentralized AI operating system. Zero gravity isn't as fast or it's 50,000 times faster and a hundred times more cost efficient than current alternatives, unleashing the power of high data applications and modular AI with unrivaled throughput, limitless scalability, and a verified AI framework zero gravity is turning the dream on chain AI into reality. Curious about how AI and Web3 can reshape the future, you can visit zerog.
ai to explore the infrastructure as revolutionizing decentralized AI. Yeah, I definitely want to go there to the economics and value curl, which we have been skating around a little bit. So I guess that brings about the question that I hear a lot, which is RL2's parasitic to the L1. So I'll post that question to Kyle. In a counterfactual world in which the L1 was otherwise scaling and sequencing, yes, if that is not your counterfactual world, then no. But like that that kind of like implicitly like the question implicitly is being asked against that counterfactual. Otherwise, you just say we're scaling them out of saying, but like you need to position it against something.
Would you guys say that the L2 is a parasitic symbiotic? Yes, they are parasitic to Ethereum. They are also net generative of value inside of the Ethereum ecosystem. And so when Arbitrum attracts the marginal user, they attract it to the Ethereum ecosystem. And by the way, the dominant asset on Arbitrum and all of the major L1s is ETH. So there's demand in these ecosystems for ETH. And there's pathways to exponentially grow the user base of Ethereum from what we've seen anytime historically on any chain. And that transaction volume and the growth of the user base, the growth of holders of ETH, including long term holders of ETH, who will probably still do that on the L1, all of that is value accretive.
There's the roll of centric roadmap will succeed or fail based on the tension between defection of chains away from Ethereum or coordination incentives towards Ethereum. There needs to be a harmony there, a yin and a yang of like we need to allow enough flexibility enough tolerance for these layer 2s to issue their own tokens to grow their own wealth to provide their own utility. But enough incentives for that value generation to stay inside of the Ethereum ecosystem. And this is actually in stark contrast to interestingly both Bitcoin and Salona, which are like kind of like monolithic chains where Bitcoin is like don't build any value outside of BTC the asset prune everything away from Bitcoin to focus on BTC the asset.
Salona is the same way, which is in my mind, net stunting is a ceiling on the total value because you're actually being very rigid on the net ecosystems that can be born. And so whether or not the roll of centric roadmap succeeds is going to be because it allowed systems to be parasitic of the layer 1 yet still be contained inside of the broader ecosystem. I think you're touching on something really important, which is incentives. There's a reality that developers are incentivized to launch their own chains. And so to the point of counterfactuals was Coinbase going to launch base on Salona as an application if they didn't build it on Ethereum or were they going to launch it as their own chain.
I am not part of the base team. We can go ask Jesse afterwards, but I think in that counterfactual world, they would have launched it as their own chain instead of keeping it within the Ethereum family, which altos have enabled them to do. So I guess I want to clarify my position, which is I do believe that altos are bad for cryptocurrency. I just believe that they are parasitic to Ethereum in their current form. Do you mean that they're net parasitic to Ethereum as they take away more than they give back? I think they're currently taking users and giving back nothing. So I think like from a like how much are they taking away?
Well, that is a positive thing. And then how much are they giving back? Well, it's like one cent a month on blobs. I think that's what about their reservation demand of like how much east is on arbitrum? Like I should don't know. It looks this up to hundreds of hundreds. Yeah, a quite a large supply of east on arbitrum. What value does that provide to the ecosystem? Oh, I would have been on ETH if it wasn't bridged to arbitrum. Sorry. It would have still been on ETH if it wasn't bridged to arbitrum. What did it? Yeah, but you would have altos have grown the usage of these networks. I'm saying that we should have the counterfactual is we could have just scaled the L1?
That's a roadmap. And the layer two's are the largest buyers that will ever exist of ETH because of how big the layer twos are going to get. Altos are not buyers of ETH. What? No. Users that I'm advertising know the deposit contracts as net buyers of ETH. That's not a buy. That's a noot. It would have been on the it was already on L1 by definition previously. That is the only place it could have ever come from. It was already there. The net value of these ecosystems, the value that they provide to the world is in addition to the Ethereum ecosystem and that value is creating reservation demand for ETH.
The value is in addition to the Ethereum, I thought they were part of the Ethereum ecosystem. For all that you guys have said in this panel so far, this debate so far that we can't talk about roadmaps, roadmaps don't exist. Your counterfactual depends on a scaling road map for Ethereum that has never existed. Your counterfactuals that all of that and for ETH would exist on the ETH L1 if it were not for Arbitram. I agree with that. I don't think there was ever a plan to scale L1. They talked about charting for a while. I don't think there was ever a serious design scale issue. I agree with that.
That is the counterfactual to compare against. It's just the obvious counterfactual. But that never existed again. It's called Salona. It does exist. We are using. Would base have been built on Salona. What do you think? Base is just a, oh, it's literally a fork of optimism. It's the same shit. Is that an application at all? It's another alt views. Alt views are forms of application. No, they're not. Okay. It's literally, it's literally, and you take the same uniswap contract and you copy paste it there. If you just copy paste the same shit 10 more times. It's still an application. That's half the applications in crypto.
But if I'm Coinbase and I want a way to bring users on chain, as I understand, is the fundamental goal of base. What am I going to do? Am I going to build my own chain, build an L2 on Ethereum, or go deploy an app on Salona? I'm going to either build a chain or build an L2. None of the above. You can just be a broker and you can look in the Coinbase today. You have Coinbase UI, whether it's the retail app or the pro app or primate or whatever, and you've got a database on Amazon. The front end happens to point at the back end, obviously, because Coinbase owns both of them. The back end is there, but the front end could point at any other place, and that other place or other places it could point to could include Ethereum, Mainnet, Arbyshroom, Salona Mainnet, it can include fucking avalanche, who cares.
Saying that they need it based to exist is incorrect. They already have the users, they have the KYC, they have the apps on people's phones, they can just tap into liquidity anywhere. The base is by definition unnecessary. I mean, they literally forked off the list of they don't, they don't have to exist at all. Can someone let Brian know? Let Brian Armstrong know? Yeah, actually, I would love to chat seriously. So one thing on, I do want to get back to is, you guys mentioned sort of like, eat the acid. One thing, yeah, like with this relationship between L2s and L1, whether the parasitics and biotic sort of all comes down to eat the acid, because that sort of is the exchange, right?
Like L2s are paying the L1 to post their data, and in return, they're sort of allowing ETH to proliferate on these L2s. So I guess I want to get your guys to take on sort of ETH the acid. Isn't enough to have it on these L2s? Is ETH money on these L2s? Where does the actual value crew for the L1 from ETHs? I think it's going to have a very hard time in this conversation because Kyle doesn't believe in money. So there's a very easy limit to ask for this. So the only assets at scale that are quoted in ETH or in Seoul or NFTs, NFTs, in fact, on no chain are quoted in dollars. They're only quoted in native assets.
But like NFTs today are down 97, 8, 9%, something like that. And if you look at the liquidity pools, the vast majority of quote pairs across both C5 exchanges and D5 are against dollars. There are a couple of pools that are each denominated. Like it's not zero. But I bet you across all 8 L1 and ETH L2s, I bet you ETH quotes as a percentage of LP volume and percentage of TVL as a percentage of actual volumes. I'm getting guessing is on the order of 2 or 3%. The number one pair on Ethereum L1 is ETH USDC. The number two pair is ETH USDT. So in this industry, we're going to just settle for the United States dollar as the unit of account because that's not the cyberpunk future I'm looking forward to.
What about the fiat currency crisis that has underpinned this entire industry for the last decade? Sorry, what crisis? The fiat currency crisis. What's the crisis? The one that we keep on printing all of them, how we printed 16 trillion dollars in 2020. What is the cry? I understand you described a set of facts, but what is the crisis? The devaluation of fiat. What's the crisis? People being able to store their wealth, soren maintain their wealth. There's a number of assets in the world you can own. Saying like, okay. We were going so long after last four years, Kyle. Good bye. You can buy real estate in New York City.
It will go up. You can buy real estate in Dubai. It will go up. You can buy gold. You can buy silver. Look, I think the real thing that people have consternation about when it comes to value accrual in the economics, etc. Let's just name the elephant in the room. It's that altos have tokens too. That's all there is to it. And it's fundamentally, I think that this is a question of whether you think that on balance, altos being on Ethereum versus whatever counterfactual you want to pick, even with them having their own tokens, is that going to be a net positive or net negative to Ethereum, Ethereum, whatever you want to call it, business model, protocol model, etc.
I don't see a case why the pie can't grow and those tokens and those tokens having value can't coexist with Ethereum's value growing. Granted, that is not what the data shows over the last several months. And so this is a forward looking statement. And maybe my counterparts here will say, no roadmaps, no future. But I think that there is a path towards altos being value accrued to the eth asset, even while they have their own tokens. I think the arguing that eth is money in 2024 or 2022, 2024 is harder because we are looking at a very distant future and arguing that eth isn't money is easy because if we are only looking at today's age, Bitcoiners have done this fantastically well where Bitcoin is actually becoming this new internet currency that is like digital gold.
But in the future world, if there is this incentive to produce chains like there has been the incentive to produce tokens in crypto, and if there is this desire to have these chains aggregated into the same ecosystem. And if one ecosystem captures all of that demand to produce chains, that which we've seen. Yeah, base is just another stack of OP fork. Maybe we should just fork the OP stack 10,000 more times. Maybe people are actually going to go do that for whatever the hell reason, probably, probably. Maybe there's an addition to other reasons other than scaling. And maybe there's one ecosystem where all of these chains are tied together, however loosely.
And this is what we call the internet. And there's one currency that's native to this whole network of chains. And that is money. You do. This has as worth $300 billion. One of the largest assets in the world. The the onus is on it to justify its valuation. And like all of the valuation value capture is explicitly leaking to the other places being to the L2s. I wonder what in like the last year, what would show up if you looked at all of the ETH L2 tokens and you kind of added them up and put ETH market share with the ETH L2 tokens and then compared it to Bitcoin. Like I wonder what that would look like, although all these.
I bet you it's about like 50%. ETH plus ETH L2 is probably about 50%. Maybe I'm putting words in your mouth. But do you think that like optimism token and arbitration token have taken away value from the ETH token? None of this is financial advice, by the way. Like maybe in the short term, based off of narratives. But also in the long term, also based off of narrative, I could equally see value flowing back to ETH. Sorry, where is that value coming from? Can you please be explicit? Multicoins capitulation. That's not value flowing back to ETHs. Can I ask a question genuinely about the Solana ecosystem?
Because I don't know. What are the primary sort of value capture mechanisms, business models, etc. of the apps on Solana? I mean, I know that there's a lot of mean coin generation. So that's an element of it. But do we see this desire to launch your own chain that we've seen throughout the history of crypto, at least since 2016, since 2014, maybe, even with all coins? And the business model of Sol today is functionally basically the same as the business model of the ETH. No, no, the apps on Solana's are. Yeah, I mean, again, every app on ETH and on any L2 has a functional equivalent on Solana today.
I don't think there is an exception to that statement. I would posit then perhaps Ethereum is living in Solana's future. Perhaps just by virtue of being more mature, having been around longer, having had apps devs go through the many painful cycles of the last several years. I mean, in many ways, I think, had the benefit of launching in a really rough market right around the start of COVID. And it's been not exactly up only, but certainly relative to that. Whereas app devs on Ethereum have cut their teeth over the years and have realized that they need a better model, both in terms of their own ownership of their roadmaps and technology development.
Also, just in terms of owning their own value accrual. And that's where this desire to launch their own chains comes from. And I think Ethereum has done itself a service by keeping them at home. So let me answer the question. Are there people on Solana who want to build their own L2? Yes, you can go look at them. There's ones sitting right there. Yes. Okay. Represent? The difference between the way that ETH is approaching this and the way that Solana is approaching this is that Solana is still focused on scaling the L1. And ETH is focused on doing as much as possible to make the L2s have. I'm seeing something else though.
I think fundamentally scaling is part of the issue. There's also an incentive issue. Well, I think that strongly rejects. That statement is implicit on the only way to capture value is to be a chain and kind of implicit on that statement as to control sequencing. And that's just not necessary. There are many apps on Solana today. Camino, drift, margin, drip, bunch that are all making dwell on. Oh, yeah. Pump is in the nine figures. All the ones that is listed are well in the eight figures. Revenue. And they're all in Solana. I mean that. And obviously like all they on ETH made that I think is doing roughly $50 million.
I think year to date, roughly revenue. So I get that this statement is just like not correct. Take your as revenue. I would say the long term. What is the best way to capture value? Maybe this remains to be seen. But I think the very fact of you to swap and unichen making this pivot arguably, I mean, certainly I think no one in this room would argue that it's not the thing that they point their mom and dad to as the app that Web 3 has enabled. I think that that's a strong data point on the other side. I actually unworded my mom to pump that fun the other day. Another question I do have the Kyle is yes, L2s are being built on Solana and they're actually called network extensions pretty ironically.
I'm curious if you think there are differences from like a text endpoint or maybe something that points to the fact that those are more extensions of Solana than L2s are of Ethereum. Yeah, I mean again, the the the term that we presented came about because I was chatting with Austin and Raj about this a while ago. And there's an academic definition of L2s and you can have like David's sector of like property rights as you mentioned earlier, maybe kind of the academic definition of what makes them L2 and L2. Then there's like the practical thing that the normal people observe. And what normal people observe today is arbitrary optimism and base are the same fucking thing as you don't want.
It's literally the same contracts deployed. It's the same applications. Like even it's the Uniswap's copy base that obvious copy base. It's like aero drone, which is like the top decks on base is a copy of like a four to use. Like you know, so it's like literally the same copy based at shit. And also it's the same assets too. And so my observation was okay, the term L2 just means L1 but a little cheaper, a little faster. And there are some people in Solana who are doing that. And I call sure call those things L2s whatever I don't like care. But then there's a group of people doing things that are off chain that interact with the chain, but that are not that.
They're not copy paced of the same things. Some examples that include grass. Another example that would do with metaplexes doing with any or a thing. There's probably one or two other examples. I saw a medic block in Solana on Solana. And I looked at these things and other okay, they're not copy paced of the same contracts and they're not the same applications. So I thought it would actually be helpful for the ecosystem as a whole to try and create separate vocabulary for that fact. Can you say in like an academic sense of like property guarantees, rights guarantees. It's the same like sure. But like there's more to it than that.
There's like what people today observe as L2s. And so the intent was to create separation there. But I just want to double click like the reason that Solana's approach to L2s is very different than each approach to L2s is that each has spent the majority of dev time over the past four years on the L2 road map. That means making being an L2 as cheap and easy as possible. And Solana has done the opposite. And we're looking at the fruits of the labor now. And we can make our own judgments on which was a good decision. But to say that there are L2s on Solana and there are L2s on ETH. And therefore both of them have L2 road map is wrong because the the road map on Solana was never to make L2s awesome.
It was to make Solana awesome and to increase the throughput to a million TPS. And they're working on it. Okay. We'll see if they get there. Fire dancers doing some some good work. I understand. But there was never a wavering in the conviction that Solana could be a place where a ton of ton of activity could happen. And there was never a, oh no, we're like not skilled enough to scale it so that we probably should let Ed Selton do the scaling for us. And I think it's partly a conversation issue. Core devs jockey paid enough on ETH. They could pay a lot more on Solana. And if you went to like Ed before he started off changing labs and said, hey, Ed, like we really want you to work on scaling the core protocol.
And here's a million dollars and you're a really smart guy. Hopefully you can help us with that. Would he have launched a token? I don't know. Maybe not. And I think the same is true for a lot of the other towns people that started L2s. If we just compensate that them appropriately like Solana is doing for the developers, we could probably have good developers working on scaling the L1 and not working on launching it on L2 token and creating time boosts to track as much value to that token as possible. I think part of your perspective, Max is just because I think you're kind of like a layer 1 maxi.
Like call it Ethereum Solana or whatever you just like you prefer a value capture to be on the layer one. And that's your, that's your frame of reference, right? I could be convinced that the Ethereum project has over indexed on subsidizing layer two. That could be convinced that Ethereum layer one once upon a time had this DeFi golden goose that is more or less giving up for free to a network of VC funded layer two that are more than happy to take it because Ethereum is not scaling the layer one. I could be convinced of that. Yeah, also at the same time, the Ethereum network of chains model, which I keep on returning back to is also under competitive threat as well.
Celestial would love to take DA consumers away from Ethereum. And I think the Ethereum DA is at 75, 80 percent capacity and getting filling in that last 20 percent is going to be relatively easy and why it can be done in the next couple of months or so. And so it's really about, do you believe in the roll up centric roadmap? What do you want your priority to be? Ethereum is trying to do it all. And I know some people therefore invest in Bitcoin and Sol as the barbell. And some people think that Ethereum will eventually do it all because it will eventually have very fast layer one block times.
And it will also have a network of chains. And I think it's really just a matter of perspective of what design architecture you think is valuable. I think we have to decide to be the best at something. We cannot be the second best DA layer or the third best DA layer, the second best execution chain or the third best settlement layer. It's the first best money. We cannot do that. We cannot be the second best on everything and expect to win. We have to be the first best on something. Yeah, it's my comments. I've made about North Star over the last couple of months. We're like this like what is what does DeFi mean in the extreme case?
And to me, that means there are thousands of consensus participants if not tens of thousands who are all over the world. And those people are synchronizing financial market information, AMM curves, sea lobs, decks, positions, whatever it is, payments, whatever does matter. And that information is synchronizing around the world at speed of light to anyone who raises their hand and says, I have a piece of hardware that can deal with that. Because obviously if you're dealing with global scale financial information, like that's not going to run on a small computer, but there's just no way to do that.
At least not to do it in real time. Because inherently, financial market data is time sensitive. And so it's like, okay, well, what are you building? And if you want to just say, look, we're building one server somewhere. Anyhow, we get you using property rights guarantees based on this other DA thing underneath. Like, okay, that's a thing. It is functionally similar-ish to the thing that I just described, but like it is not functionally the same thing. And like the question's like, what are you building? And in my mind, like if you're not synchronizing the world's financial market information in real time, around the world, everyone who raises their hand and says, I have a piece of hardware for it, then like that's not DeFi.
We're building the first best settlement layer, the first best property rights engine as David put it. Most economic security, it's the most in-demand from developers. Yes, including the developers on altos. I'm not sure what the question is there, but I will say Max, I think there's something we can all agree on, higher comp for quartet, Debs, for sure. It's my part of my platform, actually. That part, right? And we're going to pay teachers more, too. Hell yeah. And no taxing of tips. So unfortunately, we're already over time. I definitely wanted to see that play out of it. So I guess close things out.
If everyone could give I guess closing remarks based on this conversation, maybe you found some middle ground, maybe you want to solidify a position. So I guess we'll start with David and work our way down this way. I think the market demand for producing chains should be just taken as fact. In this day and age, we know that there's going to be many, many, many chains. That's the first thing that happened after we made Bitcoin was we made 15 more chains. And that was the proof of work for Confere Launchera. There's going to be more chains. Some chain is going to figure out how to aggregate all the chains.
Some chain is going to figure out how to make these chains have stronger property rights and composability mechanisms between all these chains. And that one chain is going to incentivize the production and aggregation of even further chains. And that chain will become money. What are the goals of East and what are the goals of the L2s to create censorship resistant apps to create composable apps and user experiences? That one again, I think is the big outstanding question. That's what we all need to be working on. And number three, to have a sustainable economic engine behind all of this value of crawl.
And that sustainable economic engine needs to acknowledge the reality that the best way for app devs to deploy is by doing it as their own chain. That's what we see in a mature ecosystem. And that is not at the expense of the base money of East. David, you mentioned that you might be convinced that we're giving up our goal and goose of DeFi. So that some VC funded L2s could take that away and they'll be happy to do it. What more you need to see to be convinced of that when paradigm has launched to L2s this week and has more L2s in portfolio than they have venture partners. They know what they're doing.
We should recognize it and we should immediately understand it and say, hold on a second, we see this is actually eat. This is not yours. And we should immediately act to stop the migration of financial activity in the life blood of Ethereum off of the L1. That's a question today. As I'm asking you, Russ, I was just, yeah, I think I'll get the rightful question. Oh, yeah, just come back to my North Star comment. Like, these are financial systems. That's what we have DeFi with payments. Like, do you have to be clear about what financial system you want in the world? The one I want is one in which anyone can raise their hand whether they're in India or the Philippines or in the USA or in Europe, raise their hand and say, I get to access the information at the same speed as everyone else.
I think that is like the definition of the maximally democratized open financial system. I don't understand even an academic definition that more fully encapsulates that vision. And so like that's what I'm trying to build and that's where I'm allocating my capital. Awesome. This is super fun. David, good luck with the fight tonight. Thank you.