What is Ethereum’s North Star, and does it even need one?
There has been angst in the Ethereum community, growing over the last year, as Ethereum has become squeezed by its competition. Bitcoin’s story as money is growing in mainstream society. Solana has captured the hot ball of money in crypto. And Celestia’s data availability continues to progress at a faster rate than what is found at home in Ethereum.
This is Ethereum’s Three-Front War, a topic we covered in a recent episode with Justin Drake. And today we‘re joined by Jon Charbonneau and Mike Ippolito to contextualize and diagnose what Ethereum needs in order to thrive in this competitive landscape.
------ 📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦄UNISWAP | BUG BOUNTY PROGRAM https://bankless.cc/Uniswap-Bug-Bounty
🐧 CARTESI | LINUX-POWERED ROLLUPS https://bankless.cc/CartesiSimple
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle 📈 iYield: YOUR FINANCIAL PICTURE, SIMPLIFIED https://bankless.cc/iYield
🔒 SAFE | INTRODUCING SAFENET https://bankless.cc/SAFE
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/109?referrer=0x077Fe9e96Aa9b20Bd36F1C6290f54F8717C5674E
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 6:00 Jon’s Article 16:48 How did we get here? 23:16 Ethereum’s Three Front War 43:14 Ethereum Wins by its Synergies 52:52 Ethereum’s Focus 1:01:58 Ethereum Tactical Advice 1:18:18 Ultra Sound Money vs World Computer 1:30:26 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Mike Ippolito https://x.com/mikeippolito
Jon Charbonneau https://x.com/jon_charb
Jon’s Article https://dba.xyz/ethereums-north-star/
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
There's just this massive hump that people are not going to be able to get over that they like things that cash flow, they can model, etc. So growth, they like growth growth. So the description of the world computer of Ethereum and this network, this economy of different applications that look like businesses. You got a lot of people there very quickly. And I think maybe this would be a controversial thing to say, but I think Ethereum has a better shot at money on a long term time horizon than something like Bitcoin does. Welcome to Bankless where we explore the future of Ethereum and ask the question, what is Ethereum's North Star and does it even need one?
There has been some angst in the Ethereum community growing over the last year as Ethereum has become squeezed by its competition. Bitcoin's story as money is growing in mainstream society while ETH story as a financial asset has not experienced that same level of success. Meanwhile, deeper in the crypto trenches, Solana has captured the hot ball of money of crypto attracting the marginal new user and new capital into its ecosystem. And over in the distance, Celeste's data availability continues to progress at a faster rate than what is found on the Ethereum layer one. This is Ethereum's three front war and we covered this in a topic on a recent episode with Justin Drake.
But this three front war is a technical war and armies are led by generals, projects have leaders who make both strategic and tactical decisions in pursuit of a goal. What is Ethereum's goal? What is Ethereum designed to do? What are the core devs building? Ethereum has been at peacetime for its entire life and has had the luxury of building in a peacetime world. Today, more people are thinking that this era of Ethereum's life has come to an end and a phase change is needed for Ethereum to enter into a more aggressive stance towards this competition that some in Ethereum claim that it's not competing with.
On the episode today, we have John Charbino who recently released one of his best articles to date, which thoroughly contextualizes and diagnoses the issue at hand with Ethereum. And I highly recommend reading this article, even if you find yourself averse to the ideas. In fact, especially if you feel a negative reaction to the article, I may even more encourage reading it. Joining us on this podcast is Mike Ibelito, who has always been immensely valuable in these conversations, given his breadth of knowledge to all the relevant ecosystems and his general pragmatism. John and Mike and I were on a panel together discussing this very topic at DevCon, which was the ground zero for the light bulb that triggered John to write the article in question and also for the podcast that you are about to hear today.
So, thank you for the invitation. I hope you enjoyed this podcast with Mike Ibelito and John Charbino. But first, before we get into that conversation, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. Thank you for the invitation. I got John Charbino and Mike Ibelito with me. John Charbino, professional lowercase R researcher, host of a podcast that doesn't exist. Writer of the longest articles that crypto can somehow still master the attention to read and co-founder of DBA, John. Welcome to the bank list. How's it going? And Mike, tribalist Ibelito, professional podcaster, host of lowercase R researchers, closeted soul, maxi, a man who can only turn left and co-founder of blockworks, Mike.
Well, also welcome to the bank list. I only turn left as a deep cut. I don't think the audience is going to get that one. Oh, there's just for you, David. Yeah, that will be a large in people's heads. It's great to have you guys. This podcast is coming on the back of a release of a very long blog post from John Charbino. Very readable blog posts. I think the length is actually kind of deceiving. And it was a conversation that we also had on a panel at an event at DevCon. I think this content, this post and hopefully the conversation that we're having today is like a long time coming. I think the crypto world was very ready to read your post drawn.
I think it kind of distilled a lot of the angst that we have felt in a theorem about a theorem about the ETH price. And I think some people might maybe I'll open up the conversation with this. I think some people might be ready to say, oh, it was just price action. Like ETH price has returned. Now the sentiment is fixed. But I kind of want to actually decline that idea because the angst, the issue is still there, even if price number does go up. And so John, maybe you can kind of just give us a speedrun of the article and you're kind of like diagnosis and your motivations for writing the article for people that haven't read it.
What are just like the big elements that you focused on while you were writing it? Yeah. Thanks for prompting it to the panel at DevCon was actually when so I had been like kind of jotting down notes on what I thought I was going to do of like a sort of related post. And then after we did that panel is like, this is great. I need to like write this. I literally went home to my hotel after that was like, this is what I'm doing. Skip to fence. That's what I ended up. Yes. No, I ended up like skipping events throughout the week. That was like a lot of what I did throughout the week and then the week after and then I published it.
Yeah, I mean, the the the TLDR of it for people who haven't read it yet is basically like we've kind of had this kind of clear overarching problem in Ethereum for a while now that's like, it's not a specific technical thing or like like a problem at a very low level. Like it's it's a pretty high level vision thing that like I think has generally been lacking of when you look at Ethereum as now quite a number of like very credible competitors on really all of the different dimensions that Ethereum is competing on. And in each of those dimensions, it's a very clear competitor that is like focused on those things like you know what they're like they're quote unquote like North star their goal really is.
So I mean like very specifically like Bitcoin like everyone knows what Bitcoin does like the whole point of this thing is like it's digital gold is money. And you know, it's very easy to tell the story because like everyone knows what that is. And then you have like these kind of like financial rail smart contract platforms. I mean salon is the very clear example there of you know everyone knows salon a story whether like whether you love it or hate it. Everyone knows what it is. Everyone knows how it works. Everyone knows the vision like it is, you know, totally I want to build decentralized NASDAQ.
You know, permissionless markets for everyone in the world equal access to information makes sense. And then the other kind of third leg of it is generally I would say like Celestial, which is this kind of like big kind of roll up vision, which is much more of just like a broader. You know, we want to make it easy for anyone to launch any kind of application, you know, make these unstoppable applications that are censorship resistant, you know everyone can verify these things. You know, you have a light note on your phone. And so all three of those are like very clear coherent visions of like this is the thing that we're focused on.
And Ethereum is like kind of been sitting in the middle for a while. And it's actually been like pretty unclear like what of those dimensions that Ethereum wants to compete on and like why is kind of like the more fundamental underlying question of you know if you ask someone like what like what is Ethereum's purpose. You get like 100 different answers if you ask 100 different people. And so I think the people have ignored that for a long time because that sounds like sort of like I don't know a semantic thing or like I just decentralized, you know different people see different things. And so I think that kind of like we kind of just let that fly for a long time.
But then I think the people have started to realize over the course of the past year. No, this isn't just a like oh it makes it you know hard to talk about it or just like it's this complicated thing that like makes it hard to explain to my mom it like actually ends up creating like real coordination problems. In particular like the one half of it that I described as a basically kind of like building coordination is that basically if we don't all agree on like why we're building this thing that ends up flowing down into okay well then we don't agree on like what properties we need to build like do we need to build a like fast and cheap chain that's doing execution all these things.
You can't answer that if you don't like know what's the use case that we're building for so that's half of it and then that ends up like slowing down and making a really confusing conversation whenever we try to like actually improve the chain it kind of slows everything down there and you end up with potentially conflicting goals as well too. And then the other half of it is that kind of like marketing part I would say is like downstream of like having a clear North Star like knowing what your product is. And that does matter a lot whether you're trying to you know communicate to new developers and investors in the ecosystem like hey this is the reason that we're exciting like come build on my chain you need to have a clear story to kind of inspire people.
And especially if a theory does actually want to compete on money I mean money is just a story and so if we don't even agree internally in a theory on you know what is the overarching vision what is the story well then you're never going to be able to like sell the thing. So it's this kind of just like high level kind of perspective and realization that we've seen playing out over the past year of increasingly one half as a theorem has a lot of like very credible competitors on different dimensions. And then the other half is more internal to a theory of okay it's really unclear like which of these things that we actually want to compete on a Y and so we need to like really clarify that and then kind of everything falls downstream.
When I was reading your article I was getting like to kind of parallel punchlines that really work well together the first is that if you're has a coordination problem. And this is showing up in like the all core devs calls in like discussing what EIP's if you're even going to work on to prioritize. And like some of the anecdotes that are out there is that there's some technical debates about you know which what we do next about like you know should it be fossil or multiple concurrent proposals and these are just both technical upgrades. And a lot of these are being debated technically but they're actually with you zoom out they're actually more just like directional differences like what do we want a theorem to be.
And so like while it might appear to be a technical debate is actually more of just what is what are we building here debate and without that debate being answered a lot of progress in Ethereum is being slowed. So that's like one half of I think the punchline of your articles Ethereum has a coordination problem has a North star problem. And separately in addition to that Ethereum has credible competition. And these two points really land extra hard when combined is because you know Solana Celestia more aggressively moving more aggressive teams that can like move fast and break things. And then you know Bitcoin which is kind of already very far along along and like a narrow path for itself it doesn't want to do too much it just wants to be money money is very big.
But still nonetheless like pretty clear in its like path for what it wants for itself. And so these two things together kind of create the current like angst that we've seen in Ethereum. Mike you were part of the genesis of this conversation on the panel over in DevCon just give me your thoughts about what you had when you were reading the article. I think part of the reason it's been I think it's been difficult to have this conversation publicly for a couple of different reasons. One is a psychological element of do we want to admit that there's a problem here. The second is there are multiple conversations that are getting jumbled up into one and that's why you have some people describing this as a product problem and others describing this as a marketing problem.
I would like to address or introduce two new dimensions that as well and just say there's a when you're looking at an organization whether that's something that's extremely decentralized like Ethereum or country like the United States or small startup or corporation. I think these are all roughly the same challenges and you can bucket into that coordination challenge. And or that coordination problem that you mentioned David and it's there's a leadership component. A strategy component a product component and a marketing component. And I think just to I want to return to that but the first problem do we have a problem here.
It also reminds me a little bit of the mega movement that's bring the politics angle into this I had a really negative interpretation originally of that because it's like I don't want to admit that there's a problem with America. I love America. I grew up in America. My parents told me is the greatest country in the world now. I don't know. I look at it a little bit differently because the first step to solving a problem comes from admitting that there's a problem or a challenge. And I think that basically just judging by my Twitter and anecdotal conversations. I think half of people are on the page that hey, maybe there's an issue here that we need to address and there's still another half that says we don't want to admit that there's a problem.
Everything is okay. But to break down what I think the different conversations that are happening there's a leadership strategy product marketing. And I think actually from a marketing perspective I would I'm going to maybe take a contrarian opinion that I think Ethereum has phenomenal marketing. I don't think there's a marketing problem at all. I don't think that centralized top down marketing works in the context of L ones what you really want in L ones is grassroots community driven bottom up marketing. You want a bunch of people to basically yap the problem it has that in spates more so than anyone other than Bitcoin or maybe now Cardano or XRP.
But the problem is that they're not getting a coherent input about what to yap about. So it sounds very discordant and you have all these arguments that are going on lots of yappers not much message lots of yappers not much message. On the leadership side of things I think that there's a debate to be had around leadership it ends up getting stymied because people say we don't want some centralized top down thing like Solana. But I think there are numerous different ways that you can be an effective leader and one of those is setting a vision right or North star or goal or mission or where we're ultimately going.
And then empowering and entrusting other people to act on the mission so I am a believer that someone needs to come up with the why someone that has moral authority. And then you empower other people to come up with the how of actually executing that vision which I think is the right the right vision for Ethereum. The strategy side of things you can basically think of strategy is saying no to things and I'm not of the opinion that Ethereum can't compete on everything that it's trying to compete on. I would disagree that it should compete on every single one of those verticals right now at the same time.
I think it has to say no to some verticals even on a short term time horizon. Get a wedge and become the best at one of the things that it's trying to compete on and then in a number of years it can ultimately compete I think on everything that it ultimately wants. And I mean we'll get to this with John's world computer vision but I would be in the camp that that's probably the best way the world computer leads to the money angle I think. And then there's the product stuff and I think yeah that's everything John mentioned in the article about actually creating a product that people want making it measurable and setting.
You know just quantifiable ways of is this actually what the market wants. Can we take some time and try and diagnose how we got here in Ethereum land. Ethereum has some very interesting properties. It started off in 2014 2015 with a pretty centralized team but it very quickly moved to this decentralized EIP process. Fatalic started started off with this process being pretty hands off pretty quickly into Ethereum's lifespan. And really Ethereum has to its credit pioneered this decentralized coordination model in a way that like the world has never seen before. Like the level of decentralized coordination Ethereum is like pretty astounding and to me it's kind of a breakthrough of like what humans can do with like the assistance of Internet protocols.
And that works I really well for a while especially as we had John mentions in his post some very clear north stars and like temporary north stars like the merge like the merge rally to everyone in Ethereum to get the merge done. And again to Ethereum's credit got a lot of very big things shipped into it. And I think a lot of the low hanging fruit has been picked off and now we're starting to like ask all right what's what's next for Ethereum and some of these problems of being a decentralized coordinated community are starting to like rear its head. And also like things age right these systems age as people kind of know the game like different pockets of influence emerge Ethereum.
I think really liked in John's post political interests have kind of been pushed to the margins and it like push away from the center the EF doesn't want to be top down and so it's pushed political power away. And then those political epicenters the layer to's like the MEV supply chain started like you know things like flash spots things like optimism started became like politically powerful and that influences started to like work its way back in and now we are dealing with the consequences of that. And so like that's just an age thing that's a timeline thing we're now in the year 2024 2025 and so what decentralized coordination looks like is different now than it did five years ago.
Maybe this is my kind of like setting up the context for this question but like John help us like diagnose what how and why we got here what are the properties that got us to this place. So I'd say half of it is definitely a natural age thing like this is kind of the natural progression of things. The other half and probably the bigger component component of it I would say is that I think it was quite intentional and that's. A product of kind of what Ethereum's roots were which were very Bitcoin which is not the case for all of these new you know Celestia Salana type Jans that you're seeing pop up now these are not people who were like I really wanted to build this thing on Bitcoin.
But you know I guess we just need to go make our own thing it was just like they are just building a new tech platform versus Ethereum you know had very Bitcoin or roots like that those are the people who started the project like that was around up time. And so I think that was kind of just like that is the kind of cultural inclination of most people in there and so there is. There is a much earlier and more aggressive push to like very intentionally try to decentralize all the decision making you know the whole emphasis on a very multi client architecture try not to have like a very strong single leader and try to like decentralize the decision making process is all these things.
And a lot of the culture of kind of manifested in the technical roadmap of we're going to push out a lot of the technical complexity and what that ends up doing is that further that you know in pushing out technical complexity you're also in practice pushing out kind of the political power as well. Because if you're not building those things that everyone is using now will now the the later Tuesday building those things you know they're buying client teams like all you have all these other different parties that like they end up having a lot of political influence and kind of like what what is Ethereum itself doing.
So I'd say it's a mix of those two things of like there is some level of natural decentralization and you see that even in salon and now where you know they're going to have multiple client teams you know it's not just labs doing everything it's you know Gito has a lot of input in the process fire dancer has a lot of input in the process like that is going to slow things down. But they don't have all of these other points of we're going to intentionally you know like our founder and core team are going to be less opinionated about things like they're not going to do that like they're going to keep being opinionated.
They're not going to have all these altos that are putting a lot of political influence into the process and all of those things. So it's a mix of those kind of two things outside. I don't want to add anything. No, I agree with all of that. I think part of this is just natural growing pains. Let's just remember that there were literally block size wars that got fought in Bitcoin over this. Right. There's a really it's really short. You can look it up but Naval Robocon has this quote about groups don't disagree. They give them and you can kind of understand why that is having lived through crypto if you consider yourself as being part of a tribe.
There's a natural cycle to it where you know you're part of one try this happened to me with Bitcoin where that's what gets you into the space in the first place you bind to a lot of the arguments. And then once you get a little deeper you start to see some of the issues maybe there's some some challenges here we should talk about that. But for whatever reason it is bag bias or people tying their entire identity to their coin. People are less willing to hear that it turns a certain amount of people off. There's this kind of debating conflict and then a whole bunch of people end up leaving. And so you can you can see why this this pressure to schism exists.
And so I think like John said part of this is just really natural growing pains for a protocol that's been as successful and will be as successful as a theory I'm going forward into the future. And then I think there is a there. My opinion would be that is we're not rewiring human nature here even large decentralized organizations like the US government which is actually a very decentralized organization has to have some sort of figure head because you have to. People are just wired a certain way after hundreds of thousands of years and just having someone to set. A kind of high level vision I think is important and there are numerous examples by the way of douse of the leaders of protocols attempting to decentralize hand over control of the community and then either those protocols are successful anymore without naming any names or their leaders have come back and so I think we just need to recognize that.
Whether or not the leaders of Ethereum want to take on the mantle of that power that power exists. And if they don't take it on someone else ultimately enough taking on. I want to bring up the illustration of the three way venn diagram because I think that also does a really good job of grounding the conversation. So you have three three circles overlapping all overlapping in the center you have the Bitcoin Celestia and Salana execution data availability consensus is like how I think Justin Drake will frame it I don't know if you guys if you agree with that like the relationship between the three ecosystems but I thought it was a pretty useful metaphor here.
And of course on your article is about Bitcoin Salana Celestia as being the three credible competitions to to a theory I mean Bitcoin is actually winning versus a theory in the money but all all three are competing with the theorem and then you have. We have where overlaps all together is Ethereum Ethereum is at the center trying to do all three doing all three with some measure some decent measure of success and then also you have Celestia with more data availability than Ethereum of Salana with more execution than the Ethereum layer one and then Bitcoin with just straight up more moneyness than Ethereum.
And so these are like the three players here that are trying to like unbundle Ethereum like the vision the idea of like Ethereum being drawn in quartered comes to mind or drawn in thirded by these like three ecosystems and so like I just have this like picture of like this Ethereum body with three ropes tied to it and it's flexing as hard as it can trying to pull data availability and money and execution to it and then Salana Celestia Bitcoin are all pulling those same resources away to their respective ecosystem. So that's that's kind of like the the grounding I think that helps illustrate this this conversation so on this all Salana Celestia Bitcoin three way spectrum John where do you think Ethereum lies in its like prioritization and so where do you think it is and then where do you think it ought to lie with where it ought to prioritize things.
I would say broadly it is kind of in one two three order. I will tweak it to show kind of the evolution of it I would say initially it was I would say Salana Bitcoin. Then Celestia like in the early on we're in like it really had that kind of world computer vision when it was just when it was just starting and it was like very clearly like I would say like more differentiated from Bitcoin like they weren't trying like particularly the genesis of Ethereum you know you weren't trying to copy Bitcoin. There's less focus on the money is there was more focus on the world computer which is like the kind of vision that I am trying to bring back so I would say almost like looked more like Salana at the beginning which is interesting and then I think over time with you know especially with the old ones and all these other things popped up it started to move more towards like Bitcoin as a prioritization of like we're going to be the money thing with like the minimum viable execution.
And then it becomes you know that kind of like this quotes of like Bitcoin was the vision or whatever like Ethereum is the execution of that. Like we're just doing Bitcoin with like just enough functionality that you need for all these different things. And then I would say where that's like started to progress to is still primarily Bitcoin but with like a pretty strong emphasis on the Celestia leg of it. Of you know we're really bought into this kind of L2 vision but with a kind of like different L2 vision from Celestia where Celestia is kind of L2 vision is you know it's very embodied in their like summer roll up ideology of like.
It is much more of a you know we are just making this verifiable unstoppable internet it is a much more kind of like app and user centric like we are a platform to like change the internet for you guys versus Ethereum is a more. Ethereum centric and then like everything kind of comes out from there I'm like of like ethos money and therefore this makes sense as the center of the internet and like all the other things will build on top of us because of that kind of. So where I think it is now concretely is like it's kind of shifted towards I'd say like largely Bitcoiny and that's manifested in a lot of the stuff we're talking about earlier like you know you end up with this like multi client architecture decentralized leadership people are talking about the issuance and all these things all the time.
And then on the technical focus like what most people are trying to do is like stuff like blobs and peer deaths which is concretely looking you know kind of more like Celestia. Where people have been largely ignoring that kind of you know should Ethereum execution like does this really matter has largely been ignored for a while. And so that's part of the push of what I think it makes sense to kind of re emphasize again is to kind of bring more of that back into it and start that shift over of be a little a little less Bitcoiny at least for now. A little more of you know focus on the execution the world computer you know this like neutral layer again.
And then I think that ends up evolving into like more money is at the end of the path dependence of those things matters. Yeah. Okay so the way that you would say is like Ethereum is most like Bitcoin with roll ups. Yeah you know the Bitcoin plus Celestia and it's competing with those two things the most and it's kind of disregarded its own like Solana end of the spectrum is disregarded its own execution which kind of makes sense because like which alternative ecosystem has grown the most over the last two years which ecosystem has taken advantage of that. The fact that Ethereum is disregarded its own layer one execution.
Oh it's the ecosystem that has optimized for layer one execution Mike any any commentary here. Yeah I think a lot of this comes down to path dependence and I have this memory of the challenge that Ethereum has right I think ultrasound money confused a lot of people me included. And I remember describing to my dad early on. You know I had a lot of trouble getting him around the hump of Bitcoin right but there's no. Yeah there doesn't do anything productive and you can go and look at guys like Jack Bogle describe people's natural. Why they don't like commodities as an investment in general there's just this massive hump that people are not going to be able to get over that they like things that cash flow they can model.
So the description of the world computer of Ethereum and this network this economy of different applications that look like businesses. You got a lot of people there very quickly and I think maybe this would be a controversial thing to say but even the monitor I think Ethereum has a better shot at money on a long term time horizon than something like Bitcoin does Bitcoin has sort of gone the meme approach to money and I view it as a counter reaction to. The issues that fiat money is having we print too much fiat money so may get a total fixed supply that's great as a meme that's a really strong meme on a really long term time horizon that doesn't work as a monetary property.
You need some amount of flexibility and I kind of look at Ethereum's monetary scheme and think it's a better long term scheme. The issue is you're confusing people by trying to ride two horses with one of us and I also think there's been a misunderstanding as well of where the leverage for L one's really lies because of these. Brain damage words like settlement and I'm not of the opinion that most people choose the L one because of these settlement properties I think there's a minimum viable amount of decentralization you need with a settlement part then it becomes a cost thing but really what it is is it's the liquidity of the L one and why did so many people choose a theory last cycle there is this massively liquid asset you could build anything you wanted you could speculate quite a bit that was super valuable for the network and I think there was this misunderstanding among some people in theory circles that said.
We're being chosen because we're the most decentralized and the market was not choosing Ethereum for that reason and so I'm that's why I'm in the camp of world computer focus on execution whatever you want to do and we can talk about how this I think dovetails really nicely with the roll up centric road map it's all about having leverage and users and liquidity more so than these vague concepts of or one very myopic way to measure decentralization I think. Yeah I think that does extend into the roll up centric road map very well because in twenty twenty one twenty twenty way in crypto got you know a hundred times more users they went to Ethereum because that's where the liquidity was if you wanted to mint and launch an NFT project you did it where the money was so everything went to Ethereum and that's because it's where the money and users were.
Just to make concrete examples there as well look at the early defi apps that got product market fit in a swap maker of a what were those protocols allowing people to do use Ethereum in some way right take loans out lever up get yield trade things M.E.V. All of those initial use cases were based around having a deep and liquid a one token that people wanted to speculate around right and Ethereum I will say is getting it's layer two energy is what it's powering layer two is the same phenomenon it like not to discredit the fact that a theory is decentralized in layer two's want some level of like property rights and centric resistance totally valid and also layer two will go to where the money is that incentives go to where the money is and where the users are and so I think this also kind of brings into a point that.
I think john said it's like well layer two's will follow the liquidity just like users and so it that you can like kind of imagine alternative version of Ethereum and alternative timeline where Ethereum prioritize the layer one first before prioritizing layer two's which is what what is salon is doing salon is prioritizing layer one execution. And then you you keep everyone on the boat you keep all the users you keep all the liquidity and then you kind of let layer two spawn more emergently from that maybe john you can kind of like run us through that simulation of a road map maybe like salon is where you actually are on the roll up centric road map you were totally going to do roll ups we love roll ups we love the Celestia we love the cosmos vision we're just going to scale the layer one is meaningfully as possible like what could have been in this world.
All of it like I would say like make sense in hindsight of I think the key term that we will end up saying here a lot and that like people are realizing more is like this is all just a path dependence thing of like I think most of us agree like as Vitalik is written as well like the endgame of most of these blockchains looks the same. And I think that Ethereum has at a very strong inclination over time to ignore the like what is the practical thing today in the path dependence of these things and that is probably unsurprising when you have a very you know this like optimistic research driven community which is you know talking about one shot signatures and these things that are like 50 years away.
And you are planning for this like yes this theoretically makes sense in the endgame but ignoring that point of like okay but like yeah in practice why did the L2 launch on a theory in the beginning. Like it wasn't because we had this like but honestly like this like perfect road map that had everything figured out or all these amazing decentralization properties it was all the users are on a theorem that is where the most assets are ethos worth a lot of money. We can go on board those people into our chain and like now now we have product market fit we can just like take those users in those assets.
And that particularly makes sense when you realize that kind of like frame of I mean like and this is what like totally pokes out actually all the time you mix on it all to what what fundamentally is an L2 at the end of the day when you think it's like it's good bridge to another chain. So where are L2s necessarily going to go is just they're just bridges they're going to be they're obviously going to bridge to where the assets are. And so it's not a surprise that for the first time over the past year and in a pretty consistent line with the sole price pretty much in the activity on sole is like people are talking about salon L2s for the first time.
And why is that it's because Solana now has a lot of users and a high asset value on their chain. So of course it makes sense to build like a good bridge affection effectively to salon and get their users get their assets. It didn't make sense when Solana wasn't worth a lot and they didn't have any users. It's not that Solana got you know more decentralized and had these like properties of a settlement layer from a technical level from you know a year ago versus today. Like nothing changed the building the exact same thing they don't even care about these altos. It's just that they like they have assets and users now and so people makes like oh yeah make sense to build on top of them.
And so I think that a theory I'm kind of in some sense I probably like luck into that benefit from the beginning of obviously when a theory I'm started it did not have the roll up centric road map is just like we're building an execution layer. This is the thing that we know to do. But that ended up being the right move and the like the example that I was used is like I would say the cosmos was generally the first ecosystem that very clearly understood. What is the end game that mostly matters for this is like we're probably going to have a bunch of chains we need to figure out you know how do you make it easy to launch a chain how did you make it easy to be interropper between them they had the generally correct idea.
They just didn't have the right path dependent solution to that is just like they kind of went right to like you've said this for like they kind of went right to the end game right at the beginning. And it just like it just doesn't make sense you just ended up with a bunch of fragmented chains and like none of them were actually worth a lot. So there wasn't like actually much to do on any of them and they were just like sort of fragmented and it was like there was no like kind of rallying point for the ecosystem versus a theory and was just like. We have one chain like let's be real this is enough to do like 99% of the stuff that you could do encrypted today which was very concretely.
And I think that a theory and kind of it hasn't gone all the way but there has been a trend of it's like sort of cosmos hubbing itself over the past couple of years of. And this is the reason why concretely the first time that like I like we got very excited about and invested in salon was it was like it was fall fall of 23 or whatever. Like right before the bull market picked up because I want I mean part of it was just the market view by the market's going to come back but it's I just like also had a very clear view that like this whole roll up thing again like make sense in the end game. But it is very clearly does not the present situation of crypto that we need.
100 trains with all these interoperability standards and all the stuff figured out it's like what 99% of people in crypto want to do today. They want to like trade some meme coins play around some new like deep in projects and whatever you can kind of just fit that on one chain. And so that that is still directionally where we are today is like most of the interesting things that people want to do you can fit on a chain like a theory particularly if you just scaled a bit. And so I think there's a much more realization now of yes. Obviously a theory of one is not going to fit like the entire future of the world.
But that doesn't mean that we should just ignore it completely like it actually is valuable still as the center of this kind of belt to roadmap. Right. So I want to also make a point let's say you're listening to this conversation and you're in the eth is money camp. I want to try to connect the dots in between getting everyone on one single environment and how that actually leads to eth being a better money. There's this reflexive property in between eth the L one token versus actual usage of the network. And it comes from this fact that the market size the total addressable market for apps is highly dependent on the market cap of the L one token.
Highfalutin concept to concrete examples the early like Awe and maker their market size was limited by the amount of people that wanted to borrow against their teeth. So the more heath that heath went up the more the demand or the market size for those applications was. Same thing for L to's why are L to's all very excited about launching a theory partially it's because there was a prioritization from the L one on making it easier to launch L to's but also mostly because this mass of users and liquidity on the L one. And so that's why it's very important actually there's this very reflexive property in between the price of the token and the actual adoption of the network.
The other thing too that I think is going to be a bit of a challenge just speaking about cosmos and anticipating the end game is if you look at cosmos they were really early to this trend of allowing users to pay in us DC as opposed to Adam the token. And I think that's roughly going to play out on L to's as well. This is one of those areas where L to's and Ethereum L one have very different incentives. And so the broad discussion around this has been we're trading off execution fees for liquidity network effects of ETH on L to's. But I don't see the incentive for really for L to's to make their customers adopt.
ETH if customers want to pay for things in us DC they're going to pay the L to's are going to make it very easy to pay for things in us DC. And so one of the other benefits from a monetary standpoint of maintaining more activity on your network is you have control over what happens on your network. You can much more easily collect taxes that will translate into yield that will make your asset larger and the market size fall of your apps larger. There was an interesting discussion around EIP one five five nine where they were deciding between a burn and you know all these other mechanisms that would have made it D saw.
And they ultimately if you go back and you can listen to these great upsets that hasu did on on common core when that was still a podcast. And he's talking with suzu about this concept of economic abstraction part of the reason the burn was selected was because they didn't want off chain payments happening. And so they wanted to control the fact that people needed to pay for block space in Ethereum that's an example of something that you can concretely do that would affect the demand for Ethereum if you have everyone operating on your layer versus if you move all these users L to's that are not incentivized to do.
I agree with that the economic attraction can now return into the Ethereum ecosystem via the layer twos dollars are more easy to reason about there's just better UX and as we expand crypto. People are just going to want to demand dollars to transact in dollars more than they are going to want to transact in ether I totally generally agree with that trend. And I will also say I kind of want to start to put on my Ethereum hat a little bit more strongly here. And so I'll also say that like okay that's great that people are going to spend their dollars but really that's like the commodity side the payment side of money is a very small fraction of it as opposed to the store of value side.
I will gladly spend dollars and store my eith and sure we can economically abstract ether on its layer twos and people can spend dollars but like if people are still electing to use and store their and store their value in ether and use eith as money on these layer twos that's actually like. 80 90% of what makes a money and so if layer to if users elect to use eith as money on layer twos that's way more way more powerful and this starts to get into some of the thing I some of the stuff I think Ethereum really has strengths on which is even though eth is not as great of money as compared to Bitcoin a judge by this market cap.
Even though eith is not great as execution and so on and even though ethereum has less data availability it still has a monopoly on the synergies between each of these overlapping then diagrams. So what do you get when you have a money mixed with layer twos well you can fuel those layer twos with money and you can have demand more demand for ether because because arbitrums got super fast block times and it's got a very very strong defi ecosystem. What's primarily the money in that ecosystem. And true you can maybe even dollars don't do supplant like eith in these ecosystems but nonetheless we are still in a fiat currency crisis in nonetheless societies are moving away from fiat currencies and so eith to take a leaf out of Mike norther's book is the permissionless money of these like layer two ecosystems and that's just like one synergy like what do you get when you cross this energy of money and execution Bitcoin and Solana you get layer one defi and it here is layer one defi ecosystem still has like 80 85% market share of defi like a very strong dominance of where is the ether actually still on the layer one inside of maker doubt inside of a and a quote from Eric wall recently who's like well I go gambling on Solana but like I put my winnings in a they on on Ethereum and so on the layer one on the layer one yeah yeah and so like nonetheless I think there's a lot of path dependency things that we can bring up and like John I'll say that like some of the pushback that I've heard from from some Ethereum people is not that anything in your article is technically wrong but the vibe wasn't accurate as in Ethereum is this decaying Roman Empire these smaller smaller like city states Solana Celestia are going to rise and take over but like the fundamentals the stats like are still very strongly in Ethereum favor and so I'll kind of just present that to you like talk about the synergies that Ethereum has and like how how should we like weigh these things in these conversations so I'll get to that on what's like the one quick part that I would disagree on is that on the stats that it's way ahead I actually disagree with that now on some stats sim stats yeah Solana has like a lot of economic economic energy in it for sure which is I think what it's been behind in practice like it's rise over the past year is that I think in practice like a theory like slot has actually surpassed Ethereum even including layer like even including all of its layer two's on a lot of key metrics and stuff like RV just like the total amount of like like what are users paying between MV and fees to use chain what is the amount of revenue that the apps on the chain are making you know applications like radium Jupiter pump on Gito like all these things they're printing money to a degree that like even more than more than a theory of applications they're getting institutional like a lot of the deployments that Ethereum is getting they're pulling the same things on Solana like all those different things so I think on a metric space as I think that the do put it like this all but the just the discrepancy in their market caps is much higher than the discrepancy in actual I would say like what the metrics would tell you if you're just looking at those with no understanding of kind of history but what about DeFi though I think Ethereum still has a very large dominance of market share of DeFi specifically so like TVL maybe not fees but TVL yes exactly and this gets into the like and this is where I do think it has a serious advantage and this gets into that kind of role computer vision that like I which is why I do think it makes sense to compete on this is because what Eric described is like directionally what I do too and what I think directly most people do too is like yeah I do most of my memecoin trading on Solana and then the majority I have more like my savings yeah my USDC is on Ethereum yeah it's stuff like that I think that actually it's like that that is a real product market fit it's kind of similar to win like big corners will say oh yeah I'll go shit-coining but then I'll sell it into Bitcoin at the end of the day oh yeah yeah yeah how many successfully do that so yeah that that still is the kind of like directional bias right now which is which is why I think it makes sense for Ethereum to lean into that and not just like give that up because otherwise I think the I that is the concrete that the problem is I think that the current trend is as long as clearly gaining on all of these different things it has more dex volume uses more users who are using this like paying more fees more interesting application to all these things but the last holdout really is that there's still a lot of the big money on Ethereum this is still the place that like I generally trust a little bit more with like big dollar amounts but if you just like continue to ignore this execution layer and for the next year or two have this mixed messaging where a lot of people are actively telling like applications like there's no future for the L1 like get off the L1 and then salon keeps picking up activity and black prop and PayPal and all these other institutions are deploying on salon you're eventually they're they're just going to build up their like actual serious tvl and savings there too and then like the discrepancy is like it's all gone and so I think that strategically Ethereum should not let that happen it should you know it should understand that yeah a lot of the users will go there a lot of them will do the meme coins blah blah blah but we want to try to keep a lot of the serious value stuff here because I do think that is like a real competitive advantage and then as far as kind of the synergies and getting into like that the economic abstraction point that you're talking about as well so I think that a lot of early on Ethereum as I think that in practice this was correct that Ethereum was able to kind of say l2s will like definitely increase the money in s of eith because like these are just more places that use eith more networks exactly and so early on I think that was correct because economic abstraction this is just like technically complex like no one did that you just wanted to use eith like all right we're just going to use eith on all these chains the direction now is obviously you know based announcing like oh well you will use usdc for payments like more chains are going to do that and so I would say that I think the more correct framing particularly as we play this out over time is that l2s expand the kind of the opportunity space for eith to be used as money but once economic abstraction becomes easier and easier it's just creating the opportunity for it to be used that way if users don't want it then they're not going to use it versus today it's directly more even if you don't want it you're using eith if you want to go using l2 so it's kind of like forced on people so that will generally be a negative I would say on like eith's moneyness over the longer term and so part of that is what you're saying of and I agree with this is like most of the value of this kind of currency thing is not actually from the fact that people are using it for gas payments I agree with that you know you do the mv equals pq type calculations on this like it's not a lot like it's high velocity on this stuff but I think in practice that is very likely very heavily tied to it being used as this store value and all of that like core of defy on this chain when the onboarding for everyone who goes on this chain is like you're going to own eith and you're going to use this and that is the thing that you need to own is very likely in practice that is kind of going to be the core the ecosystem it's probably going to be the main asset that ends up in all these like defy applications versus if that is just never a step that you need like I never need to get eith to go on to this change it's like I just go on there with usdc then I don't see a compelling reason why Ethereum is going to like just naturally become that asset people are just going to naturally grab it towards towards the essence they want which is probably you're actually going to be btc and usdc that is the thing that I think that bitcoin has gotten like very right and like luckily from the start of like you kind of need to start with the money because ultimately when the users have the choice they're going to pick what they actually wanted the money not just like this is the tech platform that I'm built on top of and so that that is part of the why I think it makes sense and this kind of gets to the world computer and ethos money visions of like a lot of this is really just a timescale thing of like I think that yes the endgame for these things is you want them to play out into money but I don't think that in practice the way that you can get this thing to be money is just saying like our ultrasound money or deflationary we're better money than bitcoin like I can purically most people don't buy most people prefer bitcoin unlike the just sound monetary aspects of it so I think that in general probably the way to actually just increase the value of youth in the short to medium term and just like kind of start with that base of how do we increase the moneyness asset value of it is to probably refocus on more of the focus on the oh one have a lot of the great execution there this more world computer vision with that kind of as the heart of it because that is still where in practice like most of this high value defi is all happening that is still where most users are so if you can really just increase that a lot and that becomes the home of it again in practice like ethos like probably going to go up in price it becomes a better collateral asset all these other things and then that's probably the more path dependently correct way to kind of build yourself into being money over time it's like really focused on the core and build out from there.
I want to bring up the the north star conversation again you celestial salon and bitcoin I'll have very clear north stars celestial one gig by blocks build whatever salon of what is it increase speed reduce latency yeah decentralized asset you know big bitcoin 21 million units and then you know if the conversation is the theorem just has this kind of confounded like north star idea but I want to present the idea that couldn't be the case that it's simply because these other three ecosystems are just going after a smaller vision than what ethereum is going for ethereum's roadmap is parallel its complexity is immense it's hard to explain maybe that's because it's going for a superset of what all of these things are going for it is the thing in the middle of the vent diagrams right that's why it's got a marketing problem that's why it's got coordination difficulties that's why it's difficult to understand and it's kind of like imagine trying to explain a third vertical dimension to a flat lander like that's just going to be a hard thing to explain and ethereum's governance is EIP progress its arc its roadmap is kind of like this random walk in the towards this like vibe of a direction that is like loosely articulated by vitalic so like I want to present this this like maybe that's why ethereum has like this north star vision it's trying to do like the the tweet that I tweeted out that was in this in this direction was what is the theorems like north star what is the theorems roadmap better money than bitcoin more data availability than celestial better execution and and that tweet that was a hit tweet and I think that's because that actually resonated with a lot of people like oh this is putting a lot of pieces to the puzzle together for me how do you guys what do you guys like this vibe so I think that this comes back to the comment that I made at the top this episode about strategy I do not think that it is a bad thing for ethereum's vision to be to compete on all of those dimensions eventually I think it's a mistake to go out and say they're competing on all of those dimensions right now here's another analogy that I'll give you if amazon had come out on day one and said we're going to be the everything store it would have fallen completely flat right Jeff Bezos started with books right and did Jeff Bezos only ever want to sell books I don't think so but he picked a wedge that was easy to understand he did it better than everyone else and then he expanded from there so again I want to just also just assume mount here for a second I think that ethereum has the best shot at winning the largest market which I've always viewed as commodity like money that has some amount of yield attached to it the reasons again getting back to the maga comment here is I'd be firmly in the camp that there is a problem you don't solve the problem unless you say it there's not much incentive actually for me to come on a podcast like this and talk about this right it's like I know this is going to be unpopular for people the reason is I I care about it and I want to see the problem solved in the first step of that it's admitting that there's a problem and I would disagree David with that tweet that ethereum is more complex than any of these other networks or it's just got a bigger vision I think all these networks have a very similar vision and I think there's a very similar amount of complexity across all these networks I think ethereum has to improve on its strategy here and decide again on the path dependence point on the time scale point when do I want to win each of these wedges and which wedge is going to give me the most leverage to win the next trunch up from that and I think describing it as competing for everything at once it's not hitting with people and I don't think it's the right strategy so I I would split it into two I think half of the answer is what Mike just described which is I would say like very succinctly epitomized by kobi's reply to your tweet which is you know man who chases two rabbits catches neither but everything is a fair argument it is very possible that it is the wrong move strategically to like go full force on all three these right now and this is just a matter prioritization at the end of my post that is like generally the view that I end up taking is that I you know I think on some time horizon you are competing on all these things but like we probably need to reprioritize and focus a little bit more on certain aspects of this like in particular like I think you should probably focus more directionally on the kind of like execution front today and a little bit less on the money I said you know that kind of comes later that is like my directional bias I think it probably makes sense to do that I would say the much larger actual other half of it though is what was a lot of the focus of the piece is I I don't think most of the issue today is that we are trying to compete on all of those things I think that most of the issue today is that none of us agree about whether we are competing on any of those dimensions I do not think that there is internal agreement that we are competing on money I think that like most people want this in like some loose notion but a lot of people very actively dislike it do not care about it do not want to see a theorem do it like they want to be this like decentralized economy tech all these things like it's not like it's gas yeah and I mean like the the perfect epitome of this like I described as like at the bankless summit like one of the talks is like Antigrow and Caspar talking like they've been doing a lot of work around issuance and all these things and the title of the talk is ethos money if we if we choose it to be right like that that like highlights it like we just don't know like we haven't decided internally like if we're even competing on this thing DA I would say it's the same thing of like we have this loose notion of like yeah like we're going to scale this thing like we're going to do it for four or we do peer-dose we're going to do dang shorting bubble ball like all these different things and like oh we're going to do that but I would say that there's a reasonable amount of disagreement of like like how much do we actually have to prioritize that like how valuable actually is that you know if we're just doing the whole money thing anyway I mean like Bitcoin's never going to have enough DA for the world like we're not going to have enough DA for the world so like it's fine if like most of these L2s go use Celestia and I can DA and whatever for DA like that's not really a priority like we can have this but like it's not really a huge deal we don't need to compete with Celestia directly I mean like Justin even says that directly like I quoted him in there basically a couple times of he was saying like yeah like if DA gets a little offensive in the next couple months as we go into price of discoveries like I think it should be totally social acceptable for Ethereum L2s to basically just like leave Ethereum DA go use Celestia until it becomes like cheap again like if it does like that should be totally fine because like most of the the value is not from the cash flow that's like the money in this just let them go do that so I would say it's complete disagreement there and then I would say this complete disagreement on the are we competing with salon either I would say that that is like a complete 50 50 split again of I do not think that there's any coherent message at all I like I think that like there's a mix of I mean one of the points that I highlighted in there was like Justin Vitale like I've said at various points that you know the L1 is competing with Bitcoin the L2s are competing with Salana and also very explicitly saying at times there is no future for the L1 like when he was debating totally on your podcast like if you're an application developer go to the L2 there's no future for the L1 while at the same time his roadmap was also like juicing the execution on the L1 and doing precalms for faster than Salana transactions and like most of these design like execution changes end up looking like Salana and I would say a very large amount of people in a theorem like do I would say directly agree with some of the stuff that I've been pushing I'm like we should focus more on the L1 like we do we do want to compete on this front and I put like don't crowd and like a number of other people kind of in that camp so so short TLDR to your question back to the beginning kind of summing up is like I think that half of the question is like it is a fair point of like which which of these dimensions should be compete on I think there's like a fair conversation and we probably are trying to compete a little too hard on too many of them I think we should rebound some but I think that the much bigger issue is that I don't think that we agree on any of them right now right which is one of the things that I called out at the end of like I think that like I directionally prefer this like we should focus more on execution don't worry about the money right now like that'll kind of come naturally as a byproduct of what we're doing like that is my preferred vision but I also think it would be better for Ethereum today if they just took like a hard right turn a month the other way and you're like fuck it like kick everyone off the like off the a one fine we don't need that anymore like we are competing with Bitcoin as money and like we make that a very clear story and you know we we have better economics you know for reasons x y and z Bitcoin's block reward is going to be unstable as inflation goes away like all these different things are economic mental but doesn't make sense like we're going to be better we're going to be programmable enough upcat is never going to happen like you can tell a very coherent story there even if it's not a preferred path I think that is like actually a much better path than where we are today which is like an unclear mix of none of us agree on any of the three dimensions is what we're competing on and that brings it back to that like you know what is a lack of North Star concretely end up with you can't tell your story as money if we don't agree whether the thing is money so you're obviously going to lose there and you also aren't building the tech platform to compete with salon because we don't even agree if we're competing with salon or Celestia and so that also becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy of like I wouldn't even know if we're competing with them or like we're kind of telling people not to they just leave and so then that becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy we're going to lose to them too so more importantly than honestly which direction that we like really decide to lean into I think the problem is we we just people just don't agree which you know which dimensions are we competing on?
I'd like to get into just practical actionable items that we can bring to the table for the Ethereum project because I think we all agree this is not a technical issue this is a social and political issue so like what are the actionable things that we would like to see out of Ethereum governance to really like write the ship my my attitude if I can put my like my like name in the hat here is I think we should kill the five swim lanes the urges kill the urges I want the urges let's replace them with three swim lanes data data availability execution and consensus because that's correlated to like the three big economic resources that a blockchain has and only Ethereum has really identified first and is in the lead to the idea that like we're all building the same system here so let's go build that but I think it's also let's let's reframe the three into and consolidate three routes of progress to optimize for ether to be the best money possible for Ethereum to provide the most amount of DA possible and for the Ethereum layer one to have the strongest amount of execution possible and then the layer two ecosystem will just naturally emerge rather than being forced it will just naturally emerge out of that and then the cross interoperability of the layer twos will have the benefits of a very strong layer one execution to be able to do that entering in interoperability that's kind of what I would see it's like reframe the roadmap but John Mike like what would you bring to the table what's it what advice do you have for the Ethereum team the theorem core devs the all core devs call how would you suggest to them like where should they should go so the two things I had in the posts more concretely were one section was I just called it like talk to your customers of I think there's like a very clear trend in Ethereum of there is a pretty large disconnect disproportionately to other networks of like what are the core developers doing and looking at and working on and like what are the use cases and applications of this chain and like a couple of the tweets like I'd thrown in there very clearly whereas I think it was like poachess who is basically saying like you know none of us core devs you know yeah like yeah we don't spend time looking at applications like that's fine we don't need to we're low level and then Max was pointing out like you're designing EPS like every applications transactions are now going to go through this thing like shouldn't you probably understand like at a little bit better level like what do the applications like what are they doing what are they care about I I think that's fair and don't quite had also like argued that in a similar vein of like there's a big disconnect between like what is happening on all core devs versus you know like like actually having a conversation with a lot more the applications and a lot more focus on like what are we doing in service of like our big customers and I remember Kyle had mentioned that on one of the podcasts that I remember was the one that he had done with you or Gord or one of the others but I threw the quote in there of he was kind of like making this distinction of he was like you know he was like Mark Zeller had done a podcast recently who's like the main guy at Ave who's like the largest application on Ethereum and he was talking about he's like I've never spoken to anyone at the EPS before and like that just like seems like that probably shouldn't be the case like that is the biggest application on your chain with like 30 billion dollars or whatever in it versus the strong contrast of that is like look at the slona foundation is you know he was like pointing out like they've a DeFi team a deep end team a stablecoin team all these different things that is interfacing with all the specific use cases that are important and they have had like literal technical changes come out as a byproduct of kind of that interaction interaction and conversations of like the one that he points out is like token extensions on slona which is like a feature that they have ended up implementing as a direct result of like these are conversations that we had with you know payment providers and institution providers and like different applications of like they want more control over like programmability of the token like this is a useful feature that they want so we're going to implement this those conversations like largely aren't happening on Ethereum and so kind of like the the thought process that I end up like calling out in the post is like I think the way that you generally should be designing any of these things from first principles is you ask yourself like the first question is like like what are we building for like what what is the end use case and then after that you can ask yourself like okay this is the use case what properties do we need for that use case and then you could have an educated conversation like oh this is the right EIP this is the right upgrade to get those properties to like fulfill that use case and right now directly in Ethereum there is a lot of just like skipping that first step right which makes that second step of like what properties we are optimizing for like not super clear like we don't really know and so that third step of like what EIP should we put in Petro becomes this kind of like jumbled conversation of like it's super unclear because the property is in the prioritization of use cases just kind of not there so that is kind of just like a more like cultural fundamental thing I think would be quite useful and then the other aspect of it is a more just like organizational and kind of like leadership style change and the section that I like that call that was like more times CEO which was it was from a book which I know Kyle has like used this analogy the same thing over the past few months of like it's throwing about hard things yeah it's a book by Ben Horowitz who's like one of the founders of A16z has a startup background had run businesses before and he has this chapter called peacetime CEO wartime CEO where he's talking about kind of like the different personalities of you know what what are the types of leadership styles and skills that you need in kind of different scenarios and where I would say Ethereum has like had more of a history of like being kind of in peacetime earlier on we're just like you just focus on like build up the market everything is good you know we're the leader and that's all you have to worry about versus now when you have credible competition you really need to like align people a lot more and kind of get this message straight and because like we actually like do have real competition that we need to worry about right now we can't just be like worried about 20 year research if like someone might overtake us in the next few years and the challenge that Ethereum has right now is that like we have very aggressively decentralized leadership in a bit of like in odd way that I would say and one of like one of the quotes that I had in there which I think was kind of indicative of it was a press which was talking on the court bug asks was kind of describing how like what we end up happening having in practice in Ethereum today is like Vitalik is putting these posts out on like the roadmap of your describing like these kind of five segments but what I was calling out in there is like look at if you look at his posts on like possible futures of the Ethereum protocol all of them are very clearly here are all of the technical options for you guys to look at like here the trade-offs for each of those things like asks the big questions of like a big question that we have to answer is you know what should happen on the L1 and then he doesn't actually give opinions on any of those things of like what should we do on the L1 it's very like he just defines the possible paths without choosing any of these things it's very intentional and like I under like I fully understand the the rationale and the reason for doing that is you know trying not to exercise this kind of centralized decision-making because yeah in practice if Vitalik says that thing like a lot of people are probably just going to follow with it and like I just that looks centralized the problem is I think we are like a very weird mix today where the practical reality is Vitalik is putting out his roadmap and in practice 99% of people like this is just the Ethereum roadmap right we are still just like listening to like effectively like this this is the founder like this is the roadmap this is what we're doing and as like I was calling out like I think in many ways Vitalik actually holds a higher position in a theorem than it like and then like totally doesn't salon in many ways I think that he exercises the less direct control of like saying like this is what we're going to do but just like I mean subjectively if you like look at conversations in flano or like if totally says the thing and a bunch of the salon of people think it's a stupid idea like they'll tell them a stupid idea yeah I noticed a lot less of that inclination in Ethereum um honestly um and so the the teal day of that is like we we end up it's a lot of that kind of dynamic is exacerbating what I was talking about of we have all these technical ideas like we have all these EIPs that we could look at um but we don't have a like strong starting vision of okay but like what are we building for like what's the use case like what like what is the thing that we all agree on what's the purpose of this what do we need to optimize for and so we just end up like going in circles on all like the very specific technical limitations because we really need to be fighting about the thing that's like a kind of a step earlier um and so I think the hard question is how do we in practice solve this kind of social coordination of how do we agree on like what the vision should be um and I think the easiest way to get that is like the more time CEO you know you have someone who's super opinionated whether that's Vitalik or Justin or Don Crowd or someone who just like does take a much more active role so at an individual level and then also probably like somewhat of an organizational level right of the the EF I would say has a very similar vibe to what I described with Vitalik of like right you know the EF is downstream of Vitalik and like the whole culture at the EF is very similar in a way of you know we do not take views as an organization right you know a lot of them trying to buy some traction a lot of them try not to be too opinionated on different matters um and so we end up with generally a very decentralized leadership and a lot of leadership that I would say is directionally much less inclined to give you their opinions versus if you look at salon I mean like they're all telling you they're very very opinionated strong stances all the time and then people fight it out and like whatever you come to a decision and so I I think that in practice like that is that is the easiest way and like probably the way that it needs to go is you need some people to step up into a little bit more of a leadership role kind of an ethereum to be like all right we're gonna hurt the cats like we're gonna get people aligned kind of on this vision and then you could still have this like super decentralized process and I'm like look you got all these client teams that are actually gonna go figure out the details of the how and all of this um but taking a little more agency on okay we need to align people on the vision like we need to agree on a vision to start with and I think that like the community is ready for that um as evidenced by I think like I I've been very pleasantly surprised to the reception of like the the the piece that I put out and I think a lot of people are more open to this in the last month of reusing I I think that we kind of need to align around a vision more um and so it's just really a matter of how does that vision kind of come about and how do we end up all coordinating to agree on this thing because then everything can happen downstream of there then we can figure out you know what should we prioritize as a result of that right and I want to bring up the thing that I said at the very beginning of this podcast which is I noticed there's like two halves of the article it's one ethereum has a coordination problem which is what you were just talking about and two ethereum has credible competition and I want to emphasize that the idea here is like ethereum has a coordination problem regardless of the existence of its competition and I think there are some people in ethereum who don't want to admit that it has a coordination problem because the conversation is being brought in the context of and ethereum is losing to salana and it's going to have less data availability than celestia and because it's not as great money a big coin and so framing it in contrast to these other ecosystem I think sets off a knee jerk reaction of like I decline the existence of that and I'm a fan I'm an advocate of saying if if that triggers you fine but like internally we can identify ethereum's coordination problem inside just just discussing ethereum like ethereum doesn't have a defined what are we building ethereum for it doesn't have it has this very decentralized uh leadership which has pros and cons uh and so that there is this trade off space that ethereum has made and now we are starting to run up into a lot of the cost of again maybe even early very big success for having a decentralized leadership model uh and now we need to learn how to contend with these things uh and these are the two bits of advice that john is bringing to the table for the ethereum community Mike what would you add to it?
I was just gonna say so I feel like I've been saying this for a long time but there's steel sharpened steel this is why I've always been a massive fan of there being multiple different ecosystems and communities that are focused on solving different parts of this very large multifaceted problem of how do we create and scale blockchains and I think there's a certain reality of how humans work which is in order to admit that there's a problem something actually has to break in a really fundamental way otherwise inertia is a really powerful force and it's too easy to just say no this is mostly working and something that you said at the top of this episode david is something when we did that panel at devcon we're both a little concerned about which is ultimately everything that we're saying today I don't think has a massive impact on the price of ethereum on a three or four-year time horizon I think you're already probably starting to see it ethereum has an ETF I think it's probably gonna go up regardless of what comes out of this discussion but what I worry about there is that it could paper over this larger problem which is gonna metastasize on a longer time horizon and that would be a real shame because I keep saying this also I think the market that ethereum is pursuing here is one of the larger ones in all of crypto and I agree with john's point about it it feels I don't mean this to sound mean or targeted or you know what do I know really at the end of the day but I do I do think leadership is a component here I would be this is just one man's opinion but I would be in the camp that you need more you need the why to come from a smaller group of people and then decentralize the how as much as you possibly can and I think one of the reasons why people been reticent to do this is because there's some healthy amount of turnover that has to happen I think this is something that really naturally happens again I'm gonna say in governments in startups in large companies in different types of communities where if you have two people two groups of people with competing visions both of which are viable one of those visions has to win and then some amount of those people ultimately need to leave because people will opt for coherence over almost everything else and that's I think what is lacking and so I agree with john that I think there needs to be a firmer hand on the stick when it comes to leadership and that's going to mean most likely some amount of turnover in terms of potentially users there's also a concept in startups you have to fire your your users in the early days and as you scale and you ultimately end up evolving your product and so there is going to be some turnover and that's not a bad thing that's the sign of healthy growth I would say and I think that's why as a community we've been relatively reticent to do this but I would say yeah it's firm leadership the willingness to have some turnover or fire community members or users or whoever that ultimately ends up being so that you can get a coherent vision of how to improve your product and the one obvious thing that I point out too is it's not just companies and governments and whatever that happens in exactly what happened to bitcoin yeah it is yeah which is why that I like I use that example a few times in the post is I like the reason that bitcoin has a clear vision today is because they two sides that had very different opinions on what we should do and like what their vision was for bitcoin and they fought it out and I was like all right we're going to go a separate way so we're going to go build our thing and they both focused on that thing in the better one one out and that's where bitcoin does as a result today because they are in a much cleaner straight forward place like we all agreed on what we're building this is what we're building and Ethereum has kind of like sat in that middle ground for a while without kind of the you know if there's 20% of the community who disagrees with us completely and you know wants to go like wholehearted ethos money and like kick everyone off the L1 and like like some of these things that 80% disagree with maybe the 20% should go build a different thing right and I think that would be like a reasonable kind of split to kind of end up happening at least on the margin of like we kind of need to start forcing these questions in my mind start answering them I suppose there's kind of like letting them kind of simmer because the result ends up being we end up having two visions which are just like directly in conflict at the end of the day right I personally don't think there will be a split in the Ethereum community in the same way that like the bitcoin chain hard forked and the bitcoin I don't think so either I do agree that we should force the issue and like we you know numbers going up now and now we can feel a little bit better about ourselves but that's just the dopamine like the IV drip that will kind of like just kick the can down the road like you're not actually solving anything you're just papering over it as Mike said so I do kind of and I enjoy the idea of like hey let's make that we it has to hurt first before it feels better and again admitting a problem is the first step towards the end of the article John you actually gave out a couple ideas for north stars I'll just sell money versus world computer maybe you can take us through this last leg your article yeah yeah so the the last part of it was like I was trying to make this point of I think you can very strongly argue for either of the extreme ends and like I kind of like make a case for both of them um to kind of highlight that I think you can actually go either of these directions and I think the either of these directions is probably better than kind of sitting around in the middle one of them I call kind of like the ethos money or ethos ultrasound money kind of vision where you take a very opinionated view of like we are primarily it's like we are competing with bitcoin like money is the thing like it is it is a failure if ethos not become money and we just like we start from there and we work outward so you know then you could be you know we are probably going to spend a lot of time about being super obsessive about figuring out like what is the perfect issuance policy like that like this is priority number one we're going to get our story straight so that we could start flooding bitcoin like even more effectively like we're going to point out like why their security budget is like completely screwed and why they're all if you're like definitely not going to work and like we're going to have a clear incredible story of like why this thing makes sense and then like once you have a strong story of like okay money is the center of this thing then the rest of the architecture kind of falls out from that of okay ethos money and if this is the thing that matters and that every whole month most of the technical stuff we could actually get rid of all one scaling like it's not a big deal anymore for the same reason that everyone is like desperately trying to build L2's on bitcoin right now it's because if your asset is the best money well then everyone is kind of forced to build on you because like you are the ledger of record for that asset effectively ultimately everything does fundamentally have to settle to you as the like quote unquote settlement layer I hate that word but like in practice like that's what it ends up being and so you can take a very strong opinionate of you are like all right like get rid of the execution stuff like you tell all the apps to leave we don't care you know we're not focused on increasing the gas limit we're not focused on reducing the block time like none of that matters it's like get the money stories straight like coherent vision which I think you like you can pursue that and like it might work I don't think it will work like my directional bias is like that probably won't because I think it's hard to out that coin at its own game but I think you like you can make a very clear story there and the other art of a kind of argument I would say like a direction where stars like the world computer vision of and this is the one that I directly believe in more is like if you look at Ethereum today like the hard question that we need to ask yourself is starting with one problem that I think a lot of people take is I think a lot of people I've seen take this view of like we should just ignore what the competition is doing and just like look at kind of a theorem in a bubble which I don't I don't think makes sense I think you need to like very much pay attention like what is what I'm doing what is what you're doing what did they coin doing like how do we kind of fit in there yeah um and so my my general was like starting questions like what is Ethereum's currently like it's like real unique and defend this defensible value that is providing and moat that has and right now that thing like very concretely is it is the most decentralized credibly neutral permissionless execution layer like that is the thing where this property is really matter the most it's not on the DA side right now practice most changes like they don't care if the use less to your Ethereum DA like most of them like don't really care I really do care if my money is in Ave on the L1 or if it's on some L2 like I quite frankly don't trust most of the L2s in large scale with my money I'm keeping it on the L1 like that is a very strong product market fit for a theorem right now like that example of like whatever it was talking about like I did the mean coins on salana but like for now I'm keeping my serious money on Ethereum um and I think that like credible neutrality and kind of this like unstoppable world computer I think is like a very coherent vision of impractance the theory does have that advantage today it is winning at this game it has a moat there it has technical properties which makes sense for it the multi client architecture makes sense here the liveness properties of gasper makes sense here salana goes down every once in a while that is a problem for this all that we like need to do is we don't need to get to salon a level execution the the difference is like we preserve the credible neutrality the like maxic centralization all of these things on balance though we can shift the detail a little bit I mean like the example I basically gave was like we could change the node requirements to start from somewhere from like we're toaster in the Sahara Desert level to like maybe you maybe like maybe you should have to run like a laptop at home like a pretty good laptop on you know in like good home internet like that seems like a reasonable requirement um and no you're not you're not going to get to salon a level performance overnight like it's fine like I don't need salon a level performance to just like have a large amount of money on off a and just like use that normally but like two xing the gas limit to start now and just like getting that a few x over the next few years and like getting the blocks you know down to like from 12 seconds to eight seconds and then you know we work our way down to four and two over the next like five years and you get single soft finality and they're like we make a very clear credible commitment today like we're improving the L1 like this is an important thing and we lean into that um I think that is like a very strong product and like a real thing that you can offer um so I I think it makes a lot of sense right here and to like lean into that as the kind of like center of the world computer because I I think that we have sold ourselves a little bit too much of a story over the last couple of years of like don't worry like the old two is going to figure everything out like they're all going to be like these trust lists you know burn the keys on like the governance like stage two perfect roll ups and like a year from now and like everything will be totally trustless like that's not the reality it's not going to happen only it's ever going to happen the majority of them are going to remain like they're going to have keys to upgrade these things like companies are going to want to ship faster going to want a competitive advantage like people are not going to trust these at the same levels in L1 um the they're great like we should still have it a very L2 friendly in L2 kind of like centric vision of you know we're promoting all these things they're necessary but those L2s are not the world's computer you know the the the chain that has you know a few people on the multi-sig and is run by a public company is not the world's computer that like that's like that's coin basis computer which is great it's a great product it's awesome it's very different than you know a chain like Ethereum which you know a place that you know you can get large international financial players like countries issuing CBDCs I fucking hate CBDCs but like they're the extreme example like that's the place where you'd probably issue them if you just like needed like a contract where you're just putting them that kind of thing so I think that's a real thing for Ethereum to lean into and then from there you know you could tell that like that gives you a very coherent like okay this gives us a good grounding for that conversation should we increase the gas limit now I absolutely think that you should if you like if you agree with that argument that I made then you know you know people like don't cry to retreating right now like we should double the gas limit right now like that makes a lot of sense it's obvious we that we should do that and like make a credible commitment to keep scaling over time and I think that doing those things now is a very good forcing function for making us commit to like this is this is the direction that we're going on this thing and at the end of the day this gets back to the like the path dependence of it and you kind of end up committing on all these things in practice I think that's actually the best I think that gives you the highest probability of ETH winning is quote unquote money in the long term is actually just focusing like a little bit less on like the economics and you know shouting money at people right now it's let's just build the world computer you're like if you build that thing and that thing wins like ETH is going to be really valuable like that that's really not going to be an issue at the end of the day and kind of the rest of it falls out from that so that's directly like the kind of the argument that I was laying out in there Mike what do you think about this direction for Ethereum or any new direction for Ethereum any new north star I don't really have many notes on that I think it's an interesting thought experiment to think about how the beam right there was Justin Drake unveiled the beam chain at DevCon listen to the great episode that you did with him there were mixed reviews I would say on beam chain generally as a mostly negative there was a good amount of pushback I imagine if he had one point had a slide with the three different buckets of what the hearings roadmap was focused on there was block production cryptography and I can't remember what the middle one was but I do remember he had p zero p one p two in each of these three boxes and at the bottom in red was faster slot times so four seconds lot times and it wasn't single slot finality but it was a shorter time three in three slots yeah and then like fix the issues was at the top fix the issues was at the top I wonder as a thought experiment if he had just reversed the prioritization on that what the response from the community would have been just sit and ask yourself that I I said don't think it would have been better maybe maybe a little better I think it would have been because all of these like I think I'm I'm with you on this idea that focus on world computer it's a it's a single coherent thing that that people can get to but again to me these these are all one thing you know like the mega trend I think you know David you mentioned we're in this world of crumbling fiat currency the way that I have united these two viewpoints at least in my head of there's a tech component to this and a money component to this is there is the big driver of capital into this space is concerned around fiat currency and that's what's moving capital into L ones and that's why I think on a long time horizon this whole discussion that we're having doesn't really matter I base I basically think these L ones are gonna go up over a period of time but then ultimately people are gonna start asking these questions and they're gonna matter right and I think that Ethereum has chosen again the right viewpoint here there there is a meme discussion about is this a meme and does this really do anything or is there actual utility here and I could give you a million analogs and traffic that would tell you that ultimately on a long time horizon the market size for assets that are productive and have some amount of utility is much larger than the meme assets and so Ethereum has done everything right it's just this even subtle shift in reorientation in terms of leaning into that originally correct vision of providing more utility generating fees that type of thing and I agree with I agree with John that the right way to get there is this world computer move some activity back to the L1 vision as far as the talk that's what I think was messing it I I actually agree as a result of what what we agree on as the vision that I would flip those priorities the main thing that I think was lacking was just he didn't say what the vision was it was the right it was the epitome of I I agree with most of the things that were in that roadmap on like some timescale and like that that's cool um but like the example I gave in the paper was like the reason why something like the merge or the beamchain campaign in North Star is because you know you can't pitch Ethereum to someone is like this is the chain that by 2030 is going to have a ZK consensus and single slot finality and like fix our issuance like like that's not a compelling vision the right the vision that like a user wants to hear is like okay but why like what does it do for me I'm saying it's like we're doing all these things because we are building the world computer and this is going to be the place like this is going to be the home of global finance and like you are going to use this thing and like this is going to be where you store all your money and like it's going to be great and you know computer in the sky that like that makes sense um so I think just like giving that vision is largely what we're missing and the rest is kind of down should you yeah and not to introduce this nuance at the end of this podcast but there is a difference I think in between vision and goals and a vision honestly one of the the guys who comes up with the best visions in the world is Elon Musk where if you look up look up what the vision of Tesla is right it isn't to create the best electronic car in the world it is to accelerate the adoption of green energy the vision the vision for SpaceX is not to transport weight into space at half the cost that it takes you know whoever to do it today Boeing to do it today and I they can't do anything it's to move humanity you do need this long term huge like inspires people to get out of bed in the morning a lining vision a lining vision correct but then what you ultimately need on a shorter term time horizon is okay but I need to agree that I'm working to on a two-year time horizon right right we still need to sell satellites and it sells in like actually delivering satellites in just space now to make money now yeah so we can mark the Macon ice Mars later exactly because everyone needs to know how their work funnels up into that big vision and okay the Elon Musk getting on stage and saying we're going to move everyone to Mars in 20 years everyone's like let's go Elon okay but then the SpaceX engineer that wakes up and thinks about their job on a two-year time horizon used to know what am I doing to contribute to that and so you need these two you need the vision and then you need the goals that roll up into the vision yeah guys it's been great thank you for John thank you for writing the post things are coming on and helping unpack it and then Mike thank you for joining me and helping me out here yeah this has been great thanks guys thank you too thank you thank you thank you guys know the deal crypto is risky you can lose what you put in but we are headed west into the frontier with an unknown north star that maybe we we know by the end of this year maybe next year but we glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot