ETH Staking Panelists:
Darren Langley (Rocket Pool)
Vasiliy Shapovalov (Lido)
Ejaaz Ahamadeen (Coinbase)
-----
🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/
🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
🎖 CLAIM YOUR BADGE: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/-guide-2-using-the-bankless-badge
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
💰 GEMINI | FIAT & CRYPTO EXCHANGE
https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
🔀 BALANCER | EXCHANGE & POOL ASSETS
https://bankless.cc/balancer
👻 AAVE | LEND & BORROW ASSETS
https://bankless.cc/aave
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING
http://bankless.cc/unigrants
------
📣 KYBER | Liquidity mine with Rainmaker
https://bankless.cc/kyber
------
With Ethereum's switch to Proof-of-Stake around the corner, a full spectrum of staking options has emerged. Many who want to participate will not be able to run their own self-custodied 24/7 validator node, and not everyone has the required 32 ETH. For these folks, Staking-as-a-Service allows broader participation in the PoS consensus mechanism.
To discuss this, team members from Coinbase, Lido, and Rocket Pool come together in this panel to explore their approaches to the world of ETH staking!
------
Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here:
https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
hey hey bankless nation it is time for another bankless panel this one i am super excited about couldn't be more excited about this is the eth staking services panel david the fact that we can even do this is so massive after all the time we've been waiting for eth staking i came in December of 2020. And I just looked at the stats, over 6 million ETH staked, 6.3 million. We were just talking about this on the rollup, David, about how at the very beginning when ETH2 went live and staking went live, we were worried that we wouldn't get enough stake. It took like half a million to launch the chain.
And there was some concern that we wouldn't get enough. Here we are with 6.3 million. We've got an expert panel. Why don't you tell us about the panel, David? Yeah, we have the three staking as a service products, companies, teams, projects out there. We have Coinbase, we have Alito Finance, and then we also have Rocketpool. And these are three different approaches to staking as a service or ETH staking. And so we are bringing in the people that are building out different projects, approaching ETH staking differently to ask them about their product and ask them about like the trade-offs that each product is made.
And hopefully the listeners and the viewers come away with a little bit more information as to the world of staking from the staking as a service perspective. And maybe staking as a service is the right product for them. Maybe they want to stake themselves, but we are going to find out all the different variables and nuances and trade-offs that go into the decision-making behind e-staking. Guys, this is all about options, optionality. Of course, if you can stake at home, like stake at home, stake yourself. But this is another option for you. And as David said, it's kind of the spectrum of like, um, custodied to, to more decentralized and less custody.
We're covering it all today. And, uh, these are really the experts in the field. Of course, these are not all of the staking service providers out there, but we picked these three because we feel like they, they represent, um, different points on, uh, on the spectrum of self custody versus and more decentralized versus more custodial and a bit more centralized and kind of the full trade-off mix. So strap in guys, this is going to be a super exciting panel. Before we begin, we want to thank the sponsors that made this Bankless episode possible. Balancer is a powerful platform for flexible automated market makers.
Typical AMMs just have two tokens inside of one liquidity pool, which can lead to fractured liquidity across the many pairs in DeFi. With Balancer, you can access the full power of multiple tokens inside of one single AMM, which unlocks an entirely new playing field of possibility. This makes Balancer an awesome building block for so many different use cases. Balancer pools can make asset indices, but instead of paying fees to portfolio managers, Balancer lets you collect the fees from traders who use your portfolio for liquidity. Additionally, Balancer smart pools can be programmed to have properties that change according to predetermined rules, such as changing the swap fee based on market conditions, or even liquidity bootstrapping pools, which can help you launch and distribute your token with day one liquidity.
At Bankless, we use a liquidity bootstrapping pool to sell our BAP t-shirts to much success. Balancer V2 brings powerful new features that makes your money work even harder for you. In V2, idle tokens are capable of generating yield in DeFi without sacrificing liquidity in the pool using Balancer's asset managers. Balancer's vault architecture lets you trade between balancer pools at a fraction of the cost versus trading on other platforms. Balancer's mission is to become the primary source of liquidity in DeFi by providing the most flexible and powerful platform for asset management and decentralized exchange.
Dive into the balancer pools at app.balancer.fi. Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange. I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got into crypto in 2017 and it's been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys and sells. Gemini is available in all 50 states and in over 50 countries worldwide and on Gemini there are markets for over 30 various different crypto assets including many of the hot DeFi tokens and it's one of the few exchanges that has liquid die markets. Gemini just launched their earn program where you can earn up to 7.4% interest on 26 various crypto assets.
If you're tired of paying fees in DeFi or you don't want to worry about DeFi exploits, but you still want to earn interest on your crypto assets, Gemini Earn is the product for you. Another product I'm stoked to get my hands on is the Gemini Crypto Back Credit Card, which gives you 3% cash back on all of your purchases, but paid to you in your preferred crypto asset. When I get my Gemini credit card, I'm going to make sure that I get my cash back in ETH. So whenever I buy something, I get a little bit of ETH bonus back to me at the same time. You can open up a free account in under three minutes at gemini.
com slash go bankless. And if you trade more than $100 within the first 30 days after signup, you'll be gifted a free $15 Bitcoin bonus. Check them out at gemini.com slash go bankless. Welcome back, everyone. This is the Banking Staking Services panel. We have a packed panel for you. These are the experts in the space. The Bankless Staking Service panel? Well, no, we are not. Bankless is not offering staking services. It's on the Bankless Media channel. That's why it's Bankless, David. All right, so let me introduce the panelists for you here. We've got three staking service companies represented best in the business.
We've got Coinbase. We've got Lido. We've got RocketPool. Ejaz is the product manager at Coinbase. We've got Vasili. He is the co-founder of Lido. And we've got Darren, who is the general manager of RocketPool. we are going to get into staking services first everyone welcome how's it going going well thanks for having me great to be here yeah i'm great to be here it is so cool to have you guys uh i think um it was such a bear to schedule this actually because all of us reside in different time zones in different corners of the of the world this is maybe one of the most difficult uh bankless panels that we've ever scheduled so like the timing is inconvenient for just about everybody on this panel except maybe david he's smiling i'm in the middle here he's doing okay uh so i appreciate you guys great for me well i pro it's good for australia too so it's good for darren but we appreciate you guys making time for this um it's uh we've never done a uh kind of a staking episode that's dedicated to it so i think there's a lot to unpack for the bankless nation i guess maybe i'll just i'll just throw an overview out here both lido rocket pool and coinbase all three of them they're all staking as a service products each of them have staking as a service products each uh approaches eth staking a little bit differently and as with everything in this world in crypto there are trade-offs when it comes to each staking of the various approaches we want to dive into some of those trade-offs and actually understand the points on the spectrum where you guys are coming at it from a staking solution perspective so that we can give bankless listeners some information when they're deciding who to stake with.
Let's start with some high-level introductions from each of you and your overall approaches. I want to start with Lido Vesely with you. How does Lido approach e-staking, Vasily. So what things are you guys prioritizing over other things? What trade-offs have you made in your staking services design? Vasily, why don't you kick things off? So LIDAR is a DAO that builds liquid staking on different blockchains, including and starting with Ethereum. We have headquarters on Ethereum. That's our like homeland, heartland. So So liquid staking means that people stake with Lido and get a token return, and that token can be traded or used as collateral or used in other ways.
It's liquid and transferable. So we think that for liquid staking, there is some kind of winner-stake-small situation, like with stablecoins or ropercoins like WBTC or stablecoin, there will be one big provider of the thing and other smaller. So what we think we're doing is the best possible solution for liquid staking that can win, that actually can be at the same time a winning solution and also decentralized, safe for Ethereum and easy to use. So that's what we're building here. That requires, I'm sorry, one minute more. That requires like a number to make. Like to launch earlier, we had to use a threshold signature for withdrawal in that currently Lido deposits are like under a risk of collusion for three-score signature cosigners.
And we've got the permissioned validator set, not operator set for Lido to make it safe through the initial period of E2N Ethereum stake and when the protocol is development yet. Yeah, and we definitely want to go more into details on Lido specifically because I think it's got some of the most nuanced position on the various spectrum. But Vasily, you emphasize liquid staking. And importantly, Lido is the only product that has a staking derivative token yet out onto the market. Would you say the main focus or main priority of the Lido ecosystem is really to produce that secondary staking token, the tokenized deposits of ETH?
Would you guys say that that is your main priority or main focus? So we want to make a liquid staking that is easy to use. safe and decentralized. So that's our mission. That's our goal. Yeah, we focus on liquid staking, yes. Cool. All right, guys, let's go ahead and move on to Rocketpool. Rocketpool. So Darren, tell us a little bit about Rocketpool, how Rocketpool works and the trade-offs that it has made in order to produce its staking as a service system. So our approach aligns with the principles of Ethereum. So we are fully decentralized, non-custodial and open source. So essentially Rocketpool aligns the interests of people who have Ether, but don't want to run a node.
We call them stakers. And people who have 16 ETH, but have the technical capability to operate a node. So we call them node operators. So our smart contracts match a node operator with 16 ETH from stakers to make up the 32 ETH needed for Ethereum staking. As a node operator, they only need 16 ETH, which is great. They earn commission on the matched ETH, which is even better. And they also get RPL rewards, which RPO is our token, but they get those rewards for providing RPL as collateral. As a staker, it'll be super simple. So you essentially just swap ETH for our liquid staking token, which is our ETH, and you can participate in all the DeFi glory.
and then anytime you can swap it back for ethereum plus the rewards and that's essentially how that kind of works very good we'll get into all of this some more with rocket pool i want to throw it over to uh ejaz with coinbase what is coinbase's approach to staking what have you guys really optimized for ejaz yeah so i think there's really two core principles we consider when we approach which are our staking products. And one of them is ease of use. So a simple UX, minimum barrier to adoption. And then I think the second one is security or safety. And from there, we do our best to optimize between the two.
For example, how do we achieve minimum risk exposure without compromising the product experience for a user? So if we take examples of previous staking products that we already have launched, for example, Tezos and Cosmos staking for our retail users, The user experience is pretty intuitive. So you deposit into your account and you can start earning APY periodically. You don't have to worry about running the infrastructure or delegating or anything. For ETH2, as you all know, there are some very unique challenges that differentiates this from any typical staking product. For example, there's a minimum 32 ETH that you need to deposit typically, if you're running this on your own.
You need to manage hundreds, potentially thousands of validators instead of just a few. And there's a lockup for stakers until phase 1.5. There's massive risk of slashing, correlated slashing, and not to forget like the centralization risks. So we need to take all of this into account when designing these products. And I'd say that the kind of core problem that we've looked to prioritize above others in our staking solution for ETH2 is de-risking the staking implementation as much as we can. And I think that means decentralizing different layers of the infrastructure as much as we can. And we can get into this later if that works.
But ETH is one of our largest assets held in the custody. So we need to make sure that user funds are safe. There are a few trade-offs that this creates. Largely, a lot of them happen under the hood. So it's not actually exposed to the user. But one public example is we've launched a wait list and we've been gradually rolling people off of it as we scale up our service. We really wanna make sure that our implementation handle the volumes we're putting it through and that our quality of service is maintained. Hey, Jaz, just a quick follow up on this. I'm curious since Coinbase has been staking with other proof of stake networks in the past, what would you say are sort of the main distinctions between other proof of stake networks versus ETH2 right now?
What are some of the the differences, the contrast points? Yeah, I'd say it's the two points that I mentioned earlier. Let's take Tezos, for example, right? The way that it generally works is it's simple enough to delegate Tezos tokens to a baker, which is like a stake, right? And you typically only need to operate one or two of these things to accommodate quite a large amount of principle. And the slashing risk is much lower than ETH, right? You can't get 100% slashing with Tezos. Now, when you compare this to ETH2, you have a minimum deposit of 32 ETH per validator. So now if you wanna scale this up massively, you now have to run thousands of these things, right?
And it's a non-trivial task to kind of maintain all of these validators to make sure that they're upkept at the same kind of quality and security bars that you have for like some of these other staking chains. Right. And I think just like in general, like the principle is so much more higher. The staking and slashing risk is so much more higher. So there's a lot more to be found upon at stake with ETH2 versus some of these other chains. All right. Very cool. So I think I'm starting to hear some of the priorities you guys are making. You know, Coinbase talking about user experience, ease of use, UX, Lido talking about liquidity, making sure there's liquid.
Rocketpool talking about decentralization, making sure this is open, permissionless. Some of these things are starting to come through. Let's turn to business model for a second. I want to stay with Ejaz on this because Coinbase, of course, just went public. Obviously, you've got shareholders. They're looking for profits, this sort of thing. What is Coinbase's business model when it comes to ETH staking? staking. How is Coinbase expecting to make money off this and give us some guidance on the fee structure that prospective stakers can expect? Yeah, absolutely. So put quite simply, for our retail consumers staking through our main app, we take a percentage of the rewards that they earn from their principal that's staked.
Currently, that fee is set at 25%. We follow a similar model with institutional clients, but it varies depending on client and chain and through the path that they might stake with us. But for retail customers, it's 25% of rewards. Very good. And quick poll here, because I'm curious off the top of my head. Ejaz, is Coinbase staking available to everyone or is it kind of a select group right now? Is it generally available or is it kind of waitlist beta-ish? Yeah, so for our existing assets that we have right now, Cosmos, Tezos, and ETH2 for our retail consumers, Cosmos and Tezos are rolling out to the majority of the geographies that we support.
There are obviously some geographies that we can't always support, jurisdictions within the US that we can't support, but we're working very adamantly to be able to provide support to the users there. For ETH2, we've taken a more gradual approach. So we're currently serving users within the US off of our waitlist. And we're very soon hoping to expand into international geographies as well. So as we get into the world of things on-chain with the world of Lido and Rocketpool, we still have business models in the world of on-chain economics, but they're a little bit different. And so I want to throw this question to Vasili.
What's Lido's business model? Where does it capture value? Who gets to earn rewards? And what is overall the business model for Lido? Vasily, you are muted. Yeah, so Lido is pretty straightforward in that regard. We've got people stake with us. They receive stake data tokens and they receive rewards and the LIDAR takes 10% fee. That 10% fee is getting cut into three directions, basically. One is paying out the node operators because they do all the work here in validating the network, et cetera, et cetera, and they have to be paid. And currently it's half of that 10% fee, so 5% goes to node operators.
and the rest goes to LIDAR treasury that can be used for different things. For example, buying cover for stakers, like we do it at this point, and maybe the development, the personal costs, etc. So it's spending is voted on by the LGO token holders. Very cool. Okay, so you said they were split off into three directions. One direction goes to the node operators, one goes into the community treasury. What was the third? The cover, one goes to the treasury straight and one goes to buy the cover. Okay, so there's like a little bit of an insurance fund kind of like baked into the Lido system. Yeah, it's been discussed right now because it's been very expensive to buy cover lately, and we might switch to some kind of self-cover like Aave or something does, but that's currently under discussion right now.
And Vasily, when you say node operators, validators is also another term for that. One and the same? Yes or no? So when talking about Ethereum, we use node operators because validator is like one private key that is validating the one basically stream on signatures. So Ethereum has, what I don't know, 200,000 validators right now, but only maybe like a thousand node operators. So to be completely clear here, we use node operators as entities that manage validators, individual validators. Right, right. So there are a handful of node operators in the Lido system, I think 10 or 11, but there are thousands of potential validators because that's the number of the deposits, the ether deposits into the Lido contracts.
Yeah, we've got nine right now, but we are playing an expansion. Okay, cool. All right, let's turn the conversation to Rocketpool and Darren. Darren, can you kind of give us the broad, like overarching, what is the business model or the crypto economic structure of the RocketPool system? Where does the value transfer? What's the fee structure? Tell us about these details. So within RocketPool, value is captured in two ways. So we have Ethereum fees from stakers, which I'll kind of touch on in a minute, and then RPL rewards. So RPL is our token, and it has a kind of inflation rate of 5%. And we use that to incentivize actors within the protocol to work in its best interest.
So to break that down to the specific actors, so we've got stakers who receive Ethereum staking rewards from the beacon chain, as you'd expect. Then we have node operators who are really the hero of our story. They provide the hardware and skill to operate a node. So they receive the majority of the value created by the protocol. They earn beacon chain rewards, commission from stakers, and then they get the share of the RPO inflation as well for providing RPO collateral. We also have two DAOs. We have an Oracle DAO, which is a kind of a broad group of high profile Ethereum stakeholders from kind of three target areas.
So community, ecosystem and industry. They play a supporting role. So essentially they oracle information from the beacon chain into our smart contracts. And for that, they get a share of the kind of RPL inflation. The protocol DAO, which is the other DAO, is basically to fund open source development of RocketPool going forward. So it gets a small kind of share of the RocketPool inflation to kind of drive that forward. In actual fact, we've actually got a really great explainer series on our medium about everything about how RocketPool works, specifically our tokenomics. And our fantastic community have actually put together some videos.
So it's made it really easy to digest. In terms of the fees. So node operators don't pay any fees, but they earn a dynamic kind of commission structure. So it's based on supply and demand because we're a decentralized protocol. We have to kind of promote participation when we need it. So we have a commission structure that varies between 5% and 20%, but we target 10% essentially. So stakers or RF holders, they actually get or they actually pay an average across the whole protocol. So, which should be around 10%. Okay, so you have the RPL token inflation to pay out certain parts of the Rocketpool ecosystem, but the only people that are actually capturing ETH fees, fees denominated in Ether, are the node operators.
So the Rocketpool DAO doesn't charge any Ether fees, it's just the node operators, right? that's exactly right and we found that that's the kind of uh you know least um rent seeking sort of uh option and so we we kind of stay out of it and uh we the money goes to the node operators because essentially they are doing all the work to to to put this together you said there's a supply demand balance equilibrium that needs to be struck and i'm kind of reminded of the issuance schedule of Ether, the asset, as a function of whether there are a lot of nodes on the system. If there's a lot of validators on Ethereum, Ethereum will actually issue more Ether, but rates will be more competitive and therefore be lower, and then vice versa.
If there's not a lot of validators available in the system, Ethereum will issue less Ether, but it will be more rewards per validator. And that's how kind of Ethereum finds balance equilibrium between the supply and demand of security, RocketPool kind of follows that same sort of structure, right? Exactly, yeah. So if the demand strips capacity for, so basically if there's more in our RH deposit pool than we have capacity on the node operator side, then the commission rates kind of go up so that it kind of incentivizes people to participate within the protocol. and so level it out. So essentially we get this equilibrium, exactly as you said.
So Darren, because I asked Ijaz this question, I'm going to ask you the same question. I know Lido is live and rolling right now, accepting stakers. And it sounds like Coinbase is in kind of a limited rollout right now, rolling out fast. What is the status of RocketPool? When can folks start staking with RocketPool? Yeah, that's a great question. So we're not on mainnet yet, as you've said, but we are one step away. So we'll be releasing our release candidate to the Prater testnet on the 2nd of August. And then following on from then, we'll go to mainnet. So this is a massive milestone for us.
And we're really excited to be able to finally share the kind of the work that we've been doing with the broader community. Are you sharing that right now? So is that sort of an August date? that you're sharing now? I wish I could give that to you, but we actually announced it earlier on in the week. Just like that. That's good. I didn't mean to say congrats on that. We do love you guys, but no. Breaking news for some, but maybe some already saw that. I think this next question is really important. I'm gonna keep with you, Darren, and Rocketpool, because there is sort of, with staking, There is, I guess, incentive alignment and a selfish profit motive for the individual staker.
But then there's also this public good that all stakers in aggregate are providing to Ethereum, the network. Let's not forget why we stake. Let's not forget why we are validating. It is for the continued decentralization of this Ethereum ecosystem. This Ethereum economy is super important. So I'm going to ask you this question. And if RocketPool is successful, how does your project impact the centralization or decentralization of Ethereum, that public good that I was just talking about? Yeah, so obviously we've spent a considerable amount of time building this decentralized staking protocol because we strongly believe that centralization is a huge risk.
And that problem you can see in the beacon chain deposit address graphs. With RocketPool, anyone can operate a node. So essentially, we're going to be mobilizing a decentralized army of individual node operators to perform validation. So RocketPool is permissionless. So anyone with 16 ETH and 1.6 ETH worth of RPL can operate a node and be in the RocketPool protocol. So from an Ethereum perspective, we are no different than solo staking. We provide the same level of decentralization. The aim is to have thousands of individual node operators kind of operating within the RocketPool protocol. Why is that important?
Just refresh everyone on why decentralization of Ethereum is important. So there's a few benefits to that. So first of all, there is no centralized control. So in proof of stake, it's very important, particularly with MEV. We're going to talk about maybe MEV. But so with MEV, if you have centralized operators, the problem gets worse, much, much worse. So there's a few things like that. There's also just a resistant, a kind of, it's more robust. The network is more robust because you have different setups, different machines. And so you can't have like a whole part of the network that gets destroyed and Ethereum goes down.
It'll just keep running because you're so decentralized. We'll indeed talk a bit more about MEV. That is maximum extractable value. You've also heard of minor extractable value. We'll talk about that a little bit later. But I want to throw the same question to you, Vasili. So what's Lido's take on this? How does Lido's project impact the centralization or decentralization of Ethereum? What's your philosophy here, Vasily? so um i firmly believe that with lido uh the decentralization of ethereum is better than without it so uh we we are building like not the best solution we build the best possible solution the best solution that can actually win and that's like a big difference there are a lot of models that uh give bit better decentralization and ideal work where people use them but uh we The staking is a product.
A product that can be better on loss. And there is a baseline liquid staking product that is already pretty good. It's liquid staking offered by exchanges. And we've seen it in the wild in the other staking economies to exchanges to take a big share just because it's convenient. And while it's custodial, it's convenient to use and easier. and that's like pretty pretty good baseline so decentralized protocols should be competitive and preferably better they have the the means to be better by being vertically integrated into defy and neutral and decentralizedly governable and well they they can be better for for both stakers and for the protocols but there has to be a thread of mate to make them competitive and I think that without without Lido Ethereum would be in a worse place than it is for example we've got like about 10% share right now of other that is deceived in 9 node operators.
The Kraken exchange has got like 12% or 40% of all ETH takes right now by themselves. So that's, yeah, that's what I think about it. Let me run this by you and make sure that you agree with my take on Lido. Lido is a DAO model, right? And so there's community governments, community treasury, community ownership. And so your take is that there's a certain amount of tradeoffs that need to be made as a staking as a service. You said that staking as a service is a product, a product that needs to be provided. And so the tradeoff with the currently nine validators that are operating in Lido in the future, a few more, that is democratizing more access to more people who are able to stake more ETH because of Lido.
And that community-owned, community-operated kind of LIDO DAO is how we manage those trade-offs between fewer validators but more access to staking services. Would you agree with that characterization? I'd say that the DAO is more like guiding force here. So it's not like a final arbiter here. it's guiding the LIDO through the initial period where the beacon chain is about as useful as a potato where you can stake and you can not stake and that's like what you can do and the spec is changing that like the construction side you hear a hard head going through construction side and And LIDAR governance is that hard hat for now.
But the final form of liquid staking that can actually win is first ossified, not upgradable, not governable. Well, slightly governable maybe, but not very. And it has to be permissionless with not operators. It shouldn't be a white list. It shouldn't be like a limited amount of not operators. but that can only happen when the playing field is not like changed under you, right? So our trade-off is not that we have a white list forever of small number on operators, is that we have to launch on a minimal amount of future that can actually make a good stake in product that is sufficient to decentralize for now and have chances to become better in that in the future and LIDAR DAO is the guiding force that will guide LIDAR from like a good product on the start to the best possible product and best for Ethereum not only for stakers at the end.
The beacon chain on its own is about as useful as a potato that that's a quote I'm going to highlight take away from this conversation for sure. Ijaz how about you so give the case for why an exchange makes for a good staking services provider and specifically on this topic of centralization versus decentralization of ethereum as a public good yeah um plus i think it's a great question and i actually echo a lot of what darren and vasili has said so far like listen ethereum is at its best the most decentralized, the more decentralized that it is. And I think there's often this notion or perception of exchanges that we're kind of trying to be the big bad wolves that try and centralize everything.
And I'm here to say that that's most definitely not always the case when we approach our products, particularly with Ethereum. And I just think that incentives are just different for exchanges in the way, but it's definitely aligned with the kind of principles of Ethereum in general. So in terms of whether we're towards a centralized and decentralized philosophy, we want to make sure we decentralize Ethereum as much as we can. But if I go back to one of the original core principles, to one of the earlier questions that you asked in terms of what we consider when we design these staking products, it's ease of use.
And so we want to make sure that we balance this decentralization for users with easy accessibility to be able to stake. My kind of thinking and like Coinbase's thinking as well is, yes, one could go out and set up the infrastructure themselves at home. And they're encouraged to do so. But often it's quite tough to do so for anyone that holds 32 ETH or more. or more. And so we want to be able to balance and create a solution that enables that. And there's ways that we push forward that decentralized ethos. I mentioned it earlier, and we can dig into it now or later if you like, but we look at our infrastructure stack when we do that.
I don't think just because Coinbase is the company that offers ETH2 staking for our users, that means that we should be considered a single infrastructure entity, right? I think there's ways that you can decentralize that, whether it's using multiple clients, whether it's using multiple staking providers. And I think there's a path forward there. So definitely pro-decentralization. Yeah, I definitely want to echo the fact that I think centralized exchanges get a bad rap when it comes to staking. That's a little bit unfair. And I want to make the case for staking inside of coinbase or staking inside of a centralized exchange at all um in the world where we uh say in like 20 30 40 whatever the future and that coinbase has never ever or any centralized exchange has never ever maliciously gone after ethereum well in this world which i think is actually the most likely world then all of these centralized exchanges and coinbase what they have done is they have made the ease of ether distribution as maximally accessible as possible And so I don't really think there's no reason for any centralized exchange's self-interest to harm the network that is the staking network.
Therefore, if that version of the future plays out, then all Coinbase would have done is they've been able to democratize more and more of the Ether staking and Ether issuance to a broader and broader set of people. Because that's really what Coinbase's core competency is. It's user aggregation and ease of use. And so, you know, so long as the incentives of Coinbase plays out, then they will actually be one of the most democratizing forces of Ether staking rewards of all time. And so I think that's a decent perspective about centralized staking that I don't see or hear echoed all that much. Yeah, I mean, listen, you honestly hit that right on the head, right?
Like the ethos or foundational ethos for blockchains are decentralization, right? We've seen that with Bitcoin. We've seen it with Ethereum. And like our mission at Coinbase is to create an open financial ecosystem, right? To enable paths and funnels for users to be able to access all of this, right? And, you know, there's brand and reputational risk that is tied to all of this, right? And I think like when we build these products, it's definitely with the mindset of enabling this wider decentralization. And it's through the aggregation effort. It's through ease of use. It's through a safe and simple means for the majority of users that may not want to, you know, set up and run their own infrastructure.
And that's really what we want to help pitch and create for. I want to turn the panel to this question. We'll continue with you, Ijaz, for the moment. This is around like validating and architecture, like specifically who is doing the validating. And that's a question for Coinbase. So it seems like the model for Coinbase versus both Rocketpool and Lido here is that Coinbase is sort of running the validating infrastructure. I want to ask about that. But then I want to ask more broadly, if I'm staking my ETH with Coinbase, what trust assumptions? In what ways do I have to trust Coinbase? I have to give up my private keys, right?
And we've heard, you know, not your keys, not your crypto sort of thing. What are the other trust assumptions here? Yeah, so let me take the first part of your question and then can touch on the last. Yeah, so, you know, as you're all aware, ETH2 staking was designed in such a way that encourages the decentralization of its inherent staking infrastructure. Like the 32 ETH minimum, multiple staking clients. And so we really wanted to build our solution in a way that upheld this, whilst also making it easier for our users to stake. And so one of the core focuses was to decentralize the validating part of our solution.
And we can do this through a few ways, one of which is to use multiple staking providers that meet our levels of security and quality. This is safer. It minimizes centralized risk exposure. So we reduce the chances of triggering slashable offenses. uh bison trails who we acquired earlier in the year is one key uh example of a partner but we also focus on using multiple providers and then in terms of i guess um how our validators are incentivized for maybe things like maximum uptime and stuff like that like we have a high bar for quality and security requirements in general for each provider that you know needs to be met before we integrate them um but we also have things like uh slas in place of service level agreements that ensure that our providers meet at least a minimum level of service.
And these can account for things like maximized uptime, using multiple staking clients, minimum overlap between providers, infrastructure, et cetera. And another way I like to think about incentives for these providers, because I think it's actually quite an interesting topic, is if a provider integrates with Coinbase, that's almost guaranteed eFlow for them to stake, right? And there's also reputational risk for providers itself that we use if they don't maintain a quality of service. So that's kind of like the outlook there. And then in terms of, I can go on about the infrastructure, but I want to answer your second question, which is around like, what are some of the trust assumptions?
Yeah, inherently, you know, Coinbase is a custodial solution and users that, you know, place their ETH with Coinbase in our accounts, place it within Coinbase's trust, risk and safety parameters and usability. So, you know, they don't have their private keys, but we kind of like maintain and manage your private keys. We manage the kind of like staking process. And there's like a specific way that we do that to make sure that, you know, Coinbase does this in a very careful and managed method. So that's largely the main trust assumption that's made there. So I want to turn the same question to you and with Lido, because Lido's got, like you said, has nine validators and it looks looking to add a few more in the future.
How does Lido go through the selection process of who gets to validate for Lido? And how does Lido also incentivize uptime? Because uptime is really, really important when it comes to staking as a service. So who are the validators? How is that process decided? And how is uptime incentivized? So with Lido, we've got currently nine node operators. and the process we have been used, we've been used to two different processes to select them. One was when we, before launch, we talked to every, basically, good node operator out there. I'm coming from a validator background, so I'm CTO of P2P, a pretty prominent staking provider.
so we we talked with just about everyone good and found five very good ones who wanted to be part of lido and start with with us it's steak fish certos churros and staking facilities all very good some some people had legal concerns some people had like some other concerns didn't want to be part of liquid staking or something. So we've got five very best operators at start. The second lag was when we had a process to select a few additional ones. We launched a Google form where people could make an admission and the existing node operators had a kind of council vote on who's going to be in LIDL.
The next lag is probably the same one, but that's like a stopgap solution. We use a community of node operators to select other node operators for now. That's working out pretty good for us, but that's not a permanent solution. Why we do that right now that way is that ETH is basically hostage with Nod Apparatus on Bitcoin chain right now. There are no withdrawals, they are not coming for half a year at least and the staking is locked, the rewards are locked. is no way to do anything is not operators go stroke or out of business or something. So until that hostage period is over, the white list is very important to LIDAR.
The incentive here to be a good not operator comes from like the fact that all of them are very respected and very experienced node operators and they have in total I think a few about short of 10 billion since taken in all the networks they're operating. So they are very experienced, they are very good, they are aligned with the ethos of blockchain and Ethereum in in particular, and they want to maintain reputation for a long time. So that's how it works for now. And I want to ask, what's the long-term plan for staking or being a validator or node operator with Lido? Are you guys looking to open that up to just a broader and broader set of participants over the long term?
How many node operators do you think Lido will have in one year or five year, 10 years? So it's a hard problem to design around. We need to balance the quality of node operation with permissionless nature of the protocol. We are making drafts right now, drafts, many of them. And I think it will take like at least half a year to have something actionable here. The building blocks we have for this process is mostly the history of how people operate in Lido. That's one brick. The other is the stakers' opinion on operators. So, stakers have to have a say here as well. the people where the operator that Ethereum stakers considers to be good ones should be like put more front and center than one they don't.
And something like safety model where people can stake their funds with another operators and say that if they screw up, that's my money on the line, but I won't share for what's here. Very cool. Very cool. Okay. All right. Let's go on to RocketPool as well. So Darren, I know that RocketPool's goal is to open up staking to as many people as possible. So I want to ask you a slightly different question. Who does RocketPool really go after or who do you guys find in your community that is part of your validator set? And how does the RocketPool system incentivize uptime? so we're permissionless so anyone can can be a node operator um but we have kind of rational incentives so our node operators have skin in the game they have 16 eath of their own funds earning rewards so they want to maximize their return and so consequently they are maximizing staker returns as well.
It's an equal amount essentially between the amount that they have with their own funds and the amount they get from the pool. So what we get is a natural alignment of incentives so they essentially ensures that they perform well. So I want to turn this to kind of of the staked ETH token, right? It's like the idea of tokenizing staked ETH, tokenizing deposits. This is a superpower of Ethereum, right? You know, we're all familiar with the article superfluid collateral, and all collateral has become on Ethereum somewhat superfluid in that it can be used in all sorts of DeFi applications. So the token, it seems, the staked ETH token, starts to become much more important and darren you mentioned that rocket pool has something called art eth i'm curious how our eth might differentiate itself from other um staked eth tokens if at all and just in general your thoughts on how this landscape will will play out will there just be a ton of different um versions of of staked eth tokens in the wild or would this consolidate to a few or will we have like wrapped versions that contain multiple how wild and crazy is this going to get and how is it going to evolve yeah so eventually you'll be able to use our eth across the entire kind of d5 landscape so liquidity pools lending protocols yield farming strategies uh raf derivatives and all of all that crazy stuff that we haven't invented yet.
That's all out there. But a big difference, I guess, the big differentiator, I guess, with Arif is its design. So it doesn't rely on balance rebasing to deliver rewards. So the amount of Arif is actually static. But we have this ever increasing exchange rate, which accomplishes essentially the same thing, but has some significant benefits. So first of all it is much more compatible with exchanges and other protocols um who are not really expecting balance rebasing and that's basically updating the the token balance automatically on like a daily or a daily basis essentially ample fourth or yam followed this model as well yeah yeah yeah yeah so and second of all um there's a concern in our community around the tax implications of owning these tokens and the arif design is much easier to track from a tax perspective because rewards are not continuously being pushed and creating these taxable events so obviously every tax jurisdiction is different so get some professional advice um but in general if people want to have questions about our wreath and how it works uh we're happy to answer them in our discord uh vasily that's essentially the difference vasily i want to give credit to toledo as the actually the only project that actually has a staked eth token out there in the wild so i want to get to you but but first uh ryan already brought up uh dan ellitzer's uh superfluid collateral article another article that dan ellister wrote was the death of ethereum and death was actually d-e-t-h and he stand he stood at d for delegated eth and this was actually a possible scenario that dan illustrated in this article that well uh if there is a staked eth tokens out in the wild like uh lido has a staked eth rocket pool has our eth and then in theory any centralized exchange like coinbase or kraken could issue their own like delegated eth except there's this concept of liquidity begetting liquidity uh and so while there might be many many staked eth token you know staked eth derivative tokens out there it's likely that you know, only a handful or maybe just one really just becomes the dominant form of staked ETH collateral in DeFi.
Largely kind of how we see USDC is the dominant, you know, stable coin in DeFi. And so Ejaz, my question to you is that why will the death of Ethereum not happen? If Coinbase does actually absorb a lot of ETH, and I'm assuming, and also baked into this question is, is Coinbase going to issue a staked ETH token? And then also, if they do, why would it be not the death of Ethereum? Okay, so that's a good question. So let's touch on wrapped ETH2 first, right? So I think, firstly, I'll say, I've got to be careful what I say, but I think, firstly, I'll say we definitely intend on offering liquidity for our users.
I think it's a core component for our staking experience that users are able to withdraw, send or trade their assets. And ETH2, of course, is unique in that the transition to proof of stake is phased. So there's a lockup period, as it were, right now. In terms of how, we've been and still exploring a number of options for enabling liquidity. And the wrapped ETH2 token is one of them. Another option that you could consider as well is something along the lines of like an internal order book, right, of sorts, where users that have a staked ETH2 position could potentially trade out of that position with someone who wants to enter that position, right?
And to be honest, there's pros and cons between all of these options, right? For example, an internal order book might be simpler to implement and use, but it makes it so that stakers can't move their stake off platform, right? Because there's no token. A wrapped ETH2 asset, on the other hand, is, as you said, and as Dan Elitzer says in his article, much better capital efficiency as you can hold it, take it off platform, use it in DeFi protocols. but I would say trickier to implement technically and compliantly with a holistic product experience. So that's the way we're kind of like thinking about liquidity, very important and focusing down onto a solution now as we've been kind of looking into that.
And then in terms of like, was your question, David, around why it wouldn't be the death of Ethereum? Do you mind helping me understand that last part? Right. So the concept, the idea, the thought process is that all of these staked ETH tokens will compete for liquidity. There will be one dominant winner. If that one dominant winner is a centralized exchange, then we have one centralized exchange growing. Why would you come and stake your ETH in any other platform if you want to get liquidity on that? So you choose the platform that has the best liquidity on that staked ETH. If that's Coinbase, then that's a centralization factor onto one centralized exchange.
Yeah, good point. I guess... The way that I'm viewing it is I honestly, and this is my own opinion, I honestly don't think there is a world where it's necessarily just going to be one staked ETH derivative that kind of rules all. And the reason for that is I think optionality is important, right? Like if you ask yourself, why do people use USDC over DAI, which is like, you know, theoretically a more decentralized stablecoin, right? There are different uses and purposes for that, right? Whether that token is used as collateral to back a certain thing, whether you use it as collateral in Aave to kind of like pull out credit on that or whether you use it for something else.
You know, it depends on the user and the use case in particular. And then in terms of liquidity, I think there's a high chance that it plays out quite similarly to stablecoins if I'm honest, David, right? So you could have a dominant centralized exchange that has a wrapped ETH2 token, but you could also have a decentralized version, whether that's the likes of what Rocketpool are doing or what Lido is doing as well. So I think that optionality is important. I don't think liquidity would primarily be an issue there, in my opinion. As the representative of the team with the only actual staked ETH token out in the wild, tell us about that.
What's that like? Is the Lido staked ETH token, is that collateral in any application? What's the strategy behind growing liquidity? Overall, what is the approach towards growing the market cap of Lido's staked ETH token? One correction that we are not the only liquid stake token. There are like I think four more. We are dominant like 75% of the liquid stake market but not the only one and the rest has a lot of within total as well. So there is Stakewise and STKR and the credit is where created you we are not the only one so um uh we are honestly in the bucket of uh there there will be like a dominant uh uh liquid staking token here and the runners up and that uh the dominant token can change but the equilibrium here if there is there is a domination uh on the market because That's how these things work.
When the products are not very differentiated and liquid staking tokens are not very differentiated to most users, they want an adder with some staking rewards on top and every liquid staking token provides more or less that. When they are not sufficiently differentiated, the one that has a slight edge will get used more. and slight edge might be liquidity, might be like better rewards or something, but there is a place for domination here, I think so. And then the liquidity improves, we have a positive feedback loop here. So I'm pretty sure that this will be a market where the winner takes most.
And the winner can change at times, but the equilibrium is one dominant coin and other less prominent. Guys, what a fascinating panel so far. Diversity of approaches, also diversity of perspectives on some of these issues. Guys, we have a few more things to cover that you are not going to want to miss. We're going to talk about MEV. We're going to talk about insurance. We're going to talk about what keeps these panelists up at night when it comes to staking. So a lot more to unpack here. If you are enjoying this conversation, if you want more Bankless panels and you want reminders, send notifications, make sure you like and subscribe to this channel right now.
Just hit that like button, subscribe. We are going to get to the sponsors and then be back with these panelists in just a moment. But thanks to the sponsors that made this episode possible. Bankless is proud to be supported by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure. Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum, which is what Ryan and I call a money robot. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy.
Something brand new in the Uniswap ecosystem is the Uniswap Grants Program is now accepting applications for grants. We have been saying this for a while and we'll say it again. DAOs have money and they are in need of labor. If you think that you have something to contribute to the Uniswap DAO, apply for a grant to Uniswap. Just look at the size of the Uniswap treasury. It's almost $3 billion. This mountain of capital is looking for labor. Do you have something of value to contribute to the Uniswap DAO? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a UniGrant at unigrants.org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go.
That's exactly what we did to get Uniswap to be a sponsor for Bankless, and you can do the same for your project. Thank you, Uniswap, for sponsoring Bankless. The Aave protocol is a decentralized liquidity protocol on Ethereum, which allows users to supply and borrow certain crypto assets. Aave version 2 has a ton of cool features that makes using the Aave protocol even more powerful. With Aave you can leverage the full power of DeFi money Legos, yield, and composability all in one application. On Aave there are a ton of assets that you can supply to the protocol in order to gain yield and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have supplied collateral.
Here you can see me borrowing 200 USDC against my portfolio of a number of different DeFi tokens in ETH. I'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than the stable interest rate option, but I could choose the stable interest rate option if I wanted to lock in that interest rate in permanently. V2 also features the ability for users to swap collateral without having to withdraw their assets, trade them on Uniswap, and then deposit them back into Aave. With Aave, users can do this in one seamless transaction, saving you time and gas costs. Check out the power of Aave at ave.com.
That's A-A-V-E dot com. All right, guys, we are back with this excellent panelist, ETH Staking Providers. We've got Coinbase, we've got Lido, we've got RocketPool. These guys are the best in the biz. We've covered so much so far. One topic we haven't addressed, and we absolutely need to, is this topic of MEV in an ETH staking world. This is no longer a minor extractable value. This is maximal extractable value. This is basically the idea of being able to front run transactions because validators have the god mode superpower of transaction ordering. They can order transactions and benefit certain parties over another, maybe receive a fee for providing that transaction ordering benefit.
This is almost like a, we've talked about this so much on Bankless. We've talked about this as sort of a MOLOC problem. We've talked about this as kind of a coordination problem. It's something that's very pernicious on Ethereum. I want to start maybe with Ejaz. Tell me about MEV, the structural issue that you think staking service providers are going to have around this and how Coinbase plans to approach it. And the last thing I'll say about this is this could really impact the yields that stakers get. If one of you guys, one of you service providers are able to extract more MEV and give that back to stakers, you're going to be able to offer much more competitive yields and rates.
So what's Coinbase's approach to MEV, Ejaz? Yeah, really, really interesting question. So I think, firstly, I think MEV could be a huge opportunity for us and for Coinbase. But it also comes with many interesting challenges that we need to consider, right? So given Coinbase's position, running loads of validators for a number of proof of stake networks, Coinbase now has the opportunity to capture MEV, like you said, right? And this revenue stream could potentially be substantial. As an example, I think some experts have predicted that MEV after Ethereum proof of stake mergers happened could enable ETH2 validators to increase their earnings by as much as like 60 to 300%, right?
And those all sound like kind of like DeFi summer type APYs, right? And I'm pretty sure it would consolidate down pretty succinctly. But, you know, there's definitely a marginal opportunity to increase to APYs. So that's one core incentive, right? And to your point, Ryan, like if one provider does this, right, now there becomes a competitive disparity between other providers. And so they might want to do it. And so there's a number of options to consider for how we proceed with MEV. Everything from, you know, creating proprietary strategies to maybe even purposefully opting out of MEV and maintaining a neutral stance.
At present, the full scope and implications in our opinion are unclear, but we're working pretty hard to come towards a conclusion here. That being said, what I can say is our intention is to pass these MEV rewards through to our customers. Another interesting thought that I had is there's also just some really interesting concepts and paths that you can consider for different products that we have. right? So let's say we could use NEV, let's say hypothetically for Coinbase Wallet users, right? So Coinbase Wallet is like a non-custodial option where users can kind of like hold assets there and interact with different apps.
We could theoretically have like something like front running protection, right? So let's say for example, a user wants to send a Uniswap transaction, instead of going to a public mempool, you know, you could go via Coinbase in the block that we propose in a private mempool. So some really interesting thoughts there. We are still trying to nail down what our proposed kind of like solution strategy might be, but it's just a fascinating topic to learn about, to be honest. I want to throw that same question to Vasily and Lido. Vasily, can you kind of speak to the validators that Lido currently has and works with and how does the validators there, are they equipped to be able to capture as much MEV as possible and what are the intentions can you speak to the intention to the validators and how it relates to the state eth token um so you you can uh in that regard you can think of lido the like more or less the not operators union uh so organized not not operators uh i think it's pretty likely that uh lido will approach will adopt a unified approach to mev and enforce it across all the validators because that's like in the best interest of both node operators and users and stakers.
So I think that MEV extraction, actual extraction is something that node operators are not equipped to make themselves because it's something that's basically a field, a job where you like walk without sleep for three months straight and then you burn out and not operators are like the long game players they play the game for years and decades like so it will be probably looking like right now with mining pools and flashboards so there will be a service provider that that handles the extraction, the gritty parts of it. And node operators will be like doing the high level things like setting it up and maintaining and monitoring and maybe like doing the selection of the service providers.
But the service itself should be provided by the very competent and people who don't need to sleep ever. There is not a lot of them right now. I think that's where it ends up for most of the node operators. And it's more or less what we see with mining and MEV. Same thing I think we'll have with staking. With the one important difference, well, maybe two important things that will change on transition from mining to staking and MEV. One is that staking is much more aligned, makes the alignment between Ethereum holders and extractable value extractors much more strong. So it's essentially the stakers who decide how MEV will be extracted right now.
And stakers are ETH holders. And Unlike hash power owners currently who are, well, they mostly are Ethereum holders too, but in much less amounts and quantities. So the value line was much stronger here after the stake, after the merge basically. that will change the landscape because that changes the quotient and that means that over extraction of mov will be no longer in the best interest of the of the validators so that's that's one thing and the other that's taken will provide multi-block block reorganizations and multi-block MEV extraction. Right now, the only feasible way to do it is within the block, with one block as an atomic thing, but after the merge is in, we will know the schedule for block producers and the block producers will know that, okay, I've got three blocks in a row, I can reorganize the transaction for three blocks in a row straight and that changes the opportunities very significantly.
Does that make them the opportunities more like does that increase the opportunities for providers and in which way does it change it significantly? So right now a lot of protocols are designed with a with a certain mind that the only atomic think there is an Ethereum block and between blocks you there is no sure way to ensure that you've got three blocks in a row. For example, Uniswap based oracles, that they take the last price of asset in a block as a data point. If you've got only one block to produce and you don't know who has to produce the next block, you can't manipulate that because the next block can be your adversary.
And if you, for example, unbalance price, put either to $200 to force liquidation, the next block producer can buy it out and have you take all your money here. But if you have two blocks in a row, you can in one block unbalance price, get a top point on chain, and then use that top point to force liquidation. So when you can reliably string two blocks in a row, the Uniswap top oracles are no longer as secure as they used to be. And yeah, so many protocols are built on the assumption that one block is an atomic thing that can happen. happen. And that will be no longer true. And that makes that MEV more dangerous.
So what's interesting is on the one hand, the MEV becomes more dangerous in a fully merged ETH2, and some DeFi protocols are going to have to redesign around these new parameters. But on the other hand, some of what you said made me actually optimistic, Vasili, right? You said that basically you think that node operators won't try to extract MEV themselves, but this will be somewhat commoditized. And they might plug into solutions like Flashbots, which is actually, I think, a good setup for minimizing the damaging impacts of MEV. And you also noted that, hey, validators aren't like miners. They are long-term incented toward the health and decentralization of Ethereum.
So both of those things made me optimistic. Darren, what's your take on all of this? MEV, what's Rocketpool's design parameters and what's Rocketpool's take? So we've taken a look at this. We've done considerable amount of research into this recently, and it spurred a conversation within our community and also some of the Ethereum core devs as well. So we've recently posted a Medium article about opposition, but actually, first of all, I just want to touch on something that Vasily said. So he was kind of saying about the blocks, how the blocks are produced. So decentralization is especially important when you have MEV, because with centralization, the chances of collusion between validators within an epoch, this is Ethereum based kind of proof of stake, actually intensifies kind of the potential for evil.
So having a large centralized provider, having lots of validators means they're more likely to have multiple blocks within a epoch, which means that they can actually do more damage than either kind of on on purpose or by accident. So our position is basically that we wish MEV didn't exist, but if it's going to be part of proof of stake, then we can't really ignore it. We'd prefer it to be democratised, transparent, and ideally somewhat responsible. We're collaborating with Flashbots to see what that looks like. And we've got kind of some ideas around some mechanisms to incentivize the fair sharing of MEV rewards with our stakers, so our ETH holders.
Essentially, MEV post-merge is a very emerging space at the moment. So it's certainly something that's going to kind of develop over time. Hey, David, you're muted. There we go. Sorry about that. importantly with MEV and RocketPool, MEV goes to the actual person that is running the node, right? Not the actual validators or not the ETH stakers, but the people actually taking in the ETH and actually running the node. Can you go into a little bit more detail with how RocketPool plans to incentivize the RocketPool node operators to put the earned ETH back into the overall pool of RocketPool earnings, which ultimately goes into the RETH token?
yeah so it's kind of broken down into two parts there's like a detection mechanism and uh the actual incentive um so and we've got both incentives and the incentives i guess so the detection mechanism is essentially this collaboration with flashbots in the sense that you'll only kind of be able to do mev through them um with the incentivization and de-incentivization Essentially, if you do MEV outside of that, which means that you haven't shared with the RE holders, then we have a slashing mechanism that enables us to kind of slash them based on the activity. We're also looking at the carrot as well as the stick.
So we're also looking at ways to incentivize the sharing as well as this kind of slashing. does does the misalignment between rocket pool eth stakers and rocket pool node operators that misalignment with mev there's a little bit of you know the the node operators want to capture more of the mev and kind of want to hide hide the mev that they capture under the table while the stakers are like hey we want all the mev as possible does that misalignment uh concern you at Not on the surface. A lot of the people that we've spoken to would actually do the right thing. It's just the fact that because we're a decentralized protocol, we have to design for people defecting, essentially, for people not doing what the protocol requires of them.
So we have to design that into place. But speaking to a lot of people, if they're operating within the Rocketball protocol, they're willing to do the right thing. They're willing to share it with the Aihara stakers because they know they're going to get significant benefits from operating within the Rocketball protocol. One of the incentives actually that we're looking at doing is essentially like a staking or a smoothing pool. So very similar. So MEV is very similar to proof of work in the sense that you can get these big payouts every now and again, but you can also get kind of small payouts.
So it's very inconsistent. And so what we do is we put this smoothing pool together so that we can actually even that out. So instead of having like a, getting a lower kind of return, they actually get a higher return because it's a kind of a flat return rather than this kind of go for gold sort of scenario. So from a long-term perspective, that's much better. Guys, this has been just a fantastic panel. Mind-blowing on a number of levels. Shout out to the YouTube chat playing the drinking game while we have this panel. Yeah, as we're saying keywords, I think people are drinking. I don't know what the keywords are, David.
What are they? I think the words are private keys, trustlessness, and decentralization, which are really aggressive words to play a drinking game with. Well, we'll try to avoid those words in the last question so that people aren't too intoxicated while they absorb this information. The last question to the panelists, and I want to pack two questions in one because I think this is important. The first is, tell us what keeps you up at night with respect to eath staking. So that's kind of the negative worried side of your brain. And then secondly, what's the thing that makes you most optimistic about eath staking?
So that's kind of the bright side. We'll start with you, Darren. What keeps you up at night? What makes you most optimistic? So living in Australia means I kept awake at night a lot, talking to the US and Europe. But so thank you. Thank you for doing this daytime call. I guess getting RocketPool to mainnet safely and securely, that's the thing that I am very passionate about. And that's the thing that's kind of driving me. at the moment. In terms of the optimistic side for Ethereum, I think Ethereum proof of stake is a fantastic invention and has a, in the broader kind of finance sort of spectrum, has a lot going for it.
So I think that is something that drives me as well, the potential, I guess. Vasili, same question for you. What keeps you up at night and what makes you most optimistic about e-staking? I've got this existential threat as a tech lead on the protocol that has about 9% of staked Ethernet. When we launched Lido, we did a lot of planning for failure, for bad things, what we will do if there is a disaster, what the recovery process, etc. But it turns out we didn't plan for success. And when in March it hit me that we're just very, very big already. We've got a lot of stake. How do you keep it safe?
How do you keep it aligned with the room? That's what drives me currently. So we've got at a point where we are impactful and we should, Leida should wield this power well. So that's what I'm working for right now. Where's the optimism coming from? Are you optimistic about that on the other side too? One thing that is actually, I think, underappreciated, underplayed right now about the merge and it taking off is that Ethereum holders will have a much higher political weight right now in the Ethereum governance. They are now not just holders. The stakers are making Ethereum secure and they are taking the role that miners used to have and still have.
And that makes, well, that's a tectonic shift that is not still processed, I think, by the community. but it will change how Ethereum operates. And I think it will change how Ethereum operates for good. Ejaz, take us home with this question. What keeps you up at night? What makes you most optimistic? Well, yeah, I mean, aside from this amazing podcast that's keeping both you and I up, Brian, on the East Coast. Listen, there's a few things. One of them is a topic we've already covered, which is MEV. I just think it's such a fascinating development that's playing out and probably has the potential to be one of the most controversial for Ethereum, depending on how we all approach this as a community.
And I think that being said, it's such an interesting challenge with so many different possible outcomes. So I've been trying my best to wrap my head around the latest developments around that. And I think secondly is probably echoing Vasili's point. I sometimes like before I'm going to bed, literally, I'm thinking about, you know, how much we have, you know, staked. And, you know, I can't be mentioning figures and stuff, but it's just, you know, it's a significant amount. It's a non-trivial amount. And it just can't help but keep you awake and thinking about how we can maintain that infrastructure, about how we make sure that this is done in the most optimized and best way for our users.
Now, if I were to flip that over and look at the optimistic side, I mean, guys, similar to you guys, I've been an Ethereum fanboy for years now. In my prior role at ConsenSys, I used to be on the ground working alongside a lot of these different dApps and protocols. And actually, one of the main reasons why I moved to Coinbase is, okay, I've seen all the awesome innovation that's been built out. How do I enable it in such a way that my mom, who thinks I work on magical internet money and she's not wrong, can access and use all of this? I think ETH2 staking in general is just one major way to be able to do that.
We're seeing Ethereum's decentralized ethos and vision come to life right now. Being able to empower that is definitely motivational enough, I think. Hey, Jaz, Vasili, Darren, thanks so much for joining us. This has been a fantastic panel. We appreciate it. Thanks for having us. Thank you. Bankless Nation, ETH, the internet bond, ETH, the triple point asset, ETH becoming a capital asset. These are regular themes. Staking enables all of that. Such an exciting topic. We hope you got a lot out of this panel. I certainly did. I know David did. Of course, risks and disclaimers. ETH is volatile. ETH is risky.
So is staking. All of crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the Bankless journey. Thanks a lot. Also, like and subscribe if you enjoyed this panel. Make sure you do that. Take care, guys. skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a Bankless Premium subscriber to get the most out of your Bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks.
If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless Premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings, and weekly roll-ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks.