What is Arthur Hayes buying for 2025?
We recorded this on the U.S election day so we don’t know who won at the time of recording. Regardless, Arthur says the election doesn’t matter. To him, the outcome is the same no matter who’s in power, they will print money.
We talk about the Chinese property bubble and the coming money cannon which Arthur thinks will be bigger than the COVID stimulus. The Fed’s next move, why the treasury is sucking all the oxygen out of the room. We get into his crypto portfolio, what he’s holding and why.
------ 📣 GET YOUR ALL ACCESS PASS TO THE PODCAST https://bankless.cc/podshownotes
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦄UNISWAP | BROWSER EXTENSION https://bankless.cc/uniswap
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle 🤖 dYdX | UNLIMITED LAUNCHING SOON https://bankless.cc/dYdXUnlimited
🐧 CARTESI | LINUX-POWERED ROLLUPS https://bankless.cc/CartesiSimple
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/92?referrer=0x077Fe9e96Aa9b20Bd36F1C6290f54F8717C5674E
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 5:11 Does the Election Matter? 13:44 Where are we in the Crypto Cycle? 17:23 Chinese Property Bubble 33:14 Isn’t Bitcoin Illegal in China? 37:45 Fed’s Next Move 45:16 Politics & The Money Printer 49:42 Arthur’s Crypto Portfolio 50:33 ETH as Money? 1:01:42 Is ETH Dead? 1:02:20 Ethena 1:03:46 Memecoins 1:05:42 AI x Crypto 1:09:10 War Scenario 1:18:48 Arthur’s Advice 1:20:28 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Arthur Hayes Blog https://cryptohayes.medium.com/
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
How do you have a recession when the government is like 30% of GDP? It's almost mathematically impossible, which it is right now. Welcome to Bankless, where today we explore how notable crypto trader Arthur Hayes is positioning his crypto portfolio at the end of this 2024 going into 2025. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. All right, first, we got to get this out of the way. We've recorded this on election day. So literally the day America is showing up to vote at the polls, we don't know who won the election at the time of recording.
Neither does Arthur. He's like literally getting ready to go to bed. He's in a different time zone. But the good thing is Arthur just doesn't care. Yeah, it's not actually relevant. He says the election is irrelevant. So it actually kind of fits. It doesn't matter. According to him, we talk about that in the first part of it. But to him, the outcome is really the same no matter what. In addition to the election, we also talk about the Chinese property bubble and the coming money canon, which Arthur thinks will be bigger than the COVID stimulus. We also talk about the Fed's next move and why Treasury is sucking all the oxygen out of the room.
He has some choice words and labels for Jerome Powell. Arthur has a lot of choice words, so some viewer discretion might be advised. Don't listen to this one with kids in the car. There you go. Yeah. Thanks, David. We should shout that out. He also tells us his positioning for the prospect of recession and war. And then we get into his crypto portfolio, what he's holding and why. One of my favorite parts of the episode is about why he's bullish ETH, but not for the same reasons that David and I are bullish ETH. So we get into some debate on the topic of whether ETH is money, whether it can be money.
And I want to thank David. We got a little bit of concession from him, but like not much. We identified the gap between us and Arthur, which I think is a very overcomable gap. We just need time. Having Arthur on the show is always useful just to kind of get a download on a pretty zoomed out perspective for somebody who zooms out very, very far into the ultra macro, but then also like plays in like D-Gen meme coin trenches. He's a guy that can trade it all. So let's go ahead and get right into that conversation with Arthur Hayes. But first, a message to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible, especially Kraken, our preferred exchange for buying crypto assets in 2024.
If you do not have an account with Kraken, consider clicking the link in the show notes getting started with Kraken today. to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos. With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to kraken.com slash bankless to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss.
Uniswap Wallet is officially the preferred wallet of bankless, and it's the one we use anytime when we want to transact on-chain. Whether you're on your browser or on the go, Uniswap Wallet makes it easier than ever to swap anytime, anywhere. Use your wallet to transfer funds directly from a top centralized exchange and tap in thousands of tokens across Ethereum and over 10 other chains like Base, Arbitrum, and Optimism. Uniswap Wallet delivers deep liquidity, fast execution, and reliable quotes with zero gas swaps through UniswapX. And when it comes to security, you can rest easy knowing it's backed by Uniswap Labs, one of the most trusted teams in DeFi.
Their code is open source and independently reviewed, so you know it's protected. So why wait? Download the Uniswap wallet today on Chrome, iOS, and Android. And don't forget to claim your free uni.eth username directly in the mobile wallet. Start swapping smarter with Uniswap. The Arbitrum portal is your one-stop hub to entering the Ethereum ecosystem. With over 800 apps, Arbitrum offers something for everyone. Dive into the epicenter of DeFi, where advanced trading, lending, and staking platforms are redefining how we interact with money. Explore Arbitrum's rapidly growing gaming hub from immersed role-playing games, fast-paced fantasy MMOs, to casual luck battle mobile games.
Move assets effortlessly between chains and access the ecosystem with ease via Arbitrum's expansive network of bridges and onrifts. Step into Arbitrum's flourishing NFT and creator space where artists, collectors, and social converge and support your favorite streamers all on-chain. Find new and trending apps and learn how to earn rewards across the Arbitrum ecosystem with limited time campaigns from your favorite projects. Empower your future with Arbitrum. Visit portal.arbitrum.io to find out what's next on your Web3 journey. Bankless Nation, very excited to introduce you once again to Arthur Hayes.
He is a trader. He is a macro commentator. He is the co-founder of BitMEX, also the CIO of the Malmstrom Fund. We want to talk about how he's positioned. This is the end of 2024. We're going into 2025. A lot of things happening in the world. Arthur, welcome back to Bankless. How you doing, guys? Good, man. Okay, so it's election day over here in the U.S. where David and I are located, so everyone's going crazy. I was dropping my kids off to school. Big Trump flags, somebody on the side of the road waving flags. It's a little crazy over here. What's your plan? I don't think you're located in the U.
S. right now, but what are you doing today? What are you watching? What are you paying attention to? I mean, I'm doing nothing. I'm about to, after I get done with this, I'll be going to bed and I'll wake up tomorrow morning and I'll play tennis. And at some point, you know, I'll check my Bloomberg and see if either Harris or Trump conceded. And if not, then you strap yourself in for weeks or months of a contentious battle of, you know, who won, right? I mean, similar to what happened in 2000 with Bush and Gore. And then people were debating what hanging chads and all sorts of other bullshit because even, you know, paper ballots and I don't know, it's just nonsense, right?
Like, do you think any of this really matters? let's talk about for investors for for crypto do you think it matters who wins no i don't think it matters at all i think the regulatory apparatus will be what it is i don't i honestly think it's kind of irrelevant the things that the reason why bitcoin is 1.2 1.3 trillion dollar asset class is not because of regulations either pro or against the reason why the ethereum decentralized computer is the second largest cryptocurrency has nothing to do with regulations the reason why there's all these other meme coins and all these things happening has nothing to do about you know this or that politician and what their stance on crypto is it's a fundamental a better technology of moving communicating what value is amongst humanity and then money printing right and so you know but we already talked about some other technology because it's not really yet relevant for most people.
It's all about, okay, well, I could see that my paycheck buys me less every day, every year. I can see that the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. I can see that nothing has changed, but oh, look at this new thing called crypto. And look at all these individuals who've achieved generational wealth in a very short period of time, because there's this thing, there's a new technology, there's a new way of networking and communicating, which has allowed a certain portion of humanity to escape the inflation and debasement and financial repression and all that sort of stuff. And so I don't see any of that changing in the United States, in China, Japan, European Union, any countries, right?
Everyone's doing the same stuff. Everybody has a fractional fiat banking system. Everyone has expended a lot of credit to build stuff. A lot of that stuff at this point isn't worth the money that was put in, but no one's willing to recognize the loss and impoverish some rich people. So they're just going to inflate it away and hope that poor people don't revolt. And so that's where we are. And so, you know, Donald Trump, Kamala Harris, two sides of the same coin. It doesn't really matter who wins. It's fun theater. I'm sure all the networks in America love all the campaign finance dollars that are going to buy ads and whatnot.
And, you know, Zuckerberg and Sergey Brin and all the social media bros, they love the Billions of dollars that are getting spent by each campaign to try to sway opinion. And maybe there's outside countries trying to influence opinion as well. So everybody's just spending money on media. That's better. Does that mean that you're not positioned in any particular way as it relates to the election? I mean, I was long before I didn't reduce my exposure. Yeah. You have not changed your position. Maybe I have cash on the sidelines that I'm not deploying yet because I think it's going to be a bit, you know, there's some questions about how the fed and treasury react depending on who wins and how that sort of plays out.
But, you know, let's say by the end of January, all that'll be solved, I think. And it'll be very clear, you know, the path that they're going to go on and then, you know, get on the horse. That's so funny because I think a lot of people in crypto agree with you in large strokes, but like they do still think, tend to think that politicians have the ability to at least slow things down. So they might say, yeah, broad strokes, Arthur, you're right. you know, nothing stops this train. The money printer goes burn, crypto is going to like ascend and it's just like a better communication network. And that's true.
And like if you measure that in decades, but like there's Gary Gensler's of the world, for instance, who could just like throw a monkey wrench in like, you know, Western finance clarity around like crypto and just like slow it down, put the brakes on. Do you think that that's the case, at least in the short run, like some of these politicians and the administration choices might have some impact. Like, I mean, Trump has come out and said he's very pro crypto. I mean, you would think that would be bullish if if he won the election on the on the crypto side then and like more bullish maybe than than Kamala Harris.
Do you do you see that there's like at least a short term play here? Even if let's say that the regulators actually matter, which I don't think they do in the macro sense to the long term direction of crypto. The specific ways in which America is governed means that even though President Trump or Harris can say pro-crypto things or anti-crypto things, they don't write bills. So bills are written by Congress people and senators. And in the wake of what is the Chevron case where the Supreme Court basically said, Congress makes laws, not the unelected bureaucrats. The onus is even more so on the rulemaking body to create a rule, whatever it is, good or bad, and to put that bill on the president's desk for him or her to sign it.
Right. And so if we're talking about the most polarized electorate in modern history, probably the next last hundred years, how the fuck are these guys going to create a bill that's going to get on their desk, regardless of what either candidate says for or against. So there's absolutely no chance that there's going to be any sort of bipartisan thing that they can agree on of what crypto regulation should be. And so even if you believe Trump, and even if you believe that if there's one person in charge of whatever regulatory agency, they can somehow wave the magic wand and all of a sudden all these institutional investors are going to go and they're going to market YOLO Bitcoin.
And it's going to be from like $70,000 to a million dollars. And so it somehow works. and so I on a micro legislative level and so I think people just don't understand yeah well the Americans didn't you know pay attention to civics class and then everyone else is not American understandable why you wouldn't understand this is there anything about the election that you're paying attention to because there's more than just the president right we have the presidential election we have the senate we have the house uh is there anything about the election that that is the outcome right what's the what's the makeup and then that determines like how, who gets the money.
So which particular part of the American economy or electorate gets the free money, how quickly that happens. Right. And so if it's one party controls all three branches of government, then it gets, the money gets printed faster. But if it's a divided situation, then you need a financial crisis or some sort of war that says, oh, okay, now we're all together in the printing of the money. And so we'll put aside our differences and we'll do the same thing we would have done if we were in charge. And so it's just the pace of what happens. So it's really, it all comes back to the money printer. That's, that's the biggest signal to you.
That's it. That's it. Let's do the math. If you look, I have the, I've done the math. I looked at the recent presentation to the treasury bar borrowing advisory committee by the treasury was released last week, late last week. And they have a nice chart and it shows the largest five expenditures of the federal government, which are healthcare and social security, defense and veterans benefits, and interest on the debt. And so all five of those combined grow faster than nominal GDP. So your spending is growing faster than your ability to tax to fund it. There's just mathematically no other way but printing money.
And so I don't care who gets, who's going to put in office. Both Trump and Harris are going to bomb somebody. They might not bomb the one that The other one's going to bomb, but they're mobbing somebody. So defense is going up. And nobody cuts benefits for old people because they vote. And so if you want to be the congressperson that cut the benefits of the boomers and the silent generation, then you won't be in office in two years. And so it's a very simple calculation that spending can only go in one direction because it's in the politician's interest to continue to spend. Okay, we're going to come back to that.
I want to come back to that in the context of what China's doing, too. You've written articles about this, and we'll pivot back to the Fed, too. But it's like the high level for Arthur Hayes, it seems like it's just like they're going to print money is just how fast. Right. And who's going to print it doesn't matter. It's just how fast. OK, but like before we get there, let's talk about the cycle that we're in, because a lot of people in crypto are a little bit confused. Like even even David and I have been talking like, wait, is this a is this a bull run? I mean, it kind of feels like it because Bitcoin is close to all time highs and yet institutional demand driven.
It doesn't feel like there's that there's a new crop of crypto investors. So are we really in a bull run? Are we like, so what's your sense of the crypto market cycle right now? Is this bear bull? Is this something else? Do you even think about it like that? We had a very good bull run from, call it late 2022 up until mid 2000, early 2024. So in the April time period. And if you want to be a very good student of money markets, you can take a look at the reverse repo facility at the Fed. and September 2022 was when it hit the high of 2.5 trillion and it was drained down to, I don't know, it was now 200 billion over the next 18, 24 months.
And that corresponds perfectly to the rise in crypto. So there was a bull market. Janet Yellen said, fuck you, J. Paul, we're fucking printing money. And she did it, pumped in $2.5 trillion into the economy. Every asset went nuts, right? We're at S&Ps at all-time high, NASDAQ's at all-time highs, um cryptos at all-time highs and certain asset classes so there has been a bull market it's just been it hasn't been as broad based as traditional ones where every single piece of shit altcoin is 10x right and i was like what the fuck i thought i just had to like you know buy bitcoin then the next week i sell my bitcoin then i buy the worst coin i could find on crypto twitter that goes up 10x and i sell that for a bit then i go back into bitcoin and then i just rinse and repeat, but it didn't happen like that this time.
But in a macro sense, there has been a bull market. It's just that very few people have participated in it. And so you have a lot of people who said, oh, it worked like this in the past cycles, therefore it must work like this in this cycle. And they got hosed. Sorry, David, you looked like you had something to say there. I was contemplating. All the dog shit in your portfolio? Yeah, David, it's like thinking about his life choices. Oh my God, man. All right. So what's your base case here, Arthur? Then like four-year cycle, either the way others play it out? Someone else asked me this, like, oh, it's going to be the four-year cycle.
Like, why try to be prescriptive? Disadapt to what is. I think if you try to put these prescriptive, oh, it's a four-year cycle. Therefore, in the second or third year, whatever it is, I must do this. Well, okay. If everyone does that, then you don't get the result of the past. so i don't know what the how many years this cycle is it doesn't even matter it doesn't matter yeah look at the liquidity cycle bitcoin i think for the first time is very clearly directly related to liquidity and china was in the past it was the dollar this time i mean go back it goes back to china and then maybe the global aggregate but the tech is solid the tech changes less and less obviously as bitcoin gets older and older and the thing that really matters is how much fiat is being debased.
How fast, from where, what's the pipe? Understand that. And I think you get a better sense of where Bitcoin and crypto goes. Is it a four-year cycle? I don't know. Could be four, could be five, could be six, could be 10. I don't know. It doesn't matter. All right, well, let's come back to your crypto portfolio a little bit later and see how kind of you're positioning for this. Because I think a lot of people are still wondering if we're going to have this play out, like we're going to get the altcoin kind of like trade going on. But we'll get to that later. Let's talk about liquidity because you think that's key to understanding all this.
All right. So a lot of crypto investors don't understand China. I mean, I think a lot of us like barely understand like kind of like macro and the Fed. You seem to have a take on China, which is basically this is a this is a quote from your article, your recent article in the 28th. Given that the Chinese property bubble was the largest in human history, that's what you said, the largest in human history, the amount of one credit created will rival the sum of dollars printed in the U.S. in response to COVID 2020, 2021. Wow. So you're talking about a Chinese property bubble and you're talking about like a big money cannon injection of fiat liquidity into these markets as a result.
Give us the context here. So like, how did we get here? What is what you call like monetary chemotherapy and why is China heading in that direction? But like, why is there a property bubble in the first place? Well, at the end of the day, the Chinese government said we want to industrialize very quickly and they said okay well industrialization happens in cities they were very agrarian economy coming into you know 1950 after the disastrous civil war between shanghai shek and mao zedong and so the communist party said we're going to urbanize and so every five-year plan there's an urbanization target now mao fucked things up pretty bad um while he was in power until 1976 and then things started to liberalize under Deng Xiaoping, who was basically like, I'll do whatever it takes just to create prosperity in China.
And if that goes against sort of Maoism or traditional Marxist-Lenin theory, whatever, let's just grow. And so let's get these people into the cities. And so again, all credit is determined by state preferences because the largest banks are owned by the state. The largest companies in any sector are all state owned. And so if the government says we want to have people in cities then what do we do we build stuff and so if you're going to move i don't know how many hundreds of people have moved from farms into the city in about 30 years right that's just going to create a epic boom in land prices which i think the figure that i have is they're up like 80x over the past 20 years um it's going to create an epic boom and all the other manufacturing and industrial goods you have to use to build apartments, cement, air conditioners, cheap furniture, all this stuff.
All these companies did very, very well from the late 80s until sort of the 2020. And so the problem was that at a certain point, you reach saturation in how much property you need for a particular amount of people. And they reached that saturation. And then they said, well, government policy says we need to build housing. The only thing that banks are going to lend for is not the only thing, but one of the main things is property. Therefore, I shall buy property. I shall build property. And if I'm a Chinese investor, I can't invest abroad. The currency is restricted. Of course, the super wealthy are able to get their money out, but the average Chinese saver doesn't have access to foreign investments.
And so when you're getting two to 3% in your bank account and the economy is growing at 10% a year, you're like, well, fuck, that's not, that's not, that's going to cut it. I need something else. Property was the only thing that they really could invest in that had a track record of always going up, was supported by the government, was supported by the banks and the credit. And so everybody believed property can only go up. And it was true for the past 30 years. The best thing you could do was save your money, borrow money, buy a property. And so that's what happened. And Xi Jinping gets into power and you know he's not the first one to recognize this but as well we're misallocating credit right if we want china to be this manufacturing you know country we want people to have a harmonious society if we have the most expensive real estate in the world uh when you think about it per median income i had a chart in my my essays like beijing shanghai shenzhen like um the rental yield is the lowest in the world meaning the prices are super high and if you look at the price to median income apartments in the major tier one Chinese cities are the most expensive in the world.
And so obviously that creates a lot of social angst, right? The old own all the shit. And then the younger, like, what the fuck? I can't, I can't get on the ladder. And I'm not, I'm not going to have any kids. I'm not going to have a family. And so you get sort of a birth rate decline, which, you know, when I'm in a country that needs young workers to manufacture thing, that's also bad. So she says, okay, well, We're misallocating credit. I need to stop it. Now, it's hard to stop it when literally every arm of the government has made money on this. All the major banks have loans against this.
All the major industries, the majority of their business is property. And the number one asset held by everybody in China is property. How do you pop that bubble without causing massive social unrest? And so I guess by 2020, after the COVID lockdowns and whatnot, he thought he had enough control politically and economically to pop the bubble. And so they started doing what every country does when they pop a real estate bubble, same way the Fed did in 2007 and 8. They start raising the price of credit or restricting developers from getting it. And predictably, the market collapsed. And so we've brought two or three years into this situation and deflation is sitting hold in China.
You know, the median sort of time that it takes to clear Our property bubble is, you know, five to 10 years. You think about the United States, Japan, it took them, what, 20 to 30 years to get out of it. And so that's what she's turned on the bubble, like, OK, what the fuck? What are we going to do to get out of this situation? And at the same time, you know, the geopolitical situation is heating up. There's proxy wars everywhere between China and the U.S. There's a trade war and all these things, right? And he's trying to right-size the economy in this property bubble. So there's two options.
One is you do the Argentinian situation where you do a liquidation of credit. Okay, you bought a property. You lent against this thing. It went down in price. Sorry, that's called capitalism. You lost money. And so you're going to go out of business. You're going to go bankrupt. You're going to fire some workers. That's the one option that gets rid of all the debt. Very quick, extremely painful. Could cause a revolution. You never know. Or you do monetary chemotherapy, which is you lower the price. So quantitative easing, lower the price of credit to zero, make the banks solvent again in fiat money terms, and then do bank directed credit to get the economy back going, which is what Japan has done, what the European has done and what the United States has done after their respective property bubbles.
And I call it chemotherapy because, yes, while it does cure the economy, the financial sector makes them whole, the banks are whole, they can lend again. You, you know, destroy the lower middle classes with inflation because you have to financially repress them to make sure the capital doesn't leave. And given the amount of money that China printed to create this property bubble over the last 30 years, the amount of credit ensued in China is enormous. The amount of chemotherapy they're going to have to put on their economy is just going to be next level. And so I know a lot of people think, oh, it's not enough.
There's a lot of commentators, economists like, oh, China's not doing enough stimulus. Well, everyone said the same thing about the Fed in 2008. What TARP wasn't enough. We need more. By March of 2009, you were doing quantitative easing one. S&P didn't bottom until March 2009. And then over the next, you know, 12 years, massive bull market. and they kept printing trillions and trillions and trillions of dollars. The European Union wasn't doing enough in 2011. The euro is going to crack. Mario Draghi gives a speech. Well, do whatever it takes. He's done whatever it takes. They've been printing money since 2011.
You know, Abenomics started in the early 2000s. Carudasan came in and said, I'm going to print the most money ever. You know, yield curve control, quantitative easing. And again, it wasn't enough at the start. But once you do it for 20 fucking years, it's enough. And so it's just wait. And now you don't have to say, they don't have to come out with a full bazooka on day one. It takes a while. And so I think there's a structural bid under sort of, you know, big supply assets like Bitcoin and gold that are going to go up because there's just so much Chinese fiat entering the system to reflate their system.
Yeah. What's crazy here is because we've seen this movie play out in the West, like almost like to a T. All right. It's like you were mentioning 2007, 2008. And you actually mentioned earlier in your essay that there's like an underlying reason. I hadn't clued into this, but I found this really interesting. There's an underlying reason that governments want citizens to own property. And it's actually partially, you say, for regime stability, because when citizens, a larger percentage of citizens own property, they have a shelter, they have a place over their head, and they have something that they need government protection for.
It's like you think about the basal use case of government is to like secure your property, right, to make sure that somebody with more guns can't just like come and take your home and your property away from you. So governments sort of want citizens to own property so that they will prop up regimes because they need that security overshadowing. overshadowing it so this is just a function of of governments and this is why we see you know um property bubbles basically in any sophisticated complicated economies is that right that's my theoretical that's my idea on the theory of like why government needs a wide dispersed ownership of of property in the place of like you know organized religion or some other you know cohesive move why you should respect the authority of of the state so arthur um i do want to kind of compare and contrast the 0807 united states housing crisis to the one that you're alluding to in china the the difference that i'm kind of getting is that there's like a little bit more of a like a controlled demolition rather than like uh like an uncontrolled explosion that i think happened in in 2007 because we didn't we had we had seemingly had no control over it in in the united states it was a complete surprise these rates and into starting in 2000 and what i don't know 2006 or 2007 i mean the you know the first canary to fall were the two um uh what was it bnp um harry by uh credit hedge funds they gated each other they gated investments in the summer of 2007 bear's turns went bust within seven months was bought and jp morgan had the the fourth shotgun marriage the fed was raising rates they stopped at that point, but it's always caused by a restriction of credit because the authority is like, oh, we've gone too far.
They recognize they've gone too far, but they think that in their infinite wisdom that what they could prop up, they could also take down very, very slowly and not cause any services. And it's the same hubris in every single central banker or government official. They think that they can build it and they can take it down in a slow and controlled fashion, and it never is the case. And so then they always get to the situation where they have to take the chemotherapy even though they don't want to take it. Can you kind of compare and contrast the sizes of these two things? Because like I alluded to, listeners are going to be a little bit more familiar with 2008 and the size of that whole thing versus whatever is going on in China.
We're totally uninformed about China. How big is this unraveling, would you say? The interesting thing about China is that in the Chinese system, As opposed to the U.S. system, most people buy an apartment. So like you get some money and you say, oh, I want to move in in like two or three years time. So you buy an apartment off off plan. You don't buy used. You buy new because the bank is going to lend against new. They're not going to lend against use. That's how it works in Asia. So you go get a loan from the bank, put your down payment down. So there's a proper developer and you put down, I think, 10 or 20 percent immediately.
and then within a short period of time, you have to, you get your mortgage and then you pay the full balance to the developer before you get the property. You wait years before you get your unit, but you fully paid for it. And so you're trusting that the developer is going to make good on that promise. So the developer is short a house or an apartment, long cash. And so what does any person who runs a scheme like this, they engage in Ponzinomics, where they say, okay, well, I'm going to promise to build more apartments than I have cash to. to build but as long as i have a good new sales funnel then i can get leverage from the bank on the cash i'm getting in from uh from new marks and i can build the houses that i promised to build uh in in my prior years and so that's the game that they ran and so once the developers started lost access to credit then confidence from the buyers like oh well is this person actually going to complete this house.
And because they didn't have any new sales and no bank credit, they couldn't complete the old apartments. So there's something like, I don't know how many millions of units promised to be delivered. And the question is, will these developers get enough government financing to do it? So it's a different problem. It's not exactly just straight money. It's they want, they need apartments. So obviously the Chinese government doesn't want to get in the business of building apartments because if you build it like shit, then they complain to you, not the developer. So they've been trying to pussyfoot around the situation of let's give some money here and there.
Let's try to incentivize lending. But at the end of the day, it's the market short millions of units of apartments. Who's going to build them? Right. It's a different flavor of the situation in China based on how the developers are funded. Okay. So in the United States, we needed to make our banks solvent. so we kind of just injected liquidity straight into the banks what you're saying is uh we need to still create like uh liquidity for these real estate manufacturers so but liquidity is being created either way is just like where is it going is maybe kind of the the big difference but like i do kind of want to hang on the point of just like trying to measure how big this this is at the end of the day like if liquidity it's all about injecting liquidity how can we measure the size of these two things, like, again, like just as a, uh, how big the United States 2008 housing crisis was versus how potentially large this looming, uh, housing crisis is off the top of my head.
And if you remember how many trillions of renminbi value of apartments are basically uncompleted, but it's, you know, it's probably in the half a billion, no half a trillion to a trillion dollars worth of just like uncompleted apartments that need to be built. Right. And so that's sort of the, that's the one problem that obviously they snowball, right? Because if the, if I'm a customer and I have my savings is in this apartment, I'm not going to get it. Well, then I'm not buying other stuff. Right. I'm not going out. I'm not traveling. My consumer confidence is low. So the money multiplier drops.
And so I don't, I don't go to the bank and borrow money anymore. Not that the bank wants to lend it to me because fuck, I just lost my apartment. I don't know. I busted my ass to save for this thing. and now the developer has gone bust and I'm not going to get it. So I'm not spending. So it's a multiplier effect on that. We have these millions of people who just, they don't have the units that they were promised to get. Okay, so massive liquidity injection then by the Chinese government. So like for people though that aren't connecting the dots here, Arthur, in terms of like, why is that good for crypto, right?
Your base case is more liquidity equals good for crypto. Somebody might be hearing this and say, But Arthur, isn't like Bitcoin, isn't crypto illegal in China? Isn't it hard to get? That's wrong, personal. Okay, so tell us about that. For someone who thinks that, how does it actually work in China? So Bitcoin is not banned in China. Certain financial institutions are banned from using it as a payment. The national currency of China is the renminbi. And so certain things you cannot pay with any other currency besides the renminbi. But individuals can own Bitcoin. They can trade Bitcoin. certain institutions are allowed to hold it as well.
What China did in 2007 and then finished up a few years later is they basically said, they went to all the major exchanges, the big three at the time, Huobi, OKCoin and BTC China and said, you will no longer have a Bitcoin, RMB trading product. We don't want to see it. We can't ban it. We know that's a fool's errand. People can still hold it, whatever. We know people are going to trade it P2P, but you are not allowed to have a, you know, public display of what this currency is worth in renminbi. And so that is what has been taken down. And so, yes, there's, you know, the large Chinese exchanges also operate in mainland China.
The way they do it is they have these, I don't know if you guys use local Bitcoins back in the day, but it's like that. It's a messaging board. There's local traders who are able to wire money in and out of bank accounts and you can buy and sell different cryptos. And that's how you get crypto in China. It is not banned. So that's how the average retail kind of like mainland China participant would do this with like kind of like a local Bitcoin P2P type of experience. Correct. And like how liquid is that market? How efficient is that market? It's obviously not as good as an exchange. I mean, it's huge in size, like definitely a million a dollar.
I mean, there's definitely a lot of size that goes through that. All the major exchanges, like, you know, the Binances, the OKs, the Huobis of the world, they all have their messaging boards in China and do decent kind of size. because I don't have any sort of numbers on that. It's not really- But if you want crypto in China, it's not hard to get is what you're saying. Correct, it's not hard. It's not like, you go to Hong Kong, obviously Hong Kong is China, but not China in the same respect. But if you go to the local currency dealer, it's, you know, Bitcoin, it's a renminbi dollar and USDT, right?
USDT is like massive in China, right? People don't understand, like they think fucking Jeremy Allaire is going to take some business out of Tether. go fuck yourself heather is heather is king in china they love it and it's liquid and that is the flow and the currency dealers will give you tether versus rem and b versus u.s dollar versus do they trust it more because it's not like jeremy larin sort of us gov bet like you know u.s book that's a little gray i think it's more of a just they're very comfortable with the bitfinex founders the bitfinex founders have been involved in china since the beginning i mean they started in Hong Kong, then they were in Taiwan.
And so I don't, you know, Tether complies with all the same St. Joseph's regime as Circle. So there's no difference there. I think it's just more, they know the executives, they've trusted the brand, it's been around for a long time. And so that's what's used and the sort of the flywheel of the, you know, a network effect. Okay. So, I mean, so if these markets are efficient, if you want crypto and you live in China, you can get crypto. So, and the Chinese government, you said, like knows this, knows that they can't fully stop kind of like P2P trading, at least not without taking some super draconian type measures that they're not prepared to take.
OK, so that's basically why if you're money printing in China, if you're money printing, you're the Fed in the US, you're money printing in Europe, it all goes back to these store of value, non-sovereign, non-fiat store of value assets like cryptocurrencies, like Bitcoin, right? The same money printing, if it happens in the US or China, it's still flowing back to to Bitcoin because this is why this is where people want to hold their their values. Is this correct? On the margin, people have a demand for Bitcoin. Obviously, there's bigger demand for gold and maybe foreign assets. Right. So there will be capital flight out of China as they create all this currency.
And, you know, the very rich and connected are able to get their exchange or you want for dollars and get out of the system. It's all the same sort of flows. And Bitcoin is sort of in that sort of blob of stuff that people are going to buy. OK, let's let's shift. towards the US and the Fed? And what's their next move? So they pivoted somewhat in September. What's happening next? So if you can afford it, I would highly recommend getting a subscription to Zoltan Pazar's new blog. Yeah, he's great. So I saw him at a conference recently and I went and got a subscription and I was surfing last week and in between surfing and yoga and massages, I started reading, I read all his stuff.
And so he has some very interesting sort of notes about what quantitative tightening is doing to the markets and how the U.S. Treasury has been fighting it. And so there's been this back and forth battle between Yellen and Powell. Yellen is more powerful than Powell because the U.S. government's debt load is massive and, you know, the U.S. government will get funded. Central bank independence be damned. And so what does that mean? that means that when Powell was doing QT, Yellen did, we're going to drain the reverse repo. We're going to switch the duration or the types of bonds that we issue.
Instead of issuing long-dated bonds that nobody wants to buy, we're going to issue these treasury bills, like less than one year maturity that everybody wants. And so if you've got cash in the Fed that earns, let's say 10, 1%, well, I'll give you 1.05% to buy my debt. So why don't you take your money out of the Fed and come buy my stuff. And so that's what happened. And so, you know, a trillion dollars of QT has been done since they started. Well, you only have $2.5 trillion of essentially QE. And that's why the markets are ripping. Now, the problem is once the reverse repo facility gets too low, then what happens?
She runs out of juice. And so what does she do? She goes over to Paul. She says, stop that QT thing. and he tapered in May when the US treasury was about 4.5%. I think, and this is, Zolton gets into a little bit more detail. It's probably not really relevant for this podcast, but his theory is that around this level of overnight reverse repo balances, which is around 200 billion, it actually becomes destabilizing for the money markets that underpin the functioning of the U.S. Treasury market. And so Powell has to stop QT and very soon afterwards start quantitative easing. So my base case is, well, first of all, if Harris wins the election, and I think that the Democrats are incentivized to make sure that financial conditions continue to ease and there's no financial wobbles, which means that I think the Fed on Thursday either stops QT entirely or they plant some questions in the crowd where Powell can insinuate that QT is going to end in the near future.
So you better get ready for it kind of thing and sort of soft sell that. If Trump wins, I think that they sit back on their hands and they let shit get fucked up because they don't like him. Really? So right now the Fed is like lowering rates but still engaging in QT. And you think in a Harris world, that kind of reverses and they- Well, I think it's reverse either way, right? Trump's going to put his own people in power when he gets there after, if he wins on January or whatever. Right. But in the interim, these people hate him, right? Janet Yellen's been campaigning for Harris. There's been Fed governors going on the record saying, I'm going to do what's in my power as a Fed governor to make sure that Donald Trump doesn't win.
They don't say it like that, but they mentioned Donald Trump's name as in bad for American democracy. And therefore, I, as an unelected bureaucrat, I'm going to thwart the will of the people by fucking some shit up for him. Right. So that's they said this. And so, you know, while I do believe that, you know, from a money markets and plumbing perspective, this has to happen. The timing could get a bit off if the preferred candidate of the government establishment doesn't win. Yeah. But does this mark kind of a new era that we're in where sort of fiscal policy and, you know, like Treasury is dominant and Powell matters a lot less than he used to or the Fed matters a lot less?
Or do they still like both matter that you're like, wait, which is the tail and which is the dog here? Well, obviously, Yellen has more power than Powell, right? She has, I don't know, was it $40 trillion worth of debt to finance? The more debt you have, the more power you have in this system, basically. Yeah. So if, you know, think of QE was 2008 to 2000 and whatever, 20, Powell had the power. And then they did stimulus checks. Treasury issued a bunch of money and then Powell was forced to finance it. Right. And inflation went nuts. Right. Inflation is still high. Right. It's still above his target.
And yet he's cutting rates. He's tapering the runoff of his balance sheet because the Treasury's funding needs are so large that it's causing strains in the well-functioning of the financial markets. And thus Powell has to adjust to match the reality that Yellen is creating. It's not the other way around. And so Powell is just or whoever will be in charge of the Fed next is, as I call the beta cock bitch tall boy of the Treasury secretary. new projects are coming online to the mantle layer 2 every single week why is this happening maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer 2 design architecture since it first started building mantle da powered by technology from eigen da maybe it's because users are coming on to the mantle layer 2 to capture some of the highest yields available in defy and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the three billion dollar mantle treasury in the mantle reward station maybe it's because the mantle team is one of the most helpful teams to build with, giving you grants, liquidity support, and venture partners to help bootstrap your Mantle application.
Maybe it's all of these reasons all put together. So if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto, or you're a user looking to claim some ownership on Mantle's DeFi apps, click the link in the show notes to getting started with Mantle. Centralized finance held all the power, but now DeFi gives it back to you. Enter the unlimited era with DYDX Unlimited, featuring instant market listings where you can list and trade any market instantly with liquidity. Experience trading like never before with all the trading tools you know and love all on-chain. And then there's Megavault, your gateway to automatic liquidity and yield.
Just deposit some USEC and start earning yield immediately. It's so simple and DYDX Unlimited comes packed with so much more. Leverage, prediction market perpetual futures, instant deposits, and there's even a revamped trading rewards program to get rewarded for every time you make a trade. So go ahead and check out DYDX on Twitter at DYDX to get notified once DYDX Unlimited launches. Radically simple ideas always tend to catch on. That's why Cartesi did the hard work of putting Linux on-chain. So that building dApps can be radically simple by using Python or JavaScript and their suite of libraries.
Simple, like not rebuilding the basics from scratch. Simple, like dedicated scalable compute for your dApp. Simple, like building dApps however you want. Web3 should be simple too, like bread and butter. Cartesi brings radically simple solutions to Ethereum, so developers can do what they do best. Build. Go ahead and discover a flexible, modular stack on Cartesi and build your most powerful, ambitious project yet. Visit cartesi.io slash simple and simplify your blockchain journey and start building today. It's like a pretty classic Bitcoiner take that as time goes on, the money printer always just becomes more corrupted.
It's just like the politicization of the money printer is just inevitable. I think like back when we created the gold standard, the dollar on the gold standard, that was the most like credibly neutral version time era of the dollar that we ever had. And ever as time has gone on, it's just like there's been just more and more influences, political influences that are creeping closer and closer to the money printer. And now with like kind of them like formalized flipping of power over the money printer between the Fed and the Treasury, It kind of seems like we're in the final stages of like, well, eventually we're just going to we're just going to like rip the mask off and just like not even pretend that this is political or not or credibly neutral and just start issuing money in the direction that that politics, political parties want it to go.
Is that kind of how that's the trend that I see? Yeah, but it's cyclical, right? And the Fed and the Treasury were the same organization from 1945 to 1951 in the United States, right? In China, there is no such, like the PBOC is just another arm of the state, right? And so they do what Xi tells them. And so, you know, I think that America will become American capitalism with Chinese characteristics. America needs industrial policy to build the stuff that they outsource to China. And so they're going to have to do the same thing that the Chinese did to build up their manufacturing situation. Financially repress the people at home, allocate credit to the industries that they believe are relevant for fighting a war.
Right. The chips, you know, the factories. There's going to be some new shipbuilder bill to reshore shipbuilding in the United States. All these sorts of things. These are extremely expensive, especially when you have a population that all have liberal arts degrees and no one can, you know, use a screwdriver. So it's just expensive. But it's been done before and it'll be done again. It's a cycle. All right. Speaking of liberal arts degrees, like maybe that brings us to jobs a little bit. It's like, do you care at all about recession in the U.S.? Does this impact kind of like your models? Are you looking at like jobs reports and this sort of thing?
how do you have a recession when the government is like 30 of gdp it's almost mathematically impossible which it is right now is that why we haven't had a recession correct because everyone's been talking about the looming recession the recession's coming the recession's coming and also i have some very expensive subscriptions to people who i respect i'm like look like you know in economics right gdp government transfers are a big portion if the government is like 30 to 40 of all economic activity and they are incentivized to increase nominal GDP to tax it, why would they ever let it go down?
This doesn't make any sense. And so there will never be a recession. We're never getting a recession. No. We're just going to juice. As long as the government is willing to run a fiscal deficit, there will not be a recession. Why would there ever be a situation where the government's not willing to run a fiscal deficit? Voting preferences change, hyperinflation, you know, war aftermath. maybe they've finally leveraged their balance. See, there's situations, but we're not in that situation right now. This is war time for US, Russia, China, Europe, right? They're all at war with each other. And so it's time to spend money to build stuff.
Does Europe matter at all in this equation? We talked about China and the US. Does Europe matter? Unfortunately, no. I feel bad for the Europeans, but they just elect some idiots who just keep taking dicks from the US all day. So it's like limited sovereignty, you see, and kind of like Europe over its economic destiny. I mean, look at Germany, right? They foolishly said, I don't want any more cheap Russian gas. And now one of the largest sort of ammonia producers, BASF, is shedding production. All the car manufacturers can't produce cars at the same price level as the Chinese, and they're getting their asses kicked.
Economy's slowing. Price of energy's down. And so what are they doing? They're importing expensive LNG from the U.S. and you know you can pick a european country and leaders are doing dumb shit uh because of their allegiance to you know america okay so we got china money printer we've got u.s they're gonna print money to yeah we're all free money here okay so let's talk about your crypto portfolio right now or just like in general how your position for this maybe we'll start with like you know like cash versus crypto or something like that so like how allocated are you in into crypto right now in my crypto bucket i'm almost i'm losing 95 percent invested right i have a bit of cash but yeah i you know obviously we run a fund it's all my money anyways but it's we have bitcoin eth and then we have a lot of uh locked tokens and a lot of projects um how big how big is your crypto bucket portfolio percentage versus non-crypto liquid crypto bucket um i don't know versus non-crypto is probably like five six x of the other of the other bucket five to six times larger than within the non-crypto bucket okay nice all right one of us you're one of us all right cool cool cool got that established all right let's talk about um bitcoin and ether then so you you specifically mentioned ether i want to um talk about that for a minute because it feels a little bit like ether the asset has been left behind this cycle it's like what's happening to ETH, man.
Like, do you have a take on this? So, I still haven't gotten all the numbers together, but essentially, if you take a look at, let's say, post-FTX blow-up, right? Solana went down to, what, $7? And now it's $170 or $760, something like that, right? Like, amazing performance. And ETH went from, what, like, I don't know, $1,200 to $2,500. Kind of, like, double-ish, right? So, like, why has Solana done so well? Well, on a sort of percentage change basis, the profitability, if you own Sol and stake it and become a validator, has dramatically improved over the past sort of 18 to 24 months. And it correlates perfectly with the rise in the price, right?
Revenue is up because your transactions are higher. You have the new, you have MEV, you have the sort of the priority fees and all these sort of things and the validated rewards from being invalidated, right? So the profitability of the chain has improved dramatically and therefore the price has done very well now. ETH already came into this thing as, as the top dog, right. In terms of like size of, of the network. And so on a rate of change basis, obviously didn't go down as much either. Right. So when I went from 250 to seven ETH went from, I don't know what, like 3000 to 1200, 50% decline, 4,500.
Yeah. And so, but everyone in ETH thinks, oh, it should be up 10,000. Well, show me $10,000 worth of improvement in the underlying metrics of the percentage of circulating supply that has been burnt because there's been transactions on the network. And so that hasn't happened. And therefore, the price has gone anywhere. But law of large numbers tells me that as Solana gets larger, it's harder and harder to replicate those past returns. And so a lot of the tourists who are in Solana, because it's done so well from 7 to 170 or 160, because things have improved off of a very low base, right? the network had just started almost when FTX blew up.
Well, you're not going to replicate that again. So it's going to be hard going forward to replicate the past success. And I think once that narrative shifts and they get a bit of sour grapes, then you start seeing more sort of like activity back in ETH. They're like, oh, well, guess what? ETH, you know, L1 plus some of L2 transaction volume is higher than Solana. The transaction fees are coming down. It's more secure because in a proof of stake situation, that's got a higher total notional value of the network, therefore it's more secure. And if we believe that there's like, you know, dangerous state actors or corporation that want to take down competing sort of free association of people using compute, then wouldn't you want the strongest chain, which is the one that has the most value to be slashed?
So I think all these things start to matter when the velocity of change slows down in Solana because it's past success breeds future failure. Okay, so that's cool. That's interesting. I do think that's how the market is viewing ETH right now relative to Solana. They're looking at kind of cash flows and Solana is like throwing off a lot of cash. It's almost looking like a capital asset. I will ask though, this is different than the way people value Bitcoin, right? Bitcoin doesn't have any, I mean, it doesn't have any cash, doesn't have any burn. It's different. It's just viewed as like this monetary asset.
And so a lot of people that are ETH bank holders, maybe ETH holders are like, Arthur, dude, different rules apply. Why not? ETH is money, man. ETH could have a monetary premium, this magic thing that just like makes it go up the way Bitcoin like has that. Bitcoin doesn't have to justify itself to like Larry Fink with the size of its cash flows. So why can't ETH be money? Why can't ETH be like Bitcoin? Because they decided in 2016 to preserve usability over moneyness. when the the the dow the dow yeah that that one time well it takes one time you know it takes one time what you don't want you're fucked yeah don't worry it's not money the community clearly spoke we want usability we believe the decentralized computer is better served if we sort of rewrite history and go forward you cannot be money anymore you're not money you're i want to i want to i want to debate that because there's been other times post dow when the ethereum community did not make that same choice especially with the the parity hack uh and parity tried to recover like it's largest parity hack percentage based on the total value of the network at the time was it the same percentage no no no it wasn't close to the percentage of the network as the dow was but the dow was like existential and so that i i kind of actually think that that alludes to my point like because the dow was existential like it was kind of like well ethereum kind of fails if the dow is allowed to proceed without i don't know we don't know that that's a counterfactual argument we only know what happened well then yeah essentially you were presented a choice be money be a computer we chose as the ethereum community to be a computer so guess what you're a fucking computer and bitcoin rolled back the blockchain uh just like ethereum did in 2010 like there was an inflation bug in bitcoin and they rolled back the blockchain that was a lot no one yeah no one remembers that but like it still happened i think like some of these things are like lost to history people are coming into ethereum these days and don't know about the dow and don't care about the dow and the properties of ethereum are the same nonetheless well but the problem is that ethereum is the eth is no apart from the history eth is useful right it's spent to do work when you spend them to do work you can't be money why is oil not money because i need to spend it it's got another It is money.
We got the petrodollar. Well, the dollar is worth this currency. The petro is the asset. ETH is an asset. It's not a currency. You know what's funny about this, Arthur? We actually had Peter Schiff on the podcast. And he was like, hey, the reason that Bitcoin is not as good at money as gold is because gold has some utility. He held up a phone. He was like, how much gold is in this phone? And he was basically like, look, there's some percentage of consumption of gold. And it has some utility value. and that actually makes it a better money. I don't know about the case that just because Bitcoin has no other kind of use, it's not used as a consumable, transformable kind of commodity, that that makes it a better money because gold has always been used in industry.
But actually, I want to- Well, that's the percentage of what gold's use case is. I think gold's use in industry is much lower than ETH. Literally, we're talking about cash flows. You have to spend ETH. The value of ETH as a decentralized computer is predicated on you spending ETH to use a computer. the value of gold as a monetary asset is not predicated on industry using gold let me ask another question because like we're actually you know we could get into like debating this because we're kind of ethos money bulls as as you know arthur but like let me just ask a more uh general question of like what would change your mind on this because i know you're a trader i know you're super practical i know you'd like you know you would change uh your mind on particular assets and the way they're framed if if evidence came forward to kind of like persuade you otherwise What would persuade you otherwise that ETH actually could have some monetary premium?
I don't think that – I think it's so fundamental to what ETH is that unless you're saying that there is no longer any endogenous yield in ETH, the fee is no longer paid in ETH to use the decentralized computer that's hosted on it. I don't think it can ever be money in the way I think about money. Interesting. So you think because it has utility. If ETH went to $100 million per ETH, that's actually a problem because if it's too expensive to use ETH as the commodity that runs the computer, then nobody uses the computer. And so there is a price at which ETH is too expensive and then it becomes not useful anymore.
If the price of oil went to a billion dollars per barrel, then the economy collapses and nobody uses oil anymore because it's too expensive. I got it. I still feel like people get wrapped up around this idea of like they're not separating. like ether is a separate asset from ethereum block space like ethereum block space is really the oil in this case right and ether is more the petrodollar it's the it's the monetary unit used to purchase the oil it's not the um oil itself it's not the actual commodity so like theory and block space could could could run out you know it's a different asset than ether as uh the monetary unit but i guess i can't but i don't have it i don't have a representation of both as a currency i can't separate them in terms of an asset so yeah that that absolutely makes sense but okay then give me the Ethereum block space money or asset or token, right?
That's going to allow me to sort of bifurcate these things and then have the usable thing and the non-usable thing, right? I don't have, I guess have ETH. And so I, it's both. It's interesting. There have been projects that really like create kind of like a gas token on ETH or a block space token. That might be interesting in the future. But still, you are bullish ETH from a pure cash flow perspective, it sounds like if you're holding it in your portfolio. And also it's more about the most developers. And if you think about the most innovative new things in DeFi or infrastructure, they all start on ETH.
Solana, there's copy on Solana and maybe it runs faster or whatever, but they start on ETH. And so I still think ETH is sort of the daddy chain. It sponsors all the idea that has some of the smartest people developing new things to take this industry forward. And therefore, I think it's on a long-term basis, a better asset to hold. I love trading Solana. It's great. It's liquid. It moves fast. It's got a very good community. Do I want to hold a large portion of my portfolio in Solana? Fuck no. Okay. So Arthur, if ETH isn't money, then that implies that some external money needs to be imported into the Ethereum ecosystem because Ether is the only, you know, native asset inside of the Ethereum ecosystem.
Everything else is like created downstream of it or is imported from elsewhere. And we have a large amount of like stable coin imports into the Ethereum economy. We have some amount of Bitcoin imported into the Ethereum economy. So if ETH isn't the money of Ethereum, what do you think will become the money of Ethereum? ETH might be the money of Ethereum, but I'm talking about, if I'm thinking of my portfolio, what's my monetary reserve asset? It's Bitcoin. Yeah, sure, ETH can operate as money within its own ecosystem, but I'm not really trying to silo myself. Oh, we got him. ETH is money, at least in Ethereum.
We got him, David. If the Ethereum ecosystem grows to become the dominant backbone of the internet economy, and we have all these layer twos, we have there in all these different corners of these websites, a bajillion different chains, app-specific chains, and they're all kind of hooked into the Ethereum base layer. In that world, if Ethereum does become the backbone of the internet in terms of the internet value, in that world, is ETH money? It could be. I think let's see if ETH can do that. And then let's see what actually is happening on chain. So overall, though, this cycle, the bears are saying ETH is dead.
This cycle is going to skip ETH entirely. And like we already discussed your concept of the cycle, which is like, why do we need four years? We don't need four year cycles. It just is what it is. But do you think ETH has a bid at some point in the next couple of years? It's not like dead. We haven't already seen all time highs. Like you're still a believer here. Yeah, of course. I'm a believer. I think it's going to do very, very well in this cycle. And again, I think the enthusiasm for Solano will decline as it gets so large that the percentage changes needed to equal the past returns are just not going to happen.
It's just hard. What else do you like in crypto? Should we talk meme coins? Should we talk DeFi tokens? I mean, you take us. What are you looking at? My favorite sort of thing that's in our portfolio and probably our largest position, thankfully, is Athena. So I think that they are going to do very, very well as yields in fiat are compressed relative to the growth in nominal terms across the world. And if crypto is dripping, the basis that Athena is capturing is going to blow out. And so you're going to get back to the 50, 60, 70 percent annualized yields in Athena. And that's going to bring in the TVL and the token price will go up.
Also, I think that the Athena team is doing very, very good work in just systematically knocking down exchange after exchange, use case after use case and saying, OK, we want USD as collateral so that people can use it. And we want to underpin all these different economies. I know that they're working on some of the largest exchanges, adding USD as margin currencies for all of trading, which, again, is just going to increase that that flywheel and get them on the same sort of pedestal as USDT and USDC. And then it becomes a question of like, what types of risks do you want to take? Do you want to take US dollar banking risks?
Do you want to take centralized and maybe decentralized exchange custody risk? Choose. Arthur, I know you're a fan of meme coin speculation. I'm wondering, what does it take? How do you evaluate a meme coin? What does it take for meme coin to get onto your portfolio? Are you kind of just like ape first and investigate later? Or like, do you actually have like a process for evaluating a meme coin? No, it's like I got to hear about it. Right. So I number one, I don't spend much time looking at screens. So I'm doing other shit. So if I hear about something, obviously I'm late relative to everybody else.
Everyone's always late to their to their meme coin. No one's early to the meme coin. That's the point. Because if you I don't know, I don't have the exact number, but there are some pumped up fun statistics in terms of like the longevity of a meme coin at particular. nominal values of market cap and the percentage of the total supply of all coins issued that made it to that level. So to get over like a half a billion dollar market cap is like, there might be less than 50 of these things. Yeah, it's like one in 100,000 or something. Yeah. And so, but obviously if we're talking about meme coins as an attention asset class, you need to be sufficiently large before you get the most amount of influence to your project.
So if I'm not sitting at my computer all day, I don't have time to try to find the next, you know, $10 million to $500 million market cap meme coin. Then once something crosses $100 million to $200 million market cap, and I somehow hear about it, whether it's on Twitter or somebody mentions it on a podcast or somebody's chatting about it in a chat that I follow, then I'll ape. Because, okay, it's proven that it has enough virality to make it across these very hard hurdles. and therefore it's more likely to get, you know, Matt Levine and Money Stuff and Bloomberg talking about how dumb it is that these crypto idiots are buying this stuff.
Right? When I see that, I want to own that because he's talking about it, he heard about it. So that means all these other Muppets are going to buy it too now. Right. Right. Okay. So have you been, what's Matt talking about now? Is he talking about like- He wrote something about GOAT. GOAT? Yeah. What do you think about this whole like AI meets crypto kind of thing, right? It's like it's starting sort of in the meme coin world, but there are other crypto projects. Like I think you've written a post about this. I mean, have you pivoted to AI in terms of your portfolio holdings? Are you like Nvidia stock and that kind of thing?
Or do you think crypto is a good way to get exposure to AI? And what do you think the intersection is here? I think obviously I've written about this. I think AI agents will use Bitcoin intrinsically because it's something they can understand from a particular code basis. Fiat currencies and human legal system does not entrain it to their world. But they can't have much agency on Bitcoin. They can't do much on Bitcoin. Why couldn't they do much on Bitcoin? Couldn't they spin up their own data center? If you have self-replicating robots that could build their own ASIC miners, why not? oh that's that's a future i'm not prepared to to think about yeah yeah obviously it's a longer tail thing but i think it's why if i'm an ai why would i use some coin some fiat currency the last 100 years and dies every time a bunch of humans get together and decide to debase it because they want to be elected right that's that's the history of all fiat currencies over the last 10 000 years so knowing that they've literally been trained on everything that we've ever done and written and they know our history why would you buy a dollar or a euro or a yen it will not exist in 100 years just we know this um but bitcoin theory well i i i agree with that understanding like human history like humans always like inflate their own currencies they always like make their own currencies and just they just make it up and then therefore that like aids itself lends itself to to the value of bitcoin but then also you could kind of argue the opposite side of things well like if humans always just end up making currencies won't the ais also end up making their own currencies maybe they will we don't know it'll be interesting and they're maybe they're maybe this is not what goat is it's like goat coin it's almost like you're gonna start a shit corners and i'll move up the stack as we all do come on let's be honest right as we all do but like i mean the the really neat thing and watching these experiments like GOAT or also like Luna, this kind of thing is watching them interact on-chain.
Like a revelation that David and I have had recently, and this has been talked about for a while, that the biggest group of unbanked in the world is going to be like basically AI agents. AI agent can't roll up and get a bank account, get AML KYC. So they're going to do all of this entirely on-chain. And if that's not bullish for selling block space, this block space commodity, I don't know what is, having the AI agents as consumers of all of this. You know, are you following that train of thought? Do you think that's bullish for banks here? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I caution that I think that AI agents will be able to fool all AML and KYC forms.
So they're all digitized anyways, right? They can fake an image. They can deep fake shit. They'll have big accounts for sure. But again, I think intringently to like commerce that's frictionless, that's cheap enough for them, crypto makes the most sense. Now, whether they create their own cryptocurrency, I don't fucking know. But I think this is an interesting way to start. And that's why I think there's a lot of hype around these AI meme coins, because it's a completely new life force that is entering our space. Okay, so we talked about the money printer, how that's just going to happen. We've talked about how you're positioned with respect to crypto.
But over the last, I don't know, two years, every so often, at least once a quarter, there's some kind of war scare that happens. right i can't even think of the most uh recent but obviously we've got you know the u.s the the entire world is kind of a powder keg you've got israel and iran everything is going on in the middle east you got russia ukraine you got china and the u.s whatever power dynamics are there and so like the thing that keeps interrupting this you know secular bull feeling is like suddenly could there be the outbreak of war um how do you position yourself for news events like that you You know, some country is chucking missiles suddenly at another country.
Like, you know, war, I think you had this quote, but like war in general is uninvestable, right? You want to be out of these risk, high risk assets, don't you, in those types of conditions. So how do you like trade the ups and downs of this type of thing? Or do you just largely ignore it? I mean, I think my fundamental thesis is that war is inflationary. And if you look at the price of gold after the oil shock from 1973 to 1980, gold did very, very well. Stocks did very, very poorly. Right. So if we believe that Bitcoin and gold are in the same sort of situation where there are stores of energy and energy goes up in war, because what is war is we spend energy to destroy things, which is completely retarded, but it's waste energy.
And so the energy that's stored is obviously more valuable. So over time, Bitcoin will keep pace with the price of energy in a wartime scenario. The problem is it's extremely volatile. And so if you are worried about war, then you should be using little to no leverage and you should size your positions accordingly. Meaning that like when you go to bed at night, you can keep your phone on silent and do not disturb because you don't care what happens overnight. Bitcoin could be down 75% when I wake up tomorrow. Am I going to sell any? Fuck no, right? Because I understand, okay, well, there's a short-term dislocation.
You sell what you can, not what you want. And if Bitcoin is extremely liquid, maybe it's a Saturday night and somebody threw some missiles around. The only thing that people could trade is Bitcoin. They dump that so that their risk is, you know, the right way around on Monday morning when all the other markets reopen. Cool. I'm really, I'm ready to rock and roll and handle that sort of volatility because I'm not going to get liquidated. But I know that over time, you know, five, 10 years from now or whatever it is, Bitcoin will keep pace with the price of energy and energy will go up because we're destroying it through war so that's how it feels like it should trade right it should trade similar to to gold um it doesn't always though you know like so when these events have volatility it's extremely well there's a great chart of um gold versus the german mark during the weimar republic and it's like a fucking yo-yo but obviously the generalist trend is a logger with you know an exponential increase in value and then as the mark was devalued but if you use leverage you'd have gone bankrupt multiple times throughout that cycle.
And that's the same thing. Did you hear about that fund that got bankrupt shorting Luna while it was crashing? Because they took like 100x leverage and they shorted Luna. It would have been a great trade, except they just got bankrupt. They bankrupted themselves like three seconds into the trade. Yeah, that's a good thing. The price of Luna was really volatile, but it was going to zero mathematically. We all knew that once you knew what a death spiral was and the math behind how these algorithmic stablecoins work. But did that mean that it didn't go from like 10 to 20 in like a few ticks because, oh, maybe they're going to fix it kind of thing.
Right. So it's a similar sort of situation. Just don't use a lot of leverage. If you're really worried about war, use, you know, size appropriately, no leverage. And over time, you'll be fine. You said this. I like this line. The worst thing I could do as a trader is trade based on who I think is right on the right side of this war. that will lead you to ruin as war will be met on either side with financial repression, outright asset confiscation and destruction. The best thing to do is get yourself and your family out of harm's way and then shepherd your capital into a vehicle that outperforms fiat debasement and maintains its energy purchasing power.
That's like a common theme like for you is like fiat debasement and being able to preserve and maintain your energy purchasing power. Is that still how you kind of denominate things? Like at the end of the day for Arthur Hayes, I mean, I remember one time you came on the podcast and you told us like if you could, you'd like denominate and like you'd have like you strap oil, you know, barrels to your back and like haul them around as like the way to denominate because that's just like pure energy. Is that still how you're kind of denominating these days and like the cost of energy? Yeah. I mean, I, well, first of all, I always divide any sort of fiat asset by the respective central bank balance sheet and see if it outperformed.
Tech stocks did well over, you know, versus the Fed balance sheet from 2008. S&P got smoked. Real estate got smoked. Right. So these things are not performing as the currency is debasing. Gold obviously did well. Bitcoin did fucking. Gold didn't do that well. Bitcoin did fucking amazing, right? Obviously from 2008 to the present. And so that's my guiding light of a chart. It's like, here's what happens. I have empirical evidence of what happens when a central bank decides to debase the currency. And we weren't even in a wartime, at least in the United States' perspective. And so why would I own general stock indices, right?
It's just dumb. I can see in the chart. It doesn't make any sense. I can debase things by the price of oil, and I can see that from 1973 to 1980, a unit of the S&P 500 bought 80% less oil by the end of the decade than it did at the beginning. And so stocks in general are bad inflation hedges. There are particular stocks that do well. You have to be a stock picker, but the general stock index investing leads to ruin. But gold did well. Gold pretty much was even with the price of oil after Yom Kippur War and the Iranian Revolution. So obviously nothing is as interesting as a crystal ball. But the historical precedents that I've looked at, you know, assets like gold and Bitcoin will do well as fiat's debased and energy goes up in price.
You still like gold then? You still like gold, Arthur? Absolutely. I'm a volt full of it. I like gold because gold is what the central banks are going to buy. Central banks are buying gold to de-dollarize, to save against war. There's some interesting theories about how Trump or Harris could essentially revalue the gold in the Fed's balance sheet to instantly devalue the dollar, but give the Treasury billions of dollars to spend to do industrial policy or handouts or what have you, right? Because the Fed's the only central bank in the world. I think the carrying cost of gold in the Fed's balance sheet is at $42 an ounce.
So if they just put it at the current market price, that's something like $500 or $600 billion of money money they can hand to the treasury, which then gets to spend to the economy without increasing the debt load. So there's shit like that. So gold is what the system will buy to reflate itself. The gold price needs to go up 14 times for the general central bank balance sheets to match how much gold relative to the amount of currency was issued that we had in the 1980s. So I love gold. Okay, you love gold because central bankers love gold. But do you think that changes? Maybe the current crop of institutional gray-haired central bankers need to go for that to happen.
But the new generation, does a cryptocurrency, does Bitcoin become kind of the new gold that central bankers hoard? I'm not talking about the next 10 years. I'm talking about millennials are the new central bankers or something like this. So 30, 40 years in the future. I mean, maybe, but I think the trade right now is gold goes up 10 to 20x in the next five to 10 years based on just historical precedents and who's in charge right now. Could that change? Sure, of course it could change. And my view would change and I'd adjust my portfolio accordingly. Arthur, since 2022, we've had a major conflict in Russia, in Ukraine.
We've had the largest conflict in the Middle East that we've had in a very long time. things over in Taiwan. We haven't had Taiwan in the news for a while, but still, nonetheless, like things have kind of escalated over there in that region. Is this a trend that we should pay attention to? Or was the last two years kind of just like, we're done with all of that? Where do you think like, like violence is going on the geopolitical scale? I mean, I hope, I think there'll be conflicts in a lot of other places, right? There's China versus the Philippines. there's you know venezuela versus uh was it guiana with their oil fields there's what's going on in the you know former french colonies in northern and western africa and all these are just flash points between the united states and nato and then russia china iran right and so they're all these different flash points and the theory goes is the reason why you know nuclear powers like Russia, China, and the U.
S. fight proxy wars is because no one wants to engage directly with each other because they're afraid of thermonuclear retaliation. Let's hope that theory holds because, you know, of course, it's very sad that all these people are dying in all these different places. But if we exterminate the entire human race because a bunch of old fuckers decide to throw missiles at each other, that'd be even worse. Yeah, that would be very bad for the price of crypto. We wouldn't be around. It wouldn't matter. It wouldn't matter anymore. Yeah, and it's uninvestable. It totally is. Thermonuclear war is completely uninvestable.
All right, let's end with this then, Arthur. Over the years, you've given a lot of advice, like good advice, I think, like to crypto investors and traders. What's your best advice for them at this point in the cycle? Like what should they be thinking of? What should they be doing? Read a book about World War II. And what happened, World War II, World War I, What was life like for the average man, woman, and child during these wartime periods? And see how shitty it was. And then the next time some dumbass politician is trying to get you to wave a flag and go send your son or daughter off to war, say, fuck you to them because this is fucking retarded.
And so I think that would solve a lot of problems. People don't read any books. They don't understand history. No one was around then. So they think that this is a glorious thing to go and throw missiles at each other around the world. I'd say that's an advice. And you'll also see what happened in the finance because all the things that we're about to do in every major country have been done before in wartime. And so the playbook is there. Of course, there wasn't Bitcoin back in the day. There was gold and other ways of sort of trying to protect your wealth. But similar sort of principles applied and similar sort of ways when people made a lot of money and people lost fortunes as well.
A big plus one on that and reading history. I mean, if you have a it's it kind of sucks for us, too. is like the old generation that was around, like the World War II vets and people who lived through kind of like 1920s, 1930s. It's just like they're disappearing. So you can't have a conversation with your ancestors. So like a way to do that is to go read a book. Arthur Hayes, thanks a lot, man. Great to have you back on. We'll talk to you soon. Cheers. Gotta let you know, Bankless Nation, of course, none of this has been financial advice. Crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west.
This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the Bankless journey. Thanks a lot. Bankless Nation, we're doing something. we've never done before today. We're offering an all access pass to all the best parts of our podcasts at a price that's kind of a no brainer for the value that you get. This is a price that includes basically everything. It's the private debrief episodes that Ryan and I record after our guest interviews, where we say things that we wouldn't have necessarily said on the interview itself. It's also the early access to all of our episodes so you can get the early scoop and stay ahead of the trends.
And it's also the private bonus episodes that we keep exclusive to our paid subscribers. Content directly from the best builders that will give you an edge. So you can scan the QR code for wherever it is on the screen, or you can enter the code podcast at checkout for that exclusive discount that's podcast in all caps. And then from there, you can click the premium feed and add your unique link to your favorite podcast player. And if you're in Spotify, we always ship the ad free video of every episode as well. So you can watch or listen inside of your shiny new premium feed anywhere, anytime.
So what are you waiting for? Get your all access pass to the Bankless podcast today. Thank you.