BlackRock’s Head of Crypto Robbie Mitchnick joins Ryan to unpack how institutions are actually allocating (and why correlation to “digital gold” matters), what the ETF data says about demand for BTC and ETH, and why the October leverage flush didn’t dent long-term adoption.
We dig into BlackRock’s tokenization roadmap, from the BUIDL-style tokenized money market funds and the Genius Act angle to the stablecoin flywheel, plus what’s still missing: secondary liquidity and pragmatic regulatory clarity.
Robbie lays out a realistic 24–36 month path, a 2026 “show-me” phase for real utility, and candid advice for allocators on sizing and asset selection.
------
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAXNET | MINT, REDEEM, EARN
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR L2 NETWORK
💤EIGHT SLEEP | IMPROVE YOUR SLEEP
https://bankless.cc/eight-sleep
💠BIT DIGITAL ($BTBT) | ETH TREASURY
https://bankless.cc/bit-digital
We’re being compensated by Bit Digital (NASDAQ BTBT) for this segment promoting their company and BTBT. The compensation is paid in cash as a one time payment. You can find additional information about Bit Digital and BTBT on their Investor page at https://bit-digital.com/investors
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Is It Over?
11:54 Institutional Response to Liquidations
13:57 Bitcoin vs Gold
16:36 Bitcoin’s IPO Moment?
19:29 Next Catalyst
24:23 Institutional Growth
26:41 Central Bank Adoption
28:25 BlackRock ETFs
30:21 Ethereum ETFs
32:38 Tokenization Roadmap
35:33 GENIUS-Aligned Money Market Fund
38:08 Progress in Tokenization
43:04 Regulatory Clarity
46:30 Bull Case for Tokenization
48:08 Is Wall Street Convinced?
49:59 Bear Case for Tokenization
52:01 Restructuring Banks
54:16 How Many Stablecoins?
55:10 1-Year Goals
57:37 Advice to Institutional Investors
59:47 Closing & Disclaimers
------
RESOURCES
Robbie Mitchnick
Blackrock Digital Assets
https://www.blackrock.com/us/financial-professionals/investments/products/bitcoin-investing
“Bitcoin’s Silent IPO”
https://finance.yahoo.com/news/bitcoins-silent-ipo-analyst-addresses-144047837.html
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
If you think about the big categories of institutional investors you've got family offices, asset managers, sovereign wealth funds, university endowments, foundations, corporate treasures, insurers, pension funds, you have some adopters in every one of those archetypes, but not the majority, not even close. Robbie, you run crypto at BlackRock, so I feel like you know more about institutions and crypto than just about anyone we've talked to on bank lists. So I want to start with the question that's on everyone's mind, particularly on a day like today. So we are recording this, the day that's a little bit red in the crypto markets.
Sure. They seem to be coughing up a little so prices. Is it over? Or is this just a bear trap? Gosh, well, if we count the number of times that people have declared it over over the 16 years, then that'd be pretty high number. So no, I certainly don't think it is. I mean, they put it in perspective, right? This is the fifth cycle we've seen in Bitcoin and crypto's history, right? And through each of those five cycles or at least each of the four preceding cycles, you had these extraordinary bull markets, right? And at the end of each a pretty severe correction, but through each success of cycle, the level that Bitcoin reached was massively higher than the prior cycle, right?
And collectively across these five cycles, Bitcoin's gone up by six orders of magnitude, right? One million X, 100 million percent since when it first started trading on exchanges in 2010. So this is obviously nothing new. To crypto, I actually think, you know, if you'd pulled people on this day a year ago and they said, you know, Bitcoin would be at over 100K and crypto market cap would be three and a half trillion. Those people would have said, well, that's that's an amazing outcome. So I think there's a tendency to maybe overreact in both directions. In fact, more than maybe, there's definitely a tendency to overreact in both directions in crypto markets.
And I think some of the negative sentiment that we're seeing right now is consistent with that trend. Let's talk about those four previous cycles and maybe now this fifth one. So I guess it's not over for crypto. I think most bank listeners would would wholeheartedly agree. I think they're wondering though if this cycle has is over. And so previously crypto cycles have been boom bust in these four-year increments. Some people talk about that following kind of the global liquidity trajectory. Others, you know, that it follows the the havining. But we've seen this history play out before. And this would be the fourth year of a new cycle.
So it's about time that Bitcoin would sort of end one cycle go down correct for some period of time. We might have 12 months of quote unquote bear market before things correct. Do you think that's what's about to play out like right now? Do you think it's the end of a cycle or do you think this one is different? You know, this one extends into 2026 or maybe the notion of cycles is lesser relevant now that we have so much institutional capital at play. Well, I think there's a bunch of reasons why the cycles are probably less relevant on that sort of predetermined schedule that it seems to have followed in the past, right?
The first is a lot of people believe the cycle is tied to Bitcoin having, right? Bitcoin having at this point is almost totally irrelevant, right? When ETFs are accumulating inflows, the magnitude of those inflows is many, many multiples larger than any change in supply created by a Bitcoin having event from here until the end of Bitcoin, right? So until the until the end of the Bitcoin reward function in 2040. And you also have, I think as you alluded to, more institutional maturity in this market than and certainly more participation than you had before. I mean, I was with a very large institutional investor recently and you know, they've accumulated a decent size position in Bitcoin and they say we want to buy more but we want to go down 25% first.
