Sam Jernigan, the “Unofficial ETH Maxi of Wall Street”, has been evangelizing Ethereum to institutional funds and billionaires from inside the house for the past five years.
Having the perfect blend of deep Ethereum knowledge and the full Wall Street experience, Sam guides us through how he became an ETH Maxi, why the lack of understanding of ETH in TradFi is the most bullish case for the asset and what the future holds for ETH institutional adoption.
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/17
------ 📣STAKEWISE | LIQUID SOLO STAKING https://bankless.cc/Pod_StakeWise
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🌐 TRANSPORTER | CROSS CHAINS WITH CONFIDENCE https://transporter.io/
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
⚡️ CARTESI | LINUX-POWERED ROLLUPS https://bankless.cc/CartesiGovernance ⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 7:47 Defining TradFi 20:05 Ethereum’s P/E Ratio 23:49 Sam’s Background 40:44 Becoming an ETH Maxi 52:57 The State of ETH in TradFi 57:38 ETH Bull Case 1:06:11 The Flippening 1:12:11 ETH ETF 1:19:26 Security vs Commodity Debate 1:24:00 TradFi: Friend or Foe? 1:34:39 Regulation 1:46:07 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Sam Jernigan on X https://x.com/sjerniganiv
Sam Jernigan on LikedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/samjernigan07302015/
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
The most bullish thing about ETH right now is the fact that the understanding of trad fires that it's this crypto as a big one. Because I think when they fully understand it, it's going to blow their brains out. Welcome to Bangladesh. We're today. We're exploring the diaries of an ETH Maxi on Wall Street. Yes, David and I came up with that title. I think it's a perfect description. As usual, this is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless. Our guest today is Sam Jernigan. He is the unofficial ETH Maxi of Wall Street. Now those are his words.
Sam's been evangelizing Ethereum to institutional funds and to billionaires really rich people from inside the house for the past five years and giving them the ETH narrative so that ETH killers don't take all of the marketing oxygen. I was a discussion we had in today's episode. I think this was a fascinating look at the inside baseball of Wall Street's crypto adoption and the Ethereum narrative where early is an expression Sam kept coming back to and I definitely felt like that in the episodes very early in Wall Street's understanding of the Ethereum narrative today. Before we get into the conversation, our friends and sponsors over at Stakewise want you to know what they're up to in the world of liquid staking on Ethereum.
If you're a solo staker, but your ETH is locked up in a liquid because you're solo staking, you can continue to be a solo staker in the Stakewise protocol while also being able to mint OS ETH in order to use your solo staked ETH in DeFi, on layer 2s, in I get layer or anywhere else across the Ethereum landscape. You get to keep your rewards that your node is earning while doing more with your ETH. If you're not a solo staker, Stakewise is interesting a vault marketplace to choose perks that you want to add onto your staked ETH between custom MEV strategies, DVT, insurance, API boost, all things available through the Stakewise vault marketplace.
There is a link in the show notes if any of this stuff peaked you. Dan's been on Wall Street longer than some of you listeners have been alive probably. So he's seen a thing or two about Wall Street and has just one of those guys that was open enough to crypto to really get piled on crypto like in a very deep way. And Sam's connected to a lot of just like the Ethereum OGs, people like Justin Drake have been going back and forth about like the Ethereum narrative, why it fits inside of Wall Street. But for a long time, Sam's been more or less like wearing the Wall Street gag. If you work in Wall Street, you can't really talk, you don't really have total freedom of ability to express your thoughts and opinions about things.
But Sam has since left Wall Street. So we get an exclusive peak into the stories that Sam has from being on Wall Street in 15 years as well as just all of the times different crypto people have come into the world of Wall Street to pitch their layer one among other things. And so just hearing the takes about like somebody who's a Wall Street veteran, that's also crypto native, who's finally get to tell their story after such a long time is always a pretty interesting episode. All right, guys, let's get right to the episode with Sam. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our number one recommended crypto exchange for crypto natives.
And I guess Wall Street can use this too. That is Kraken. Go create an account today. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Kraken. One of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world, Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive, and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos.
With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Are you worried about the security of your cross-chain transactions? Cross-chains with confidence using Transporter, the revolutionary token bridging app designed to give you peace of mind.
Powered by Chainlink CCIP, Transporter is your trusted gateway for securely moving assets like ETH, NativeUSCC, and Link, and so many more across some of your favorite blockchains. Over $2.8 billion has been hacked from token bridges to date. Transporter puts a stop to this by ensuring your transfers are protected by the most robust security features available. Chainlink CCIP provides level 5 security backed by multiple decentralized oracle networks and an independent risk management network. Transporter also provides real-time tracking throughout your transaction with its newly engineered user experience so you'll never have to second-guess the safety or location of your assets ever again.
And the best part, Transporter makes it simple. Whether you're a blockchain beginner or a seasoned trader, Transporter's intuitive interface lets you execute cross-chain transactions with just a few clicks. No additional fees, just a low cost for using CCIP which can be paid in Link or your blockchain's native gas token. But don't just take my word for it, see for yourself. Why Transporter offers a stress-free bridging experience, experience the future of token bridging at transporter.io and just send it. CELLO is the mobile first and EVM compatible blockchain that's built for the real world and designed for fast, low-cost payments worldwide.
Driving real-world use cases like Opera Mini-Pay, one of the fastest growing Web3 walls with over 2 million users across Africa. CELLO is seeing a meteoric rise with over 375 million transactions and a million monthly active users. Not to mention Tether and Circle just deployed native USDT and USDC on CELLO, supported by leading exchanges like Binance. And now, CELLO is looking to come home to Ethereum. As a layer 2, with a game-changing proposal core contributors at CLabs, aims to leverage Optimism's OP stack pioneering a transition as the biggest L1 to become a layer 2, with TestNet arriving as early as summer 2024.
With the CELLO layer 2, gas fees will stay low and users can even pay for gas using ERC-20 tokens, including native USDC and USDT, sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect. But CELLO is a community-governed protocol. Make your voice hurt in the CELLO forum to shape the future of Ethereum. Follow at CELLO on Twitter and explore the ecosystem built for the real world on CELLO.org slash quest. Bankless Nation, today we have an opportunity to pick the brain of someone who I think perfectly straddles both Tradify and Ethereum. Sam Jernigan is a macro investor. He spent the last 15 years trading many different asset classes, including crypto.
He built and ran crypto at more capital, which is one of the largest oldest macro funds in the world, space in New York. And before that, Sam launched a global macro fund that could trade digital assets. This is one of the first out of Mike Novogratz's family office. So he's done so many things in finance. He helped pioneer crypto options, executed the first ever option on ETH. And before that, he even spent some time in the belly of the beast at Bear Stearns and JP Morgan. And to give you a sense of the straddle in what he's up to right now, Sam is currently both a participant at the US monetary policy forum.
So that sounds pretty central banker. And also at the same time, an Ethereum ZK EVM advisor to the project scroll as a layer two, which you've heard about. So that is deep crypto and central bank again straddling these two worlds. Sam, this episode has been a long time coming. We've wanted to get you on for a while. But you have not been able to because I think you've been under some tradify rule sets that have not allowed you just to speak out and talk about crypto in the way we're about to talk about it. So welcome to the bankless episode. Thank you guys. So thank you for having me. I am a long time listener.
I rarely miss an episode. I'm a big fan. I think you guys do a public good. Appreciate it. So let's talk about we want to get your background in a minute and how you kind of ended up here and like what you've been up to just like the behind the scenes because that's a super interesting for for bankless listeners what it's like in the belly of the beast. But I think the context for this episode is we want to talk about Ethereum and Ether and how to sell it to tradify like what narratives resonate in order to do that. I think we need to set up this term tradify is something that crypto natives use.
I don't know the institutions call themselves tradify. They're just like five. They're just like finance, right? But I think that like for crypto natives, yeah, finance for crypto natives, right? It's basically anything not crypto is tradify. I mean, that is maybe a simple way to explain it. But when we say the word tradify, like what does that mean in your world? Right. I remember the first time one of my best friends is a chief economist at one of the largest banks. I remember the first time we were out the first time I said this word tradify. I mean, it's like what is that? What is that? That was not long ago.
I think I would say, you know, we think about when I say finance, you know, I think about basically like the investment banking world that sales, trading, research, investment banking. And then that's what we call the the sell side. And then the buy side would be what most people would usually consider like hedge funds and private equity funds. Venture funds are really outside of Wall Street, really. You know, I was pointing out to somebody that like Andrew Sinor was maybe a huge fund, but I doubt there even a client of JP Morgan. So they're just they're not, I think they probably use Morgan Stanley or something maybe, right?
But in general, venture funds are just separate really from Wall Street or what I call tradify. Or what most people, I think, call tradify. I think you would be thinking of Goldman, JP Morgan, Citibank, you know, etc. The investment banking world that comprises institutional buy and sell side. So why what I want to get out of this episode, Sam, is we are entering the era in which crypto and tradify are becoming closer than ever. We now have the Bitcoin ETF. We're about to have the Ethereum ETF. And now our conversations are going to go directly into the years of quote unquote, tradify. And so I'm trying to learn how to best sell what crypto has to offer.
And right now, that's Bitcoin and that that's it. That's it. But in order to really like put the correct words in the correct order, we really need to understand the audience. And so understanding that the audience is not venture capital, but it is Wall Street. Let's keep on going down that path. Like what is what's the makeup of tradify? Who are these people that we are actually like connecting to via the ETFs? Right. Well, I mean, I think the ETFs, I mean, there are some hedge funds that probably, okay. So I mean, I think I'm probably a couple years ago. I actually, in a chat, I mentioned you guys that most major funds are now papered up.
That means that they are now papered. They have legal documents in place with say Coinbase in particular to actually trade spot. That can be a very long process. I would say we got about maybe a third of the way through that process in the last cycle. I remember at one point, like, I think Coinbase had a backlog of like a thousand funds that were waiting to onboard. They simply couldn't do it. And then the things kind of went off the rails. And then I would say like half those docs probably didn't get done. And they have of the last year or a third didn't get done. And then the last third probably have been getting done over the last brief kind of emerging bull market.
So yeah. So most funds are actually now like more wired or papered as we say to trade crypto. And the infrastructure that's got a lot better like Coinbase Prime, which will be the primary platform that institution going to use. I can't even describe to you like the evolution of the platform has gotten a lot better. It's also much more crypto native. We could say that for another conversation. But the web wallet integration particularly on the back of their win at the SEC is going to really change things. I don't I haven't seen that picked up on crypto Twitter. But so yeah. So the infrastructure is very good.
That kind of actually goes back to my origin. To go me is the smart order router was acquired by Coinbase. And is now what's integrated into prime. And I was one of the first people ever demo that back in 2018. So yeah. So the infrastructure is very good. And a lot of accounts are are quote papered up to be able to trade spot. But there are still other funds. And I would say like even like to smaller prop shops and and then like family offices. Some family offices I would consider like track fight institutional right in the Wall Street sense. And then the next tier I would kind of you know I would almost kind of put them in the next tier out because they don't trade a lot of they're not as active.
The next tier out are going to be you know more like pensions and endowments. And they're obviously also you know part of track five. But this is kind of like permanent allocated portfolio capital. And there's that's actually a very compelling story. I'm actually not surprised by the adoption of the coin ETFs by large long term allocators. And you know we can we can get into this the portfolio allocation benefits. And that was to having not just Bitcoin but ETH and other crypto assets. That was that understanding that story from an academic standpoint based on some work a former senior fed official friend of mine had done while he was actually at the IMF is what actually convinced me to start the first fund.
So I guess that's a long way of saying you know tradifies definitely going to be very involved. I think in terms of selling it Bitcoin is digital gold. Maybe we're seeing a little bit of a change to that with opi cat and some of these other initiatives. I saw the stark wear actual little video earlier from earlier today. I'm really kind of trying trying to prod the Bitcoin community into embracing scaling. Embracing a lot of the technologies that Ethereum has pioneered by the way. But for the time being you know Bitcoin is just digital gold. And I look I understand why that has been a very attractive for Bitcoin investors.
Right. It's like if we ever get to the size of gold like we're all rich we've done great like what more do we why risk why take any any of these risks. You know or potential risks that they perceive anyways to try and do more. And that opened up this opportunity where Ethereum you know entered and said hey we can do a lot more with this ledger than just have a a meme coin on it or some something that we all agree has value like like gold. I do think by the way that Bitcoin is a superior gold that was also part of my evolution into into the space and I can kind of explain that. And it is a you know I was one of the first people to really begin advocating for it as a macro asset and telling the story of that as this permissionless non sovereign asset that can be transferred.
But you know the part that getting to Ether you know ETH took this one step further and added a Turing complete adding a Turing complete which maybe is a little overuse term but adding a Turing complete programmable environment now. I think the reason people think it's very difficult to tell the story of ETH is because it's so compelling you can really almost do anything with this with this this environment and that is a good problem for us to have telling the story of either being difficult is okay. I can tell you one the way I kind of view it the way I've tried to explain it to track five people like it doesn't always stick you know this is going to be a long process but again that's you know to the hashtag early this these are good problems to have the the actual way to one simple way to think about a functionality of ETH that every track five person can understand is very simply to to explain that Ethereum the network is a little bit like Swift plus chips so chips so everybody now knows what Swift is Swift Swift is a messaging system it does not settle right so it is literally just a format for for banks to communicate or even yeah banks to communicate basically on sending of dollars and increasingly other types of securities but at the end of the day banks have to settle and they use primarily chips which stands for the clearinghouse corporation it goes back you should look into it it goes back problem was 200 years it's owned by the 25 or 30 largest banks in the United States you know we're talking about gross settlements every year of hundreds of trillions and fed wire and these are basically 24 hour cycles and what Ethereum is again and there's one very narrow definition where I can show you what it can do that's game changing to this otherwise massive and critically important global financial system arcade infrastructure is to think about Ethereum the network as Swift plus chips so messaging of financial transactions not just cash but any type of financial transaction plus the settlement of those transactions and you pay a fee and that fee then accrues to ETH which is basically this this equity and that that is then transferred via a buyback right so when you pay a fee to do a transaction on Ethereum that that ETH is then burnt and it's the same as you know one way that you can take that that application then kind of another analogy is to say it actually lines up well from a modeling standpoint actually is to look at Ethereum a little bit like mastercard or visa so mastercard and visa you usually do not pay the fee yourself when you when you check out at and at the grocery store or a restaurant but the the merchant does they pay anywhere from a 3 to 5 percent fee and imagine if that 100 percent of that fee was was basically cash flow which it's not it has to pay for op X and it has to pay for taxes so the drop through from cash flow those fees actually to net earnings is about or cash flow is about 50 percent so they that model has very high margins but ETH basically has 100 percent margins but at any rate so you know you have to pay the employees that run mastercard and you have to pay some marketing expenses maybe and then you have to pay taxes and the net of that if it were all to be used to buy back stock that would be very similar to what Ethereum is right so but here mastercard visa traded like a 25 times price earnings multiple and I think that you know I've I've generally thought that a reasonable framework is that ETH's Ethereum should have roughly a 2X that multiple so 50 times price earnings multiple one because it's growing faster but two because it doesn't have to pay for op X and it doesn't have to pay for taxes doesn't have to pay taxes so it's a very clean revenue and return of revenue to to holders of the equity like asset ETH and it's important to understand that for the system to be permissionless the the ownership of that asset which you have to use to pay the fees like oil has to also be permissionless and it has to be highly decentralized and so that's why it can't be you know eat the security or eat the publicly traded stock it has to be eat this permissionless crypto crypto reused but you know crypto asset that anyone anywhere in the world can have access to and can use to access the network the same I think you've given us a taste of preview of the rest this episode right where we're going to be camping on some of those subjects I guess a few things just just to tie off one one thing what what is ETH's PE ratio right now just out of curiosity I don't know if I had that it's like in the hundreds right like I don't know I saw like 150 something in that range so maybe a bit more than like 2X what Master Garden V's are right so I think I would have to check I don't know offhand to be honest and so I don't if I don't know the answer I don't want to make it up I think you also need to make sure to be clear issuance is a cost and I want to kind of set the record straight on this I just like a lot of people watch your episode with Justin and Anatoli and you know Anatoli's had a very strange I think I said on Twitter naive understanding of economics for some time I remember he said something very similar to this back in December and Twitter it is definitely it is definitely a cost you can think about it a little bit like paying the employees right so issuance pays the miners or pays validators and you if earnings are the net of that that the what you're taking in in terms of the fees minus your costs that is your that's your net your net earnings going back to that visa or mastercard example so Ethereum is the only system that has positive net you know net earnings net yield also for staking validators and you know I've seen your previous episodes on you know the the risk free rate another another issue I'd like to get into is I feel like I I was trying to I saw I saw a previous episode you guys did on you know the risk free rate and this you know the staking yield I feel a little bit guilt in a lot of ways I actually helped point out to a lot of the people behind the scenes I point out to people that this was a positive real yield the only positive real yield that is economically sustainable and generated by user activity that's very important is the only positive yielding real positive real yielding asset in all of crypto and part of that is accrued through that buyback mechanism and part of that can be be a staking and but I think that the one of the reasons I say that I kind of regret heavily pushing this understanding is that you know this is now running into this issuance problem we're having that several of very bright researchers like Ansgar and Casper have have been talking about and it's worth having us having a followup episode on that but you know it is very important that eat the asset maintain this this quality of a positive real yield and being ultrasound deflationary money in the same way that every year apple is able to buy back its stock and it's the outstanding stock of its of apples equity declines in value that is how that is how value from the network is returned to apple shareholders and we need to make sure that that issuance is the issuance curve is adjusted to maintain that same quality for a lot of reasons that that a company that returns its earnings via buybacks and in our case buy and burn the burning of of ethos for transactions that we're able to retain that that this unique and very powerful differentiation the sam there's there's so many air like ways we could like fork this conversation right like we've just brought up a ton of different topics right you know one is I'd still kind of like to get your your your background and how you came for this place of straddling sort of tradify and a theorem that's important we you know I feel like we've mostly talked about who tradify is what we mean by that but I don't think folks to understand the size of tradify right now and then you just like branch branched out into a conversation around ethos kind of monetary policy and like how issuance is a cost to the network and a theorem is kind of like the only crypto network with the true source of yield so like I want to hit all on all of those things just like not sure where to go first so let's do this let's backtrack and could you give us some of your background on how you came to be and then we'll hit some of those other items how you came to be here so I have sort of you're like seeing your personal trajectory a little bit from afar I've like heard rumors of sam sort of you know in the in the tradify space as this liaison role between kind of tradify and particularly a theorem like I think you've been described to me as like you know a tradify eat super bowl you know kind of like a you know Mike make Michael sailor behind the scenes only for a theorem right and so I'm wondering how you took that rule can you give us like how you got into crypto you said you were originally piled with with bitcoin how did that start and then how did you come to the place where you are like eth pills and having conversations with the movers and shakers in the institutional tradify world like how did that come to be and what why are you doing this sure um so uh I started my career in New York at Bear Stearns um and sales and trading um I successfully made the transition over to um JP Morgan and um while they're um you know it got the crisis right um the oh eight crisis right internally um I was uh they almost fired me actually because I was trying to tell people that well hell was about to break loose and um they were like if you don't stop telling people this we're going to like fire you anyways thankfully all hell broke loose and I kept my job and got promoted um and I I worked on a um a internal desk that uh uh basically traded the banks capital or what's called proprietary trading so I worked on a I worked on a portfolio that reported to senior management um and we did both long short equity and global macro you know um one of one of the early trades I had there so just to kind of you know I having got the crisis right I was very deeply uh learning about economics and JP Morgan has probably the best economics team period and I had this unlimited access to this huge resource both of the publications but also to the economists and I took advantage of that and um became very good friends with um several one in particular uh former Fed but senior comments to JP Morgan that's how I developed a lot of my Fed network and former staffers and and um one of the early trade you guys had a recent interview with uh Timothy uh Mesa uh Mesaid um and uh where you talked a lot about the year and all the futures market that was great interview for everyone watching a highly encouraging watch that uh year dollar futures was actually one of the biggest trades I had early in my career at JP Morgan so they're commonly used to bet on their it's a it's the market has evolved since uh since then but at the time they were the most liquid asset for trading um basically expectations about Fed uh rate hiking cycles and as compared to everyone whether you know uh you know uh bitcoin maxis at the time that emerged in this period of time of the crisis or tried five people everyone thought that the Fed was printing money and we're gonna have hyperinflation and I didn't think that was the case and so the way you would do that is you would buy your dollar futures that were pricing in Fed rate hikes betting on quote lower for longer and so that was a trade we nailed both in 2010 and 2011 proprietary trading was outlawed though under the vocal rule um and so and 2012 I left um I worked at a few different macro funds um I think the kind of the the next kind of little anecdote here I think that that fits well as I think what where I I was exposed to bitcoin a few times between uh 2012 and 2014 um and I probably cost people being billionaires talking them out of this asset that I viewed as like yeah look I think you know I thought it was uh I thought it was a joke I thought it was an incarnation of the reach for yield or this incarnation of this view that I felt was wrong that the Fed was printing money and they were gonna have hyperinflation I disagreed with that you know I thought that the Fed would have to keep rates low for longer uh to facilitate a slow recovery and the inflation expectations have been significantly de-anchored to to the downside or at least you know we're we're very low um and um so I missed it in fact I remember it went from 100 to 50 and I declared victory and I never I don't think I looked at it again for like two years so I was like I see it went from 150 and that was you know that was that was extent of it that what changed for me was in 2015 I was at a different fund I actually told this story just before COVID um at the first macro conference to talk about Bitcoin for Wall Street that I ever helped put on back in 2019 um and the the my former boss was in the room um we were betting against the Chinese RMB so in in 2015 2016 we have we had a very large uh um options trade in the forward market on basically that the dollar would go up against the Chinese RMB and when you're playing against something like you know when you're betting against the you know CNY or C&H offshore you're playing for like this like four to six percent move right this very small move and you know I remember I was on the phone with our HSBC um salesperson in uh Hong Kong and I was like hey you know or like the Chinese billionaire still trying to get money out of China like in did they still want dollars basically and he was like yeah the only thing they want more is it's Bitcoin I'm like what are you talking about he's like he's like they love Bitcoin they can't get enough Bitcoin they they basically buy Bitcoin they move it out of the country and they swap it the OTC brokers into dollars and I was like oh my god this is unbelievable you know he's like pull up the chart overlay dollar CNH versus Bitcoin and put Bitcoin on log what you have to do so I do that and of course it's like this perfect correlation I was like holy shit you know we're playing for this like four percent move and this Bitcoin is moving like four hundred percent and so I printed out this chart I remember I took it into my boss's office and he did not like being disturbed during the daytime by the way he liked to read his office he's you know where's like I'm a little bit the opposite he did not like to be disturbed so I went out I was like David I'm sorry I need you to look at this we have the wrong trade on and he's like what are you talking about I was like look at this I was like we have the wrong trade on he looks down at him he goes what is this I said it's Bitcoin it looks it looks back up to me he goes we don't trade Bitcoin and you're like yeah I was like but we should be I was like but we should be you know and you know that was I think you know that was the first realization that this this was a macroset and you know I think that an important thing I wanted to kind of communicate I did it recently at a the Denver actually this panel I spoke to like I think a you know when you think about macro we spend so much time or I think the popular press and CBC really over like dramatizes like 25 basis points even a hundred base point hikes here from the Fed if you're dealing with an asset like Bitcoin who cares right if you're dealing with crypto this is much bigger than a small fed cycle right don't you know this this is about the movement of of of capital global capital about people about politics this is about the for the first time in really ever that you've been able to instantly and permissionlessly transfer assets across borders and around capital controls this is so much bigger in a lot of ways than anything that Fed can do and don't let you know that is why every macro person on the planet is is literally blowing their brains out that the Fed is much higher than they ever thought they were going to hike to and yet Ethan Bitcoin are basically at all time highs that was not possible for anyone you could have gotten on your show you know a year or two ago and it's because they just you know don't let the noise let you lose sight of of the forest here so there was a force for the trees maybe I have the throng so anyways um but I think and this will come back when we talk about like what to track five people understand about crypto like look after that experience I was like well you know we can't trade Bitcoin right and frankly just I didn't think about it again until later in 2017 I was hired away to another fund to cover US policy so fed policy and DC policy for another fund and um you know one of the things I realized was that a lot of the hedge fund billionaire founders worked and this was coming out some of this in the press but a lot of them were trading Bitcoin and Ethan their PAs and I was hearing this from friends that I know at a lot of funds when we say PAs we mean personal accounts personal account yeah okay yeah I was hearing this from a lot of my friends who work at these funds and I was you know so but but none of these hedge fund macro billionaires and guys running these funds were doing it in the fund because they didn't want to take the risk of alarming or startling existing investors in their fund or what we call the you don't want to take you don't want to take LP risk on the 2% basically right so they you know so I saw an opportunity there so I saw an opportunity to basically a greenfield opportunity to start a macro fund with the ability to trade digital assets in the docs but I I'll admit I wasn't completely convinced just because people are speculating on something doesn't mean it's a you know it belongs in a macro fund you know people speculate on Ferraris or art doesn't mean it belongs in a macro fund what and even with the experience I'd had seeing how it was being used in the context capital flight out of China that still wasn't enough what really what really moved the needle for me was that a friend of mine I think I can use his name because his his work is published and he still updates it you know Benson Durham who was then I think he was a deputy director at the IMF under Christine Lagarde he had previously been associate director of monetary affairs at the at the board of the Federal Reserve Board and he had been asked by Christine at the time to look into whether or not this is 20 late probably mid 2017 whether or not what was going on in crypto was a reach for yield was this just pure speculation or was this the emergence was it possible that we were seeing the emergence of a new asset class and for for Fed economists and you know people of this ilk like that that is a very high bar and there's a lot of statistical tests that I would never even begin to explain much less do I barely understand them so but the short answer was that there was surprising result was yes and the reason I knew about this was Benson knew that I had some interest in he was Regent and talking to me and asked me to kind of review a draft and and I was taking it back because one of the findings was that it was bumping out and what's called the efficient frontier and that basically means that and this a lot of this he ended up publishing this research in a the portfolio of journal journal portfolio management in 2019 but it basically means and now BlackRock is like running away with this whole theme but it basically means that almost every portfolio should have a little bit because on a volatility adjusted basis because it is uncorrelated or has no correlation to any other asset it provides diversification benefits and the benefits are massive we're not talking about you know one or two percent portfolio diversification we're talking about you know huge huge benefits to what's called again the the efficient frontier and so I was like that was that was really convinced me to that I had to do this unfortunately we were just way too early we might never get you know a great macro PM who had very publicly gotten into crypto I was introduced to someone who was working out of his family office anyways we might give us some sort of capital and space to start up the the fund but you know I think that you know I you know everything takes longer than you think that well even when you take account for how long it's going to take you know Hofstetter's Law and it was definitely the case not only was the whole realization of crypto as an asset class not yet mature the tooling and the infrastructure and it was like the the accountants and the you know the auditors like none of that stuff it was very difficult but it was still an amazing experience I you know just to kind of put you back in this period of time you know my I remember my then future partners said to me you know Sam you just FYI Mike is not convinced that you know Bitcoin belongs in a macro portfolio if you remember like it was really confined to venture funds at the time and paradigm had just raised a lot of money I think at this time and and I remember the first question Mike said to me was why is Bitcoin a macro asset and I said it's a macro asset by birth it's written in the Genesis block Chancellor on a break of second bailout Jan you know 2008 he's like that's a great answer I'm gonna I'm gonna use that and you know but you know it was a very long and difficult bear market but it was great you know I mentioned earlier that I was one of the first people to use to go me which ultimately was acquired by Coinbase and became integral to Coinbase Prime you know paradigm trading which is now where 70 plus percent of all options Bitcoin and ETH options even see me is now block trades are done through paradigm I was one of the first people to to do that a non as an amazing builder we were probably 10% of the Bitcoin options open interest at this period of time you know Bitcoin was at like 3,300 and we put it you know we were the first people which this is crazy in retrospect people watching this will laugh that know this derivative space we were the first people it even got written up by ledrex ledrex by the way was the only like legitimate place to the CFTC registered and and to really trade Bitcoin options it was difficult though because it's fully collateralized and liquidity was low but it took and there was only one market maker it took us I think two or three weeks just to get like a few million notional of options premium on in Bitcoin which is not a lot but at that time that was like 10% of the options open interest which is crazy for something that's now 20 billion market so it was it was an amazing experience I got to you know see a lot of the early infrastructure that that now is being used by institutional investors that are papered up to trade spot and help facilitate the growth of that market we were very early on there a bit so to finish out your story Sam what got you a kind of eth build as well because that's how you've been introduced to me as well I think like maybe like three years ago it was just like hey meet Sam the guy who is popularizing the Ethereum narrative to a bunch of unbelievers and tradify and so you told the story of basically crypto and Bitcoin and how you kind of like dialed in there Bitcoin but correct me from wrong I don't think it stopped there and now I know you as more sort of a you know tradifies Ethereum evangelist so tell me the unofficial self-proclaimed eth maximum fall street yeah is that is that what they say um so you know you mentioned earlier I we traded the first option on eth we did that with a via an isda an OTC trade I remember eth was at a hundred dollars I'm sorry 160 and we bought no I'm sorry what it was it was at 120 and we bought 160 six month call six month calls I remember there was no vol curve for eth at that time because Deribit had not yet launched and so I remember when we were negotiating or we're like what are we going to use for this for the vol curve it was like we'll just take Bitcoin and add five points to it that was like that that was the that was the logic that went into figure out what the vol the forward volatility curve of the Ethereum should look like um you know I was I never really expected to get as deep into the into the Ethereum ecosystem as I did I was pretty happy playing this more trad fi you know being an allocator and trader in the space what kind of happened so in a flash forward a little bit I was hired to come in and I was pretty much the only person I'd really built to what is a sufficiently credible institutional setup for trading to the assets at that time I was asked to come in and build out crypto for more capital to to to a sufficient standard and during the course of 2021 in particular and I think it reached kind of a crescendo for me and uh sexually in December 2021 I think it was when um JP Morgan had his first and only digital asset conference um you know they're you know I and this goes a little bit into one of the bullets I put that I wanted us to talk about like what does trad fi know about crypto the knowledge level is very low in a lot of ways you know I joke that trad fi is worse than retail and the reason why when it comes to FOMO and the reason why is because trad fi often is not allowed to use metamask or is very highly like concerned about getting caught by compliance it's a little bit vague in my prior job whether or not even I was allowed personally to use it or did that $3 you know each transaction counted something I need to report you know like that you know people this is not sufficiently important enough for people that they like even want to play with it right in a lot of cases that ambiguity and it's not until you really get into these deep bull cycles that people are like trying out metamask you see that you those usage spikes so knowledge is unfortunately low because trad fi doesn't actually know what private keys are you know this haven't interacted with the same way retail has so I've actually said I think at a permissionless conference a few years ago with you guys and I actually think retail has a little bit of an advantage over trad fi or the or the billionaires because they actually engage with the technology and that that's very helpful um so I became very concerned that I was seeing a lot of at that time what what we called eat killers coming through making the rounds in in New York telling institutional investors that Ethereum was going to die that you know that so and so was going to be the new it was going to replace Ethereum and we you know we still see some of these coming coming around but not to the degree it reached then and I I don't think Anna Toley was as guilty of this and again I'm referencing conversations that and pitches that I saw happening in trad fi type environment and conferences um Eman Van Goon definitely went around saying this um yeah that's the founder of the age for people who don't know yeah um Anna Toley not as much Kyle Samani did um versus but that was not actually a new thing for Kyle yeah Kyle told me the night the day we bought those first call options on Ethereum it was at 120 I remember we were I met Anna Toley during the seed round um because Kyle had introduced us and I remember I wasn't going to tell the story but I remember it was like nine o'clock and I was talking to Kyle on the phone and we had just again Eath was at 120 we bought six month Ford 160 uh strike calls and I was like Kyle what do you think of Eath here he's like it's going to zero focus it's focused on Solana I was like reminds me of a younger version of myself this kind of you know overconfident you know when you're younger you you think you know a lot you're very overconfident you know as you get older you get beat up in the market a little enough you become a little bit more uh a little bit more humble but yeah flash forward to 21 I think he in particular was out there telling I remember seeing on twitter this comment uh that he said he was uh getting called by all the billionaire so you know what I think that was probably true I think they probably were and he was telling them like Solana is going to kill Ethereum basically and so so that that whole thing was very frustrating to me and the reason why is because guess what Ethereum does not have a marketing department the way that uh Solana does it does not have a marketing department the way evil labs or whatever it is does that plasters the New York City subways with avalanche uh advertisements and then we had Luna and this thing I knew within 15 minutes of looking at it on the website this thing was a Ponzi scheme there were little toy versions of this on eos and Ethereum back in the prior bearer uh prior bear market there were everybody knew there were jokes and here this thing's actually become like a real this is like a huge thing I was genuinely alarmed and so I reached out to uh Justin Drake and I said look I understand that Ethereum and the EF etc doesn't you know have any interest in or doesn't have like a any type of interaction I mean one of the problems was like JP Morgan didn't even know how to get in touch with the EF the team that is building their blockchain solution could not get in touch with anybody at the EF and I would assume like tradify deals in like hand shakes and meetings and conversations and so if they can't have that form factor they probably just have to sit on their hands well I mean they're certainly not supposed to use messengers as the SEC is like in active these very large fines on messaging apps I don't know if you've seen these like billions of dollars on the banks and now they've been looking at some of the funds that's why I was not allowed to use messenger apps until I until I left my prior employment um so what I would say is uh you know it just the Ethereum doesn't have a marketing department there's no single person you would reach out to like I remember I said to Tyrone Logan you know who like runs Onyx and Jerman I was like oh my god Ethereum is so decentralized this is like this I like this call me to court in the future and I get like testifies that I'll decentralize Ethereum is that literally the group running a get client in JPMorgan cannot get in touch with anyone at the EF and so I facilitated its introduction and the first call that took place between JPMorgan and the EF in 2021 which is just a it's pretty remarkable but it's also a beautiful story and I think it really speaks to the robustness and I think it's getting back in a long way I apologize to like why I ended up getting pulled into this right you realize that these are assets these this is a space where you've got to do a little bit of your part when when the opportunity or when the when you're kind of called upon to do that and I had to do it in a very careful way in my prior job um you know that included for example trying to do reference calls for Coinbase to keep people from going on to FTX and because anybody who was close enough to these markets looking at what shenanigans alimade was doing I was terrified frankly that it was going to drag down my career and the respect for the space or not that we had a lot begin with but and so I was trying to do my little my my part right both to say you know on the on the sex side prevent a lot of Wall Street firms from onboarding at FTX unfortunately I I was not sufficiently successful and that really set us back but that was me trying to really protect my career in a lot of ways I didn't want us to go through this um but it was also that there was an opportunity for me to play a little bit of a role in the Ethereum ecosystem that wasn't being filled and part of this again was that because nobody you know if when even van Goon or Anatoly and to much less extent Kaosamani comes in and tells tradify people something that's slightly sophisticated sounding they don't know any better than just like not along and be like yeah that makes sense you know Anatoly in particular has this debate style where he says something kind of complicated sounding and then he laughs about it as though you should have this is obvious everybody knows this and uh it kind of almost makes you feel if you're not Justin Drake or Denker advice you know you're not sufficiently competent or confident in your view to really refute that and I'm not saying that he always does that in a malicious or negative way I think it it is just part of the way he communicates um but there was a lot of there was just you know again Tara Luna was just uh I needed I felt a need to try to stop a Ponzi scheme from promulgating throughout all of crypto all of five sorry traditional finance and that meant that we needed to have people that could speak on behalf of what I feel is going to be the global settlement layer for the global financial system Ethereum and you know people like Justin Drake or Dan Krad or Ansgar and these like really brilliant really smart earnest um great communicators that are also uh uh uh researchers in the Ethereum space and try to get them or at least be no enough to then communicate it back to people in Treadfly.
Well I feel a lot of residents with that story actually one of the reasons why right and I started bankless is because there was just a void uh about the story about Ethereum like no one was really telling it and as a result of that void that if the Ethereum community wouldn't really fill just it just didn't really have that sort of desire like you said there's no marketing department at the Ethereum foundation uh because the Ethereum community it didn't fill that void like the big coiners did uh and like the Alt layer ones did uh just because it was free real estate uh and so that was like one of the main motivations of starting bankless is like well let's let's make a media organization that actually can effectively tell the fair story of Ethereum at least how we see it and you did it I consider myself a uh you know a a bankless acolyte a follower I appreciate that and also doing our same role inside of the world of Wall Street right where there is a void that many of the VCs with East Killer investments will happily fill the void of like the lack of understanding around East uh with their own with their own narrative uh I'm wondering and maybe you can kind of give us the download on on what is the current understanding of Ether and Ethereum in Tradify like what is the average Tradify member the Wall Street uh goer understanding about Ether and Ethereum like how should we think about this you know I once asked someone you know a Tradify person what is ETH what is Ethereum and the answer was Ethereum is a cryptocurrency like Bitcoin but it has some utility and I was like that's actually a very good answer right um you know it's it's it's very concise it's it's like a very high level and it is descriptive but it under the surface of that simple statement is like all the juicy details right and so that is probably a good line to just to think about when you're like what to start I know they know it's a cryptocurrency like Bitcoin which is digital gold and it has some utility but they don't really know what that means and um you know what are the other topics uh this this person will be okay with me telling this through what the other topics that we're going to get into later is like um you know have there been like uh Tradify or like in particularly like Fed people that have been pulled in you know been uh been ETH build and um you know besides my friend Benson who had written this uh this paper one of the first papers on the portfolio benefits of having crypto assets in a portfolio um there was a guy who worked for him at the time and um we met like five years ago and I haven't seen him since but I was in Dubai uh representing Skrull and I was actually at aether Arthur hazes party and this guy comes up to me behind me goes you're Sam Jornigan you used to you you know my friend Benson Derm who I used to work for the Fed and I was like oh my god who is this you know I turned around and I couldn't remember his name at first he was like Dion I was like oh my god Dion how are you he's like good I was like what are you doing here you know this guy used to be a used to work for you know a you know a asset pricing theorist at the at the Federal Reserve I was like yeah I was like what are you doing here like on this you know this like beach party for Arthur Hayes in Dubai and he goes oh I uh I get him in the crypto now I'm a DeFi founder and I was like what did you start and he was like uh term lending I was like oh my god it's brilliance one of the the missing pieces in DeFi is actually fixed rate lending so Dion and his partner have started uh a termed off finance and um he goes uh you know what have you been up to blah blah and I told him he he asked me he goes well what what do you think tried five people understand about crypto and I used this line and I remember Dion looked at me he goes say you're saying I should still be buying ethos and I was like basically you know like the most bullish thing about eth right now is the fact that the understanding of of trad phi is that it's this crypto asset like Bitcoin because I think when they fully understand it it's going to blow their brains out um you know I had a breakfast last week with uh a financial institution that has some periphery exposure to crypto let's say and I had to explain this so we walked through what is digital gold uh you know Bitcoin is digital gold and you know they had uh knew the Michael sailor routine well and then I I was like but you know for example tether which you've probably heard of USDT is like of course I was like you know none of that is on Bitcoin is like what do you mean I was like there's no tether on Bitcoin and he did not know this I was like I was like you know I was like all of it is on Ethereum and Tron which we don't want to talk about is on Ethereum and Tron and you know tether the company pays fees to the Ethereum network they do not pay any fees to Bitcoin and this was he he looked I think he said something the effect of tell me more explain this he did not know this so that the the understanding is is is pretty low even for you know I would say people that on intradify that are are reasonably exposed to this to already to the space and so that's a very that's very bullish but it also should again hashtag early and it's it's early okay so tradify has very limited understanding of Ethereum they sort of like now have barely wrapped their minds around Bitcoin but by and large they don't understand Ethereum and Sammy said something interesting there he said once they do understand it minds will be blown like yeah so why and maybe this gets back to the conversation we were having earlier around sort of the the risk free rate in Ethereum and this idea of eth producing positive yield was a term you said and we said we'd get back to this in the in the podcast but does this have something to do with why you think tradifies mind will be blown when they understand what this asset actually is get give us the case here well you know this is where this is where like you you risk you run a lot of risk doing an hour long podcast for this because I tried to give you one very simple vertical one simple utility of Ethereum say swift messaging of financial money assets and this simultaneous settlement of those funds that alone is going to change the world you can think about stablecoins is having pressed a button on on an unstoppable progression at this point but that alone is a is a huge deal but you know and I think you know the natural kind of evolution of that is that if you have this this decentralized permissionless asset eth that is effectively accruing value and becoming whether you want to call it outright deflationary or ultrasound or whatever you kind of description you want to put around it now it becomes collateral because this is a cash flow bearing asset the cash flows from that asset are returned right now they have two primary issues primary means the first is cash flow is is bought and burned like apple buys back its stock to return the earnings to shareholders here the eth is burned to return the cash flows to eth holders and then some of it is accrued to stakers but this system as a whole is over a meaningful period of time these are very low right now that's partly because we're still in bear market basically I mean I think traditionally a bold market is when you're making new highs you know we're not quite there yet in Ethereum part of that's because we're in a bear market and you know we haven't started that virtuous process of bringing in a lot of new people playing with Metamask or Argent etc part of it is because the recent upgrade part of denksharding was a scalability enhancement right so this was not a minor upgrade this is one where we actually scaled Ethereum in a very meaningful way we scaled it so much that fees are cheap and that's what we wanted and that is likely to be a temporary phenomena right you know you've had Justin on here to talk about this but it's you know if Anna Toli's like you know they used to be that this a lot of bear case Ethereum was a fees are too high but you know guess what we did a lot of really advanced cryptographic work I mean you know the work d'ancrod does I think he's probably probably the smartest person all of crypto you know d'ancrods team these are you know cryptography ZK and very advanced cryptographic schemes are scaling Ethereum in a way that I don't even think crypto understands certainly tradfied does not you know one of the things you know this this line of italic has that I think is hugely underappreciated is that you know ZK is and maybe even eventually fully homomorphic encryption but ZK is Ethereum's transformer moment right you know this is hugely underappreciated this is a largely not just a crypto manifestation driven by Ethereum but even in academia you know Ethereum community has driven the academic community within cryptography around ZK and not HG and you know so fees are the the burn right now temporarily is low because we have proto danksharding significantly you know the addition of blobs has made it cheaper to transact on Ethereum it's made it cheaper for L2s to consume Ethereum DA and that's great but over time that the cheaper fees will more a lot more users and eventually they'll go back up and that's why we will progressively increase the number of blobs and we'll also eventually have full danksharding which will you know as you guys know well basically allow infinite scaling for pennies and the number of transactions will be much higher so right now temporarily the burn looks a little bit lower but again that's for good reasons it's because we have actually scaled Ethereum to make to allow more onboarding cheaper via cheaper fees and but long term you know again with with the right thoughtful changes to the issuance curve or other appropriate adjustments so we can keep a outright deflationary asset it actually collateral and now you have a permissionless decentralized collateral that exists in the world that has never existed before and I think one of the most underappreciated bull cases that Justin Drake has laid out actually a few years ago at DevCon in Bogota I guess maybe year and a half or so ago where he explained how you know what would be the what would be if you had a eth only governance free eth collateral I stablecoin how what would the price of eth need to be in order to provide for this utility we need eth to be ultrasound collateral to use the meme but basically deflationary collateral such that it cannot go to zero and that is really crucial because then you can very safely again with the with the addition of removing as much governance as possible and keeping it capital efficient which were which we have a plan for but we're not there yet you know eth can be collateral not just for stable coins which there's a trillions of demand for that but for other for other types of assets as well you know I remember it was like five or six years ago I think it was Joe Lubin who like had this had this idea he said hey like you could make and you could have a smart contract in the theory that was an agreement between say the US and Iran that is collateralized by eth this permissionless collateral where they both have to put up and if one of them violates it you know neither of them can control ethereum or eth and so you could this would be a slashable type of penalty right so you could you can enforce behavior good actions you can basically enforce contracts using this this this asset and that's I I don't think people have even like really wrapped their head around the the design space beyond just again crypto collateralized stable coins and we can have but we're talking about trillions of additional value for this call of collateral value on top of the cash flow value so you have this you have the cash flows that are crewing to this swift plus chips or fed wire settlement system right this moving of financial assets and the fees that accrue and then that then allows you to have this permissionless collateral that can be that that has an additional value so I think this is one of the reasons it's very difficult to tell the story of of of eth is that it is it's well it's infinitely kind of infinite possibilities but I would say like that is at a high level you have the cash flow story and then you have the potential value of this permissionless collateral and the smallest what I used to jokingly say this is the same or the smallest addressable market for eth is 5 to 10% of Chinese deposits so call it two to four trillion dollars that is the smallest addressable market for eth the asset do you think the addressable market for eth of the asset is bigger than the addressable market for Bitcoin this is a test of your eth maxiness amp so do you believe in the flipping do you think that's going to happen you think these are equivalent assets or is just like one destined to always be larger than the other or is the theorem going to flip in Bitcoin does that question even matter in your world the answers yes the the market opportunities is definitely larger I think that the Bitcoin community is probably figuring that out that's why all of a sudden you're seeing you know efforts like opicat and some of these turning on opcodes that previously you know the the the religion of Bitcoin said was unacceptable yes unquestionably so does that mean that the lever evolve or evolve on time or evolve sufficiently we're enabled you know sufficient functionality to challenge it's probably not even in like the 100% scenario of a Bitcoin maxi or let's say like a let's say you had a great guess on recently who kind of walked through some of this I don't remember his name I'm not sure from the I remember here's from North Carolina actually because I grew up in North Carolina we're talking about so many guests and so many anyways you know like I think like people who want to do more with Bitcoin and have been inspired by the what Ethereum has done and want to enable some of that capability even in their wildest dreams I don't think they'll ever really get there I think but and look I mean I think you know even if you were able to get all that the Bitcoin community is may not you know at the end of the day this is these are social systems I think it's underappreciated the degree to which at the end of the day these are social systems and you know one of the things that caused me to want to put my reputation in my career behind Ethereum is after spending a few years now getting to know and interacting regularly with the the the the Ethereum community the breadth of it but also the individuals that that like say I like on the the research side this is this is probably the highest functioning and executing group of people anywhere in the world and you know I I had a better I said that better probably a year or so ago to someone and I wish I could remember the exact wording but you know it really is I mean I I'm close enough to understand just how both functioning but also like the values in the way that people interact with each other you know this is one of the reasons you don't be here on Twitter you know maybe with a couple of exceptions a lot of screaming about ether degrading Bitcoin etc the same way the Bitcoin Maxi's do it's just not part of the culture so I was both impressed with the people the culture the way that people communicate with each other the the focus on research and not noise and that I guess I was either built and you know now I'm trying to tell that story to to a broader truck by audience new projects are coming online to the mantle layer 2 every single week why is this happening maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer 2 design architecture since it first started building mantle DA powered by technology from eigen DA maybe it's because users are coming on to the mantle layer 2 to capture some of the highest yields available in DeFi and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the $3 billion mantle treasury in the mantle reward station maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with giving you grants liquidity support and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application maybe it's all of these reasons all put together so if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's DeFi apps click the link in the show notes so getting started with mantle have you ever felt that the tools for developing decentralized applications are too restrictive and fail to leverage advancements from traditional software there's a wide range of expressive building blocks beyond conventional smart contracts and solidity development don't waste your time building the basics from scratch and don't limit the potential of your vision cartesie provides powerful and scalable solutions for developers that supercharge app development with a cartesie virtual machine you can run a full Linux OS and access decades of rich code libraries and open source tooling for building in web 3 and with cartesies unique roll-up framework you'll get real world scaling and computation no more competing for block space so if you're a developer looking to push the boundaries of what's possible in web 3 cartesie is now offering up to $50,000 in grants head over to cartesie's grant application page to apply today and if you're not a developer those with staked ctsi can take part in the governance process and vote on whether or not a proposal should be funded make sure your vote ready by staking your ctsi before the vote's open arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions arbitrum has the leading defi ecosystem strong infrastructure options flourishing NFTs and is quickly becoming the web 3 gaming hub explore the ecosystem at portal dot arbitrum dot IO are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own arbitrum orbit chain arbitrum orbit allows anyone to utilize arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain giving you access to interoperable customizable permissions with dedicated throughput whether you're a developer an enterprise or a user arbitrum orbit lets you take your project to new heights all of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum experience web 3 development the way it was always meant to be secure fast cheap and friction free visit arbitrum dot IO and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities okay so the story for trad fi is a theorem as this almost this like unified ledger for global financial settlement right so like there's that part part of the story and then as as this collateral asset that is like you know supra national and exists outside of the nation state control that's the dual story now we have a new narrative that's sort of entering this is maybe on the shorter term time horizon which is the Ethereum ETF and going to this episode the reason you like Dave and I kind of prefaced it the way we have is because now it's time to explain some of these things for trad fi and I'm just wondering in your mind as you see the Ethereum ETF finally being approved like what's the significance of this for trad fi does it de-risk things do you have any assessment of what the impact might be for either the asset like what the flows might look like just in the broad broadest of like terms how big of a deal is this for trad fi to begin with you know people watching people that spend too much time on Twitter or just a normal person spend some on Twitter don't worry so much about what happens in the very short term um you know I remember when they go in ETFs launched people like oh it was priced in fell down for like you know like went sideways for a month and then it you know kind of ran off again and blah blah you know don't be so short term focused um I have no expectations as to what the initial adoption of Bitcoin ETFs will I'm sorry or Ethereum ETFs will look like and in the short term it just doesn't matter right but when that does happen again partly again this this if you want to be able to occur a little bit more ETH over time like myself included like I hope it actually goes a little bit slower to be honest I hope that I get a little bit more time to buy ETH below all time I says so I would not pay a whole lot of attention what happens in the very short term again um but over time it's kind of inevitable that that more people well um get exposure to this asset class and a broader audience and they they'll be able to do it more comfortably even those firms that are quick papered up in like the Wall Street firms the the hedge funds of family offices that are papered now to trade spot at Coinbase they're never going to do it in the same size as if they can hold it in uh an ETF form so I think that's that's one of the reasons the ETF flows on the Bitcoins had exceeded people's expectations it's not it doesn't surprise me it's just a form factor that the organ that an organization a Wall Street organization can get more comfortable with and when I mean comfortable I mean size right like hundreds of millions billions billions of dollars and so I think and I think the what will happen with ETH you know it seems likely just on based on my understanding of how they're arriving at this or my my understanding until now as to as to why how the process has worked um you know they've been able to the ETF issues have been able to show a tight correlation between spot and Bitcoin CME futures and ETH CME futures and there are no CME futures on any of their assets so these two are likely to be kind of quasi-entrined unfortunately but you know kind of quasi-entrined because of that narrow path by which we're gonna have spot ETFs for Bitcoin and ETH and over time when flows do come into ETH say they let's say that they're the organic new flows into ETH there simply will not be any ETH for sale you know the the the dollar values even with fees very low on ETH and of course once ETH starts making new highs you know transaction transactions are gonna go up fees are gonna go up and that means you're back into a deflationary mode so even with the very modest amount trickle of new ETH that is flowing on to the market with activity low post prototyping charting it's it's nowhere near you know one average day of Bitcoin ETF inflows is 10X the net issuance of of ETH whereas that barely offsets the issuance of Bitcoin on a daily daily basis so I think the price reaction could be actually pretty absurd what about the clearing of the rate that's why once it starts making new highs then you have new users and you're entering that cycle where now it's like supplies contracting as more money is flowing in these ETFs I think it could be quite dramatic to be honest I don't again I don't know if it'll take two days to happen I don't I don't know if it'll take two years and it doesn't really matter like hope that it takes longer to be honest for me personally what about that let me just let me just there's a second derivative here is that I don't care if you are you know a hundred dollar retail investor or a hundred billion dollar you know Bitcoin a billionaire investor everyone chases and so you've got one 25 30 billion in Bitcoin ETFs when ETH out starts to outperform this is going to your question about the flipping that money that's sitting in those Bitcoin ETFs again this is just simple economics this is so in FX you value currencies on relative inflation right and the relative inflation of ETH is lower so you know when the when when ETH starts out performing Bitcoin people will chase and so money will not we're not just talking about new money into ETH we're talking about money that is the 20 or 30 billion that is sitting in Bitcoin ETFs is now going to start chasing Ethereum ETFs and so you already have this large pocket you know in the beginning they'll call it a diversification of their their crypto asset investment you know so it's like maybe it's 2% of some you know pension fund right that they've got in the BlackRock ETH Bitcoin ETFs and so they'll say oh well the market waiting of you know when ETH starts out performing after a while everybody gets phoma remember you know they'll start saying oh well we shouldn't have all Bitcoin we should have some of the ETH ETF as well and so they'll do like a market waiting you know they'll start with 10% then well you know you know we should have 2 to 1 right because Bitcoin is twice the market cap right so they'll then they'll add more ETH to get a market waiting of Bitcoin to ETH but it's just a it's just human nature I don't know the timing it is very difficult in markets one I've got a lot of gray hair at this point one of the things I've learned in markets is that it's hard enough to get the direction and the magnitude correct don't try to also get time correct you know leave that leave that would alone expected to take longer and focus on the the direction that I get to how about this breaking of the kind of the regulatory haze I don't know if that's made a big difference for for Tried 5 right but it's like a theorem because of the lack of action the SAC or you know that this sort of the banning about of people like to chair chair Gensler it's been unclear what its status was was is it a theorem of security is SAC going to try to claim this is it a commodity and now with the SEC's approval of the theorem ETF it's just quite clearly a commodity has has was there is there a group in Tried 5 that was just like waiting for this to happen like there was this some regulatory haze over Ethereum and they had not purchased ether but now they will because it is securely a commodity or does does that not matter very much I'm not sure I'm not sure I have a view on that I one thing I would say that I know from you know in 22 I think that there were some large well-known hedge fund hedge funds that were long semif and I remember I got a message from one of the large bank sales coverage and I remember she basically was like hey like so somebody tell me it's going to be declared a security this is like two years ago and I was like that's not going to happen it actually I wanted to give you guys credit you guys you know this is reason why you need to watch bankless every single one is because there are alpha drops in bankless episodes of people don't realize the biggest alpha drop that nobody realizes was in a bankless episode where Justin Drake was right before the merge towards the end of a conversation he remember this the list of reasons to like be bullish on ether like eth won't be a security or something like that and one of them was a statute of limitations yeah and I went and looked into this because I had never heard anything about this I had this was so I went and spoke to several big law firm lawyers including a former head of longtime head of enforcement at the SEC she almost would not engage with me on the conversation because she said east not a security and I was like but if it was she's like but it's not and I'm like please help me here I'm like if it was would this would it the the and here specifically what I don't think he gave this detail but here's what I figured I found out basically there was a change to the National Defense Authorization Act of 2021 summit if you want to by the way we can talk about politics and I had a repair on Capitol Hill in a prior life but you know if you want to get something into a bill you want to get it in what's called the omnibus which is a spinning bill you want to get in the defense authorization bill because everybody's got to vote to pay the troops right you got to vote to you know there's all these bases you got to brace salaries and that's that's done the authorization bill anyway so somebody slid in a change to the statute of limitations uh into the National Defense Authorization Act of 2021 that changed the statute of limitations from 10 years to five years and so he was correct that there was and I again did some due diligence to to to double check this I was pretty confident that that ETH was not going to be a security and I um that having done some due diligence on that amongst other things um and I said as much and so the way I would answer David's questions is to say that I don't think recently people have like not owned it because of or rather they've owned Bitcoin and not ETH um I think there's some of that right like it was just you know nobody wants to take headline risks like what if it is a security there's there's that's a small segment of the market but what I can say was certain is that there were people say back in 20 on 22 that weren't just worried about the fed racing rates and selling or FTX blowing up or whatever there was also in in Wall Street this concern even back then that because I guess 22 that ETH was going to be deemed a security so I think that there were people that otherwise probably would have been around long for the ride or maybe on the ride on it you know on again off again and they kind of got off due to that concern back then but I think it had it people just don't own ETH right right now really on Wall Street it's still pretty small relative to Bitcoin people are very crowded in that concentration in that experience say I'm one general question I think for a lot of crypto natives is like is it a good thing to have tradify on our side right like it feels kind of good right now to hear Larry think talk about the Bitcoin ETF and he's also talked about tokenization and with black rock getting and Ethereum ETF approved I know he's going to be on the media circuit talking about ether the asset as well and all of that is great but like great right we're excited about that in general we're not really sure what they think about defy though we're not really sure what they think of the concept of a decentralization if we create a another privacy mixer on Ethereum like not really sure where they'll fall on some of these issues like decentralization and like the broadest of questions is do they consider crypto a threat you know could they use it the way they want maybe for tokenization of real world assets but then also be concerned and try to choke off the the defy touch points because those are those are threatening to the large institutions you know you got a bank like Wells Fargon has 200,000 employees and then you have a you know a protocol like Uniswap with just like a few dozen got to like you know trillions in terms of trading volume like we can do so much with far less people and is that not threatening to the existing institutions and incumbents so where do you come down on this I know you're kind of like representing a tradify but you're also straddled in the in the crypto world here so you've got like you know a foot in on both sides here do you think tradify is is going to be a friend of crypto or a foe of crypto or just like something in between so I think it's good I do not think we want those ETF the Ethereum ETFs staking you know if there were a mass slashing event that would cause that would cause governance risk right you could imagine if this is actually why we need to limit the percentage of the network that is staked or evolve staking in a way where a portion you know uh that only a portion of it is a slashable staking versus non-slashable uh a fatalicus introduced proposals around this so I do not think for the time being we want those ETF staking they should be simply receiving that the risk-free rate which is the deflation you get from holding native eth that is the real risk-free rate because you can be slashed and you know it hasn't happened sufficiently up to now for people to be worried about it but it freaks me out to think about you know black rock having uh getting slashed like I just don't I don't want that data happen I I we need to keep the networks such that you know the risk-free rate is the deflation that 50 bips are 1% you get from holding native eth um that's really a side conversation the next part I would say is like I think that look defy is super cool right I mean this is this is an evolution and they love it I think this is why I think I was surprised that somehow Larry Fink was able to become the crypto maxi within such a short period of time after I never I will admit I did not see that happening that quick I I thought that I would take two or three times as longer it's still this one I got a good example why I don't do timing right like this I did not expect this to happen so I think that there this is remember I said like their minds are going to be blown when they figure this out this is an example like traffic is going to be blown away when they figure this out and I think actually getting back to this unified ledger you mentioned this you know the BIS introduced this piece around what they call the blueprint for the for the future uh financial system or and the glue the unified ledger and I remember when I read the first half of it I texted a former Fed friend of mine I was like the BIS is trying to fork Ethereum because what they're trying to do is basically deploy a central ledger that all other banks and financial institutions and central banks within settle to and that is that it you know the power of a unified ledger that enables just infinite uh uh composability and tokenization is an insanely big concept and it's going to happen and it's it's it's what I would almost say it's um it's a little bit like DeFi growing up you know I think you'll always have the uniswops and these and compounds and obvious in the world but I think you're going to have remember we talked about JP Morgan on X JP Morgan's onyx that uses basically a the geth client that consensus maintains consensus bought that from um JP Morgan in 2021 um after JP Morgan had been maintaining it for a long time but it is trivial so right now JP Morgan basically tokenized dollars and tokenized treasuries and solved one of the last remaining problems from the global financial crisis and this was what's called triparty repo this is where banks basically can't trust each other during the period of time it takes for these two assets to settle at different times so dollars and treasuries settle at different times but if you tokenize them they settle at the same time and right now they're basically just doing with a small handful of counterparty so it's basically just like gold men and JP Morgan doing what's called repo loaning each other money for a short period of time overnight barring dollars using treasuries the collateral which again have both been tokenized but it is trivial to and it's private and permissioned right so but it is trivial to connect that to the ethereum l1 and so now put yourself back in my same journey again my prior seat in a very large global macro fund and let's say we have um you know let's say we have JP Morgan and it you know uh tread fight institutions on the buy side so hedge funds etc we want to trust JP Morgan we need to trust JP Morgan but we would love to have the ability to also immediately move that asset with finality to settle to settle say a margin requirement at Deutsche Bank and so if you were to connect you know the JP Morgan uh onix get client and basically make it a validity proof or basically an l2 right you connect it to a ethereum l1 and now if Deutsche Bank or Goldman Sachs has a has a uh their own zk rollup maybe it's a maybe it's a l2 maybe it's an l3 construction or a validity m in most most likely will be some sort of a validity m construction so that all of the data is not posted to the l1 it'll be posted to a data availability committee which is fine because again you know the we're talking about hedge funds that want to trust that need to trust JP Morgan so we're okay that the data is housed there the data availability is there but we want the interconnectivity of being able to uh utilize this unified ledger the ethereum l1 so i actually think that most major banks and financial institutions will have their own execution environments that will allow their clients to uh that are permissioned to interact and execute in these permissioned environments and then move those assets around via the l1 and this is not a new concept by the way like this is i would say i've had conversations where like this is the holy grail this is this is the goal and this is why from my perspective when i read the bs paper i was like oh my god they're they're forking ethereum basically because this is really transformative like you know stablecoins pushed a button that really can't be undone you know it was you know uh stablecoins were a phenomenon of the prior uh bull market that did not go away and in fact they've they've burned and proliferated and they have really legitimized the use case for for open public systems but you could imagine this is going to reach a limit like JP Morgan is not going to allow a hundred percent of its a balance sheet to be monopolized by this this corporate squid you know circle right so if circle were to grow to a certain size JP Morgan be like we're not going to just like let you take over all of our deposits they're going to tokenize their own and so you have pushed a button i you know i don't know if you're familiar with tokenized deposits if you know we should we should you know we should have that conversation to follow but stablecoins pushed a button that can't be really undone this is basically the global proliferation of dollars that's that for the first time ever really anyone and everyone in the world no matter where you are is allowed to save hold and transact in dollars and that is that's never existed before you know china alone has more than 500 billion of capital flight a year this is this we this is not reported obviously but it shows up in what's called IMF air and emissions data it's the difference between the current account and the capital account and so we know that money flows out like the average Chinese citizen is only allowed to hold 50 is it was only allowed to buy 50 thousand dollars a year and they have to hold it with their domestic bank but if you have an ethereum account you can hold as much circle or tellers you want right in your in your ethereum wallet so this is a this is a really big deal right like i mean we're see it this is why like adoption in parts of asia and in south america has been very high for stablecoins and the number of of individuals in these countries that have either held or used stablecoins for transactions but ultimately that is going to result in banks saying hey we want to get on this too and we you know we can't have this like corporate entity but 30 employees monopolizing our balance sheet we're gonna we want to tokenize our deposits and they will go on public blockchains because private permit we know this from the air of the internet you know there used to be what's called the inter the intranet and you know the internet but before the internet of the world bud web right and now you still have i'm sure maybe you guys have like a little bankless corporate you know intranet with your hr or whatever most companies do jib morgan intranet but you spend your time on the internet and i think it'll be very much the same way you know you the the analogy of you'll have businesses and banks that will have their small permissioned private and permissioned execution environments but they're going to be connected via the ethereum l1 the unified global ledger so you're painting a world here sam where tradfly doesn't try to choke off crypto and defy at all because it's not in their best interest to do so right the the idea of tokenization on this unified global ledger is very appealing to them gives them opportunity to just like upgrade their infrastructure gives them new products to sell gives them more things to financialize which is i think bullish i mean as we end this conversation one other topic we've we haven't uncovered yet is regulators and how they'll feel about all of this because it's a similar sort of you know cost benefit analysis when you get into kind of a regulators head or like a big government's head there are some things about crypto that are threatening to nation states and common powers and regulators and there's there's also clearly some benefits they're almost in a similar position as as the banks and so from a regulatory perspective i'm just curious your general take on what you think needs to happen and you also i think wanted to talk about because we we asked you part of this episode hey sam do you have any like any alpha to share any like you know thoughts on various topics and you brought up this term that i'm not super familiar with but i want to ask you about it's called uh chevron deference and that that sounds like a legal mouthful something that only a regulator could love but maybe you can explain the regulatory landscape what's needed this concept of chevron deference what what does that mean why is that important to the story sure so the the first one um again i think regulation i i i once said this uh with matt from vanneck on on a panel i was like i don't i never worry about regulation because it takes care of itself and i certainly recommend 95 percent of the people watching this podcast don't worry about regulation since i've been in the space people have always worried about regulation and if that kept you out of it well it has kept a lot of people out unfortunately so it doesn't mean that you don't need to call your congressman and calls work better than an email by the way call when you know when imported bills are coming up etc or when i mean you get the point but don't let it keep you out of this space that is noise that is short-term noise um so i think regulation will evolve fine um and we at least the in the very near future um we are awaiting uh this this uh basically um 40 years ago fascinating story 40 years ago there was a uh supreme court case um involving the chevron corporation EPA and environmental defense agency uh organization that the the short version is that the supreme court ruling at the time gave the power basically said hey agencies or experts we judges are not so when a law is written ambiguously we should give deference to the agency and as it turns out the head of the EPA at that time uh and this was a win for the EPA the head of the EPA was Neil Gorsuch's mother Neil Gorsuch is the sub is a supreme court judge um his mother was head of the EPA at this time now this uh it basically again it basically says when uh there's a uh a law that is ambiguous um say is crypto a security or a commodity if it is ambiguous the uh the courts should defer to the agency expertise basically and this has been used uh to varying degrees by both republicans and democrats uh republicans used it actually took out to to reduce a lot of protections in the clean air act and clean water act under bush uh bush um w people might remember that um but then that turned very hard the other way under obama and also under Biden and so for example the the EPA uh in particular had you know this has had huge implications i mean we haven't had immigration law in god knows how many i mean the 50 years so like everything that is done is interpreted by the agencies and courts give them deference when you say agencies you're talking about the regulators right SCC the CFTC the executive agency regulators okay so and the courts simply have to defer to them over the lab there have the the supreme court is currently very conservative um as most people know and has taken a couple of strikes at this chevron deference again goes back to the original company chevron corporation 40 years ago uh has taken a couple strikes at it most recently was actually last year uh they did what was called the major questions doctrine the uh coinbase actually took advantage of that decision uh as an in part of their defense against the uh the SCC the idea of being that hey the the court said hey if um if a topic is of national significance it's a major question the court should not defer to the agency for example right but then the question is like what's a major question right um well in uh october of last year not many people noticed it i almost missed it the supreme court agreed to hear a case of uh i believe it's herring fishermen there's actually two cases one's called relentless uh the other is called loper bright v remando uh remando is the head of the commerce and what what's at issue here what is basically that these fishermen um these fishermen there was there was a law passed years ago that said that the national marine fisheries should require observers on on commercial fishing boats um the problem was that uh it cost money and the the congress did not say how to pay for and that didn't provision money for it and so the agency interpreted it to say that they could charge the fishing boats it turns out that and this you see this in the case that the cost of having an observer on every single boat was going to cost as much as 20% of the profits for these fishermen so they sued and they lost straight up into the district circuit the DC circuit where katanji brown jackson was sitting at the time and it the they they lost based on the national marine fishery commerce department um claiming um uh chevron deference that they had written these rules under chevron deference of course this was then appealed by loper bright enterprises the name of the the fishing boat company and the sec took up i'm sorry the the supreme court accepted the case so they had three options they could hear the case on its merit they could hear the case on curtailing chevron deference or completely removing chevron deference striking it down and they elected the latter two and katanji brown jackson is recused from that case having previously heard it as a result the the conservatives on the court led by Neil Gorsuch whose mother originally is responsible for this being in place he's leading the charge to remove chevron deference and so they don't have just a normal majority as they normally do they have a super majority because one of the liberal justices is recused and we must the the way that the supreme court term happened works is they accept cases and it runs from october to june so any day now that's june 4th when we're recording this could be this coming monday could be the monday after but any time in the next i would say two to three weeks we are likely to get a decision in lope of bright the ray mando on chevron deference and you know if you google this you're going to see articles that talk about the potential chaos that could ensue from this because the agencies ability under chevron deference to interpret and write rules and regulations was so broad it stretches across finance it stretches across like i said immigration and the environment but in the hearing you should go and listen to the world arguments for the supreme court crypto comes up a number of times in the world arguments and it's even used as an extreme example of how chevron deference has effectively caused a problem where this unique quote uniquely 21st century phenomena digital currencies is seeing overreach by a regulator that clearly doesn't have authority so the implication there being that if and when most likely i would say 90 plus percent probability chevron is that minimum significantly curtailed if not completely removed um there will be no question but that crypt that like the regulator assault on crypto is basically done i mean it's it's done and that actually has significant implications about whether or not you actually want to see legislation like as it stands i can tell you you know i personally do not want any legislation passed you know it's much better like we're so early in crypto if you write something with a certain definition or understanding now it may not be relevant six months from now much less 30 years from now and it is almost impossible to get something taken out of law once it is put in law this is why you you know like you hear about like these laws of like the 1800s you know they like it's very difficult to appeal the to repeal them you know Arizona is having to do this now in the in the context of rovy of the rovy wade and the abortion decision that's like there's like 1800s law that they're having to quickly repeal so you don't want i mean i think in my opinion with the exception maybe of a very narrow stablecoin bill i personally would just prefer to have no regulation and that is especially true because almost any day now the agencies are going to be completely neutered the SEC is going to be done their assault on crypto is basically going to be cut off the legs i think they know that and i think it's one of the reasons why they have implicitly you know kind of pivoted so this is cool so just like maybe just to connect the dots and then you know i finished this out so if chevron deference is overturned then it defangs one of the core problems that crypto has had with regulators which is like regulatory overreach these unelected like officials gary gensers of the world that are basically like hating on crypto and doing everything they can to just like put up roadblocks and it completely defangs that and i guess if we were able to thread the needle needle at least in the us is we'd have regulators aggressive regulators defang from their ability to do kind of like over over a broad rule making and then we'd also probably have a hung congress at least for a while so that they only get through legislation on like stablecoin bills and they don't go full you know like prying to the business and trying to overregulate everything which would which would draw us into a quagmire in crypto very interesting i had no idea that that case had anything to do with crypto and uh so yeah it sounds like it's a big deal well sam this has been uh excellent thank you so much for guiding us through this i do you have any just like parting thoughts on um you know like david and i have this this bet right now which is uh on the next rollup we're going to give our like pitch for a theorem uh like to tradify and i just like i feel under equipped to do this although he's like uh i'm i'm i'm definitely going to beat david right uh so you know david's got no chance uh here but um he's shaking his head but when we're talking to tradify what is kind of the the simplest pitch that we can give them is it what you you said earlier which is like hey this is bitcoin but it has extra utility is that what a theorem is yeah well how would you close this out you know i say to myself that to myself that ethos like apple you and uh you know jim kramer has this line you know own it don't trade it and um that's the way i think about it you want to own eth um it is a it is a platform it is a secular um shift with you know unbelievable fundamentals underneath it um you want to own it uh don't trade it that's uh that's how i approach it personally there you go own it don't trade it we will leave it there of course gotta let you know none of this has been a financial advice it never is on bankless cryptos risky you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot you