ETHZilla wants to turn ETH into Wall Street’s new reserve asset, and they’ve built a plan to do it. Ryan sits down with Avichal Garg (Electric Capital) and Mac Rudisill (ETHZilla) to unpack why ETH treasuries exploded this cycle, how credit markets (converts, preferreds, and debt) supercharge accumulation, and why stablecoins → DeFi → ETH forms a flywheel that turns Ether into high-quality collateral. We dig into leverage discipline, mNAV premiums, operational security, and the business math that makes an ETH treasury look more like Berkshire than a hype trade. Plus: can this wave trigger a DeFi after-boom, and what does “winning” actually mean for ETHZilla?
---
📣RONIN “ONCHAIN NINTENDO” | DOWNLOAD THE RONIN WALLET
https://bankless.cc/RoninWallet
---
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAX | SELF SUFFICIENT DeFi
https://bankless.cc/Frax
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
https://bankless.cc/unichain
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK
https://bankless.cc/Mantle
---
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
3:53 Catching Tom Lee and Peter Thiel Backing
7:53 Treasury vs. ETF vs. Just Holding ETH
11:58 Why Treasuries Are Booming
16:51 New Debt Instruments & Appetite
22:00 Leverage, Rehypothecation & Risk Controls
29:50 The Big Unlock: ETH as High-Quality Collateral
34:35 Stablecoins → DeFi → ETH Flywheel
38:55 “ETH Is the Next Bitcoin?”
54:51 Why ETH Lagged BTC
56:05 ETH vs BTC Treasuries: Yield Surface
1:01:33 Why Electric Capital Runs Deployment
1:03:45 Buy Rules: Time vs. Price
1:09:00 Attention Matters: Spokesperson & Community
1:13:24 What “Winning” Looks Like for ETHZilla
1:17:59 Where Are We in the Cycle?
1:26:12 DeFi Afterboom?
---
RESOURCES
Maria Shen’s “Beyond Stablecoins” Report
https://x.com/MariaShen/status/1942658782439395815
---
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Why wasn't this possible 10 years ago? The credit guys, the debt markets are now willing to consider Bitcoin and ETH as collateral. And that was a thing that you didn't have five years ago. You just didn't consider this worthy collateral. But now that the ETH markets have gotten deep enough, all these convert guys are like, look, my mandate, the reason my LP is, as a debt guy, give me money is to go generate yield and find these kinds of opportunities. Here's a new form of collateral to the tune of, you know, in the Bitcoin case, $2 trillion in the case of ETH, $500 billion. These are now sufficiently large types of collateral at the SECs, cool with these now, their ETFs.
So I'm now willing to consider this as a new form of collateral against which I can lend. Welcome to Bankless. This is Ryan Sean Adams. It's just me today, David's out. So I'm here to help you become more bankless. We have ETH Zilla on the podcast. This is Ethereum's monster treasury company. All right, this is a new ETH treasury company that's launched. Now, I guess this is the fifth episode in our ETH treasury company series for those keeping track. We had Tom Leon, Joe Lubin, Andrew Keeds, Sam Tabar. Each of these conversations had a unique vantage point. I think you really have to listen them all in order to get a sense of what's going on in this ETH treasury meta and what the future is for either the asset.
I asked many of the same questions I asked of previous guests and many new ones as well. Some of the common questions like why ETH, why a treasury vehicle, what's the bull case for ETH? What I found is the one thing they've had in common is they all view ETH as an institutional grade asset, the same type of asset that Bitcoin has emerged into. Also, this is a multi-year macro trade for each of these treasury companies. The guests today use the term store of value to describe ETHER, a store of value, of course, with massive upside. Some comps to gold and other crypto assets as you'll hear. One unlock for me in this episode was the depth we got to in the reason treasury companies have become so viable right now.
This is the first crypto cycle that ETH and also Bitcoin have turned into something unique, which is a high quality liquid collateral asset. Okay, remember that term because that collateral asset aspect has made these very attractive to US capital markets. You'll find out why. This is almost the infinite money glitch that Michael Saylor has tapped into. It was nice to have two guests in this episode. Max spoke tradify, the virtual spoke crypto, and I had the opportunity to pick a virtual's brain at the end, some deeper crypto questions I wanted to ask them, including this one. Will the ETH treasury boom cause a DeFi after boom?
That could be some investing potential. Stay tuned for his thoughts on that. Before we get into that episode, I wanna shout out our friends and sponsors over at Ronin. This is the chain Ronin, of course. They want you to know that Ronin is coming home to Ethereum. So if you wanna go experience Ethereum's on chain in Tendo, you have to check out Ronin. Used to be a side chain, it still is, the home of Axi Infinity. It's becoming an Ethereum layer one. So Ronin as a chain is coming home. They're doing massive volume. Fun fact, even more volume than they were doing during the Axi Infinity 2021 Mania.
You've got 4.5 billion and NFT volume alone, 30 million wallet downloads. You can download their wallet, go check it out because their Ronin L2 is gonna be even more wild. They're getting 12x faster because they can borrow all of the security and decentralization from Ethereum. Plus, they've got some Ron staking rewards for both builders and their communities. Download the Ronin wallet. That is the action item. You can get started. You can get a taste of the on-chain Nintendo, Bangladesh.cc slash Ronin wallet. There's a link in the show notes. All right, let's get right to that episode. Bangladesh station very excited to do another deep dive into an ETH Treasury company today.
So this one is called ETH Zilla. Yes, you heard that right? This is the Godzilla monster of Ethereum. Devouring all ETH in its path. The ticker is ETH Z that is new. They're number five on the ETH Treasury leaderboard and they're closing in on 100,000 ETH. I'm joined by two guests, a virtual guard. He's a repeat guest on bankless. He's a partner at the lecture capital. They are an anchor investor in ETH Zilla. Also have Mac Rosadale. He is the chairman of ETH Zilla and together they formed this entity. Guys, welcome to bankless. Good to see you. Thanks, Ron. All right, I got to tee up with this question.
So Tom Lee, he's got 1.5 million ETH in supply. That's $7 billion. Are you guys going to be able to catch Tom Lee? That's a question for you, Mac. All right. Ryan, we are going to make a really hard run at it and the answer is I think we can do it. You think you can catch Tom Lee. So what's the plan to do that? Like what's the ETH Zilla plan to go accumulate a whole bunch of ETHs? We're going to buy it in the market buying ETH on a daily basis. We've got access to a billion shares of shelf availability on our ATM. And we're in a very similar place to where Tom Lee was when he launched his bitmin immersion deal.
And I believe it was late June when they got started. We just got started not even 10 days ago. And we're already going to be over 100,000 ETH pretty quickly here. We're on a run rate that very similar to what he was on. So I think we have this same conversation a couple months. We're going to be substantially higher. Yeah, it's not bad. I guess for 10 days in, he's got almost $500 million worth of ETH. So it's a good start for sure. Well, the other thing to note is I think with Tom stuff, he set this target of 5% ETH. And so there is a little bit of a diminishing return at some point. On the one hand, it compounds with the flywheel.
So he can keep buying one more and more because he's scaling up. On the other hand, I think at a certain point, he starts having to pull back. Having too much ETH is also not good for the ETH because of some of the ETHs. Do you like the guys as that? So I think there'll be a window there where some of the other treasures like Espat, Joe Lubin and other Joe and ETH still have a shot to sort of make up some ground at that point too, I think. One thing you guys share, actually, with Bitmind Tom Lee is some of the investor pool, one of which is a notable name, Peter Teal. Okay, so Peter Teal owns ETHzilla.
So this was disclosed in public SEC filings, I believe, and it's a substantial portion. I, you know, it's a pretty big investment. And what does it take to land someone as an investor like Peter Teal, Mac? We met with the Founders Fund team on the road show and they are really experienced Ethereum network investors. And I think what they saw in us was, it's a differentiated strategy to what you see with some of the other Ethereum Treasury plays. We are partnered with Electric with Avichol and they're managing our Ethereum. And we're generating a lot higher yield than all the other players in the market because of all the various things that we're doing.
And I think that is the primary differentiating factor up front. And then I think the second thing that they saw was our connection to the Ethereum network. There were just a ton of DeFi founders that came into this deal who own some of the largest protocols and by having access to those people, it gives us access to not only their yield-oriented protocols, but also all the things that are going on in the real world to bring to codify real world assets using Ethereum, ETHzilla is going to have access to. And I think when you bring the two together, that's what they're investing in. Is there's a really differentiated component to the business that we're creating that generates a ton of free cash flow that we can then use to go buy more ETH with?
So what is someone like a sophisticated investor, Peter Teele Founders Fund? Why would they go with an ETH Treasury company rather than some sort of vanilla ETH Buy or even an Ethereum ETF of some sort? I think that's actually a great question. I mean, with ETFs, you're paying like a 1.5% feed to the ETF manager on average, whereas if I was a public market equity investor and wanted to invest in Ethereum, I would definitely invest in Ethereum Treasury company because you're receiving cash flow as a shareholder. So you have this kind of base level of cash and Ethereum that you're investing in, which is naved, and then you get a multiple on the cash flow that the company generates above it, which generates that premium to nav.
You're never going to get that investing in Ethereum ETF, and you're not going to get it just buying ETH outright. The scale matters a lot in this accumulation of ETH, and I think that's what you're betting on when you're buying an Ethereum Treasury company. The pure scale of cash flow that compounds is you buy more ETH. I would add, I think there's two things going on here. One Mac just identified, which is, would you rather have an ETF, which today they can't stake, maybe one day in the future they can in the United States? And even if they can, they can't do anything beyond the staking. And then they'll always underperform just vanilla staking because they have to manage the liquidity.
So you need some ETH that's on state to manage your redemptions, right? So kind of by definition, the ETFs will always underperform staking. And so it's a tough place, if you want to max yield, and so the DATs can outperform, and there's a sweet spot there. It's just a larger your DAT gets, the harder it is to outperform ETH staking yield, because there are not that many other places to put it beyond base staking. So you sort of converge to staking yield. So there's actually an advantage, I think, if you're thinking about, as a public market investor, having exposure to ETH, DATs may actually be the right way to do it in a relative to an ETF.
And then if you're not a public market investor, per se, you could go by vanilla ETH on your own. So let's say your mandate lets you do that. Then the question you have is, okay, well, do I want to go manage any of that additional yield? Like, do I want to go put money into DeFi and then set up, like I have to have assets at a qualified custodium, I got to set up like a multi-sig, who in my firm knows how to do this kind of stuff, it actually be quite painful. And so in a fact, if you can just get that sort of DeFi exposure that yield exposure that you get on chain, through a DAT effectively, passively by holding the shares and the DAT, that starts to be a pretty compelling offer.
And so I think there are these like two pools of capital institutions that may otherwise have considered an ETF. And you're like, wait, this is better than an ETF. And then some institutions are like, well, I could buy the ETH, but I don't want to deal with any of the DeFi stuff. And so this lets me get like outside of the yield through exposure of DeFi activity without having to hold the ETH. And so I think there are large schools of capital that would pursue that. Interesting. So even that on that first point of each of the slides, even when we have Ethereum staking ETFs, like your point is not 100% of that ETH will actually be in staking receiving yield and it can't be because there's redemption, I guess, like laws and you need some liquidity and vanilla, because I mean, people may know, like right now, the ETH staking exit queue is pretty high.
It's like, it takes about 20 days to withdraw your ETH. And an ETF for redemption purposes needs that liquidity immediately. That's right. Therefore, they can't have all of their ETH in a staking, be subject to a 20 day withdrawal staking queue. So they have to, you can only stake a portion. You're saying that alone, juices, like treasury companies can put all of their ETH. Because when the ETH is when these like, when the shares are being created or redeemed, you're liquidating, you have to move the underlying, right? You gotta go get some ETH or you have to get rid of the ETH. And so you gotta manage your liquidity.
And so by definition, you know, you're gonna be, and if you're conservative, you know, you can probably look at what BlackRock does or what Bitwise does, you probably have to conservatively keep 20 or 25% of your ETH on the balance sheet, because you can have significant liquidations, right? You could run into real issues. Like, imagine a situation where, you know, I don't know, the SEC says something. Does like 20% of your ETH just change and redeem out? Like, that doesn't seem crazy, right? Give and have all until these assets are. Yeah, so yeah. So almost by definition, in the current incarnation of what the rules are, you're gonna, in the ETH, you're gonna, even if staking were allowed in the ETH, which is not today, even if it were allowed, I think by definition, you end up underperforming, but not all of the staking.
Does this explain the rise of treasuries in general? I was really interested, like, even this week I was looking into, there was a, there was a crypto headline, it was basically like the Sovereign Wealth Fund of Norway, there at Norway Sovereign Wealth Fund. Double the amount of Bitcoin that they had in the second quarter. And I looked at that and I was like, oh, double the amount of Bitcoin, that sounds fantastic. Well, they were actually holding a microstrategy. That's how they were measuring the Bitcoin. It was not a, or sorry, not Bitcoin in an ETF. It wasn't vanilla Bitcoin on spot or held in cost to your anything like that.
It was actually, they're getting all of their Bitcoin exposure by route of a Bitcoin treasury company that is microstrategy. And so, these are smart people. They run sovereign Wealth Funds, okay? There's gotta be a reason they're choosing treasuries. What accounts for this? I think number one, there was a lot of liquidity and microstrategy on a daily basis. I'm not sitting in front of Bloomberg, but I mean, in terms of how many billions of dollars it trades a day, I'd gotta be in the top 50 stocks in the United States. And so I think that's one reason they're choosing to get their Bitcoin exposure through that.
And then the second is, I think the power in these vehicles is the scaling effect. I mean, I think if you simplify it down to owning $100,000 worth of treasuries and how much cash flow that throws off, you know, $4,000 bucks and owning versus owning $100,000,000 worth of treasuries, then that cash flow starts to really matter. And I think that's what investors are looking at in microstrategy and the sales of the world. They're looking at that compounding cash flow and saying, this is a real business that is extremely high margin. And I can put a really high multiple in the business and I get exposure to the upside of the underlying Ethereum.
So that's why I think you're seeing such a proliferation. But I think there's a wide disparity in quality in the market already and in what you have access to. Yeah, I think underneath that, I agree with all that, there's a funny thing that's happening, which I don't know if people fully understand or realize, which is the beauty or the brilliance of what Sailor figured out is he has tapped into an entirely new basic capital, which is these credit markets. So you have our guys that will lend you these large intuitional firms that will lend you money anywhere from zero to 10% depending on the duration and the terms in the area, but let's say 10% just to make it easy, right?
And they'll lend you money at 10%, but you can go turn on and buy an asset that goes up 30% a year, right? And so Sailor looks at this correctly and says, wait a second, I should just do this all day. Like you're gonna lend me money at 10% to go buy assets that go up 30% to 40% a year. This is a no-brainer. I should just like turn this money printer as much as I can. And there are all sorts of structural reasons for that. Like the debt guys have certain mandates. This allows them to do like converts and they're typically getting 10%, but now they have exposure to a thing that might go 100% up in a convert structure, which is extremely typical.
Like the converts are usually done in these credit facilities as downside protection. It's like, in case you can't pay me back, I will convert. In this case, they're converting into a thing that's going up 50% and this is unbelievable. You're gonna juice my returns to my credit fund on all about this. And they're happy to lend you money at 10% and you turn around and buy assets that go up 40% a year. And then as the assets go up, you can either like sell some to pay off the debt and go rinse and repeat or now you have that much more collateral value. So you go bar or more. So it's actually like I think people may not fully understand that there's like a capital markets reason that this stuff is happening.
And there's a bunch of people that are trying to pursue yield in different places and they sort of like sailor plugged all this plumbing together to make the money flow. And now I really sort of realize this is actually like a capital markets function. And so what the net net of that is for I think like a sovereign wealth fund is that they're looking at it and saying, well if I just hold one of these shares, the amount of Bitcoin I own per share goes up. And because he got really good at some of this leverage, I've seen these graphs which are pretty remarkable which shows like micro strategy stock performance relative to Bitcoin.
Yeah. And because he got it all really dialed in, it's actually outperforming Bitcoin now, right? It's like a you by holding micro strategy you got directional, it's like levered Bitcoin exposure. It was like something like 30x versus 8x of holding Bitcoin. Yeah, I was gonna say it was a 30x return versus that. I mean, I think he's a creating 16 cents a share in Bitcoin a day. And if you quate that to like what Anice Zella is doing, just like on a pure percentage differential basis, I mean ours is substantially higher. And I think you're seeing the same thing with all the other Ethereum treasury companies to the point that you have a child made.
Employed volatility of Ethereum is so much higher than Bitcoin today. And it's really at the same place that Bitcoin was five years ago. And it's part of the mechanic that's going on with the debt capital market investors and the Ethereum treasury companies and why we're able to raise convertible nodes and debt. It's at low interest rates because they've won. Number one, they want the exposure to the volatility, but two, they want exposure to the upside and the east. And so when you get them both in a combined setup, it allows you a lot of access to capital. So this is a question I've been thinking about because it does seem like Michael Sailor's tapped into this infinite money printer of convertible nodes and debt, right?
My question though is like, did he tap that out fully? Like has he already consumed all of that convertible debt appetite in the market for crypto? And the reason I ask is because just this week, right? He's sort of announced, I believe, some Ford guidance that they will now be doing ATM purchases, basically diluting shareholders above a MNAV. I think like he used to be, he said he wouldn't do ATM below an MNAV of 2.5X or something like that. Now it turns out, yeah, he's offered some guidance that they may be doing it lower than 2.5X. And right now I think MicroStrategy, the MNAV premium is like 1.
6X. And so some of the investors are not happy about this. MicroStrategy was down 8%, at least like, you know, temporarily basis. But you kind of wonder about that. And you're like, okay, well, did Michael Sailor run out of this, you know, sweet, infinite money printer convertible debt that he was using? And is there any left for the East Treasury companies? He's doing something even better than convertible debt. I mean, two weeks ago he issued a senior secured redeemable preferred. It was fully collateralized with Bitcoin and cash into effectively like a money market structure with Morgan Stanley.
So if you're a client at Morgan Stanley, you can buy this and you get a 9% yield instead of putting a 4.5% money market treasury fund. So he's not giving any of the upside away. And he's paying out 9% on a fully cash collateralized balance that he's carrying at, you know, mid fours, fives maybe, percent. And then paying out the delta while he's sitting on all that Bitcoin that he just bought with the $500 million that he raised. So he's taking the convertibility out of it just in the last two weeks. Mm, okay. So this implies that there's more capital like that, more appetite for that type of capital, where Michael Sailor can get that type of a deal again and so can East Treasury companies?
No East Treasury company has access that kind of product yet. It is something that's interesting. We talked a lot about, but it's a lot more equivalent to the preferred market or high yield money market than it is the convert market. It, Mack, would you say it's equivalent to sort of like what BlockFi was doing, doing that like massive institutional scale? Like essentially what he's got is this like pile of Bitcoin and he's borrowing against it and he's paying interest against it in order to borrow those US dollars in order to go buy more Bitcoin. And the effective rate that he's paying is 9%.
But if you think about that, like a collateralized Bitcoin loan at 9% in order to turn around and buy Bitcoin, if the duration is long enough, on the dead is a pretty great trade, right? So he's kind of like tapped into yet again, like I think what the brilliance of Sailor is like finding these pockets in the capital markets where I don't know what the number is off hand, but isn't it something like there's $7 trillion? Some obscene amount of money sitting in money markets. I wish we had a Jamie, I wish this was like the Rogan podcast, me like Jamie, look at that part. Like you know, there's some obscene trillions of dollars sitting in money market accounts, generating 4%.
And so what happens is rates come down, right? As you get fed rate cuts. Like historically those assets flow out to higher risk stuff. And so what he's essentially gone is to those markets now and said, I'll give you 9%. Instead of holding it in a money market, go to your Morgan Stanley guy and have it move over to this like micro strategy strike thing. And I'll give you 9% collateralized by Bitcoin. And that starts to look really, really compelling to some percentage of that assets. And so he's raised on the order of 50 billion. If there's like seven to 10 trillion sitting in money markets, like a very, very, very small percentage has to move over.
Like 1% has to move over for him to double the amount of available capital. He could double the amount of Bitcoin he buys just with like 1% of that money moving. It's just like these capital markets are so enormous. So this last instrument that he created is like, is a very, very, very clever instrument. I think you have to get to enough scale that like a Morgan Stanley says, oh, yeah, we'll plug you into our wealth management product suite or a money market suite or whatever. And we'll go talk to the institutions about this. And so I wouldn't be surprised if six, 12 months for now, like the ETH Treasury companies start tapping into the same pools of capital.
And especially as rates come down, stuff like this collateralized lending to make 9% or 10% starts to look really compelling. These capital markets, these debt capital markets are available for micro strategy is probably going to be available for ETH Treasury companies. Right now, you're saying ETH Treasury companies, the way they've been buying has it primarily been the ATM. The types of market operation, which is at the market, where they basically, they dilute shares above MNAV and use that to purchase additional ETH for their balance sheet. That in addition to, of course, the initial pipe funding is that how the ETH Treasury companies are purchasing the ETH today?
Yes, and summary, they are. We issued a smaller convertible note as a percentage of the total 600 million that we initially raised at a 4% rate. That other vehicles have gone down a similar road where the ratio of ATM to convert. But the primary mechanism has been ATM. All right, so that implies there's a lot of growth opportunity maybe for these ETH Treasury companies that can tap into some of the debt capital markets. Rachel, you mentioned the name BlockFi, actually, which is sort of is cool in a way, and also sends shivers down my spine in another way, because, of course, quite famously, BlockFi eventually had a really bad time on some of their trades and some of the lending and borrowing they were doing with the crypto assets they had in reserve.
Is that type of risk present in these, so when you're saying like Michael Saylor has 50 billion or so in these debt type instruments, that's leverage, right? And leverage is, wow, isn't leverage scary? Can't leverage go turn on us in a hurry when market cycles go down, or are there some safety valves in this type of leverage? You know, it's a great question. I don't know the terms of the strike notes that he's doing exactly, so it's hard to say specifically in his case, but I think maybe abstractly speaking, we could look at tourists. I think on the BlockFi side, the risk really came as a side effect of re-hypothication.
And so when you're taking the same assets out, that have been used for collateral and then lending them back out, you've created this like looping, like for defy people, this is effectively forms of looping. And once you start doing looping, as already in DeFi knows, that can unravel pretty quick. And I think that's part of what happened with like the Celsius in DeFi and BlockFi kinds of situations, where you're taking bad collateral in exchange for good collateral, you're levering up, you're re-hypothicating the same assets, that can unwind pretty fast. In this case, Saylor's not doing that, right?
He's just taking the dollars and you have one counter party, and it's pretty clean from that perspective, so I don't think you have that kind of a risk. What you do have is some sort of like protracted bear market, that comes to do with a wrong time kind of situation. And that's what happened like in the BlockFi situation or the FTX situation, that was like the second order effect, right? Like as asset prices start coming down, everybody else who has any kind of collateralized loan, even if they're not re-hypothicated, all of a sudden the collateral is worth less and you're getting margin called.
And so you might be forced to sell collateral at the worst possible time, if you can't top up your margin, right as assets are going down, which creates like this death spiral situation. And everybody's exiting high quality collateral at the exact same time in order to make sure that their loans are not underwater, and that can be really, really bad. And so I think that in my opinion, one possible failure mode for a strategy would be that the debt is coming due at exactly those moments in time where Bitcoin price is depreciated. And so now you're in a situation where like he has so much, if he tries to move billions and billions of dollars of Bitcoin at those moments where the market does not want Bitcoin, what happens to Bitcoin price?
And what does that do for subsequent tranches of debt that he may own? I think it's certainly a risk. Now what he might say or what others might say is that well, the capital markets are so large, the rather than selling your Bitcoin at that time, you refinance your debt, right? And so you just say you pay off the debt with new debt, longer term, you know, higher rates, whatever you got to do to not liquidate all your assets and enter a death spiral. So there may be a way to fix it on the capital market side. But I do think that like there is some risk there, which is why I also think on the ETH treasury side, buyers of these assets potentially should be mindful of how much of the total supply to these things own, because I think if you start getting into that, high single digit percentages, like that creates systemic risk for the underlying protocol as well.
And I think you want to be really, really careful about honing too much here in one vehicle. I see. You almost become similar to kind of a grayscale trust. And where do you have so much of the market that there's some contagion in other pieces of the market at the ice back in the day, right? If you remember, like the 2017-2018 era, and they had to hit the circuit breaker, was it, I think in COVID they hit the circuit breakers, right? In like 2018, it was, I think the way they said it was like, oh, our servers went down, or like the servers melted down, but like, I don't know, the conspiracy theorist in me is like, there was definitely somebody at the max that was like, this whole thing is going to zero unless we unwind this.
And like, it's so much of the market and they were so levered up. That route was just getting destroyed in that COVID March situation. And so they like hit the circuit breaker when Bitcoin got to like 3,500 and they're like, this thing can't go to zero, otherwise the whole thing unwinds. So you can enter situations like that, right? It's just, and you really want to be mindful of it. If you have too much concentration, if you have too much leverage, if you have too much ownership in one place, everybody having to dump it one time would be really bad. Okay, and which, could you guys go over once again?
So why does this leverage opportunity exist? Who are the buyers of this sort of, you know, microstrategy like bonds? Again, Rachel, you said like basically like money markets, you know, people kind of, I guess, in Tratfai sort of seeking yield. I just, coming from the crypto space, and Max just speak to this, he's like, Max, I think you have to get for us. I think you have to separate microstrategy, who the buyers are, and who the buyers are on debt for the Ethereum Treasury companies. So to date on Ethereum Treasury companies, the buyers have been convert, traditional, convertible note investor.
And those are really large hedge funds and mutual funds that buy converts. Okay. Michael Seller is accessing every aspect of the global capital market at this point. He's accessed converts, accessed high yield capital markets, debt, just a regular way of debt, and he's accessed what is effectively now the preferred market and the money markets. So he's kind of tapping all the different places that you can go. We're nowhere near that right now that converts that we just issued. They're fully cash collateralized. So we're literally, we have the option to take the cash and we're at a holder as the option to convert in the future when the share price rises.
So we're not taking any risk with our shareholders money. We just have an option to basically take more cash on the balance sheet. And that's how most of the Ethereum trust converts are structured today. And it's a pretty low risk debt situation just to add more capital to the balance sheet. And that's why you see Ethereum Treasury companies holding more cash is extra collateral to make sure that their balance sheets are protected as they continue to scale it with more teeth. So we're just much earlier in the lifecycle of these Ethereum businesses relative to what we're talking about with Michael Seller.
I see, but as you level up, as you get to Michael Seller level of being able to kind of tap into all of these capital markets, who is the buyer of debt in those types of situations? So you're talking, these are multi trillion dollar markets. I mean, the IO market globally is just in the trillions, hundreds of billions of dollars a day of transactional volume. They're actually looking for opportunities like this that have recurring cashflow at pretty high margins, like you get on the Ethereum network to put leverage to work because they have so much interesting come coming into their fund on a monthly basis that they just have to redeploy.
I mean, they're actually a point right now even with where yields are that they're searching for yield. These would be buyers who want to maintain some sort of cash or bond type position or something, right? And it's like, I think of something like Treasuries, which is maybe the risk free rate, you like short duration Treasuries, right? And what's the yield on that? Four, four and a half percent or four point, three percent, something like that. Okay. So if they bought some sort of debt instrument for a future ETH Treasury company that was able to marshal these assets, what kind of return are they getting there and what type of risk above the risk free rate are they taking on there?
It depends on the ratio of how much ETH that company has relative to how much debt they're taking on because they're using the ETH yield to pay the interest expense on whatever debt they're raising. So I think an easy ratio to think about is Treas $200 million of debt for every billion dollars of ETH you held. And your coverage ratios on your regular way debt would be really high. I see. And this goes back to what you were saying is basically, like, especially as rates go down, but even now everyone's looking for yield. All of the time they're looking for like relatively safe yield and to be compensated for, you know, I guess they're cash position accordingly.
Yeah. Or maybe observation here, which is part of the reason that this is a big unlock that I think, like why wasn't this possible 10 years ago? Even pre ETFs, like why didn't people figure this out? And I think what has like fundamentally changed is that the credit guys, the debt markets are now willing to consider Bitcoin and ETH as collateral. And that was a thing that you didn't have five years ago. Like you just didn't consider this worthy collateral. But now that like the ETH markets have gotten deep enough, all these convert guys are like, look, my mandate, the reason my LP is, as a debt guy, give me money is to go generate yield and find these kinds of opportunities.
Here's a new form of collateral to the tune of, you know, in the Bitcoin case, $2 trillion in the case of ETH, $500 billion. These are now sufficiently large types of collateral. And legally, I'm okay. The SEC is cool with these now, they're ETFs. So I'm now willing to consider this as a new form of collateral against which I can write. That's the unlock. That's the unlock. It's a big unlock, right? All of a sudden, yeah. Yeah, $2.5 trillion collateral that previously you couldn't really touch. It wasn't considered high quality collateral. And over the last five years, you've had this transformation where the SEC has said, hey, these are securities.
Oh, we got ETFs. It's all good. And so the capital markets have opened up and said, oh, this is a new form of collateral. And of course, if there's $2.5 trillion of collateral, like why, as a credit guy, I now have like, I can make 10% a year learning against high quality collateral. If I need to seize and liquidate, I can seize and liquidate. And it's easy to do that and like, Coinbase is set up and they're qualified custodian and like all the infrastructure is now in place. And so these credit guys, these debt guys are like, this is great. I have a new form of collateral like in line against like, of course, I'm going to do that.
And the yields are so much better than I could get in other places. So of course, I'm like as a fund manager, my fiduciary responsibility is to pursue that as a new type of yield. And so that's kind of what's happening behind the scenes with like the debts and the credit markets getting glued together. In the Wild West of DeFi, Stability and Innovation are everything, which is why you should check out Frax Finance. The protocol revolutionizing stablecoins, DeFi and Rolex. The core of Frax Finance is Frax USD, which is backed by BlackRock's institutional fiddle fund. Frax designed Frax USD for besting class yields across DeFi, T-bills and carry trade returns all in one.
Just head to Frax.com, then stake it to earn some of the best yields in DeFi. Want even more? Bridge your Frax USD over to the Frax steel layer two for the same yield plus Frax steel points and explore Frax steel's diverse layer two ecosystem with protocols like curve, convex and more, all rewarding early adopters. Frax isn't just a protocol, it's a digital nation powered by the F-XS token and governed by its global community. Acquire F-XS through Frax.com or your go-to decks, stake it and help shape Frax nation's future. Ready to join the forefront of DeFi? Visit Frax.com now to start earning with Frax USD and staked Frax USD.
And for bankless listeners, you can use Frax.com slash r slash bankless when bridging to Frax steel for exclusive Frax steel perks and boosted rewards. Imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly. That's what mantle is pioneering with blockchain for banking, a revolutionary new category at the intersection of Trad5 and Web3. At the heart is you are the world's first money app built fully on chain. It gives you a Swiss iBan account blending fiat currencies like the euro, the Swiss franc, the United States dollar or the Remimbi with crypto, all in one place.
Enjoy real world usability and blockchains trust and programmability. Transactions post directly to the blockchain, compatible with Trad5 rails, impact with integrated DeFi futures. You are transformed mantle network into the ultimate platform for on-chain financial services, unifying payments, trading and assets like the MI4, the meath protocol and functions FBTC. Backed by developer grants, ecosystem incentives and top distribution through the UR app, reward stations and buy bit launch pool. For MNT holders, every economic activity in UR drives value back to you, embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem.
Follow mantle on X at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking. That's x.com slash mantle underscore official. Okay, this makes so much sense to me. I don't think I've had anyone explain it to me in that way, but basically both Bitcoin and now Ether have crossed a threshold of being labeled as in thought of in these, like the global capital markets is high quality liquid collateral. Yes. The other high quality liquid collateral, I do understand, of course, you have treasuries and sovereign bonds and that sort of thing. I imagine you have something like gold being high quality liquid collateral.
What other assets are high quality liquid collateral that they tap into is real estate? Is that another one? Real estate is one thing. Oil, most commodities are considered, most liquid commodities are considered high quality collateral. And then portfolios of other securities are, that's the number one thing that a lot of the banks lend against all the time. And so that's effectively what you're just doing here. They've decided that Ethereum and Bitcoin are part of that pool. That's huge. Why eth all of the sudden? I mean, I guess this sort of makes sense. We saw an explosion of eth treasury companies, but it started back in late May when we first caught wind that Joseph Lubin was going to take a sharp link gaming and call that SBET, convert that into an eth treasury company and they were off to the races.
And I thought at the time, okay, this is kind of interesting. It'll probably be, you take many years to play out, right? Micro strategy, Michael Saylor's been at it for like four or five years or so. I don't probably take some time. And then bam, another one popped up, and then another, and then another, and then another, and then another, and now Eatsilla is one of the newer ones pursuing this strategy, but it just happened, like I guess suddenly and all at once at the exact same time. And that would sort of fit the narrative that that's about the point in time that all of the regulatory, I guess, FUD around ether the asset and Ethereum was fully cleared up.
We had a new SEC chair, Paul Atkins, who basically said reiterated that ether is all security, all of the kind of the lawsuits against some of the Ethereum developers disappeared. I guess we got that regulatory clarity in the same level of regulatory clarity that we've had for Bitcoin. And then it was off to the races. That's one interpretation of what happened. What do you guys think? Why did we get all of these eth treasury companies, all of the sudden back in May? I think the regals are a clarity as a huge enabler and catalyst. I think the other is the realization, the way we've been talking about it, we published a report, we sort of reiterated our eth thesis.
We've invested in eth and the DeFi ecosystem for a long time. But I think there are two others. One, I think stablecoins and stablecoin legislation happening and the vast majority of stablecoin activities happening on Ethereum. And so I think people sort of sat up and said, wait a second, stablecoins are a thing. What is the platform they're running on? They're running on Ethereum. Like what is all this other stuff that's adjacent? It's like an Ethereum is a thing. And so I think people kind of look up to this flywheel around stablecoins, you know, uses of stablecoins. People needing to buy eth for security, that driving up eth price.
They're sort of this like flywheel that you could construct there. That I think stablecoins are big unlock. And then the other one is people starting to get their heads around what the hell if Ethereum even is and eth the asset. And so you've seen a pretty big shift. I mean Max, we've talked a lot about this over the last few months. And you've seen like people start to get their heads around this. And you know, I think the way we've always talked about it is Ethereum is where Bitcoin was in 2019. It just turned 10, right? In July 2025, you turned 10. And Bitcoin turned 10 in January 2019. And if you look at the institutional understanding of what Bitcoin is and all the stuff that Sailor did, it all happened between 2019 and 2024.
Like that five year window is where Wall Street got its head around like what the hell is this thing? And I think we're just at the beginnings of that. And so a lot of the smart money that just saw this happen over the last five years with Bitcoin, so wait a second, history rhymes. Wall Street is about to figure out what the hell this thing is. And it's actually a unique and special thing. It's got its own origin story. It's hard to replicate. It was community funded. It wasn't VCs. It did this proof of work to proof of stake transition, which means it's got broad distribution. All the stablecoins are running out like this is its own thing.
And we shouldn't think of, you know, I think there is this one world view that some people embodied, which was that Bitcoin was somehow unique and special. And because it was the one, it was the only one. And there's another take you could have on it, which is that the probability of there being a second or a third or a fourth of such a category of things, it's like a new type of digital asset that the internet birthed goes up after you get the first one. Like the probability of there being zero is very, very, very, very high. But as soon as you get one, it doesn't stop at one. Like you probably get two or three, right?
And so I think if you're in that camp, all of a sudden you say, wait a second, maybe Bitcoin is not just, Bitcoin is unique and interesting, but it's not the only. It's an existence proof of this type of category of thing existing. So what's the next one? And I think the market sort of tipped around that. So like these three things all kind of came together. Like all the SEC changes and the regulatory changes and like a new president, the stablecoin stuff really hitting from the legislative side in the US and people saying, wait a second, all the stablecoins are on ETH. And then people sort of saying, wait a second, this thing actually has a bunch of unique properties.
And I should maybe have some exposure to this in the same way that all the institutions did in 2019 with Bitcoin. So I think all of that kind of came together in the last six months. It sounds like what you're saying is ETH is the next Bitcoin. I'm from a certain vantage point, right? From a capital pool perspective, from a treasury perspective, it's following that same trajectory. In many ways, yeah. I mean, history doesn't repeat, but it certainly rhymes. And I think I do think like there are gonna be a lot of people that wake up over the next three, four, five years and say, wait a second, this is a 100% digital.
It's a purely like endogenous thing to this whole ecosystem. It's a bearer instrument. It has very, very low inflation rate. Like once you start doing the math, it doesn't have the 21 million meme, but it does have this sort of, you know, burn mechanic, right? That sort of makes the inflation rate even lower than Bitcoin. It has all the stablecoins on it. It has a robust DeFi ecosystem so I can be productive with it. The US government is cool with it. Like you start looking through like, why did Bitcoin work? Yeah. And like you look at this thing, and it's like, well, kind of checks all the same boxes.
And so why wouldn't the market just run with that? Like setting aside any notion of maximalism for a second? Like this argument here that I'm making. Yeah. I'm making it purely like pragmatic capital markets argument, which is like the capital markets will look at these characteristics. In the same way that they looked at the characteristics of gold versus Bitcoin, and they said, wait a second, Bitcoin just checks all the same boxes. Of course, I would rather have Bitcoin. I think the capital markets wake up and they just say, wait a second, ETH checks all the same boxes. Like why wouldn't I have this too?
You know, it's also, I'll add to that case, which is like 10 years of history, which is really interesting. So if you go back to Bitcoin in 2019, it was 10 years old roughly. At that time, Bitcoin was worth about $66 billion, something in that range, okay? ETH at 10 years, just had its birthday in July, $350 billion, right? So I mean, you look at kind of the scale of it. It's followed the Bitcoin trajectory and then some in the first decade of its performance, which is incredibly impressive. Maybe let's dwell on this for a little bit more, of each one, which is kind of the full case for ETH, because the entire premise of any ETH treasury company, ETH still included is, of course, the value in the price of ETH goes up over time, right?
Maybe not immediately, you're not trading the day-to-day or even the month-to-month, but it's got to increase in value for this whole strategy to be worthwhile and work. Virtual, you were mentioning kind of a report that you guys put out at Electro Capital, the case for Ethereum, where one of the things that you tied this to was the case for stable coins. Of course, we've seen the genius act, we've seen, it was a 50% plus of all stable coins on Ethereum, and then in this paper, you linked stable coin growth to the value of ETH or the asset. Why don't you just kind of lay out the case for your report and what the arguments you were making and kind of linking stable coin growth and ETH or value, because that's somewhat disputed, I think, in some circles and crypto, but you laid it out quite cleanly.
Our basic mental model with the report, actually, if anybody goes to X, they can just search for my partner Maria's name, Maria Shen, and it's called Beyond Stable Coins, the case for Ethereum. And we looked at it from the perspective of, like it's very obvious if you're paying attention that stable coins are a thing. And most of the world lives in these very high inflation rate regimes, a fifth of the world, almost a quarter of the world, lives in something like six or 8% base inflation, which is pretty wild in some places or even more. And so all those people want dollars. And as soon as you get dollars, you immediately, if you're one of these people, we would say, well, don't I want to be able to, like, generate yield on these dollars?
Don't I want to be able to lend them? Don't I want to be able to invest them somewhere? Like, what do I do with these dollars? And so it opens up this question of what the world really wants. If you think about it also geopolitically, what the world really wants is a US dollar denominated system that is globally accessible, that's safer institutions, and is resistant to your local governments interference. So like, you know, your local government can't shut you off from it. But also that the US government has a difficult time shutting you off from. And that's effectively what's happened in this sort of Ethereum DeFi ecosystem that like the market has produced what the world really wants.
What the world wants is this like US dollar denominated financial system. And it's now available. It's 24-7. You know, it's got 10 years of uptime all these things that we were talking about. And so if you sort of buy this basic idea that like the stablecoin ecosystem is happening on ETH and there are a bunch of relanceding properties around ETH and Ethereum, the asset that we talked about, then what you enter is this flywheel that says you have demand for stablecoins. There's a desire once everybody has stablecoins to say, well, what do I do with my stablecoins? How do I put them to work? Which creates demand for DeFi.
And a lot of the DeFi when you go look at it, like that base collateral that's being used as ETH, right? That's like the reserve asset in this whole ecosystem. That's what people lend again. Those people bar against because it's purely endogenous, right? You don't have to rely on some third-party custodian for it. And that drives demand for ETH, which makes ETH price go up and security go up because people need this endogenous, fully digital, not relying on some external ledger collateral. And as the ETH price goes up, more institutions say, wait a second, this is large enough that we should be paying attention.
And all of that is of course then drives stablecoin demand because now all these institutions are coming in and offering either real world assets on chain or they're trying to tap the stablecoin capital markets and move them off chain into their own other products. And so you're now back at the growing demand for stablecoins part of the flywheel. And so our belief is you sort of enter this flywheel enabled by stablecoins, which then enables all these other things. And that positive flywheel is sort of is going to make this whole thing kind of work. And so, you know, it's a very different path than Bitcoin.
Right, like Bitcoin doesn't have stablecoins, Bitcoin doesn't have this. It has other flywheels that make it work. But the fact that there is a flywheel here and people are getting their heads around with that flywheel is and then saying, wait a second, this underlying collateral that backs this whole system is itself really valuable as a store value is kind of the unlock. And once people get their heads around that, that sort of takes off on its own. So some of the counterargument in here, and I think this is primarily you know, crypto-native circles less than trad-fi. Maybe trad-fi just sort of sees, yeah, circles doing really well, genie-sac.
Yeah, most stablecoins are on Ethereum, bye-bye-bye. You know, Ether is like a world reserve asset, therefore, right? Maybe that makes sense, okay? Maybe that's on kind of the left side of the mid curve and the right side of the mid curve. It's actually quite right. But there is another position that says, well, Vichel, these real world assets, you know, something like stablecoins, a lot of that's on Tron right now. Is Tron decentralized? Is anyone using, you know, the Tron token for as a store value asset? I guess there's, you know, the Justin Sun Tron Treasury, but I mean, that's not a high-quality liquid collateral in the same way that Bitcoin or Ether are, let's say.
Or they see something like circle or stripe. These companies are launching L1s themselves and they look at that and they say, well, it could be the case that Ethereum is kind of over-provisioned in terms of security for something like real world assets or something like stablecoins, right? It could be the case that, you know, stablecoins are actually a better fit for a more centralized network because after all, a circular tether can kind of, you know, turn it off or freeze or do what they want from an issuance perspective in any case. What do you say to that argument that maybe the future of stablecoins is not actually Ethereum after all.
Once these more centralized faster networks kind of take off, they're good enough from a security perspective to host these stablecoins and other real world assets. Yeah, so I think it depends on the use case and I think it depends on the market participants. So like if you look at the Tron case or other like fast L1s on the blockchains, I actually think stablecoins will exist there as well and they will have very specific purposes because, you know, if you're like a day worker in the Gulf and you're trying to send money back to South Asia, you know, Bangladesh or Pakistan or something, you kind of don't care about the decentralization, you wanted to be cheap and fast and all the exchanges, you know, I've set up Tron Rails and so the money shows up instantly and it's all tethered and that's fine.
I think when you're talking about institutions though, they do care about that and they care about it from a censorship resistance perspective, they care about it from a credible neutrality perspective, like who are the market participants here really matters? If you're dealing with retail versus dealing with institutions, I think that's like one top level fork. And then when you look at the institutions, I think there are some use cases, especially if you're already within like full US jurisdiction that you might use a circle L1 or a Stripe L1. That starts to look a little bit like the, if anybody remembers the Silvergate send network like back in the day, it's sort of reminiscent of that, right, it's like fast or settled or existing infrastructure, existing parties like before you're regulated.
But I think a lot of the world has to be really careful about this and they're a little bit reluctant to be 100% in the US jurisdiction. They want dollars, but they want to be a little bit on whose length and this is why for example, you have like a euro dollar system, right? Like you can't stop two counter parties from creating debt, like if you're doing business between Brazil and Turkey, like one party doesn't want Brazilian rail and the other party doesn't want Turkish lira. And so we're gonna settle that transaction in dollars, right? And this is why like the unit of account of the world is dollars.
And so most of the world will actually create debt and denominate debt and credit and do business in dollars. And they want to be really careful about where they're doing this, right? And so like the decentralization and kind of over provisioning of uptime and all these things is a huge feature. So I think you'll actually get kind of like three systems that exist in parallel. I think there'll be a retail system, which is like remittances, fast, exchange to exchange, like Western Union use cases and that can exist in like really fast blockchain ecosystems. Maybe that also exists on ETH and some sort of L2.
I think you get an institutional and that very well may be a Stripe L1 via consortium or a Circle L1 via consortium. That's like a replacement for really, you know, Krufti 1970s technology inside the US. That can exist and that can be a thing because those people are already subject to US laws and yet, and then I think you need something that's like a parallel global 24.7 outside the US system, which is kind of like euro dollar 2.0, but now fully digitized. And that I think of as like the internet of money. Like what the internet really did is it took these regional geographic information networks and built a network of networks, right?
It took and made that a global information network that anybody could participate in and that's what this stuff is doing. And that's where I think Ethereum really shines. And so I think these three things can coexist, but Ethereum really sort of wins in that third camp as it is as dividends by, you know, $250 billion of stables today. So if Ethereum wins in that first camp, then reinforce the other thing you said, which is ETH or the asset itself and ETH as a store of value because most of the world probably doesn't believe that at this point. I think some of the crypto world believes that now, but a large portion of them still don't believe that.
I think they, you know, similar to Bitcoin in 2019, right? The world did not believe Bitcoin was a store of value asset. The world does not largely believe that Ether is a store of value asset. You've got this chart in your report where you have all these store of value assets. Bitcoin, art, gold, US treasury, stocks, real estate. You've got these dimensions as well, you know, which ones are portable, divisible, durable, scarce. And then you've got Ether sitting, you know, beside these other store of value assets recognized. They have, Ether has check boxes and all of it. All of the same check boxes that Bitcoin has, except two additional.
One, Ether is yield generating, right? Whereas Bitcoin is not. And the other is Ether is programmable. Whereas Bitcoin's programmability is limited. Can you reinforce the case that Ether is a store of value and it's superior or at least different, it stands shoulder to shoulder with some of these other store of value assets? Because I think the market doesn't quite believe that. We've very much even in crypto circles. We've emphasized Ethereum the network. We haven't talked as much about Ether the asset, but you guys are collecting Ether the asset itself. So it's very important for you to understand what you're buying here.
The notion of what is a store of value is kind of an interesting concept, like economically or conceptually. And I think it has these characteristics. And you need it to be portable, easily divisible, you need to be durable, scarce, they're probably scarce, all these things, right? And that's where you can look at something like a gold. And actually, humans are pretty rational. So if you look at the periodic table, there are actually very few elements that could have met all of those characteristics. And it turns out gold was the one that was the easiest to mine. You know, like we weren't good enough to mine flat number, rodeo or something yet.
It's a gold sort of has this cultural significance because it was the one that we could ascribe all those values to and actually met those utility functions. And I think Bitcoin and ETH both meet those utility functions and actually in many ways better than gold. Now, I think that's maybe conceptually hard for people to get their heads around. It's like, oh, okay, well, like a Bitcoin is digital gold, can ETH really compete for that? So I might pause it maybe a lower bar, which I don't think is the terminal way to think about this, but maybe it is an easier hurdle for some people to get their heads around, which is, well, would you rather have a bunch of ETH or would you rather have a bunch of silver?
And I think a lot of people when presented with that and silver is like a two to three trillion dollar asset. Like, do you want to lug around 100 kilograms of silver? If you just want to have some ETH on your phone, right? And like ETH is clearly superior. And so I think once you start sort of comparing it, gold is just sort of has this really significant cultural position and Bitcoin has this really interesting cultural position in society. So it's hard for people to make that comparison, but I think when you compare it to the alternative, I think you might even argue that there's some world here where you're like, well, would you rather have like fine art?
Would you rather have like an additional piece of farmland? Would you rather have more silver, more platinum? Or would you just rather buy some ETH? And I think a lot of people went to present with that and be like, okay, I see why ETH might make sense. And then of course, if you get there, it's very easy to say, well, then like why wouldn't you actually compare it to some of these other larger source of value that seems special, but actually when you start looking at them from a utility perspective, they're not that special. Like there's nothing intrinsic about gold other than like we've liked gold, humans like shiny things.
But from like a utility perspective, this thing checks the boxes in the same way. I mean, by the way, this is the exact same argument we were making for Bitcoin 10 years ago, right? And so like anybody who kind of understands that argument, I think should understand this argument. And I think it really to comes down to like, you know, gold isn't the only store of value, right? Fine art is not the only store of value. Like when you have a portfolio, you start thinking about allocating across multiple stores of value and being thoughtful about what the risk factors are. Like some things can be more easily seized in certain places.
Some things have more carrying costs. Some things are more liquid than others, right? And so as a part of a portfolio, I think it also makes a lot of sense to start thinking about where it is to slot in. Yeah, I completely agree with that. I also think there's a whole history of monetary economics. Like we feel like we live in this world where gold won. And it was always quite obvious. Well, there were like hundreds of years, even thousands of years as early as the 1800s, where we had bi-metalism. In fact, that was the, basically the US policy. It was not just gold, it was silver end gold. Yeah.
I mean, China was on the silver standard up until the 1930s, 1940s. Yeah. So it was somewhat kind of the British empire was an accident of history in some ways that gold eventually won. Yeah. Didn't have to be the case. And these two, a store of value assets fought it out for many centuries. Or for a minimum in there. Like that, the class, like Klippoli and had aluminum silver, where because aluminum was harder to mine than gold. And of course, you know, that changed because of chemical procedures and so on. But yeah, I mean, I think we humans have short memories, right? And so we just assume this was predestined when there's no such reason to believe that's actually true.
There is a question though, when it comes to this cycle of each also, you are quite clearly, Nitha Advocate have, you know, Eath Holdings is part of Lecture Capital and then in Eathzilla. Why has Eathor underperformed Bitcoin, this cycle so far? Do you have an explanation for that? Can I have a Mac answer that one? I'm going to throw all the hard questions to Mac. I don't know, I have thoughts. It's, I think it's just, my base take is, I think it's basically taken a while for the, is it like the next tranche, it's gotten so big on the retail side that you need the next pool of capital to come in, right?
And I think that the Bitcoin folks did a phenomenal job, the Bitcoin community did a phenomenal job of bringing the institutions in over the last several years. And that's kind of what, you know, I think the function of the debts in some sense, really I think like Tom and Joe Lubin and Mac here are carrying a lot of water for the community. Right. I want to hop in here for one minute just because if you have accounts at a variety of different banks and you want to buy Bitcoins and I'm talking 18 months ago, 24 months ago, I had to sign a lot of paperwork to even buy Ibit or MicroStrategy. And if you wanted to buy the Ethereum ETF that complies departments, someone wouldn't let you do it.
So Ibit became the first ETF security and then a lot of people were buying Bitcoin exposure through MicroStrategy and their brokerage accounts at large banks. But only until recently, and this is just in the, even in the last couple of months, has Ethereum been something that you're able to trade at some of the major banks in terms of buying even the ETF. So it's actually happened a lot faster than it did with Bitcoin and the adoption has just kind of just started. And that's just the reality of the situation. Yeah, I think people in crypto don't realize how long, because Erick Peters made this point, he is the CIO of Coinbase asset management to me recently.
But basically, he made the point that crypto has been a retail phenomenon. It sort of hasn't evolved. It's the first kind of, I guess, asset in a very long time that hasn't come out of Wall Street in that whole world. And so Wall Street just really happened to all those capital pulls, haven't had a way to purchase the asset. That pipe hasn't been there previously. And so it's just taken time. We've only now, this cycle got in there with Bitcoin. And only now, maybe as early as this summer, are we starting to see this pipe open up through all of that capital into crypto assets for Ether? And it's still not fully open.
When we don't have pensions aboard, we don't have very much in the way of sovereign wealth funds that have invested in this asset class. So the pipe continues to open, and treasuries are just kind of the next step in that story. Let's talk about maybe the comparison of a Bitcoin treasury versus an Ethereum treasury. So one of the columns that you checked in, is it a store value Bitcoin versus Ethereum is yield generating for Ether the asset. So that's not native for Bitcoin. That is native in staking for Ether the asset. But there are other yield generation opportunities. What is the difference between Ether treasury and a Bitcoin treasury when it comes to generation of yield?
We have a lot of opportunities to generate yield on chain just because of the way the Ethereum network is set up. So I look at the two almost completely differently. You think about Bitcoin as digital gold, and you're invested in a Bitcoin treasury company because you believe in Bitcoin and the price of Bitcoin is going meaningfully higher. And I think both I would y'all and I believe that. But Ethereum, you're not only betting on Ethereum, you're betting on network expansion. So you're betting on the Ethereum network growing, the various layers growing, the ecosystem expanding. But then I think what the most interesting thing to me is when you start bringing Wall Street onto Ethereum and you start tapping into all these different asset classes because it's the perfect mechanism to codify debt.
It's the perfect mechanism to codify assets that are regulated. And when you start talking about those numbers, they're much, much bigger than anything that Bitcoin could ever access. And that's when I get pretty excited about all these Ethereum treasury companies and what happens is transactional velocity increases on the network. What kind of yields are you guys looking at? What kind of yields can you expect? I guess just Eath Staking, vanilla is north of 2% or so. But can you get more than that without going too far down the risk curve? It's a question of how much risk you want to take. So I think that's the right question.
And you want to be really, I think, thoughtful and diligent and deliberate about that. So we have a pretty robust risk framework around this. And there's a whole spectrum of options that we're considering, you know, some things that are a little bit more than based staking, right? You can get into sort of like LRT's situation. There are categories of things, I think, on the RWA side. They'll be really interesting. I think the risk reward on some of those things is that come online will be very compelling. In large part, in addition to sort of it being say, Eath Factory collateralized or happening on chain because you might have some escape hatches.
Should there actually be issues? Because the RWA is existing on chain as well. All the way out to, you know, I think entirely new protocols that need to get bootstrapped, which will be really, really good for the ecosystem to have the bootstrapped in a relatively small position, you know, like a couple million dollars might be really meaningful to some of these protocols to get the flywheel going. And in exchange, those protocols might be willing to do token incentives upward. So via 15% or something, right? And so there's a pretty big range there. And without getting into too much of the specifics of how we're doing it, you know, I think, because that gets into sort of NMPI because it's probably a company kind of territory.
I think the full range of options is available there, depending on kind of where we're on the cycle and what the specific opportunities are. Or, you know, for example, just to get really concrete. You know, if you have a new protocol, but it's, you know, based off of like an extremely well-tested code base. And let's say it's, let's say it's Ave, the newest version of Ave or, you know, Ave V2 or something going on to a new L2. And there's a lot of incentives for some reason from either the L2 or from Ave to put teeth into that thing to get the flywheel going in this new L2 ecosystem. Well, that thing is like formally verified.
It's both tested for the last five years. There haven't been any hacks and issues. You know, that starts to look like a pretty good risk of a word, perhaps, right? I'm not saying we would specifically do that one, but like there, I think there are many such cases and the ecosystem across all the L2s has gotten so varied that I think there are many, many such opportunities between stables and lending indexes and so on that you can take advantage of and really help the community, right, like this. So this is what's great about this is it's a win win, or it's like not only can the shareholders from the SOA benefit because there's outsized, you'll be generated, but you're actually making it so that the Ethereum ecosystem is more vibrant and has protocol that are successful and liquid and so on.
And that is what makes the Ethereum successful. So as an ETSL holder, you don't want to just hold ETSL and then sit on it, right? You can actually actively make your investment more likely to be successful. That's even better, right? So you're actually improving the likelihood that Ethereum itself ends up being more successful by participating in our opinion. It sounds like we're starting to get into some of the secret sauce of ETSL itself, which is like, if you guys have been doing this type of thing, yield generation and electric capital for a while, and my understanding is you guys are not only anchor investors for this vehicle, but you're also doing some of the asset management to deploy that.
Yeah, that's right. And that might be in contrast to some of the, you know, more trad-fi type of ETH Treasury vehicles that don't have as much experience here. I sort of see Mac as kind of the trad-fi native and Rachel's the crypto native, and this is kind of a team up here to bring ETHzilla together. But it is the case that electric is going to be doing some of the asset management here, yes? Correct, yeah, that's right. And we've had a lot of, a lot of it comes down to tooling and sort of like operations and procedures to do this securely at scale. You know, the assets are still sitting inside Coinbase and how do you have like NPC setups and the right way and so on and so on.
So there's actually just like a lot of knowledge around how to do this. Yeah, I think, you know, at some point over the next two to three years, you know, a lot of trad-fi people will figure this out and they'll try to replicate some of these things, but, you know, the state of the art moves over two, three years. Like if you'd asked me back in 2021, let's say, you know, four years ago with sort of the last cycle, would a bunch of Wall Street people and a bunch of generalist VCs have figured out that there's all of this amazing opportunity on chain? And I said, yeah, there's no way, five years from now that these people haven't figured out that there's just, you know, 16% yields and you can go buy, you know, these things when they're down 60 or 80% and like hold them in Coinbase and they go up five X and like, there's like some pretty obvious stuff if you paid attention to crypto for the last 10 years, that would, that would, you know, outperform pretty much every venture fund and none of them did it.
You know, so it's sort of like, it's also surprised me how long it's taken for people to kind of get their heads around with the supplier. It's kind of the same reason though we were getting too early, it's like, this is not invented in Wall Street, it's not invented here basically. And so they haven't had the piping to actually connect them to the DeFi ecosystem. They're not, they're still not fully connected and there's a lot of people that just, they don't want to take the time to learn about it. Well, I think once, I think they will over time and that's part of the education process that we're going through it.
Mac, when you guys think about buying ETH, right? Do you buy as much as you can? Like as soon as you can, is this thing like time bounded? Like you're just like buying as much as you can when you have an MNAV premium surplus and you're doing the ATM thing when you could get your hands on more credit, you just buy ETH, or is this somewhat price bounded? Are you like, oh, you know, under 5K, ETHs look good and we'll just like wait for entry points. How do you think about purchases? I mean, we were obviously aggressive like right out of the shoot and got a big position together. And then we've just been in the market every day, dollar cost averaging on it.
I mean, I think where ETH can go a lot higher. So we're not thinking about it like any one day is the right day to do it. But it's really more we want to get a large position together over the moderate term because we think it's going to go up multifold over the next couple of years. And that's kind of how we're thinking about it. What's the steady state? What's the right MNAV premium? Because recently we've seen MNAV premiums, they were up and then they've kind of collapsed a little bit. So much so that crypto Twitter, of course, the flavor of the week right now, they're saying, oh, Treasury companies are dead.
You know, they'll never. Yeah. The MNAV premium will come to the stock market, right? I mean, look, there's going to be, there's a couple of things that go on here. The Treasury companies are on the NASDAQ. They're going to correlate to NASDAQ liquidity flows number one. So when the NASDAQ comes off, they're going to come off at a higher payday. And that's what you've seen happen over the last couple of days with this little sort of bump in AI. Longer term, what's the right range on MNAV? I think you could see MNAV go from a discount to MNAV all the way up into three X MNAV and what's the right normalized MNAV?
Probably like 1.7 to two times somewhere in there that it, I mean, it seems like where they've been trading and possibly higher if you start to get into a pretty strong full cycle with, with ETH. And then to the downside, you know, it probably compresses if you get into a bare cycle with ETH. And then you just have the opportunity to buy back stock of that happens. There was a recent bitmex paper I believe that talked about some of the cost structures of these Treasury entities. And comparing them to something like the ETS, right? They talked about, look, it's expensive to get SEC filings and legal paperwork and go through that whole process.
There are asset management fees, there are Wall Street, they get visor type fees, all of these things. Some of these Treasury vehicles will be less liquid than others, right? And some of them, you know, all of them, of course, will be less liquid than spot ETH. How do you think about some of those risks of foreign investor thinking about these types of vehicles? I just look at it as a business and I look at our business and you look at what the net margins on the business are. Even, you know, at scale, we're at billion in change. And they're very high, like double digit net margin business in terms of just like absolute cash flow on the core of the ETH.
You don't need a whole lot of cost structured operate. So there are a lot of high costs to get started and raise all the capital because of what you mentioned, lower fees, banking fees, you know, that's a pretty high entry or like once you're up and running there's a ton of fixed operating leverage at these businesses. It's a lot more like circle than anything else. I mean, you can manage a lot of assets with pretty, you know, small amount of people. Or Tether or Berkshire. In my head, I think the opportunity for these things in the limit is like a Berkshire, which is if you look at what Warren Buffett got right, he had this sort of core one or two assets that produced phenomenal yield.
And really when you sort of lay unlayer that, okay, you're like, what's an insurance business? So what is an insurance business? It's like a yield, it's like levered yield on US dollars, which isn't some sense what's happening here under the covers. And if you do that right, we end up with a thing that spins a bunch of free cash flows. So let's play this out for let's say, you know, if in this is a not financial advice, like but a bull case, just not process, right? Let's say ETH is in fact worth a couple trillion dollars, right? It's worth five or 10X, what is worth today? Could you have treasuries that are sitting on $30 billion worth of a notional ETH, where if it had 10X is like if you can get a couple that get to a $3 billion, right?
So, you know, BM&R and SBET and ETHC, let's say get into that kind of a zone today, and then they end up sitting on $30 billion plus. At a 3% yield, you're talking about a billion dollars a year and free cash flow. And I mean, that's like in a single year, you would have more dollars than the entire budget, like the total available budget for the ETH foundation. Now, you're talking like crazy, crazy amounts of money in cash flow, and could you take those and start to ring best them back into things that generate 30, 40, 50% cash flow is just the same way Warren Buffet has. I don't think that's crazy.
You know, and they're aligned with what the ecosystem needs, right? And so, I mean, the operating leverage when you have a core asset that can scale to those kinds of numbers and generate yield off of that asset, it's like a pretty phenomenal business. And to me, the closest analog is like a, like a Berkshire sort of situation. That's the bulkiest thing that I would be betting on or buying these things. And that's exactly why we both got involved. I mean, the actual business is an excellent business to be operating because of the free cash flow yield. Berkshire, of course, has a Warren Buffet and MicroStrategy has its Michael Sailor and BitMine has its Tom Lee and we got Joe Lubin.
Some of these treasury entities seem to thrive based on a spokesperson who's willing to go to all corners of the universe and preach the gospel of Bitcoin or ETH or whatever particular asset they're hoarding in their treasury. So who is the spokesperson for this vehicle? How important is the attention economy for growing a ETH treasury strategy? I mean, I've had an interview two or three times a day, every day, since we launched this vehicle. So if people who aren't watching the video, Mac is literally taking this episode from his car. Okay, so that's how dedicated he is to making these things happen.
Yeah, no, it's been really, really busy and the amount of interest has actually just been crazy in terms of who's wanted to talk, all the different media sources that want to talk to us. And there's a ton of education that has to go on. I mean, Tom Lee's done an unbelievable job getting out there in the marketplace. I listened to his podcast that you had him on here the other day and look, I think we're all doing the same thing in terms of educating Wall Street and using our connectivity on Wall Street to talk to people about what's going on. So that's what I've been out doing for the last couple of weeks is explaining this to people.
I would add, I think there's an opportunity. Part of what we did in the fundraising process for this was pulled in a bunch of the DeFi founders. So you know, Constantine, the founder of Lido, Robert and Taroon, Taroon from Connolly, Robert from Compound, Shree Rom from Iron Lair, Mike from Ether File. I mean, if you start looking at TV, all of these, so that's your lies, right? They're part of your lies, guys. That's your name, man. You know Zach and Grant. So if you look at like the TVL of these protocols, you know, it's something like 60 billion in TVL. And many people who have been in and around the space for a long time, you know, like Danny was at the East Foundation and managed the proof of work to proof of state transition.
So people have been really long-term committed to the East. And I think part of the hope here is that as we start being able to plug this East back in on chain and through some of these partners that we have and we can make noise around that, obviously. But what we really can have is the East community pulling here as well. That's not just, you know, it's sort of, I think, what would the East community, like, it's a very, I think, East Ethereum ethos way to do it. Which is like, yes, you can have some sort of a front and they can go do some of this work. But it really should be a community effort.
And I think if we say, hey, look, there's an option here for the Ethereum community. You can either have Wall Street people come in and co-opt East. And now like all the money is sitting in these like, you wrap equities and go on and so on. Or we can go co-opt Wall Street. And I think for a lot of people who have been in this ecosystem for a long time, that's the preferable option. And so if we're gonna do that, let's make sure that the East is getting put back on chain and being used productively. Let's make sure that the transactions that are happening are not just Wall Street legacy transactions and tradifying credit markets.
Let's make sure those are all happening on chain. Can we actually get tokenization to happen? And can we pull that into under the chain? Can we get the credit markets to move on chain? Like that to me is a much more interesting thing if we can pull it off. And we need the community's help to do that. And so hopefully this turns into the like, oh, the ETH still guys are trying to do the right thing from our perspective. And so like the story I always tell is everybody, in the United States and Canada, we're gonna come up on the fall here and people go home for Thanksgiving. And like every family has one cousin that's like the crypto guy, you know?
And every like two years, that crypto guy is a genius or an idiot. And this year the crypto guy is probably a genius. And so if the family is sitting around dinner and saying like, hey, what's going on? And like, oh, I heard about this like digital asset treasury thing, which one should we buy? Hopefully a bunch of crypto people, you know, Ethereum people say, oh, by the one that's actually putting this stuff to work back on chain. By the one from the, you know, that has the people who are thinking about how to make this thing work over the next 10 years. It's not a like one cycle thing for them because they've been, they've already been around for 10 years.
And so I have confidence that they'll still be here in 10 years. Some sort of rug poll at the end of the cycle. So if you're going to do it, go to those guys as hopefully part of the message here that people get. And so in some sense, it's like, yes, Max should go do a bunch of this work too and is doing a great job of it. And then hopefully we have this like multiplier effect from everybody in the community saying, oh, yeah, those are, those are aligned people like we want, we want those guys to do well. So that multiplier effect in the communities is that the win condition for it? So like what does winning mean for it?
So are you at a, you know, a certain place in the ETH treasury charts? Are you, you know, is there, is there like, what's the wider mission? I think that, I think being getting up to the top three on the ETH treasury charts is one thing. But I think differentiating ourselves in terms of our yield generation and then how you see the business operating is what's really going to create this operation here. Because I think once the market sees that over a couple of months and a couple quarters, it's going to be very different from the other treasury companies. You think the market consolidates mergers and acquisitions in the months to come or like maybe in the years to come, when do you think that sort of activity picks up?
I think there will be some consolidation. I think it'll be hard for there to be, you know, 20 of these. I think there's some in scale that you have to hit and I think if you can't get over, you know, at least a billion in market cap, you're probably in a struggle for a while. And so I think a lot that probably shakes out in the next bear cycle. And I think there's probably some sort of consolidation that starts to happen. And I think it'll be an interesting question for some of the smaller ones, you know, the sub one billion dollar ones of where do you go and how do you think about that? Because the thing that I think they'll have to fend off is actually the activist investors.
Because once you're on the Wall Street train, right? Like what's going to happen is somebody who can buy, let's say you have an East Treasury and you're one of the smaller ones. Therefore your fixed costs are higher. Therefore you're burning all of your yield to just like keep the company running. Do you start to trade at a discount to Nav? And if you do, then there's an incentive for somebody to come in and say, well, you're trading, you know, a 20, 20% below Nav, I can come in and buy enough shares and pressure the board to liquidate the assets and I make 20% as an activist investor. Or, you know, imagine like a really crazy scenario, which I don't, I actually don't think is that crazy.
If you're somebody like Sailor and you have, you know, a thing where you buy a dollars worth of BTC and you're worth a dollar 50, let's say even in a bear market, you know, he might be able to retain some premium. Does Michael Sailor go out and start to buy a bunch of these guys up and force liquidate? Not eat treasury. He would never do that. Oh yeah, totally. What? I'm making an even stronger argument, which is I think there's an incentive structure for Sailor to go after ETH or other. Oh my God, that would be the thing. And then sell them, right? Because if you can effectively like, let's say you're willing to go, let's say they're trading at 80 cents on the dollar, right?
Can you go to the capital markets and borrow a dollar? Sure. Buy things at a 10% discount. Like, do you go to these companies to say, look, I'm the best bidder in market. Like, I'm going to liquidate this thing and I'm going to pay 90 cents on the dollar. You're only worth 80 cents on the dollar today. I'm going to pay 90 cents on the dollar. How do you, as a fiduciary, as a board or a CEO, say no to that, right? If they were control, if they're, if they own enough of the common. It's a tricky situation, right? And then what he's doing is essentially buying dollars for 90 cents, putting them on his balance sheet where those dollars are now worth a dollar 40.
This is like a straight killer arbitrage for him and he's getting the double whammy of like, not only is he dumping the things that he doesn't like, but he's picking up a bunch of stuff that he loves, right? So, I wouldn't put it past, you know, some of these. You know, like, are you saying, if he's like, he might go, you know, hunt down these ETH treasury companies or trading under MNAV, go buy them, basically, some act of this takeover. And then do you think he'd sell the ETH? Because he's got that Bitcoin maximalist thing. That's right. That's why it's a double whammy, right? Yeah, we're just sharing.
I think you could, you know, like, I don't, what's, I think the magic of Michael Sayler, and I say this with respect, and this is not like a valid judgment, like a negative valid judgment. He's so committed that I think for him and many of his followers because it is, it is cultish behavior, but I think he's brilliant is like, that is the point, right? Like the only thing that matters is Bitcoin. And, and so like, is it out of the realm of possibility that you, you take these other things which are sucking up capital and sucking up capital from the debt market. And you say, look, these, these are bad actors.
Like these, these are nefarious actors. We're actually doing a public good by taking them out. And so we're going to go like buy these all L ones. We're going to take their tokens or we're going to dump them in the depths of the bear market and crush those tokens in order to turn around and buy more Bitcoin. Like that doesn't seem crazy to me, actually. No, it doesn't at all. I mean, it certainly fits the, the, the character that he's created. Well, on the subject of cycles of each little, maybe give me a take on this. So where are we in the crypto cycle? If there is a site, do you still believe in cycles?
Is this playing out the way previous, you know, bull cycles have? Yeah. And like how, how much further do we have to go? That's a great question. Short answers, I don't know. Longer answer is, you know, I tend to think that the cycles are more tied to rate cuts than anything else. And like capital flows. That's sort of the conclusion I've come to. And like, are you saying liquidity? I mean, just to us, the four-year happening, it's just like more, yeah. And it's like a monadic element to it. Sure. These things have historically been relatively illiquid. So it didn't take a ton of money with the mimetic aspects of the four-year cycle to make this thing work.
And it's really hard. I, you know, it's, it's, we tend to have for what it's worth because we're venture investors. We're, you know, in these 10 year locked up funds, we don't, we don't trade. We don't manage the liquid assets that way. We, you know, are primarily thinking about, what does the world look like in 10 years? So we've been able to sort of think about these things cross-cycle and be patient. And, and sort of align RLP's around this idea that, you know, this ecosystem is a fraction of what it will be in 10 years. And that's really what you're betting on, ultimately. More so than like the short-term price of these assets.
But it is something I think about. I think, I don't know the answer. I mean, the four-year cycle is certainly possible. I think there's an argument that you have, you know, some extended four-year cycle, which is like, it's almost like a COVID, you know, like the Trump tariffs where there's a weird detour that we had to take for three to six months. And that just set everything back. And so you effectively have a four-year cycle, but it's like a 4.25 or, you know, 4.5-year cycle instead of a four-year cycle. Because we did this weird detour that took the capital markets out of whack for a while.
And then I think there's, there's some people, like, you know, if you talk to some of the folks on the ETF side, they say, hey, look, if you look at the gold ETFs, there was new gold inflows every single year, you know, for like 10 years. Like, you know, it's like inflows have never been down, basically, right? Yeah, it finally went down like 10 years after the gold ETF was launched or something, but for many, many, many years, like each year of gold inflows was actually higher than the previous year. And so these capital markets just move really slowly. And so, you know, the sort of thinking here would be, you know, you, it will take many years for this to play out.
And the four-year cycle is over because you just have this sort of constant bid coming in from Wall Street now that those rails are all set up. I don't know. I don't know where I land on that. I just think it's, for me, it's much easier to think in like 10-year windows and just like, what happens with the next 10 years is much easier to figure out that what happens over the next 12 months. Ethereum's layer two universe is exploding with choices. But if you're looking for the best place to park and move your tokens, make your next stop uni chain. First, liquidity. Uni chain hosts the most liquid Uniswap V4 deployment on any layer two, giving you deeper pools for flagship pairs like each USDC.
More liquidity means better prices, less slippage, and smoother swaps, exactly what traders crave. The numbers back it up. Uni chain leads all layers to use in total value locked for Uniswap V4. And it's not just a deep, it's fast and fully transparent, purpose-built to be the home base for DeFi and cross-chain liquidity. When it comes to costs, Uni chain is a no-brainer. Transaction fees come in about 95% cheaper than Ethereum maintenance. Flashing the price of creating or accessing liquidity. Want to stay in the loop on Uni chain? Visit unichain.org or follow at Uni chain on X for all the updates.
Because you're on this episode as the ETH guy, like, you know, as an investor in ETH Silla, you got to put you on the spot and ask for some ETH price point predictions. So Tom Lee is making predictions for end of the year and he's got some pretty wild predictions in the future. Do you have any sense for what you think ETH will be at the end of this year, or maybe the next 18 months to three years? Short answer is no. Short term price predictions are really, really tough. I think the way I think about it, and it's a little bit of a cheat code, actually, if you think about it as an investor, right?
This is the cheat code for seed investors, for example, which is what we are primarily, right? We mostly do these like early stage two people in an idea, sorts of investments. You know, if you're investing in things when they're worth very little and you look at it and say, I can underwrite something that is more than a 10X from here. You have a lot of margin for error. And so you can say, like, it's just worth a lot, a lot, lot more than it's worth today. I don't know when it gets there, and I'm willing to be wrong for a while, as long as the court thesis doesn't change. And so that's kind of how we think about it is it's, you know, if this thing works, in the same way that we talk about Bitcoin, you know, it's just like, if it works, it's just worth a lot more than it's worth today.
I don't know what that means. Is that like a 10X? Is that a 25X? Are you Tom Lee a hundred X? Yeah, I don't think that's crazy at all. And I'll walk you through some math, right? I think when we think about Bitcoin, historically, we've always said, hey, look, this is, if this is digital gold, gold's worth 20 trillion. You do the back of the envelope math and you factor in the Bitcoin that's been lost over the years in Satoshi's Bitcoin, that gets you to a million dollars of Bitcoin pretty fast. Yeah. And if you do similar numbers for Ethereum, you're like, look, the comp here is some sort of store value like gold, and that's at 20 trillion, and eth is at 400 billion today, then that's a 50X right there, right?
And then I think there's this element that people forget, which is I think one of the lessons of software over the last 20 years and 30 years is that you get Tam expansion. So every time you make something easier to acquire, the market size goes up. So take Uber, for example. Like the criticism of Uber back in the series A was, well, the entire taxi industry's worth 10 or 12 billion. And that's how they sized it, right? How could you possibly be worth more than the entire taxi industry? But in retrospect, you're like, oh, well, when you put things on a phone, you actually get 10X market expansion, right?
Because it was so hard. So far delivery too, now, right? And you get the second order effects that you couldn't predict it, right? And so I think one of the lessons, in a lot of, like, if you, there's a recent podcast from Mark Adryson who talked about this, who said, like you can never call the market sizes on the things that you're investing in early, and you're almost always wrong. And you're wrong in two ways. One is that for the things that didn't work, you're usually wrong that the market sizes were just too small. You're like, oh, it turns out people don't really want this. The product wasn't good, but the market size was too small.
Yeah. And in the cases where you're right, it turns out the market sizes are like so ridiculously large that you sound like a crazy person if you were to predict it, right? So like, could you have predicted Coinbase would be a $100 billion company, right? It just sound, like when you're doing the series A, when the thing is worth like 30 million, you just sound like a crazy person saying. Yeah, you'd size it against banks or something like that. There's no way this is going to be as large as one of the five biggest banks in the world. That's just what you sound like a crazy person if you said that, right?
So it's funny, like the market size thing always gets in the way, but it gets in the way in like two totally different situations. Like when you're wrong, it's usually like you overestimated the market size, right? And when you're right, you're actually more prone to like dramatically undersize the upside market. And so if you think ETH works, actually like the thing that you should do is say like, actually, I think it's bigger than gold, or the same thing with Bitcoin. Like I don't think anybody who's like a Bitcoin bull should not be saying, oh, it gets to gold and then stops. Probably the intuition and the learning from the internet is it's probably five x bigger than gold.
And so similarly, I think for ETH, I think that if it works, the market sizes are just, we're going to look back and be like, we were stupid for thinking it was so small. I mean, the fact of the matter is like we've never seen, humanity's never seen, history's never seen, a digital store value that's accessible to anyone within the internet connection. I mean, gold is not accessible in that way. Yeah, gold is really hard to, for anybody who's actually tried to buy gold, it's really painful. It's like quite challenging. And you gotta like, it's pretty painful. And what do you end up like, you're talking about like actual physical bear asset gold?
I mean, that's like, yeah, I don't even know how you do that. Yeah, for most of the world, it's basically impossible to acquire. And you know, it's like painful to store and you don't want to tell people you have it. And if I remember the numbers, it's, you know, if you take out things like wedding rings, it's literally only like 400 million, it's like a couple hundred million people, mostly in India and China and the Gulf that actually have any kind of physical gold. Which is a relatively, on the internet, 400 million people is kind of tiny. You know, like telegram has twice that many. You know, it's just like, you can open up your phone and then you probably have like, all of the apps on your home screen probably have more than 400 million monthly users, right?
So like 400 million on the internet is not that large, actually. This has been great. I gotta ask this ending question because it was in my head as you were thinking about it. So Yitzala, of course, has almost $500 million worth of Yitzala, you guys plan to deploy that, go get some yield. I imagine some of these other ETH Treasury companies plan to do the same. I mean, I don't know how much we have here. You know, 10 to $15 billion worth of ether. Yeah. So I think about that in kind of the yield pursuit. And of course, some of that goes to staking and some of that's gotta go in the rest of the Ethereum economy.
It's gotta go into DeFi protocols. Yeah. So I'm just like looking at this and I'm saying, okay, are we in store for a DeFi after boom on the back of this whole Treasury expansion? Is that just like the obvious play? I mean, maybe I'm asking you to put on your lecture capital hat for this last question. Yeah, we tend to think so. We think that it's just this is the case around stablecoins and this is the case around Dats. It's just like once you own the thing, you sort of look around and you say, what can I do with it? And if there's some opportunity to generate yield, it's not that you go 100% of your assets go into that necessarily, but you sort of look at your portfolio.
Like is it so crazy for X percent of my assets to be generating yield on top of this and I'm willing to take that risk and there's some percentage probability that you get a total loss scenario in your data. But I think a lot of people will do that and relatively small percentages with like a very large base value for ETH all of a sudden, you're talking about numbers that are bigger than like the dollar sitting in US banks, right? So yeah, these numbers get pretty large pretty fast. So yeah, we do think that we're actually having a conversation internally with one of our partners Ken had this insight because he does a lot of our DeFi stuff that maybe DeFi summer was like the 99 moment, which is like everybody just got over their skis and we sort of like invented all the right primitives very quickly, like if you look around, you're like, oh, actually a lot of the ideas were basically the right ideas in 2020 and 2021.
We were just over our skis in terms of how quickly we thought it would happen. And if you're looking a lot of those ideas from like 97, 98, 99, they really started to be able to be manifest in like 05 to 08. Like it took five to eight years and then like you finally had enough scale of the users on the internet and like advertising finally worked and broadband finally got there and all that kind of stuff, right? All of the things the internet promised came true. Actually, they did, right? And even like the craziest, stupidest ones, right? Like, oh, you're gonna do grocery delivery and then here we are at Instacart is like a probably data company, right?
And it's a web band with like the infamous one that Sequoia lost a bunch of money on but it turns out they were just 10 years too early. The idea was a good idea. And so we kind of, we kind of been having that thought is like, actually if you look around, like a lot of the primitives kind of work. Like Avi works, you know, Lido works, Peniswap works. You know, they kind of like stood the test time here and they've gotten more sophisticated and so on but the basic ideas were basically the right ideas and so at some point we think that maybe you hit that sort of 05 to 08 kind of window where the rails are set and everybody understands it and it's ready to go and, you know, we're like five-ish years now after DeFi summer and so maybe like kind of the setup is the right setup now phone?
I like that setup. I think one way to think about it or the one way to play it is just if this is the institutional cycle for crypto and I really do think it is, it's unlocking all that traffic cycle that you wanna be in institutional assets and Bitcoin is becoming an institutional asset. Ether looks like it's becoming an institutional asset. Just look at the ETF flows, just look at these treasury entries and then you wanna be an institutional DeFi protocols because where's the yield gonna go? It's not going to go in kind of the new smart contract platform that was just set up, you know, six months ago.
It's probably going to go into these DeFi blue chips that are time-tested. Anyway, not financial advice but as one way to think about the cycle of each of Mac, it's been so great to have you. Thank you so much for entering public markets very excited to see what Yitzelah does in the future. It's been great. Good to see you. Bangladesh Nation, gotta let you know. Of course, none of this has been financial advice. Crypto's risky, you could lose what you put in. This is the frontier's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the Bangladesh journey. Thanks a lot.