✨ DEBRIEF | Ryan & David unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-pacman-blast-l2
------ Pacman is one of the most interesting builders in crypto right now. After creating Blur, a disruptive NFT exchange, the crypto wonder kid is targeting the L2 space with his new yield bearing L2 called Blast.
In this episode, we cover Pacman’s story, how he built Blur, how he pioneered Points and finally, we get into Blast, the already third largest L2 in TVL.
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
💸 CRYPTO TAX CALCULATOR | USE CODE BANK30 https://bankless.cc/CTC
🦄 UNISWAP | SWAP SMARTER https://bankless.cc/uniswap
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 6:45 Pacman’s Story 24:40 Blast’s Perception 29:36 Blur 34:45 Points 47:55 Blast Genesis 54:35 Blast’s Native Yield 1:19:05 Yield Risks 1:23:15 Net Gas Revenue 1:26:00 Projects on Blast 1:30:12 Is Blast a Multisig? 1:32:51 Blast’s Vision 1:34:10 Blast on OP Superchain? 1:36:53 Closing Thoughts
------ RESOURCES
Pacman https://twitter.com/PacmanBlur
Blast https://blast.io
Pacman Blur’s Episode https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KBKRrKtGTY8
------ Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets.
See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
We want to build the L2 that provides the most value to developers and users. The most value of any L2, that's our goal. And we see the path to getting there is you have this L2 with native yield where everyone's just earning that by default, but also now you're enabling new types of applications. Robinhood, for example, right? Like them charging, you know, zero fees. That's actually providing more value to the market than if they had charged no fee. So it's like these business model unlocks. It's not just like, oh, it's a new business model. It's like, no, this is actually providing more value to the market.
This is why these like disruptive business models get adopted in the first place. So the only thing driving us is that we want to build the L2 that provides the most value to end users and developers. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless. Pac-Man is one of the most interesting builders in crypto right now. He created Blur, which is an NFT exchange that came out of basically nowhere in 2022 and now has over 70% of the NFT market. And it almost seems he's about to do the same thing with layer two.
He's got a project called Blast, which has blasted its way to number three in terms of total locked value of all layer two's. You do not want to miss this fascinating conversation with this crypto builder. Number one, we talk about who's Pac-Man, this crypto wonder kid, where did he come from? What's he about? Why is he here? Number two, how he built Blur into the world's largest NFT exchange. Number three, Pac-Man actually created the points meta that we see today. What does he think of points now? Number four, Blast, the yield bearing layer two. That's Blast its way to third largest layer two.
How did he do that? Is it secure? Is it safe? What about all of the criticism surrounding Pac-Man projects? There's a lot to pull out from this episode, not just about the technical details around Blast and what it actually means to be a yield bearing layer two, because I think a lot of people actually don't fully understand the technical implications of what that means, and that's something that we pull apart here on the podcast with Pac-Man today. But just zooming all the way out about yield as a concept, points as part of the meta, the movement of eth and users onto layer two's, and really how to be a builder in this space.
Depending on who you are in this space, whether you are a user, you are a builder, or you are a VC investor, there's something in this episode for you, depending on how you look at it and what you want to get out of it. So we touch a little bit on many different metas that are going around in the cryptosphere in the middle of this bull market, and I've found that I've learned quite a lot. I think I like many other people kind of discounted Blast in the early days, because of the spinal reflex that I think a lot of people had from his go-to-market strategy, which we also talked about with Pac-Man, but this was me coming up Blast with fresh eyes, and really appreciating the novel mechanisms that Blast rewired into an OP stack fork in order to make native yield bearing a thing inside of the Blast ecosystem.
Yeah, he's got a way of implementing these clever shifts in mechanism design that have really used the term profound outcomes. We'll see BanklessLister if you see one of those profound outcomes in the conversation today. Of course, David and I will unpack all of this in the debrief, which is available to you if you are a Bankless citizen on the Bankless Premium podcast. Newly available and Spotify might I add, so you can get Bankless Premium in Spotify, go check that out. All right, let's get right to the conversation with Pac-Man, but before we do, we don't thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our recommended crypto exchange for 2024, and the way to blast your fiat into crypto.
That is cracking. Go trade it out. If you want a crypto trading experience back by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive, and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way.
Along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos. With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Cello is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon-negative blockchain built for the real world.
Driving real-world use cases like mobile payments and mobile DeFi, and with Opera MiniPay as one of the fastest growing Web 3 wallets, Cello is seeing a meteoric rise with over 300 million transactions and 1.5 million monthly active addresses. And now, Cello is looking to come home to Ethereum as a layer 2. Optimism, Polygon, Matterlabs, and Arbitrum have all thrown their hats in their ring for the Cello layer 2 to build upon their stacks. Why the competition? The Cello layer 2 will bring huge advantages like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability, secured by Ethereum validators, and one block finality.
What does that all mean for you? With Cello layer 2, gaspies will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC20 tokens, sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect. But Cello is a community-governed protocol. This means that Cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Cello forums. Follow Cello on Twitter and visit Cello.org to shape the future of Ethereum. Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax obligations for providing token grants to your team? It's no secret that token management gets complicated.
Between learning all the legal language and tax obligations in every country that your team is in, token grant management can feel like an obstacle course. But it doesn't have to. That's where Toku steps in. Toku provides practical tools to handle token grants, allowing for effective oversight of token distributions and payroll tax compliance for employees, contractors, advisors, and investors. They also handle tax withholdings through their real time tax calculations that can be done by Toku or integrated into any payroll EOR providers in any jurisdiction. Toku is a trusted provider of protocol labs, dydx foundation, mean of protocol, and many more.
Get started for free and make token compensation simple at toku.com slash bankless. Bankless nation, happy to introduce you to Pac-Man, the co-founder, Blur creator of Blast. We had Pac-Man on the show a little over a year ago to talk about Blur and my how things have changed in just a year. Blast is now the number three layer two on Ethereum by TVL. Despite just being a few days, maybe a week old, already has a countless projects trumping at the bit to deploy on Blast and build inside of the brand new Blast ecosystem. Pac-Man, welcome back to bankless. Jam Jam, thanks for having me. So Pac-Man, you are two for two on projects that have completely redefined metas inside of the crypto industry.
Blur really just changed the game in terms of NFT trading and the whole NFT marketplace ecosystem. Blast has now done the same again because there is now a new focus on natively yield bearing layer 2s, which was a narrative, a theme, a construction, completely novelly introduced by Blast. Two for two on projects that redefine the industry is a pretty unique place to be. So just a little bit of just like, who is Pac-Man? How does he not miss? Where did you come from? Who are you? Yeah, really appreciate the kind words. So just for like a brief overview, I got my start in Silicon Valley around nine years ago.
I started off as a software engineer working at a company called T-Spring. I actually had a bit of a typical journey. So I went to T-Spring when I was in high school and ended up dropping out to work there for a year out of high school after my sophomore year and after that. Dropping in high school. We're not starting a college. You dropped out of high school. Okay. Yeah, I dropped out of high school. So I was 16 at the time. Yeah, it's fuzzy now. It's crazy how the time flies, but 16 at the time and then I went over to Silicon Valley and I stayed and I ended up actually starting a company right after T-Spring.
And we went through, it was called Strong Intro. We went through by Combinator and the Winter 16 batch. I was the youngest like batch mate at the time. I was 17. I went through that experience and then I really wanted to go to college after. I ended up going to MIT and I studied math with computer science there for about two years where I met my co-founder Anthony and we basically just immediately started hitting it off. We started building together. He graduated a year early. I ended up receiving the Teal Fellowship to go and drop out again after my sophomore year. Seriously? You just keep racking school, man.
Yeah, I know, I know. But MIT actually has a really nice program where it's like you can drop out and just come back like even when you're 15. So I would like to go back at some point just for the fun of it. To drop out of third time. Exactly. Exactly. Maybe I can drop out of the mnge program. But I left and Anthony, we started our first business which was name-base and that was a really niche company built on a blockchain called Handshake. It was like a decentralized domain name blockchain and we ran that for around three years and we sold it at the end of 2021 to name-cheap. And then basically after, immediately after that, Anthony and I we started Blur which is the NFT marketplace for road traders.
And we've been contributing to Blur for the past two, two and a half years now. And we, you know, a few months ago released Blast which is our mutant latest project. It's a L2 with native yield. And so that's kind of like the short summary of my professional history. Well, when you were in high school, I'm curious back then just so we can get some insight into you and how your mind works. What gave you the conviction to drop out in your sophomore year? Yeah, it was actually like super super easy. So I had discovered hacker news which is like a very popular like it's kind of like Reddit before just like nerds discovered that when I was 13.
And I basically just became super obsessed with Silicon Valley. Red all of Paul Graham's articles was really into that. And my dream, like my number one goal was just starting a company and going through by a commonator. Like that was like the only thing that I wanted to do. And I got really lucky when I was in a sophomore year of high school. I discovered Teespring which was this like custom T-shirt printing startup. And they were like doing incredibly well. Their founder had written a blog post on how they got to a million dollars in revenue in eight months which was like crazy at the time.
And I became super fascinated with that. And I actually wanted to go and like build a competitor to Teespring in Boston. And I was like a high school student and I ended up coding up like a competitor to Teespring. And then when I got around and finished a clone, I was like wait a second, like there's a lot more to building a business than just making a website. So I ended up emailing the CEO and I shared what I had built and they hired me as an intern. And then after working as an intern, they were just growing like crazy at the time. So they really needed more hands. And everyone at Teespring was like really, really professional.
Just like really exceptional quality in terms of builders. And I just felt like it was like a good mentoring opportunity. So I asked them if I could work full time and they agreed. And the rest was history from there. Do you advise this to any particular high school student that might be listening? Or is this just a road last traveled that is only suitable for a few? Yeah, that's tough. You know, there's a lot of, there's a lot you miss from like not going into to school. I'm actually like, I'm not anti school. I actually really love school. It's not really college. I think it's like incredible.
And high school too is like so formative for your like social and emotional development. So I'm actually like really bullish on school overall. I would say if you like really want it though, it's like it's not really something I can like advise. It's more so just like if you want it, you're going to do it. And I wouldn't like tell someone to do it or not to do it. It's really just like a matter of like what they want. And what did you want about this life? What attracted you to Silicon Valley to Paul Graham Post that you read and now later into crypto? Yeah, I think just the ability to build things that are really massive was something that was just incredible to me.
You know, the idea that you could have, you know, the classic Silicon Valley stories, you have these kids who are coding up a website in their dorm room and they go and build like the next big thing. That was just like so incredible to me. I was like, how is that even possible? It seemed like a pipe dream. And the closer I got to it, the more I was like, oh my god, this is like real. And you can actually do this. And it was just like, I was just like super addicted. I was like, I wanted it no more than anything. I just seemed fascinating to me and being able to actually like go into that world and, you know, live and work in Silicon Valley.
I actually got to spend a lot of time and there was like early in the Teal Fellowship, which also like funded Metallic. They actually had this like house column machine control where they hosted a lot of the Teal Fellows. So I got to like hang out there, made a bunch of other, you know, like young kids who had dropped out and to start things. And, you know, they actually had funny stories of, you know, Metallic staying there in the early days and trying to like give people Ethereum as compensation for them and crash on his on their couch. Really? I don't want your Ethereum. Yeah, nobody wanted the Ethereum and then everyone regretted that afterwards, of course, but yeah, it's like really cool, you know, being in that ecosystem just surrounded by builders, you know, it's there's really nowhere else like it.
I feel like it's all the different now, but like definitely in that time, like 2014, like that era, which is like really incredible for Silicon Valley. What do you think about this life motivates you so hard? Is it like building towards something that's larger than yourself? Is it like to me the whole kind of Pac-Man ecosystem between Blur and Blast? There's a little bit of like world building going on there. Like what about this life is so like motivating and compelling for you? Yeah, I think it's just, it's like a very like visceral thing. I think building things is like really satisfying. And I think if you're going to build something, you should try to build the most significant thing you can build.
You know, actually, there's there's someone that I know he works out like OpenAI and he says something about like, you know, people basically could increase their ambition a lot. Like almost like across the board, if you talk to anyone, you could have them like 10x their ambition. And that's probably like still like beneath where their ambition should be in terms of like what they can actually accomplish. I think my perspective is just like, yeah, like I really enjoy building things. And when I think that there's, you know, problems and opportunities, I want to go after it. And specifically, I really want to go after like the biggest problems and the biggest opportunities.
I'm not particularly interested in like smaller things. I think it's like totally fine to go after that. But it's just like, I think for me, I really just want to go after like the biggest things. And you know, I just throw all my energy into it. So when when you get a till fellowship, do you get to meet Peter Till or like, how does that work? What's the selection process like? And just like, you know, yeah, it's pretty basic. They just like, you know, you do interviews, you try with like the other fellows fellows. If you've ever done like a YC application, it feels like very similar to that.
But a little bit more process, but you know, very, very similar to that. You do get to meet Peter Till. At least, you know, like I did, it was cool. He's a cool conversation. But you know, he doesn't really spend a lot of time with the fellows. It's kind of more like, you know, he brands the, the kids and then gives them 100K and then he's just like doing his thing. So I only had one conversation with him. But the biggest, I think the biggest benefit is actually just being able to hang out with the other fellows because it's, they do a really good job of just kind of like curating a group of, you know, some of like the most like motivated people, you know, of that age bracket, you know, kind of like in the US, kind of in the world.
So I think just that network alone is where most of the value is. I was going to say that's like a good portion of the value of going to college, going to university too, is that sort of that selection effect. And I guess you sort of get that with a tool fellowship then. Yeah, I think you do get a lot. I would say it's different though. Like MIT is the densest network of high caliber engineering talent that I've, you know, ever seen in my life. Like when my peers there, they're like way, way smarter than me technically. And you use go there and you know, every, every kid there can just, they can build anything.
Like there is really nothing that's like rocket science there, like not even rocket science is rocket science. Everything is learnable. You get access to, you know, the people that like invented the technologies that we use today. I think going there is is something that's like I'm paralleled. The tool fellowship, you kind of get that more for like entrepreneurial people, but that's different than like engineering density. So I think they're both like very valuable for different reasons. Well, I know we want to focus a little bit on more than a little bit on this episode on on blasts and that whole ecosystem.
But kind of like as I intro to you, I said, Pac-Man is two for two on projects that have redefined the industry. How surprised would we be? Should we be if there was a third or are you, do you already have ideas that you're thinking of? Let me just say I would be surprised. I would be surprised. You would be surprised. A third. Yeah. I was surprised that there was a second actually. That was never the starting intention. That one was more like very fortuitous. In some ways, I'm happy to kind of like share more about that. But yeah, I don't really go out and just like, I'm not like actively like, oh, I want to start like 20 different projects.
It's just like, you know, blast was something that I felt needed to be built. And so I started working on that. I would be surprised if there was a third. But you know, anything could happen. Pac-Man, we started this episode with calling you Pac-Man. And I got to think that's not your actual name. Can you tell us at least your nation state name? Let's call it. Where did that name come from? Why do you call yourself Pac-Man? Why do others call you Pac-Man? I think you started with a blur, you sort of pseudonymus. And now you're not. Can you tell us the story of how that happened as well? Yeah, totally.
Pac-Man is just my pseudonym. I'm Doc. My real name is Tieshan. It's Tieshan and Mandarin. And you know, actually adopting it initially, it was more so about like optionality than anything else. I had a conversation with Anish who's at paradigm at the time, but now he's, I think he's on like the founding team of, of ritual. And he was really deep into, you know, Ethereum as well. I was just like, hey, like, what do you think are the pros and cons of, you know, doxing versus not doxing? And he was saying how, you know, he actually, in retrospect, probably would have started like Anon if he, if he could.
And he said, you know, at minimum, you always have the optionality to dox. And you know, it was like a free option, just sounds sounded great to me. So I decided to go with Pac-Man as a, as a nickname. And yeah, it's just suck. One of the nice things about it that I didn't realize at the time was having a name that people know how to pronounce is actually like a huge advantage. Normally, when I introduce myself, like with my real name, it's like, you know, they're spending five minutes just trying to figure out how to pronounce the name. Just to say, hey, Pac, I'm Pac-Man. And then that's the end of the conversation.
It's actually extremely nice. I never really realized that benefit before. Yeah. And so how did you become like, was it your choice to become sort of quote, unquote, doxed or how did that happen? Yeah, it was, you know, my intention from the beginning was basically two dox. We never really went hard on the like Anon, you know, mentality. Like if we, if you were to actually try to be Anon, like it takes, takes a lot of work. You have to be like, really, really thorough. And it's like, yeah, you have to be very, very thorough. It's almost always going to get out eventually. Like even the Anons in the space, like, you know, a lot of people know who they actually are, you know, behind the scenes.
So for us, it was, and for me, it was never something that I intended to do forever. It just felt like a convenient thing to do at the time. And then after, I think I doxed after the blur governance launched along with the token. And, you know, it just felt like it was getting enough attention at the time that I might as well, you know, going kind of to share with the world who I was then. So that kind of came, that was where it came from. But the self intended. You did it yourself before somebody else did it to you. Yeah, exactly. I like, I like to be able to do it, you know, like on my own terms, just like, if I'm, if I'm going to dox, I might as well do it myself.
Now, has that changed anything for you? Like in the post-docs world, is it easier? Is it better? Or is just you really haven't noticed anything? You know, actually one time I got recognized in San Francisco, which was kind of scary to me. I was like, never really expected that ever. So, you know, besides that, I don't think it really has made that much of an impact. I would say I do, like, there are a lot of benefits to being pseudo. It's cool just being able to like navigate the world without people knowing, you know, and just being able to have, I think it's really just like an optionality thing, like having the optionality to, you know, divulge that information with someone that you trust, like, when you want, that's like really cool.
First is like, when you're docs, just like, everyone already knows by default. And I think in many ways, it's like, you can get more authentic interactions with people if they don't know your background. First is when they know your background, it's just like by necessity, like that's just going to change how they think about the situation. So, I think there's actually like a lot of benefits to being, you know, Anon or pseudo. But, you know, like the docs is like the default state for like almost every, you know, builder in the world, like ever. So, it's like not that bad. I wonder how much of this, too, becomes like sort of a persona that you wear, almost like, you know, Peter Parker has Spider-Man, right?
He's got a superhero outfit and a superhero name, and it's sort of a different person of Spider-Man versus, you know, Peter Parker. I don't know if this has become that way for you, Pac-Man. But Pac-Man definitely has a name in the crypto industry, I would say, and sort of a narrative associated with us. David, I kept mentioning we're going to get to these projects. Like, Blair has been an incredibly successful project. Blast has been an incredibly successful project. You is kind of like a young, a wonder kid kind of like founder building these things and seeing the vision for them, making them so successful.
I'm curious, what you think the perception of Pac-Man is kind of like the narrative. How do you think the industry sees you? Yeah, that's an interesting question. I think it really depends on who you ask. I think if you ask, you know, crypto natives for like on-chain, I think that they would think of me favorably. Maybe they've even used blur, maybe they've used blast. I think they, you know, would probably enjoy that as users. I think if you talk to, you know, different crowds, maybe they think I'm like reckless or something, you know, based on what was built. So I think it really depends. Are you reckless?
I would say no. Although I think there's definitely a perception of that. I wouldn't be surprised if there was a perception of that. But in general, I actually don't like, I don't like taking risk, which might seem weird. Where do you think the perception comes from so far? I think it's just like optics. I think I would have to share like, if you like, let's say like specific names, I might be able to like try to like put my head in there, you know, put my head in there like mindset. And then I think about from that perspective. But I think that, yeah, I think just like optically, it's like really easy to like fud ultimately.
And what I've noticed is like a lot of fud really comes from like optics more than like fundamentals. So I think that's really what it comes down to. Usually when you get into the fundamentals, like you're going to find a different story than what you see just like on the surface level, on like crypto Twitter. And that's just not not just for me, but you know, something across the board that I've observed is that when you talk to people who are like really deep into a system and ecosystem, they usually have a very different perspective than when you talk to people who just kind of understand things at a surface level or maybe like don't understand like the technical underpinnings of a thing.
And so there's kind of like different levels and narratives based on like how deep you go. So I think like on the surface level, that's that's probably where it comes from. On the surface level, what do you think just to put an archetype on it? Like the classic, eth, maxi, decentralization, maxi? What do you think their perception is of the Pac-Man ecosystem is? Yeah, I think it really, it really depends because for some of them, like some people like really, really get it. And I think that they would be like very positive. And I think other people would would be negative. I think if you if they're like specific perspectives that you share, then I think I could give my perspective on it.
But what I typically do is I really just care about the end users at the end of the day. And I like to think from first principles is like, okay, like what are we doing? And how are we doing it? How do I feel about how are we doing it? Can I analyze how we're doing it and evaluate it against certain criteria that I think are important? And then from there, that's basically underpinning everything that, you know, I and the team is going to do. And then I pretty much ignore everything else other than, you know, like the user perspective. So I would say I don't really have as a clear of a perspective on like, you know, oppositional framings.
But, you know, if you share specific ones, I could definitely talk about it. Yeah. Well, one of my interests in this episode is really unpacking the technical properties of what it means to have a layer two with native yield. And maybe that's kind of what you're referring to as more of the fundamentals. But I think people's, this is me sharing a perspective. I think people's like reflex when they saw the launch of blast was they saw a founder who was very successful gamifying the launch of blur with different strategies for getting the token like season one, you would do this activity to get this many points.
I think I think correct me if I'm wrong, but blur was one of the first things to do points to begin with or just like have seasons around like how to get the future token really like kind of like crescendoing and corralling a community to do something that the protocol want. And this more or less spawned the points meta. And I think when people saw the launch of blast, they saw a founder who had experience doing this and really just like turned that dial up to 11 with a launch of blast with relatively like aggressive marketing of points, marketing of yield, blasping the layer, the native layer two, and then launching the system before it was even a layer two.
So like launching a layer two that was actually a multi-sig with aggressive incentive marketing with both points and yield. I think this was like people's spine reflex. And to this day like for people that still haven't like looked into blast, that's probably still their perception of what blast is. And so hyper financialization, hyper incentives, aggressive marketing is like one like a decent cohort of people's perception of what blast is. Like how would you how would you respond to that? Yeah, I would think that for a cohort of like the crypto population that that definitely resonates with what I've seen.
Yeah, you know, actually some of this is very interesting about the points meta is as far as where we were the, you know, on the blur side, we were the first, you know, team product protocol to ever do that. What was really surprising to me was that I thought that that was going to get copied like very, very quickly. Like I thought it was like very clear to me that this would be, you know, the new distribution model. I thought everyone was going to do it. And actually it wasn't really until 15 months later when when blast was released that I think then I started seeing a lot of points starting to proliferate.
And it's like weird, it's like 15 months is like a really long time, right? And I think it was just like maybe like the market just kind of need to see like the track record of, you know, like you're saying like the two for two. And then they're like, okay, maybe there's something here. And then they started copying. But it was very surprising to me that, you know, other builders like didn't really pick up on it sooner. Friend tech, friend tech was definitely a very big leveraging of points was like the only ecosystem that I remember that came before blast that really leveraged points. And if I remember correctly, they also credited the whole blur campaign is like one of their big prime motivations.
Also, paradigm shared investor in both blur and friend tech. And so maybe maybe they were like, hey, points work, you guys should do points. Yeah, yeah, definitely. I think that they, I think they came out like in the summer. So it would have been like maybe like 12, 13 months post, you know, the initial, the first blur campaign, which was in May of 2022. So it was May of 2022. And I think friend tech was like August of 2023. And then blast was November of 2023. And then yeah, I guess, I guess from that perspective, actually, there was like three, three like good data points. And then, and then we started seeing a lot of it.
In terms of like the, you know, that perspective that you shared, like the aggressive, like hyperfinancialization. And in terms of like how things are developed, that's like never the perspective. Like that's never something that's like considers like, oh, how can we like hyperfinancialize things? Like that's that's like never, never actually the root of it. And even like the incentives, the incentives are always an afterthought, actually. The thing that's the starting point for everything is just really just, you know, where do we see gaps in the market? Where do we see problems that aren't being addressed?
And then how do we provide more value to the end user? And you know, this is a financialized market. So more value typically is very correlated with, you know, is a user making more, you know, in this system than an alternative system or the status quo. And those are the first principles in which we're basically addressing these problems. And then from there, we'll design things where you think, okay, this is actually going to provide more value to the end user. And then, you know, from there, we can design like a launch, right? And we can design like a campaign. But that's always like the base of it.
So I think that those like reactions, it's like really interesting. I think those are reacting to like the surface level like outputs. But it's actually the inputs that are actually driving everything. And I think the inputs are actually way more more interesting here when you look at it. So happy to talk about that. But I know you were going to switch topics. No, that's actually exactly where I want to go. I want to go into just like what is the secret sauce inside of the blast system. But before we get there, I kind of want to just like speedrun through the arc of time that got Pac-Man to blast.
So we just got to, for the listeners who didn't listen to our first episode Pac-Man all about blur. Let's see if we can just like speedrun through the history of blur. We had you on the show in February 2023 to talk all about it. So like speedrun us through your thought process to like wide launch blur. And then we're some of the big lessons that you learned during blur that carried forward into blast. And then we'll formally unpack the blast conversation. Yeah. So blur started off, started building it in January of 2022. The impetus for blur was actually in my own experience as a user. So I really fell in love with NFT trading in 2021, minted a blipmap as my first NFT.
It was actually from the Lou ecosystem. Yes. It was actually a warm emoji. I don't know if you were familiar with him, but he's in the NFT ecosystem. And he was working with Dom Hoffman at the time. They worked on the TikTok competitor that was later like other solders shut down. But you know, from that day, they started blipmap and he was in one of my group chats. He was like, hey, I created this project and I think you guys should check it out. And I was like, you know what? Like why not just like throw a few hundred bucks at the time to the NFT. And I bought one. And then the entire like NFT bull run happened.
And I ended up selling around like 2530. And I was just like super hooked afterwards is like, what is this crazy ecosystem? And I started getting really into trading NFTs. Like I was writing, you know, I was like doing some scripting, doing some like data analytics, just like really getting into the ecosystem. I just really fell in love with the entire NFT ecosystem myself personally. And then as I was using the different infrastructures, I realized that everything was just like really, really inefficient. Like I as a user was, you know, feeling a lot of pain, just like a lot of repetitive clicking, a lot of like slow load times.
And then it's just like very frustrating. I think there's like a lot of studies on this where it's like any sort of like perceived like lag by users is like really like painful. It's like actually like infuriating for people. And I just like felt that myself, right? So I was like, okay, there has to be a better way here. And that was an impetus for blur. So then we started building blur in January of 2022. We ended up launching in October of 2022. And basically within three months, we went from like 0% market share to greater than 50% market share. And then now we set around like 70% market share.
And that was like the kind of the trajectory of it. So we released a blend at some point. I think it was in May, May or June of 2023. And blend was the a blending protocol. The first pure to pure Oracle free, you know, blending protocol for NFTs. And we integrated that. And that basically became immediately the number one, like literally like within one day, the number one NFC blending protocol on Ethereum. And since then we've just continued building and contributing to blur. How'd you do it when you kind of look back at the spirit of history when we go from 0% to like 70% of of market share?
I mean, obviously competitors weren't sleeping either. I mean, they were continuing to build. And there was some that thought the most around things like platforms like OpenC were pretty hard to like, you know, hard to get over. Pretty impetiturable. So what do you count to the success of blur? Why do you think it did so well and is doing so well? Yeah, when you looked at the landscape at the time, there were a lot of NFT marketplaces. It was like, I actually remember like looking into them like early on, like before, sorry, I'm blur, just because I was curious as a user. And I kind of like, there was like a spreadsheet early on, but like 40 different NFT marketplaces.
Coinbase, of course, famously was they spent like, you know, millions and millions. I think it was maybe like hundreds of millions like launching there and a team marketplace, which is like a total flop. Of course, there's OpenC. There is, you know, looks rare. There's actually why too. There's there's so so many attempts. I think the reason why there is an opportunity, which is because, you know, even though there was so many attempts, no one was actually really building, I think for the end user that kind of like fit my profile, which is like, I really loved trading NFTs specifically. So there is a lot of people kind of focusing on the retail aspect of things, but they weren't focusing on the trader aspect of things.
And the vast majority of activity was coming from the trader side of things. And so no one was actually, so even though it was like very like competitive, no one was actually building for the traders. And we were really the first to build for the traders. And it's not trivial to build like a really fast real-time platform. So I was really fortunate that, you know, my co-founder and I, we recruited a bunch of our friends from MIT. They worked at, you know, trading firms like, you know, Citadel and, you know, like other other firms were, you know, just building like really high speed low latency, Infra is like, you know, very important there.
And it's like, it's non-trivial, for sure. So it was a combination of like being the users ourselves, and then also just kind of being fortunate, and that our skill set was very aligned with what the market needed. So Blur has obviously been very successful. And so is the concept of points, which I think we've basically even you credit for. And I think, well, deserve Pac-Man of sort of creating that meta in crypto and launching the current points craze that we're in right now. Can you talk about the genesis of points in Blur? Was this like a very obvious concept to you or like, how did this come to be?
And why did you do it? Yeah, Blur was very interesting because, well, obviously it's like a protocol, not just like a startup, but if you think of it like a startup, it's like very interesting because normally the startup journey is like, oh, you're supposed to like launch things quickly, iterate a bunch, and actually you're going to like pivot a ton, you know, all on the way because your like thesis is going to be wrong. You're going to have to like update. Maybe you go into a cold pony market, you know, et cetera, et cetera. Blur was totally different. Blur was basically like before even starting on it, the entire like road map and what was going to be built and how it was going to be built was pretty much planned out.
We knew that we wanted to do a point system. We knew that we wanted to do an NFT marketplace for protraders, make it like a real time, Blur terminal as experience. And that was, you know, all conceptualized, you know, prior to launch. I think the motivation behind it is, you know, our perspective is it's not from a perspective of like growth. It's not like marketing. I think if you're thinking from a perspective of marketing, you're probably thinking about it wrong. It's more so about how do we align incentives with the users? What we wanted to do is we wanted to basically create this system where it's like as a user, if you're contributing to the growth of this protocol, then you're going to be rewarded.
In the same way that if you think about like Bitcoin, it's like as a Bitcoin user. Bitcoin actually aligns incentives like so perfectly, right? It's like you as a user, you can hold it and you can chill it, right? And that's actually supporting the growth of the ecosystem as a miner. You can, you know, go and build out mining capacity and that increases security of the network, which is actually allows, you know, more users to come in and you're rewarded that way. So Bitcoin actually like, like, like almost perfectly aligns incentives. And it's no wonder that it's, you know, grown to be as big as it has been.
And I think there's like the OG, like, incentive alignment. That's just like so, so beautiful to study. When we think through like, okay, we want to build this protocol and in our view, there's a way to actually build a protocol where the entire market is benefiting from it. Well, how do we create a system that is basically kind of tracking people's contributions to that system? And so that's where the points came about. So it's funny because I think that a lot of people would probably not people who are like users, but people who are like kind of like outsiders like watching in, they might kind of think of points as this like just like cheap gimmick in a way.
But it's again, like, that's just like an output from someone that's like not a user. The entire point of points is that it's actually incentive alignment with with the user base. And so basically we wanted to encapsulate and be able to measure people's contribution. And then our perspective is like, okay, from there, then they get to end up basically controlling that network that they're contributing to in a similar way to, you know, again, like with Bitcoin, it's like if you build a minor, if you're a holder and you actually, you know, on board more people, you're actually, you know, being rewarded for that implicitly.
You know, that's the motivation for everything. Well, it's not about marketing. It's about incentive alignment. How's that different than marketing? So in your mind is marketing a bit more kind of like top down the startup, the protocol kind of like pushes that out to the masses, whereas, you know, something with aligning incentives makes each individual user a marketer. How do you like, yeah, why is this not marketing? I think of marketing. You can consider it like, I think it's fair to say like the output is is kind of doing the job of what marketing would do. I think like marketing is a byproduct.
Right. Marketing is a byproduct. So the input is incentive alignment. One of the outputs you could say is marketing. I think that would be very fair. When I think of marketing, I think of more. So it's kind of like more of almost like a selfish orientation. It's like, oh, how do we like, you know, sell this product to users or how do we like get this into the hands of people? It's really from the perspective of like, what's good for like a specific organization or whoever's like doing the marketing? And like, that's fine. That's a that's a separate thing. And it's like very valuable actually, right?
Like there's you need to invest in like marketing. Like there's definitely a thing that that matters. But you know, for for the point specifically, that's not the goal. It's not the thing that like, it's not the input that's leading to the design. It is like an output though. I think that's super fair. What do you think of where points have evolved up to this point? Where up to this point? Yeah. Where there are so many crypto projects now that have implemented points. Are you sort of proud about your contribution here? Do you think they're doing the right way? Do you think this is a better state than like the world of crypto 12 months ago, which basically had no points apart from the blur project?
It's interesting. I what I've seen a lot of is something akin to what I would say like copy trading where it seems like there's a lot of teams, you know, implementing points probably from the perspective of like marketing and then being like, this is like a good growth mechanism. And it doesn't actually seem like there's a lot of like, in-depth understanding from first principles. And I think that when you're not approaching it from first principles, then the output is going to be like really, really different. You know, something that I see a lot of is, you know, something kind of akin to like farming the farmers where they almost seem like predatory programs that's just extracting value from the user base in a like very gamified way.
And I think that's fairly sub-awesome. And a similar way to like, you know, I think Bitcoin like align incentives and create something really incredible. But that doesn't mean that like every crypto project that spawns since Bitcoin has been like a net positive to users, right? I think a lot of them have been fairly large net negatives that doesn't detract from what Bitcoin has owned. I just think it's, you know, some projects are kind of taking learnings from Bitcoin and implementing things again, from first principles to create net value for the world. Other projects seem to kind of just maybe copy it for, you know, their own reasons.
And I think that ultimately it's the ones that are, you know, really thinking about it from first principles that are making contribution. The other ones just kind of just like copy trading. It's not necessarily beneficial. Go into that more. Where do current point systems go wrong, do you think? What does it mean to farm the farmers? What did you mean by that? Yeah, I think that if you like, you know, something that I see a lot of is there's two things. Sometimes like they're like very undefined timelines. That one I think is like really, really hard. But it's not just undefined timelines. It's undefined timelines plus basically what the incentives are doing is that instantivizing people to transfer money from like their wallet to the team or the protocols wallet.
And so basically like what that is doing is it means the teams are being rewarded in the short term. And the users who are participating are, you know, hopefully rewarded in the long term. But there's almost this like incentive misalignment where it's like the teams actually have like a short time horizon in which they're benefiting. The users have a long time horizon in which they're benefiting. And actually in the short time horizon, the users are losing out because they're like literally spending money and, you know, getting their wallet drained over time. And that incentive misalignment I think is actually like really, really sub optimal.
So, you know, I think if you look at like specific projects and you kind of like think about it from this perspective, you can see, you know, these like incentive misalignments coming out. Really what you want is you want, you know, all of the contributors, whether it's like the team, investors, like random users, you know, core users, like everyone, ideally is incentive aligned on a similar time horizon. That is like the best thing. But if someone's like benefiting in the short term and others have been in the long term, that's misaligned. This just reminds me of just the same pattern that we've seen throughout crypto throughout all of the cycles where the ICO movement started with some of the best projects that we know of the major one being Ethereum itself.
And then as time went on, the ICOs increased in their misalignment between token issuers and ETH receivers. And surely that principal agent problem that is, I think, more or less what you're talking about where teams benefit in the short term, users might benefit in the long term. But as time goes on, that might becomes, you know, even more dubious and almost assured that the users end up not, users end up getting kind of like exploited, just because of that incentive mismatch. And this is something that I kind of see happening with the points meta, like people are using points very effectively to get what they want done.
And I'm worried as time goes on, that appropriate leveraging turns into user exploitation as kind of this meta spirals out of control. Pac-Man, just what advice would you have for users who are interested in points, who also don't want to lose, lose out on their stack, lose out on their what advice do you have for users who are playing in the points game? How should they think about this whole thing? The best way to think about it, and you know, this is tough because it requires like effort and like thoughtful analysis which takes time. And especially in this market where it's like a bull market and you have crazy opportunities, you know, popping up and you kind of have to like act fast.
I think it's like really, really tough, right? It's like every single bull market is similar. Same thing with the ICOs, right? It's just like, oh, if you've heard it's been in the Ethereum ICO, it's like you were made through that. It was like one of the best like wealth creation events in history, especially for like the general public. But then a lot of the ICOs after that were obviously just like taking funds from users and you didn't want to like miss out on the next thing. So I think it's like really, really tough. I think that, you know, to the extent that a user can try to understand the system and get a sense of, okay, is the team that is implementing the system?
Are they actually incentive a line with us as users, you know, on the same time horizon? If basically if everyone's on the same boat, then I think that that's probably a good heuristic. If the users are on one boat and, you know, other people are on a different boat, whether it's like a team or investors or, you know, other, you know, kind of parties in the system, if they're on like a different boat and you're not on that boat, then you're probably on the wrong boat at the end of the day. Maybe it still works out, but, you know, I think it's much more dangerous. So I think about it from that perspective.
Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem, all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network, a brand new high-performance Ethereum layer 2 built using the OP stack, but uses eigenlayers data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer 1. Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle.
Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboard it, like Game 7 for Web3 Gaming and Buybit for TVL and liquidity and on-rounds. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure and decentralized Mantle. If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. It's everyone's favorite season in crypto, tax season, and crypto-tax is always an absolute headache especially for all you de-gents out there, but it doesn't have to be a nightmare.
That's where crypto-tax calculator comes in. The software built four de-gents by de-gents. As Coinbase's official global tax partner, crypto-tax calculator focuses on making complex transactions into easy ones, supporting over 300,000 currencies across Ethereum, Arbitram, Optimism, as well as a thousand other integrations as well. It's as simple as connecting your wallet, pulling in all your transactions, and following the automated suggestions to quickly and accurately calculate your tax obligations. Plus, for all the airdrop farmers out there, crypto-tax calculator has your back, as they are consistently adding support for new and upcoming layer 1s, layer 2s, and all the airdrops that you're currently farming.
2024 is the year where the de-gents do their crypto-taxes with speed and confidence. Make taxes this year easy and affordable with crypto-tax calculator. Sign up at crypto-taxcalculator.io and get a 30% discount with code bank30. Click the link in the show notes for more information. Uniswap is revolutionizing the DeFi space, not just by enabling swaps, but by empowering you to swap smarter, with a comprehensive suite of products for faster, safer, and more informed swapping. Say goodbye to pop-up wallet extensions. The uniswap extension is coming soon, and this extension is not a pop-up. It is a sidebar in your browser that persists no matter where you are on the web.
This means you can swap, sign, or send, and receive crypto anytime anywhere without obstructing your browser window. But that's not all. The uniswap web app now features limit orders, so you can buy and sell any token at your price on your terms without having to watch the market. In the best part, limit orders are built on uniswap x, which means no gas fees. Also new to the web app is the data and insights pages, with real-time candlestick charts, price data, transaction logs, and detailed pool data all integrated into the uniswap web app. All of these new releases come together to create one platform to help you swap smarter every time, no matter where you are, on web, mobile, or on the extension.
Click the link in the show notes to sign up for the extension, waitlist, and download the mobile app. Start swapping smarter with uniswap. Let's finally get into blast. The subject matter of the episode. All of that, I think, was five or six or seven different ways to enter into the blast conversation, and now we're finally here, but really starting at the very very beginnings, where did the idea for blast come from in the first place? Because you already had blur. Blur is already a project that you could spend your whole entire life building that whole kingdom, but blast is also an entirely brand new, very ambitious project.
Where did the idea for blast come from? Why does the world need blast? Why do you need a build blast? With blast, the intention was never to start up another project. That was one contributing to one is enough effort. Doing two simultaneously is extremely exhausting, but blast came about, for a number of reasons, one of them was actually informed by my experience contributing to blur. At a certain point, we started looking at layer 2s. I think layer 2s in general is pretty obvious. They're the future. Someone has spent 50 dollars in gas on an NFT on L1. That just really prices out a ton of use cases and possibilities of what NFTs, which is non-fungible digital assets can be.
