Ethereum just turned 10, and Vitalik Buterin returns to reflect on the last decade—and where it’s headed next.
In this conversation, Vitalik shares what surprised him most about Ethereum’s growth, the hard lessons from challenges like The DAO and NFTs, and what he’d do differently if starting again.
We explore Ethereum’s evolving cultural identity, privacy as a core value, the tradeoffs between L1 and L2, and how Vitalik envisions Ethereum surviving an AI-dominated future.
------
🎬 DEBRIEF | RYAN & DAVID UNPACKING THE EPISODE
https://www.bankless.com/podcast/debrief-ethereums-next-decade-vitalik-buterin
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAX | SELF SUFFICIENT DeFi
https://bankless.cc/Frax
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
https://bankless.cc/unichain
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK
https://bankless.cc/Mantle
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
0:52 Ethereum’s First 2 Years
2:25 Ethereum’s Top Contributions
4:18 Biggest Surprises
7:37 What Took Longer than Expected
9:05 Overcoming Challenges
11:03 Lesson for Younger Vitalik
15:53 Bitcoin vs Ethereum
18:49 Ethereum’s Cultural Evolution
32:11 Privacy on Ethereum
37:42 Nation State Resistant Privacy
43:03 Cypherpunk vs Mainstream
56:05 World Ledger
59:09 Ethereum in 2024
1:02:23 Changes in the Ethereum Foundation
1:10:10 Economic Alignment
1:16:38 Scaling the L1
1:31:21 Ethereum’s Barbell Strategy
1:39:28 Ethereum Nationalism
1:48:28 ETH Treasuries
1:55:19 The Next 10 Years for Ethereum
1:59:35 The Next 10 Years for Vitalik
2:01:25 The Next 10 Years for Bankless
2:02:52 Closing & Disclaimers
------
RESOURCES
Vitalik Buterin
https://x.com/VitalikButerin
2021 Endgame
https://vitalik.eth.limo/general/2021/12/06/endgame.html
Convex and Concave Dispositions
https://vitalik.eth.limo/general/2020/11/08/concave.html
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
So what are your hopes and dreams and goals for Ethereum to accomplish over the next 10 years? A future of computing where a trustless vision of security that is based on cryptography and verification of code. The era of trust me for security starts looking as archaic as the era of I'm like not cleaning our water looks just today. But we've already gotten there with the CTPS. I think we need to get there with it with everything else. And I think Ethereum can be a huge part of making that happen. Ethereum just turned 10 years old and we have back on the podcast, Vitalik Buterin. Vitalik, welcome back to Bankless.
Thank you so much, David and Ryan. It's great to be back. So first happy birthday, Ethereum. The Ethereum white paper was published all the way back in 2013. And then the Ethereum mainnet launched in July 2015. So 10 years later, Vitalik, how has Ethereum turned out compared to what you envisioned? I mean, definitely far bigger than I was expecting. I think that's the most important thing. Also, it's definitely taken longer than expected. It's definitely turned out to be more than I expected. I think when I wrote the November white paper, my plan was still that this would be a site project that I would quickly get done over a couple of months and then go back to university.
And of course, that ended up not happening. And then at some point, we thought that we'd have four stages. We get to proof of stake. And then exactly at that time, the foundation went around of money and then the project would just kind of sit on its own from there. That also didn't happen. Then, of course, all of the DeFi started happening and the various different waves of people launching different kinds of tokens had started happening. And a lot of that was written in the white paper. We had derivatives in the white paper as a used case. And that actually exists, though, of course, the words that people ended up using are often different in a couple of cases.
ENS happened, stable coins happened. But at the same time, lots and lots of really fascinating surprises. Now that we have just 10 years of Ethereum in our view mirror, there's a lot that more or less went according to plan. I think if you read the white paper and then you look at what Ethereum is, you're like, yeah, that actually kind of followed suit with what some of the original visions were for Ethereum. Looking back, what has Ethereum uniquely contributed to the world that perhaps you are most proud of or most happy about? I think it has contributed to openness and decentralization and just being a norm and a default mindset for a lot of people.
In a way that I think needs to be refreshed every generation. So what in a traditional free and open source software was in the 1980s and 1990s, I think, another blockchain world is in a large part meant to be basically that, but for the 2010s and the 20s. And I think for a lot of people that has actually done that, it's contributed to making a lot of things possible. Prediction markets are one of those examples. Back in the early 2010s, there were mostly an idea and I think Ethereum was the big experimental ground that really took them from idea to reality. The whole concept of DAOs, of course, lots of ups and downs in that space, but just to generally taking governance of organizations and structures that control resources and turning that into something that's much more hackable.
I think very proud of that. And I think we're going to keep on seeing dividends from that over the decades. So a lot of different things. But you mentioned some surprises along the way. I can imagine there have been a number of surprises. One of which, which is kind of fascinating trivia, is you expected this to be a side project. And it's turned into a 10-year, more or less full-time engagement and pretty massive in terms of scale. What were some of the big surprises, though, along the way with Ethereum? Things you didn't expect. The DAO getting such a huge amount of eth and then, of course, breaking almost immediately.
I think in retrospect, the first was a bit more surprising than the second, but still. That was a runaway use case. It was sort of an early DeFi use case in a way, because it was all about capital formation. And you're like, suddenly, man, I don't recall, but suddenly, it was like 5% of all ETH supply or something incredibly massive. It got all the way up to 11%. 11% of ETH supply. China remember, was it 11% of all ETH or was it 11 million ETH? Because if it was the lighter, then it would be like 17%. But it was, yeah, it was crazy high. It was the first instance of animal spirits kind of really rearing its head on Ethereum.
Okay, so that, what else along the way? I mean, of course, ETC. That was the hard fork war. And then I love how it was almost like a TV series where just as the ETC chapter was winding down at that exact time, the Shanghai Dostech chapter began. The writers put that at exactly the right time. Maybe it was the same writer, I don't know. But that was such a fascinating series of technical challenges. NFTs were a big one that was not really, yeah, expecting anything like NFTs at all. I mean, definitely just like the scale to which DeFi grew once it actually started, going from just a Uniswap barely existing in 2019 to just like the really big boom that we had even only a year and a half later.
Another thing. Well, proof of stake taking much longer than I expected, of course. ZK, yeah, happening like five times faster than I expected. That was good. The sheer level of institutional and then even government interest that came almost from the beginning. Even in the 2010s, there were lots of big companies that were floating around that were really interested in this space. A lot of governments were interested. I think a lot of that early interest was like the area abstract and I think just people trying to either be innovative or show that they could be innovative. But no, even still, it was not something that I expected.
And then now, of course, we're seeing the institutional interest come back, but in this much more concrete form, other things. One of the meta things you mentioned, Vitalik, is that all of this took longer than you thought it would, at least when you published the white paper. Why did it take longer? When you say take longer, are you talking about it's taken longer to get to proof of stake in the first place to implement the roll-up roadmap? What specific pieces took longer than you originally thought? And why? Part of it, I think, is just software being hard in a way that I did not have the experience to appreciate.
Part of it was also I think us just sitting higher and higher standards for ourselves. The version of Ethereum that we wanted to get out in a few months was actually what we would today call a layer two on top of Prime Coin. And then, of course, what happened was that we saw the amount of attention and interest that we got in January. And we realized this is something a lot of people are putting their hopes into. This deserves a much more serious job. And so we decided we would actually make a proper roll-up one. And I mean, of course, at the time, L1s were really made sense to build all two as on top of them.
We're not really something that existed. What else? I think it's probably a combination of those two things. It's technology taking longer than expected. And us, just like continually raising our own standards. In Ethereum's history, you talked about some of them. There have just been some of these huge challenges that were just totally unpredictable. The Dow fork being the first one, the Shanghai attacks. But even in times of Ethereum success, like the NFT Mania in 2021, there were also challenges to the Ethereum project. And the Ethereum project has just been faced with just a series of challenges over and over and over again.
And I want you to comment on how Ethereum specifically, how that strategy has emerged as a culture, as a community, as people inside the Ethereum foundation, people in Ethereum core devs in the Ethereum community, we've developed responses, strategies. We have a particular strategy to overcoming challenges that is unique to Ethereum. And now that we have kind of 10 years of data, how would you articulate what Ethereum's unique strategy is for overcoming challenges that are inherently unpredictable? I think we do a really good job of approaching the problem as an ecosystem. There's always a lot of different approaches to get tried at the same time.
There was generally an L1 based approach. There's some kind of application layer approach. Often there's multiple competing approaches in each category. And I think actually are able to pursue a lot of tracks in parallel. We're able to even get a lot of synergies between different tracks, particularly in the way that a whole bunch of different efforts in the space, simultaneously contributed to making Azure Snarks more mature that all helped each other. Yeah, I think the style of collaboration that the ecosystem has developed, I think, has proven really fascinating. And I think it's definitely not been perfect, but taking all together, it's worked quite well.
If you could go back in time to a younger version of Vitalik or a younger version of the Ethereum Foundation and teach them something that would help them in Ethereum's journey, when would you go back and what would you teach? I mean, one answer that comes to mind is, of course, all the way back to the beginning and just everything we know about ZK Snarks. Mike, that just has been such a powerful, the game-changing technology in so many ways. Just in the sake of leap-rugging Ethereum ZK technology, 10 years. Yeah, exactly. I think there have been a lot of these technical either wrong steps or side roads, so we've taken that we did not actually really need to take.
And if we were just knew what the end state actually looked like, then there were situations where we would have saved a lot of resources and a lot of cases come to things much more quickly. Not being able to predict the future is definitely one of those annoying downsides of Ethereum. Yeah, it's interesting. People do ask me, what time capsule message would I have? Since to myself. A lot of the time, the answer just is, I mean, one of these, I kind of just give myself the correct answers, technically, sort of things. But I wonder what other answers there even could have been, other than just a big warning to be more realistic in terms of expecting timelines.
There's like, sometimes I think to myself, might there have been ideas on the year. I guess you could call it more social side or economic side that in retrospect could have made things quite a bit better. So one of those examples potentially is, should Ethereum have had like time limited portion of the supply given to public goods based on even some crappy mechanism that we knew about back in 2014. The argument there would basically be that we could have potentially been able to have no explicit pre-mind, but then have basically something like miners voting based on flags in the past thousand and 24 blocks.
I mean, look on who gets the developer awards. And it possibly would have led to very similar results, or potentially, yeah, even more funding for both the foundation and other organizations, but it could have bought us more credibility in the earlier days. One of the things I think about is also could things have been done better in terms of the early relationship with Bitcoin. I think it's kind of always a bit sad that Ethereum was not able to capture more Bitcoin momentum. Okay, maybe here's one of the crazy, crazy hypotheticals. If, for example, Ethereum had like one done the issuance based on the formula that I said, and then two, let's imagine if it actually had been a fork of Bitcoin, and then like it just said, basically, hey, we are switching to proof of stake.
We're going to start with some crappier proof of stake on day one, but then will basically issue the entire and entire remaining four million east based off of like some developer formula, right? Potentially, Ethereum could have just been the Bitcoin big blocker camp. And I think, remember, imagine you guys have probably read the reviews I've had of the big and the big and small blocker sides of the block size war. And I wonder if like basically, if like Ethereum had just been the Bitcoin blockchain the whole time, like there probably would have still been a fork, but like the whole thing could have potentially proceeded much more productively.
So like that's one of those things that I sometimes think about, but then like there, but it's easy, you know, there's unintended consequences and surprises in all directions, right? Like it's possible that if you drag an existing community with you, you have lots of stakeholders from day one, and then there's just like a lot of things that you end up not being able to execute well on. So I don't know. Like, I mean, it's always certainly that the Bitcoin kind of religion or philosophy is somewhat evolved into monotheism. And so I wonder if any kind of split coin would have always been destined to divide that community and splinter them in some way.
But we're 10, we're 10 years in now, right? And Bitcoin is what? Or 16, something like that? 15, yeah. Well, 16, yeah. Okay. So, you know, we're all kind of growing up together. I guess, you know, Ethereum's entering its teenage years. And I guess Bitcoin is just learn how to drive something like that. Do you feel like the relationship is improved between Bitcoin and Ethereum? Or is that just the ratio? I feel like Bitcoiners are always nice nicer to Ethereum folks when, you know, suffering on the Bitcoin ratio. So they're kind of quiet now. But when when price direction changes, maybe, maybe things will change.
But I feel like there's less hostility, maybe between the newer cohorts of Bitcoiners and Ethereum's like, how would you characterize the relationship to that? That's what you mean by the new cohorts, right? Because I think there's like different types of new cohorts. There's the people who are trying to be technical and trying to do a bit VM and taproot and cat op cat and all of that stuff. And then there's the Sailorists. And like, I don't really expect the Sailorists to ever be particularly friendly or to have like any, especially aligned values with Ethereum. On the technical side, I mean, I think there's definitely the smart ones.
I think they have a lot of respect for the things that Ethereum is doing in terms of both the technical progress that it's made and increasingly the way the ecosystem is standing up for privacy. I think both more and more openly and more and more in a way where we're not just bringing vibes. We're actually bringing results. And on that at the same time, I think it's a lot of people respect how people in Bitcoin actually are really trying with like op cat and some of these new Bitcoin layer two ideas. And there is quite a bit of really fascinating technical work there. I think it's definitely more positive in that way.
When you see people building on Bitcoin in the technical way, people building on the bit VM and trying to make Bitcoin more expressive, do you ever think, man, you guys are just wasting your time, just come build on Ethereum. That's what we build Ethereum for. That's what it's for. Or do you actually look at it with curiosity and optimism for what they can do there? Some of both, I guess. I want to ask about the current moment of time that Ethereum finds itself in. Recently with the election of Donald Trump, we've seen a social trend shift both inside of crypto and outside of crypto. And maybe just to name this social trend shift, I'll describe it as a feminized WEF soyboy mentality shifting to a branch age mindset to quote someone on Twitter, kind of like out with a woke in with a base.
This is kind of the current zeitgeist of culture in this time. And then we saw this in crypto too, where many projects just kind of like jostled to position themselves as like USA based projects. We had that infamous like Solana Marketing video about wanting to invent technologies, not genders. And now we're seeing this still today in the cultural debate that's like spawned out of like Sydney, Sweeney's jeans. Notably, oh god, has that infected crypto yet, David? Oh, I mean, I see it on my time. It has now kid grads. This episode is the mimetic super spreader of edge. Yeah, exactly. So notably, Ethereum has not participated in this trend shift.
But if you're whatever, I want to publicly thank Sydney Sweeney for not making any NFTs fully or you've also given her an idea. So I want to ask about like, whatever Ethereum was before this cultural trend shift, it still is today. And I want to ask, is that by design? Is Ethereum supposed to be this bulwark against the changing like zeitgeist, the changing fat of the times? I mean Ethereum is so I think supposed to be a pluralistic ecosystem of that incorporates a lot of different people and a lot of different viewpoints. Though at the same time, especially in a world where there's many different cryptocurrencies and many different ecosystems, you are going to get different levels of drift, like self-selection happening organically.
I mean, even if Ethereum was the only cryptocurrency, I think you'd expect to see differences in cultural elements between Ethereum and AI, for example. I mean, I think it's the duty of each project to just try to make the best and most upstanding version of the philosophy that it's members are most enthusiastic about and comfortable with. And hopefully the result of all this is that we get things that are productive and that improve the world across a lot of different directions instead of just like projects that fight each other in like either fight each other or that like basically yeah, get stuck in this mentality where all that they do is just kind of shout vibes.
And then I mean, you just have like one group shouting one vibe and other group shouting another vibe and they yeah, you know, feel very righteous, but then you come back in three months and you realize they haven't actually made any progress. And so like I think, personally, there's definitely things that worry me about quite a lot about various cultural shifts that we've been seeing in the world. But then if you just worry, then ultimately you're just one of the fibers. And so I think the practical question is like, well, how do we actually advance and respond and actually create the next and better version of a competing alternative, right?
And so I think in that regard, like the couple of new themes this year have been, and so one of them is that I've tried to kind of say and do things to sort of reset the conversation on public goods funding in Dallas, right? Because like I do think those are important topics, and I do think that if you just give up on funding public goods, if you give up on what basically any form of governance other than founder dictatorship, like that still has a lot of quite negative consequences. And you know, the end state of that is that you just sort of get back to like essentially trust me a land. And but at the same time, like quadratic funding has actual problems, like token voting delegation dows have really big problems.
And so I've been milked trying to be supportive of prediction market based funding and prediction market based dows. I've been working with DaVanch quite a bit. I mean, he's been doing deep funding. And he which is like public goods funding. And there's a version two, which is pretty directly based on prediction markets, basically combining together like prediction markets with this jury mechanism that's like basically the ideas that if you have a gadget that can give an opinion of like a high quality opinion of how valuable something is, but it takes a lot of effort, then you can use prediction markets as a way of scaling it.
And my underlying philosophy is to try to like replicate the best aspects of free markets. But for the public goods funding right. So create that you know, in open, well, what political scientists call an open access order like a game where anyone can come in and if they do a good job, then they can feel succeed and they can feel like they have a fair chance. Then something that like doesn't evolve into being a social game, something that doesn't evolve into being a game of convincing a few central actors. And then trying to like actually push that into into some actual experiments. So, Devanch and the Aquarius team have been doing somewhat quite a bit of work there.
And then the other big thing that I've been like really trying to push is this greater focus on privacy, right. And I think, you know, the reason why is because first of all, privacy is like, it has been a core part of the cypherplunk spirit since the beginning, right. Like if you remember, Chami and Ekash from 1982, Chami and Ekash was actually not decentralized, right. Like at a central operator that all of the transactions went through, but it was private and it was private from the central operator, right. Because that was those were the properties of the technology that we could actually do.
And it was because of technological limitations that we flipped over and we once to Bitcoin, which was decentralized, but it was not private. But now, of course, we have ZGaSnarks, those technological limitations are gone and we actually can be decentralized and private, right. And so we actually should be. And so there's been some really interesting work that's been starting to happen in terms of like really standardizing kind of railway privacy pools, type of things, making it easier to incorporate privacy protocols, looking at privacy of reading the chain. So basically, yeah, like if you're an ordinary user and you have a browser wallet and you don't have two terabytes to spare, then, you know, what is a way for you to access a theorem without just revealing all of your data about everything you're doing to and so there's been some really fascinating cryptographic and academic work that's been happening there.
And like I think they're like it's I actually like I think in service of cultural triangulation, my role model there is Millay, right. Because if you look at when Millay did, I think it's actually kind of brilliant, which is that he basically had like he has bronze age vibes but his substance is actually the same basically the kind of stuff that I think all three of us support and would have supported at any time in the last 15 years, right. I mean, he has made markets more free. He has made the government more efficient. He has really reduced inflation. He is simplified a lot of a lot of things in housing markets.
He has done he has done a lot, right. And he's also he's reduced tariffs. He has made the country more open. I mean, he is in his government even, you know, I kind of worked with us to make it easier for people to get visas for DEF Connect. So actually, yeah, like in a lot of ways on the substance, he is like a very not like that kind of substance, but at the same time, you know, he has divides of the other side and so he manages to appeal to a lot of people very successfully. And like to me, privacy actually has a lot of those same properties, right. Because privacy is freedom. Privacy is a very important right that we're all here to protect privacy is something that's that that just has to be built technologically speaking.
If you have privacy as a focus, then it is is what the game that you're playing is a game that's about doing and it's not and it's not about talking. But at the same time, you know, what privacy is not is privacy is not, you know, like multi billion dollar grifting privacy is not, you know, people ripping off T-shirts and something their chests a lot privacy is not, you know, like more colluding with all politicians, like, and so it's one of those things that I think really, yeah, everyone in the, yeah, Ethereum ecosystem should be able to get behind. And so I think it's something that we just have to really keep pushing forward on.
In the Wild West of DeFi, stability and innovation are everything, which is why you should check out Frax Finance, the protocol revolutionizing stable coins, DeFi and Rolex. The core of Frax Finance is Frax USD, which is backed by BlackRock's institutional fiddle fund. Frax designed Frax USD for besting class yields across DeFi, T-bills, and carry trade returns all in one. Just head to Frax.com, then stake it to earn some of the best yields in DeFi. Want even more? Bridge your Frax USD over to the Frax still layer two for the same yield plus Frax still points and explore Frax's diverse layer two ecosystem with protocols like curve, convex, and more, all rewarding early adopters.
Frax isn't just a protocol, it's a digital nation powered by the F-XS token and governed by its global community. Acquire F-XS through Frax.com or your go-to decks, stake it, and help shape Frax nation's future. Ready to join the forefront of DeFi? Visit Frax.com now to start earning with Frax USD and staked Frax USD. And for bank listeners, you can use Frax.com slash r slash bankless when bridging to Frax will for exclusive Frax will perks and boosted rewards. Imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly. That's what mantle is pioneering with blockchain for banking, a revolutionary new category at the intersection of trade five and web three.
At the heart is you are the world's first money app built fully on chain. It gives you a Swiss iBand account blending fiat currencies like the euro, the Swiss franc, the United States dollar, or the Remembee with crypto all in one place. Enjoy real world usability and blockchains trust and programmability. Transactions post directly to the blockchain compatible with tradfi rails and packed with integrated DeFi futures. UR transforms mantle network into the ultimate platform for on-chain financial services, unifying payments, trading, and assets like the MI4, the MEs protocol, and functions F-BTC.
Backed by developer grants, ecosystem incentives, and top distribution through the UR app, reward stations, and buy-bit launch pool. For M&T holders, every economic activity in UR drives value back to you, embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem. Follow mantle on x at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking. That's x.com slash mantle underscore official. Ethereum's layer two universe is exploding with choices, but if you're looking for the best place to park and move your tokens, make your next stop unichain. First, liquidity.
Unichain hosts the most liquid uniswap V4 deployment on any layer two, giving you deeper pools for flagship pairs like each USDC. More liquidity means better prices, less slippage, and smoother swaps, exactly what traders crave. The numbers back it up. Unichain leads all layer twos in total value locked for uniswap V4, and it's not just deep, it's fast and fully transparent, purpose-built to be the home-based for DeFi and cross-chain liquidity. When it comes to costs, Unichain is a no-brainer. Transaction fees come in about 95% cheaper than Ethereum mainnet, slashing the price of creating or accessing liquidity.
Want to stay in the loop on Unichain? Visit unichain.org or follow at Unichain on x for all the updates. Let's talk about it some more, because I think that's like an interesting cultural component of how we balance kind of Ethereum values versus like this mainstreaming moment with tradfires to talk about privacy. So I guess Malay you're saying is that he's got, he's sporting the Bronze Age mullet. Let's call it where, you know, it's Bronze Age in the front, but it's good sensible policy and getting things done in the back. It actually works. And so, how do we Bronze Age mullet our way to privacy on Ethereum?
I mean, it does seem like, it seems like in some areas we've made tremendous progress on the cryptography side of things, like we have ZK technology, that's just like incredible. But times where we've tried to implement privacy, I mean, tornado catch, we've got the live court case going on. We don't know yet the verdict at the time of recording of Roman storm. And so, anytime you get into financial privacy, you get nation state pushback. And there's an argument that I've always thought was somewhat valid that if Ethereum or Bitcoin for that matter, shipped privacy on layer one from the very beginning and it was all private, we would have never gotten this far in terms of broad acceptance because there are forces out there that would have strangled this technology in its crib.
And so, how do we about, I guess, what's a realistic way you think privacy can evolve, right? We've got very niche applications, I would say, still like tornado cash and even things like rail gun. They can do some things. It's not user friendly. It's not broad. It's certainly not privacy by default. You've got things like Aztec that are spinning up. They're going to be in main net, but that's going to be its own separate roll up. How do we balance all of these things and get to a place where we're happy and we're content? And I guess maybe nation states that try to preserve some level of freedom also feel fine with letting this move forward.
What's a realistic privacy roadmap here? Yeah. I think there's two parts to that. One part of that is just how do we get from privacy being very niche to privacy being a default part of the experience? And question two is how do we make a critical mass of governments and regulators? Okay, what's that? And I think for question one, so the reason why I have not supported like literal on-chain, layer one privacy, yeah, like 7503, you know, like wormhole type of stuff so far is not because I think it's fundamentally wrong, but because I think like it's basically too early technological way to make that kind of commitment.
And what I mean by that is that one, we don't yet know exactly which technology is will be optimal. And if we put a technology in as layer one, then we could be walking ourselves into something very suboptimal, right? And this is obviously a concern with any EIP that we make, but with privacy because like the data is inherently private, like you can't just kind of muck around and basically replace the tree and like search and replace one thing with another if you really have to. And so it's like it's harder to upgrade, right? But tell us, does this imply that you believe privacy on the Ethereum layer one is fundamentally correct?
I, I mean, I think in the long term, I'm very open to it, right? So one argument as that, right? It was, I mentioned like future compatibility, the other argument is security, right? Because like you have to remember that a privacy gadget on 01 breaking would be extremely bad because someone would be able to steal an unlimited number of coins undetectively, right? And I think like eventually the tech will be good enough that I think we will be able to make that jump, right? Like I, you know, I am serious when I said in my recent blog post about two weeks ago that like there is a trend line that the number of bugs in code actually is trending down to zero.
And so we will get to the point where we're going to have be able to have very high levels of trust in code to the point where like security researchers who have been trained on the past the past 20 years will find it unimaginable. And I think AI will accelerate that. But like before that and also Zcash to their credit like they've been brave and they've just like gone ahead and done it, right? But even still like that's a high bar, right? And so the question is can we make privacy as default as possible without making it layer one? And to me, the medium term target is to make privacy defaulted wallets, right?
And the way that we do this is basically that I think the biggest mistake that we're making as an ecosystem right now is that we came up with this concept of a privacy wallet, right? And like we should not have privacy wallets. Privacy should be a feature of wallets, right? Like, you know, you should like privacy features should be something that can be incorporated into existing wallets. What are you talking about? So if I'm in my existing crypto wallet browser extension, let's say you're on mobile, there's an option, like I can send a transaction normally or I can send a private transaction, that kind of default.
Exactly. Like you have private, private balance and a private send button. And it's all like part of that, a basket, a rabbit or a vampire or whatever. And can we do that now? And why don't we do that now? You know, I mean, there's actually some work that's starting inside the EF to try to move things in that kind of direction already. So hopefully, yes, some of that should come out over the next few months. What about the other part of that question, which is how can we get nation states? Like, obviously projects like Ethereum want to push the overtunt a window towards more privacy, more open source, more decentralization, right?
And so go to some extent that will be anti-sum, you know, government some cultures that don't embrace that. But we want to push the culture over. And also, we want mainstream acceptance of this thing, right? We can't have it illegal in all of the countries of the world. Is there some sort of balance we can like get to get some of the nation state concerns around criminality and money laundering and also balance the cypherpunk values here? Are these just incompatible? Yeah. So I think first of all, like all of the progress that we've been making on like the privacy pool's concept over the past couple of years has been very good, right?
Like now, real way, yeah, like real gun exists. And you can use it. And there's successful cases where we can point to words actually prevented people who have hacked large-scale defy contracts from putting their funds privacy pools doing very similar technology. So like that whole concept is starting to be more battle tested, right? And like the thing to realize so far, right, is that in terms of illicit funds that pass through privacy protocols, like by far the largest portion of it is people stealing from my defy protocols or possibly people get subcases stealing from individuals, right? And in both of those cases, like both of those are actually very amenable to this kind of like like privacy protocol level blacklisting, right?
Because you know, if your money gets stolen, then like there's just presumably there will be just an API where you can just basically flange your own coins as being suspicious, right? And if a defy project gets hacked, then it will do the same thing, right? And so I think like that already is something that can really push things forward quite a bit. In terms of like how much more we can or will need to do, I think the thing to keep in mind, right, is that like the fiat ecosystem is definitely not a paragon of bad actor resistance, right? Like there's all kinds of bad actors that have all kinds of ways to move money around to like anonymize themselves to avoid detection, you know, like the equivalent of, you know, like seven proxies and all of these things, like, well, there are ways and they get and they know how to use them, right?
And given that, you know, the funds are transparent on a public blockchain, at least in the sense of like you can point to transactions that are happening. And you know, if you're, if something happens to your money, like, you know, you know, when it's it's getting moved, like I actually think that getting to a level of like bad actor resistance so that or unfriendliness that approaches the fiat ecosystem, but at the same time giving people much more actual privacy is like probably quite doable, right? So I think to me that's like one part of those prongs. And I think the second prong is that like we do just need to make the positive case for why greater levels of privacy are important and including being important from the perspective of law enforcement type objectives, right?
And like for me, the motivating example of this is that like, there's been a couple of these cases, like it actually happens all the time now. Most recently, there was like telecom wire tap data, like the type of data that basically telecoms are required to collect and that give to the government under the communications assistance to law enforcement act, like a bunch of that got hacked and type of leave. Like it's the evidence as a leading that it got hacked by China, but or some China affiliated actor, but like actually, yeah, I'm going to look what like I have no idea, I'm going to look at all of these things are probabilistic.
And like this is like that's just one example. And like actually, you know, this happens in all kinds of directions among all pairs of my nation states, all quite a lot recently, and so like a world where like every, yeah, basically, yeah, a world where you have this kind of centralized data collection running rampant is a world of fragility because if those databases get hacked, then data that you think might be contributing to national security, just in case, will will actually end up contributing to national insecurity, right? And I think like that just is a case that needs to be, yeah, needs to be made much more strongly.
Yeah, I mean, like two lawmakers to the to the public in general that like aggressively minimizing data collection is actually the yeah, safe thing to do. And this is the thing that we should be moving toward and privacy preserving finance is part of that. So I think you're signaling that you at least would like to hold firm in crypto and Ethereum on on privacy, right? And it's like this goes back to a broader culture question. I guess I want to ask about Ethereum. It's been my observation of the last like 10 years that some of the cipher punk things that we've tried have worked, but not in their idealized aversion, if that makes sense.
And so right now we're at a moment very much in Ethereum's history where we're on we're actually onboarding the world. I mean mainstream is coming like Robin Hood doing a layer two and JP Morgan talking about doing stuff on Jane and Coinbase getting larger and larger and they're all coming to Ethereum. And so there's kind of a question here about when you get some that traditional finance and mainstreaming who don't have cipher punk values, right? And you're talking about Ethereum pluralism, okay? So we would let more people into Ethereum, but with this pluralistic idea, but they're less cipher punk.
They care less about the values that that maybe we care about. And so there's a question of like where do we draw the line because I think about something like stablecoins. My idealized version of a stablecoin would probably be something like rye. You remember that project rye, okay? So it was all it was all completely decentralized. It was all crypto native. Guess what? That didn't work. Like no one wanted it. There wasn't product market fit in the in the Silicon Valley parlance and what has worked circle tether these other less idealized cipher point punk stablecoins, but they are helping people mean go to emerging countries.
And this is exactly what they they sort of use. I guess the question is broad. How do when should we hold fast on cipher punk Ethereum type values? And when should we adapt to the world around us and really prioritize product market fit and actual usage? Yeah, I think there is a couple of places that are like really the most key in terms of prioritizing privacy and cipher punk values. I think one is of course the low level protocol, right? Because you know, you can build a centralized or decentralized application on top of a decentralized backend, but you can only build a centralized application on top of a centralized backend.
And for I think similarly, like there are places where if the blockchain is fundamentally not at least friendly to privacy and friendly to like intermediary free ways of accessing it, then like that just does not create space for the privacy present friendly. Yeah, things to happen on top of it, right? And so like one of these examples as this is the reason why I've been continuing to work on account abstraction and continuing to improve EIP 7701. Basically because I think if we do not do that, then any smart wallet use cases or any multi-says, quantum resistant things and also privacy protocols, they will only be able to function through an intermediary ecosystem, right?
And the thing with intermediary ecosystems is that that's exactly the sort of thing where like they work until they yeah, they don't work for you, right? And so you know, there like there does needs to be some constituency that's like really yeah, watching out for these kinds of things and just making sure is it at least possible to interact with Ethereum in a way that is privacy preserving? Also, for example, in a way where you're not depending on a centralized intermediary to do your basic things if any servers that you talk to disappear, like that does not lead to any of your funds getting stuck.
And so like especially at the lower levels, these are things that I need to be really watched out for. And then I think the second aspect of this is that the the strong privacy focused and I would say intermediary minimization focused like way of doing Ethereum, like it needs to at least be possible, right? And part of that is the protocol layer, part of that is doing some of this work on the wallet layer, on the application layer. And I think to me, it's fine if the majority of people do not take that option, but what we do not want to see is we don't we don't want to see a world where the infrastructure to do that does not exist, and we do not want to see a world where the top level protocols like ERCs and standards are like just in some structure all way hostile to it, right?
So I mean maybe one analogy to this is I think email is like actually a really great analogy to mine, right? Because theoretically, email is an open protocol. Anyone can make an email server like you can go get a VPS, you can get a DNS account and like you can set up, you know, like Ryan and David email.com and then give yourselves, Ryan at Ryan and David email.com, David at Ryan and David email.com. If you want, you could even write all the software yourselves and like the LLM's make that like actually way more practical for you guys than you might have ever imagined. But at the same time, you know, the problem you run into is basically, okay, you've got your own dinky little email server, but then by default, all the big providers blacklisted and they're blacklisting it because of like basically spam, right?
And so de facto email ends up relying on being much more of a centralized and the ends permissions thing that it could have been, right? And so then there's a question of like, well, you know, like what things could have been done with email to try to preserve its its openness better, right? And I think, well, like basically what we want to ask the equivalent of that type of question, but then for any particular standard that comes up, right? So for standards for moving tokens from one layer to another layer to right for like intent-based standards, like one of the things I've been making sure is that for some of these, you know, like intent-based like trade tokens on optimism for tokens on arbitrary approaches, like make sure there is a way to do it without talking to a server, right?
And like it is totally doable, right? And the challenge is that if you don't think about it, then like all the standards end up kind of assuming at the lower level that there's servers that you talk to and then like you just get privacy leaks, right? And so I think like having people in the right places that are just watching for these kinds of things and that just make sure that like privacy-friendly, intermediary-opt minimized, like more self-sovereign ways of doing things actually exist and don't have at least like a needless performance penalty to them is important. And if not everyone takes that option then fine, right?
Like if a bunch of people like start like continue to hold their coins inside of coin-based and fine, right? If a bunch of people continue to use metamask that directly, you know, like full-each rusts inferior without any protection and they yet decide not to add any of the protection based on, you know, like either Helios or some of the private RPC stuff that we're just starting to do, then like fine, right? But like the the place to start is just the option existing and the social norm that is like a product protocols and standards that get built have to take into account the need to be at least accommodating of people who take that option.
Yeah, great news for David and I too is Ryan and David.com email.com is available right now. So we can just go spin up a VPS now. I wonder if any of you LL my agents have already registered David and Ryan E. question. I want to get into some more narrow topics about Ethereum in more recent times, but in order to get there I kind of want to ask one last zoomed out question to really kind of frame the stakes of some of those incoming questions. And so I want to present the future. There are particular versions of the future that we know are coming our way. We know AI is going to define the future and we can know we can talk about the different ways that that looks.
There are also geopolitical tensions that seem like they're on their horizon. There's seemingly an increased Balkanization of the world. There are just possible versions of the future out there that are like kind of scary. And you know there's other possible you know there's other things to talk about that are also kind of cool like gene editing and all that kind of stuff. There's just the future is coming. What role Vitalik do you think Ethereum has to play in the future that we know is coming our way? By the way I'm glad that we're on the same page that gene editing is the exciting thing and AI is the scary thing.
I think there are plenty of people that have that flipped and I think the version that you described is the correct one. But yeah we'll roll into Ethereum play. I think to me the answer has always been in two parts. The fundamental product I think that Ethereum offers is protecting people's freedom and self sovereignty and ability to organize in a way that does not depend on or is like any kind of mask for any individual person or company or a nation state. And I think in a world that is more Balkanized that the physical layer like that's a very valuable thing and that's an increasingly rare thing right like if you if you turn back the clocks you know the clock 15 years ago tell like Facebook like I think basically yeah there were a lot of people who were willing to give Facebook the level of trust that today we were like we pretty much all agree that is a level of trust that is only really deserved to give to something that's like a blockchain right and so 15 years ago I think you know that in that sense sort of the market was not ready right because like no the whole idea that trust issues are something that you have to worry about was not really there like famously it was the era of privacy is over my yeah remember I mean there were a lot of people you know Mark Zuckerberg's real name policy famously more than I personally remember searing people like basically saying like privacy is open is over at cloud computing conferences and then of course you know fast forward 10 years and then like even those guys are starting to talk about things like tea is now and so I think in that sense you know the the market for trust technologies is something that's ready like it's and I mean market in like a very expansive and metaphorical way right like there's people who are willing to pay money for these things and then also there's people who have like say social problems that they care about who are willing to embrace these kinds of technologies as a part of the solution and I think that's that like that exists too much greater extent than that existed 10 years ago so I think that's part of it right which is just building the technology that actually is able to do those things and and the second part is like I think there is an unavoidable aspect of this which is global community building which is basically that Ethereum is this powerful intellectual attractor for people who care about decentralized finance for people who care about new forms of creating organizations for people who care about things like prediction markets increasingly for people who care about privacy for people who care about making like democratic modes of organizing actually work in a technological advanced society like there's a lot of these different topics that if you're a man's up being adjacent to where I think like the community itself is a valuable good even in a hypothetical world where let's say yeah tomorrow we discovered that Simon O.
P. equals N.P. and we all had to pack up our bags and go home in terms of what in terms of walkchains because cryptography can't exist anymore right so I think that's also something that's really valuable to continue building on in the early days there was this meme of Ethereum as kind of a world computer that has kind of ebbed in flow as a meme that's worked in your may post early this year you called Ethereum a world ledger which I think that resonates with me and feels less abstract a bit more concrete maybe to some folks it won't but to me it sort of implies okay it's a world ledger that I can use to register things like property for instance and another thing I keep coming back to like what is Ethereum it's a decentralized property rights system I get for many normies that's still a bit to abstract but to what extent do you think that encapsulates what we're trying to do here Ethereum as a world ledger yeah I think to me the release yeah valuable thing about Ethereum as a world ledger is yeah it's like the problem with the world computer is that a computer is like an inherently super expansive concept right like computers do everything for you like computers generate your cat pictures now they yeah you know they get used to look at your cat pictures they can convert your cat pictures into videos they can translate the thing that the cat is holding up on its sign into German and then you know do a video it's a video for that okay I have lots of cats and AI examples clearly but the point is they can do lots of things for you right they can categorize your life okay how about that but you know like basically they do lots of things that are just obviously totally inappropriate for especially the Ethereum L1 right and so the nice thing about ledger is as a word is that it feels like it encompasses the subset of a computer that's like really yeah highly economically valuable and I think I mean obviously the word ledger has these very financial connotations and so it's also very clear to see what it implies in the context of DeFi but then it's also I think very easy to see the metaphor for you know like what the equivalent of a ledger is for something like EMS right so and then the nice thing about that term is that then it starts to like I think the thing that I specifically said is that the Ethereum L1 is the world ledger right and and so I think it also at the same time tries to make the yeah relationship between L1 and L2 more clear which I think is one of my explicit goals yeah and I think I mean it's to the extent that people picked up on the phrase that's definitely been successful at those things if Ethereum is the world ledger what does that make eth okay right now we have to figure out what is like the ledger equivalent of gasoline I mean I guess it's ink I mean okay fine ink is a layer two but like if ink has the TM symbol beside it it's a layer two without the TM symbol then it's like guess is that okay works for me I want to zoom into some of the conversations that was ongoing in the Ethereum community in 2024 I'll just kind of say I'll define 2024 as like hard times for Ethereum mostly just due to the decline of the relative ETH price and it kind of created a bunch of in-fighting and what to do about that fact in the Ethereum community did you think Ethereum had a rough 2024 is that is that what you felt I definitely think so how do you account for that how do you explain like the story of Ethereum in 2024 yeah and I think I mean the low ETH price was definitely one of those very big aspects that that led to a lot of things I think a big part of it for a lot of people was also that like some storylines were ending without other clear storylines replacing them right in the sense that I think there were definitely people who became kind of quietly dissolution with dows but like it wasn't clear you know if you're if you're the sort of person who likes dows but then suddenly dows don't work then like what else do you do then in NFTs we're also end of dying down in 2024 meme coins were definitely on the rise in 2024 but then at the same time I think no Ethereum people just by nature wants to make a serious difference in making the world a more free and open place and it's kind of harder to see how meme coins contribute to that and also of course I mean although the largest meme coins were all happening on Solana so what other I mean there were like a lot a lot of these I mean also I think another big part of it was I mean although the whole like layer one versus layer two thing and how kind of post in people sometimes like pin it on 4844 I'm not sure to what extent that's actually true not 4844 but or actually yes 4844 and like having an independent fee market for for blobs and like basically the question of like well are L1 and L2 actually yeah cooperative and then like once there's a realization that there's this is like more misaligned incentives like that naturally yeah like leads to inviting more so I think it's a combination of all of those actors right or all of those factors right like it was a moment where you know the price was falling and at the same time it felt like you know there were a lot of storylines were kind of meeting their natural end and it wasn't quite yet clear what is the new thing that would actually come and replace them where that I think that new thing has to be something that both is a money maker and that the Ethereum community could get behind until actually I mean I actually think in 2025 we're like actually starting to see answers to some of those some of those questions so I think that's like one of the reasons for the positivity that we're seeing now yeah I mean there's still debate in Ethereum today about how much of the story of 2024 was just narrative siops versus actual real problems that needed to be fixed like the story one of the big stories was that like the Ethereum roll up centric roadmap would just became not what we thought that it would be the fragmentation between chains was pretty bad every chain every layer two feels like a brand new chain and in contrast to that the layer one was just trying to not wasn't really a trying to scale and it's kind of felt like there was a the story out there that the Ethereum roadmap just felt incoherent to what it's like endgame was supposed to be which is this global unified world computer and then you know downstream of that there were there were changes made at the Ethereum foundation or or perhaps not downstream of that maybe that's part of the siop um maybe you could actually kind of just fill us in and illuminate in the the parts of the EF that many people aren't able to see why were there changes made at the EF what needed to change and where is the EF today I think this is one of those cases where there were a lot of things that were coming for a long time but like you just needed any kind of triggers like make them actually happen right so I mean the the change in leadership was one of those examples right and I think like has actually yeah I mean like I think feeling happier in the yeah her current president of board role and she yeah you know continues to be active in some some projects around I think adoption in Boutin was always I'm like one of her kind of interests and on there are some other things on the on the financial inclusion side that like she has been spending more a more time on like the executive director job is definitely not something that any one person should be in forever and I mean like lasted longer longer than like basically everyone else at the EF combined and so that was and then I mean there were also you know like new voices that have a kind of new emphysees I think I mean you know Tom and Michelle were both very strong technically in their own different ways at the same time there's been a lot of new people who are leading I'm like different parts of the foundation and different and different initiatives so one like kind of organizing the the effort around scaling and UX was one of those parts I think now one of the things that I'm focusing on is also kind of better organizing the yeah like censorship resistance and privacy side of things made and so basically yeah there's a lot of things that are happening in terms of making PSE a more kind of focused team that's like basically moving from being about privacy and scaling exploration to about like bringing privacy ideas into production so there like there's a lot of a lot of interesting new initiatives that have started and I mean I think like these are things that like I think would have happened at some time anyway but like sometimes you know these kinds of extreme moments like they yeah they service triggers and often kind of accelerate and bring forward things that are things that are coming and like me come all happen at one time so that's one part on the L1 versus L2 thing I mean I think the interesting thing there is how that's like I think a relatively disconnected topic from the EF I mean obviously the work that's being done to increase the L1 gas limit is very much in that EF topic but well and then also the other big thread that we've been working on is the the improving interoperability between L2s so that's I mean it's actually an initiative that started all the way back in mid 2024 but it just and I think that's like a good example right of how like there are a lot of things that happens that weren't said just like all caused by everything that happens at the beginning of 2025 they were happening already but then got accelerated quite a bit and there's continuing to be good work happening in terms of the in terms of the L2 interop stuff a lot more L2s have become stage one I think the next priority after stage one is going to be like so I actually think higher priority than stage two is getting to one hour withdrawal times or actually like it's it doesn't even have to be one hour like look there's no reason it can't be like one minute or 12 seconds like the fundamental limitation is just how much gas you're rolling to pay and the reason why is basically because if withdrawal times take an hour then or if it was all times take a week then it's just too capital inefficient to use like native depositing and withdrawing for a lot of applications and so like sort of trustless and L1 based ways of issuing assets are just not going to wait in the long term right and like what is going to win is basically yeah all kinds of like custom mint and burn bridges that ends up concentrating power and control and a multi-sig right and so the thing that we need is for the L1 based approaches to actually be viable but for that to happen like basically yeah you have to bring that one that one hour timed out right or that one week timed out right because for that one that one week time it's just that if you want to move assets from one chain to another like you don't want to make people walk up your coins for a week or even pay someone else to walk up your coins for a week like even the capital cost of that is too high right but if you instead of one week you see an hour then suddenly like the liquidity for intent based up bridging becomes like very cheap potentially free for a lot of cases and then of course if it goes all the way down to 12 seconds then like potentially you couldn't see a world where like uh was drawing and depositing through all one just becomes the natural way for a lot of people to move their assets between altos um so yeah but and like these things they require a lot of movement from a lot of different actors of the ecosystem right like they benefit from work inside the EF they benefit from work in altos themselves they benefit from work being done by people like succinct the whole ZKVM effort i'm like risk zero all of the other different ZK providers so it's so one of these like big things where there's just a lot of these moving parts in the ecosystem and like it just has to come together and like really turn into a concrete solution and so I'm definitely yeah more like quite optimistic now that we're on a good path to getting all of those issues resolved and you know both having a strong L1 and having altos with a much clearer relationship with the L1 um but and so you know it's it will still take time to finish all the different technological steps but uh in general i think we're in a good place here's a take Vitalik and David and I have discussed kind of the 2024 Ethereum mule is a little bit right not all these a concept of altos being parasitic you know and you what should be done it is true that I think David and I most people in Ethereum feel much better about the current state of the Ethereum roadmap with some of the new leadership at the EF and also uh some emphasis on scaling the L1 and in particular a strong L1 um but I wonder about kind of the the the rollup roadmap there's of course a lot of things that have worked tactically about it you know based to playing a rollup you know um Robin Hood more recently more tradified to come incredible adoption on that side but sometimes uh i i wonder uh and have been concerned with the fact that we have emphasized you know the different stages of kind of property rights basically user property rights on Ethereum layer two and we made some progress in getting to stage one and I think we will stage two that's that's going well we've had less emphasis on sort of the economic alignment if you will and the coordination across these layer two's there are some things tactically that can be fixed fairly easily I feel like with UX and uh standards where you can get assets from one team to another I'm not so much worried about that what I am worried about is lack of economic coordination between all of these actors and so if you get into a state I remember your 2021 endgame post which goes through conceptually a state where you have like basically Ethereum that's decentralized Ethereum layer one that's decentralized and then you have maybe there's a world where you have one big rollup that has all the execution state inside of it right and you still make the argument hey that's that's still fine because you know big block production that could be centralized we'd still validate and verify things coming the chain and that could be an okay states maybe not ideal what I worry about in that scenario is what happens if we get layer two's that becomes so much stronger than Ethereum layer one that they essentially get to dictate the rules okay they could break away from Ethereum at some point in time that just doesn't seem like a good economic balance and this what it felt like with different chains in their own brands they just they didn't feel as Ethereum as Ethereum layer one did back in the day so what do you think about this economic alignment piece do you think we can get that right is that still off yeah I agree with that and I think like you can look at the economicalignment issue from two different angles right like one of those different angles is basically like hey altos are not paying enough fees and like I think you know we should have a higher min base fear and if we just set or min blob fee and if we set them in blob the all the way up to one way then like I think it would make a lot of things better and I think that's good but then a lot of the time I'm also not sure if like fees or even the right like primary variable to be focused on right I think the right primary variable is more network effects and then okay okay maybe I guess this is like here like a police where I should that I kind of explain the reasoning behind this like what focused on one hour was draw time I bit better right because to me like that actually yeah like the thing that you say is exactly what motivates my goal of focusing on that which is basically that like if you have the thing that is likely to lead to altos sort of de facto spinning away is basically if all of the assets are issued on altos and like the assets are and then people move them through mint and burn bridges and then basically the L1 is not actually involved at all right and the thing that keeps the L1 relevant is where assets even if most of the activity happens on altos are issued on the L1 and the reason why I think that's important is basically yeah I mean it's much better from a trust list as perspective because all of these altos you know they still have governance they still have upgrade issues and so on and so if you have the asset issued on the Altos and basically no matter I'm you know where you move it like you you have to trust that Altos right but on the other hand if the asset is issued on L1 then like you you can actually natively use the withdrawal functionality and then like the L1 actually is this kind of ultimate decider right so it makes the security model clear and it also makes a lot of these like it makes things much more permissionless and because activity can more freely migrate from one L2 to another L2 I mean it becomes more viable to have like applications that just need to do things across different altos like basically yeah if and then also of course you know then any kind of technology that becomes developed for doing defy operations like synchronously between L1 and L2 we'll just like naturally be much more able to work with all of those assets right and so I think yeah like encouraging assets to actually be issued on L1 and making it economically viable to do that and then just like using the standard deposit in which strawberry else for doing that like that like that to me actually is one of these really important pieces in terms of keeping the L1 central and so I think we should do that and I think like I personally think also again now increasing the the main block base V all the way up to something like one way is good and like we should do we should do both of those things continuing to figure out some of these like synchronous composability blocks like can you make it possible for altos to have blocks that synchronous we do things between L2 and L1 I also think that's good we definitely do needs to keep what pushing forward on these things and I think we do needs to keep like pushing that vision that the point of L2 is something that gains value from interacting with the L1 and from being able to offload a lot of things to the L1 instead of an L2 just being a chain that like happens to have a bridge somewhere.
So Dave and I very much operate on the layer zero which is the social layer and one kind of conclusion we've come to is that in order to sort of speak softly but carry a big stick and increase Ethereum's layer one a soft power you have to have a scaled out L1 that scales maybe from a transactions per second perspective but is also the home for DeFi it's the home for liquidity it's the home a subset of that is for minting of the assets and the stronger the L1 the more that you have the ability to kind of a corral the layer to essentially you give them the carrot which is you get the liquidity of of Ethereum essentially that's why you're attached to this and that's why we're excited about I don't know if you'd use the P word pivot there's been some debate about the semantics of this but we're excited about the the initiative to scale the L1 we're also by the way excited we think that a higher value ETH is essential in that conversation because ETH is a store of value asset and the the larger ETH gets in terms of price the more kind of liquidity and command you have over you know the L2s if they decide to get a bit rowdy anyway can you comment on the scale the L1 path so it's always been in the roadmap somewhere maybe when ZK technology evolves to scale the L1 so from that extent it's not a pivot but there has been some recent reprioritization it seems like and it does seem with with the new EF leadership that's like number one it's scale the L1 you can scale L2 plus basis what as well but scale the L1 is a here and now thing what's the case for scaling the L1 from your perspective yeah I think the big question is always like how do you scale the L1 safely and like safely means not breaking the network safely means not completely centralizing no operation safely means being not breaking the staking ecosystem and I think we actually have technologies to do that and that did not exist years ago right so the big one of course is ZKVMs and ZKVMs are like almost production ready this year in a way that was totally not true I think even one year ago and so that's one thing that a lot of us are leaning in on explicitly like I think there's willingness to explicitly say like we're going to increase the block gasoline it by like 3 to 5x and then if that ends up eliminating the bottom 10% of solo stakers we're not telling the 10 bottom 10% of solo stakers to go screw themselves instead what we're saying is well I the bottom 10% of solo stakers can use the ZKVM approach to validate the chain instead of re-executing everything manually and like that's actually safe right because well 10% of the network relying on ZKVMs is like basically while the technology is at this medium level of maturity like it's actually fine as long as it stays under a third right and so it's like the ZK is at this level of maturity we're actually can start strategically relying on it partially various in various ways like you can think about it as the equivalent of sort of that L1 itself going into stage one in a certain sense right and then at some point once security goes the of technology goes out more than you know L1 goes to the equivalent of stage two and then you can start relying on the majority of the network using this kind of stuff and so that's one part but ZK is definitely not the only technology for this right so the two other examples of technologies one of them is history storage right so a big problem has been that nodes take up a lot of space and now we've recently yeah finally implemented the most basic form of history expiry which expires history from before the merge and so basically every yeah if they were a node has shaved a few hundred gigabytes off of its storage requirements and then the plan is to keep on going further like eventually get to what um expiring after one fork and then like I think the long-term target should be expiring after 36 days and then for that to work well you need to have some kind of peer-to-peerced like and torrents network type of distributed storage so that we make sure that the chain actually does become fully yeah accessible like fully yeah accessible and fully verifiable right so that the chain doesn't disappear right like we definitely do not want to become like ripple where like there's weird things that happen because like this so I think the first 35,000 blocks like disappeared and they were just not able to find them ever right and so that like so like the distributed history ideas from portal like those are actually making their way into production that's another example um gas repricings another example block of access lists I think are another one of those really powerful examples because what block of access to us what you do is they basically say every node except for the node that creates the original block can execute the block with maximum parallelization like it doesn't freaking matter of like EVM versus UTXO versus Solana whatever right and like base that what happens is the node that creates the block has to execute sequentially but it can generate hints right and the hints are basically intermediate states after every transaction and then if you have those hints then you become able to verify and re execute the block by running every single transaction fully in parallel and you can even parallelize between the execution and the IO right so you can have like the IO itself is actually much more efficient if it's massively paralyzed and then that goes in like some threads and then in other threads you basically parallelize you know like you break up the block into different transactions and then basically you have like a massive level of parallelizability that's completely independent of like what the underlying virtual machine model is right and so that also is a thing that makes it safer to run Ethereum at much higher gas throughput levels right so basically there's a lot of these technologies that did not exist and like now they do exist they've been really refined and really optimized quite a bit and because of that we have a lot more options than we did before to really get the best of both worlds.
Do you think with this combination of technologies we can keep the quote-quote same level decentralization that Ethereum has while doing what what Donkrad proposed which is like aim for a social commitment of 3x per year in terms of scalability I don't know Ethereum right now is after the recent block size increase I don't know we're 20 transactions per second 3x per year is what Donkrad says and then Justin Drake thinks a you know longer term resting point maybe five year time three to five year time something like that is giga gas on Ethereum layer one so 10,000 transactions per second do you think that those targets are realistic here?
I mean I definitely become kind of less sure of the higher end of some of those although actually I think like my my skepticism is probably more on short slot like ultra short slot times than it is on ultra high TPS like actually if I had to like like if I had to choose one between that you know what like give one second slots and 10,000 TPS like I think like in terms of which one is safer for Ethereum I think 10,000 TPS with 12 second slots is far safer than one second slots with current level TPS because like at those levels who just run into like speed of light like very fundamental DGO decentralization type of stuff so like I personally believe in caution at the higher ends but I definitely think there's a lot of headroom to optimize and like I definitely think we're going much further than the current 45 million level yeah and then in terms of like keeping decentralization I mean I think we're going to be at this interesting place that's hard to judge where like actually I'm hoping that in a lot of important ways decentralization is actually going to increase and I can give an example of what I mean by this so one of the things that I think everyone kind of quietly complains about is the fact that like basically no one is actually running nodes and everyone is trusting RPCs right and I think now actually for the first time in a while like I feel confident that we have a very solid roadmap to not needing to do that anymore right and so one part of this is of course helios right and like being able to have a light client inside of a wallet and the efficiency of that continues to improve but then one other big reason why the cypherpunk types tends to value personal full node operation and this is something that's like I actually did not even realize until like I personally yes spent more time to like actually going out and talking to some of them right is the ability to run a personal node for the sake of privacy right because like imagine if you're someone who is using these Ethereum privacy protocols and you are you're using many accounts to do many different things and you really care about your privacy not getting compromised but then like you're still pinging infura about every with every single one of the addresses that you're calling get balanced on and so if you're still knows all of your links to everything right now running your own node is this incredibly powerful way of not having that problem right because if you run your own node then I know you actually are just downloading the yeah whole chain and like nobody knows what your reads are because your reads are entirely local right and so the question is well how do we get the best of both worlds and the answer is that we actually will be able to and quite soon right there's two different tracks for achieving this so a track one is can we start from the current concept of an Ethereum node and can we make it much more efficient right and so here's how you make it much more efficient you say one you do aggressive history expiry you do aggressive expiry and not storing of everything in fact you even don't need to store the the the branches of the state tree all you need to store is like the table that just is the state that table is 80 gigabytes and if you have block level access lists and if you have a zero knowledge proofs like ZK EVMs to verify that the block level access list is correct then you're able to stay up to date on the current Ethereum state doing basically no local compute and only maintaining an 80 gigabyte database locally 80 gigabytes is tiny 80 gigabytes is the size of like three or four different LLMs right but like like locally running LLMs like everybody has 80 gigabytes so like even my phone has 80 gigabytes so 80 gigabytes storage very low compute still medium bandwidth but that's fine right so that's kind of what and then if we decide to scale L1 by let's like be yeah medium conservative let's say yeah we're scaling L1 by 30x right then obviously 80 gigs is going to turn into 2.
4 terabytes then 2.4 terabytes is still it goes back to being a lot right actually yeah it goes back to being like basically the amount that you need to run a full note today or like basically pre the pre history expiry so actually with like we've effectively given ourselves that's 30x of headroom already right but if you want to go further there's this concept of a partial state node partial state nodes basically say uh well you just store all of the state except the junk and there's a lot of junk and then there's a lot of like complexity lying there in terms of you know your definition of what the junk is but like really if you just say store state that's relevant to the top 100 applications and store all EOAs and all smart contract while it's like that's already going to be like massive shrinkage right and so so that's like one direction the other direction is to say well let's start from a browser wallet and let's add guarantees to it right so part one is Helios and so like line to can verify the chain part two is um you can use a technology is like um in the short term it's t e is with oh ram in the longer term PIR which has cryptographic level trust properties where you can make requests to a server without the server knowing what you requested and uh like the server gives you a response but the server has no idea what it just responded with right and so if you make make that kind of thing the standard then like you're actually able to have this kind of strong privacy guarantee like you're basically able to have a light client where the light client is not just giving you the security property of a phone node it's also giving you the privacy property of a phone node without actually needing to have a phone node right so like basically we have like a couple of different paths from which we're actually able we are going to be able to give people decentralization properties that they did not have even back into 2017 right like even back in the days before a line like basically started significantly scaling at all right and so I think uh on a lot of dimensions we get more scale and more decentralization and more privacy more censorship resistance at the same time there are places where I'm worried like I think uh like continue to make sure proof of stake stays decentralized and block building stays decentralized is like one of those points where I think we need to watch out for and uh like I think having many different high quality research teams that have different focuses and uh approaches is going to be really valuable there um right but uh no on average I think we have like actually a very good track for uh increasing decentralization and scale at the at the same time when we have to just take it I was listening to on a recent epicenter podcast with talika and there's a quote that stuck out to me that I want to get you to double tap on uh the quote was if ethereum gets sucked into directly playing the hft game the high frequency trading game as a layer one then to me that will just fundamentally destroy ethereum's soul because getting into the hft game does destroy your soul I didn't quite follow that that uh conclusion I'm I'm wondering like why does you know layer ones that play the hft game destroy your soul what do you mean by that and how is ethereum's layer one scaling strategy different from that yeah so I think uh the core principle here is basically that if you optimize for one thing very aggressively then the yet in state of that is that you end up anti-optimizing for everything else to a potentially infinite extent right like it's actually the exact same arguments that you hear from uh people like elizor yudkowski about ai safety right and uh like it's just a general principle of optimization and uh the thing with uh like very low latency hft type finance is that there is always like a lower latency that you can go right and uh if you want and then the further you go into uh into lower and lower latency the more that uh increases the incentives for ecosystem actors to go in that direction and uh like there isn't really a natural stopping point right and uh it's a very easy route for just uh progressively giving up on more and more uh global decentralized decentralization and so at some point you get to things like i mean i can uh make some of this concrete with numbers right so like for example let's take uh a one second slot time right and like if you try to analyze what that means right so first of all to have a slot time of one second you have to break that up into two parts there is block propagation and then there's attestation right and then each one of those has to take one x network latency one x network latency is 500 milliseconds right then average ping time from uh from one uh like one part of the world to another part of the world is somewhere in the low hundreds of milliseconds right and so basically yeah to even like even being able to do that at all is like a challenge that requires some pretty aggressive fear to fear optimization like you cannot have any redundancy in there like you have to have a very direct broadcast and uh what this ends up leading to is uh like that basically the challenge is like the bar that we have to meet is not the bar of like of of capability of participation the bar we have to meet is the bar of not having um strong incentives to co-locate right so it's not about non-collocation being possible it's about non-collocation being at worst only a little bit less viable than uh every then co-location right and then if you co-locate like basically if you co-locate with a proposal then effectively instead of having two hundred milliseconds latency you have zero latency right and uh like that's a really huge boost and so if we uh go into that like that direction then like the co-location incentives end up being everywhere right because uh you know if you're a defi uh participant then you know you'd want to be able to send your transactions in knowing all all of the latest information as much as possible then uh if you're a builder then like you actually have uh like every five milliseconds of latency that you get is uh gives you uh or that you removed gives you an ability to send out your block one percent further into a slot and so potentially like that even gets you like I'm not sure the exact mathematical details but close to one percent more revenue right and so uh you know we see what hft systems are like in reality right and they're like basically a bunch of co-locations of servers like everyone tries very hard to get uh you know like to get like very close to each other right and so there is this like type of uh activity where like I actually think uh like this is if there is barbell strategy right if there is barbell strategy of l1 and l2 is basically that l2s do the thing that that requires centralization and they actually get the benefits of centralization in which includes the ability to do hft but at the same time they um like they benefit from l1 providing security and censorship resistance and then they give l1 the benefit of contributing to this shared pool of activity but also sort of quarantining the l1 in terms of uh like concentrating uh like making sure that some of these uh co-location incentives end up not affecting the l1 directly right because l2s are independently sequenced so actually this is also one of the reasons why like recently I have pivoted somewhat to being like less enthusiastic about based l2s and more enthusiastic about l2s that just say like hey we're a sequencer and uh we're gonna get the benefits of that right and like you could do lots of things in that configuration right like you can even say you know you can have decentralized governance for taking you out the sequencer and like that might often might actually be a very good approach right and so I think l2 does a good job like l2s are the right structure that does a good job of absorbing uh some of that demand um actually if you fast forward even further right like we could talk about the ai economy right um so uh ai's like think a thousand times faster than we do right and so uh if you if an ai thinks a thousand times faster than a human then what from the ai's perspective the subjective speed of light is only 300 kilometers a second right so subjectively it takes only a second it takes an entire second for a light to get from one city to a neighboring city and so from the ai's perspective what once you have an entire economy of ai's which uh you know we're definitely going to get uh quite soon then uh effectively the concept of uh a global financial ledger doing everything actually stops making any sense right like at that point you actually need like basically city ledgers and like what is the right structure for city ledgers to be part of the ethereum economy like i think l2s are just uh there are a very natural answer here right and so i think uh like basically if the yeah l1 starts going in this direction then uh so a lot of centralization incentives uh end up uh end up piling up and also if we commit to being competitive and then like we commit to be like if we commit to being competitive in the hft game then we're committing to being competitive in a game where like everyone else is very aggressively optimizing while caring about decentralization much less than we do right and so i think uh like this is why like i think the barbell strategy is the right approach right where i basically yeah like l1 does needs to improve and i think l1 does needs to have uh like pretty good uh low latency from uh a human perspective right like i think bitcoin with uh 10 minute block times definitely gets it wrong right and uh like actually mill it if bitcoin had uh say a 20 second block time instead of a 10 minute block time like i could see that um you know significantly yeah i'm like making this whole uh i kind of trend uh you know like a Michael Sailor style self-custody doesn't matter like basically like like happening uh quite a bit less right i mean it's only one of the 10 factors but uh it's still important right and so like l1 having uh somewhat somewhat lower slot times is good but uh like i do think that uh like this sort of market separation where if you want uh kind of like decently low latency then you do all one but if you want aggressively low latency then uh l2 is the place to be in we actually like do the work of uh figuring out how to make that synergistic is likely to be better for us.
i hear in your answer something that i hear pretty frequently uh which is downstream of probably what is your most cited blog post between me and Ryan on this podcast which is the concave versus convex uh dispositions blog uh and like what i'm hearing is like for example bitcoin which is a convex ecosystem they're a maximalist ecosystem they focus on the 21 million hard cap and the bitcoin ecosystem and the bitcoin culture downstream of that is all focused is all centered around the 21 million hard cap and you can look at salana and you can make that same comparison salana is centered around the ibrl me like to reduce latency a high frequency trading focus that's what that's what salana focuses around ethereum tends trends to be more concave it tries to keep all possible doors open it tries to be more balanced uh and it tries to be just a little bit middle of the road but if it's how there's also that line out there uh that i also kind of like which is everything in moderation including moderation and if we follow that that meme that logic that means that like you know ethereum should be balanced about many things but some things it should not be balanced about some things it should be convex about uh and like Ryan my partner here he's actually trying to you know beat his chest as an ethereum person and become like an ethereum nationalist and promote ethereum nationalism and kind of like ethereum pride about the things that ethereum stands for uh if you were to have your definition of ethereum nationalism what would it be what what should ethereum culture and ethereum values be convex about hmm now it was interesting because I yeah I started thinking about an answer but then now you kind of pivoted into those uh sort of ethereum as a nation discussion which is uh sort of fascinating in its own way um but I think up maybe okay maybe we'll start with my yeah and if the answer I was planning right which is that I think uh one of the other like really important points here is that uh like actually the world is more complex than choosing one point on a slider right and uh like ethereum benefits a lot from having multi layer structure right because if you have multi layer structure then often you're actually able to get the best of both worlds um I mean actually I can give a nation state analogy here right because uh recently yeah I'm in a famous way there have been not quite a lot of people arguing that uh it might be better to have uh nations that are run by dictators right so you know you have a courtesy arvin saying in the arc I should have a king um like this is a common viewpoint that lots of people have right and they say things like oh you know dictators can uh uh kind of uh they don't need to negotiate with people they don't have political costs they can just do all kinds of things if they were just very efficiently and they can direct big projects that make society better at scale right now one of like there's lots of reasons why yeah you know this is like like like I'm not pro dictator obviously right and uh there's big downsides of dictators that I think more than outweigh dictators right or without more than outweigh the benefits but what's interesting is that the benefits of dictators are real but like I think democratic capitalism has based like you can think of it as actually being a way of like basically yeah kind of putting dictators in a box and getting their benefits without suffering their costs at the same time right what is a dictator in a box it's an entrepreneur right you know you have these big titans like uh you know Jensen Huang and uh you know the the various uh AI people and whoever else and uh you know there are even what they command significant amounts of resources and then they as that layer of the stack their goal is to kind of move around these uh large you know quantities of resources and these large objects and to try to produce outcomes and uh like I mean they do have to negotiate with people but definitely yeah much much less that if you try to allocate the same amount uh democratically but at the same time you know you have this other layer of the social stack that's supposed that that actually is much more democratic that's supposed to decide on these systems of rules and incentives where if Jensen Huang makes the world better then he's able to get a lot more money and he is able to play the next round of the game with even more resources or if Jensen Huang makes the world worse then uh lower uh kind of case uh he had he makes less money or I mean no maximally a low case he goes to jail right and uh basically yeah I mean of course I mean this is something that has to be maintained carefully right and uh if you get into a world where like basically the yeah the entrepreneurs sort of escape the blocks and then they start like effectively writing their own incentives and like that whole model breaks and then uh effectively yeah you risk getting the downsides of I you know the courtesy of an world without the upsides right uh but uh like I think there's an analogy here too uh I mean L1s and L2s are one of those examples the yeah applicant even on the application layer there's a lot of examples right and uh the yeah analogy here you know there's uh basically that a lot of the time these things are much more centralized than Ethereum a lot of the time these things make UX trade-offs that are kind of much more so you might say normy favoring than the yeah Ethereum L1 um a lot of the time they yeah care well and they care less about various cypherpunk values than Ethereum but at the same time if built correctly you can have structures on the L1 whose job it is to hold them to account right and so one example of like the most basic example is the proof system right because the proof system prevents the L2 from cleaning that something false is true and it prevents the L2 from stealing people's money right and other example is like the bypass channel right this is uh the mechanism where if the L2 starts censoring you then you as a user can like send your transaction and then your transaction like is just forced to be included in a block and then you're able to get your assets out right and like there we actually saw I think interesting examples of these bypass channels actually being used in real life right and uh another example is like this uh idea that I briefly mentioned where if you have a centralized sequencer like you could have a gadget on chain for first switching the sequencer right if people vote that like a we have off chain evidence that the sequencer is like abusive in some like extractive MEV front running sense or they're not responsive enough or whatever then people can vote in the uh and then that vote needs to be censorship resistant obviously so it happens on a one and so you replace the sequencer right and so this gets into the discussion of like what I think Ethereum strength is right that we are this uh ecosystem that has different uh different actors and so I think we as Ethereum like we have to figure out you know like what is this uh this right set of uh incentives and uh I mean I think as you guys said right a thing like like a strong L1 that's actually able to run all of this machinery is uh a really uh importance part of these incentives right because if you don't have a strong L1 then effectively you're uh you end up letting the entrepreneur out of the box right uh like uh you end up like for example you know you have a proof system that works in theory but then like you start doing the fine prints and you realize like actually there isn't enough space on the L1 for everyone to exit at the same time and so like the whole thing is kind of a and so you know like strong L1 is uh part of this right and uh basically you know the uh L1 uh like part of its role is to uh create these uh these boxes you know and uh like a little and then like actually like make things on the uh the the full spectrum of uh like different types of uh you know essential essentialization uh trade-offs and like rapid uh like low latency ux trade-offs and all of those things uh actually accessible to users uh so that's uh kind of how uh like that's what I think if you're um uh like answer to the uh the question of where the slider should be right like to me if you're um is the uh uh this uh kind of uh sandbox uh where the uh like it's supposed uh let people build on as many positions on the slider as possible at the same time and they think that's uh one of its most valuable traits and uh yeah okay i i i i i i feel like i've taken the nation analogy and like probably it's all the way different direction from uh what you guys expected but no no i mean we can continue expanding out we love talking nation analogy for ethereum but to what one one area maybe we could extend that is um ether the asset so all nations have their own currencies and some have world reserve assets and so um you know the the social air let's call it uh in ethereum and part of ethereum nationalism and kind of the the the way that i use it is uh using ethiasit is kind of a shelling point and so let's talk about a few concepts here one question i have off the bat though is what do you make of these eat treasury companies that are springing up right so you said tom Lee on the podcast he says he wants to go acquire five percent of all eth all right so now have a hard time doing that without bidding the price up um what do you what do you make of these vehicles are you are you are you think they're good you think they're bad or you somewhat indifferent to them yeah so i think uh the first on the first question uh like the value of ethereum and i think uh eth is the the biggest thing that everyone in the ethereum ecosystem is economically aligned on and i and so i think maintaining a strong role for eth is uh importance just for that reason like if we had a world where you know the yeah incentives of base and the incentives of bankless and the yeah incentives of the eF uh like went off in uh three different directions with a zero overlap like ethereum would break as a community right and it's so you know i think uh that kind of core of uh like like that economic core that he creates is something that is uh really uh important right and uh i mean i also you know i have like many different theories of like where the value of east could come from like there are many days when i realized that like it's actually uh hard uh um i would perform the theory that uh the set of price the the price of east is uh set by uh a cabal of uh uh fourteen demons who live on the moons of Jupiter and uh right and like basically everything the word do i guess just like uh a competitive game of who best gives uh the the demons on the moons of Jupiter the best show um but it's like even from that perspective like actually yeah you know making uh if you're making a theory on my uh uh more relevant and uh and more central ecosystem too uh you know a global echo applications and finance is still the right thing to do right um so i think you know there's transaction fees there's network effect arguments and i think uh the best uh things that we do are things that are kind of supportive of east from all of those perspectives um the yeah yeah the treasury company is um i think this kind of uh puzzles me sometimes right because uh like to me yeah i yeah think of this as uh i mean first of all you know they're they're they're not operating with their own money right they're uh primarily yeah like the point is the people buy into the treasury companies and the treasury companies use this in order to buy east and so they're effectively creating this kind of interesting leveraged financial product on top of east that's like somewhere in between an option and a yet derivative and uh you know there's clearly yeah a lot of people who uh who buy it and uh who value this uh this kind of thing which one's your favorite um who's my favorite say east uh treasury company i mean uh i guess uh i mean you know the the u.
s government that keeps confiscating from hackers is kind of cool um um but let me maybe make the case for for for east treasury companies and and this is a case of moderation okay so there's obviously a world where east treasury companies go too far there's too much and it's custody it's not bankless all of these things a case for them is that they act as a a shelling point coordination mechanism for um ethy acid itself and propagating that story into mainstream in some ways to a lesser extent in some ways the way bitcoin has done that successfully now you know always go too far over leveraged like more and custody than you want but it feels to me like in entering twenty twenty five versus now eat this healthier in a place and a theory is healthier with a strong eth when you have some of that activity and there's some representation of it in traditional finance you get some of those capital inflows what do we get from that more economic security and more economic bandwidth to go create the cypher punk things we actually want so at some level in some moderation we we had zero percent now we're at like one percent of each supply like this seems to have a good effect that that would be my case for why east treasury is equals good yeah yeah I mean I agree and I think yeah like the the social aspect of coordinating around east just being an asset that companies can have as part of their treasury is uh is good and valuable and like giving having different vehicles for people to have access to east which is I think one of the reasons why yeah I mean like people are buying into treasury companies instead of just huddling it directly is uh also good right like giving people more options is good there's always people and all kinds of different financial circumstances that put all kinds of like requirements or incentives or properties on like what formats of things that they yeah participate in and so no I think there's definitely yeah valuable services that are being provided there and yeah like if you woke me up by three years from now and told me that's you know treasury is led to the downfall of east then of course my guess for why would basically be that somehow they turn into an over leverage game and then at some point you know like they yeah a 30% drop turned into force liquidations that turn into a 50% drop and then a 70 and 90% drop and then that got compounded with a loss of credibility and so but I mean I think that you know people in Ethereum in general you know even including the people doing finance in Ethereum are responsible people like you know these are not so I do one followers that we're talking about and so I think like yeah as long as like leverage does it go too high and that these things like don't start getting into those those kinds of mechanics so like I know I mean like derivatives of east existing or like a fundamentally fine and stable thing so no good for them zooming back out you know some one of these eat treasury companies maybe two will definitely be around in 10 years I think that's kind of why people are excited is that these treasury companies can stand the test of time if they do things right but I want to zoom back out and just talk about the next 10 years of Ethereum so in Ethereum is 20 years old and we hope to bring you back on the podcast in that time to talk about we're going to be old data we're all going to be that's fine and but Ethereum will be young Ethereum will be nearly 20 years old okay what Vitalik because Ethereum is an ongoing project the jobs never really do I think like the job can become more done but I don't think it'll ever be 100% done so what are your hopes and dreams and goals for Ethereum to accomplish over the next 10 years if the jobs not done what do you want done in the next 10 years for Ethereum yeah I think one is like the technical roadmap like basically being at at least some kind of like you could call it finish line you could call it maintenance mode so like I think to me this includes one ZK snarking everything to replacing any component that's some not optimized with a component that is optimized so you know replacing Kajak was beside in or something better replacing EVM with risk five or something better at the very least as an option making all verification happened through was he case marks or I get it would have to be starts making making every node ultra light and that verifying it verifying making privacy a yeah defaults part of the experience starting with payments and increasingly getting into I think more and more sophisticated forms of DeFi also some form of self custody that is both self sovereignty friendly and friendly to normal users like I think it actually can be done and I hope that we get there formal verification on everything I mean it will be lovely if we could have a formally verified secure open source chain all the way down from you know top levels of the stack like dApps and then you get into the Ethereum clients and then you get even lower down to the operating system and then ultimately to the hardware I think that would be really cool then in terms of like impact on the world I think I mean finance happening on Ethereum by default would be yeah amazing like if we actually get to a world where the financial infrastructure is such an infrastructure that if a user wants to you know they actually can kind of open up developer mode and like take their assets out of one application and then start to use another I use other applications instead be able to permissionlessly go and connect different things make sure that people have strong options for preserving privacy I think be able to take their funds out of one wallet and then move them into a different wallet and all of these things I think that's all really important in general is like a future of computing where a trustless vision of security that is based on cryptography and verification of code being a societal default and us getting to the era where we are using things where we have a strong assurance that they are secure and the the era of trust me for security starts looking as archaic as the the era of like not cleaning our water looks to us today I think that would be amazing you know we've already gotten there with the HTTPS I think we need to get there with it with everything else and they think Ethereum can be a huge part of making that happen.
Vitalik you wrote the white paper in 2013 you were still a teenager at the time and so now maybe a personal question as we wrap this up it has since grown of the last 10 years into a network that hosts almost $1 trillion in assets and it does seem like increasingly the entire world is building upon this world ledger but over the next 10 years what do you see as your role for Ethereum are you sticking around are you going to finish this vision what does this look like for you hmm yeah I think continuing to do everything that's needed in that Ethereum is definitely a big part of it I mean I think over the last few years I have been and I expect I yeah continue to be involved in like some of these broader deac efforts so you know we've talked about bio-defense we've I think before I'm like security at some of the lower liars of the stack that we've talked about I think is also going to be yeah importance as well so basically yeah you know like making this kind of full stack open secure and trustworthy yeah world actually yeah become a reality in in ways that include Ethereum and also include a lot of other things I expect so we'll be a big part of my my focus over the next 10 years as well I mean I think it's basically yeah you know it's it's the same goal that or I've had all the way since you know even joining Bitcoin back in 2011 and that was that excited that we can make it happen so vertellic bangles has been around about half of Ethereum's lifespan five five out of the 10 years of the blockchain knowing Ryan and I are probably going to keep on doing this right Ryan sure dude yeah well do you have any requests or guidance or advice for how bangles should be with Ethereum for the next five to 10 years no I think you know you guys have definitely done a good job just like being consistent this whole time and covering all of these really different and valuable parts of the Ethereum ecosystem I think continuing to do that is important I think also especially some of these like there will definitely be a lot of newer things that need to be covered and supported whether it's the things that are happening on the privacy side or even some of this newer wave of doubt of doubt stuff that is coming or I mean potentially yeah even all of these various different ideas of making Ethereum into something more like an actual nation so no and it's it's a big space and I mean I appreciate all of the work that you guys spend uncovering it well metallic thanks for joining us today happy 10th birthday to Ethereum that's a belated birthday but we're still around that mark and it's been great having you on thank you so much it's been great to be here too thank you guys got to let you know none of this has been financial advice you guys know crypto is risky you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is still the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us in the backless journey thanks a lot