Monad just launched Mainnet!
That’s why Ryan sits down with Monad co-founder Keone Hon today.
We ask the blunt question: do we really need another general-purpose L1?
Why not just build this as an Ethereum L2 instead?
Keone explains how Monad’s parallel, pipelined EVM works under tight consumer-hardware constraints (32GB RAM, 2TB SSD, 100 Mbps), delivering ~500M gas/sec, 400ms blocks, and fast finality while preserving decentralization.
Enjoy the episode!
------
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🔵COINBASE | ETH & BTC BACKED LOANS
https://bankless.cc/coinbase-borrow
🪙FRAXNET | MINT, REDEEM, & EARN
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR L2 NETWORK
💤EIGHT SLEEP | IMPROVE YOUR SLEEP
https://bankless.cc/eight-sleep
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Another L1?
1:36 Why L1 vs L2?
2:46 Decentralization
10:19 Run at Home vs Datacenter Chains
12:09 The Purpose of a Blockchain
14:06 The Purpose of Monad
16:00 Why EVM?
28:33 Solana for the EVM?
29:47 Monad vs Ethereum
34:23 Monad Scaling
36:40 Ethereum Roadmap
39:43 How Monad Benefits Ethereum
42:51 Keone’s Background
50:49 How Fast is Too Fast?
59:12 MEV
1:04:07 Monad Layer2s?
1:05:14 Monad Launch Decentralization
1:06:00 Launch Ecosystem
1:08:22 Monad Token
1:16:55 L1 Token Valuations
1:19:18 Monad vs MegaETH
1:23:59 Monad’s Success Case
1:25:57 Mainnet
1:27:11 Closing & Disclaimers
------
RESOURCES
Keone Hon
https://x.com/keoneHD
Monad
Monad Website
Monad Links
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
the monad design delivers performance that is needed right now and also delivers a high degree of decentralization right now and delivers that fast finality right now some of the struggles in other ecosystems are related to slow finality and in that in particular that problem is already kind of addressed in monad. Keonia I got to start with the question that I think is in everyone's mind as we enter this episode do we really need another general purpose layer one chain. I love the question monad is a significant engineering effort you can think of it as a technology effort to bring new technologies to the EVM and pioneer those in a way that are all compatible with each other and that stack on top of each other to prove what's possible and to prove that decentralization can become more powerful if we focus very deeply on software architecture improvements.
I agree with your line of questioning in the sense that new layer wants need to be very different and very innovative but monad is an effort that is really grounded in research and engineering to deliver a really powerful experience for the EVM and to make the EVM more powerful and more perform in a highly decentralized way. I think that's a theme it's a massive optimization of the EVM we'll get back to that but why not just build monad as a layer two maybe on Ethereum why instead go in the direction of the layer one. There are really interesting and important optimizations that are needed both at the execution layer and at the consensus layer layer two's tend to focus only on the execution side but consensus is really what gives blockchains their property of decentralization and what really gives blockchains the borderless aspect where control of the network is split across many many entities that are existing many different countries around the world.
Consensus is a really important problem it's sort of the you know consensus, Nakamoto consensus is the basis of the Bitcoin project and I just think that innovation of consensus layer as well as the way that consensus and execution fit together that's an extremely important and under explored aspect of crypto these days. You've used this word decentralization a couple times now what does that mean to you? What does decentralization mean to you in the crypto context and the blockchain context? I'll answer your question in two different ways from a technological perspective decentralization means that control over the system is split into many different horror cruxes I guess you could say like split into many different entities that all keep each other accountable and enforce the rules of the system and enforce the only state transitions that are allowed are those that are defined by code and that's an extremely powerful aspect because when you don't have to trust each other when trust is enabled through just the code itself and everyone following the rules but also a system that allows actors to keep each other in check that's when we can build more powerful applications and institutions on top of that base trustless layer so that's sort of the first answer is like from a technology perspective it's about many many nodes in the system all keeping each other accountable it's just like that the you know our civics class in the US is kind of the separation of powers is it that sort of idea where no single branch of the network gains control and has the ability to execute its own will you're like independent of the other branches correct yeah it's about that aspect and then the ensuing consequences and productivity and efficiency that can come from the fact that everyone knows that there's not a single power that can override state or make arbitrary state transitions okay that that's like the technical definition you said there was another definition as well I'm not sure if we've gotten into maybe the other definition with with some the the political expressions of power inside of the network but what's what's the other definition that you were thinking of yeah the other aspect is the social aspect decentralization means having a large number of people that are watchdogs of the system and that are contributing to the network in different ways building applications or building integrations or connecting the system to the rest of the world and also even people that are not directly like writing code but people who are observing what's going on and serving as the white blood cells of the system yeah some of this I think when we talk in terms of like what does decentralization mean it feels a little squishy to some folks is something that's not very squishy but I think is important and I wonder how much you think this is important and how much you've prioritized it for from on add which is the ability of normal people outside of data centers to run a node or run a validator in a permissionless way in your network that is something that Bitcoin I think has elevated it's very important something that Ethereum has also tried to elevate something that other networks maybe not so much how about that the definition of decentralization at least a very important component for a blockchain network is it the ability to run a node from say my home office decentralization is a big part of it is about democracy and about the fact that anyone should be able to participate in the system in the early days of monad a big part of our decision-making was like a constraint that we've had since day one is that anyone should be able to run a node without expensive hardware so monad's a consumer grade hardware chain it's not a data center chain anyone can take a Costco MacBook the specs of that and run a node based on that and so in particular 32 gigs of RAM a two terabyte SSD 100 megabits of bandwidth and a reasonable CPU those are the constraints of monad and that made building monad actually quite challenging because it meant that the system can't rely on keeping all the state in RAM or there's various technical things that are kind of downstream of that but it's a really fun constraint to build for and now three and a half years later from building this it really means that anyone can run a node in monad and have access to the full state and verify the entire chain verify every state transition and every account balance you can now borrow usdc against your Ethereum and Bitcoin on Coinbase crypto backed loans on Coinbase make assessing liquidity seamless for crypto powered by Morpho Coinbase crypto backed loans gives you direct access to on-chain financing allowing you to take out loans that competitive rates using your crypto as collateral over $1 billion in loans has been opened through Coinbase to date on the Coinbase app eligible users can borrow up to 1 million USDC using Bitcoin or Ethereum as collateral users can convert their USDC into Fiat to make down payments, refinance debt or cover urgent expenses more the benefits are interest rates are variable typically between 4 and 8% and respond to market conditions loans are approved in seconds without credit checks repayment schedules are variable meaning there are no fixed deadlines the kicker Coinbase will not treat borrow transactions as taxable events manage loans directly in the Coinbase app with ease it's currently available to us customers except New York and additional collateral types and increased loan limits are coming soon once learned more click the link in the show notes or visit coinbase.
com slash borrow crypto is risky your sleep shouldn't be eight sleeps mission is simple better sleep through cutting edge technology their new pod 5 is a smart mattress cover that fits on the top of your bed it automatically adjusts the temperature on each side so you and your partner can both sleep the way that you like it's clinically proven to give you up to 1 extra hour of quality sleep per night eight sleeps pod 5 uses AI to learn your sleep patterns regularly temperature reduce snoring and track key health metrics like HRV and breathing with a new full body temperature regulating blanket and built in speaker is the most complete sleep upgrade yet upgrade your sleep and recovery with a sleep use code bankless at eight sleep dot com slash bankless to get up to seven hundred dollars off the pod five ultra during their holiday sale that's eight sleep dot com slash bankless you also get 30 days to try it risk free link in the show notes for more information Ethereum's layer two universe is exploding with choices but if you're looking for the best place to park and move your tokens make your next stop uni chain first liquidity uni chain hosts the most liquid uniswap v4 deployment on any layer two giving you deeper pools for flagship pairs like each usdc more liquidity means better prices less slippage and smoother swaps exactly what traders create the numbers back it up uni chain leads all layer twos and total value locked for uniswap v4 and it's not just deep it's fast and fully transparent purpose built to be the home base for defy and cross chain liquidity when it comes to costs uni chain is a no-brainer transaction fees come in about ninety five percent cheaper than a theory of maintenance slashing the price of creating or accessing liquidity want to stay in the loop on uni chain visit uni chain org or follow at uni chain on x for all the updates which other chains have automated optimized for that approach so it does seem that the kind of the world of layer one chains and even yes layer twos it's less important layer twos are kind of de facto misrunning in in data centers least many of them right but let's go back to layer ones so which layer ones have opted for the kind of ability to run at home versus becoming data center chains like I don't know that many people think among like along this access but certainly people in the Bitcoin and Ethereum community do and it's it's indeed one of the main critiques that they you know relay against some of these faster high tps type chains is it just Bitcoin Ethereum and now monad I don't know about cardano and in some of those chains I don't I'm not as familiar with those but are those the consumer hardware type chains and then is everything else turned into effectively a data center chain I think that maybe there are some chains that are you know very similar in nature to Ethereum like using the same tech stack that are forks of Ethereum that might have a similar hardware footprint but much less usage than Ethereum has so yes I agree that monad is standing among a small set of blockchains that has this characteristic but also more generally that is really focused on adhering to that property in perpetuity but always being able to be run by anyone and also that's continuing to try to push the boundaries of this amount of performance we can squeeze out of those constraints because that's what it's really about it's about low hardware requirements plus a really high performance okay so this level of decentralization you you said it's pretty hard you know few chains have to have achieved it and are achieving it I guess this begs the question of like why we're maximizing for this level of decentralization right with like why why isn't it fine for validators and nodes to be run primarily in data centers which kind of it goes to the root question of what actually are blockchains for in your view what what is the purpose of a blockchain in my view the fundamental purpose of a blockchain is to give a means of coordination and a means of transaction and value transfer and asset issuance and you know world building that is only enabled by shared global state where we have coordination among many many actors if you look at for example when exchanges add a new add support for a new blockchain to to their network to their product they need to run a node when Tesla starts accepting payments in Ethereum they need to run a node when other businesses start to accept payments on that blockchain they need to run a node because they need to be able to verify the further themselves that they've received a payment but they can let the person that walk onto the Tesla dealership and drove away with a car they actually made a payment so it is about self verifiability it's about self-sauverity and it's also about fundamentally just enabling a layer of coordination from which from which there can be great amounts of productivity that are unlocked from for example people that are anywhere around the world getting access to the same financial tools or resources it's interesting how I think different crypto communities would answer that question in different ways so the Bitcoin community might say the purpose of Bitcoin the blockchain is a store of value isn't you know the application is Bitcoin itself the asset I think that Ethereum community might agree that store of value is a important use case but then add that property rights are equally important and the ability to kind of scale decentralized finance in a way that you know they'd probably also agree with what you said that is verifiable and permissionless and uncorruptible is important the Solana community says that what they're trying to build is a decentralized NASDAQ which I think implies something a little bit different as well what is the purpose of monad do you have like a moniker are you trying to build an open financial system is this more general purpose have you kind of settled on a a particular set of use cases you mentioned finances is finance the primary use case here finance is the use case that immediately enables greater productivity and enables more opportunities for people around the world at the end of the day I think that you know we're starting to live in a global world where people living in one country can be employed by a company in a country completely on the other side of the world but there are significant inefficiencies payment systems like there's just a lot of stuff that's not very efficient right now and I think that for for me crypto is really about unlocking greater efficiency and greater opportunity for everyone around the world and that is enabled fundamentally by a really performant really decentralized permissionless layer one wherever one can get access three and a half years of work you're close to main net we'll talk about that a little bit later in the episode how did you squeeze out this performance from the EVM and the consensus layer it may be take us to the existing EVM right now well what's good and bad about the EVM and in what did you really have to focus on the EVM is honestly a great bite code standard it is really the standard of crypto and smart contract programming several others have you know been proposed and used in different ecosystems but the EVM is very much the dominant standard but has over 80% of all TVL on chain it has you know many libraries a lot of tooling almost all the applied cryptography research has been done in the context of the EVM so it's really a great standard however there are just fundamental inefficiencies with existing implementations and with the monad project we worked on and introduced a bunch of different basically six different major improvements that kind of stack on top of each other to ultimately deliver over 10,000 TPS of throughput or in gas terms as people frequently like to use in the space 500 million gas per second on day one and monad main net I can tell you more about some of the optimizations but I think maybe just the really high level summary is that it's a combination of stacking multiple improvements on top of each other that are all needed why did it take so long why did this all take three and a half years when I think about when I reflect on the past I think we could have maybe done it a year faster if everything had been exactly like perfectly efficient but it's the reason is that it starts from a lot of research so the first year or so of work was you know building out tooling and testing and researching different approaches before I'm actually committing to specific directions when you're building new technologies when you're solving a problem like at the end of the day the purpose of monad is to solve these existing scaling problems you need to build a prototype in some cases of the solution to know for sure that you're on the right track and so and with a couple of these new innovations like there's a ton of research that went into it maybe you take us through some of those six things that stacked one on top of the other in terms of where you're squeezing out the optimization tell the story here where where'd you start and what what are some of these important components I seem to recall something about having to redesign the entire data structure behind the EVM anyway I don't know which technical questions actually yeah so just got us through it I think the way to think about from a very technical perspective the way to think about blockchains is that there's kind of a staged process where block proposals which have a bunch of transactions and have to make their way through many stages of work in order to ultimately be finalized and enshrined in the canonical chain and in existing systems these stages you know there's a lot of like you know stage one is happening and then the system is waiting for that to complete before being able to progress to stage two and then that has to complete before proceeding to stage three I think one of the common patterns of monad is introducing pipelining which is a really common technique in computer science like I don't we certainly can't claim to invented this at all it's just the idea is intuitive of instead of doing all of these sequentially it's much better to have one piece of work that's at stage one and then when that finishes moved to stage two in parallel start work on another piece of work in stage one and kind of progressed them through similar to how when doing laundry you would do a load of laundry in the washer but then when that is completed then move it to the dryer and in parallel do another load in the washer so that's like the common pattern that you will see in practice what this is translated to I'll tell you about the different improvements from the I guess like the highest layer as I think of it to the lowest layer and I'll tell you them all up front and then I'll maybe try to explain them in a little bit more detail so the highest level the top level improvement is monad BFT which is a new consensus mechanism that introduces pipelining within it as well men addresses a big problem that existed in previous pipeline to consensus mechanisms that's the first thing a second thing is asynchronous execution which decouples the two major parts of a blockchain which are consensus and execution it decouples them from each other so in most blockchains consensus proceeds and reaches consensus and then all the nodes each go and execute all the transactions in that block and while the execution is happening consensus is waiting and then when execution completes consensus starts again but while that's happening execution is waiting and so in asynchronous execution we decouple those two things and run them both in parallel to each other in a pipeline fashion so that's the second thing the third thing is parallel execution so when the execution process has the job of executing a whole long list of transactions in a block the transactions are all ordered from one through let's say a thousand and the true state of the world is the state of the world after executing those transactions one after the other like that's how it's officially defined so parallel execution is a technique where many of those transactions are executed in parallel optimistically assuming that all the inputs to those transactions are correct producing pending results which are optimistic executions of those transactions and then committing those optimistically generated pending results in the original serial order and making sure that every input is correct and re-executing if one of the inputs was incorrect so it's sort of I guess similar kind of thing where there's you know computers have a bunch of cores they can run many even more threads to run many many pieces of work in parallel but what is the constraint is often like other resources like pulling data from the database pulling data from disk so what you want is to be able to do it be doing a bunch of work identifying dependencies for the database in parallel and just like proceeding whenever the lookups end up returning and it's it's best to do all this work in parallel and then just commit those pending results while still maintaining the correctness as if those had been executed serially so that would be the third thing a fourth thing is we have a thing called just in time compilation or jit compilation this is a technique where the EVM bytecode so I actually have to take a step back here for one second in Ethereum and in Monad smart contracts are developed typically in solidity and then they're compiled down to this bytecode standard called the EVM bytecode and this is like kind of a unique bespoke standard when it is executed it needs to be executed in a virtual machine like it's not actual machine code that could be executed directly by the CPU so there's this sort of abstraction layer that exists in Ethereum and other blockchains to execute this EVM bytecode within a runtime kind of similar to how I don't know if you remember in the old days you would sometimes have a Java program that would run in the JVM so there's like this program that was existed on your computer called the JVM runtime and when you wanted to run Java programs you could run them and the benefit of the JVM was that it could be like cross-platform and people could just develop apps for common standard anyway the point is like this is the kind of the same thing happening in blockchain where people build applications for the EVM it generates this EVM bytecode but that is not machine code and so it's much less efficient we have compiler that compiles that EVM bytecode into machine code allowing that execution to be a lot more efficient so that's like a huge unlock for the EVM standard that we're really excited to deliver in the monad system along with others and then I know I'm kind of giving you a very long thing but I'll keep it up yeah number five right so number five we have a new database called monad DB so the context here is that Ethereum at the end of every block generates it stores all of the state of the world in a thing called a Merkel tree and the Merkel trees property is that it enables verifiability so that the Merkel tree has as it as you know trees do in computer science data structures like a tree has a root and that root is just like a little hash but that hash is a commitment to all of the state in that tree so if you are running a node and I'm running a node and we want to make sure that we have all the same state instead of having to compare every single entry line by line if we just compare our Merkel roots and we see that we have the same Merkel root that actually means that we've ensured that all of the state is the same this is a really cool attribute that Ethereum has that enables verifiability that allows nodes all around the world to ensure that they're all in sync with each other and to do so in a very concise manner this is the good part about a Merkel tree but the bad part of it is that it's expensive to update and its storage is currently in existing systems very inefficient because it has to kind of get pushed into another database typically level DB or rocks DB which have another tree structure under the hood there's a huge amount of sort of abstraction that happens that generates inefficiencies we have a custom DB that's specifically designed to store the Ethereum Merkel tree state natively on disk so that when doing lookups of data on disk we can deliver those much more efficiently and also pack all of the data that's relevant to each other very close to each other in pages because when you sorry more detail but when you look up data from a database you get an entire page of data you don't just get a single piece so you can pack a lot of those pieces of data all in the same page the lookup is going to be much much much more efficient is that number six as well so that was number five and then number six is a block propagation it's a communication method called Raptorcast which allows for really efficient communication of large blocks all around the world through a just a really smartly designed multi-step process where blocks are cut up into chunks and then chunks are sent to different nodes in order to ensure that all of the nodes get all you know enough chunks to reconstruct the original block it sounds like you've taken kind of consensus execution the EVM piece by piece and really tried to engineer all of the inefficiencies out of all of those pieces to the extent that you've kind of built some of these things like a Monad DB sounds like your own kind of data structure that you actually developed so you've built some of these things from the ground up is that right that's correct everything is built from the ground up I've heard Monad referred to as a Solana for the EVM and I think they're talking about sort of the spirit of continuing to optimize and parallelize execution consensus to the nth degree in order to max out the throughput in transactions per second do you think that fits is Monad Solana for the EVM?
I think that in some ways Monad is the EVM's answer to Solana I think in other senses Monad is quite different from Solana because Solana has really high hardware requirements and Solana has taken a view that in the design and every design need to be opinionated but in that opinionated design that hardware will continue to get more powerful and therefore it's fine to just require nodes to have a large amount of hardware. It's a data center chain I mean right I mean I think the the requirements there for Solana node I mean are getting into the if you actually want to collect some MEV and you actually want to produce blocks you know 10 gigabits per second right you run this thing out of a data center in order to run Solana okay why hasn't a theorem done this so some of the core values that you've espoused earlier on like decentralization certainly the Ethereum ecosystem the theorem foundation they they care about those things do a lot you know sometimes almost to their their detriment why haven't they gone piece by piece through the EVM and engineered the efficiency out of it instead they're taking it kind of a different path it seems like which is more of a a ZK type of path they're starkifying the EVM they're turning their validators into verifiers such that you can run kind of the the verifiers at home but they're not taking the approach that Monad is taking which is like highly engineering all of the efficiency out of each piece why not why are they taking a different approach I think that for any project there needs to be a decisive direction taken and I have a ton of respect for the Ethereum researchers and engineers and the approach that they have taken of focusing on ZK scaling I think that for Monad we believe that we can get a lot more performance out of a single node so out of each singular node and we can really sort of squeeze the sponge down into just like a high level of efficiency where every node can have the full state of the world and every node can scale state to a much larger extent one thing that I think is really cool about Monad is that as state continues to grow the system can continue to support a massive amount of state so I didn't really explain the super well before but Monad DB is an effort to get the absolute most out of SSDs today so SSDs are really cool they're really powerful and SSD costs or sorry like a two terabyte SSD costs like 150 to 200 dollars on Amazon so they're quite cheap and they're very very performant you can actually load up a machine with a ton of SSDs or with 32 terabyte SSDs this is very cheap hardware as compared to with scaling with RAM because RAM is about 100x more expensive than SSDs so it's very realistic to have 32 terabytes of SSD but 32 terabytes of RAM is an insane ask for anyone to run a node and the reason I'm telling you this is because Monad has taken a design to get the most out of the SSD and to make it possible to have a blockchain that scales to 30 or 100 terabytes of state while still being extremely performant and without requiring a lot of hardware to do that whereas for other blockchains like a lot of data centerchains like you were mentioning or projects that are focused on single sequencer with a really large node really high hardware requirement that actually doesn't scale to much larger state because you're just going to need to keep throwing more RAM at the problem and RAM is really really expensive so I think the reason this matters is because if we want to grow crypto adoption massively if we want to have a billion people using AVE for their banking basically for the banking for borrowing and lending if they want to use Uniswap for trading and they're going to hold a bunch of assets like every single thing that they're doing just adds more state and in order for state to really scale to global adoption and to have the shared global state that can hold the entire world all coordinating with each other we need a system that can rely on SSD rather than on RAM so it's a very technical kind of nerdy reason but at the end of the day I just think that there is a fundamental approach that we believe in that we think like a single node we can get a ton of performance out of that and we can have a system that has thousands of nodes all globally distributed all keeping in sync with each other maintaining this shared global state that the entire world is on.
Just those hardware requirements again and maybe bandwidth requirements so like what are they to start and you know three years down the road what do you think they'll be? The hardware requirements are 32 gigs of RAM, a two terabyte SSD, a reasonable CPU and 100 megabits of bandwidth. Okay and this is to run a node and a validator at home on the mona network correct? That's correct the bandwidth just to be very precise the bandwidth requirement for running a validator is a little bit higher it's 300 megabits per second okay but for a full node it's 100 megabits and then does this scale in the future so you know get more state that kind of thing like three years from now what will this look like?
Yeah that's a great question I think that the way to think about the different constraints or the things that couldn't be much larger in the future it would be the number of people that are using the chain that are adding to the state another variable would be the number of validators participating in consensus number of full nodes out there and the overall like transaction usage like the amount of transaction flow that's going through the system and just to answer that question directly on the state side we've run we've tested nodes that have up to 30 terabytes of SSD without any issue so that means that's like a 15x growth in state that is possible relative to that baseline set that we have right now for context Ethereum is about 250 gigs of state right now so that's two orders of magnitude 100x more state than Ethereum has right now and I think that can continue to scale as well so somebody with an add home validator would need to add those solid state drives over time to their existing rig certainly it's still possible to do from home they would just need more hard drives more solid state yes that's right yeah and for context the I think the cost of assembling that machine that I mentioned right now is about $1,500 so maybe talk for a minute about the direction that the Ethereum roadmap is going in because I would like your perspective on that so it is very different than what monad is doing so again the emphasis is on snarks validators no longer doing the full validation of each block on chain they're turning into verifiers that verify proofs and the block validation is happening elsewhere in the block production process what do you think of that overall design the so-called lean Ethereum roadmap that Justin Drake and others are are talking about I'm excited about it as I said it's a very different direction and when designing a system you have to choose a direction and then execute deliver optimize and on some level like you know we evaluate the result years down the road when we see what the system is capable of it's like building a rocket ship and you know like a bunch of scientists can get together and decide that a rocket ship that has you know fins that are like this certain shape or optimal and another one would be like nope there needs to be I don't know like a spoke hub and spokes I'm just make this a really dominology but you choose something you test it a lot but ultimately you build it and we get to see the results and I think the thing that's exciting is that you know like all the things I've described are here today right now in monad like it isn't it isn't a road map it's here right now it's open source anyone can go look at it anyone can contribute to it or learn from it it's just like it's a thing that's here now and I think that can push EVM usage forward substantially and I will also say that not although Ethereum is certainly going down this lean Ethereum ZK route there are still people in the Ethereum research community that are working on things that still do fit you know well into the system like people are working on single slot finality or I think maybe it's like the current proposals three slot finality or something people are working on their researchers are working on asynchronous execution in Ethereum right now there is actually you know some dovetailing of the research interests and road map but the cool thing is that for some of these things like we have them here in monad right now anyone can look at the code the Ethereum community can look at the code and adopt the code and like this is all very exciting and we're excited to work with Ethereum researchers on in their own because every blockchain is different and like you can't just directly like port code directly into another code base but I think some of the ideas and things that are tried the architectures are potentially translatable and certainly something that can be collaborated on and Keone this whole stack that we've talked about so far are you saying this is this is open source so anybody in the Ethereum community can basically take a look at this adopt this at some level if they want to I guess maybe for the ethmaxies in the bankless audience listening this what benefit does your work your development work on the EVM provide Ethereum in the future do you think I think it's really valuable to have a fully functioning system that exists in production and that proves out the benefit or cost of various design decisions I'll give you one example asynchronous execution like I was saying this is something that some folks in ethereum researcher interested in and they're interested in it for very good reason which is that it's actually very inefficient that consensus and execution are interleaved in ethereum and other blockchains right now it really massively reduces the time budget for execution substantially because execution has to get squeezed into a very small portion of the block time because consensus takes up most of most of the block time and yeah it's one of the foundational improvements in monad and it will improve ethereum if it can be implemented well in ethereum but the process of implementing it has been definitely like a significant effort in part because there's a lot of interactions with other aspects of the system eip702 is a really good example of this because eip702 allows eoAs like end user accounts to have code themselves and thus becomes smart contract accounts it's a really cool innovation that makes account abstraction a lot more available to all people that have ethereum accounts right now makes them a lot more portable and then the downstream benefit of that is that now ethereum becomes or ethereum accounts become a lot more powerful because we can have different mechanisms of authentication like past keys or native multi-sigs or means of like backing up like social recovery for accounts things like that those are all enabled by account abstraction and that's specifically all enabled by eip702 but I can tell you that the process of making asynchronous execution work with eip702 was a massive effort that involved developing a new way that like consensus actually produces blocks in the way that consensus interact with the execution anyway but the good news is like for the ethereum research community all of this has already been explored and you know went down a lot of paths that didn't work found one that did work and now anyone can look at that and just take that before the skewney you worked at jump trading I believe you're on the high frequency trading team a jump what about jump or what did jump teach you in high frequency trading teach you about scaling a blockchain I was there for eight years and over the course of those eight years the trading system that my trading team built evolved quite a bit it went from from a performance perspective it went from tens of microseconds of latency to below a single microsecond of latency it also went from a very sort of proof of concept system or a very naturally defined intuitively defined system into something that was really finely tuned and honed for efficiency every day we analyzed a lot of data and made decisions based on the data that we could see ran a lot of experiments my work in a small team learned how to ship a product rapidly and iteratively and I learned how to take risk as well and how to manage risk it was a really I don't know just a very good precursor to entrepreneurship although definitely leading a team that is doing engineering work but also doing a lot of non-engineering work and a lot of ecosystem support work is quite different as well so that's been been really fun over the past couple of years were you there during the exciting times of the Tara Luna you know trades and the downfall or the head you already left by then so I left jump in January 22 I think the Tara collapsed in May of that year I was there right before the or the I think my last week was the week that wormhole got hacked so that was that was crazy and it's it's crazy how far the industry has come since then I remember when the Monad community first formed it was the week of the FTX collapse and we've been through some pretty tough bear markets and conditions since then but at the end of the day I it's like because we know because of there's a vision and because there's a north star that's very clear and very needed there's no fear I know jump has gotten into some client development as well and you know one thing that they had been working on was the Salona fire dancer client which I believe is supposed to be a massively high throughput Salona client I'm sure you don't have particular insights into the fire dancer project or although maybe you do but having gone through similar engineering types of initiatives do you have any sense of why fire dancer hasn't shipped yet that's a great question I think that I actually don't know now the now that you ask that and haven't thought about fire dancer in a little while so it's kind of crazy I do think that the Salona code base is massive and there's a lot of sort of tech debt and situations where the spec is literally just the code base at least this is historically what was true and so I think maybe one thing that was challenging for fire dancer in developing a second client is that there is no in some cases no spec the spec is just the first client so then in order to build something that's too spec you have to first coordinate with the maintainers of the other client to define what the spec is and yeah I just think that maybe due to tech debt that had accumulated they needed to work through some of that that would be my impression so can you give us the throughput stats for monad at launch I think you mentioned 10,000 transactions per second was the goal how about block times you know some of the other stats in terms of performance yeah monad delivers 400 millisecond block times with two block finality so two times 400 or 800 millisecond finality every block has a gas limit of currently of 200 million gas per block so if you divide 200 by .
4 you get 500 million gas per second which is which is great which enables a lot of throughput a lot of usages simple transfer is 21,000 gas if you divide 500 million by 21,000 it's about 24,000 transfers per second or for more complex transactions like you know say 50,000 gas transaction that 500 million divided by 50,000 is 10,000 TPS imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly that's what mantle is pioneering with blockchain for banking a revolutionary new category at the intersection of trade five and web three at the heart is you are the world's first money app built fully on chain it gives you a Swiss iBan account blending fiat currencies like the euro the Swiss franc the United States dollar or the Remembe with crypto all in one place enjoy real world usability and blockchains trust and programmability transactions post directly to the blockchain compatible with tradfire rails and packed with integrated d5 futures you are transforms mantle network into the ultimate platform for on chain financial services unifying payments trading and assets like the mi4 the meath protocol and functions f btc backed by developer grants ecosystem incentives and top distribution through the ur app reward stations and buy bit launch pool for mnt holders every economic activity in ur drives value back to you embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem follow mantle on x at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking that's x.
com slash mantle underscore official introducing at frax usd the genius align digital dollar from frax it's a secure stable and fully backed by institutional grade real world assets custodyed by blackrock super state and fidelity it's always redeemable one-to-one transparently audited and built for payments defy and banking the best of all worlds at the core is frax net an on chain fintech platform built to align with emerging us regulatory frameworks where you can mint redeem and use frax usd with just a few clicks deposit usc send a bank wire or tokenize treasuries and receive programmable digital dollars straight to your wallet frax net users benefits from the underlying return of us treasuries and earn just by using the system whether you're bridging minting or holding your frax usd works for you frax isn't just a protocol it's a digital nation powered by the frax token and governed by his global communities join that community and help shape frax nations future by going to frax.
com slash r slash bankless frax designed for the future of compliant digital finance one thing that's interesting there is the 400 millisecond block times something I've been thinking a lot about is the talix I forget where he said this I also asked him at the last time he came on bankless but his quip that if you focus too much on latency I think he phrased this if you become a high frequency trading blockchain you lose your soul and I think what he's referring to essentially is when you start playing the very low latency you know millisecond block time type of game game then you start to invite centralization in co-location that sort of thing in fact earlier this week at dev connect this is a quote from his presentation he said low latency is the inherent cost of decentralization if you want to geographically distributed neutral system that can be participated in worldwide it's impossible for it to have a latency of 50 milliseconds not 400 50 milliseconds if it did have that low latency then all activity would eventually be concentrated in one city having worked a jump you've built hft types of engines I'm sure you're very familiar with the types of optimizations and games hft traders actually play what do you make of this like it would seem that 400 millisecond block times might actually decrease your ability at monad to stay decentralized if Vitalik is right do you do you think he has a useful critique here I completely agree with Vitalik I think that decentralization is the north star for crypto and is certainly the north star for Ethereum and for monad and that means that there needs to be geographically distributed and decentralized block production and consensus and that naturally due to the laws of physics and how big the world is means that there is a there's a there's a floor on the block times that are possible like if two nodes are on opposite sides of the world because let's say Sydney and New York then the transit time from one to the other is on the order of 200 milliseconds I think it's it's a little bit less than that like 170 or something like that with optimal fiber and that's literally just like how far apart they are that does have an impact on where what the block times can be I think the cool thing about how this all has played out though is that 400 millisecond block times are still very fast from a human perspective so if you are a user who is trading on a decentralized exchange or yeah like using a social app or you playing a game or something like that that 400 millisecond latency is close to imperceptible to you as a human so there's sort of a natural like a nice happy medium where we have decentralization we have global block production but it's still really fast from the user perspective and yes there are like in centralized exchanges there's this I don't even want to say like tendency it is literally like almost like just factual that in order to compete as a high frequency trader on a centralized exchange you need to co-locate you need to have server in the same data center where the matching engine is and the exchanges go actually to great lengths to normalize all the cable links between all the servers and the data center and the matching engine so there is not unfairness and in years past like when I first started working 2011 then there were people whose jobs were to like you know test out different servers in a data center and try to see if there was one that had a faster connection to to the exchange so I think incentives ultimately drive behavior and in the case of HFT the incentive to in reacting to a centralized exchange is to try to get as close as possible and then sort of pushes up the cost of operating because everyone needs to rent servers in that one data center which then allows the data center to charge a lot of money another funny anecdote if I'm I'm rambling a little bit but CME Chicago Mercantile Exchange actually moved their entire operations from a data center that they didn't control they were just renting out to a new data center that they owned in a different location so that they could charge rent on all of the servers that were next to them because before they were kind of creating value for someone else and then there is that was like a bad commercial decision so they moved everything in order to be in a data center that they controlled and I think it's just an example of where yes in an environment where we have centralized actors centralized forces there's going to be this push toward value extraction and middleman kind of coming in and the benefit of a decentralized system that kind of holds the you know hat puts up a bulwark against the waves of centralization that's really where something special can happen yeah so do you think you can hold that at 400 milliseconds I guess is the question because there's some debate in the Ethereum community it like and there's probably no magic a number of course it's a spectrum right Ethereum is 12 seconds right now there's talk of dropping to six to four and then two you get lower than two though and maybe you get into some of the HFT wars where you know as italic said you know you're kind of destined to lose your soul the incentives for centralization become too powerful to overcome yeah sure it doesn't have to be 12 seconds but at 400 milliseconds do you think you can really hold the line against these HFT powers of centralization on it I think the way that I would frame it is that there are incentives for there are advantages that centralized actors tend to have at the start because as you said they can deliver a trading experience that's you know milliseconds so actually the question that you're asking I would flip into a statement which is basically that it is actually extremely important to re-engineer decentralized systems to be at the limit of what is possible while being decentralized and while allowing everyone to participate and having minimal hardware requirements we should do whatever it takes to make decentralized systems more performant and more capable so that they can exist at the limit of what's possible and thus be competitive against what otherwise would be a very unfair playing field between decentralized and centralized systems and then when you combine when you accomplish that but then you also get the network effects that come from a permissionless borderless credibly neutral network the people can coordinate with having to trust each other that's something really special can happen 400 milliseconds if you got 100 milliseconds or 50 milliseconds would that be kind of like too much would you be uncomfortable with that is 400 seconds kind of your line my line is wherever there is a compromise on decentralization so the line is close to 400 milliseconds because that is the block time at which we can still have globally distributed validators and that there is not this centralizing force i think it is it is literally impossible to have a hundred millisecond block times while still preserving that property so my line is not it's fundamentally like downstream of the physical properties of the earth and fiber optic cables can't break the laws of physics can we can we talk it for a minute about MEV so I'll see from flashbots and others have impressed upon me that MEV is actually another scale dimension that's important for blockchains right so you know maximum extractable value that is kind of attacks on users of the system it certainly can incentivize some centralization as well know all chains kind of struggle with this at least to some degree a theorem is seem to find some ways to manage it salana is working on it does monad bring anything special with respect to MEV extraction ways to mitigate that you have a philosophy for this yeah a couple of things to point out i think that there are forms of MEV that are that are toxic that are are bad for users sandwiching in front running are bad for users and an ideal system would would be resilient to that and would not have that be a possibility where we are right now in blockchains in general is that sandwiching can happen because blockchains exist as you know with public mempools because when transactions are submitted they sit in a pending state before they are built into incorporated into blocks and the ordering is chosen and the leader has discretion about how they order those transactions so that's sort of where we are right now in my opinion it is a huge problem for the industry overall Ethereum and salana each have seen a sort of third party system developed that allows arbitrageurs to express ordering preferences and submit them as bundles to validators and have the validators incorporate those bundles in return for an extra fee that the submitter on the arbitrageur submits and it's sort of a good news bad news situation where on the good side that fee mostly goes to stakers so it's extra revenue for those stakers on the downside it is sort of like an efficient market that has that enables like people to submit these ordering preferences two things that I want to point out the first is that monad is kind of like shaking up the boggle dice because asynchronous execution means that leaders don't generally know the state of the world right before when they build a block they don't know the immediate state right before that block because of the lag between consensus and execution they're building off of the lag state so the default monad client implementation only takes into account the priority fees and does a priority gas auction which is like the way that Ethereum was several years and I think in the short term there will be less MEV happening on monad because of this property as well as the fact that the systems that are I believe building sort of third party MEV solutions on monad are only enabling bundles of size two which typically are the you know someone submits a bundle they're trying to land a transaction after appending transaction which are generally less toxic forms of MEV usually this is like an Oracle update shows up and that unlocks the liquidation opportunity and anyone can submit a transaction that does that liquidation there's a small amount of profit available to the person that wins that competition but this is not front running this is like an opportunity would exist no matter what due to the Oracle update anyway so my point is that in the short term I think that monad is better positioned right now than maybe some other blockchains are it's a temporary situation because the ecosystem is still very nascent but in the longer term what I would like to see is pretrained privacy so that trend like blocks are built but they're built in a way where the builder doesn't know the actual like what's in the transactions until after the builders already committed to that block and then afterward there's some sort of unmasking of all those transactions because pretrained privacy or other pre block building privacy that actually is the thing that will ultimately address this MEV problem is there a world where monad has layer two is almost going to ask the question of your kind of your philosophy of monad whether it's a these are terms we used to use more don't so much but monolithic versus modular type of design monolithic meaning like kind of it's just one single kind of flat state versus modular meaning you might have layer two's on that are built on top of monad you have a perspective on this I think that there's a huge amount of value that comes from shared global state that has atomic composability which is to say the I guess what we would call monolithic approach when I say monolithic I don't like the association that that has of implying that it's like a big chunky hardware like kid data center chain thing you could use the the euphemism like a integrated integrated state yes although also to be honest I feel like people are using modular versus monolithic terms like a lot less than they used to like a year and a half ago let's talk about maybe the level of decentralization of monad at main net launch one of the right question I'm not sure how much it applies but are there any kind of kill switches or back doors or admin keys that you guys are going to launch with what what parts of monad are not decentralized at launch that's a great question there are no kill switches no admin keys no multi-sigs that is the really cool thing about building decentralized layer one is that everything is just enforced through code and decentralized validator set that has to make decisions for itself about whether to dot code changes what do you expect the the launch ecosystem to look like so on day one what sort of things can people do on the monad chain well first of all I think that even the existing integrations and basically delivering a fully backward compatible system that integrates with all of the beloved dev tooling within the EVM ecosystem while also keeping up with really high performance that alone is something that I'm really excited about there are great tools in EVM like tenderly or Falcon blockade metamask chain link stablecoin issuers all of that's going to work out of the box everything that works for the EVM and Ethereum ecosystem right now that's going to work out of the box it will it wasn't a easy process to get there in some cases because I'll just give you an example like certain simulation platforms have their own like modified gath client in order to deliver their all the simulation that they do but of course monad doesn't use gath monad uses a completely new text act so they had to retrofit a lot of things to make it work well keeping up with the performance of the chain but yes that's the whole exciting thing is that developers don't have to like we do all that work once so that developers don't have to worry about they can use all the same tooling is there a single client at launch just the client produced by is it the monad foundation the client is produced by category labs previously known as monad labs I will I'm really hopeful that a couple of years from now there are multiple or many clients running the monad protocol that would be something that would give me a lot of joy but yeah definitely one of the like for me the story about decentralization is from a protocol design perspective like enabling that level of decentralization and then over time like getting multiple clients in place having a even larger even larger validator set because that is a north star let's talk about the token for a minute because you are a layer one blockchain of course proof of stake so there is a token involved that token is going to go live I believe that at main net now currently there is a token sale going on actually which is sort of a first first that I've seen this is on coin base the coin base platform makes me think that initial coin offerings are back or or something like it so can you talk about the coin offering of monad how you worked with coin base to make that happen give give some folks some background who actually haven't seen what's going on there and then share a little bit more about what the token does in the monad network we were extremely excited to the monad is the first project on coin bases new token sales because it really was the opportunity to allow many more people to get access to the token and thus achieve much broader distribution of the token before main net launch compared to what projects have been able to do in the past in the past I think that there's been a very airdrop oriented approach for distributing tokens ahead of launch and there are definitely some nice things about airdrops but it's also quite challenging to distribute a token through airdrops because there are tons of airdrop hunters and people running bot farms to civil protocols and at the end of the day what I really care about is having as broad of set of holders of the mon token as possible and contributing to the network's decentralization through that broad holder set and the token sale through a really reputable platform like coin base which has you know existing practice of you know how they onboard users already and like that that just ultimately allows the token to be distributed more fairly and I think that's just important to the at the genesis of main net to successful long-term growth we would have never seen coin base kind of launch a token sale in any of the years that I've been encrypt out I mean this really is the first what what's changed from a environment perspective from a regulatory perspective to actually make this happen I think that it is actually surprising to me that this hasn't happened in the past because I do think that for the this coin base token sale and as I understand in general the the way that they're going to be approaching their token sales like these are token sales of main net ready projects that are functionally complete and that are you know about to turn into public main net and potentially list a token on an exchange so it's a more mature set of projects with much more stringent disclosure process compared to I think what has happened either even in the past year with other token sales or in the past like in the 27 2018 era of token sales but yeah I think it's a combination of coin base believing that now is the right time to expand their offerings and delivers a product that gives retail users the opportunity to participate in early or stage projects that are still quite mature and that have high degree of disclosures and operating practices that combined with just over the past year the greater interest in token sales and the proliferation of such platforms so let's say I have the monad token it's once monad is is main net what can I do with it so assuming it's like another layer one crypto currency asset in which I pay for gas fees in monad assuming there's a way for me to stake my monad coins and earn some sort of return assuming if I have a certain amount maybe of monad coins I could spin up my own validator and start to stake monad from home is all that right what else can I do with the token yeah those are all correct assumptions maybe something to point out also is that all insider tokens are locked and thus are not eligible for staking which I think is also a unique aspect of monad and monad's long troll took to other projects so sorry the part about tokens being locked for insiders that's not that is typical but what is atypical is that those locked tokens cannot be staked which means they will not receive any I'm sure there's some sort of network issuance some sort of block reward that you're providing to stakers and all of those locked tokens would be ineligible for that block reward is that correct that's right until they become unlocked they're ineligible for staking so that means that the opportunity to stake is really people that are receiving an air drop or acquiring the token through the Coinbase token sale or on the secondary market after that would be the people that are able to stake how did you think about sort of the issuance schedule for monad tokens so what does that look like and by the way are there any like slashing fees if a validator commits some sort of offense to the network yeah the block reward is 25 mon per block which annualizes to two billion ish mon per year the total supply is 100 billion so that's a two percent inflation rate in year one the inflation rate is chosen to be as low as possible and while still being high enough to reward a participation in the network as a staker and so it's kind of like you know a little bit of a needle threading thing where we think that this is the optimum I will say two things one is that lower issuance rate means that there is less dilution for people that are not participating as stakers staking is a really important role in the network and we wouldn't want to say that it's not something that is important and worthy of rewards but on the other hand there are a lot of blockchains there's a lot of cases where the rate is too high and it does a couple of things one is it raises the effective like cost of capital for that asset in defy and a second thing is that it kind of penalizes all the people that have their native tokens that they're actively participating in defy or other ecosystem things that are going on and are not able to stake them so having a low ish staking excuse me a low ish inflation rate ultimately kind of ensures that there's not too much of a penalty for not staking does the issue go down over time do you know the way Bitcoin does where it sort of happens every once in a while or is it a bit more algorithmic the way Ethereum's issuance schedule is based on the number of validators what's the policy there the policy is just flat issuance per block and thus basically flat issuance per year assuming the same number of blocks per year there's like 2% forever kind of thing assuming the same blocks number block per year well a little bit it's 2% in year one and then in year two because the denominator is 102 billion instead of 100 right as numerators will two so it's gonna go down a little bit I see okay in percentage terms well what's your take on like token valuation in general for layer ones so I think we sort of in crypto for a while this has been an ongoing discussion there's been many different it takes at this I think we're now out of phase in crypto where there's kind of two ways of of viewing an asset and different assets maybe fall in one or both of these buckets which is viewing it based on revenue how much revenue does the token actually return to token holders or viewing the asset as a monetary asset a store of value so give canonical examples for both store value asset Bitcoin right it's definitely not valued on its discounted cash flows definitely not valued on revenue revenue asset or something like say Awe which is you know kind of valued as a discounted cash flow of of future revenues I've argued and bankless has argued that me through the asset maybe hits both of those boxes is more on the store of value side think the more decentralized your layer one network the more you can kind of get away with being on the store of value side of the equation but some people think that's just you know meme science this is not really real there is no such thing as store of value it's all kind of a narrative what's your take on token valuation for something like the monad token I would say that first at the end of the day the most important thing is network effects and the value that's ultimately being unlocked to all of the users of that network I think that different systems that enable that value creation that are kind of downstream of that will ultimately perhaps inherit some of that value through different mechanisms like transaction fee processing and certain effects from being the native currency of an economy that is substantial and growing and that's enabling a lot of value transfer and value creation but I think at the end of the day the thing that the crypto industry needs to focus on most is just growth of amount of value that's being created for the end users and everything else will kind of follow from that we've talked about monad versus salana we've talked about it in comparison to ethereum but I think the the biggest comparison that I often see for monad is mega eth for some reason so mega eth is a very high performance layer two that's coming out I believe at the same time I feel like you guys are like I don't know talking to one another about your release schedules and like timing it so you're doing things very closely I mean token sale around the same time the main net is happening around the same time what why do people compare monad to mega eth is it just a product of you've been building together and you have similar timelines or are there some underlying similarities there I think that there are certainly some surface level similarities in the sense that both you know people from both projects probably talk about performance and the need to make the EVM more performant I think the differences though are in the approach and for I would say for monad we're just really focused on decentralization and the complete problem of making consensus really performant and building a really performant decentralized layer one ultimately to address the bottlenecks that we see and the trade-offs that exist otherwise right now without those foundational software improvements I think mega eth is maybe from what I understand like pretty focused on hardware assumptions and having really high hardware requirements whereas like if you're just asking me to compare them I would say that there's like a spectrum of low hardware requirements really high hardware requirements and can't speak for for them but I think on the monad side there's just a really high focus on allowing anyone to run a node and really making it cheap and feasible for everyone to participate I think the mega eth reply would be basically like oh well you know the decentralization part the consensus decentralization part we effectively as a layer two we've outsourced that or in the process of outsourcing that to Ethereum so we don't really need to think about decentralizing our consensus layer because that's what Ethereum is there for and maybe there's some sequencer stuff to decentralize or something like that but I think that would be the reply in fact that's the entire layer two design so maybe it comes full circle to like you know comparing layer two's to a high throughput EVM layer one but what do you what do you make of that response I think that there are different layer two designs and plans that would need to be evaluated against each other with consideration for how they're utilizing Ethereum for data availability or not what the trust assumptions are how feasible it is for a for example a high performance optimistic roll up to actually have other nodes keeping up and verifying because that's really what an optimistic roll up is assuming is that there are a bunch of other nodes that are all keeping up and independently verifying so they can note if there is a fraud and raise a fraud proof so I think the debate between different layer two systems will kind of focus on that I agree with your framing that ultimately if there's a question of like the monad approach of making the layer one really perform it and introducing your technologies to achieve a degree of scale all within a singular share global state that's fully globally decentralized versus the approach of like having constellation of different layer two's that all are utilizing Ethereum for a component of the of the work but not others then I think that I will just say that the monad design delivers performance that is needed right now and also delivers a high degree of decentralization right now and delivers that fast finality right now some of the struggles that exist right now are basically are in other ecosystems are related to slow finality and in that in particular that problem is already kind of addressed in monad take us to the year 2030 of monad is successful what does that look like it really looks like a couple of breakout apps that everybody uses that are powered by decentralized rails it looks like many more people having access to financial tools that were not developed in their country that are just built for a global buy and for a global audience it means everyone having access to dollars it means everyone having access to competitive yield markets where they can earn yield on their dollar deposits at a competitive rate rather than whatever is just local to what their bank offers them it means people being able to build businesses and you know take out loans or or get access to capital markets that are better than whatever their local market offers them it's really about a more interconnected world that can coordinate on top of a decentralized trustless layer talk about a failure mode so if monad fails you like why do you think it will fail that's a great question I haven't haven't envisioned failure in a specific way I think that the most important thing is execution and speed and those are really related to both technology and adoption I guess the failure mode would be that it ends up being that no one cares about the properties that we value deeply and that we're championing and that other folks in the ecosystem champion and have been championing for for a long time in a way that's very inspiring to us I think that's really the failure mode Keoni thank you so much for joining us say this has been great I'm not sure when this episode is going out but remind us of the main net date is it the 24th of November that's correct next Monday all right so it's next Monday at the time of recording this might go out earlier than that or it might be on the 25th so if we are living in the future here and you're listening to this then the monad main net may be available and what's your advice what should people do they're very first thing if they want to go check this out I think that people should check out the validator map it's kind of it's just like a reminder of the like the physical manifestation of decentralization if you google for validator map for any blockchain you got one for Ethereum you get one for monad you don't get one for many other blockchains so I think you should check that out first doesn't require having a wallet or anything and what should people be impressed by I think I have looked at this like 300 validators or so and and fairly evenly distributed in various geographies right yeah it's really showing the decentralization and the performance and the block times and the pace at which monad moves very good we'll include a link in the show notes for that Keoni thank you so much for joining us today thanks for having me run thank list nation got to let you know of course crypto is risky so our new crypto networks you could lose her to put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us in the bagless journey thanks a lot you