We were really digging into the various L2s. I was fortunate to be able to talk with pretty much like every team, the founders of the various L2s had my co-founder digging into them as well from a technical perspective, and the thing that really stood out to me after doing that investigation was, and this is from the perspective of a builder. There's different perspectives that you have to consider here, but from the perspective of a builder behind one of the largest L1 apps, if you go out to and look at the gas consumers, blur is consistently one of the top ones. From the perspective of a builder from one of those apps, I didn't find any L2 particularly compelling.
They seemed to all offer pretty much the same thing, and it was really confusing to me because I was like, actually, my perception of L2s as a buy center. This is like as an outsider. The outsider perspective is usually the perspective that you can kind of discount the most. At least you wait at the least, but as an outsider, initially, I was like, oh, these L2s are super differentiated. This one has this feature, and this one has this feature. They all talk about different things, and they're all kind of have their stake in different aspects of the market. That was my perspective, and then once I actually dug into it, I was like, wait, actually as a builder, I don't really find any of these, particularly compelling.
That was one. Another one was on the blur side. A problem that we experienced was that the blur pool had around like $100 million in it since February, basically, of 2023. That eth was just sitting there, not earning any yield. We realized we're like, wait, this is a ton of eth in the pool. If yields could be earned from this, it could be really utilized in a helpful way. It could fund further contributions. It could go back to the users. Those would be great things, but when we dug into it from a technical perspective, it was not really feasible to go ahead and take advantage of the yield, just due to the transactions and the gas and just the mechanics of what needed to be done.
We had this pool with a ton of eth, and there was value that could have been unlocked from it, and we were never able to tap into it. Then basically, those were two underlying principles. Blast came about from identifying after digging into the L2 market, realizing that there was this large gap that wasn't filled, and that none of these L2s were offering yield to the users. We think about yield. It's a really important concept, because ultimately, there's two high-level principles that you hold to be true. One is that markets will march towards efficiency, and two is that liquidity will flow to where it can get the highest yield.
If you think about the different types of yield, there's a lot of history that you can study. One example of yield, of course, is the quote-unquote risk-free rate that the Fed controls. This raising this or lowering this by even a few bips actually has drastic impacts on the economy, and it's how they actually control and influence inflation. Just with a few percentage points, they're able to drastically have significant impacts on the economy. If you look on-chain, there now exists on Ethereum a similar low-risk yield in the form of each-saking. Ethereum as an L1 had this yield, right? It's around three to four percent, and that alone sucked up around $20 billion of liquidity into the various liquid-saking protocols.
Now, it's probably more, having checked recently, but that was the case on the L1s, but on the L2s, all of them had a baseline interest rate of about 0%. When I realized that, that really stood out to me. I was like, wait, the interest rate is 0% on L2s when it's actually around three to four percent on L1s. The realization was that we could actually basically have a zero to one moment. We could raise interest rate from 0% to around three to four percent, but implementing native yield into the L2. There's a big question initially on whether that was even possible. We had to make really significant changes, as well as just coming up with fairly novel mechanisms to actually make that native yield possible.
That was like step one, but once we identified that that was possible, we're like, okay, this is clearly the future. This actually enables a lot of really interesting things. One is obviously for the users. Now, they're just earning more by default. So, like, Blast users as a whole are earning around 130 million in annual yield just by keeping their, you know, eth instables on Blast, but actually from a developer's perspective, it actually enables you to build new kinds of apps and specifically new business models that aren't really possible anywhere else. And once we realize this, we're like, okay, this is clearly going to be where the future lies, and that's where we threw the energy into.
So, again, it wasn't like a premeditated thing. We didn't plan on going out and my co-founder, we didn't plan on starting up an L2. We weren't like, oh, the L2 market is like a big market and we want to get into it that was not at all the intention. Really, it was us as users, as builders. In this case, you know, looking at L2s, basically realizing that none of them were particularly interesting for us as builders. And then from there realizing, oh, like, what, you know, this is the shape of something that actually would be really interesting and valuable to us. All right. So, Arbitram, Optimism, Polygon, they're all going after like EVM, Ethereum equivalence.
And you were looking around the layer to landscape and saying, well, there's not a lot of differentiation here. And then noticing just the massive opportunity there is and just like putting dormant assets to work inside of a layer to hence blast being the natively yield being natively yield bearing layer two. I'll have to admit that I actually totally mid-curve to this when I first heard about blasts in the first place where and maybe that you can actually answer this question. I always thought that like my first impression of blast was like, why does it need to be natively yield bearing when I could just use lido-staked eth inside of Ave on Optimism, right?
And now now I'm getting yield and I'm on Optimism. And so, like, why does the layer two need to be native yield bearing instead of you could just use a state eth token, send that over to your layer two, and now you're just getting that yield that you would be passing along to your users on blast, but now you're just doing it in all the other layer twos. Tell me why I'm mid-curve on this. Yeah, that's that's a great great perspective. Like that reaction is like that's like a I think that's like a reasonably smart person like default reaction. So like totally makes sense that like that's like the default reaction.
In terms of why it's important is because fundamentally when you think about the on-chain economy and specifically within the Ethereum ecosystem, there's a base unit of currency that people use for transacting and that's eth. And all of this infrastructure is actually built around spending eth as this transaction primitive. When you look at altos, it's similar, right? Like everyone's spending eth as a transaction primitive. And actually that as like the default transaction primitive has like that default really matters because all of the infrastructure, all the users, they're all oriented around spending eth.
When you have a ERC 20 instead, there's a number of differences there. One is there's just like baseline just like programming differences in terms of like, you know, you need to approve the spend on an ERC 20. It's less gas efficient. There's a number of like UI UX differences between spending eth and spending an ERC 20. And then again, there's there's a lot of default infrastructure that's built around eth that you have to basically change to build around like an ERC 20. And there's just like a lot of path dependency basically where because of that path dependency, using a ERC 20 is actually like really so volatile because you're not going to get adoption within the system both from the the DAP side, the infrastructure side, and then also just from the user side.
His users are very oriented towards spending eth. So the eth itself and again, like it's it's not just that it's like a default, but actually, you know, what you can build when you have eth that you can spend that's earning yield versus like an ERC 20. Those are those are different things. Okay, so maybe we can just like kind of set the table here. The reason why wrapped eth exists on the Ethereum layer one at all is because E is not an ERC 20 token natively on the Ethereum layer one. ETH is ETH. All the other ERC 20 tokens are ERC 20 tokens, but ETH is ETH. And so there's this mismatch there that creates the need to have wrapped ETH, which is the ERC 20 version of Ethereum that can be like used is used in Ave is used on OpenC is used in Blur just to make it compatible with all the other ERC 20 tokens.
And so what you're saying is that like if we denominate our layer two, technically at the technical level at the deepest level in an ERC 20 token that can open up some DeFi UX, new surface area, new improvements. And simultaneously, it also allows us to have native yield as the unit of account, the denomination of the blast layer two. Is that what you're saying? That's a long lines, but I want to make it clear it's it's not an ERC 20 that is like the native unit of account on blast. It's it's ETH itself. And there are significant changes that we had to make to make the ETH itself natively yield bearing.
And that's that's actually what we mean when we say native yield. What's really funny is that post launch, we've seen like a lot of competitors actually kind of like copy that that wording and they say like they'll basically deploy like Steath on their chain and they'll be like we now have like native yield. And it's like really it's like really funny when we see that because it's like okay they're copying the marketing like they're copying the output, but they're not actually copying the input, which is like what is the thing that's natively yield bearing? It's it's the ETH itself. I think a good way to like get intuition on this is imagine if like Ethereum as an L1 suddenly made all of the ETH yield bearing, right?
So you're not you're not converting your ETH it's not that everyone's converting their ETH into Steath. It's that you know your ETH itself and your wallet is now natively yield bearing. You know the effect of that would be so profound like the second order effects of that would be so profound. It's very very different than just Steath on its own existing because Steath already exists on Ethereum, right? But if you consider if you imagine scenario where ETH itself was the thing that was you're growing, you'd have a very different output from like a system perspective. Now ETH you know can't really do that.
Well maybe maybe I like the technical level with like certain upgrades like maybe that would be possible. I think that you know that's not really something that we've really considered like you know ETH and from a practical perspective is not going to do that. But an L2 actually can do that and L2 can basically create an environment where it was as if Ethereum itself had ETH be the the yield bearing asset. And again the the second order effects of that are quite divergent than you know what you have on an L1 today which is you have ETH and Steath. It's kind of interesting and of course Ethereum will never do this for the same rate.
Like for partially maybe some of the same reasons that the US the US would never do this. But it's almost like US economy runs on the dollar basically and what if there was a you know a US government treasury update which basically made all dollars into treasuries or something and you got like the dollar plus your you know five percent yield or whatever the you know the current Fed fund rate is that's essentially what you're doing inside of glass. But you're you're making that kind of the the unit of account the medium of exchange for for for everything there is you just providing the yield. So how does that work as a as a user then Pac-Man?
So basically if I move some ether over to L2 does it instantly become yield bearing? And how about my stablecoins too because you're not just limiting this to ETH right? We're also if I move my SDC or my dyer something like this it magically becomes yield bearing. Can you talk about the mechanics for someone who hasn't used blast before? Yeah totally and before I dig into that I think that your example was really great for developing an intuition on this right? It's like oh like for US dollars like yeah we do have options where you can deposit your US dollars into a yield bearing account. But intuitively you can understand that if if everyone's US dollars right the dollars that you're spending from your credit card the dollars that are in your bank you know the dollar you're wiring if every single dollar that people were using was actually yield bearing that would have very different effects on the system.
And I think that's a great way of like developing an intuition about it and it's like a very subtle thing right? So it's like it's not it's not like a media obvious but it's a subtle thing but it has like a profound impact. And in terms of what the user experiences so this is actually the hardest thing. When you bridge your ETH over to blast. Basically you'll have like let's say you're using Metamask right you bridge one ETH from Maynet to blast. You switch over to the blast network. You're going to see one ETH in your Metamask wallet. The difference is that in a year that one ETH is going to become you know 1.
04 ETH automatically right? And the next year would be 1.08 next year would be you know 1.12 etc etc. So as a user you don't actually have to do anything to opt into this. It's just automatically happening and your balance your balance is actually like automatically growing. And the challenge that we had was actually making sure that we could implement the system while maintaining EVM compatibility. That was super hard. We based out of modify you know low level details about how the EVM works including the underlying storage layout for every account for every wallet in order to make this possible.
So it's pretty significant engineering that went to it. But the output is actually like really simple. I think that's actually why it's really easy to like dismiss it because the output is just like oh I deposit my ETH over to blast. And now I just have you know the same amount of ETH in my wallet optically from a user from a UI UX perspective is actually the same. And a lot of work how to go into making that experience the same. So that's like the technical note around blasts is like you guys have done like the hard low level engineering to make this thing technically feasible without breaking compatibility with the the EVM ecosystem.
You keep saying this word profound about like what this unlocks and all of the downstream consequences of that like spark our imagination here like what what about this is so profound. Yeah I think there's there's a few different aspects of it. And frankly I actually think that like even my understanding because it's like it's very hard to think through like second third level effects. So like even my understanding is going to be probably like limited in terms of like what actually ends up happening and the differences that that end up happening. But you know just like at a service level if you think from like DAPS right like you think about every single every single like successful DAP category.
Once you have this native yield as a primitive when you think about like the unlocks you actually are able to unlock new business models that aren't really possible otherwise. So I think a great example is if you look at like Perp Dex's. Perp Dex's they typically will go ahead and monetize off of trading fees right so like that's like very standard. But they actually have and have a lot of TBL you know like DAPS will have like a few hundred million in TBL GMX to a few hundred million you know they regularly have around you know like a few hundred million TBL. And what you could do with this native yield is that you can actually have a Perp Dex that monetizes off the yield instead of trading fees you know very very easily.
And now it's it's a again it seems very simple but it's basically a disruptive business model approach where you can kind of be like Robin Hood with all the the brokerages right. Robin Hood came out and they charge everyone you know zero trading fees and you know they coupled it with like a nice mobile app but it was mobile app coupled with you know new business model and although their you know trading firms were charging like $5 per trade you know that kind of thing and you know Robin Hood actually you know had a profound impact on the market right on the server level it's just like oh they just like charges you off fees like that's that's not really you know something that's interesting but actually the second third level impact was that an onboard a huge amount of retail you know into trading and it's where like Wall Street Bets came from right and there's so many other things that happen you know as a result that's just for you know Perp Dex as an example if you look at you know Dex's you know Uniswap has like billions in TBL on L1 and across like all their different different dApps those that TBL could be used to one give the yield back to the LPs so now you're increasing the you know basically like the yield rate for people who are you know market-making effectively for Uniswap so that can actually you know deepen liquidity because if you increase the rewards you're going to have you know more participation another thing that could happen is you know all of this drama around the Uniswap fee switch you know there's a world where actually Uniswap just monetized off that yield and they never had to turn on the fee switch and they actually never have to worry about what happens when they turn on that fee switch right because you know I guarantee as soon as Uniswap turns on that fee switch there's going to be competitors that are trying to vampire attack Uniswap with a zero fee model of course we'll have to see if it works but you know that that's just going to happen but in this world it's like you can actually completely circumvent that entirely because now you have a protocol that can fund itself in this you know kind of invisible way because people don't really like fuel yield intuitively I think that's why like you know this why like the the dollar supply increasing is like so invisible to people right inflation is like so invisible to people on the holidays like really bad so there's a lot of things that you can do with it that you you can't really do you know without having that primitive built-in historically inside of the Ethereum ecosystem we've illustrated it's East staking is like the opportunity cost it like the 3.
5 3.8% the rate that you get from staking your East is the payment that the Ethereum protocols paying you to forego any other opportunity costs that you would have in DeFi and this is true when you put your East into the East USEC pair on Uniswap you're not staking your East right when you're lending out your East inside of Ave or compound you are not staking your East you're getting rewarded for it but it comes at the cost of not being able to also stake your East and so it's really always been like do you either stake your East or you use DeFi and you never really get to do both but really you've you know seemed to place a lot of emphasis on the aligning of incentives maybe one very simple way to articulate what blast is is it's DeFi and staking rather than DeFi or staking is that like a dumb way to put it a simple way to put it yeah I think removing the opportunity costs and changing the order to end is like a very simple way to put it but I think I think that that's this is a good description and again this this has really significant impacts because we know we know that when when interest rates are zero in the US like now there's no longer this or you know psychology that I have to go through it's actually it goes to an an an right because you're you're earning zero percent anyway so you might as well go and deploy that capital into the market and we know that that is a very different market that we operate in then when you have interest rates at 5% and now that or is actually quite significant and basically we're changing the the order to an end the other thing that comes to mind is that being a developer becomes a lot easier to leverage in all of the yield if you don't have to think about it and so previously like if you were building like GMX on Arbitrum or or any other DeFi app anywhere else you would have to think about like the opportunity cost that you're giving up in trying to like manually rewire yield back into your app by re-denominating in like Lido Stake Death or like staking natively inside of your own protocol that's like overhead for all the developers who would manually have to manually have to like wire that up and so what you've done at blast is just you've wired it up natively into the whole entire layer two without breaking compatibility so like the developer overhead is much easier like they get efficiency out of the box by being inside of blast yeah exactly although I would say it's not just like overhead like in some cases it's like it might just like not even be feasible right because there's certain like contract size limitations there's also just like gas limitations like if you have to if you're taking an eith and you have to like reroute that into a different contract to get like Steve and then when users want to like take that out you don't have to like unwrap the seed somehow right so you're probably going to have to you know like sell it and maybe you're taking slippage and maybe that's just like unacceptable right so maybe have now keep like a separate pool of like each seed so you not actually able to like seek the entire eith that you take in you have to say like you know 80% and then if it if more than 20% it gets withdrawn at a time you know you have like a very difficult situation where like the withdrawals either take a long time or you have like you know incredible slippage for the users like you know it's it's not just that it's like overhead it might just like not really be feasible given the you know technical constraints and also just like the business constraints of the DAP so when you have the eith like natively yield bearing that that just really changes things now that isn't to say that like DAPs can just like copy paste you know what's on you know a theorem out one and put that onto blast and take advantage of it they can do that and their DAPs will actually just work you know fully without having to do anything we have like some very interesting basically we have modes for different DAPs where they can actually either opt in to take advantage of the yield or not and this we we had to design the systems so that you could have this kind of like on a period where DAPs can actually deploy onto blast before they fully take advantage of the native yield and have this like transition in order to take advantage of the native yield like you have you do have to actually like change like what you're building right like if you're if you're building a perp DAPs that's charging you know zero training fees and you know monetizing off the yield it's like that's you're gonna have to code it a little bit different than if you're doing a perp DAPs that that charges fees so it's like it's not just like oh you kind of get it like without any effort but it's more so it actually makes it possible for you to kind of put in some of the effort to design a new system to take advantage of it when it wasn't really possible before where does this yield come from for ether Pacman so obviously it's from kind of eith staking right which is sort of again the risk free rate for ether but is this inside some sort of a staking pool like is it you know under the covers is it all going into something like lido or what is this coming from yeah that's that's a great question and you know actually this is something that we we saw criticism on that we're like wow this is people like really not getting the the path forward here which is kind of interesting to contend with but basically the yield for the eith is coming from lido it's coming from c the yield for the stable coins is coming from maker dows dsr and on the on the topic of like using lido this is the infrastructure that the protocol uses during this boost shopping phase the in the long term lido is not going to be the only protocol use it might not even be use at all what's really important is that the layer 2 gets to choose like what strategies are applied lido was chosen initially because it's you know the largest e-saking protocol has you know over 20 billion dollars in it that's like a very large security bounty so it made a lot of sense to us to rely on that you know initially but in the long term the l2 can basically replace lido with other additional you know liquid saking protocols and actually you know this the nice thing about this is like it can actually decentralize liquid saking even further because lido has like a crazy amount of share right and all those deposits are controlled by lido but in this case all the blast deposits are controlled you know by the l2 itself so the community in the future could actually you know divest away from lido and actually you know basically decentralized the the saking pools even further than it is today and and that was actually something that I I saw a lot of criticism on because people were like oh like they're using lido they're just like making lido like even more of a of a threat to the system is like no it's it's actually like the best way that you could actually probably decentralize assets out of lido in the future you just have the thing on a longer time horizon so are there is there a notion of like other modules like yield modules that you could leverage as the layer two so e-sena comes to mind as like another place to generate native yield in dollar denominated terms there's eigenlayer for not just e-saking but now also restaking for additional yield so what is the thought about the evolution of where yield actually hooks into into blast yeah so this is something that we're going to have to work with the community on I think ultimately anything done here has to be a community driven initiative if it was if it was not I just I think that really affects the governance of the system like I think has to be community initiated but to the extent that any of these initiatives are put forth by the community I think at minimum you know and this is something that we where we still have to define the the process right so like this is something that that will come out you know once you know we're we're right now still in like the building phase like the bootstrapping phase it's like all the focus is pretty much on helping gaps on the l2 actually take advantage of the native yield so it's really more so on the application layer but when we think about like the the yield layer and you know what improvements can we make there there has to be like a lot of process that's you know defined for it but I think it's really important for the community to think through and analyze like what are the risks of any of the models right so like you know eigen is you know clearly like a very interesting model that has like a ton of TVL there's a lot of people that put their trust in it but I think eigen is like it's like relatively new right and we I don't think they've even like turned on their their AVS's I'm not like super deep into the system but it's like you know they're been slashing isn't even like possible right now right so you have a ton of ton of value in the thing but you don't actually know like how much slashing will occur and hopefully you know they turn it on and there's like no slashing and everyone's just earning like a lot more yield uh you know basically like for free like that is like definitely the hope but we don't actually know that yet and that's not that's not like a uh to like to neg eigen or anything like that it's just like I think for for like the l2 when you think through like you know what is driving like the yield for like assets on the entire chain you have to choose things that have uh you know better security profile like a better track record you know more lending right this is why like Bitcoin is where all the value occurs because if you want something else it's like a better digital gold it's like you don't really have the track record you don't have like the you know the trillions in in security budget that Bitcoin has right because if you can attack Bitcoin you literally have you know chose a value that I can unlock there and they haven't really successfully attacked it yet so you know that just shows that there's uh there's a lot of trust that you can kind of put in it you know similarly I think for any new strategy whether it's like eigen or Athena um you know you really have to uh look at what the security profile of that strategy is uh you know I think I think in a similar like on on the stablecoin sign it's like okay they're they're basically democratizing the basis trade um like that that's great that makes a lot of sense but there's like you know we we know ways in which the basis trade doesn't work out right if the interest rates go negative if the if we switch from a bull market to a bear market um you know you you can have these issues where we're now like you're not no longer earning yield you're actually um you know you're actually losing money over time right so you have to like really think about each of these uh different strategies and in terms of like you know ultimately it's like securing the value on on the chain itself um so I think that you know will the out to you know basically decentralize the strategies the yield in the future across like multiple different strategies like absolutely yes uh is that something that's gonna be like super fast or should be super fast uh like no it needs to be something that's like very very thoughtful um because ultimately it's like the security the entire chain yeah and I even wonder if you'll ever want to go there I mean it's kind of like when we're talking about forklifting upgrading the US economy to to T-bills imagining that rather than T-bills yield from corporate bonds you even if it was like a massive company like a apple uh bonds for for example I mean would you really want to risk forklifting your entire economy and and making it run on apple bonds rather than uh you know risk risk risk free rate of T-bills is kind of the question here and you know what were you talking about rates oh go ahead Pac-Man I was just gonna say like I don't I don't really think it makes sense to like have different types of yield I think it's okay to have different providers of yield so it's like you know it's not light-overces like lending to some random like firm that's like you know giving you some interest on that on that rate it's like a light-overces like um uh you know like the next biggest liquid-saken protocol right or some other liquid-saken protocols yeah exactly um so while we're talking about yield we've been talking about ether most of the time but you also slipped in that that stablecoins have a yield here and it comes from die the DSR you said so that the die savings rate uh I assume so if I move dollars into this thing uh what happens you know I understand what happens with my eath but do I get yield bearing dollars and can I move USDC in this or is it just limited to die can you describe what that what that looks like yeah definitely um and actually I'm happy to touch on this and there's another thing which is uh not stressed as much but actually really important as well which is the blast is an L2 actually gives all of the net gas revenue back to the depths uh so it's we had to come up with like pretty novel mechanisms so actually do that in a in a secure way and I'm happy to talk about that um and then it is for that was like when we thought from the ground up like what could an L2 be we kind of realized that that would be something that we really valued uh as builders um but just to touch on the stablecoin side of things so basically when you bridge over like USDC USDT uh you know die two blasts what you get on the receiving end is USDB which is blast native stablecoin and USDB is a yield bearing stablecoin uh so you know basically it goes from uh if you have one USDB in your wallet today uh in a year it becomes you know 1.
15 USDB the current uh you know interest rate for you at 15% wow 15% yeah and that's coming from DSR right the die savings rate yeah it comes from MakerDow so basically when you bridge over your assets are put into uh MakerDow's DSR and MakerDow recently updated their interest rate from uh 5% to 15% um and and and where that yields comes from is it's a combination of things uh a portion of it is in uh there's various like T-bill like strategies that MakerDow has uh that uh it's like Monticello's like Clieta Sale or something like that um basically there's uh some of it is in uh like you know off-chain like T-bills a lot of it is also just being lent out so you know MakerDow is this this protocol where you can like deposit E if you deposit like one you can you can uh basically mint like a few hundred dollars of die right so I can overcome collateralized uh lending protocol and basically the borrow rate for that die is 15% that that's very cool let me ask you you're talking about sort of robustness of the of the system and you know like the different sources of these yield how you have to be very careful um it strikes me that the entire setup though of this system is um for like a positive interest rate environment positive yield environment and um you know like recently in in COVID of course we we saw rates go into for some central banks in some countries kind of like negative uh interest rate territory um I'm not saying that could happen with ether but it's not completely off the table there are some protocol upgrades that might make that a possibility in the like medium to distant future uh and also the DSR could get into negative rate territory what happens to blast if some of these assets start getting like negative rates um this capital just flood out or have you thought about that scenario very much yeah it's it's a great question and actually it's it's interesting because a lot of what is implemented for these individual protocols right like whether it's like Lido or or maker or you know a lot of these different like you know yield bearing protocols uh is is something that the altitude itself also implements so pretty much like every protocol has this uh insurance program uh that they run right whereas like they have this insurance pool and in the case of like adverse events they can deploy that insurance to make everything whole um and you know for the for the most part I'm pretty sure that hasn't really needed to be deployed um but uh that's what these underlying protocols uh you know utilize and similarly for the L2 itself uh it also uh utilizes an insurance pool so that insurance pool uh grows over time and basically you know to the extent that like insurance pools of the underlying protocols are kind of like blown out uh then the the L2 itself uh has an insurance pool that can be utilized and this um entire system it's i mean yeah we can talk a lot about like insurance like the the finance of insurance is like really really interesting but it's basically just like you're borrowing from the present in order to pay off like debt in the future right because like you know in in in a long enough time horizon you know maybe something adverse happens and if you borrow enough in the present you can actually like pay off those adverse events uh in the future that's like basically how insurance works and that's basically the same model that the L2 has I was thinking less insurance though that that that is great and it's important to kind of cover that and more actual like uh rates of ether itself going into kind of negative territory because there they're have spent some talk of this as a potential in the future we've never done a bankless podcast because it's still kind of like research type conversation but yes we have I did it with that okay well so some ability for there to be like a hard cap on the number of um eth validators potentially which you could send rates into kind of negative territory and the reason that the protocol may want to incent for this is so that not like a hundred percent of the eth uh you know it doesn't get staked right that might the ethereum might decide that's not the best interest of the ethereum network we start to get negative staking rates here right um I guess capital kind of floods out of the system and maybe that kind of equilibrates and in balances out or or maybe it stays negative for a while what happens if ether goes negative again this is a hypothetical in the future but probably comes into play if your entire layer two is based on eth yield yeah that's a great question um this is this a very interesting model if if like the L1 were to upgrade to do that um i'm sure it would be something with like months and months of uh like preparation ahead of time so i can't imagine a world in which that happens and the L2 is still like staking its eth to get like a negative interest rate it would just it would just operate like every other L2 and not staked the eth um so i think like the simple answer is that it would just stop uh staking it and like lighter right it would just keep the eth in the bridge which is the default on on every other um L2 and and the system is built to basically handle variable interest rates so if the interest rates went to zero in that sense because like now it's a longer getting uh then the the layer would uh will basically be able to update uh to handle that um there would they're not really need to be any changes made uh to do that it would just be like okay now you know if you have a one eth in your wallet uh you're from now it's still gonna be uh one eth pack man get back to this last thing uh that you you mentioned earlier uh the net gas revenue goes back to the depth so i actually wasn't familiar with how that work can you describe how that works in blast yeah so basically the way every L2 works uh today is that the the dows or it might just be like the foundations behind the L2's they're earning sequencer revenue right so it's like you know people are paying a certain amount of gas to use the L2 and the L2 is paying a certain amount of gas to put those transactions onto the L1 and usually there's uh you know a difference between those and the L2 is like actually like making profit um and you know millions of profit uh from that net gas revenue and those foundations you know typically keep that revenue from the cells which you know makes sense given their their business model but something interesting that blast is able to do is because it has this yield as a new primitive it can afford to actually uh zero out the gas revenue uh so you know i kind of talked about how this yield enables like new business models the for depths that are impossible uh today uh but actually it enables new business models for the L2 itself that are impossible today uh as well and that all the net gas is actually given back to the depths um that are you know generating the transactions and this is uh i also think that this is really interesting because now you can kind of build new types of dApps that monetize in different ways right like if you have a dApp that you know isn't really you know accruing a lot of tvl but it's actually just like use a lot uh right like maybe it's like the dispersed app right or like you know some some random dApps like that um you you can actually monetize that dApp uh through the gas because uh they can basically just like call call a function to basically send all the net gas revenue uh to like a separate address um so like that's like one model the other thing is you can uh have like assets whereas like maybe instead of having like a token where you charge like a you know five percent tax uh maybe you can just have the token uh basically give all the net gas to to the creator and now you can have like a new business model you know like for that token uh similar with like an NFT it's like oh every time the NFT gets gets traded or used in like a game uh whatever the net net gas is it actually you know it could be sent back to the creator um so that's like another primitive that i'm really excited about but any any of these new primitives is gonna take time for it to play out like it's you know we've only been live for at this point you know 18 days uh um really really happy with where the ecosystem is today's like over a billion uh if tvl in the dApps is like the second largest l2 by uh dApp tvl right third largest by bridge tvl but second by dApp tvl which i think is you know uh you know it just is important if not more important but in terms of like the builder life cycle to take advantage of these primitives it takes like a a number of months to actually go and you know build something new like if you're like a legit team and you're building something that's providing value to the end users like that's probably going to take you at least three to six months if and that's if you're like a really quick team so i think it's going to take a long time to kind of see this play out um but it is a primitive that i'm very excited about there's recently a competition of sorts that happen on blast for all these different projects that are incubating themselves on blast uh there's like a hackathon of sorts where there was like competition for blast points uh and can and uh like support from the blast team uh what kind of projects did you see uh what would the if you just kind of gave us the lay of the land of the projects that are building on blast what do they kind of look like what are you excited about yeah so the purpose of the big bang um honestly that the name the name was like fairly uh descriptive the purpose was basically just to kind of like start up the ecosystem uh from zero uh and so we actually focus on very basic categories those were you know perpdex's botdex's lending protocols you know NFTs gaming you know social fi uh so those were the the key categories that we focus on and we focus on those you know those are categories like everyone already knows we focus on them because you know this is a new layer we need to boost up the ecosystem with this you know fundamental infrastructure that we know exists on every layer right you know a spotdex is going to exist on every layer you know uh perpdex is going to you know a lending protocol is going to um so those were the types of apps that we saw um something that was really exciting to us is we saw the level of like nativeness that we saw amongst the submissions I think before the competition we kind of just assumed like you know if you look at like every L2 like they kind of have all the usual sub-sex right they have like you know soft deploying they have like ava deploying um you know you have that like same basic infrastructure uh and it makes sense for those you know applications to go and you know deploying on those L2s um but the thing that I was really curious about was like okay how many of these teams are actually going to be like blast native teams whereas like they're very clearly tied to the black spots ecosystem and you know uh some of them are actually doing interesting things with the yield already or some of them are planning to uh but you know regardless of where they are at and that like development life cycle like they're you know bought in and they're building and that was the thing that stood out to me the most uh if you look on like defy llama right now if you look on uh uh the daps and you look at like which ones have tvl uh pretty much like every top-depth that has tvl is a depth that only exists on blast uh is not is not on other chains like a blast native team um that was the thing that was really uh impressive to me like it was not something that we like planned for or something that we hoped for uh but the fact that you know that was kind of like an organic development was really cool right and this is because you can't just copy and paste like ava or uniswap on to blast because you actually do have to rewrite some of the code to um fit the native yield bearing nature of blast correct uh yeah it's a little bit different actually so you can you can just copy paste uh on the uniswap uh actually i i i'm pretty sure the uniswap uh foundation is like deploying on blast uh like this week or something like that uh they had reached out so it's like you can't actually just deploy because we set up the system such that daps can actually opt in to take advantage of the yield and we did this so that you could have existing players or existing contracts that you know are tried and proven uh deployed uh very very quickly um but in order to actually do something with the native yield you do have to modify the contracts in order to do that um so i think that you know if if i was like understand like why i don't actually know why i seem like there are so many like blast oriented teams uh in the competition um you know if i were to like guess it would be that you know something that we really stress is that we don't really care for things that just exist in other altos the only thing that's interesting to you know to us as builders about blast uh and and the thing that i think it is the only thing that makes it enduring is that it enables you know new types of daps that aren't possible on other altos i think that's the thing that probably is what drew a more native crowd of course we're gonna have to see that play out over over time is gonna take time for people to actually you know do the programming necessary to to do that uh but i think that just like conceptually that's probably why it attracted more more native builders um but i don't i don't have like uh i'm not like gods i don't really know you know what went inside the head of all these builders but i think that might be why yeah maybe just uh bring this conversation full circle are you going to put blur on blast yeah the blur uh you might as well blur account tweet something uh in in in February late February i think February 29th uh but blur will be coming uh to blast in pack me and can you update us on kind of the security so uh you you mentioned some of the the flood or some of the criticism when blast was first launched right i'm reading one crypto headline blast tvl hits three hundred ninety million with no product the three of five multi-seag contract promising air drop in 2024 would be a top five tvl basically three to five multi-seag contract i'm also looking on on layer two beat which is uh of course i think a pretty objective um source for the security profiles of various layer twos you've got um two of the five slices of the pie in green congrats on the on the green slices and then three in red which uh all note is similar to uh op main net what is uh the current security profile of blast is it still a multi-seag like what does this look like stepping back a bit uh it's the security profile like of the layer is very similar to often as a main net uh the uh original like source code was started off as uh as a fork of the op gath uh but it's quite different now uh and just kind of give some like intuition around that um you know op gath started as a fork of uh ethereum gath right go go ethereum the co-diff between uh op gath and gath uh you know uh uh is smaller than the co-diff between uh blast gath and uh op gath the version that uh was originally used as a base uh so you know because of that uh you know uh history uh it's a very similar you know model from like an l2 perspective uh two optimism when it comes to the security so every l2 bridge basically operates the same way where every uh l2 basically has a uh multi-seag that's used for upgrades uh and there's many important reasons for that but like whether it's arbitrum, optimism, base, polygon, blast uh it's all the same security model i think the reason why uh blast got like so much uh generally so much noise for it is because i think this is one of those things where it's like for people who are like really deep into the weeds they would understand the security model is actually the same across the board but for people not um in the weeds they'd be like oh it's like this contract which doesn't have like a live l2 uh on top of it is just like a multi-seag like that's like a really easy like take away to take if you're like not really deep into the weeds um but if you actually get deeper into it it's actually the reality of it is that every l2 effectively has the the same security model uh from this perspective now they might operate in different ways but when you consider like security and the different uh attack factors like they all kind of like share uh this like risk surface area um i just think that you know like it was just like an object thing it was very easy to kind of call that out about blast specifically impact man you are now number three or at least blast is by total locked value behind arbitrum and op main net and um pretty early in the journey i would say as well are are you going for number one like uh uh you know are you competing up the charts uh is that uh the end destination what do you think it'll it'll take to uh to continue to grow here oh yeah i think there's a difference between emergent outcomes versus the inputs and for for us the input is we want to build the l2 that provides the most value to developers and users the most value of any l2 that's that's our goal uh and and we see the path to getting there is you know you have this l2 with native yield where everyone's just earning that by default uh but also now you're enabling new types of applications that are actually you know like robinhood for example right like them charging you know zero fees that's actually providing more value to the market than if they charge uh no fees so it's like these business model unlocks it's not just like oh it's a new business model it's like no this is actually providing more value to the market this is why these like disruptive business models get adopted in the first place so the only thing driving us is that we want to build the l2 that provides the most value to end users and developers i do think that an emergent outcome of that is that you know conditioned on accomplishing that goal we would be the largest l2 uh by tvl and usage uh but the input is really just you know how do we provide the most value are you are you going to join the op super chain is is that part of the roadmap or have you already no it's it's it's different because of my understanding i actually have a of only loose understanding of the op super chain my understanding is that it's basically all op sack forks right it was based like each chain is like a copy pace of the op sack base and um they're basically just like different instances of it so it's like different like go to markets maybe um but blesses like very different uh from optimism at this point so it wouldn't i don't i don't even know if it was like technically possible i don't know like what can like is is is is it actually like a technical thing with something's part of the super chain or is it just like an op sack fork is technically part of the super chain uh but i either way it wouldn't be part of it just because it's it's quite different now yeah i'm to answer some clarity on that it starts off being an op stack fork uh and then beyond that then you can opt into the op optimism collective and then you're a part of the super chain if you're technically differentiated from the op stack fork you can still become a part of the super chain it is just another um technical lift in order to formally enshrine uh blasts version of the op stack as a verified thumbs up part of the op stack super chain optimism collective is that like a more of like a governance uh like vibes thing or is it like a technical thing like the arbitrage of the super chain or is it just like no arbitrage from cannot become part of the super chain because you have to be an op stack fork to to start there uh i mean like maybe that's technically not true the closer you are to be technically similar to the op stack fork to the actual reference code the closer you are to getting into the super chain but beyond that then it turns into a vibes governance thing so it's a little bit of both like how technically differentiated are you because that is a technical lift in order to make homogenous block space a thing uh but then once once you are within like reason it's kind of like um like argentina is never going to be come part of the EU although the EU could technically vote in argentina it but it would still never happen it's kind of like that um and so like being technically differentiates differentiated removes you from being part of the super chain but then you could still lobby to have your forked version of the op stack as a verified part of the super chain and then you there you could have like multiple blasts be a part of the super chain you could have blast get forked into blast two and three and four and then all of those would be like approved modules inside of the super chain uh but then ultimately it is still like governance uh collective unionization kind of thing just to provide clarity there yeah that makes sense uh i guess like my uh my model would be like you know if if china like thought it was valuable become part of that you it maybe it would but it's probably like not going to um it's probably gonna say an event and i think that's probably the case for for blast yeah yeah that makes sense hackman this has been uh really cool uh to just understand you understand you as uh as a builder um you know going through blur going through through blast i i'm wondering about kind of your your current your current commentary out in the state of um just crypto right now in 2024 and uh in general i guess i would i would say maybe a few themes of course yield has been front and center in 2024 with everything eigenlayers doing and certainly you're contributing to to to to part of that with a blast um so has uh layer two's right sort of now it's being pitched of we've got the you know the modular stack and all of these ethereum uh based layer two's and ethereum line layer two's and they just got you know uh a new uh eip um 4844 that's decreased the gas and you know gas fees are are down versus this monolithic approach from from salana and some of the other parallelized chains layer ones that are developing uh what's your take on all of this how do you think it's going to play out specifically on the on the chain wars side of things do you are you like do like the modular approach uh monolithic you think it's going to be some of both who do you think kind of nets out as a winner here yeah i think that when it comes to the the chain wars you know especially in financialized spaces typically there's extreme power law outcomes uh and i think the intuition for for wise because uh you know there's there's network effects to these systems liquidity tends to concentrate it doesn't really disperse you know over time so i think the the outcome that you'll see is it's kind of so much what you see now which is uh you know you have one dominant layer one right that's bitcoin uh then you have the next most dominant layer one which is you know a theorem uh and then you have the next one which is salana and if you look at like a theorem the bitcoin it's like uh you know like a three x difference like salana to a theorem it's like a two x difference uh and the drop off is like very extreme uh after that so i think that the the end outcome uh you know and i think l ones will like always kind of get a bit because there's always going to be people be people who are like oh what's the next a theorem or what's the next salana so i think there's always going to be you know some noise about that but in terms of like what is like the end you know structure i think that it's you know likely the case that there's really going to be only like two to three relevant ones you know to the extent that you know a theorem is salana kind of like different you know stakes in the sand uh i think that they can like all coexist um i think that's still regardless of you know which which path is like right um it's just going to be a very clearly it's going to be like a parallel um outcome uh just regardless of how it goes pacman as we maybe finally close this out uh it's been a bit great do you have any advice to sort of um you know i consider you sort of a you know gen z builder i don't know if you're you're officially in kind of that generation but kind of like younger up and coming the older gen z so you're an elder gen z at this point do you have any advice for any of the upcoming crypto gen z builders like what's um yeah well what would you say to them a younger version man it's it's so hard to give like generalize advice like i'd really have to you know see like a specific builder uh because everyone's going to have like different skill sets i think ultimately though i think the thing that should drive any builder is are you able to provide net value to the end users like differentiate a value to the end users that doesn't exist elsewhere you know i think there is a lot of you know trend surfing there's a lot of it's really easy to kind of like look at the market and be like oh this is like a big market and i should like get into it and like go and you know build this kind of protocol because this kind of protocol has been proven to be valuable you know by the market um i think that that is something like that i very see uh i see a lot of uh across the board but that's not really the thing that's interesting what one is i don't think that's really how you you know build something gray uh but also it's just like that's like not an interesting thing to do for you like spend your time on um i think the only interesting thing is like can you actually provide something that's like creating value uh for the end users or for the stakeholders that are involved you know if you're doing that then i think you're probably on the right track if if you're not then you should probably re-evaluate what you're doing well thank you so much for uh joining us today pack man this has been a lot of fun it's back around thanks guys this is really fun banklostation got to end with this crypto is risky you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the banklost journey thanks a lot you