Solana is emerging as a competitive Layer 1 platform, promising scalability and a growing ecosystem. Join community thought leaders Santiago Santos and Konstantin Lomashuck as we assess the Solana Value Proposition.
How important is decentralization? Why build on Solana? Can different L1's coexist? Does it seek to compete with mainnet Ethereum or Layer 2 scaling solutions?
We've been hearing a lot about Solana lately. It's time to dive in.
------ SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ ️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ CLAIM YOUR BADGE: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/-guide-2-using-the-bankless-badge ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
GEMINI | FIAT & CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
BALANCER | EXCHANGE & POOL ASSETS https://bankless.cc/balancer
AAVE | LEND & BORROW ASSETS https://bankless.cc/aave
UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING http://bankless.cc/uniswap
------ ⚽️ SoRare | Collect and Play! https://bankless.cc/SoRare ------
Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 8:00 Santiago and Konstantin 10:05 Why Bullish on Solana? 16:31 Solana is Optimizing 24:05 Decentralization 34:56 Running a Node 55:57 Skeptical ETH Maxi Hat 1:04:40 Initial Sale 1:12:32 Valuing SOL 1:19:08 Developer Activity 1:24:11 Can We Be Friends?
------ Resources
Santiago on Twitter: https://twitter.com/santiagoroel?s=20
Konstantin on Twitter: https://twitter.com/Lomashuk?s=20
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Hey, Bankless Nation. We are excited to bring you another bankless panel. This one is all about Salana. Salana, a layer one blockchain. Some have people have called it an ETH killer, maybe an ETH competitor, maybe it's an ETH companion. David and I realized we wanted to learn a bit more about Salana and the ecosystem and to have a panel where we could have a fairly neutral conversation about Salana to dig in deeper. So that's what we're doing today. We brought two fantastic guests that I think can represent a bull case for Salana perspective in a kind of a credibly neutral way. So know these two guests are very passionate about DeFi, know they care about values that the bankless nation cares about.
That's why we wanted to bring them both on. David, do you want to tease who the guests are and then maybe we can give a quick tease of what this panel is going to cover and our position is going into this panel? Yeah, sure. So we brought on Santiago Santos, who is a big Ethereum bull and is also bullish on Salana. And so for somebody that I resonate with, their bullishness on Ethereum, I would like to know what are the rationales behind the bullishness on Salana. And so we're bringing on Santiago just for that angle. And then we also have Constantine Lumishuk, who has worked many different projects around the world, run the crypto ecosystem part of the Lido team, part has experienced with validating systems, proof of stake systems, blockchain systems.
So he will be useful to talk about the nature of the technical details of Salana and is also bullish on Salana. And so I have detailed questions about that. And then I also, I think we also have to ask, you know, kind of more or less the same questions that all blockchains have to ask themselves, the nature of the token distribution, the nature of who gets to validate and just the why it is a, what did it unlock, right? So from what I've been able to gather, so Salana is a pretty cool piece of software from the people who are technically more competent than me. They have good things to say about the software that is Salana.
And so I want to dive into that as well. Yeah, absolutely. I think we probably both of us have a particular thesis coming into this conversation, right? One that we've held for a while. So you know, first of all, the vision when we started bankless was we want a self-solver and bankless money system for the world. The most decentralized system possible. We saw that in Bitcoin, we saw that in Ethereum, we see that in DeFi. And we've always had an open mind to like what is coming next. I will say I probably have a preconception going into this conversation. And that is this. Salana, as David mentioned, is a cool piece of technology.
There are real project. There's a real team behind this. There's some fantastic engineering and a real community. They have a real community. I see backing from some interesting funds, FTX and other crypto banks as well. So I see some traction. So it felt time to have a conversation about it. Other layer ones like haven't reached even even this stage where it's worth spending a lot of time on at least for me. But David and I thought it was time to have a conversation about Salana. I will say my current perspective on Salana is that I believe it might be a bit too decentralized or too centralized to be a global world settlement layer for DeFi.
Things I'm going to ask and I'm concerned about the ability to run a node from home is very important. The ability to kind of verify transactions and opt into the system. There's some issues with state growth that seem unresolved. Some questions around the supply of the token. This got a start in sort of VC land and in a a pre-sale that wasn't publicly available. A relatively small group of folks who have been distributed the token at least in the early stages. Some of that may be decentralized. I think ultimately I've concerns about the number of validators that it takes and the number of colluding parties that it takes to kind of co-opt the network, censor it, roll back the chain, these sorts of things.
I feel like my take coming into this conversation and the way the reason I'm sort of spending some time to illustrate this is because it's important to get a sense for the questions David and I are asking is it feels to me like Salana is a fine platform for lower value settlement. Maybe things like NFTs are great for it. Maybe other low-value use cases, but I don't think it's decentralized enough to be the bankless defy settlement layer that we want from this space. At least that's my thesis going in and I'm open to the conversation around this open to change my mind, but all of this might mean it doesn't actually compete against Ethereum.
It's actually a companion to Ethereum in the same way other side chains are, other layer 2s are even centralized exchanges help propagate and they do settlement on Ethereum too. So ultimately I do want to echo the sentiment that this is not a zero-sum game, like we're all in this together. I do think that Salana is actually good for Ethereum, so the ETH killer versus Ethereum thing is somewhat of a myth, but we do need to get to the bottom and have a conversation about the trade-offs of various systems, and particularly the layer 1 that we select for this industry as kind of the shelling point for all DeFi, we need to make sure it is as decentralized as possible.
So I'm probably going to be asking these panelists some questions along those lines. I don't know, David, if you have anything to add, that's a longer preamble than you did at all. Yeah, I felt it was important. All right, so let's go ahead and get into the takes from our guests, and so before we get there, we must talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. When you shop for plane tickets, you probably use Kayak, Expedia, or Google to compare ticket prices. So why would you limit yourself to just one exchange when you trade crypto? When you make your trades, you want to make sure that you are getting the best possible price on your trade, and that you aren't paying high gas costs that you could have otherwise avoided.
That's why you should be using Matcha. Matcha routes your orders across all the various DeFi exchanges on Ethereum, Polygon, Binance Smart Chain, and gives you the best possible prices without taking any commission. Matcha has smart order routing that splits your order across multiple liquidity sources, if Matcha sees that it gets you better pricing. Trading on Matcha is super easy, because it pulls the liquidity for me into a single easy to use platform, and that has even saved me multiple times from accidentally picking the wrong decks to trade on and accidentally getting a bad price. Matcha also allows for you to make limit orders on chain, so you can set and forget your DeFi trades, and they will go through automatically while you're away.
Newed to Matcha is an integrated Fiat on-ramp. You can purchase crypto directly with your credit or debit card, and have that Fiat be instantly traded for any token that has liquidity. When you're making a trade, head over to matcha.xyz slash bankless, and connect your wallet to start getting the best prices and most liquidity when you trade your crypto assets. Arbitrum is an Ethereum scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi. If you've been using Ethereum for the past 12 months, you probably notice the high gas fees and the slow confirmation times that have been plaguing DeFi.
Too many people want to use Ethereum, and it doesn't have enough capacity for all of us. That's where Arbitrum comes in. Arbitrum is a layer 2 to Ethereum, which means Arbitrum can increase Ethereum's throughput by orders of magnitude, at a fraction of the cost of what we are used to paying. When interacting with Arbitrum, you can get the performance of a centralized exchange while tapping into Ethereum's level of security and decentralization. This is why people are calling this Ethereum's broadband moment, where we get to add performance onto decentralization and security. If you're a developer, and you want to save on gas costs, and make an overall better experience for your users, go to developer.
offchainlabs.com to get started building on Arbitrum. If you're a user, keep an eye out for your favorite DeFi apps building on Arbitrum. Arbitrum has been working with over 300 teams, including Ethereum's top infrastructure projects, and will be opening up to all users shortly. There are so many apps coming online to Arbitrum, so you may want to pack your bags in preparation for the great migration to the Arbitrum layer 2. To keep up to speed with Arbitrum, follow them on Twitter at Arbitrum and join their Discord. Hey guys, we are back with the panel that is all about Solana. We have two guests for you, really excited to introduce them to you.
The first is Santiago Santas. He is a crypto investor. He spends most of his time at the intersection of DeFi and the Metaverse. He has a crypto punk, of course, number 9159. He's a former partner at Parified Longtime Investor in the space. Also, a repeat bankless gas Santiago. Thanks for joining us today. Hey, thanks Ryan. Thanks David. It's great to be here again. We also have Konstantin Lamascha, who is an investor in the Ethereum crowd sale, and also a Solana seed investor. Both of those networks at the same time has watched them grow from little seedlings to what they are now. I think offers a fantastic perspective.
Also a validator in the space, co-founder of the p2p.org project. Also, Lido, he is a Unisox holder, need to mention that. We've got to pump our NFTs whenever possible, right guys? Konstantin, welcome to the show. It's good to have you. Hi guys. All right, fantastic. Well, we are going to get into the panel with I think the first question, which sort of sets the basis for all others, which is what makes you bullish about Solana? Santiago, maybe start with you. Yeah, look at me. I think it was interesting. I think generally, when you're investing in this space, you have to keep an open mind of how things are evolving.
I think protocol, there are organisms that expand and grow. I saw Bitcoin early on and Ethereum early on as well. They've taken a shape of their own and they've grown in a very meaningful way. I think what drew me to Solana was a couple of things, but I think this idea that the number of developers that were entering the space, not just like Solidity Devs going to Solana, but it was more like new talent entering the space. I think that was large part of the gravitas at SAM, FTX, and that consortium has. They have a lot of muscle and resources to attract new developers, which I think isn't that positive to the space.
When I say the space, I think like Ethereum, Bitcoin, just broadly crypto. To me, it was really encouraging. I was a judge in a few of the hackathons and the number of developers entering the space was improving and talking to these developers. The thing that I focus on the most is how easy is it to build in Solana. I think the dev tooling and resources have come a long, long way since I launched what is it a year and change ago, a year and a half ago or a year and a month ago. To me, that has been most encouraging. It followed the devs and why they're building in Solana and understanding that led me to become more interested in the space.
Also, I think you alluded to this in the preamble, which is, well, there are certain things that I think certain blockchains is my view that are application specific blockchains. A blockchain doesn't need to do everything. I think we're in this mindset that we think of the internet as this one, just the internet. But I think blockchains might be different where they might lend themselves to this trade-off that you're making the security and synchronization and faster throughput and settlement and execution and lower cost. I think, ultimately, I think to me, this is a growing desire to see more different use cases be explored, whether it be social or NFTs or stuff that if you're settling a million plus dollars, well, you're going to value security a lot.
But there are certain applications that might not require, and especially the user might not even appreciate decentralization and security. So, ultimately, I think it's not positive, as you said, and to me, that was most interesting, and have been for a while now supporting and just observing what's happening on the DeFi side of things and also the NFT kind of metaverse side of things. So, but I'll pause there. We definitely want to get back to the conversation around the use cases for Solana, how that might be distinct from Ethereum or similar to Ethereum when we talk about the apps. But let me throw the same question to Constantine now.
So, Constantine, you were there from the very beginning, both of Ethereum and also of Solana. So, tell us what made you bullish on Solana in the early days, and then what makes you bullish now? Yeah, you know, my answer is pretty simple. It has a different vision of scaling, and it's not bad, it's good, you know, like if you do only, I mean, the same things, it is a bad for ecosystem, we should try different ones and compete with each other. It will bring, you know, like a better project for final users. And before we start the discussion, I also want to say that I'm a big believer in Ethereum success, you know, like, and have, you know, like much more Ethereum that they bought on, for example, in CrowdSale.
And so, I'm not going in this conversation, try to sell Solana. My goal is, you know, like to show that Solana and Ethereum are good friends, and they can co-exist together. And together, we can achieve, like, the goal of decentralization and censorship resistance faster, and like to bring more value, I mean, to everybody, then if you compete, attack, and try, you know, like to compete with each other. And also, I mean, in 2014, you know, like, I'm either report about all blockchains, and this valuation is more than $100,000. So, it was about $100 of them. And we split them already in 2014 and proof of stake and proof of work.
And what did we try to understand? What is different between all of them? And what we saw, we saw, even in 2014, already a lot of Bitcoin maximalists, you know, they still exist, you can see them. Now, we have a lot of, also, Ethereum maximalists, I don't try to say that it's bad. It's also good, we love the products that we build. But what I tried to say is that, I mean, we need to look deep more, we need to make more critic, not only to competitor, but also to products that we love, and push to make them better. So, back to the question, you know, in 2018, when it was the beginning of crypto winter, so nobody wanted to allocate capital to new products, especially to layer one.
And I had a conversation with Anatoli where he told me like a lot of different things, you know, I didn't catch everything because he is more technical than I am. But one thing that I catch, it was like that he want to build the blockchain that scale with the speed of technology. You know, like, and it is a little bit different, as it's that we have in Ethereum. For example, when you want to like make more like transaction, for example, when you want to build more scalable solution, and if it is new hardware exists, you can make more transaction per second. And in this different vision, you know, I'll allocate my capital because I think I don't know what the vision is, I mean, like, what is better finally, what will be, what a system will be.
I will help you that like all this ecosystem coin is co-existent, we'll find own like place on the market. And there this is my goal, that's what I tried to do from 2018, I run a really data, I run this notes, I help, you know, to make it sense to strip these systems from central, the centralize. Yeah, this is my answer. David, you meet it. Fantastic, Constitina, I appreciate that perspective. And both of you got, both of you guys just answers had some sort of allusion to, so Lana being a meaningfully different innovation than just what would be just a fork of gaff, right? And I think the reason why like we are doing a Solana panel rather than like a Binance Smart Chain panel or a Avalanche panel is that both of those things are just forks of gaff, right?
And that's not really true innovation in my mind. And ultimately, it's talking about the EVM, it's ultimately just talking about Ethereum with extra steps. Solana is not that. Solana is its own thing, it's bringing its own innovations to the table. And so my question to you guys is what is Solana optimized for as a result of its new like package of software, right? And do the, what if Solana is optimized for something, is it optimized for something that is similar to Ethereum and what Ethereum is optimized for or is it something different? Asanteago, let's start with you. I was going to say Constitina, if you want to go first, but you sure, I'll jump.
I think you know, ultimately don't, my view is that Solana perhaps takes like every network, I think, through utility decentralizes. So Bitcoin and Ethereum were pretty centralized, I think, initially as well. The Constitina's point of view, I mean, I spoken on a totally and he worked at Qualcomm, I believe, and so has a sort of view of how networks scaled in the early days of the internet. And I think there's sort of these sequential waves where, you know, you have this technology, no one really cares about it, then it gets a lot of traction and it pushes the limit of a server of network and then you have sequential waves of innovation.
But there's this sort of gap where there's more demand with the network in support. And I think that experience on a totally coming from the network side of things is interesting. Ultimately, I think both Ethereum and Solana are designed to be just generalized and I don't think to have a particular like vertical in mind. Now I think, as I think of it, I mean, I'm skewed, right, because I like DeFi, but I've also become more interested in entities and the metaverse. And back to my original statement, I think Solana is more, this is my view, I don't know why it was, if there's, if this is true of its design, but I think that, at least for now, you are more likely to see applications that require less security, both from, especially on the user side of things, and can scale more easily.
And I think those are naturally things that have been tried in Ethereum that haven't gotten that much traction, or have gotten reasonable traction, but I think you're seeing a lot of like, I think you're seeing over a million active users in Solana. And number of transactions for users is like two, three times higher than Ethereum. Why? Because I think it's just cheaper, right? And so all that's telling me is that social NFTs, gaming applications at the moment of where the network is in terms of its security and concentration of validators, sort of you look at the like Nakamoto consensus, I think is more well suited for those types of applications.
Now over time, let's not to say that like DeFi applications, for instance, cannot, I mean, there's something like mango and a very thriving DeFi ecosystem that is being built. A lot of which has been, hey, what's working Ethereum? Let's port over to Solana and build that, right? I think DeFi is like a core backbone in any of this, I think most layer one blockchains are now realizing, hey, look, wow, DeFi is really the killer use case, at least in Ethereum, let's port that over and have all these yield incentives to attract users. My view that perhaps we should discuss at some point is this idea that DeFi protocols, when you're securing that type of value, you know, like I think TVL in Solana is actually quite small, at the moment, it's like three billion or so, and Ethereum is like 30 or something or much, much more.
And the question is, can you actually get there and will institutions and funds get comfortable, like, meaningfully staking value in the Solana ecosystem? And I don't know, it's sort of like, I think it's still TBD. My view is that it might take a little bit more time to like, battle test this network. But it's not to say that it can't get there. So, long with an answer saying, I think at the moment, you're in this curve of security, decentralization where applications that require less security are probably in our more like computation density, we're going to get more traction. But, yeah, that's all pause error.
But Good day, with your muted again. Thank you. Constantine, same question to you. Since Solana is a new suite of, you know, software, it's a new collection of softwares. How is that, how is that software collection like optimized for differently or similar to what we see on Ethereum? You know, I think like from blockchain, tried to like, like, optimize to, I mean, from one side security, from other side's colorability, from other side's decentralization. And there are, I said that like, it's a lot of pretty thick to everyone. Still to Ethereum, for example, I mean, launch would be conchained from one side security, but like, it's give a lot of chance for exchanges to be like the leaders of proof of state, for example.
It is also like, I mean, for example, so, and I think like Ethereum tried to be secure first, you know, and they're decentralized and then like scalable, you know, like by different and to move not so fast. And there, Solana doesn't have, you know, like this option to move so, so slow. I mean, like, so in a so secure way, they take a lot of maris because, you know, like, I mean, Ethereum like is a almost number one blockchain for, I don't know how much for years. So, I mean, if you don't like look on Bitcoin, for example, and Solana only launched in 2018, you know, and they try and to build the ecosystem, to build developers, to do all these things, to build the product is really difficult.
And it's not easy. That's why, you know, like when somebody, like, like, make a lot of critic to any products, I send them to build something, you know, and I think of course, Solana from one side, they won't be censorship resistance. And do they, as they do in a lot of work, I can say, yes, they've been so many validators. They spend so many funds on top of it. They spend more time on like validators than maybe any other blockchains, maybe like exactly did a good work in Cosmos. Of course, it is like some issues with that, but like Solana did a great work in, I mean, Solana to build like this validators community.
And it's not a lot of other blockchains that gives this example. But I think the main goal of, I mean, like Solana is give you scalability. It's still thinking about security and about decentralization, but the main goal to run like an application that can be composable with other applications and has one billion users. Is it a complex task? Yes, it is. Is it like a lot of different way how to build such blockchain entities? And this is like just different approach. So I'm curious about your your model for things guys. So when I think in my head about like decentralization, right, and trustlessness, first of all, it's very hard to pin down and define, right?
But it's very clear there's also like a spectrum of trustlessness, right? And decentralization. And so let's say you have on the on the far left of, you know, most decentralized smart contract chain out there, we put Ethereum, right? And then on the far right, you might have, you could call something like Coinbase, for example, or Binance or something that settles to other public chains, chains of the missiles, right? They're kind of like you single validator, I guess, ledgers, if you will, that settle on top of this open ecosystem of chains. And then if you move a little bit further right, you might get like side chains, for instance, with some sort of, you know, delegated proof of stake, you might have like Cosmos, you might have, you know, Polygon in its in its for in its current form.
And then maybe somewhere in between, you know, I can't quite make up my mind, you have like a, a Salana, which is possibly a bit more decentralized than a delegated proof of stake sort of, you know, tenderment based chain, like something in the Cosmos ecosystem, something like Terra, or not. And what I, first of all, I'm curious if this is kind of your mental model. And in also like what one, I guess, a thing I forgot to mention is we also have layer two, which is essentially I would say further, further left, closer to Ethereum, because while it has some, you know, cryptographic and economic sort of additional trust requirements, it's still using the Ethereum network ultimately for its economic security and its full security.
So it's kind of like A, is this the model, is this how you model the world in your mind? And then like B, how much decentralization is enough for something like DeFi? And Santiago, I'm curious your take on this first. I, I think your mapping is relatively how I think of it as well. And, and jumping directly to the question around DeFi is, look, I mean, I think, I think, I'm sorry, Constantine alluded to this earlier, I think if you and until I have heard him say number time, there is an implicit belief and assumption in sort of this Moore's law concept that the cost of running validators, Lana will go down, but either medical over time, which will allow for more, I guess, diversity of of the validator set.
And because right now there's what 900 coming up to 1000. And, but it's still relatively expensive, I think, to run a node. And Constantine, you, you, you can collaborate, collaborate, correct me here if I'm wrong. But, and so it begs the question, right? When you think about security, I think the security is, what is the economic cost to the taxes change? Okay. And, and, and, and I think the, simplistically, you'd say, okay, I think you need like a third or whatever to a third or two thirds, I guess, like to, to, to, to, for validators to glue and then like, you know, roll back the chain or like attack the network fine.
But I think when it comes to DeFi, so I think DeFi protocols, it's an interesting dynamic where my theory is, okay, so if you're a DeFi protocol, you have a lot of these assets, you have your own token, right? And they have all these users, right? That are using your protocol, you're maybe an AMM or a money market. But I think when you have the choice of which validators to use or like, I think it, it's sort of like, increases, I think, the cost of the, the attack, because like, you know, there are these stewards, I guess, of capital in the system that are, that are going to choose, I think, the validators.
So like, it's not as, like, we think in theoretical terms, I think, okay, what would happen if some were to buy all this equipment and then like, try to attack the network? But the reality is there is some choice in that, I think, process. Where DeFi becomes an interesting, I think, mitigator to, simply simply just saying, oh, it's going to cost X to like, get X percent half rate or X percent of validators set and just, like, collude and try to attack the network, I think, is my theory, but I'll let constant teams jump in. Yeah, what do you think constant teams? So, you know, same question. Is this the model that you see, the spectrum of decentralization?
How much decentralization is enough for DeFi? You know, it's a complex question. I mean, I can't measure, like, this decentralization of Salana on this spectrum. And there, we even don't have a lot of data to do it. I mean, if you look on our, for example, Ethereum validator set, how we can collude, how many real validators are running as a network? We can't, you know, like, I'm running as a network and don't know how. I mean, like, individual people, like, companies, like individuals, like some other parties, you know, how many professional validators are running in Ethereum, you know, and the amount is really low.
Why? Because Ethereum didn't have delegation. And as a light of it, try to find this professional validators and bring them to a validator set. Is it any one result reaches? We will be happy to give you, like, some stake. But I mean, and in case of Salana, it is also like, they have now, like, for example, 900, 980, like, validators in validator set. But is it all real people? I mean, it is difficult to understand. It's different to, like, measure. What is, you know, like, I mean, what is a really censorship resistance? Is it, like, 1,000 validators? Is it 10,000 validators? And when I speak with these guys, for example, it's Anatoli, or like, it's Dancreth from Ethereum, you know, they all push them as they say, we need 10,000 validators, you know, but is it economic enough to pay everyone, like, for the running of validators?
Is it possible to run individual, I mean, validator by the, by individual? Is it, you know, like, flash and condition? So it is, you know, like, really complex thing. And two, you know, like, and it is a, so it is a lot of things how we should measure it. And it could have more metrics. And now we don't have, so, you know, like, yeah, I even can't, like, say, like, is it, like, Ethereum, proof of stake network? Is like, for example, time, like, how much decentralized? I can't measure it, you know. If I could ask a question to Constantine, because, you know, I've been involved in Lido, and I think Lido has seen impressive growth, but there is this idea of how much Lido would be like, like, what percentage of the network should Lido have, right?
Because Ethereum is transitioning to proof of stake. And it's a, I'd be curious, because when you talk about this mapping runner, you think about decentralization for the state concept is how much is too much? Because Lido has gone incredible traction. But in, maybe if you can talk about that concept, because like, I think like, it forces to think about, like, Ethereum and so on in the context of, okay, Lido is getting all this fraction. You're, you're approving some validator sets, right? And new validators into the Lido trusted ecosystem, if you will. So, so, I think that acts as a mitigator, right?
Because you know these people, you know these operators in some capacity, you know, that they're, you know, there is always some sort of social trust in any of these networks. Now, it's not realistic to assume that you're going to, you know, world where there's like 10,000 validators, you're not going to know all of it, right? And it's sort of this permission, the system that anyone could just spin up, right? Their own infrastructure. And so the question is, to you, Constantine, as Lido expands into Sloan, I'm like, would you say that like, okay, it's a fairly like limited validator set today, but if you're a DeFi protocol or if you're a big soul holder, and you're going to choose which, which validator, then then you're going to have to like do some due diligence, you're going to have to bet that, right?
If you're a DeFi protocol and you're holding all these soul and tokens, well, like, I think that's ultimately like we forget, but I think blockings are social constructs of coordination. Like, there is always an element of, hey, I trust Constantine, because he's been running validator nodes forever. And I know his like, I know his slashing rate, I know that he's super competent operator. And there is an element that I know of him, and I know he's probably has an incentive not to attack the network or be corrupted, but that's just my sort of perspective. Yeah, you know, like we are, as Peter Tork, we are running nodes like for many years, and you know, like, it's how people choose validators.
They can't understand, it's more marketing, you know, like, or sales. It's like, I mean, users even have funds, they don't think really a lot on security. And this is an issue. And that's why, like, products like LIDAR can solve this problem, because what is the goal of LIDAR is to make happy Ethereum holders, is to extract, for example, MEV to his holders, is to keep network decentralized, is to choose like best validators. And the more competition between such actors like LIDAR, then more they will be in validators. For example, I'm picking this Anatoli and say, oh, we're going to LIDAR want to launch us on Salana.
And he say, oh, we need 10,000 validators, you know. And I say, how, you know, like, what should I do? It's impossible. And he say, let's do it, you know, let's find the way we will find some like brands, some other things. And it's complex, it's complex things. And what I try to say is that, you know, like, to make this network decentralized, you are, like, bankless, what bankless is doing, you should push people to, like, to go to LIDAR, to go to Ethereum Foundation, to go to other parties and push them, like, to make this network decentralized. It should be more politic discussion of stakeholders to push, I mean, to decentralization back to the question of Salana, you know, like, I mean, it's, it has like 980 like validators.
But I mean, like, it's more maybe decentralized than like 10 validators, so 120dators. And I mean, we still don't know how the biggest like decentralized network has, how many validators it has. But I mean, amount of validators, it's only part of decentralization. Also, it depends how like, it's come to track, architectural, this, blockchain, and all other questions. If there are so many factors that make up a decentralization, including, like, even token distribution, which we could talk about, I'm, yeah, let me maybe throw out, throw out kind of some of my experience. So, um, Konstantina, I, um, used to actually have a validating entity, validating company, um, did some work with Cosmos, was on the early Cosmos test net.
And, um, one of the things that was interesting from a, you know, observers perspective of being a validator was, you know, Cosmos, uh, had an ICO, so it had some distribution. But what would seem to happen, post the launch of the Cosmos hub, is that a lot of the state kind of collected in the hands of, of whales, and a relatively small number of validators. So, nominally, there'd be like 100 validators, right? But like, a good portion of the network, they were all in the same disc, we're all in the same channels. We knew one another, you know, like, um, it, a lot of the actual validators were former employees of like, tendermint and, uh, and Cosmos.
Uh, and it just, it just felt very, and of course it had, um, you know, governance on chain vote governance. And it felt very centralized. And I don't actually fault the Cosmos ecosystem for that, right? It's using, it's kind of, you know, delegated proof of stake type model. And, uh, to be fair, its vision is actually not to have a, a single chain that rules them all, it's to have this massive ecosystem of self sovereign chains in city states, right? Um, but this is kind of where I'm coming from when I look at Solana, right? So, we have, uh, generally a closed sale, VC sale, he had to be an accredited investor to get the tokens dominated by a bunch of, uh, VCs, but also validators who got in early on the Solana launch, right?
And many of these validators know one another. I've heard that, you know, 18 validators or so have 33% of the network. Like, it's a relatively small group of people, but, but, uh, what it doesn't have, and what I think Ethereum does have is the ability to actually run a node at home, right? Like on my comcast internet connection, I want the ability not to run a validator necessarily that I want that ability, but also to run a non validating node on Ethereum and just val, like, make sure that, uh, I'm not getting a bunch of like garbage injected in by a clueding group of validators. So to me, that's what's, what's kind of different is it's, uh, you know, coming from that perspective, um, it feels like it had a more centralized launch than something like Ethereum.
You have a small group of validators who become kind of the, you know, almost like the early banks, right? This is, like, they control sort of the, the ledger. It's a smaller consortium, smaller group of people. And then the average user doesn't necessarily have the ability to, to run their own node to, to, to clinch it off. And so with Santiago, you were saying earlier about, hey, some of this stuff, uh, decentralized is over time. Actually, I partially agree because I think token distribution decentralized is over time. But when you construct a network that, um, requires such massive like bandwidth and like, uh, you know, state growth is a problem.
It's a problem for Ethereum, for instance, right? I worry that Ethereum is going to become more, uh, centralized over time. And because state is like state growth issues remain unresolved. So I'm curious your perspective on some of this. Maybe we'll just start with like the ability to run a node at home. How important is this for the decentralization of an, of the network, Constantine? Yeah. So, or, you know, like you tell so many equations and I even try, sorry, I remember your product, you know, like back in Cosmos ecosystem, you had like a beautiful website. This is a good for, for big fishes, you know, like I remember this are, uh, like mythos, right?
Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So I, I, I, I, I, you were one of the first who, you know, start to work in Cosmos ecosystem made a website. I mean, before everyone else and start to reach people, you know, and I saw on your website try to copy some like pieces and they're trying to do the same. And I agree with you that like Cosmos ecosystem, for example, I don't remember how talking holders they have, for example, three cells, yes, but are, uh, I mean, the distribution was, I mean, pretty centralized. But you know, I, I, I, I agree with the opinions that the more utilities and better distribution, if we look back in Ethereum, it was only 10,000 people who participated in crowd sale.
For example, I participated two times. So maybe like it was, I don't know, I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm, congratulations. Couple, couple of elections. Yes. But I try to say that it's difficult to, uh, understand, uh, the real, I mean, like, uh, decentralization of state, but we know that Ethereum has like traction. It has a lot of users and the distribution happened during this time. People sold tokens or like something happened the same. I think it's here than more like utility for the network than more, uh, network will be decentralized in the long term. And also, uh, about the running, uh, like the equipment and home, I ask my team, you know, like the upstream, how much that's equipment, uh, I mean, is the price of this equipment?
I, it can be like the prices until be like from five to 20,000, like for the eight, once the top. And you can run it at home. For now, I mean, it's not so many transactions. Salana, when the state will grow, when they're like, uh, I mean, uh, amount of transaction will grow. You need more, for example, like, uh, like a video card, but still the same with mining, you have like, I don't know, small, uh, like container of some is like a lot of different mining equipment. So can you like run it at home? I think yes. Uh, the question is, like, would be like the best, like performed note, I don't think because you need to have a team around it.
Uh, I mean, uh, but if you add devops, you can like buy it. And I also, you know, like this equipment is cheap and cheaper, like, every like two years, the price is going down. So that's why you know, like if you speak about YouTube in 2000, everybody tell you that, I mean, it's impossible to, that somebody will, for example, have a YouTuber and nobody will would invest in a YouTube and 1000. The same with Zul or Skype, for example, Anderson and Horowitz, you know, when they start to work on browser, one of the first idea was to make like calls between each other, but it was impossible. And what I tried to say is that, you know, like, I mean, uh, the, the price of hardware will drop down.
And for example, you already like on, uh, I think like, uh, on a PlayStation has one petabyte of like, uh, yes, SSD. And you have some other, uh, like metrics. So I, in my point of you, if you want to run an out, you need to have some delegation in stake, uh, and you can do it in Salona too. And also, yeah, from a practical perspective, like, I'm, I'm just curious, because I do think this is a fundamental trademark trade, trade off that Salona makes, right? So like, uh, we can run an ETH2 validator and we do, uh, on a Raspberry Pi at home, home internet connection, basically, right? Um, you know, uh, solutions like rocket pool, do things like, you know, decentralized, I know Lido's moving to a more decentralized model too, but the average user can run it at home.
I couldn't do that necessarily with, um, my Cosmos validator note. I mean, that did require a bit more DevOps, but it was possible. Maybe, right? Salona, I worry that like, from a practical perspective, maybe like a hypothetical, yes, somebody one guy could figure out the DevOps and like run this thing from home. He's got, you know, high super high speed internet, but it's not part of the culture. And maybe that's a trade off that is made. It's basically like, hey, we're going to have lots of, uh, validating nodes and other nodes throughout the world. They're all going to be on AWS and they're all going to be in data centers and various locations.
And that's okay. That's the point at which Salona is on the spectrum of decentralization, but it has not prioritized the ability to like, for a regular person to run a node and read right to the Ethereum chain. Is this kind of a fundamental tradeoff? Because this is part of the challenge. I went, when I have Salona, you know, discussions with people, I always feel like we can't get to like the bottom line of, okay, there are some trade-offs that are being made between, uh, Ethereum and Salona. It's like, what are they? If this is one, cool, I understand. Now we understand the trade-off. Now we can have an argument of whether that's good or not.
But is that the trade-off do you think constant in the inability to run a node as an individual user? Yeah. All right. How many for your friends? You like know a lot of people in Ethereum community. And maybe like it's a critic, you know, but we need to like speak more openly about it. How many of them are in Ethereum node? Really like, I mean, validation node. And for example, I would be really, because of the slashing, because of the other risk, I would really, I mean, worry to run it by myself, because I'm not so technical, I can't run it. Or I would use a special software that can, you know, like, damage my node.
And I would be not really sure that it will work in a way, in a secure way. So how many people do you know, like, who is running Ethereum node at home? I think the answer to that question misses the point. And it's not the wrong point. But the option to run a node is extremely important. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And so you can run like Solana node at home, I think. I don't see like, I mean, I know people, there's the most people. They have a like VPN inside that home, you know, like, they have like a server that come and they're running the VPNs and some other things. Is it possible right now?
I think it is. But there, what you need to be like to do some research to spend some time. And you will stop it. I see it home. Santiago, let's retake all this so far. I think yeah, like, look, I think the Solana foundation would tell you, it is hard to run a node today. It is. It's just a more expensive, it requires more technical expertise. The hope is that and and and it totally says it's a technological problem, not a computer size problem. It's an engineering problem, not a computer. I've heard him say this a number of times. And I think he's right. I mean, ultimately, you are banking on this idea, like our weave is, for instance, the cost of running a node will will collapse every time.
This sort of Moore's law construct of, hey, it's going to become cheaper, easier. You're going to abstract away some of the complexity for anyone to run a node. And maybe that's what opens up a lot of these use cases that we talk about where it really, you know, as I said earlier, it might just open up and Solana can become visa might choose to settle USDC on Solana, but it chose Ethereum. So is it too late at that point? Maybe, maybe not, I don't know, but I do agree, like from a design perspective, at this moment in time, I think we can all agree that it's harder to run a node on Solana. And I think the Solana team will tell you, yes, and they're focused on that.
And that's the challenge, right? So then, I think it moves on to the second part of the question, I think Constance is moving to is, then social trust and diligence becomes very important. The social layer of these networks and the culture becomes more and more important, I think earlier on. Earlier in the stage, I think there's a transition of trust and sort of security in decentralization. Right now, I would say there is a lot of trust in Solana that you need to be trusting these validators that, as you say, Ryan, I don't know if they all potentially could collude. Well, I think like just to pose another question is like, how much do you trust in Pyro and Joe Lubin and the consensus team?
And you know, there is concentration. There will always be concentration in the same way that, like, if you look at political systems, it is unrealistic to assume that everyone is going to run a node in their home. This is like agree on that because it's not going to happen, I think. We can probably make it easier for people and try to layer in some incentives. But I think people ultimately just delegate and want to use trusted delegators. And those concepts seem to say, there needs to be more talk and more discussion across networks, not just Solana, but also Ethereum. And also we talked about a big point, like where's Hashtray?
It's all in China, right? Well, let's talk about that. And let's figure out ways to mitigate that, not like brush over these things. And I think it becomes important to do, for instance, tooling and educational resource to say, hey, this is a track record of this validator. And this is where it's based, these people, maybe there's a blue check mark that says, these are whatever someone's like validating, or like a testing to the legitimacy of this validator or something like that, right? Ryan, if you're running a mythos, well, hey, like someone can vouch for you. And then there's an implicit social layer, I think, on top of this consensus, that that creates, I mean, this is sort of the idea of slashing, right?
But you can potentially maybe include a reputation layer built on top of that, that becomes interesting because I don't think you solve it as easily for any network. I think you're always, there will always be a gravitational pull towards some concentration. The question is how hard, I think it's Solana, it's easier to go towards that extreme that you're talking about, Ryan, where it's just by design at the moment, it's easier to go to a state where it can become uncomfortable for financial institutions and large people to settle value, like meaningful values that work. This is kind of what I like what I worry about.
And like back to David's point, just because many people don't run nodes at home, you know, it's kind of like, I mean, many people don't vote in their democratic elections, right? Particularly their local ones, right? And so should we say at the protocol level, well, hey, we only get like 25% shown up to these elections. Let's just stop elections. Be way more efficient if we just had some, you know, central leaders who could make the decision in this jurisdiction, this area. It's like, well, no, because it's important to have the option to vote in these elections. And I think that's important for the most decentralized base layer, settlement layer, DeFi protocol to preserve.
And I think Ethereum preserves that. And that's kind of my question about Solana. Maybe this is why I would say, like, I think we're all on the same page that Solana plus Ethereum is like pie expanding, and it's great for the space. And it's great. It's great for Ethereum. It's also great for Solana. So like, I don't ever want to couch it as like this versus that. But I do want to fight and make sure we preserve these values of decentralization that the entire crypto movement is based on the ability to opt out of the existing system. I don't want to have us at the protocol layer, the deepest layer of this whole financial stack, some kind of a centralized lock-in.
And maybe the Constantine's point, hey, it's like, look, man, this is all going to centralize anyway. And people aren't going to run raspberry pies through their home. And like, if that's the case, then man, you know, that would be sad. We will have lost something in crypto. And then I kind of go existential and like, what the hell was the point of the whole thing? You know? And so yeah, I mean, the users get about decentralization. No, but okay, like, let me offer you other data points on the networks that I was running validator. So like, it's a Tezos, for instance, if you were one of the early bakers, which is the validators, you were gone.
Like, to your point, if you were on top three, like, you would, it was more at that point, a marketing effort and BD. And it was practically impossible, because I would be offering like 10%, 5%, like, take rate on the, on the reward. And you got to go find whales, don't you? I mean, I played this. Exactly. It was, it was an incredibly hard to convince people to undelicate and re-delegate. And they were paying 40% to a validator. And it's wild. And I said, economically, rationally speaking, you would say, these people would switch. And they didn't, right? It's hard, right? People are lazy or what have you, when it comes to money, you've really switched your bank account.
And I think that dynamic for me, Tezos, was interesting to observe. Now, of course, you could undelicate. And you, I think that kept like, the validators honest in what they were voting for. And you could, you know, there was a process to undelicate in a cycle and what have you. And so, okay, that's fine. The optionality is super important, right? I definitely agree. But look at, look at cosmos too. I mean, you have to have a certain amount of delegated atoms to even be a valedict. Now, like to your point, a lot of that was an early advantage from a lot of employees from Tendermy who who who cleaned up.
I mean, it was just easy for them to do that, right? And it was an unfair advantage. I didn't like that. I didn't agree with that. So I agree. I said, you know what? I don't believe in that. Even though Tendermy as a protocol, I think is pretty interesting. But I didn't like that dynamic of the validator set. And I thought it's a big kind of, it's a challenge, I think, for a newcomer, at least in some of these systems, just to get reasonable validation. This is difficult. So it's also a sales effort and a BD effort. I think Tera is doing something interesting, actually, where obviously like there's more apps being built in the Tera ecosystem, which has been pretty impressive to see.
And what they're doing is the air drops that some of these protocols are issuing and the Tera, the Tera foundation, I think is layering in rewards to incentivize users to delegate to smaller validators in the set. And this is what I was going at. I think like this could be an incentives design where if you're the foundation, heck if you're the Solana foundation, let's just agree that that's sort of like the more neutral party that has a really strong incentive not to like for the network to be secure, the same way that the Ethereum foundation and consensus did it early on. And the Tera guys are doing it.
Well, let's just like create incentives to stimulate a very more vibrant validator set. And incentivize users to delegate to the small guy, or to even subsidize part of the hardware. I don't know if this would be practically possible with Solana, but this is an idea that I've had, which is Tera is doing it. And I found it interesting because even as sort of as a fond or what have you, I was like, okay, this is interesting. I'm just going to re-un-delegate from the large guy and try to re-led delegate to maybe the guy that's on top 10 or top 20 and has never has been slashed or what have you never skipped the block.
Yeah, I just want to add something you know, like I don't try to say that, I mean, I am happy that like Ethereum can run like on Raspberry Pi. I just try to say to look like, and I think it's one of the most important things, you know, that you can launch a node in any place and to run it, you know, but I just try to say, I mean to look on reality, you know, like to discuss it, to push it, you know, we need more discussion. For example, now to run a Ethereum node, you need like 42 is, how much is it? No, how much 30 is right now? It's like $120,000. Is it a lot? Is it like expensive? Is it, I mean, I mean, how much could it be?
Well, Raspberry Pi is cheap, but like this take is expensive. So I mean, it is a lot of things that we need to push and I'm 100% agree that it should be available to run anyone and not at home. This is definitely, I mean, the right to blog, I was at the blog change should give you. I do want to make one quick distinction, like 32 eth to run a validating node, right? But like, you could run a non validating node at home, which is, which is important, which is also essential, so that an individual can read and write to the blockchain without going through any third parties. But I've talked so much, David, I want to get, you get a question in here.
Well, I do want to move on to other subjects, but I first want to maybe hopefully wrap up this conversation with this, with this question. And I'll put on my skeptical eith maxi hat and say that Ethereum as a consensus system is built to be neutral to allow any sort of expression of alternative systems to be built on top of Ethereum. That's kind of its goal, maximally simple layer one blockchain to allow layer two's to be however they want to be. And so my skeptic hat is saying why didn't Solana get what it wanted to get out of like a more scalable platform as a layer two to Ethereum? And my malicious skeptical hat will say, well, if you deploy as a layer two to Ethereum, Solana wouldn't be able to do like a VC presale race and enrich a lot of many early founders.
Like they wouldn't be able to hype themselves up as a as a layer two in the same way that they would be able to hype themselves up as a scalable layer one. And so they perhaps chose the layer one path rather than a layer two on Ethereum with a money motivation, right? And to me that like taints the incentives of the bootstrapping the genesis of this ecosystem. So that's my skeptical Ethereum maxi hat. Why is that wrong? Constantine, I saw you shake your head. Why is that wrong? Yeah, yeah, you know, like you know, how much are like the sell to solution now raising obviously money? Do you know the valuation?
I think I've just said a 1.2 billion dollar one, right? Yeah, much bigger than like only one solution. So any like that one to build. Well, so the question still stands like, why why build a layer one instead of a layer two? Yeah, so the question is the same. Yeah, so I mean, like a layer two solution still has some, I mean, like a cost, you know, like to run on Ethereum, it has some restrictions. It's not so, I mean, it's dependent on what you can do in Ethereum too. So you need like if it's like roll up, for example, then you need to have an ability to like, I mean, to execute it on a Ethereum, it's something happened.
And this is like price. This is like user experience. It is like some issues that go in with like auto solution. And there, you know, like it is a lot of people who have own vision of of a solution. And it's good, you know, like it's a big thing. And they have it. Why they can build on way how they think like this layer one should work. And about like this VC money, I mean, what we see is doing is usually allocated capital and not all of them, but you know, I am allocated capital and many blockchains. And we allocated capital. It was a small capital. It was my pocket money allocated in Ethereum.
And it was a big thing for me, you know, I'm a boy from Calingert, you know, like I don't think that you know where is Calingert. But I mean, I just want to say that like Ethereum, you made this chance, you know, like to do it. Salana didn't give a chance. They didn't like give a chance. I mean to everyone to invest, but not because they don't want to do it, because the market changed. It was impossible to make I saw in 2018, not because you didn't raise capital, but because it was securities. They're based in the US guys. And it's a reality, you know, and as they did their rates, I think by 40 cents and something like that by quenlist and a lot of people can participate in it.
So, but it's not a lot of people participate. So, they have, they give an option to everyone coming. So, I mean, to like answer this question, that I am, you know, like for broader ecosystem, the more solution we have, the more competition we have. Do you remember like how slow Ethereum development was three, four years? Now, Ethereum community is much stronger. It's better. Why? Because it is like some competition on the market. It's good for us, you know, it's good for Ethereum believers, that it is some strong people like building something else. And it's pushed Ethereum also forward. And I think it's good.
Tim, Sasha, do you want to add anything upon that? Yeah, look back your question, David. I think that there is, there may have been some motivation to, and look, we've seen that in ICOs, right? People realize that you, you belly around and there's, there's much more sort of the idea why employees leave Google to, to go start their own. There's more upside. So, so there may have been some of that. I think it goes back to the very, very first question, which is, I think they, and it totally had a vision for a different architecture design to a blockchain. And Vitalik has been talking about scaling in Ethereum since they won.
It's been an issue in everyone's minds. And I'm not totally, I think from his perspective, had a different way of constructing a blockchain. Credibly, like it's not like BSE, your point, David, you were the one that brought it up. It's not avalanches. It feels more unique in its architecture and in its design that is refreshing. Because we don't really know, like, I don't think we have perfect answers to how these systems will work. I think it's very early. We can try to think about this stuff and look how much has roadmap of Ethereum changed over time. And I think, you know, to me, that's instructive.
We don't know. This is why this space is so exciting. It has a lot of technological challenges and social challenges that haven't been resolved. But it's fascinating. This is why the smartest people will keep coming to this space because people love working on difficult problems. And so the other point that I want to make is I think adding to that, whether you build an L2, like Arbitram or Optimism, you're still sort of beholden to L1. And what happens at the L1, right? And so, so like, to be fair, if you really want to break from this architectural system that is Ethereum, then you have to you have to break and you have to make a different system.
Now, my thesis is it will be a multi-chain world, and there will be a lot of connectivity between these platforms. Now, yeah, we've talked about composability and all this sort of stuff. But by and large, I think we can all agree here that it is win-win in many ways, where there might be huge gaming applications in Solana and social applications in Solana, and then there'd be a much thriving, evolved, developed, secure system of DeFi and Ethereum. And let's talk about that. Let's understand the connectivity of these chains because I think it will happen. I think it's unrealistic to assume that one change will rule them off.
I think, you know, it is net positive to see flow even though people have terrible experiences there and realize very quickly that sometimes, sometimes, decentralization does matter. It's sort of like flooding trends. When shit hits the fan, you're like, oh, okay, I should have on insurance. But people realize until they want to withdraw and stuff. But by and large, I mean, it's bringing on how many users have NFTs brought to Web 3. And look, the idea is even even Libra coined, not to get too off topic, but even Libra, I was slightly positive on because I said, okay, well, you have two billion people that are all just going to wake up in the wall and say, what the hell is this?
And then they say, okay, I want to earn money. And what else can I do with this? And I think that's what I'm more excited about. It's perhaps more practical approach. But, you know, I think, I think, is Solana an L2 to Ethereum? Maybe is so, or maybe possibly, right? You just put a nice bridge. And it's, it's our problem. These bridges, but I think someone will crack that back. Yeah. Can I add the one point here? So, for example, I also invested like, in a bit from like some other projects, I should disclosure it. And I will be a political editor. Yeah. So I also like, I'm a good friend of like, Alex, who is building the cat sink.
And it's amazing software. And I hope that it will be successful. But it's a little bit different, you know, like, it's still, I mean, to launch it to, I mean, to bring ecosystem, it's still really complex. And there are, I also like, I had a team that is working on EVM for Solana. And, you know, like, it's EVM, just a program inside Solana. And my vision was, I like, I like, I like, it capital to, you know, to build the roll up. It's called neon labs, you know, like, it's like, to build the roll up from Ethereum to Solana, you know, like to execute Ethereum, EVM, but use Ethereum, like, security and Scala Solana's collability.
So my goal, you know, like, it should be all interpretable. It should be all like, like, tied together and use the best features of everyone. Yeah. I think we're in full agreement about kind of like a, you know, a multi-chain world, right? Whether that's like, you know, we already are at a multi-chain world, which is what I say when people ask that. It's like, it's like, look, Binance and Coinbase. These are all additional chains. These are side chains, right? Like, and they said all these public networks. Let me ask you another question. This kind of weaves in maybe Seoul as an asset, as a token and kind of the valuation of it.
So another thing that's kind of trip me up in evaluating Solana in the past is this, this pie chart and the far right, which is distribution of Solana. And I think Constantine, you made the point earlier, like, okay, for folks that can't see this, by the way, 48% of Solana distribution, according to a Missouri analyst report, was allocated to insiders, credit investors in the US. This is the initial sale of Solana. So this doesn't account for how it's distributed since that sale versus Ethereum, you know, 15%. Right? So we had more concentration at the very early stages of Solana, which kind of lends in the, in sort of the crypto native crowd to people calling Solana kind of a VC chain, if you will, right?
Not as not birthed by the community, like something like an immaculate conception of Bitcoin, or because Ethereum was the first ICO and it was kind of publicly available and it, you know, it got through that gateway and issued publicly, like, it has kind of a special story about its issuance. Solana was birthed just like any other kind of Silicon Valley VC project. And by the way, not their fault, right? We understand the financial prison that we live in in the US, for those of us who are listening from the US, that prohibit some of these, you know, ICOs and crowd offerings and this sort of thing.
My question is, how does this affect the trajectory of the network, though? We've had this ongoing conversation about monetary assets in crypto, right? This conversation of is Bitcoin money, is it a story value, this conversation, eth as money, is a story value, is a pristine collateral, but as something that is used as a unit of exchange and meaning of the account. Now, we have Solana, which is less distributed from Genesis. Does that mean it takes a different path? Do you think? Does this affect the effect that decentralization of it? There's no proof of work, a period of time where it's distributing.
It's kind of going back to the validators and the owners. So what are your thoughts on that and our, our, our souls essentially competing as money? Santiago, let's go to you first. Yeah, I want to make one point, which is if you look at the blue shade in this chart, the you pulled up, I think the, it's a little tricky, right? Because there was no VC allocation in Ethereum, although there were some very, very large Ethereum holders that participate in the ICO that had the new each other that collectively owned a big big stack. I think insiders, like, is a little bit misleading because there were large whales in the Ethereum ecosystem, just to be fair, that collectively owned a big big triangle on network.
And over time, I think what was perhaps one of the best things that came out of the 2017 ICO boom was that people were spending their eith and that led to reorganization and further distribution of eith across many, many hands. But it's a little tricky, but like, I'll take the point, right? I mean, is, is Solana VC coin? And what is that? What are the implications of that? Because every other network, you know, to your point, Ethereum was the macro conception of what an ICO was and it was, oh, shit, we can't do this. And so we're forced to work within a construct and it's very difficult. It kind of is a dialogue we should have regularly.
It was like, what are we designing here? Because what are the side effects of this uncertainty? But anyways, I think a couple of things, right? If it centralized, I mean, I think Solana, one of the things that I've been thinking about is how quickly can a network involve and adapt? For a long time, it felt like Ethereum was sort of gridlock and it was very difficult to get shit moving. It was difficult also to fund development. If you were a whale, if you were a protocol, it was somewhat difficult. It's like, who should I get money to? Okay, Jill Luebin's fun of consensus, which looked a lot of really good projects came out of that.
And I think, look, Kudos to that. And I think the Ethereum community and protocols come a long way as a result of that. But it was difficult, right? I wonder for many, many years, like, okay, if you're a DeFi protocol, how do you give back to Ethereum? Because I was like, how many actual developers are thinking about each two-scaling solutions? And what if I wanted to give grants to that and have some say in that decision-making process? And it was difficult, and I guess there were competing designs. And look, I agree with Constantine. I think the pace of development and Ethereum, maybe it was DeFi that put pressure on the network.
It's like, all right, we've got to figure our stuff out quickly, or a combination of that, DeFi taking off, a killer use case, and then other protocols launch. I think it's healthy competition goes a long way. I think Solana, again, is that state and other networks are more centralized. And that allows for certain changes in the protocol to be, they're more agile. Now, you may agree if that's good or not. I think some design trade-offs and changes in Solana and decisions have been made in a fairly swift manner by a few insiders. That, you know, you have a community call and what have you, but at the end of a day, you know, you can credibly vote certain stuff amongst a few people.
I think that's still the state of the world for some of these networks, including Solana, and Infinity, and maybe Filecoin, and we're like, you know, a few funds and large holders in including the team, unless the team is abstaining can pass this stuff. But ultimately, like, I'll give you my more practical answer to all of this is the beauty of a blockchain is it's this hyper competitive world of open source. So if you want to do dumb stuff and you want to do stuff that destroys value and is short-sighted or near-sighted, people are just going to go to another blockchain. And that's a beauty of competition, right?
It just keeps people more accountable. If you're, we tend to think about like a concentration is bad, right? If you're Apple, if you're some random went-to company, yeah, like people can just vote the stuff for proxy vote and whatever. And no one there's no accountability, there's no transparency, but you just suppose that it worked through world, which is open source, ruthlessly competitive, and the cost of copies barely nothing. So like, I think protocols, whether they're apps like DeFi protocols or layer ones, are always beholden to, hey, we start doing stuff that pisses off the community as small as it may be, then we're not going to go far.
And so even if you had even more so, right, if you have a big, big stake in a network and you're a VC and you're a team, why would you just throw a value? And you're being held accountable in real time because it's open and transparent. And that, I think, is the biggest, it's sort of like the Heisenberg principle. People are observing you in real time, being super critical of what you're doing because everything is publicly visible and immutable. And if there's a digital footprint of everything that is being done in these networks. And I think that while concentration is, I'm not agreeing or not saying that is good or bad, I'm just saying concentration, you should decentralize over time.
Yes, sometimes being more centralized can help in agile development and making decisions. But at the end of the day, blockings are coordination tools. And the community is the layer zero of all of these networks. And if you don't listen to the community, even though they might have a smaller stake, you're done. You're not going to, it's sort of the fastest way to be irrelevant and and die in this ecosystem. What about that second question that was woven in there, which is about having a monetary premium? Do you think, does that factor into your analysis of of the valuation of souls, right? Like right now, it's interesting because like, you know, the framework where we see things like Bitcoin is, you know, it's primarily store value.
Ethereum, it's like you got capital asset, we got cash flows. We also have a commodity being used as gas. And we also have it being a store of value. So this monetary premium, do you think a salana is valued in the same way that Ethereum and Ether is valued? Or do you think there's a different valuation lens through which or do you think like sometimes people like me tend to overanalyze all of this? And it's like who the market doesn't care. It's just kind of a narrative. And so however this plays out in the long run, the short run, it's just going to be valued based on the way Ethereum is valued.
It's a great question, right? Because I come from a fundamental background, much like you and I like Ethereum, especially now the IP 1559. I don't think, by the way, I don't think most people appreciate the full extent of the IP 1559. I think most people are just like constantly focused on NFTs and I think those, but like, I don't think the full, okay, I don't think the entire market is woken up to the idea of how transformational the IP 1559 is to it here. Like let's just start with there. I think the market, because it's so early, we can't even agree on valuation methodologies for crypto. I mean, it took 40, 50 years of traditional, in traditional markets for Benjamin Graham and like, in valuation methodologies of P ratio and valuing it off of EBITDA and recurring revenue.
These things take time. I think it requires like banks to like put out like equity research reports or like, you know, folks like us that like are tweeting, oh look, you know, some of these like protocols are trading at the stress multiples and they have all this cash flow and people are like, oh no, I'd rather ape into like some random protocols on the track. Like, this is how we're rashing with this market is like, this why I don't short this market. So I don't really know how people are valuing these networks at times. I can, I think it with a theorem, it's easier for me to understand the value proposition of what E is as a substrate in the system and seeing all the activity.
And I think in a similar manner, my framework first line is not through to similar bacteria, which is the upsole, you're going to consume soul, maybe less. But it's sort of like how the things that I rest on, like where I get conviction on is what I said earlier, which is number of developers, which is now up to a thousand in Solana. How easy is it to build? What are the applications being built as a proxy for how big can this never get? The number of transactions and settlement. And putting aside, hey, listen to assume that like this number is not going to be attacked and all this stuff like that.
This stuff can be figured out. But you discount, by the way, you discount the valuation of Solana at this stage based on these risks that we've discussed in this call. Whereas the theorem is far too long in that. You know, when London was announced, and EIP59 was also agreed upon by the by the miners, I'm like, all right, well, to me, that was a very clear motivator of an in chains of dynamic apology, look at it here, in a very meaningful way. And I can tell you other large players in the market that were hadn't any exposure to ETH also were very, very observant of this dynamic. Because for a long time, it's only been Bitcoin.
This monetary premium you talk about, Ryan, has only been Bitcoin. And so, oh, you know, it's like, how many Bitcoin maxes are like, oh, let's see, let's see, let's see, supply with the area. And it's just like they would always go to that and it would be like the most dumb like argument that you could ever make. But lo and behold, you know, people listen to that. And then you have an network that is burning. And then you're saying, oh, wow, it's a settlement layer of the internet. Oh, wow, all these transactions. Oh, there's a very clear way to Matthew of this network. So anyways, very long in response.
My framework for Solana is somewhat similar, very similar to Ethereum. Does it have a monetary premium today? TVD. Constantine, do you want to touch on these subjects? Yeah, you know, like, I mean, you also should understand that it is a discussion, you know, like if we like say that Ethereum and Solana children, so Ethereum is seven years children, you know, like and Solane is three years, you know, as a different, yes, of course, like they have different problems on different levels. In case of, I mean, back in 2014, when we most thought about like, how, what is their value of the blockchain?
What is their, I mean, talking value, what how we can compare it, you know, like, and we like tried to be compared like Ethereum, for example, with the country, you know, like, and where you put micro economy and macro economy. And there are the more transactions inside, the more companies inside, you know, like the centralized applications, the more activities there are, the more values there are, the more you can extract, you know, in case of burning. The same, I think, is with Solana, you know, like if you have a developer inside, if you have applications times, they make transactions, then they can do transaction with Ethereum, for example, cross chain and macro economy.
I happened, you know, like, the more value for, and the more narrative to use, I don't know, like Bitcoin, Ethereum, or like Solana as a currency, but you still will look on numbers, you know, like you still will look how activity inside, how many like assets locked, for example. So, and this system is much more transparent than current system. And that's why we are here, you know, that's why I love, like, all these projects, you know, that's why I love to spend time on it. And they're, yeah, so I think like any product that will have real activity, not just transaction, you know, for, I don't know, like, validation, or for something that has real people inside, real products, they will find their own value, and they will have find own value proposition, and they will have an extra, you know, like, and maybe like, can be used by as money.
And you know, like, I believe, like, East as money, and big funds already invest in East as money, and like, for example, all, why they're like, except only East as money, because you know, like, it's a really good case, and good example. I appreciate that perspective. And I want to, as we come to a close on this panel, and I appreciate all of you guys' times and going a little bit over. So, I'll ask this one quickly. Ryan and I are often criticised as being East Maxis. Ryan will definitely say that he's not an East Maxi. Definitely not, David. Definitely not. And I would also like to reframe, like, what I am maximalist in is developer activity.
And if we are talking about smart contract platforms, which I do believe is where this industry goes, I will be a maximalist about whatever the developers are a maximalist about. And so if one specific system has like 99% mine share in developer activity, then I am 99% of maximalist in that thing. And so what it would take for me to become really, really bullish about Solana is seeing a developer ecosystem grow around Solana, but also things that the developers are building on Solana being built there first rather than being built on Ethereum, right? Because like, we are seeing a bunch of like copycat NFT projects, like now we have Solana punks and we now we got Solana squiggles.
Like, what are you really doing here? And so like, my question to you guys is, what are you excited about that's coming to Solana that you might think will come to Solana first before it comes to Ethereum? Santiago, you want to start? That's a great question, David. I think you will see perhaps more complex, computationally intensive DeFi primitives like option protocols and perks that have been struggling in Ethereum. I think like Mango or Synthetify, you'll get just a number of users of some of these protocols more complicated, especially option protocols, haven't truly taken off in DeFi and Ethereum.
And I think it's allowed you because it's expensive to update the repression. So I think that's one that comes to mind. The other one is gaming, something like Star Atlas or I think some of those applications may be social as well. Those would be my top three kind of use cases that I think may may garner like more attention. I'm seeing like from a use case perspective in the developer composition, to me it was interesting to learn that a lot of these developers are like new folks that don't know solidity and just enter entering the space. There's a few of been like rage quit Ethereum because it's like I'm done.
There's a couple of examples but it's mostly been like folks. So like I think Solana has a big office in Chicago. Chicago is a very very like trader focused like market and there's a lot of folks like Sam was it jump and you know pretty tech sorry it was the Jane street and so or jump and some of these shops that you know they're like financial guys but they're also quants they're developers so like I think you'll see more and more developers in that arena and so naturally because they're coming from that field they're going to probably want to build more complex DeFi primitives on Solana. So so that's what I'm keeping an eye on.
Constantine same question to you. What do you think? What's the developer environment on Solana going to be like and what do you think are what are you excited about coming first to the Solana ecosystem? Yeah first of all I want to say it's a little there's a lot of problems inside Solana you know we just tell a lot of good things but I mean it's still I mean early days it wasn't a lot of hacks so we don't have any like attacks and don't know what we can what can happen. It is not a lot of auditing companies. I mean it's a big market so like maybe somebody like will build an audit company for Solana and it is really difficult to like develop application right now because it's not so many examples good examples and you know like it's a beginning and I mean to launch like not even product is really complex and but I mean I think I think like with like more experiments is more tooling it will be easy and more easy you know and I'm a reviewer I mean Santiago about the use cases about financial use cases about deflinable games so where you want to for example to I mean to use to make like like application with chip transactions and I mean try to you know like to do it right now so some of them will try to build on Solana but for now which we understand that it's more complex and build it on salinity but uh so I mean given I'm also have a lot of own issues you know like sort of Solana is multi-threaded so it's quite a lot of lies it's also it's you know like because a lot of unique features guys this has been a fantastic discussion I know you know David said he's kind of a developer maximalist I would say like for myself I'm a I'm a I'm a bankless maximalist so I carry I carry very much that you don't create a new financial system that is owned by a new class of bankers that just take it over like our existing financial system and I actually think some diversity in experimentation is good and I do think Solana provides us that for sure and look guys it's just great having a a rational conversation like a neutral conversation about this topic because crypto is so tribal sometimes and it's hard to separate the signal from that that noise of you know tribalness that that goes on so we definitely appreciate you guys joining and and thanks I guess maybe my last question for each of you as we close is this how do you think that Solana and Ethereum can live together in in harmony in the future like how do you think this is going to to really work out for both of them moving forward Santiago let's go with you David's laughing in my question but let's do that yeah um uh I think you there will be coexistence so let me just agree with that now I think the way may look thinking probabilistically is um kind of like we chat has developed in China because they totally lead for our financial infrastructure so it started with a social app messaging and then they built a suite of products around that and and then you combine that with like the sort of aggregation theory that I think this space will will really kind of go towards because right now we're all beta testers it's like it's like a speck of dust like a number of users really get paid to like experiment with this stuff that has still a lot of risk in Ethereum and Bitcoin everywhere um but like you know just give an example um maybe a lot Solana is just an onboarding funnel a big one or that you have like things like star atlas and games and social applications and then you might just click a button and say oh I want to earn yield on this or or swap my my endgame items and then that might get settled in Ethereum depending on whoever you're using uh the end user may not even know or care which blockchain to get settled on it just by default will get settled on Ethereum let me tell you why because when let's just assume that 95% of users don't interact directly with later one they don't even know maybe they're interacting with the blockchain but large financial institutions may say PayPal or Visa or JP Morgan or whatever and I think at the moment uh security is the thing that most people say hey the users care about these centralization I think they may not even care about the centralization I think Binance marching kind of told us that in a very clear way at least so if we assume that most users may not value the centralization as much they might value utility so again they might be starting Solana they might swap or use some sort of financial function which you're going to be using Ethereum maybe potentially why because you're aggregator maybe the JP Morgan or the game that you're using will route to Ethereum because it's safer or because they perceive it to be safer and then security gets more liquidity which improves the set like the slippage on the trade and so I think that's like the state of the world that I'm excited about which I think Ethereum has a mode in DeFi which is it's the most secure chain today so if you're an institution like Visa or PayPal you're going to use Ethereum and so more liquidity because security because more liquidity and so it's that virtuous flywheel that is just going to be more efficient to trade on Ethereum inside and your your aggregator your financial institution your app whatever you're using may just decide to route it to Ethereum because it's this just easier to do so that that's probably now technically I'm not in a position to like comment on on the feasibility of that but I am actively kind of thinking about bridges and how that might work so yeah I think that's how it probably you know worry to have millions of users in Solana which are going to require doing other things other than playing and some of those some of that in that journey they're going to use Ethereum on since what's your take on this how do these chains coexist live in harmony how does this play out over the next few years well thank you for the discussion I mean yeah it's a great that we discuss all these things and they're openly and they're I think we should take more both the problems and they're you know like who are like this Solana in Ethereum it's like we are like we as a community we are people who is doing it discussing in right now who is pushing it like in some direction and what we need like we should keep this blockchain this centralized together Solana like Ethereum like to less all validators of Ethereum lands around Solana and Solana validators around Ethereum nodes you know like and it will be already big things and we have what we are building you know we are building like internet or value and it will be bad if it will be built on only one blockchain you know because it is also a risk it will be good if it will be a lot of different layers and it will be more secure I think was that collaborating together to you know like I mean to give every one on the planet like to make a transaction without like permissionless and not censored and our goal as a community like of this like blockchain is you know like to like speak more about it to push this blockchain keep them to be decentralized you know and this is important you know like so what we can do what like Solana and Ethereum we should like work together on and bring our values I mean to our community and they're tried to keep the blockchain decentralized and work together to attract more like billion people here and give them this values absolutely those values are the layer zero of this entire crypto space Santiago Constantine it's been fantastic to have you thanks for walking us through Solana today learned a lot great discussion was had thanks so much yeah thanks guys really appreciate the time bankless listeners risk and disclaimers of course crypto is risky so is defy you could definitely lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot living a bankless life requires taking control of your own private keys not your keys not your crypto that's why so many in the bankless nation already have their ledger hardware wallets which makes proper private key management a breeze but the ledger ecosystem is more than just a secure hardware wallet ledger is the combination of the ledger hardware wall and the ledger live app and if you're used to seeing all of your crypto services and favorite deaps all in one place ledger is where you want to be not only does ledger let you buy crypto assets straight from the app but it also hooks into decentralized exchange aggregators like periswap which makes sure that you are getting the best prices on your trades without your assets ever leaving your control defy never stops growing and the ledger live app grows alongside with it so click the link in the show notes to see all the defy apps that ledger live has and stay tuned as more and more apps come online and if you don't have a ledger hardware wallet what are you even waiting for go to ledger.
com grab your ledger download ledger live and get all of your deaps all in one place bankless is proud to be supported by uniswap uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum which is what Ryan and I call a money robot no human counterparties or centralized intermediaries just autonomous code on Ethereum input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy something brand new in the uniswap ecosystem is the uniswap grants program is now accepting applications for grants we have been saying this for a while and we'll say it again dals have money and they are in need of labor if you think that you have something to contribute to the uniswap down apply for a grant to uniswap just look at the size of the uniswap treasury it's almost three billion dollars this mountain of capital is looking for labor do you have something of value to contribute to the uniswap down no matter how big or small your idea is you can apply for a unigrant at unigrants.
org and help steer uniswap in the direction that you think it should go that's exactly what we did to get uniswap to be a sponsor for bankless and you can do the same