🇫🇷 Welcome to the Bankless EthCC 2022 Experience 🇫🇷
With fantastic guests from all corners of the ecosystem, this 8-part series is an exploration of crypto culture and the current state of Ethereum.
In episode 3, we cover the recent announcement of the StarkWare token launch, the exploding zkEVM ecosystem, and the future of StarkWare.
------ 📣Rhino.Fi | Massive Mystery Airdrop https://bit.ly/3o9trRE
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🚀ROCKET POOL | ETH STAKING https://bankless.cc/RocketPool
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦁BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
🌴MAKER DAO | DECENTRALIZED LENDING https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
🔐LEDGER | SECURE STAKING https://bankless.cc/Ledger
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 2:30 Eli and Uri 4:52 zkEVM Explosion 10:30 The StarkWare Approach 16:20 StarkNet on Ethereum 19:35 The StarkNet Token 24:30 Token Models 26:53 The Future of StarkWare
------ Resources:
Eli on Twitter: https://twitter.com/EliBenSasson
Uri on Twitter: https://twitter.com/ukolodny
StarkWare: https://twitter.com/StarkWareLtd
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome, bank notation back to this third episode of the ETH-CC experience in this episode. We're talking with Erie and Ellie of the StarCware team, and this is coming off of their StarCnet token announcement, which is, of course, the subject matter of this particular episode, but not the only subject matter, of course, there are many different things to talk about. I get their perspective on the ZKEVM's that were released, not from the StarCware team, but from three other competitors all having to get their ZKEVM release in the same week. Skrull, Polygon, and ZK Sync, but since StarCware is peripheral to this, they are a ZKEV roll-up.
I get their perspectives on this whole role and where they fit into this conversation. Of course, like I said, ask about the StarCware token, and then just really clear the air as to where will StarCware be in the future? Are they ever going to make their own layer one? Are they ever going to use it on alternative layer one other than Ethereum? And I'm too good at producing content to tell you that answer here in the intro, so I'm going to wait for you to find that one out in the actual show. But first, we're going to speedrun the sponsors all here right now so we don't have to interrupt the conversation later on, and we're going to start with Rocket Pool.
Rocket Pool is Ethereum's decentralized validator network where you deposit ETH and you get R-ETH in return. You can take that R-ETH into DeFi, and if you run a node, you let other people deposit their ETH into your node, and you get to charge them 15% for staking rewards as payment for your node operating services. Then you can take that R-ETH and use the Acros Bridge to join over $2.3 billion in the Arbitrum ecosystem. Acros, of course, is the fastest cheapest and most secure cross-chain bridge, and one of the safest ways to bridge your harder-and-assets in the world of crypto. And of course, Arbitrum is where you want to be, with over 35,000 contracts and 1 million unique addresses, Arbitrum is leading the way into the age of roll-ups.
You know how I know these numbers, because I watched Arbitrum's talk at ECC, which you should also go watch, but not before you're done watching this. But when you do watch that video, make sure it's on a privacy first browser, which is why you should be using Brave. It blocks all the browser ads, it's got a native Web3 wallet, and it puts the user first the Web3 way. You know what else puts the user first? Ledger hardware wallets and the Ledger live ecosystem. I know Ledger is a great product because I have literally 9 of them, and I have 99% of my crypto assets on my Ledger wallets. And the Ledger live ecosystem is all you really need when it comes to living a banquess life, such as buying with fiat, swapping, and staking.
But for the rest of you that are sitting on stablecoins, because the market is scary right now, make sure you're using a decentralized banquess stablecoin, may I suggest die from MakerDow? The most tried and tested stablecoin in existence. But with Maker, you don't have to hide your stables on the Ethereum layer 1, Maker is building die portals, so you can mint die natively across all the layer twos, so you can make sure that your assets don't go down another 90%, but you still get to go do all the DeFi things across the L2 first. And I hope you use all of these sponsors on your quest for going banquess, and now I bring you my in-person conversation with Erie and Ellie at the Starquare team.
Ellie and Erie, Starquare, what's up guys, how's it going? Hi, hi. Hi, pretty good. Yeah, exciting. Is this your guys? Not in your first ECC, certainly. Uh, actually, it is mine, but it has been here a few times, yeah? Yeah, at least three. Yeah. How do you like the city? How do you like Paris? Amazing. What's not to look? Maybe they have good food, right? Yeah. The current state of the crypto world, we're in this, like, bear market, whether we're whether or not you think ether at 1500 or Bitcoin at 22,000, wherever it is, is a bear market is up to to be decided, but the current, like, meta that we've going into is that we need to build our way out of the bear market.
We're not going to just, like, magically come out of it, we have to actually do something to get out of it. Uh, and StarCraft has certainly been, has down, guys, of course, started with StarCrafts, the proprietary app specific change, we would call them, uh, but we are now going into the more generalizable ZK rollups, uh, which is what we're doing with, uh, StarCraft. Uh, so let's, let's talk about StarCraft first, because that's the thing that's getting everyone super excited, uh, what, where would you say in the grand roadmap of StarCraft? Where are we and where are we about to be soon? We think about this in terms of, of, of three phases, overlapping phases.
The first phase is the feature completeness or the feature phase, uh, we're pretty far down the road there. People have been able for a good number of months now to build whatever they want, um, on, uh, StarCraft. The second phase is, uh, what we refer to as, there's the scalability phase in there, the intent is by the end of the year, to, uh, reach 10 times the theorems through put at 100th of the transaction cost. The third phase which started a long time ago, the decentralization effort, uh, and this is a gradual phase in where making sort of incremental progress there day in, day out, uh, this will culminate in the ability of anyone, uh, anywhere being able to run a prover or a sequencer on StarCraft.
There's a, there's a recent tweet, uh, from John Adler, which was pretty funny, because Polygon just announced their, uh, ZK EVM and then scroll announced their testnet, and ZK thing is like, no, we were first. Uh, so there's like a lot of hype around, uh, ZK EVM. I'm wondering where does, where does a stocknet fit into this whole story? Um, we, we, okay, we're proud of the actual in production achievements that we made. I actually do not want to go into this fight of who did something first. We have been operating in production for now more than two years, uh, using what some people call ZK technology.
We prefer to use the validity technology because it actually is not ZK. So, you know, our numbers and performance speak for themselves. So we prefer not to enter this fight, but, uh, or pick who is the real first. Uh, we've been added for a pretty long time, and I think, uh, the world, especially developers knows this. So I, I do want to add that on the, on the ZK EVM front, I think that the excitement is terrific. I think we're all sort of waiting for the real production systems to be out there with proofs turned on, et cetera. Uh, we have yet, uh, to see that. And that's a big achievement we're looking forward to.
I would add that in the context of stocknet, uh, one of the things that, uh, a bunch of people have expressed interest in and I think we're likely to see is people deploying an emulation of the EVM as a layer three settling on, uh, stocknet, which would be sort of, uh, as sure as in nature, right, stocknet settling over ethereum with the, with its EVM and then the EVM being simulated as verifiable computation layer three onto, uh, a stocknet. To what extent will that draw the attention and excitement of developers? It's a very interesting open question in my mind. Okay, so is that part where you can, is that where we get the EVM, uh, expressivity built on stocknet?
Is like, would it be a layer three, not a layer two? Yes. Okay. Yes. Okay. So the, the technical details are something that, um, challenges me in my, my understanding. So stocknet, not a ZK EVM, but you could do a ZKV EVM as a layer three on a stocknet. Is that correct? I want to clarify something that, that, um, getting, uh, emulating the ethereum virtual machine, which is what is often referred to as ZK EVM is not stocknet's end goal, right? Our end goal is to provide the best scaling solution for ethereum and we strongly believe based on our deep understanding of both EVM and how to build stock systems that you are far better off in terms of scaling if you use a different, uh, virtual machine and hours is Cairo.
So I think what's going to happen is that even though you can emulate EVM inside Cairo and this will happen, the real scale will be derived from native, starknet, Cairo written, uh, smart contracts. Okay, so this, I, sorry, I start to understand this a little bit, uh, a lot of developers talk, uh, with very frustrated tones about the EVM, uh, it, it limits them. There, there's the, it doesn't, uh, it's not parallel, uh, I know some of these words. Uh, I just generally know that developers are, are feel very limited by the capacity of the EVM. Uh, so if, if I'm tracking correctly, Cairo is something far more optimal, uh, and also more expressive and allows something like, like the EVM, which people are already familiar with, but also much more than the EVM to also achieve scalability while also having the Ethereum security.
Uh, I, I, I actually beg to differ in the following things. First of all, I think EVM, Ethereum and Solidarity are amazing. They are what delivered V-gold standard for a general computation blockchain. And Solidarity was, and the EVM were built under this set of constraints that says we need a Turing complete programming language that will be best fit for blockchains. And it's an amazing achievement of Vitalik and, you know, anyone who worked on it in the early days and advanced it since then Gavin Wood and others, anyone was involved in this. This is amazing. Now for better or worse, when you build scalability through validity rollups and in particular Starks, you just have a very different set of constraints.
And you need for scaling, you need a different virtual machine model. So Cairo and Starknet, they are not better than Ethereum. They are built to address a different set of constraints to allow Ethereum to scale. I, I want to add to that that the question of, of say, assuming the existence of highly performance EK EVMs, say five years out, the question of whether at that point in time, if you're a new developer, building some massive hit, whether specifying, you know, coding that for the ZK EVM makes sense or not is an interesting question, meaning that code as such, almost by definition, will not run on a layer one.
It will be too computationally intense for a layer one. And so at that point, will that be the optimal tool chain for whatever scaling solution, you know, is developers first choice? I don't know. That's an open question. And certainly, Stark X, the first implementation of Starkware, has generated some absolute hits. Immutable has blossomed into them into an ecosystem and just seems ready to roll into the world of traditional gamers with traditional gaming companies. And so their, their BD skills are absolutely insane. We had, for sure, the X, one of the biggest volume exchanges in, in all of crypto that's also decentralized because of, because of Stark X, I'd like to take a peek into the world of, of BD for Starkware.
Like, how do you guys get this done and why do you guys have so many killer hits? Well, we actually don't think of ourselves in those terms, meaning we, we would really like to be the technology developers that we are by nature. And so focus on the research and the engineering effort and the product effort. But at the end of the day, hopefully leave it to the people building on top of us to blossom and profit and, you know, sort of build all sorts of innovative stuff on and bring it out there. And as you mentioned, Immutable is a wonderful example. DYDX is, of course, they, you know, they've really built a powerhouse with the help of, of Stark X.
And so rare is a very interesting, sort of, real world application that many people have told us feels like Web 2, I, I know of no bigger complement in someone saying to us that felt like Web 2. Certainly. I want to add that even though I, I mean, I thank you for the complement of like doing amazing on BD and having so many successful companies deploying on it. And of course, we're very proud of that. Our feeling is that even just the Stark X systems have so much untapped capacity that we would love, we would love far more, you know, many more companies and entities to deploy on them. And I don't know if you're out there and you need scale and you like what DYDX or AIR immutable have been doing, then definitely talk to us.
There's a lot more room on Stark X. I mean, I think Stark X is wonderfully useful for the, you know, the use cases that we've envisioned. You know, for example, minting and trading of veneftees and so on. The mind-blowing stuff is, once again, we see that day and day out is the stuff that we never thought of and no one else thought possible that developers are building on Stark Net. And certainly, Stark Net and that generalizability and composability is where that serendipity happens between DFI apps, right? We all love the word composability in this industry. But I'm getting a hint that you guys think that the Stark X side of things, the more like app specific chains that are built for one company, each one at one time, also still have a lot of potential left in them that is there's no left.
Can you hint, can you talk about that a little bit? What's left for us? I can't announce, we won't go into the announcement of an announcement of an announcement game. But there are a whole bunch of things in the pipeline on the Stark X front that's going to come online in the coming period, which is very, very interesting. But once again, limited to the use cases supported by Stark X. Say a bit about L3. So you know, Stark X is going to move up to layer three. So what is layer three? Ah, right. So what is another Stark innovation? Which is it? Yes. It's another Stark innovation. Recursive Starks are coming to main net to support our production systems in a short number of days.
But so what is layer three? So instead of having the Stark X systems that today are proven off chain and then verified by smart contract on Ethereum. Instead of having that verification done on Ethereum, it could be done on the public Stark net. And by merit of doing it on the public Stark net, you could sort of conceive of these applications as having moved one layer up. And that's why we refer to this as layer three. So I think the first things we're going to see at layer three are the Stark X instances. And for those applications, the benefit is trivial for one. It's just lower gas spending.
So better economics for them and their users. I think we're going to see a lot of excitement on layer three with custom Stark nets. And I think that's where a lot of sort of the app-specific action is going to take place. I think it's going to strike a very interesting balance between offering sort of the best of both worlds, meaning the best of decentralization and censorship resistance and general computation and composability. And yet, at the same time, offering those applications, the certain degrees of control that they deeply care for, which are essentially taken away from them on a public chain and doesn't matter whether that public chain is Ethereum or the public Stark net.
Right. There's been growing interest in the Cosmos ecosystem lately, and this starts to look a little bit like... Cosmos, right? For sure. Yes, yes. This is a vision that Zaki described to us three years ago. And so the strategy is you have the generalized settlement layer, which most people assume I'm talking about Ethereum, but you guys are actually talking about Stark net. The generalized decay roll-up that is the foundation for the layer threes, the more proprietary Stark axis, right? Well, it's a two layer sort of foundation, right? There's Ethereum providing its security and support at the bottom.
That's the massive... Those are the shoulders of the giants we're standing on. And on top of that, we have the public Stark net. On top of which, the layer threes are going to be instantiated, yeah. And there's a growing conversation in the Ethereum community is like, okay, well, all these Stark X or general layer three settling on the Stark net layer two makes Stark net own ecosystem, its own vibrant, vibrant ecosystem. And also, you guys released the token details, which we'll talk about in a second. But the token had native fees, payment, and its own token, as opposed to something like Arbitromer optimism, which take fees in ether.
And so there's a growing conversation in the Ethereum space about is the Stark net layer two interested in actually becoming its own kind of sovereign chain that disconnects from the Ethereum layer one. The technical details, a little skate me as to how this would work, but is that a future world that we might see where... Absolutely not. No. We do not foresee this. We don't have any plans for such a thing. We are relying in so many aspects on Ethereum, and that's a strategic decision from day one. It's a four-year-old strategic decision, yeah, yeah. Okay, so there's no plans for the Stark net to become its own layer one.
What about settling upon a different layer one, in addition to Ethereum, setting a link to... We've been approached many times by anyone you can think of. Our answer is simple and straightforward, we're a layer two on Ethereum. That's what we've been building for years now, and we're very proud of that. This is where we're at, this is where we exist. And what are the properties of Ethereum that really make that true? What about Ethereum keeps you so aligned with it? Well, two things, fundamentally, culturally, there's this developer focus and mindset, that's a sentiment we share, and that's something that sort of runs in our veins, and we're very happy to see in that regard the fast-growing ecosystem around Stark net, which is really sort of developer focused and developer first.
That's really top of mind for us. At a more technical or technical economic level, the security offered by Ethereum is unmatched. There's just cannot be compared with anything else other than I don't know it, Bitcoin. I want to add to that that everything about our team and our technology, the way we work is about future proofing, so the technology is the most future proof of all the options of proof systems out there. The most future proof layer one we see today is Ethereum, so it's a very obvious choice. Yeah, certainly the idea of assurances is very, very important in crypto settlement assurances, but also just assurances that the ecosystem that you build upon sticks around for the long time.
For sure. Especially in these very nascent years of crypto, we were 12 years into it, but we know that this is a century long endeavor, having long time assurances is super, super important. Of course. Okay, so let's get into the details of the token, because the token was recently announced, and I have to start with this. Sue-Zoo accidentally leaked, well not accidentally, he leaked the details of the token, and then the token blogs, which were already seen like they were already ready to go. We released 24 hours later, was Sue-Zoo anything to do with the timing of when those articles went out?
Yeah. Unfortunately, it had nothing to do with it, meaning that was actually the game plan, and as you indicate from the three-part series, this was a well-thought-out sort of... Yeah, maybe no one will believe us, but the target date many weeks before was July 13th Wednesday, and we're working for the fourth episode. Yeah, I'd like to hire anyone who can produce that kind of content in 24 hours, that sort of clarity of thought and expression, yeah. And get everyone to sign off on it, inside the team. So did you guys feel like rugs by Sue-Zoo for... No, no. No, no. I think there in a situation of extreme distress, right in finance class, you know, the ear taught about the cost of distress, we're seeing this sort of extreme behavior.
Unfortunate. There's a part of the Ethereum community is actually very happy about the things that have gone down with it with Eros Capital because they think that the decentralization of Sarknet is super important, and so they're actually kind of happy to see that the tokens that 3.0 Eros Capital owns to be distributed amongst almost anyone else other than 3.0 Eros Capital. Is this a sentiment that you guys share, or any thoughts on this? I got to say the sudden Freud is not something that I sort of... Sure. On a more formal and technical level, the whole legal process that is unfolding with 3 Eros is not something that we are in control of or aware of all its details, or part of our party, yeah, yeah, we are...
So about the actual token launch, so let's run through the next week's months of Sarknet and the token and the roadmap for that. Can you guys, for people that haven't read the blog post, or perhaps they only consume data through video and audio, what's the roadmap for the launch process for this token? Okay, so 10 billion tokens have been minted, and their allocation has commenced. Allocation has begun to investors, to core contributors, which include Sarkware, employees, consultants, and developer partners. In parallel to that, a foundation is being set up, that once it is set up, I mean, it is being allocated slightly over 50% of the tokens.
And those tokens are going to be used both for user-driven rebates and provisions, around 18% in total of all of the 10 billion tokens. In addition, there are grants, and the foundation is going to have a strategic reserve, and other things that you also see in other layer twos and in other chains. Now, this is being done right now, so the foundation is being set up now. By September, the tokens which are now off chain are going to be placed on chain in the ERC-20 token. All of the tokens that thus far have been allocated to investors, core contributors, are going to have a four-year schedule of release, one-year cliff, and then gradually release beyond that.
Looking a little bit later on, shortly after they are placed on chain, they will be requested for governance and voting on upgrades to the network operating system. And then, next year, at some point, we will transition to allowing fees, and then demanding fees be paid only in the start of the token. And further down the line, within 2023, these tokens will be used for staking, for the purpose of participating in consensus and leader election for operating in a decentralized way, the system. And so, the economic model that I've come to understand generally about layer two tokens, it's like, Optimism, Arbitram is not, they don't have their token yet, but I'm assuming it's going to follow this path too, is that you stake the token to validate the chain, same thing with Ether on the layer one for Ethereum.
But the difference between the stark net token and the other concepts or strategies of the layer twos is that layer twos, Optimism, Arbitram, at least the generalized Optimistic rollups, pay for the transaction fees in Ether. But the difference here with stark net is that you pay for the transaction fees in the stark net token. What's the thought or strategy behind this? Why this decision? Well, our focus, as I mentioned earlier, our focus is on developers and developers first. And we believe that this mechanism that we've put in place, that would allow people to pay, via paymasters to pay ether for transaction fees.
But the native token of this layer will be the stark net token. We think that this creates an economic ecosystem that would give developers the environment that they need to build and thrive in. We think that long-term, this is the healthier ecosystem that needs to be built. I want to just add a few more details. So it's really important for us that developers further down the line, experience inclusivity, which means, you know, suppose there's probably someone she's now in college or, you know, maybe high school in three years down the line, she's going to write some amazing smart contract that's going to be really important and valuable.
And now, how are we going to find a way for her to have a say in the governance, for her to participate in operating the network? Well, the mechanism we want to come up with, and we're very proud of trying to innovate on that as well, is one in which a portion of the fees, and these are governance tokens, right? And also use for staking for operating the system are going to flow automatically to smart contracts as a portion of the fees being paid. So now this imaginary smart contract developer, she will start receiving tokens that allow her to participate in the governance and in operating the system, which can only be done if you have a native token and demand the fees to be paid in it.
That's why we're doing it. And we're, of course, like I started this interview in this bear market, which is also a build market, and we need to build our way out of it. And so just lay down the vision for how you, you hope that stark net progress is where, where are we in six months, where are we in six years? Where are we in six months? I think where we were six months ago, where are we in six years? Same answer. Writing code, deploying systems, educating developers, onboarding more people into the blockchain ecosystem, into the broader Ethereum ecosystem. That's where we want to be. And six years maybe also hardware.
Not just software. All right, well, I hope you guys have a fantastic rest of your ETC and enjoy play. So thank you for coming on. Yeah, don't forget the sunscreen. I think it's okay. Certainly. Okay, thank you. Thank you.