Ameen Soleimani is the Founder and CEO of SpankChain, the co-creator of MolochDAO, and the co-founder of Reflexer Labs, which created RAI.
David and Ameen chat about Moloch, coordination, DAOs, and what DAOs can do for both Ethereum and the broader world. Additionally, they get into Ameen’s recent fight against the Federal Reserve.
This is a mind-expanding discussion that you won’t want to miss. Enjoy!
------ 📣 Swell | Liquid Staking for the People https://bankless.cc/swelldiscord
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🌱 LENS | WEB3 SOCIAL PROTOCOL https://bankless.cc/Lens
🚀 ROCKET POOL | ETH STAKING https://bankless.cc/RocketPool
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
🌉 JUNO | BRIDGE FIAT TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Juno
⚡️ ZKSYNC | THE LAYER 2 SCALING ENDGAME https://bankless.cc/zkSync
----- Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 5:25 Ameen’s Crypto Perch 7:22 Ethereum’s Culture 9:55 Ameen’s Activity in the Space 14:03 Moloch Meme’s Origin 22:03 Moloch DAO & PTSD(AO) 31:31 Ability to Freely Exit 35:20 Organizational Change 42:55 Slaying Moloch 50:25 Global Settlement Layer 54:20 Sticks vs. Carrots 59:18 RAI, the Fed, Ponzis, & the Dollar 1:10:32 Thomas Jefferson & Slavery 1:15:34 Dollar Printing Gone Wrong 1:18:00 Invading Iraq 1:19:50 Ignoring, Overreacting & the Dollar 1:27:18 How Ethereum Fixes Things 1:34:11 Closing
------ Resources:
Ameen Soleimani https://twitter.com/ameensol
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Layer Zero. Layer Zero is a podcast of unscripted conversations with the people that make up the Ethereum community. Crypto is built by code, but it's composed by people. And each individual member of the crypto community has their own story to tell. The cypherpunks understood that the code they write impacts the people that use it. And Layer Zero focuses on the people behind the code, because Ethereum is people all the way down, and always has been. Today on Layer Zero, I'm talking to Amin Soleimani. And I've said his name on the Bankless podcast a number of times before. He's been on the Bankless podcast a number of times before.
He helped meme Moloch into existence in 2018 and 2019. He's the creator of Moloch DAO, one of the first DAOs to come out of Ethereum after the DAO. And he makes this joke about how he made Moloch DAO with many purposes, one of them being to help the Ethereum community get over what he calls PTS DAO, as in PTSD over the 2016 DAO that caused the Ethereum classic hard fork. So we talk about Moloch coordination DAOs and what DAOs can do for the landscape of both Ethereum when it comes to coordination, but also for the broader world. And really why Ethereum is just coordination tools all the way down.
But then we get into some broader subjects such as as his recent fight against the Federal Reserve and how the Federal Reserve has this relationship with the broader world that is unsavory and how we as a people need to resist what is going on with the Federal Reserve. And Amin has always been a very big patterned thinker, a big philosophical person who can see the biggest patterns that the world has put in front of us and sees them for what they are. And he's a pretty controversial guy. He's pretty sharp around the edges. He's definitely not afraid of putting his foot down and making people be very uncomfortable.
So I actually do not recommend that you listen to this episode with kids in the car or, you know, young ones who aren't ready for very mature subjects. But even though, I mean, definitely has his controversies, he's a hero of mine through and through for the way that he thinks and what he thinks about and the lessons that he brings to the table, because they're very emblematic of this particular podcast, why I call it Layer Zero. It's because he gets down to the bottom of things in a very fast, sometimes crude, but effective way. So I hope you enjoy this episode with Amin Soleimani, and we'll get to that conversation right after we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible.
Arbitrum is an Ethereum Layer 2 scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Some of the coolest new NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home, while DeFi protocols continue to see increased liquidity and usage. You can now bridge straight into Arbitrum for more than 10 different exchanges, including Binance, FTX, Huobi, and Crypto.com. Once on Arbitrum, you'll enjoy fast transactions with cheap fees, allowing you to explore new frontiers of the crypto universe. New to Arbitrum, for a limited time, you can get Arbitrum NFTs designed by the famous artists Ratwell and Sugoi for joining the Arbitrum Odyssey.
The Odyssey is an eight-week-long event where you can play on-chain activities and receive a free NFT as a reward. Find out more by visiting the Discord at discord.gg slash Arbitrum. You can also bridge your assets to Arbitrum at bridge.arbitrum.io and access all of Arbitrum's apps at portal.arbitrum.one in order to experience DeFi and NFTs the way it was always meant to be, fast, cheap, secure, and fiction-free. The Brave Browser is the user-first browser for the Web3 internet with over 60 million monthly active users. And inside the Brave Browser, you'll find the Brave Wallet, the secure multi-chain crypto wallet built right into the browser.
Web3 is freedom from big tech and Wall Street, More control and better privacy, but there's a weak point in Web3, your crypto wallet. And most crypto wallets are browser extensions, which can easily be spoofed. But the Brave wallet is different. No extensions are required, which gives Brave browser an extra level of security versus other wallets. Brave wallet is your secure passport for the possibilities of Web3 and supports multiple chains, including Ethereum and Solana. You can even buy crypto directly inside the wallet with RAM. And of course, you can store, send and swap your crypto assets, manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps.
So whether you're new to crypto or you're a seasoned pro, it's time to ditch those risky extensions and it's time to switch to the Brave wallet. Download Brave at brave.com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. Juno is bringing crypto-friendly banking straight into your checking account. With Juno, you can send money from your Juno checking account straight onto a layer 2, like Polygon, Optimism, Arbitrum, and they have ZK Sync and StarkNet support on their way. You can skip the ACH wait times, you can skip all the gas fees, and go straight from your checking account to an Ethereum layer 2 in seconds.
Inside Juno, you can buy and sell crypto with $0 fees, and your Juno checking account comes with a metal MasterCard that gives you up to 5% cash back on your spending. Juno is also giving you $10 cash back on your first crypto deposit and $100 when you set up a direct deposit. This ad just writes itself, so go sign up at juno.finance.com. What's up, Amin? How's it going? Great. Thanks for having me. That's quite the eccentric background you've got there. Yeah, had to fit the unicorn into the picture. Is that a Cherith that you're on? Yes, this is a nice little pink throne-y Cherith thing. We'll get into all of that and more.
But for listeners who came in perhaps in 2021 or beyond, the most recent cohort of crypto listeners, content consumers, they might not be as familiar with you as I once was when I first got into this space. uh can you explain your perch in the ethereum and broader crypto ecosystem what would you say that you do here uh yeah so i'm the ceo of spank chain which was the first uh one of the first attempts to bring the benefits of crypto to the adult community uh so from that perch i get to sort of you know it's like a libertarian viewpoint how to make things useful for everyday people uh you know not so much like uh the grander things too but uh yeah that stuff's more about like helping sex workers uh you know use ethereum tools to keep their money safe um and and so forth uh sell nfts and um but we do some other things too uh we made the first l2 uh spank live so that was a fun opportunity to learn about you know putting l2s in production four years ago a lot of lessons learned that we've been able to use now uh four years later when it's like finally time uh for layer twos um i try to focus on the types of things that people aren't uh and like where the blind spots were too so it started malik dalek back in the day uh ethereum was very utopian and i was uh concerned that our utopianism uh wasn't going to like you know be very scalable or sustainable forever so yeah yeah go into that a little bit more uh if one of the things that brought me into ethereum is just how optimistic and perhaps utopian is the right word everyone is it's like it's infectious like everyone's really generally happy and accepting uh but but i think perhaps somewhere to our our own like naiveness naivete like when you come into ethereum and you see like the culture here what do you see yeah i saw a lot of like well-wishing sort of people right it's like um we prided ourselves for years about being a very welcoming community about being very friendly and it led to the ethereum community getting hacked in sort of predictable ways uh by people who were like oh you know uh up front like very friendly but then had sort of their own intentions and goals that were maybe not aligned with the Ethereum community.
And so a lot of the Kumbaya culture isn't very well designed around adversarial thinking and things like that. And so, you know, the idea of like Moloch was very appealing to me because it described these sort of like game theoretic traps uh where you have to make some sacrifice of something you value because everybody else does and like ethereum doesn't exist in a vacuum uh it would be nice if it did but like it's still subject to the competitive forces that drive everything else and so if we want our values uh of you know uh pro-social and uh positive sum to expand to the rest of the world we sort of have to compete to protect them and to advance them against other things that might try to out-compete them that don't have those values and i saw a lot of people taking this idea for granted that ethereum was just like the best it was going to dominate forever and it was just going to win because we're the good guys and like in my experience that's like not how anything works it's like nice when the good guys win but it's like typically because they're more powerful than the bad guys it's not because they like are nicer than the bad guys like I mean I don't know you can make the case that like they could coordinate better but like yeah that's getting sort of deeper into the subject Mm-hmm.
what do we do with that thing? Oh, we, we apply it to like making sex workers lives like easier. And then like, you have this like era value that's very like, I kind of find like Ethereum aligned in that we're here to move the needle of humanity, but we're not going to take ourselves too seriously while we do it. And, and so like, well, this started off as like, you know, what, what am I going to do with this payment technology? I'm going to go like straight into sex work in like 2017. And then like that kind of also, I think also relates to how you interface with like the broader Ethereum community.
It was like, oh, everyone is in this like growing the pie mentality, but I'm going to be like the hardliner that enforces like adversarial thinking and thinking of everyone as an enemy because all of you people aren't doing that. That's kind of how I like quickly and quickly and roughly summarize your activity in the space. Does that resonate with you yeah absolutely um it was uh it was basically a reaction to the prevailing utopianism that uh drove me to embrace the malik meme and feel compelled to share it um because i like it's not like to be clear like i like the utopianism right i like the aspirational nature of a theorem i like the optimism uh i i think uh it's important to sprinkle it with a dose of realism um and like also there's other communities where like the slang malik meme wouldn't have worked out uh because they don't care so like you know maybe in other communities that are less mission oriented and more mercenary you know oriented uh you know they don't care about slang malik they're like wait i can trade my values for competitive advantage fuck yeah that sounds great let's worship malik and do that right uh is there a point to this whole blockchain stuff that beyond getting ourselves rich?
I don't know. But like, who cares? You know, but like, that's not what you feel in Ethereum. What you feel is like we are advancing something that matters, right? And, you know, I just, I also care about that goal. And I wanted to help advance it how I could. And that also, you know, meant acknowledging that like, it's not always going to be, you know, sunshine and roses, like sometimes it's you know not going to be great like we actually have to make sacrifices and if we want to you know keep advancing these values then we have to fight for it uh we have to out-compete the rest of the world and so the paradox of malik uh that that i talk about sometimes is that like you sometimes you we talk about slaying malik but like the paradox is that in order to get the power to do so, we like sometimes have to worship at his altar.
Right. Like if we didn't at all strengthen ourselves or become competitive, then, you know, we just auto lose. Right. So there's like some middle ground between and this is why it's a paradox is like it doesn't fit, you know, very cleanly. You're like, I just want us to be the good guys forever, you know. But it's like, no, it's like if you have this value thing you want to preserve, protect, advance, you have to compete for it, fight for it, do all the things that you normally do. You just have to also preserve it because that's the core thing that you're trying to do. So, yeah. I don't know if all that made sense.
We'll have to actually explain this Moloch meme. This is a meme that Bankless has been just like, it's the banner that we kind of live under. But again, we haven't really talked about it in 2021, 2022 nearly as much as we did in earlier times. But maybe we could actually explain the Moloch meme by giving a history of its relationship with Ethereum, which is an intimate part of like your own story with Ethereum. So maybe we can go back to where the Moloch meme was really just getting incepted into Ethereum culture for the first time because you were really leading that charge. Could you take us back in time and start the story there?
Yeah. Moloch means a couple of things. So I read the blog post Meditations on Moloch by Slate Star Codex, Scott Alexander. It's his rationalist blog post. And it describes the rationalist god of coordination failure. Put a word on an anxiety I've had my whole life, which is like, why can't we all get along? Why can't we have nice things? And it's like, you know, because people and, you know, in these competitive situations, they have something that they can sacrifice that they value in order to get an edge. And the end result is everybody does it. And so, like, you end up in these sort of, you know, unfortunate equilibriums where, you know, as a country, we want to spend money on guns and bombs and play it.
I'm sorry. We want to spend money on healthcare, education, and infrastructure, but we end up spending it on guns and bombs and planes because we, like, can't coordinate with everyone else to disarm at the same time. And even if we did coordinate with everyone else on the planet to disarm, then, like, whoever is the last person with all the guns, you know, takes everybody else over and then the world reflects their values, which is, like, secretly amass a bunch of weapons. and so like the whole disarmament like wasn't very effective and Moloch is used as like a shorthand to describe these like coordination failures where like if we could all just work together and had some mechanism to do that that would be great and maybe we could reach a better equilibrium but because we don't we have to like compete and fight and we're trapped in this like less good equilibrium and the story of how it relates to Ethereum is that I also discovered Ethereum in like the same week, discovered Moloch, and then tried to bring these ideas because I realized that Ethereum was a platform for building coordination technology.
So like if you're in one of these unfortunate equilibrium, you want to get to the better equilibrium, how do you do it? Well, you need to come up with some game to coordinate with everybody else in order to, you know, advance this sort of better coordination station. And so the tools for doing things like that are what Ethereum is all about, in my opinion. And so I was like, how do I get people to feel this thing that I feel right now? I'm going to call this down MolochDAO. Hopefully, it'll get all these people to read this blog post. And we're like several years downstream from that. And now there's like comic books and like more literature and memetics that are being developed around the Moloch meme.
And it's turned into a sort of rallying cry for the Ethereum community to coordinate around what is our own mission, what is our goal. And it's helped crystallize. It's like, well, what do we do here? We build coordination tools. It's not about my country, my faith, whatever. It's like about building things that allow us to like progress past the like coordination systems that we can even imagine today. You know, like countries are great, but they have borders, you know, outside of the border. Like you're not really our friend. So it like has a scalability limit to how far it can, you know, coordinate people.
Same with faith. You know, faith have heretics and nonbelievers. and so they run into limits on coordination. And so the idea is like what if, you know, the big idea for things like Ethereum is like, well, you know, how do we do better? Like what if we took like country and faith and like other types of coordinate, you know, group, nonprofit, corporation, like these are our starting points of coordination technology. And so the way that we, you know, slay Moloch is we improve on coordination technology itself. And that's a powerful thing because I think a lot of, you know, we're used to being raised in this like us versus them mentality.
Everybody is. And so like trying to identify the traps like of the us versus them, you know, it's like us versus them is kind of a psyop. So we're like trying to figure out like what exactly is the, like why is it us versus them in a specific way? Like, how do we unlock, you know, more coordination value out of humanity? And when we started making DAOs, like, there were three DAOs, right? Moloch DAO was, like, it was, like, DAO number four. So we've had a great opportunity to, like, sound, like, complete, you know, really out there. Like, you know, heretics or nutcases or whatever. We're like, yeah, there's going to be 10,000 DAOs when we're on DAO number three.
This is stuff that we used to say. Eva and Peter and James Young and all the people who were early Moloch DAO because we could see the coordination potential that we could see about to be unlocked. We're like, people are going to flip when they figure out DAOs. right it's like and this was back in 2018 19 yeah we're like building it in 2018 being like oh my god this is gonna be so much fun like people are gonna be so excited you know and there's like 10 DAOs by the end of the year yeah 2019 it was like me and Peter and Telegram groups just like starting another DAO every like couple weeks like marketing DAO and there was like a Orici DAO it was like a DAO for drinking you know events it was like the kickback guys made it there was all sorts of DAOs.
We made the Yang DAO just to pay some kids in Colorado to put up flyers and pay the deepfake memes for Andrew Yang. So between 2019 and now, like 2022 at ETH Denver, I helped Andrew Yang get inside the event because he was stuck outside the event. You were talking to him because you were talking to him about DAOs and about his Lobby 3 DAO. It was like a special event. And I was like, this is sweet. I want to go to Andrew Yang's event. I helped start Yangdao. Let's see where he's gotten in three years. So we just roll up, you know. I'm like stuck outside of Denver. And there's a dude in front of me wearing a suit.
Like who the fuck goes to Denver wearing a suit? And the event organizers like wouldn't let him in. And I look over and it's like Andrew Yang. Like apparently running for president isn't enough, you know, to get into Denver. turns out he'd like given somebody his badge or something so i was able to you know give him my badge get him in uh and gave a great talk with you guys on stage so um yeah it feels pretty cool to see all of that stuff happen uh and then people like research malik you know they're like oh look like this now it's like cool to have uh you know put that like medic brick in this like what you know immutable wall uh and see that you know pay dividends in terms of uh recruiting people to uh be aligned with the original mission we were trying to help people frame and understand that was a long rant i've had a lot of caffeine thanks for listening to all that just to make it extremely extremely explicit as to the connections being made here but you said ethereum is a platform to build coordination tools and then and then you went through the history of ethereum as it goes from three to thirty thousand daos you can extrapolate beyond 2020 to where we are today where everyone you can spin up a dow to buy a constitution if you so choose but just like can you just connect the dots on all of these things about Ethereum as coordination tools, DAOs, and Moloch?
Yeah. So like Moloch DAO, you know, was one of the first DAOs. The first one blew up, right? It was called the DAO. And it's why we have Ethereum Classic and Hardfork and da-da-da. And we had PTS DAO. And so we made Moloch DAO to be very simple and to just like fund grants with ETH and do very little else. but between like you know MolochDAO itself was a whole ordeal like we were onboarding people with Etherscan at ETH Denver you know I was like manually typing in zeros it was very early in the whole process like now there's you know DAO tools for basically spinning up everything and there's a lot more flexibility and it took a lot of people just grinding for years uh we we made moloch dao uh like as as a non-profit just to do the grants for with eth right so so it didn't have any of the other features uh the original design for like my investment dao moloch ventures is like closest to like what is being released just now with like moloch version three um so that we the version one was like just grants uh just you know deposit couldn't do any other tokens didn't have any proposal types couldn't change the governance couldn't do anything right and that was uh to help address the security issues you know around launching these things because the last one had blown up and stuff um and so um it was what we really needed to get over what you just called our pts dow of just like okay let's eliminate all complexity and do one thing and one thing only which is agree to coordinate as to where to send ether.
And so all other, all of much surface area was just like stripped away because we as a community still, when you said the word DAO, people would flinch because we, you know, almost blew up Ethereum and had to hard fork away. So we needed this like, yeah. Don't do that. Sounds scary. Why would you do that? Did you see what happened to the other guys who did that? They got blown up, dude. We're like, okay, relax. Like we'll just do it the dumb way, the simple way. We won't do anything complicated. And then people, you know, other people would be like, we got this great feature idea for your DAO.
And we'd be like, that's a great idea. We're not going to do it. Talk to me in a year. And so we had to like run a grants DAO for like just a year. And it turned out to be like the right thing to do to advance, you know, the coordination culture, to have more people who've done DAOs. And like I have this mental model of progress. Maybe it's more relevant for like open source stuff. But, you know, I see progress as a series of motivational equilibrium. Like I don't actually have to solve everything myself. I just have to push the ball, you know, to push the state of affairs to like the next motivational equilibria where there's like more people more motivated to solve all the problems.
And I feel like that's kind of what we accomplished with Moloch V1, just grants, you know, ran it for a year. got you know to hustle basically like 20 people for 100 ETH early on raised a couple mil got EF consensus Vitalik Jolubin put in a couple mil made some grants Tornado you know probably the most important um bunch of other grants around ETH2 you know helped give the first grant to like the thing that is now Protocol Guild uh back in its inception um you know did all that but like also helped meme DAOs, you know, like help people recover from PTS DAO, helped educate people about how to DAO, like, what does it mean?
There's proposals, there's, you know, a grace period, you can exit, like popularize the rage quit as a way of embedding minority protections into your DAO so that, you know, participants can leave with their share of assets at any time. And like, it took years for these concepts and like to proliferate and percolate in the, you know, ecosystem until now there's like lots of DAOs, you know, there's investment DAOs, there's like, uh, protocol DAOs, there's nonprofits, there's social clubs. Um, and they, they run using, you know, different types of systems. Some are multi-sigs. I'm like a DAO boomer at this point.
So I'm like, all right, you know, that's a multi-sig get off my lawn. Um, but yeah, uh, like people started coordinating, right? Like all of these are examples of coordination. Um, With Moloch Dow, we raised money from like, I don't know, 25, 30 some people in like 10, 12 something different countries with no paperwork. Nobody signed anything. It would have been a lot harder to do the same type of thing in like your, you know, meat space. You know, I talk about these things as like your jurisdictional stack, right? So like in order to do the thing which Mollictout did, which is like allow you to pool money with a group of people, but also like vote on proposals.
And if you, you know, at any time don't want to spend your money anymore, pull your money out without asking anyone. It's like impossible to do in Meatspace because you have to like set up a bank account, hire lawyers, come up with bylaws. And then you have like several people, you know, to do every process. You're like, oh, we would like to collect signatures on a vote on this thing. oh, okay, you have to like go through some software, Carta, you know, like some like management thing to like collect signatures and authenticate people. And you have to do that every time you want to, you know, spend money on anything.
And then like if somebody wants to leave, they have to like ask for permission. And then like you have to go through the lawyer to go through the banker and like send a wire. And like any of those steps could like fail for whatever reason or get held up or frozen or, you know, censored. And like the reason that people trusted the Moloch-Dao smart contracts was because they knew that they could push a button and the smart contract would release their money. They didn't have to talk to anybody. There's no like jurisdictional stack of things that can fail. And that unlocks a lot of value. That overhead that isn't there now makes it so that it's viable to create a group like this to solve a problem that would otherwise have been not worth making a group like this.
to solve. And so like when I'm talking about unlocking coordination potential, like that's the kind of stuff I'm talking about. It's like specifically the coordination overhead is a number and it gets smaller, right? Across all of the participants needing to verify that other people have done stuff, that the treasury is accurate. Like these are all, you know, trust things that allow us to trust each other more quickly and allow groups to scale trust more quickly and execute their goals more easily. So, yeah, this is like stuff. Nothing has changed, right, between 2018, 2019, and now. Like some more code has been written to make these things easier.
But really what's happening is stories. Like I remember interviewing a Coindesk reporter last year at EmCon. I just got back from EmCon. in Denver. So that's the Meta Cartel Conference. So they did MCON 2 this year. Last year, they did MCON 1. And I talked to this journalist, and they asked me what the limiting factor was for growth and more people thinking it's a good idea. And I said that the code is mostly there. The limiting factor is stories. People need to see the narratives develop. People need to see the story of somebody doing a DAO, being successful, you know, raising money for some cause, and then being able to imagine themselves as part of that story in their own way.
And until that happens, you can't recruit people because they don't have any examples of how to work with it. You know, the framework, they're like, okay, you have a DAO, like, what do I do? Right. And so it's really important, I think, to push narratives forward. And so with with MolochDAO, you know, the story was an ETH dev, didn't feel like going through the EF for grants, made his own DAO for grants and, like, started funding things to advance the ecosystem and, like, eventually got other people, you know, including the EF to buy in and, like, operated his nonprofit, you know, using this technology with a community of people that were into it and, protected their own minority rights, you can too.
It was basically a non-starter to consider using things like DAOs for nonprofits and stuff. And so we had an example of us doing that in a successful way. So a lot of times, you just got to go first. One of the elements of why this works so well, you touched on it and I want to double down on it is this like free ability to exit as an individual. And it's truly something that only is, is possible because of private keys, because of, you know, really the invention of being able to custody your own funds and have people ask you for permission rather than you being the person to ask for permission.
Can you just, let's double down on that. Why, why is that such a fundamental part about like, why all of this coordination stuff works in the first place? Yeah, this is a great, great question. Custodying funds is great because it means you don't have to ask people for permission to use your money. Just very high level, like custodying funds is one of the core things that blockchains, specifically cryptocurrencies, are about, right? Like even if DeFi and stuff doesn't, you know, where it's like you don't want to have to like call your bank to send a wire and they're like, no. Right? Just basically like that.
You never want that outcome. And like the Bitcoin network, you know, so long as it remains censorship resistant, we'll never say no to you. Ethereum network will never say no to you. And then we can like piggyback off of this like custody property to do other cool and useful things. Right? So like one of the, you know, differences between something like MolochDAO and something like a nonprofit with a bank account is that you have custody of your funds. This is also different if like you use the multisig, right? You know, the operators, the signers of the multisig are, you know, custodians of the funds, right?
But Moloch Dow had this very unique new property called the Rage Quit and that allowed you to maintain custody and sovereignty of your funds even while you pooled it with other people. And so that's an important thing because it turns your like donation to this nonprofit into more like a pledge, a revocable pledge. and so you can choose to exit you know if a proposal isn't going the way you wanted you voted no the rest of the you know dow is like well we really just do want to spend money on this and like if you don't like it so be it you can be like well okay fine you know i accept that you guys are still going to fund this i disagree i don't want to do this anymore i'm taking my money i don't want it to go for this cause and i'm rage quitting i'm exiting with my pro rata share of the remaining funds.
And so, you know, I'm out, right? And I had custody of my money. I didn't need to ask them for permission to do that. But it does also change this game theory. If you've heard about, you know, the voice and exit, like custodial systems have no exit, right? You can have a voice, you can, you know, complain or ask for help or permission. But at the end of the day, unless you can exit, you're sort of trapped. And then you can be coerced. You can be forced to do things with your money that you do not consent to. And so being able to have custody over your money, even while it's in a DAO, even while you pooled it with other people, even while we can submit proposals and decide how to spend it together, but also retaining that ability to exit whenever you want is super important because it makes it a lot easier to join in the first place.
I would – I'm basically willing to join any Moloch DAO because if it has a rage quit, I'm like, well, what's the worst that could happen? They submit a proposal. I don't like it and I leave. So, yeah. The cost of joining any DAO is as close to zero as – it's basically a gas fee. And so – In theory. There's some social costs of like, oh, I joined. Now I have to leave. I have to talk to people. But exactly. It opens up the landscape. Right. And so like the, the joining like a nonprofit has overhead, right? So how many nonprofits can one person really manage their, their relationship with in their lives?
Probably a single digit number, probably even on the average person, no more than like two. But like in with DAOs, like your participation in DAOs is really as many discords as you feel compelled to like pay attention to. Basically. Yeah. And how does this change the relationship of like the broader org with, it's individual members. Because now, like, this is all about putting power into the hands of the individual, right? Like the individuals always have, well, maybe they don't have the most power, but you don't have, organizations don't have power over the individual if there is that rage quit mechanism.
So how does that change, like, the nature of the organization when that is the new equilibrium? It makes it much more likely that the decisions of the organization will reflect the values of the individual members. You sort of get this like all proposals are consensual implicitly because everybody has the opportunity to leave if they disagree with any proposal. So the game theory of it works out that like the organization is not incentivized to pass any proposals that they think will make a lot of the people leave. Because even if I can make this proposal pass, like if you guys all leave then you know i'm stuck paying for it i might end up being like paying more for it right so to the extent that i want to share the costs of things with you it's to my uh it would behoove me to make sure that like we're spending the money on things that like generally benefit everybody um and if there's any imbalance uh even perceived imbalance uh then the people have the opportunity, you know, to rage quit and make that known.
And that disincentive, you know, provides a feedback mechanism for the group. Maybe the group just doubles down, because now there's less, you know, outside like, like, conflict within the group. But also, that's a good outcome for the group. For the remaining members, it's like, we can actually build alignment over time by shedding some of the members who might be less aligned as we go. And so I think it's actually a good system for both the individual goals and the goals of the group. the world, but crypto killer apps need ZK Sync as a platform to build on first. It's generally accepted that zero knowledge roll-ups are the conclusion of crypto blockchain scaling technology, and ZK Sync is leading the charge into the final frontier of crypto economics.
So if you're a developer who wants to build your app on a future-proof foundation, which gives your users the best UX possible, check out ZK Sync's website at zksync.io. And yes, there's also going to be a token, so give them a follow on Twitter too, at ZK Sync. extra 15% staking commission on the pooled ETH that uses your node to stake. You also get RPL token rewards on top. So if you're bullish e-staking, you can boost your yield by adding your node to the decentralized RocketPool network, which currently has over 1,000 independent node operators. It's yield farming, but with Ethereum nodes.
You can get started at RocketPool.net, and you can also join the RocketPool community in their Discord. You can find me hanging out there sometimes in the chat, so I'll see you there. Lens Protocol is an open-source tech stack for building decentralized social media applications. It is the new era for social media. We all have toxic relationships with our Web2 apps. We want to break up with them, but we can't. These applications own our digital lives and all the relationships that we've made. We need to break through to a new paradigm of social networking applications that we control rather than them controlling us.
Lens isn't a social media app. It's a protocol to let 1,000 Web3 social apps bloom. Lens is a permissionless and transparent social graph that is owned by the user. In crypto, we say, not your keys, not your crypto. And on Lens, we say, not your keys, not your profile. With Lens, your followers go with you to whatever social media application you want to use. And instead of being trapped by an algorithm chosen by that app, Lens lets you choose the way you want to experience your social media. Lens is the last social media handle that you'll ever need to create. So in order to get started, there is a secret code word in the show notes.
Enter that code word in the Google form linked and you'll be well on your way to entering the world of web-free social. And we can like do a quick compare and contrast of like other social systems, right? Where like, say, say there's a Dow, maybe, maybe let's like take the constitution Dow, just because that's kind of the big one that everyone knows about. That's the most modern and say like the constitution Dow leadership voted to pay themselves half the money in the treasury. And that's like eight of them. And say this vote actually goes through, well, then there's the rage quit mechanism that all these people can rage quit before they, they, they're half their money gets paid to the leadership, right?
Which makes this vote not even like feasible in the first place to ever do. But like, we can compare this with like, I don't know, maybe a nation state where the leadership of a nation state, since they're the ones that control the military, they can just say, hey, all gold is now illegal, you must pay it to us and we now own all the gold. It's harder for these individuals to exit because like, you know, it's one thing to exit from a DAO by processing a transaction on Ethereum to get your money back. But it's another thing to like process the exit from a nation state where you have your home and your family and your life and your culture.
And so like this thing is. And they just took your gold. And then, yeah, right. And so like, I mean, we're doing an apples to oranges comparison here. But like this is the difference between what is a systems that are free to exit and systems that have a high cost to exit. It's like high cost to exit systems allow for opportunity to like bully you around. That's right. Yeah. The first question, you know, people ask is like when you try to get them into this type of thing, it's like, how do I leave? And, you know, the concern is like I don't want to be bullied by the other members. Like I don't want my funds to go to stuff that I don't want.
So I either have to trust the other members or, you know, trust that I can leave, trust the mechanism. And like when you can trust the mechanism, you know, it's a lot easier to spin these things up and start making grants and see, you know, see how they go without as much overhead, without as much risk, without as much opportunity for coercion. There's a line that I go back and forth with Kevin Owocki, and I believe also you, is that like you don't actually kill Moloch. You don't actually like magically solve all coordination failure. but you can make that make moloch retreat right can you help us draw this connection between like all right well we didn't exactly you know by you know the state of dows in 2022 it's not like we've really solved coordination failure we kind of just made a bunch of ponzi's now we're in the bear market but uh oops but but also like uh we have created a new system where moloch retreats right can you just explain like going where where we have like this new coordination platform which is Ethereum.
Now we have this new coordination primitive, which is DAOs. How is Moloch less deadly as a result of this? I think the cool thing, maybe this is like a frustrating thing, but I started saying this more recently is that like, I think it captures this concept fairly well uh slaying moloch is an infinite game uh and like what that means to me is that like you know uh looming behind the rotting corpse of the most recently slain moloch is like a shadowier deadlier moloch you know waiting to strike right moloch level two moloch level three and and so it's like this endless series of boss fights you know uh and like we can just keep going and see what happens.
And it's still worth playing this game because it still seems worth advancing coordination because I think that's what it means to be human. What the hell else are we going to do? Yeah. The opposite of that is just winning some intermittent zero-sum game. so so yeah i mean we did all this dow stuff uh now we have to sort of like the way i see it now is like we have we have dow veterans now right so like last year it was like freshman year activity fair activity expo you know you show up to college there's booths everywhere you want to be in every club you sign up for 10 you you know you make it to the end of the semester and like you're lucky if you're still showing up to like three or four, you know, maybe, maybe less.
And then this year is like sophomore year, right? Everybody's like, okay, we know how last year went. We will sign up for a couple of clubs and we will, you know, stick with them and we will like, you know, make sure it's useful and not like too much to handle and blah, blah, blah. And by junior year, you're like leading clubs, you know, you're, you're, you have like a leadership position. And I see everybody going through the same sort of progression that we did, which is like we start out, we have no idea what we're doing. We hope we're doing useful stuff. And then like after a while, we like figure it out.
It's like, oh, like, you know, flat organizations are kind of hard or like, oh, like this isn't just like a corporation on a blockchain. Like, you know, people who come from both sort of sides are having, you know, sort of trouble and like are learning to like build structures within the context of dao's and like figure out what processes work how to do compensation right and so there's like cultural knowledge being built up in you know a thousand different groups at the same time about how to do all of this stuff and that is what is going to anchor the next generation of dao contributors and people right so like in the same way that everybody who more or less joined MolochDAO like went on to start some kind of DAO, right?
Peter started a bunch of DAOs. Cooper started a bunch of DAOs. Ryan, you know, started Bankless. He was in MolochDAO, you know. So a lot of the people who have now come into DAOs as contributors, as tourists, get to learn and figure out what's going on that, oh, you know, it's not all just like these DAO guys haven't figured everything out, right? Like we haven't just solved coordination, but we have like discovered, you know, useful tools at coordinating better. And like, you know, you can look at the amount of money raised or the, you know, number of these groups that have formed and like the excitement around them all as indicators that like we're making progress uh we're doing something right and like the things that will you know interest me more is like next generation right so like uh right now we have like plutocracy you know plutocracy like for basically everything like token vote um italic writes about this you know in collusion resistance that we need more you know identifiable systems so that we can vote with people uh have some amount of democracy in addition to having all the you know plutocracy that we have um like nobody has really done that well like optimism is trying they have their like two-tiered you know governance system that's pretty cool to see uh i think we'll see more structures form uh some might even be like more centralized and like have explicit like ceo type or like hegemon type uh and and i think that like if you zoom out like all the things that we're building dows for right now are like toys and prototypes uh like the cool things is like when you know when is the united nation on chain right uh it's like that's like our sort of like terminal you know like when are when are like international agreements on chain like i started reading for fun about the ancient daos uh like the greek city-state agreements uh that that they made the peloponnesian league and the like delian league these are the athenian and spartan-led daos uh that they used to coordinate ancient greece and they have like interesting policies like spart sparta ran theirs differently than how athens ran theirs like sparta is like we're the we're gonna have a deal with every city-state and like you sign a deal with us we might not even like really tell anybody else the terms but like uh you agree to have the same enemies and allies that we do is the sort of foundation of all all of these um and then the athenian version uh there's a little bit more uh democratic they have like a council you know within athens that they like vote on proposals for and then like if those proposals pass they like go to like the the greater council with all the other city states uh and then you know they try to pass them there and like athens would often abstain and like it's interesting things about how how they manage them.
And I think that's like where this is going, right? Like we don't, like maybe we aren't paying attention to it as much. But like if it's not going there, like I'll be really surprised because this stuff is so useful that it will naturally find a home in like the most high stakes, you know, environments eventually. Once we've built these narratives and once we've done this infrastructure work and all that. And really what you're talking about is like Ethereum as like this neutral middle ground between nation states or between like the largest coordinating entities in the world. Is that the image that should be in listeners' heads?
Yeah. Global settlement layer, coordination platform for humanity, you know, these kinds of things. Like when we say that, you know, we kind of mean, yeah, it'll like also settle your crypto punks, you know, and like that stuff. But like, like the goal, you know, like why do we care about censorship resistant? Right. It's like, why do we care about neutrality? Like the reason we care about these things is because we're trying to build a system that doesn't give specific advantages to one nation state or, you know, religious group or whatever. right um and it it you know just sort of runs on math and does math things and like uh can operate you know virtual machine and settle contracts but like doesn't care too much about contents of those contracts and so forth right um and that's sort of what you need to allow for like i i don't know if i talked about this with you but like maybe we like when i watch vikings And like the ancient game theory between kings is like they just have these hostage trades with their children, right?
It's like, you know, ancient like coordination in that era was like I will make you, you know, the way to make our behavior more mutually predictable to each other is to deposit our children into a two of two multisig such that we both need to work together to unlock the children. And if we fail, they die. it's like what like everyone just went along with that because that was like the best system that had ever existed to that point it's like savage right but it worked and it's like you're just talking about like all right like you've got a daughter i've got a son we're gonna put them in the same room they're gonna have babies and we're gonna stop hating each other is that what that's what you're I'm talking about like I give you my son to raise and like you give me your daughter to raise.
But like a lot of times they did also do like marriage contracts was like down the road. And it was like we'll raise your daughter for a time. You raise – or they'll both be in our place for three years and your place for three – and then it doesn't serve as much for the two of you. Just a brute force coordination with each other. Yes. And like if you could coordinate better, like you might survive better because like you would out-coordinate the other guys who like couldn't put their sons in a multi-sig and therefore had a smaller army. Right? It like sounds dumb to say like that. But like that's like how things worked, right?
And that was like – people were like, yeah, right, like whatever. And like if you didn't put your kids in a multisig, you're like, bro, this alliance is suspect. Our kids are not in multisigs together. There's nothing aligned here. Yeah, basically. And so like the question for things like Ethereum is like can we do this without being savages? Like can we put ETH into a 2-2 multisig? But can we make ETH neutral enough, you know, that like people trust it? enough to work as this like you know bearer bond like neutrally enforced by like the system based on some you know contract so like in the future maybe peace treaties uh or alliances or non-aggression pacts uh would be seen as suspect if they don't have an on-chain bond in a neutral currency right right right and so like my head has gone to like sweet we are definitely beyond the barbaric era of like using children as collateral so like we're now in democracies but actually we have like nuclear missiles pointed at every single corner of the globe and like people forget about that when they just are going about their like day-to-day basis but like you know using children as collateral definitely barbaric but if that's barbaric and we're using that as like a facetious example of like how to force coordination upon warring tribes what the hell is this like push button nuclear Armageddon that we have?
Like, how is that not just barbarism to the nth degree? And that's because like this physical nation state world is based on like physical rules of who's more powerful than the neighbors. And you already gave the example of just like, you know, we can't really just globally demilitarize because that just leaves the most brutal military as the one that's left standing. But that's because that's the physical world, right? Like in Ethereum and And Bitcoin, there is no stick. There are only carrots to incentivize coordination. Because Bitcoin incentivizes coordination by paying you Bitcoins to mine it, right?
Ethereum incentivizes security by locking up your Ether. And then it will punish you if you try and attack the blockchain. And then DAOs, as we've said, DAOs are like, so long as there's a rage quit mechanism built into them. And that's kind of like table stakes for DAOs that like there's no stick in the system. There's only opt-in incentives. And so like I don't know how we get all global like tribes to coordinate with Ethereum. But whatever it is, it has to be by definition like an opt-in carrot-based system that doesn't – because they don't have sticks. Ethereum doesn't give you a stick because it's stuck inside of the internet.
Yeah, at the protocol level, Ethereum doesn't have sticks. it only gives out carrots you can think of like a stick as like slashing but like that's a you know you can opt out of that you don't have to stake yeah you opt into the slashing you don't have to opt out of the slashing if there was like a war treasury as part of the protocol fund you know then maybe Ethereum could have a stick the United States started without a stick too in some sense because it started not collecting taxes like at the federal level. It didn't have a federal tax. It only added that later on. I don't think it's likely that Ethereum adds protocol, you know, level funding.
I think it's even less likely that if we have it, it goes towards funding sticks. But yeah, that's what you would need to do. So yeah, it doesn't seem likely. Right. The U.S. dollar is a protocol with a stick, a really big stick. It doesn't even really speak softly anymore. Right. Yeah, we like to blow up. The whole dollar demand, propping it up, petrodollar thing is kind of weird. I went on a bunch of rants about this after the tornado stuff because I was angry and people were like talking about how tornado was like the bad guys and how like you know crimes are bad and it's like I agree that crimes are bad there's just like nuance there because like a lot of things that were crimes like aren't crimes anymore or we like look back at them and we're like really ashamed of them being crimes and you know we like don't do the thing where we like reward the entrepreneurs uh for their like taking on the risk of like breaking those crimes uh or laws or whatever and in order to like normalize and make progress for the rest of it like i order marijuana in a store i pay taxes it's fda approved to make sure it's like very high concentration and there's like people still in jail for you know having small amounts of it like years ago uh a lot of times in the dollar bubble we're like we're the good guys uh because like we you know we're america but like we also do questionable things to uh enforce dollar demand like blow up iraq to enforce the petrodollar you know steal everybody's gold stop you know doing dollar redemptions and then i'm getting the chronology a little bit out of border here but it's just it's a long list so yeah it's a long list and it's it's not just the u.
s it's like every country sort of does this thing uh so this is this is maybe a segue into rye uh like my other project rise a fork of maker dow you know trying to um try to see if we can make stable coins without explicit pegs to the dollar uh and so it is pegged to like a dollar denominated number but it it's allowed to float uh and rye has been great so far because of what it's been able to teach us uh where like you know what we're doing on ethereum like we we want to like we we want to believe that like the systems that we're building are like improvements over the status quo right um bitcoin gets to say that like because of 21 million you know they're transparent and you know it's not uh inflationary uh you know and the inflation doesn't like benefit a specific cartel right ethereum gets to make similar statements not quite as hard on the currency uh side but like you know we we take some liberties because we we uh have the utility of the uh smart contract platform and so we optimize for making that as useful as possible um but we haven't like you know like solved money uh and money is like the scam that like every country runs on its citizens uh and we have like the privilege in the united states of like not having it be as bad as most countries uh where the inflation is like pretty bad uh and like often you know increases unexpectedly uh and like we don't you can't like ask central bankers how to operate a central bank like right now uh because the way that they do it is so like bastardized from like how it in theory should be done uh because they just have to like manage their like most of them didn't come up with the scheme that they're just like inherited some ponzi that they're trying to keep alive for as long as possible uh and that's like what they're judged you know on their job uh and and so like with ethereum uh with with things like die the original idea that's such an awesomely like reductive way of explaining what the fed does is just like profit the ponzi and good good feds promote the longevity of the ponzi yeah yeah um i'll come back to that point but uh yeah we we haven't like we haven't like gotten past the dollar right like we have our usdc we're like yeah we're defi you know we had our die it was backed by ETH at first.
We're like, yeah, you know, we've decentralized finance, but like, it's still mostly dollars, right? And so we want to look at it and we want to be like, well, how do we get away from dollars? And there's a couple of ways, right? There's one, which is like, well, back it with something else, right? You can, you can have a dollar denominated instrument, but that doesn't come with, you know, the, like the USDC block lists, for example, if like you use DAI or something, you know, or even like FRAX. But with DAI, it was like, originally it was like, well, let's back it by Ether. And then, you know, the collateral can't be frozen.
But then they back it with USDC and then you're like, okay, well, shit. Now what? And so that's why with Rai, it's backed only with ETH. But it's still like dollar denominated, you know. So it's still somewhat subject to the esoteric policies of the, you know, Federal Reserve. It just like can float, you know, around it. You mean it's dollar denominated in the sense that if I ask you the price of rye, it will – Yeah, it's a dollar. And the interest rate is expressed in dollar terms. Right, right, right. Yeah, yeah. So – and then it started at 3.14. It's floated down. I think it's like 2.85 now.
and so it has a negative interest rate fairly consistently since the crash to incentivize people to deposit ETH to help RIB holders or borrowers get out if they need to. That's what the elevated RIB signal on the market tells the system to do automatically. We don't have to have meetings about this. We just let the controller run, sets the rates automatically. So this kind of thing is nice because what RIB is, it's like sort of a central bank in a box, you know, and Like you can like operate your little thing on the blockchain, your toy, first principles developed, you know, central bank thing.
And then you can use it and then look at theirs and be like, how the fuck did you get there? Like what series of, you know, like what monstrosity have you wrought? Like you guys, like if you try to explain, you know, how you get to the Fed and like MakerDAO, you know, like starting from something like MakerDAO, you're like, okay, so first you have to rug pull the collateral. right uh you you really you know nixon wants to drop bombs on vietnam uh you told everybody that the dollars were pegged to gold including all the foreign countries that you promised that you would redeem uh so we'd lie to everybody uh we really want to bomb vietnam so we print a bunch of dollars bomb vietnam but now there's more dollars same amount of gold you know uh france comes calling with their battleship maybe it's someone else but uh they're like hello fort yeah fort knox like Give us the gold.
And then Nixon's like, public announcement. In order to defend the integrity of the U.S. dollar, we are ending redemptions. Right? He did that because he heard that Charles de Gaulle III or somebody sent the battleship to go get the gold. And so the battleship was on the way to go get the gold. And Nixon was like, I'm closing the window. So you guys didn't make it in time. Sorry. We're closed. We're closed for business. Yeah. Right. And then basically everybody scrambled. People started selling their dollars and then the US came up with the petrodollar scheme. And so this was like the – let's like pump the Ponzi on the demand side.
Let's find our like pool two. And so their pool two was in Saudi Arabia. and they made deals with the Saudis and the other oil-producing nations to sell them – sell oil exclusively for dollars and they give discounts to allow the Saudis to reinvest in bonds and stocks and whatever and they get military bases and F-15s and so forth. And so we did this to prop up the dollar in the face of – And so then it's like the reason I bring all of this up is because like you need all this context in order to have a moral conversation about the dollar. Because without all that, it's just like dollar good, you know, alternatives to dollar bad.
You know, and it's just like, oh, my God. Like, let's go down the list. And like, you know, like the reason I like to bring this up with Americans is because there's sort of like two places that you get to. You know, when you start thinking this through, you're like, okay, either we're like full real politic, like, fuck yeah, America, you know, World War I, World War II, back-to-back champs, right? Like, dollar Ponzi forever, right? Like, it's the best Ponzi ever. Like, we're winning, right? Like, that's the mentality, you know, like imperialism, we're the best at it, right? versus the other, which is like acknowledging the dollar as like a cost and you're like moral balance sheet because you have to like occasionally go blow up a rock because Saddam is selling oil for euros and we don't like that and we want to set an example.
And like maybe like the US empire is like a good thing, good thing like generally for the world. Like in terms of our ability to combat China, our ability to thwart Russia, like if the U.S. wasn't as powerful, Ukraine would have a much harder time, possibly also be Russia right now. Right. And so like it's a good thing that the U.S. has the strength to fight off these like, you know, despotic invaders and authoritarian communists and, you know, these types of things. and but like then at least you've put the like dollar ponzi thing into like a moral you're like the cost of doing this is like we have to do this stuff in order to be able to and then at least that's like a more reasonable conversation you can have out of that because then you can be like well what happens when the US stops being like a good policeman internationally or something like maybe this isn't you know able to be propped up um uh like you know it's not morally uh worth it uh or something um but you're but you're what you're saying is that at least you are having to consider the worth of it as in at least we are not just dumbly saying dollar good we are actually doing a cost benefit analysis on this thing yeah and like there's other things you know around this too where it's like the dollar being strong in the sense that like post 1970s petrodollar dollar as the world reserve currency uh hollowed out a lot of american manufacturing and like middle class jobs and shipped them over overseas because uh you know that's uh like the currency valuations were more favorable for that and so like the u.
s became a net exporter of dollars and so the entire financier class made a killing uh and everybody else the manufacturing class took the l and i actually remember explicitly asking lynn alden if the triffin dilemma what we're talking about here the the fact that the dollar is the global reserve currency was that the main main source main reason why donald trump got elected and she was like yes i do believe that that's why that happened because donald trump ran on that platform of manufacturing in pennsylvania like all the all these high manufacturing uh states that flipped red and elected donald trump they lost all their manufacturing jobs because we just started exporting dollars for free because we were printing them and then you know the it's like that that domino meme you know down the line because of because we have to export our dollars because of the petrodollar like we lose all of our internal manufacturing jobs and then we elect donald trump because we're aggrieved yes 100% yeah these are like the things that are like downstream of the like you know currency like scams and you know the discontents of the currency manipulation like the decision that the US made as an empire was like we're going to switch to being like a financial thing you know we're going to just export dollars and play with money and then it becomes really important to prop up demand for the dollar, right?
Right. And, like, the only real collateral we have because there's so much dollars is dollar denominated debt, which is real bad. Yeah. Right, right. There's a story that I like to tell. And this is about Thomas Jefferson and slavery. And, like, the reason I tell this story is because, like, when we think about this, we, Like we think about this as like a problem that like, you know, it's almost intractable. Right. Like like you couldn't go protest this. Right. Like like, OK, a lot of times when I talk to people, they seem to think that like working inside the system is like the best option for making change.
Right. And that like almost every problem you can like, you know, solve eventually by working inside the system. And I like to bring up like the American South and slavery and civil war. Thomas Jefferson, the guy who, you know, wrote like all men are created equal. He also came up with this like really fascinating financial instrument, slave collateralized debt. He basically made maker doubt for your slaves. so he rolled up to a bank and was like yo i've got all these slaves i need money can i use the slaves as collateral and get cash and the bank was like huh interesting idea we're down and like fast forward 50 60 years the entire south was like using huge amounts of loans uh like backed by slave collateral.
And so like this was basically a slave Ponzi that went out of control. Like they were yield farming, like literally yield farming, right? And that you'd like leverage up, right? Oh, I got some money. Let me buy more slaves. Let me get more debt. Use the yield of the slaves to get more money, to get more slaves, to put more slaves as collateral and cycle it back up. The slave population of West Virginia, I think, was like 60 percent. And maybe it was like South Carolina was 60 percent and like Virginia was like 40 percent. So the slave populations had grown a lot. And like every founding father, like the banks were trading these contracts, like fast forward 50, 60 years as if they're like mortgage backed securities today.
Like they bundled, you know, like, you know, and so it's basically this like bank enforced Ponzi at that point. right because it's not like the banks are going to let you off the hook right the banks aren't just going to allow you to jubilee right so this is one of those cases where it's like even if the political will existed even if the moral will existed within that context within the south it didn't matter because the economic reality was that you couldn't get everybody to pay back their debt at the same time in order to like release their slaves and and not only that they were like terrified of their slaves like because of how you know poorly they'd been treating them they're like this is why they made the clan and stuff after is to continue terrorizing them uh you know as like a first strike um but uh every founding father died uh knowing that this war the civil war was inevitable uh because there is no way within the system uh to get out of that slaved at Ponzi, right?
Uh, if you're a person in the South and you're like, Hey guys, I think this is a bad idea. We should stop doing this. You don't get very far. Uh, everybody sort of has to be opposed to you. Uh, even if they don't like, even if they agree with you, uh, like, you know they they they can't uh help you uh like like malik has gone too far right right and so like the only the only path out is a is a financial crisis the only path out is a financial crisis where the collateral the slaves are liberated at gunpoint you know uh like that's the only way out of that system like it's it you know it it can't stop itself right and and so like the mental model like is you know that comes out of that is like sometimes wars have to be fought to end ponzi's right you know oh shit i think i think i see where this is going you might see where this is going because then it's like, huh, do we as Americans have the political and moral will to end the dollar Ponzi within the United States?
Because if we don't, then like we should expect that people will try to end it for us. And that's going to look like war. And we probably deserve that war, you know, because it's not like we were going to do it ourselves. Right. That's like an awkward conclusion to come to uh as a good guy okay so what is this metaphor here so like there's a ton of debt out there and we have been printing dollars to pay for like you know cheap chinese goods and paying for cheap philip you know philippine labor like who are the who are the who are the like the if we've been printing this dollar and like who are the who are the people that really want this system to end.
So everybody that isn't the United States that has to use the dollars doesn't benefit from their own seniorage as much as they could, right? To the extent that we go blow up a rock or something, we sort of like... To the extent that the dollar is a dominant reserve currency, we have exorbitant privilege with our seniorage, our printing has a much larger market to absorb our printing. And so we're sort of taking that value from every other country that would otherwise be benefiting from their own seniorage in an increased capacity. But of course, it's more about the strategic rivals, like Russia and China want to, they're promoting transacting using the Renminbi and the Russian currencies.
So, yeah. Like, people also say, like, there's no alternative. Like, what else would you do, right? And I think that's, like, the thing that you else would, like, the other thing you would do is, like, not invade Iraq to prop up the dollar. You know, like, you would just allow the dollar to, like, not. Yeah, it would just be okay with some probably serious loss in purchasing power, which would look like high inflation for a while. But at the end of it, a fair system has America extracting as much value from the global market as it has actually earned with its contribution to the market. not like over and above its contribution to the market because it's extracting a rent for basically the rest of the world using dollars as the currency and the American financial system.
So allowing the dollar to inflate if we hadn't invaded Iraq sounds like, okay, we'll throw up the flag and just we won't let this Ponzi perpetuate. But instead we chose the path where we kick the can down the road because we want the Ponzi to perpetuate as long as possible. So this is the thing that's weird, right? It's like why did we invade Iraq? Like this is what we were saying about voting and coercion and like democracy and it's like I didn't vote to invade Iraq. Everybody who was in favor of invading Iraq lied about it. They said there were weapons of mass destruction. They printed it in the New York Times.
We believed it. They said – like I remember I was 10. I listen to this on the news every day, weapons of mass destruction for years and years and nothing happened, right? So, like, who – it's like maybe, right, the Russian people didn't vote to invade Ukraine. Putin decided to, you know, invade Ukraine. Maybe the American people didn't vote to invade Iraq. But like the pattern of maintaining the dollar dominance, you know, as managed by the Federal Reserve is why we invaded Iraq. How is that different than me as a U.S. citizen being controlled by the Federal Reserve dictatorship? You know, if like if that is the pattern of war in this country, then like, you know, like like it's not like, you know, somebody actually threatened America.
Like that was all lies. It was like they threatened the dollar Ponzi. And so we blew them up. Right. Right. Right. So like that makes me feel like I'm living in a Fed dictatorship. Right. And then this has been the question I've been waiting, kind of like circling around, like the Jerry Brito, unrelated to all this conversation, Jerry Brito, when I talked to him about like the tornado cash thing, which was one department out of the global, the larger United States government, one department, the Treasury, banned tornado cash. like it had nothing to do with the fda it had nothing to do with like congress it was just like one part of this broader machine and so he said he said the united states is not a monolith it was just this one and part of this broader system that did this one thing but then if you like zoom all the way out and kind of get a little bit more you know uh satellite view of like the whole entire incentive structure of the broader american system yes the u.
s government is not a monolith. It is a modular set of interwoven agencies and representatives. But at an incentive level, you can talk about the nation state, both the United States nation state, other nation states as a holistic system. And it works out like most of the time, as in, if you assume agency by a nation state, you can kind of predict what it's going to do as a whole. And that is weird to me that you can do that, but it works pretty damn well a lot of the time. One of my favorite models for this is like some – so like democratic processes I model by being like, oh, they react too late and then they overreact.
So like if that's like all you knew about the United States, you could like model our COVID response pretty well. You know, we're just going to pretend like it's not a problem and then we're going to shut everything down. right? It's like, you can often do that. And that's like typically our control system as like humans. Like when we think of like, Oh, Malik, you know, we like global warming, right? We're going to ignore it. Sick. And then we're going to overreact. And then it's going to be like austerity measures for everyone. Right. So it's like, it's pretty common. Like this, like, so like you, you can model things using like, just get like, what kind of control system is this?
Like, what is, what is the feedback, you know, response to, uh, things that come up and like, yeah, that helps you predict it. So holistically like tribes, organizations, governments, they're not a monolith, they're independent parts, but they kind of have like agency, right like there's the uh who wrote who wrote um the leviathan thomas hobbes leviathan where like it's actually like all the interdependent parts are part of this like larger creature and it's like the united states has agency because it has its own wants and desires and like desire to live and it's really the dollar that i think is like one of the main things that needs to have value because as soon as the dollar goes to zero the united states falls apart and so it's like the dollar that's keeping things together.
So it's like the dollar has its own like demand to live, desire to live, and it creates this incentive structure out of that demand. Um, so how, how does that, how does that relate to the, the democracy ignores it and then, um, and then overreacts? How does that, how do those things relate? Um, sure. So like, let me, let me try to apply that theory right it's like um maybe like we don't see the like egregiousness of the u.s dollar uh right now like as citizens within the country so we ignore it right um in the same way that like it takes a while for us to like decide that slavery is worth fighting a war over right it has to like grow big enough and oppressive enough um and so like maybe one day you know uh we realize that like the way we're managing the dollar is like not great um also uh i just want to like pull apart a couple things right not liking the dollar and like not liking america are somewhat different um like you could be a dollar ponzi minimalist right and be like we should not be you know have this reserve currency that we like try to prop up demand for artificially and like still like America and like be a U.
S. citizen and like be a patriot even. In fact, I think it's patriotic to want a future for the U.S. that is separate from the dollar ponzi that we're fighting wars to maintain. I think a better use of America's people, you know, armed for like it's like not throwing them to help prop up the dollar ponzi. But what do I know? Right. But like, you know, in the future, it could be that we like overreact. Right. And then we are like, no country can operate the reserve currency. You know, we like we go all in on neutral reserve currencies or something. And like we start propping up Bitcoin or Ethereum as like collateral.
That's like one. or it's like the you know we ignore BTC and ETH for so long and then we overreact by like banning them completely right they're both like outcomes that I think are you know possible for the government the idea is to try and come up with systems that anticipate you know problems and like can work to overcome them The problem is that it's hard to get people to coordinate around doing that when it's like not immediately apparent that that's a problem, right? So the hope for things like Ethereum is that they can actually solve these global coordination problems. Like why are we fighting over – like the world is on fire, you know, like we have a global climate crisis, right?
Like things are only going to get more scarce. Supply chains are only going to break down on their own. Like we could spend our, you know, effort to try to solve some of these problems, you know, put our heads together, figure out how to clean water, clean air, you know, restore things. But instead, we're like fighting over Ukraine, right? it's like uh maybe one day there's like a you know radicalist environmentalist league or something uh and they like have their own uh you know proposals to like boycott things or like protest things or you know there's a bunch of people like sitting in the forest in germany and they like wouldn't get down from the trees so like they couldn't cut them down uh that was pretty cool You know, like things like that or get, you know, throwing wrenches in the way of people destroying the environment.
Although that's not great either, because now, you know, we're like everybody's dependent on Russian gas. And the reality is that like that's, you know, fueling the war in Ukraine now. It's like so even sometimes when you try to get away from these things, they still come back. and so to to tie a bow on this conversation how does ethereum fix all this uh ethereum fixes all this by inspiring people to try and think about how ethereum fixes all this and step one obviously uh motivational equilibrium uh but but i i mean that like half jokingly and i like i actually mean that uh seriously too like there is now like things like vita dao uh that's doing like longevity research on the blockchain where they have like nfts as like ip and you can invest in that and help fund you know longevity things that you want um like okay it's gonna sound this is gonna sound weird um so like every empire is basically a join or die Ponzi.
Like one of the funny contracts that like Athens, you know, as part of the Delian League made, I think it was Isle of Lesbos. And this is pretty funny. Maybe it was another one. But like, like the reason Lesbos, like lesbian, it's like they basically like showed up to this island and were like, you guys can join the league or we'll kill you all. And they were like, we will not join the league. And they were like, fuck it. you know, we're going to climb the walls, kill all the men, sell everybody to slavery and like sell the women to slavery. And like Lesbos has no more men. That's why it's Lesbos.
But like, you know. What happens when somebody puts a join or die Ponzi on chain? like what if the join or die ponzi on chain is like more efficient than uh the way empires work like the the thing that citizenship sells you uh like like in the in the maslow's hierarchy of needs of citizenship the base level is deterrence right like i agree to be a citizen of the united states because like if i go somewhere and somebody hurts me like that you know they'll maybe get hurt worse. Right. Like it means something to me. I feel safe and protected, you know, domestically and abroad. Right. And so like your your main like service, your main offer as a nation state is deterrence.
So like when I think of Coca-Cola, you know, I see like sugar water. When I think of a nation state, I think of like an assassination guild with a public goods department. Right. You're like – like imagine trying to operate a nation state without an assassination guild. You know? Like you're going to have a really hard time doing any deterrence. You mean a monopoly on violence? That's another way of describing it. That's how we've described it on Bankless before. Yeah, monopoly on violence. Yeah, yeah. So, yeah, it's like – it's just like one of those things. Like if like I could see, you know, citizenship being disrupted, for example, if somebody can offer deterrence as a service more cheaply.
Right. If I join some thing and like now I know that, you know, I'm protected in this way, like, yeah, I'll maybe pay for it a little extra or something. But, you know, like that's the number one reason. And it's like maybe you don't need to operate this like massive expensive infrastructure in order to like operate a, you know, deterrent in 2022. Like maybe it's a lot cheaper. Now, I don't think we're going to see any of that anytime soon. I don't think we're going to see like join or die Ponzi's where people are like, you know, you have this option. But like I'm kind of afraid of it. Because like the, you know, like when we talk about beating Malik, we talk about like these coordination systems.
Like what if we unleash, you know, an even better coordination system, right? Something like, you know, religion, which I'm like sort of diametrically opposed to given my upbringing. You know, sort of had Islamic fundamentals father, fought a lot. But it's like religion is like what you get when you solve Malik for your system, right? Like I want the males to not infight over the women. And so we're going to make a bunch of rules to like manage our conflict internally. And now like we're a really, you know, like highly coordinated and like more trusting society. And that gives us the opportunity to like go take everyone else over and impose our, you know, God Ponzi on them and like the way we do things on them.
and so it's like you know from the inside looking in you're like oh man how do i solve this problem of like these monkeys just like fighting over you know breeding rights and like resources and yeah yeah and like fucking killing each other over this shit like the fucking animals you know and then uh and then you make some like crazy rule book and you kill everybody who doesn't uh enforce it and then you end up with this like god ponzi that lasts 2 000 years and so I think I think maybe there's like positive Ponzi's that like we should be optimistic for that it's like you know join and thrive or something like live and let live Ponzi right and like that's that's what we should be trying to help promote is like I agree to – like I don't know.
Like I agree to not pay taxes would be funny like as a commitment device. I'm not advocating for that. I think paying taxes is important. I just think like if you end up at the point that you're like, okay, the government is just blowing shit up and like not saving the world. Like we need to be saving the world, government. Like I'm now boycotting – like being able – able to coordinate you know activism boycotts uh movements um to to try and make our systems more accurately reflect our values instead of like our systems just being ponzi's that sustain themselves indefinitely even when they are opposed to our values is like uh the idea maybe more things need a rage quit you know it's like every system it like starts out useful and it like ends up scam everything it's like exists on a spectrum of like useful and scam right and like the beginning of its life it's like useful the end of its life scam that's why that we need that you know the destructive creativity uh to burn down some of these like scams that have outlived their usefulness in 2022 uh well i mean i hope uh i hope people's uh imaginations have been expanded to uh what it is we're actually doing here, why things are Ponzi's all the way down, and how it's also just coordination.
So thank you for telling me, helping me tell this very creative story. Thanks for having me. We always come up with something new when we do this. It's always fun talking to you, David. Appreciate your contributions to the space and helping educate everybody and raising the army to slay Moloch. Well, as the lead general of that army, I've been following you for a while and I'll continue to follow you into this very weird world that eventually people always seem to catch up to you on. I've been inspired by how much I've been able to learn from the people that I helped inspire. So it's two ways to me.
Thanks, David. Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did head over to Bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a Bankless Premium subscriber to get the most out of your Bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless Premium subscriber today.
Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings, and weekly roll-ups where we summarize The Week in Crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the Bankless Nation.