BTC vs. ETH. It's the crypto title fight.
Crypto is a non-zero sum game, but there can only be one #1 blockchain. Which of the two giants has the better monetary policy? What about roadmap? Community? Culture?
Tune in as the two communities square off to find out which protocol is the more sound.
***** POOLTOGETHER | DEFI LOTTERY https://bankless.cc/PoolTogether *****
SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ ️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
MATCHA | DECENTRALIZED EXCHANGE AGGREGATOR https://bankless.cc/Matcha
LEDGER | SECURE YOUR ASSETS https://bankless.cc/Ledger
ALCHEMIX | SELF-PAYING LOANS http://bankless.cc/Alchemix
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 4:00 Dennis, Muneeb, and Justin 7:09 What is Money? 11:18 Soundness 14:32 Properties of Bitcoin 19:45 Bitcoin's Security 25:33 Stacks vs Rollups 31:55 Blockspace Value 35:25 Fee Markets & Security 41:05 Properties of Ethereum 45:08 Weak Subjectivity 53:07 Proof-of-Stake 1:01:55 Money vs Smart Contract Platform 1:08:17 Stacks 1:13:24 Money & Execution Layers 1:17:25 Attacking the Network 1:25:27 Slashing & Hard Forks 1:30:37 Soundness & Monetary Policy 1:39:02 Ossifying and Innovation 1:43:29 Closing & Disclaimers
Resources:
Justin on Twitter: https://twitter.com/drakefjustin?s=20
Dennis on Twitter: https://twitter.com/Dennis_Porter_?s=20
Muneeb on Twitter: https://twitter.com/muneeb?s=20
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Hey, Bankless Nation, today we are having a special episode, a debate about Bitcoin and Ether, the infamous debate which one is money? What is sound money? Which one is more sound money? And joined me, co-moderating this debate, is Dennis Porter, who I've actually done one of these debates with before. So this is actually round two of a ETH versus Bitcoin sound money debate. Dennis, are you ready to get started with this? Yeah, I'm ready. Thank you for having me on, David. I really appreciate it. I had a really great time last debate that we went back and forth. It was mostly civil for the most part, so it was a good, back and forth.
We were able to discuss our points. It was more of a general Bitcoin versus Ethereum type of conversation, but this one looks like we're going to be focusing a lot on sound money aspect of Bitcoin versus Ethereum. So I'm looking forward to having it. We'll be joined by a couple of great ones as well. Absolutely, yeah. And so whereas last debate, it was just me versus Dennis, and then eventually we tapped in some people from the audience. We are bringing in some technical people as well. So I'm tapping in Justin Drake and then Dennis, do you want to intro who you have brought along for your teammate?
Yeah, I brought along Manib Ali. He's the founder of Stacks. He's building on Bitcoin is what they're working on, trying to bring smart contracts, NFTs, you name it, all the fun stuff that you Ethereum folks say can only be done on Ethereum. He's trying to bridge that gap with Stacks. So really interested to have him on, but also the reason why I bought him on is mostly for his technical skills, technical savvy, similar to Drake, really understands the framework of how these technologies work. All right. Well, without further ado, I think we should go ahead and get right into the conversation about Bitcoin versus Ether, which is more money, and so we'll get right there after a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible.
Arbitrum is an Ethereum scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi. If you've been using Ethereum for the past 12 months, you've probably noticed the high gas fees and the slow confirmation time that have been plaguing DeFi. Too many people want to use Ethereum and it doesn't have enough capacity for all of us. That's where Arbitrum comes in. Ethereum is a layer two to Ethereum, which means Arbitrum can increase Ethereum's throughput by orders of magnitude at a fraction of the cost of what we are used to paying. When interacting with Arbitrum, you can get the performance of a centralized exchange while tapping into Ethereum's level of security and decentralization.
This is why people are calling this Ethereum's broadband moment, where we get to add performance onto decentralization and security. If you're a developer and you want to save on gas costs and make an overall better experience for your users, go to developer.offchainlabs.com to get started building on Arbitrum. If you're a user, keep an eye out for your favorite DeFi apps building on Arbitrum. Arbitrum has been working with over 300 teams, including Ethereum's top infrastructure projects, and will be opening up to all users shortly. There are so many apps coming online to Arbitrum, so you may want to pack your bags in preparation for the great migration to the Arbitrum layer two.
To keep up to speed with Arbitrum, follow them on Twitter at Arbitrum and join their Discord. Living a bankless life requires taking control over your own private keys, not your keys, not your crypto. That's why so many in the bankless nation already have their ledger hardware wallet, which makes proper private key management a breeze. But the ledger ecosystem is much more than just a secure hardware wallet. Ledger is the combination of the ledger hardware wallet and the ledger live app. If you're used to seeing all of your crypto services in favorite DeFi apps all in one spot, ledger live is where you want to be.
Not only does ledger let you buy your crypto assets straight from the app, but it also hooks into all of the DeFi apps and services that you're used to. Using ledger live, you can stake your Ethan Lido swap on decks like Paraswap or display your NFTs with Rainbow. You can also use wallet connect inside of ledger live to connect to all the other DeFi apps that keep coming online. DeFi never stops growing and the ledger live app grows alongside with it. So click the link in the show notes to see all of the DeFi apps that ledger live has and stay tuned as more apps come online. And if you don't have a ledger hardware wallet, what are you even waiting for?
Go to ledger.com, grab a ledger, download ledger live, and get all of your DeFi apps all in one space. All right, guys, and we are back to get into this conversation about Bitcoin and Ether. What is more money? So we have two new guests on the show today. You guys just met Dennis, but we are also joined by Munib Ali and Justin Drake. Munib, do you want to tell us a little bit about yourself and your background and who you are? Of course. Thanks for having me, Sam Munib. My background is mostly distributed systems. I did a PhD in Computer Science at Princeton and then got into Bitcoin in around 2013.
And many of you might know me mostly from the Bitcoin community, but a little known fact that I was actually part of the Genesis sale of Ethereum. And I have been involved in the Ethereum community. For example, was part of the seed round of OpenSea and a bunch of other things like that. Fantastic. Thanks for that color, Munib. If you are a frequent bank listener, you probably know who Justin Drake is, but if you are new to Bankless, Justin, tell us a little bit about yourself, who you are, where you came from, and what you do in the world of crypto. Sure. So I'm Justin Drake from the Ethereum Foundation.
I mostly work on a set of upgrades to Ethereum, which we used to call Ethereum 2.0. And that includes proof of stake and shouting. I guess my background is technology. I studied mathematics. I was a FPGA programmer in the past life, Pyram Space. So I know a thing or two about Bitcoin as well. And Dennis, I know we talked a little bit about you and the intro, but also want to tell us a little bit about yourself and your background and how you came to be in the world of Bitcoin. Yeah, I jumped into the world of Bitcoin in 2017, tried to go all in on mining, but that was a lost endeavor. Eventually, I decided to kind of hunker down for a couple of years, do my due diligence, study this asset, study this market.
I'm a Bitcoin only kind of guy. Some would call me a maximalist, prefer to go by Bitcoin only. But now I've jumped fully all in on the world of content creation. So I started a podcast called Smart People Shit. And I also do another show called the Update, where I regularly update my listeners on what's going on in the space. Also a very avid and consistent contributor to Twitter spaces, where I do some of the better rooms, also involved politically as well. So helping candidates like Erica Rhodes and California's 30th District try to take down the most anti Bitcoin congressman in office right now.
Fantastic. Thank you for that, Dennis. And for anyone tuning in to Bankless, for the first time, I'm David Hoffman, co-host of Bankless, where we are big proponents as Ether as money, decentralized finance, and overall living a bankless life and promoting tools that helps one live a bankless life. And with that, out of the way, gentlemen, I think we need to start this conversation by setting some foundations. And the whole point of this conversation is figuring out which one of these assets is more money. But first we need to figure out what money is. And importantly, what is sound money? So Dennis, in your opinion, what do you think sound money is?
I'll keep it real brief and short and simple here. Let's start with what money is. Money is a tool. We discovered it 10,000 years ago. It's what it helped us form societies. We use it for storing value, transferring value, and measuring value. For me, sound money is money that is not prone to sudden changes, appreciation or depreciation and purchasing power over the long term. So pretty short and sweet. It has three uses, storing, transferring, and measuring value. And then as sound money, it maintains its value, doesn't go up or down appreciation or depreciation rapidly in a short term or long term.
Obviously, we'll get a little bit more into that as we continue, but just keep it simple for now. Justin, how about your definition of money and sound money? What is sound money to you? Right. So for me, money is basically an asset which has monetary premium. Monetary premium being this magic meme energy, economic energy that provides this asset more value than the base utility. And the classic example in my mind is gold, right? Gold has this industrial utility. It's using every single iPhone. But if we were to try and value gold purely on utilitarian terms, it would be worth maybe a trillion dollars.
But it turns out that it's worth more like 10 trillion dollars. And so this extra value is monetary premium. Partly because it's used as money and so it gains this premium. In terms of what is sound money, for me, it's kind of the ability to simply to accrue and maintain this monetary premium. And so basically, there's a space component and a time component. The space component is how much monetary premium can it accrue? How big can it become? And the time component is how well can it retain this monetary premium over time? I love that answer as well. Munib, tell us about your opinions of money and sound money.
What properties are required to produce sound money? Yeah, I think in my mind, money differs from sound money quite drastically. Like in the sense that money would focus more on the medium of exchange part. Like anything that you can use on a daily basis, like for example, if you're traveling to land in a new country, you pick up the local currency there and then you spend it. But you don't think about that currency as like a long-term sort of value. The minute you were to think about that currency as a long-term sort of value, you would actually evaluate it very differently. So I think in terms of as soon as you start talking about sound money, I think you start looking more into the long-term sort of value and potentially the unit of account.
So if I'm holding sound money over a very long time, like a decade or something, then I want to make sure that how will other things get priced against this asset? So that's the difference in my mind. One concept that I use internally to not have this confusion about money and sound money is I use the term currency instead of money. Because what is currency comes from the what current is basically money that flows. And so really I think it's important to distinguish maybe for this conversation currency and you even said the word currency money, which I guess for this conversation will be sound money.
So I don't think either of us, either two parties, the Bitcoin or the ETH party, is interested in their money being currency. I think we both are okay with it being currency. But really what we're going after here is the sound money property. And ultimately this is basically like which asset's number is going to go up the most? More or less over time. If you kind of really bake down the things like which one holds its value and accrues and captures its value over time the most. Does anyone have any problems with that differentiation? I mean just to be clear there though, sound money when you are looking at the definition of it, it doesn't necessarily have to go up in value over time.
It can also go down in value over time as long as it's very slow and incremental over time. So if you're looking at the actual definition, yes we would all want our sound money to go up over time obviously. But the true definition is a stable money, not necessarily a money that always goes up in value. So I think that's a very historical definition. And I think the notion of money is all around selling points and these selling points change as technology progresses over time. And so what might be in a reasonable definition of sound money in the past, you can list a bunch of properties. If you are able to innovate and come up with properties that transcend these old properties, then suddenly you've redefined the notion of money.
And part of the reason is because there's this comparative dynamic or even competitive dynamic. And you can look at, for example, with gold and Bitcoin, it's possible that Bitcoin will differ in gold and gold will no longer be considered sound money. Maybe because it doesn't have properties such as being digital. And so really it's important to look at these selling points and properties in the context of time and innovation. I think just said differently, there's a Gresham's law in economics where it's called bad money drives out good. And I think that's what Justin Drake is saying where, well, Bitcoin and gold, they have really similar properties.
But what one do you think is going to drive out the other? And I think maybe Gresham's law is basically saying, well, money collapses, converges down to sound money over time. I think it's important to know this there too that it doesn't make it not sound money any longer. I think just that in over history, humans coalesce around the soundest money. So gold didn't stop being sound money. It's just that Bitcoin is much sounder than gold. Just like how gold store stole monetary premium away from silver. Bitcoin will still monetary premium away from gold. So just a little bit of nuance there. I don't think we necessarily disagree.
Yeah, I'll share my mental model there like in terms of when you mentioned the numbers going up far. Like I think interestingly, like currency the solve problem. Right. So like there's nothing like new there. We already have currencies and we use them on a daily basis. But sound money interestingly is not a solve problem in today's world. And whichever solution you look at, you know, look at Bitcoin or eat, I think both are in their discovery phase for them. And in the discovery phase, you're likely going to go up and value because they're market size that potentially much larger than the market market size today.
And once you actually reach a stable point, then it will be interesting to see that the sound money aspect does it retain value go up in value or actually slowly lose value or time. You'll like that is now adequately defined. So unless anyone wants any final statements about the definition of sound money, I think we can go ahead and get into the differences of monetary properties of Bitcoin and ether. Sound good. All right. So since a Bitcoin came first in history, I think Bitcoiners get to go first on this one. Dennis Munib, what about the properties of Bitcoin make it the most sound money? Munib, you want to go or me?
I think you can go first. Okay. Yeah, for me, the attributes that make Bitcoin sound money that protect its ability to be sound money are the fact that its issuance is extremely stable and highly predictable. Bitcoin has a hard supply cap. So that that cap is set in stone at 21 million can ever go up, can ever go down. Obviously, people could burn their Bitcoin, make it even more scarce. It's also very extremely difficult to create. It requires a large amount of energy, labor theory of value kind of kicks in here in this place. But most important to me, the reason why I believe that Bitcoin is the most sound money is not just because it is extremely stable, very difficult or nearly impossible theoretically to corrupt or manipulate.
By governments or those in power, but because these components themselves cannot be changed. So it's very stable, highly predictable, can't be changed. Bitcoin has a hard supply cap, can't be changed. It's very difficult to create. And that actually goes up in difficulty over time, which increases its value and makes it more sound. So the biggest part for me when you're looking at sound money is does it have the attributes that you and I will probably agree on. But the one thing that I think is the most important is removing human control or the human ability to manipulate the issuance or the supply cap of that money in any given time.
Muni, before I bring in Justin here, do you want to add anything on to that? Yeah, I think my lens is a little bit more technical, like in the sense that for me, the fact that there is proof of work. I'm like involved here, actually adds to the fact that it is sound money, like in the sense that, you know, back in the day, people would actually do some work to dig up gold. And that actually adds an element of scarcity here, right? And I think that is a fundamental component of the proof of work. And I would say secondly, when it's easy to define, you know, some sort of new cryptocurrency and basically say that it has a hard cap.
I think that's relatively simple. I think what's what's like much more interesting here is the community that has emerged over the last decade around Bitcoin and how they have basically inherited this value and they're kind of like the defendants of the 21 million cap. And I think it's the value added by the users of the network and the community of the network. And the last part there would be that Bitcoin as a network was really designed from day one to be a global network. We're meaning that anyone around the world with, you know, a normal laptop computer could actually open up their laptop and independently verify that this is the correct state.
And I have the right number of balances. So I think it's a combination of these things, like proof of work with global access along with a community that is going to basically die on the hill of life, you would never be able to change the change supply. I think that's interesting. We need that you're adding in the community behind one of Bitcoin's defense layers because I've frequently got into bait about like whether or not Bitcoin has a social contract or not. And many, many Bitcoiners will say that Bitcoin doesn't rely on humans at all. It actually relies on math and math alone. That's one of the properties about Bitcoin.
But are you saying that there's actually a community human involvement that also puts up a shield around Bitcoin and makes it immutable? I think basically what I've noticed is Bitcoin makes it extremely hard to make changes at the consensus level. So the threshold to making any changes to the consensus level is extremely high, like the number of miners required, the number of scrutiny required for any even small changes. And that sometimes gets criticized as well, that Bitcoin doesn't evolve, doesn't change that rapidly. And I think the community where they play a role, and I think this was very apparent in the kind of like the block size wars where the community was basically was at one point, even the big companies and exchanges were on one side.
But it was the average users basically said, we're not going to let this change pass through. We just outright reject it. So I don't think that they have the property of coming together to define a change, but they're just very, very good at rejecting changes. And basically saying that we will always fall back to the base case to make no changes. Justin has anything that Dennis or Manip said, raise a flag in your mind about the soundness of money. Yes, so I think the main red flag is basically the security aspect of Bitcoin. I just don't see the long term security aspect of Bitcoin. I think it's a broken design to be completely honest.
I think part of the reason I think it's a completely broken design from a security standpoint is because it's linked security Lindy resets every four years. We're asking the question, can Bitcoin be secured on smaller issuance? And in that sense, you can kind of think of Satoshi as kind of this D Gen blockchain designer kind of trying to see how far he can push down the security of Bitcoin until eventually it kind of breaks. And so it's kind of like slowly boiling the frog over several decades and kind of seeing if and when it breaks. I guess the answer that Bitcoin is what put forward here is that Bitcoin will be secured by transactions fees.
I mean, we were to discuss that transaction fees is kind of a great B fuel for a number of reasons. One of them is that it's very volatile. It's also can be stolen. But even if we remove kind of these issues, if we just look at the quantitative aspect of transaction fees, today transaction fees on Bitcoin are about 2% of the issue. And so like 50 times less. And if you compare it to other systems like Ethereum, it's also 50 times less. And basically you can ask yourself, why is that? And I think the answer is basically that Bitcoin provides very little transaction or utility. The utility of Bitcoin is in the hotling is in the not moving.
You buy Bitcoin, you put it in a cold wallet, you hold it for two decades and then you sell it. And so that's two transactions over two decades. And so basically Bitcoin has in a way cannibalized its security plan by not adopting a virtual machine that allows for programmability. And then a Bitcoin has such as many of my coming and say, hey, I have stacks and I will provide programmability and I will provide scalability for this side chain. But the problem with side chains is that they lead transaction fees. So if you have a transaction on stacks, that transaction or utility is going to be captured by the stack network.
It's not going to be captured by Bitcoin. But then you might say, hey, hold on. In order to have transactions on stacks, we need to have deposits and withdrawals to and from stacks. And those would go through Bitcoin and so you'd be paying fees on Bitcoin. But that's also not the case in the long term. If you have a very successful side chain, all the deposits and withdrawals and all the bridging will happen natively with that blockchain. Like one very easy example is an exchange, right? An exchange can just hold a lot of wrapped Bitcoin on on on stacks. And basically when someone buys Bitcoin stacks, it just goes directly to that user internally to the stacks.
And so really the model of scalability and programmability for Bitcoin is inconsistent with it with it security. And then once you don't have security, you've lost, you've lost everything. And one of the things that you've lost in particular, most likely is, is your scarcity. Like the whole, you know, meme and narrative of having this 21 million copies is an illusion, right? It might hold true in the short term, but really what Bitcoiners are doing is that they're trading off short term predictability. So in the short term, we can understand this, this monetary schedule very, very well. But at some point it becomes unsustainable and something must change in the long term.
I want to make it need to jump in on the stack stuff, but there was one thing at the very beginning that you had said that I thought was interesting that I'd like to address. But I think addressed the majority of what you just said. But in the very beginning, you were talking about issuance and supply issuance. Well, the difference between I think really Ethereum and Bitcoin, which is a very important distinction here, is issuance versus a supply schedule. There's no issuance rate on Bitcoin. It's purely just a supply schedule. And in 2140, when it is finished, there will be no more supply issued.
With Ethereum, the problem I see when you decide to say, well, we need to have an issuance rate that we can manipulate or change, that's when you introduce the question of how much is enough? How much issuance is enough for minimum viable security? And unfortunately, when you start asking that question, the only person who can answer it is a human being. And thus being a human being coming into the situation, it requires human control and human manipulation over the monetary supply, over the monetary schedule. And so that's why I prefer a supply schedule. When you say that it's only dependent on fees, yeah, that is the future that Bitcoiners see.
I'm so bullish on the price of Bitcoin that I do believe that fees and they have over time, if you look at it, there's charts out there, you can look up. I can't post any here like I normally do on Twitter spaces, I can post some charts up top. If you send me a link, I can true. Yeah, there are charts that show the fees are over time predicted to become the dominant reward when mining. But I would love for, obviously, Justin, I'm sure you probably had something to say back to that, but I think Manib should address the stacks. That's a, that's a, that's a very well known type of criticism for Bitcoin's supply.
And like, how would, how would the incentives work once the Bitcoin? Right. And I think the way the way to think about this is that, first of all, let's separate out proof of work from the incentives for. Work will keep functioning, right? Like that thing is there, as long as they're incentives for minus a mind, they will keep doing the work. And at some difficulty level, and they will, they will still secure that. Interestingly, I think you can look at the phase during which the point is rewarding coming out as almost like a bootstrapping phase for Bitcoin. I think the biggest difference between, you know, my mental view and Justin's mental mental model here is that I actually don't look at Bitcoin as a transaction network at all.
So it doesn't matter to me how many transactions Bitcoin is doing, I look at Bitcoin as a settlement layer. Right. And that's, that's literally how stacks is defined as well. So it's actually not not a side chain. We call it a layer 1.5 and it has cross layer consensus between Bitcoin and stacks, meaning that the consensus transactions are literally happening with Bitcoin. So the stacks miners are heavily incentivized to pay very high transaction fees, because they want to mine a block. So if the incentives on stacks go up incentives on the Bitcoin side also grow up and those incentives are not coin base rewards.
So these people, like if stacks is valuable stacks as a, you know, 3.5 billion dollar market gap right now, very small and the grand scheme of things. But if stacks are successful and there are more incentives there that actually directly results in more transaction fees, very high transaction fees, because these people are heavily competing with each other. And that's the settlement use case. And I see Bitcoin as mostly as a settlement layer. And I think that given the limited block space on Bitcoin, people will be willing to pay insanely high transaction fees to put any data on the chain. And so I'm actually not worried about the incentive mechanism for work in the long term.
Just do you have anything you want to say to that? Yeah, I mean, I think the most interesting point is on the settlement layer, but I'm happy to also reply to Dennis. But I mean, I'm very curious to know basically how much is stacks paying? Like the way that in the firm land, we have shared security is basically through roll ups where basically these roll ups pay for putting data on the charts on the firm blockchain. And this is exactly the words you use pay for putting data on the blockchain. Now, my understanding is that Bitcoin is not roll up friendly. So you can't have, you can't have this model.
Instead, you might have a different model. And my question to you is basically, if you have twice as many transactions on stacks. I mean, that you're being twice as much data on the Bitcoin blockchain. My guess is that you're going to say the answer is no, like there's going to be every single block, you know, there's at most a constant amount of block space that's going to be consumed. And that's going to be orthogonal to the transactional utility that stack is providing. So that's, that's, that's not how it works. And basically, let me clarify the roll up line a little bit. So I think the only difference between roll ups on the Ethereum side and roll ups roll up type systems on the Bitcoin side is the competition power.
It's a Bitcoin does not have a full tiering complete programming language, but it does have Bitcoin spring. And you could do limited type of competitions there. We don't even do that. Right. So we mostly are automatically publishing hatches on the Bitcoin side, but this is actually cross consensus, meaning that part of the part of your application is literally running on the Bitcoin side. I'll give you an example of a Bitcoin lending application. So the Bitcoin lending application has your Bitcoin on the Bitcoin main chain. If you're lending your Bitcoin, you're actually paying a Bitcoin transaction fee to send out your Bitcoin.
So a collateral in a stable coin could be a smart contract on the stack side. Right. So you, I think the fundamental disagreement again between the Bitcoin and Ethereum camps is this idea that you need a full tiering complete language at the base layer. In our world, we're like, you don't need the full tiering complete language at the base layer. You can still build applications without having the full tiering complete language. I mean, the key word that you said here was hash, right, and not data. And there's a very different distinction between a hash of the data and the data, right, hash is constant size.
Yes, but it depends on it. It depends on the it's an order of applications, not order of something else. So it's order of usage. How many users, how many applications are, but let's say, even forget about hashes at the end of day, we're talking about a very scarce resource, which is the block space. I think you and I would agree that block space can grow infinitely. So the block space and Ethereum is scarce, block space and Bitcoin scarce. And at some point, the transaction fees is really how much are people willing to pay to write anything doesn't matter if it's a hash doesn't matter if it's something else, if they're willing to pay to write to a scarce resource.
And that's where the value of the transaction fees coming from. It does matter because if you're making one single checkpoint every single block, for example, then you're putting you just need, you know, one transaction per block, and that's a constant amount. And so there's this, there won't be necessarily a competitive dynamic there. Is your is your argument that Bitcoin block space will not be scarce. The people when we know is that the demand for the for the block space won't be that large because it's only one hash or one transaction per block. So I will disagree on two points. It's not one hash per block, but that's not how stacks works.
It's a it's a big olf miners, the number of miners plus the application. So it's a big olf miners plus the big olf applications that are doing the cross chain consensus, meaning part of their data is literally on the big one side. And secondly, I would say that I am willing to take the bet that the block space and Bitcoin is going to be insanely valuable by the time the Coinbase rewards actually run out. But let's go back to that point because I keep my I can't get my head around how Bitcoin's block space becomes insanely valuable. And while also Muni you said that Bitcoin is a settlement network, not a transactional network, right?
It's not it's not a visa. It's not a master card. It's just where Bitcoin's come to to settle, which seems to be in alignment with what Justin was saying where the main use case for BTC is holdling. It's for saving your wealth. You can use Bitcoin without actually ever making a transaction on the network for years, if not decades, in theory, Satoshi has used Bitcoin without actually making a transaction on on ever since 2009. And so where do you think all of this demand for Bitcoin block space, which is the way that the blocks a block chain sustains its own security? Where do you think this demand comes from?
Yeah, I think I have a great example that actually answers your question and Justin's critique as well. So recently, Bitcoin NFT started picking off. So every single NFT has its data, the hash stored on Bitcoin and every single transfer also results in information. So if you just look at an NFT market, so again, it's a big go off NFTs here, not a big go off the we're going to need you guys to define big O because that goes ahead. So big is basically it's a let me try to simplify. So when you're looking at a function, what is the input that is going to grow that is the main vector that is going to help grow something.
So if something is dependent on the number of miners, then let's say if miners go from 10 to 100, the resulting function is going to grow based on that. So let's say if something is dependent on the block, the number of blocks, but not their transactions. So it doesn't matter if you do 10 transactions or a thousand transactions, it's only going to do like one hash per block because it's based on the blocks not on the transaction. So in this example, an NFTs example, I think it's a perfect one because then the data on Bitcoin is growing based on the number of NFTs not based on the stacks blocks.
And so in that sense, I think that that example basically clarifies it that why would Bitcoin's block space be valuable because the Bitcoin NFTs are taking off, then people are paying for that. So just real quickly too, I think we're looking far into the future here when you're talking about the supply schedule being complete and there being the final 21 million Bitcoin. The world in our eyes is fully on a Bitcoin standard everybody is using it. I think a lot of us see the the block space on Bitcoin probably won't be used by the average person or the average user, it'll be used by very large institutions banks for trade, global trade where they will want to see finality on very large transactions.
And so far into the future when you know all of us are dead because that's how far away it is when the reward runs out, not a single person on the planet today will probably be alive unless they live for, I mean they guess I could live for 120 years, but that space will be used by the very, very large institutions, global trade and they will most definitely be able to keep the value of that block space up. Okay, so I want to return to one of the original question, which is we started talking about Ethan Bitcoin as sound money based on the sustainability of the chain. And so Dennis and many of you guys just gave some cases as to why there will be block space demand which will generate the fee market required to sustain Bitcoin.
But I would contend that the growing fee market of Bitcoin actually needs to increase at a rate that's commensurate to the actual growing in value of BTC because it's one thing to have dollar denominator transaction fees be sustainable, but I don't think we want to secure our chains based on the value of the dollar because the value of the dollars fleeting. So when in a Bitcoin denominated world, the value of the Bitcoin blockchain, the security budget needs to be sufficiently large in Bitcoin terms. And I think even with the decreasing fee budget in Bitcoin terms, the growing dollar value doesn't grow at a rate fast enough for to maintain security when the value of a Bitcoin is growing way faster than the value of a dollar.
Does that all make sense? I think it makes sense like what you're trying to say. I think my answer is pretty simple there, like I look at Bitcoin security budget to be something where it is it needs to be so high that even a state actor would find it very hard to attack them. People talk about difficulty that Bitcoin difficulty is going down, but recently, for example, Bitcoin difficulty went down when miners moved out of China. I wasn't worried about it at all, because on an absolute scale, the difficulty level is so high that the Bitcoin network is secure. So what we're talking about is really I think we can put aside like proof of work.
We can just look at the incentives available for the miners and are the incentives resulting in a high enough difficulty level that a state actor would find it very hard to actually come in and attack before work. So I think that value that number given like how early we are in prepare right now and that difficulty level is already so high. I think 20 years from now, 30 years from now maintaining that level of difficulty wouldn't wouldn't be an issue. Another thing here too, I really like Justin, did you want to give final comments there? Since we're co-moderating, I think it would be good to also kind of flip this now and try to move the other direction.
But I think Justin, you should get the final comments here, but to start to move towards is why is Ethereum sound money? What's your argument about that? Because obviously we can go back and forth all day on Bitcoin here, but we'd like to kind of hear what your guys' points are for why Ethereum is sound money and then obviously get the back and forth. But Justin, final comments on what Manip just said. Yeah, so Manip just talked about resistance to state level actors. I think that's an illusion. Basically, you can try and quantify the security and you can talk about basically economic security.
How much economic resources are securing a particular blockchain? When you look at Bitcoin, it's relatively straightforward. What you do is you take the hash rate, which is about 150 million terror hash per second. And then you ask yourself, how much does it cost to manufacture and deploy one terror hash per second? Now, my rough guess is that it's roughly $50, but some Bitcoiners will say that maybe it's like $100, but I don't think any reasonable Bitcoiner will tell you that it's above $100. And so basically, we're looking at roughly $15 billion of economic security and in the grand scheme of things, that's peanuts.
If you look at the security budget, for example, of the US, it's $750 billion per year for its army. And now, maybe that's a good segue into why Ethereum is sound money. Because you can start looking at the economic security of Ethereum. And it turns out it's several times larger than Bitcoin. And for Ethereum, it's even easier to see what the economic security is. You just take the number of EF tokens, which are currently staked, multiplied by the price of each token. And you get roughly $32 billion. Even today, it's two to four times larger economic security versus Bitcoin. And I still believe that $32 billion is too small.
We need to have a trillion dollars of economic security. And I see a roadmap with Ethereum to achieve that, partly because we have this guaranteed issuance. But I just don't see it for Bitcoin in the context of this exponentially decreasing issuance. And just to ground the listeners so far, the reason why we've been talking about transaction fees and transaction volume inside of blockchains and security is that all of these things relate to the soundness of the money because it relates to its ability to hold value over time. So when blockchains can be secure over time, the money of the blockchain can also hold its value over time.
Just wanted to make sure that we had the listeners grounded on that. Yeah, that's a fair point to make just so that people kind of understand where we're coming from. We moved away from the aspects of money to being just purely security focused. So I'm sure we won't need to cover security too much when it comes to the conversation around why Ethereum is sound money. So let's go ahead and do that with you, David and Justin. Why do you believe that Ether is the most sound money? Well, to elaborate on what Justin said, I think the proof of state consensus mechanism is the most efficient consensus mechanism possible.
Proof of state collapses down the cost of providing security down to the absolute minimum. A computer connected computer connected computer, excuse me, and which most everyone already has. And then after that, what's left is capital. And really when you think about it, all consensus mechanisms, all security mechanisms are just a bit of computing power, an internet connection, and then something for that individual to lose if they do something wrong. And capital is the most efficient form of that, right? If they have a bunch of capital at stake, they have a significant incentive to not lie to the blockchain, which is what makes the blockchain secure.
Proof of work has the same dynamic. There is computers with computational resources. The Bitcoin computers are really, really big computers with a lot of computational resources. And then they also represent capital as well. Roughly one third of proof of work staking or validation comes from the fact that the cost of operating a mining farm is one third computer hardware, which kind of is your stake. It's kind of like proof of stake with extra steps. But the collapsing of security down to proof of stake allows for really, really efficient security. And what this means is when you have efficient security, is that it actually costs very little to secure your blockchain.
And when it costs very little to secure your blockchain, you don't have to issue as much money to pay for security. And so because the cost of security really, really efficient. So you have very, very little issuance to secure a very large market cap of economic activity, which goes and lends itself to the property of sound money. If you have a global crypto economic system that is secured by the most efficient consensus mechanism possible, which I believe is proof of stake, then you have the least amount of issuance possible, which retains the value of the supply of the currency by issuing the least while being able to secure the system.
So proof of stake is one of the properties that makes ether very, very sound money. Let me ask a couple of questions there. So I think there are two aspects of proof of stake that I might generally have concerns about. And by the way, just to clarify, I think proof of stake can work for certain types of applications, where the stakes aren't that high. But we're talking about building a global reserve currency and people's livelihoods are depending on this. And this is the kind of the base layer system upon which everything else is dependent on. So the stakes are very, very high over there. So I think the issue in my mind, the proof of stake is kind of two pulls.
The first one is if you go back to the beginning of this podcast, I was talking about that can a normal person, a normal user of the internet, just on their laptop, independently verify that is this the correct version of the blockchain or not. So that you can't do with proof of stake because of the bootstrapping problem. And we will, we can debate that, but I think this is, this is almost like a proven theorem and career science that you have a bootstrapping problem for the stake. You have to trust certain nodes to be able to boot up. You can't boot up on, on your own. I think Justin wants to say something over here.
So let's let him. No, go ahead. I mean, you're talking about activity. Yeah, so I can, I can, I can define the problem very concretely. Right. So let's say I'm, I'm a user, I'm setting somewhere in Japan and somebody gives me like five different copies of the Bitcoin blockchain. I don't have to talk to anyone to independently verify which version should I go for. Wait, if I'm the same user sitting in Japan, someone gives me five copies of a proof of stake blockchain. I don't know what to do. Like I have no idea how to verify which copy is the correct one. Yeah, so this, this is something that's been like talked about, I, I know them.
And basically, you can, you can argue that Bitcoin as well as weak subjectivity in pretty much the exact same way. Basically, the problem is that, you know, if you, if for some reason you're caveman and you've been disconnected from the internet for very long amount of time, you know, years. And, and you come out of your cave and you, you, you, you run your, your, your Bitcoin clients, then, you know, you'll be able to sink to, to, to the head. I mean, that's, that's just not true in practice. One reason, for example, is that, you need to be downloading the latest version of, of the software, you know, to have all the security patches to be able to, to run the latest consensus rules and, and, and verify them.
And so in the process of downloading this latest client, you, unless you're going to be verifying, you know, if your caveman is very sophisticated and he's going to verify every single line of code, which no one does, they're going to be trusting basically this, that source of where you, you, you've done. You've downloaded the software. Another aspect of weak subjectivity, which exists in Bitcoin is basically the net, the peer to peer networking bootstrapped notes. So when you connect to, to the network, basically, there's a set of IP addresses, which is, which you're going to query the very first time you, you, you run your software.
And if, for some reason or another, these IP addresses are compromised, then they can just give you a version of the world, which is just not the true version. And so they can fool you into believing that some, some chain is the longest chain when actually it's not. And so weak subjectivity is just a fact of life for both Bitcoin and Ethereum. I absolutely disagree here, because I think the core invention behind blockchains is that you can trust the state of the blockchain independently. You take away that core property, like the rest of the problems that you're describing, those are all known to pierce nice problems with really good solutions, like how do you verify software downloads?
How do you verify that you're connecting to the right peers and can verify that you're downloading the data chance accordingly? But these things have existed even before blockchains, right? These, these things have been there for like 20 years or something like that. The only new thing that blockchain are adding is that you can independently verify that this is the correct version of the blockchain. If you are throwing away that property, then you start entering the land of like, why are you using a blockchain, just like start trusting other people for, for, for running some sort of a consensus system.
Typically, you don't have to trust people if you stay offline a small enough period of time. And you know, you talk about verifying like the, you know, where you download the software from. I'm imagining you talking about signatures. So basically, if you're going to download Bitcoin core, you're going to be verifying, I don't know, Peter Waller's signature or whatever. But, you know, here you're trusting Peter Waller, you know, and it's, it's the exact same thing with flexibility. The way that you bootstrap from with, with, with subjectivity is that you, you have whatever trust assumption you want to make and then they will give you some sort of state of a checkpoint of the state and then you can take it from there.
But again, this, this, this checkpointing mechanism is only required if your caveman, which most people are not. And I think if you are caveman, then the same problem applies to Bitcoin. I think this, this problem is much deeper, right? Because it's, first of all, it's not about caveman, it's about in the ethos of decentralization. A normal user should be able to self verify that is this the correct copy or not. So you're basically breaking the number one ethos of decentralization that a normal user cannot self verify. You always have to trust somebody else to be able to then verify that, okay, I can only verify if I trust the initial state and then I can verify the state from there.
No, no, not just the initial state. It's the software as well. Like are you as a normal user going to read every single line of code and compile from source and run the executive. I think we can get into how to verify that you have the right software. There are many ways of actually doing that, like people, people have been solving that problem for ages. That's not a unique thing to Bitcoin. Like you're, you're, you're conflating how you verify that you got the correct copy of the software with verifying a blockchain. Can you all agree that it's important to verify that the blockchain state is correct or not, or be able to independently verify that blockchain state is correct.
Then why don't you use a blockchain that you just trust whatever is running on the other side of your computer. When you have a state machine, you have the state, but you also have the state transition function and that is going to be your code and you can't just dissociate the two, which is verify the state without, you know, verifying the state transition function. You need the two verified. So let me, let me pose the same problem in a different way. Because of Bitcoin's proof of work, let's say there's an attacker that wants to fool you and is trying to create multiple invalid versions of the history.
Every single fork actually requires an insane amount of work to be done. So the attacker is limited in how many blockchain histories the attacker can actually produce to even present to you. Whereas in proof of stake, I can give you a million different copies of a blockchain and you wouldn't be able to tell which one is the correct one. Because it requires me just signatures to create a million different copies and a million different histories of a proof of state blockchain. No, because in the context of Bitcoin, you can have, you know, if you're attacking the networking layer with these bush trap nodes, you can have an eclipse attack and basically you can censor every single chain that has done a lot of work.
And so even just a small amount of work is enough to fool. And same thing for the code, you can have consensus rules, which just fork off because they consider invalid change, you know, legitimate change would have done a lot of work. And then therefore you're falling back to these insecure chains, which have done almost no work. Sorry, sorry, let's say let me make it more concrete. Let's say I want to make a change that goes 30 days back. I would need to do 30 days of work to be able to create that separate version of the chain, right? Real quick, the committee, could you do one this last comment here and then Justin and let we should probably get back to proof of stake just like.
We should move on. Yeah, but like the money, but then Justin one more. Sure. So I think what I'm saying is let's make an attack very concrete that let's say I'm an attacker. I want to change the history of the launching 30 days back. So in proof of work, I'll have to do 30 days of work to be able to even try to fool somebody that this is not the correct version of the chain. Like that's that support in a proof of stake system. I can give you 10 million different copies that have each have a different version 30 days back without doing a work. That's that's the part of the art. Work argument doesn't hold because you can have rules which disqualify change which have done a lot of work.
And so you could have a chain, for example, which where the difficulty kind of decreases, you know, in such a way that or, you know, a chain with very few blocks, for example. Once you once you smash around with the state transition function, you can't validate state that's just fundamental premise. Some of the things that I'd like to go back to because just in regards to some of the points that David was bringing up, some of my core issues around proof of stake, which my big, really to be honest, my biggest issue is moving from proof of work to proof of stake. I think it's been pretty well shown that a theory has had a very difficult time doing that and that I've heard, you know, I keep hearing over and over again.
That's going to happen. I think that's a kind of a separate argument that a lot of Bitcoiners try to make. The one that I really would like to attack is this idea that proof of stake is a better model because it will incentivize saving. Okay, yeah, you know, I can, I can see that, but my problem. I'll actually pitch why proof of stake is a better model in a different way. Yeah, let me finish this one and then you can pitch it in another way as well, but some of the biggest issues that I see with proof of stake is it does kind of incentivize. I would say incentivize is hoarding in a similar way that Bitcoin does, but the problem is that it incentivizes hoarding with the people that are minting the eth.
So those that are creating the eth are incentivized to hold on to it. The difference between proof of stake and proof of work is the miners have an economic cost and they are incentivized to distribute the Bitcoin that they are creating. But what ends up happening is it's harder to disperse and you have this large consolidation of supply in the hands of the wealthiest people potentially on the network, which really inevitably when you look past in the past in the history of money, the incentive to debase, manipulate or corrupt monetary supply or issuance as always happens when there is a heavy amount of people holding on to a large amount of that supply because there is an incentive to manipulate or to base the currency.
So and this is the real big problem that comes down to is there will be a time when the human control over the Ethereum issuance will lead to debatement and manipulation in my opinion. The other part is again, just this transferring from proof of work to proof of stake, I'm not sure it's, I'm not sure it's possible. It feels like it's like open heart surgery while flying a rocket ship hasn't been done yet. Seems like a lot of other protocols don't have too much of a problem with being on proof of stake, but I think from the very beginning you can go all the way back and see that this has been a very big issue for Ethereum.
And when you were talking about this minimum viable security, minimum viable issuance, it's great in theory, but it's kind of a problem also in a sense that you have been taking from the miners over time, you went from five east to four east to three east. And then I'll now also again with EIP 1559, you are taking away the fees from these miners, these are your paid security guards that you guys have been having on your team, and they've kind of been getting screwed over by you. When you decide to move from proof of work to proof of stake, I see a real issue here because these people that you have essentially been screwing over for the last several years are not going to be incentivized to protect the chain for two reasons.
One, you've been screwing them over, but two, the other one is that you're going to be dropping the difficulty bomb, and that is going to ruin the chain that they are protecting. Well, I don't know about you, but if you've ever had employees, I don't ever warn my employees that I'm going to fire them three or six months in advance, tends to lead to instances of them colluding to steal from me. You know, right, usually what you do is you fire someone, you walk them out the door, that's not going to be the case from proof of work to proof of stake. I really do see, you know, the mev getting kind of out of control, I think you'll get, you'll have time-banded attacks that kind of get out of control, and it could be a very turbulent time ahead for Ethereum as it moves to proof of stake.
Justin, I have the things I want to say, but do you want to take this one first? Sure, so many things have been said. One of them is execution risk, and part of it is just having software without bugs that works, but there's also the risk that miners will somehow revolt and attack the system. And, you know, if we zoom out on the topic at hand, which is money and monetary premium, you can start looking at a whole list of shutting points. And really, like in my mind, there's two types of shutting points, there's kind of these short-term competitive shutting points, and then there's the really important long-term competitive shutting points, which are based on network effects.
Now, the two really important ones, in my opinion, in terms of the long-term ones, is one security of the blockchain and two scarcity of the asset of the token. Now, it is true that Bitcoin, and in these long-term categories, I truly believe that Ethereum is kind of always of magnitude ahead of Bitcoin, and as such, Bitcoin has lost the long-term game. But if we look at these short-term ones, there's a whole list of them, so you can look, for example, at financialization. So the notion that Bitcoin has an ETF now, that makes it more money than Bitcoin, then Ethereum. Yes, I would agree, but these are very short-term things that basically have a lifetime associated with it.
It's a shutting point, which will disappear. And actually, if you take a historical perspective in financialization specifically, the time scale just keeps on decreasing. So Bitcoin came six years ahead of Ethereum in terms of the genesis, and then you can ask, for example, how much of an advantage did Bitcoin have for grayscale? Well, there were three years, grayscale had a Bitcoin product three years before Ethereum, and then you can ask yourself, what about futures? Well, it turns out that half of that, again, Bitcoin had futures one year and a half before Ethereum, and you can ask the same thing for ETFs, and it wouldn't be surprised if it was also half of the previous thing.
And the execution risk is the exact same mindset. It's kind of this short-term, myopic mindset of short-term shutting points. And the reason is that execution risk, well, guess what? It disappears once we've executed. And the same thing for attack risk, it just disappears once there's no more miners, once proof of work has been removed. So maybe you're right, maybe there will be issues, but it's very short-term thinking, in my opinion. Another thing that was point that was brought up is on distribution, and this is a misconception that somehow Ethereum proof of stake is not distributive. And the reason is very simple is because when you stake ETH and you receive the rewards, that counts as income in all jurisdictions pretty much.
And income has income tax associated with it, and let's say roughly 50%. And so you have this natural kind of forcing function to sell your ETHR, you need to sell 50% of it. And so that is a very similar distribution mechanism to Bitcoin. Bitcoin, you need to sell your Bitcoin because you need to pay for ETHR city bills and hardware bills. Well, it turns out that in the case of Ethereum, you need to pay your income tax bills. For the governments for your issuance, that's an interesting trick I haven't heard. For the record, I actually think there's a better argument than the income tax being a forced distribution.
Although it is worth noting that that is actually blanketed across the world. The distribution aspect of proof of stake comes from the nature that proof of stake has made it trivial to become a validator to the chain. Which meaning, and so Dennis, we talked about this last time we debated. Bitcoin and Ethereum have both the same problem of, we have this money, and when you have money, you have a money printer somewhere. The Bitcoin protocol can print money if it wanted to. The way the Bitcoiners and Bitcoin has solved this is that it's just like, just just kept that, just killed it. Just like, no, kill the money printer.
Destroy it. Take a hammer to it. It's gone. And that's what Bitcoin is. No issuance for anyone. No one gets anything. Ethereum does something different. It says issuance for everyone. And all you need to do is bring your computer and capital because everything is involved with capital. And so by collapsing the cost of validating the chain, Ethereum solves the seniorage problem. It was like, all right, we have this money printer. What do we do with it? By spreading it out to the maximum number of people. And by doing that, you also receive maximum decentralization and maximum security. So whereas Bitcoin just eliminates seniorage, Ethereum tries and finds a way to spread it out to the maximum number of people by reducing the cost of providing security to the absolute minimum.
So my question for ETH is money is, I was actually a bit surprised when I started even seeing the meme because for the longest time, I kept hearing that ETH is gas for small contracts, which actually made a ton of sense to me. It deserves a lot of credit for basically inventing and smart contracts and then getting some of the early applications there. And so in my mind, ETH was always a smart contract platform and then it has competition there. And three years ago, you know, everybody would laugh at when somebody would say, no, these other platforms are going to build better, faster smart contract systems and then they're going to get traction.
But I think fast forward to like 321 and that's happening. Right. So the solanas of the world, the avalanches of the world, I would even argue, even to some extent stacks of the world, they are getting all these applications and Ethereum is kind of like losing at home ground, like this is the main thing that you're supposed to do. I just don't understand why is the theorem even trying to pick a fight with a blockchain that has just one use case. It is a single purpose use case. The only thing it is trying to do is to be the best money layer for the time. Right. So I like help explain to me, how does those two use cases differ from each minute, like what type of technology do you need to build to be a really good smart contract platform.
And what type of technology do you need to build for being a really good money there and which fight are you trying to pick. So one of the realizations, I guess for me is that it's impossible to be, you know, an outstanding smart contract platform without the monetary premium, the premium, the premium area. And it's necessary for two reasons. The first one is that it's necessary for security. Right. And the whole product of the blockchain, the block space that we're selling is all about settlement guarantees, aka security. And in order to achieve this resistance against state actors, we just need tons and tons of monetary premium.
Right now we have $32 billion of economic security. It's too small by a couple of orders of magnitude. So we must grow that if we're going to build a platform, which is resistant to world war three. Another reason why it's required is because we need trustless economic bandwidth. Right. The defy is sorry, the small contracts, many, many cases are interesting because they manipulate value. And you enter the world of finance and in the world of finance, you need collateral. And when you want to build these trustless and decentralized applications, you want to minimize the number of assumptions that you're making.
So at the minimum, you're taking on the assumption that the firm is secure. Right. That's kind of like the basic assumption, but you don't want to be making additional assumptions. So, so like the most natural way forward to not take on assumptions is to just reuse the native money, which is if as your collateral, as your economic bandwidth. If you try and do something else, for example, you try and use wrapped Bitcoin, then now suddenly you're trusting Bitcoin. And that's very, you know, your weakest link is Bitcoin, which is not satisfactory. But it turns out that kind of security and scarcity are mutually beneficial.
The more, you know, security that we have, the more transactional utility that we have, the more fee burn that we have, the more monetary premium that we have, which gives us more economic security, which gives us more utility. And so it's really a foolish game to try and detangle and disassociate the notion of security and utility and monetary premium and money. So it's said differently, Munib, I think the way that you presented this is that, you know, Ethereum pick a lane like, are you money or are you a smart contract platform. And I would actually turn that around on you and just kind of which is going to be reframing exactly what Justin Drake just said where he says, you need economic activity to drive scarcity.
Actually, I think Bitcoin needs to do some more defy stuff. And also the whole ETH killer phenomenon needs to do some more Bitcoin things. It's not Ethereum that needs to pick a lane. It's Bitcoin that needs to generate internal native finance. And then also the ETH killers need to actually become decentralized so they can have the monetary premium. So it's actually the opposite ends of the spectrum that needs to come and do both because it's both that gives you both the decentralization and security that allows you to be money while also generating the internal native financial economy that drives blunt demand for block space, which generates scarcity into the L one asset.
Yeah, so I can I can give you the Bitcoin model. So the Bitcoin model is that Bitcoin is the decentralized money layer, then you have a smart contract layer like stacks stacks is purely a gas asset, never trying to be money. They'll never be money because it literally depends on Bitcoin for its existence. It can't exist without Bitcoin. And there's a separation between what is money, what is the store of value and what is the gas asset and then they can they can interact with each other and you know you can use this in that way. But then extending that argument like do you guys then also believe that every other smart contract platform or forget about smart contract platforms like Solana look at you know polygon.
So you know polygon recently had more daily active addresses than Ethereum. So with that type of network activity happening that does magic becomes money and would start and like beating the Ethereum would Solana will become money and have a launch will become money are we all in that game because my model of the world was very simplistic like Bitcoin is money. Let's just bring smart contracts to it. There are a bunch of other smart contract platforms as well, but this argument seems to say that everything is trying to be money. In my opinion, everything that is an L one token is trying to be a global sovereign on sort of value asset.
Yeah, I agree and I think this is actually part of reason why I believe that that stacks is kind of you know a little dubious in the sense that one of the things that that stacks is is is is claiming is that it has is inheriting the security of Bitcoin. I don't know how to how to do such a thing like my my guess is that if you know more than 50% or more than some threshold of the STX tokens are controlled by an attacker then that attacker can just you know do all sorts of bad things like censorship and maybe even break. That's not how stacks work stacks not a proof of state system there are separate miners that use.
We don't need to get into it, but that's not how stacks works. Right, but you do have an honesty assumption in addition to the honesty assumption that Bitcoin has. So parts of the applications basically think of them as cross chain right so part of your application is literally just running on Bitcoin. As the lending application you're you're just doing Bitcoin transactions to lend your Bitcoin and part of the application is running on the stack side. So your collateral for example is more contract on stacks and then that is settling those those that data is settling on Bitcoin and their miners involved that running on the Bitcoin side.
It's not it's not proof of stake. I know that's the world you guys come from, but we can we can get into it separately. Right, but let's let's let's remove the like the the programmability aspect for now and just just think of stacks as just like a site chain that provides a bit more throughput. Like are you claiming that stacks has solved Bitcoin scalability in the trusted fashion and it has exactly the same security model. It it helps like how lightning helps, right, so lightning can scale payments and then you're doing something. So stacks is the programming layer it has more contracts. So you can do it a lot more smart contract activity that is eventually settling on on the Bitcoin chain and then you have the cross chain connections between them.
So you can build applications that basically are running on code. Okay, now my understanding is that there's this this proof of transaction aspect where basically I haven't looked into too much because I don't completely understand the documentation, but basically what I understand is happening is that there's money Bitcoin specifically, which is being sent to various STX holders presumably. And as an attacker, if I'm willing to I have a lot of Bitcoin and I'm just willing to spend and give a lot of Bitcoin to these STX holders that presumably I have some amount of control. And if I'm willing to spend more than what the others are doing, then I can start doing bad things like censorship or reverting bad chains or stuff like that.
So the way we think about that is a stack follows the proof of work type of security model. But instead of it's burning electricity, you're actually consuming Bitcoin. So your so that's where does the security budget is coming from. But that's that's like specific to how kind of like stacks functions. My main argument is that separating the money there and letting the money there be the money there and building basically contracts around it is is one model. And I actually disagree that I don't think like if you talk to people as so on our ever launched other places, like I don't think they would say that they're trying to do money.
Like they would argue that they're not trying to do money. They're trying to build decentralized computing platforms that are valuable for different reasons than then decentralized money's value. I think if they think don't think that they're trying to be money, they're making a mistake. Like maybe they don't know that. But again, if you commit to being an L1, you commit to trying to fight for monetary premium. Right. And money if you're saying that stacks is secured in a very similar way to proof of work, except that the work is spending this Bitcoin. And so basically, that probably means that that that stacks has, you know, orders of magnitude, maybe 10X or 100X less security than Bitcoin.
And the Bitcoin simply because, you know, the expenditure of electricity on Bitcoin is just so much larger than the expenditure of Bitcoin for stacks. And as such, if stacks doesn't compete for monetary premium, it just won't have a security. And then it just will be irrelevant. It stacks does has less security budget right now than Bitcoin, but the design is very, very interesting where all of the four histories of stacks are secured by Bitcoin literally. So you benefit from the security of Bitcoin because Bitcoin is securing all four histories on stacks. But here's the interesting thing, even if I take your argument that stacks is less secure than Bitcoin, let's say somebody attacks stacks.
The core argument of keeping your money there separate is that nothing happens with Bitcoin. And, and securing the money layer in my view is the most important thing. Once the world gets decentralized money, there can be many smart contract platforms. There can be many type of different applications that are that are filter. Actually, something that I think a lot of ethereans might agree with, we just separate our stacks differently. And so you called Solana and all these other eth killers as like computing environments or smart contract platforms. And the way that I would phrase that is that these are execution optimized blockchains as in they are optimized blockchains that have sacrificed decentralization in order to increase scale.
And the ethereum world and really this is just a neutral technology roll ups are the same thing they are execution optimized networks. And that they have sacrificed decentralization to be layer two's on Ethereum preserving the money layer, which is the asset transfer layer of Ethereum, which is contrary to a lot of what Bitcoiners say, actually a very simple L1. Like it's generally pretty simple as far as it goes. Maybe proof of sake it's a little bit complex, but in the grand scheme of things, you have all these compartmentalized financial application layers, these roll ups where is very, very performant.
And then you can tap into the very, very secure L1 of Ethereum. And this goes back to what I was saying earlier where Ethereum is trying to do it all. It's trying to have a decentralized layer one, which has a very significant monetary premium that is highly secure. And then it's designed to have highly executable layer twos that can conduct all the financial activity. And so it literally gets the best of both worlds and it captures all of the money, all the value of decentralized finance using the roll ups. And then it injects it into the security layer of the layer one. Yeah, so can I can I can I can I give the Ethereum people some unsolicited designers like I think I tried doing that back in like 2016, 2017 when I effectively said, you know, don't try to do sharding.
You won't be able to do it try to work on L2s. And I'm pretty sure Justin has been like years and years, so I don't want to want to discourage him for doing that, but sharding turned out to be a pretty, pretty hard problem. I would say that if I was involved with Ethereum today, I would actually not try to move to proof of stake. You actually have a fairly secure network with proof of work right now, you actually have like a bunch of traction and usage and and and L2s are working like arbitrum is coming online. I actually pretty solid solid solution. If I was designing Ethereum today, I would stick with proof of work, I would actually try to limit even further the types of activity that can happen on the L1.
Maybe you just want to do a roll ups, maybe you just want to do fraud proves at the L1, but discourage applications to be built at basically try to minimize your L1 there instead of like keeping it very complex. So any types of applications are being built and don't try to do sharding, don't don't try to move to proof of stake. And then you have a serious shock at becoming a money layer because you inherited all of the properties that the arguments that I was making like why a proof of work system is actually better because it actually has security defined outside of the system. We didn't get into this that much because what's happening with proof stake is you're trying to define security within the system, everything's pointing to each other.
You need you need a referee that is actually setting outside of the system that when things goes out, someone can actually step in and be like, here is how you define security because one of the first things that's going to happen if something goes out within the system is, how would you then recover from it? Like I can give you an example, all these blockchain systems are BFT systems. Let's say for some reason, you know, a bunch of exchanges get compromised and close to 33% of your staking power is now not not not cooperating with the consensus system. We'll stop making forward bars, right? This wouldn't happen in other types of designs.
So I think like defining the security of the system outside of the system itself is actually the critical critical difference here. There are also some other problems as well. I would like to kind of get your you and David and Justin's answers on here. A lot of times the argument from the Ethereum community is that it's economically infeasible to attack the proof of stake network. But when you take into consideration this aspect of slashing, which could be one way to help make it more economically feasible, you could also target large holders of Ethereum. You could buy wallets off of off network so that there's no transaction.
There's people are unaware of the movement of those coins to other holders. But you also have this issue with these derivative companies that have been formulating. So like the Lito protocol, I think they've captured like a very large majority of the staking in a very short amount of time because they give Ethereum holders this token in exchange for staking on their protocol. And so it leads to this really kind of parallel situation where the supply is becoming any and the staking is becoming very, very centralized in a very short small amount of hands. Combined with the idea that if someone has a large majority of the staking power or control, they could intentionally get into a situation where they try to slash themselves and also slash their competitors leading to a situation where they again have a larger control or percentage.
Of the network so I'd like to kind of hear what you guys have to say about the ability to kind of supply hijack the network and the staking protocols. First off, Lito is a decentralized staking as a service protocol. It's a Dow half of Lito I would say is distributed rather than centralized but relatively centralized and the other half is completely decentralized. The people that are the aspect that's decentralized is that people come in and submit their ether to the validator network. It gets bonded to the beacon chain and it also gets spread out amongst I think like 11 validators. Meanwhile, they're also working on this thing called shared secret validation, which is basically like splitting up the keys to a validator allowing the actual validating network to also become decentralized.
It's not a corporation in the same way that Coinbase is. When I see ether going into Lito, I'm actually seeing it becoming part of the decentralized staking network that Lito is offering. This is actually a model that a lot of Ethereum teams applications are actually expanding upon. Rocketpool also comes to mind where yes, the ether is actually being owned by a central contract address but that contract address is represented by a very large number of people, both validators and eth suppliers. It's actually not accurate to say all this ether and this one address is centralized. Sure, but a lot of the governance tokens are being controlled by a very small amount of people, which does have an impact on the centralization of that supply.
It also leads to this issue with the costliness of money, which is a very important aspect going back to sound money and when you are able to essentially give your Ethereum to them and you get a one for one token back, it completely eliminates the costliness of production because you can be a part of the staking and you can be a part of the issuance without any cost to yourself whatsoever. Does she have anything to say? Yeah, so one of the things you said, Dennis, is that we're claiming it's impossible to attack the network with proof of stake. That's not the claim, right? The claim is the exact opposite, is that with proof of stake, just like with proof of work, you can attack the network but there is a cost and that cost is measured in terms of economic security and right now is on the order of 32 billion dollars.
That's my point, though, is that it's cheaper than that because of the fact that you can get away with slashing your competitors. No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no No, there are not many ways of making sure that we can listen to them more often.
in a repeated fashion, and this is a key differentiator with Bitcoin. When you look at an attack, you can look at it as a one-shot game, or you can look at it as a repeated game. In the case of Bitcoin, if somehow you manage to accrue 51% of the hash power, then you can attack Bitcoin over and over and over again. So for example, you can just continuously censor it and not produce any blocks. And so there isn't this recovery mechanism. In the context of proof of stake, if an attack happens, sure it can happen one time, but then we're going to slash you. Okay, maybe it happens the second time, but then we'll slash you again.
And guess what? Every time there's a slashing event, it becomes harder and harder to pull off the attack because it's just less and less Eve in circulation. And also, this is what Munib was talking about about external security versus internal security. Where Justin Drake is saying that if Ethereum actually derives its security by not by removing this what Vital calls a spawn camping attack, a proof of work, which has external security, Bitcoin can't delete ASICs because they're external, but Ethereum can delete its own ether because it is internal. And so it gives it an extra layer of defense when it comes to attack.
I would push back on that, right? So think of this way. Let's say that someone is able to get to up to 51% on Bitcoin. At that point, it's open warfare, right? Like anyone can go try to get more hash power and you're now fighting, you're not fighting publicly to gain more hash power. And the way Bitcoin and not come out of consensus works is everything is probabilistic. You can actually go back in time, fork from another place, and the system has self-recognitively baked it, right? Whereas in proof of state, you've actually removed one of the actors, which is the external reminder. Now everything is internal.
And once someone actually gains access to, let's say a massive hack happens, like Kraken gets taken down, CoinBiz gets taken down, or person like that. Once someone has more than 33% of ETH, you're told, you can never be able to make forward progress. No, it's the opposite. If Kraken or CoinBiz gets compromised, they will, they will get slashed. And so they will get removed. I mean, if they abuse that power and and and and and and attack the system. So, so you're saying that in terms, you were in terms of the, you started slashing like the like 33% of economic power on the network, and they will start losing their eat.
And then what if the attack is bigger? What if what if now, if you were talking about 51% attack on the coin, what if somebody has 51% of economic majority power? That can they do anything on the network now? Because they're the majority? No. Well, if they start abusing the power, they'll get slashed. That's kind of the TL. But who's going to slash them? They're the majority of that one. Built into the network. Well, it depends. There's this. Okay, we're getting technical here, but there's kind of two types of slashing. Like one type of slashing is like the cryptographically provable slashing.
Like you made a double vote, you know, you tried, for example, to finalize two inconsistent checkpoints. This is automatic slashing. It happens, you know, by by by the network. There's another more subtle type of slashing where as a majority actor, you can, for example, do censorship. And here, basically, the the resolution is social social slashing. So the ifim community can see, okay, well, there's this one actor. It's clearly compromised. It's clearly attacking the network because it's censoring all these blocks. The good news is that we can identify this actor. We can see that, you know, the owners of pubkeys X X Y and Z are not producing blocks, for example, they're censoring the network.
We're going to go ahead and socially slash them, which is, you know, a hard fork, but it's a very similar process where, at the end of the day, the attacker loses the. I think this, this, this is, this really highlights the difference in the two school of thoughts. Like in the Bitcoin can. There's no concept of a social hard fork, right? That I'm going to remove the economic, I'm going to remove Bitcoin from somebody's wallets. Or I'm going to change, I'm going to roll back the, the state of the watching. Those rights. When, when have, when have, when happy. They can happen is the point, the point is that they can happen.
I think, so that, that, I think that's, I'm pointing to the difference, right? People can pick which camp speaks to them more. I think on the Ethereum side, it is acceptable, like, like with the Dowel fork, to roll back history, or to take away tokens from one wallet address and give it to someone else. And the Bitcoin wall that's completely unacceptable cannot, cannot be tolerated by another community. Wait, you know, that you have Bitcoin as wearing you, you know, user activated software, UASF hats, and you know, like saying that is completely unacceptable, I think, is a mischaracterization.
And also, it hasn't happened on Ethereum. And like the two networks are on power here. Like it's, it can happen in both cases. And when let me give you one example, I want to compare, sorry, sorry, sorry, I think people will get confused here. I want to compare a user activated software to the Dowel pack, right? There is a huge, it's like night and day type of a difference here. The user activated software is not changing the balances of anybody, is not rolling back any transactions. It could. It is, but it, there's no way, but it wouldn't be a software at that. It would be a hard fork at that.
No, it would be a software. You can, you can freeze funds. So let's, let's assume, for example, that a quantum attacker comes in and steals 10% of, of the supply. This is the exact same situation as the Dowel. The Dowel is basically one attacker being in control of an outstanding number of coins. Let's say 10% or 15%. Would, you know, would the Bitcoin community say, okay, yeah, that's fine. You can have just one attack. They would control. They would literally, they would literally say that and it would never roll back. Okay. But at the minimum, they would have the option to do a user activated fork to freeze those funds and effectively destroy them.
It will not fly in the Bitcoin community. It will literally not fly in the Bitcoin community. That's a subjective argument on a technical one. Let's just make it a historic historical argument. Has never happened in the Bitcoin history. Has happened in Ethereum history. So that's just a historical fact. Yeah, to me, this is a very weak argument because the Dowel hack happened in 2016, which is five years ago, out of six Ethereum, Ethereum's, Ethereum's lifetime of six years. And there's also been a very significant number of proposed hard forks and proposed EIPs. That did something like this for like fund recovery, famously, I think EIP 999 to get the parity funds back.
And many, many other EIPs, which never really make it to the surface of the conversation, just because they get denied. And so like, yeah, Ethereum had its like mulligan, but also at the same time, there's a lot of things that Ethereum has denied from proposals from the community that like Bitcoiners just don't hear about and kind of really illustrate the new level of immutability that Ethereum has achieved. Right. So I think let's, let's take, for example, EIP 1559. Right. So here's the, here's the paradox of that. As a economic policy, I actually think it's a much better economic policy than the previous one.
Right. So I think, I agree with you that it's an upgrade. As a Bitcoiner, I also know that that would not have happened on Bitcoin. Right. And I think this is where the fork on the road is that in, and we don't know like what is going to win in the future, but I think it's important to differentiate the two paths. The path on the Ethereum side is that you're willing to have social consensus around monetary policy and then change the monetary policy. Bitcoin is saying that there's no concept of social consensus around these things. This is all proof of work. And that's it. That is a social consensus, by the way.
Mike, like I think it was the ultimate point and our last debate between me and David, which was that in order for something to truly be sound money, it needs to not be able to be messed with or tinkered with by human beings, because throughout history, we've had 10,000 years of history to prove that anytime you leave the door open for human beings to come in and change the monetary supply or the issuance, they will and have always done that. And so I think that it's very much the difference between the Ethereum camp and the Bitcoin camp is that you guys kind of think like, okay, well as long as we as a community are okay with these changes, that's okay.
But there will come a time, in my opinion, eventually it could be 10 years down the road, 20 years down the road, who knows, could be beyond our lifetimes. But the fact that you leave that door open for human tinker ability to the monetary supply and issuance is ultimately leaving the door open to corruption of the monetary supply itself. Like I asked you the question, I said, you know, if the dollar became deflationary today, right, like they just, they finally raise rates, they stop printing money, they go full blown, deflationary with the currency start burning it, does that make the dollar sound money?
And I think your answer was, was no, because the door is open to tinker ability. And I said that the door is still open for tinker ability with Ethereum, and that was kind of my whole argument. I'm curious if you kind of had a, something to say to that, to the effect of that, since our last debate. Yeah, and I think the video aspect of this will actually help out here. So like Bitcoin, it has maximized for immutability more than anything else. And I think Bitcoiners don't really appreciate the fact that Ethereum is actually, the door is more open than it is with Bitcoins. Although I will say there is no such thing as perfect immutability.
The Bitcoin, it's always a spectrum of how open the door is. The Bitcoin door isn't completely shut. It's open just a smidge. And the Ethereum door is open a decently more amount than Bitcoin. And then we have the dollar, which like the door is like all the way open, right? And so it's actually really hard to get changes into Ethereum. Like we don't implement that many changes. And the changes that we do implement have like hundreds and hundreds of like highly technical eyes on them. And those people that are putting the eyes on the changes have thousands and thousands of eyes on those people.
And so in start contrast to this whole like 12 old white dudes behind a closed door, Ethereum is like done on open forums in the court of public opinion and never actually really can do anything that's against the community. And so you know there is a door that is open. It's done in a very transparent way with the social commitment of eventually we are pushing that door more and more closed every step we can while we work on integrating all the technological upgrades that we can while we have this time of flexibly updating blockchains. Two things. I want to say two things. You said that Ethereum closing the door doesn't change very often but you guys hard fork like every three weeks, four weeks it feels like at this point maybe even less than that.
It's roughly once every two years. And the things going into those hard forks are just very, very small. And the court of a public opinion, you know, again, this is the court of public opinion. It's human control and you may have made the human control aspect of your money more decentralized than a dollar. We can 100% agree on that. I think the dollar is the ultimate shit coin. But when it comes down to it, you've left that door open and there will come a time in my opinion in the future for a majority of people to get into a position where they can make changes to their benefit that don't benefit all the users.
I think most of the changes that you said this last time every change that we've made so far has benefited the users of Ethereum. But that doesn't mean that that will always hold true. Also, I would say that the community as a whole is I think it's interesting that you don't include the miners in there because as I said earlier, you've went from five to four to three and now you're burning the fees. So you have hurt people in your community. It's just interesting that you don't see the miners as part of your community. I want to add some things that I think this is also a very fundamental point that when you're talking about making changes or even the need to make a lot of changes or not making changes, that's where conflating the smart contract platform with money actually hurts Ethereum, in my view, because there will be more changes required to upgrade a smart contract platform.
Like maybe you could even argue that a proof of stake system is a good upgrade for a smart contract platform. Or maybe at least in my view, it is not a good upgrade if you want to be money. So I think because those two things are conflated at the Ethereum base there, something like Solana which in my view is just trying to be a smart contract platform can actually hard for or upgrade. Their stakes are very different from a money layer. And in the case of Bitcoin, where Bitcoin's money layer is separate and stacks the smart contract platform layer is separate, stacks can actually hard for more and just optimize for whatever functionality that the developers are looking for without ever changing the money layer.
This is also true with rollups. This is the same pattern there. Exactly, which goes back in my recommendation that you can even right now try to stake the proof of work, try to actually minimize the Ethereum base layer instead of making it more complex. And just do most of the competition and rollups and health tools. I know Justin is itching to say something. And Dennis, you said in Muni just said something that I think aligns here is like, you guys are kicking out the proof of work miners, just stick with proof of work. Under proof of stake, the users and the trans actors and the security values of Ethereum are all the same people.
And so it's fundamentally more about aligning incentives where proof of work miners are really mercenaries. They have to be profit driven. They have to sell the asset. And they represent a two tiered society that wraps around a chain. So the people that have the ability to mine the chain and the people that can only buy the asset from the miners, right? It's the same thing as like the money printer paradigm that we exist. There's two classes of citizens. There's people that can access the newly freshly issued coin. And then there's the rest of the world, right? With proof of stake, we actually collapse all parts of Ethereum into, are you an NFT trader?
Are you a DeFi speculator? Are you just interested in the protocol? Well, all three of those people can all be Ethereum validators under proof of stake. And it's not that we're like kicking miners out the door, Dennis. Actually, miners have been, we've been noticing the accumulation of Ether by miners leading up to the suspected timing of the merge. And so miners are actually going to very elegantly morph from proof of work miners to proof of stake validators preserving their business model. Justin, do you want to say anything I know you're ishing to ask something? Yeah, I just have a few thoughts.
I guess on the whole changing the rules aspect. I think one of them is on time scales. I very much disagree that it's easy to change Ethereum and it's changing regularly. And just to give a few examples, proof of stake has been part of the plan since before Genesis. And so it will basically take seven years to deploy proof of stake. Another year from today plus the six that Ethereum has had. EAP 1559, these have been ideas that have existed or have originated from five years ago. It took five years to get EAP 1559. And one topic which, you know, I joined a different foundation four years ago.
And the one thing I was working on was shouting. And shouting is going to take 10 years from start to finish. And when you compare that, you know, to changes with Bitcoin is actually, you know, we're more conservative than Bitcoin in a sense. If you look at, you know, segwits and tap roots, these don't take 10 years, you know, to go with deploy. But they take, you know, significantly less. Another thing that was, you know, brought up is kind of the good ideas versus bad ideas. Like, you know, it's not about making a change in of itself. It's about what changes are being made. And I think Ethereum has an excellent filtering mechanism at play.
And it's kind of the honest minority assumption kind of thing. If there is a bad idea, it just takes one single actor to blow the whistle and show that this is a bad idea. And basically, you know, convinced the e-holders who are incentivized to bring in only good incentive, only good changes to come in. And so because of this honest minority aspect of changes, I think, you know, Bitcoin has fundamentally kind of handicapped itself because it's given away the innovation. Innovation, which is very safe because of this honest minority aspect. Another thing that I want to bring forward is that eventual ossification for Ethereum is inevitable.
It will happen. It will be fully ossified just like Bitcoin. And this goes back to, you know, my short-term thinking versus long-term shedding points. The fact that we are changing right now is like, oh, myopic. It's all noise. It's all short-term noise. And the reason why we eventually need to ossify is because as the total value lot on Ethereum, you know, increases as there's more and more activity. It just becomes harder and harder to change. And the reason is that we have to make these backwards compatible changes. And our level of paranoia and conservatism kind of scales with the amount at stake.
And so at some point, we kind of trapped in our success where we can no longer move and will be fully ossified in a very similar fashion to Bitcoin, unless there's some sort of like external looming threat, which is some sort of forcing function for us to take emergency action. And one of these forcing functions could be quantum computing, for example, which forces us to upgrade our cryptography. And then the final point that I want to bring forward, and this is something that Bitcoin has always sweep under the rug, is that the fact that the monetary supply is fully programmatic is an illusion, right?
The door, every single four years, kind of grows and grows and grows and grows. And eventually, because Bitcoin will be unsustainable from a security perspective, something has to change. And it turns out that the easiest thing to change is just to remove the 21 million cap and just have this continuous kind of tail issuance to secure the blockchain. Many, do you want to jump in there? No, I would just say the same thing, but that's a very big assumption to say that that Bitcoin would be not secure, given their discussion we've had about Bitcoin being a settlement layer. And miners don't care if they're in senders or coming from connections or from point of view.
And that's anything to add? Yeah, you know, it's interesting too, because you do say that Ethereum or Bitcoin gave up innovation, but there are some other ways that Bitcoin is innovating. And that's in the world outside of Bitcoin itself. I think that it's pretty well understood at this point that the mining hardware that's being used, the chip production that's occurring, is all innovations that are occurring because of the desire to find more efficient ways to mine Bitcoin. Because of the having that is programmatic, miners are forced to upgrade their hardware. It's also incentivizing renewable energy throughout the planet.
And I personally believe that we'll have a very big period of time where the mining and the renewable energy production in this country and across the world will grow dramatically because of the impact of proof of work and because of the impact of mining itself. And I think that also when you look at what's going on in the community, there's tons of work being played into things like stacks, things like liquid, to enable Bitcoin to do all the different things that Ethereum claims it can do. And something was said earlier to, as far as smart contracts, NFTs, all of these things were created on Bitcoin.
They were first invented on Bitcoin itself, but we haven't found a reason or a need to change the protocol in order to enable those functions to occur. Happy to let them occur over on Ethereum until all of it eventually comes back to Bitcoin. I think the closing statements that I will say is that there is a gap between Bitcoiners and Ethereum is much larger than what's perceived to be much larger than what's actually true. I actually joke with Eric Conner a lot that, you know, Ethereum and Bitcoiners, they actually have the same values. They just believe in fundamentally different executions.
We believe in the immutability of money. We believe in decentralized the world of decentralizing finance away from the powers that be into the hands of the people. And it's really more about the execution about how we actually get that done. And so while there appears to be many, many differences between these two camps, I think we all have to be reminded that we're all in the same industry we're fighting for very similar things and at least we're not a centralized blockchain. Yeah, I mean, that's the only dry man, screw the fed. I can, I can, I can plus one that actually sometimes a joke that the difference between the Bitcoin model and the Ethereum model is actually one layer of indirection.
All we're saying is that keep the base there simple build the complexity in a different layer, which is kind of like happening, but the L2 use anyway, right. And that's, that's really the only technical difference that I'm talking. This is literally what stacks as on top. Justin, any closing statements from you? No, not really. I mean, I do want to kind of echo this, you know, we're all going to make it in the sense that the industry as a whole is obviously going to make it. And I, you know, I think that we, you know, we're all going to make it in a sense that it's very, very likely that, you know, we're all going to be able to accrue money to premium and be successful.
I think it's just a matter of all those of magnitude. And I think, you know, Ethereum is in the position, you know, to just win in terms of these orders of magnitude aspect of. Well, Dennis Munib, Justin, thank you for coming on and hashing out one of my favorite subjects, ETH versus Bitcoin as money, which inevitably these debates always go and find their own paths forward. And I think this one was no exception. So thank you guys for joining us on this bankless live stream. Welcome, Steven. Thanks for having us on. Dennis, do you want to give a quick shout out where people can find out more about your content that you do and where you live in the Twitter sphere?
Yeah, find me Dennis Porter on Twitter. If you search that, you'll find me easily. But if you want the handle, it's Dennis underscore Porter underscore. I spend a lot of time there. I do a ton of spaces in and out of there pretty frequently. I also have my podcast. So I do smart people shit. That's where you're going to find my channel. And then also I have another show under that channel called the update where I regularly update listeners on just kind of what's going on in the Bitcoin space broadly. But also I try to bring on experts like on chain or technical analysis mining. I also have a as I've said before the very beginning.
I do have some experience in politics and I kind of try to make that a framework for what I do. As we all know, the crypto tax reporting amendment was a big problem. And so, you know, even though we fight on a lot of things, there are some things that we all fight. You know, mutual enemy. And that is the, you know, the governments around the world that are trying to screw us over and trying to suppress. So I look forward to continuing to fight politically here in the United States. And yeah, if you want to DM me, my DMs are always open on Twitter. Thanks, Dennis Munib. Where can people find you in the the world outside of this livestream?
Yeah, so I'm simply at Munib on Twitter. That's my first name and UN EB. And I spend all my time working on stacks, which is a smart contracts for Bitcoin. So if you want, if you're interested in locking up capital and earning a pure Bitcoin yield on the main Bitcoin chain. And try out some of the smart contracts there. Or recently, I think there is Bitcoin culture being represented in Bitcoin NFTs through stacks as well. So if you, if you want to collect some Bitcoin native NFTs that describe the culture aspect of Bitcoin, you can check out some of the new market places that are coming up in stacks.
Fantastic. And Justin, where can people find more about what you're up to and where you live in the Twitter world? Sure, yeah. I'm Drake, if Justin on Twitter. But you can also DM me on Telegram. I'm just in Drake there. Or you can send me an email just in that if you're in the log. And then also you can check out his website ultrasound.money. All right. Thanks everyone for coming here and pow outing about one of my favorite subjects. Cheers. Thank you. Thank you. Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence.
We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops, raffles and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me any things and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content.
Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation.