Sam Kazemian is the founder of Frax, the fractional-algorithmic stablecoin protocol. After co-founding the decentralized Wikipedia startup Everipedia, Sam set out to pioneer the algorithmic stablecoin space. The FRAX stablecoin now has a market cap of over $2.6 billion, and the protocol’s FXS governance token is up 300% in the last year.
In this episode, we explore the Stablecoin Wars, in which different protocols compete for liquidity and composability in DeFi. Sam brings a 1st-person perspective into the developments surrounding UST and the recently launched 4pool on Curve, which consists of stablecoins UST, FRAX, USDT, and USDC.
A highlight of this conversation is Sam’s parable of an archetypal central bank, in which he cruises through a number of salient takes on money markets and macroeconomics. There is a lot to learn about this Cambrian explosion of financial technology, and Sam is a great teacher. Stick around to find out why walked away from this conversation bullish on Frax.
------ 📣 M·A·C: NFT | Keith Haring Collection for a Good Cause https://bankless.cc/MAC
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALED ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🏦 ALTO IRA | TAX-FREE CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/AltoIRA
👻 AAVE V3 | LEND & BORROW CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/aave
⚡️ MAKER DAO | THE DAI STABLECOIN https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 3:30 Sam from Frax 7:50 The Stablecoin Narrative 13:45 The Central Bank Parable 24:45 Backing an Exchange Rate
28:10 Frax Analytics | What is Frax? 37:34 Frax Analytics | The Peg 42:30 Frax Analytics | Comparing 45:03 RSA Gets Frax-Pilled
49:42 MIM vs UST 53:16 The LUNA Token 56:41 Frax Roadmap | FPI
1:04:36 The 4pool 1:14:00 The Stablecoin Wars 1:18:35 What Happens Next? 1:23:20 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Sam on Twitter https://twitter.com/samkazemian
Frax Finance https://app.frax.finance/
Decentralized Finance and the Debt Cycles https://academy.blue-swan.io/blog/decentralized-finance-and-the-debt-cycles
Market Share Chart https://www.theblockcrypto.com/data/decentralized-finance/stablecoins/total-crypto-backed-and-algorithmic-stablecoin-supply
Do Kwon’s 4pool Tweet https://twitter.com/stablekwon/status/1510021707377287170
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Stable coins are one of the three trillion dollar narratives of crypto and I think that three trillion dollar narratives are Bitcoin, ETH, and stable coins. Hey, Bankless Nation. We've got a fantastic episode for you today. This is the stable coin wars we're talking to Sam from Frax who is deep in the stable coin wars. He's he's one of them actually and you know his framing is maybe not so much wars, but we're going to talk all about Algo stable coins. We're going to talk about UST, the four pool curve pool that was just launched. What all this means how it turns into actually we are pre recording this entire episode.
So we've already had our conversation with Sam and it's a fantastic conversation. David what were some of your takeaways? Well first off, Sam, Sam starts the the conversation with a story about Central Baking kind of a made up story of a parable but really grounds. We like to say a number of times before in Bankless that crypto is just speedrunning the history of money and finance and so Sam speedruns through the history of Central Bank management right in a very fantastic story that really frames the whole rest of the conversation and I had a fantastic time to sitting and listening to that story and had so much to learn just in that one story and I kind of understood exactly how the rest of the conversation was going to unfold because of that story.
So I'm excited for listeners to be able to because that's where this conversation starts first, but then we even get to lean into again the four pool, the USC, the Doquon spiciness and how frax has gotten caught up in the middle of this two fraxes benefit. Yeah, I'm gonna be honest David, I walked away from this conversation really bullish on frax. Yeah, like really actually excited. It's been a while since the project it was just like wow, this is really neat and so we were in we were in education though that that entire time actually like on the receiving end learning. Guys, we're going to get to that conversation one quick announcement though.
We've been telling you for the last week or so about these M-A-C-N-F-T's from consensus Keith Herring NFTs were telling you that that was released would be released on April the 10th, which is National HIV Youth Awareness HIV and AIDS Awareness Day. Those NFTs have been released. Okay, a whole bunch of them are sold out. I managed to get my Keith Herring Red just now because I think the yellows are sold out, but the reds there are still some reds left at least right now. I minted this baby. I actually you could pay in credit card David so I didn't have to spend any ether on this. What? No gas fees paid with the credit card.
I don't want to pay you bought one. You have to spend any youth. Yeah dude so I no gas fees I just like and it's minted on polygon so this is it. This is my OpenC account. It says the floor price is 179 okay but there's I'm sure there's no liquidity on this. These red you pay $25 for and of course all of the proceeds go to 100% of the revenue I should say go to support national or go to support AIDS and HIV youth affected by by that disease. So super cool there and there's still time. There's 195 owners of it and there's and there's 250 total left so that is 55 of these ones left and you say there's no liquidity you want it but that's because no one's buying a hundred and eighty dollar NFT that they can go and buy for a hundred and fifty dollars.
Yeah yeah that's no liquidity. Well there you go so anyway there's still an opportunity to do that just enter your email address again no gas fees so quick PSA there that's the status. David I want to ask you the question I ask you before all of these episodes which is what is the state of the nation today? Oh the state of the nation today Ryan is learning. We are learning. We're learning every single bankless episode but we're learning a lot. Sam had a lot to teach us. He's a great teacher he's a great orator and so I just felt like I was in the middle of like both a history lesson and a lesson in finance and economics and it's my favorite type of show when when I am not only learning but also being entertained at the same time and so the state of the nation today Ryan is learning.
All right great episode. Learn with us guys on the state of the nation we'll be right back with Sam but before we do we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Ava is the leading decentralized liquidity protocol and now Ava V3 is here. Ava V3 has powerful new features to enable you to get the most out of D5 including isolation mode which allows for many more markets to be launched with more exotic collateral types and also efficiency mode which allows for a higher loan to value ratios and of course portals allowing users to port their Ava position across all of the networks that Ava operates on like polygon, phantom, avalanche, arbitrum, optimism and harmony.
The beautiful thing about Ava is that it's completely open source decentralized and governed by its community enabling a truly bank this future for us all. To get your first crypto collateralized loan get started at Ava.com that's A-A-B-E.com and also check out the Ava protocol governance forums to see what more than a hundred thousand down members are all roving about at governance.Ava.com. MakerDow is the OG D5 protocol. The MakerDow produces dye. The industry's most battle tested and resilient stablecoin. Using Maker you don't need to sell your collateral if you need liquidity. Instead you can spin up a Maker Vault and use your collateral to mint dye directly.
With Maker the power to mint new money is in your hands. The Maker Protocol is extremely hardened and operated by one of the most experienced dows in existence. They've been here since the beginning. They've seen it all and so you can mint dye with the assurance that your collateral is safe. Soon Maker will be present on all chains and altos so minting dye can take place on oasis.app, zaryon, zapper or any other D5 protocol that you use. Follow Maker on Twitter at MakerDow and learn from the oldest and most resilient down existence. The Brave Browser is the user first browser for the web3 internet with over 50 million monthly active users.
Control your digital footprint with built-in privacy and ad blocking. Inside the Brave Browser you'll find the Brave Wallet. The first secure crypto wallet built natively inside of a web3 crypto browser. Web3 is freedom from big tech and wall street. More control and better privacy but there's a weak point in web3, your crypto wallet. The Brave Wallet is different. Brave Wall is built natively inside the Brave Browser. No extension required which gives the Brave Wallet an extra level of security versus other wallets. With the Brave Wallet you can buy, store, send and swap your crypto assets and it can even manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and D5 apps all from the security of the best privacy browser on the market.
Whether you're new to crypto or in season pro, it's time to switch to the Brave Wallet. Download Brave at brave.com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. Bankless Nation, we are super excited to introduce our next guest, Sam Kasmian. He's the founder of Frax Finance. A lot of Fs there. He previously got into crypto, same way David Hoffman and my co-hosted by a GPU mining. He also worked on the decentralized Wikipedia project everpedia but in 2019 he started this really interesting algorithmic slash hybrid stablecoin project called Frax Finance which is the topic of today's show because we're going to talk about stablecoins and be some of the stablecoin wars that are going on and what Sam thinks of the situation.
Sam welcome to Bankless. How you doing? I'm doing great. Thanks for having me. This is awesome. A huge listener and excited to be on, discuss everything. Stablecoins, crypto economics. Awesome. Well, we're going to get I think in the back half of this conversation to some of what people are calling the stablecoin wars with the introduction of this four pool on curve and sort of what that means. But I think we should start with maybe the top explaining Frax a little bit. But before we do, I want to talk maybe get some context on why the stablecoins are in the focus of all of crypto right now. So there seems to be like this narrative of stablecoin wars and a lot of conversation around UST these days and algorithmic stablecoins.
This wasn't the case in 2019 when you started Frax, right? Like stablecoins weren't as talked about and certainly algorithmic stablecoins weren't in the limelight. Why do you think everyone is having this conversation now, Sam? Yeah, definitely. That's a great question. So like you said, I've been in the crypto space for a while, kind of like how David got into it. I got in around 2013, 2014 ish. I was at UCLA college student and I started kind of just mining crypto currencies. Dogecoin was actually the first one. I started mining. I still remember being like one of the first people to sign up for the ETH newsletter when it was announced in like 2014 when Vitalik started talking about ETH and back then it was a counter party and colored coins were the thing, right?
As you guys probably remember. And stablecoins were not even in the conceptual like framework back then, right? The earliest thing that's kind of I think I like to call the stablecoin white paper is Robert Sam's the signer it shares white paper, which some people might have read. I actually like to call it like it's one of the most kind of like important pieces in like stablecoin design because it introduced the two token system of you know you have a stablecoin on a blockchain and then you have a share token or like you know the volatile token that represents you know future cash flow or signage or whatever and you could try to stabilize these things.
And that was even before you know smart contracts came out. His thing his white paper was about proof of work blockchain. You just have a proof of work blockchain and you know you have two tokens in it instead of you know one one volatile one. And so the industry has come a really really long way, right? And just like how there's really important trends that you know grow exponentially like DeFi summer 2020, right? Like all of the yield farming DeFi primitives and all these things and then NFTs I think the next big thing is stablecoins. And the reason for that is I think the infrastructure and the ability to launch your own you know stable asset is finally mature enough to have that kind of Cambrian explosion, right?
Like I actually like to kind of say there's you can now there's like a WordPress of stablecoins that right? You can you can create your you just you need like a deep curve pool or you need the three pool or something some really concentrated liquidity. You have to make sure to give enough yield there. And it's like a cookie cutter playbook now, right? The infrastructure is there just like how the infrastructure for NFTs with OpenC and minting and in generative art and stuff was there and then you have this kind of curve, right? We're at the point where you have the infrastructure to kind of cookie cutter stablecoins.
So there's going to be a Cambrian explosion of these kinds of things I think in the next you know from now until the next like 12 months basically. Do you think we had a guest recently who said stablecoin is crypto's killer app? Would you go as far as to say that? Like stablecoin is the big thing that you know crypto is meant to deliver? I think stablecoins are one of the three trillion dollar narratives of crypto. And I think the three trillion dollar narratives are Bitcoin, ETH and stablecoins. That's my view. And so that's why I got really interested in stablecoins. That's why I have like kind of I look at it from a historical point of view like you know the first you know stablecoin white paper you know this and where Frax falls in line and maker and all these things.
I try to actually almost study it like a like a evolution right? And I think it is a trillion dollar narrative and so I actually am of the belief like for example Bitcoin is a different kind of asset and ETH is a different kind of asset and stablecoins are a different kind of asset. All three have such large potential that they're the three in my opinion multi trillion dollar you know narratives the T the T size narratives of crypto. People have spent their entire careers focusing in on stable coins when there's so much to pay attention to in the crypto industry sometimes people just get compelled by stablecoins and that's just the thing that they are interested in.
And inside of that algorithmic stablecoins have had their own very rich history in the crypto industry. There's plenty plenty of history lessons to learn as Algo stablecoins have tried to get out the door. There's there's the the story of basis then there's like the exploding stablecoins of empty set dollar and dynamic set dollar and it really took a while for the Algo stablecoins to really get their engine revving. I think Frax being one of the first models of the stablecoins that the kind of algorithmic stablecoins that really started to work and then USD being the second one but correct me if I'm wrong Sam but we've never seen a pure Algo stablecoin actually work.
Frax has algorithmic components USD has algorithmic components but they all step away from the purely algorithmic stablecoin model. And I'm wondering if you think that the Algo stablecoin model is actually impossible it just based on perhaps some of the design decisions that goes into Algo stablecoins. Do you think it's at all possible to produce a purely algorithmic stablecoin? That's a good question and in fact I think a short story about central banking is like a good way to frame this conversation and I actually got this short story from JP Koning's blog who's like a money blogger but basically this should kind of answer your question.
This is like a short story about a central bank so it goes like this at the beginning there's a central bank and the issue pieces of paper that say one ounce of gold dominant and everyone's familiar with this and every single day there's a redemption window at the central bank physically and people are able to come and give their pieces of paper to the central bank to get an ounce of gold for each one. And the next part of the story goes that central bank says that hey there's a two-month renovation at the central bank and so we have to close the redemption window but the gold is all there for every one piece of paper that says an ounce of gold there's an ounce of gold at the central bank but we're closing redemption for two months because the central bank has renovations and it's going to open after two months okay after two months the central bank officials come and say okay actually the renovations are taking much longer than we thought it's going to take six months more and the central bank is still closed but we can't just have these pieces of paper that say they have one ounce of gold written on them not trade for an ounce of gold right especially because you know there haven't been redemption for two months so what we're going to do is every day the central bank officials are going to go in the central bank grab some of the gold go out into the trading markets and buy and sell the pieces of paper for an ounce of gold from the gold that they take out the central bank aka they're going to provide liquidity at the exchange rate of these pieces of paper and every day they're going to go back and get more gold if they need to or they're going to buy more of the pieces of paper for an ounce of gold to make sure that the exchange rate of the pieces of paper that say an ounce of gold stay there but no redemption right this the central bank is under construction no redemption no one-to-one getting from the central bank but the gold is still there it's all it's all one-to-one backed by a vehicle okay so after the six months of the renovation turn around and six months later the central bank comes out and says okay look there's actually not one-to-one gold in the central bank we actually lent it out during construction and sold some of it but we have assets we've we sold it out for loans bonds and these things we have some gold which is what we're continuing to go every day and market make the pieces of paper so that they are always worth the amounts of of gold per per piece of paper but we don't have one ounce of gold for every single piece of paper in the open market so construction's done but no more redemption's we don't there's no more redemption window no one can come to the central bank and actually ask to be redeemed for but we will keep doing the thing we're doing whereas we take some of the gold we have in we're going to go buy and sell pieces of paper for an ounce of gold we have a commitment or a central bank with the largest market player in the entire economy we will make sure those pieces of paper trade at an exchange rate of an ounce of gold per piece of paper and so after a while right the final part of this story and and one one thing I actually want to say here is is the gold standard that everyone talks about right like 1972 when Nixon took the dollar off the gold standard the gold standard everyone really likes is this part of the story right now where there's you can't redeem dollars for for the the actual backing because there isn't one to one at Fort Knox there isn't enough gold ever right but the government has a complete you know duty to maintain the exchange rate of of the piece of paper as best they can right so where does our story end right the the final part is after a while right the central bank says okay look it's really hard to keep these pieces of paper that say an ounce of gold pegs at an exchange rate of an ounce of gold with a very little gold we we sold most of the gold we have a bunch of loans that are making money but but that's not gold right the prices of those things change and stuff so what we're going to do is forget that one ounce of gold per piece of paper we were no longer gonna market make at that price and guarantee that what we're gonna do is that we realize that an industrialized economy the most important thing is not that our pieces of paper are you know peg to an ounce of gold what we have to make sure to do is the people that are getting paid in these pieces of paper we need to make sure what is the most important thing in industrialized economy that people need such as food such as rent medical care cars electronics you know just good consumer items right things that keep your standard of living the same you need to be able to afford medical care rent all of the stuff and what we're gonna actually do is we're gonna compile all the prices of those things against this piece of paper and if the price of those things are going up right then what we're gonna have to do is we're gonna have to buy some of the piece of paper back with the assets that we have which is very little gold but a bunch of other stuff right and if the economy is becoming more and more productive so more food is being produced and more cars and all these things and the and the prices of those things are going down actually what we'll do is we'll just print more pieces of paper right to make sure the price actually stays the the same right and so we'll buy more balance sheet assets forget the the the gold exchange rate right and that's what happened after 1972 right and I wanted to tell this the story to actually frame this this full conversation about stablecoins because obviously this is actually the full true story of central banking evolution right you you start with one-to-one redemption and then you you stop the redemption you say you can't actually come to the central bank and get stuff from us and then that's when the central bank can be like we can sell some of it right there there's no longer need one-to-one we can invest it in stuff and make money but we have to make sure we have some to market make it make sure the exchange rate is always the same thing we want and then you start realizing or the the the government starts realizing like holy crap it's really hard to keep the peg of something when you don't have a lot of that thing right and then they're like it's actually much better to just peg to consumer basket of items and that does actually have obviously certain advantages right but back to the stablecoin question the reason I I wanted to say this is that every financial thing including stablecoins evolves somewhat similarly and has properties of these things you look at for example tether right tether started out as saying look we have pieces of paper they're called US DT tokens and each of them have one dollar behind them right after a while tether was like okay actually you can't redeem them anymore because like you just just promise that that we will keep the exchange rate the same but you can't redeem them from us only some people can't or whatever and then after a while they're actually we don't have one to one like dollars for the pieces of you know paper or US DT tokens right it all looks the same and obviously like there's there's like laws that are passed as a society where people are like look if you issue piece of paper that say like there's something behind them right you need at least 10% of that thing at least right otherwise you're committing crime right as it's called reserve requirements right and so back to your question I think it's interesting because at first people thought that you could have algorithmic stablecoins with absolutely no anything right like the equivalent of this would be a the central bank with zero gold with them saying the the pieces of paper have to have one ounce of gold you know exchange rate that's that's not going to happen right like that so the answer to that I think is is no unless there's you know a lot of market making going on so someone's got to pay for it right and so that's actually where Frax falls in line here is like we like to call ourselves the inventor of the the fractional stablecoin right and the the thing is Frax is named after that the name is a portmante over the word fractional and algorithmic right and the idea behind it is it actually sits right in the the kind of second to last point which is you can have a fractional banking system that works pretty well obviously there's constraints right if you don't have enough of the thing things start to fall apart right but most of our financial system revolves around the fact that if you keep a currency stable you need some of it right you need some of the gold if you're pegging to gold you need something very very very very very similar to dollar equivalents if you are pegging to a dollar but you can have an algorithmic you know supplier expansion contraction kind of thing and that's what Frax this Frax actually invented that before Frax no one else was talking about that and you know I think if there's one thing in terms of crypto economic design that you know we're hopefully going to be known for is that we invented the fractional you know algorithmic design and one thing is that we've never broken our peck and our definition of the peg is one cent of one cent on each side so one dollar and one in 99 zero cents and we only look at like on chain stuff because all of our liquidity is on chain so like centralized exchanges can trade whatever they want but on uniswap on curve which were the largest pool on uniswap were number five or six we have never broken our peck and we have billions of dollars of liquidity on chain so like that's one thing we're very proud of that we've we've designed so that's kind of where Frax falls along Sam I think we want to get into the design of of Frax a little bit more but that was a really really interesting story and I think for for a lot of people yeah I really enjoyed that that was lovely um JP Koning by the way is you know it's really fantastic on the space interesting sometimes JP Koning is crypto skeptical which I actually enjoy as well but you know the story also reminded me of this chart from Ray Dalio I don't know Sam if you've ever seen this right it's like he's like the macro cycles of money where you start with the hard money like metal coins and then society inevitably goes to claims on hard money so from type one hard money to type two claims on hard money which is bank notes and then you get to type three which is which is fiat money just the US dollar today where it's not really backed by any claim on hard money it's certainly not hard money and it strikes me in crypto we have all three of these experiments kind of brewing at the same time we have the hard money which would be you know the the first two pillars of trillion dollar use cases you might say which is the Bitcoin and ETH and there are maybe some other examples in crypto of hard money and then you've got the claims on hard money and then you've got like fiat money and I'm wondering like what what what what what fracks is in this is it sort of a type two claim on hard money would you say it's it's certainly not full um type three fiat money where it's you know more kind of algorithmic is it something more like you know a claim on hard money yeah so this is actually a great thing as well the the cool part about the story like like you're saying is we can actually ask that question right like where in the story that we just talked about it does this fiat money come into play is it where you can no longer redeem the pieces of paper that say you know an ounce of gold four gold from the issuing entity or is it when uh you know the issuing entity says that they no longer have one to one behind it but they'll do everything they can with the assets that they have to maintain the exchange rate in the open market is that where fiat money is or uh I think personally so from from the question I think it's when you as as like a government say okay uh we're no longer maintaining even an exchange rate to something that's hard right something that is you know something like gold and doing something like the basket of consumer goods because that like when people talk about the gold standard right when Nixon took us off and stuff the US government did not have enough gold for the circulating supply of like the the the money stock right the monetary base there's uh and so the way they were doing it is they're just stabilizing the exchange rate right and I think that right now most people would think that fiat money is when you just completely float against an exchange rate of like any hard asset right and so uh that's interesting because as you guys probably know and we'll talk about we had the fracks is a two stable coin system right there's the fracks price index that we actually released last week uh but I think that fracks basically right now is um partial hard uh claims on on like hard money right because we have hard assets right and we try to keep an exchange rate to to the dollar can we um can we actually look at this I know David David wants to get to like more talk about stable coins more general there's more triangles more trillemas ahead of us but just really quick so so we can understand so I'm I'm pulling up a app dot fracks dot finance this is sort of a chart of fracks and fxs and a few other things wondering if you could just kind of decompose us a little bit so we see here fracks we see this number market cap of 2.
6 billion dollars we see this other uh number over here if 85 percent collateralization ratio we also see this other asset called fxs which is a 1.8 billion um market cap can you explain some of the things that we're seeing on on the dashboard so that folks can understand fracks with with the numbers and what it's actually composed of yeah definitely so fracks launch with just two tokens fracks and fxs all the way until last week actually when we launched the the fracks price index stable coin so fracks is just the dollar stable coin each fracks is is one dollar super simple uh price is great fracks shares is the uh governance token of the fracks ecosystem and it's actually named after the robert sam's white paper that I think is a historical one because it's called signer and shares we name this fracks shares um and so that's just the governance token the collateral ratio there is actually the hard assets that are in the reserve or in the smart contracts and the series of you know system smart contracts uh we started out a hundred percent as you can see and then quickly kind of stabilized or kind of moved around between 90 to 80 uh and those are the hard assets that the protocol can can lay claims to a lot of them are curve LP tokens as you can see right under the uh value there a lot of them are collateral from lending operations which we call AMOs algorithmic marketed operations those are just very similar to maker down right you you have a bunch of fracks that you can borrow right and and you collateralize it with over collateralize it with ether or everything else right so that's kind of like the the maker down die kind of system the algorithmic section is the section that is kind of the supply is expanded and contracted based on minting uh or burning uh fracks share tokens right like the the actual governance token some people like to call it um fracks is a hundred percent collateralized but there's just some of it that's collateralized by its own governance token these are it's it's it's not just semantic but i think it's important to think about like i would never say like something is necessarily backed by itself because like you can't say like the dollar is collateralized by other dollars at the federal reserve i don't know it's just it seems a little monsensical i hope let's understand that again so these curve AMOs these are curve LP tokens right so these would be composed of other stable coins basically basically it's a year bearing stable coin position right yes exactly so die us dc uh us like tether that sort of thing plus trading fees and curve exactly and and crv emissions and cvx emissions that's got it and this liquidity AMOs you said that was more like maker down collateral so those are like protocol and liquidity so like we have like you know some eth as collateral that we we don't keep idle in a smart contract we actually like deploy in like a you know uniswap pair other places and you die uniswap v3 LP positions exactly exactly so there's a lot of protocol on liquidity just outside of curve um and and we're on many chains so a lot of these are actually on different chains that are like natively protocol own liquidity fraxes uh mintable and issued on 12 different chains a lot of them evm and l2s like the harbiterum optimism polygon moonbeam you know phantom all of these things so a lot of that is on those other pins as well cool and this this algorithmic section which is about like on a 15% or so is that about right that's that's the on backside or it's or it's backed by the value x fxs which is basically the frax governance token um now for you to contrast this with like us t for example ust would be like almost entirely this algorithmic type section which is like all kind of lunatocons aside from maybe you might start to count the the reserves the bitcoin reserves that the lfg group purchased recently yes yes yes i would say that that's that's correct like in fact you know um i think a lot of stablecoin projects especially tera which is like the the largest decentralized one currently are seeing there's a lot of you know important strengths to the fractional model right so yeah i think that basically before the bitcoin announcement this if you were to make this chart with with tera most of it would be black right most of it would be algorithmic right and now there would be a big slice uh i'm not actually exactly sure i think is like anywhere between 10 to 30 percent or something like that would be bitcoin right it would basically uh there would be a slice of bitcoin it's funny because we see us t moving in your direction they're moving more in that the like fractionalized direction and less algorithmic so it's almost like i don't know frax is moving more algorithmic but they're certainly coming more towards your design yeah i mean so we so like i said what our our name is literally after the fractional stuff we we invented but i don't really even think we we like own the idea or anything i think what's interesting is like i said financial evolution has the same kind of uh evolutionary pressures it's just economic right so i like as as things progress right in like an economy they start looking the same in terms of what the the kind of right answer is in terms of efficiency and and kind of like how everything will work i think i think most things will look a lot like this the only difference is like what collateral ratio they'll they'll keep stuff at right and in fact you know you you could argue that you know maker doubt for example is is not algorithmic it's it's over collateralized but the other way that i like to compare you know maker doubt actually is that going back to our kind of central bank story right maker doubt started with a very fundamentally sound thing right they were like we're gonna issue pieces of paper that uh say a dollar but like we can't actually hold dollars right so what we're gonna do is we're gonna back the piece of paper with like two dollars worth of other stuff for every one one dollar that we have uh piece of paper that needs to be a dollar we're gonna have two dollars of other things right or like a loan on two dollars basically um after a while again every one whether you come from the algorithmic side of like zero percent or the maker doubt side of like over collateralized the theme here is you start realizing it's extremely difficult to issue pieces of paper that have an exchange rate for something without holding a substantial amount of that thing right and so that is part of the reason why you know the closest thing to you know dollars uh usdc is is both maker it has exposure to it and as as do we right like you can you can look in there's there's curvilp tokens in this stat and so for example even Tara right like Tara works with uh jump and all of the largest market makers right if you don't have the you know the actual asset in your central bank you know inside of the building or whatever right you have to at least pay someone that does to go out into the market right and and like you know make sure that the unit is is trading at uh that amount right and so it's like like jump is absolutely massive right they're absolutely huge like if you recall the the wormhole like uh the unfortunate which was really really unfortunate i was saddened to see that but the wormhole hack of like what was it 300 million or something eath uh jump was like i had no problem here's 300 million uh let's let's you know uh let's make everyone hold which was great and respectable the same place where all that money comes from is also the same place that you know market makes the the biggest of uh stablecoin markets right and so the thing is if you want to actually autonomously and internally be a central bank which i think Tara is going to be the biggest and most impressive one with fracks and probably maker right and and us you know these are the big three right now you need to actually have uh stuff to to go out and do that right you need to have the the actual assets the hard assets rather than uh having other people kind of do it and i think that's where the evolution of this stuff is going right where that's what we're seeing both honestly both with maker right with with fracks with Tara with with everyone right and that's that's the honest truth Sam so there's a bunch of different collaterals uh in the the fracks reserves right and this is the the ammo that that fracks has to defend the peg right so going back to your story about the credit window right where i've got my fracks hokens and i go to this to the fracks de-central bank on a theorem and i say hey i would like some assets uh do do i get to pick like which of the assets i redeem for or how does the peg get defended when i come and come with my stablecoins of fracks tokens and i would like to redeem them like how does that work yeah when the when the redemption window is open which is like if the peg is even one third of a cent off so like literally point uh three three of one cent right you can actually go and redeem them on on the redemption tab and what it is is that you get a mixture of assets like so you could see here if it was open you get usdc and fxs minted to at the ratio of the collateral ratio so that there's never actually uh there's never like no reserves even if you're the last five percent to redeem obviously you know the the thing is everyone gets a piece of the fxs which they sell right which might have like negative price action and things like that but the idea behind the way we've done redemptions is everyone gets a ratio of the balance sheet right and so it actually is an anti kind of bank run mechanism in the sense that it's not that the first redeemers get you know uh one one usdc for fracks or or one you know dollar worth of assets and then the last get all of the you know governance token that's like plummeting it's actually uh equal you know it's a egalitarian and so the collateral ratio also as you could see is dynamic right so the the collateral ratio has moved up and down uh across you know all the times that we've uh launched and the collateral ratio will go up during times of uh you know market you know turbulence and and like volatility so that we give back a higher ratio of assets and it'll actually sell uh fxs you know to stabilize at that collateral ratio even if there's no redemption even if no one's actually beginning to make sure there's actually like that much assets if the collateral ratio is at you know 90 percent right so it's actually been a very good uh at dampening the you know the what people like to call the reflexive you know bank run uh spiral since we've never had one right yeah that was one of my questions is is like is there risk of people running for the door right and this was a conversation that we had in our UST episode where uh people are fearful that if there is a lack of confidence in UST there would be a rush for the door and if you are unfortunately later to get through the door you end up holding these tokens that don't have any collateral in the reserves uh but what you're doing with with fracks is saying well it doesn't matter if you're first through the door you get a pro rata share of what you are owed which disincentivizes going through the door in the first place so kind of instilling confidence in the in the in the value that you would get in the first place kind of disincentivizing the actual run on the bank that's exactly correct and not only that but if there's times where there's a lot of redemption happening or if the peg is even off by a third of one cent the collateral ratio will go right and so like the actual amount of hard assets and uh you know the share token you're getting it's actually going up you're getting more hard assets so it's like an anti-bankfront mechanism and all of these assets here are these all like sort of on-chain or does does some entity have to some off-chain entity have to maintain custody of some of these assets right it's like we were we're talking about usd and the lfg group actually has to maintain custody of a bitcoin it's not like on-chain it's not kind of smart contract back is this uh all on-chain or is there a portion that's not entirely on-chain in fact uh we take an extremely decentralized uh and and like autonomous kind of approach and there's no actual legal entity right because because there's no off-chain yeah there's no off-chain assets everything you see here is not only on-chain but also uh readily available right it's not like oh there is a there is some assets here they're on-chain but like they're over there and like you know we'll you know we'll we'll go get them or something it's entirely on the system smart contracts it's entirely uh readily available in terms if you can actually go see exactly in real time literally per block where everything is where you know you can it's amazing yeah it's crazy you even have to ask that question Ryan why i mean the reason i have to ask is because um because usd doesn't have an on-chain well so what's interesting about this so uh deep and i just finished up last week we did a uh you know usd episode just unpacking that learning all about it um it was it was a pretty good episode but like there's kind of the contrast point of sort of the dichotomy behind like a maker dial type design a maker design and a and a usd design i guess i walked out of that episode seeing the trade-offs on both sides right so one of the strengths of maker is it's far less prone to like these these tail-risk type of events and like depaging me in a catastrophe a run on the bank because it's collateralized right so it's more safe for illustration the collateralization radio ratio that we see the 85 percent which is very strong for an algo stablecoin maker dial is something like 250 percent so very very safe right and so it's got you know safety uh but uh you know the the maker bear and i guess the usd bull was saying yeah cool it's safe good nice nice good job bro but it's not scalable it's not scalable at all right and so they're saying the usd design look how fast this thing got to $16 billion and it's because of this kind of mimetic utility demand sort of aspect and and the bear the usd bear was saying yeah cool but hold on that's not safe and it hasn't actually been tested what's interesting about the frax design is it sort of maybe takes the best of both worlds or takes a little bit of column a little bit of column B and it says hey we want to bring some of the scalability of an algo stablecoin design model without having the tail risk event of like it being fully un collateralized they're being a run on the bank that could absolutely wreck this thing i'm wondering if that is sort of the tradeoff space so is is frax more scalable than something like maker uh and likely a little less safe but maybe you know like acceptable risk parameters but tell me about the scalability profile of something like like frax is it can it scale in the way that a usd can yeah i thought that episode was great by the way i think that everyone was too polite uh against each other i was like well uh i think that you know this is a great point but i was like where's the animosity you see on on uh oh my god people thought we were like uh we were terrible like eith maxi's asking even the questions we asked that was just the oh it was it was actually so uh it was actually very polite in my opinion uh for everyone i think it was great yeah um but yeah so what about the scalability yeah so i think like like you said earlier i think a lot of these uh stablecoins will probably look something like fract fractional algorithmic like frax's model the question will be like what collateral ratio right like what is it something that's the very conservative fractional uh like frax like 85 86% or like right now Tara is moving upwards a little bit i think there's 10 to 20% btc i don't know they they're increasing it that's for sure right um but i think it just depends on the the actual uh protocols aggressive like growth strategy right now one thing i will say is that um let people focus too much on the actual collateral ratio and less on the actual ability to keep the exchange rates of the thing at the the actual desire you know peck right going back to our like story about the the one ounce of gold per piece of paper it's really hard you know it's really really hard and uh let's be real like both fracts are right now and uh maker fracts has less but but still they have exposure to usdc right and and so maker has like what 60 something uh 60% 57 or or something like that it depends on how much leverage for eth there is uh and in in terms of that but the reason that's there is because it's really hard to keep an exchange rate to a dollar even if you have you know two dollars of of other stuff uh or two dollars worth of loans and you can't actually still keep an exchange rate without having some of of that thing and no one's been able to fully exactly figure it out now i will give really big props to to Tara's guys and and like they're they're really smart and they're really really really uh good at um strategy and and getting uh Tara adoption the thing is they obviously have a lot of market making activity from people that have a huge say like interest in in usd working out right they have billions of the the people have like billions of dollars of luna right luna is like the number seven largest uh cryptocurrency right it's it's absolutely massive right and so when you have a lot of other people that have billions of dollars of of of dollars right and they have as you know a huge interest in making sure to buy and sell the the stable coin at that at that peg right then it becomes a little bit easier right but but when uh for example frax and and maker what you see on the chain is what you get we there's we have like no uh there there's no market maker uh none that we've ever talked to or that i'm aware of that for the goodness of their heart is it's like you know deciding to uh keep uh frax at at a dollar peg and so what you notice is the two stable coins that have every single thing on chain uh they do have some usdc exposure right like like again it's very very very very difficult to keep uh a piece of paper that says one ounce of gold trading and an ounce of gold if you don't have a bunch of gold like a lot of the gold itself right um but we actually uh are doing a lot of stuff to lower usdc uh exposure in fact don't quote me on it right now in the spot but i'm i'm pretty sure if you actually do the calculation going down underneath um again don't don't quote now but i think we have significantly less usdc exposure uh then then die currently does i think we have like 40 something or or low 40s in terms of like actually usdc and tether exposure when you when you check the actual lending amounts the algorithmic amounts the the curve pool which some of it is is die itself as well right so like die underneath it is half or 50 60 percent usdc but when you go through it we've actually done a fairly good job of being entirely decentralized and consistently weaning off as much as we can uh fiat coins right usdc and tether um while making sure everything is on chain everything is what you see is what you get which is an extremely difficult thing to do this is really cool decentralization maxi in me likes the on chain yeah same here i might be getting for xpil right now it's uh that's really cool um i i want to just draw our attention to this chart really quick because you said um there are three you know august applecoin designs and we're looking at them here for people we're seeing on youtube this is usd in proportion uh looks like a market cap of about 18 billion dollars so the largest now and die is uh kind of second if you if you sort of count die as an algorithmic stablecoin right maybe it's a defy stablecoin as some people would say nine billion uh die and then fracks up here is about two point seven uh billion dollars worth but there's also mim here which uh i didn't realize that has um gone up as well this is a two point seven billion can you tell us a little bit about uh mim that's is that uh dandy cestus uh project yeah um mim mim i think it's an over collateralized model actually we we and this kind of goes back to you know what we're we might talk about with like stablecoin drama or news and stuff but uh we love everyone um and and so we tried to work with mim a while ago and they weren't really that interested and then uh they i don't know they had the the weird cifu episode or whatever and i think that their uh liquidity is kind of a little bit weird these days but it is an over collateralized model it is fairly uh large um i think that part of the thing is like it's used for a lot of dejan leverage right and so this is actually a good example of like you can be over collateralized i believe mim is significantly over a hundred percent at least right but it doesn't mean that it's not risky right so that's actually a really good counter example of of like just looking at the CR right of like how much of this thing is immediately redeemable for hard assets like if there was like a redemption window or something doesn't actually give you a very good uh picture of of like the the full risk because the risk is is a an entirely uh summation of all of the possible market activity right and so for example i think actually to be honest obviously like i think frax is as as safe as as die right um i really do in fact um i think it you know die is extremely safe i actually think that to be honest i think usd is way more safe than people think um and and hopefully the you know this is uh not you know people don't think i am saying that because we had the forpool partnership and stuff because there's a lot of people that have a very strong interest in the usd peg right and so even though that's a very difficult thing to measure right like it's difficult to model because it's you know it's it's hard to actually quantify it's it's much safer than what people think about uh like there's nothing here other than uh the governance tokens volatility if that were the actual truth right if that was the entire picture there would be way more times that the usd peg something that they would have collapsed and in all of these like you know these crazy uh downturn you know markets like right when when like whenever we wake up one of those days like and then crypto markets like negative 30 right and everyone's like oh my god right uh it would have happened way more than that right so i actually think the big three uh and i like to call the big three is like usd frags and die they are much safer uh then then people actually think uh that's my personal opinion one last piece sam because we talked about this in our usd episode of course like um part part of the backing of usd is a big part of the backing is the the lunatokin itself which is driven by like utility value right which is of course we've talked about this in a layer one chains but presumably aside from kind of the meme uh monetary story value potential behind the lunatokin there's also some utility of a lunat being used in uh in the lunat ecosystem right what are the drivers of um fxs price like why would why would that go up or are down in terms of values is it purely sort of like meme value monetary premium value are there some fees that uh fxx holders get can you tell us about the drivers behind this yeah definitely um so the fxs token can be staked as ve fxs so a lot of people that are familiar with curve uh know that this is a uh model that's fairly popular and what that is is you come and you can yes exactly you come in you can stake uh your fxs tokens for anywhere between one week to four years once you stake them you can't transfer them right you you actually they're they're staked they're not tokenized uh and then you have a ve fxs balance proportional to you know how long you've uh staked your uh fxs tokens and you actually get cash flow from the profit of the market operations of fracks we call them algorithmic market operations and you could see right now the APR is is 4.
74 percent uh down there um it goes anywhere between you know uh three to like 20 percent depending on how profitable things are and and yield opportunities that the protocols actually conduct things stabilizing market operations in um and this is entirely uh self-sufficient actual profit not token emissions not inflation um and like one statistic that i i put out is like so fracks is about 2.7 billion supply the protocol makes about right around 200 million dollars of annual revenue oh my god yeah that's a strong ratio what we think in our USC conversation apologies see keep going back to that but i think it's useful context so just let let me say to everyone's listening uh if you haven't listened to our bull in bear case of us to go listen to that because i think that's also helpful to understand this entire sector but when conversation we had it's a big driver of us t value and market market cap i think has been the 20 percent um yields that are being distributed from the the anchor protocol on on the Terra network and um the conversation there is that that's basically marketing spend right so like the jump capitals of the world are not sure exactly what the sources are but those who are incentive to push out USD into the world are subsidizing that and you heavily subsidizing that this 20 percent rate it's not necessarily long-term sustainable to do that but maybe it's worth it for now this 4.
7 percent that that's not coming from the like marketing spend um barge not an issue in higher education yeah that is entirely cash flow out all on chain cash flow then so economic sustainability you love to see it love to see it very good uh Sam just a last few set of questions before we get into the uh the spicy side the four pool the stablecoin wars and why doe why you think doecoin has it out against diet we'll talk about that but first just the remaining road map uh that's on on the uh on the road map for for frax let's talk about that uh can you explain what the FPI is uh what it is how it works and and how it helps increase the adoption for frax yeah definitely um the FPI is the second stablecoin in the the frax ecosystem um it's the first ever uh stablecoin pegged to the CPI consumer uh price index which is the prices of a basket of consumer items um in fact we we started working on this last year um and last week it coincidentally we uh launched and and it was a very successful launch and it was uh highly anticipated um again going back to kind of the grand vision right like the thing I said stablecoins are are the third trillion dollar narrative of crypto the evolution of stablecoins will probably look like the evolution of of central banking right and remember the last part of the story of the the central bank was that after a while they said okay uh let's not actually peg to some external exchange rate that that we can't control let's peg to a exchange rate that is our definition as like a society and a government of like a standard of living of like items that we we want this you know piece of paper to be able to afford right um and that's where the FPI is like the FPI is basically uh in my opinion like the final evolution of stablecoins on chain uh we'll probably see a lot of uh stablecoin projects kind of taking inspiration from like the FPI design in fact we are uh working with volt protocol which is uh um led by Kirk and a few other guys close to Fe which is another project and I think there will be a lot more of of these and that's a great thing right and again like I think evolution no matter you know what you think about it it's going to evolve in in that direction right and I think it's really powerful because we're going to basically be able to be kind of the the Bitcoin of a self-savory and peck right and so the idea is at the beginning we're going to have the CPI uh of the federal government right and that's a lot of people have a problem with that they think it understates inflation or all this stuff uh eventually the idea is having the weights of the the basket of goods be entirely uh governed on chain right like basically a a self-savory economy with a self-savory definition of standard of living and inflation right inflation is defined as uh the actual price divergence of the currency you use against the basket of items right against the the thing that you need that's exactly what the Fed actually defines inflation to be right and coincidentally today was the you know Fed and BLS dog of report on CPI right which is every month the US government releases the prices of the basket of consumer goods right in dollars and the inflation rate is defined as what are the prices of those things in dollars compared to what were the prices of those things last month in dollars right if the prices of those things went up if you need more dollars to afford the same things as as you did last month there is an inflation of the dollar right it's value is going down you need more dollars for the same consumer goods and coincidentally uh you know today is I think the highest CPI uh reading of in like 45-50 years in in the United States which is very concerning obviously um but that basically means that in the past 30 days the value of those pieces of paper to what they were supposed to track is uh not doing very well right can I just break this down for people right so it's like crypto has just produced something really cool and new in the FPI and in FRAX right so if everyone saw the headline it was a headline around the world this week uh CPI now 8.
5% so and that that's a lower bound estimate the same just said but your dollar is worth 8.5% less than it was a year ago this time so did you get an 8.5% raise in your paycheck and the answer for just about everyone is probably no I didn't maybe I got a two three percent if I'm lucky well you lost money you lost 5% as a result making less money going forward yeah by holding it in the dollar you're making less money by getting your your uh paycheck denominator in the dollar actually making less unless you got a raise to compensate so what is crypto produce this thing called FPI which doesn't actually track the dollar it attracts it attracts CPI inflation so that 8.
5% that everyone's like oh shit I just lost 8.5% oh my if you held an FPI you would have actually been neutral you wouldn't have lost that 8.5% if you got paid in FPI you would still preserve your purchasing power versus getting paid in the dollar that's something new that crypto is producing that no other system on the planet is producing uh consensual banks don't produce that like they're not in tune with what consumers actually want and demand and uh this is what's so neat about this project yeah and and that's exactly correct and so like uh that you said it better than me actually um and and so the thing is uh that's exactly what it is uh we actually just launched it uh last week and you know we see a lot of people minting FPI you can mint it with FRAX at the actual pet price so like obviously the growth of the FPI stablecoin will be going higher and higher as the the actual pet tracks CPI itself right in fact it's it's kind of interesting because it's almost like currently it's almost like a dollar stablecoin that is growing uh at the inflation rate because we use the exact same CPI basket as the Fed uses for the dollar right now obviously right the trillion dollar vision here again is like eventually crypto is the self-sover in digital global economy we can vote on the weights of those things right and then at that point the FPI could float against the dollar it could grow higher than what the Fed defines as inflation or lower it depends on what the voter I think we'll take you I mean protection from even the 8.
5 percent in this in this climate this is like back to the 1970s that like that that's that's definitely worth it and I guess the one dependency that this is introducing as well as this um connected to like a chain link oracle or something like that to get the CPI data on chain yeah so they actually use a custom chain link oracle that we we designed with chain link and and vault projects um and the good news there is like there's usually two issues with oracles right one is the actual publisher right that needs to be honest and then two is the place they're getting the actual data uh correct right and so since we're using the the government currently right it's unlikely the government is going to lie about what the government actually says it's more about like is what the government is saying is it you know unbiased or non-political uh that is obviously just going to be fixed when there's on chain you know ability to uh have governance on the CPI gauge all right guys so that was the deep dive into the fracks uh got way deeper than I thought we were going and and we got excited and we got excited and like we always say we haven't said it recently so I'll say it here crypto is always speedrunning the history of money and finance and fracks really seems to be like skipping right to the right to the end like right to the point of the frontier uh so that's really what gets me excited about this story and the second half of the show we got to talk about um some of the current events going on because uh dokwan's recent proposal uh for the curve four pool uh is uh the cause eventually the the fxxx token the fracks token to go from $22 so over $40 inside of a day uh and so now there's a bunch of just like clamor about what's going on in the four pool so we're going to get to those subjects and also just the long-term equilibrium of the stablecoin wars or what Sam thinks that the long-term equilibrium is going to be right after we get to some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible if you're trying to grow and preserve your crypto wealth optimizing your taxes is just as lucrative is trying to find the next hidden gem also IRA can help you invest in crypto in tax advantage ways to help you preserve your hard earned money also crypto IRA let's invest in more than 150 coins and tokens with all the same tax advantages of an IRA they make it easy to fund your alternative IRA or crypto IRA via your 401k or by contributing directly from your bank account there is no setup or account fees and it's all you need to do to invest in crypto tax-free let me repeat that again you can invest in crypto tax-free diversify like the pros and trade without tax headaches open in alto crypto IRA to invest in crypto tax-free this goes to alto IRA dot com slash bankless that's a l t o i r a dot com slash bankless and start investing in crypto today the layer two era is upon us theorems layer two ecosystem is growing every day and we need bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a layer two life across as the fastest cheapest and most secure cross chain bridge with across you don't have to worry about the long wait times or high fees to get your assets to the chain of your choice assets are bridged and available for use almost instantaneously across bridges are powered by uma's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens from layer two back to ethereum a token proposal is being deliberated as we speak in the across forum where community members will decide on the token distribution you can have your part of across the story by joining the discord and becoming a co-founder and helping to design the fair fair launch of across if you want to bridge your assets quickly and securely go to across dot t o to bridge your assets between ethereum optimism arbitrum or boba networks arbitrum is an ethereum layer two scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use defi and NFTs over 300 projects have already deployed to arbitrum and a defi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly from the coolest and newest NFT collections have chosen arbitrum as their home all the wild defire protocols continue to see increased usage and liquidity using arbitrum has never been easier especially with the ability to deposit directly into arbitrum through all the exchanges including finance ftx phobi and crypto.
com once inside you'll notice arbitrum increases ethereum's speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee if you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users visit arbitrum.io slash developer to start building your dap on arbitrum if you're a degen many of your favorite daps on ethereum are already on arbitrum with many moving over every day go to bridge.arbitrum.io now to start bridging over your eith and other tokens in order to experience all right guys and we are back this is a tweet that dokewan put out the very start of this month and he rewrights introducing the four pull between frax finance tfl redacted pretty much we own all the cvx the governance tokens for curve and he's introducing the four pull a new curve stablecoin liquidity pool between ust frax usdc and tether and he says the curve wars are over all emissions are going to the four pull and so this is one of the spicier tweets has come out lately because it's what it's doing is it's removing a lot of liquidity from die and it's redirecting the liquidity from the former dominant three pool out of curve and pointing and saying it's going to be pointed towards this four pool which instead of die the dominant decentralized stablecoin inside of ethereum is pointing it towards ust a decentralized stablecoin that is non-native to ethereum frax another decentralized stablecoin that's on ethereum and then usc and tether and so first off sam did this surprise you this proposal surprise you well so so first yeah i think some background no i didn't surprise me because i've been talking with with dough for a while um dough as i think everyone knows is one of the smartest and most ambitious guys in in the entire space i mean luna is like i said before literally one of the largest crypto currencies in the entire space in the entire industry right i've known dough since like 2018ish right when they like started uh terror we briefly talked about stablecoins and stuff and then you know we went off and and worked on our own things and one of the things that's really impressive about dough uh that i think a lot of people um might not get is like he's a very very good strategist but also you know taking everything literally uh and i think Jose said this to right like i don't think uh he straight up means that you know the classic meme of it's not like i should succeed but it's everyone else should die or fail you know i i don't think you should you should take that super seriously and in that literal way um but the the back story here with the for pool is that we are frax and tera are are very methodical and aggressive about how we want to grow and and actually permeate right if if your currency issuer which is what tera is and and praxis and maker is right uh you want to get your currency out where there's an economic activity so people can uh take debts denominated in your currency they can uh trade in your currency they can hold your currency they can save in your currency they can do all of these things right and there's multiple ways to do that but at the end of the day this this success of how big a currency is how much of economic activity and people are actually using uh your thing right and and a good mixture of it right like everyone's using ust right now to save an anchor again like it's it's great um but you we need to get like uh if your currency is sure you need to get your currency everywhere else we're willing to do really big things with the for pool at like like basically giving uh a lot of yield working with other projects to actually uh use for pool as the as their metapool of choice and curve like i said curve is kind of like the the WordPress of stablecoins are making pegd assets whether it's stablecoins or eth and steth or whatever right and and like correlated assets curve is a really important piece of infrastructure because it's basically allowed this kind of camberine explosion of of these projects to evolve we want to support that we want to actually give incentives and actually spend part of the uh money that fracks makes right or part of the money that you know terrorist foundation and and they all have access to right and there's there's nothing wrong with maker not wanting to do the same thing with die there's you know and so for example i'm not going to come up here and be like uh i hate maker and stuff and and actually i think i tweeted like if maker does want to actually do a a die for pool we will give maker the same thing we're willing to spend on every other uh project and uh i actually i know that maker guys you know i talked to Nick uh at maker i've talked to Seb i've talked to bunch of them uh they're all great guys they have different uh execution opinions uh i've tried before to see if there's like appetite for like a fracks psm or just kind of a lot of different things and i think they take a very uh thorough slow methodical and i don't want to really say like bureaucratic but sometimes it might feel that way uh approach to to governance and things like that and it never really went anywhere because i think there was just kind of lukewarm uh you know um desire for it and but doe and i have a really good relation have been like we like to strategize we like to move fast yes are are kind of like risk to growth tolerances is higher um i don't think that means we're in in any case like enemies um or not at least at least all of us come up here and say like fracks is is not um but but it's just something the die is not interested in um and if they are uh at least from fracks the you know we're always willing to outstretch the hand and i think uh i think so is doe i mean obviously i can't i can't like put words in his mouth but i think the knowing him and and knowing both how strategic and smart he is i think that's that was his way of saying the same thing i'm saying just just in in his uh personality and uh i think that's what Jose said on the show as well i think this kind of lines up okay uh i so there is like this one piece of real estate which is curve which is really really important for liquidity and with stablecoins and curve is designed to be fought over right it's called the curve wars for a reason and so like do you think we this stablecoin wars the where do you think the equilibrium of the stablecoin wars ends up is the stable is the war word even appropriate or is that just like the like the clickbait headline that people like to talk about so where do you think the long term like equilibrium of the stablecoin fight for liquidity and defy ends up at yeah i think curve is more important than some people uh think in fact part of the reason maybe the uh maker is not that uh interested in like working with us is like i think their opinion of like how important curve actually is is different they're like okay this is just like a dex it's like losing money on all the CRV emissions and and stuff and it's just a funny game people can play we're doing real world assets and our you know our focus is over there um and stuff and that's fine and that that's actually fantastic you know the difference of opinion but we want to focus on this because like i said we do think curve is more than just a dex at least i do i think it's a algorithmic savings account where people can deposit the ratio of of stuff that's you know in the curve pool and they get a yield on that in in CRV and cvx which is a convex a governance token and then anything else right like uh you know if you if you do the uh bribing system or whatever like you're saying but like some people don't think that's actually interesting then people think that it's just a uh Ponzi game of like a dex that's not profitable or something like that uh i think it's an incorrect assumption because curve is not just a dex um and you know we can have an entire podcast just describing like mechanisms that look like something but are entirely different uh and i think curve is is one of those but the that's the thing uh fracks has the largest cvx holdings uh which is the convex token which does control parts of curve uh Terra also has a very large amount uh maker does not they could purchase it if they want to but i doubt they will be based on their uh strategic opinions um they could also you know work directly with us in terms of that but i don't think they will and there's nothing wrong with it i i think though that the four pools gonna be absolutely massive when once things get going we just actually launched uh the the four pool on arbitrum uh and the gauge for that uh which is the thing that earns the CRV emissions uh should be going up any hour now literally um and then uh the one on phantom is already out this this period there will be emissions to it the one on uh i believe on polygon is actually uh also already out and then the emissions will start soon so i think this will take the entire stablecoin world by storm i think it's actually gonna be bigger than what the headlines say once everything is rolled out it's it's gonna take it slightly longer than people think uh to roll everything out like this week and then the next week and the week after that but once it all comes together uh i think it's gonna be the savings account of a very very large part of the crypto industry that is cool and um yeah thanks for explaining that i guess one thing to impress upon our listeners is um we call it the stablecoin wars but um that can be the focus uh but there's also a massive amount of stablecoin synergy here so even like fracks itself is backed partially based on on dye that's in these uh LP tokens and curve and what is dye um backed by well increasingly these other real world assets so uh at some level fracks wins when uh dye makes a deal with tesla as they did like two weeks ago uh to use uh to to provide um blending lending protocol services to tesla so all of these real world assets coming into defi actually strengthen fracks as well and i do think this uh this lattice approach of all of these different experiments and different strategies to address stablecoin actually makes the defi space more resilient and stronger because we don't just have one strategy we have like five different strategies right and they're all happening at once and yeah some some will win some will lose some will prove more successful over time but there's strength in having this uh this plurality of of approaches here i think i guess sam as we draw to a close and this has gone on longer than we thought just because i think we've been intensely interested in in what you've had to say and learning more about this project so so thank you for your time i'm wondering if you could give us some predictions on what happens next in stablecoins just like you're you're thinking about this day in and day out do you have any hot takes any any predictions for the next one year the next three years in terms of how the space evolves and what happens next just anything that comes to mind yeah definitely um so first thing is i actually always like to say uh we're we're positive some players at fracks and and i think a lot of this is actually catching on because i always like to say uh stablecoin pegs are stronger together than they are trying to actually take from each other it's always a good idea to grow the entire economic piece of the pie rather than take uh other people's piece of the pie whether it's liquidity whether it's like size market cap or users um but basically that's the philosophy we always do at fracks right so like we we love terra we're willing to work with them and we're out we are going to do this absolutely massive for pool uh we're willing to work with pretty much anyone we love fey and those guys as well um joe is a great guy and and the people building volt which is the other uh project in terms of where we see the space going i think that you know i i don't want to like kind of to my own horn but we've been pretty spot on with with like you know the things like looking like fractional uh stablecoins us releasing fracks is like the first you know fractional algorithmic one and then also releasing the first CPI you know pegged stablecoin in the FBI i think what's going to happen is that in the next 12 to 24 months there will be uh consolidation around three maybe four uh decentralized stablecoins uh and by consolidation i mean it's going to increasingly look like you know things like ust fracks die probably fey maybe and stuff are going to be kind of the the ones that are all the new projects are using as collateral right like like what we like might be using for usdc i think that's going to there's going to be a consolidation on the decentralized stablecoin level right um and second thing is i think there's going to be a lot of uh the narrative of these uh inflation resistant assets talked about in terms of is is bitcoin and eth uh better for inflation resistance or is are they better central bank reserves on these decentralized central bank uh protocols like fpi and and like you know tera and stuff because one thing that's really uh important that doe started the narrative on is like btc's like the new gold right and they're using that as as like tera's uh basically gold right and we think the same thing for eth and and basically uh some btc right to have some kind of exposure to but i think that eth is is basically the same kind of trillion dollar asset as as bitcoin and what's going to happen is there's going to be a lot of shifting of the narrative of you know inflation resistance is is where you go with like bitcoin and eth and instead it's going to be you go to these stablecoins because they literally have an inflation resistant peg and then you invest in like eth and and btc and stuff to increase your your net worth denominated in these like fpi stablecoins or or like dollars if you still use those that's my kind of hot take and the reason that i'm uh people call me like a stablecoin maxiors or something like that and and i always try to not you know take the the maxi moniker but it's like i think that for stability and inflation resistance uh stablecoins or currencies with like an actual algorithmic monetary policy are uh superior but i believe that the two big other trillion dollar narratives which is ethereum and bitcoin make the perfect reserves for those kinds of stablecoins so that that's kind of the the way to end this i think that's a really good take and i think bankless is um definitely the bankless thesis agrees with what you're saying and i certainly i think our our listeners listeners can relate to how painful it is to spend their eth and spend their bitcoin right you'd rather be sending something like uh is a fpi which is which is kind of like an earning an fpi and and you know keeping kind of your your one to two month reserves in that and uh never having to spend just stack your eth stack and stake and uh same with bitcoin as well um thank you so much san this has been a lot of fun and i think you turned on the light bulb for a lot of listeners so we appreciate you coming on bankless and telling us about the stablecoin wars talking to us more about frax this is my pleasure thanks guys guys will include some links in the share notes the frax dashboard also the elgo elgo stablecoin market share dashboard that uh that we displayed on youtube of wrist and as always eth is risky bitcoin is risky stablecoins are that's for sure crypto is risky you could definitely lose what you put in but hey is it any riskier than fiat i'm not sure these days uh the truth is we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend it joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me any things and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation