Ryan & David debriefing the Worldcoin episode. Want to listen to all past and future Debriefs for all Monday podcast episodes? Become a Bankless Citizen for access: https://www.bankless.com/join
----- 🎬 WATCH THE FULL EPISODE HERE: https://youtu.be/4HFyXYvMwFc ----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Hey guys, this is called a debrief episode. It's an episode that David and I record right after the podcast. This one was delayed by a few days. I think it took us a while to catch up after the episode with WorldCoin. But we wanted to release this on the public feed. So everyone has access to it. And you can see our thoughts coming out of the conversation with WorldCoin. Usually this debrief is available only for bankless citizens available on the bankless premium RSS feed. But today we are releasing it publicly. So we hope you enjoy this should give you some insight into the conversation we just had with WorldCoin.
Thanks a lot. Hey guys, welcome to the debrief after the episode that I wasn't on with WorldCoin. Sam Aldman, cool thing about debriefs. It doesn't matter. Okay. Tell me about it. We had on Sam Aldman and Alex Bologna of WorldCoin. First time Sam Aldman's been on the show. First time Alex has been on the show. And so yeah, it was so you weren't there. So I have to tell you about what the episode was about. You guys recorded on Mother's Day. I couldn't be there. Oh, that's right. That's why there was also it was also a Sunday. I don't think you would have. Yeah. Yeah. I probably would have hoped out anyway.
Yeah. So it was just a straight forward. We'll download on WorldCoin. Okay. So for people who had never heard about WorldCoin before, this would be a great episode for them. Talked a little bit about like the drama about WorldCoin's launch, which we actually had not like a wasn't like how we had a play in the we had a like a quick story about the the WorldCoin launch way back when because they were going to come on the show and then their PR company canceled because you sent out the tweet. What the fuck is going on with the WorldCoin and the PR company thought it was hella hostile. So they do.
Yeah, you know, did you guys bring that up? Not in the recording, but afterwards. Yes. I would say Alex and Alex was like, oh, yeah, we fired those people for like a long ago. Like they were terrible. And I'm like, thank you. They were so stupid, man. I like, okay. So that put a bad taste in my mouth when that happened. And that's not the only two times that's happened. Actually, besides like maybe I won't count Charles from Cardano, but Gavin Wood. Okay. Right. Gavin Wood. Yeah. Coconut scheduled. Yeah. We're like, hey, could it. And then could Gavin come in the podcast, haven't explored the polka dot ecosystem.
And then like I think maybe a few days before. Really close. Yeah. The the comms lead at polka dot reach out and was like, Hey, you know, we went back through some of your previous tweets. Like years ago. And like we don't like what you. I mean, and Gavin's not going to come in the podcast. So we should cancel this and try to substitute someone else at polka dot in the podcast. And I think I asked for like what the fending offending tweets were. And they were so tame. There was a week. It was just so tame. Like anyway, that kind of puts a bad taste in my mouth when projects do that. But I guess they're saying.
So I'm giving you. I'm giving world. It was a PR firm. It was a PR company. And I knew that it was we knew that it was because like when the PR company like canceled on the show originally on us, that I went to Alex just straight on Twitter. And it's like, Hey, fuck your PR company. Like you need you're getting. World coin is getting the absolute shit slammed on them right now. Like the backing away from like the public spotlight is this is not the right time to do that. Everyone is asking the sit questions that we would ask you on a pod. Right. Yeah. And so I said, I basically said that to Alex and DM was like, you need to ignore your PR company.
You just come on. Mainly a that was very valid and real and authentic advice. And B. I also did not want to emergency find another. He just like he didn't he didn't go for it. Anyways, the cool trivia about that episode is the episode that came out of that was ultra scalable Ethereum, which turned out to be an absolute banger. Oh, the one that we did last minute. Yes. Yeah. We put together a crash agenda. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Anyway, so that was the precursor to this whole story. So finally, well, I like that was like a that had to been over a year ago. It was a long time ago. Now world coin is still still around still building has won some hearts and minds to have joined the team and support the effort.
Mainly people, I respect DC builder. I don't know if you know that name floating around on crypto Twitter. This is not DC investor. Not DC investor DC builder. This is your knowledge cryptography researcher guy that everyone generally trust and appreciates in this base. He joined world coin. If you have the people joined world coin, optimism and world coin are collaborating on OP main net slash OP stack stuff. I think they still have a major uphill battle. So I am about what? Okay. So let me just say two things about this. One is I am very excited to listen to this episode actually. And thankless listeners should know I'm coming the debrief not having listened to the episode.
So you guys are at an advantage to me. So we actually are recording this because schedules David was in Zizalo and just schedules preventing we're recording this. I think like weeks later, really. This debrief, but I still haven't listened to the episode and I am excited to listen to it. And I intend to go into this episode with an open mind. I also don't think it will answer all of my questions. I think it'll be like to high level. It'll be a high level. All right. 60 minutes. Yeah. It'll open up the door for other questions. And I think one of my big questions is around sort of probably the privacy of this network, probably like, how decentralized really is it?
Like how public goodsy is it? How values aligned is it? I'm actually not sure what series of questions this will completely unlock. But I guess I don't want to hear a VC marketing machine tell me these things. I want to hear like independent community like representatives in that people that I respect and privacy and decentralization talk about these things. So, but I guess so that's one part of it. The other part I would say I think that they are just it's just hard. I mean, I said this on the roll up last week, David, but like the crypto bros want to orbue, right? And like, it's not great. I mean, to what to capture identity and who's behind it?
It's the guy who's the most powerful AI in the world, Sam Altman. And like, I don't know, that's an uphill marketing battle, I think. And like, maybe it should be. It's a very, if you're going to do something of this type of magnitude and make these types of vision commitments, then I think like you owe the world a commensurate level of transparency, auditability, openness, like that's a pretty high bar to me. And they say all that stuff is on their roadmap. They say, and I'm trusting individual, I tend to believe them. I think like there are some projects out there that are very in the crypto world that are very like beloved, like get coin comes to mind, protocol galed, optimism, I would say it has some of this.
World coin has like the opposite of that. It's like, whatever is the opposite of beloved, I don't know, but it's like, it's easy to hate world coin just by a nature of what it is, which is like, if you trust world coin and believe world coin, then it's like totally unfair because they're doing the same thing. It's just like, we're trying to, but you just said, so you just said, David, you're trusted, you're trusting individual. Why are you trusting individual? After all the shit we've gone through in crypto, like, why would you trust anybody in this space to do any like, there's a trusting individual before crypto first off.
And so it hasn't just been like my disposition is jaded you hasn't hasn't crypto kind of like show you to be less trusting in some cases, particularly when you have sort of the setup of large VC allocation, a coin, super ambitious kind of promises, lots of ways to cut corners. I'm not saying world coin could be fantastic. I have no idea, but I'm just saying the pattern fits many patterns we've seen in the past of like, this not working out very well. And I think that's what that's what the white blood cells, the immune system of crypto is just kind of like indiscriminately attacking. And I think if you want to get more precise in the white blood cells, you really have to go dive deep.
Most people don't have time to do that, including myself, honestly. It's like, I'm going to be relying on their party privacy researchers, people in the crypto community, I trust. I'm going to do a little like, I'm going to be able to do levels of due diligence, but I can't vet this thing from the ground up. Anyway, this, this, this trust, like, why should we, why should we trust what they say at all? Like, why shouldn't we default posture to like, oh, this is a bunch of bullshit. And then, you know, work our way out of that. So I, well, I'm not going to make the case for why one should trust world coin, but I will make the argument for, let's see, I'm not, okay, let me just say that, start that again.
I'm not saying that you should trust world coin, but here is the argument for like why it, why you could, why, why there are some green flags here that are different from like all of the 2022, like, mess that we don't want to go back to. One is like the idea, if you accept that the idea that biometric scanning is the most civil resistant mechanism to produce proof of humanity, then then you get something like the orb. And so you can start to like cast away the negative connotation that Iris scanning and the orb has, which is like a very source of like distress. It's just like the whole aesthetics of the whole thing.
So you have, so you can like, try and shave that from your brain. Then there's like, okay, VC, like allocation, serializing humans, like all, all that kind of stuff. Well, like, say, like, do you trust Sam Altman? Like maybe, maybe, like, what does Sam Altman have in it that like a three hours capital or doh Kwan or SPF? He just doesn't fit those types. And neither does Alex Blanya, right? Like, maybe if Alex Blanya was loud on Twitter and, and they're not populists. You're not populist, right? Yeah, exactly. Yeah. So there's not that, right? There's not, it doesn't seem like a get rich quick scheme.
They actually have a road map to produce something uniquely valuable and unique and have itself to crypto. I don't think it maps onto like the whole like things that we should map onto like a VC coin VC alternative layer one that we've seen so many times. I know it's not actually an alternative layer one. So that alone makes it kind of different. But, you know, we've seen many just ridiculously funded alternative layer ones that kind of like go liquid and then you just sort of get this feeling and kind of see the data that the VC's just dump on you once it once it gets into the market. And they don't really go anywhere.
They don't have product market fit. It just feels like corporate, top down. It doesn't feel organic. There's no builders. There's no community. And so I guess the where that usually turns into is not an outright scam, but just like, I don't know, exit, you become exit liquidity in some cases for VCs and then it becomes sort of a zombie chain, which is not like the worst outcome. That's not like a SPF, FTX style outcome or Lunatera outcome, but it's still not a, it's not a great outcome. So it's heavily VC weighted. There's two things that there's two ways to approach VC waiting there are like the easy like, yo, let's fork Ethereum, fork the EVM, which the Ethereum researchers have been building for like almost a decade now, more than a decade now.
And then let's raise on it and then like keep all the tokens for ourselves and dump on the followers. So like get other people to do the lift work, pump the token ourselves with our VC marketing dollars and then dump. So like not much work a lot of upside. So the world coin project is a ton of work is a ton of work. It's not like a fork. It's not like a me too of something like the VC raise the amount the VC dollars are legitimate because there's no way that they could get the orb mass produced in a way that other people can produce the orb. And there's no way that they could get people to scan other eyeballs.
Like that aren't in the world coin in like aren't in world coin employees. Like that whole lift side of things requires VC dollars. It's very legitimate use of a capital raise. And then like the whole like so like that that just checks out to me. Like you need VC money for that. So it still doesn't fit the mold of a typical VC exit scam kind of thing. And I put scam and quotations because it's actually just ghost chain low product market fit where you become exit liquidity. If you buy this particular token, but you don't have to write. And also it's not even the point of a world coin isn't even the token.
Like that's one of three points. What are the three points? Hugh proof of humanhood. The coin and a missing one. Maybe maybe just two. I feel like there's there's world ID. There's the world app which I think is pretty similar to world ID. It's like yes, the wallet, your authentication. But I guess that's pretty similar to world ID. This is built on a layer two, right? So right now they're deploying an OP main net and eventually they will make a OP stack chain. And so this will be their own sort of will it be like a layer three type chain or. There'll be an independent OP stack chain. Which independent OP stack chain.
Which in theory like fits into the optimism super chain model. I mean that's kind of cool, right? Yeah. I guess. So like as an OP stack chain, the app that so it's like an app specific chain. And what does that app specific chain do? It provides proof of human hood the world coin way to the OP super chain. Which is eventually just a theory. And by the way, the reason I'm coming in a little hotter in this is because I think this is how the white blood cells are. These are the questions. I guess maybe the last we don't have necessarily full satisfactory answers on what you just raised already. But I think you are offering some valid points of how this kind of breaks the pattern typical pattern we've seen.
That's all I'm doing right now. And I think that's what the crypto community is doing pattern recognition. But there's there's this third kind of negative pattern that I think people see. And that is the figure of Sam Altman, which is like, all right, tech, bro, I put him in quotations billionaire. I don't even know if he's a billionaire. I heard of going for a billionaire. Okay. So, but he went in front. He walks like one in Congress. I mean, he has no equity in open AI. Like I just don't even know how this works. Yeah. He has no equity in open AI. I think that that you can't necessarily take that at face value because like he could have no equity open AI.
And then open AI I could get liquidity and then he could get like a billion dollar open AI. So there's like ground about ways where that doesn't really matter. He feels like the Mark Zuckerberg of the 2020s in that he has created this technology that is clearly going to change everything about the fabric of the way humans organize and interact in open AI. Right. And so he is sort of this. And now we're at a phase I think in the world where like tech bros from Silicon Valley are like all kind of grouped into this parasitic extractor type of motif. And some people might think that's fair. Some people might think that's unfair.
I think the majority of society just doesn't trust that sort of individual at this point in time. And so I guess a question to you is like or maybe just just a question to mull over is like is this guy legit or is this guy going to be like somewhat evil or somewhat influenced by MoLock traps and all of the things that we've seen tech billionaires get influenced by leading to like bad outcomes for society. I guess the question is can you really trust Sam Oldman is what it comes down to. So yeah the archetype of like the web 2 extractor the zuck zuck web 2 idea like I'm reminded of the this quote from Sam Harris where he was talking about how everyone is like they are fewer people in the like there's a modern movement to ignore expertise.
Just like oh experts are wrong they're all they're all wrong like experts like told you to wear a mass and they're wrong. And so he was throwing a flag at that whole like movement that's going on in the intellectualism. Yeah exactly. He's like the way that society progresses is like there are experts and then they say things and then we prove those experts wrong. That's how society moves forward but who actually proves experts wrong. Other experts like more experts not the masses and so like in the to carry over this analogy Zuckerberg is the old expert Sam Oldman who knows if he's a better newer expert who proves the old archetype wrong but as me as a trusting individual I would like to leave that door open that the way through that that bad branding for tech bro VC tech bro founder innovator type is actually we find one that like does good for the world like who fixes the problems like it's not going to be like the average Joe that solves proof of humanity proof of humanhood in the AI world it's going to be a VC tech bro.
That's why he's a VC tech bro is that's how you solve these problems. What was your impression of him during the conversation? I'm slowly liking him more and more and more. Why would you like about him? He seems authentic. He seems nice. He's not running away from the alignment problem. I mean I think so if he is good in the front and then bad in the back he's a world class sociopath. What does the the AI safety community think about this guy? I mean I know I don't know I don't know he caskies like burn down all the GPUs like I'm so he's an extremist. Okay but I'm surprised that AI safety I haven't really seen AI safety and alignment groups come out and like torch open AI or Sam Oldman very publicly anyone right now I haven't touched towards anyone.
Is that is that sort of happening or is there the general impression in AI alignment communities that hey well open AI is not perfect they've done a fairly good job so far and they're not completely ignoring safety they're still trying to remain competitive and they're trying to do ripening AI has an alignment division inside of them and apparently contribute to this world. Well there's another factor of why people are scared and that's just because these tech billionaires are so powerful these days so like how how powerful is Mark Zuckerberg at this point how powerful is the individual who is masterminding open AI right and now you're doing decentralized identity as well you're doing world coin as well I think that that a nurse people one thing I'll say though because this has been somewhat you know me throwing a lot of grenades and criticisms what is the alternative to decentralized identity yeah like that's the threshold to cross is like basically what we're going to be left with is some sort of nation state digital identity right and that's all we have I mean India has already has that deployed now and that's completely centralized now you might argue well that's you know this is the probably the Roman Gray argument that well yeah of course decentralized identity it's great it's you know democratic nation states sort of proposing this and putting this forward and so that that's a great thing but that is definitely centralized technology and I do think that is the only viable alternative that we've seen for all of the decentralized identity experiments in crypto so far none of them have really taken off so as long as this thing is better than that or different enough than that it feels like a worthwhile experiment to to keep running like what's the downside I guess would be my question that's where I go back to like the claim that biometric scanning is the best form of simple resistance if that I don't know you there's probably some measure of truth or falsity to that but still this biometric there's a reason why we do biometric scanning so turning biometric scanning into proof of humanhood I think is a noble endeavor and so that is why I am categorizing myself as a world coin apologist wait you'd say a world coin apologist yeah so that like apologist means like you're fighting for a world coin like you are evangelizing for world coin you are sort of making the argument I'm just saying that like the world the existence of world coin is not the thing to be upset about I guess my take is and this might be a more moderate take I'm just open-minded I think that sometimes the crypto white blood cells attack too hard and destroy things without like without good reason and so I am pretty open-minded about this one and excited to see how it plays out when are you going to get orb david or like well I'm not getting orb'd why if you're an apologist though you have to get orb'd at some point I will get orb'd when I need to do something that requires me getting orb'd what's the benefit of getting orb'd anyway is it just you get actual world coins yeah you get world coins sooner you get a distribution of world coins and that the idea is that world coins like any crypto token appreciate and value over time yes same woman actually talks about that on the podcast I think explicitly like yeah well I'd never go up like so like the interesting thing you think about world coin is that like not only is it's a currency that might be used but it might also be like a graph for like things like air drops or distributions so if if world coin as a distribution mechanism becomes legitimately decentralized and distributed to humans equally all over the planet then it becomes a very good like graph to distribute other things to remember remember you read bill bouders book red notice yeah yeah so like there's a big problem when the Soviet Russia went from communist to capitalist like how did they distribute the equity of the companies of the to the to the people of russia and so they gave out like these vouchers things and to to people like if there was world coin they would have just been air dropped here's the equity of the company to the citizens of of russia right it's just like a it's a legitimate mapping of equity and capital as far as far as like the most legitimately distributed asset all the time is the thesis that they're going after why world coin why are they calling this thing world coin it's all right well open-minded and then when's this thing launching did you do you find that out they do not have a public pay yet okay well I do know that it rolls out it's not like one thing that launches it rolls out over time do you know our editor luke of bankless newsletter he got it orbed actually on thursday new city luma yeah luma got orbed luma got orbed yeah he went to the offices and uh got orbed as a test no shit yeah so I haven't debriefed with this is gonna be like the what's that dr.
Seuss book starbelly sneakedids or whatever orbs if you're or if you're not yeah you've been orbed or not yeah yeah um I just I feel like they could have done something different in the marketing but me there's no other way I world coin that's what I was thinking about like okay so if you once you commit to the biometric scanning thesis like then you then you conclude this is like outside of just crypto stuff then you conclude that iris is already most legitimate um so like biometric scanning technology so you are scanning irises if you believe in biometric scanning you believe in scanning iris so you're saying there's no way how do you how do you make is a thing that is mass-producible so that we can capture eight billion irises like what shape do you put that in you wanted to be a box because the box isn't much better like do you want to like dress it up like a teddy bear because that's kind of worse like how do you do it how do you do it in a way that doesn't make people squirm it's not possible maybe could you do it yeah it's probably not possible if you have to have an independent hardware device you can't like trade an app for it or something like this right yeah well you know what once we make it once you make its own device you have to have to be custom it can't look like anything else like what how do you do it I I still think chrome orb is like as good as idea ideas any I still think that even though this is very well funded given the names and given the kind of the ambition as well it kind of should be I still think that the most likely scenario of a product like this is it doesn't reach a product market fit right and I just say that because that's generally what happens with startups this is the startup phase and so maybe I think a few things to watch is like house traction going is it able to resist simple attacks or not that's a huge one big big one what's you know I guess how many new ideas are they getting over time um it's stuff like that I think that really the big question is like yes because like Sam Altman is doing this because the world of AI is coming and so I think without the world of AI wait what's the time because you need to prove who the humans are on the internet yeah and so like world coin without AI I don't think is has much legs like I think Sam Altman is going to simultaneously produce the need for world coin using open AI and that has actually been his plan all along is like first I'm going to make open AI and then there's going to be a eyes everywhere ooh then we're going to need to figure out who the humans are so I'm also going to make this world coin thing so I create the problem and also the solution I mean you can you can see how this is my idea because this is bottle yeah uh anyway to be determined we'll see I would definitely be great to have Sam on the podcast again and talk about AI stuff as well but I'm sure we'll get into that some future stage he's going to oh the world a handful of conversations while Banclas Nation let us know what you think of world coin and this conversation as always we appreciate you being Banclas citizen thanks a lot