Danny Ryan is an Ethereum 2.0 researcher at the Ethereum Foundation, but he is also a cat owner, husband, and outdoors enthusiast. With some of the longest hair in crypto, Danny is solving extremely difficult and important problems at the protocol level for Ethereum. He is a communicator and a thinker—he is technical but also personable.
Danny is a human at the center of this movement, navigating through high-stakes subjective decisions and surrounded by smart, passionate people. This conversation also covers what it’s like working for a protocol. What’s it like working without a boss and concrete job description?
Danny’s answer? He cares a lot.
***** 📣 POOLTOGETHER | DEFI LOTTERY https://bankless.cc/PoolTogether *****
🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🍵 MATCHA | DECENTRALIZED EXCHANGE AGGREGATOR https://bankless.cc/Matcha
🔐 LEDGER | SECURE YOUR ASSETS https://bankless.cc/Ledger
🧙♀️ ALCHEMIX | SELF-PAYING LOANS http://bankless.cc/Alchemix
------
Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 4:00 Danny Ryan & His Hair 8:50 Coding & Building 12:45 Communicating 19:37 Subjective Decisions 25:05 Existential Risks 31:35 Work Culture & Accountability 38:08 After Ethereum 41:21 Proof of Stake 45:36 Social Interactions 51:42 More Proof of Stake 55:40 Bitcoin 58:10 Clean Money 1:00:15 Happy Devs & the Mock Merge 1:06:01 Personal Stuff 1:14:55 Closing
------ Resources:
Danny on Twitter: https://twitter.com/dannyryan?s=20
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Layer 0. Layer 0 is a podcast of unscripted conversations with the people that make up the Ethereum community. Crypto is built by code, but it's composed by people, and each individual member of the crypto community has their own story to tell. CypherPunks understood that the code they write impacts the people that use it, and Layer 0 focuses on the people behind the code, because Ethereum is people all the way down, and it always has been. Today, I'm talking with Danny Ryan, who is the coordinator of the Greater Eath to Effort. And Danny is in an interesting position. He's one of those people that can go deep into the weeds with code, but then also zoom all the way out and explain it to the non-technical folk like me.
And so we went through a little bit of Danny's pretty Ethereum history, and where he got his skills from, and then it turns out he's got a little bit of an entrepreneur in him. And then we asked some greater questions as to why Danny feels as somebody who works for the EF and kind of doesn't really have a boss, where he gets his accountability from for waking up every single day and contributing to Ethereum when no one actually forces him to do that. And then also expanding that to the other developers as well. We also talk a lot about this recent dev interrupt event, and what it's like to be there as a developer, and then also I share my perspective as what it's like to view these things from the outside.
And then we finished off with an interesting conversation about I asked Danny whether he is an introvert or excuse me, whether he is an optimist or a pessimist, and what about the world makes him what it is. And I thought his answer for that was pretty interesting. So without further ado, let's go ahead and get right into this conversation with a Danny Ryan. But first, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. Matcha, everyone's favorite deck aggregator, has just launched an open beta for gas list trading. So if you're trading more than $5,000 in common ETH and wrapped Bitcoin pairs, then your gas fees on matcha are free.
And that's why you should be using matcha. Matcha routes your orders across all the various DeFi exchanges on Ethereum, Polygon, Binance Smart Chain, and gives you the best possible price without any trading fees or unnecessary slippage. Matcha has smart order routing that splits your orders across multiple liquidity sources. If matcha sees that it gets you better pricing, trading on matcha is super easy because it pulls the liquidity for me into a single and easy to use platform. And it's even saved me multiple times from accidentally picking the wrong decks to trade on and getting a bad price.
Matcha also allows you to make limit orders on chains so you can set and forget your DeFi trades and they will go through automatically while you're away. So when you're making a trade, head over to matcha.xyz slash bankless, connect your wallet, and start getting some of the best prices and most liquidity when you trade your crypto assets. Alchemics is one of the coolest new DeFi apps on the scene. It introduces self-paying loans, allowing you to spend and save at the same time. Deposit the die stablecoin into the alchemics vault in order to get an advance on the interest it generates. Barrow up to 50% of the total amount of your deposited die in the form of Al USD's stablecoin.
Here's the craziest part. The loan pays itself back and you cannot be liquidated. Unlock your assets potential in the ultimate DeFi savings account. And brand new to Alchemics is the ETH vault where you can deposit ETH into the application. Barrow ALETH against your deposits while having your advance gradually paid back over time. V2 is rapidly approaching which will allow for even more collateral types plus a variety of yield strategies to choose from. Harness the power of alchemics at alchemics.fi. That's ALCHEMIX.FI. Follow alchemics on Twitter at alchemics.fi and join the discord to keep up to date with alchemics V2 and to get involved in governance.
Hey Danny, how's it going? Pretty good. Yeah, having a good time. Where's your basement? Where in the world is your basement? Can I dox you as the first thing I ask on the show? Yeah, that's reasonable. I don't think it's a secret. Boulder, Colorado. One of the Colorado clans, huh? Yeah, yeah, I've been here for a couple of years. Yeah, the Michael Wong, the guy who does culture and memes at Bankless jokes about how all the Colorado people are really into public goods and have long hair. Well, I won't pull it down, but I think I have the longest up the hair. Longer than Milwaukee? Oh yeah, my hair's to my waste.
What? Yes, I'll actually pull down. Oh my god, really? Yeah, it's usually in a braid if it's right, which you know, oh my god, it is the longest hair. Wow, you have the longest hair in all of Ethereum. Look at that. I think that is. Yeah, that's great. How long have you been growing that thing out? I don't really know. I mean, a while. I think before you were in Ethereum? Yeah, but probably like three years ago, I cut off like six inches. I just wanted to be six inches shorter. Three feet too long. It's just a tremor to keep it healthy, but I know I don't follow the guidance. Well, wow, I've already learned something new about you.
So or so early into this show. Danny, I want to I want to hear about your time before Ethereum. What did you do? What were you doing right before you got into Ethereum? I was doing a mix of various like software and business consulting. So my niche was probably like not just being a hired hand, but also like working closely with small business CEOs to like help them figure out how technology could actually make their their lives better. Some of this was like helping like literally small businesses like Louisiana that like literally didn't know databases existed or like how to track customers and things like that.
And that was you can make a big impact. But I also like I also did a lot of work with a company called Kidding Co, which was like an Airbnb knockoff for families traveling with kids. So I built a lot of that stuff and like worked closely with the CEO on. I don't know strategy and that kind of stuff. Were you working as an individual or was it under a company? Always, I mean, as a company, but just as a front for myself, you know, limit some liability and helpful taxes and that kind of stuff. And so your your typical client was like kind of a boomer that didn't really know technology is what it is.
Is that the vibe? It was it was a bit of a mix. Yeah, I think it was it was actually not boomers. It was probably like 30 somethings that were like, you know, go get a businessman that just hadn't awoken to all the things that technology could do for themselves. Was being an entrepreneur one of like have you always been an entrepreneur? Or before that did you ever work for a company? Have you worked for a nine to five? I've never had a real job. I don't think really. I started a screen printing company when I was 15. It still runs today. Yeah. Wow. My business partner and best friend. That's his full-time gig, but I'm still involved somewhat.
No way. Okay. This is like a peril, right? Just like making cool shirts and stuff like that. You started that when you were 15. Yeah. I mean, we primarily do it for other people. So like they take the risk on of like their cool shirt and try to sell it. Just make it. Yeah, we do like 100 to 10,000-piece orders for all sorts of different entities. Got a shop in Louisiana. Okay. So would you say that you've always had some sort of entrepreneur DNA part of you? Yeah. And I've always had the desire to not have a normal job and to dictate my time on my own standard. And this is probably the most normal of a job I have.
I mean, it's like, I work for an entity. And I don't have hours, but I have things that I'm trying to do, and I get paid to do them. But it's entrepreneurial sense that no one tells me what to do. And I just see what needs to be done and kind of try to bring the value where I can. Definitely. Yeah. So you are, you are your own leader, even though you have a paycheck, which is the fact that the EF is the most normal job you've ever had is absolutely insane. When did you learn to code? In college, actually, I've always like used computers. And it was like a power user probably, but I never dipped into coding until I had to take a computer science course for a mechanical and aerospace engineering degree I was doing.
And then, and this is my sophomore year of college. And I loved the class and switched my major and went all in. And I, you know, and was like, it felt like a light bloomer, you know, like I'm never going to make it a computer science or programming because like people have been doing this since they were two. But they worked out. It's working out. Yeah. What about code just resonated with you? It felt immediately like the most sane way to get through college because it was fun. I guess I was doing the mechanical and aerospace engineering degrees. I thought because I thought it would like build things.
But you didn't really build stuff at my school until junior or senior year. Whereas day zero of the programming class, I was like building cool little things. And that just kind of struck me. And it felt like solving puzzles. And I felt like I could, I could spend the rest of my college career solving puzzles and it would get me through school at least. So the, is the builder DNA also in you as well? Like whatever, you, whatever medium you have to build something the easiest and the fastest is what resonates. Probably so. I don't know. Sometimes I think I'm a builder and then I see my wife who's like sowing and like making dresses.
And like it's always building shit. Like literally always building shit. And I'm like, I don't much of a builder. You don't think you're much of a builder? I am a communicator. I'm a prototyper. I like to think deeply out hard problems. But like, at a certain point, I'm also not the guy who builds it. And nor do I think I'm the right one. Like if you look at the, say like the Sigma prime team, you know, Paul's a builder. Paul, like Rex building lighthouse. And like is it is just constructing crazy shit? I mean, proto, proto is a builder too. And I build things. But I do a lot of other things too.
And like, if I spend all of my time trying to build things and trying to bring something totally to production in terms of from my own hands, it's it. I don't get. I have a hard time doing that. I have a hard time like focusing quite like that. So I like the mix and stuff I do. I made this mistake with Kevin Awaki once or maybe it's actually Ryan that alluded to Steve Jobs and Kevin was like, I don't, I don't like that analogy, but I'm going to do it. I'm going to do it into it. Anyways, where Steve was in the act was yelling at Steve Jobs saying, what is it that you actually do? Like what are, what are your skills?
Like you don't actually build anything. And Steve Jobs gives this anecdote of like somebody going up to a conductor of an orchestra and asking more or less the same question. Like, what do you do that a metronome can't do? And the or the conductor gets really, really offended obviously. And he goes, well, you know, the trumpeter plays the trumpet. And then the, you know, the flutist plays the flute. I play the orchestra, right? Like that, that's his instrument. Would you say that that metaphor is kind of apt for how you are the conductor of all the East two client teams? I will not take like the Steve Jobs analogy direct.
I cannot accept that, but I will say to a certain extent because like the conductor probably played an instrument most of his life and knows and knows music inside and out. You know, knows how to communicate about the music and things like that. And so to a certain extent, sure. Yeah. You know, and I enjoy that. So what has it been like to be the, I kind of, so the other metaphor that I think I have for what I think you do is like kind of like a traffic control man for all of the different, just like packets of communication data that all the different client teams talk about. We were, me and Ryan were just got out of done reading recording a weekly roll up and we were reading one of the ZK roll ups like announcement blog posts.
And we were just trying to unpack their blog posts over and over and over again. And like it was very, very clear that a developer wrote this blog post, not a communicator. So like as somebody who is a good communicator, how is it, how has it been like to like communicate with all these like, you know, developers who speak in this very, very like technical, non-communicative way? Oh, that's fun. I mean, I, I can speak the language. And I, like, I don't just communicate, like in this, in this interrupt last week, like I did, I did a lot of communication. I did a lot of kind of organization stuff.
But I, you know, I'm in the weeds, like figuring out like the optimizing the engine API, right? And like figuring out how that's actually going to run and like some of the edge cases and stuff. And so like I, I think if I could not get deep into it, that I would be, I would not be effective at what I'm doing or what I've been doing the past years. And so on the technical side, it's very fun. And then I really enjoy explaining things. I really, really enjoyed teaching. And so I really enjoy like finding the right metaphor or the right, like thing analogy to communicate a technical concept to people who maybe aren't as deep in the weeds.
And so because I get to deep, I get to be deep in the weeds, then I also get to then turn around on the other side and communicate outward. So when you're at these dev interrupt events where everyone there speaks code, like speaks developer, you don't need to use metaphors, right? Like that's that metaphors are for you to communicate to people like me or or do metaphors are they useful in that environment? Like what are the communication skills there? That's an interesting question. The metaphors are different, but they're still valuable. They're still like sometimes you're talking about something very complicated.
And like if you can abstract it and be able to talk about it more from a higher level, like one, you're going to get the three people in the room, remember here that knew what was going on and the four people over here that didn't quite yet, you're going to help expedite that process, which is good. And also just it helps, like we all have to think about different, like we have to be able to think about different layers of abstraction. So like once we have a good metaphor, even though we've like worked on the minute details of thing A and thing B, once we have a metaphor for how thing A and thing B kind of lived together at a higher level, once you have the details worked out, then you can talk about that higher level and not have to worry about the details unless you need to open it back up and go back in.
So they're very valuable. They're not the same metaphors all the time. Sometimes they cross. Sometimes they're good for educating an outside audience and for communicating amongst themselves, but they're certainly valuable. Computer science is all about abstraction and that's metaphors in a certain sense. Is there a specific event that comes to mind when like you just could not figure out how to get two teams to communicate or you couldn't communicate with someone is it was there ever like a big like breakdown and communication that's happened? That's the story you can tell us about. Anything come to mind there?
There there are some things and there they these types of things are if you if you talk to my wife would be the things that over the past three years three four years have like stressed me out the most is this communication breakdown. I will probably I will not go into deep about any one of them. I will say that early on in the east to be can change journey. We had done a lot of work on consensus a lot of work on the core security the core state transition how these things come together, but the the networking was not in full view and there and there was a bit of a lack of expertise on the networking and ownership over it and when it when we got there that was probably one of the hardest times is just that there were parties on both side of the aisle that thought very very different things about how the networking should be built and how it should look and it like almost drove me crazy because I could not I could not like it took probably months to get past and resolve an issue and it ultimately came down to just being like we're gonna do it this way we can't do it both ways sorry you know and usually we're better compromised usually we're better at finding a solution where all the parties are like eventually all the parties are like oh yeah that makes sense because which is really good I think I think in Ethereum most people operating at this layer one like they truly want to find the right solution and like often we propose solutions that get iterated on or just totally shut down and like you have to do that most people are very good at that and don't bring a lot of ego to their solutions and because of that I don't think we get to these like weird impasses where we're just bike shedding to death I mean we bike shed certainly but like not about the important thing was bike shedding it is a term used quite a bit that the idea is we're building a bike shed you and I and obviously bike shed foundation they probably need a concrete foundation they need walls they need to be a door all sorts of stuff you maybe even need locks for your bikes for security but like instead of dealing with all that we're sitting here arguing about like the color we're going to paint the shed you know and the shed doesn't even exist yet and so bike shedding is when people get hung up on some sort of minute detail that like doesn't really matter and we're not like we're not even getting to the meat of it so like the name of an API endpoint like that could be the thing that is bike shed to oblivion because there's no there's no correct name there's literally no correct answer like this there's it becomes a matter of opinion and once you get to these areas that are a bit more of a matter of opinion rather than like some sort of absolute correctness and nothing has an absolute correctness but there's certainly things that like get closer in that direction but when you get farther away from that direction like naming things like that you get you get into bike shedding and if you look at like all decor dev calls sometimes it'll be like 20% meat and then 80% bike shedding but then if you say that people are bike shedding then somebody that really cares about the issue be like this is a bike shedding this is really really important right they don't think they're bike shedding they think that they are presenting the objective like yeah right okay so I want to unpack that a little bit because building a theorem no one knows what a theorem is it's kind of like the internet and like the future of a theorem is like what a theorem should be is a subjective thing right we don't have any objective like reference point for what we are trying to build when we're building a theorem so like you said all all choices are subjective and some are some are easier to come to consensus to versus others would you would you say like one way to describe your role is that like you are the facilitator of all these subjective decisions some of these subjective decisions all the teams have consensus on so we can just leave that you know we put that in the rear view mirror but perhaps a lot of them need to have you know powwow's and deliberation and debriefs about how and why choices are made so what would you say like your role has been to be the facilitator of these conversations about these subjective choices that's that's one of my roles I'd say that's one of my roles and the we like it is subjective there is no absolute as to where we're going but there are design considerations there are like deep philosophical things that are guiding us obviously like we don't have to all agree on them all but like you can go we can you can begin to cite you but like we've been working on proofstakes for like six years and like it has these the like these these are things we're trying to achieve and like the ethos of the community is kind of rallied around this you know and so that becomes something to help you help guide you but also there's other design considerations complexity is the the enemy of everything in consensus systems and so like minimizing complexity even at the cost of some advanced feature set or like some optimization often you know is a guiding light and that you know is generally agreed upon you know but maybe there's 5% of engineers in this process that like they're not afraid of complexity at all right so there's a bit of there's like a compromise that has to happen there so so yes subjective but there's this there's this like ethos and philosophy and and kind of design guiding like guiding light that's guiding us and sometimes I have to help try to contextualize that sometimes I have to help try to figure out what the community thinks is designing light or the the priorities and like I don't know it's all messy right so yes you you said values and ethos will help guide the decisions how how much how well defined do you think that actually is because like if you really want to get down to it there's no actual source of single source of truth for anything in this universe right like are there any very very concrete things that like well this choice abides by this set of values obviously like decentralization is perhaps a very concrete value that no one disagrees with are there any other values that like you can like name for for for us here but even decentralization is is on a spectrum and so like you know the Bitcoiners might say that we've we've like gone off the deep end you know in terms of it being some sort of centralized process or centralized protocol or something like that and I don't I don't agree with that but then I think other protocols have gone off the deep end in terms of centralization and design considerations and things like that so decentralization certainly top one decentralization also there's many different things that can mean often in protocol design we're considering like it not being able to be captured by powerful interests and not being able to be censored and things like that and the I would say there's there's an ethos of in ethereum of assuming that the world as it is today and in the way of the world interacts with blockchain today is not as the world will be in five 10 or 20 years so you end up seeing protocols that they make what I would what people consider pretty large compromises because well this is how it works you know no one's doing this no one's doing that like it's going to be fine whereas there's a very strong ethos and an ethereum assuming that something that can be captured will likely attempt to be attempted to be captured if it's valuable enough and we're attempting to build things that are very big and very valuable and so the we're trying to think about like you know what what happens when a state actor cares what happens when you know some mega cartel of some of the richest people in the world care like that kind of stuff what happens when when the banks are trying to shut it down whereas and so that that's definitely it's definitely a design consideration what are the other philosophies that proof of stakes better than proof of work I mean I could that seems pretty binary yeah I mean there might be a spectrum there yeah maybe we're trying to do hybrid proof of work if you stake it one point so that's that's the spectrum although I don't think that was actually a good idea even though I wrote the EIP but the yeah I mean it's messy it's messy what's something that could be captured because like obviously all of ethereum is like or like you know enough stake to validate the chain in ways that you deem appropriate like having enough ether that's one way to get capture but like what are the other like mechanisms that like maybe somebody that's not developed or minded like I am wouldn't think of that is like an attack point that you guys ran hard and up well you would well I think that this is this is something you would think about which is capture the governance process sure you know like the fact that you can upgrade ethereum is dangerous the fact that we can upgrade ethereum is dangerous and it probably becomes increasingly so as the powers that be give shit about the stuff you know like there's there's a bunch of developers a bunch of community members there's a bunch of signals and stuff and and those I'm certain could all be manipulated and I don't think that's what's happening today but I do think that that could happen in the future right what about something that actually involves writing code in a specific way where if we write the code this way like it might be open for capture in the future yeah yeah let's one thing that comes of mind is is p2p networking you know it's we make assumptions about the amount of honest actors on a network we make assumptions about being able to connect and being able to get in and actually find the right network and some of that the p2p stuff in general actually becomes a bit like a bit more a bit harder to define an objective way like consensus mechanisms you can be like if two alternative chain histories were created a minimum of this amount of stake is slashable like that you can make it you're very clear to find it whereas like defining someone being griefed on a p2p network and and the all the vectors there and and being eclipse and things like that is usually a bit usually a bit tougher and so definitely places places that you have to it's easy to not harden that I guess is the is the point but you you got to spend the time doing that we think dependencies that's an interesting one reducing the software dependencies that you have um reduces the ability for people to kind of make their way into your code unsuspectingly like for example if you had a dependency for a big integer library some random library and like one guy maintains it and like your client is running on this then all of a sudden that one guy can potentially like get a bug in that dependency that then affects all the arithmetic in your client which could then lead to xyz by you know printing a million ethers like that multi-client helps us there but it's you know there's a lot there's a lot of different entry points not even an attack vector that I even knew who existed they're called that's called a supply chain attack on the on the software itself but there's hardware supply chain attacks too and apparently you know well there's a lot of stuff there but the like you could imagine there being some sort of box that people love the stake on and you literally just bugged the hardware and you still use keys right yeah but that's not your responsibility it's not but it's worth considering if there are safe ways to try to prevent that I mean one consideration for that would be like the separation of of the active staking key and the withdrawal credentials you know by doing that by by having the ultimate ownership of funds being a key that could be much colder and maybe on a hardware wallet you know protects you against certain supply chain attacks at least you know you could these those attacks could still potentially still keys but and could get you slashed but you maybe lose one eth instead of 32 right so what what you're talking about I think for for listeners who didn't follow that is that when you stake your 32 ether you predetermined the out go outbound Ethereum address where when you unstake that ether where that ether actually goes so when you want to take your ether rather than just like uh unstake my ether and send it to this address you actually give your Ethereum address that it will be unstake to when it is unstaked that was right right right right so you you you you talked about uh made house there are some assumptions that are made in the Ethereum protocol and this is of course a subjective decision that must be made um with with historically with all these client teams and making these decisions is are people generally come to consensus about these things about where what the assumption level should be or is it a bunch of like is there disagreement or ten toward just disagreement or ten toward agreement what's that process like case by case basis yeah I mean it's a bit of case by case basis I think that the people that are working on you know the the proof of stake consensus aspect of this protocol one inherited a lot so an inherited a lot of the philosophy and a lot of the design considerations from eth one from the existing proof of work chain um and uh you know a few court people wrote a lot of the the initial specifications so like myself the talent Justin Drake and others and so those initial specifications are grounded deeply with a certain philosophy uh but then design and considerations ripple outward from there so one you know we we iterate quite a bit on specifications with engineers and teams and then the specifications only contain so much so engineers are ultimately making decisions but I think they are grounded very deeply in a certain ethos but you do see a bit of a you you see different philosophical decisions coming out in different clients um so maybe like an enterprise client might cut corners here or there to make things nice for enterprise or make you know some user experience really nice whereas like a client that wants to be running on you know unstoppable embedded hardware and like routers and all sorts of stuff over the world like they might have like a different you know standard that they're they're holding to and maybe it makes the UX worse so switching years a little bit here although I think this conversation is going to going to weave in and out a little bit is uh uh the culture around all of these uh client devs um uh not none of them work for the EF they kind of they correct me if I'm wrong here um like they all kind of have their own internal treasury that they used to pay out all of the developers but I feel like the the vibe of the job is they're all kind of kind of what you describe your job at the EF is like well you receive a paycheck but you don't really answer to anyone you kind of just have your your job so everyone's a lot more loose loosely organized everyone kind of just like gets up and works loosely works what what's so like the the answer is probably obvious but uh like when you get up in the morning and like I don't I don't think you have a boss um or maybe you technically do but you probably doesn't feel like you do um like what keeps you accountable like why why does Danny actually do the things that are in his job description I asked myself that sometimes I don't I don't have a job description but I perceive job job description yeah I because I care I care a lot and I don't know why I mean I think I know why but sometimes you know throughout the years of ebbs and flows in different directions but like I cannot help myself like I cannot I cannot not wake up and immediately like figure out what the new problem is or wake up and like realize that if I don't do xy or z that the merge literally might be delayed by two weeks because we're like trying to get the specs out and stuff and like I just I care and then I care because I care about the technology but I also like the way it's all structured is it's all this it's all this open source project that we're building together and and and it's a community so like the accountability doesn't necessarily come from a direct boss or anything the accountability comes from the facts that I'm a member of this community building this thing and and I have I have this emergent responsibility building this thing with these people and if I if I didn't do what I thought I could do and do my best to do so I would be not giving giving my my all to this community that I care about and I'm deeply integrated in and that's there's a community angle there's the like I care about shipping this piece of technology and then I don't know there's there's certain level of obsession that I and pretty much everyone else I work with has and that's probably because of the community thing it's probably because of the impact but it's just like someone someone mentioned it like Ethereum is just the ultimate nerd snipe and I the word nerd isn't even the right word like I don't necessarily consider myself a nerd but just the like it is such an interesting problem it is such like the combination of of economics and photography and game theory and and programming and distributed systems like it's unbelievable it's like hilariously interesting and it's captivated me for many years now I just had to look up nerd snipe so for those that also needed to look up nerd snipe nerd snipe is a slang term that describes a particularly interesting problem that is presented to a nerd often a physicist tech geek or mathematician the nerd stops all activity to devote attention to solving the problem often it is or her own peril Danny do you feel like at your own do you feel in peril at some times because of Ethereum sometimes sometimes I feel like if Ethereum holds you hostage I think it might I think it might I'm serious like I've been infected you know like the memes that this is but the the mimetics like the infectious idea like that that thing like you know I've definitely been infected like I cannot it's hard for me to think about other things I have to like rip myself away and like go go to the gym or go hike in the woods to like force myself to not think about this thing which is incredible I never thought I'd be so wrapped up in something and care so much about something but it's also like it's also a lot yeah yeah um do you like if you went and just like effed off for the day like went to the beach or just like whatever like maybe two two days in a row like would you feel like would you feel guilty what what emotions would you feel while you were not working on Ethereum no I don't think I definitely some anxiety because like it all keeps moving like because I'm gonna open my phone even if I didn't look at it for two days on my phone I'm gonna have literally 500 messages and like many of them are gonna be in like interesting technical conversations that one I want to follow and two uh I often I often have very strong opinions about all these conversations and so like I want to make sure that I help steer in the direction that I think is is good um and so you know if I if I disappear for too long you know who knows might be steered in that direction I have to like try to write the ship might have implemented a D-Post EIP or something I don't mean to I don't mean to imply so I think I work a lot I do and I love and I enjoy it but I think I actually have like a pretty good work life balance compared to to some like I go to the gym almost every day and I love camping I love hiking I got a beautiful wife that we hang out out with you know plenty of friends that kind of stuff so like I I I pride myself in having a good work life balance but I also think I work a time so I don't know there's I don't know where the line is right right yeah the cool thing about a theory is like when I think everyone who finds a job in probably greater crypto too is that no one actually feels like they're working um I mean I'm sure some people do um but the the perhaps why this thing has been so sustainable when it comes to infecting your brain is that because like it doesn't actually feel like work I yes I agree and simultaneously uh it does not feel like working but it can still be exhausting sure yeah right yeah absolutely there's then yeah plenty of things that aren't work are very very exhausting I think a marathon is exhausting but it's it's not technically my job right um have you ever thought about like what you're going to do with yourself once Ethereum calcifies no um I will either not be in technology or I will be working on open source technology I'm not I will not be working on closed source technology ever um I know as a matter of principle yeah I mean it just doesn't interest me and also one of the reasons I'm doing what I'm doing is because I'm trying to make an impact on the world and I don't think close source software is the the right way for me to make that impact right but it's we'll see we'll see it's hard to imagine doing something else um although I certainly will do something else eventually um and yeah my guiding principle is is to work on things that I I care about and to try to create value not in the sense of like lining my pockets with cash but like fundamentally try to create value um and in doing so I will continue to open doors and be able to work on interesting things that has worked out for me so far I'm also very fortunate very lucky person in many respects but um I figure if I keep doing what I'm doing keep working on interesting things keep working with interesting people that um whatever that next door is it will it'll be it'll be good one do you see yourself putting the entrepreneur hat back on and building something on a theorem and now now that you've finished the the foundation build the product maybe um I think that that would be I'd it'd be the right thing and have to be the right people you know if there was a person or two that I really really wanted to essentially pack on a project with for a few years um than than I would um but I'm not I'm not certain there's a funny a funny um so I got into proof of stake so like I I work on a lot of things but like I really focus on proof of stake of stake in plantations and research and specifications and security and all that kind of stuff um in 2017 right at the beginning I got rid of all my clients uh because I had become obsessed with theorem and I was going to figure out how to make it work how to make in my job um and uh I for that first probably half year I oh she's kind of bumbling around you know I was I lived in New Orleans at the time and I thought to myself if I'm going to be serious about this I need to go to the New Orleans Ethereum meetup and there wasn't one so I made I made the New Orleans Ethereum meetup you know and then I I was like I had never contributed open source before which is crazy because I was a believer in open source and I used it a lot in my projects and stuff but I had not like gone to a project and just contributed back so I was also like just start contributing to anything and everything you know I contributed to piper's web3.
py library of python tooling library for Ethereum um and and started just contributing things and I was wrote a few smart contracts trying to figure out maybe I'll maybe there's a business opportunity there and then I then I was like learning more about this shift this proof of stake thing coming and my first thought was that's never going to work that doesn't make any sense um but then two two days later two weeks later two months later I don't remember uh it it I was like oh I get it you know both of these are proof of dedication of economic scarce economic resources to the protocol you know it's easy to prove that about mining hardware and electricity and it's also easy to prove about the end protocol asset itself and so I was like okay this is starting to make sense and so I thought maybe I can make a staking pool and so I started I started digging into proof of stake because I thought it was coming in like five months and I thought I could make a staking pool and so like that that opened up my my contributions like that that that is why I got into proof of stake because I was like there might be a business opportunity here and uh turned out there was a lot of work to still do so I had to kick the can down the curve on the business opportunity um and I will I will say oh hardly at this point I have zero intention of making a staking pool and that does not interest me at all at this point uh but that's the the business opportunity was what actually made me do the deep dive on proof of stake to begin with that's that's pretty funny here I also in 2018 thought about like a model for a staking pool company and I actually pitched it to this ICO advisory company that I worked for at the time and uh Peter Vestness who was the uh the owner of the company new alchemy uh he said that uh proof of stake is years away and I was like no it's not Peter it's like right around the corner it's like six months away we got started building this thing and that was again in 2018 yeah yeah I helped write EIP 1011 hybrid proof of work proof of stake and at the time I and I was in 2018 I was like certain main net by the end of 2018 no problem like no problem it's really funny that like um the 2017 bull market at least with inside of the ethereum land everyone was like buying ether and ether was running up to fourteen hundred dollars because people were like speculating that staking is casper's coming casper's coming is like it's right around the corner right and in 2020 and 2021 it's the same thing it's really coming it's coming I went to the I went to the merge interrupt and and uh saw some beautiful things it is actually coming how was that by the way I was thinking about it when you said that work doesn't feel like work um because multiple times during that week and we were in Greece I was like walking back to my room and just and I get overwhelmed just with like a I'm having a fantastic time like I'm having a great time uh and after having been spending eight hours like in a room with 30 other people like thinking about hard problems and debugging software and all that kind of stuff which like I don't know if I don't know if I'm allowed to consider that having a great time but I was having a great time so um it was awesome it was like exactly the right time exactly the right group of people um and five times more productive than our wildest dreams so uh it was it was very very excellent is the in real life component with the reason why it's so productive you think I would say yes except yes within asterix the asterix being that it has to be the right time in a project it has to be the right group like it made a lot of sense because we're done with London we're done without air and we have the we have like the core specs for all the stuff and there was a little bit of lead time so that people could work on and lay the foundations in their software before and that and so like all of that doing all of the other stuff before probably would have wasted time if we were together um you know whereas we got together and we had this like very interesting structure and interrupt where most a lot of the software work had been done leading up to it and what you're doing is you're kind of like pairing off with different groups and and you're like can our software work together or let's fix the bugs and then you switch and you go with other group and you kind of like architect this pyramid of increasing complexity throughout the week and at the same time having conversations to iron out okay now that everyone has implemented the specs what are the issues you know what do we need to refine you know so we get a very deep conversations about ironing out the last bits of the specs and at the same time also like do this like culmination thing where we get to this mega milestone at the end of the week and and so yes there's magic to being in person but I I'm also like a um decentralization maximalist for for a lot of it too because like the value in what I can do at home and writing software and stuff like like it's just a different it's a different type of exchange and you don't want one or the other all the time and but it was really nice coming together after like two years of being a part right yeah um I think a lot of people had very similar feelings in uh New York recently for for main net where a lot of people are literally just coming out of their homes for the first time since COVID and also crypto is very very different in 2021 than than pre-COVID times like we've actually blossomed into some sort of like society uh and um just the the richness of the social interactions as well as maybe as a result of that or just maybe just in general inside of crypto for some reason social interactions in crypto seem far more rich than all the other social interactions I've ever had in any other context and I think maybe it's because everyone has like shared stories shared values shared like purpose and is also in electric intellectually curious I think everyone in crypto is generally intellectually curious and then like when you like hide people away for two years and then get them and then and then pump their their asset prices by 10x and then put them in a room together turns out they have like a lot of things to share yeah I think that's that's all it's all very true hey guys I hope you're enjoying the conversation with Danny thus far stay tuned for the second half of the show where we talk further about the dev interrupt event and also Danny's optimism or pessimism about the future of the world and what he can do about that I had a fantastic time talking with Danny here but first before we get there I'm on with to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible Arbitrum is an Ethereum scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs and now it's live and has over a hundred projects deployed gas fees on Ethereum L1 suck too many people want to use Ethereum and it doesn't have enough capacity for all of us and that's why teams like Arbitrum have been hard at work developing layer two solutions that makes transactions on Ethereum cheap and instant Arbitrum increases Ethereum's throughput by orders of magnitude at a fraction of the cost of what we are used to paying when interacting with Arbitrum you can get the performance of the centralized exchange while tapping into Ethereum's level of security and decentralization this is why people are calling this Ethereum's broadband moment where we get to add performance onto decentralization and security if you're a developer and you want to save on gas costs and overall make a better user experience go to developers.
offchainlabs.com to get started building on Arbitrum and if you're a user keep an eye out for your favorite DeFi apps being built on Arbitrum many DeFi applications on the Ethereum L1 are migrating over to layer two and some are even skipping over the layer ones entirely and deploying directly on layer two there's so many apps coming online to Arbitrum so go to bridge.arbitrum.io now and start bridging over your eth or any of the tokens listed and start having the DeFi or NFT experience that you've always wanted living a bankless life requires taking control over your own private keys not your keys not your crypto that's why so many in the bankless nation already have their ledger hardware wallet which makes proper private key management breeze but the ledger ecosystem is much more than just a secure hardware wallet ledger is the combination of the ledger hardware wallet and the ledger live app and if you're used to seeing all of your crypto services in favorite DeFi apps all in one spot ledger live is where you want to be not only does ledger let you buy your crypto assets straight from the app but it also hooks into all of the DeFi apps and services that you're used to using ledger live you can stake your eth and lido swap on decks as like periswap or display your NFTs with rainbow you can also use wallet connect inside of ledger live to connect to all the other DeFi apps that keep coming online DeFi never stops growing and the ledger live app grows alongside with it so click the link in the show notes to see all of the DeFi apps that ledger live has and stay tuned as more apps come online and if you don't have a ledger hardware wallet what are you even waiting for go to ledger.
com grab a ledger download ledger live and get all of your DeFi apps all in one space the thing about the interrupt and about some other similar events is like how much everyone gives a shit um raises the level of engagement with the level conversation and level of just enthusiasm and fun whereas I could imagine being in a more traditional business context and like people are there like do their job but you know there's not there's not that like giving a shit that that's there also just everyone's so aligned on shipping the merch um philosophically from a perspective perspective climate change like all sorts of angles like everyone there was like like they're on a mission like we're doing this thing um whereas you could imagine other things even in a theory or in crypto there's like less of that like deep deep deep mission like state expert I mean state F3 is incredible like we we need we need a sustainable state solution period end of discussion but doesn't have that uh as much of this like world changing feeling to it but I'm also very biased I love proof of state why why is proof of stake so grand when it comes to meaning and impact for so many people at the dev op event and or interest the Ethereum dev devs in general one of the big things was was climate change a lot of people just like uh and I hadn't I hadn't expected how much most of the people at that event were were feeling impacted by that like I talk about you know proof of stake making things more secure more sustainable and more scalable all the time you know and I mentioned the the reduction energy usage by like 99.
99 percent you know and but and and I think it it makes an impact to some but I was surprised and I shouldn't have been but I was surprised throughout the week how often various developers were just like this is literally the most impactful thing I will ever do with respect to climate change in my life like I will not be able to like outstep this this accomplishment you know so there was just this like feeling of actually being able to make an impact especially when you look at estimations and the theorem uses like as much energy as Poland or something and all and and and climbing is it simply just a function of Ethereum using less electricity or is there a deeper like relationship between proof of stake and climate change or is it simply as simple as just moving away from proof of work yeah I mean I think it's if we have crypto economic consensus mechanisms and uh which the asset securing it the the quantity and capital securing the protocol scales with the value of the protocol um when that is energy consumption um you quite simply have this like tough relationship between energy consumption and the and the security and value of protocol which like we all want the security and value of the protocol to increase um and so there's a a bit of a I guess the dark side to it um and I look I you know we could I'm I don't buy the like Bitcoin or uh green energy thing or that like Bitcoin is going to usher in the new way of green energy I don't buy that I think there is probably some nuance to the argument I think you could have like an interesting debate as to like if you have these proof of work mechanisms what does the future look like in 20 years you know does it look like Bitcoin using 50% of all the energy in the world probably not it's like it's hard to imagine that that becomes the reality um and so maybe there's like more nuance into how this this actually ripples outward but um nonetheless I I would uh I would make a pretty grand bet that 80% are more of a Bitcoin and Ethereum's energy consumption is not clean um and making an impact on that seems seem meaningful I think there's also there's other components not just the um not just CO2 emissions climate change that kind of stuff I mean there's also the uh the access and the the potential like the amount of people that can participate in a proof stake protocol on a meaningful way is probably much larger than proof of work um it's also more equitable in a sense that I can very purely turn capital into an equitable participation in the securing the protocol whereas in proof of work like that scales very poorly for small actors so like the the more capital that you have the more entrenched you can get into real world supply chains the more return you can get on your capital and the economies of scale and so like you you know fundamentally even you set the energy stuff aside that asset being grounded so much in the real world in not the metaverse uh means that you you don't get kind of the the same equitability and in the crypto economic consensus mechanism which one is maybe not nice from a philosophical standpoint but it's also not nice from a security security standpoint was there um any conversations at this interrob event about bitcoin and how bitcoin is like bad or needs to change or um should like should be shut down or any sort of like resistance towards bitcoin as a as a system um there's been too much time on bitcoin uh it's certainly it's the butt of jokes sometimes um you know I think people people that are working on it there in proof of stake find bitcoin probably pretty uninteresting um it's very interesting because it moved the needle you know from zero to one but it uh people also I think tend to find it very uninteresting and then there's certainly toxic there's toxic members of any community um I think if you look at a twitter there's a lot of uh loud toxic uh bitcoin members community members and so I think that sometimes when conversations come up about type of group like we we would focus on that we're instead of focusing on maybe some of the good but I don't think we see a lot of the good because we don't we're not deeply ridden in the community we just see loud uh toxic people we they're in conversations we were there was a running joke about um writing a proposal maybe a bitcoin improvement proposal to utilize uh not not our beacon chain not the theorems beacon chain but a but a beacon chain you know and instantiate instantiation of uh of the same technology to do emerge for bitcoin and to help them get off of proof of work um there are some complexities there and how you actually lock your lock your stake you might actually might need a new opcode and I know there are pretty resistant to that but I think it'd be pretty fun um even to just take as a social experiment yeah I mean literally just like you know in 2017 there were a hundred thousand bitcoin forks like bitcoin diamond and whatever the hell uh you could you could you could make a uh you can make a bitcoin fork once once the theorem has proven that you can safely move and purport the proof of stake you can make a bitcoin fork and try to try to rally the world around it uh using the same technology that we've used in a theorem to to secure it I think um who does that really matters right yeah well why not you that's what I'll do once once the theory massifies I'm gonna I'm gonna help bitcoin move the proof of stake yeah um what about um ruin christian sins blog post with uh recent blog posts I don't know if you read that or not was that a topic of conversation at the interrupt event I don't know the blog post I'm sorry uh he was proposing that maker Dow with its efforts to go into the real world and search for a real world collateral specifically finds climate aligned collateral right so uh maker Dow has already financed like a two point four million dollar loan die loan to a solar panel farm in New York and then he talked about like you know more philosophically maker Dow should find a collateral like find opportunities to finance and get collateral that is climate aligned and can actually like move the needle with the guards to climate change and then we didn't come up a conversation this interesting I mean there's two different angles there one is like ride the hype like maybe you you get you get good press and it helps maker Dow to just like have this aligned basket but there's also like yeah I think it's more interesting if you can make a compelling uh business case you know maybe the the thesis is that these are actually the the types of collateral and the types of businesses that are going to be very fruitful over the next 10 to 20 years and that's why you know maker Dow is being aligned um you know I don't know I don't know exactly his angle there yeah um my my angle on it was that like there's a lot of uh the very far left social justice warrior cancel culture types that are also very very anti capitalism um and what what happens if you can like create a money that fights climate change where if you use this money or by proxy mining climate change like you actually might like onboard some of that demographic into into the world of money and finance and say like yeah we do we do know that money and finance is corrupt and bad but not this money and finance like this money and finance is actually good it's the inverse of that yeah why don't you learn to use money and finance and new coordination techniques to create the world you want to see um yeah totally um so one thing about the the dev uh interop event and overall like that I was joking with uh I think both Ryan and Anthony Susano in different contexts about this like from you you know what it's like to be there and actually to experience it a lot of us who the non tech types view it from a distance right view it from Twitter and we just see the pictures and so like from our perspective it's like this semi-regular like ceremonious time where we see pictures of all these developers looking at this projected screen with a bunch of code on it and they're all happy they're all happy and clapping and so like all the devs are like looking at the screen and they're all everyone smiling and then like everyone else is seeing the smiles on the devs face and so for us it's like yay that's the devs are happy I don't know what's going on but like they're happy so that's nice I showed that picture to my sister last night and I showed her the other picture they're been edging in sweet and I showed her the other picture of um of the screen we're all looking at and she's cracked up she thought it was hilarious she's like that of course of course for context I don't know if it's on that picture but one of the pictures that were shared with the key was there's a tiny little piece of text that said proof of stake stage entered or entered proof of stake stage you know and that's what we were all cheering about right right right okay so this is the first mock test net or actual test net for the the merge so you simulated the merge was that what happened right so we kicked off a proof of stake beacon chain that was not merged you know like the beacon chain is today in production and we kicked off a proof of work chain that was not merged and was run by proof of work both of these things hung out in parallel for a while and then they uh they did the dance to take the valuable things inside of proof of work and to instead put them into proof of stake and stop listening to proof of work and finalize and and move on with its business um so it was it was the what we were cheering was kind of the culmination of the week which was we had a lot of very short lived dev nets so like even just transitory I have two nodes running on my computer like running an experiment for 30 minutes and I'm like okay the experiment worked that's good you know and and we had like I said we had a lot of these different client pairs where like gath and tech gath and tech who would like pair up for a bit and like make sure the software worked together and and nimbus and nethermire would pair off and like make sure their software worked together and like we're building out more and more complex versions of all the interactions throughout the week um and but often you know with two or three nodes like nothing crazy like very small toy networks and what we did at the end of the week was Perry who is a dev ops wizard at the EF who has been increasingly taking ownership over test nets and automation and all sorts of good stuff he'd been working all week on automation of all this stuff and so he took all the configuration and uh automated a hundred node deploy around the world so like hundred different cloud instances around the world with different client pairs and builds and like automated the creation of the the beacon chain network and the proof of work network and and and kind of kicked it all into motion and then it was about I think they ran independently for about an hour and then we had it on the projector when they when the the trigger event came together and they and they merged and so it was really that like taking it from a toy on our laptops and you know different like reduction and complexity of different configurations so like bringing it to something that really you know felt real uh that network I think was torn down yesterday and there's a new one pithos which is the um so it's supposed to be a longer standing one uh that is was it launched literally like an hour it was launched this morning but like the configurations became available about an hour ago and I already started seeing some of the East staker guys I think lamboshi was on it he was already running nodes and you know so now the the community can also interact with it um can you tell us what the sound was like when in the room when that preposake mode entered happened like what's it was it like oh yay neat or was it like more about it roar of people I mean it was it was legitimate like legitimate joy legitimate like clapping not not just like a little golf clap but like clapping cheering and people people literally hugged each other you know um it was it was it was an incredible energy and we actually we had this closing dinner at 7 30 that night and the the time stamp that we we did the merge because proof of works especially when you're CPU mining a proof of work chain it's like hard to fully gauge the timing but it was 7 29 it was t-minus one minute till dinner like we were either going to go to dinner like super fucking excited and floored about what just happened or like kind of with our heads hung like the last chance of running this experiment it failed and it was a success and like we kind of we all just went to dinner after and had a had a great evening celebrating this that's so yeah a minute before you you have to go to dinner so I'm sure maybe some amount of clapping was like oh thank god we get to go to dinner I don't even I mean I doubt I mean I think we were all a bit late for dinner but it was um the the timing couldn't have been couldn't have been better it couldn't have been more suspense inducing in dramatic yeah do do you get shivers I probably not I got something I got one needed to go in a completely different direction um is your wife a crypto person yes okay does she understand like what you're up to my wife works for the Ethereum foundation oh okay so she don't well there's the answer to that question yeah I didn't wish she there with you um she uh she used to be a pastry chef in a French restaurant in the French border in New Orleans and I started traveling a bunch for work and so us being you know young and having fun was like well definitely quit your job and come travel internationally a bunch um and she got to know some of the people on the grants team and they needed someone to help like answer emails and stuff uh so she started as the person who helped answer emails and stuff and then like three or four months later was the team lead nice very cool yeah so like when you when you were like uh I mean you work at home but when you quote come home from work and like vent about stuff like she's like oh god the the guys from take you were just up so annoying today is that some of the conversations that go on we some yes I certainly she knows what I'm when I'm bitching about something she knows what a bitching about um and uh and she understands things enough to like when I describe some issue I'm begging my head against the wall she like understands the domain of the issue right yeah but it's also sometimes we'll be like driving into the mountains uh for for a weekend and we'll just be like talking about a theory and be like we get to stop like we like I can literally talk about a theory all day to the people on the internet and then I can like go have dinner and talk about theory and more and it's uh it's very cool but it's also it's sometimes a little much Eric Connor who is the first ever guest on on layer zero we were talking about this dynamic where like you literally can wake up and do a theory and things until you go to bed uh and then repeat that for years uh and then you get what we call this thing called a theory and brain where like you know you just have like toxic levels of a theorem going around in in your brain did uh but you said you have good work work life balance so so maybe you don't have too much a theory and brain I um I have a good work like balance I do I do get a step away from the computer I do make sure I have nice little trips and things like that and I I do go out to dinner and stuff but I also um I'm probably toxically infected when you when you say you guys go to the mountains are you hiking or backpacking uh bit of both just kind of depends sometimes we'll go stay at a motel in the mountains and hike around a bit and put around some downs or sometimes we'll go backpacking and my favorite thing is to swim in very cold alpine lakes so often we'll be hiking up to 13,000 feet to find a nice late to jump into yeah which was like recently snow a few weeks ago uh yeah I mean it just it just depends I mean sometimes there's like snow on the on the outside of it still uh just spend some time with the air I you know I think we're minimum the minimum snow hey Tyco um three weeks ago and I think it snowed up in the mountains about a week ago so the cycle has begun if you're if your cat hadn't come on screen I was gonna ask about it so that's Tyco Tyco yeah uh how old the eight eight the image I have of you we were on zoom at some point in time but there was this timer you had you had Tyco and Tyco was facing the computer so uh he he yeah he was facing the computer so like kind of like pseudo looking at the camera and you were just like massaging his head it was like at least 20 minutes long of like you you just yeah just like massaging your head while Tyco like kind of looked into the camera right in front of you I thought it was absolutely hilarious yeah and there he is yeah yeah I mean I tell Tyco sometimes Tyco you're my best friend yeah and I mean it and not in a sad way that goes my best friend nice yeah he uh he's looking to spend spent a lot of time working on proof and stake with me nice yeah more more support Danny you can do it Danny so uh what what else do you do for fun other than backpacking and hiking are you a gamer at all no I probably left gaming behind when I was about 13 I was I played I think Diablo 2 and Starcraft were my main games at the time I play a little bit kind of strict and stuff but I um music and girls became much more interesting way to spend my time so playing or listening to girls no to music oh what do you play um these days I play mainly piano but I in high school I played a lot of piano but also uh bass I played in like jazz bands and metal bands do and you still play play piano to the same when I was 18 I went to school and I stopped playing music and um about four years ago I got a piano and I didn't I play about every day so I took a hiatus uh but I I play most days now at night I very much enjoy it what kind of piano do you play hmm I learned some classical pieces um and and play that I also which is kind of mess around and I do actually when we launch the the beacon chain I bought myself the present um I got this like moog synth so I have a piano and I have the synth uh next to each other and like you know I kind of mess around and make weird electronic stuff uh between the two guys have you have you heard of um uh uh uh band from optimism his Ethereum song yes yeah ever ever ever thought about uh writing something like that uh or is that or is that tainting of something that's holy that doesn't need to be mixed I definitely I think it definitely doesn't need to be mixed I also I I don't think I've ever played the piano and sang at the same time so it would be a challenge it would be a new challenge maybe I should try so I think this question is always much more fun when somebody's actually a musician what kind of music do you listen to so in college my music taste change um because I started coding no shit so I stopped listening to music with words like almost entirely and started listening to a lot more electronic music and I listened to like ambient electronic music most of the time uh very experimental like very like kind of out there sounds and soundscapes and things like that and I can definitely attribute that to like being in college drinking that cup of coffee put on my headphones and just like coding and like getting into coding for some and like what what got me going when I code and like I that radically has changed my music taste and over the past couple of years I've like tried to reintroduce not what I'm coding but like if I'm in a car or different things like that like I'll put on I don't know talking heads or put on like the Beatles or put on something where somebody's literally saying words um so like pull myself out of the uh the ether but is it because the words are distracting while you're coding or is there something else there I think so I think that's probably it I mean it's not just the words are distracting it's that these soundscapes are like enhancing um like I oh here's a good one when I first in 2017 when I got rid of my clients and I wanted to figure out how to make theory in my work I would listen to all the all core Dev calls and the opening is um steep hills of vicar dentiers by a winged victory for a sullen um that's incredible yeah um so that that became like my anthem for a while like that album like every morning I would just like I'd drink a cup of coffee put on the headphones and like figure out how to make a theorem you know where to bring value to a theorem and I would just like listen to that album and something about the fact that it's the opener to the all core Dev call um and that it also kind of fit my ambient soundscape mode like it became like my uh my power music that's that's awesome that's a great story um Andy Danny as we come down to the end of the show I have just a few more questions for you are you an optimist or a pessimist hmm I I used to be an optimist so when I was a kid very extremely optimistic and I think it served me well and I've realized actually probably over over the course of the past few years I've become less of one so I'm very optimistic about my life so like I you know I I have a good life I have a great cat got a cool wife um I have a great job all that kind of stuff um and so so I'm definitely optimistic in social relationships and and kind of the microcosm of my world um but I definitely like the old man like shaking his finger at the rest of the world in a certain sense like I don't you know I'm super pessimistic about politics and super pessimistic about like our you know uh mass surveillance capitalism I'm super pessimistic about a lot of that kind of stuff um and to to to a way that I I need to make peace with um because I think it like gets me a little bit too much um and I also sound like the whack job when I'm talking to uh regular people but um the but that's also one of the reasons I work on Ethereum you know if you asked me in in 2017 why why I wanted to work on Ethereum one nerdsniped totally but two was just like I don't I don't like the trajectory of the world I don't like what's happening with with big technology I don't like how we're all super manipulated by our phones and like we have these little slot machines in our pockets and they're just like abusing us and like I don't think Ethereum solves all of those problems but I do think that Ethereum in a related technology might help change the trajectory um and I think it might help change the trajectory for good you never know you never know I do worry about that sometimes you know like the tools that are that are built are often co-opted by the powers that be to kind of continue doing business as usual I do think that the theorem in related technologies allow for new ways to interact and maybe kind of help avoid some of those previous issues but you know I'm also naive well Danny I think that that is a fantastic place to end this conversation so thank you for joining me on this layer zero thank you very much enjoyed it cheers hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me anything and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation