DAOs are heating up. In 2021, the tools and infrastructure surrounding DAOs have taken off at an incredible pace. Digital organizations have the potential to fundamentally change the way we coordinate as a species.
We bring on DAO experts Kain Warwick, Cooper Turley, and Tracheopteryx to provide insights into this budding movement.
What is different about DAOs? Why are we excited about them? ------ 📣 TracerDAO | Building DeFi Infrastructure. Join the Discord! https://bankless.cc/TracerDAO ------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ 🎖 CLAIM YOUR BADGE: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/-guide-2-using-the-bankless-badge ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
💰 GEMINI | FIAT & CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
🔀 BALANCER | EXCHANGE & POOL ASSETS https://bankless.cc/balancer
👻 AAVE | LEND & BORROW ASSETS https://bankless.cc/aave
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING http://bankless.cc/uniswap
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 4:00 Kain, Cooper, and Trach 6:32 Are DAOs Different? 10:55 Leadership in DAOs 16:32 Keys to a Successful DAO 23:08 Purpose and Values 29:13 Optimal DAO Size 36:20 The Goal of DAOs 41:00 Does Coin Voting Suck? 51:49 The DAO Lifestyle 57:21 Fluidity, Growth, and Community 1:04:07 The A in DAO 1:10:45 Slaying Moloch 1:15:11 How DAOs Change Lives 1:19:32 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Kain on Twitter https://twitter.com/kaiynne?s=20
Cooper on Twitter: https://twitter.com/Cooopahtroopa?s=20
Tracheopteryx on Twitter: https://twitter.com/tracheopteryx?s=20
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
You Hey, bankless nation. This is panel time on bankless. We the panel is an opportunity to deep dive into a topic with a number of guests who are experts in the space. And today we're talking about DAO's. This is how to DAO. And we've got a fantastic group of panelists for you. We're going to have this conversation. David, why don't you give us a preview? Yeah, there's a number of conversations to have about DAO's about like, are they really all that fundamentally different? What rules about organizations have changed now that we are in the DAO world? And also what rules are actually exactly the same?
What does it mean to have a good DAO? And do all DAO's follow the same rules about what it means to have a good DAO? What are all the same problems that DAO's are are faced with? And what problems do only some DAO's have? There's a lot of things to unpack here because collectively as an industry, we are all learning how to DAO. And so we've brought on some of the best leaders who have some of the most experience with DAOing to get their perspectives as to how to DAO. Yeah, absolutely. So we've got Kane Warwick, Cooper Turley, and Drake from The Wire and Protocol. We're going to be talking to all of them.
And we really think that DAO's are the new opportunity to front-run in crypto. There's a massive amount of opportunity. This is really how crypto is coordinating human capital as well as asset capital. DAO's will replace companies one day. We firmly believe this. You remember our Josh Rosenfall episode where he talked about the crypto Medici? Well, we are the new crypto Medici. And joining a DAO is one way to dive deeper down this rabbit hole. You will not regret it. Speaking of which, DAO opportunities. Our friends at Tracer DAO have just launched a DAO. They're working on a DeFi perpetuals product.
Pretty exciting stuff. They're looking right now for governors and contributors. So if you're interested in that, join their discord. Get involved. We'll include a link in the show notes. Guys, we will be right back with our panelists. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Living a bankless life requires taking control of your own private keys. Not your keys, not your crypto. That's why so many in the bankless nation already have their ledger hardware wallets, which makes proper private key management a breeze. But the ledger ecosystem is more than just a secure hardware wallet.
Ledger is the combination of the ledger hardware wall and the ledger live app. And if you're used to seeing all of your crypto services and favorite deaps all in one place, ledger is where you want to be. Not only does ledger let you buy crypto assets straight from the app, but it also hooks into decentralized exchange aggregators like periswap, which makes sure that you are getting the best prices on your trades without your assets ever leaving your control. DeFi never stops growing and the ledger live app grows alongside with it. So click the link in the show notes to see all the DeFi apps that ledger live has.
And stay tuned as more and more apps come online. And if you don't have a ledger hardware wallet, what do you even waiting for? Go to ledger.com, grab your ledger, download ledger live and get all of your deaps all in one place. Bankless is proud to be supported by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure. Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum, which is what Ryan and I call a money robot. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries just autonomous code on Ethereum.
Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. Something brand new in the Uniswap ecosystem is the Uniswap grants program is now accepting applications for grants. We have been saying this for a while and we'll say it again. Dows have money and they are in need of labor. If you think that you have something to contribute to the Uniswap Dow, apply for a grant to Uniswap. Just look at the size of the Uniswap Treasury. It's almost $3 billion. This mountain of capital is looking for labor. Do you have something of value to contribute to the Uniswap Dow? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a unigrant at unigrants.
org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. That's exactly what we did to get Uniswap to be a sponsor for Bankless and you can do the same for your project. Thank you Uniswap for sponsoring Bankless. All right, guys, we are back. This is the How To Dow panel. Really excited to introduce our three guests to you. The first is Kane Warwick. He's the founder and benevolent prefrontal cortex of synthetics back on synthetics these days. Kane, how are you doing? Been really well. Yeah. It's been a good couple of weeks. Just got back from our Western atmosphere off site. We're in about 15 or 4 contributors for the first time.
That was really cool. Hey, hey, people in a Dow actually meet in person and get to know. It's great. It's great. He leads crypto strategy at audience. Governance and friends with benefits. Another Dow also an advisor to the variant fund. They are big into Dow's and the creator economy as well. And he's a general Dow operator. I feel like he's in every Dow I've ever seen, or been a part of, including pleaser, C club, forefront, fingerprints, probably some other dows. We don't yet know about coming in the future. Cooper, how are you doing? Doing wonderful. I'm excited to dive into it. I think this is a hot topic and you've got some of the best on the holidays.
So thank you for having me. I think it's the hottest topic. And the reason I say that is because like we're front running everybody else right now. It's kind of, I think you said this last time we were on together, Cooper is like where NFTs were at this time last year. Lastly, we have Drake. He is a contributor at wire and Lex punk and coordinate really cool infrastructure for decentralized compensation, servicing dows to Drake. How are you doing? Doing great, man. And I'm, yeah, also psyched to be here and talking about this amazing stuff with you guys. Man, we are psyched to have you on psyched to being crypto at this time.
So we're going to dive right into some Dow topics. You guys ready? Let's do this. All right. You know, I'm going to start with this play the devil's advocate because like, you know, why not? Let's start with the skepticism first. So the skeptic says, even the skeptic in me, quite honestly, are dows really that fundamentally different from say a traditional LLC? Maybe it's just like an LLC or a corporation without a nation state registration. But isn't it fundamentally sort of the same same thing? And if so, why are dows even special law? Why are we having this panel? Why are we excited about dows if that's all they are?
Why don't we start with you, Ken? What's your take? So yes and no, right? Like yes, you know, corporate governance is a coordination mechanism. It's just a really shitty one compared to dows. And so, you know, when you look at what a Dow enables, you have the ability to kind of transcend any one regulatory jurisdiction or like any legal structure. You don't need to be domiciled in a particular place. But the Dow itself is kind of the arbiter of the rules as opposed to, you know, needing to kind of resort to some external court laws or legal jurisdiction. And that's a really powerful mechanism that, you know, dows enable is this kind of self-contained coordination mechanism that is autonomous, right?
It's outside of any particular place. And I think that's powerful, and I think that's why we're seeing people from all over the world come together to form these dows in a way that you couldn't probably do something easily with corporate governments. Okay, so Ken making the point that dows are super national. They're outside of any single nation state jurisdiction, Cooper. What do you think about that? Is this still the same like corporate governance, just in a super national structure? Is there something more here? I think that it's a lot more fluid. You know, the biggest thing I'd call out is there's no team and user dynamic, you know, team and community are one and the same.
What that does is it allows for people to come in in a much more free-flowing manner. So with the dows, you don't need to worry about going through an HR process to be hired to a multi-year contract with the vesting schedule. You can jump in and start contributing today. I think that ethos to allow people to come in and contribute as they see fit. It opens a design space for a lot more collaboration and also allows there to be a lot more ownership in that project. And so beyond the legal structure, I would say the precedent behind working for a dows has a lot more ownership involved with it. And as a result, you see people coming in and doing things in a much more fluid manner that we haven't really seen outside of like a cooperative or a freelance model, which I'd say is fundamentally different in the ways that dows work today.
So Tray gets this idea that we've got this super, super national entity exists outside of the nation state. There's also permissionless. Anyone can join, anyone can contribute. Everyone has sort of a vested interest in what goes on. What would you add to this question, then, Drake? Yeah, I would say it's part of a developmental process in the collective consciousness. You know, you can look back. They're, if they're not fundamentally different than former forms of human organization, but they are fundamentally better. And they're kind of breathtakingly better in so many ways. Just as like the capabilities of a tribe or a religion or a nation or an incorporation, now you have a doubt in each one of these different shapes of organization emerges from different financial legal theories, different theories of personhood.
And on top of blockchain, you know, beyond nations out in cyberspace where anybody can be whoever they want and their permissionless and open dows are just kind of radically different and better. One thing that's striking to me, Tray, because I'm looking at your like Avatar, right? Like I see, you know, I don't see a person here, right? And so this is the idea that you're getting at of kind of pseudo-anonymous contribution as well. You could never contribute to a company in this way. There are probably few organizations we could contribute in this way. But like a Dow is much more meritocratic.
You don't have to have a nation-state ID in order to contribute. And here you are contributing as what would you call your insignia here, Tray? Well, here I'm a kind of shaman dinosaur, which is actually pretty close to what I am. So what one question that always arises with me and Dow is in the name Dow is the word decentralized. But there's hasn't really changed any sort of role with regards to leadership or has there. And so my first question, my question on this is maybe to you Kane as the founder of synthetics, which has then morphed into synthetics Dow, how is leadership in Dow's the same as previous organizational schemes?
Or how is it totally different? You're muted as well. Thanks. Yeah, it's a topical issue for synthetics, I think. So it's honestly a hard question to answer. I think that there is always a necessity when you have group people for some level of kind of responsibility, right? Diffusional responsibility is very dangerous when coordinating people. And I think that that's one thing that we haven't maybe solved yet. Like right now, we're really powered by enthusiasm, right? You know, people like Cooper who in 85,000, just working 24, 7 and just super excited about the space. There does come a time, and I think synthetics being four years old or whatever it is, where people need to be put into some kind of leadership role when it comes to organizing other people who are going to be doing something.
But the critical thing, I think, and the critical difference in a Dow versus even the old synthetics open source software foundation model is in the foundation. There was a person who was the ultimate controller of that organization, right? In the synthetics Dow, there is no person who sits at the top of the hierarchy, right? There's a council which is a representation of the will of token holders, but the token holders are tens of thousands of people spread all around the world. And so you have this idea of there isn't one person who controls the outcomes or decisions or whatever of this organization, but there may need to be people who help coordinate the individual humans doing some specific activity.
They can't choose what to do, but they can help coordinate what has been chosen by the community. Cooper, as Kane said, you're a part of roughly 85 Dow's. So how has leadership changed or how have different Dow's chosen different leadership models? And what have you seen that has worked out in some of the Dow's that you're a part of? The great question. I'd like to clarify, it's actually 87 Dow's. I just could destroy two more, but as we as we started this podcast. I mean, I think that framing was really accurate from Kane. You know, I think that in the early stages of a Dow, obviously, someone's going to play a pretty key role in getting it off the ground.
I think that's necessary for it to get started. But what you start to see is that after that first operator is hired to sort of run the day to day, you know, those responsibilities start to get positioned outwards. And I think the more that people are taking key roles in Dow's that are not that specific leader, that's when the conversation around decentralization starts to happen more meaningfully. You know, to me, when I heard that word, I think about, what does it mean to have a voice in this project? You know, are my criticisms, thoughts and feedback actually being heard, or are they being deflected?
You know, this is not a support desk re-open. It's like a ticket on Zendesk and then have someone respond to you two weeks later. You know, there's a discord channel where you can talk to a leader in real time and really voice your opinion. And with token-based governance, you now have a way to show that in a way that actually is meaningful and impactful. You know, and I think that in the world before this, there was never really a structure to voice those opinions very meaningfully. And so to answer your question about how they evolved over time, I think we're still figuring out what it now looks like at full decentralization scale.
What we are seeing now is that leaders are becoming more comfortable empowering contributors to actually take on meaningful stakes in these projects. And over time, I think that's a really powerful precedent that I don't have to be best friends with Kane to work for his protocol. If I show up and I do meaningful work for a community, the people around me are going to see that and I'm able to own a significant stake in this network. Drake, you've been on the front lines with coordination inside of YURN and also started building out your own tooling to solve your own problems with regards to coordination in YURN.
How have you seen leadership inside of YURN grow and develop and what thoughts do you have on the leadership question with regards to Dows? Yeah, it's a really important question and I really resonate with what both Kane and Cooper said. One important thing, a lot of people think that you know an evolved corporations or organizations, Freudian slip there, evolved organizations that there should be no hierarchy. But that's really kind of just kind of logically false. I mean, the sun's bigger than the earth, you know, like there is hierarchies in the world. Like somebody knows more about something than me, that's important.
What the problem is around rigid hierarchies, you know, which is kind of by default what happens in a legal corporation, you have to have these kind of rigid structures. And Dows, what's really important and different is you don't have to have it, but it doesn't mean that you don't need leadership. You still need leadership. And we really also need to develop new processes, new tooling that can support natural and fluid leadership. Like we say at yearn and coordinate, the leader is the one who knows what to do next. And you really want to be able to support that type of leadership. That's super cool.
The leader is the one who knows what to do next. Very cool. Let's talk about this. So I feel like Dows are in the early stages maybe, but they're starting to enter sort of the crypto, Z-Guys, the crypto hype cycle, if you will. And I feel like some people think, oh yeah, all it takes will take this idea that we have or this model we have, and we'll sprinkle a little dow on it. It'll just grow and like it'll be successful and it'll flourish and it'll be worth millions. And everyone will be excited about it. But we've seen through history. I mean, right now it's not the first generation of Dows.
We've seen many generations of Dows. And those of you who've, you know, been in the space for a while, remember like cycles of previous failures. So I want to ask this question because we've all been a part of Dows that have failed. We've been part of some of that are successful. What is the difference? What's a differentiator between a successful Dow and an unsuccessful Dow? Drake, why don't you weigh in on that question? Yeah. So actually, I'm going to coin a term here. The three P's, which just came up with this today, purpose, principles, and process. And it's a nice way to talk about things that we're doing at year and now.
And I've been thinking a lot about, you have to know why you're doing something. And then you have to know who you are, who you're trying to be, you know, in the organization where your principles are. And then how you're doing it. And if you're doing those three things in a Dow, it's really important. I know some people will kind of don't like the idea of stating principles because it reminds them too much of like Google's bullshit principles or whatever, right? You don't have to do it in a boomer way. We all have principles, right? And actually, most of the Dow's that I'm in or that I know, they actually have really strong vision in principles, just often it's not stated.
It's almost like if you state it, you're going to become an old dude. It's kind of how you hold it. It changes. It's alive. It reflects the system, but it helps you remember what you're doing. So yeah, purpose, principles, and process. Can I ask about the last one really quick, Drake, and a follow-up? Because I feel like there are some Dow's out there that have maybe the first two sort of down. They get the principles and they got the purpose, but they fall down on the process. And we do need to reinvent processes for this new organizational construct. Do you have any insight into successful Dow's from a process perspective?
What do they do differently? Yeah, it's super important. But also important, you don't want to over-define processes. You know, you don't want to like rigidly structure everything, but you need process. How do you make decisions in a Dow? Of course, there's coin voting, but there's so many other types of decisions that people need to make. How do you elect members to this synthetic council? How do you handle somebody being an asshole to somebody else? There's a lot of types of processes that Dow's need, and it doesn't mean that they have to be the old bad style of business process, by the way.
But you still do need process. Yeah, and I wonder how much of these things we can borrow from the old world from different organizational structures, for instance. Cooper, I want to turn the same question to you. I know you've been a part of 87 Dow's, and like so successful ones versus unsuccessful ones. What are the big differentiators in your mind? I would say broadly over simplifying, did it go to zero? So yes or no binary question. I would say if people are showing up on a recurring basis to meet and discuss the purpose of that Dow, it's considered successful, in my opinion. I think the biggest unlock that we've seen from the first chapter of Dow's is that we now have liquid tokens representing ownership in these communities.
In the first chapter of Dow's, you typically had non-transferable shares that represented social capital in some claim on assets, but it was fundamentally different from being able to expand and have an asset that traded on a secondary market. Now we can use key metrics like token prices the way to gauge sentiment there, but I think success of a Dow is actually much more on the human side. If you go into a discord, if you come to a community call, is that Dow scaling in operations? Is it consistently taking on new work and shipping new things? If the answer is yes, I would say that that's successful in my mind, and if it clearly doesn't have a recurring contributor base that's coming back to discuss things, then I would say that that basically went to zero and is a failure.
So, Cain Cooper is saying if the Dow has a pulse still alive, then that's some measure of success here. Let's talk about the mega-dows, the ones that are going to dwarf companies in size and their success. What is it about Cain? Is it talent? Is it about community? Is it about better process? Do they have first mover advantage? What do you think are the core things that make a Dow super successful? It made my experience the things that have really enabled Dow to be successful and have continuity is a sense of legitimacy, that the processes and the systems that the Dow uses are legitimate. This is really important for some of the things that both Cooper and Trick mentioned.
People need to be able to come in and contribute and feel like there is some meritocratic principles that they're operating on that it's not just some kind of click of people that can exclude you or whatever. So, they need to be open, they need to be transparent, they need to be legitimate, all of the processes that they're using. But I also think that there's not, you know, the missed goes for the synthetic community. I think there needs to be a level of kind of buy-in of all the community members that they're all kind of working towards some shared vision. And if you go back to the bad days of synthetics, there were only like 20 people.
But there was a really strong sense of purpose what we were doing and everyone felt like they could contribute. Ideas, concepts, work, whatever it was. It was very open, low-barried to entry community and there was a lot of engagement from even back in foundation days, myself and other members of the team with the community. It was a collective effort that we were all working towards. Obviously as we've moved more towards a doubt and deprecated those kind of legacy functions, that's gotten even more powerful. But I think now today you can turn up in synthetics, you can start contributing and there's a real sense of legitimacy of the processes that we implemented.
Drake brought up the word purpose and all three of the panelists used that word in their most recent answer. And so I kind of want to dive into the values and visions that we see inside of DAO's. And I want to start with you, Kane, because synthetics and other defy DAO's, like Uniswap or urine, have a very concrete purpose. Like urine is to optimize yields. Synthetics is to generate a synthetics asset trading platform. And then we have DAO's like bankless DAO, which is a little bit more nebulous in their vision. It's to propagate the bankless meme, the bankless message and bankless infrastructure and education, which is not as specific as simply just like maximizing trading volume or a synthetics market cap.
So let's start with what you think is the values and visions of synthetics and how that plays a role in maybe DAO membership, DAO organization, DAO coherence. But what is overall the role of values and visions for a DAO to succeed? I think within synthetics the kind of primary guiding factor for us has just been solving hard problems, iteratively experimenting towards a solution to this very difficult problem of how do you have a productive, lateralized network of synthetic assets. And we've had a lot of iteration and a lot of experimentation and not all of it's been successful. But we've always had this very open-minded approach that we test things and anyone can come in and suggest something that they think would be a good potential solution.
And so I think that that kind of overarching principle has allowed us to be very fluid in how we've tackled problems. We haven't locked into this is the thing we do and we only do it this way and everything outside of that is kind of excluded. The solution is based over with synthetics. But I think even more broadly outside of trying to build a synthetic asset platform, more like over time my sense is that the community is as kind of interested and as driven by this idea of coordination and actually building a governance framework that is legitimate and can allow this to operate. Now the fact that we need to be decentralized for a whole bunch of reasons has kind of been a forcing function for us to get this right.
But we've started this process a long time ago and it's been a continuous process of moving decision-making more and more into the hands of token holders. So I think that that maybe, you know, Vitalik kind of talked about this like DGov versus D5. In my mind, the DGov part of synthetics is probably more important than the D5 part of synthetics. You know, in 20 years time when we look back, the experiments that we ran on governance will probably be far more important for the overall ecosystem than the experiments we ran on synthetic assets. Turning to you, Cooper. Kane is the, you know, like we said in the intro, the benevolent prefrontal cortex of one specific Dow, but I think you might be up to 80 dows at this point now in the call.
And so with all these dows that you're a part of, how is values and visions an important component of all these different dows? What's the general role of values and visions in dows? Yeah, so it's like by saying that most of the dows that I am are more social clubs than they are financial protocols. And so I think fundamentally that, you know, view on the way that the Dow is meant to operate changes sort of the focus. You know, I'd say for a lot of the dows that I am in, it's about meeting people online, it's about finding a sense of purpose and community in the way that you spend your time on the internet.
And I think when you start to think about values from that perspective, it's less outcome driven. You know, if I can go into a discord community and meet three people in my local city and make a friendship online, that's kind of the end state that I'm driving forwards towards. And I think that when you start to think about culture as a means for value accrual and for sort of just identity, you start to get into very different situations. And so I'd say a lot of the stuff happening right now around the NFT market with profile pictures, a lot of stuff happening around social clubs like friends with benefits.
You notice that there's not sophisticated financial products being built. But when you look under the surface, you notice that people are far more interested in governance because they feel a sense of purpose and ownership over the way that they're contributing. And as you scale that outwards, I think the mission here is to make sure that no matter where you go in the world, any city at any time, you can find someone that has a shared value as you and go and hang out and have a good time, grab a beer, grab a coffee, whatever. And so long as there's, you know, these sort of pockets around the world to meet community members, I think the values of the Dow simply make friends online.
We can do that well. That's a successful down my book. Drake, take us home on this one. What is the role of values and visions inside of a Dow? Well, it really helps align people's effort and helps unlock their creative energy. You know, so knowing what you're headed towards and how you're going to get there. So, you know, it's an active living discussion at year. And you're in kind of came from chaos. And, you know, we're growing all these new organs all the time. But there are principles that matter to the people at year and like action, creativity, innovation, initiative, collaboration, and integrity.
You know, like what I find in, in year and in many places in DeFi is that not just trying to make a ton of money and like take over the world, you're trying to do something more meaningful, you know. And that's, I think where a lot of the also the organization stuff comes in, I really resonate with Kane is saying, like when I look at the things that are most exciting to me, it's like how we are learning to coordinate. And we're doing really hard things, you know, and doing it, you know, with no nets where we're we're walking this tightrope and you need incredible trust and incredible integrity and to coordinate like that.
Drake, I want to ask you this question about like Dow size, like David and I have talked about from the earliest stages of of bankless that this whole crypto movement is about social scalability, essentially scaling human coordination, right. And we have this hard-wired constraint called Dunbar's law or Dunbar's number, which is like inside of our biology and inside of our DNA. And that's that's the idea that any human being has a hard time managing over 150 personal connections. So I'm curious about Dow's as we think about like the size, the optimal size for a Dow. Like what is the optimal size for a Dow?
Sometimes it seems like Dow's can be very successful early on when you've got a core team dedicated and focused almost like a mini, mini startup, if you will. But then like can we scale beyond that? Or are Dow's meant to be sort of small tight knit teams? What's your take on the optimal size for a Dow and how it how it might scale in the future? Well, I think there's so many different types of things that people will use Dow's to do, you know. And often when we're talking about Dunbar's number or looking at research from like Mark Granaveta or Bill Putnam around weak ties and social cohesion, you know, you're thinking about certain types of activities in certain environments.
But in Dow's there's going to be even every type of activity. Like I could be part of a science fiction book club Dow, right, with tens of thousands of people. And if the decisions they're making is just what book are we reading next? That'll be a pretty effective Dow, you know. But if the Dow is trying to do things like create an incredibly complicated piece of software with a certain design, etc. It's going to be hard to do that with so many people. You need a smaller group to do that, or at least you need groups of smaller groups that can coordinate in an effective way. So it really depends on what you're trying to do.
But I think we'll see Dow's from one person to billions of people. Kane, for what synthetics is done, you guys started as sort of a very small, even like a centralized team and now it's this decentralized community. What's your take on a Dow's size and how that has scaled with synthetics? So just first to go back, you asked a question earlier about like actually there was a question about early Dow's, right. And I think one of the issues that we had with the early Dow's is the Dow created some fear in people and you know to have this like unconstrained thing that was just like deployed immutable and you know it could go wrong in all kinds of fun ways.
And I think that then a lot of this kind of subsequent Dow's that launched were really just bullshit Dow's, right. Like synthetics was not a Dow, maker Dow was not a Dow, right. Just because it had Dow in the name did not mean it was a Dow, right. It was a foundation was run by you know one or two people. It's only been you know in the last like well three weeks or something that maker Dow actually became a Dow right by wanting up the foundation and kind of you know handing over control to you know the system itself right to open holders. And so I think when we look at you know that evolution from these very centralized entities that were not really Dow like at all to now the big difference is that we have tools you know there's a lot of tools there's still a lot of tools to be built.
And I think that there's a huge open space you know a solution space for people to build better Dow tooling. I mean the project that got me most excited in the early days of Ethereum is our right now you know our gone obviously the love spectacularly again not a Dow. So there's something we said for that as well right like it's it's amazing how these non-dows you know have such you know interesting coordination failures but there's there's no question that there's a lot of room for better tooling in the Dow space you know things like snapshot safe snap you know compound governance module there's there's definitely stuff out there but there's a lot more work that needs to happen but when you've got something like synthetics I think you are kind of inclined to just roll your own tooling to an extent and one of the things that I've been pushing for within the community is for us to kind of try and get this tooling a little bit more accessible so that other people can use it.
And I think that that's a really big thing that we need to be pushing for old Dow. So if you build something cool urine does a really good job with this you know as I said compound is done you know some of the cool stuff balancer you know snapshot like you the onus is on you to get it out there and you know make it accessible for people to use I think that's really critical and you know it's something that it's like it should be a really you know important part of not just building your own tooling but making sure that it's cool and that's accessible to the rest of you know the different community because that's the only way we can kind of test and experiment and iterate on this things.
So Cooper how about you want to bring you in on this the same question about Dow size like so Jeff Beza I think Amazon has implemented in the past something called like the two pizza rule where no meeting size should be larger than the amount of people who can eat from like two pizzas right so like if you run out of slices your meetings too big it's the idea and that's the idea that like large numbers make things inefficient and effective hard to make decisions do you think there's an optimal Dow size and Drake said kind of it depends on what you're trying to accomplish but what have you seen from your travels.
I would say that for the core working working groups of a Dow anywhere from five to ten people that have legitimate you know responsibilities and that feel really good to me I think having a circle for passive contributors to come in and contribute makes a lot of sense but being able to assign key ownership roles to five to ten people and feeling confident they can always report back to a wider structure has been what I've seen work well you know I'll call out that there's no one size fits all Dow model you know I'm in one Dow called fires where it's four of us and we are very intentional about not opening that up we want to keep that up for members you know I'm in another Dow conference with benefits that it's 1500 members and counting and both of those are working extremely well you know on Monday we had a town hall where 270 people came together we had about 10 of our 80 contributors come to the call and discuss what they're working on and what I'd call out here is that while there were you know 50 to 80 people in the Dow that are doing work on a day-to-day basis the fact that those thousand members can come in here about that and feel a sense of ownership on what they're working on they then feel more inclined to take that next step and get involved and so the thing that I'm spending a lot of my time on is it's very clear to me people really want to work for a Dow there's a lot of people I have a lot of skills to offer and they want to get involved but right now we just don't have good onboarding funnels and so organizational structure of Dow is to be able to identify you're really good at something I'm going to put you into a team to work on that I think that's the single biggest hurdle we need to make Dow is more scalable and that's something that I'm spending a lot of my time on to figure out onboarding talent specifically you're talking about Cooper correct Cooper you earlier said that you are largely a part of like social Dow's and so I want to ask this question to you there could I could I think I could argue pretty effectively that it was it the goal of all Dow's collapses down into increasing capital and that's extremely obvious when it comes to Dow's like yearn which is trying to you know put a bunch of you know YFI and ETH on the treasury or Dow's like Uniswap was trying to take trading fees and they all have their own tokens and they went token price to go up do you agree that the goal of all Dow's is to increase its capital and I also want to put into into your your brain when our episode with Joel Manegro really opened up the definition of what capital really is it's not just you know the financial capital that's on on the balance sheet but it's perhaps the social capital and human capital which maybe that maybe that fits into the social Dow conversation but in your opinion what is like the end game for Dow's what is the goal for all Dow's yeah I would definitely double click on the fact that capital is both financial and social I think increasing relevance in the world is extremely important and so when I think about you know what is the purpose of the social Dow's how do you value culture you know this is a question that I asked a lot I think in crypto so far we've been able to value financial assets which has been fantastic but now that you're seeing a lot more interest in sort of meme and speculative investing what does it mean to place a price tag on a community ethos or to place a price tag on a fashion brand or something like that and so I think it's a new asset class fundamentally but to answer your question directly I would say the mission for all Dow's increased relevancy and mind share in the world and whatever you define as capital to be able to define that that's kind of what a Dow looks like to make.
Trink with the goal of urine is the end game simply just to collect as much fees as possible and have the Dow be as well capitalized as possible or is that overly reductive yeah I think it's that's one of the goals but the goal is also to just continue to find new ways to innovate to create to work together to improve the space yield aggregation is the thing that we're focused on now but that could change who knows. Okay and same question to you I think you know again it comes down to purpose right like the purpose of synthetics is absolutely to you know expand the market capital synthetic assets because that's the utility that that's the service that we're all coming together to coordinate provide but you know as I kind of alluded to it may be that in chasing that purpose or chasing that goal we end up developing something that's far more powerful which is you know these decentralized governance tools right so I think that they're positive externalities for Dow's because they operate in the open they're transparent all the software's open source should be if it's not you need to take a look at yourself not in any names but you know I think that they're you know creating public goods in a sense right you know when you're building this tooling and so yes like in a very narrowly defined sense like synthetics is about expanding the capital you know the assets and management and the market cap but I think that that can throw off some some positive things that are outside the scope of just capital a cool guys this is a hot panel we've still got some more things to cover including Vitalik says coin voting sucks in his recent article I want to get into that topic also talk about opportunities so the average listener is not yet joined to Dow wants to be more active in Dow's how do they get involved what are the opportunities in this space but before we get to those questions we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible when you shop for plane tickets you probably use kayak expedient or Google to compare ticket prices so why would you limit yourself to just one exchange when you trade crypto when you make your trades you want to make sure that you're getting the best possible price on your trade and that you aren't paying high gas costs that you could have otherwise avoided that's why you should be using matcha matcha routes your orders across all the various defi exchanges on Ethereum polygon Binance smart chain and gives you the best possible prices without taking any commission matcha has smart order routing that splits your order across multiple liquidity sources if matcha sees that it gets you better pricing trading on matcha is super easy because it pulls the liquidity for me into a single easy to use platform and that has even saved me multiple times from accidentally picking the wrong decks to trade on and accidentally getting a bad price matcha also allows for you to make limit orders on chain so you can set and forget your defi trades and they will go through automatically while you're away new to matcha is an integrated fiat on ramp you can purchase crypto directly with your credit or debit card and have that fiat be instantly traded for any token that has liquidity when you're making a trade head over to matcha.
xyz slash bankless and connect your wallet to start getting the best prices and most liquidity when you trade your crypto assets Arbitrum is an Ethereum scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use defi if you've been using Ethereum for the past 12 months you've probably noticed the high gas fees and the slow confirmation times that have been plaguing defi too many people want to use Ethereum and it doesn't have enough capacity for all of us that's where Arbitrum comes in. Arbitrum is a layer 2 to Ethereum which means Arbitrum can increase Ethereum's throughput by orders of magnitude at a fraction of the cost of what we are used to paying when interacting with Arbitrum you can get the performance of a centralized exchange while tapping into Ethereum's level of security and decentralization.
This is why people are calling this Ethereum's broadband moment where we get to add performance onto decentralization and security. If you're a developer and you want to save on gas costs and make an overall better experience for your users go to developer.offchainlabs.com to get started building on Arbitrum. If you're a user keep an eye out for your favorite defi apps building on Arbitrum. Arbitrum has been working with over 300 teams including Ethereum's top infrastructure projects and will be opening up to all users shortly. There are so many apps coming online to Arbitrum so you may want to pack your bags in preparation for the great migration to the Arbitrum layer 2 to keep up to speed with Arbitrum follow them on twitter at Arbitrum and join their discord.
Hey guys we are back fantastic panel so far we've got a few more topics to cover we've got Kane we've got Cooper we've got Drake illuminating us on the world of DAO's how to DAO. I want to get to an article that Vitalik published actually earlier this week and Kane you made reference to it earlier this idea of DeGov being really important let's figure out to centralize governance maybe that is the biggest thing that crypto is actually doing maybe that's even bigger than going bankless and bigger than defi I don't know but one of the points he made is kind of like coin voting sucks right like we can do better than simple coin votes in how we govern our defi protocols and govern our DAO's I'm going to throw out something from his summary here coin voting is attractive because it feels credibly neutral anyone can go and get some units of governance token on Uniswap I mean practice however coin voting may well only appear secure today precisely because of the imperfections in its neutrality namely it's an important part large portions of the supply staying in the hands of a tightly coordinated clique of insiders so I want to ask you does coin voting suck and if so what's better where can we evolve to Kane what's your take I mean you know maker aside from being an incredible solution to stablecoin problem was also kind of a natural experiment improving the coin voting sucks like I think pretty definitively put the nail in that coffin that like direct coin voting has so many negative aspects to it including like chilling effects it's you know lack of participation lack of engagement all kinds of things right so I'm 100% agreement with Vitalik that the direct coin voting on on kind of individual proposals is really sub optimal the thing that we this view that we had I guess in synthetics was like how do we maintain rough consensus while overlaying some control for how do you balance those two things and so in the early days it was like just discord right you had a personality in discord you could be a non whatever and that was the kind of you know one person one vote rough consensus about specific proposals and then I think that over time it evolved into a coin voting system but that coin voting system was sort of established in such a way is to ensure that it wasn't one coin one vote it was sort of you know we applied like quadratic waiting to voting you could only vote for one council member so you can't run run the table and get all the council members on there so there were a number of things that we did to kind of constrain the direct coin voting and it created something that was more robust so you know there's still a lot of experiments in that direction I think around delegation and representative democracy but in my mind that's kind of a hybrid thing so I still think you need some control for token holders you don't want to divorce you know the tokens from governance but you also don't want to have it so coupled so you know so tightly coupled that you get the you know all of the issues that we've seen with the maker and some of the other direct token voting systems.
Drake what's your take on this the suckiness of coin voting and is there something less sucky? The suckiness is enormous of coin voting and you know I mean there's so there's so much this question I love Vitalik's article read with it very much you know you need I don't even know where to start the you know urine has developed a whole system of governance in order to do both listen to wifey holders and allow for people to make independent autonomous decisions without having to go for to whip votes for every new decision which is just a nightmare and you know one of the things that happens I think in crypto is we get so obsessed with adversarial environments and in blockchain and we think that everything's supposed to work that way but that doesn't make any sense you know like there is a role for trust what a world with no trust and it is not one I want to be in you know but the beautiful thing is that because blockchain creates this incredibly strong trustless foundation you see so much more trust flourishing on top of it and it's not about just open trust do whatever it's about being thoughtful with how you create structures and how you bestow trust and making it transparent so that you know one of the nice things about trust is that it can be broken and it can teach you how to make new systems to avoid that happening in the future and to get stronger and to share things in a better way and so we develop all of these tools like urine governance too you know it's we've been having this awesome collaboration with synthetics recently looking at our two sides of different ways of governance which both have solved similar problems in different ways and neither of us have done direct on chain voting for you know direct control of treasure your contracts no for good reason it can be just like metallic lays out there's a lot of ways can go wrong Cooper what do you think about this coin voting you know I struggle with this topic a lot I think when you take a step back governance is such a small small problem for so many people in the space right now in more broadly the world you know I think for a lot of people the idea of using any asset to vote on something that you have a role in is a very new topic you know for the vast majority in people this world they've never participated in a governance decision most likely they never will and so I think that this article highlights a lot of really accurate points for like deep crypto governance systems today where I get caught up with it is um recognizing that we're not in a place yet where we've gone to a large enough scale for these experiments to play out in like a really meaningful manner and so to me what's set out from that article was just sort of emphasis on quadratic voting you know I think that can't touch on this as well but we're slowly shifting into a world where it appears that you know the amount of individuals voting on something is the larger signal than the people with the most capital voting on that and so I think that trying to run more experiments in that direction where you're encouraging participation you know you're allocating capital to governance and you're trying to make sure that people recognize this is something to pay attention to I think we can get to a place where once we have more diverse opinions in the conversation we can start to see more meaningful conversations around this but right now I think that for the most part it's the same hundred token holders voting on every protocol and I think to me that's a very small subset to make definitive you know decisions about whether or not systems are broken when in reality we're still so early in the conversation of what global governance would look like I think that's a really good point and uh well I I also agree with the italics article coin voting sucks I think it's also important to like take a step back and and look at um all of our existing legacy system suck more right like once the last time you or any users had any influence in what twitter does or uber drivers they have any influence in their network right so like even the the basic zero to one of now users in the community to your point earlier Cooper have a vested interest in this network that is a big step forward so yeah coin voting still sucks and we can drive towards better solutions but like everything in the old world sucks way more like I want a piece of every network I am a part of as a user in this world this is what crypto has taught me yeah maybe I think yeah sorry I think like italics counter argument to that if I could be so bold this is the speak for him uh would be that like you can have ownership of a thing without you know resorting to like direct token vote right like those things don't need to be coupled um and yes like the ownership component is far more powerful um of a thing that means system systems um but you can have you can have an ownership component with no governance rights right and you know that would still be better than you know the the status quo um because you don't have governance right now governance rights or um you know or uh a stable uh in the um in these systems like Uber or whatever um so I think that the like we should be careful about a couple of those things two times good point Cooper you have anything to add there where we go on yeah I mean I think that King's exactly accurate there I think the uh education around why governance matters is something that I care very deeply about you know I don't think that a lot of people understand that if they take the time to learn about governance there's financial freedom at stake there's social freedom at stake you know I think for a lot of people when we hear governance we think about electing the next president which is a conversation that has not been naturally very exciting to them what I've found a lot of purpose and in crypto is being able to use governance as a means to work on what I love and so you know outside of the mechanics for how governance is used I think that being able to educate people that by participating in the deepest nuance of the networks that you know in love you can work on literally whatever you want in the world and I think as we get to a point of figuring out what that looks like you know the mechanics for how we do governance we'll get more defined you know as that kind of opportunity gap closes and everyone recognizes if I spend 10 hours a week on a governance forum chances are I'm going to make more money that any salary you could ever pay me in my life guys so far this conversation has really been about Dow's holistically so I want to actually turn the conversation to individuals who make up these Dow's and how a Dow lifestyle is different than the lifestyles that you know we would find ourselves in a typical legacy job and so Cooper as somebody who's part of all these social Dow's how does what is a Dow lifestyle mean to you what does it mean to work for a Dow and how does that change how an individual can live their life and how to explain it to your parents the great question the way I live my life now is ownership stakes and all the products that I contribute to so I'm slowly supplementing any form of consistent income on a fiat basis to just ownership stakes and networks and I think that principle of going into a community and being able to earn a significant ownership portion for the value contribute it's extremely scary you know to my parents them me telling them hey I'm not going to take um USD per month to pay my rent I'm going to earn magic internet tokens they're going to be worth more you know for the last three years they're like what the hell are you doing but you know as this started to pan out more and we saw specifically this last year those ownership stakes become valuable I think that it's easy to recognize if you go into a network and you start working for ownership over capital there's going to be a path forward there I think to answer that question very directly of how I spend my time it's a connector role you know I think that the single most important thing to do for Dow is is putting people into the right pockets together and then helping to coordinate that effort and so a lot of my time is basically identifying who are the key contributors in that Dow how do I make sure that they're actually owning things that matter and how do I make sure they're touching base with all the other people that know what matters so that the ball is moving forward and they're communicating that to every other member of that Dow.
Drake can you kind of compare and contrast what your life was like before you started working at yearn and how just the lifestyle of working inside of a Dow has changed how you live your life? Well I was writing a science fiction novel before I started working at yearns it was pretty different but before that I ran a company you know and it's super different and so many ways like one of the things that I'm most passionate about with working at Dow is is creating I call it like the party bike you know a system where on a party bike anybody can pedal as much as they want you know somebody wants to steer they can they can drive and you want to stop peddling and just chill and drink your beer that's fine like Dow's can be the system that harvest all the action from all of the contributors in any way that they want to contribute it which really supports this kind of self sovereign response individual responsibility of what is it that I care about what do I want to work on I'm not going to sign my life away as a wage slave for X number of hours any hour of my time is worth more than that money you know but if I just do those things that I'm called to money flows through the magic of Dow's and through the magic of crypto just like Cooper was saying like I just when I started a year and I didn't know I like wasn't involved that much in crypto until last summer and I just showed up at year and I was like holy shit Dow's are incredible I'm there's nobody's in charge here I'm just going to make the role that I want to do and I'm going to do that and it has I mean the extraordinarily beneficial in my life and it's wonderful what is that role by the way Drake I was a good question I mean I work on ungovernance and compensation and organization stuff yeah stuff it's stuff Ryan yeah so fun fact Kane also was working on a a book before he came to synthetics if you guys didn't didn't know that but Kane you've been a serial entrepreneur dare I say workaholic for for for like years now so as somebody who's had a perspective on the the laborers inside of synthetics as well as yourself how what is like what does work like inside of synthetics and and how do you see that as a model for Dow's at large yeah so we had a really interesting contrast right because blue shift the company that I found before synthetics which was this payment gateway that a bunch of the crypto exchanges in Australia used to you know get around banks which is thanks didn't like crypto back then they still kind of dove they're a little bit more open so we in our office synthetics kind of grew you know out of the blue shift office right there it was you know they were kind of similar people working on it and so you had this very like rigid corporate hierarchical structure with like investors and you know a CEO and like all these different things and then this like crazy thing over you know the other side of the office right which was a very flat structure even from the beginning but I think the primary difference when we transitioned from foundation to Dow is we went from a model where people had to do what I said right like they were actually obligated to do what I said right and you know I like to think that I was pretty open about you know collaborating with people listening to the mill that sort of stuff but the reality is that if I said you have to do this like you had to do it right and then we went to this model where that didn't exist anymore and you didn't have to do anything that I said right you don't know what you want it and so now we've got you know all these different stakeholders in the project and people just do whatever they think like Tric was saying you know they make their own roles they carve out your positions for themselves etc and it's a very different working environment it's much more open and I would argue a lot more fun it's a bit more chaotic but it's more fun than I reach it higher I think Tric I want to ask this next question to you uh Dow's we've seen are a lot looser in their borders right if you're a part of a Dow you can freely become part of another Dow when there's no jealousy there's no employment contract like there are with with legacy companies and that's kind of opened up the design space for the products that Dow's can build and so now that members can be a part of multiple Dow's and Dow's can less more freely collaborate with other Dow's what kind of things can we unlock with Dow to Dow collaboration now that there's less of a competitive environment and more of a collaborative environment with Dow's what can we do now yeah it's a really cool concept really and like the thought experiment like what if like one third of Apple employees also worked at Microsoft you know like what or if that was the dominant paradigm for you know the fang cadre I think so much and I think in order to get there I mean we can do so much in terms of just collaboration and really shifting what is the purpose of what we're doing is the purpose to create these gigantic immortal company entities that extract resources and turn it into work product you know is that the purpose of what we're doing here no you know so does it like we have all these trappings from the past like this corporate veil and legal boundaries and oh I've got this salary and this compensation and I've got this lock-in investing all this stuff and we import all this stuff into crypto just because you know we haven't invented anything better yet in a lot of ways but a lot of what I'm working on is like better ways to do compensation so you don't even need to worry what other projects you're working on who cares if you're moon lighting or if you're working on another project if you're bringing value to a project it should be rewarded so we need more fluid systems for enabling that type of you know contribution Cooper since you're a part of so many social doubts do you notice a lot of the same members in one doubt being a part of another doubt and how does that change the dynamics of all the different doubts you're a part of I think it just encourages positive some games you know we see a lot of the core contributors to social clubs leading into every community that they're in they'll do recurring panels in one now the host workshops in another one and you start to see that the camaraderie in that sector is a lot stronger because people are sharing everything together you know to Keynes earlier point about open sourcing valuable tooling I've been recommending so many people use their besting contracts for liquidity mining contracts they may have been you know the market standard and I think in the next three to six months here we're going to see the same level of open source tooling for more social applications so things like coordinate I think are a fantastic example around getting paid we're now seeing stuff around like tokenized membership events so for FWV we've built like a gatekeeper product that allows you to go to IRL events using an RSVP system you know so something that we're now going to open up and allow other communities to use and I believe over the next like year so here we're going to see both like financial products that are shared between communities and more important you know social coordination mechanism so that if you have a group of 20 people on the internet how do you assign identity and reputation and the more we can figure out systems on that front I think the more we're going to win together as a whole Cooper just a quick follow up on this like at some level it used to say this in the early days of DeFi that feels like we're we're beta testing we're all beta testers in the future the world's future financial system right it still feels that way but like I also feel that way with with doubts right you're talking about like all of these ways to participate in community well like what has community just about everything like everything like you talk about artists you talk about like you know fan clubs you talk about like the video gaming market these are all little pockets of the community it feels very much like crypto is just alpha beta testing all of this infrastructure that the rest of the world is about to use any reflections on that on how big this could get yeah the biggest mental model I've been following for a Dow specifically is community meets products not product meets community you know in the world previously teams will build a product and try and find users to go out and adopt it with Dow's you are building a community and that can use deciding what to build together and even if it's the shittiest product in the world they're all going to go out and go to back for it because they built it together and I think that precedent of only building things because a community thinks it's valuable actually helps us to identify what should be built and reduces a lot of the friction around things that don't really matter.
Kane has the again the prefrontal cortex of synthetics which is a very goal oriented project it has very explicit outcomes that it wants would you ever notice the people the contributors of this synthetics ecosystem will have their attention drift elsewhere to other projects and how was that ever a problem or was that kind of cool. You may recall DeFi summer um that was very distracting sir it felt very distracted. Oh my god uh but you know what like and this is where I think the difference between you know go back to like you know my formal life as the CEO of BlueShift versus you know the founders synthetics it was it would not have been acceptable for all of the stuff of BlueShift to just like run down the street chasing off to some fucking crazy thing right like that just was not like that wouldn't happen it couldn't happen right like there's a lot of oversight around what people are doing they're very defined roles um you had you know people within the synthetics community like helping out to launch new projects they were like you know helping out with community helping out with coordination they were just yield farming themselves they were degenerating they were you know doing all kinds of crazy shit they were you know doing code reviews for people um all it's like and there was no real way to kind of constrain that and there was at that one point I think there was a little bit of concern um within the project of like everyone is very distracted and I just sort of said like this is the process right like you know everything that everyone's doing people are going to learn from and you know it's going to come back and it's going to you know populate the project with a whole bunch of you know good and bad information that people gathered out in the outside world and that's just the way it goes right um so you know we we took a very kind of uh you know um I guess open view of you know letting people do whatever they wanted and um you know and now with the with current kind of structure what we're trying to work out is how do we have some uh level of coordination within the core contributors right we're paid they're paid to stop and monthly to work on specific things to make sure that the outcomes that we're looking for um you know from those people are kind of met um but it's a hard problem right like when you start from a very open kind of framework it's hard to apply retrospectively um you know some rigidity to it so we'll see how that goes but it's definitely an experiment from it right now it's super interesting because you definitely want accountability but you also in the Dow world have such loose ties on talent but you know uh I think that can actually be an advantage for crypto in that like hey talent's not going to want to work for handcuffs anymore like your Google your Silicon Valley non-compete clause like forget that right doesn't exist in crypto so I do think this is going to be a boon for for bringing talent in the space this new way of working is going to catch on when I ask another question to the panelists um David and I have had a reoccurring discussion right so this term is Dow that we've been seeing the entire time decentralized autonomous organization Dow right um the A in that sometimes I find a little bit um not troubling not there's intentional deceit but like doesn't necessarily reflect the meme of Dow right because a lot of what we're talking about is not autonomous by autonomous we just mean like written in code right ideally immutable code on something like Ethereum for instance um do you think that these are really dues digital organizations instead of Dow's that we've been talking about this whole time and um how do you square that in your mind is the meme sort of wrong Kane what what are your thoughts yeah so you know my my sense of autonomous even if it wasn't the original intent and I think it kind of wasn't like again if you go back to the Dow right the idea was that it was this you know set of you know contracts running on Ethereum that um you know didn't require any intervention right but again I think what is that intervention because it's still required humans right humans were an import to the process of the Dow right so it had to compel humans to want to do something right which was like put up proposals to be funded etc right so it was never like autonomous to like the human species right it was never just piece of software that was going off and doing something that never interacted with humans right humans were an implanted process um but I think from me the autonomous component as we've kind of iterated on this this concept is more about being uh you know self-contained right it doesn't it doesn't require like the the humans that are an input to the process are within the Dow if that makes sense right um and it doesn't the rules are self-contained um and and coherent and it doesn't require uh sort of resorting to some external arbiter of uh you know like a legal system or something like that right everything that is done within the Dow happens within the rules set that's created within the Dow um and that also can obviously change right you know there's there's dowels that evolve and the rules change um but even the changing of the rules is encoded in the Dow itself right so you know that there's this evolutionary concept but but still there is this sense that they're distinct um and self-contained and that's where the autonomous community really rests.
Drake what do you think about this weigh in for us? yeah that's an awesome explanation and yeah I like to think about the autonomous part is kind of recursive or holarchic um which is that the whole object is uh autonomous and then Dow is really this kind of soup of human and software objects all functioning autonomously and the people inside the Dow are also autonomous and I think it really brings it back to that core crypto of value of sovereign tree self-sovereignty and it's like I am responsible for my actions with the other people I work with and together we are responsible for our actions we are autonomous.
Cooper I love that description that Drake just made of this the software and human soup that's really what it feels like it's being like a stew the other human beings interpicks with code do you have any thoughts on this question of how autonomous our Dow's or should we even care? yeah I think echo some of the earlier comments when I think of the word autonomous I think about independence you know we've heard multiple panelists say that many contributors and Dow's are self-defining their own role they're self-defying their own responsibilities they're leaning into something that feels very empowering to them and so I think of autonomous I think less about well this thing work in the absence of humans I think more about will this thing work with people feeling fulfilled from the work that they do in that Dow organization and so when you start to look around at all these Dow's and sort of judge the mental health of the people working on them I think you're going to find that it's much more autonomous and sort of how those people are living their day-to-day life and an aggregate I think that that energy just brings about such a new level of productivity that you know I could care less honestly if it's being run by software humans but so long as there's sort of a collective consciousness that's pushing it forward in a meaningful way I think that's the degree of autonomy that I measure.
I think the original definition of Dow's really focused on the humans on the periphery and code at the center definition of Dow's where we and this was these very pynus guy ideas of like Uber and Airbnb on the blockchain and Uber instead of being like a bunch of bureaucrats with a bunch of you know people in the middle with the with the value creators on the outside we could just replace the inside with code and the value creators would just talk to this like robotic like hive mind Uber app that was somehow a bunch of contracts on Ethereum and there would be actually no internal human organizations and I think the way we've gone from that OG version of Dow's which we actually have never actually seen before to where we are now which is kind of how everything is a Dow the way that that definition really changed is the A started to be inclusive of human incentives and so now we are just making big assumptions that humans are going to act rationally and basically our entire industry is based on the that assumption that human incentives are now going to make this thing take the next step forward and so that's really where we regain control and and appropriateness over that word autonomous in digital organizations so I wanted to add a few sense of my answer David are you saying you're okay with it being called Dow's now that's what I heard you say well it was it's not like we're ever going to be able to change that I do think the appropriate name is do's but did for digital organizations but it's that ship has absolutely sailed yeah remember we tried to open finance rather than defy yeah we got cyber on our our remember it very well guys I want to turn to the last few questions that we have in this panel and this panel has been absolutely mind blowing I'm going to have to go back and listen to it myself and on the bankless program we are obsessed with the concept of slang mollock he is the god of coordination failure and we want him to retreat forever and ever and ever and that is kind of the the through line that we think this in crypto industry can really help us achieve in this world and so from from your perspective how do Dow's fit into this conversation how can Dow's help slay mollock Cooper let's start with you I mean it's short I think that communities have never had the opportunity to share financial and social capital together so when you think about the way that you spend your time online it's not about going and working nine to five to spend your time on the weekends doing what you love I think dows are the means of which we can work on the things we love and get paid for that and so as far as it relates to mollock and sort of slang coordination failure I think when you start to shift focus away from financial capital as ends meet to instead like financial capital as a mean to work with your peers in a more productive manner I think dows are the single most important way that we can get to a place that feels really positive in that conversation.
Drake same question to you how can Dow's help slay mollock well I think every different shape of organization has a different cognitive capacity basically and what a child is capable of doing or solving is far different from what an adult can do and the organ is the best level of organizational technology we've had in the past these corporations are kind of like rusty machines compared to Dow's which can be like nature and if you look at what nature can do it can it can grow a grasshopper from dirt you know like yeah we can make a Boeing 747 but there are classes of problems on this planet that we are so far from solving that dows will be able to unlock for us.
Kane why don't you take us home on this one how can dows slay mollock? So one of my favorite books the whole time is inadequate equilibrium by Eliza Wiegowski and I think when I was reading it it was like 2017 2018 something like that and to me it was almost like a roadmap of like every problem that like better incentive mechanisms and coordination games can solve right like you know the book goes through like 10 different things right that like are just kind of equilibria that exists in the world that you know are kind of hard to break right there's a bunch of examples like you know replication studies and you know academic literature the fact that like no one's incentivized to do that you just wonder you know published novel results and it doesn't matter and I think that a lot of the reason for these things is corporations right like corporations have captured academic literature right like there's you know huge corporations that are you know responsible publishing certain journals they want you know the eye popping headline things right it's a little bit like you know media as well right you know they know there's no there's no money in replication studies even though that's what we need to actually kind of get science done and so when I look at something like a Dow to solve this this problem of like academic literature coordination it's obvious that that as a coordination mechanism could solve it unfortunately I don't have the time to do it but I hope that someone somewhere you know gets this idea and kind of runs with it because you know it's it's a really hard thing to kind of publish and distribute academic research right and peer review and do all that stuff it takes a lot of resources and you know to Drake's point like corporations were the only ones that could kind of accumulate enough resources to do something like that on a global scale and now we have DAS right like maybe governments maybe we're like the alternative the governments are pretty slow and shitty and corporations kind of run rings around them for a long time but now we have these DAS that have the ability to accumulate the resources to actually do things on a global scale and you know can basically reset incentives and create new economic incentives and set up new coordination games that can really shift the equilibria you know on a number of these problems a super cool framing government slow and shitty corporations a little bit faster dows order of magnitude faster than that maybe able to tackle new class of problems super cool that book was called inadequate equilibria if you missed it as as Kane mentioned adding it to my reading list maybe go join a reading club down and get more more of those recommendations guys this has been a fantastic panel and I want to end with this question so we're just talking super big picture right like pie the sky like how is this going to the social technology going to change the face of of of humanity how's it going to make the world better I want to zoning on you guys individually right so tell us about kind of your your DAO story how have DAO's changed your life and in what ways Cooper will start with you I mean I can confidently say DAO's are the single only reason that I have the name I do in crypto right now you know my entire trajectory in the space is owed to DAO's you know starting out from Mollock DAO and Medacartel working my way in for shares for writing articles to then getting involved with DeFi DAO's to now more of these social clubs if DAO's were not a thing I simply wouldn't be here today and so I think for anyone out there that's looking to get involved I'm not a developer by trade I have absolutely zero technical skills but the fact I've been able to build a career on the back of this cool new internet technology solely thanks to DAO's I think it's an incredibly powerful precedent that if you go out of your way to find people to work with online you know they're going to be financial opportunities greater than anything you could have ever imagined 21st century upward mobility Cooper do you mind if I ask how old you are for some of the folks listening you're like in your in your shoes yeah I just turned 26 in June crazy guys crazy can how about you have DAO's changed your life I think you know as someone who's done a lot of startups and as someone who has tried to tackle some pretty hard problems and failed to do so the ability to kind of coordinate people coordinate capital and work on really hard problems is you know I think something that just wasn't really contemplated in like the startup world you know 20 years ago those this idea yet to go to VCs what VCs would fund is a bunch of old white guys on Santa Road right like the the solution space of problems that they were willing to tackle is very very narrow as much as they would like to think that's not the case and I think that DAO's and you know crypto capital formation and DAO capital formation just opens up a world of different problems that that can be tackled you know and it's incredible and obviously super sad to be involved in that trade how about you how have DAO's changed your life well you know yeah I mean I worked really really hard for many years starting companies running companies doing project work for clients and it burned me out hard you know I tried to I tried to bring in a lot of these new ideas into those old companies like teal organizations and tried whole accuracy and things like that and worked okay but you know I ended up like you know selling my last company a few years ago and I was like you know I'm I just spent time like a year just healing you know I was like from all that work I didn't really expect that I'd come back in anything like this and you know when I found DAO's though it was like there's a few times in life where you're like wow this is like the combination of all the things that I'm excited about and I actually have the skills that I can really help this space and so it's yeah it's brought me back into this kind of you know creating impact in the world and another way has changed my life is it really challenges me personally you know it makes me question a lot of my assumptions about myself a lot of my psychological hang ups you know because when you're in this space of like infinite possibility um you really have this chance to question what the fuck you're really doing you know and that's a beautiful question to ask what do you really want and DAO's help me ask that super cool guys I think there are hundreds of stories like this maybe thousands of stories but there there about to be hundreds of thousands of stories maybe millions DAO's are really going to change the face of how we organize collectively how we do work in the future like so many things like I always think about this when we have a really insightful panel or a bankless episode it's just like you look out the world and the world sucks like it sucks sometimes but crypto is something that gives each of us hope right like I am optimistic because of crypto and it's super exciting to see these new social technologies emerge in this way and the spirit of optimism and guys thank you for making us even more optimistic on DAO's panelists Kane Cooper Drake you guys have been phenomenal we appreciate it thank you guys if you're hanging on youtube make sure you like and subscribe David I fit this one in like and subscribe again David's nodding his head happy about that risks and disclaimers of course Douser risky ethos risky Bitcoin is so is crypto you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend it joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me anything and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we