Austin Campbell (NYU) and Omid Malekan (Columbia) debate a simple question: is Ethereum ready to host real-world assets?
They walk through stress tests—what if an exchange is hacked, a stablecoin breaks, or a court order targets the chain—and whether the network should ever step in.
You’ll hear where they agree and disagree, what protections are realistic today, and what still needs to be built before RWAs can scale.
------
📣RONIN “ONCHAIN NINTENDO” | DOWNLOAD THE RONIN WALLET
https://bankless.cc/RoninWallet
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAX | SELF SUFFICIENT DeFi
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK
🎩DEGEN | JOIN THE COMMUNITY
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
6:13 Twitter Debate Genesis
8:58 Bybit Hack
17:56 Crypto vs RWA Immutability
29:29 Ethereum Validator Intervention
33:11 Dealing with Multiple Jurisdictions
52:23 Credible Neutrality for a Multipolar World
1:00:32 Blockchain Use Cases
1:13:40 Consortium Chains
1:24:57 Closing Arguments
------
RESOURCES
Omid Malekan
Austin Campbell
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
the people, the users, the assets, the companies who issue those assets and the governments who regulate those companies will find themselves on a decentralized network because it's the worst option except for every other one. And I think ultimately decentralization will win by the fault. Austin, I don't think we could ever get away from the real world or the constraints of the real world and humans are going to human. I think as a result, if we want to bring the majority of real assets on chain, we're going to be forced to acknowledge that reality. But I think the value of decentralized store-of-value systems is by providing people an opt out.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is Brian Sean Adams. I'm your only host today. David's out. So I'm here to help you become more Bankless. We have a debate episode today. I always love these. The debate is on the question of, is Ethereum ready for real world assets? Got two professors. I'm going to tell you first what they share in common because I think that's interesting. They are both previous Bankless guests. They are both crypto advocates and they are both longtime friends and also co-workers. So why is there a debate? Why is there daylight between these two guests?
Well, Austin, on the one hand, doesn't think Ethereum is a good home for real world assets like stablecoins and tokenized equities and all of the things we expect to come on chain. He thinks the attributes that make Ethereum decentralized, things like immutability, the element of code is law. These aren't so much features for real world assets. They're bugs and he simply doesn't think Ethereum is the right architectural fit. Well, meet on the other hand, thinks that the decentralization and the neutrality of Ethereum are exactly why the largest financial powers in the world are selecting and will select Ethereum.
These are the institutions. These are the sovereign countries and they're going to trust Ethereum with their assets and liquidity because without decentralization, after all, all we're left with is a system like the one we already have. It's just tradify. This is a fascinating debate. I think it's a good point in the cycle to talk about this as we continue to onboard more and more financial institutions and traditional finance. Now, before we get into that episode, a quick shout out to our friends over at Ronin. Ronin wants you to know that they are coming home to Ethereum. They are Ethereum's Nintendo.
Already today, the Ronin chain has seen 4.5 billion in NFT volume. That's like 30 million wallet downloads and actually a fun fact. You may know Ronin as the Axi Infinity chain of yesterday. Today, the Ronin chain actually has more on-chain activity than at the peak of the Axi boom in 2021. They have grown fast during the bear market and into this bull market. Now, they are launching the Ronin layer two on Ethereum. So Ronin is coming home. That's the news. It's going to be 12 times faster because it borrows all the security and decentralization from Ethereum. Plus, there are staking rewards in the form of the Ron token.
That's RON. This will now reward builders and their communities programmatically for adding value to Ronin. So you got to go check it out. Download the Ronin wallet. Get a taste of the on-chain Nintendo. There's a link in the show notes or banklist.cc slash Ronin wallet. All right. Let's get right to that debate episode with Omid and Austin. It's coming right up. In the Wild West of DeFi, Stability and Innovation are everything, which is why you should check out Fracks Finance. The protocol revolutionizing stablecoins, DeFi, and Rolex. The core of Fracks Finance is Fracks USD, which is backed by BlackRock's institutional fiddle fund.
Fracks designed Fracks USD for best-in-class yields across DeFi, T-bills, and carry trade returns all in one. Just head to Fracks.com, then stake it to earn some of the best yields in DeFi. Want even more? Bridge your Fracks USD over to the Frackstall layer two for the same yield plus Frackstall points and explore Frackstall's diverse layer two ecosystem with protocols like curve, convex, and more, all rewarding early adopters. Fracks isn't just a protocol. It's a digital nation. Powered by the F-XS token and governed by its global community. Acquire F-XS through Fracks.com or your go-to decks, stake it, and help shape Fracks nation's future.
Ready to join the forefront of DeFi? Visit Fracks.com now to start earning with Fracks USD and staked Fracks USD. And for bankless listeners, you can use Fracks.com slash R slash bankless when bridging to Fracksstall for exclusive Fracksl perks and boosted rewards. Ethereum's layer two universe is exploding with choices, but if you're looking for the best place to park and move your tokens, make your next stop Unichain. First, liquidity. Unichain hosts the most liquid Uniswap V4 deployment on any layer two, giving you deeper pools for flagship pairs like each USDC. More liquidity means better prices, less slippage, and smoother swaps.
Exactly what traders crave. The numbers back it up. Unichain leads all layer twos in total value locked for Uniswap V4. And it's not just a deep, it's fast and fully transparent. Purpose bill to be the home base for DeFi and cross-chain liquidity. When it comes to costs, Unichain is a no-brainer. Transaction fees come in about 95% cheaper than Ethereum mainnet, slashing the price of creating or accessing liquidity. Want to stay in the loop on Unichain? Visit Unichain.org or follow at Unichain on X for all the updates. BanklessNation, I've got a debate for you today. Everyone loves debates and I think we're all going to enjoy this.
The question, I think we're putting forward to the two gentlemen on this episode is how much does decentralization matter? That's the wide sweeping question. What are the implications for real world assets, for traditional finance, for government regulations, for crypto-native assets, and I have the perfect debate opponents to talk about this. Austin Campbell is a professor at NYU Stern. He's a big stablecoin advocate, and he's a repeat bankless podcast guest. Austin, how are you doing? Doing quite well, thank you. I'm excited to do this because as you get to our needs intro, you'll find there's some significant overlap between the two of us.
We get to see what you agree on, what you disagree on. That'll be interesting. Omed Malaykin is a professor at Columbia. He is also a longtime blockchain crypto evangelist. Omed, welcome back to Bankless. Thank you. All right. I think the genesis for this conversation was like all great conversations started on Twitter, or the platform formerly known as Twitter on X, and there was some back and forth with you guys. I'll read a few quotes Austin. I think this is maybe a podcast video clip that was put forward on X. You said this, I don't think Ethereum is ready for prime time, for prime time real-world asset issuance.
Then you give an example of the Bybit hack. We're in a place where the Ethereum validators aren't willing to do something about exploits. Omed, you pushed back a little bit. You said a blockchain that isn't perfectly neutral is a terrible database, worse than anything Tradfi has today. The neutrality that Ethereum has optimized for more than any chain is the reason it's likely to become the global settlement layer and attract endless trillions in capital. Okay. First, since I put you on the spot, Austin in a defensive position, you said Ethereum is not ready for real-world assets. What did you mean by that?
Yeah, so there's this central problem that you run into when you're thinking about RWA, and it's something I used to think a lot about when I was running a stable coin of your fundamentally stuck between two worlds in terms of the masters that you answer to. Maybe the best way to make this distinction clear is to start with something like Bitcoin. What I mean by that is Bitcoin is stateless, non-sovereign, purely programmatic money, and that's kind of fine, in that there's no physical representation of Bitcoin in the real world that is answering to a sovereign government. This is purely an electronic construct and the network behaves in the way the network wants to behave, and fundamentally like as somebody who owns Bitcoin in ETF format before somebody tries to rob me, I think this is actually a very good adventure for the world that I'm in favor of it.
The problem, though, is to go the other way, like let's take the example of like if we tokenize ownership of houses and grandma's house title, right, is tokenized, and somehow it gets hacked in the North Koreans end up in possession of it, like so like my grandmother lived in Connecticut. Do you think the United States is going to let the North Koreans evict her and move into her house? The answer is no. And so there's this inherent tension with real world assets between what are the programmatic rules on a blockchain, and what are the actual factual rules in the real world of how this asset is going to be adjudicated?
And the tension that you run into is if you can't make your ledger ultimately responsive to what is going on in the real world, I would suggest that on a long enough time frame, it is certain that your ledger will eventually break. Okay, does that get into the buy-bit hack? Why is that a relevant example that you brought up? Okay, so the buy-bit hack starts to become a relevant example for two reasons. One, I was using it as a demonstration of there is currently no real coordinated way within the Ethereum community to handle these sorts of nation-state level expropriations, right? Like put differently, the buy-bit hack this time was eth.
How would it have been handled differently if it was a real world asset of some sort? Specifically, the interesting part about the buy-bit hack to me is less the individual token targeted and more the sophistication of the attack, which is to say they got into buy-bit systems themselves and compromise the people actually managing what was going on internally. And this time it was buy-bit, but thought experiment for the crowd, what if that had been tether? What do you do if tether loses control of their own smart contract? Right, right. So in this case, it was a hack of Ether, I believe, primarily.
That was the asset that was taken. And of course, no government, I suppose, could intervene and you're saying, what if this was the tether smart contract? What would happen in that case or something? Yeah, as a guy who ran a stable coin, and this is the nature of like rolling discussions on a podcast, they can be a little bit disorganized at times, but my core concern is InfoSack is never perfect. It is a matter of time, not a long enough timeline until people get hacked and the question is how much damage it does and how do you recover from it? And so my concern is if we're living in a world where it is obvious that there are actors sophisticated enough to compromise people's internal security systems.
What like genuinely, like what is the response if like tether USDC has their smart contract compromised? And how do you do that in a way that doesn't then subsequently as you roll down the chain brick like 95% of things that are currently deployed in the world on a theory? Well, I mean, those are some arguments for you. What do you say? I say that the bite bit hack is actually the best possible advertising Ethereum could have because the overwhelming shrug that the community gave to calls of doing something about it, even though it was clearly big and was clearly some kind of a very sophisticated actor.
It wasn't one of those. Sometimes there's an issue on chain where like somebody makes a mistake or one person claims a hacking and then the other person notes says, no, this was a legitimate transaction. The bite bit hack was a great test case because it was like the perfect boogie man scenario that anti crypto people and anti Bitcoin people had been telling us for like a decade, which is that what are you going to do when literally North Korea still is a billion dollars worth of money. And Ethereum's response was absolutely nothing. And I think that's great because neutrality is the only thing that blockchains could do well.
They don't do simplicity well. We all know how complicated they are. They don't do performance well. They don't do cost well. Despite the efforts of my friends at Salana, they don't do bandwidth and throughput well, not by the standards of Web 2 and Trafi. But the one thing they can do well is to say that we have a network or a platform here that is always going to do exactly what it's supposed to regardless of whatever legal, moral or political order somebody else wants to put on it. Now clearly the bite bit hack was a bad thing. So I don't think this needs to be said, but I'll say it anyway.
It's bad that it's happened. It's overall, it's clearly bad for bite bit, bad for the customers, bad for the price of eats during that period. But to me, the North Star of all of this is to build infrastructure that the rest of society could organize around because it is neutral and predictable in a way that very few things if anything in the world currently is. And I think the example that Austin gives is a really interesting one, Ashley. I got to give you credit Austin. I'd never thought about the potential consequences of somebody like hacking, tether or circles, smart contract. I guess like they could just like mint a trillion USDT USDT USDC.
And that would definitely be catastrophic in D5. It would be problematic everywhere. And far worse of an example than the bite bit hack. So I appreciate you throwing that out there. But the question I have for you is like, what do you propose to do about it? That risk is out there, however small it might be. So given, we know what my point of view is given your point of view, what would be the solution? I think this gets into why I started with Bitcoin because with what you're saying about something like Bitcoin itself or maybe ETH. So in ETH's case, because of proof of stake, there may be a long-term governance question like, okay, the bite bit hack happens.
The North Koreans appear to have sold most of the ETH and moved on with their life. But if they kept it and staked it and now we're participating in governance, so then continue hacking people over time at some point you have a structural problem. So let's leave that aside. But just acknowledge that we'd have to think about that at some point, but that's a pretty extreme scenario. I think what I am ultimately advocating for and why I've raised this point is that there probably needs to be a different set of rules of the road at the network level for what I will call crypto-native tokens like ETH or Bitcoin and real-world asset tokens.
And the reason for that is that ETH, like itself, definitionally, or made to your point about what's valuable about it, is not going to be like responsive to a federal judge, right? Like somebody in the Southern District of New York can write an order ordering all the ETH validators to do something and post it on the internet, then the ETH validators can totally ignore that person and like move on with their lives, that there's basically nothing that's going to happen. On the other hand, if Tether's smart contract gets hacked and that same order gets written to like seize all the assets because the North Koreans appear in control of it and they show up at Cantor Fitzgerald's office, who by the way is managing Tether's reserves that are like, here you go.
Guess what happens there? Cantor hands over all the reserves. So my point is because there are two very different legal structures behind call it crypto-native things and things that are grounded in the real-world and definitionally not decentralized, I think the network probably needs to be willing to roll back or have some sort of way to handle a hack of Tether in a way that it does not need for ETH because you know actually you raised this point earlier which I think was very astute when you were speaking is if Tether's smart contract gets hacked and the PAT answer that you'll get from a lot of people as well Tether can just drop a new smart contract.
What's the problem? Repudiate the old one, drop a new one. I would point out to everybody that nukes basically every single DFI protocol that has Tether integrated into them in the current like design of the ecosystem like Uniswap is not robust to that AVE is not robust to that compound is not robust to that right like you now have pools that are immutable that exist that people can transact against that have a thing in there that's now completely worthless in sort of a one-step jump right and this is where I get to the requirement of network controls like for the audience by the way oh me and I go back like a decent ways at this point we both worked at city and so I would like to make the point that holding traditional financial and really any human institution to the standard of not making mistakes can be easily refuted by our old employer because while we were both there they said oh me and what was it like $800 million to the wrong people around them like a hilarious like error and by the way anybody if you trust that your bag knows what they're doing boy are you wrong and so like my point is even if we leave malfeasants aside like it is a matter of time until somebody just fuck some shit up right because I posed like what if Tether's smart contract gets hacked but maybe here's a more hilarious one what if somebody just loses the private keys right like you need obviously I think Tether please has better controls than that but like you need ways to like recover from these sorts of human error things as well and again if somebody loses the keys to their private wallet and it's so be it that was the deal that you made to use this product and I think I agree with oh me by the way the value at the base layer for that token is the decentralization I think the problem is again you can't be like well grandma lost the key to her NFT she can never sell her house again like the woman's dead we can't settle the estate 500 years from now nobody lips there so Austin it almost seems like you're saying for immutability on the layer one in particular is a bug for real-world assets where it's it's a feature for crypto native assets we'd say to this that is exactly what I am saying right is that real-world assets are not a beautiful at all just let me go I don't know who's ever argued that we should turn houses into bear assets but I'm clearly not one of them so I know that to me is a bit of a is a bit of a straw man argument like no one there was this idea back in the day like eight years ago that we're going to put deeds on the blockchain this was really one of the endless manifestations of the blockchain not Bitcoin thesis but like even back then nobody said oh well we should have it be an NFT that anybody could hack and steal but I like this tether example because if I understand you correctly Austin you're saying that because the smart contract is vulnerable to hacking we should introduce a mechanism at the network layer to undo certain kinds of hacking is that right I'm going to be very careful with what I say about network layer here I think there are multiple like potential solutions to this problem but I think the thing you need to introduce that the network layer is the requirement to have one of those solutions in place if you are going to put rwa on the network let me posit two worlds one option and by the way this exists like you could create an avalanche like subnet or l1 or whatever you want to call it with this technology of we've got a permission validator set with a hard boundary and like delays to get something off the chain so in that case if somebody had deployed a stablecoin and the smart contract gets hacked the validator set can be like whoa and that I think oh me you would classify as a network level control another one for instance could be theoretically if we build the defi ecosystem properly so that every smart contract that adopts a token has sort of call it a kill switch built into it and if some oracle that we've all agreed upon throws the kill switch the smart contracts just freeze you could no longer transact with them and all you can do is withdraw assets that might be an adequate response to something like the tether smart contract risk as well because again my concern is this like let's right now go look on like uniswap and be like how much eth versus usdt is there out there I also think it's very dangerous to live in a world where if usdt gets compromised and we agree the old contract is worth zero somebody just goes and trades that poor right that would be telling LPs like you have systemic risk to this ecosystem and basically tether getting hacked sets the zero which I think is bad for each and thus my point is it's it's not just the validators where the solution could reside but I do think it's probably the validators that need to enforce you need to have some kind of solution guys here don't just put ticking time bombs on our chain so what happens when North Korea hacks the permission validators on an avalanche subnet or the agreed upon oracle that triggers the kill switch on important smart contracts because the way I'm hearing you you're worried about a specific risk for a specific coin tether smart contracts and your solution is to introduce a universal risk to the chain or a universal risk to literally every smart contract that has this hacks which and by the way permission chains have been hacked oracles have been hacked so these are not theoretical the tether one is simple answers to some of those things I actually on the first one go back to something that I learned way back in the day and catastrophe risk which is an area where I would say blockchains have currently failed pretty badly which is what is your fail state right so like the reason I raised an oracle specifically only with a kill switch is my fail state there is okay well we can't transact with those LP pools but everybody can withdraw damaging in some form like somebody throwing that is really fucking annoying but it doesn't fundamentally like destroy things in the way that actually continuing to transact with the smart contract itself got hacked would right and the reason I raised this is it has to do with how you think about engineering in general like a good example of this principle gone wrong was Fukushima right where you should be building your nuclear reactors such that if you lose power they shut down not cause like a completely out of control chain reaction and you know if you look at like modern designs of nuclear reactors they're going to hold your control rods that'll stop a nuclear reaction with electromagnets so that definitionally if you lose power they drop the rods yeah bricks your nuclear reactor but you don't have an uncontrolled meltdown okay and I'm arguing if you want to think about risks in smart contract world you should probably be building things that way because yes it would be painful to wake up and have been an LP and be like well I expected my LP would be working instead like everything is frozen and all I could do is withdraw my assets okay I guess but that's way less painful than just losing all your assets so one of those is thinking about fail states to if the North Koreans are able to hack an entire permission validator network and you had a large enough permissioning set with differential security protocols so be it right what I mean by that is at some point the financial system is financially systemic you can have some amount of redundancy but like equivalently if the North Koreans can hack like Zell for all of the major banks simultaneously and then start sending themselves money there's probably not a lot you could have engineered to stop that but that feed is significantly harder than hacking nearly one bank so I agree with you at some point the risk is non-diversifiable right like for instance eat is always catastrophically exposed to a meteorite striking the planet destroy girth right like the value goes to zero okay I get it but I am saying there are like well-known things we can do here to build a much more resilient ecosystem and thus one that also isn't inevitably probably in like a decade period is opposed to like a thousands of year period like going to brick itself when we get into a fight with the real world legal system because all of this oh made to go back to the original point comes down to when I'm running a stable coin in the back of my mind is always my custodian is going to respond to the U.
S. government whether I like it or not sure but um Ryan correct me if I'm wrong the Ronin hack was a majority multi-sig validator set that was it the Lazarus group that hacked and stole hundreds of millions of dollars yeah I believe so that's what's been reported if 400 some million yeah the by-bit hack by the way for listeners was this happened in February 21st 2025 this was a four hundred thousand each hack of the by-bit cold wallet that's about 1.4 to 1.5 billion at the time so these are pretty large hacks yeah so I bring that up because I just want to point out that Austin's tether smart contract example remains theoretical the having a permission to shame be hacked by North Korea example did happen uh and was quite costly and if I recall correctly a lot of it was a social engineering hack which is very very very or a lot easier to do when you have a permission the validator set of any kind and you know who they are you know where their computers are you know who their employees are and um you can figure out the back doors that way now if the argument is that dpsi protocols should be more thoughtful about what kind of fail saves they integrate into their smart contracts to handle with certain scenarios I think that's a different argument um I still think the most important dpsi protocols will not do that I would encourage aze for example or uniswap to never do that because at the end of the day the guaranteed outcomes that they provide the 99.
99 percent of their users and transactions that are not problematic is not worth bastardizing in order to deal with a black swan event right but if other non fundamental d5 protocols want to say here are smart contracts actually have some kind of a um fail safe built in like Austin's nuclear example I think that would be an interesting experiment um in the long run I think they would end up attracting a lot less capital because the people who would use them would sit there and say like okay but what if the back door is hacked which happens or what if the back door is somehow weaponized to harm my transaction right so planning ahead as uh Austin said I think one of the things we both agree on is that we are headed to a future when one way or another trillions of dollars will live on chain of native assets and rw ways and other things in between and in preparing for that world I think the infrastructure that says you can always expect reliable outcomes will win over the ones that say most of the time you can expect reliable outcomes but sometimes either one of our engineers get socially hacked or a government compels us everything goes out the window and you have no idea what protections you're going to have right that's not a bad thing that's just a stratified thing that's a web 2 thing that the world already has so then the people who would bring their capital on chain they would say wait a minute I thought the reason why I'm coming on chain is I'm going to get censorship resistance but now you're telling me actually know there's a censorship censorship mechanism they're going to think I thought the reason I was coming on chain is because I'm going to have composability but you can't have composability if the smart contracts of one defy protocol have a switch that can then deny access to the transactions required from another protocol right and then they're going to say I thought I thought we're going to have transparency if I use a completely permissionless no failsafe switch are they I know exactly what the code is and how it works and what it's going to do but it would be prudent if you do have a failsafe to not advertise exactly how it works because then you know the hackers would figure out how to hack it so then that would be defy users are going to say okay so you're going to tell me that it's something that may or may not do what it's supposed to and has some mechanism that I cannot know that might be triggered to stop a transaction which I would have been the beneficiary of right again that's not a bad thing I'm not here to argue against the world being this like cold mechanical libertarian everything's a better asset the smart contracts do whatever they're supposed to do even if like the end of humanity is upon us code is law yeah I'm just saying that the assets that want or need neutrality are going to optimize for that and if they don't want to need those things they should really not be on any of these permission chains because those are just bad databases and we have much better databases off chain well let's get to that in a second I want you to strengthen the argument of you know Austin's more extreme example of not sort of a a fail safe on smart contracts but a more extreme example would actually have a theory and validators do something about some of these exploits so I mean I think you're pretty against that and tell me why why are you against that the idea that a theory and validators or any validator of a layer one system can kind of roll back the chain or interference in these transactions why is that a bad idea so it's one thing to talk about that in the abstract like in the magical world it would be great if that was a feature that worked right first I question how you would implement it because we've all seen firsthand how messy and often broken governancees on decentralized systems right and this is effectively going to be a new governance mechanism except it's a governance mechanism or like the fate of the chain and maybe a hundred trillion dollars are in its hands so I would put that back on Austin to explain to us exactly what this solution looks like who decides when action is taken is there voting is there on chain coordination is there off chain coordination because part of my sort of like do nothing of recommendation Ryan is based on the fact that when you say no no no do something and you start getting into the weeds of what the something might be you open up a whole new can of worms well get Austin to weigh in in a second but I want to add this get your thoughts on this oh me which is maybe what Austin is arguing and we can ask him he's right here but maybe what he's arguing is not so much you know you want to have validators be able to kind of reverse transactions on the chain just ignore that for a second we're saying more is if you have a completely immutable permissionless decentralized chain maybe that's not the place for real world assets that's another you know tactic you would take in fact this is sort of what Bitcoin does you know Bitcoin what is the Bitcoin network well it's just for moving Bitcoin essentially and everything else goes off chain Ethereum has this blend where it has all sorts of tokens some real world tokens some crypto native tokens and he token you wanted to play you can put and you inherit the the properties of Ethereum so maybe he's just saying real world assets don't belong there on the theorem are you Austin I mean I is I do think what's the right way to say this there is some internal hypocrisy in the current arguments around Ethereum that there is not in Bitcoin for exactly the reasons that right interest raised right like if I were to take these concerns to the Bitcoin community the answer that I get from the Bitcoin people is cool that don't put that shit on our chain to which I'm like oh you know what that's intellectually honest right like I think that may put in the long term an upward cap on Bitcoin prices but what you've said to me is completely intellectually honest of like get that shit out of here because I mean like the core point I would make to you is real world assets it's not a backdoor it's the front door right like the responsiveness to real world legal systems is the core feature of the product and you have to deal with that whether you like it or not because essentially here's what I'm saying and where I sort of bring in the hypocrisy here like if I'm running a stable coin in my reserves are US treasuries the number one group of people I am responsive to is US lawmakers regulators and like judicial persons period full stop like no judge none in the United States is going to be like well you know some random anonymous validators say that the North Korea zone your money down so we're going with that they're going to be like absolutely fucking not like we have OFAC I understand what the concerns are we have sections losses those assets the coin is Brit okay but can can we go into that Austin too it's like let's describe what that means too yeah let me finish the bridge and then we'll come back to that which is to say I am asserting this which is if you want on your chain to have tokenized real world assets you really really really need some multiply redundant mechanisms to make sure that your chain could be responsive to the real world legal frameworks that govern those assets because if you do not have that and you do not have call it like error catching around that take the tether example it is a matter of time until you brick the asset because the real world like legal process will win there's a lot of people with a lot of guns who are going to enforce that who's legal process so if you're doing this is the problem is the answer to that is it depends on your real world asset if I'm talking about like a US dollar stable coin it will be the United States of America if I'm talking about gold that is custody that blended metals exchange it's the United Kingdom right if I'm talking about like you know call it tokenized deposits for a bank in Hong Kong it's fundamentally China and look I don't have an answer to the fact that the real world is messy the real world is messy but I'm saying if you want to inherit real world assets onto your chain you have to have a reckoning with the fact that that is the case and there are many many disparate views on that and again this is not a reputation of like do it this way for the east token or bitcoin but it sure as hell is to say if you have a US dollar stable coin and the US government disagrees with you I don't think your blockchain is going to win so I think the appeal of going on chain is that the asset regulated in the US the asset issued out of custody in London and the asset controlled in Hong Kong could coexist with the natively issued asset like it's I think that is a killer application because all of these parties for the first time ever I'm except maybe wanting to ship gold back and forth to each other could use a way to interact with each other economically that no other party could impose their will on it that the US users will say you know what I am going to use this this neutral blockchain because China doesn't control it and the Chinese users are going to feel exactly the same way but I'm not this is not East versus West thing and the London tokenized gold issue is going to be like hey look here's a blockchain that has a trillion dollars and the trillion you on and that's where I want my tokenized gold to be because then people could borrow and lend against it when you talk Austin about well the real world asset legal systems plural are not going to tolerate this right and that's why the chain to attract their assets should have some kind of a control mechanism or or um exception handling error control whatever you want to call it right then what I think is you are headed for a world where some transaction involving the US party and a Hong Kong party happens and then the Chinese authorities go to the chain and say this is an invalid transaction you must stop it and then almost immediately President Trump tweets no it's a valid transaction it must go through and now you have destroyed your sensible or or fail safe blockchain because it's become completely politicized so my argument is if these assets are going to go on chain they are going to go on the chain where everybody's treated equally and that treatment is we don't care you get hacked here you get robbed there you make a mistake there the Chinese government wants us to do something the US government wants us to do the opposite thing we have no power to change any of it I think that is going to attract far more users and assets than it's going to repel because by the way also as you know better than most of our listeners most of the world's most valuable payment systems already work that way whether it's Fedwire is counterparting almost every other country these RTGS or real-time gross settlement systems have a rule which is that the intermediary which in this case is literally or almost as always the central bank is not getting involved in dispute resolution which is why the example that you brought up from Citibank is they accidentally wired out hundreds of millions of dollars the only way they could get it back is to go to court and use the legal system to sue the recipient to give him the money back and first they lost and now I think they want on appeal but the most important thing is the Fed's position right the mother of all centralized traffic jackal island intermediaries who processes trillions of dollars in payments a day their position is we are neutral not our problem you make a mistake not our problem the central bank of Pakistan was hacked and he was routed through Fedwire and the Fed's response was not our problem so given tradfied recognizes the importance of neutrality when it comes to important transactions I actually don't think it's that far of a reach to say that hey that's how the blockchains going to work unlike Fedwire though it's going to be for different currencies and tokens and NFTs and whatever and I think the tradfied mind if we could call it that will be like oh okay you're doing the same thing that every central bank does but in a more universal way well for the same reason that I'm glad the central bank is neutral I'm glad that the blockchain is neutral and we're going to move my assets on there well I so I'm going to say I don't think this is a correct description of how the federal reserve operates because I agree with you they are neutral for the people that they choose to let on their network and boy does Caitlin long to have some things to say about that for instance and also if people are repeat offenders they will totally kick them off their network so one of the things that the Fed is doing and I think we should both like just say this for the listeners is they are highly permissioned as to who gets to use the Fed infrastructure to set payments in the first place so they part of why they can be like well you made a mistake you made a mistake is it's big boys only who are there by permission like you had to be led into the club by the bouncer right the bouncer is being the group that gives master accounts at the federal reserve and that too boy do they do bag supervision right like these are people going into all of the members and like observing them auditing them setting rules and procedures like this is not just you show up and you get to do what you want so I will concede if you were to create like an L1 blockchain where the validators and the people using it were permissioned in the way that the Fed does I'd be a lot more chill about neutrality but we've just eliminated 99.
99% of users for blockchains because now it's just big banks so part one there part two I think the hypothetical world that you have proposed where there are these permissionless trades on blockchains and nation states can't to do read does not exist and is not the world we live in I think the hypothetical you gave of what if Donald Trump starts shouting about this is valid or not valid is unfortunately the one we are already in with real world assets because again I will go back to the point of the unfortunate reality that we face is actually let's take your example because I think it was a really good one we have a world where we have eth we have tokenized golden London we have a Chinese stablecoin and we have an American stable point right now I'm going to use Chinese and American because the assets just need to reside there like you could have a weird like Euro American fight whatever but there's a Chinese and American one here's what I'm saying is the way the chain ultimately functions whether you like it or not and the question is just does your code reflect the real world reality London controls how the gold token operates China controls how the Chinese stablecoin operates an American controls how the American stablecoin operates because if you could brick the reserve and brick the issuer you control the coin and I agree with you oh me there are things governments can do that would destroy the value proposition of the chain or at least using that specific asset on the chain but the problem is yeah like that's just the way it is I don't like that right I do think there could be better real world frameworks but I think that requires a lot of legal right regulatory reform that has not occurred yet because here's the fundamental problem with your system let us say that China says no this trade did not occur and goes and joins the issuer from like ever withdrawing the money for those tokens it just confiscates it now what right like it's just broken on chain forever if you cannot represent that reality on your blockchain and so what I am fundamentally saying here is that decentralization is a feature in situations where there's lack of trust and people want neutrality I agree with you on that but it is a bug in situations where the underlying asset itself is not decentralized and by creating this fiction that something can be decentralized that does not interact well with reality all you're doing is stuffing a live gradated to the system so that almost sounds like you're against stablecoins though because yeah they have the frequencies capability and even if like circle doesn't want to implement it the US government could always jail Jeremy a layer which you know we hope not we like Jeremy well the US government has never jailed anybody at crypto for like sanctions or money or yeah trump top charges so but that's to me ironically another reason why we want neutral infrastructure because neutral infrastructure creates a competitive playing field for different kinds of assets including ones that are issued from off chain rwa stablecoins etc and ultimately if you do have a world where avay becomes the repo market which I think it could but you have tokenized treasuries and tokenized dollars and very large financial institutions all over the world are borrowing and lending against each other the stable coin that ends up dominating that market is going to be the one that has the most perceived neutrality it is not going to be the one that has the most built in fail saves and kill switches because everybody in traffic understands that that could be weaponized against them right like counterparty risk is something that's drilled into the DNA of risk managers like you actually when you used to be one right so they understand that and they're gonna say I'm not worried about me being hacked and then not having a way to stop the hack because I can address that problem by making my infrastructure my wallet my custodian more robust they're going to think I am more concerned about a counterparty weaponizing some kind of an error resolution system to undo a trade right made money or that was vital to me and because of that they're going to be more attracted to the RWA's that are the most neutral I think they're actually going to be the ones that advertise this just like Apple has made a fundamental part of its brand to be privacy they put up billboards that say we protect your privacy and they even stood up to the US government after an actual terrorist attack right and they say we will not help you break that iPhone because we protect privacy I think they're going to be real world asset issuers that advertise themselves on neutrality and then they win so whether it's dollars or euros or Remimbi or gold whatever it is we'll see how the balance of global asset preferences shift over time too if you have a neutral blockchain it's going to attract more neutral assets including the ones that are issued off chain they'll never be fully neutral but there will be a CEO of a stablecoin issuer who advertises himself as willing to go to jail in order to fight again some kind of a court order from some government and then the market will ultimately attract more and more of these assets and then you're like the little smaller London tokenized gold issuer you're going to think I want my goal token to be the winner because that's how I make money right my vested personal interest is to make my goal token neutral so you get this sort of like network effect of the RWA is becoming more and more resilient and the final boss in all this I think we all agrees the government right I think the governments that want their currency to be more widely adopted which is all of them well almost all of them maybe not the Swiss and the asset issuers whether it's their tokenizing commodities or just equities or whatever right they're all going to want to win the neutrality race and then the governments who want their businesses to win who want their currencies to win who want their version of the US treasury or the actual US treasury bond to win they're all going to say you know what we want to win the neutrality Olympics because then we get more money more spending more jobs more taxes so if you start with this base infrastructure that is neutral I think it creates a cascading effect where the assets become neutral and then the issuers of the assets become more neutral and the final boss the governments that issue those assets are going to be more willing to be neutral than they are today so I would say I don't think as of yet that's been shown to be the true revealed market preference for real world assets like I actually think you've just made an exceptional argument in favor of Bitcoin to be totally honest with you right like I know all three of us like believe in Bitcoin to some extent in addition to ethos and assets so like I think this one we're preaching to the choir on but I would tell you like you could create a stablecoin like that but the costs of it are very high right like I would need to find some sort of relatively neutral offshore jurisdiction the assets I'm going to need to hold are like physical fucking bills that involve so that they're not responsive to judicial procedures and then I'm going to need a bunch of people to defend the thing like Eric Prince and I are going to need to have a contract right so that we can keep this stuff secure and by the way all of that is actually doable and in fact don't need I think you and I both know a lawyer who's thought about the joking idea of a central bank physical currency right like you could if you want to like to send it to like levels of madness go like Hideo Kojima Metal Gear style like let's create a like offshore military contractor that holds all the currency type behavior but the costs of that are high and the market has showed zero adoption preference for that it just want shit the tie we liquid globally and I think what I'm getting at here is like asset preferences are not monolithic and there appear to be a lot more people I think than you would like who are willing to make the trade off to have liquidity I also think government is final boss is something we will never get away from like government is just a word for the things we do together and you know in many ways like we're talking about reordering how we think about human civilization which maybe maybe down the road this will occur but it is not a decades like that is a centuries thing and so I'm saying in the world we live in today like it or not the revealed preferences are for highly liquid centralized stable coins and crypto exchanges and that these are responsive to real world like legal systems whether we like it or not and deliver that reality without breaking shit it's going to be a matter of time until blockchains need to find a way to be responsive to real world legal procedures by the way I think the rubber is about to meet the road on this globally for stable coins in a way it has not because of the passage of genius like if you go read that bill there are some serious hooks in there with regard to like ecosystem monitoring of responsiveness to court orders and like law enforcement and I'm going to tell you knowing something about how US regulators regulate foreign banks they're going to tell you if you want to have a US issue token that means your foreign entity is also responsive to us not all of those things so you are going to find explicitly US dollar stable coins responding to US freezing seas orders going forward and I think my point is we live in a world where oh me your negative case is actually just the base case like that is what's going on right now and I'm not endorsing that is good but I am saying that's the world we live in and so the reason I would say to bring this all the way back around to Ryan's initial question because like yeah unsurprisingly with you and me out here said to us down a rabbit hole immediately which is amazing is the core reason I said I think eth is unprepared is what is the right way to say this I think you think some of these concerns are highly speculative they may be less speculative than you think and people may have already been fighting about them in private it's a matter of time until what of the happens imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly that's what mantle is pioneering with blockchain for banking a revolutionary new category at the intersection of trad five and web three at the heart is you are the world's first money out built fully on chain it gives you a Swiss iBand account blending fiat currencies like the euro the Swiss franc the United States dollar or the reminbey with crypto all in one place enjoy real world usability and blockchain's trust and programmability transactions post directly to the blockchain compatible with trad five rails impact with integrated defi features you are transforms mantle network into the ultimate platform for on chain financial services unifying payments trading and assets like the mi4 the me's protocol and functions f btc backed by developer grants ecosystem incentives and top distribution through the urf reward stations and buy bit launch pool for mnt holders every economic activity in ur drives value back to you embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem follow mantle on x at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking that's x.
com slash mantle underscore official dgen started as a tight-knit community on farkcaster and organically grew into one of the top meme coins on base what began as a simple idea tip anyone who joins the fund sparked an economy that turned into a movement the community runs the show from the logo and the lower to funding and building ambitious ideas together over one million dgen's now power each other with their generosity creativity and ability to get things done at the center is the dgen token it rewards engagement fuels tipping and drives the marketplace for builders and fans that same energy gave rise to dgen chain a fast low cost layer three for new projects and now the dgen app the easiest way to connect earn and participate in decentralized social media with a built in wallet and real token utility in dgen the has stays on join dgen and get on the app weight list at www.
dgen.tips Austin I just a follow up on this right this this point that omitas making with respect to neutrality one thing we have seen with the genius act is of course nation state support of a stablecoin in the us we have not seen the you move we have not seen india move we have not seen china move what's very interesting to me about this is um we already have the swift network essentially which is kind of a us controlled i know it's a european sort of entity administered this basically us controlled payment apparatus china is creating their own payment network some they called sips that's sort of the you know china controlled ability to freeze you know whatever they want done on on sips we don't have a credibly neutral third player that has entered maybe part of the argument that omitas making is well that's a theorem that's the the layer one here and so yeah what china what the question for china or the EU or for any or india or any sovereign country is which set of chains are you going to deploy on and it seems to be the case that you'd want to deploy on a chain on a payment network essentially that couldn't be freeze by another sovereign country and potentially your adversary when it comes to the EU in making decision in terms of which chain to issue their currency wouldn't you think neutrality would be a factor when it comes to china don't they want to deploy to something that the us can't intervene in can't censor in like what do you make of that argument because we've started to see the rubber meets the the road but that's only in the us once we have geopolitical adversaries and interests uh you know colliding won't they prefer neutrality to omits point well i i would remind everybody europe has moved they have mecha it's just terrible and broken because in the classic european fashion they misunderstood the problem and so created basically bank captured tokenized deposits that can only function within europe so golf clap guys could work so right i might argue europe's revealed preferences actually know we just want to control things that don't want to be a blockchain at all and we'll just you know essentially take it in the face economically for that choice um europe has clearly not been prioritizing growth for a long time and this goes back to kind of the point i was making that you were saying about where is the credible neutrality i agree with they want a blockchain that cannot be unilaterally dominated in all ways by their nation state adversaries but here is the problem that you're going to run into for instance with china is they're going to tell you we don't want to be on a chain that the united states is in control of like unilaterally but we also aren't deploying on a chain where we can't control our own currency because that will obliterate our currency controls so you get into this sort of prisoners dilemma if you will mexican standoff if we started incorporating the u2 where like everybody wants to have that control over their thing but they don't want other people to have control over their thing right so like china doesn't want the us to run their currency the us doesn't want china to run their currency the you use not okay with either of them running their currency and so on and so forth but also all of them want like a place to transact and this is sort of why i'm coming back to if you want a blockchain that could simultaneously be the warehouse of the majority of rwa and actually trade call it more freely amongst each other certainly more freely than the current very sort of siloed global network but you also want it to be something that people will actually use what you're getting into is a system where it's local responsiveness to local tokens only right like china can't tell the us how a us token works and the us can't tell china how a china token works but they need to be able to tell themselves how the tokens work because if you don't do that while i agree with you the eth will have some value it's essentially going to become the trading venue only for limited forms of fx and maybe certain forms of physical commodities securities will not be on their derivatives will not be on there many forms of trade finance will not be on there so on and so forth because like once things start breaking with real world legal systems like you're just done right like congratulations i have a token that's non-representative of the economics of the real world it has no value to me and so this this is back to like i think there's some nuance to this argument that's very important which is i'm not fighting with people about the properties of eth or bitcoin and i am not saying we should have a chain where the us just gets to dictate everything but i am to go back to the real world is messy point saying if we want to tokenize the maximum number of assets and maybe that's not your goal we can come back to that in a minute but if you want to tokenize the maximum number of assets you're going to need a real world system where you can revert some of these things because like simply put to go back to the basic examples like the north koreans are not moving into grandma's house in Connecticut and they're not getting a board seat on apple if they somehow like act the apple stock contract and steal a bunch of it like it's not happening and so you wouldn't need a chain that can reflect those legal frameworks one way or another i still don't understand what your solution is you just made a more eloquent argument than i could as to how messy legal frameworks are in an international geopolitical setting and then you're saying and i want a blockchain that's accountable to all of them like i really like how does it work what's the consensus mechanism what's the governance like in the event that china wants to dispute a stable coin transaction do they file a form is there a website and then where does it go you're going to have validators right and you tell me what consensus mechanism you're running what is the process by which they decide that this messy chinese request that is now being disputed by a messy american request is going to resolve in the chain something simple like we're going to freeze a transaction how would that work i think the punchline on how you make those things work is unfortunately relatively simple and i think most crypto people are not going to like this um back to your pre-specified systems if i were designing a blockchain and i were thinking about tokenizing real assets at scale on that chain i would want for each asset when it's deployed to have to specify who does it think it's answerable to and to have the network agree with that definition for the thing to exist so i guess what i'm fundamentally saying is i think the permission it might need to exist at the do you get to put your token on here layer which is probably an unsatisfactory answer to a lot of people in crypto and i understand that but would solve this problem pretty well which is to say usdc would drop and say we are responsive to like the us government us states and that is the answer and if you want us to do something go to them and if you don't like that fuck off because that's how it works for us right like deal and then it would be relatively simple again obviously you want to get the security model properly don't just do this with like a single point of failure one to have some sort of Oracle network that like reposts us court orders of the chain will enforce whatever those are code them properly right like we could have standards here that doesn't bother me but like we need some way to communicate effectively in this vector and so if china comes it says well we have a problem with this usdc transaction the answer that the chain gives because it's already set these rules in advance is cool go to a us court get an order or fuck off right but it will also work the other way with china is my point is like the united states out of trouble can't just stand up and be like i don't like that transaction that happened with the chinese cbdc on this chain so reverse it they'll be like dog go get a court order from china it says it right there that's the only thing we can enforce so i'm not against even oh me deer point like immutability with regard to those rules my point is just what the rules are probably needs to reflect how the real world works because if they don't you have a problem and again what we may be getting around to here is an argument that actually most assets should not be tokenized yeah you just you just proposed swift yeah i was going to say to what extent is what you said different than what we have today in in tradify okay so here is actually a core point where i think a blockchain is vastly superior to what we have in tradify it's something that i think people under discuss which is i know decentralization is a buzzword for a lot of people in crypto but i'm going to make maybe the hot take here that i'm not sure that's the most important feature in blockchains i actually think it may be the open access and composability that matters more because one of the problems like let's go back to me it's example of the federal reserve the federal reserve system works like this conditional upon you being allowed into the system and that conditioning is the point of a huge amount of corruption and like political contention and like arguments blockchains don't operate like a private club they operate like a public park right that is to say your default is you can come in here and if you start doing shit we don't like maybe we can kick you out some of them are not even like that they're just like even if you're doing shit we don't like you can stay forever but at least some of them are designed in the way of like the default is you get to come in and then we have to kick you out for bad behavior that change alone is a dramatic and extremely important difference compared to the traditional financial system the second part is that blockchains kind of function is like a layer cake right again back to what omed and i have been talking about here and i think the two of us intuitively understand this so let me expose it better for like the people at home just to drive the point now i'm going to meet pilot if you disagree but like one of our complaints with the current system is also that it's incredibly fragmented and toll gated like for me to get a bank account in like Singapore and get a bank account in Switzerland and get a bank account Dubai get a bank account it is fucking sucks right and like a lot of people functionally cannot do it right but again with a blockchain you now have all of these like at a single layer cake where people globally can transact in ways that previously they were not so that's part one part two the composability like let me propose a hypothetical for people if you have a great business idea that would be value additive for the world and consumers on which you're not going to charge egregious fees but the problem is you need to build it on top of the chase banking app in the Apple store what do you think your odds of success are right it's basically zero because chase can just block you or brick you at any point they want and so the other part of blockchains that i think people are really under discussed and sort of like undervalued is the composability component right like part of what's so fucking cool about defi primitives like you to swap like ava is not just that they exist on a standalone basis it's that we can start frankenstiting them together and using money in new ways that were not possible previously because of the centralized control of a lot of intermediaries and so what i am fundamentally saying here is while decentralization may be a bug with regard to responding to legal norms in like real world assets and that is the heart of my critique of the current structure i think it is as oh me and i have agreed upon elsewhere a feature in a lot of other ways and i actually think one of the most important like features of blockchains existing and why i've gotten so interested in them is breaking down a bunch of walled gardens and access controls around these things more than sort of back end responsiveness to judicial orders the system that you propose has no composability because if i understand correctly what you're saying is we're going to permission the asset issuer at the network layer right though i have that right that like in the chain that you envision the future circles and tethers would have to get permission from governance to end to issue an asset but then anybody can hold their token do i understand that correctly i think essentially if you want rw a to work properly yes and the question becomes what is that permission and condition done because the good part about a blockchain like i know you and i agree on this is we can kind of set the rules of governance in advance in a transparent way as opposed to having like four dudes a jackson hole in a private room decide whether tately gets master a counter got but how again like you're you're in your system the validators set for a blockchain will somehow publicly determine whether circle gets to issue uscc on that chain or not vote how that's a legal governance thing it's not a consensus thing right are they going to have voting i was going to decide yeah my my answer to that is ultimately oh me this all comes back to social consensus and voting with real world assets like whether we like it or not that is what the current system is because like again to go back to the root of my critique if the eth validators say a transaction is good in usdc and the us government says it's not the us government wants yeah i mean that's the present state and my point was that because the eth validators are not going to get involved circle is less likely to want to do something which then in the long run will make the us government less likely to do something now you're saying that no the us government is always going to want to flex its muscle and we should design the system to give the us government what it wants i say no we shouldn't we should design the system for to optimize for mitigating counterparty risk giving guaranteed outcomes whichever one of us turns out to be right remains to be seen but i just want to point out in a system where the validators get to permission the issuer of an asset there is no composability because just as easily as the validators could permission a stablecoin issuer they can de permission that's stablecoin issuer and you would have to be insane to build a massive of a like lending market on a stablecoin that the validators could decide tomorrow is no longer allowed on this chain right the risk is there always and this is a fundamental problem in defy that the circles of the world could do that too right if circle wanted to tomorrow they could break all of defy however if they did that it would destroy their business their thirty-ish billion dollars in in market cap would go to zero the personal wealth that the executives have built particularly recently as the sock one public would collapse so the way the system is designed today they have a very strong financial incentive to leave things be in defy which by the way they have right you know this whether a me that circle has historically actually been resistant to when governments come and knock in and say we need you to permission this and the permission that but what you want to do is take that risk which i can see it is already a liability for defy and integrated at the consensus layer which to me means that we've just blown up the whole thing and if that's what you want then i would like to introduce you to a new jersey based firm named dtcc they already permissioned everyone and everything for you they are quite good at it they've been around a long time uh never been hacked by north career as far as i know it's hard that it's hard to hack paper share certificates jeppy hack they they have been the demobilized and dematerialized lately so actually it's mostly now um just electronic ledger yeah but the overall point is like it might be that what you and i disagree on is whether the neutrality of an actual permissionless blockchain is desirable in of itself even for non permissioned assets i think it very much is but i think it's valid we don't know yet right it's still as you pointed out on other podcasts like the size of crypto is still a rounding error to the size of trafi yeah so we'll see what it is my point is if you think that is all the world will tile tolerate then please for the love of god use a database do not use hash functions that serve absolutely no purpose do not incorporate public key cryptography that serves absolutely no purpose other than to slow everything down and make it needlessly complicated and do not use words like composable composability composability at the end of the day is only possible if the infrastructure is as neutral as the laws of physics right and you might turn out to be right i disagree but you might turn out to be right that that's not what the world is going to tolerate but if that's the case then sorry bankless guys the podcast is not pointless block chains are not useful for anything other than just like mean coins and niche dj activity also austin and i are going to have to find new topics to teach and become experts in because it turns out that the actual tam of public permissionless networks is limited to just what bitcoin does all right so i have i have two points on this where i think it's a little more nuanced than what you've said though i though i appreciate the rhetoric you're like you're good at what you do one i think some of the argument is actually more about the volatility surface of errors i would tell you in the current space the problem that we have with blockchains is they're incredibly fragilized which is to say when you have a system where circle is collided set of eyes to the current way they are which is to resist as long as possible the problem is what you have there is your volatility is none none none none oops right that is to say at some point the united state shows up at bony melon and it's like give us the entire reserve and you're just broken because if they find severe enough issues they're not going to do the thing of like oh you know i want them to go shade a little it's like we see like four billion dollars in the hands of the iranians we're just freezing everything and we'll sort this shit out bankruptcy and it does all go to zero so it goes from fine to fought right is how i would describe it i am arguing we might be better with a system that has medium amounts of volatility at all times because those tend to evolve towards stronger outcomes like omid i think part of our disagreement is i think we are more likely to get to a future where we force governments to chill the hell out about like the extreme degree of control that they currently want by putting these things right in their face and like revealing to everybody the consequences of what they're doing right i think the current system is kind of trying to trade away from it disguises like call it the malfeasance of that i think it may be better a little bit like you know when your dog like peas in the house to bring the dog over to it be like see what you did but you want to put it at the protocol layer right it already exists at the asset issue or a layer circle is already heavily regulated i but you want the blockchain to incorporate and again i'm not saying that the validators need to enforce specific transaction restrictions but they should probably enforce some degree of redundancy if we want to do it this way because again like there is a non zero chance that in 2027 we wake up and 100 percent of circles assets are phrased and then what happens again like in the current system you're a very binary like it's great we're fucked and i'm arguing it would be better to have moderate levels within there is one part of it to to get to your other point i actually do disagree with you on the composability thing because dtcc is a great example here there are middle states between a fully decentralized blockchain where we have tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands to millions of anonymous public validators and five dudes in a broom closet new jersey right like the controllers of all of this stuff i do think there is a pretty good argument as somebody who spent a lot of time thinking about financial market structure that something like a blockchain because again none of you trust each other composed of like call it the 500 largest financial institutions in some jurisdiction or set of jurisdictions that are willing to cooperate is significantly better than dtcc right because they are the ability for individual entities to exert outsized influencer compromise the system goes down dramatically so i think it's less binary than like you've laid it out i think again it's like the problem with traffic people as we like binary options like we want a zero or want enough fixed outcome and this is more of a volatility surface problem but i think blockchains are usable for significant improvements i do not think private like unilateral blockchains are like i think oh me and i both agree that like private bank chains are absolutely abridged to know where why are you doing this please for the love of god just use a database yeah right like that's pointless but a blockchain of like the five hundred largest call it american financial companies in the world to move all these assets around even if we're only talking about local to america is probably better than the current system i love this example because first of all having both worked at banks i like to think about the sausage making of creating such such a chain because every bank of five hundred institutions are going to have to have a bunch of lawyers involved they're all going to have to have a bunch of risk people involved biz dev reputation and of course this is going to be the global clearing layer for everything so then management and the board is going to have to be involved so now we have like i don't know two thousand to ten thousand bureaucrats in a room and they have to decide how to design a consortium great good luck with that i think that's literally impossible but for the sake of argument i'm going to say that austin you you might be the one person who can pull it off you're very connected in that world you're extremely witty and charming so you corral the bankers and they agree on a consortium that they're going to do this great one of the things i love about permissionless public permissionless is that they provide very simple answers to the most fundamental questions who owns it who controls it who gets to use it who gets the data who profits from it right and if i asked those questions about ethereum who owns it nobody who controls it some very diffuse group of stakers nodes token holders i've heard it's a single podcast right but controls that thing on this fact driving the entire right and then like who gets to use it everyone our fees determined by the market so forth and so on in the consortium chain example you've corral the bankers they're all going to agree okay who owns it okay so we get equity one let me be very clear here i think if it's just bags it fails because you have like a specific stripe of narrow interests right you need many kinds of regulated institutions even better who owns it hold on let me finish two i think the way that you end up getting there and this goes back to the ownership question there i actually agree with obi there's zero chance like zero you're going to get bureaucrats in a room and they're going to decide on this like what was the median time to launch a new product at city was probably like two years and that's just us making a decision i was going to say never but you're being more generous at somebody launched one it was two years um so thank you outlier yeah well again as you said i'm uniquely qualified here but like joking aside i don't think they're going to be able to do it this goes back to my point of when you incorporate these things and start forcing people to look at the consequences of their action do you know what does actually dramatically change things is legislation i think you have to hold the feet to the fire of the people it it's a little bit like okay i'm going to reveal that i'm a like OG internet d gen but i was around for like the creation of the malicious compliance subreddit and i would suggest to people that this is like my inner spirit animal of like you've got to say to people hey if these are the rules you said we're actually going to do the thing that you said the rules do so like looking what's happening idiots i would tell you i think designing chains to operate in this way will force governments to start having to respond to oh shit all of this stuff is broken right like actually we need to fix it and the answer is to how you get to this sort of state of the world oh mead is that people will put pressure on them to bring the hammered out and i think i have way more faith about that than many people because like i've been personally involved in the united states and like talking to politicians and lawmakers and legislators and regulators and watching the ball move from like the hysteria of like the anti crypto by madman to like degrees where they were like trying to ban all public blockchains and like committed perjury in a court Utah to try to destroy a product debt box versus SEC if anybody doesn't believe me to the point where we're like passing legislation on this stuff and grappling with these things i i maybe have more faith in the political process forcing people to come to these conclusions and then you have much more unification between real world governance and what's happening out of blockchain than the two of them like in sort of like the cartman versus jimmy fight from south park to determine like whose ledger wins once again you have reinvented tradify and even if the government compels it which by the way it's maybe for you but not for me i'm here for something fundamentally different and most people might not know this but the core infrastructure of law street and tradify was created in the exact process that austin just spelled out whether we're talking about clearance system settlement systems uh payment systems dtcc to the chicago mercantil exchange to visa and mastercard they all began as regulatory blessed consortiums where people in suit said you know what we need we need the responsible executives of large corporations to get together and build some kind of important infrastructure that they all share and and by the way to be fair at the time great that they did that it's very important that we have the kind of tradify infrastructure up until this point right my argument is that with crypto we can now go categorically better but i'm not arguing that we never should have done this because the result would have been that we would not have the great capital markets that we do today that's one of the things that i think also now and i agree on that many other crypto people underrate we should give credit where credit is due but we should also study the history of the exact consortium model that was just proposed and what ends up happening over time is the consortium entity realizes that it's more powerful than any one of its power of its founding members and then it systematically begins to screw most of them the nasdaq stands for the national association of securities dealers automated quotation system right it began as infrastructure for members of the n a s d to trade with each other over the counter right but now it is a public corporation that is probably more valuable and far more powerful than almost every single one of its founding members right there is a lawsuit outstanding against the four traders from the good old days in chicago i believe of the of the merc and they used to be the owners most of the triad file infrastructure was mutually owned aka a consortium and they're suing that they think when the exchange won electronic it screwed them over and it started preferencing new kinds of financial entities and it probably did right i don't know about any of the details of it but the point is and it's the same with like these and mastercard these as market cap and mastercards market cap is larger than i would guess 98% of the companies that initially founded them and they're clearly far far more powerful right they're more powerful than some regional bank that issues cards on their network so what i'm saying is that while today if we think about what Austin is proposing it would solve a lot of problems today it would probably get like more no coin or executives to join it and issue assets on it Jamie diamond i'm sure would be all over it because jp morgan is already one of the largest owners and participants of the triad file infrastructure so given fake crypto infrastructure to control and own two and he's going to be all over it but i don't think we're achieving anything so the question then is if we do things my way is it going to work or not and Austin made a great point about reveal preferences that i think is actually there is more data there than than we know because when i first started talking about bitcoin in 2013 the most common response i got particularly from people who worked in finance was the government will never allow it a non sovereign decentralized money or store of value whatever you want to call it that they don't control governments the world over will ban it and here we are today the president of the united states is the biggest bitcoin bowl and we're debating about whether we should have a strategic reserve or not so the reveal preference there was that the decentralization became something that even governments gravitated to gravitate towards possibly because as we experienced during the Biden administration when you try to kill it you only harm your own people right and then with stablecoins i think i wrote my first block post arguing something like stablecoins are going to be a killer app in 2018 right and again there too specifically people like at city bank who Austin and i both work with said the government will never allowed a non k y cd permissionless dollar to exist it said i don't care about your frequencies capabilities i don't care about your arguments that more money laundering happens through traffic i don't care about how good chain analysis data is to try to like catch the bad guys the government will never allow this to happen and here we are in the aftermath of the genius act where the government has actually enshrined the fact that you are allowed to own a let's call it semi permissionless dollar because there is the frequencies capability which by the way all the bankers out there if you're not freaking about what this means for you you should be because this is going to be a huge problem and that's another thing Austin and i integral so i actually think the reveal preference on the neutrality and decentralization has been that eventually people come around to it a lot of things you have to get tried in the meantime a lot of experiments have to fail in the meantime i think the fact that many many many consortium chains have been attempted and like hundreds of millions of dollars spent and years later they have nothing to speak of has led us to the world where more and more people are sort of being like be gradually dragged to my point of view including governments so one omid i just think you made a great argument for my incremental change idea of like if we put this in the government's face eventually they have to start doing things about it but to and this is an important point that i think there's an area of a lot of agreement on the reality is we will always be building these castles and then the next generation of omids and ostens and riots will have to lay siege to the castle that we built that build what the next generation is laying siege to that like there will always be this process of building things and then they get corrupted and you have to destroy it you have to build the next thing that is the nature of reality i think what is important and why i'm less concerned about the permissionlessness of real world assets is having something like bitcoin or eth existing now acts as a check on the behavior of those things in a way that did not previously exist because you have an alternative right like i don't think you have to fully co-opt the castle so long as people have the option to leave the castle and use something else like it mass adoption of permissionless systems is not required the existence of permissionless systems that people could mass adopt if the current system is profoundly corrupt is all that is required to keep them behaving much better okay now as we move to a closing arguments here you want a reflection i have in in listening to both of you and it would fantastic debate appreciate you coming on is that it seems to be the case that we are already we're in the process of letting all of the experience these experiments play out and we're letting the revealed preference of the market sort of decide it seems to me with crypto there's like kind of three things going on there's traffic over here but there's three things going on in crypto one of course is the store of value type of case another is defy decentralized finance and the third might be more what you were talking about Austin which is open finance right we see all of these experiments at play we see the store value case with bitcoin and ether we see the defy case or something like ethereum some other ecosystems as well we also see the open finance case you know stripe what they didn't decide to deploy a layer two they didn't go on the theorem it's a it's a stripe layer one this seems to be sort of the open finance maybe that you're advocating though we haven't seen the details so as we close out I mean I think for the listener we're letting all of these experiments play out right and who wins the debate or it's a combination of winners will probably play out over the next five to ten years because it's all happening right in front of us right now and I want to throw this to omit for your closing arguments so I think we started the question of why does decentralization matter the two of you both agree that it does matter very much for store of value for this open finance use case in real world assets omit you're still of the opinion that it greatly matters for that whereas Austin differs with you on that when we make your closing arguments for you know this debate I wrote this blog post not that long ago that vectors of centralization for any on chain solution or like the exhaust ports of the death star eventually the rebels will find them not because they're easy to find what because the incentive to find them is so high and if Austin's version version of a semi permission the future or consortium future becomes true it'll blow itself up so to me at the end of the day the people the users the assets the companies who issue those assets and the governments who regulate those companies will find themselves on a decentralized network because I'm going to garble this but it's like the quote that the Churchill said about America or democracy or something it's the worst option except for every other one and I think ultimately decentralization will win by default Austin I'm going to go back to sort of the beginning of this which is I don't think we could ever get away from the real world or the constraints of the real world and humans are going to human I think as a result if we want to bring the majority of real assets on chain we're going to be forced to acknowledge that reality but I think the value of decentralized store of value systems is by providing people and opt out right so the way I would think about it is this way Bitcoin is now your floor you have to do better than Bitcoin in order to be more valuable than people just owning Bitcoin if eth works the same way eth is now your floor you have to do better than eth to actually create significant value above that and where I think I differ with Omead is I don't think transaction preferences are monolithic there are some areas where like speed and controls and error reversal are significantly more valuable than others I care less about mistakes if I buy a five dollar sandwich that I do if I'm clear like five trillion dollars of overnight reverse repo for sure right and so I don't think this is a monolithic system and I think the real legacy of blockchains is going to be doing two things at once and they don't need to be done in the exact same way the exact same time which is one raising the floor on global conducted financial markets which I am just going to strictly say is a massive massive improvement in human rights on average over time and I think what's happening here is incredibly important but that number two it will lead people to have to cooperate in different ways because now there is a credible alternative and sort of raise the standard even above that in many things that may themselves be more centralized over time so I think what we're really looking at here is a governance revolution where again I've said I think the value of decentralization writ large is over value but that's just because it will force better behavior elsewhere very good we'll end it there of course bankless listeners none of this has been financial advice as you know crypto is risky you could lose what you put in but we are ahead of west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot