✨ THESIS FOR 2023:
https://messari.io/crypto-theses-for-2023
—— Ryan Selkis is presenting his Crypto Theses for 2023 on today’s State of the Nation.
Every year, Ryan publishes a massive document that wraps up the year in the industry, and looks forward to what’s coming next.
After an insane 2022, what does 2023 hold in store? Ryan Selkis of Messari brings the answers.
------ 📣 Kraken | The Crypto Exchange for Everyone http://k.xyz/bankless-pod
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/?utm_source=banklessshowsyt 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: https://availableon.com/bankless
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
👯 DESO | DECENTRALIZED SOCIAL BLOCKCHAIN https://bankless.cc/Deso
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
📡 TRUEFI | CRYPTO FINANCIAL HUB https://bankless.cc/TrueFi
👾 SEQUENCE | ALL-IN-ONE PLATFORM https://bankless.cc/Sequence
⚡️FUEL | THE MODULAR EXECUTION LAYER https://bankless.cc/fuel
------ Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 7:00 Pain 10:05 Crypto is Still Inevitable 16:00 Surviving Winter, Redux 20:10 Who to Watch 26:30 How People Fall 32:20 CeFi Contagion 40:30 Institutional Capital 47:00 SEC vs ETF 51:30 SBF and Crypto Policy 1:03:00 Bitcoin 1:07:40 Smart Contracts 1:11:45 ETH Killers 1:15:00 DeFi Trends 1:19:30 DAOs and NFTs 1:24:00 Back to Crypto 1:26:30 The Block and Crypto Media
------ Resources:
Crypto Theses for 2023 https://messari.io/crypto-theses-for-2023
Ryan Selkis https://twitter.com/twobitidiot
Messari https://messari.io/
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Brian Seltkis is bringing on his crypto thesis for 2023 in today's episode. Fantastic way to end the year and look at the next year. David, what are we talking about today? Every single year, Brian Seltkis comes with a massive document that is a fantastic way to snapshot the year. It always feels like this document that comes out every single year out of Missouri that Brian Seltkis spends weeks producing. It's a great way to tie a bow on one year and look forward into the next. So while this is a snapshot of 2022, it is also Brian's 2022 crypto thesis. And so this is just for all of the tunnel vision that we've got focusing on SPF and FTX and contagion.
This is a nice way to zoom all the way back and talk about just the trends across the industry, which will remind the bank listeners. It's very broad and wide. So trends in Bitcoin, trends in Ethereum, trends in DeFi, trends in NFTs, trends in CFI and got an unpack. We do have to unpack the regulatory landscape, the gray scale and DCG landscape and a number of other different topics such as who to pay attention to in 2023. If you were on that list, that prior list, who to pay attention to in 2021 in 2022, it was either a very good or bad to be on either way. Who you are. Yeah, exactly. Guys, speaking of who to pay attention to, we think you should be paying attention to our friends and sponsors over at Kraken.
David, this is a crypto platform that didn't rug people in 2022. And they've been at this for like 10 years, providing secure, solid service. Well, it feels like everyone else was a number of other competitors were getting distracted by the newest bright shining object in crypto. Kraken was just serving the industry without fail and really remained a rock during 2022. What should our listeners know about Kraken, David? Yeah, after interviewing Jesse Powell and investigating a little bit more into Kraken, the ethos behind what Kraken is really aligns with me and makes me feel good about having them as our strategic sponsor moving forward into 2023.
So this is going to be a long term ongoing relationship because the way that they are building that exchange is I think the product that the crypto industry deserves, especially with their emphasis on user verification of exchange liabilities is aligned with the ethos of crypto where we use cryptography to empower individuals to verify don't trust. And so we think this is a great strategic sponsor for bankless moving forward into 2023 and we're excited to work with Kraken moving forward. And if you would like to learn more about Kraken, there is a link in the show notes to go and get started with Kraken also Kraken.
com. Okay, David, in addition to the thesis that we go over with Ryan Selkis, there's also kind of a bonus section to this episode where we ended the episode. We finished, we hit the stop recording button, but there's one question I really wanted to ask him, the question about crypto media and this news about the block, which is a crypto media publication being secretly owned by SBF. So we get into some of that as well in a bonus episode that will provide for bankless listeners. But apart from that, what else should folks be aware of going to this episode? Yeah, it's just a broad trend download.
So it moves pretty fast. Ryan's got some very broad takes and because of how ingrained in this industry, he is, he can connect so many different parts of the industry to other parts of the industry. And that's really the way to get a broad snapshot of what the hell is the state of crypto at the end of 2022 and moving forward into 2023. We talk about CZ and Brian as the last in the remaining exchange leaders. We talk about Anatoli and the state of the Solana ecosystem. We go through the anatomy of a crypto credit crisis and Selkis calls the gray scale trade crypto's widow maker. There's just so many topics to pay attention to.
And just as you are listening to this listener, remember that all of these topics in crypto, hyper thread with each other. We are one industry. We are this is one spot. And so the trends in C5 relate to the trends in D5 relate to the trends in NFTs. So as you are paying attention to this, make sure to connect all of the dots to all the other dots that we are talking about as we go through this podcast. All right, guys, we're going to get right to our episode with Ryan Selkis. But before we do, we want to tell you about these tools to help you go backless. The brave wallet is your secure multitrain on-ramp into Web3.
And it's built directly into the brave privacy browser. Gone are the days of managing multiple wall extensions that put you at risk of phishing, spoof, and tracking. With the brave wallet, you can securely manage your crypto assets across more than 100 different chains, including Ethereum, Layer 2, Solana, and more, all without downloading risky extensions. The brave wallet is easy to set up and removes the headache of jumping between wallets and extensions. It's lightweight, but packed with great features like built-in token swaps, buying and holding NFTs with a gallery view, and support for hardware wallets.
But also, much more than that, because brave is shipping new features every single month, with the mission to make Web3 easier to navigate for its over 55 million users. Wall extensions are the thing in the past. So get started with brave's Web3 ready browser today and experience a decentralized web seamlessly without all the clutter. You can download the browser at brave.com slash bankless and click the wall icon to get started. If you've been listening to bankless, you know that we're fans of the modular blockchain thesis. The idea that blockchain will separate execution from data availability and consensus, allowing all three to become the best versions of themselves.
And Fuel has built the fastest modular execution layer in the industry. By supporting parallel transaction execution, Fuel unlocks significantly faster throughput for the Web3 world. Fuel also goes beyond the limitations of the EVM, with its own Fuel VM, which is more efficient and optimized, opening up the design space for developers. And lastly, Fuel brings a powerful developer experience with its own domain specific language sway and a supportive tool chain called fork. With Fuel, you can have the benefits of smart contract languages like solidity while adopting the improvements made by the rest tooling ecosystem, letting the Fuel development environment go beyond the limitations of the EVM.
If you want to learn more, there's a link in the show notes to see how you can get involved with a Fuel Network. Bankless Nation, we have Ryan Selkis on the episode today and we're diving into his crypto thesis for 2023. Super excited to get into these topics. I've been reading these since forever. Since I've been in crypto, I always jam packed full of insight information. How many pages is this one, Ryan? This one's a beast. I think it's 168, but that includes the cover and the disclaimers and all the other garbage. 168 pages. That's what we're talking for patients. Yeah. Anyway, walking to bankless is great to have you on again.
Okay, a word for the year. David and I were talking about this, but like you got 168 pages, a lot of words. If you were to summarize 2022 and give it a word, what word would you give it? What's something that pops into mind right now? Well, I think that depends if you're looking forward to looking backwards. I think if you're looking at your interview, it's. Let's look backwards. 2022. Pain. Yeah. Okay. Right, Mr. Full, full, full Mr. teaming, right? Pain. I think if you're looking forward, I don't want to call it relief, but I think optimism is a pretty good starting point. And we'll get into that.
I think the big thing that happened this year is the core crypto thesis remains unchanged over the next 10 years. One thing that did slow pretty significantly is, the institutionalization or the wall stratification of crypto. And that's got its benefits and its drawbacks. But I think most of the damage, most of the pain this year was certainly in the latter cap versus the true decentralization and some of those core projects that are going to be the backbone for this economy. David, I like that word. We're debating some words back and forth contagion. You said yield was another hubris short cuts, but I think pain.
That gets right to the point. My God, 2022 is painful. It's a good word because I think it's obviously from the economics of it. It's been a pretty disastrous year for investors. But I remember listening to your podcast when this turmoil was really hitting its peak and just listening to David, I could feel some of that of like, we've been building here for so long. And it's just so fucking disappointing. It's going on. It's like the parent being disappointed, not mad. We're past the anger phase at one point. And I think everybody had some type of moment like that of a dejection in the fall. And once reality settles in and you realize, this is just another con artist, just like anyone else, the industry is going to be just fine.
And the core remains, then you can get to rebuilding and have some optimism for the new year. Ryan, Mr. Salkis, one of the reasons why I like these crypto-theses at the end of the year is that it's such a cohesive and comprehensive snapshot of where we are in time. It's a moment to reflect. It's a moment to look back on 2022 and to make informed takes as to what happens in 2022 and how is it going to determine what 2023 is like. And so you've created a number of different overarching themes. And so looking at the table of contents, I'll just kind of just read out the themes. The top 10 narratives of an investment themes, top 10 people to watch, top 10 trends in CFI, top 10 trends in policy, Bitcoin and crypto dollars, top 10 Ethereum and layer one trends.
And then it continues into the second page, top 10 trends in DeFi, top 10 trends in NFTs and decentralized social, top 10 trends in Dowson Web 3, and then of course some bonus content as well. And so I think we'll definitely going to be touching on the SBF contagion and all the content that bankless listeners and everyone in crypto space has hammered, gotten hammered into the heads of the last few months. But I think what we also want to do is kind of get back to our roots. Let's talk about the trends in DeFi. Let's talk about the trends in NFTs. And so using the URTCs for 2023 and beyond, I think we should just get back to some of the basics of to what is at the very root of this industry using some of the trends that you've identified here.
So to start off this conversation going at the from the top, top 10 narratives and investment themes, there's two sections I wanted to pull out. You open this section with winter is here. It's time to build. And then also a section crypto is still inevitable. And I actually remember I think almost every one of your thesis documents has a section like this, which is the crypto is inevitable section. And it's such a nice refresher to remind ourselves that yo, this technology is coming to steamroll over the world. It's different now because of what's happened in the last year. So Ryan, while you were writing this section about why crypto is still inevitable, what was different this year that really bolstered your confidence to be able to once again say that crypto is still inevitable, why is after all of 2022, why is crypto still inevitable to you?
Well, I think my favorite slide that we've made as a company is this one that's in the deck or in the presentation in that section, which which really lays it out in full detail. And it basically outlines three core drivers, which is generation change. We kind of evolve one year at a time to a more digitally native generation. The second is just the influx of talent that we've seen this cycle. And the level of talent is at a significantly higher mark than we've seen in any cycle previous in terms of business talent, legal, technical, and then there's just dry powder, right? Like real dollars that are on these balance sheets for different projects, whether it's infrastructure, you know, related companies or whether you're talking about the projects themselves and their treasuries.
That wasn't the case last time around, right? Like a lot of these ICOs, they raise an eith, they crash an eith, or they're raised and had these big kind of native token treasuries, but they didn't really have much dry powder. And so, you know, a bunch of projects, you know, fell by the wayside. And then more than anything, you've got a number of stepwise, you know, you know, optics in innovation and like zero to one progress in DeFi, in NFTs, in DAO's, layer two kind of scaling, the Ethereum merge, another cycle of, you know, Bitcoin kind of proving its bonafides as a very censorship-resistant digital commodity that can be a form of money for people and, you know, that need a store of value that they can secure in their head and move across borders with.
And then stablecoins, which continue to have record months, month over month, right? So both the kind of derivatives that sit on top of crypto rails and then many of the crypto primitives themselves have just continued to see, you know, pretty tremendous growth cycle over cycle. And even though the dollar, you know, values are down and now some of the volumes are down, it's still a higher low versus the previous cycle number one. And number two, they're sturdier foundations because of the capital talent and just, you know, compounding growth of open source. So it's, I guess it's like a crypto twist on, you know, Jeff Bezos quip on the stock market and I think Bezos Warren Buffett, you know, maybe it's a few folks he can attribute this to about the market being, you know, a voting machine versus a weighing station, right?
In the long term versus the short term, there are two different things. And we're certainly seeing a lot of people vote for the exit right now, but the weight of crypto is still getting heavier and heavier, right? And I don't think that that's going to change. It's going to be very difficult to displace. So that's one thing that I come back to and for someone that's been through multiple cycles, it's somewhat easier to feel a little bit of relief right now because you almost feel like the air is near fully out of the balloon. And you can kind of get back to, okay, where now that the tide is going to wash out, you see, you know, not only who's swimming naked, but where all the dead bodies are.
And now you know, you know, what was real and what is going to have some staying power that you can build around for the next cycle. And we've seen that in 2013 and 2014 in 2017 and 2018, and we're going to see it again in 21-22. So I think that's glass half full. I think a thing that makes crypto pretty powerful. And on that note of looking backwards as to some of the things that we've said previously in previous market cycles, I just wanted to pull out this quote from the surviving winter redo, Redux. And you are citing yourself that you had written at the top of the bull market. I just want to pull this out here.
In addition to eating big paper or real losses, you'll see people having breakdowns go bankrupt due to over leverage or poor tax planning quit otherwise promising projects turn nasty, depressed, or apathetic and generally lose sight of the longer term potential of crypto. At the same time, the grassroots crypto herd will thin out because it's tougher to wage war when you've lost 90% of your savings and need to find a real job. This was actually not a part of your thesis document. This was a you citing an earlier thing that you wrote at this top of the bull market. And then you continue in your in this thesis for 2023.
And you ask the reader, do you still believe if you're reading this report, there's a good chance that you do, but are now wondering how to best navigate a prolonged winter. The answer is as simple as it is challenging and unglamorous built. In many respects, it's easier to build in bear markets and bull markets. There are fewer distractions. Real product market fit becomes easier to identify without the noise of a token and the weak and flaky contributors wash out of the market. Ryan, I can tell from this section in this document in just knowing you, bear markets excite you. And maybe you could pass a little bit of that excitement onto the listener.
Why should they get excited to build during a bear market? And why is this just another part of the crypto cycles that people that have seen a thing or two like you just know what's up? Well, I would phrase this slightly differently. I'd say the slope of enlightenment excites me, right? I don't take any joy in seeing my personal net worth go down or seeing people get blown up or all these others. Yeah, exactly. I'm not like some of these Twitter space hosts that are just like doom porning just shamelessly and kind of capitalizing in the situation. I think it's somewhat disgusting for people to get some pleasure out of this.
So I certainly wouldn't say that like that part of the bear market, the steep decline, right? This catastrophe that we've had this year is enjoyable. But when you do find a bottom, it's not going to be a v-shape recovery. And some people are going to get apathetic and they'll wash out. But for the rest of us, that's when it feels like, okay, we're more on more stable ground. All of the folks that we didn't really think we're going to be here for the long term if washed out. And the people that we were driving with and that we thought were going to be long term builders and contributors. And we're doing things for the right reasons and really excited about them for the right reasons.
They're still here. And by the way, now they're getting a lot more oxygen and attention. That's I think the exciting part. And if you kind of come in with that mindset, there's plenty of problems to solve within the industry. And every single cycle, the biggest problems from the previous cycle tend to be solved. And the solutions providers end up having the next unicorns in the cycle that ensues. So it's a pretty good entrepreneurial feedback actually. If you're looking for ideas and if you're actually committed to the long term. I think that's worth just emphasizing is that this product feedback cycle and being able to build inside of a bear market where you have so much signal is unique.
It's a unique opportunity during the parts of the cycles during the you don't get that in the manic part of the cycle. What you do get in the bear market is a lot of signal for product builders to understand that they are actually building something inherently useful. And to also take some of the idealized features of what made Emania Emania NFTs, for example, and actually execute on that while shedding some of the the short-term things that only actually last in the peak of a bull market. All right. So Selkis, 10 people to watch. All right. We're in the bear market in this build a season, of course.
Who should we be watching right now? I noticed one of your picks were two exchange operators CZ and Brian Armstrong. And you tied them. They're tied for the number one leaders of the two largest central exchanges left. The central exchanges left. Can you believe SBF would have been on this list a year ago, probably now completely gone, the Coinbase and Binance. So why these two? Why are they two individuals to watch, particularly coming out of this year? Well, it's interesting you say that because last year in the report, I did refer to Coinbase Binance and FTX is the three biggest exchanges to watch maybe.
So we were watching. We were definitely watching for for all the wrong reasons. I think looking backwards, FTX probably had the most hype, institutional momentum and political momentum out of the three. That's obviously come crashing down. I've been exposed to be a Hasakard. The other two remain. But the other two are front and center for I would argue the right reasons. And that's because of their volumes and trading dominance, being Binance, and then their custody market share being Coinbase. Because Coinbase is a mega custodian in its own right. But it also custodys the gray scale trust. So it has 11% of all the Bitcoin and circulation, 16% of all the ETH, 11% of maybe the other camp of crypto.
So it is just a massive market participant, which everybody knows. But just to put that in perspective, you know, you are talking about 10% of the economy and crypto centrally is safeguarded by Coinbase. So how those two CEOs kind of navigate the next couple of years, I think is going to be pretty critical. And for CZ, I think the challenges are really going to be headline risk related and regulatory and legal in nature. I think that there's a lot of fear uncertainty doubt around Binance right now. We've seen this in the last couple of weeks, really pick up steam. And my nuance take of whether that's good or bad is I think it's overblown.
I think the the foot is overblown, but I think it's good if it reduces that market share. And it disperses some of that trading volume because it is I think unhealthy for the industry to have that much reliance on kind of one centralized exchange. And I would actually argue that for Binance, they will be healthier if there are several other, you know, very large competitors that are kind of going back and forth to them in terms of the volume lead. With Coinbase, you know, it's somewhat similar, but I think their fate and really their success is going to hinge on the U.S. regulatory situation and how effectively they're able to thread the needle the next couple of years, assuming that we don't get comprehensive legislation.
I don't expect that we're going to get comprehensive oversight legislation, you know, basically until we we have a new administration. And we can maybe get into that in the policy section. The next character that we wanted to pull out of this section is that that was number one. Number one tied for first with CZ and Brian Armstrong. I wanted to skip over to number five, Anatoli Yakovenko. And the quote that I really liked here was that I saw firsthand how hard it was to kill Anatoli and his team in the last bear market. In my eyes, that's the leading predictor of long-term success in crypto. As such, I'd expect the Solana core team and ecosystem to persevere once again.
But can they ascend to new heights? Ryan Selkis, could you unpack a little bit as to how and why you put Anatoli in Solana as the number five person to watch in 2023? I think that they were the largest Alts, they were, or are the largest Alts L1 community that is an EVM compatible, right? So in terms of other base layer blockchains that are using a fundamentally different design than Ethereum, I think Solana has been the project to watch and it's certainly attracted arguably the second most developer attention outside of Ethereum. It had an absolutely crazy parabolic run in 2021, but there's also been quite a bit of innovation around that community.
And interestingly, they've made a big effort in mobile, right? I think what they're doing with the Solana phone and the Solana mobile stack is a differentiator and it is pretty interesting and attracting developer talent if you're excited about your bringing crypto to the masses through handheld devices because you can't necessarily trust Apple and Android or are going to let those apps through. So I think for those reasons, it is in a league of its own in some respects, you can look at where it stands from a market cap ranking now and it's obviously slid pretty significantly, especially given the size of stake that FTX had.
A lot of those early investors, there could be some overhangs, some cell side pressure that's still embedded in that ecosystem when you're just talking about the token, but when you're talking about the developers and the tech, I would say that they are the leading contender for the second crypto operating system, if you will. Cosmos being similarly situated, maybe slightly behind. And traditionally, that's what you've seen in mobile and the browser wars and PC operating systems. You've seen two major players and this do optically and then basically a pretty steep order of magnitude drop off for the other players after that.
So will they be able to consolidate some of that market ownership around this second Alts L1 stack? So on this people to watch thing, what's interesting is how quickly people in this industry can go from hero to villain? And so last year on your list, Dokwan actually made number 10. And these are people to watch. These are not necessarily people that I know you are saying like, I don't know if people want to be on my, I don't know if people want to be on this list. It's not necessarily a good thing. Yeah, this is like the SI cursor, the Madden cursor, I think. But also, but, but, but, but also, um, you know, Sam was on a two years ago.
Barry was on two years ago. Suzu Kyle Somani. What, what do you make of this, right? It's like it's just this whole people to watch. There's an element of yes, I totally agree, Brian Armstrong and CZR people to watch. We want to understand what they're saying. And also, a major mistake I feel like we've made this, this, um, uh, bull cycle is we paid too much attention to these demagogues and to these, you know, Icarus, hubris types of individual, individuals who kind of rallied, uh, uh, uh, rallied pop, you know, populist messages and, you know, Twitter armies, all of these things. Um, so I agree that we want to watch people, but also like what, what do you make of that dimension?
Should we be not watching people? Should like the actual people to be watched should it just be the protocols? Or what is this interplay between, you know, people and code and the tech and how much this industry is led by leaders versus, um, how much we want it to be in the hands of individuals and, and completely decentralized. It's just a thought for you because like it's so interesting to see how quickly in the space, people you thought were pinnacle, right? I mean, SBF coming into 2022. Um, this guy was unstoppable. This guy was somebody that Brian Armstrong, CZR could not stop. And now where is he?
He's literally in jail as we're recording this. How the mighty fall so quickly? What are your reflections on that? Well, don't do meth. Um, is number one. Um, and the other, um, or whatever amphetamine he was on, I don't, I don't want to get sued for, for mislabeling the drug here again. But, um, well, it's, it's interesting. So I have a couple, I have a couple of thoughts here. One, if you're talking about relatively static tech or, or, or static ecosystems, I know the Bitcoin community is going to skewer me for this, but then you don't need leaders as much, right? Then it is much more community driven.
Um, I think, you know, Satoshi was able to disappear and Bitcoin is, is operating just fine. And it has, has major upgrades over the years, but it has not truly had a leader, you know, since he disappeared, right? Um, Ethereum as decentralized as community is, Vitalik is still the figurehead and the leader and the person that people look to, he's, he's kind of the culture, you know, uh, standard setter for, for that community and still sets the vision in, in large part. Um, and, uh, I think, you know, when you, when you look at, you know, people to watch is, is, you know, pretty much shorthand for, you know, uh, what does that person represent, right?
Um, in, in Brian and CZ's case this year, it's like, okay, the two exchange operators that have the biggest, you know, targets on their back, and, and they're holding the, the greatest weight of the industry on their shoulders, right? So I think thematically, they fit as like, the people to watch is the canaries and the coal mine. But I think looking backwards at like, who's, who's risen and, and who's fallen, um, it is, I think, good to draw lessons from history, right? So, you know, SBF was on the list. Um, Dokwan was on the list in, in prior years, um, Susu was on the list. But they flew too close to the sun and they overextended or, or got greedy or, or made some catastrophic error in judgment or, you know, in, in, you know, in, in, in, in, in some way, shape form, judgment, you know, ethics or business or otherwise.
Um, there are other people that have been hit hard, but it's just because the market corrected viciously, right? You know, so you mentioned Kyle, um, you know, CMS holdings, you know, they were, they were in that same category of Susu. Look, I'm sure they like us, probably lost a lot of money this year, but they didn't get extinguished, right? Because they, they weren't overlevered and, um, and, and they're still operating. I'm sure they're going to get through this cycle and, and, and, so be here for the long term. Um, so it's interesting to, to kind of draw lessons from like, okay, who, who flamed out spectacularly versus who was just at such a high that they basically had nowhere to go, but correct in the next year.
Those people that don't really think are targets for ducks, the ones that were on a pedestal had everything, the world in their hands, and then got knocked off from their own hubris. Big difference, right? Fair, fair game. And, and I think it's good that we have those case studies, you know, each cycle so that, you know, people can point to priors and say, you know, this person is reminding me, I'm, I'm, I'm pattern matching a little bit too much with this new person that looks and feels a lot like Mark Carpellis did or looks and feels a lot like SPF did or Doquan did or, you know, whatever. And, um, uh, and we're, but because our history is speed run, right?
We don't even need to go to the outside world for, for examples. Um, we can, usually there's, there's like a crypto equivalent that people can tie back to. I'd really, another, another person, by the way, I'd really love to get your thoughts on later in the show is Barry Silver because he's, he's sort of somewhere that's not maybe someone in the middle of these things, right? Um, well, I'm not, I'm not going to comment on him in particular, uh, for, for different reasons, but I'll, I'll comment on, on the situation at DC juniors. Let's definitely get to that later. But David, you might get this moving.
That actually is exactly where we are going next. Okay. Uh, the next section here is top 10 trends in CFI. And what was 2022 other than contagion across CFI lending desks? Uh, and, uh, Rhino, uh, Silcus, you, uh, the first section that you bring up is called anatomy of a crypto credit crisis and it's got this great graphic that I'll show on screen here in a second. The quote that I really liked that you opened with is the grayscale trade, the GBTC trade. We've talked about this a little bit on bank list. The gayscale, gray scale trade, aka crypto's widow maker was integral in helping create much of the crypto contagion we saw this year, starting with grayscale and GBTC.
Can you walk us through this flow chart that you've, uh, put into your TC stock that we're also looking out on screen? Uh, can you walk us through this autopsy? Like what, what happened in 2022? Well, I'll, I'll start with the punchline, which is this is all the SEC's fault and I truly mean that. But, um, but, uh, so basically, grayscale came public and offered these trust products, was able to raise money from accredited investors as accredited investors could create shares of GBTC by sending grayscale Bitcoin and, um, they took those shares public through something called rule 144 and, and it's kind of like a side door ETF.
With an ETF, you can create and redeem baskets of shares daily, right? So these synthetic instruments, these shares are going to map basically one to one with whatever the value that Bitcoin is that's in the trusts. Through rule 144, you had this bifurcation of the market where accredited investors can create shares, but then they have to wait six months and then they can sell them and that's when retail investors can get their hands on them. For a while, there was more demand than supply for the shares because people, one of them in their 401ks, or there just wasn't really public market access to Bitcoin exposure for a long time.
And so, you know, for years, you had a 10, 20, 30, 50 percent premium at times. I'm GBTC shares versus the underlying value. Some funds, including three hours capital and BlockFi saw that and started to think, hmm, well, we can just run this trade, you know, over and over again and clip the premium every six months. And then in 2018, there were some, you know, the introduction of the crypto lending desks and, and that included Genesis capital, which is a sister company of grayscale and all under the same DCG umbrella. But basically, we got into a situation in, you know, 2021 where three hours capital and BlockFi borrowed, you know, or created new shares of GBTC with leverage, whether it was with outside lender or with Genesis capital slammed this trade and then all of a sudden, the, the premium started to slowly collapse.
And as soon as it started to come down, it fell off a cliff because one of those entities or some of those investors that were hitting that trade decided to offload their entire position in February 2021, that premium went from about a 25 percent premium to a 15, 20 percent discount and the matter of like a week. So it essentially killed the trade and, and again, it turned this grayscale trade, which was a profitable trade, but not arbitrage because you were taking duration risk, you know, time risk and it turned it into what we call the Widowmaker trade. At that point, three AC and BlockFi had combined about four billion dollars worth of GBTC shares.
So now those levered positions are underwater versus the underlying trust assets. But again, because this isn't an ETF, the only path the liquidity is through the shares, right? It's in an ETF, you would be able to, if you had a discount like this persist, redeem those shares for the trust assets. That doesn't happen through rule 144. It hypothetically could, that's a longer, more detailed story for that's that's going to bear it in the report. But but the long short of it is now you've got these lenders or these, these borrowers in size that barred a ton of money to create this grayscale trade.
Now they're impaired to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars. The only lender in the market perhaps that would have looked at them as somewhat credit worthy would have to be an entity that's related to grayscale because from their perspective, Dennis's capital, it's money from one pocket to the other, right? They know that their sister company has the assets and the grayscale trust. They know that whether it's six months from now, five years from now, grayscale controls the redemption mechanism. So they would be able to look a little bit more favorably upon GBTC shares now as collateral instead of the underlying Bitcoin.
And so this is where the spiral started because three eras capital, I think block fight to a lesser extent, but especially three AC began to basically just roll the trade over and say, you know what, we're going to just roll all of this on all these underwater shares with Genesis capital. And if you're Genesis capital, you're like, this is this is great business because you know, if you charge in three AC five percent a year on two billion dollars in shares, that's a good line of business. And that's basically an annuity. It's like a hundred million dollars a year guaranteed and captive as long as that discount persists unless and until like an ETF has approved and that that window would close.
So it created this really kind of, you know, weird dynamic in the market. And I think it was one of the first things that really set off some risk for for three AC. Now having said all that, I don't think that there's anything that this is really kind of a comedy of errors or just like a perfect storm, right? That this sequence that happened because that by itself would not have been enough to do in three eras capital, right? They had to make another couple of really bad toxic synthetic bets in Lunatera and then in state D thief in Q2 of this year that ultimately set them put them under. But remember, I mean, they they were in avalanche, they were it seemed like they could do no wrong with all their other crypto related trades and investments in 2021.
So even that big number, a hundred million dollars a year in interest, if that's what it was, right? I'm just using it as a ballpark. That would have been, you know, easy to absorb in the context of what people thought was a ten billion dollar fund. But you fast forward and you get to Q2 of this year, Lunatelapses, it turns three AC bad and then the bad credit really starts to just line up like Domino's one after the other. That ultimately creates, you know, forces genesis to reclaim or kind of call all the collateral, the GBTC shares that, you know, three AC had pledged as collateral in the trade.
It, you know, ultimately still leaves a hole in the genesis balance sheet. There's a crisis in confidence in BlockFi at the same time. There's a run on BlockFi. Voyager has a bunch of exposure to three ACs, you know, some of the other lenders, you know, kind of all go under like one after the other after the other. And then we have a little bit of a breather, right? So it looks like all the bad credit is watched out in Q2. But we come to find out months later that that wasn't quite the full story because we still had to deal with this backstop between digital currency group and genesis. When genesis had this billion dollar hole blown in it from three ACs bankruptcy, DCG absorbed the liability and then they had an inter, you know, company loan.
And now that's, you know, kind of created some issues in the aftermath of the FTX collapse and some withdrawal rapid withdrawals from genesis on the part of their creditors. That's created a run in the bank with DCG or sorry with genesis which could impact both genesis and DCG. What do you think is going to happen in that run that the DCG empire? I mean, that's kind of the the last thing people are, well, hopefully the last thing people are trying to figure out from this massive contagion event of 2022 is DCG going to be able to make it like and if so sort of how, you know, people still can't give any retail listeners listening who deposited into the Gemini earn account.
They still can't withdraw their funds and that's all wrapped up into this too. Do you have any takes on how this might unfold? I think it's actually pretty promising that we haven't seen any bankruptcy filings or proceedings or anything like that in the last few weeks. You know, we're outside of the 30-day window that's kind of standard in some kind of cure periods for depending on the lender. You don't know what the specific agreements were between genesis and its creditors or DCG and genesis like all that's a little bit of a black box. So we'd run some analyses just based on public information on DCG and grayscale and then what we knew about the genesis fund raising needs and basically you come out to a situation where DCG could either recapitalize the business but at a 90% reduction in equity value versus where they raised money last year or you reach a resolution with the genesis creditors directly.
And at this point, given the market softness and how multiples are coming down and how people have cooled on crypto and this being a distressed situation, I think the path to a resolution here probably swings on whether the creditors are able to make a good offer and they're able to come to a resolution where genesis creditors take some partial liquidity today and then maybe roll some of their exposure into DCG or otherwise have kind of upside and can be made whole through the other healthy businesses and healthy assets that are under the DCG umbrella. So you think they're going to make it? You think the probability is that they could make it through this?
I don't want to speculate. So I'll be I'll be coy and I'll say 50-50. I think it's a coin flip. You know, the the issue is remember, you know, if right now DCG has two different options. One, you try your hand in court and try to limit the liability that you have with this bad subsidiary and you basically let them go bankrupts. The other, so that's kind of like the hard ball play, it's very risky because DCG was itself a borrower from genesis. So they, you know, are one step removed from owing all of these creditors, you know, capital. The other is there's, you know, some resolution with the creditors and so it's a little bit of a game of chicken, chess, whatever you want to call it, but it's not as if a resolution with creditors is a panacea for DCG because it's still going to create a new, you know, massive either liability or preferred, you know, instrument at the holding company level that, you know, could hypothetically wipe out a good chunk of equity value if things go sideways in next few years for DCG.
So I think that answers a big question that I kind of had, which was, is this whole potential DCG bankruptcy going to overhang the crypto industry kind of in the same way that Malcox did for so long and in a way still does. And from what I'm, the tone I'm hearing from you is that it's not really going to overhang all that much. Maybe there's some bad stuff, but for like overhanging self pressure, not that much. I think that there are some similarities in the reaction, not in the structure, right? Like these are totally, totally different, you know, stories, but in terms of the damage it has done potentially in the worst case scenarios of this resolution are somewhat similar to the worst case reactions that we saw after Malcox, right?
Like, Malcox was not, it actually wasn't that damaging at the time because from a market pressure standpoint, because the funds had been slowly let away over the course of years, right? And people just didn't know that the funds weren't there. So it is asked for everyone that lost money, right? But it was not necessarily like a situation where you just saw hundreds of millions of Bitcoin hit the market and kind of instantly become sellable because they were hacked. With this situation, and then in the aftermath of Malcox, we had the bit license and we got a bunch of jurisdictions become hostile to crypto and took quite a bit of time for rest of the make progress after that.
I think with the DCG Genesis situation, you know, one of the issues that we're confronting with this, and one of the reasons I think we need like a good positive resolution is you've got Gemini as one of the primary creditors. Gemini earned customers are owed about $900 million. And now you're pulling in US retail. There's another similar earn-like program that I think was just reported on last week through a European exchange, BitVavo, where they have 300 million in a similar earn-like program. So that could potentially pull in the European regulators, right? And we're running out of bodies right now, and generally like warm bodies and leaders in the industry.
And DCG is extremely well connected. They've got Larry Summers as an advisor. They've got Glenn Hutchins. He's golfing buddies with Obama on their board. And then Gemini is one of the best regulated exchanges and custodians in the US. So you're starting to lose just like one too many chess pieces on the chess board in terms of like the adults in the room. If you can't figure out if there can't be some kind of adequate resolution here. So I don't think about it as economically damaging in terms of there's more credit contagion risk still in the market. I think that's probably mostly washed out.
But now we're at the part of the cycle where the black eyes are going to be potentially permanent in nature if they get encoded into law. And I think that's the biggest concern right now on the reason everybody should be rooting for some amicable resolution here. Okay. So this is the top trends in Define just to gift draft. This C5X, he's being the top trends in C5X, just to wrap this in a bow. You call the gray scale trade the Widowmaker. But he also said this was all the SEC's fault, all Gary Gensers fault. Could Gary have really waved a magic wand and just convert that GBTC thing into an ETF?
And this whole arbitrage mess crap all the fallout would have been solved. I know that doesn't help FTX necessarily in all of the other contagion. But would that have made the Widowmaker not make any Widows? If we had a spot ETF, none of this would have happened. None of it is way, yeah, wait, what do you mean none of it? Three O's capital wouldn't have over leveraged. Sandbank been freed would have been a fraud or like what specifically would have happened? I mean, think about the impairment the three AC had, right? You know, you're talking about mid nine figures worth of impairment plus all of the interest payment that they had as they had to continue to bar against these shares over the course of the last year.
So this was a significant, you know, going to dead weight loss for them. But, you know, the flip side is, yeah, I'm sure they made money money on it in the beginning. The fact remains that this asset being publicly traded well, I mean, at its peak, it was a $40 billion trust, right? That the retail investors are able to invest in. And it's just become like hot potato collateral for, you know, some of many of the entities that have blown up are faced significant distress this year. And at the end of the day, who's holding the bag, it's a bunch of folks that are holding GBTC, you know, and their retirement accounts, right?
There's almost a million GBTC shareholders that would benefit from the conversion to an ETF, which is the equivalent of a snap of the fingers of the SEC. It just has to do with treating spot ETFs the same way that they treat these, you know, insane, you know, CFTC derived derivative ETFs, these futures ETFs that are garbage. Do you think, do you think Ryan that like, again, so looked at this and was just like, you know, I don't know, evil villain in kind of an armchair somewhere and just like let them burn. That's what crypto gets like, I could fix this, but I won't. Is it, is it that sort of nefariousness going on here?
Do you think he really has an end for the industry? Or is this all bureaucracy and, you know, just couldn't get to the ETF? I'll give the like, you know, conniving version and then the, and then from like the regular, the most charitable version, I guess, for someone like Chair Gunsler. The most charitable version is we are not going to break policy, which is we don't have oversight of the exchanges that are trading these spot instruments. And we're certainly not going to reward bad behavior, right? So just because this trade existed and created a bunch of problems like that is, that is not our doing, right?
This was a loophole that was exploited. You've made your, you know, you've made your bed now laying it. That's, I think, you know, the one hand and essentially it's just default. No. The other is that, you know, this setback and this continued pain is, you know, arguably a good thing because it shows, it backs their position and it just shows the other, you know, policy makers that they're trying to convince. Look, this is how unwieldy this crypto market is. We need full oversight of all of the centralized players and these things are either securities or having an impact on the securities markets.
So it makes sense to empower XYZ regulator that already has this oversight responsibility and these other adjacent areas with, with the same power so we can clean this up. And so, yeah, I mean, unfortunately, like, I don't really see there being a resolution anytime soon. But now you've got a situation where, you know, GBTC shareholders are 50, 50 percent under water. And the only people that win are, you know, kind of intuitively, it's, it's DCG through grayscale, right? Because they're still making their, you know, $300 million a year on these trusts. And, and the SEC, because we're able to play hardball and use this as a negotiating trip for the, their long term position.
Well, I think this underhands us right into this policy conversation, the policy section. So wrapping it, tying a bow on the 10 trends of CFI, we're going to go into the trends in crypto policy. And there's a number of sections in here all about SPF and the insider baseball. Without giving too much of the juicy details away, Ryan Selkis, can you kind of just like, I know you, you are very involved with policy in Capitol Hill and, and like, that whole world, can you kind of just like summarize the insider baseball that was going on that we are still learning about to this day? Yeah, like what happened?
Yeah, what? What? One for the real? What? Like, yeah, what? No, seriously, like, I mean, SPF wrote that post. There's talk of the DCCPA. We had him debate on Voorhees, like, on the podcast, defending that position. And then 11 days later, he turns out to be short, $10 billion. Like, what happened? Well, I think that's the last 20% of the, of the right up because this really started in, in the fall, I think, you know, even folks within kind of DC policy circles for a while underestimated how far the FTX team had been able to push DCCPA, right? This, this stab it out Bozeman bill. And it, it really started to become more apparent in September.
We actually hosted a policy dinner around Mainnet and, you know, supposed to just be kind of a celebratory dinner, look how far we've come since the infrastructure bill. We had a bunch of speakers in town that were from the policy side. So, you know, someone dropped the bomb during the dinner and essentially said, you know, can we just talk about the elephant in the room? You know, Sam's trying to sell out the industry and create a monopoly for himself. And it was, yeah, I mean, it was, it was, it was, it was wild. Like, it was, you know, you could have heard a pin drop type of moment. And, but it ended up being very healthy because you got a lot of people talking, you know, for all reasons, right?
Like, it was, you know, it was, it was an interesting night after that. But, in the aftermath of that, I think, you know, people kind of woke up to, you know, how close they were getting. And, and, you know, several people myself included, you know, started to push Sam and, um, and the FTX team to, to start being a little bit more open with, with some of the other groups, particularly those in the DeFi side. And so, you know, there was a number of, you know, meetings that, you know, the casual like armchair observer on, on, you know, Twitter is going to say, oh, it's a smoke-filled room or it's this or that of the other thing.
It's like, no, you had a situation where one entity was making enormous strides because of all the political investments they'd made. And, um, and a lot of people were not necessarily, you know, in, in tune. And a lot of those other people that, that, you know, were, were able to get in touch and start, um, comparing notes with FTX after, you know, this dinner and after these meetings were representatives of major DeFi projects or some of the other major trade associations. Um, and, and, and the hope was that we were, we were going to be able to make some progress in the DeFi language in, in, in DCCPA as drafted.
Then when things leaked, um, you know, all the help kind of broke loose. Sam couldn't stop talking about it and the circle retightened. Um, and what I think, you know, there's, you know, there's, you know, there's, I'm not going to name names, but there's a couple of people in the industry that are pat themselves on the back for, you know, basically like, oh, it, you know, it took, took down like SPF by, you know, doing this or, or, you know, we, we stopped the DCCPA because, you know, we, we kind of blew the whistle on this and, and brought the, brought the fight to crypto Twitter. I'm telling you right now, that's nonsense.
The thing that stopped the DCCPA, the FTX bankruptcy. It was, it had nothing to do with the leak. The only thing that the leak did was tighten the circle of people that were going to contribute from that on out. And it could have been pretty damaging if this had gotten pushed through the lame ducts. So we dodged a bullet. We got lucky, I think, with FTX. And I'm not going to really spend much time arguing counterfactuals, but I had a few people call me out. And so I decided to do the full post-mortem since I was in some of those rooms. And, and that's what happened. Yeah, I haven't read all of that.
And I want, like, that's so interesting to me, but, but like, zooming out was SPF really just kind of a puppeteer trying to control the, the, the strings in DC and like benefit his, his own exchange over D5. Was he basically pulling up the ladder after, you know, it climbed up it, pulling up for everyone else. Was there something nefarious going on here? Or, you know, is that not the case? It's, it's just very tempting to look at everything he's doing now under that lens and be like, wow, this guy is, you, you called them political investments. It's, yeah, it's basically don't campaign donations, right?
Yeah. Look, I mean, I think he was playing a game, right? And, and by the way, he was playing it very well, right? Regardless of, of, you know, just like a McAvallion type game. Yeah, it was a very Mac McAvallion type game. I think that he was looking out for, you know, his own self-interest, but every single company that lobbies, right? And every single company, you know, that is, is kind of advocating for themselves in the policy side is doing that out of self-interest, right? Now, there's operating out of self-interest and then there's operating out of self-interest and only self-interest, right?
And I think that's a difference with some of the other big crypto companies, you know, you've, you've seen Brian Armstrong tweet about, you know, not pulling a ladder up on DeFi, right? Like we have to protect, like he has every incentive to make sure that good exchange oversight legislation gets passed because he is the incumbent, going bases the incumbent. But if that's going to be at the expense of all the long-term innovation in the, in the industry, I think, you know, he recognizes, for instance, that, that's the long-term detriment of his business as well because you're talking about the growth of the industry.
FTX was a little bit different because they also had this relationship with IEX and then, you know, Tom Emmer has been all over this. You guys should listen to, to the interview that, you know, Representative Tom Emmer just did with Nick Carter on the, on the Brink podcast, but he goes off. And I mean, he, it's, it sounds like he wants to, you know, go after Chair Gunsler hard in the year. But essentially, you know, saying, you know, okay, there's all these self-deilings between this, you know, securities exchange, you know, IEX and FTX was, you know, where they basically lobbying for FTX to have CFTC oversight and then IEX to have a monopoly over the crypto securities market.
And then these two would be joined at the hip, they'd have to factor monopoly on the whole thing. And yeah, there's, there's, that's definitely, you know, I don't know, maybe that's a possibility. My point in writing this is, there was not a single piece of, of Sam's business that he didn't know exactly what's going on. He is extremely smart. He thought that he knew, like he, he, he thought that he saw the entire chessboard, you know, he, he seemed to have his finger on the pulse of, of kind of the politics of the situation and, and this particular bill. And you know, when he was in meetings with his policy team, the policy team was the supporting cast.
He was the one predominantly that spoke and kind of led the discussion. So it's just like he was kind of following the advice of like the folks in his policy team. I'm sure he was, right? But he was also very much leading these discussions. And, and he, he seemed to just enjoy it. So I, I find it hard to believe that, you know, he was so detailed oriented and meticulous and, and 3d chess, 40 chess oriented in this regard. But, you know, somehow, you know, missed everything else in his eight billion dollar balance sheet hole. And I remember, I, I would imagine everyone in DC is just like who's been associated with, with him is just kind of running in the opposite direction now trying to distance themselves with that, is that what's going on?
Maybe distance themselves from crypto. Who knows? It's maybe some of the climate. Yeah, I mean, we've got like long term damage control, right? So, you know, I think the only thing that's going to help that is time. Now, the, the most important win this year in the policy side is that this, this didn't become law. The next couple of years, I think, unfortunately, are going to be a little bit of a war of attrition, right? It's going to be trench warfare, a lot of legal fights, warning off, you know, enforcement actions and regulation by enforcement from the, from the SEC in particular, but also potentially from the CFTC in some cases.
And, you know, we might not get, you know, comprehensive legislation for exchanges or for like what constitutes a token security or commodity until we have a new administration in place. The one exception, you know, potentially, I think, could be in the stablecoin realm that maybe we'll see some positive stablecoin action. There's always a chance that that something more comprehensive gets done, but with the Republicans in control at the house and, and Democrats in control at the Senate, still, it, it seems, you know, more likely than not that this is going to be gridlocked, which, by the way, is probably a net positive right now versus the alternative, for, for, you know, some of the folks that have it out for us.
Certainly. Well, the idea that SBF was a leader and knew everything and was playing the board is in stark contrast to his public speaking tour after every place. You know what I don't know damn thing about my own company, which was definitely the vibe that he was trying to get off. Ryan, we have so much more to cover. We got Bitcoin and crypto dollars, top 10 Ethereum and layer one trends trends in DeFi, which I say, if I'm reading the lines, you are calling the DeFi bottom, I got my own story to tell you about that one. We'll see how that works. Ryan, so much more to come in the second half of the show right after we talked to some of these fantastic sponsors that help you go bankless.
Sequence is the all in one developer platform you need to build web three games and applications. For your users, sequence is a smart wallet and it's the easiest, most intuitive onboarding your users will ever experience and comes with all the features the users need to feel empowered in the web three world. Multi-chain support, NFT display, and users can buy SFTs, NFTs, and crypto directly with a credit or debit card. For developers, sequence is the plug and play platform for web three games and apps. Their APIs let you bring NFTs, SFTs, and tokens into your game or application, and a sequence relayer enables gasses transactions for your users.
Sequence already powers some of the best web three games like Skyweaver, NFT projects like cool cats, and marketplaces like NiftySwap, and sequence is compatible with all the EVM chains, including Ethereum, Polygon, Binance Smart Chain, Arbitrum, Optimism, and Avalanche. So go to sequence.xyz slash bankless to start building or speak with a sequence team today. TrueFi is DeFi's largest credit protocol, connecting global lenders with institutional-grade lending opportunities. TrueFi has completed over $1.7 billion in original nations and paid out nearly $35 million to lenders, proving that DeFi is ready to take its next big leap into the $8 trillion credit market.
TrueFi gets lenders like you, access to sustainable, high-yield opportunities backed by real-world investments, usually reserved for high net worth individuals. At the same time, fund managers use TrueFi's financial infrastructure to bring their portfolios on chain, benefiting from the global liquidity, cost savings, and transparency of DeFi. TrueFi is a decentralized financial utility. The protocol is owned and governed by the TrueFi Dow, and TrueFi is here to bring DeFi into the Golden Age, bridging the power and access of crypto with institutional-grade lending opportunities and portfolio tooling.
Explore the diverse financial opportunities available on TrueFi or launch your own portfolio at TrueFi.io. The reality today is that five corporations control the entire world of social media. They own our names, they restrict our content, they monitor our every move, and their time is up. Thanks to our sponsor, Diso. Diso is a layer one blockchain built from the ground up to decentralized and scale social networks. With Diso, you can own your own identity, content, and social graph, and take it with you across hundreds of applications already built on the censorship-resistant Diso blockchain.
Diso storage advantages make it finally possible to build infinite state applications that can efficiently store and index large amounts of content and data fully on chain. Diso also offers multiple crypto-native monetization primitives for developers and creators, including social NFTs, social Dow's, social tokens, and social tipping. So in order to experience the social layer of Web3, go to diso.com and claim your username. That's d-e-s-o.com. For a decade, Bitcoin's best defense will continue to be its inability to be held hostage by one charismatic leader, and its volatility and boringness will deflect attention in different ways.
Ryan, looking forward into 2023, how do you expect the conversation around Bitcoin to unfold? I really like this line. We will debate Bitcoin's role in society for as long as it exists. What are we going to debate in 2023? What's Bitcoin's role moving forward here? Well, first off, I don't even remember writing that paragraph, so I'm like, I'm partly terrified that I plagiarized it, and the other half is maybe I was just writing it in a Stephen King-like bender mode. But yeah, look, I think in going forward, Bitcoin has benefited greatly from his boringness cycle. People just have such ridiculously short memories that every single passing cycle, it's the same exact thing.
People underestimate Bitcoin. All the excitement's over here. All the application development is over here. This, that, the other thing. And it's just blocked by block. The fees are relatively low. The community is crazy, so no one really pays attention to them. There's no one to go after. In terms of a figurehead, the core developers truly are decentralized and extremely tough to pin down for any type of, you can't really put that much pressure on anyone. It knows exactly what it wants to be when it grows up. It's a borderline, miraculous tech. And I think that's going to have staying power as a money.
And we can argue about whether Ethereum will surpass it or Bitcoin will remain number one. But it will have staying power for that reason almost by itself in a really chaotic global environment. So just like we saw in the last cycle, I expect that people are going to underestimate Bitcoin, call for the flipping. Maybe maybe not. Maybe this will finally be your year, guys. I think that if you as a country or you as a company are going to put your, are going to think about like a currency hedge, not an inflation hedge, but a currency hedge, then I think Bitcoin still remains like the first choice.
And then Ethereum has probably moved into that number two spot. Yeah, I certainly remember going through the 2017 to 2018 media and on the end of 2018, I definitely had more respect for Bitcoin than I did at the start of 2017. That's for sure. And it's a little bit after the chaos of a collapse of crypto of the collapse of the industry, the appreciation for one block every 10 minutes definitely hits a little bit harder when we are down in the depths of a bear market. So I will give that one to you. I want to also, however, move on to the Ethereum and layer one trends. And I just have a broad conversation.
Oh, we're going right over all the good stuff in the Bitcoin section. No surprise. Well, this actually, this actually isn't even diving into the Ethereum part specifically. I just from your perspective, from the outside of the Ethereum community, which Ryan, my Ryan and I find myself ourselves very in the middle of it very frequently. How would you describe the landscape of smart contract change going into 2023? Like who are all the relevant players and who's showing strength? And with all of the all layer one landscape, can the entire all layer one landscape hold a candle to Ethereum's layer two ecosystem?
What's your take on just a smart contract landscape in 2023? Well, I think you have to look at market cap, market dynamics, and then developer activity. I think you have to look at all three for signs of strength. So I know that apps don't necessarily follow price, but price is what ultimately secures these proof of stake networks. And that's also an indication of community health. It's the one barometer that you can look at. It's not perfect, but it's directionally correct in terms of order of magnitude importance of the different ecosystems. And then the one A to that is the market dynamic.
So this would be the changes to Ethereum supply and the new issue and schedule and the post merge economics of Ethereum. And I think if you just look at those like that one in one A, Ethereum is just so far ahead of everybody else in a kind of a class of its own right now as a layer one that you're really looking at as I alluded to in the Anatolia, you know, comments and earlier, you're looking at Ethereum and EVM compatible chains, whether that's roll ups, whether that's kind of this modularity thesis for different types of blockchains, or whether you're looking at other EVM compatible like layer ones, like avalanche and others that have these bridges.
I think no matter what, that is going to continue to be one of the dominant ecosystems and probably the dominant ecosystem, you know, for crypto not named Bitcoin for the foreseeable future, right? Everybody else is kind of playing for a second, especially post merge, right? I think last year, you know, when we had this conversation, as you know, my quip on the merge was always take the over, right? Whatever the date was, take the over. And for a while, that was money good. You'd make money hand over a fist if you just always took the over when it came to, like when people instance, be the merge would come.
But the fact that it came, the fact that it went off without a hitch, I mean, just miraculous, just one of the most impressive technical achievements, you know, of, you know, my career, my, you know, kind of professional life that I've seen. And, and, and it's, it's something that I think solidifies, you know, Ethereum for the long term. And in terms of not only it's, it's the stability of the platform, but I think the, it's attractiveness to other outside developers, right? Because that was such a hard problem to take on in such a tall mountain of scale, I think there, there should be quite a bit of confidence that like other equally tricky problems would get, will get solved over time in a really thoughtful manner.
So I don't underestimate that at all. And I think, you know, just Vitalik and the other core devs that, you know, spent years on this, just, you know, they're, they weren't the people to watch just because I didn't want to curse Vitalik. I was worried about the, the S.I. and I think there's, right? And like, so is that not that I, you know, I think Anatoly could probably not have much of a worse year than this year. So I think, you know, he's, he's probably, yeah, exactly. But I think that those guys, I mean, just the, the bright spot and a really bleak year for sure. So Ryan, can we just do this?
All right, because we've had two cycles of the meme, ETH killer, Ethereum killer. Like something is going to come kill a period, right? Is that dead now? Is there, are we going to have another ETH killer cycle, the next cycle? And oh my god, repeat this whole thing. Not to say there won't be competitors with the ETH, but like killing is different. Yeah, I think the ETH killer cycle, like now everybody realizes it's not enough to kill ETH because the fees are high, right? And, you know, it's not enough to kill ETH because it's proof of work, right? Or it has this looming technical upgrade that's a bunch of smoking mirrors and a, and, and, you know, this mechanical, this perpetual motion machine that's the roadmap, like, that's done, right?
Like that's, that's in the rearview mirror. Now there are still some challenges that need to be, you know, tackled like the, the potential sensor ability issues around, you know, MEV and, and those are all on the roadmap. But I think that those are significantly less challenging than what we just saw in, in terms of the merge. So you're going to have to compete on, you know, fundamentally new use cases. So, you know, I'm not a, I'm not a very deep, a deeply technical person, but would some of these move oriented blockchains, right? The ones that spun out of the, the Facebook DM project, like Aptos and Sui, you know, are they going to, you know, introduce some interesting applications as Salana, going to introduce some interesting applications that just run better faster cheaper and, and you just can't do them on Ethereum, maybe.
And then, you know, the other one to keep an eye on is, you know, will, the Cosmos app chain model ultimately attract, you know, more communities, more applications, because of the, the customizability of the app chains themselves. So, do IDX, like watching that experiments the next year, their migration from ZK roll up to, to an app chain on Cosmos is, is probably going to be the most important project for, you know, Ethereum killers, you know, proponents to watch, because that would be one sign that maybe some of the interesting use cases and some of the really scalable crypto apps are actually not going to be built on Ethereum, but maybe they'll move to something like the Cosmos app chain model.
I don't know what the right answer is, but I would say those are, you know, the three that are covered in the report in depth, Ethereum, Cosmos, Salana, and then everything else is, you know, is, is referenced. And we cover, you know, probably about a dozen different layer ones, and, you know, layer 1.5 or whatever you want to call polygon, which had a pretty monstrous year in its own right, in terms of some of its wins, but we cover all them on a quarterly basis. So, you know, those are alluded to in reference, but I only, I can only write so many pages. I did my best, but I know that there's going to be some communities that are pissed off.
I already know that, like, you know, fucking Goon is going to, he's going to DM me and be like, you didn't cover avalanche again. Whatever. I love you, Goon, but, you know, come on, man, I wrote 170 pages in two weeks. Give me a break. I don't want to drill down on that app conversation because that brings us to the trends in DeFi, and there's one that I really wanted to pull out specifically because it hits home for me. And so I'll read one of the quotes here. Ethereum transaction fees are way down this year, and the competitive dynamics with DAPS have shifted. Uniswap, Lido, and OpenC, the three largest Ethereum-based apps now generate more monthly fees on a combined basis than the entire Ethereum layer one.
Ave and Uniswap launched their protocols on various emerging networks this year, and it came quickly to dominate their segments in terms of volumes and TVL. This shows that the shelling point for most users isn't around chain-specific native versions of lending and decentralized exchanges, but of the top applications by user. Just as Binance will likely steamroll the first top domestic tie exchange in Thailand upon entrance into the country, Ave is also likely to dominate in whatever digital country aka a layer one. It enters. Interesting. Right. Yeah. And so then Ryan concludes this section.
Mr. Selkis says, why then does DeFi still sit at all time lows versus ETH? I'm bullish on DeFi dominance versus Ethereum in 2023. Absent hand-fisted new regulations. Ryan Selkis, are you calling the DeFi bottom? Is that what's going on? I've been saved. Selkis is going to save your calls. Yeah, but I said at once not like three times. Yeah, I mean, I think look, I would personally own both, right, is the way that I'd frame it. I think the reason to be bullish is because of the dominance and the feed generation of some of those DeFi 1.0 apps, if you will, right, and their ability to I think accrue value for themselves in their community's long term.
The reason to be bearish and kind of take the under on that is there are going to be significant regulatory headwind still, right? And so that creates that's like a known unknown. So you've got like those counter via valing forces. The reason I am much more relatively bullish maybe on DeFi than Ethereum though has to do with my mental model for both, right? So DeFi is about 0.1 to 0.2% of the market cap and TVL of traditional financial services. So do I think that decentralized finances, penetration in the real world is going to be more than one, three thousand, or whatever of the traditional financial system, I think the answer is yes.
With Ethereum, it's a slightly different calculation if people's mental model of Ether starts to change, right? So I made the point in here, you know, we're going to talk about the either Ether's money in which case the sky's a limit, right? Or Ethereum is a platform like the cloud computing platforms or like a distributed bank. Right now, its economics as a platform look a lot more like a distributed bank than they do a distributed cloud computing platform in terms of margins, in terms of sustainability of the fees and whatnot. And it is a transaction fee based, you know, kind of model that Ethereum has, you know, if you kind of net out like all the sticking rewards.
So if you think about like Ethereum as like the meta decentralized bank of crypto and financial settlement platform, then it's sealing might be a little bit lower than the most bullish proponents think and defies, you know, sealing is probably significantly higher than I think a lot of people currently handicap for. So, you know, I think if we can get some resolution and some like sandboxes around DeFi in the next couple of years and the US and Europe, we could be close to the bottom here, David. And one of these days, you might just be right. So he's over the floor. Ryan, this has been great and look, we couldn't cover all 168 pages of this, but we'll definitely make sure that folks have a link in the show notes at the end.
But we can only touch upon a few things. Is there anything that really jumps out at you from the report that you just really were like, guys, we should have talked about this. It tells us about about that thing. What's something that you'd like to pull out for us toward the end of this is we begin to wrap up. Well, I'll do a buy cell for NFTs and then DALS, which are the last two sections that we didn't get to. So I think in like the NFT and kind of metaverse space, I am pretty bullish on decentralized social applications and identity and and pretty bearish on individual NFT projects and GameFi.
GameFi, I think is the most overhyped, ridiculous friends. That's a strong opinion. Interesting. An absolute capital and generator for years to come. Dan Spencer would like a word. I think NFTs are best thought of an aggregate versus as particular projects. So I think that the picks and shovels businesses around NFTs will continue to do well. But the point that I make in here is Bitcoin in 2013 to 2017. If you do the digital gold versus physical gold comparison, you could see it's kind of steady march upwards and its market share kind of capture reflected the value of Bitcoin. NFTs, I don't think the same thing is going to be true.
I think that we will see like a 10X in the NFT market, but it will be because of a 10, 20, 30X increase in the number of projects and the number of supplies. So you want to bet on the category on like the collectibles category rather than the beanie babies, right, individual projects. Yeah, I think that's right, but I would also say that as a consumable primitive, right, I think it's really important. But I just don't think that people should be thinking necessarily about NFTs writ large as an asset class. It might be better to think about them, you know, very specific niches like digital art as an asset class.
The example that I've used is, you know, your physical wardrobe, right? You buy fresh kicks or, you know, a new suit. When you're ready to sell that thing, it's going to be 20 cents on the dollar. If you're lucky. And I think that give it to a thrift store, you know, it's basically exactly, right? So, and so that's kind of the model that I have could be wrong. We'll see, but I don't think so. And then on the on the the Dow side, I'm still hyper bullish on Dow as we could do, you know, a whole episode on that. But so I'll gloss over that. But the, I think the one, you know, kind of critical area of investment.
Next year, I expect we'll see an uptick in as as what we call deep in decentralized physical infrastructure networks. Cloud infrastructure companies are about five trillion dollars of market cap. You guys want to guess where deep in is right now. If you include Filecoin or we've helium live peer, some of those projects. Okay, give us the numbers again. So what, what was some five trillion for cloud? Yeah. What is the crypto equivalent? I'm going to say, yeah, I was going to say under 10, but I'll go under five because that sounds. That's right. About two and a half. Wow. Yep. So if you think about both the pressing need to decentralize our dependence on some of these big platforms and hardware networks and just the just enormous revenue opportunity and the very clear unit economics here too, by the way, of these projects.
I expect that should be a good kind of tailwind for the industry. The question is, you know, how quickly we'll demand pickup for those decentralized networks because the supply side is largely figured out through token incentives. But can we continue to see good kind of steep growth like we have the last few quarters, even in the teeth of the bear market and usage of some of those decentralized physical infrastructure networks? So that's a small sampling of the 95 and appreciate being able to run through with you guys. No, it's great. And maybe just to close us out Ryan, can you talk about 2023?
So where do we go from here? You had this section somewhere in the report that talked about 2023 as a time we need to get back to crypto back to crypto in 2023. I think that's a good theme. If 2022 was paying back to crypto is a great theme for 2023. And you said, you want more personal wallets from my cold dead hands rather than exchange margin accounts, which is bad. You want more privacy? It's none of your business what I do. Then institutional adoption, we could slow that process down. And you want permission financial and social applications, a live and let live policy versus Ponzi economics, the frauds that we saw in 2022.
See what the real manifestations of this crypto vision, not the fakes. Wrap this up for us. What can we expect in 2023? What does back to crypto mean? Well, first off, I did a fine replace of Web 3 anywhere that it accidentally slipped through cracks in the trash. So to kill it, I killed it with crypto crypto. Yeah. Okay. And and I think there was one or two that slipped through the cracks in the graphics, which I'm not too happy about, but that's that's my that's my fault. Wait, so we're putting Web 3 in the grave? I just well, I don't I'm not going to tell other people how to live their lives, but it's got bad juju for me.
I'm not calling it Web 3 anymore. Okay. All right. Every every every ever since we all said started saying Web 3, we started getting a high on our own supply. I believe many people are full of shit. So I don't hate that. I remember reading the A16C report that that came out that said that Web 3 pulled well with people. It was the best polling a term. Yeah. How's it polling now, David? That was the absolute top of Web 3. It was down only. All right. So back to the basics, back to crypto in 2023. Ryan, this amazing. Hey, action items for you, bankless listeners, of course, you can go download the report.
We'll include a link in the show notes. Any special instructions on how to download and access that, Ryan? Oh, man, I should have the I should have the link, Andy, but it's it's going to be right on our homepage. So if you go to msari.io, it will be on our homepage when this drops live amazing. Guys, I hope you enjoyed this. We stuck this in before the holidays and you appreciate, Ryan, you hanging with us. All right, Ryan, here's my only regret with that conversation is we forgot to talk about the block crypto media. So I know like I saw some of your tweets after this. My brain just about exploded earlier this month when I saw that.
So basically the news that SBF had a controlling secret interest the entire time in one of the largest crypto media publications in our space. And here's why that hit me so hard is for so long, I've been kind of preaching like and David too. And I know you have is the answer to our really shitty financial media coverage of crypto is crypto media. And here here we are. Here's this entity who's caught up and involved in this this corruption, this SBF thing. And I look, I know it's not everyone there. There are tons of fantastic people at the block that goes without saying who are not aware of any of this.
But to see it kind of seep in, I don't know, my jaw hit the floor. What was what's your reaction to this? Because I wanted to talk to you about this for a while since it happened. I feel like with anything like that, it had to have been an extremely small group of people that knew about this, if not a group of one. Because stuff like this always gets out. Right. And I just don't really think that there's any reason to suspect that the vast majority of not pretty much the entirety of the editorial and research teams of the block really adding any idea that this was the structure. I know that the block's founder, Mike Dutus, had was completely blindsided by this.
He had said that he thought that Mike McCaffrey's source of funding for his buyout of the company was just from family money. And so it seemed like this took everybody's surprise and it was very much an isolated group of people that knew about this. So in some respects, I think it's unfortunate stuff that a good chunk of the team is going to be maligned over this or have their integrity called into question. I think that's necessary. And I think it just also flies in the face of their actual coverage on some of this stuff. There are, I think, much more pernicious issues with pay to play within crypto media that is outside of CoinDesk and the block.
CoinDesk broke the story that unraveled FTX and has now turned around and created contagion as a parent company. So I think the CoinDesk and the block editorial teams are two of the best decrypts. Another one up there, you guys obviously do great work. But in terms of like traditional like news, like journalists. Yeah, we are not journalists at all. Yeah, I think I think those three are definitely pillars of the ecosystem. And so I didn't really spend a whole lot of time in the shouting for right of it. I just thought it was like another, whatever can go wrong, we'll go wrong this year because that one was more of just like an own goal that's going to look a lot worse than it really is.
I think in terms of the outside world, because I think we know some of the folks that are over the block, right? And I would be shocked if Frankie Scoops had any idea of something like this. I mean, his reaction was like someone that just got stabbed in the back in the heart, right? So I think that's unfortunate and maybe unfair. But I think there is a bigger question in terms of should we have like an associated press of crypto, right? So something that is a little bit more open and that is focused on doing the journalists to grunt work. But where the information is ultimately like a public good.
Okay, well, so let's talk about that because that's that's very really where my mind went. So and by the way, we hopped right into this question with Ryan because he's totally up to speed. But for bankless listeners who aren't aware, the block, large crypto journalism news institution in crypto turned out that their CEO was getting loans from SPF in Alameda, that entire thing and was using that to buy up a majority stake of the block. So in some shadow type pseudo way, SPF in Alameda was actually the owner of the block. And the question of does that taint coverage? What were the intents behind this?
Also the CEO, former CEO of the block is obviously he's no longer the CEO and owner is also given like apartments in the Bahamas as part of this as a reward. So it's just some shady things. Anyway, that's the background that we're going into. But like what what Ryan can we do to not become like the legacy media? How do we make this corruption resistant? SPF won't be the last that tries to bribe out and buy out a crypto media publication. How do we develop some armor for this the next time around? And that maybe goes to the idea that you were talking about like associated press. So dig into this.
What do you think the solutions are here? I actually think this is a pretty good case for Adele. And the reason I say that is like I ran coin dust for a couple of years, right? So the acquisition and restructuring that we did at DCG in 2016, it was me that led that turnaround and like a team of six, right? Like it was like Pete Rizzo, Mike McSweeney is now over at the block and like an events team like that. Our editorial team was down to like two people and like one one contract, you know, like, you know, European that was doing the night coverage and helping on weekends. And and so I know what controls we put in place in terms of like editorial firewalls just so that coin desk was was not perceived to be like, you know, just a mouthpiece for DCG.
Like we physically moved out of the office. You know, we had these like firewalls and this kind of code code of conduct that's that I mean and Rizzo worked on and you know, I didn't get in his way and vice versa. I stopped writing for 18 months. Like that was the only time I didn't write. Basically was through the 18 months that I actually ran coin desk. And I think that model works if you trust me and that is kind of a size the point, right? Like you shouldn't trust that I was, you know, not getting calls from Barry and then funneling that, you know, in a conference room to Rizzo essentially saying like if you write about this, you're fired, right?
Like that's that's something that you know, I think you get taken for granted because I think you know, coin desks, you know, body work, certain to some two feet people had a lot of confidence in like the integrity of the editorial team that we had and and that we wouldn't do something like that. But it's still leap of faith and you can get unfairly maligned, you know, by association just because that construct exists. And I think the same is true with the situation with the block where you had a business focus seat, you know, not really in the editorial, you know, function, not really in the research function, doing something totally outside of both of that that is going to make them look bad.
And now it kind of impunes the the integrity of the rest of the group or you know, at least the the brand, right? And so if you think about what a Dow could be really good for, you know, it could be good for funding a sustainable operation for journalism that is truly independent where the content itself is ungovernable, but the funding source is secure, right? So one of the issues that you always have is you want good news, but you never want to be the object of bad news. And that can create a bunch of, you know, kind of gnarly, you know, incentive problems when it comes to, you know, running a commercial business, you know, I can't tell you how many folks on the on the coin desk side were like, we're not coming to consensus, we're not supporting you like, this is a garbage publication because there was a negative article about them because they did something, you know, shitty or they had something like mishap and the journalist covered it.
So I think there are ways to monetize a business like that and basically automate the business operations of like a decentralized media outlet. And we might be at an interesting moment in kind of crypto's life cycle where combination of a recession layoffs, some of these, you know, kind of brand issues at, let's forget the brand issues. Some of the change of control issues that might exist at both the block and coin desk since the block is probably going to have to restructure based on McCaffrey's ownership. Coin desk is rumored to be on the block because of DCG's other issues that it's other subsidiaries.
So you might have a perfect storm where there's going to be a lot of talent that is potentially looking to hit the market. Could you spin up almost like a constitution down, but for funding sustainable like crypto journalism and then organize a business unit just like you do, like you have a centralized like editorial desk and crypto. Could you have like kind of a hub and spoke model where you have a centralized editorial desk and then like a freelance kind of Dow model. Kind of like would you guys have done with bankless Dow as some of the kind of specialist contributors. And I think if it's ever going to happen, like it's probably going to happen soon.
So you know, maybe you guys take it up and then you know, just shoot, shoot, shoot, shoot, shoot me a tip if it works. I was going to ask you to do it. Well, I'm probably, you know, I went quank. I don't want to get in trouble because my team's like you have too many ideas. Yeah, people I hear. And so we have we have to focus. So but I do think it's really interesting. The other thing that I think is really interesting about this idea at this point in time is I think the economics of the journalism business have been total dog shit forever. And that could potentially get flipped on its head with things like GBT3 in the coming years.
The reason I say that is with more automation of the writing process, you're still going to need the fact checkers and the architects of these stories and like the investigators, right? So even though you can do the write ups, it's like a scientist, right? Like doing the write up is the easiest part. You got to design the experiment. You got to get all the controls right. You got to, you know, basically set everything up. And then, you know, if the experiment is well constructed, then you read out the results and then the write up kind of that's the easiest part is just explaining what you did.
But the concoction building everything itself, that's the difficult part. And I think, you know, with something like GBT3, if you started recording all of your interviews, right? Or you started like just inputting all of your raw notes into, you know, an NLP engine. And then more importantly, you had a trove of historical data and historical stories and historical notes that your entire desk had done. Now that model gets more efficient and smarter over time and can make many more lateral connections and maybe break stories like FTX, far sooner because that model would say, okay, we're looking at all the market cap info for these assets over here.
We know that Alameda was doing these investments. We know that the market corrected here. We know that this press release went out then. We know what FTX's volumes were. And then, and then they have a billion dollars to bail out BlockFi and they've a 500 million of bailout Voyager and they've, and you like, it could literally just slam all these together and say something's broken here, right? There's, there's something that doesn't add up about these numbers. And now you've got like your smoking gun. That's just one example. But you could potentially do that at with any combination of things and really kind of glean insight from the noise of most of today's news by having that source material.
And you do need the source material to put into these models. Otherwise, you're going to run into copyright issues. So I think, I think the economics of the news business are more interesting. I think doing decentralized way is more interesting, given the incentive mismatches. And every time I talk about it out loud, I kind of want to do it. Yeah. My team's going to be pissed at this in the bonus. But it's exciting. And like, so, so the last thing I'll say, because I know you've been with us for, for a while, and I just wanted to get your thoughts on this. And this has been very helpful. You know, I noticed number, I think number four on your top people to watch list was citizen journalists.
Now, look, that was actually success in 2022. If we look at like you named Molly White and autism capital and autism capitals doing all these things about SBF, another one that comes to mind is that Twitter account, Zach, XBT, just do deep due diligence on like crypto influencers and surfacing the grift and just being like, hey, look at this guy. Like, so if we can coordinate and unify some of that citizen journalist energy in some sort of a doubt structure, I mean, that starts to get really exciting. I don't know what that looks like, Ryan. I Dave and I certainly don't have time for it right now.
But we are cheering on whoever's listening to this and wants to start spinning that up and thinking about it. And yeah, thanks for weighing in on this. Appreciate it. That's your bonus episode right there. Thanks guys. Happy holidays with that. We are done this time. Take care, bye. As always, wrist and disclaimers got to let you know none of this has been financial advice. You don't get any of that from bankless. DeFi is risky. So is he so is crypto. So is web three. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey.
Thanks a lot. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation.