Today we're joined by James Seyffart, a research analyst at Bloomberg who's the perfect person to answer our questions regarding the convergence of crypto and ETFs.
We dive into: - The probabilities of a Blackrock Bitcoin ETF and why - Important dates in which the SEC will need to give us answers - Neutrality, or lack thereof around the ETF approval process
------ 🚀 Join Ryan & David at Permissionless in September. Bankless Citizens get 30% off. 🚀 https://bankless.cc/GoToPermissionless
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | TRACK & MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK
👾POLYGON | VALUE LAYER OF THE INTERNET https://polygon.technology/roadmap
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 7:44 What is an ETF? 13:00 ETF History Lesson 17:40 ETF Market Size and Holders 22:46 Types of ETFs 27:02 Where Are These Assets Stores 34:04 Who Approves ETFs? 40:08 Neutrality Of Regulators 44:16 Types of Bitcoin ETFs 49:17 Reasons For Rejection 55:12 Does Gary Just Hate Crypto? 58:13 Does Blackrock Change Things? 1:04:46 Will Blackrock Get Approved? 1:15:20 Possible Approval Dates 1:19:09 Lack of ETFs to Blame For Crypto Fallout? 1:28:38 Why Should we Care? 1:34:14 Risks and Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
James on Twitter: https://twitter.com/JSeyff
Trillions Podcast: https://www.bloomberg.com/podcasts/series/trillions
------ Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Yeah, let's be I'll be very blunt. If you look at all the things that they have said and written over the last three years, this will be denied But really a lot there's a lot of circumstantial evidence that suggests that It will be approved the it goes back to what I said they come back into whatever decision they want to Okay, well you said two things there James. I want to be clear When Bitcoin ETF that is the question on our mind today is the Bitcoin ETF actually happening or not will happen this year or not BlackRock fidelity some of the largest ETF issuers in the world have now Subended filings for ETFs with the SEC is Gary Gensler going to let them through and at this point can he even say no That's the question we raise with James Saifert He's a Bloomberg analyst who's tracking this thing closer than anyone I've ever met He's on the episode today and he gives us a date by which we should have a clean answer from the SEC on the Bitcoin ETF So is he over or under on the probability that SEC approving a Bitcoin ETF this year?
You have to listen to the entire conversation to find out. I'm psyched about this episode And before we begin I want to address a question that some of you might have which is why is bankless even covering the Bitcoin ETF That's not very bankless of you you might say I disagree with that and here's why I think when people buy crypto assets they buy into crypto values Not all the way not all at once But a little bit at a time. This is just another step forward crypto ETFs in my mind are a gateway drug a type of gateway drug I don't think people will stop with just the Bitcoin ETF in their retirement account I think that's the gateway to them setting up an exchange account For instance and buying spot Bitcoin or spot ether that way Which is the gateway to going full bankless and taking custody of their own keys In order for people to care about crypto They actually have to own crypto and this is an easy way for people to own crypto in their retirement accounts When we get more crypto ownership we get more economic security And we get more people who care about crypto issues in their respective jurisdictions We need a lot more people to care about crypto in the United States in order to turn the regulatory tide There's one other thing.
I think we get from this episode Which is learning more about traditional finance How is crypto supposed to eat traditional finance and disruptive? We don't even understand how it works Like do you understand how ETFs work today? What backs them? Why people love them? Why they're popular? I didn't and that's where we start this episode with James This is a college level course on ETFs from their birth in the early 90s To the Bitcoin spot ETF and the possibility of that today I'm doing this episode solo today David is off climbing mountains, but he'll be back soon And he'll certainly be back in time for an event that you should pay attention to It's called permissionless This is the crypto conference to go to in 2023 If you only pick one and I think you should pick one the bear market conferences are the best conferences You got to come with David myself the rest of the bankless nation to permissionless It's happening in Austin, Texas September 11th through the 13th so that's Texas Austin, September 11th through the 13th and we have an absolutely stacked agenda We've got Eric Voorheese who's talking we've got Hester Perse from the SEC commission We've got Stani from Ave go click the link in the show notes Get a ticket and come with us to permissionless this year All right guys, it's time to go find out about this Bitcoin ETF We'll be right back with James, but before we do I want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible Including Kraken the number one crypto exchange I recommend to all of my friends and family This is the way to get onboarded to crypto go create an account Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry The place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices Even when I'm not looking to place a trade On Kraken Pro you'll have access to advanced charting tools Real-time market data and lightning fast trade execution All inside their spiffy new modular interface Kraken's new customizable modular layout Let's you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen With Kraken Pro you have that power Whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out Join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs Visit pro.
Kraken.com to get started today Enter Mantle An entire ecosystem dedicated to the adoption of decentralized token govern technologies Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dowled Web3 ecosystem All built on top of Mantle's first core product The Mantle Network A brand new high performance Ethereum layer 2 Built differently from the other layer 2s that you may be familiar with Mantle asked the question How would you build a layer 2 if you had the technology of 2023 Mantle Network is a modular layer 2 Built using the OP stack But uses eigenlayers data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer 1 Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80% compared to other layer 2s But it also reduces gas fee volatility Providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow owned treasuries in Defon Which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboard it To help the growth of Mantle like Game 7 for Web3 Gaming Or Edgey Dow for the world of DSI And buy it for TBL and liquidity and on rents So if you want to build on the Mantle Network Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding To promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle If you want to get started working with the first Dowled layer 2 ecosystem Check out Mantle at Mantle.
xyz And follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle Are you planning to launch a token? Is your token already live? And are you granting your employees and contractors vesting token words? And are you trying to figure out how to take care of taxable events for your team? Toku makes implementing a global token incentive award simple With Toku you will get unmatched legal and tax support To grant and administer your global teams tokens Toku will help you navigate across the lifecycle of your token From easy to use pre-launched token grant award templates To managing post-cliff taxable events with payroll For legal finance and HR teams it's a huge complex task To have to comply with labor laws, payroll, and tax obligations Tax reporting and crypto regulations in every country that you employ someone It's difficult time-consuming, manual, and costly And is drawing more attention from global regulators and governments Toku makes it simple for leading companies in the space Protocol labs, Hedera, Gitcoin, and many more So if you want some help navigating the complex world of token compliance Go to tooku.
com slash bankless or click the link in the description below Bankless nation, the question on our mind today is a Bitcoin ETF happening We have an expert who can weigh in on this James Saferd is a research analyst at Bloomberg He's got one foot in crypto and the other foot In ETFs, he's currently a Bloomberg intelligence ETF analyst And he's here to drop some insight on the question I just opened with when are we going to get that Bitcoin ETF James, welcome to Bankless Thanks for having me Ryan, happy to be here You know, we talk a lot about crypto in on bankless, of course And so I think it's in some people some listeners They got their first exposure to finance By way of crypto actually my co-host David Hoffman's very much like this So I don't know if David's ever purchased an ETF in his life And I think there's probably some bankless listeners that fall into that camp too So could we start by going through some of the basics What is an ETF?
I think I know the acronym Does that stand for exchange traded fund? Is that correct correct? And what is this thing that we're talking about today? That is 100% correct So it's exchange traded fund It's basically people a lot of people have 401k's 403b's these types of plans at least in the US And usually what you're investing in is a mutual fund And those have much longer tickers within X at the end typically But essentially what that means is Those funds are not traded So you give money and at the end of the day they put that money to work the next day For when your money comes in And for mutual funds for 401k's and plans like that it makes complete sense It's easy You're not usually super time commitment because you're just contributing on a regular basis But an ETF is a traded vehicle And the real story here is that the ETFs were invented after the SEC Wrote a report in 1987 there was this big crash A lot of it had to do with futures and derivatives And the SEC said basically they wish they had something that was more physically Backed rather than derivatives or derivative of different assets And basically this this guy Nate most came up with the idea for what is now An ETF and it comes off the idea of these things called commodity warehouse receipts They've those have been around forever and the idea of commodity warehouse receipts If you think about it this way is like say you had a bunch of gold or a bunch of barrels of oil or Whatever wheat corn you name it right and one thing that you used to be able to do is you would store that somewhere And then the warehouse would Charge some sort of fee and in return they give you pieces of paper that say you have this much exposure Or it was a vault or gold you would say you have this much gold and you in rather than moving that physical gold Those physical commodities around you trade those pieces of paper So those pieces of paper were a right to two those things held in that warehouse And that's where the idea of an ETF came about and basically the first one in the US was the SMB 500 And then basically those instead of commodities being held in that warehouse It's Stocks or the SMB 500 the stocks that make up the SMB 500 held in Biocastodian so those stocks are held by somebody and what that means is at all times the key thing that makes an ETF work and why it's Super efficient is because you can always access those underlying stocks or in or in the example the commodities You can always those access those underlying commodities So basically those shares are right to your ownership of the underlying asset So in the SMB 500 ETF you can always trade in shares of the ETF and get back the underlying stocks In the potential Bitcoin ETF would be the same way you could always trade in the shares of the ETF and get back Bitcoin Or vice versa you can always trade in Bitcoin and get back shares and what that means is We can get into this more but like one thing that I'm sure a lot of your viewers have heard about is GBTC The grayscale Bitcoin trust that operates more like what we what in our world we would call a close-down fund It's technically not one but it means ETFs have that mechanism where you can create shares and redeem shares because always the underlying can be exchanged for the shares of the product right So in grayscale's case there's no way to access the underlying Bitcoin I can't hand over GBTC shares and get back Bitcoin Which is what grayscale is suing to do to try and get access to that mechanism so that you don't have a situation where the price of those shares Is very different from the value of the underlying assets they hold so when you have an ETF that problem doesn't have And because you can always at some point if somebody thinks the price of the ETF is not in line with the underlying asset You can buy those shares of the ETF or buy up the underlying asset and exchange them It's called arbitrage.
They're they're always the same thing So basically there's some trading costs so there's my new differences there But for the most part you can always exchange shares for assets And that's what what's causing a lot of the problems in different parts of the market So the way to think about an ETF is if you're used to looking at stocks or even cryptos really right you you know the supply So for the most part Bitcoin's big currency back example since it supplies ever increasing But if you look at a stock typically the the supply of shares is relatively stable right it you know what it is And what drives the price is that change in demand so if you think about like two bars in a graph Basically the what drives the price of most assets is the change in demand right obviously supply impacts it as well The benefit of ETFs is as demand changes you can change supplies you can add more shares to meet demand And if demand drops you can destroy shares to meet demand So that way the price and the value of the underlying assets of the price the fund the price the value of the underlying assets are always going to be very close So that's the background of an ETF and why so many people view this as like the the key to the holy grail for for crypto and bridge to tradify You just opened up probably a thousand questions in my mind and you want to get to them that that last point that you mentioned I want to draw an analogy for bankless listeners So as the demand changes you can increase the supply USDC you know a stablecoin kind of works like that as well.
I'm think of that right so how much USDC can be minted Well kind of pretty much as long as the US continues to give access to Coinbase in circle to to US bank accounts It's kind of an unlimited supply as much as as the market will demand and it sounds like ETFs work that way too So a few things just to recap so this is a new-ish product I guess in the in the full scope of financial products You said it sounds like it was invented maybe in the late 1980s so kind of took off 93 was the first one so technically I told you about that guy Nate most yeah He actually went the first ETF ever launched was technically in Canada a few years because the SEC took like three years So you get comfortable with the ideas Yeah, so Canada did it first in like 91 after talking with Nate most in these guys So they got it done in like a year And then we came along afterwards in the US and finally figured it out Okay, so 93 was the first time and they're along the whole way There's been people questioning the the structure saying it was going to cause issues And they've done nothing but proved themselves as an efficient It's the way to think about is it's a wrapper and it's a technology in a way.
It's a democratizing technology In the way it's been used and it's interesting that people would say that this would cause issues Because it actually seems much simpler than the other kind of like Price exposure mechanisms based on derivatives and that sort of thing It's like because it's pretty simple. It's just a wrapper for underlying assets, right? Yeah Like what can go wrong? Yeah, so we don't need to get too far into the weeds here But essentially a lot of the people say like if you're looking at bonds so they're all there's bond ETFs They hold other assets that are less liquid than typical stocks But so people like think you're adding liquidity There's a lot of nuance here But essentially what it comes down to is in the good times an ETF can be way more liquid than the underlying because people don't have to go and access the underlying market to trade it Right They can just use the ETF shares and sometimes it just trades back and forth There's a lot of market makers that can handle that but in times of stress That like access liquidity ETF offers is not going to be there.
It's not magic So basically if the underlying market freezes up like happened in in March of 2020 during covid Those they basically the ETFs don't aren't they're not magic So if the underlying market is locked up there's going to be issues with the ETF but with an ETF you can always trade So basically like yes in the good times there's more liquidity Because the ETF is there. It's operating on exchange. There's market makers. There's always bids and asks So if you think about a bond market it's mostly over the counter traded like literally some of its like phone calls still like That's the way things are traded still but like basically what happens is like the ETF will look like it's dislocated But what really ends up happening is just the underlying market is out of whack There's not enough liquidity nobody's willing to buy or sell or there's just mismatch of what's going on So there's plenty of examples of things like that that happened in March of 2020 But all the ETFs in the US and around the world have held up extremely well and were perfect Beacons of of efficiency during that time They really like proved their metal even some of their most ardent critics Even had to come step back and admit like they did extremely well and handling the issues You sound like an ETF bull my friend I mean, I mean one of the things we've always said is like We get we're going to get into a lot of this but like if the SEC had approved this thing Honestly all the people and these markets these market makers that operate in this market Like they're not going to let some of the the fishy stuff that has been going on in crypto Like they're going to go to the the exchanges that are operating cleanly They're not going to get involved in a lot of the other things that plenty of people have been involved in In this space so if we do get one it's going to clean things up It's going to drive down trading costs ETFs trade like penny-wide Very very tight so there's no transaction fees on most brokerage platforms The and then if you look at most brokerage platforms They don't really tell you what the bid S spread is you can find it back into it by looking at like what the trading looks like on coin base or Binance or any of those things right?
But you there is a spread so you know you're paying a fee typically to do the trade and then there's also a spread Between what the bid and the ask is and like usually market makers are making that money So there's a lot of money to be made in offering markets in the crypto markets and when an ETF comes about It's going to get way tighter so you'll see a lot of people who trade Bitcoins specifically in crypto markets to learn to start to use the ETF and vice versa people from the ETF world We'll probably go to the underlying crypto markets and make things more efficient and more liquid because you have the behemoths of the US trading and financial system come in I think I was first exposed to kind of the ETF concept just just you know earlier in might sort of a you know adulthood and Early investing career through like Vanguard group and in John Bogle like the idea that hey, you know what you don't have to like Outperform the market you just buy buy an index fund buy a Low cost index fund of some sort and you'll outperform You know like 80% of active traders out there and so it's always been a good concept and of course You want to keep your management fees low and my understanding is a lot of ETFs can can somewhat provide that So that's what is that a reason and I want to ask you who are the holders of these ETFs is it Is it like kind of large pension funds is it sort of big money capital pools or is it is it mainly like Individual Americans like retail investors with a fidelity account or Schwab account With their 4 ok money as you alluded to earlier who were the net buyers of these things So really it's that's the beauty of the ETF.
It's everyone So in the old mutual fund world what you're used to looking at in your 401k or whatever might be if you're a US listener There are multiple share glasses So like you need to invest a certain amount of money to get access this lower fee Because you get all these other things right the economies of scale whatever So they have all these different share glasses a b c i for institutional There's different things right, but what the ETF did is it democratized it all so everyone's playing in the same pool So if your grandma wants to buy an ETF She's buying the same ETF as citadel if they're looking to trade that or some other big hedge fund or pension or p fund So really everyone is involved in this and that's the beauty of the ETF ecosystem because it incorporates everyone So you have all the liquidity from the big Tradify players who are looking to make short-term trades alongside the mom and pops you were talking about who some of them might be looking to do short-term trades A lot of them are just looking to buy and hold like you were talking about local ETFs and hold them for a very long time They can get exposure and part of the reason they can be so cheap is because so many people are using them so many different types of people are using them How big is the ETF market James in terms of you know assets inside of ETFs are we talking hundreds of billions are we getting into the trillions here?
Yeah, no, we're definitely a trillion so like we're right around 10 trillion globally But most of that is in the US. I believe we have I'm looking it up right now. I think we have seven. I think we're right around seven trillion In the US alone I'll tell you the exact number seven point two five trillion Would you find that info is that like a term? Yeah, that's a Bloomberg function But I don't I probably vetify ETF calm things like that will probably have that type of information But the global markets like over 10 as well, but that you got to remember that includes like it hold stocks There's gonna hold bonds it'll hold treasuries yeah modities everything you can think of if it has basically been thrown into an ETF wrapper Even even cryptos just not in the US what right right we'll get we'll get there to crypto I you know we're building here building our understanding here.
Okay, so uh 10 trillion dollars worldwide How much of that would you guess is kind of like retail mom and pops versus like the big guys? It's hard so a lot of the so if you look at the way the US market works like for the most part a lot of the money is via advisors and platform So we can't see exactly how much is retail but a lot of people will use advisors So roughly we estimate right now that US advisors the people that are helping like if you went to somebody to help you manage or your money Right um they they control about 30 trillion in assets and they love ETFs specifically independent advisors So um the way the old mutual funds like you've talked about used to be sold is there was basically kickback So if you put your client into this fund you got some money out of it And possibly into perpetuity and different things like that.
So basically mutual funds were sold By people that were wholesalers and trying to get advisors to put their clients in those funds because they get more money Everyone basically the money gets is kickback all over the place ETFs. It's not some of that kind of happens But it's not directly the case. It's more that ETFs are bought So advisors are huge owners of this hedge funds like to use these things institutions are using these things to park money For the most part because they're super low cost so retail We don't have a like clear breakdown on that front But it's a decent chunk. I would say At least 30% probably more.
I'm just because a lot of it is buy and hold But there's also plenty of ETFs that are not built to be bought and held some of them are built to be traded And like I said the SEC came about this because they wanted an alternative to Futures and different things that were happening So they wanted people to be able to use these and trade and would there are some ETFs out there Like the S&B 500 from spy and plenty of others that we refer to as like pseudo futures where institutions are using them for liquidity So like they had they got a certain amount of money They can't put it to work fully and exactly what they want to So they're going to throw it into an ETF or like you even have mutual funds some of those guys are talking about that are picking bonds picking stocks And what they'll do is they'll pick the hold an ETF in like three percent of their portfolio or four percent of their portfolio If they're a large cap manager the hold a large cap equity ETF if they're a high-yield bond manager They'll hold a high-yield corporate bond ETF and basically they just use that like sleeve almost if you think that as a moat around their portfolio They're picking the bonds they think are going to outperform the most give them the best whatever characteristics They're looking for and then rather than holding cash, which is what they did historically which doesn't give them exposure to the market It's called cash drag Actually in the last couple years it might not have been that bad with the way rates have gone but Essentially what they do is they want to have exposure to the market But they know that ETFs are super liquid so I keep going back like everyone uses this people across the traditional financial ecosystem Are using ETFs in many different ways Yeah, and I'm looking at kind of a list of different ETFs You probably have a better list in your head But you know like you basically buy any collection any set of assets in ETF So we mentioned you know the spy S&P 500 index if you want general stock index in the US You know, there's a NASDAQ we've got equity precious metals you can buy a gold ETF Should we could buy silver?
