We are scaling out the crypto vibes, and that was abundantly clear this week. Far larger than any previous ETH Denver, this conference truly felt like a Schelling point for folks changing the world via novel, elegant mechanisms. We just can’t wait for ETH Denver 2023.
------ 📣 NOTIONAL FINANCE | DeFi's Leading Fixed Rate Yield https://bankless.cc/Notional
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
👀 POLYGON | LAYER 2 DEFI https://bankless.cc/Polygon
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦊 METAMASK | THE CRYPTO WALLET https://bankless.cc/metamask
💳 LEDGER | THE CRYPTO LIFE CARD https://bankless.cc/Ledger
🧙♂️ ALCHEMIX | SELF REPAYING LOANS https://bankless.cc/Alchemix
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING https://bankless.cc/UniGrants
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 12:01 Journey to ETH Denver 16:18 The Panels 22:37 Vibes
34:00 Kevin Owocki & Erik Voorhees 43:28 Pragmatism 50:57 Public Goods Funding
1:00:00 Andrew Yang & Crypto Alignment 1:06:31 Lobby3 1:13:53 Roadmaps & Executive Orders 1:22:14 Action & Optimism 1:27:45 Audience Questions
------ Resources:
Kevin on Twitter: https://twitter.com/owocki?s=20&t=O_vNoy9YMBatb8lIbf9ByA
Erik on Twitter: https://twitter.com/ErikVoorhees?s=20&t=O_vNoy9YMBatb8lIbf9ByA
Andrew on Twitter: https://twitter.com/AndrewYang?s=20&t=O_vNoy9YMBatb8lIbf9ByA
Lobby3: https://twitter.com/Lobby3D?s=20&t=q417PS_HIJMGmpXqJYhPVg
Take the Green Pill: https://greenpill.party/
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
I love that crypto technology has allowed that kind of thing to flourish, and for all this creative energy to go to these problems with technology that wasn't around a decade ago. Hey, Bankless Nation, welcome to another state of the nation episode. David, we're pre-recording this, and this is all on the back of Heath Denver. Okay, I'm watching from afar, so I'm the guy with FOMO, like asking you about all of the highlights I missed at Heath Denver, and you're the guy who went, spoke at many of these events, and can give me the Heath Denver experience, as if I'm there. That's what today's episode is going to be about, right?
That's exactly right. We are scaling out the vibes that we all experience at Heath Denver across the internet by reflecting and ideating about all of everything about Heath Denver. It was really, really cool. Bankless listeners will know that I shall Heath Denver every single opportunity. And I think the first lesson or first reflection that I have was that I had this kind of pseudo-O-O moment going into Heath Denver when I realized that this thing is three times bigger than it's ever been before, and there are so many new entrants coming into this conference. And I didn't know, like, is this Heath Denver going to be the same Heath Denver that I know and love, or are the new people that came in to 2021 going to actually share the same experience and share the same vibes of all the other previous Heath Denver's that I've been to.
And the answer was quite equivically, yes, the vibes were not just, we're not diluted, but much more insid amplified. And it was even more of the same Heath Denver that I know and love. And so I'm so like glowing from this whole entire conference because it was such a fantastic experience. That's awesome. So guys, David on Twitter said it was the best week of his life. So I want to hear about that. Not even close. Hands down. So we're going to talk about that. Also, we have some content for you coming up in today's show straight from Heath Denver. So David, what are we going to be looking at after you and I talk about Heath Denver for a bit?
There's I think two, two clips, maybe two interviews that we thought were worth highlighting. And we wanted to get on the bankless podcast. What are the things upcoming in this episode? Yeah, so there were two panels or interviews that I hosted on the main stage at Heath Denver. One of them was planned. One of them was not planned. And I'll talk about that one second. The first one was a talk which we titled transcending individualism and collectivism. And that was with Kevin Awaki and Eric Voorhees. Both of these two individuals are Coloradians, Coloradians, who are a very big in crypto and think crypto can make the future better because of what crypto has to offer.
But they think it does that via very different routes. Eric Voorhees is a very famous libertarian. I think he's perhaps a libertarian thought leader is a way to describe Eric Voorhees in this space. We've had him on the podcast multiple times before, both great episodes. And he's coming in on the side of individualism. And Kevin Awaki is coming in on the side of collectivism saying that it's actually collectivism is how we fund public goods. And so Eric Voorhees and Kevin Awaki have had friendly Twitter spats every now and then they go back and forth on Twitter and debating about whether how to fund public goods and whether taxation is coercion or how we can fund public goods using crypto.
And this is an ongoing conversation between these two leaders in the cryptocurrency space. And so this was the first time we've had this conversation able to be hosted in person. So I was honored to be able to to moderate a friendly debate debate, not the right word, but a friendly conversation between these two people that are 99.9% aligned, but disagree on the priorities of how as society we should fund public goods. So that was a fantastic conversation. Do you know those two are I'm actually haven't listened to this yet, but those two are the archetypes for this like dichotomy I see in crypto, you know the political compass thing you're seeing that.
So you've got sort of a quadrant and you've got the top two squares of this quadrant, you know, authoritarian. So the top part is authoritarian the bottom part is more libertarian and then you've got like economic left and economic right rather than rather than most of our political landscape is people think of left and right, but I also think like there's also the political compasses you're the authoritarian or libertarian. I think of Eric Voorhees as libertarian right most people in crypto are in the bottom part of of this box inherently bottom. Yeah, inherently bottom because it's inherently anti authoritarian, but Eric Voorhees lives in the libertarian right square and Kevin a walkie lives in the libertarian left square right he thinks that you know there are collective goods are public goods.
And I think at some level this can also be a dichotomy between a theorem and Bitcoin you often see that breakdown they see both. So that's why I think it's the perfect conversation because both of those two embody these two ideas in crypto that are unified and being anti authoritarian but have some. You know there are a bit at odds whether we're more collectivist or more individualistic and I think that's interesting so I can't wait personally to listen to that but that's just the first content piece what's the second David yeah the second one is the unplanned piece of content which I was just shocked that this happened.
And I was I just happened to be in the right place at the right time to seize this opportunity there was a surprise guest going into East Denver that was not on the agenda but as soon as he showed up in the room we cleared out the agenda for the on the main stage talk so this man can speak. And that man is none other than Andrew Yang decided to show up at East Denver a few people kind of had the idea that he would come but 99.9% of the people I need to ever had no idea that Andrew Yang was going to be there and he rolled in right it through the doors and immediately just get swarmed by everyone wanting to really oh god yeah like it was like a dog pile of people trying to talk to Andrea myself being one of them and this is right on the heels.
Yeah it's like hey can you like can we do it I lined up and made all the requests to everyone else was doing this was on the heels of me and a bankless content operations editor Luke we're going around East Denver with his camera and a microphone and I was just doing these micro interviews five to ten minute interviews of people's experience that's also coming later on the bankless podcast sometime somewhere or at least on the YouTube and so we went up to Andrew Yang is like Andrew can we do just a quick five to ten minute interview. I do about like why you're here and stuff and some one of his posse was like wait do you just want to like have that interview but on the main stage and I was like well absolutely and so we went over to the green room we went over just a quick agenda of what we wanted to talk about.
And then we just hop right on stage and had a 40 minutes of just me interviewing Andrew Yang on stage of East Denver and a little bit of a Q&A at the end of it personally an extremely surreal experience because the room got filled up and when I looked out at the crowd it was just what looked like a thousand people watching me and Andrew Yang on stage and Andrew Yang just absolutely crushed it he brought the energy he brought the excitement just like every time he talked there was applause. And so I was just like dumbfounded by this opportunity and now we get to showcase it on the bankless podcast.
That's super cool and none of this was playing he was just like a he decided to come to the Denver conference at at a whim just to see what's up see what the community's doing. Yeah well he's really found alignment with the crypto people I think in the world of politics Andrew Yang kind of has a tough time because of how middle of the road he is. And so he's like an enemy of both sides he's not he's not Democrat enough to be Democrat he's not Republican enough to be Republican and he's fine and but the crypto people don't really identify by those terms and also Andrew Yang's always been a futurist and also an optimist and if there's any two qualities that crypto has its futurist and optimist.
And so he's found resonance with the web three community and so he started what is basically a Dow called lobby three which is what he's announcing on stage and and talks about how he finds alignment with the web three community he also I don't know if this was this is the first time I've heard about this this might be alpha right where he talks about he talks about how the Biden administration in the next two weeks it's going to drop an executive order that is going to I think force regulatory agencies to actually put into. Create clarity about our industry and so he's got wind of this executive order coming out of by the bottom administration that's going to force clarity which is both scary because it's going to make legislation happen that is going to regulate our industry but also an opportunity because we all we also want this don't screw it up guys please don't screw it up I bet we'll be talking about this though yes a hundred percent now and Andrew Yang I think really kicked off that conversation at East Denver so really important conversation to listen to and.
We didn't get this in the video but this is sadly was not included in the interview but when he walks up on stage he just does it he doesn't even wait for anyone to introduce him he just walks up and stage and grab some microphone and goes it's Andrew F and Yang. So sadly I think you might be able to find that on the long the long East Denver live stream on the YouTube account but sadly that part didn't make it into. Does that work for you when you walk into your room it's David F and all. Absolutely not people just cringe. Alright man well we're going to get into those so guys expect a podcast in three parts first we're going to talk about some other East Denver vibes because I still want to pick your brain for a little bit then we're going to get to that Eric Voorhees and Kevin Milwaukee conversation and then the Andrew Yang.
But first David before we get into the meat of this we've got to talk about our friends at notional finance. Look man this is a fixed rate loan on defy okay was it a week ago last week the week before block five got shut down basically no new block five accounts can be created that is centralized lending and and borrowing products. Notional is a decentralized finance product it cannot be shut down if you still want your crypto fixed rate loan. If you want to earn some interest on your USDC on your ETH on your wrapped Bitcoin what else they got die you can do that fixed rate loan. So the terms don't change once you lock it in it's like seven point eight percent on USDC a lot of value locked here so four hundred and fifty million right now and I just love these types of products because like has this compared to a bank account.
How you doing in your Wells Fargo savings account David what's your interest rate buddy God negligible I don't even ever just because I don't even think that it exists. If they don't pay me any interest rate I would have no idea. Do you know there I don't know if you've gotten it but they send the tax the tax docs on like that and it's got a line of interest. I got I made like fifty cents or something a dollar which my accounts what you're going to do with that right. I'm going to I'm going to file with the IRS and show them that I made that dollar. So silly anyway notional fantastic product you guys should go check it out there's a link in the show notes.
If you want to earn some stable coin interest go do that go check it out. All right man why don't we start with this David because you wrote this really cool post kind of summed it up some some of the things you've Denver. Eight things you missed to eat Denver we'll talk about those eight content pieces and some of the vibes going in but maybe set the stage for us because it Denver has changed a lot since 2018 where you went for the first time I don't know did it start before that as well was there an eight Denver like twenty seventeen. The first one yeah twenty eighteen collected every single poll out.
Twenty eighteen three thousand people what you said now the price was six hundred dollars that was before we were new we were deep in the bear market we're just entering it. Uh eat Denver twenty nineteen four thousand five hundred people that was deep bear market territory hundred dollar eat the contrast point eat Denver twenty twenty six thousand people okay we hadn't really recovered but all the tourists left but still increased attendees by one thousand five hundred to six thousand people this is right before covid. And then of course nothing last year in twenty twenty one and now this year what did we hit this year how many people twelve thousand people is the estimate fifteen thousand people were given tickets and expected that twelve thousand people actually showed up.
This event was completely saturated. And like I said earlier I was worried about this just kind of like diluting the experience but no it just didn't happen and what it was what's not listed here because it's kind of hard to quantify is like the energy at each of each of these events. It's twenty eighteen had some pretty good energy it was my first one I didn't really know what to see how to compare it. And the energy was was infectious to begin with that's eight hundred twenty eighteen was why I dropped everything and got into crypto in the first place like experiencing. Ethereum and Ethereum culture first hand did you literally plan to do it at the conference like coming out of that conference we're just like okay this is it I'm all in no I was in twenty eighteen my first e-tember I was planning on going to the conference just to check what's up because this thing is interesting.
But on Sunday of the conference the last day of the conference I was planning on going up to Boulder Colorado to to our physical therapy school because that was my plan. I was going to go to physical therapy school. Well then Sunday came around and I was like you know what like physical therapy schools forty five minutes away and also this like that's a forty five minute Uber that I'm going to have to do to tour this thing. And also this Ethereum thing is really cool the conversation that I have a really awesome and you know what like I think I'm just going to go all in on this Ethereum thing.
Yeah and that and that was that was it that was it that was e-tember twenty eighteen amazing. I literally had this moment where I was talking with a one of the talking with a talker one of the panelists after a talk and just just share like shared brains with him for like thirty minutes straight and just and he told me is like yo whatever you're doing like you need to get into this base. And so I went and just like sat down and had this reflection moments like oh yeah I'm going and I'm going into crib. I don't know I still don't know what Ethereum is I still don't know what the hell I'm going to do but if there's no chance I'm going to miss it.
Okay so that was e-tember twenty twenty eighteen right like you said right at the cusp of the bear market and then e-tember twenty nineteen. We was like you know everyone was wrecked everyone was broke like there there was no no tourists. There was everyone had left but it from from twenty eighteen to twenty nineteen the vibes and the energy of e-tember was like twice as strong. So even though like our portfolios were just like one tenth the size the energy and excitement about Ethereum was like twice as strong. And then that pattern continued the next year it's like it got even stronger like the east price recovered a little bit but definitely was not out of the bear market.
But the vibes in twenty nineteen were stronger and in twenty twenty were stronger and then in twenty twenty two this last week they just absolutely exploded like the numbers of people that showed up exploded the types of content the number of stages. The who we had Andrew Yang was there and so like it's just a complete fantastic symptom or a sign of adoption when you have like fifteen thousand people get tickets and twelve thousand of them actually show up. That's awesome and the best week of David's life well let's talk about some of the the must watch e-tember panels right so I think we're going to be showing two of those panels two of the panels today.
But there are some others to add to your list me let's just go through real quick there's eight of them what's the first one. Yeah this is the first one was of course Vitalik's keynote speech was on stage for an hour so it's a long interview and it's titled steps to the digital state and then also an open AMA at the end of it. And so this was a fatalex main appearance at e-tember and it's all about just like kind of where we are in in web three and also talks a little bit about the city of Denver itself and Denver's role in in the city of Denver. And then number two we have web three in politics and lobby three that's the Andrew Yang conversation am I right.
Yeah this is the one that was about to hear yeah. Okay number three you've got listed the off chain internet with Evan McMullen what's that about. Yeah Evan McMullen has completely what I call has disco piled me disco is this decentralized identity app that's coming and I think she has really cracked the nut of decentralized identity. Decentralized identity is being has been tackled or has it been attempted to be tackled by many many people in many many different routes. But what Evan McMullen is balding with her team over at disco I think she's cracked the nut and her talk I think really illustrates why NFTs are actually not good for identity because think about this Ryan like your Ethereum address is public like everyone can see it but your identity inherently isn't public your identity is you and you need to be able to have choice about how you express that.
And so first we need to have privacy with regards to who we are in our identity and that means like not putting stuff on chain. She uses this line the space between the chains and so it is what we've we've coined the term the off chain internet so everything about like properties of trustlessness and immutability and verifiability but doesn't actually ever become a transaction on a theory that's what that talks about. That's interesting I think that's a space worth watching to well here's another EF2 panel as well who are these individuals on the EF2 panel this is the road to EF2 that's number four David.
Yeah came in Nava Alex Stoke and Alex Stokes and Preston Van Loon were interviewed by McKenzie Cigalos who I met McKenzie is a new to me a new reporter on the scene out of CNBC specifically covering crypto and I got introduced to her because somebody told me that hey like there's this crypto reporter out of CNBC who actually like knows what she's talking about and is very well informed about the nuances and the deep dives about crypto so not only is this a fantastic panel just to talk about where we are in a theory. 2.0 development even though the nomenclature for a theorem 2.0 is deprecated so don't use it but also McKenzie is somebody that I'm now paying attention to as a source of quality good crypto information that is coming from a more mainstream new source CNBC.
Does this mean we have to stop making fun of CNBC David. We can slow a little bit. Ethereum proof of stake in our solar punk future that's number nine with Danny Ryan what's this about. Yeah this is all unpacking the nuances of proof of stake and why proof of stake why we've as a Ethereum community elected to go to proof of stake. The the strengths that proof of stake has and it's security over proof of work and also just some technical explanations as what's actually happening when we take out proof of work and input proof of stake instead. And then it just has some great graphics and some illustrations that really help people reason about proof of stake.
Danny's actually sent me some of those slides and so I'm using some of those pictures in a coming article that's going to help debunk Lin Alden's recent anti-proof of stake tweets which I think are just inherently wrong and Danny's talk well is really good evidence for that. By the way we're having Lin Alden on the podcast in the future to talk about her proof of stake article and hopefully have some good back and forth maybe some good nature debate about that too. So Danny Ryan of course is like a primary person responsible for helping bring I'm going to call it Ethereum to but the next generation of Ethereum to to market or to to public.
The sixth is the transcending individual and collectivism individualism and collectivism which we could skip because you're going to hear that here shortly. The seventh is a self-shale so you you gave a conversation you had a conversation to crypto is here to set you free by David Hoffman what's what's that about. We actually don't have to talk too much about them that one because that's actually going to come out as an article on the bank loads of years later on Wednesday but basically the theme is Kevin Awaki recently wrote a line crypto is not here to make you rich it's here to set you free.
Being being wealthy being a prerequisite to being free so these aren't at odds with each other but it also talks about how in web 2 and tradify we have inwardly concentrating wealth as in things collect towards the center. But in web 3 and defi we have social structures we have defi apps we have web 3 protocols that push wealth and value and governance out to the margins and the key innovation that really unlocked that to happen is to have private keys because private keys allow for wealth to actually be routed like a mailbox out to the margins and what does society look like when we have a new equilibrium about how wealth collects it collecting at the margins versus the center.
So that's what that talks about. Number 8 what's this how to contribute to dows by a trache trache optics we've had him on the podcast he's all it's just always great using great nature and biology metaphors to illustrate how dows organize and then so he's just taking his experience working with year and coordinating with year to talk about how to contribute to dows. 8 pieces of content for you guys to which are already in this this episode so just stay tuned you'll knock two out of the way but six more for you in that and then some bonus things there's some some fun vibes so like you're part of going to a conference is always like the conversation that happens the different themes that are flowing through all of the people you talk to.
This this was one so Vitalik became a buffer corn what's this about. Yeah so the we have a mascot at East Denver it's Buffy the buffer corn it's a unicorn buffalo which we made up and it's as it turns out I don't know if he was wearing it 100% of the time but Vitalik definitely put on the buffer corn like suit and walked around East Denver which I think is just brilliant because you know when you when I had I had a little bit of this experience. As well so if people know who you are you walk around East Denver like you can't actually go anywhere because you get stopped along the way and Vitalik you know it's Vitalik if it happens to Andrew Yang it's going to happen like five times more to someone like Vitalik in a theory conference 100% and so in order I don't know if he meant to it meant to do this to dodge all of those people but I mean it's pretty dressifiable so he put on the buffer corn suit.
And like no one knew it was him and so he got to experience East Denver completely invisibly because it was Vitalik inside of the buffer corn mascot suit dude. It was so good a little a little sweatier but yeah definitely look at this before and after I love. Yeah so he actually had a panel that he had to attend and no one could find him but then the buffer corn showed up the buffer corn just sits down and then it's Vitalik inside of the buffer corn. I love this sweet my entire net worth is in this man's hands it's Vitalik staring down at a clipboard dress it is a buffer corn suit half-sipped up at this point because it's got to be sweaty in there.
That's cool all right another thing that happened is DevCon 7 was announced so a conference announcing another conference but what's special about DevCon? Oh DevCon I think is the other most significant Ethereum conference this one hops around the world so this one is in Bogota Columbia last time it was in Osaka Japan before that I can't remember where Prague I think. And so finally after a year and a half I think now of kicking DevCon 7 out because of COVID it's finally been officially announced October 11th through 14th in Bogota Columbia. It is the biggest Ethereum conference of all time every single year and so if you're interested in that plan out ahead because now we know the dates.
That's cool first time in South America as well which is kind of neat maker Dow became cool again the OG D5 project became uncool for a period of time but it's cool again what's that. Yeah this is my claim. This is the first ever party that maker Dow through and for those that don't know if you go to a conference is there's just infinite numbers of parties every single day and maker Dow through a party and everyone was raving about it. It was in this very cool church very cool venue the music was great and this it would not have ever been able to happen when the maker foundation the centralized version of maker Dow the maker foundation was around because they were so hamstrung by legal and compliance that they just couldn't do anything sort of ironic for a D5 project isn't it right and strung by compliance totally and well and that was a big critique of maker Dow in the first place where they had always they started off very decentralized and very organic like these 10 15 people that didn't really have any legal structure and then they realize like you know this is just going to go a lot faster if we just centralized this thing.
So they centralized it under the maker foundation which you know paid out salaries W2 employees stuff like that but then the maker foundation was dissolved about a year and a half ago I believe and ever since then maker Dow in my opinion has started to do some really cool things. I attended the dinner of like the 30 30 to 40 maker people and every single time I hang out with the maker people I'm just overwhelmingly impressed by how smart and convicted they are and loyal they are to maker Dow like all of them believe that maker Dow is the future which is something that I think the rest of the crypto industry can't really figure out how to wrap their heads around and I think that's because of the foundation the centralized foundation has really just limited how awesome maker Dow has been allowed to be but now that the maker foundation is gone I think maker Dow has leaned into becoming cool again so this is my claim that maker Dow is cool again.
That's cool all right another one is a alt layer ones buying love so who's paying for this conference is generally a set of sponsors and was that alternative layer ones this year were they many the sponsors there were many many sponsors and a significant number of them were alternative layer ones both harmony and avalanche were alternative layer ones are a few others that I'm forgetting that sponsored East Denver and this has always been a theme with a theory of conferences is that like a theory of killers or you know whatever you want to call them alternative layer ones have always sponsored them because they need to buy access to like eyeballs in community and this is actually something that we learned after DevCon 5 and I remember and I'll W from the breakdown podcast made this comment about how alternative layer ones need to bend like have to ask if the Ethereum community for legitimacy and and so this is definitely something I saw here at East Denver where alternative layer ones were we're paying their way into relevancy into in this Ethereum conference to a little bit to the frustration of the the Ethereum community who wanted the Ethereum leaders and the Ethereum builders to be on stage where other alternative layer ones had to buy their act way act by their way into and you know this is we've seen this before and it's happening again.
Alt layer ones buying people's love. It's funny. I mean somebody's got to pay the bills yet at the same time. Can you really buy love? Can you buy a community? Can you buy a legacy? It's hard to do. It's hard to do. It works in the short run. It's hard for the longer term. Also, bankless merch everywhere. So real stuff. This is the Dow punks. These are the Dow punks. Bankless merch was absolutely everywhere. It felt like 5% of the people were wearing some sort of bankless merch, whether it was the bankless collegiate hoodie or the ultrasound summer shirt or one of the many other derivatives of bankless merch that we had the Dow punks were out and forced.
This this photo I just took just because all these people happened to be around me all the same time. There were like three times as many of the as people shown in this photo that were actually out and about ethember wearing their Dow punk t-shirts. For those that don't know Dow punks is a project out of the bankless Dow and you it's a you know profile picture NFT projects that you know we all know like like you know board apes or crypto punks. But specifically built out of the bankless Dow but the cool thing is you get to have a shirt that has your Dow punk on it. So while they're all Dow punk shirts no two shirts are the same just because no two Dow punks are the same.
So those those the Dow punks showed up in absolute force at ethember. That's cool. Reminds me I got a cash in at least one one more my Dow punks for a t-shirt. Lastly a lot of bankless listeners think I'm Ryan. What did that happen? Yeah at least I think you are Ryan. I should say. I thought David was Ryan. So at least five or six times people would like like when I would they would walk by me and they would just like yeah like hey Ryan it's great to meet you. I love the podcast. I'm like no David. I'm David. You know that's you know it's funny. I don't know if I saw this on Friday or Saturday but a tweet showed up in my timeline.
And it was like I'm loving this talk by Ryan at eat Denver. He's just hopped on the conference stage and I look at the picture and it's a picture of you. I don't know how people are mixing this up. I guess we do look a little bit alike at least not when at least not when I haven't. It's just voices man. You know people don't know whose voices who. I guess that's it. But I thought I thought we had this meme pretty well instantiated. David is the one that goes to real glasses. And Ryan is the one that stays home because you say I like I thought I thought everyone knew this. Yeah come on. What's going on?
I guess we have to mean that a little bit harder. Well that's awesome. That's the eat Denver experience at a high level. I think we should get into you into the rest of these panels, these conversations. So should we roll with that any other parting words here? No that's exactly right other than the fact that East Denver needs to scale. There were like hour long lines to get into the conference. So it wasn't it wasn't a perfect conference. So like you don't have to feel too much formal, especially if you don't want like people were waiting in the COVID testing line because you have to get tested to get in for like two hours.
So what we've learned with this East Denver is that the venue that we've always used the the sports castle is what it's called. It's too small. Next year we've got to do the convention center. There's literally no other bigger conference or bigger venue that other than that one. So you get into that size. I mean 15,000 people's that's a pretty big conference. So for sure. So guys stay tuned for the conversations we're about to have with Eric Voorhees and Kevin Milwaukee is the first one and then Andrew Yang conversation straight from East Denver. Before we get to those we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible.
The Brave Browser is the user first browser for the Web 3 internet with over 50 million monthly active users. Control your digital footprint with built-in privacy and ad blocking. Inside the Brave Browser you'll find the Brave Wallet. The first secure crypto wallet built natively inside of a Web 3 crypto browser. Web 3 is freedom from big tech and wall street, more control and better privacy. But there's a weak point in Web 3 your crypto wallet. The Brave Wallet is different. Brave Wallet is built natively inside the Brave Browser. No extension required which gives the Brave Wallet an extra level of security versus other wallets.
With the Brave Wallet you can buy, store, send and swap your crypto assets and it can even manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps. All from the security of the best privacy browser on the market. Whether you're new to crypto or a season pro it's time to switch to the Brave Wallet. Download Brave at brave.com slash bank list and click the wallet icon to get started. When you shop for plane tickets you probably use kayak, expedia or Google to compare ticket prices. So why would you limit yourself to just one exchange when you trade crypto? When you make your trades you want to make sure you're getting the best possible price on your trade.
And that's why you should be using matcha. Matcha has smart order routing that splits your trade across all the various liquidity sources in Ethereum. And it's also operational on polygon, avalanche, finance, smart chain and other chains. Trading on matcha is super easy because it pulls the liquidity for me in a single easy to use platform and allows me to make limit on chain orders so you can set and forget your DeFi trades and they will go through automatically while you're away. So when you're making a trade head over to matcha.xyz slash bank list and connect your wallet to start getting the best prices and most liquidity when you trade your crypto assets.
Bank list is proud to be sponsored by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure. Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum that lets you trade any token at the current market price. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. The Uniswap grants program is accepting applications for grants. Do you have something in value that you think you want to contribute to the Uniswap ecosystem?
No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a unique grant at Uniswapgrants.org and helps to your Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. Thank you Uniswap for sponsoring bank lists. So if you guys have been paying attention to both Eric and Kevin on Twitter, every once in a while they get into a debate around public goods. And if you guys know, Eric is a very big libertarian and Kevin is really, I guess I'd call him a collectivist? I'm not sure if that's true or not. Anyways, while these two men have done so much for this industry and they are 99.99% the same, they tend to disagree on one thing.
And that is the priority of individualism versus collectivism. So we're going to unpack this today on a spankless podcast. And so I'm going to start with you, Eric. Eric, why is individualism at its very essence good and how does crypto enable individualism? Alright, well first I want to clarify something that I am only an average size libertarian. I am 5.11. So there are bigger ones than me. Alright, so rephrase your question. Why is individualism good and how does crypto enable individualism? Alright, so I'm actually a little bit disappointed that even answering why individualism is good has to be a thing now.
This used to be like understood by most people at least in America that all individuals are people with different preferences. And to respect individuals as themselves with their own preferences is like a really good basis for civilization. Somehow it's become an extreme position to advocate for individualism and one of my favorite things about the crypto world is that it's starting to bring that back and empower people as individuals. And Kevin, a very very similar question to you. Why is collectivism good and how does crypto enable collectivism? Hello. First off I want to say shapeshift is awesome.
Thank you for everything you've done for this space, Eric. You're a legend. Kevin, a little closer to the mic please. I love shapeshift. Thanks Kevin. Sorry, I love shapeshift. So your question was why is collectivism good? Why is collectivism good and how does crypto enable it? Yeah, so collectivism is the idea that if we, is that a lot of the value that we get out of society is from things like public goods and things that are in the commons. So things like clean air, like transportation networks. This whole space is enabled by the internet which was researched at ARPA through a government grant.
And so the idea here is that public goods are good. 80% of the value that we get from our lives is from public goods. What good is a Lambo if the sky is on fire and public goods are good and we tend to take them for granted until we don't have, we don't have them anymore. You don't realize you don't have clean air until you're breathing toxic air. You don't realize that our digital infrastructure is underfunded until there's a black swan event and there's a huge hack. And so basically the idea is that we're all standing on the shoulders of giants and even the most successful entrepreneurs in this space have been standing on the shoulders of giants.
They've been enabled by the generations before them, contributions to humanity and that we should recognize and respect that. Crypto in Web 3 allows for greater combinations of strength and intelligence to come together and to fund public goods. And I think that that's one of the really great opportunities within the space. Eric, do you think that cryptocurrency enables individualism more than it enables collectivism? Is cryptocurrency inherently an individualist technology? Yeah, cryptocurrency is absolutely fundamentally a individualist technology. It provides every individual with sovereignty over their wealth, their finances, and now far beyond finance.
So absolutely yes. At the same time, I mean I agree with a lot of what Kevin is saying. Public goods are very important. I think what we disagree with is how they should be funded. Just because something is a public good doesn't mean you need to steal from your neighbor in order to fund it. So I think that's where we tend to disagree on things. But yeah, cryptocurrency, you can tell just from this event how individualistic it is. There are people here from all different backgrounds, all different places in the world. They see different things when they look into the prism of Ethereum. And I think that that's a beautiful thing.
Eric, I want to make a counterpoint to that. So many people from so many different walks of life are all here. So all the individuals of many, many different flavors are all in the same room, sharing the same vibes. Is that not collectivist? I guess we have to define collectivism, right? There's a definition of collectivism, which I think is the dangerous one, in which groups of individuals are coerced into certain behaviors that they wouldn't otherwise be doing. I think the most dangerous forms of collectivism tend to turn into war, where hundreds and thousands or millions of people are literally murdered under the banner of collectivism.
Wars always happen under the banner of collectivism, under the banner of nationalism. I'm completely opposed to that. And so for everything that you can say about how the internet got funded by the government, yes, okay, what other things has DARPA funded, right? The same organization literally built the nuclear bomb and murdered 100,000 people in Japan. So personally, I want to find different ways of funding public goods than giving it the money forcefully or taking it from my neighbor and giving it to like the most atrocious organizations on earth. Kevin, do you want to respond to that? Well, I'm happy to respond to that, but I think generally what we're trying to do is create a synthesis, not a tit for tat conversation between me and Eric.
I guess I'll just say that there are different ways that collectivists and individualists define each other. So an individualist will, I think to find themselves on the basis of mutualism and cooperation, whereas a collectivist will focus on group goals, what's best for the collective group and the interpersonal relationships in them. And I think that an individualist would define a collectivist as being willing to accept forced coercive cooperation in order to meet those group goals. And that's the primary sort of like axis of disagreement is whether or not coercion is an acceptable means to an end.
And I guess, you know, the real question for me is, would you accept a 20% tax on your income to create a 10,000% better world? Kevin, we started this industry with Bitcoin, which is I think the most individualist part of this whole entire industry. But I also kind of think that this Web 3 phenomenon and these community-based organization phenomenon is much more collectivist. Do you see that the Web 3 side of the crypto revolution as we are currently in that phase? Is that the collectivist side of things that's coming out? I think the Ethereum, first of all, I don't know much about Bitcoin, so you can still think anymore.
Ethereum is a programmable, touring, complete, global, transparent and immutable substrate for human coordination. And when something is programmable, you can program your values into your money. And so I think that there will be different parts of the Web 3 ecosystem that will program different values into different monetary systems. And some of them will tend more towards multiplayer games and collectivist type things. And some of them will tend towards more single-player games. And I think that that's great. The great thing about crypto is that it's founded in a root of not your keys, not your coins.
And that allows you to fundamentally have sovereignty over your bank account, which is fucking cool. And then from there, from that foundation, we can build more non-coercive collectivist systems. And so imagine a global web scale infrastructure for funding public goods that is non-coercive. I think that that is the synthesis of Eric's value set, my value set, the synthesis of what's possible in this space. And I think that we should reorient the conversation around how to create a synthesis of safer punk values and solar punk values and realize that world together. So in search of that synthesis, you guys I think have both articulated a pragmatic argument, but coming from two different angles.
Eric said that we DARPA made the internet, but it also made the nuclear bomb. Well, we can create one good thing out of collectivist government efforts, 10,000 evils come after that. But then Kevin says that what good is your Lambo if this guy's on fire? And so we need some sort of government management or public goods funding to make sure that this guy is not on fire. Both of you guys seem to be articulating pragmatism as your arguments. How do you guys square this thing? Eric, can we start with you? I think when I look into the crypto world, I see people ultimately cooperating peacefully with no central coercion.
And I think it's a beautiful example of what public goods actually can be created without coercive funding. There are so many things that the public here use in terms of infrastructure, code, mathematics, language. All of these are public goods and they're not funded coercively. So I think a lot of people maybe just don't quite realize how much actual spontaneous order exists around them that isn't coercively funded in the first place. Kevin, do you want to answer that same question? Sorry, could you repeat the question? Yeah, both of you guys seem to make pragmatic arguments to justify why perhaps you should prioritize collectivism over individualism.
Eric said that, well, we can produce the internet via collectivism. We might actually produce wars as a result. And the trade-offs, Eric, and what I think Eric says, the trade-offs just aren't worth it. But then you say pragmatically, it's actually just worth it if the government can take 20% of my money if they can make my roads not bumpy and my air very clean and my water very clear. So how do we square these things when both of you guys are making pragmatic arguments? Yeah, well, I guess it just depends on what you think the biggest threat to human thriving is. I think that we're in this space to create a thriving of a global citizenry that no matter where you're from, no matter who you are, what your background is, that you can create thriving both economically, emotionally, socially.
And so I think that it really just kind of depends on whether you think the biggest threat to your thriving comes from coercion of a collectivist actor. Or if you think that the biggest threat to your thriving comes from global coordination failures like climate change, underfunded digital public goods, transportation networks, clean air and water, herd immunity, and those type of things. And so depending on which one of those things you think are the biggest threat to your thriving, I think that maybe that's where the chips fall. All right, guys, in your opinion, what's the best way to find a non-coercive way to fund public goods?
How would you prefer it be done, Eric? First, you have to define what public goods should actually be, right? So one of my main issues with government generally is that they simply get bigger and bigger and bigger, and they're always providing more and more things under the guise of public good. So there's probably a lot of things that Kevin and I both think are like legitimate public goods that need funding, but that's such a small portion of what government money actually goes to. So limiting the scope of what is an actual public good, I think is important first. I think we all know that if the only thing the government did was make sure the air was clean and build roads, there would be no libertarian movement, right?
That wouldn't be a thing, but that's not actually what your money goes for. That's just such a tiny piece of it. So yeah, I'll leave it at that. Yeah. I think the question is how do we coordinate to fund public goods, and one of the things that I see with the government definitely has a large administrative state that is slow and bureaucratic and way less efficient than a lot of the technology that we see in this area. I do think that one of the big opportunities that I see is with Ethereum we've got a transparent, immutable, programmable substrate for global coordination. So nation states cannot do global coordination around global coordination failures.
Nation states, because they don't have a transparent, incorruptible ledger for you to check on what they're doing, you have an opportunity for this administrative state to really grow and to get really bloated. And so what if we shifted the foundation of funding some of these public goods onto something that was more transparent and could not be corrupted, smart contract once it's deployed cannot be changed even if the values of the person who deployed it changed. Whereas with a lot of these governments it depends on what bureaucrat is in charge of administering the system. And so I really just think that we've got a foundationally better substrate for human coordination with blockchain based systems for creating transparency and therefore accountability and therefore we can build systems to coordinate without a large administrative state.
And maybe that's the synthesis of where we're going. I want to lean into the where we're going part of that. Eric, how do you think that this crypto industry's role, how does this industry play a role in funding public goods over the long term? Still in the very nascent phase of crypto, a lot of experiments going around. Do you think that this industry actually has a role to play with making public goods funded and safe and secure for the long term? You may be stuck in the past but my generation of crypto people are still focused on sort of the first mission which is removing money and finance out of the hands of government.
That is a monumental undertaking and is starting to work but it's going to be like a decades long process. I love that there are people now in crypto that have different missions and are using this technology in other ways so that's great. But when someone says like how should crypto be used to fund public goods that's such an alien concept to me because it seems like a question that might be appropriate in the future but today we still have the Federal Reserve. Today someone born in a certain country can't send money to someone else just because of their background. Today everyone here and their fee occurrences are being debased at 10% a year and until we stop that cancer I think it's almost futile to start talking about the public goods that also do need funding in some other way.
I think what your answer was just that money is a public good and government is ruining that public good for the rest of us by debasing the fee occurrences. I'll carry this cancer metaphor a little further. If you're dying of cancer you don't want to talk about what clothes should I be wearing right now. That might be important if you're not dying of cancer but when you're dying of cancer you stop the cancer. I believe that fee occurrences is a cancer upon the world and when that gets solved I will be the first one to start figuring out other important problems that humanity has to tackle. Is money the meta public good?
No money is not a public good. Money is a private good. It should be a private good. Everyone's money is belonging to themselves. We all use the same money so yes I have my money that's in like that I own but I only own that money because everyone else also owns that money because it's a global utility system. Do you not consider that the instantiation of gold for example is a system that exists all across the world that we are all collectively using as a utility of transferring value. When you say that we're debasing money I hear that we're ruining a public good. Yeah gold wasn't instantiated.
Gold emerged through the trading of goods by individual private parties based on their individual self interest. This is actually an example of something that is useful but that is purely private. It does not require government funding. It does not require it to be like it's not a public good. It's just individual commodity that individuals use as when they see fit. I think something like air is a much more difficult challenge because it is shared among everyone. It's very hard to limit and contain it so there's a lot of important questions of how to keep air clean. I think that's a fair point to debate.
I want to go back to the question of how crypto can help fund public goods over the long term and you have a book right there called Green Pilled talking about regenerative crypto economics. Is that another word for helping fund public goods? Yes is the answer and thank you for shilling this book about how crypto can regenerate the world that I wrote so that I don't have to. The reason why the book is called Green Pilled and not doesn't have the word public good in the name is that you need a lecture in economics to understand what public goods are but everyone viscerally understands regenerative systems systems that recover over time and our anti fragile when exposed to stress are regenerative and public goods are a subset of that.
I do not want to be overly technocratic and get into economics and definitions with people when I'm trying to explain how crypto is good for the world because that is a good way of losing people. That's why we're talking about Green Pills and regenerative crypto economics instead of public goods in the book. The answer to your question is that the atomic unit of how crypto can regenerate the world is an impact out an impact out is defined only as something that has a positive externality for the world. So basically that positive externality can be financial like get going grants creating funding for open source software funded 53 million dollars worth of open source thus far.
So not noncursively and so that is one example of an impact out another example of an impact out is I think like climate out is a really great example of an impact out that is tokenizing carbon credits in order to allow us to purchase purchase carbon credits using Ethereum and therefore pay down the carbon impact of not only the Ethereum ecosystem but eventually the entire world using using Ethereum technology and I think another great example is proof of humanity identity and the ability to transact as a human is is regenerative for the world. People in Argentina that because they have civil resistance on proof of humanity are living off of you be I fuck yeah that is the world that we want to create so the impact out is the atomic unit of how we build a regenerative crypto economic system impact because we have positive externalities and they can be on many different vectors financial material social intellectual shout out to Gregory Landua who is around here and talks about eight different forms of capital of which financial is only one of them and by stacking these impact dials on top of each other and choosing to invest our financial resources are intellectual resources into them.
We build a non coercive regenerative infrastructure for the world and I really hope to see this community at East Denver and beyond investing in creating positive externalities with the projects that you are all building because the book is called how crypto could regenerate the world and in order to get us to a world where crypto will regenerate the world we all have to choose it and that means all of you. I love everything that you just said Kevin because none of it is coercive I love that and I love that crypto technology has allowed that kind of thing to flourish and for all this creative energy to go to these problems with technology that wasn't around a decade ago.
Kevin when you talk about regenerative crypto economics I picture in my head a mesh network of many many systems that all have positive externalities upon the world and you rattled off a bunch of different categories where if we can make impact dials and all these different categories and they can grow to fill the void of the world around us all of a sudden the engagement in these things starts to come back to us. I want to introduce some sort of basal level of funding for the world around us as this mesh network of dials grows out and comes to maturity does that strip away some of the responsibilities that governments currently have.
We're not there yet and I don't really speak bureaucrat so I don't really know sorry. Alright guys I want to close out and change this conversation to something a little bit more topical which is East Denver you guys are both veterans of East Denver Eric what does East Denver mean for you. So I'm from Colorado and it's I mean for me it's been really fun to see the this branch of crypto which is a theorem it's become a major branch. Like come back to my hometown and where I'm from and for every for all of you to visit this beautiful state is just very special to me you know like back in the day when I would go to Bitcoin conferences it was always in other far off places and that's that's great but to see to see a comfortable circle and come back to Colorado is just kind of just kind of special for me being from here.
Kevin same question what does East Denver mean for you. East Denver is a shelling point for us all to come together commune with our collective possibility build the future and we are going to put Colorado on the map as the place to move to when when you want to build the future Miami's got nothing on Colorado David. I want to thank my two guests Eric and Kevin I appreciate both of you guys are here personal heroes of mine and every time you guys speak I always listen so it's an honor to be able to ask you questions directly face to face cheers thanks David cheers thank you so much thanks Evan.
You can find these apps at portal dot arbitrum dot one and you can bridge your assets over to arbitrum using bridge dot arbitrum dot IO in order to experience DeFi and NFTs the way it was always meant to be fast cheap and friction free. Gemini exchange has been my exchange of choice ever since I got into crypto I use Gemini to both buy the dips and also manage my regular automatic monthly purchases of my preferred crypto asset on Gemini you'll find over 50 different cryptos including many the top DeFi and metaverse tokens like Wi-Fi and Axi infinity using Gemini earn you can earn yield on your various cryptos including 8% on the GUSD stablecoin Gemini is available in all 50 states and more than 50 countries worldwide.
So if you're looking to upgrade your crypto exchange sign up at Gemini with Gemini dot com slash go bankless and get $15 of Bitcoin after you trade $100 or more within the first 30 days that's Gemini dot com slash go bankless. Andrew it's a it's pretty surreal to see you East Denver at an Ethereum Web 3 conference. Why are you here? First I have to say when I was running for president one of the first communities that embraced me was the crypto community folks who had a sense of the future had a vision and also a spirit of optimism and possibility and abundance. And so when I spoke at consensus a couple of years ago when I spoke at a blockchain for good conference I felt that the folks in this community were super aligned with what I was trying to do on the presidential and it's a thrill to be now here in earnest trying to contribute and help.
Because I firmly believe that the work that so many people here are doing can help contribute to the end of poverty in our time which has been my mission for the last number of years and I know a lot of people here want to take that mission forward as quickly as we can. Andrew I think a lot of the one of the differences between you and the average politician is you think in longer terms than the average politician a lot of the average politicians trying to get reelected in two to four years but you're thinking about things like automation and how do we support every single individual on this planet in an economic way.
And I think that's why you find alignment with the crypto community with the web three community can you talk about just the importance of thinking in the long term and how that sets you apart as a politician. I think a lot of you know that I'm something of an accidental political figure certainly there wasn't a lot of you're going to be president in the Yang household when I was growing up like that wasn't the conversation it was more like you know keep your head down get good grades cleaner room that sort of thing. So I ran in part because I didn't feel like our current political system was thinking long term was going to actually champion bigger solutions like universal basic income or some of the things that you all are working on like the next generation financial system.
And I think that there are real parallels to web three and someone who's trying to make a difference in our political system right now because there's an entrenched system that is doing its thing and is highly resistant to someone who comes along and says hey maybe we should do things differently maybe we can do something that's more bottom up the top down. So the goal is in my mind to take the innovation that's improving people's lives and help people help the folks in DC understand that this is not something that only will benefit a narrow few if we do it right it can benefit millions tens of millions hundreds of millions even billions over time.
Andrew there's a decent amount of in competency in the world not just in politicians but in our social structures the corporations things just seem entrenched and that has caused a lot of social strife and one of the things that I think the web three world is really trying to do is how do we build out new social systems. But how do we actually convince Washington that we need to turn over new institutions how do we convince the people the leaders of countries all over the world that it's time for change. I'm so proud to have announced this week the launch of Lobby 3 it's Lobby 3.io and the goal is that we can make a case to the folks in DC who are frankly right now in the process of writing these rules to have a fuller and broader understanding of not just the risks but also the opportunities and rewards.
And the fact is right now if you're in DC you tend to think more in terms of one side than the other. So we can translate the work you all are doing but it's not going to happen on its own. If you imagine someone sitting in an office building in DC and their approach to these technologies it's not just you know time zones away from this gathering it's like a completely different frame of reference a different mindset. So we have to invest resources in trying to bring the stories and the opportunities to the folks in DC as quickly as we can. In my view the biggest risk to web three is that onerous regulations come out of DC over this next number of years and push a lot of the development energy frankly outside of the United States.
And that's something I would love to prevent and I would love your help in helping me prevent that because I think that innovation and development should take place right here in the US of A. I want to learn a little bit more about Lobby 3 because I think a lot of the people in the crowd here who might be part of a Dow or might be part of some social community might find a lot of film familiarity with what's going on with Lobby 3. What is Lobby 3 and what's a day in the life of being a part of Lobby 3 like? I'm going to do my best to summarize the way you try and approach politics here in this room today which is you try and ignore it honestly right.
Like your building days your making these go faster and then politics seems irrational and tribal and inefficient and you're like oh please let me not have to deal with that stuff. Is that about right? Yeah that's very reasonable. I was right there with you before I made the decision around for President of the United States circa 2017. So that's the world that you'd like to operate in but you also sense on some level that there are now forces that are pushing towards much more direct regulation and oversight of Web 3 technologies and digital currencies that are going to be written not you know three years from now but in my opinion it's going to be measured in weeks and months.
The Biden administration is likely going to have an executive order that gets issued in the next one to two weeks. Charging the different agencies with a coordinated regulatory approach to Web 3 technologies. So even if you'd love to ignore this stuff and you know you want to just like let it someone else deal with this it's going to end up impacting your work at some point in this next little while probably. So the goal has to be to try and make it so that to the extent these regulations are formulated they're reasonable they're transparent they're done in coordination with industry leaders and people who are just trying to build from the from the bottom up here in the industry.
And that's what we're going to do with lobby three we're going to build a coordinated effort we're going to have professional lobbyists in DC yes but we're also going to be doing grassroots efforts in congressional districts where they just need to see this technology in action. There are so many misconceptions about the people that benefit from these technologies that we can show people in real life folks are benefiting from digital wallets from next generation of financial services it can help to shift the perception that right now is in danger of congealing into rules and regulations. One of the lines that always resonated with me and I think this is rampant throughout Washington is that if you're not at the table you're on the menu and so we all have a responsibility in this industry to be at the table and I think that's what lobby three is doing it's giving everyone else everyone here in this room of voice to speak about what are our values and how can we get Washington to align with them rather than just stamp out what the innovations that we have here are today.
For everyone listening everyone in this room and everyone listening on YouTube what's like the easiest thing that they can do to help move that needle forward either with lobby three or just helping having crypto be represented in Washington. Within lobby three join our discord you can go to lobby three dot IO we made it so it's very very accessible to be able to join lobby three down like it's going to be something that if you want to participate you should be able to do so. And bigger picture let people know that look there's a caricature going on around the communities that benefit from web three that isn't accurate the use cases are go well beyond what do you all think that the DC conception of use cases for digital currencies are.
Money laundering drug deals human trafficking you know that that if you were to ask someone in DC like what are the top uses like those three things would probably pop into their list top five and you all know that there are millions of other purposes and transactions that the technology used for every single day so in addition to getting involved with lobby three directly the single biggest thing you can do is spread the word about the fact that look. There are creators that are being empowered in totally different ways there are organizations that are able to govern themselves in whole new ways there's a technology that can.
Allow us to get away from frankly having these mega corpse have control over our lives in part because we're not able to interact with each other with trust and transparency and so if you introduce that and you can see why in some ways that there are folks that have a. There's a lot of political figures might talk about a particular version of the world or values but when they're presented with the actual possibility that that world could exist that they don't embrace it they actually sort of you know like shy away from it so it's a fascinating challenge and it's something that I would love your help with undertaking because I'm going to go on a limb and say the future of web three depends upon what we do collectively in the next 12 months.
It's lobby three a Dow lobby three Dow it's in the name so you know it itself will be a decentralized autonomous organization when someone asked me what the priorities of the Dow will be I respond to ask the Dow. Who are the other leaders of the lobby three Dow. So I have a team that I've worked with for quite some time that are part of lobby three itself you're all not going to believe this well maybe you will you probably believe it but so I actually hired a bunch of DC lobbyists back in 2020 to advocate for cash relief and the child tax credit and anti poverty measures. And I did it in part because it was based on an onion article I'd read in 2011 that said the American people hire lobbyists to fight for interest on Capitol Hill.
Think about that for a second and I thought it was the funniest thing I was like you know that the fact that we'd have to hire a lobbyist but I was like oh we probably should hire a lobbyist and so in 2020 I hired a bunch of lobbyists to advocate for anti poverty measures and now that team is going to be spearheading our conveying. And I want you to imagine if you were let's say a democratic member of Congress in that office and then someone comes to you and says hey these technologies can really help people if the messenger that's bringing it to them is a bipartisan think tank or an anti poverty organization that's like a different conversation then if they have something like professional like industry association in their name.
You know what I mean like like that's the reality of what's happening in DC right now so I'm happy I'm proud to say I've been working on anti poverty initiatives in DC for the last two years and in my mind Web 3 could be the biggest anti poverty initiative in the history of the world. Andrew when you ran for president you moved the over 10 window on a lot of things and you were the figurehead that spoke a lot of reason about new issues in new ways and it really changed the whole entire democratic platform regardless of whether you won or lost. But you are just one man and you have actually spun off and inspired many other people who are also running for elected official offices in different states Erica Rose comes to mind and if this movement of what you inspired whatever this movement is it needs to have other leaders it needs to decentralize because decentralized networks are impossible to stamp out and all that's needed for a decentralized network to exist is for people to believe in it.
And I think the Dow model is allowing people to rise up and allow this movement to be spearheaded by more and more more people. Is that the goal? That's 100% the goal David and Erica Rhodes raise your hand if you know who Erica Rhodes is all right so I want you to imagine a member of Congress let's call him Brad Sherman who really hates crypto. He's an incumbent that really no one likes honestly he's like one of those unlike members of Congress who's been hanging out for a while he is unabashedly anti cryptocurrency anti Web 3 he has a lot of backers in the frankly like the banking system. Now his opponent is Erica Rhodes who's completely pro Web 3 and she also is a compelling personal story she's an elementary school teacher she's half black half Asian she's a volunteer in my campaign who's now running for Congress is raised hundreds of thousands of dollars had a Twitter space with Jack Dorsey the other day.
So if you want someone like Brad Sherman to know that being against this industry is a political loser then you should back his opponent Erica Rhodes you can look it up it's Erica for Congress it's spelled A R I K. So there are different candidates like this around the country that in my mind the community should be getting behind now this is not lobby 3's work lobby 3's work is going to be go to DC and talk sense to the regulators but there are other people who are putting political energy behind folks who are fighting for this industry and I think that we owe them our support honestly. For those of you that happen to live in California 30th district that's your race so I'm sure there's some of you in there Andrew a lot of doubts in the Web 3 world have road maps does the lobby 3 Dow have a road map.
Yeah if you go to lobby 3.io there there is a road map one of the things I would suggest though is that the priorities of the Dow will probably shift in real time as the agencies actually put forward draft rules and a bunch of other things so you're going to want to be adaptable and responsive in real time. For those of you who want nothing to do with DC maybe some of you actually could find some enjoyment in learning about this process maybe I don't know if that's too far bridge. One of the things I described to people as you can actually game a file lobbying maybe you could say like hey like that you know here's a member of Congress here's an agency here's a this so the road map of the Dow I'm sure will end up shifting as different priorities emerge.
Because this is very much a right now concern the Biden administration is announced an executive order is going to come out probably again in the next one to two weeks. Do you know more details about that executive order what do you know about that that seems actually a really big deal. So what I've heard is that the executive order will say to the agencies let's come up with a coordinated regulatory response but it will not put forward the response itself just yet. So what it is to me is the starting gone it's like okay these agencies are then going to draft these rules and we need to have a direct line with them so that they don't write rules that are frankly very very onerous very heavy handed.
Prioritized managing the risk well over innovation and development and growth so I'm happy to say that we're relatively optimistic about the executive order announcement itself. But it should be a massive call to action for the Web 3 community. This is an all hands on deck moment. It really is I want you to imagine a world where eight months from now a bunch of rules come out of DC that end up pushing a lot of energy overseas reducing the enterprise value of folks who've been working on projects for years and years. It's all very much a realistic possibility. I also want you to imagine a world where rules come out that you might not love but actually allow you to operate and build for the long term.
And I dare say that if you were to have this latter scenario you might see the energy in the industry shoot up because right now there is an overhang of this regulatory risk. I know exactly what the approaches are going to be, what the regime is going to be, what the rules are going to be, even who the regulators necessarily going to be. So if you get clarity on those things then you can imagine as glorious as this gathering is here today in Denver you can imagine the future of this just multiplying over and over again because everyone will know what the rules of the road are. That's a vision I'm willing to fight for and I hope you'll join me in it.
So can you model out what we need to do as an industry to turn this opportunity into a W and what would we, what would also happen if this would actually turn into an L? Like how could we drop the ball here? What would we fail at and also what do we need to do to make sure it's a dub? Well I think the single biggest thing we have to do is know that as much as you might dislike politics a lot of you might even think like hey I hate the idea of any regulation. In my mind some form of regulation is going to have to be accepted and somewhat inevitable for the industry to mature. But the path of least resistance and there are people in the industry that are direct touch with the folks in DC like the blockchain association and others.
So there are folks who are advocating but the single biggest misstep would be someone also take care of it like I'm doing my thing like let me just focus on this for the time being. Because someone in this community has to make the proper investments and resources and energy and time and commitment to try and keep these regulations on the right side of reasonable. And I am I'm not sure if you can tell from my tone of voice like I am kind of concerned I'm actually going to pose this thought question to you all how much do you trust Washington DC to just get things right? So if that's a relatively low level of confidence then I want you to think about what would need to happen for you to have a higher confidence level.
And generally speaking the gap between where you are now that higher confidence level involves resources, investment, ingenuity, time, energy, passion, narratives, storytelling, broadening people's conception of what is possible. It's one reason why I love Web 3 so much is like this is a group of people that's legitimately building a better version of the future. And unfortunately there are so many Americans who right now are struggling with like this boot of scarcity on their throat and then when you say to them like hey these great things are possible they're unable to envision them. You know what I mean?
Like that has to be the biggest thing that we change together is if we help them see what's possible and maybe even get that boot off their throats then we can live in a version of the future that will be proud of. Andrew you talked about time energy attention resources these are all things that Dow's need so when you are growing the lobby three Dow you and the other other Dow leaders in there the organizers what talent or what resources does lobby three Dow need the most does it need capital doesn't need foot soldiers doesn't need developers what what could it use the most. Everything you just listed there David for sure i'm not going to you know to pretend like we are going to need probably some significant institutional resources will come in and i'm happy to say that many of them seem very excited about this effort but there were also going to need people who are helping us identify the stories to amplify.
Who are reaching out directly to folks in a particular community saying look like members of congress will respond to their constituents so there are folks that you know that are in particular parts of the country that could end up being very very crucial. It's going to be an all hands on deck effort and this is the single thing i would say is like if you think this is a problem that just some like industry heavyweight with a lot of money can solve like that's probably not quite what we're facing right now you know what i mean like you have to think about again that democratic member of congress in Ohio or Michigan or another part of the country like what do they care about what is going to make them go from being very skeptical adubious about crypto currencies and what.
We have three to being neutral and maybe even positive and sometimes it's the kind of thing where if you just like threw your weight around DC like maybe that moves some people but what would be most effective and this is actually in some ways a cause for optimism it would be people in their community benefiting from web three. And then if they're actually shown that if like a local community leader or an activist or a nonprofit says hey look what it's doing for this neighborhood that you represent that's the single most powerful way we can help turn this negativity around among congress members.
I think the web three community traditionally crypto has been very like anti-government we can do it ourselves no government but the web three community I think is a little bit more reasonable at least in my opinion that we want to be able to be better than the government but we'll accept government regulations at the end of the day and we've seen different leaders show up and actually lean into politics. Ryan Selkiss I saw him over there not long ago taking a leadership position what advice do you have for people that might actually want to lean in and be representatives of web three in in Washington or in their local communities or in other regulatory bodies.
There are a number of organizations are now advocating for sensible regulations blockchain association I just mentioned is is one lobby three will be a new member of this system but certainly if there is someone who wants to lead on this charge just get in touch with me or Kristen Smith or one of the other people that's actually talking to the folks in in DC because we need you we need you to lean in and help lead and I will suggest that this is something that's going to happen. I'm just going to help everyone here it's going to help everyone who could potentially benefit from these technologies I pride myself on just trying to be you know frankly like you know like intelligent about like how you invest time and energy like right now this is maybe arguably the most important area of investment for web three in my opinion because you're looking at a legislative window and a regulatory window that that's like very much open right now and if you rewind a couple of years ago this was not on anyone's radar you know what I mean like if you were to say hey we need to like shape this it's like yeah it's not really there it's there now like this is very much like on the front burner for a number of people in DC so we have to get after it right now.
All right Andrew I got one last question for you and then we're going to open up to questions so if you have a good question you can line up at the microphone and we're going to get there in a second right after I asked my last one. Andrew one of the things I think we align most with between you and the web three community is we're all optimistic about the future because we think we can build it better why are you optimistic about the future what makes you optimistic why am I optimistic about the future. I'm optimistic about the future because of entrepreneurs who are solving problems in front of them every day that that's what's made me tick that's what led me to run for president believe or not I just saw a giant problem I thought I could help solve it and we need that approach and orientation and energy more than ever because like I said before there's so many Americans are struggling right now not just Americans but around the world I don't know if you've noticed but like the world is kind of going to shit I mean I don't know if you all like sense that.
So you as my causes for optimism it's that things can change really quickly both positively and negatively so we have to take advantage of the positive as well as the negative we can't just let's say like oh things are going to get worse I'm going to do my own thing over here that's actually my challenge to the folks here together in Denver today and if you're watching YouTube find whatever. So let's make it so that people can see the benefits of these technologies in the real fucking world as quickly as possible. All right we just got about two minutes left so we're going to take a few quick questions ideally simple ones can you take it away for us.
Hi I'm Dr Kelly Paige from Digital Promise the National Center for Research and Emerging Tech in Education and Learning. I'm curious your thoughts on the decentralization of learner and employee data that we have in our institutions both across the country as well as our organizations and the emerging trend towards LERs learning and employment records being decentralized. Do you have any thoughts on that? Thank you for the work you're doing. I'm a huge believer in anything that helps create alternate paths to employment that don't involve four year degrees or traditional credentialing. Right now there's like so much of it operates in an antiquated system it's not serving people well people are doing what they think they're supposed to do incurring massive debt loads they're not finding the opportunities that they need.
So if there is a way that you can actually translate your value and data to potential employers that's independent of our current educational system and even into some extent like the professional advancement system that exists I would be 100% supportive and we need to do more in that area. Thank you. My question is about the Forward Party and if you plan on leveraging Web 3 within your campaigning or once you have members get into office what the stance for legislation might be. Thank you so the questions about the Forward Party I don't know how many of you know but I started a third party in the United States of America.
And I did that in part because the duopoly is not working it's actually turning people against each other more than anything else. And the Forward Party wants to be the party of technological advancement and progress so we're going to use Web 3 technologies at every every stage hopefully. My goal is that there is a Dow and again the joys of it is that we may have nothing to do with the Dow that looks up and tries to find the best opportunities for independent political candidates for people who are running as Democrats or Republicans who are aligned and we put our energy and ingenuity behind this because you have a failing political system.
You have failing systems of different kinds in America but the failing political system is one that is right in front of everyone 62% of Americans want to move on from the duopoly they just don't know how to do it. And I'm going to suggest that the people here in this room can show them how we can move on. Say look it doesn't need to be that you have no choice but to slump and accept the lesser of two evils you can actually invest in a positive alternative. Thank you. I believe we just have time for one last question so take it right. Cool. Hi Mr. Yang. I'm wondering if you can lay out kind of what are the gaps in Washington that the community can help with.
So is it knowledge, is it yeah analysis like what do they sort of not understand about tokens or innovation that might happen that we can all kind of help with yeah what are the gaps. Thank you for the question the reason I'm laughing is because like the gaps are not gaps the gaps are essentially a gulf or a chasm. So the average member of the House of Representatives is approximately 59 years old. The average US Senator is approximately 64 years old. The average member of Congress who's been in Congress has been in Congress for 10 to 12 years. So I want you to imagine that human and then if you ask them hey crypto currencies tokens like digital assets what do you think?
Like they have no idea what you're talking about and and so right now they're looking around saying what do I think about this they ask their policy team what is our stance on this the policy team then looks up and says what is our stance on this. And then they will ask a few people hey like what's a reasonable place to land on this the people they may ask include people in their constituencies. It may include bipartisan policy councils who are known for having like an even handed approach. One group that they may or may not want to take guidance from would be like the industry itself. Because the industry itself they'll be like okay like I kind of know what you're going to tell me you're going to tell me that you know like we should do next nothing.
And so that's the state of affairs right now. But if you were to try and put yourself in the head of the average member of Congress just imagine total confusion and you are there. That's where it is among the vast vast majority of them. Now that confusion can then be tilted negatively very easily by for example a press story about scams. You know if that's the only thing they see then they can head in that direction pretty quick. So we have to balance some of the things that are out there in the media ecosystem with some accounts of again creators having their lives transformed for the better.
People having new access to digital service like financial services they wouldn't have otherwise. I'm going to pose this to you all. How many of you think that the negative stories about Web 3 outnumber the positive stories let's call it 5 or 10 to 1. So that is the landscape that these lawmakers are forming their opinions in and it's up to us to try and lead them to a more realistic picture. Don't blame them just imagine that there's you know 50 to 60-year-olds who might only know about this stuff because one of their children or like a nephew or niece has been trying to explain it to them unsuccessfully.
Andrea and everyone. Thank you Dan for let's go let's build a future and it's not going to build itself am I right? Thank you all. Hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for air drops, raffles and unlocks.
If you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today. Also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me any things and weekly roll ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation.