🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: http://bankless.substack.com/
✊ STARTING GUIDE BANKLESS: https://bit.ly/37Q17uI
❤️ JOIN PRIVATE DISCORD: https://bit.ly/2UVI10O
🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
👕 BUY BANKLESS TEE: https://merch.banklesshq.com/
-----
GO BANKLESS WITH THESE SPONSOR TOOLS:
⭐️LEDGER - BEST HARDWARE WALLET TO SECURE YOUR CRYPTO
https://bankless.cc/ledger
🚀 ZERION - INVEST IN DEFI FROM ONE PLACE
https://bankless.cc/zerion
💳 MONOLITH - GET THE HOLY GRAIL OF BANKLESS VISA CARDS https://bankless.cc/monolith
🤖YEARN - YIELD-SEEKING MONEY ROBOT THAT FARMS DEFI FOR YOU
http://bankless.cc/yearn
------
Ethereum vs The STABLE Act | Rohan Grey
Rohan Grey is an assistant professor of Law at Willamette University, an Advisor to politicians including Rashida Tlaib, and one of the authors of the STABLE Act, which wants to impose Federal Bank Chartering upon any stablecoin issuer.
Interesting, this proposed legislation includes entities like Square's Cash App or PayPal! Anything that offers a claim on 1 Dollar is cited by this law.
Rohan and the STABLE Act appear to be an outgrowth of the rise of MMT and the power and ability of the state to solve economic problems like poverty and joblessness. Rohan wants to protect 'money', which he believes is a public institution that needs protecting!
Also interestingly, the goals of the STABLE Act and DeFi are highly similar, yet are opposing in their strategies for achieving these goals.
Tune into the conversation to learn about a diversity of perspectives regarding how to protect money!
The STABLE Act:
https://tlaib.house.gov/media/press-releases/tlaib-garcia-and-lynch-stableact
Coin Center's comment on the STABLE Act:
https://www.coincenter.org/the-unintended-consequences-of-the-stable-act/
------
Don't stop at the video!
Subscribe to the Bankless newsletter program
http://bankless.substack.com/
Visit the official Bankless website for resources
http://banklesshq.com/
Follow Bankless on Twitter
https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ
Follow Ryan on Twitter|
https://twitter.com/ryansadams
Follow David on Twitter
https://twitter.com/TrustlessState
-----
Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time we may add links in this channel to products we use. We may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. We'll always disclose when this is the case
No summary for this episode yet.
If you want to live a bankless life, you need to get a hardware wallet. There is no alternative for storing your crypto in a self-sovereign fashion. That's why I have four ledgers that I use to manage my different crypto assets using the ledger live account as well. Your live is like your home base for managing your Ethereum, DeFi, and crypto accounts. It does a really good job of aggregating all of your different Ethereum wallets if you are the type of person that uses more than one, but you can also add other cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin or Cosmos or whatever your preferred blockchain is, and then it will display an aggregate portfolio of all your accounts at the main page.
One thing that ledger is doing a really good job of is enabling all the money verbs that me and Ryan talk about with the bankless skill cube enabled in the ledger live app. Right now in the ledger live app, you can buy, sell, lend, swap, and stake your crypto assets, which is doing a really good job of fulfilling all of the money verbs in the bankless skill cube. Something that's new to ledger live is ledger swap, where you can swap assets one for another directly inside the ledger live application, ensuring trustlessness in your financial activity on Ethereum and on Bitcoin. If you want to learn more about what you can do with a ledger, go to the blog post, the power of ledger live on the ledger website, where they share some of the more advanced things that you can do with your ledger that you might not have known about.
There's a link in the show notes that will take you to the ledger shop where you can get your preferred ledger hardware wallets. I personally like the ledger Nano X, but I also have both, they're both great options. When you own a ledger, you own your own assets in the way that they have been designed to be held by the user and the user alone. So go get your ledger today to make sure that you are as self-sovereign as possible. The bankless state of the nations are brought to you by Wired. Wired is DeFi's first self-building community run project, which I just get really, really excited about.
Wired is a system that seeks out yield in DeFi, and it does that in a number of different ways. A very aggressive way is with the vaults, where you can deposit your preferred asset of choice, and different DeFi experts will come in and generate a strategy for what to do with your deposited token, right? And so it'll go find ways to get yield in that deposited token in DeFi. For those who want to just earn yield on their stable coins, the earned system is for you, where you can deposit your preferred stable coin, and Wired will go and figure out which money market on DeFi and DeFi is producing the best interest rate, whether it's DUIDX, it's compound, or AVE, it looks around DeFi to see where the yield is coming from, and it directs stable coins automatically, so you don't have to.
Check them out at YERN.finance to get started, and also check out this stats page to see what other people are doing as well. Bankless Nation, we are super excited to have Rowan Gray here. He is the assistant professor of law at Willamette University. He is the president of the Modern Money Network, he's advisor to politicians, including Rashida Taleb, and he's one of the authors of the stable act we recently had a state-of-the-nation show with Coin Center where we brought this up, and they said, why don't you bring Rowan on the show so he can speak for himself? So that's what we're doing. We're bringing Rowan on the show to talk a little bit about the stable act in some of his core beliefs.
Rowan, welcome, Bankless, it's great to have you. How are you doing, sir? Thanks for having me. Well, I'm still alive, so you know, that's a bit of a problem, but I appreciate you having me on. I'm just surviving the tsunami of Twitter DMs and, you know, terrible comments, I'm I'm sure. Yeah, flaming bags of dog shit on my, on my loan that was standing every day. Metaphorically speaking, well, who is it? Was it Balaji recently, David, who, who talked about, or was it, what of our guests talked recently about, like Twitter being sort of like the, like the French revolution, right? Where there's, like, the French forks, French cheese down and guillotine the entire time.
It's very much in my experience, I'm sure it's yours lately as well, but we are not here to do that. What we want to find out, Rowan, is what some of your, maybe, people start there at your first principles. So, David and I, the Bankless Nation, the Bankless program has a variety of first principles, reasons why we are in this space. We describe it in various ways. One, of course, is like more self-sovereignty to the people, more power to the people away from the institutions that have historically controlled our lives. For us, it's very much about a public good, a public infrastructure that we are creating, a public money system that's accessible to the world, and that is credibly neutral.
These are some of the principles that, undergird the Bankless movements, we'd call it in crypto and DeFi, a subset of that movement, but let's talk about you first. What are some of your first principles? Why are you doing what you do? Why do you care so much? What is the foundation of your belief system? Yeah, well, thanks. That's a good question. I mean, the first thing is that I'm, you know, I'm a leftist, I'm a progressive. So the people who don't want to take any value in that can sort of tune out here. But I believe pretty deeply in individual sort of freedom and individual empowerment.
And I think there's a role for monetary systems to play in empowering individuals and in sort of allocating social resources and structuring the social provisioning process. A lot of what I focus on are the ways in which public institutions, undergird markets, undergird systems of production, and to sort of trace back or peel back the layers of what may seem to be sort of neutral or decentralized or sort of free market processes to look at the structures that underpin them and that govern them where there is some sort of actor who is exercising some sort of power. And to try to look at how we can make those systems more democratic and more accountable to average people, not just people who are born into privilege and wealth and access to means and things like that.
I'm an Australian, as you can probably tell by my accent, I moved to the United States in part because I am pretty acutely aware of how imperialism works in the modern age and there's not really much attempt to much use in trying to change the world from Australia, at least in public policy when the United States can pretty much exercise a veto in anything that we do. So if you're living in ancient Rome and you wanted to make change, probably going to Rome was the starting point and I moved to a point where I was about 15 minutes away from Wall Street after living in DC so you can sort of take what you will from that in terms of where I see the power line, not because I have any love for bankers or anything like that because that's sort of where in the modern global economy that this sort of power lies.
I think probably where we disagree and maybe a good starting point is just I think I have a very different theory of where money comes from and where it's value derives from. I don't think that it comes from sort of markets. I don't think it comes from some sort of technology of a meeting maybe exchange or some sort of commodity that solves butter and a double coincidence of once. Those were certainly ideas that I was introduced to as at a young age and through sort of standard economics education and the more I looked into it, the more I looked into the history, the anthropology, the legal history and the sort of legal institutions behind those systems, it became clear to me that that was a myth and largely propaganda and once I started looking at where money actually comes from and how it actually operates throughout history and large advanced societies, it led me to the kind of understanding of money that I have today and the kinds of attempts to make change that I do today.
I care about things like private anonymous cash. For example, I care very deeply about and I care very deeply about how to make sure in a digital world those kinds of features get retained but I think where I would disagree with a lot of people in your community paths is the idea that we can achieve that without it being a fiat instrument, without it being a tool of public money and I think that that's probably why I think that a lot of the work that's going on in the crypto world is a distraction and a wasted energy and that the real fight, the real struggle will be over anonymous digital public cash which is where I think we should all be focusing.
So we want to get to that, we want to talk about that a little bit, even including kind of your description of like the history of money and where it came from, I wouldn't say that David and I are necessarily of the cut of the cloth of hardcore Austrians, like you might see many in the crypto space. So I would say that we are like also very open to the idea that the money is not just like from a barter system that it is kind of a debt type instrument. It's definitely a social construct very open to that idea. So you might actually find less divergence of the opinion there, but we did it in higher podcasts on that concept is actually one of our very first podcasts where we kind of went through like the the barter myth and instead the how money was created by a community where they created a depository institution, right?
Like I win the in the podcast, I called it a granary, right? A place where you know farmers come and deposit their food, right? And then their deposits were given credits and that's basically the formation of a money by a social system that when you scale that up, you create a nation state with it with a with a fiat, right? And I think that's kind of how well where you're coming from Rowan, where that's kind of more or less how money is made. But before we even get there, David, you know, like I definitely want to get there, but I actually want to hear more about Rowan on kind of the problem statement today, right?
So before we get to that, let's talk about Rowan, what do you think the problems actually are with today's money system? Because we have a nation state controlled money system. We have fiat, like fiat one, that is the reserve of the world. What's wrong with it today? Why, like does it need to be changed? What's not working for the people? That's a great question as well. I mean, I think the first thing is that we haven't sort of created a democratic society and then created money out of that as a democratic system. We had systems of empire, of warlords, of white supremacy, of slavery-based economies, of feudalism, and we fought sort of tooth and nail to carve out pockets of public accountability democratic institutions that are very fragile.
I think we're seeing that right now around the world with the rise of strongmen or theoritarians. I think we're seeing that right now, even the United States with things going on that, if we don't keep actively fighting for those and expanding them, they're going to contract again. And that the default throughout history is that most of these sort of governing institutions have not been democratically accountable. It's not that we start with sort of public democracy and then wonder what happened. And so what I think we saw after the post-war era was a kind of moment where the energy pushed towards more democratic accountability with some notable kind of exceptions, particularly including things like race in the United States.
There was a very kind of white bent to the new deal kind of compromise. And of course, an imperial bent outside of the US with the Marshall Plan. But if you look at what happened probably from about the 1970s onwards, there was a kind of empire strikes back. And historians are political economy and others will call out the kind of neoliberal era. But what it was was an attempt to re-naturalize money and the economy as something that exists as a product of markets and quote unquote private enterprise. And that was a very successful propagandistic effort. People have sort of documented the big money from rich people and companies that went into constructing that, to buying up university departments, to building narratives in the media.
And the narrative that we have today is that money is not a public good. It is something that comes from markets that the sort of dominant metaphor in public finance is the taxpayer. Because where does money come from? It comes from somebody who pays taxes. Well, that kind of begs the question of where did the money to pay taxes come from? It had to actually been created before it could be paid in taxes. But if you start with the idea that money grows on taxpayers or grows on people, then you end up with sort of Margaret Tatch's world where there is no such thing as public money. There's only taxpayer money.
And I think that's the world in which we live today where public policy is being constructed on the basis that money is scarce. That investment has to rob Peter to pay Paul. That yes, in theory, there is sort of productivity gain from efficiency or from full employment. But in most contexts, zero sum game, no free lunch thinking is the dominant way of thinking. And that private investment can do things that public investment can't. So I think that's the dominant starting point. And the other big narrative, I would say, which is a little bit away from what we sort of think about in this conversation with money, but not that far away, is the fight over full employment, the fight over what it means to be a worker in the economy and to add value where we had debates in the 1940s, and then again in the 1970s about guaranteeing everyone a right to participate in the economy and to add value through their labor.
And we're still fighting that fight today. We have millions of people unemployed who would love to earn money, who would love to contribute to some collectives to common good, who can't do it, because we have not got a full employment economy where there's more work to be done than people to do it. I mean, there is work to be done, but we not paying people to do it. So I think the failure of full employment, the neoliberalisation of finance and money, and the kind of dominance of private interest in collective governance is where I would see the problem today. On that last point, the dominance of like private interests, like what we would talk about is probably the dominance of banker interests, whether that's commercial banks, whether that's other forms of plutocrats, plutocracy, you know, kleptocrats, we might say, but also central banks.
So one of the like the Ephesus and Bankless and in the crypto world writ large is that like the contillion effect or the cancel on effect, as some call it, is basically positions the kleptocrats and the plutocrats in those in charge closest to the money spicket. And so when they start printing money, like buying back bonds or purchasing stocks or quantitative easing injecting it into the economy, the recipients of those funds are those who hold assets. So if you hold stocks, if you hold real estate, you know, if you hold crypto even, you are a recipient of that inflation and that issuance, it's not necessarily going to the people.
And that has led to massive wealth inequality among a number of other factors over the past couple of decades and is continuing to increase. Is that a problem that you see as well? Because for us in crypto and in banklets, right? Like that's the state doing something that is not good for the people. That's the state implementing monetary policy decisions that are actually benefiting the wealthy and the bankers. And excluding the people, is that a criticism that you see as well? Yeah, so there's one little technical curve which we don't have to go into, which is I don't think quantitative easing is necessarily all kind of monetizing government debt is the moment where a lot of this necessarily happens because I think if you look at government debt as a form of money, then there's actually a separate layer going on there.
And the reason I start with that is because I think where I look at this and see a problem is that central banks are one institution in the public system. And that institution is built and constructed in a certain way to give bankers basically direct access and to put their interests in the interests of what we might call free enterprise above other democratic considerations. And so I spend a lot of time you can search my Twitter record and things complaining about the 1951 Treasury Fed Accord where up until that point, the expectation was that the Treasury that is to say the Secretary directly accountable to an elected president would be able to determine interest rates and to do to basically sort of have dominance over the Fed.
And there was an institutional fight between the Treasury and the Fed at that point where the Fed representing certain free enterprise interests aggressively pushed to take that power back. And it came down to literally somebody being sick in hospital on one side of that fight and the other guy double crossing them basically. Like it was a it was a knife edge historical turning point. And now if you read macroeconomic theory, you read central banker reports, they'll say central bank independence, the ability to set interest rates according to how we think should be done over elected representatives is a critical bullwalk against government spending run a mark.
So the entire edifice of central banking today is built on a fundamental distrust of elected officials and people representing the interests of the public. Now you can take that lesson that the government is corrupt and that any kind of public governance is corrupt or you can take that lesson that the private banking interest won a critical fight against democracy and that we've gone on a bad direction there. And I take that second view. So I completely agree with you that central banks today are a reactionary tool of class interest against the public. But I think the lesser there is we shouldn't seed public governance to those actors in the same way as we shouldn't have seeded it to the futilists or to the slave owners, right?
That there needs to be in a re litigation or central bank supremacy within public finance. And if you look at for example bills we've worked on with Rashida to lead, we proposed minting a trillion dollar coin which caused some people's heads to explode, which was kind of but the point there was the treasury would issue that you can again look at look at all the resources that we put out about that. We called it fiscal money for fiscal policy. We don't need to come with our hand out to the central bank. We don't need to ask them for permission. We don't need to issue treasury securities which people are going to misunderstand and think as debt is something different from money.
I don't think it is different from money but it's it's easy for people to get confused because they think of it like their own debt. But we don't need any of that. If the government wants to spend on emergency cash relief to every single person which was the first bill I worked on with Congresswoman to leave, then the way to do that is issue the money and give it to people and do that through elected officials and through their representatives and leave these central bankers to their bullshit and don't let them be gatekeepers to good public macroeconomic policy. So I probably agree on the diagnosis but I'm not sure we agree on the solution.
That's probably true and by the way I do think there's a third option there, right? So you've got a corruptible bankers and corruptible politicians and you said you had to pick one or the others. We kind of think both become corrupted over time through the money system but I'll let David jump in with a follow-up here. We'll get more to that later. Yeah, I think this is actually where we could start to tease like the more concrete components of this conversation with growth specifically with the stable act but also Rowan with the problems that you are trying to solve with like you know your life's work you know when you wake up in the morning and and try and get things done or things specifically with this stable act like who are the people that are being like who are the losers that are trying that you are trying to protect right who who are the disenfranchised that the current system is set up to that doesn't include right like what are the main fundamental issues that you see that things like legislation like the stable act can help protect like what are the really big problems that that you are concretely trying to go after.
Yeah and I think I probably should have mentioned one other thing at the beginning to clarify here which is in addition to sort of financial interest there's also technological interests right there are also and I think we can go back to the early history of governance here like the 5,000 year history of debt and things and it was not just financiers it was also describes and the lawyers it basically anybody that had control over the complex tools of administration of governance who exercised power from their position with those tools and so today obviously finance is crucial right how are you going to pay for it who's got money who doesn't is a critical like layer of power but there's also who runs the technology right every computer around us in our pockets etc and I think we're seeing now a realignment of power around that in the same way as we saw with the railroad in the same way as we saw with oil and steel and other forms of technology at different points in history that there's a new power structure emerging around digital computing technology and there are going to be people who are going to be the new scribes the new governance architects of the future that's being built right now whether that's Mark Zuckerberg and Eric Schmidt or it's a tribe of very you know white male technologically savvy free market oriented people who distrust any form of collective governance you know whatever the group is they are positioning themselves to be the new elite in whatever kind of ocracy comes after the one that we've emerged out of right now and so to go to your question with this bill there's a couple of things one is there's a history of financial interests playing cat and mouse with banking regulation the minute you regulate bank notes they switch to deposits the minute you regulate deposits they switch to another kind of instrument and there's a constant game of sort of pushing out to whatever margins and when those actors eventually need public support and we can talk about why but inevitably they do in moments of crises they then come and ask to be bailed out in the name of the average person or in the name of the entire economy and the lesson I think of banking history or shadow banking history is the way to deal with that is to regulate it on the upswing is to acknowledge that they're engaging in activities that you know while they've tried to put a different face on it put a different label on it are still fundamentally the same activities that we've regulated in the past and to minimize how systemically important they are so with this bill there's a couple of things one is if these kinds of stable coins become successful in the way that they hope you know whether it's Mark Zuckerberg with DM or Circle and Tether or Die if it becomes successful that it's mass adopted there will be millions of people who aren't you know bankless nodes who who follow the podcast or you know people who are deep in in the community right capital C it'll be people who just expect to be able to use this as another PayPal right who don't want to think about it who get a wallet it's it's been made super easy to download on their phone or whatever else and one day they wake up and the whole thing is suddenly that their money's gone right that's the kind of risk if this if this kind of energy succeeds in its wildest dreams at the same time if it doesn't succeed like that what I think is going to happen is the same kinds of financial institutions and big money investors that have played this shadow banking game at every other stage in history we'll get in we'll eventually turn around and get some sort of regulation just like USDC is trying to do now partnering with Visa just like others are trying to get bank licenses or money transmittal licenses they will glom back on to the official system they'll start complying with the Patriot Act and everything else but they'll do so with just a little bit more power than they did before just a little bit less accountability we'll we'll we'll forget some of the lessons about democratic oversight that we had last time and we can see this already with money transmitters money transmitters get to do things that banks wouldn't be allowed to do and the reason we have money transmitters is because there was a hole in the banking regulations at a certain point and they exploited it right PayPal is doing things today that it wouldn't be allowed to do if it got a banking license and it didn't get that banking license because it managed to find that with all and so I think on one hand it's about protecting the consumers who will be using these systems on the other hand it's about realizing that there's a power reallignment between tech industry telecom and and banking and to try to address the new lords before they start doing the next thing that they do because once upon a time you know Jeff Bezos and and you know Zuckerberg and others we're just young punks with a startup right and now they're super super kind of you know oligarchs who don't really give a shit about any accountability to any public at all I think what you're saying is like the the new bus is going to be the same as the old bus unless something but they're going to know how to code right that's going to be and you were recently on Dimitri's podcast and Dimitri on an even earlier podcast with somebody from the DeFi ecosystem the decentralized finance ecosystem Van Spencer Dimitri gave the opinion that like the reason why he thinks the world of DeFi and to me when I hear DeFi it's almost anonymous with with Ethereum he saw that DeFi is cool and valuable explicitly because of regulatory arbitrage right like the DeFi ecosystem is unregulated therefore we can do cool new things in this new ecosystem what you are worried about is that these cool new things becoming really really big and then starting to represent systemic risk and things like a circle and and USDC are just leveraging new rails with that are unregulated to do new things and I would totally agree I do I do agree that like there is like the centralized actors like USDC like Paxos like any like Tether that are definitely scourting regulations in order to establish their businesses and establish their own native currencies to be a part of this ecosystem now I do want to draw a line and this is where I think a lot of the crypto folk get really upset about some of this regulation is that there doesn't seem to be room for what me and Ryan are really bullish on which is protocols money issued protocols and we can definitely debate about like the decentralization of something like die like I feel you are fully aware about veils of decentralization or decentralization theater and and die is definitely not as like decentralized as like Bitcoin is or TCP IP is and so there are central there is a centralized team there are centralized beneficiaries but it's still more decentralized than than circle right it's still more decentralized than tether and what what I'm hoping to get out of this conversation with you Rowan is is for you to include room in your mental models for what's going on in this industry that does allow for a fully decentralized currency to exist that doesn't that would be outside of the stable act right I do believe that there is the possibility for protocol driven money that is that wouldn't that does wouldn't necessarily be doesn't cause the some of the existential risks that you are worried about I don't see when in your previous conversations I don't see you including room for completely computerized completely protocolized completely humanless uh monies and I mean Ryan are bullish on these possibilities coming out of our industry so yeah I think there's two things there the first thing is and I appreciate you guys taking the time to listen to other conversations and things I hope you've seen this bill isn't targeting private currencies Bitcoin is its own unit of account Ethereum is its own unit of account are not actually a stablecoin under the definition in this bill right the instruments that qualify as a stablecoin under this bill are instruments explicitly designed to function as public money by which I mean denominated in the fiat unit of account and to circulate in ways that public money is trying to do and just to get it out of the way at the first instance because I'm a big believer in decentralized anonymous digital fiat catch my goal is to build a system where if you want to do peer to peer cash transactions in US dollars where nobody able to see it you can my view on that as a as a as a theory of money is that the only way to do that in a safe secure and stable way long term is for the government to issue itself that isn't say the government issues all money right but it is to say the US dollar issues issued by the government has unique properties relative to a US dollar denominated token issued by anyone else and so we can try to play the game of my token is safe just trust me and I think we played that game throughout history with bank deposits with bank notes and the time and time again story is the only actual thing that can be guaranteed is when you issue the dollar yourself to ensure that the dollar convertibility so the first thing is no ethereum no bitcoin if you want to issue a private currency more power to you the second thing is about the technology I don't have a problem with people developing technology the problem here is the systemic risk that comes with its wide scale adoption in day-to-day transactions and so when it comes to what you might call sort of computerized money I think the reality is that the economy is not built on humanless transactions the economy is built around human beings if you and I transact with a piece of paper or a paper dollar bill the paper dollar bill is is computerized in the sense there's nobody involved in it right but if you and I have a dispute there we go to a court and the court adjudicates that the court doesn't say the piece of paper has decided right and and my my old advisor at Cornell James Grimmelman who's a code I wrote a great piece called all smart contracts are inherently ambiguous and there have been others who talked about this in the context of code you know going back to Larry Lessig and others that code itself is not a substitute for law it can automate certain physical processes but the economy and commerce is built on legal institutions of property rights of contract dispute resolution of accounting principles of limited liability for entities and corporations for tort law even in instances where you didn't explicitly contract all of those things continue to apply regardless of what technology you're using to interface with another human being and so I could have a a perfectly written code and then we could disagree about how to interpret that code in light of an existing arrangement and that disagreement is going to come down to a court and a judge looking at two human beings on either side of a dispute whether or not the judge chooses to agree with the code or not will be a question for the judge and so I think that this you know to me it's sort of like saying the trenchball in Matilda well I'd love a school without children how easy would it be to run a school if there were no messy children involved right having an economy where there's a money that doesn't involve people is in my opinion not a coherent concept because the economy is made up out of people just like the internet is there's I can there's ISP providers there's people running individual servers in their basement there's property rights around the land title of your basement right so I just I think I question the premise that we can automate social interaction to a point where society is not involved so the the way that I see you trying to eliminate risk out of the public institution of money is through an MMT type of perspective where you want a stablecoin issuers like USDC to get a federal banking charter so they can get that FDIC insurance in case that something goes wrong what ends up backstopping the risk from platforms like USDC is the ability to print money is that is that accurate yeah I just to be clear FDIC insurance I think is actually one of the like lesser tiers it's actually access to the Federal Reserve's balance sheet and the general protections that come with being part of the banking system and again colleagues of mine and my advisors have written a piece called the finance franchise where they where they look at the history of chartered banks and originally charters would come through specific pieces of legislation the Massachusetts legislature would pass a bill creating the Massachusetts bank and it was explicitly acknowledged as a kind of public private partnership it was like the Panama Canal and over time those private corporations or quasi private corporations began to consider themselves independent of any public accountability right give me all the benefits of limited liability and none of the obligations to actually serve a public interest beyond profit that's the that's the neoliberal as long as I'm earning profit I'm doing good for society right and and so the the FDIC insurance is less important the real important thing is if you're the creator of the dollar whether that's a Federal Reserve or the Treasury or some consolidated government that sits above any one institution it's the sort of you know constitution and everything else um you you make the dollar so yeah there there is an infinity sign next to the amount of dollars that can be created by the US government of course that doesn't mean they should create infinity right but it does mean if if a dollar bill is a promise to pay ten dollars then you go get a take a ten dollar bill to the bank and you ask for the dollars they'll just give you two five dollar bills right because it's the same thing whereas a bank note is a promise to get those US dollars if you take a bank note in 1830 to the bank and you ask for US dollars the bank may or may not have US dollars and that's the same true whether it's a centralized stablecoin issuer like tether or usdc or a decentralized like die where the theory is that there's collateral sitting somewhere and that collateral is either actual dollars or worth enough dollars and hopefully the value of that collateral won't change but all of that is a theory that when you come with your token with a promise to pay somehow I'm good for it and I think our view is one actor in the whole system has a unique answer to that there's one unique answer to that that problem said and that is if you actually issue the dollar you can always pay right right and that's that's where the de-risking of a of a money system comes from is there's the inherent solvency of the original issuer in in the defy space in in what we call trustless finance or decentralized finance we we attack that same problem via the almost the opposite route where like the if a an application on Ethereum is going to be quote unquote trustless it needs to be over collateralized and I've heard you on various podcasts talk about or criticize like what's going on in the crypto space as just like the next iteration of financial like innovation or engineering right where you said like you know we we allowed the shadow banking institution to happen and then it got out of control and now it's massive and now they are saying like they just give the same old excuses as to like why they shouldn't be regulated and now you're what you say about defy is something along those same lines like we have this new platform for innovation and this time quote unquote this time it's different right same old excuse as as we've all heard before I actually do think that quote unquote this time it's different and in the fundamental reason why is that there is a design ethos that is backing institutions like Bitcoin and Ethereum and defy protocols that could produce a dollar denominated stablecoin that they're designed good good protocols that get me and Ryan and the bankless world really really bullish are protocols that are designed to withstand world worth three right Ethereum 2.
0 it's it's in its rollout phase it's been designed with an anti world with world worth three resistance like what if nuclear bombs went off Ethereum 2.0 should still operate and a lot of the defy protocols that that we are really excited about are the ones that plug up all potential attack and risk vectors in order to make them world worth three resistant and so earlier you said you said we were talking more characterizing some defy protocol that would produce a dollar where you would say hey use this money it's risk free trust me we actually don't ask for your trust and that's why defy is so cool to us is that the way that these protocols are set up are inherently over collateralized with all possible attack vectors hopefully sealed probably not sealed and many Bitcoiners would criticize the defy ecosystem for not having adequately sealed protocols but that is the vision we we believe that we can create these like inherently strong hard protocols that are are de-risked by the market because if they do have a chink in the armor if they do have a failure then they die and then they get replaced by new ones and those ones are supposed to be better by the laws of the free market and so what we are excited about is the potential for having de-risk financial institutions that don't actually require you know money printing to backstop risk that and that's kind of where our perspective comes from is that is that new to you or is this is this old information no this this is old information but I'm happy to go there because I don't think I've done in some of the other interviews so there's two things there one is when it comes to the collateral you say over collateralized right that's a conclusion right that's not a that's not a statement of fact you're saying that X collateral is is over whatever line that you consider to be the line of safety and maybe that's just where we frankly disagree is that I don't think those theories of overcladalization actually survive the tail risk kinds of risk that I'm talking about and then the second point there is well if it's got a chink in the armor it'll fail and something you will take its place looking for the front page of defi look no further than zirion.
io zirion is your home base for managing your defi portfolios zirion offers a central place for you to engage with all of the defi protocols and assets that you engage with on a daily basis but all in one central spot here you can see I've loaded up a wallet and zirion is giving me the portfolio performance of all the assets in this wallet over time as well as a breakdown of all the assets that I own as well as all of my transaction history that I've ever done in an easy to view fashion. zirion also lets you invest right into defi's best yielding financial opportunities right from their home page.
zirion also makes it super easy to access interest in defi using applications like compound and ovate in the background and you can also exchange your assets using the zirion app using an exchange aggregator in the background to make sure that you always get the best rates. you can even use the zirion mobile wallet to add your metamask or argent or another ethereum address right into your mobile wallet so you can see your portfolio and engage in defi on the go. here i just loaded up my argent wallet and now i'm going to load up my metamask as well and zirion will do the same thing it will add all of my assets and wallets together all in one space and give me a portfolio summary of what's going on adding wallets is trivially easy if you already have a metamask you can get it right into the zirion app and it can sync with your desktop app as well and the best part is you can also buy ether right into the app itself use the invest tab to look at all the things that you have invested in as well as other opportunities and coming soon to the zirion app is the ability to buy and sell your assets straight from your mobile device as well so download the app it works on ios and android go to zirion.
io plug in your wallets and get a historical report of your portfolio over time as well as a comprehensive breakdown of all the assets that you own and how much yield they're generating for you we're also brought to you by monolith monolith is your cool new defi account your defi savings account your defi checking account except the cool thing about the monolith defi account is that it gets software updates right you actually get to increase the usefulness of this over time so here are some of the features monolith is a smart contract wallet with a lot of the features that you would expect if you've come to know defi and what it is you can you can add money to it you can put that money to work in compound and accessing yield but you can also swap through uniswap what was cool with monolith is that they will send you a very sexy monolith visa card that connects to your smart monolith smart contract wallet on ethereum so it's a really awesome tool to live a bankless life with a savings account that gets software updates so this is something that you're never going to find out in the real world but you can still do real world things with you know real money it like by your groceries so that's just fantastic coming soon to monolith actually already here to monolith is now you can buy dye and get it sent to your wallet directly right so it's also being an on ramp so you don't have to go through your centralized exchange like coin base or Gemini or wherever you can just go straight from your bank account right into your monolith checking account smart contract wallet so check them out at monolith.
xyz and then the second point there is well if it's got a chinkamiyama it'll fail and something you will take its place that's exactly the argument that was given for free banking and what we saw was every time one of those failed a bunch of people got hurt right say say DM actually takes off and then it fails and then Mark Zuckerberg goes well we've learned our lesson you know the next people that come after Facebook will will have a better system well there's two potentially two billion users in the middle of that learning process and you know not not shaded you but there's a lot of tech people that think the entire world is their playground to not learn the lessons of history and to repeat them like oh maybe I'll just do some human experiments oh that's unethical or there's problems with doing that well I guess I learned something this time no actually we learned that lesson a hundred years ago and nobody should have let you pretend we hadn't learned that lesson and try it all again and when it comes to these defy things I mean again if we're talking about 20 million dollars it's it's surrounding it if we're talking about 200 billion dollars that's not the kind of lesson we just let fail it is too big to fail whether whether we want it to be or not if there's if there's two trillion dollars of customer funds in these systems they're too big to fail they we can't just say lesson learned the free market will pick it up that is the kind of Austrian response to the global financial crisis is we'll just liquidate everything right just let everybody go under let mortgage owners go under let people lose their jobs and the market will re adjust yeah millions of people die in the meantime so here here here's I think maybe a difference in kind of foundation because what you were saying is basically like everything ultimately settles back to the nation state legal system right with fiat currency yeah with with fiat currency but like with law in general it all kind of settles to that layer um we are like much more bullish on a new social layer that is being created just like you know um some things in the human experience are settled outside of the nation state and outside of the legal system um things like you know ethics morality sometimes those things get written into law but religions are another human institution where some sort of settlement can happen um like you you made the point that basically um crypto systems aren't decentralized because at the end of the day property has to settle to some sort of legal system but what about property transition between countries that don't trust one another who is the the judge that supersedes between a China that is antagonistic against a United States of America right which judge from which country sort of decides this is why we need overarching credibly neutral systems that essentially can provide uh the the ability to transfer value and a property rights system that don't have any biases to one nation state or another we're talking about not like just a money system we're talking about a new social coordination system that is being built on these crypto rails and this is powerful stuff and it's outside of the legal system in some ways the nation state legal system and the thing about this is um right like it is immune in some ways from the authoritarianism that you also want to to prevent right because it is not of the nation state it is a different social structure and social system we're bullish on that but what we see when we look at the stable act is a little bit of like we're with you on the the DM stuff and the Facebook and the Zuckerberg trying to become a new banker and centralized control i hear you like we're with you like we understand what you're talking about i'm even with you on kind of these new crypto banks becoming like the old crypto banks that we used to have like i get it we're with you where we depart is we believe that there are credibly neutral protocols that can be developed and a protocol like the constitution is a protocol TCP IP is a protocol no single country owns the protocol of TCP IP it's a standard for the communication of information of data we think such a thing can exist also for value and for property and we think that you should not squelch that you should be like we're on the same team we want a more bankless world basically and we want some of that innovation and that protocol to also grow in in in the US so maybe it was a misinterpretation of the the stable act maybe some things should be like crafted in it to like protect what we're trying to do on the kind of the DeFi side and the self-sovereign side of things but we absolutely want the ability for every citizen to run a node and a theory of node without fear of some kind of legal reprisal because some some company has issued a stablecoin that is against a regulatory regime so i guess maybe without getting to the specifics of the stable act like do you resonate with that are are you okay with this experimentation happening do you believe that maybe you're skeptical of it that's fine to be skeptical of it there's tons of people are skeptical of crypto but are you fine with letting that experiment play out and seeing if we can actually build a bankless money system that it sort of meets the standards of of not having central intermediaries what do you say well so there's a couple of things there one is again this bill isn't stopping anyone for creating a private currency so you want to create private currency go for it it's the point in which you start issuing a stablecoin denominated in US dollar or another fear currency instrument and trying to pass off a public money where there's going to be an issue and then and then to go from there the point about the nodes just to be very clear and i've clarified else about a clarify here there the the law regulates the issuance of stablecoins and requires you get a banking charter for doing that what people responded almost immediately was you'll never you'll never stop us because these networks are decentralized right so immediately they probably lost you if you agree that there's this veil of decentralization right but that was their response well we're going to create a network where there's only nodes there's only nodes there's no one else above nodes so you can't you can't go after anybody who is for these stablecoins unless you go after every node operator and my response was if that's true then the only response is to go after every node operator because if you have 100 people engaged in a criminal enterprise their fact that there's 100 instead of one doesn't mean that they're not all liable right but and this was a crucial part that everybody stopped listening i don't think that's actually an accurate description in these context i don't think ethereum is decentralized i don't think if there was a stablecoin issued on the ethereum network that it would be impossible to identify the issuer above a node level i don't think that's true and so it wouldn't be going after node operators on ethereum it would be going after the issuer of the stablecoin on ethereum and if people say oh you can't find us we're hiding amongst the nodes i just call bullshit on that frankly but if you were going to design a system like that if you're going to say okay we want to keep doing this and we get caught up on ethereum we get caught out so this time we're going to design a system where we are perfectly hidden amongst the nodes on that system the answer would be okay we're going to go after each node operator and i think that's that's the line where i am willing to take a hard stand because you can't hide amongst a hundred people to do something that would be illegal if you were doing it on your own that's the basic principle here that isn't to say we're coming after node operators who run an ethereum node i'm i'm happy that people fundraised off that i'm in for people managed to tell me to do a little off that good luck with them right but that's not at all what this was bill was about i mean would you be open to carving that out in such a bill to just clarify i literally i've literally said to people first of all the way that we wrote the bill was that any activity the commercial activity so if you're running a non commercial if you're engaging in non commercial node validation fine you're immediately exempt anywhere but any commercial activity related to this stuff would have to get prior approval from regulators in the same way as if we issued dangerous drugs you get to get prior approval now what i would support and do support is have a carve out for people who are engaging in node operations as long as that operation is not the only entity responsible for issuing the stablecoin right any node operator who is not the primary actor or a member of the class primarily responsible for issuing stablecoin would be exempt that's fine now there's a question of how you draft that i think that should happen at the layer of regulation the bill gives regulators your authority to write that law if you want to lobby for regulators to put that rule in place as an interpretation of this law on day one i'll sign that no problems right what i am not going to allow or i don't think is reasonable to allow is someone to say okay i'm going to create a decentralized blockchain where the whole network every single node is identical there's no miners there's no validators they're just all identical and the whole thing together issues stablecoins but you can't come after anybody unless you come after all of us if that's created the answer is to go off the rule of so so the the node operators don't have any explicit relationship with a specific protocol on a theorem so like you know one one protocol on a theory i might just simply be like the usdc contract address and so while i run a node or i'm mining a transaction i'm processing those transactions from that contract address even though i'm not the issuer and so in terms of usc it sounds like the stable act would go after usdc the issue or circle the issue and then and then with die or make or down you know you're you're calling bullshit on the decentralization theater there are people there that we could go talk to and exert regulatory pressure upon them and therefore we don't even need to talk about nodes in that instance either kind of going back to what i was saying though with like world war three resistant protocols the goal of a theorem is to produce such a human removed entity a human removed protocol that it is in itself is almost synonymous with a theorem when something is completely decentralized in in with and there are contracts on a theorem there are protocols on a theorem that are 100 percent human removed and when that you do you don't even you it sounds like you don't even think that's actually possible no if every single person who's running an ethereum node today turned it off where would those smart contracts exist and they will they would be stored in the database which so every single person who ran one of those nodes destroyed those those nodes where would where would the smart car then then it would be eliminated but if identified a layer of human beings haven't yeah but but we're talking about all like 8,000 nodes i think just got spun up in the last week and then i think it's over like 12,000 now like at some point where we have to talk about how feasible it is to even be able to track all of this stuff okay but now you've switched gears right let's be honest here you switch gears from there's no people to there's a very large network okay how many how many people are in are in organized crime networks you think there are mafia also groups that don't have 8,000 members i mean there are right that we know there are because we've seen them in throughout history right 8,000 sounds like a big number when you're used to networks of 20 servers it's not that big a number when you're looking at criminal enterprises it's band nations so i don't think that's a fair comparison because mafia mafia networks are human to human and they they create trails but nodes are one node is completely independent from any other node i could have three nodes in my house that are all independent from each other and and it's just part of the scene like nebulous set of at the end of the day you're totally right these these big coin ethereum protocols on ethereum they're created by humans but at some point it becomes such like a kind of like a virus like how do you control a virus like it's just it just it's a whole idea about these systems is that they are so easy to self replicate that they it's like a termite you can't get rid of it but we do we do get rid of talents we do get rid of viruses we're not very well not well but but not zero right like what New Zealand has just eliminated COVID right and the way they did that was they dealt with a country of five million people and they put a wall around it now i'm not saying that's the right way to do every kind of problem but i think that there's you know you've got to be honest here with yourselves there is a difference between saying there's a large distributed network and that there's no individual people involved in that right the three nodes you choose you choose what you're putting on those nodes i think if this is an argument that the nation state could stamp out like a bit coin or a theorem i think like a coordinated nation state attack against these systems could do them significant damage there are humans that run the validators and run the machines what are the guarantees that we haven't talked about yet is of course the crypto economic guarantees which is the reason that people don't shut off their validators is because they're incented not to so if one country goes like authoritarian on a decentralized network like a bitcoin and a theorem but another country or some small pocket decides not to they benefit disproportionately and so they don't that's why these these crypto economic systems are so resilient to that kind of attack at this stage whether a nation state could take it down or not it's not really the issue i don't i don't see the U.
S. or like a western liberal democracy doing that at this point i mean like i guess two other issues i kind of had with the stable act right or the point of point of point you just go on that on that question yeah sure sure sure before you go to the stable act which is that's also true of like Nazi gold right if if we say we're not going to let Nazi gold go into people's bank bolts and then Switzerland puts its hand up and says i'm not going to look and ask questions or argentina says yeah sure you can come here and set up a pig farm doesn't matter i mean the argument there is is not unique to computers it's just pointing out that people can engage in arbitrage between nation states and that's why there's a bunch of billionaires with bank accounts in the Cayman Islands i i get your point on that but i'm not sure it's unique to crypto it's just if i'm rich and powerful enough i can find someone willing to let me do what i want what is unique to crypto specifically with with Bitcoin and Ethereum is these protocols are designed to be as viral as possible right they are engineered to be unstoppable which means that like the having it to a conversation about whether we can or cannot i think is it's futile like there if these things are doing their jobs they are untouchable therefore like any sort of like top-down control upon node operators it's not going to work because even if you do control the node operation from inside the country that you have domain over the network is ultimately unfazed as a whole do all the nodes that you don't have domain over so then why do even bother trying to exert control under your own constituents well i think this is where there's maybe a dissent misunderstanding of the point of the bill right the point of the bill is not to stamp out networks the point of the bill is to manage systemic risk from those networks and so what the goal of the bill is is to prevent these stablecoins from becoming the new banking right from becoming the new primary layer of the economy that millions of consumers are putting their money into now we didn't stamp out torrenting right but that doesn't mean that most official commercial companies right now get all of their content by illegally torrenting now i happen to have no problem with torrenting right i think that's quite fuck fuck i p producers but i think the the point there is you don't need to stamp out a hot network you just need to make that network unattractive to the point of becoming central to the official economy and in the case of the united states like i think yeah the united states probably should take responsibility for the rest of the world in in in what happens to the us dollar but if you had a system where no individual consumer in the united states and no major company and no business small business in the united states was using a risky stablecoin i would consider that a success in the sense that the systemic risk of stablecoins to the us economy is going to be reduced there's not going to be that bank run in merry poppins of average americans right that's the goal so yeah you're not going to stop someone in cyberia running a node necessarily like that but you are going to stop that from becoming the new shadow banking that has trillions of dollars in the american economy when there's a crash they're too big to fail but that's the goal right it's a feature not a buck another another piece of the the stable act is there seems to be an issue in the stable act when any currency kind of uses the unit of account of the us dollar right so you could envision something possibly that's not been created yet something like a die but much more decentralized right maybe maybe sort of as decentralized as a theory of an ether and bitcoin but is somehow pegged or leverages the unit of account of the us dollar you seem to have an issue with that right so this is different than a a circle or a coinbase or a Facebook issuing their own kind of stablecoin this is a very a decentralized protocol network issuing an asset that might be backed by collateral or however they do it that that is decentralized but it's using the unit of account of the dollar the stable act the brand yeah uses the the stable act minor standing would prohibit that too why like what's what's what's the issue what's the issue there why why can we not use the public good of the dollar with these with these defy protocols yeah so there's a good question and just to be clear the point here is not anything that ever uses the unit of account it's the unit the issue the issue something in the unit of account with the expectation that retain a fixed or or so stable as so fixed as to be stable value so stocks for example are issued in the unit of account the stocks fluctuate in value right that nobody holds a stock expecting it to maintain a stable nominal value relative to the us dollar they fluctuate now one moment where that becomes an issue is the money market mutual fund industry they issued shares right that were in theory a share can fluctuate in value but the point of the MMF shares was that they were supposed to be stable in value they were supposed to never break the buck right and when they broke the buck it was a huge source of systemic risk because they had built an entire business model on the expectation and belief that they can't do that and so when we look at how instruments function it's not the collateral backing in and of itself that's the problem it's the promise of stable value that can't guarantee because if people take it seriously if it takes it its word yeah yeah this is stable we're literally calling ourselves stable coins right and then they start using it as though it says good as us dollars right people use money market mutual fund shares as though they were as good as bank deposits they weren't and that caused a huge systemic risk and when you look through the history of common law obligations monetary obligations in contract law in in financial commerce things like that what the over and over a really important layer was what they called the nominal layer so people you know Austrians others will complain about the real purchasing power the US dollar fluctuating right but what a hundred dollar bill will guarantee you is you can pay a hundred dollars worth of debts that's a nominal layer you can you can disagree how important you think that is but on that layer the nominal guarantee of a hundred equaling a hundred if it turns out a hundred doesn't equal that's incredibly risky and destabilizing to the whole monetary economy we had banks that issued bank notes that were worth ten pounds and then people realized those banks were risky and every time they walked into a store they had to negotiate how much of a discount they would put on that bank note so there'd be a ten dollar bank note and you would pay for something worth seven and they'd say this bank note is actually only worth five and the next day it might be worth eight the next day it might be worth four but if that bank note is designed to function like it's always going to be worth ten and everybody starts using it interchangeably with US dollars right oh who cares if I have a hundred dollars in my actual bank account or in cash or I have a hundred dollars in my stable coin balance they're the same thing they're both a hundred and then it turns out one day the stuff that was in your stable coin wallet is now worth fifty that is the source of systemic risk the nominal stability not not just and that's tied to the unit of account because we we denominate debts so bro and I take I take your point about money market mutual funds act against kind of a shadow bank like we've seen that that that happened like one could also argue that that euro dollars right now exhibit those same behaviors and by the way that's a absolutely massive market much bigger than the thirty billion dollars or so in stable coins out there so I'm hopeful this bill has something to say about that if it's if it's targeting I mean at my understanding euro dollars would meet the definition of of the stable coin deposit okay but but that aside one thing that is being missed here I feel like is I can't click view source on my euro dollar like I have no idea what's inside my euro dollar yes and like what's back your euro dollars issued by a European bank yeah a black box like so the difference with DeFi is this you can actually like click view source and see all of the assets all of the collateral that back a given asset right this is a much more audit ever easiest audit ever it's a much more open and transparent monetary system it doesn't have the black box flaws that something like the euro dollar might have or some traditional finance those banks submit to audit requirements they submit to reporting requirements the problem is the theory is wrong the theory of why they work the way that they say they're gonna work is wrong and so you can you can audit that code right but you may look at a certain thing and interpret it slightly differently you may you may look at an upgrade and think oh there's nothing wrong with this upgrade and you made a mistake or let's be honest if this becomes systemically important how many people are auditing that code how many I mean do we really think that 200 million Americans are gonna start using stable coins as their primary median payment and they're all gonna be inspecting the source code of course not they're gonna trust certain actors in the same way as we trust we trust auditors and intermediaries credit reporting and all other kinds of stuff let me ask you let's say the crypto people are right right I think you think this is not going to be the case but let's say that Bitcoin or Ether become a reserve asset for the world right would you have something like would you have a big problem with that like fundamentally because your whole the fear of money that you have is basically to to save us from the systemic risk we need it in the hands of a public institution that can sort of print money right so the prevent bank rank right so I understand that but you can't do that with a Bitcoin or an Ether so it it would seem to be the case of the mining pool you could well so sure but it seems to be the case that you would be against a monetary system like that too even if the people chose it if kind of the free market chose it and essentially we adopted it like that that's where some of this becomes a little bit of like you know at what point does the nation state sort of restrict individual choice and say no sorry citizen you can't choose your own money this is the money that we have for you it's a public institution you have to adopt it like we're banning these spits like how far how far do you push it well for the first first of all nobody's banned gold I'm not recommending banning gold I have never said anything like I've never said I've never recommended that in my life I didn't wish it to leave it going either right but but to go to your point there's two things one is I don't think that's going to happen if you actually look through the history of gold standards in throughout history they have been actively maintained through public law and I think going back to your earlier point this idea of sort of creating a layer above nation states you asked about China the United States I mean this is real politic right they have armies do you really think that they're going to put down their armies and and as a scribe to some liberal theory of property rights above the nation state I mean this is liberal idealism at its at its highest that suddenly people who have control over means of enforcement are going to just sort of out of the better nature agree to some higher ideal against their interests that's that's not how we've actually got any democratic gains throughout history we've got it by seizing powerful institutions I mean there is no international layer there that forces those two actors to do what they want they go to war and that's a problem and there's a reason why we haven't had a war within the United States between states since the Civil War because we don't let individual states create armies against each other now if you want to have some one world government based on a belief in private property rights I mean more power to you but I don't think that you're going to miraculously have the institutions of power give up that power in the name of of ideals that's not how it works it happens when people stand up and demand accountability and up until now the the flip side has always been democracies been on the side of the debtors it's been on the side of the people without property rights it hasn't the people who've been standing up to create supernatural institutions to defend property rights have been usually doing so against the interest of working people and so when it comes to your currency model a hard currency like the kind you're talking about a commodity backed or a commodity linked currency whether it's a digital currency or real commodity is pro creditor it's inherently deflationary which means if you got in early and you have assets that you own you get richer and richer the expense of every next generation now to the extent that there have been moments in history where feudal lords have convinced peasants that it is in their best interest to maintain feudalism yeah i think you can fool some of the people some of the time i happen to think that those systems are pre fundamentally anti-democratic now luckily that's not a problem we have to deal with an stable act the stable act is specifically dealing with an emergent risk right now in the banking system you want me to ask me what i would do in the moment where we have a hard currency i'd be in the room saying we shouldn't do this we should have a currency linked to human labor where everybody who wants to work to contribute to the common good can earn currency doing so that we eliminate rent seeking whether that's intellectual property or landed rent or whatever else and that we provide free goods to people outside of the cash nexus like we do with health care and education and everything else that works well for universal service provision and that the laborers who earn the money to to contribute to the common good provide the services that are then available to people who can't work that's the kind of democratic monetary system i want to build but it's not about protecting private property rights Ted turn around half of Montana fuck his property rights so we're on another thing that struck me as odd in in the stable act is you are a very sort of anti big bank yet these stablecoin issuers would require a bank charter in order to operate like we very much believe the sort of a you know the banking system is a cartel of sorts and protected cartel of sorts why force them to be members of this cartel what the stable act seems incomplete if it doesn't incorporate the other aspects of your of your vision and it's just leaving the banking system as is but like forcing stablecoin issuers to become banks what's your response to that yeah that's a good question is a couple things first of all the bill that we released a month before this bill was the public banking act which would create a new facilities at the federal reserve create a set of grants create a onboarding process for the chartering process to speed it up to create a separate form of deposit insurance and securities license or actors that wanted to create public banking institutions owned by the public government not for profit without shareholders in the interest of communities and that's specifically designed to make those commercial banks obsolete we don't need them to do anything systemically important right now one of the reasons why those commercial banks are important is because they run the payment system right they go wonder people can't make transactions too they're responsible for a large amount of investment we don't get to make bank loans the economy stalls what we proposed we'd reshaped to leaves bill originally was anonymous digital cash and better counts for everyone at the central bank and a postal banking system where they could go deal with their banking services at the post office right the post office the first internet right they subsidized packets going around the whole country they created information network where nothing existed one of the most socialistic institutions in the US government it operated since the birth of the republic and it issued postal savings and deposit accounts in the 1940s and 50s and 60s until the big bank shut it down because they didn't like the competition so before the big banks came for crypto they came for public postal banking and that was the bigger threat that actually did threaten their commercial interests commercial banks don't get feel threatened crypto they're just going to take it over when it becomes important but what we're trying to do here is it's a lesser of two-eval situation I mean I have you know personally my politics go towards the side of I don't need commercial banks at all but this bill is saying if you're going to engage in banking activity you need to be regulated like a bank and be explicit public private partnership because you know go back to that earlier point that I made about neoliberalism the whole point of neoliberalism is to give the impression that actors that rely on public support are purely private they don't have any accountability beyond the market and profit so these shadow banks are doing everything that regulated commercial banks are doing in terms of systemic risk in terms of socializing the benefits and private socializing the losses and privatizing the benefits but they're doing so without any of the accountability that comes with the public private partnership and so getting them out of the shadows into the regulated system is a critical step is that as good as replacing them with public banks entirely no but it's a it's a it's an important step and the the solution in my opinion is not to throw them even further to the shadows and say they've got even less accountability to the public is to bring them in now in 2009 there was a point where they could have socialized and nationalized half of those banks instead of bailing them out they didn't do that because the banking interest didn't let them that's that was a failure right the next time this happens maybe that'll go differently but if we had a system of anonymous digital cash fed accounts postal banking a government investment program and a and a network of public banks there wouldn't be much need for commercial banks anymore and all the claims that the crypto stablecoin community has is if you regulate us too much you'll kill innovation well I don't agree with that I think there are ways to have public investment in innovation that would not require them to be allowed to do whatever they want without accountability so that's the alternative you you you you require them to get a banking license some of them are going to get banking license is going to come out of the shadows some of them aren't going to come into existence and all that energy could be redeployed in pursuit of actual public financial infrastructure so everyone is it possible for you to do all of this like go pursue MMT go pursue this new banking system in the US without crushing crypto through aggressive regulation and crushing defy and crushing this experiment that we're running to create a different set of social protocols that the world can run on top of like we're worried that you're trying to crush the new internet here that we're building and we think that a lot of the goals that you have are common with the goals of crypto and the bankless movement I feel like hugely synonymous actually well I mean take your point I mean there are many in crypto who are very anti-MMT of course right but like go do MMT right and like may the best system win why can't we just have that sort of relationship in a free and open republic such as the United States what's your take my my take is if you want to create a private crypto currency I honestly wish you the best I don't think stable coins meet that definition and and for example if somebody said hey we just want to counterfeit US dollars why can't we just be left alone if you want to print US dollars at the US min go do that and let the best man win well no there's a reason why those two things are intention we can counterfeit it is a little bit different let's okay let me be clear it's different only in the sense that a bank deposit and a US dollar issued by different actors but counterfeiting a bank deposit is what a stable coin is doing in my opinion now you may disagree with that fine but if you accept that view that that a stable coin is an unlicensed bank deposit and that the reason we license bank deposits is because they are an extension of the public monetary system then these actors are not trying to just do stuff in the in the privacy of their em basement they're literally coming for the US dollar they're literally trying to encourage on the space the public system if you want to create a private currency in your own unit of account by all means I will defend your right to the death to do that and I will defend it against other people who would love to shut it down but if you want to start trying to mimic public dollars you're not creating the new world you're just doing the same thing that every other bank has done in history which is piggyback on the public monetary system and when it comes to building the internet I know nobody in your world is going to find this remotely convincing but I'm actually trying to save you from yourselves because if you if you build an entire crypto community on the back of stable coins which is what's happening before our eyes right now right those those Bitcoin Ethereum systems are piggybacking and increasingly dependent on stable coins and that whole system comes crashing down you will have destroyed the vision of the whole thing and actually if we look back at the both of the internet I work for you know I'm a network manager sort of evangelist for this group called the Freedom Box Foundation it's run by Evan Moglin he was the he was the legal counsel for the first software foundation he worked with Richard Stalman directly for 25 years I believe very deeply in free software free hardware free culture free bandwidth right and I think that if you look at even groups like the EFF and the sort of zealous defenders of section 230 they have become their own worst enemies because what is the internet now it's a bunch of walled gatehouses run by big mega companies right that vision of the free uncensored use net of the 90s it exists around the margins but it's fucking dead and I wish it hadn't been allowed to die and if we had made some different decisions earlier on it might still be alive in a different way and I think this is this is one of those moments if you if you sell out to the US dollar you will live through a credit when's your legislation going to come down the pike that will support DeFi and true decentralized networks and protocols and crypto in the US when is that legislation you believe in this vision and you want to save us from ourselves how are you going to foster that innovation in the United States well first of all I signed on board of coin centers you know I'm all in support of their of their letter trying to protect the right to self-host wallets I am all in support of that and I think it's really important advocacy work and as I said earlier and I wasn't being ironic I'm genuinely happy they managed to fundraise off misrepresenting my words because they're an important voice out there and I'm glad they've got a you know a place in DC I wish them all the best on that work I disagree with them when it comes to money because I think my understanding of money throughout history is it's not an anti-government tool it's always a rich and powerful elite group relying on government supports to support to to fund themselves and if you want to create a private a genuinely decentralized net stay the hell away from money do it with information do it with knowledge do it with culture I I support all of that stuff and and when it comes to bills like that I mean to be clear I'm a monetary expert right that's where I focus on I'm focusing on digital currency the work that I'm doing around anonymous digital cash is honestly there's about three people in the world doing it with me I feel very alone I would welcome people in the crypto space to fight on that and props to Jerry and Peter when we have this conversation they immediately went out and wrote stuff saying if we're going to have a digital dollar it needs to be anonymous in cash and I said yes you guys are right you're on the right track we're completely aligned on this because as far as monetary systems and the digitization of money goes these governments are going to build a surveillance system unless people step in and every person who goes you know what I'm just going to tune out and drop out like that's the 1960s hippie approach it didn't work the people who stayed in the boring room wearing the suit built the the Wall Street of the 1980s without them while can I just say Rowan I'm worried that you won't be successful in that I'm worried that you won't I'm worried that I'm worried that what what's going to happen is we're going to centralize more power in the current monetary system that we have and people like you might want a private money system but not enough people in the government do and we'll end up with something like the what China's doing with their digital currency and like so so this is the thing like we can't put all our eggs in the basket that you're talking about like we can't as a society and as a people like what happens if you're wrong what happens if you don't win those arguments we end up with a more centralized system that's now doing NMT and it's fully surveilled and we can't even open a bank account against an authoritarian government who's like what happens if you're wrong about those things we lose we all lose yeah but we lose anyway made this is my this is maybe just a tactical disagreeing or strategic disagreement if you're talking about building a currency for World War III compliance I don't know what planet you're talking about after World War III right but you're talking about one where there's probably a nuclear winner for 20 or 30 years you're talking about most vegetation on the planets did but hey at least I've got some digital gold assets I mean come on this is not this is not the priority in that moment if you really think that there's a way to build around that the governments of the world and the control they have I don't I just don't agree with you I don't think the currency layer is what stops tanks I just don't think it's true and you know mass revolution sure I'm with you but but like making sure that your hundred million dollars is safe in your basement it doesn't make a difference you can have as much gold as you want I have this conversation with Dimitri you can have as much gold as you want if they're coming from every single member of your family or your race it's not going to help you and what Dimitri said is well at least you can buy your way out and that works if totalitarianism comes in one country it doesn't work if it's everywhere so if it's World War III and it's authoritarian regimes from the US to China where do you buy your ticket to I mean what Milton Friedman's grandson C-steading in the Pacific you think that the cruisers in the Pacific are going to let him do that come on I mean what is the alternatives we're all in we're all in this bloody globe together and we either we either stop them from building the the procedures of totalitarianism or we don't but if we don't digital currencies private digital currency is not going to save especially not one built on the US dollar Rowan I'm I'm struck by the very strong similarities that I see with what you are doing with what we and Ryan are doing while simultaneously they're being some absolutely completely polar opposite features as well as far as like a discussion goes I'm really happy that you came on and gave us some of your time to go through some of these details I think it was for me it was really educational to kind of hear a similar yet opposite or or similar yet different perspective and I think I hope a lot of the listeners kind of learned about like what are because I do believe that there are some very real criticisms of the cryptocurrency industry coming coming from from what you are saying and I do hope you know that at the same time like it is a constant conversation in the world of crypto that if we just end up recreating the same systems that we've seen before then we've lost like the crypto is supposed to be something new something better something cool and that likewise I see you acting as a steward of public goods I understand that you understand that public goods are some of the most important things that we can endeavor to create that's also something that we see ourselves doing here at bankless and making sure that the listeners understand that there are more than one ways to get to public goods I think is really important and I think you coming on and sharing your perspective I think was really valuable to what we call the bankless nation I have an article that I want to send to you and then get your opinion on it's called the global public goods in the protocol synch thesis it kind of illustrates how we see public goods coming out of the space and I want to see if it resonates with you and likewise I think this will not be the last of Rowan Gray when comes to crypto legislation and I'm looking forward to maybe having you back on in the future to talk more about this object matter yeah thanks for having me and yeah I completely agree I think we do share a lot of common goals I think we diverge at a very sort of early point in the road and that's where it ends up looking like there's a lot of difference and look if you're right and you succeed honestly I'm happy too right I think you I think it's the wrong way but I think we do actually want to avoid the same kinds of risk in the long term so thanks for having me on I appreciate the fact questions sure Rowan it's been a pleasure guys that has been another episode of bankless risks in disclaimers of course eat this risky so is crypto so is Bitcoin my goodness nmt feels kind of risky too you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but thanks for joining us on bankless