I'm sure there's all sorts of other commodities you can buy a lady on you name it Yeah, I know of them I've seen you know certainly yeah oil ETFs as well if you're kind of want to go down the commodity stack Real estate ETFs of various types. I don't know if it gets as specific as like let's say I want to bet on the real estate market in California Maybe that's a bit too specific, but you know Maybe they have something like that actually they do have some stuff They have muni bonds that focus on they have muni bonds that hold focus on that so you could bet on the California muni market But also like that basically there are those real estate ones.
They don't hold physical real estate They own reats with the real estate investment trust which had been all of the news lately because public reats are trading Very different from private reats, but ETFs will wrap those things as well And hold them so give you exposure So like maybe one reats specializes in like the southwest United States of California, Arizona, whatever And so you if that's what you're after you could just buy the re that's kind of similar to like buying a stock And these will give you like here's the US market or here's here's a reate for like multi-family homes or stuff like that There's it's becoming sliced and diced in different ways There reads out there that focus specifically on like retail warehouses or data warehouses that hold all these servers So like they own the real estate and people rent those warehouses to put all their servers in them And that that has been one of the best performing areas of the read markets So like there's ETFs that specifically target that so yeah, there's ETFs that basically target money markets Can you just buy like dollars in an ETF or something?
Yeah, there's actually yeah, so there's some dollar ETFs that like basically they the way those work though isn't like They're just holding dollars. There are money market fund ETFs elsewhere. There's money market funds obviously that aren't ETFs For the most part people just use like treasury ETFs if they're looking for that type of exposure It because it just holds treasuries the Treasury bills specifically you can look at T bill ETFs But yeah, there are some money market ETFs in Canada just not in the US yet But again, you get those T-build type ETFs and they think of you a very similar Exposure otherwise there's ones that basically You can bet on the direction of the US dollar So it'll go like long US dollar futures and then shorts a basket of other currency futures.
So it'll short the great push pound the Japanese yen the euro Brazilian real like you name it so it'll tell you what it's going long and what it's going short And that's how you could bet like tactically on where the dollar is going I have for crypto natives crypto listeners Triedify You thought of this idea of tokenization before crypto did this looks a lot like tokenization Of different assets, doesn't it? Okay, so this other point that you raised which is like the thing that's different about ETFs is you can always access the underlying assets I think that will come into play when we talk a little bit about crypto again We're still building to the crypto conversation James But this idea of you can always access the underlying assets.
I want to get into the details of that right? So for something like stocks It's it's weird. It's interesting because like when we say the underlying assets What are we talking about actually like piece of paper like legal documents somewhere I want to contrast that from a commodity like a gold or like oil for example where the underlying asset At the root of it is much more clear the underlying asset is like a barrel of oil somewhere in a warehouse You know, you hope actually so for oil It's you mentioned I mean I was debating saying this before but like oil one of the we like to call some ETFs They're like wolves and sheep's clothing because they look like they're simple There are no ETFs that hold physical oil because you can't really store it at cost too much money There's a multitude of reasons there are some people like I know some people who are thinking they want to trick Give it a try but really all the oil house oil.
Yeah, they wear house oil They want but the only way to really get oil and the oil ETFs work is they they roll they invest in futures They invest in derivatives Which is how a lot of commodity ETFs also work except for those precious metal ones You were talking about and there are some others but all right So let's talk about those so well first let's talk about maybe the precious metal ones So if I buy a gold ETF of some sort Where is the actual gold bar? You know stored and can I actually like can I actually redeem that for gold? And you said you said it's always able to access the underlying asset So I want to convert my my gold ETF into like you know a physical bar of gold It might actually able to do that or there's some intermediaries in between here Yeah, so this is going to get in the weeds on like market mechanics of ETFs a little bit So I'll do my best to keep it simple But essentially the way to think about it is there are There's a few people involved in a creation redemption process So usually it's what we refer to as a market maker think of those as the big trading firms The Citadel's if people out there have heard of obviously people have heard of Jane Street If you're listening to your show Virtue those are they are big ETF market makers.
They're they're pairing trades And they will access the underlying if they have to make a trade happen or it's more efficient to do it that way Then just sourcing the under the the actual shares in the exchange So I keep saying at any point you can access the underlying market to create a redeem shares These market makers know that and they know what's more efficient Is it more efficient to just source the actual ETF shares? There's a more efficient to go to the underlying market and make this happen Sometimes the buy is so big that there's not enough shares to be demand So they have to go to the underlying market to make it That might be a little more costly or it could be more efficient in buying those that many shares in the market Like it's the same thing.
It's like a big whale comes to a crypto market and buys a ton of Bitcoin You're going to blow through the price But if you could theoretically figure out a way to buy Bitcoin more efficiently That's how you would do it So but the way this works is those are the market makers There's also something called an authorized participant Which has been in a gray scale situation as well And the APs are the people that facilitate that creation think these are the huge banks with massive balance sheets think Bank of America are gold men There's a whole bunch of APs out there Merrill Lynch They'll basically like they are the people that facilitate that creation of shares and redemption of shares That work with the issuers that own these ETFs Now for the most part it's these market makers and these APs That are making sure that the market is efficient in the underlying if you need to tap the underlying market Whether it's to create ETF shares or destroy ETF shares They're the ones doing it So the market makers are constantly trading every day They're dealing with the APs The APs are dealing with the issuers In some instances not to get too wonky The market makers can be an AP as well But like essentially it's these people These institutions that have specific licenses to operate in whatever markets That can operate in those markets and make the creations and redemptions That said that's the way most things work Because for the most part you need like 100,000 shares of the ETF To do a creation of redemption right So these are big So like if you that was what make like you or I Actually, I don't know maybe you're a well But like if you wanted to buy an ETF It's these people in the back end that are batching the entire market together To make sure it's operating efficiently There's very low cost to trade All of those things they're making sure that the ETFs are created or destroyed To demand to meet supply Now that's dead There are ETFs out there like OUNZ For gold ETFs This is a gold ETF And basically The creation of redemptions are way lower at the minimum So like there is going to be a cost if you owned enough You could get gold delivered to your house But that's like a special exemption that they went through to get to happen But also like most ETFs hold their gold in vaults in London There is one that holds it in Switzerland There is an ETF that used to hold it at the Perth Mint in Australia So there's like all these different ways you can do it Everyone has different custodians But gold is like a unique subset So some people like the true gold bugs Or like I don't trust anyone to hold my gold There's a lot of issues where people are worried about paper Paper gold with futures But for the most part the gold has to be stored in the vault And every share of the ETF should be backed by physical gold Now sometimes the trading is literally like Some guy in London goes into the vault for the spider GLD And takes gold out and moves it to the vault down the street For like some other trading firm or gold trading firm Or whatever what may have you But like on to our view Like that's gold leaving the trust that we were interested in Or the one we were looking at and going into a different one Right that's a creation of redemption So hopefully they're using a Brings truck Or some security apparatus for that transfer And no and literally sometimes it's the same building Like it's just a little bit different Like it's still moving it from one vault to another And if they didn't If they didn't move it, would we really know?
Yeah Okay so there is like auditing and stuff And more than the I'd like to think it's better than the auditing we've seen in the next time Well I couldn't get worse with respect to FDX and the CUSSE But what's interesting is like we have You know as with crypto We have like with the gold example We have an actual bear asset Which is like we have it Like it's kind of valuable Like that's the thing possession Is the asset itself It's not like equity it's not a legal agreement Or something like that That's enforced by some sort of Legal code It is actual physical possession But there's a clean separation of responsibilities In kind of ETFs You mentioned the APs You mentioned the kind of the market makers And then a third group You said is kind of the custody providers Whether that's a you know Somewhere in Perth in Australia Or that's somewhere in some vault In London These are not the same entities Right Like the vault is not the AP is not the market maker Generally these are There's some clear Division of responsibilities Is that approximately right That is correct Which is one of the things That the SEC is going after Coinbase for In this lawsuit They want them to break up their brokerage Their custody All those things And to separate legal entities Cool You know I appreciate like Coinbase Or sorry The SEC is like asking for these things But it's also not providing a clear way to actually do it Which is this weird scenario We're in Okay but so if I own a gold ETF It's pretty much like It's pretty rare to own an ETF Where I could actually get the gold bar Delivered to my house Maybe there's kind of one of those Um well Well so for the average person If you had millions of dollars in there You could absolutely get the gold Right Like you could like it would not be a problem But like for the average person Who's not going to have millions of dollars In this ETF How do you know with gold It's so weird though It's like let's say add millions of dollars A gold like What do I just show up with my like minivan Or something Like loaded back Yes So like Canada specifically Does they have ETFs that do this as well The the Canadian Royal Mint Has had They're actually I don't even think they're technically ETFs But they operate like ETFs Yeah You can do the same thing Right You can get it delivered to your house essentially Like I don't know exactly what it looks like Uh but I imagine like basically A brinck truck would show up Um But I'm sure if you're moving enough money It's not you're not going to have it delivered to your Your house Okay So you could But Bitcoin obviously is different Because of the way it's transmitted and stored We can get into that And to be clear Who is responsible for approving ETFs Who's kind of the gatekeepers As somebody in government Is this always the SEC You have to go and not You have to register There are different divisions in the SEC That make these decisions On different ETFs But it's always the SEC The one that we're specifically These issuers are dealing with right now And the one that has been the traditional holdup Is the place called the division of markets and trading But it's really SEC And it comes down to a Gary Gensler He's the overarching head Basically they do what he says for the most part So uh Gary Gary Gensler Or the the current whatever Whoever that Whoever the current chair of the SEC Is basically emperor king of like Well You know giving the this final sign off for an ETF Is that It Yeah Pretty much But the the thing is here Like the way that the There you might have seen like notice about Like some of these Republican senators Who are pro crypto trying to change the way the SEC is set up But basically there's There's four commissioners And then also Chairman And usually it's two Republicans two Democrats That's the way it works So then the chairman is the one that has like the overriding power Because typically it's two versus two So theoretically if you were if somebody was able to swing Which I wrote about in one of my notes One of these commissioners Basically that could change things as well Because like Gary would be outvoted But the Hester purse which i'm sure Anyone listening knows who that is crypto mom She has descended on multiple ETF denials in the past For most recent the most recent descent came this year And for the first time the new commissioner joined her in her descent of the SEC's decision to deny Vanneck and I don't I think it was Vanneck this most recent one But whoever it was they they they wrote a descent letter kind of like you would see from like the The supreme court descent from judges that disagree So if they get one of those other commissioners to agree with them one of those two Dems Against Gary then all the sudden this thing is likely to get approved So it's not as cut and dry as like gensler is fully in charge But like 95% chance that gensler is the one making decisions here Because and you got to remember he reports to the democratic party right Think Elizabeth Warren That there's a lot of jokes about her like getting orders from Elizabeth Warren But there really is a lot of ties to that side of the the democratic party And what's going on here?
But let's draw that out because um Shouldn't the ETF process or maybe I'm asking a question of historically how has it been So who are the issuers of ETFs who are filing in and asking for the SEC's You know permission to do this. This is a small Collection of of very large companies. There's a pretty uh, you know distributed in diverse And what's the process? I I would assume that we've had a process in place For regulators to be somewhat neutral and to have kind of guidelines and rules But they can't I would assume they can't necessarily pick winners or losers right like uh I have friends at at at BlackRock Versus like you know, I hate Goldman or whatever and I'm going to choose one Issuer over the other what's this approval process been like historically for traditional finance So let's just say that they can do that and they do do that and I'll go into why they do that But they basically can make the decision and back into it legally But wait wait wait they can be biased however they want The technically they shouldn't be but they can are they you would have to prove it and I that gray scales trying to prove that in court right now Right, but for the most part they have been biased and some of the things that they're doing And it's definitely coming down from what the democratic side of the The ticket wants to have happened so it's already been criticized prior to crypto you would say is this like kind of like a part of it and so like on the inside Yeah, so I would say like the Winkelvalls twins tried to do this first in 2013 right they were small They got denied they tried again.
They ended up getting denied again in 2018 That was the first time that has their purse dissented on the decision I would argue that the denial then actually kind of made sense because the way that the Winkelvalls application was constructed Um, I don't we don't need to get into the weeds on that but it's a lot of different issues So I'm looking now I have 40 different filings for spot ETFs and 37 different filings for Futures ETS. What do you mean you have them? You're just seeing them. I just looked at a list Yeah, I have a list of like it's literally an Excel spreadsheet of where I track them And I can look at the links and see what the SEC is saying about them and all the above I try to track everything that's going on It's basically so when I first came to be I was covering commodities and we added crypto and I had already Own crypto personally.
I was interested in a personally and I reported to Mike McLean who's our commodities analyst who covers crypto heavily as a strategist And then I reported to Eric Belltunis who is my boss Who covers ETFs and eventually I got moved up and I'm specifically in the ETF side But that experience of my personal experience covering crypto from a strategy side of point of view And having all my ETF knowledge made this like ETF potential fund And Eat crypto stuff was like my squarely in my wheelhouse So that's why like I was tracking this stuff already on my own and it was made a complete no-brainders start writing about it So how many on those lists are crypto related in your queue?
Would you say it was like 40 or so? Atoba so a lot of them have been denied There's only eight that are currently active for on the spot side But if you look at all the filings your at Let me see Yeah, you're at 40 plus 37 you're at 77 total filings and we're waiting for 30-ish issuers How many how many Filing so far if you include the ones that have been denied and are active and these are Bitcoin ETF filings to be clear Not just Bitcoin their crypto the some of them is gonna eat futures ETF a couple of them are eat spot Which had no shot of ever getting approved I guess people figured they'd try But yeah 77 different filings and there there's some others that you could argue that will are kind of like Crypto ETFs, but they're a little they might hold a little bit of futures But they also hold some other stuff so But yes 77 different ETFs are have either been approved denied or Are kind of like in limbo right now waiting to see if they get approved?
Jumping back to that question about the the neutrality of kind of a regulator like how are they supposed to Go through the process of approving an issuer But and then also contrast that with how it it happens practically for Like for requests outside of crypto Yeah, so the SEC is supposed to be a disclosure regulator. They're not just merit regulars So there are some country that merit regulators that decide whether an investment has any merit and should be allowed The SEC's job is to do basically Have they disclose all the risks? They're not saying whether or not something is a good or bad investment And that stated in the in the law that that yeah, that's around the formation of the SEC Yeah, yeah, exactly so Hester has written descent saying we're getting danger Dangerously close to being a merit regulator, which is a key term that like I think a lot of people don't realize how strong that statement is But they they're really doing a really good job of telling that line And I would argue they've kind of crossed it, but it's more of a gray zone than like a black and white They're saying this is a bad investment, which is not something they should do Okay, so they're supposed to be basically a neutral neutral regulator If they're not supposed to make merit-based decisions and what that means effectively is you know, they may personally think that Gold is just a you know a shit coin asset or whatever they say completely useless.
They might hate it But they cannot You know have that determination in in their rulings right they have to be neutral with respect to what they decide to allow Retail ETF investor not ETF investors exposure to or not and that's different than some other regulatory apparatus is outside of the United States Is that approximately correct? Yeah, so the way to think about it is their job is to prevent fraud manipulation Anybody getting taken advantage of that's what they're there to do They want to make sure that's not happening and honestly some of the stuff that they've done that has been questionable has Probably saved some people from getting rugged That's happened in crypto space, but I would also make the argument that they should have been going after these Actors before anything ever happened, but that's a whole different discussion But the way that the process works so there's there's two ways that this works So basically this all goes back to the 1933 act and the 1940 act which are just laws about the US financial markets securities markets We don't need to get to in the weeds there.
This is where the SEC was formed. There wasn't an SEC previous to this right? Yeah, I yes, so essentially the way that It initially worked was like everyone had to go through this 19 before process, which is Essentially where what we're doing right now at these spot applications and what that means is there It's exchanges that apply to the SEC for a proposal for a rule change and at the end of the day the rule change is to be able to list a spot that coin ETF right And those are specifically for ETFs that are under the 1933 act in 2019 this they made this rule called an ETF rule For anything that's under the 1940 act 1940 I think things that hold securities that are diversified There's more requirements on those on those types of products They made the rule because before this everyone had to file a 19 before to launch an ETF right for if it was remotely new now under the 40 act It's just a more simple process you apply and you have after 75 days the prospectus or the application to launch a fund Goes live and you can start trading it Before those if those in those 75 days the SEC can say no no good you can't launch and then it's bounced But it's not the same process of the 19 before process Futures ETFs the first one that came out were were launched under that process because the SEC didn't have to trading a market It didn't have to okay anything that happens with those applications because they're 1940 acts products because The futures ETFs they hold treasuries and you can argue that Holding treasuries and futures is a specified portfolio and therefore they can fit under the 40 act Which is the same reason that all these eath futures ETFs They actually all got denied in June because they applied and the SEC within a week was like now taken back The 19 before process of the process that we're going to spend most of the time talking about Which is what spot Bitcoin ETFs have to go through and that process like I said is for the proposal of a rule change Can you define that term a spot Bitcoin ETF spot Bitcoin?
What's the significance of saying spot Bitcoin versus just Bitcoin ETF? Yeah, so we have Bitcoin futures ETFs which like a futures ETF typically the way it works is Most of them hold like the front month futures contract so a futures contract basically means you entered agreement to either Buy or sell Bitcoin at the end of a month on a given date and you can trade that right to do that or the the ability to do that Via futures contracts, but the problem with that is that like I said, it's every month So right now if you're holding a front month futures contract for Bitcoin You're going to have to sell it towards the end of July and then buy the august contract right And typically the way these markets work they work in like where they're in contango So the July contract is maybe priced here and then the august contract might be priced just a little bit above Sometimes it can get steeper or not But that means you're selling low and buying high and it eats away at your return So this is constant churning of holding things of holding these futures can be bad detrimental long-term returns That said these Bitcoin futures ETFs that have been in the market have done very well Historically they if they had launched a few years ago They would have vastly underperformed the spot market or physical market as you can also call it But it's really just the futures market versus the spot market and The holy grail here would be to have a physically backed spot Bitcoin ETF I mean the the Bitcoin is stored in cold storage somewhere And you have the shares of the ETF are a right to the underlying asset in this case spot Bitcoin Whereas in the futures ETFs that the SEC has approved You have a right to those futures contracts So we want spot Bitcoin because it's just a much better user experience right I can't imagine if I was purchasing is sort of a Bitcoin ETF in my fidelity account as a retail user And I'm trying to deal with like selling at the end of the month to buy the kind of the next month and just what terrible user experience Compare yeah, so for the ETF you don't have the ETF does that for you so it does that for you So you just hold it I see so the but that rolling is the problem right It's and it's not actually holding spot Bitcoin.
It's it's paper exposure is derivative exposure Okay, so a lot of people prefer not to handle that. So we talked about oil ETFs before Sometimes those things can go into massive contango where like the next contract is super expensive or Acredation, which is where the current contract is more expensive than the next one So I don't know if you some of you guys probably remember when oil went negative in 2020 that calls a lot of problem for these oil ETFs But because like I said they all hold futures to get their exposure So I if I'm recalling correctly and you might remember the full history So correct me if I'm wrong here James, but I think when againstler took over that was when maybe the Bitcoin Futures ETF what was approved somewhere around there and my wrong with that Yeah, so he was already in charge He took over after the ripple lawsuit had been filed But so that's what most people associate with him and after coin base when Um Was like a proof to go public okay, but he is the reason that we have futures ETFs.
He gave his speech in Late July againstler was 2021 and this is not verbatim, but he essentially said they had denied all futures ETFs upsell his point And at the end of the speech he was talking a little bit of crypto and he said we look forward to applications For Bitcoin futures ETFs filed under the 1940 act. Mm-hmm that one line in like a relatively longish speech And then like everyone filed for for futures Bitcoin ETFs And sure enough we got one approved in November We also have an eth one too, right? And neither one. No, we don't have any. We don't yes Yeah, so they've applied but they haven't been approved so the SEC will not approve ethereum futures ETFs largely Gensal of the one thing will he he will admit is a security is not a security is is their coin And he won't say the same now for ethereum which has been covered extensively So yeah, I don't think he's gonna allow those things anytime soon Okay, but but because of that statement and because of us talking over the people is why in September or October of 2021 Why we were so bullish on the fact that we were gonna get a launch and we actually were very Different from a lot of our counterparts at the trad five space the saying that this launch was gonna happen And most people were just banking on history and What the SEC has typically done and saying no shot that this thing gets approved And that's where we made a name for ourselves.
I guess honestly on the on that front So why is Gensler in favor of kind of the the futures Bitcoin ETF style and not the spot Bitcoin ETF like what like I can tell you his argument. What's the difference? Okay, his argument is that they're they're CME futures. So They are covered by the CFTC. It's a regulated market There is not going to be any manipulation of those futures contracts That's what they would say but the the real fact of matter is the pricing of the futures markets Are dictated by something called the Bitcoin reference rate and the Bitcoin reference rate is based off of a bunch of spot markets Including coin based Kraken and a few other Gemini So other so it's literally the price of those futures contracts are determined by an aggregate Of the spot market value of Bitcoin.
Okay. Well Gary's a smart guy. I mean, he surely knows what you just said, right? So that's what he said What do you think the real reason is do you care to speculate? I don't know why he I think I think the problem is they couldn't deny They realized they were going to run into issues with the facts that the CFTC had approved these things and let them list They are not making argument that Bitcoin is security and Basically saying that what you can't launch these ETFs first of all the the like I said it goes under a different process So it didn't go through division of trading and markets So these things kind of got a little bit of a green light because they didn't have to go through the same process the 19 before So Yeah, Gensler kind of gave that to the crypto community and it's what's biting him now So ironically there were other ETFs that were filed before Gensler made that speech and it's 19 before process takes 240 days Basically you file The SEC can bounce it back to you for changes and then you can refile but essentially it starts a clock And the clock goes 45 days and you have to approve delay deny 45 days 90 days and then at the end of 60 days after that You either have to approve or deny there is no more delaying and there were was an application from a company That is a commodity CTF provider to crem that had filed before Gensler gave that speech for a 33 act one that goes to this 19 before process And I wrote about this six months before it happened But I said this is putting the SEC in an absurd place to be like they approved these future CTFs under the 40 act Um, and now we have 33 act applications that are fundamentally very there's very little difference between the two of them Um, and the SEC is going to have to decide how hard they're going to stay on this 19 before process In approving them versus not not approving them and what they did is they approved this ETF and the argument they made So one of the reasons why all ETFs have been denied is because there is no surveillance of an underlying market And they specifically say they want surveillance of Surveillance sharing agreements or they want a regulated spot market of significant size and the two keywords There are regulated market and significant size and the way that they got around those This is where I said they can kind of back into what they want the way they got around those requirements for the CME futures market Because we talked to somebody in crypto They would tell you there's billions of dollars trading in futures markets in Europe and on these exchanges and what have you but Specifically regulated crypto mark regulated futures markets The SEC basically said that it was a regulated market of significant size with respect to itself So the CME futures market is a regulated market of significant size because it's market of significant size Because the entire market they were looking at was nothing but the CME futures market.
So like they can kind of like Make they can kind of back into whatever reasoning. That's what I kind of hinted at before So that's a good example of like what the SEC will do Just to make sure they can do things the way that they want to and that in that application They spent pages upon pages explaining why they were going to prove that futures ETF and still not allow spot ETFs And then a couple months later we got the gray scale denial which we also fully expected and gray scale has sued and now that's where we are Guys, I think we're going to get to the crypto part of this conversation all in on whether we're going to get a Bitcoin ETF Anytime soon.
I've got a lot more questions for James But before we do I want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible including Metamask and their portfolio application If you haven't looked at your Metamask portfolio go check out your crypto wallet right now download Metamask and load it up Here they are Metamask has something new introducing Metamask portfolio Metamask portfolio is the best way to view your crypto portfolio from a holistic level See everything across all the chains all at once in your portfolio Metamask will report the aggregate value of all the assets in your Metamask wallets And even the other wallets you import too But Metamask portfolio isn't just a passive portfolio viewer It is a place to do all of the money verbs that make defy so powerful You can buy swap bridge and stake your crypto assets So not only is Metamask the easiest place to see your wallets in aggregate But it's also a powerful battle station for all of your defy moves So go check out your Metamask portfolio because it's waiting for you to open it up Check it out at portfolio.
Metamask.io You know Uniswap it's the world's largest decentralized exchange with over 1.4 trillion dollars in trading volume You know this because we talk about it endlessly on Bayclas It's Uniswap but Uniswap is becoming so much more Uniswap labs just released the Uniswap mobile wallet for iOS The newest easiest way to trade tokens on the go With a Uniswap wallet you can easily create or import a new wallet Buy crypto on any available exchange with your debit card With extremely low fiat on rent fees And you can seamlessly swap on mainnet, polygon, arbitrum and optimism On the Uniswap mobile wallet you can store and display your beautiful NFTs And you can also explore Web 3 with the in-app search features Market leaderboards and price drugs Or use wallet connect to connect to any Web 3 application So you can now go directly to DeFi with the Uniswap mobile wallet Safe, simple custody from the most trusted team in DeFi Download the Uniswap wallet today on iOS Here's a link in the show notes Arbitrum 1 is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability And is continuing to accelerate the Web 3 landscape Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum 1 Producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems With a recent addition of Arbitrum Nova, gaming and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitrum home Both Arbitrum 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum And provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EV and compatible On Arbitrum both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds With significantly lower gas fees With Arbitrum's recent migration to Arbitrum Nitro It's also now 10 times faster than before Visit Arbitrum.
io Where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs Bridge your assets and start building your first app With Arbitrum, experience Web 3 development The way it was meant to be Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free Okay, you mentioned that the SEC can basically back into whatever they want And it seems like they're having trouble Maybe keeping their story straight With all the different things they've said and actions they've taken Is there like a real reason that the SEC and Gensler is not just approving a Bitcoin ETF Okay, surveillance, all of this type of thing Is it? I mean, crypto will just tell you I mean, there's definitely a lot of conspiracy theories here Of course, but the simple explanation seems to be Gary Gensler and some political body Within the government does not want to propagate crypto any further And so they're just trying to hold the line For as long as possible and delay things For as long as possible because they don't like crypto Is it as simple as that, James?
Or have you seen anything in your journey here To bring up kind of an alternative Alternative explanation for all of this That I would say that's a huge part of it But you also like it's part of it The other side of that is one that sounds very wrong But at the same time like Look what's happened with FTX Look what's happened with Celsius I mean, those are the ones that seem to be ones that committed really bad acts Then you have prime trust also And then you have the companies that went down with them Whether or not they committed bad acts in BlockFi and Voyager I mean, we can name all of them right And this kind of gives credence to the SEC's argument As far as I'm concerned, right?
There is some definitive reason Well, let me ask you this though But like if they, to your point earlier I think you made this point That if we do get an ETF It'll clean things up Right? I mean like the reason that people Had to trust an FTX or felt like they did Wanted to trust a Celsius or something else Is because our regulator, our gatekeeper Wouldn't go through the process Of approving a regular spot Bitcoin ETF Do you think that argument has any merits? Like I mean crypto people crypto don't want to get ripped off either So, so how about the regulators I'm create some alternatives Rather than just setting up blockers all the time Do you do lend any credibility to that argument?
I lend a lot of credibility to that argument So like I find that when I'm on track Phi type We'll say podcast but it's really anything loaded If it's a client call I find that I talk about that side a lot more than Side I spoke about earlier because they focus on that side So basically the whole thing is like there's two sides of the coin here But I agree with everything you said The problem is that also I would say some of the Some of it wasn't people would never bought the ETF Because they were chasing Celsius And those other actors because they were promising Like whatever Unimaginable returns and people Didn't do their research and understand how it was actually working It feels like the spider-man meme of all the spider-man Like just pointing at each other and putting each other there All right, so something new It feels like has happened this year But I want you to tell us if there really is anything new here Of course you said there were 77 different applications For Bitcoin ETFs So we'll crypto ETFs over the years But this year some new participants have thrown their hat in the ring One of which is BlackRock It was very interesting Earlier this week as well We had Larry Fink doing kind of the That's the BlackRock CEO Doing kind of a mainstream media tour And talking good things about Bitcoin And about crypto in general Which is very interesting because You know six years earlier He had called it I think the direct quote as an index Bitcoin is an index for money laundering So definitely a change Maybe some education that that happened Maybe just changed his mind Maybe has a product to sell I don't know Believe what you want to about that But BlackRock entering a $9 trillion asset manager The largest in the world Is that different There's also a stat here where They've done like over 500 different ETF applications And they only missed once It's like so they don't often miss Once they file Application so that feels new Is there something new here or is this more of the same So the one when we To go basically coin desk broke the news That they were going to file And we saw it and we me and Eric And other people are like whoa And in the industry like it's can this be true Sure enough few hours later We got the filing hit and we were like My eyes were wide open You were not expecting this So let me explain what we're expecting So like one BlackRock is the only new entrance Everybody else has already tried this this year So the only new entrance to this space To try and launch one of these is BlackRock Like even fidelity They had tried previously Yes Yes multiple times actually So there's been multiple people that Everyone else who's doing this Has already done it in the past aside from BlackRock That said we always expected BlackRock No matter at one point They were going to launch a big coin ETF Particularly after they partner with Coinbase Last year for for different things They they use Coinbase for their institutional Their institutional clients They use them for pricing into their Aladdin Some technology that BlackRock sells Which we don't need to get into But they they've had a partnership with Coinbase They we knew they weren't shining away But BlackRock is so big They have so much distribution They have so much marketing power We didn't think they were going to waste time Just fighting with the AC to get this thing launched We figured it would get approved And then BlackRock would file And they were they would be ready to go So this caught us by surprise Not that BlackRock filed at all But that they were filing to Fight with the SEC to get this thing out the door first He just thought they'd be a fast follow After somebody gets it approved Then of course BlackRock is going to throw their hat in the ring But like why be you know Mesheting your way through the jungle And be kind of a lead here Exactly And honestly you mentioned that that think interview That was like way stronger than I expected him to Like we always so one thing we also knew Once they filed this we knew Larry signed it off on this Right Larry is one of the biggest figures in traditional finance And we knew that if BlackRock filed this They knew that we're going to start a race Right They knew that we're going to If they filed that everyone else was going to file after them Because it's just the way the way things have worked historically The key difference here with what BlackRock offered And their filing as they said They were entering into a surveillance shooting agreement with the spot Bitcoin ET trading provider We guessed at the time that it was Coinbase Subsequently we learned it was definitively Coinbase after the SEC made them name it Before they could fully file So that's the big difference They entered into a surveillance sharing agreement And I mentioned those earlier as that's what the SEC has said When they denied all of these They want to surveillance sharing agreement with a regulated market of significant size I a lot of people initially said no way Coinbase is not a market of significant size I've written notes that debate the opposite Because it is the largest Bitcoin trading pair with US dollars They are the largest US exchange They are the largest exchange that accepts US dollars as an en ramp So in our mind it is a market of significant size The biggest market is obviously Binance But Binance all that is done on stablecoins like Tether and True USD And things that the government really doesn't like as it is anyway So I think it is a market of significant size Then everyone else jumped on board to try and get this Now one thing I said that I want to correct is I said BlackRockFile Technically these 19 before filings are filings from The exchanges that they're partnered with So in this case it was NASDAQ that filed this in partnership With BlackRock but it's a NASDAQ application And then we have other nice e New York Stock Exchange and CBOE Has partnered with other issuers to also file them That seems to let we blend a bit more credibility to it I don't know how this works But when you say NASDAQ plus BlackRock Is filing rather than just BlackRock That's very interesting or NASDAQ on their behalf But is this also with the comments this week from Larry Fink Is this also a signal from BlackRock Or are they trying to broadcast something Or are they trying to say Hold on US regulators You've gone a little bit too far We actually want to lean into this asset class And if you're not going to let us do it in the US Then we're going to fall behind all of the other jurisdictions Is this a kind of a coordinated pushback?
Is there a signal or should we Should I not read that into what the messages that are going on here So I would say that that's putting your tinfoil hat on a little bit That might be the case honestly We also thought that it's because of BlackRock Let's be clear BlackRock is the gorilla in the room BlackRock is 31, 33% of US ETF assets Vanguard is 28% and then everybody else is nowhere close So it's BlackRock and Vanguard Vanguard is never will never file for Bitcoin ETF if I had to guess Maybe very far down the line But they're more conservative It's not they don't have a gold ETF It's not something they believe in It's not something they do There are low costs, index, equity, and bond That's what they do Like that's what they specialize in They don't even have a gold ETF Jack Boldold didn't believe John Boldold didn't believe in investing in gold To be And he hated crypto Bitcoin But he's not there anymore They've changed a lot of things that he didn't like He also didn't like ETFs I thought they promoted too He thought they promoted too much trading He much preferred the old mutual fund index fund cheap Yeah, but he was for stocks Yeah, he was a sure Yeah, exactly Eric Beltunus, my boss has written a note basically says DeFi people can learn a thing from Jack Boldold It's called Haitians, crypto natives You learn that Yeah, I forgot where I was going with that Well, let me just ask you So BlackRock filing Is that just slam dunk like it's going to happen now Or is that not the case Because I was giving you that like that track record Which you you you know I think maybe I probably read it from a tweet that you put out Which is like Yeah, it was only missed that ounce Out of 500 Yeah, it's five We've said five 75 I think the technical number is five 46 I'm upon like super close inspection That we could find but we could be missing some But either way it's over 500 they've only lost one And that one that they lost It was for something called a non-transparent active ETF Or we call them ant active non-transparent And it's just a structure that doesn't have the same like Most ETFs are fully transparent So you can see what's in the ETF every single day When it's trading you know exactly how much of each stock Or bond or whatever And this is like where it's kind of hidden a little bit So people can't frontrun you And that was in 2014 and they approved these things in 2018 I think 2019 something like that But it ultimately did get approved They were just early So that's a good sign The other point is like If you look at biddo which is the first But futures Bitcoin ETF in the US That thing got one and a half billion dollars in two days That has 96% of the Bitcoin futures ETF assets And 99 I don't know what the numbers are But it's like nine over it's in the 90s percent Is the one billion One billion in two days is that good That was the best launch ever So the previous record was GLD The gold ETF in 2004 Which hit over a billion in three days Which let's be clear a billion dollars in 2004 It's worth a lot more To the billion dollars in 2021 But that's the way we We're kind of having to look at it But even still biddo would it beat it Because they went to 1.
5 after two days So it wasn't like they just cracked the one billion dollar mark So and but the problem is like they're a first mover vantage So if BlackRock thinks they could possibly Be first and get that type of exposure And charge relatively high fees compared to what they're used to charging The odds don't have to be very high For them to take that swing right Like if the benefit was not that high Maybe they wouldn't have taken this risk But I think the this is me playing devil's advocate a bit Like they don't have to like even if they think the odds are 10% Or 20% that could be out first Like the benefit of getting what they think maybe 2 billion dollars in a week Or 10 billion dollars in a year And charging 50 60 70 basis points On that is very strong even for BlackRock Despite the amount of assets they have That's a lot of margin that they can get So like the benefit of being first and doing that Is pretty strong So and the downsides are Yeah, so what they have another loss on the record And they piss off some people at the SEC Like there's very little downside in my eyes But that said BlackRock is not in the game of filing things Willy-Nilly just throwing spaghetti at the wall Right, this is not a company that's going to do that This is not a company that's just going to jump into this Without doing their due diligence And they also have very close ties with the government They've done some of the they've helped the government do Like different exchanges The Fed do different things with buying programs So there's a lot of I don't want to say it's not a revolving door But it kind of is there's a lot of people that Are at BlackRock who are at the SEC and vice versa So I mean there's a close relationship there There has to be some political pressure Building on the SEC to kind of do something And this is why I'm just like Totally speculating But it feels like it's it's never been closer Even though SEC is you know in 2023 Especially been very anti crypto I mean this feels pretty big But you do think still James There is there is a possibility There's always a possibility But like it's not a remote possibility That Gary and SEC could still deny BlackRock That's still on the menu right Yeah let's be I'll be very blunt If you look at all the things that they have said And written over the last three years This will be denied But there's a lot there's a lot of circumstantial evidence That suggests that It will be approved It goes back to what I said They come back into whatever decision they want to Okay well you said two things there James I want to be clear So you think that If you look at the history of the last three years And what they kind of you know said Then it looks like it's a denial Yet when you look at the circumstantial evidence You think that it's maybe pointing to an approval Yep Exactly so like we'll act rock jumping in We think race scale is going to win their lawsuit So race scale is lawsuit is hinging It's called an administrative procedures act If you are in the US and you heard about Like some overturning of the EPA Saying they overreach their bounds And stuff that the Supreme Court has done The administrative procedures act basically says Like you overstep your power Or you didn't treat like situations alike And that's what this one is And race scale's whole basis is like You can't approve futures ETFs And then not approve spot ETFs Because the futures market And the spot market are completely intertwined Which is an argument that everyone has been making Since the futures ETFs were approved But the SEC has basically said There's still no way to detect fraud In manipulation in the underlying spot market Which again is a kind of an overreach From anything they've done for other commodity ETFs Like if that was the case Then we shouldn't have oil ETFs Because OPEC is completely manipulating that market So you can push arguments and push buttons In any different way that you want But yeah So there's a lot of circumstantial things But we think the SEC is going to lose that lawsuit To race scale And what that means is the judges will Almost certainly say Look you can't deny for the reasons you gave Go back to the drawing board And either the SEC is going to have to approve Gray scale's application That they're suing over Which is to convert GBTC to an ETF Or they're going to have to deny For other or those same reasons And additional reasons on top of it That make it so that the situations Are not like for like So there's pressure building For multiple angles here Not only do you have like You know Larry Larry think And you black rock In kind of the 77 previous application Of crypto ETFs You also have this Gray scale lawsuit And what's the timeline Around the gray scale lawsuit Like is there any When would the court Have to make a decision by Yeah, so with the The decision need to be done And it we it doesn't have to be done So that that's not that the courts Kind of like roll through things Right But our litigation analysts Elliott Stein who I work with Expected it by the end of before the end of the third quarter So that's before the end of September So in the next couple months here We're expecting it this year Wow really The one but the one thing I would say To caveat everything we just said The circumstantial evidence is There's hard evidence that the SEC Is suing coin base And they're the people that are going to be Like the stodian for this black rock ETF They are going to be the surveillance sharing agreement partner And What they're suing is obviously They're suing coin base of other things Not Bitcoin Exactly that's the key point here Right the SEC is It will Bitcoin is the one thing That Gary will admit is commodity It's not a security He's suing coin base and finance Finance for every different things They're accusing finance of fraud Minipular practices, wash trading Spoof trading, spoofing All the things you name it They're accusing finance They're not accusing coin base of that They're saying they're basically And on registered securities broker Because they're trading securities on their platform So they're focused on different securities So that in my mind If Gary and the SEC Are going to back down anywhere And give like bend a little bit On this front It'll be on the bitcoins That's what it's felt like to me But of course you know better But so are you over under On a spot Bitcoin ETF By the end of 2023 So this goes back So now we get again to the detail That's something we didn't talk about Okay When BlackRock filed There was so I talked about 19 before process Right so you submit the application The exchange sends it to the SEC And the SEC has some time period Before they have to accept it and acknowledge it Or they send it back And they basically say You didn't do this With BlackRock that's what they did With all the CBOE filings Vanak bit Bitwise at NIC You name it Invest go in Galaxy Wisdom tree They sent them all back And said you can't submit this With the surveillance sharing agreement Without telling us who it is And giving us more information This happened recently Wasn't this Yes Yeah This was a Wall Street Journal article And which was not surprising The SEC was never Can't approve these things Because these filings Said they were going to enter into an SSA Right So it wasn't surprising that they shot them back But the key difference here Is that 21 shares Which is an ETF issue In Europe they hone They have the most crypto ETFs launched In Europe based in Switzerland But they partner with ARC Which is a big ETF issue We're here in the US to launch an ETF They were denied recently This is ARC This is Cathy Woods Cathy Woods She partnered with Cathy Woods So Cathy Woods has been on the board for 21 shares We actually just did a podcast Yesterday Two days ago with the president of 21 shares If anyone's interested So she gave us some insight into what they're seeing on their end But that's on the Trillian's podcast Sorry to promote some of these No, we're not doing anything on it In the show notes So Trillian's podcast Okay Yeah, that's Bell Trillian's podcast So They filed So they were denied Them and Van Eck were denied And then the SEC I told you issued those dissent letters But after they were denied ARC in 21 shares Got right back on the horse and applied again I'm pretty sure it was So they basically applied Not too long after we heard the oral Argumage in the grayscale case And that's when we got We were like After hearing the judges' conversation With the grayscale lawyers And the SEC lawyers We were confident that grayscale had a legitimate shot To win the case Not guaranteed Obviously we'd My litigation And let's put it at like a 70% odds of grayscale winning And we talk about what that means Really But They filed So I think they filed because of that Right And they wanted to have An application Outstanding with the SEC So they submitted that on April 25th And then the SEC acknowledged it on May 9th So the only application that's active In that 19 B4 process Where I talk about that 45 day 45 day 90 60 day Process The only ETF that was active Or the application that was active Was ARC 21 shares in partnership with CBOE So then BlackRock dropped this application On June 15th CBOE and a bunch of issuers And NYC and Bitwise filed suit And they were bounced back by the SEC And then the first one we saw Is ARC 21 shares submitted an amendment So basically their clock has already started So we have a date We have dates on when we know the SEC Needs to issue a response Delay, deny, approve For ARC 21 shares All the other ones were sent back And bounced back to the issuers in the exchanges And they had to refile The SEC hasn't acknowledged those And basically had knowledge Means they post it to the federal register But like it's essentially The SEC says we got these And they post them to their website And then we get dates of when These things are going to happen But the only ETF that we know exactly What those dates are right now Is ARC 21 shares And the next The fun The interesting thing is the SEC On June 15th Came out and issued ARC 21 shares a delay But the deadline was until June 29th So the SEC was required to respond With the delay deny approved By June 29th and they delayed On June 15th The day that BlackRock and Nasdaq filed their application The next date is August 13th Now again the SEC that's a deadline They can go before that But at the end of that 240 day time period Is January 10th of 2024 So we will have an answer by January 10th, 2024 At the very least No way And okay So this would be basically Like the 21 shares The ARC one that you mentioned That's kind of the leader That's the first one And like the way It would be very difficult for the SEC To deny this one And then like approve some of the others in queue Right So is that why you're thinking That this January 10th, 2024 date Is kind of the last and final Cannot be delayed any longer date On which this entire crop Of ETFs in this season In this cycle Given this political climate Will either be approved or denied Yeah, so let's be very clear The Alkary has also filed in Nasdaq So they also, Nasdaq is the one They're further along in their agreement with Coinbase We don't know exactly where it is But there's different language So in the first filings We saw expecting to enter Into a surveillance sharing agreement Right Expecting So the CBOE still said that In their amendments and they name Coinbase But the BlackRock ones Said they executed a term sheet So there's like I don't know exactly what all these mean From a legal perspective CBOE says their term sheet is already Ready to go too But essentially BlackRock and Nasdaq Well specifically Nasdaq is further along Than CBOE and NYC Right So they have gotten further along in the process So If for some reason Which I can't I don't think this is going to happen That like CBOE can't enter into an SSA With With Coinbase That's the one thing that differentiates BlackRock And Nasdaq's application Then maybe they could deny Our 21 shares and approve Some BlackRock But that would be shock That would be absolutely shocking to me But also what the SSA could do is They could approve Like I said There's all those deadlines But the SSA can make a decision Whenever they want Right They just have to have a decision Before those deadlines For example They went 14 days on arc and delayed it Initially I thought that The first deadline So August 13th With these surveillance sharing agreement information If they delay there Then it's probably just going to get denied The more I look at it The more I talk to people This is going to require a long conversation This is this whole process Is going to be a back and forth Between these issuers, the exchanges And the SEC So I would say now That if they do delay At the first instance of the BlackRock And all these other applications And arc 21 shares in August I expect BlackRock's deadline to be I'll tell you right now I'm estimating Because it depends when Like I said The SEC doesn't always acknowledge them On the same time frame But it'd be like the The first week of September That we would get a delay And I approve on the BlackRock and other ones Got it So this is all kind of coming to a head Over the next few months And this also matches the And January 10th might be Might be a date At least for the 21 shares arc one 2024 But this also Is interesting timing With the grayscale case Which you said a decision could be made Don't know when But September is a possibility here So all of these dates are kind of You're like Narrowing in By the way, just a quick A side quest on the grayscale thing GBTC That was a I think a Cause or Folks in crypto Have said that Not having an ETF And being reliant on GBDC Caused a whole cascade Of shitty things To happen in 2024 Right we had Three hours capital in solvency Which let this I have strong views here Give me your strong views Okay, cause so there's a crypto narrative Around something that you know People want to blame the GBDC And the SEC Not approving an ETF And others will say Well that had nothing to do with it What's your take James?
It did have something to do with it A lot of these applications Have said including grayscale And their applications to prove It's like this product is broken Retelling but The SEC's goal is to protect investors Right and this product is broken A lot of retail investors got hurt Or have been hurt by the The huge discount And one of the arguments has Historically been look at what we have In the market now there's already things Out there people are using Micro strategy to get exposure Like an ETF is a proven Rapper that we know That's so crazy to Investors by the way That we have to use Micro strategy And Michael sailor has a proxy To getting Bitcoin exposure In a public That's crazy Yes, it's but the SEC has come back And said they don't take that into Consideration and look They're trading as a markets Way that they're looking at things Right they just basically said They don't care about that That's not something they're worried about They they acknowledge the situation The flip side of this Which I do agree with all this thing said Is we might not have found out This shit that three AC and FTX We're doing without this entire blow up Is it could have gone on longer Exactly If the SEC had approved these things We might not have caught all this This fraud Bliton fraud that happened Or I guess I shouldn't say blatant Because it hasn't been proven yet But it's likely to be proved Seems pretty blatant in the FTS FTX's case But I mean you look on the three AC Which arguably triggered like what's Like they were also triggered by the Luna stuff So it was all kind of related Genesis is having issues Because of this it Block five was heavily invested in the GBTC stuff It doesn't look like block fried necessary You're saying you're saying you're like Well the ETF not approving the ETF is To blame here but like Consider yourself blessed crypto market This needed to happen This is a cancer that needed to be caught up Cut out at this point in time It would have just consumed the entire body If we had another like three to five years For this malignant tumor to kind of grow And it would have been far less And to continue it sharing leverage And doing things And they should be doing Yeah so I tweeted today I made the argument that like You know like this might have been like One of the best things the SEC could have done For the long term health of the crypto And bitcoin markets specifically Because they didn't allow people to get out of it Basically it comes down to the fact that people couldn't access Access the underlying value of the bitcoin In GBTC What you can do in ETF So because they couldn't access the underlying Bitcoin They couldn't like Cover up all the other shit they were doing I didn't expect to come near to the end of this episode And say Thanks Gary But maybe maybe that's a part of the conclusion here Just a couple other points before we Before we depart on this on this issue So one is that Bitcoin ETF spot bitcoin ETFs are already Outside of the US This is already happening in other jurisdictions Is that correct?
Yes there are Canadian spot Bitcoin ETFs As of 2021 2022 Early 20 I don't even remember 2021 2022 I don't remember the exact date They're even long before long before that they were available in Europe They're not technically ETFs in Europe They're what's called ETCs But functionally their ETFs They're spot backed Physically backed Bitcoin ETFs And they have plenty of other crypto ETFs They have some stuff I mean they had an FTX ETF in Europe They'd be in B ETF in Europe They have a lot of like things in the US It's very far away from ever getting to So Do with that information while you'll But yeah And the other thing is I want to say is like They've been around They were around for all this crazy stuff that happened And they handled everything perfectly There was no issues No new issues with accessing the underlying asset There was no issues with Bitcoin just not being in the On the wallets that you expected it to be And the traded very smoothly A traded very tight It was about as efficient or as good as you could Hope that it would be And it should be used as an example of What we can do here in the US And I know for a fact what the SEC will say Because they've said in the past is Where the oldest most trusted financial markets So we're going to have more requirements And blah blah If you look to other markets These things have handled even Brazil Brazil has about Bitcoin ETFs from Hashtags Which I mentioned two-gram before But Hashtags is a crypto ETF provider That basically Partnered with two-gram to take over their application Because two-gram was like We're not first like it doesn't matter to us Anywhere but Hashtags is provider That wanted access to the US market And they partnered with them to launch it So Hashtags which is ticker DeFi We haven't something we haven't touched on yet It's the only 33-act Bitcoin futures ETF 33-act futures ETFs are the only ones that can hold Spot Bitcoin So theoretically if we do get an approval here That could be the first ETF On US exchange that holds Spot Bitcoin They would just have to change the prospectus And file an amendment with the SEC and get accepted But theoretically they could be one of the first ones holding Spot Bitcoin That's interesting Oh okay, so Ethereum Hasn't ETF Is that happening any time soon No Unfortunately not Why not?
Because There is Ethereum futures ETFs And I thought they were going to come quickly After the Bitcoin futures ETFs But Gensler and his SEC Bounced that back immediately Right after in early 2022 I said I gave it a year And I said we'd have futures ETFs So within a year of the Bitcoin futures ETFs And I got that blatantly wrong And basically it's because the The SEC is like arguing now That ETH is security They won't say They probably based that on the Hinman speech Like kind of the SEC Yeah exactly Based on the Hinman speech I thought for sure it was going to the fact That we had futures The volume on the futures in the CME were strong And the fact that it follows the same It would follow the same path that Bitcoin did But Gary has held the line And almost regressed on the SEC's posture towards 100% has regressed Yeah, I totally agree with that So not having any time in the US But is Well actually let me give you one caveat It's not happening Unless Congress steps in I'll give you multiple caveats Unless Congress steps in Give some regulatory oversight And clarity Please Congress Yeah But that I won't hold my breath for that to happen The other thing is it's not going to happen With Gary at the helm So if a Republican wins In the presidential election Gary will likely not be at the helm of the SEC And then you'll have somebody in the Republican So theoretically Republicans have been more pro ETH crypto Bitcoin On that side of things So you could get one that way But still seems very unlikely Because you would have to undo some precedent That the SEC has already sent And set in different ways But like I said, Ethereum futures We had Ethereum futures Like you mean one second They'll take exactly one We had Ethereum futures ETFs apply in June No in May Of this year Yeah, we had So basically what happened there was Gray skill applied on May 9th For a few three ETFs And they would go under that 75 Checking clock time period One of them was a futures ETF And then four issuers followed suit immediately The next day and applied for any Ethereum futures ETFs And those were denied One of the ETFs that's likely going to launch on It'll be approved I'll tell you exact date July 23rd This is this is also kind of comical Because it looks like I see it's going to have to let it go through Because it satisfies all the rules they have But what it'll do it's It's going to hold a slew of international Bitcoin ETFs, the likes of Canada And Europe And for like 40% of the fund And the other 60% It's going to hold Bitcoin miners And that's so basically So give me that's a silly product I feel like But okay I don't know if the I don't know if So one thing is that Grace it's called the grace scale Global Bitcoin composite ETFs But they're using ticker BTC And there's some wonky stuff here But I think they need the file Have an active application Because they're hold on the ticker BTC Might have gone So I don't know if they actually plan To launch this But if they do It would be completely It just shows the ridiculousness of Like the SEC's current stance And even if you talk to Anyone in this for the most part They agreed that Old proving future's dying spot It doesn't make a lot of sense Even people who are The Abinley Anticripto So those people tend to advocate For the position that the SEC Is going to have to Basically reverse the decision In approving futures ETFs for Bitcoin In order to get out of this Can they do that?
They can't reverse They have done it in some instances in the past But it would It would probably open them up to more lawsuits Wow, this is very fascinating Of course this You know it comes into play When you have a gatekeeper Over a kind of Your tokenization Types of events Of of which Gear against the SEC is James as we get to kind of the The end of this episode Concluding question to me is Some people will have been listening to this Being fascinated by This exploration of ETFs And and how this works And all the people involved The companies, all of these things And then they'll ask the The question of like Well, why do I care?
Like I could just go by Bitcoin or Ether any asset That I want on Coinbase This isn't a very bankless product Is it an ETF product By definition custody By someone So is by definition banked Can you tell us the price here Like what Markets does a Bitcoin ETF Actually open up Like why is this good for maybe For people who are very price conscious Bitcoin price Or for Bitcoin Being price exposure Being in the hands of more people Why is even having a Bitcoin ETF A good thing How does it affect the market How does it affect price From your perspective I mean the dumbest answer is That is just another way Another market In a way that people could buy But the really way I look at it It's going to act like a bridge Right There are going to be some people To go in this way And might go over to the bankless side of things Right Like it's that's not That's how a lot of people have acted I know for a fact Some people have gone Through the grayscale option And then have figured out ways To do it differently The other side of it Is it just opens a whole bunch of people There's a lot of endowments Pension funds Institutions that have mandates And what they can and cannot invest in And a lot of them say They can only invest in securities Or they can only invest in securities And debt instruments So they are literally Against it would be against their mandate Against like everything They were founded on to hold Bitcoin directly So when you have an ETF All of a sudden Any ETF is securities So you're wrapping And you're able to hold it In that instance So that's just opens up For a lot of different people To hold this and use it or trade it If you will The other side of it is In the US I hinted at I said this before There's $30 trillion with advisors And advisors love ETF Specifically independent advisors But because it's the most tried and true Trusted practice So if there are products out there On ramp and other things They're trying to work with advisors To custody the assets for their clients If you had an advisor Typically the way they make money now It used to be Like you get paid Commission kickbacks For selling those mutual funds Now it's a more fiduciary standard And you get paid Say Or if I was your advisor I get paid like the average Just like 1% of your assets every year And so What's happened in many instances Is clients of them Of these advisors One they couldn't They had no way to get access To the crypto markets or Bitcoin So their clients were doing it on their own And they don't know what they're doing So they don't know what their riskous fosures are They don't know like They wouldn't The advisor one Just from like This is a pro love This is a positive way to look at it Like the advisor doesn't know That the client is risking all this money In this market that they can control The other part of it is Selfish is that it's not under their umbrella Where they can charge the 1% fee So they would much rather Bring that Under the 1% Under the umbrella where they can charge for it Any of the parties like I mentioned this on ramp allows you to kind of do it directly There's other competitors that are trying to Would allow advisors to store In cold storage wallets or what have you But It's for most of these advisors They're not going to be putting significant client assets In these things right They're going to give them 1,5% exposure to something like this They probably would honestly prefer Like a crypto index ETF To put like a couple percentage exposure And if you're going to be doing that You don't want to be setting up Like tons of different contracts With different providers and custodians Like it's just so much easier to be like I can just hit click and buy for these clients And then I have it under my traditional financial It basically takes Bitcoin And puts it in the traditional financial rail So this is what GBC did GBC did but in a less efficient manner We talked about all the issues with that But this would be the holy grail of doing that As far as I'm concerned I've actually talked with The CEO of OTC markets Which is where GBC trades A lot of these pink sheets think penny stocks But they have a market And he thinks Another area is these things will trade as Basically Depository receipts I think that might happen as well But I think just an ETF is a tried and true Tried and true A technology wrapper An easy way to do this We know it will work We know it's clean We know it's efficient And people would love If they want exposure That's how they'll get it Fantastic summary James I appreciate all your help on this I think that the bottom line For bank listeners For those crypto investors On the journey is This could be a bull catalyst Of course The exposure of Potentially You know tens of trillions of dollars Into crypto the opportunity To purchase an ETF Could affect price In some way If the demand is there I'll give you one counteracting point That We had CMA futures launched At the end of 2017 In early 2018 And Bitcoin futures ETFs Launched at the end of October in 2021 So If you've been able to kill the market In 2017 Yeah Yeah The more the hidden market is What's already dead man Like crypto's doing bad You know How we're expecting It's a very different market cycle right now But who knows where we'll be in January Yeah That's a great point James This has been incredibly helpful Some action items for the bankless nation I think the first action item is You should go follow James on Twitter If you want updates On the Bitcoin ETF James What's your Twitter handle J-S-E-Y-F-F There you go We'll include a link in the show notes James I just want to thank you for coming on bankless It's been a lot of fun today Yeah, thanks for having me Ron Also another action item In the show notes The 21 shares podcast that James mentioned Will include a link to that Gotta end with this Risk and disclaimers Crypto is risky price goes up And down We don't know when we're getting an ETF All of crypto is risky You could lose what you put in But we are headed west This is the frontier It's not for everyone But we're glad you're with us On the bankless journey Thanks a lot