And that's a dangerous game. You know, one of the dangerous games is the interesting strategy, but it's also fascinating because when's the last time you heard or saw that behavior from most people in crypto markets, right? Most people in crypto markets say they tend to get more enthusiastic, the more it's gone up and they tend to sell as things go down and that creates reflexivity in both directions. So now that you have this institutional participation, I think you have more ballast in the market. Look at October 10th, for example, the 21 billion in liquidations that we saw in crypto that day, we could talk more about, you know, what's going on there because I do think it's a really important event.
What was the impact on ETF outflows? Tiny, right? A couple hundred million, 21 billion being liquidated over there. And the ETF investor base kind of had nothing really to see or there wasn't any relevant news like it was just kind of noise. And so I think that you will see probably a muting of some of those maybe cyclical effects that have happened in the last pieces before anyone starts to, you know, declare a cycle over. If you look back historically through the previous four, there were some big events that actually precipitated those endings, right? And we haven't seen anything like that here.
And the second cycle, it was the Mt. Gox implosion. In the third cycle, that rally had just gone, you know, totally parabolic insane, where, you know, because it 2000 in September or 2017, it was at 20,000 in December of 2017. So that was crazy and obviously unsustainable. And then in the fourth cycle, you had just an enormous pile up of really negative events fueled by excessive risk taking bad ideas, outrageous leverage, et cetera, that all sort of coincided whether we're talking about, you know, Tara Luna, or we're talking about, you know, eventually FTX, which was kind of the final blow to end that for a cycle, but that hasn't really happened yet.
Now, what we have seen happen that I think is caused for some concern. Obviously, there was a lot of exuberance around digital asset treasuries. Some of that may have gotten ahead of itself, right? And so that so far, those seems to be fairly orderly in the way that that amplitude has has come down and sort of the, you know, don't see a lot of new financings being announced anymore in that category the way you did sort of every single day this summer. You also see, I think, a worrying amount of leverage in particularly leveraged perks. And so that really was the story of the October 10th flash crash.
There wasn't a whole lot of news worthy of a negative market reaction, but you had so much leverage in the system. And obviously you had some collateral pricing dynamics that exacerbated the impact of that. But to see, you know, how severe that reaction was as a reminder of just how much leverage there is on a lot of those platforms. And that also, you know, we talked about that in the past. It's really confusing to sort of the marginal institutional adopter, the marginal financial advisor adopter, when they think of something like Bitcoin as, you know, this digital gold, diversifier potential hedge, it exists outside of anyone country's economic fiscal, political, geopolitical matters, et cetera.
And then there's these periods where Bitcoin and crypto trade like their levered NASDAQ on sort of economic and macro news. And that's puzzling to people. And sometimes people try to slap this risk on framing on it to sort of reverse rationalize what's happened. I don't think that makes a lot of sense. The drivers of crypto and certainly Bitcoin are very distinct from, you know, your traditional equities or other, you know, traditional portfolio assets. But when you have these levered futures where trading does behave that way and sort of amplifies these sell-offs alongside equities, even if they don't make a lot of fundamental sense, that's confusing to the incremental adopter.
Introducing at Frax USD, the genius aligned digital dollar from Frax. It's a secure, stable, and fully backed by institutional grade real world assets, custodyed by BlackRock, SuperState, and Fidelity. It's always redeemable one-to-one, transparently audited, and built for payments, DeFi, and banking. The best of all worlds. At the core is FraxNet, an on-chain fintech platform built to align with emerging US regulatory frameworks where you can mint, redeem, and use Frax USD with just a few clicks. Deposit USDC, send a bank wire, or tokenize treasuries, and receive programmable digital dollars straight to your wallet.
FraxNet users have benefits from the underlying return of US treasuries and earn just by using the system, whether you're bridging, minting, or holding your Frax USD works for you. Frax isn't just a protocol, it's a digital nation, powered by the Frax token and governed by its global communities. Join that community and help shape Frax Nation's future by going to Frax.com slash r slash bankless. Frax, designed for the future of compliant digital finance. Ethereum's layer 2 universe is exploding with choices, but if you're looking for the best place to park and move your tokens, make your next stop uni-chain.
First, liquidity. Uni-chain hosts the most liquid Uniswap V4 deployment on any layer 2, giving you deeper pools for flagship pairs like ETH USDC. More liquidity means better prices, less slippage, and smoother swaps, exactly what traders crave. The numbers back it up. Uni-chain leads all layer 2s in total value locked for Uniswap V4, and it's not just deep, it's fast and fully transparent, purpose-built to be the home base for DeFi and cross-chain liquidity. When it comes to costs, Uni-chain is a no-brainer. Transaction fees come in about 95% cheaper than Ethereum made net, slashing the price of creating or accessing liquidity.
Want to stay in the loop on Uni-chain? Visit Uni-chain.org or follow at Uni-chain on X for all the updates. Bit Digital, ticker, BT, BT is a publicly traded ETH Treasury company that combines the two biggest metas of our time. Ethereum and AI compute. Bit Digital believes that ETH will power finance and AI compute will power everything. Bit Digital gives you direct exposure to both. Bit Digital holds more than 150,000 ETH with institutional grade staking and validator operations. On top of that, the company owns roughly 73% of white fiber, an AI infrastructure business that runs high-performance GPU data centers that adds a meaningful exposure to the growth of AI compute with over 27 million shares.
This is an ETH Treasury backed by real operations designed to capture staking yield today while positioning for the future of intelligent computing tomorrow. The ticker is BT, BT. This ad is not financial advice. Do your own research learn more about Bit Digital and try their MNAF calculator at bit-digital.com. That's bit-digital.com. Bankless is being compensated by Bit Digital for this ad. You can find out more information by clicking the link in the show notes. It's confusing, doesn't scare them away. So when you have a 20 to 30 billion dollar flash crash in the month of October as we had encrypted the biggest liquidation event that we've ever seen, does that scare institutional investors away from this asset class?
It certainly does to some extent. I would say not all sell-offs are created equal and what's behind it has a larger effect necessarily than what the amplitude of the drawdown is. So luckily for Bitcoin and crypto to some extent in that event was that the alleged explanation, the alleged trigger, was so diminimous in terms of its plausibility as a negative event for crypto that it didn't really draw folks attention all that much other than wow, that was sort of a big sudden drop, which is different than to say back in April where you had tariff dynamics and equities obviously were down in the short term on that.
When Bitcoin also was down at the start, you had a lot of questions because people said, wait, fundamentally this is digital gold, this is supposed to be the diversifier and hedge and why is it reacting to tariff news and sort of economic dynamics and that didn't make sense to people and it did temporarily give them pause. Now to Bitcoin's credit as we've seen in many other instances where this sort of behavior happened by even just a couple of weeks later, Bitcoin was off to the races because the long term fundamental buyer base had said the more economic and geopolitical uncertainty there may be actually the more advantageous that is for Bitcoin as this global scarce decentralized asset that exists outside of all these economic and country-specific systems.
Robby, I remember you beating this from when you came on, it was just over a year ago I believe and you talked about Bitcoin is not a risk on assets, it's really more like an uncorrelated hedge type asset, more like a digital gold. Now when you see the performance of actual physical gold this year and institutional investors see that which is they've been calling this a debatement trade, I think gold is up on the year, about 50% times it was as high as 60% has certainly outperformed Bitcoin at least from a year-to-date perspective and so people are looking at that and saying well if physical gold is overperforming this digital gold then maybe Bitcoin is not an uncorrelated hedge asset, maybe we needed gold all along.
Now some people in crypto are saying wait just wait for the catch-up trade, Bitcoin is going to catch gold price. What's your take on this and what do you tell institutional investors who are asking why gold just keeps outperforming Bitcoin on the year? Well actually some of this is gold's catch-up trade because Bitcoin actually had a massive rally to end 2024 going from high 60s to over 100k. That artificially maybe inflated the 2025 starting benchmark a bit and gold didn't have that same reaction that it's now obviously had a tremendous year since particularly the last month or two. For a lot of that debatement trade rally that gold has been enjoying Bitcoin was right alongside that is a big part of what boy to Bitcoin to that 126k new all-time high.
It was very closely tied obviously to the government shutdown developments and continued fears over US physical and political dynamics in the long term and that probably would have continued frankly if not for the October 10th slash crash which had nothing to do with anything fundamentally for Bitcoin but it totally derailed the momentum that had happened and created this sort of new hangover overall of crypto and certainly undermined in an unhelpful way for Bitcoin to change the channel from the debatement trade which was enjoying a long cycle to volatility and risk on type behavior justified or otherwise.
There was an article this week that made the rounds at least among crypto investors. It was an article by an investor analyst Jordy Bessier and he was looking at the numbers and you know trying to explain the reason why Bitcoin has been somewhat stagnant I guess on the year and again year to date right I'm talking about and one of his explanations for that was just looking at long term holders the original Bitcoin whales and he had some graphs where you can kind of see long term holder selling in these graphs he brought out the point that you know galaxy digital they did a $9 billion trade with some unknown crypto whale and the point I think the article was entitled the IPO moment for Bitcoin he was drawing a analog between you know public companies going IPO and the early believers you know the early VCs the early investors the early employees kind of selling you saying the original cipher punks and libertarians behind Bitcoin this is kind of their moment to sell as their capital has appreciated into the millions and hundreds of millions and the billions now we have ETFs and so they're taking opportunity to sell so it's Bitcoin's IPO moment as you know one class of investors maybe the early pioneers early adopters shifts to entrepreneurs or sorry sorry to institutional capital and you think that's the reason for some of the stagnation do you buy that argument do you see any of that in the data a little bit not not entirely I think that to draw parallel to IPOs I think maybe a little bit of a stretch here I think more of what's going on is a hundred thousand was a target that I think a lot of very early investors maybe had for whatever reason right so it's a nice round number but people who came in in their cost base was you know a hundred or five hundred dollars and a hundred thousand seemed like a nice round number to take some chips off the table and frankly I don't blame them and these are people who deserve a lot of credit for having the conviction over many years and through many volatile cycles right to continue holding and holding and I think it's pragmatic the way I think about it I certainly don't expect to ever have that kind of wealth in in my life but if you think about if you have billion dollars you know how much better is your life if your billion dollars becomes two billion dollars I think what like maybe two percent better like not a lot better right so at some point like you do you have to take some chips off the table and say maybe it's not prudent to have 98 percent of my net worth in Bitcoin as much as I believe in it and so I think that's probably the primary explanation of what's going on I think it's entirely reasonable we are 21 months from the launch of the BlackRock Bitcoin ETFs and all Bitcoin ETFs so been in the market for a while almost two years I think one of the questions we have this cycle however long this cycle continues or does not continue is what's the catalyst who are the new buyers of crypto assets one thing we've been waiting for for over a decade in crypto is for the institutions to come now we're talking to BlackRock now we have ETFs that have been purchased I assume by some of the institutions so are the institutions here yet how much crypto do they actually own like what's the next net new buyer of the Bitcoin ETFs if the institutions are already here do you see any catalyst well the institutions are here at the very leading edge right so if you think about the big categories of institutional investors you've got you know family offices asset managers sovereign wealth funds university endowments foundations corporate treasures insurers right pension funds you have some adopters in every one of those archetypes but not the majority not even close did you also mention sovereign wealth we have sovereign wealth in the category we do have some adopters in sovereign wealth that's right yep and so you have early adopters but they're very much the minority still and I'll tell you what is the critical thing that either unlocks or doesn't their adoption it's all about correlation and that's why you know we've talked about this in the past that I was on I talk about this a lot I'm sure it's very annoying to some people how often I I harp on it but it it's because it is that important in terms of the way people look at this from an institutional allocation perspective I was with a client recently sizable pension fund allocator and the CIO said literally that's the one metric I'm looking at correlations that's right because if it actually is uncorrelated digital gold like instrument that is a diversifier and a hedge it's a slam dunk to put a couple percentage of portfolio allocation in it right from their perspective but if it's more like lever nazdack if you know it's whatever this risk on narrative sometimes proclaims it to be even though you know that's I think counterproductive and also not really supported by fundamentals then it's a totally different bar because then an investor has to say what is the sort of broad investment thesis on the technology and the utility and the adoption curve its future money and all these sorts of dynamics which lots of people do that analysis and they come out and say okay Bitcoin's interesting eats is interesting you know these other crypto assets are interesting like you can get there but it's a very different threshold and you're competing against every other interesting technology play that exists in the world today and there are lots and that's a very different question then is this digital gold and if so well then you know it makes sense as a hedge against monetary debatement inflation fiscal challenges geopolitical uncertainty to have some in my portfolio so that's what almost all these guys are watching so ideally for them to buy more and buy in size you you'd want to see Bitcoin and other crypto assets presumably but in particular Bitcoin correlated with gold rather than the nazdack and risk on assets that's right so for Bitcoin that's the thesis right for the vast majority of new adopters say is this this idea of it as digital gold right a global scarce emerging monetary alternative for the rest of crypto it's about blockchain adoption digital asset blockchain adoption right and so the proof point for Bitcoin is how does it consistently behave against that and people have to look beyond these short term moves which are largely driven driven by levered perpetual futures kind of volatility and more about you know medium and longer term how does it track against that dynamic and when you look at it in more zoom that lens it's actually been very compelling even with these short term variations the proof point for for ETH and for the rest of crypto is show me the use cases show me the adoption show me how the technologies actually being deployed and transforming different parts of our economy and financial system and so back to or the institutions here and in what size so you seem to indicate that there are pioneers in each of the major categories that are here are they in size yet like if we were to try to say I don't know if it's a baseball game what inning are we in as far as institution cap institutional capital that could be allocated to crypto or what percentage of you know 100% are we kind of in I think would we don't really have what you know crypto natives maybe the bank listeners probably don't have a lens for is how much institutional capital we actually have like how far we know central banks like don't really own very much crypto but how about these large institutions have they already bought in or are they just starting well I would say that the allocation levels that you're seeing from those who have is typically in kind of a 1 to 3% range so that's the most common range that we're seeing from those who have and that's actually you know pretty significant and the way that's showing up the first quarter after we launched the Bitcoin ETFs Ibit for instance was over 80% direct retail investors every quarter thereafter that number has come down to the point where today it's close to 50% and so the other 50 is the growth in wealth advisory and institutional and so the trend is very clear those ladder buckets which are of course a larger asset based ultimately than retail investors in the direct channel are today is moving more slowly but they are moving and they're paying attention to a lot of the subtle dynamics around adoption around long-term tailwinds around political and regulatory environment and yes around some of the price behavior and how that fits or doesn't with certain investor narratives so we're still early in the journey it sounds like even with respect to institutions how about central banks I mean part of the big driver of gold at least lately has been talk of central banks increasing their gold allocation you know China Russia other central banks we haven't seen quite that movement or anything close to that with respect to Bitcoin but the whole Bitcoin crypto narrative has been in the fullness of time you know it starts with retail and it gets institutions larger and larger institutions the biggest institution of all is a central bank treasury and that's where gold has found itself how long will it take Bitcoin to find itself there what's the path well I don't think that that should be a core part of anyone's investment thesis remember that central banks absent a little uptake here the historical trajectories they've moved away from gold right that used to be the fundamental basis of central bank reserves and as we moved off the gold standard around the world the migration has been in the other direction and obviously there's a little bit of a rebound in the last couple of years but you know for Bitcoin I think those other institutional categories that I mentioned are probably far more likely to see meaningful adoption sovereign wealth funds pension funds insurers it down its foundations family offices then our central banks could happen you know there've been more surprising things that have happened certainly there's discussions in various countries about the strategic value of accumulating some some degree of Bitcoin reserve so that is happening but I would say that's kind of out of the money option at this point in in Bitcoin's valuation let's talk more about the ETFs so the two big ETFs that BlackRock has launched are I bet the Bitcoin ETF and ETHA the Ethereum ETF how successful have these products been and can you put this in I guess a comparative lens with other ETFs that you've launched over the many decades at BlackRock yeah it's been pretty amazing right and I think that what's happened is the value prop of being able to hold these assets in a accessible turnkey convenient low cost way you know that for the traditional investor the institution the financial advisor can be you know traded as conveniently and held as as owning any stock has been massive right and so a meaningful share of the investor base and particularly of new adopters that the ETF has been resoundingly their vehicle of choice and the way that's manifested you combine that the value prop of the ETF wrapper which has tremendous appeal obviously there's a reason that there's many trillions of assets held that way today with a Bitcoin and with Ether which have justifiably generated a lot of excitement from now hundreds of millions of people over the world you get a recipe for what we saw which was unprecedented levels of inflows and and asset growth so I bet today has been the fastest growing ETF post launch in in history you know fastest to reach 80 billion by a factor of roughly four X faster than in the prior record and then etha has been the third fastest in history to its respective milestones on the curve 10 billion and now 15 billion so it's been quite a remarkable couple of years no question.
etha had a bit of a slower start of the iBIT ETF was just like rock star from the very beginning it has felt like the Ethereum ETFs they really took off during the summer and I don't know if this was the the Tom Lee effect or what you know Tom Lee launched of course his Ethereum debt strategy over the summer seemed like the Ethereum ETFs were really catching a bid this summer although the inflow has been positive for for quite some time what what changed and you know how to explain the the more recent uptick in the Ethereum ETF has this been a narrative that has finally clicked well I think for one sentiment in either had gotten overly negative if we think back to this winter you know I think it got even below 1700 and and it was kind of all doom and and gloom I think that was a little bit overdone and so there was there was some element of a relief rally once that that reversed and you know people recognized that there's still lots to be excited about in Ethereum and I think it was also helped frankly by the genius bill and optimism around stablecoins and and the growth of that as a really powerful use case I mean there's lots of people who look at this base and you know maybe they've struggled to to really resonate with it in lots of the different applications that have been thrown out and that have been explored over the years but stablecoins is is such a logical one to so many people when you see what an unlock that is for moving value around the world in a low cost efficient way so stablecoins I think some of its options around tokenization which obviously you know has been a topic that's generated a lot of excitement particularly in the last year we've seen you know green shoots of of a progress in terms of growth and adoption there and so I think all those things together were enough to really you change sentiment and and get folks attention that that drove what would you know it was a pretty extraordinary summer of inflows and price action this word tokenization this has been a word that Larry think has uttered more than a few times recently I was watching him on CNBC I think it was a week or so ago and he said this I I believe we're at the beginning of the tokenization of all assets from real estate to equities to bonds across the board and he described this as taking traditional financial assets and repotting them kind of a tokenization shell can you paint the vision of how that happens so we obviously we have stablecoins so that's one form of tokenization but Larry's talking about tokenizing tokenizing all of the financial assets that we have so how do we go from here to there what's the tokenization roadmap for BlackRock well we as you know really started with Biddle as our first public blockchain tokenized fund it's a tokenized private money market fund and that's been very successful right almost three billion in assets and the key unlock there and I think this is a really important point to remember it's all about taking the generalized value prop of tokenization which has lots of exciting things right 24 7 real-time settlement ditchly native global interoperable programmable and saying how do we deploy that in a given asset class in a way that creates material new value or utility for investors right and so in the case of Biddle and in general in the case of money market funds tokenizing them has broken the paradigm that previously existed that forced you to choose between capturing full yield on your US dollar savings and having full liquidity right for the first time you could hold US dollars and it's tokenized money market fund and then as soon as you needed liquidity to make a payment or settle a trade etc you could convert that to a stablecoin and dad I think is a really powerful value proposition that's why this asset class far and above any others to date has seen real growth and adoption and tokenization so now the question is where do we go next and a lot of it is going to stay in this category right because there's lots more to do to be able to open up access and serve more and more clients and investors but also it's about figuring out what are the you know second and third you know next most viable asset classes where you can use tokenization to drive real utility to expand access to create an incrementally distinctive level of value for users of that and that's the journey we're on now it seems like an exciting journey I noticed a headline that I didn't quite understand it was earlier this month and it was a black rock unveiling a genius act aligned money market fund wasn't actually sure if this was middle or something else and what in particular needs to be genius act aligned what does that unlock for money markets another tokenized products of black rock sure so there's a regulatory construct in the US called two a seven and that describes a very specific very strict approach to managing a money market fund that is meant to effectively maximize liquidity and safety of the way that's held and it turns out that the genius act prescribed a reserve management framework that was quite similar to two a seven but not quite the same I see and so what that headline was referring to was an existing fund there's a two a seven fund simply having some slight modifications to the reserve management approach that would make it a viable option as a genius compliant measure now that fund is not tokenized but that is saying to the extent there are potential money market fund clients who do need to hold their assets in a genius compliant way that's a vehicle that historically has always been two a seven compliant now it's also going to be genius compliant so this is about black rock getting its money market funds in a position such that they can be used by other companies to essentially back their own stable coins so this could be the backing further stable coins out there that's right we would expect that the vast majority of stable coin reserve assets are going to be in money market funds and that's a competency that we are very deep in black rock we manage roughly a trillion dollars in in liquidity funds and money market funds globally and so it's exciting to see the growth of the stable coins which were big believers in you know we've had a long standing partnership with circle dating back to to 2022 and and the growth of usd c chicot in the last year has been amazing to watch and we're we're very excited for that and so this is like this a category that's going to I think continue to grow in significant ways last time you were here we asked a question about you know tokenization in terms of what's missing right what's missing to get tokenization off to the races and you said there were three things that were missing institutional custodians secondary marketplaces and more regulatory clarity in the past 12 months or so how far have we come on those three dimensions of what was missing so I think the first one actually tremendous progress in a little over a year where a number of the largest global banks global custodians have or are developing capabilities for custody of both crypto and tokenized assets so I think outstanding progress on that front and that's going to be critical certainly because if you think of the majority of institutional investors they intend to they would want to if they're going to hold an asset that these to hold in a non tokenized form and now they're going to hold a tokenized form they would way rather be able to just do that with the existing custodian that they use for whatever that asset class is or whatever that fund category is right now that's possible much more possible it's it's made tremendous progress I would say it's not quite there in a full ubiquitous way but it certainly seems to be headed in that direction liquidity venues I would say mixed there's been tremendous progress obviously in the DeFi world of creating platforms for tokenized assets to trade and also to do other things with them to to borrow against them to use them as collateral etc but less so in sort of the tradify exchange world extending into tokenization and listing assets and so I think that may yet come internally we've seen some announcements to that effect in recent months and then the third piece of regulatory clarity and this is the really interesting one as much as this SEC has been incredibly supportive of innovation in this space this is a really hard problem it's not as simple I think crypto people sometimes need to to realize that regulatory clarity doesn't just mean clarity that there are no rules and so there actually is a really complex challenge before us as an industry and frankly in concert with with agencies like the SEC to figure out how to make the old set of rules and and what novel rules and exceptions come into play that harness the innovative potential and opportunities from this technology without undermining some of the key principles that exist in market structure today and I don't think there's anyone in the world who has written down on a piece of paper like here's all the answers if only the regulators would do this then it would be great it's a really hard set of problems to solve and that's a journey that we're on with other players around the ecosystem and with regulators imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly that's what mantle is pioneering with blockchain for banking a revolutionary new category at the intersection of tradify and web 3 at the heart is you are the world's first money app built fully on chain it gives you a Swiss iban account blending fiat currencies like the euro the swiss fronk the united says dollar or the remember with crypto all in one place enjoy real world usability and blockchains trust and programmability transactions post directly to the blockchain compatible with tradify rails impact with integrated defi features you are transforms mantle network into the ultimate platform for on chain financial services unifying payments trading and assets like the m i4 the m e's protocol and functions f b t c backed by developer grants ecosystem incentives and top distribution through the u r app reward stations and buy bit launch pool for m in t holders every economic activity in u r drives value back to you embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem follow mantle on x at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking that's x.
com slash mantle underscore official crypto is risky your sleep shouldn't be eight sleeps mission is simple better sleep through cutting edge technology their new pod five is a smart mattress cover that fits on the top of your bed it automatically adjusts the temperature on each side so you and your partner can both sleep the way that you like it's clinically proven to give you up to one extra hour of quality sleep per night eight sleeps pod five uses a i to learn your sleep patterns regulate temperature reduce snoring and track key health metrics like hrv and breathing with a new full body temperature regulating blanket and built-in speaker is the most complete sleep upgrade yet upgrade your sleep and recovery with a sleep use code bankless at eight sleep dot com slash bankless to get up to seven hundred dollars off the pod five ultra during their holiday sale that's eight sleep dot com slash bankless you also get 30 days to try it risk free link in the show notes for more information on this journey of regulatory clarity is this going to take a bills in congress is this going to take something like the clarity act or is this is is most the block blocking tackling behind this sort of rulemaking with regulators and sort of just defining processes and and the nitty gritty of things what's it going to take I think it's meaningfully more complicated to try to create legislation to address all the tokenization related regulatory challenges and so I think that that is more likely to happen at the agency level than necessarily through a new piece of legislation we'll see how that plays out right there've been points where that idea has been been floated of trying to tackle tokenization within clarity or within a separate bill and that may yet happen but you know there's as I said it's just it's a pretty complex topic the good news is there's a lot of positive energy around finding ways to help make this work to support innovation in the space particularly innovation around tokenization so I do as hard as the challenges I'm quite optimistic and then do you feel like we've made progress on that so if it's a lot of blocking tackling you know regulators you just sort of defining things 12 months ago I don't know where we are were but now as you look forward to like where we are now and even looking forward over the next 12 months do you get the sense that we're making a lot of progress that we're on the right track I think so I think that frankly what needed to happen was for players in the ecosystem to actually you know do the work knowing that there was an opportunity to engage with regulators and figure out solutions to these problems for for people industry to to do the work of actually defining in a very clear way what the problems were and what what a reasonable set of solutions would look like I think that work has happened on a lot of fronts now there's a process of engaging with regulators to in a very consultative way it's been very sort of consultative collaborative process to try to put that into into action and and deliver the the clarity that's needed so if we have the institutional custodians if that's kind of you know checkmark and we're on the path towards greater regulatory clarity will we get the third by virtue of that so once we have more of the regulatory clarity will we get the secondary marketplaces will we get the liquidity and is this all falling into place now I think that is the natural progression of it so obviously this is a space that we're spending a lot of time on as a firm lots of players around the ecosystem are and I think that these elements of progress across those three threads that we've talked about do you have a self reinforcing sort of flywheel effect compounding off of each other and so you know this will be a pretty pivotal you know 24 to 36 months ahead where tokenization really has an opportunity to prove itself in generating adoption and driving real incremental utility and efficiency in markets it in in the way that you know has long been held out as a as a real area of promise what's the bull case if we look forward to say five years from now 10 years from now for tokenization I recall you saying last time it's kind of a binary either we have kind of no tokens none of this works or basically everything we have many tokens everything is tokenized so looking at kind of Wall Street and US capital markets in five to 10 years is basically all of our assets when it comes to ETFs or stocks or a real estate just everything under the sun is it all available in some sort of token form and all of this available on kind of your your Aladdin platform let's say well that is the bull case I think five is probably too soon but you know when you talk about 10 with all these technology innovations right there is a a S curve where if you really hit lift off the the rate of adoption can really accelerate and and there can be a a fast pace migration to a new technology paradigm and that's that's the journey that we're on and as you noted there were many asset classes that are pretty interesting candidates for this obviously we started with money market funds but you think about stocks bonds ETFs commodities real estate private markets funds lots of asset classes that have been tried with mixed degrees of success but once you have a bunch of asset classes that hit that inflection point it becomes a lot a lot easier to bring along other asset classes in behind it because more and more people are migrating to that new infrastructure paradigm and they've built comfort with it and they've built the capabilities in the systems to be able to interact with it who's left to convince on Wall Street Robbie so I think you know the cryptos take it a while to really saturate in Wall Street feels like in this cycle we had some major achievements on that score even Jamie diamond I think it was a clip from last week he's got this quote crypto is real blockchain stable coins JP Morgan deposit coin coin you can move stuff smart contracts are real all this stuff is real it'll be used by all of us to facilitate better transactions and customer service this is even Jamie diamond who is himself been crypto skeptical in the past seemingly warming up even further to crypto is that everybody we've got black rock we've got JP Morgan is there anyone else left on Wall Street to convince well frankly JP Morgan has been a great leader in this space and they have been for many years and that's you know there's a lot of development work around tokenization they're a huge player in the ibit ecosystem they've been a leader there so they've been innovating I think frankly the group that needs to still be convinced is actual investors right because that's one of the challenges the tokenization has faced so far is that these projects will develop tokenized asset offerings and the end investor demand hasn't always showed up right and and that's not you know their fault it comes back to what is the actual tangible utility unlock that you're using tokenization to generate for me and does that overcome the inertia effect and whatever risk and operational complexity is involved in migrating to that new format and so the bar for that is pretty high and we've passed that with stable coins but it's not clear that we've passed that with other assets may maybe flip this is there maybe more bearish case for tokenization so what if we only get to stable coins and money market funds that kind of back stable coins and the middle fund and that sort of thing and nothing else takes off can you envision that world like what would what would go wrong you think with tokenization in order to to have that type of a more bearish outcome yeah I think that probably the the bear case is that only stable coins work right it's hard to imagine a world where not even stable coins I have significant adoption because already today it's 300 billion in market cap right and that's in a pretty high interest rate environment which is remarkable right so the stable coin value proposition disability to move money around the world in near real time and near zero cost between any two people with a smartphone to get access the world over to digital US dollars which many many billions of people around the world have shown a clear desire to be able to to have that access that horse has left the barn and it's just a question of how fast and how broadly adopted across other domains to stable coins get whether we're talking about you know retail remittances which are massively inefficient today cross-border payments for corporate multinationals which have you know lots of frictions and costs associated with them and maybe more ambitiously financial market settlement activity so subscribing and redeeming from funds in stable coins settling trades in stable coins processing corporate actions margin and collateral in stable coins so lots of pretty exciting applications for it that I think is is the bear if that's a bear case for tokenization it's actually not that bad I mean even the bear case I guess with stable coins in the in the genius bill it's not clear that that's been I guess fully priced in it seems to you said that the horse has left the barn but it seems like we are only getting started on that how is that going to shake things up or or change things across traditional finance I mean will this change the structure of of banks there have been some instances where you know maybe some banks are not you're favorable of letting interest go to say crypto exchanges at least there's been some fights about this but one gets the sense that the underlying structure of traditional finance will be shaken up will change a little bit with the advent of of stable coins do you know how do you have any predictions well what's interesting is I think if the industry executes well then the whole sort of fight over interest which ultimately was was banned in the genius bill becomes not that big of an issue because tokenized yield funds become the natural vehicle through which users hold US dollars on a sort of going concern basis to digital US dollars and capture that full interest and and they're holding these assets which are clearly securities but that's okay because they're being used to hold not to make payments and then the moment they need to make a payment or settle a trade they convert right and so stable coins become sort of the operating cash and tokenized yield funds become the investment or hold cash and the the latter is where you capture yield so even if stable coins don't pay any yield they're still going to be very useful in payments and we sort of see that as the natural future state of this ecosystem and obviously to do that you need to really drive frictions to zero pretty much in moving between tokenized yield funds and stable coins need to have tokenized yield funds that are accessible and that have you know essentially instant and very very cheap liquidity convertibility back and forth between themselves and stable coins if we have that do you do see a world where where we have many different stable coins or right now we have kind of two power law winners there's tether and usdc from circle but will that change will we have hundreds maybe thousands of different stable coins I don't think so you know network effects are really powerful in the stable coin space and so there's a lot of value in being widely accepted in having liquidity from a trading perspective and being you know used on platforms ultimately in the future in having liquidity and volume in a foreign exchange pair against that stable coin so you know I think you'll continue to see growth in the industry and healthy competition but I certainly would expect we'll have you know a thousand different stable coins I don't see that level of fragmentation as being efficient we're getting closer to the end of 2025 and the beginning of of 2026 if you fast forward you think about maybe November of 2026 what do you hope that crypto has accomplished by that time what does it look like are there some major things in your mind and and maybe the same question for blackrock yeah I think that the big tests of the next year plus is going to be okay for many years there was frustration over an absence of regulatory clarity in the US right and certainly you know some of that was was a fair complaint but it became almost a mantra cliche at points to hear you regulatory clarity regulatory clarity now that's coming right it's been a very supportive environment from that standpoint over the course of 2025 and so the test is going to be prove it show the adoption show the real economic use cases and there's obviously lots of really exciting early proof point proof of concept type stuff happening particularly in in the defy world but show me the examples of places where we as a human society or economy either couldn't do something or we had to do it in a really inefficient way and then using blockchain or using digital assets we've now solved that and we do it overwhelmingly using blockchain in a much more efficient way right and to date there's been a pretty short list of things that fit that category Bitcoin as a the first monetary instrument in 3000 years to gain global adoption because of its technological breakthroughs stable coins in moving value around the world in a you know 10x better more efficient way and a handful of things are happening on Ethereum and in some of these other blockchains but that's sort of tidal wave of really powerful use cases I think we're still waiting on beyond that and now it's finally environment where that regulatory support exists and so it's time to prove it 2026 is the the show me phase maybe it's the the building phase probably this has been great I mean last question so every every cycle we have institutions who talk about crypto but they don't necessarily follow through and build or give very excited during the the bull market but they head for the exit you know as things turn down the bear market and so for those institutional investors or those institutions who are building on crypto and this is there maybe their first cycle actually in they see this volatility you know they see the 30 billion dollar selloff or red days like today where this looks to be a maybe a negative 10% on total crypto market cap and they start heading for the exit what's your advice to them well I think my advice is more for the people coming in in how they approach the space I think it's very important to be discerning and to be very particular about which assets one is going to hold right there's a reason Bitcoin is still yeah roughly 65% of the market cap of the space because it has very clear product market fit and investor narrative and a big addressable market is this digital gold like asset there's a reason there's consolidation in a lot of the rest of the market cap in a few top assets which is those are the handful that have really proven themselves and developed some degree of product market fit and economic utility one has to be very wary going far down the table there's hundreds of thousands of crypto assets out there today the vast majority of those are will be that totally worthless and so investors have to be careful around that and they also I think should be wary around trading on a short term basis certainly short term levered basis is a tough game a lot of times in the crypto space and I think the people who've done the best in this base have taken a much more long term fundamental view and understood that you have to be patient and you have to understand that there's volatility in this base and there will be cycles probably misshik thank you so much for joining us best of luck to black rock in the show me face of 2026 appreciate your time to thank you Ryan good to see you gotta let you know none of this has been financial advice of course you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad to have you on the bankless journey thanks a lot