✨ DEBRIEF | Ryan & David unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-the-eric-wall-interview
------ What’s the Endgame for Bitcoin Scaling? That’s what we asked bitcoin builder and researcher Eric Wall.
We start by exploring the evolution of Bitcoin and the genesis of scaling solutions on top of it. We then get into the intricacies of the BitVM, what exactly is a Bitcoin L2 and what’s coming next.
Eric is the perfect guest to explore this frontier of Bitcoin Rollups, he tells it like it is and he understands both Ethereum and Bitcoin.
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo ⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🏠 CASA | SECURE YOUR GENERATIONAL WEALTH https://bankless.cc/Casa
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🌐 CARTESI | APPLY FOR A GRANT https://bankless.cc/CartesiGovernance
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 5:47 Eric Wall 9:48 The Evolution of Bitcoin 21:31 The Genesis of Bitcoin L2s 36:40 Runes 46:22 BitVM 1:04:45 Why Bitcoin L2s are Inevitable 1:09:07 Stacks 1:11:37 Bitcoin L2 Endgame 1:17:39 Scams 1:23:13 Bitcoin’s Direction 1:27:25 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Eric Wall https://twitter.com/ercwl
Taproot Wizards https://taprootwizards.com/
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
I mean, what we ultimately need for Bitcoin is... Actually, I'm not that convinced that we need to take everything that Ethereum has done and put it onto Bitcoin. We don't need all of the Ethereum stuff to exist on Bitcoin. I don't think so. But what I do know that we do need, we just need a way for me to be able to send Bitcoin to you in a scalable and private fashion. Just so that Bitcoin as a currency works. Welcome to Bankless, where today we explore the frontier of Bitcoin Layer 2s. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. The big question, can Bitcoin scale through Layer 2s the way Ethereum has?
I think it's the most important question that Bitcoin builders are facing today. And it's hard. There's a lot of noise out there. We've got to find out what's real, what's narrative, what's a scam, what the future actually looks like for Bitcoin. That's why we're having this episode today with Eric Wall. He's on today, and he's got the most thorough take that David and I have heard on this subject. He's the perfect guest for this because not only does Eric tell it like it is, he also understands both Ethereum and Bitcoin. So a few topics we get into in the episode. Number one, the Ordinals and Runes Awakening, why that is upon us and what effect it's had.
Number two, why Lightning failed. Number three, the state of Bitcoin Layer 2s. Where are they today? Number four, we talk about BitVM and the fatal flaw it might have. Number five, we talk about the answer, the solution, the cat op code. You'll have to hear Eric talk about that and evangelize for it. Number six, Eric's message to us, be extremely cautious when you hear the words Bitcoin layer two and why he says that. And number seven, why Eric is optimistic about Bitcoin's future and the building that is going on today. The progress of what you can do on Bitcoin, the evolution of Bitcoin, I think it actually runs in parallel to the story of Eric Wall himself.
Early Bitcoiner who like self-described as becoming an outcast out of Bitcoin because the laser eyed monetary maximalists decided that you don't put any sort of ZK magic on Bitcoin. That's not what it's for. And then entered the Bitcoin dark ages where Eric Wall was forced to look elsewhere for scaling solutions. And that's where he found the Layer 2 space outside of Bitcoin, but still had like his first love. These are all his words that I think he used to describe his own arc when we did our first episode with him. Eric Wall comes back and kind of gives us an arc of the Bitcoin renaissance, how it started, where it's gone and what the current frontier is.
The current limitations, too, of the Bitcoin Layer 2 space and what might be next steps for the actual technical evolution of the Bitcoin protocol. all. So just a really a masterclass in Bitcoin, I would say, along with just like the current issues, current events of the time. So let's go ahead and get right into that conversation with Eric Wall. But first, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible, especially Kraken, our preferred place to buy crypto in 2024. If you do not have an account with Kraken, consider clicking the links in the show notes, getting started with Kraken today.
If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive, and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone, everywhere to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos.
With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Celo is the mobile-first EVM-compatible carbon-negative blockchain built for the real world. Driving real-world use cases like mobile payments and mobile DeFi, and with Opera MiniPay as one of the fastest-growing Web3 wallets, Celo is seeing a meteoric rise with over 300 million transactions and 1.
5 million monthly active addresses. And now Celo is looking to come home to Ethereum as a layer two. Optimism, Polygon, Matterlabs, and Arbitrum have all thrown their hats in the ring for the Celo layer two to build upon their stacks. Why the competition? The Celo layer two will bring huge advantages like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability secured by Ethereum validators, and one block finality. What does that all mean for you? With Celo layer two, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC-20 tokens, sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using Social Connect.
But Celo is a community-governed protocol. This means that Celo needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Celo forums, follow Celo on Twitter, and visit Celo.org to shape the future of Ethereum. Arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications. Arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale, with low fees and faster transactions. Arbitrum has the leading DeFi ecosystem, strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs, and is quickly becoming the Web3 gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.
arbitrum.io. Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitrum Orbit chain? Arbitrum Orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own Orbit chain, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput. Whether you're a developer, an enterprise, or a user, Arbitrum Orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum. Experience Web3 development the way it was always meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Visit arbitrum.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities.
Bankless Nation, Eric Wall, is a crypto OG, first enamored by Bitcoin and the many irreplaceable properties that Bitcoin has, and then later also by many of the technical research breakthroughs in the Ethereum ecosystem. Eric now finds himself straddling many different universes, but all with strong cryptography and trust assurances underpinning what Eric finds interesting and pays attention to. Eric also recently shaved his head because the ETH-BTC ratio broke below a certain level that he said that it wouldn't, even though no one really asked him to do that. Eric, welcome back to Bankless. We're happy he did, though.
Well, there are some people that insist that Eric doesn't just lose a bet like that. So they think that the reason that I shaved my head was because I was camouflaging a hair transplant. So that I lost the bet in order to get a hair transplant without anyone noticing. And I'm fine with either of those theories. I'm happy either way. Either or maybe both. What was the real reason? So wait, did you shave it in solidarity with Ethereum or in solidarity with Bitcoin? I'm not familiar with the whole story. Just David showed up one week to me and he was like, yo, Eric shaved his head. There's multiple reasons.
You could say I shaved it in solidarity with the fragmentation issues of Ethereum. Thank you. Or you could say that it was, there was this guy who kept haggling me over a prediction that I made that we were all, we had already reached the low for the year for the FBTC ratio. And so I kind of bundled all those together and just shaved my head. And I think I was kind of done with the man bun anyway. I think the man bun had lived its life. So I think this is for the better. Are you ready to make another prediction on the show today about the ETH Bitcoin ratio? Now can you call a low? And what will you do publicly?
What will you do if you're wrong about that? Yeah, I think we've reached low for the year. I don't know which parts of my body I'm left to shave. It doesn't have to be a shave. It could be like tattoo. Yeah, we can do a tattoo. You could fight David. People are doing that. One at a time. One at a time. Everyone get in line. I'm happy fighting David if I get to join the ring with Nick. I think me and Nick together stands a chance against David. Oh my god. Actually, the first time I ever met Eric Wall in real life, I think I was immediately put into a pretty aggressive headlock. That's true. That's one of the reasons that I fear for Nick, because you were kind of, like, I don't know how, if I could have gotten you down.
like you're kind of you know resistant okay since we're going into the story like this was at ecc right after covid so this was the first time i was meeting basically everyone i had been talking to online for the last like three years and i'm in line at some party for i think like the bar or something and i get put in a headlock and i'm like oh okay somebody somebody who i know is putting me in a headlock in a friendly headlock uh and they're gonna let go and i'm gonna turn around and realize who this is except then like the being let go never really happened it was just the headlock just got more and more intense over time dude it's a bitcoiner headlock we're not dabbling with an ethereum headlock here i think i think i think my main gripe was that uh you guys in the ethereum world have started to call ethereum clients that just uh sink the ethereum state rather than executing every single transaction you call those full notes whereas in bitcoin they are we have to validate every single transaction so it's like there's david i'm gonna i'm gonna punish him for this diluting the term of what a full node actually means uh coming up with new terminology and and i guess that's what we're going to talk about a little bit today uh what's the definition of an l2 and there's also been like a degradation of that term which you guys have also played a little smart i have two like we all we're all guilty of uh degrading what it means to be an l2 yeah oh yeah i love when eric wall comes on an episode because I know we're going to bring back the purity of decentralization and why we're here.
And trust us. We should get into it then. Let's set the landscape a little bit. Eric, almost two years ago, November of 2022, you and I did an episode discussing the technical potential of ZK layer twos on Bitcoin. This was like, it was only 18-ish months ago, but still super early. Like, ordinals weren't a thing. Runes weren't a thing. Everything was completely theoretical. and now not only do we have both tokens and nfts on bitcoin but now there's this emerging class of layer twos on bitcoin um how would you like explain or characterize the arc of what bitcoin was back then i'll call that like 2022 2021 bitcoin dark ages maybe you agree or don't agree uh but like characterize the arc of bitcoin technological progress uh since then like what do you think about the current direction of bitcoin if i recall correctly i think the origin of that episode was that the Human Rights Foundation, together with a grant from Starkware and CMS Holdings, assigned a research paper to be written about what are the potential scalability benefits of putting a ZK rollup on Bitcoin within the block size constraints of Bitcoin.
Like if you just use the full four megabyte block that Bitcoin has, how far can we get with the zk roll-up uh in like ideal circumstances and uh john light was the person that wrote that i i was the person that at human rights foundation that sort of selected the person to write the paper and i selected john light because i think it's uh uh what i liked about him was that he was actually sort of anti zk roll-ups before writing the paper but i know that he's a neutral guy and he's going to stick to like what the research says and the results that he came to were pretty interesting. Like we could be looking at a 40x, 50x scalability improvement on Bitcoin if we had a ZK verifier and a covenants opcode on Bitcoin.
So that was like, I think back then what we were excited about was that, well, if we actually had ZK rollups on Bitcoin, not only would the scalability improve significantly, but we would also be able to tap into the full expressiveness that ZK rollups give. And that could also lead to privacy enhancements because if you have a zero knowledge proof, you can embed any type of virtual machine, private or non-private into that as well. So ZK rollups suddenly like came back to the scene as this is like a real, this has a real potential to improve Bitcoin on all the sort of facets that we could think of.
So I think we were just trying to bring back ZK roll-ups back into the discussion of what should the next soft fork in Bitcoin be. And there were some people at that time that were thinking that, you know, a ZKP verifier opcode is maybe not impossible to get into Bitcoin. So maybe we should look more into that. But to sort of describe the overall arc of what has been happening since then is that, I mean, this was still like ZKP verifiers in Bitcoin were still, you know, there's a lot of people that need convincing. And it's not only the people that need convincing. It's also which type of ZKP verifier do we put into Bitcoin?
Because it's not like in Ethereum where you have a roll-up and you can just upgrade the roll-up to use... We usually have admin keys that with a delayed function can upgrade the roll-up to use some type of new circuit if you find a new one. But in Bitcoin, we really have one soft fork and then we have one zero-knowledge proof system, one proving system. And that now maybe has to be the zero knowledge proof way that we verify things in Bitcoin for, I don't know, five years, 10 years. Right. You got to get it right the first time. Yeah, we got to get it right the first time. That led to some discussions of like, let's maybe put something more generalized, like a ZK Wasm verifier.
and then we can put other types of uh zk circuits inside that so that the zk wasm sort of verifies the starts and the snarks and the growth 16s of the world um but what has happened sort of recently over the last year as i've as i've uh you know gone around and spoken to different researchers the most significant one i think was in palo alto last year where we got together a a bunch of CK interested people in Bitcoin, which aren't a lot of people, by the way. Within the research community of Bitcoin, I'd say there's a small fraction of people that are knowledgeable enough to have a real conversation about zero knowledge proof in Bitcoin.
But the sort of crew that we could amass, that we could gather, we gathered in Palo Alto. And going out of that meeting, I actually felt we were further away from getting zero knowledge proofs into Bitcoin. than I felt before getting into that meeting. So I'm sort of less optimistic that we're going to get a CKP-verified opcode in Bitcoin in the next, say, two or three years. I'm not sure that that's... Why pessimistic on that? Is it just so hard to get any kind of opcode into Bitcoin, much less a ZK-proof opcode, that you just think that's politically insurmountable? Or I don't even know if politically is kind of the right word for that.
Yeah, so choosing the right one and not being able to upgrade that is maybe the hardest challenge to tackle. So if you wanted them to do what I described, that you wanted to have a ZK WASM that you put other verifiers into, then the problem is that if you want, for example, Starks, which I think are the least exotic cryptographic primitives, if that's what you want, then you sort of lose those benefits if you verify them in a sort of a WASM environment. Because if you have different layered ZK verifiers on top of each other, you sort of lose the characteristics of one if they sort of all have to go through a funnel of multiple ZK verifiers.
And the complexity increases too. and I think another thing that has shown that has made me more pessimistic is that you know we're fighting right now to just get this opcat opcode into bitcoin and we're making very good strides but opcat is basically an opcode but the only thing that it does it's it can it concatenates two elements on the stack also bitcoin is like a stack-based scripting language so you have like a bunch of elements that are on a stack and you can multiply them. You can use addition, you can use subtraction, but you can't really do anything like super advanced. For example, you can't even concatenate, which is a pretty regular thing that you do in programming.
Like you can concatenate two strings. So if I have A, B and C, D and I concatenate them, I have A, B, C, D. Or if I have a two and a two and I concatenate them, I have 22. So that sounds like, so the most like, if you had a calculator and there was a concatenate button, that's like one of the simplest, like it's more simple than cosine or sine or something like that. And even that is like a massively technical conversation in Bitcoin. And the conversation is really about, does this destroy Bitcoin and in effect the world? Like, does this destroy humankind? It's sort of the conversation. The stakes are high.
Yeah, concatenating numbers is like a really dangerous thing. Make sure you can't divide by zero on that. Right. However, like one interesting thing about concatenating number, concatenating strings, is that Merkle tree, how you get a Merkle tree actually just comes from concatenating hashes to have, let's say, 16 hashes at the base layer of a pyramid and you concatenate until you have eight and then you have four and then you have two and then you have one that is actually how a merkle tree is constructed and if you can then verify the hash of the the root node in that merkle tree now you can verify merkle roots and blockchains in general like how both of it both ethereum and bitcoin merkle verification is like the one of the primitives that we use the most so like optimistic roll-ups merkle tree verification syncing the Ethereum state route, Merkle tree verification, SPV proofs in Bitcoin, Merkle tree verification, or Merkle root verification.
And it turns out that with just that small opcode alone, I think maybe we should get into this a bit later in the episode, but just through concatenation, we can get Merkle verification, but we can also get a form of covenants. I don't know how familiar you guys are with covenants, but that's like, covenants is the ability to create, let's call them finite state machines. You know, Bitcoin is stateless, doesn't have a way to update variables and carry over state from one transaction to the other. Covenants is a way to do that. It's a way to sort of restrict where coins can go in specific paths in sort of like a state machine.
You can sort of program that state machine to decide like how the different paths in the state machines can look like and what you do in those different paths. So apparently concatenation alone through some weird cryptography that comes from Schnorr signatures. you can actually do this with ecda signatures too uh you can actually get covenants with just this one uh uh with this one uh concatenation opcode alone and uh you can even there so there's some people at starkware that think that they can even actually program a start verifier with just this one this one simple opcode that's cat so you could you could actually verify like starkware starks And if you have covenants and Starks, so what we talked about in that previous episode that you realized, you need a ZKP verifier and you need recursive covenants in order to create ZK roll-ups on Bitcoin.
So if the Stark verifier works with the cath, which we're still unsure about, then we can actually get ZK roll-ups on Bitcoin. my company taproot wizards we since we don't know for sure yet that we're going to be able to do zk starts with just cat alone we have an alternative approach which does optimistic verification of arbitrary computation it uses something called mat which again uses merkle trees to a very large extent so that you know how in in in optimistic roll ups that you have a state route and then you update that state route with another one and then in order to find if there was like fraud between those state routes that didn't follow a specific state transition function you can do uh you can do bisection games and identify okay this is where this is the part where you lied about what the computation was we can do that in bitcoin if we have merkle verif if we have merkle root verification so that is basically the idea of matt so if you bundle matt with recursive covenants, then you can get a, and actually a real version of optimistic.
Sometimes it actually becomes more like plasma, but some, some hybrid between plasma and optimistic rollups with just capital, even if we can't do stocks. So that was a mouthful. And I think that does a really good job kind of illustrating some of the aspirations that technical people have for the future of Bitcoin rollups and also the technical hurdles that need to be overcome in order to actually make true, valid Layer 2s spawn from Bitcoin. But Eric, also at the same time, we're seeing many, many Bitcoin Layer 2s spawning to this day that are skipping over basically everything that you just laid out.
Because as maybe listeners kind of got the gist of, it's really hard and complicated and not technically there yet. You get an opcode in specifically, right? Exactly. But nonetheless, there are the Bitcoin Layer 2s are like a whole thing. Like VCs are funding them. Users are starting to use them. One of them just went mainnet this week. So how do you like square these two things? How do you feel about that dislocation, that discrepancy between, well, you don't have OPCAT in, yet nonetheless, Bitcoin Layer 2s as a narrative is here. How do you feel about this? Yes. So this is difficult. But I think what basically happened was that Casey Rottermore invented the Ordinals Protocol.
And I think maybe a bigger invention that sort of the ordinals protocol itself was this thing, which are called envelopes, which is how you packet very large blobs of arbitrary data into Bitcoin. And basically finding data availability. Yeah, it's like, oh, apparently we had access to call data in Bitcoin, a part of the block space that we don't execute. That's just a dumb data blob. Apparently, we have that. And you needed to come up with a small script, which it basically creates an if statement. And then that whole if statement is false. So you never actually check what is underneath that if statement, because you just know that this part of the script is false.
And then what you can do with the rest of the script is you can just put arbitrary data in there. So that is what is called an envelope in Casey Rottermoor's ordinal theory. And that ability that, I mean, we've actually had the ability to packet large amounts of arbitrary data in Bitcoin before. It was just way more clunky. Like you could divide all the stater blobs into different transaction outputs. And it was just like you needed to be a somewhat savvy programmer writing an arbitrary data scheme in Bitcoin that looked at different parts of transactions and carved out this part from here, this part from here, this part from here.
But basically with this sort of envelope trick, it became very easy in a block explorer to see, oh, there's all my data. Like I can see in the block explorer, there's all that data. And I don't have to like tie it together with that transaction input and that transaction input. So what this means is that what this meant was that, okay, now we can put 400 kilobyte data blobs in single transaction inputs in Bitcoin. And they will propagate in the Bitcoin network. That's usually one of the issues, like when you create non-standard transactions in Bitcoin, while they're valid in the blockchain, nodes will not propagate them.
And miners running that same software will not actually put them into blocks. But if another miner does, it will still be a valid block and they'll accept it as valid. But what we have since SegWit and Taproot was that we have this 400 kilobyte arbitrary data blobs that propagated freely over the network and miners included them into the blockchain. So now all of a sudden we have like this huge part of the block, which is like a place where, you know, it's a free for all. You can do whatever you can. You can even write an entire EVM inside of that arbitrary, like as a sovereign roll up, you can embed a whole blockchain into the Bitcoin blockchain that way.
And that was actually what I, so we started using this for JPEGs, right? So Taproot Wizard. And yeah, so the first. That is shameful. I can't believe you did that by the way. Yeah. So the first, I mean, the first ordinal inscription, number one, is just dick butt. Of course. Dick butts. Let's go. Let's go. Yeah. And that was actually inscribed by our CTO at the attack. He joined later as the CTO of Taproot Wizards. And he's actually the same guy that has now implemented this way of how you use the CAD op code to create like recursive covenants. So he's actually a super smart guy. But the first thing that he did when he sort of discovered the Ordinals Protocol, inscription number one, just put a dickbutt in there.
The thought that I had was that, okay, well, we have this arbitrary data space in Bitcoin. Now we can build meta protocols inside of Bitcoin that are, like, we don't have to work with the same confines as previous meta protocols as Bitcoin had to, you know, confine themselves to. So like writing meta protocols inside of Bitcoin is actually not something that is super new. You know that USDT used to exist on Bitcoin and then Ethereum sort of took over all that USDT. That meta protocol was called the Omni layer. So that was a fungible token standard that lived inside of Bitcoin. And there's been other protocols like Counterparty was also a protocol like that.
But however, they had to sort of work with restrictions on how much data they could put on there. So you couldn't have like an Ethereum style sequencer that, you know, takes all transactional data and ZK proofs and bundles them into each block of Bitcoin. That was like not really practical before. But since we had Ordinals, that now became practical. Cool. Anyway, so what happened was after the dickbutt, Taproot Wizards, we made a four megabyte block that was just a JPEG of a wizard. And then people realized, okay, so the entire Bitcoin block is just up for grabs. You can put any amount of, we had to go, we had to like contact the miner and be like, can you like modify your node and like put it into the blockchain?
Nowadays, there are specific services that are popping up that are doing this like as a service. So Marathon, the Marathon mining pool has one called a slipstream. So now like this is not something that you have to, you have to do anything weird. You just have to connect to the Marathon API and just send them whatever data you want to pack it in there. Anyway, so I mean, I guess as everyone knows, and you as Ethereum people know that, you know, Ethereum NFTs has sort of been struggling a little bit price-wise. Like, I don't know, Bored Ape is like 12 ETH these days. I don't know how the others are doing.
Moonburst, like all, a lot of these blue chip NFT collections have sort of collapsed. And I guess that some people felt that, well, we need a new narrative here. And the narrative was that, well, what if instead, like we had links to JPEG, like what if instead of putting, what if instead of us putting IPFS links to pictures on the Ethereum blockchain chain we inscribed the whole jpeg into the bitcoin blockchain so it stays there forever so we're working with a scarce bitcoin block space you know all the nodes download all of the blockchain is going to get replicated over a whole network of tens of thousands of nodes those are like real pristine like fine art uh fine art entities so that became like that took its own life and now we have marketplaces for that so and now we have communities we have dj communities for that so so like contrasting to what the the bitcoin layer two space has been looking like in the past because it's not the first time that we have like layer twos let us call them sites so side chains so the liquid side chain the root stock side chain that's not new at all we've had those for a very long time now uh that there's like large amounts of money that are floating around trading NFTs on Bitcoin.
Now there's a sort of season two in the Bitcoin space where we have our own native degens that are trading NFTs with Bitcoin. And actually the way that we trade those NFTs is actually kind of interesting as well, because most of the trading for Bitcoin NFTs are actually on chain using something called pre-signed Bitcoin transactions. And those are atomic swaps like you atomically swap the bitcoin nft which is actually an a specific satoshi well a specific utx so what are the first satoshis of a specific utx so you swap them uh with bitcoin in one transaction atomically there's no uh there's no uh doesn't go through a centralized exchange it's actually on chain atomic swaps that's how entities on bitcoin are traded so like you're basically like writing an open check saying hey whoever wants to fulfill this check here's a check for like this amount of money uh for this jpeg if you want to take the other if you also want to sign here you can send me this amount of money and then you can have the jpeg yeah exactly so this this this is the start of the bitcoin season two starting to drum up right and then so one of the things that i was uh sort of trying to make popular was that well we can use this arbitrary block space to create sovereign roll-ups on Bitcoin.
So that means you take something like, let's say, for example, you take ZK Sync and you look at what is it that they're putting into call data on Ethereum? Well, I should say in the blob space of Ethereum, you just take that and you put it into Bitcoin in the Bitcoin blob space. Now, you're not going to get Ethereum nodes that are verifying those knowledge proofs and making sure that that computation was done successfully. But you can have other nodes like external nodes that read the data out of the Bitcoin blockchain, and you will get the ordering from Bitcoin and you'll get the data availability from Bitcoin and the persistence of data from Bitcoin.
So that's what sovereign roll-ups or many of those sort of celestia's sovereign roll-ups work the same way they become sort of their own layer ones but they get so much of the uh properties of bitcoin that these this is now actually an interesting way to make uh i'm not i wouldn't i wouldn't necessarily call it a layer two uh it it it's a layer two if it does act if it aggregates transaction in some like compactful way so there are some people that are saying that if you use uh zero knowledge proofs with state diffs now that's that's a layer two because you don't have all of the transactional data but in reality like how state diffs work it's um state diffs only really compress like the the transactional data that they have that you have to put on chain if it's sort of the same state that is getting updated multiple multiple times in the same block and a lot of times in you know blockchains you know you you're sending money to charlie charlie is sending money to eva eva's interacting with a compound contract.
There's a bunch of things that is happening. Not always can you just compress all of that because there's different states that needs to get updated. But anyway, you get some compression benefits when you have state diffs. So I guess you could call some of those sovereign rollups, like actual layer twos. Anyway, so started with ordinals, and then some people are starting to build sovereign rollups. Alpen Labs and Chainway are some of the teams that are working on software. Bison Labs is another one. And I'm an investor in Chainway and in Alpen Labs. And I was sort of advising them to, well, you can't build your ZK rollup right now on Bitcoin because we don't have these ZKP verifier opcodes.
But you can build a sovereign rollup and make a vibrant ecosystem. And then by the time that we actually do have a way to verify zero knowledge proofs on Bitcoin, you can transition. so that was that that's like mid 2023 and now now there's like okay we have ordinals and we have sovereign roll-ups there's like a full ethereum virtual machines running inside of bitcoin that are zero knowledge proven this is what is getting like investors to get excited so even then like in the middle of 2020 and 23 people are getting excited about bitcoin innovation in a new way because and if you also think about it like all that what what what was the reason for like okay so you have root stock and you have liquid on on uh connected to bitcoin through side chains but what is the user base like who who's going to use that there's traditionally been almost like no material usage on those chains but if you see that super like if you see that very vibrant uh ordinal activity and you imagine that well they're gonna hit scalability limits and all And also, the way that they're doing, and I don't know, so it started with NFTs on Bitcoin, but then that later gave rise to another thing, which were called BRC20 tokens.
I think you guys are familiar with those, right? But the BRC20 tokens suck. Like, I don't know if you have tried actually to transact or sell a BRC20 token. It is the worst trading experience that has existed in any protocol that has existed under the son of blockchain since the dawn of mankind. It is so awful. It is so awful because you have to sell... First of all, if I want to purchase on BRC20 token, there's going to be listings like offers for sale. And I can buy 10,000 from that guy and 60,000 from that guy and 100,000 from that guy of these tokens and then i have these these uh like clumps of like piles of tokens and then if i want to sell like five of those then i have to make like a new transaction that slices up five from my existing pile and then i can sell that uh pile of five but then the per the buyer who now wants to buy let's see why he wants to buy three he can't buy three thousand he has to buy my either my whole 5000 pile or none of it so it's like the the tokens are fungible but you have to sort of manually slice them up as pizza slices and then they're like non-functional force fungibility so that was that's how brc20 token uh trading works and still works this day on bitcoin so everyone's sort of realizing that okay there's there's there's there's a lot of money here but uh they're they cannot like we and we don't we don't have uh automated market makers either right so we don't have like liquidity pools or anything so so the whole the whole uh trading is like completely one-sided where there are there are offers but there are no bids so there's just one-sided uh liquidity marketplaces there's no liquidity pools or anything really quick in the brc uh 20 thing that that was kind of like old tech right we had we had casey uh the creator of ordinals and runes on on the podcast not too long ago and it's like very excited about the launch of of runes, which like the TLDR from him was basically like runes is a better version of a, you know, a Bitcoin fungible tokens and upgrade from the BRC 20.
Is that, are you also considering runes when you're talking about BRC 20? Or is that sort of like, is the new tech a lot better? So runes are better in the sense that they integrate with like traditional, traditional Bitcoin wallets better. So a bit, so runes are just UTXOs. BRC 20s are not. BRC20s are like, you have to go into the arbitrary data space of an inscription and then read a JSON. And then you understand, okay, this person owns that many of that BRC20. In runes, it's UTXO based. So if you own this UTXO, in the up return of that UTXO, it'll say how many of those runes that you own. So you can build like regular Bitcoin wallets that are only used to working with UTXOs.
They can like own these runes. as pure UTXOs. So it becomes a lot more easier to build, to integrate that with sort of traditional Bitcoin wallet software. However, the trading experience is exactly as shit as VRC20s. Oh, no. Yes, yes, yes. I didn't realize that. So right now, Unisat is like the biggest marketplace for VRC20s. Actually, I think OKEx eclipsed it for a while. I think it might be back to Unisat marketplace at the moment. But as a user, as a technical person, you understand, well, runes have benefits. But as just like the retail user that's trying to interact with these tokens, it looks exactly the same.
You still have to like, OK, I have to buy either like 1.5 million of this token or I have to buy 20,000 of this token. And then I have to slice them up. So the trading experience is the same. So it's actually, it's the exact same shit. It's just more, it just works better for people that want to integrate this with Bitcoin wallets. So runes are great. They're better. Like we love them. And the main reason that we love them is because BRC20s bloated the UTXO set of Bitcoin. So if you're buying BRC20 tokens, every time that you're splitting them up or sending them to someone else, the UTXO set just keeps growing.
And that's basically like the state. So you know that you have problems with state bloat in Ethereum, like the state just keeps getting bigger. In Bitcoin, yeah, our UTXO set gets bigger also. But sometimes you want to take all your unspent transaction outputs and you want to send them to one person. And then it actually collapses. So the UTXO set tends to grow and shrink depending on people, like when people are consolidating their transactions. But BRC20 tokens had no consolidation mechanism. So it was just like, and if you look at these charts, up only and that means harder RAM requirements on Bitcoin nodes.
So it's actually kind of like an attack on the Bitcoin system. Rune's avoid that because they are UTXO based, they can collapse and combine in the same way that UTXOs do. So they don't have that up on the UTXO problem. But they didn't solve the user experience of trading. They didn't solve the UX problem, sadly. They just told, okay, now people are more happy with the growth rate of the UTXO set. So we still, so the situation that we're in, that we have been in is that, well, now there's actually a need for layer twos on Bitcoin that can offload some of this UTXO bloat and runes trading. And you have seen the fees gone crazy on Bitcoin, right?
There was a, I think there was a day that, of course, it was right after halving. It was $78 million in fees. 80 million dollar day and that was a day where like ethereum just to give context was like five million dollars or something so like actually like it crushed um ethereum that day and feed revenue a single typical bitcoin transfer was 170 or something for a short period of time yeah so i mean doing this dgen token and ft trading uh right now is still small so like sometimes the fees are low but obviously this is not going to scale for for right for the long term so that is why vcs are saying that there's going to be a need for second layers on bitcoin so they're very interested in these sovereign uh sovereign roll-ups like okay how can they aggregate transactions with zk and they're even interested now in more fanciful versions of um federated uh multisigs So if you're not just like, so Liquid is an 11 out of 15 multi-sig on Bitcoin.
That's the, you know, predominant, you know, famous sidechain on Bitcoin. But if you start doing something that's like a little bit more exotic than that, then Bitcoin VCs are now, okay, like maybe this is interesting. And I think like the analogy that I'd bring is that I'd say is that, okay, so Polygon started out as a sidechain to Ethereum. and they were Ethereum aligned. And then I think that they, I think the Polygon proof of stake chain launched before roll-ups really even existed as a thing. It did, it was true. Yeah, and then by the time that there were, you know, ZK and roll-up technology existed, they started to pivot to that.
So I think that's maybe how the VC thinks that, okay, some of these things are side chains. As long as they can get traction and momentum, they're going to be able to adopt any type of new technology for layer twos on Bitcoin that that will emerge. Mantle, formerly known as BitDAO, is the first DAO-led Web3 ecosystem, all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network, a brand new, high-performance Ethereum layer two built using the OP stack, but uses Eigenlayer's data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one. Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications.
The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest DAO-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has sub-communities from around Web3 onboarded, like Game7 for Web3 gaming and Bybit for TVL and liquidity and on-ramps. So if you want to build on the Mantle network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle. If you want to get started working with the first DAO-led Layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle.
Taking self-custody of your crypto is one of the most important things you can do on your bankless journey. It's also one of the hardest things to get right, with huge consequences if you don't. If you want help going bankless, talk to Kasa. Kasa helps you take custody of your crypto assets so you don't have to wonder whether you're doing it right. Kasa is a one-stop shop for doing self-custody the right way. With Kasa Vaults, you can hold Ether, Bitcoin, stablecoins, all with one simple app and multiple keys for the ultimate peace of mind with a support team to help you every step of the way.
But it doesn't stop at self-custody because even though crypto is forever, you are not. We all plan on making life-changing wealth in crypto but with Kasa's inheritance product, life-changing wealth can elevate to generational wealth for your kids and your loved ones who don't know anything about crypto. With Kasa, you won't lose your private keys and you won't accidentally take them to the grave either. Click the link in the description to get started securing your generational wealth. Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax obligations for providing token grants to your team?
It's no secret that token management gets complicated. Between learning all the legal language and tax obligations in every country that your team is in, token grant management can feel like an obstacle course, but it doesn't have to. That's where Toku steps in. Toku provides practical tools to handle token grants, allowing for effective oversight of token distributions and payroll tax compliance for employees, contractors, advisors, and investors. They also handle tax withholdings through their real-time tax calculations that can be done by Toku or integrated into any payroll EOR providers in any jurisdiction.
Toku is a trusted provider of Protocol Labs, DYDX Foundation, MENA Protocol, and many more. Get started for free and make token compensation simple at toku.com slash bankless. Have you ever felt that the tools for developing decentralized applications are too restrictive and fail to leverage advancements from traditional software programming? There's a wide range of expressive building blocks beyond conventional smart contracts and solidity development. Don't waste your time building the basics from scratch and don't limit the potential of your vision. Cartesi provides powerful and scalable solutions for developers that supercharge app development.
With a Cartesi virtual machine, you can run a full Linux OS and access decades of rich code libraries and open source tooling for building in Web3. And with Cartesi's unique roll-up framework, you'll get real-world scaling and computation. No more competing for block space. So if you're a developer looking to push the boundaries of what's possible in Web3, Cartesi is now offering up to $50,000 in grants. Head over to Cartesi's grant application page to apply today. And if you're not a developer, those with staked CTSI can take part in the governance process and vote on whether or not a proposal should be funded.
Make sure you're vote ready by staking your CTSI before the votes open. And here's where the important part, the savior from the sky, which uh is was was this white paper called the bit vm vm we've heard so much about it yes so uh bit vm uh posited that you could actually do arbitrary computation on bitcoin sort of what i was talking about previously were okay well you have a basically a merklized uh a a a merklized state. And if you transition to another state, you can sort of do these bisection games and identify this is the part where some computation went wrong. So like a fraud, an optimistic way of doing computation for Bitcoin emerged through this white paper.
Well, it emerged as an idea through this white paper. And that is what people have been hacking on since October 2023. And what people imagined was that we could use this mechanism of bitvm to if it has the ability to do arbitrary computation on bitcoin and sort of optimistically verify that then we should be able to build something like optimistic roll-ups has been sort of the what people have been talking about with the caveat so so they what what people have considered is technically possible today with bitvm is uh you know how arbitrum has whitelisted uh whitelisted uh entities that are yeah whitelisted fraud provers like white listed verifiers so that is the that is the technical uh state that you that people thought that you could get with with bitvm so it's not it's not perfect it's not like a permissionless uh optimistic roll up where anyone who can post the security bond can can challenge an invalid state uh root update so so that that's what arbitrum promises once they remove this white list that has that that's what bit vm or that's what arbitrum and bit vm would promise is like uh no no so arbitrum promises that they're gonna oh i see this but but for bit vm it's a hard constraint you can't yeah it's a hard constraint it's a hard constraint.
That is not the only hard constraint of BitVM, though, unfortunately, as we've discovered. So the Bitcoin scripting language is just the same today as it was years ago. There's nothing new. We don't have covenants. We cannot do finite state machines. We could maybe, inside sort of a state channel resolve arbitrary computation optimistically through a complicated verifier challenger game. However, so one of the constraints is that like when you do this on Ethereum you have sort of a like in optimism for example you have sort of a chess lock, a chess clock dynamic where, okay, I'm going to assess that the fraud happened here.
So this is the part of the transaction that I'm disputing. Now, the sequencer then in Optimism has to prove, no, this is how I did it. So you sort of bisect down to the part where the computation was done incorrectly. But they have sort of a chess clock mechanism where here's my proof. Now it's your turn to give your proof back to me. In Bitcoin, we don't have like chess clocks. So you have these like long time windows where you can either within that time window post the second round in your multi-round fraud proof or not, which means that this dispute resolution mechanism in BitVM could, like the first versions we saw this would take six months.
there's been some people that are now arguing that they can compress that down to four weeks so where where you guys are working with like seven seven days seven day settlement windows we're working with either six months and maybe we can compress it down to uh four week uh four weeks so we're struggling with like harder constraints on that side the other thing that we're struggling with is that in order for this to work at all you need to do you need to set up sort of a stage channel between all the participants in the, between all the challengers and verifiers, or actually let's call them operators and verifiers.
So that requires them to share pre-signed transactions that describes every single sort of state transition in the BitVM virtual machine. and they have to share all those transactions with each other. So that's like a large amount of data that has to be shared between the participants of this game. And it makes it very difficult for other channel participants to join sort of the BitVM dispute resolution game. So it has clunkiness on the sort of the setup side. It has clunkiness on the challenge response side. But the primary clunkiness that was discovered to me quite recently, because I was actually kind of bullish on BitVM.
I've been writing tweets that are trying to describe like this is how we can do something that looks quite similar to some flavor of optimistic roll up on Bitcoin. But there was a part of like when we actually got to the implementation stage. And when I say we, I mean more the teams that have jumped up. And so the number of teams that are building on BitVM these days are Alpen Labs, there's Chainway. Actually, Rootstock is doing that. Even Stacks is doing this. And let's see, what am I forgetting? Well, basically, the only exception is Liquid is the only one that's not trying to do the BitVM direction.
Bison, BitLayer is another one. So if you see any fancy Bitcoin L2 these days, 80% probability is that they're building on BitVM. Or intending to. They explicitly say, hey, BitVM's not ready yet, but at some point we'll just move to BitVM. The one thing I want to add for listeners too is BitVM, correct me if I'm wrong, Eric, does not require an opcode change, importantly. Correct? Yeah, that's the whole thing. That's the whole thing. Yeah, that's the whole thing. Okay. You can do it natively on Bitcoin without anything. However, now we get to sort of the big problem, which I think might be an insurmountable problem.
The problem with BitVM is that when you deposit funds to Optimism, you send in, here's my $10,000 worth of Ether. I send it in. And then when you want to withdraw, when you withdraw your funds, that's when you can do this fraud. That's when the, if the sequencer picks up the transaction and puts it into the state route, now there's an invalid transaction there. That's what you can do the fraud mechanism on. That's where you do the dispute resolution. It's on the withdrawal. In BitVM, it doesn't work like that. In BitVM, how it works is that the operator, so the sequencer, has to send the funds to the people that are owed these monies.
So if you say, I want to withdraw, give me my $10,000 worth of Ether, then the sequencer will oblige and say, okay, here's your $10,000 worth of Ether. And then he can reimburse himself with the Ether that you previously posted. and it's the reimbursement that you can now do the fraud dispute resolution game on. What that means is that he cannot use the money that you deposited to pay you out. He has to front the money, that capital for you, for your withdrawal, and then he can reimburse himself later. When the first time that I read that this, I thought like, okay, he does a withdrawal and then he reimburses himself for the money and then he processes the next withdrawal.
But that's not how it works. It's a whole window of withdrawal that can be like, let's say, a week. All those withdrawals he has to front. And then after a week's time, he can now reimburse himself. And so that got us a little bit, because I mean, at Taproot Wizards, we also want to play around with L2s. Like we also want to improve the current situations of the BRC20 tokens, the rune trading. We want to upgrade that and put that into environments where we can actually improve Bitcoin. And we have like longer term, like the vision that we at Taproot Wizards, it's not, okay, let's enable a bunch of degen trading on like meme coin trading on Bitcoin.
That's actually not what we want to do. what we want to do we want to provide like a more scalable environment for bitcoin the bitcoin asset itself and potentially add some type of serial knowledge type cryptography to give privacy to bitcoin which we desperately need anyway so we studied okay so how large uh what could the net outflows of a big roll-up look like so we did some analysis we actually uh worked together with data always on this i don't know if you're familiar with that researcher but she yeah he or he does great research great and found out that uh in 2021 arbitrum within one week span had a billion dollar uh net outflow and i think that was do you remember like in the early days of arbitrum there was like a neon cat uh ponzi yeah yeah it was like the right after the marbiter made net like the nyan cat ponzi was like the first like reason why so many people push money into arbitrum because this pond was going on but then it then it ran out like the the the game ran out because the token went to zero because there was like the the apy that you were earning just inflated the token so the token went to zero right uh so people were farming and selling the token and token went to zero and now there was no longer any money to earn there so all that billion of capital that had breached into arbitrum they were like okay what's the next game that i can play what other food token can i play so this is not even like a malicious attack this is just like uh we um want to go somewhere else and have fun somewhere else okay so imagine now that you're the arbitrum uh operator i gotta find a billion dollars to to just to to and and so and what happens that if you don't if you cannot fulfill that uh if you cannot fulfill that liquidity requirement requirement in that week what's basically so what you can do like so there are people that are now in the bitvm after we sort of brought this up as a big problem this they said well you can just uh the the role of the operator you can just push that role to another operator and give him a chance to fulfill the liquidity requirements and you can just kick the can down the road but if this is like too big of a liquidity crunch that no one is going to be able to solve.
I don't know how it actually helps, like, okay, we can't do it, we push it over to the next guy. What are the odds that he's just going, okay, I just happen to have like a billion dollars, I can resolve this. So one of the main features of a layer two is that it allows many, many, many people to be aggregated all at once. And I think what you're saying is there's a fundamental problem here when There are many, many, many users of a layer two, but there's a single operator who's responsible for that withdrawal. And so that one single operator, if this layer two gets successful enough, no matter how size their size is, they will still be overwhelmed by an eventual success scenario, which is that layer two has so much capital in it that eventually there's going to be a moment in which a lot of capital would like to outflow.
and that one single operator can't be a sufficiently large market maker to satisfy the outflows out of that layer two. Is that kind of the problem statement? It's like a liquidity crisis, right? It's a liquidity crisis. And so what can happen in that situation? Like if you do what the current like BitVM implementers say, well, you just push the can down the road and you give the role to someone else. At the end, if no one can fulfill this liquidity crunch requirement, what happens in the best case is that you put it all all the funds into a multi-sig and now the multi-sig can distribute the funds uh to the participants without like they they actually just receive all the money from the roll-up and now they can if they're honest they can now send the funds to whoever owes them but it actually just puts the hand in the full control of the multi-sig and i mean so you could argue like okay ethereum has these kind of issues too like with the security councils.
But I mean, at least in Ethereum, we can move away from that. And the security councils can have time delays before they can take the funds. So this is the best that we can do. We can have an operator that has these upfront liquidity requirements, and if you can't fulfill them, it devolves into a multisig. And you can argue here that, okay, why did we do all this complexity with all the challenge response games and all the liquidity? if it all devolves into a multi-sig in the worst case and sort of we we are sort of we have to build these systems with the worst case as the assumption because if you're in sort if you're a george source type attacker you can just force this uh to happen you can you can force it to happen too so then multi-sig is ultimately the underlying security model um and it seems like a pretty anti-climactic conclusion for a ton of technical research to make the vm happen it gets worse it gets worse it gets worse because even even if there's not a liquidity crunch like even if it's happy days and yeah i can satisfy you know 50 million dollars worth of withdrawals like i'm capitalized i have vc funding and i'm using but imagine how capital inefficient that operator is that he needs to have 50 million dollars of capital that he's rotating non-productive capital non-productive capital that he cannot like so he ultimately needs to charge higher fees from his customers in order to make it work like in order to pay the interest that he has on that capital that is probably uh borrowed then uh he has to make sure that he earns enough in his role as operator to make his business you know work or you could be like fractional reserve i guess and just like face a possible run run on the run on the chain basically and then if there's a run on the chain then everything goes into like i'll call it bankruptcy court which is like this kind of multi-sig for for redemptions i said no i am talking about i am talking about the fractional reserve situation but even that fraction that he has to keep on hand is uh gonna be uh yeah a lot ten percent at least you know yeah yeah it's gonna be a lot of money like how how much how much capital is in arbitrage these days like we're talking about billions 15 billion yeah so are you going to want to keep uh 1.
5 billion at hand uh again anyway anyway so so mike when i'm and and the liquidity crunch issue is not the only problem that i'm thinking about i'm also thinking about well you have this constraint of who can be a participant like who can be a verifier it's like It's more like a stage channel than like an open system where anyone can sort of participate in. There's been a new paper called BitVM version 2, which I've heard from the people that work on it. It's still kind of impractical. And then you have these setup phases and you have these very long, drawn-out challenge response games that take four to six weeks.
And if you're running by the model where you're delegating this liquidity crunch problem over to someone else, to someone else, to someone else, let's say you have a hundred different operators that can that stand in line to take over this responsibility and they all have a week on them now we're talking about like a hundred weeks before it even devolves to a multi-sig so i would rather have a multi-sig that just always works within minutes notice then potentially having a system that runs into liquidity crunch keeps my capital away from me for a hundred weeks and then devolves into a multi-sig that always works is It's called a sidechain though, right?
And we already have those. Yes. So I generally think like the people that went into BitVM, they did this with the best intentions. They're just trying to be, they're honest, good builders. They're just trying to make the best that they can with this actually pretty brilliant, pretty awesome new type of way of resolving arbitrary computation on Bitcoin. But as we get closer and as we start to understand these restrictions, it's starting to look like something that maybe isn't, it's hard to say, like maybe isn't that much better than like maybe just build a really, really good multisig with like loads of signers and like you can have a large validator set and then you can do like subcommittees that sign things around like randomly assigned committees to sign things quickly.
So they functions like, for example, that's what I think what Botanics does. is what uh the guys that you mentioned that the guys are just spinning up their system i think that's what the uh meso uh like uh tbtc uh people are doing with these very large uh multi multi six sets yeah so that so the bitcoin l2 space like where are we with all with all of this i yeah because like it seems to be that the bitcoin layer 2 space is going to be built no matter what like technical constraints aside like that ball is rolling like they're already committed builders here there's already like vc interest in there so like the the bitcoin layer 2 landscape is going to happen it's just a matter of just like what does it look like on the end of it why do you say that david why do you think it's going to happen is it sort of the case that now all of these like roll-ups are are uh being developed in layer twos are getting invested in and like even if bit vm proves to be sort of a dead end right like kind of the worst comes true here then they'll still force like political change and the op codes that eric was talking about the beginning of this episode to be pushed through?
Why do you think it's inevitable? Not necessarily. I just think that there is enough. Eric's going through the arc of Bitcoin history with ordinals and runes, and then the constraints of the supply of blocks based on the Bitcoin layer one. All of that was to, in my mind, was to express the need for Bitcoin layer twos, right? Bitcoin needs layer two. We've got ordinals, we've got runes. We are seeing up only interest in building on the layer one, which therefore creates the need for Bitcoin layer twos. And now also there has been just like an ecosystem of many, many, many Bitcoin layer twos across a broad spectrum of quality, like some like thinking about how to do this on the most technically advanced frontier possible, the high quality ones.
And then like some on the opposite end of that spectrum, some vaporware kind of stuff and like everything in between. So like this, but this whole ecosystem is now a category. There's like been venture investment in these teams. They are committed builders to building a product that they are calling a Bitcoin layer two to do Bitcoin things that settle on Bitcoin. And so, like, I think the ball is just rolled at this point. It's rolled. So, like, we're going to get some set of products on the other side of things that look and feel like Bitcoin layer twos. And it sounds like, according to Eric Wall's constraints of the Bitcoin, the BIVM, that there will be needing to be some shortcuts being taken.
And now it's a matter of just like, what does the market feel is like satisfactory shortcuts? And what can they get out of that? Yeah, I hear what you're saying here. And like, obviously, Eric can kind of answer this. But I guess to all you're saying, David, it feels like a narrative is here and building is happening. But from what I'm hearing is there's like this technical brick wall, which means all of the layer twos will like hit that brick wall and they can't have like a full layer two. Yes, they could have a sovereign roll up. Yes, they could do a side chain with a super secure multi-sig.
But like you can't be an Ethereum layer two style roll up with fraud proofs, et cetera, on chain. Yes. Yeah. But also at the same time, we don't even have Ethereum style roll ups in the Ethereum ecosystem. Sure, sure, sure. Sure. Okay. Thank you for making my point. Sorry for that sidebar, Eric. I think, David, you've gotten smarter over the years or something. I swear to God, I've always been this smart. Yeah, it was ever since your headlock. You know, you just choked some sense into them. No, but I think David is completely right in that, you know, ordinals, runes, demand for L2s, the ball is rolling.
There are teams that are graced. there's this uh there's this fantasy of bitvm coming in and like creating actually permission lists and trustless l2s on bitcoin like the man is here and there's vc funding and so like the and the vcs like i don't know so i don't know how much these vcs care like they could the vcs can say well i don't actually care like how much your bitvm bridge sucks and how much you patch it up with multi-sticks that you hide uh because if you say great guys yeah if if if we say that this is a bitcoin uh l2 that uses secret proof somewhere and uh you know uses ck proofs for aggregation in some part of the stack and uh you know uses some bit vm things something over here even if it also takes stacks for example stacks is like billion dollar uh a billion dollar like multi time like i think it's like market caps like four or six billion dollars uh stacks is like um you know do you know what happens i don't know how much time we have left of this episode but i can go into like a small like detour i want to know like if stacks a real layer two an eric wall definition of like what we just described layer two or not and does it have a path to become one yeah so it's kind of funny uh so the short answer is no absolutely not uh okay But so what happened with Stacks was that Stacks had this consensus algorithm called proof of transfer.
And how it works, how it worked was that the people who owned Stacks token could stack them. And then other people would send the Bitcoin to those people and win the right to create a Stacks block and earn the Stacks block reward. So they were basically bidding for Stacks, for the Stacks block subsidy, and also for the right to make a Stacks block. However, since this is happening inside a Bitcoin block, it's completely possible for the miner to just censor all the bids for the Stacks block reward and just send their own like one Satoshi bid and win the entire Stacks block for nothing. And this was actually happening.
So F2Pool were completely fucking Stacks over and just picking out the Stacks blocks reward and didn't give a shit about Stacks. So Stacks has needed to fix that problem by completely revamping how sort of finality works in the Stacks blockchain. And they're calling that Stacks Nakamoto. They're using like signers to basically checkpoint which blocks are the valid ones. they're using both like mining and stacks it's a little bit complicated but basically they're trying to like fix this problem of okay our shit was completely vulnerable to to minor uh manipulation uh they've so they're rebranding stacks into something that's called stacks nakamoto now and because they have had to hot fix this problem in what i would describe in kind of an ugly way they're calling now stacks an l2 like that we we fix this finality problem with with our blockchain and now it's an L2, even though, like, even if you read the white paper, if you read the white paper itself, they outline, like, these are the requirements for a real 2 on Bitcoin to exist.
It requires the ability, and maybe I should have said this sooner, what is the definition of an L2? In my opinion, it's the ability for a user that has deposited funds into the L2 to have the unilateral right to pull those funds out whenever they want to. That's an L2. Agreed. And I will say that's the Ethereum definition of an L2 as well. and sometimes that gets abused in the ethereum world i'm glad that you said that ryan because i've seen people all over the ethereum space that are like oh well yeah but i agree that should be the that should be the like how we define l2 so we can call those other things other things but uh yeah that's my definition of an l2 and if you read the stacks nakamoto uh paper then they do admit that they have made no strides and no progress towards like enabling uh the ability for you to unilaterally withdraw your funds back to the uh to do to the bitcoin chain uh so no stacks is not an l2 uh the bit vm things like i don't know if they're l2s but they have this liquidity crunch constraint that pushes them to multi-sig in in in worst cases so like to answer your question like we don't kind of have l2s on bitcoin and as you say there's sort of a technical brick wall here and the thing that we need and actually what the bitcoin industry is working towards is we need covenants we need covenants because covenants allow us to create finite state machines and if we if if the covenants that we chose within the bitcoin community was cat cat is a covenants opcode then we could do these merkle tree verifications uh as a side bonus that actually allows us to build actual layer twos on bitcoin so uh no bitcoin doesn't really have practical or functional l2s at the moment uh we need uh covenants recursive covenants and we need merkle tree verification cats is one of those off-codes that give us gives us both and that is why like that's the you know i used to be um arbitrum delegate i'm a board member of the startnet foundation i'm an optimism delegate i'm actually one of the largest arbitrarian delegates i have no idea i i've i've been dedicating you know i've because i i came from uh from the bitcoin space and i wanted to build better layer twos than what lightning network could provide because i think in in a layer two how it should work is that you give me your address and i'll send you funds that's that's that's how that's how the dynamic should work.
That's not how it works in Lightning. And I think that Lightning is not going to be very successful. If you tell me that, well, you can't send me funds yet, I'll have to go and borrow funds from David so that I have enough inbound liquidity to receive those funds. Crypto has UX challenges enough as it is, for people to manage private keys and all that. The second layers cannot add more UX challenges and think that they're going to be more successful than their layer ones are. They have to reduce the technical challenges that people face. And Lightning, unfortunately, added a bunch of technical constraints.
When I was young, when I was naive, I thought that we'd make it work because decentralization is so important. Now I feel like if your system is so decentralized that the UX sucks so that everyone uses custodial solutions instead, you have actually done a worse job at creating decentralization because there's so few people that actually use it. So that's sort of the adult take that we've come to. So anyway, roll-ups, I think, are the types of... Even though I have my reservations with how the fragmentation... I know you guys had an episode with Justin Drake not long ago about how we're going to solve fragmentation issues with shared sequencers.
I pray to God that that works and it doesn't take like three years and then we figure out that it's like charting and uh you know my hope is out there that we're gonna solve that uh but just one single roll up alone is still a much better uh layer two solution than what lightning is and um I that's the direction that I've been wanting us to go towards so like no one you know I've wanted this I really want the L2 solutions to work on Bitcoin. I'm not here to try to... If we could do them, if Tappered Wizards could just spin up a BitVM roll-up and it's going to work awesomely, we would be doing that right now.
But there is no shortcuts here. We need covenants and probably we're going to need a way to do CQP verification also. If all the people that are genuine about wanting to build proper L2s on Bitcoin, if we like sort of band together and get this cat opcode through, then I think we're actually in the clear. Then we don't have that much to worry about. So that is what we're fighting for at the moment. And I don't think that, you know, so this BitVM stuff that people are working on, there's not a finished implementation for that. Like that is, I would classify BitVM as sort of like a school experiment or something like that.
it's going to take years to really flesh that out into like a production grade system that people can work with. The path to activating CAT might be a shorter way than that. So if you're an L2 builder in the Bitcoin space, the fastest way for you to actually get a proper permissionless bridge, a proper two-way peg without any liquidity constraints, and that doesn't have these weird setup phases or weird like channel based uh constraints where there's a limit on who can do like fraud proofs uh then uh getting cast activated is is probably what what you should be focused on so that's sort of the message that we're we're trying to if we can get all l2 builders on this goal together then we're good otherwise i'm i'm not sure so sure we might have we might be in a situation with like polygon pos is the side chain to bitcoin uh for i don't know how many years uh i there was one other thing i wanted to say also which is i think that the people who are building on bitvm now i would classify them as earnest genuine talented some of them are extremely smart extremely capable and and you know just good honest people that are trying to make this work uh we haven't touched at all on like the whole scam side of bitcoin l2s because ever since the bit vm uh paper came out there's been the bitcoin space has been awash with complete scam projects not sure if i shouldn't name their name specifically because i'm gonna have them up my ass for the next couple of months if i do but there are um one okay one obvious one is like the one which was called satoshi vm they just said like we're we're a bit vm they had some white paper that described something about bitvm the the white paper made no sense the token launched on ethereum and it actually trades now you can search for this savm is the ticker and it's just like a complete scam ticker has nothing to do with bitcoin whatsoever another one is called a merlin chain uh that actually like copied a lot of the um uh you know how the sort of brand of tappered wizards is let's make bitcoin magical again and it's about wizards so they just created merlin chain it has like a wizard symbol and uh their their tagline is let's make bitcoin fun again and um if you go to their technical docs try to figure out like what is this It says that it's a Polygon ZK EVM Bitcoin layer 2 that uses Celestia as a data availability layer.
But if it's a Polygon ZK EVM that uses Celestia as the data availability layer, how is it using Bitcoin again? And then in some, like if you'd read further into the docs, it says you'll find like cropped out screenshots from Robin Linus, BitVM paper somewhere where they just, oh, you can use NAND gates to do arbitrary computation. This is like future research. But in terms of what actually exists on Bitcoin, it's just an address. It's just like a wallet. You just send Bitcoin to someone's wallet and they call that like, they actually do call it like a Bitcoin ZK rollup, which doesn't like technically exist at all.
And there's a bunch of them. There's BEVM, BVM. And if you go to these Twitter profiles, to the Twitter profiles of these accounts, you'll see that they have like 250,000 followers and 10 million transactions and 1.5 million daily users and 700,000 active wallets. And, you know, these numbers don't make sense at all for a wide category of these so-called Bitcoin L2s. So unfortunately, like the Ordinal's hype and the BitVM paper just gave scammers the, they understood that, okay, there's demand for, everyone's looking for what's the new Bitcoin layer 2 going to be. And the whole, you know, the whole Bitcoin space is unfortunately awash with these scams at the moment where people are just pretending to be like fully fledged BitVM L2s.
But they haven't done data. Like I said, BitVM doesn't even exist yet. There's no canonical. There's a few projects that are trying to implement the stuff that Robin Linus has talked about. Robin Linus himself is trying to build a reference implementation. It is not finished yet. So no one really knows how any of this is supposed to work. But there are a bunch of projects that have started to scam and saying that that technology is already complete. And they have tokens that are trading on Ethereum that are trading at everything from like 70 to 250 million dollar valuation. So that's like one of the negative sides of this excitement that has also happened.
So my point was basically to say that, yeah, there are some BitVM builders that are struggling right now. But it sort of feels unfair to criticize them when there's a larger group of just pure scammers that are grifting the space at the same time. So this is a difficult, what I want to say to people that are listening to this, be extremely cautious to anyone that says that they're a Bitcoin L2. Try to understand what it is that they have implemented, what exists in open source code that you can look at. I know that most people don't do this research, but if there's any space that you need to be very cautious, it is currently the Bitcoin L2 space.
It is a complete mess. Scammers and fraudsters are actually a byproduct of an actual growing and real ecosystem. So there's actually like some symptom of success here. I know, Eric, you've been with Bitcoin since like the early days, back before the Bitcoin dark ages, I'll call it. back before, like the monetary maximalists, like laser-eyed maxis really gained control. And I think this is where our very first episode with you kind of talked about that change in Bitcoin culture. But now we're seeing it kind of shift back to, I think, a more familiar territory. And despite some of the challenges that I think you've illustrated here on the episode today, the fact that there are challenges in Bitcoin that people are working to overcome is like extremely refreshing and very optimistic.
So overall, just like how would you rate the health of the Bitcoin ecosystem and your perception of its direction? Yeah, as much as these Bitcoin L2s have problems, I am so thrilled that we have Bitcoin L2s with problems rather than just having lightning that everyone says is amazing and is going to solve everything. If I had to choose between either of those two things, I would much prefer the reality where there's tons of teams, smart people that are aggressively trying to bring better layer 2s into existence. So, I mean, what we ultimately need for Bitcoin is we don't, actually, I'm not that convinced that we need to take, you know, everything that Ethereum has done and put it onto Bitcoin.
Like, why? You can go and do that on Ethereum. if you definitely if you you know if you really really need to do like decentralized lending and decentralized trading and all that just just go do that on ethereum uh get a reasonably secure peg the end bitcoin uh peg the inversion of bitcoin and do those activities on like that we we don't need all of the ethereum stuff to exist on bitcoin i i don't think so but i what What I do know that we do need, we just need a way for me to be able to send Bitcoin to you in a scalable and private fashion, just so that Bitcoin as a currency works. And everyone has believed that that would be Lightning, that Lightning would solve those problems.
And same way that I was bullish on BitVM initially, I was bullish on Lightning initially too. But, you know, Lightning developers are also coming to the conclusion that these channels that we're trying to scale Bitcoin through have constraints with inbound liquidity. The user experience, as much as we're trying to patch it up, some problem appears somewhere else in the system. It's like a balloon that you're trying to squeeze out the water of and it just pops up somewhere else. That's sort of how it works when you're struggling with the Lightning design space. I think that Lightning developers are at the stage now where they would happily say, we want our next upgrade of Lightning to not use channels at all.
So if that gave them a convenient out of not saying, okay, Lightning Network didn't work. We have a new version of Lightning that doesn't use channels. It uses the state route updates and either ZK proofs to make sure that those state route updates are correct or some type of optimistic challenge response. So basically roll-ups, but let's call it lightning. So, but yeah, I think the Bitcoin ecosystem has woken up to the idea that lightning is not going to work. So that's why everyone is trying. You know, so a lot of the hardcore, the hardcore Bitcoiners, there was a white paper that came out for something that was called ARK.
And I don't know, you guys maybe didn't pay attention to this, but there was a massive interest in ARK. And if the reality of the situation was that everyone in Bitcoin was happy with Lightning, Why would everyone throw themselves to this new protocol called ARK, which claimed to have solved some of the inbound liquidity issues of Lightning or some of the other issues of interactiveness of Lightning? Obviously, there is this big pent up realization now that maybe getting Lightning to work in a decentralized way is not where we're going to end up. We're going to end up, we're seeing like you just have to look at the data, like custodial wallets rule the day.
90% of Lightning users use custodial wallets because it's just so much more convenient. And that is such a sad outcome. So we know that Bitcoiners, as much as they don't want to admit that sometimes that Lightning has been a failure, we see themselves throwing in themselves at things like ARK, like anything that is different or that is better. So, yeah, the overtone window has changed to we need better second layer solutions on Bitcoin. And I think that with enough people with grit and will and desire, we're going to get there. Well, Eric, it's always fascinating having you on and both your commitment to technical assurances offered by cryptography and the way that they are just leveraged across the space is always just a fascinating learning lesson.
And also just a good reminder of some of the history of this space. So thank you for coming on and kind of updating us on the progress of Bitcoin. And as bankless listeners might have been able to tell, like we've been doing more Bitcoin content lately. and that's because of some of the technical unlocks that Eric has been talking about here on the show today and a much more like optimistic and bullish frontier than we've seen in the Bitcoin world than we've ever seen before. So Eric, thank you for coming on the show today. Thank you. And David, is it the 30th of May that you're going to be entering?
Yeah, 30th of May. That's right. Yeah. Are you going to be at consensus? I'm going to be in the audience. I'm going to be, I'm not going to be rooting for you. You know, Nick is one of my best friends, but I will- So you have a side, Eric. Wow. Wow. Okay, this is, we're talking about the 30th of May. We are friends. And I hope you guys have a great fight and you both get to like show your muscles. And I hope you fail in a non-embarrassing way. Do you have money on the other side of my polymarket? I cannot. I'm not going to. He doesn't want to tell the markets. Oh, that's right. You do. You do.
Oh, I forgot about that. No, no, no, no. No, no. I love Nick and I'm rooting for him. I think you have a decent shot though. Eric, let me ask you, though. You're a betting man. I know you. Okay, so if David wins, will you shave your head again? No comment. All right. I'll take it to Twitter. All right, Bankless Nation, you guys know the deal. Crypto is risky. DeFi is risky. Layer 2s are risky no matter what. Layer 1, they settle too. But we are headed west. This is Frontier. It's not for everyone, but we are glad you are with us on the Bankless journey. Thanks a lot. Thank you.