What are the best investing opportunities in Tech for 2025?
Elad Gil is one of silicon valley's legendary investors. He's backed 40 unicorns including Airbnb, Coinbase, Figma and Stripe to name a few. He's super active in AI and hosts the no priors podcast which is like Bankless but for AI.
In this conversation, Elad explores the state of AI and how the industry is evolving, what he thinks about Crypto. and why he’s bullish on Tech in general given the new United States political administration.
------ 📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦄UNISWAP | BUG BOUNTY PROGRAM https://bankless.cc/Uniswap-Bug-Bounty
🐧 CARTESI | LINUX-POWERED ROLLUPS https://bankless.cc/CartesiSimple
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle 📈 iYield: YOUR FINANCIAL PICTURE, SIMPLIFIED https://bankless.cc/iYield
🔒 SAFE | INTRODUCING SAFENET https://bankless.cc/SAFE
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/114?referrer=0x077Fe9e96Aa9b20Bd36F1C6290f54F8717C5674E
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 6:02 AI in 2024 8:21 The Future of AI 12:35 Where are we on the S Curve? 17:38 AI vs Other Tech Revolutions 20:23 Are we in a Bubble? 23:59 Evolution of AI 29:06 AI x Crypto 34:12 Centralized vs Decentralized AI 37:46 AI Agents 42:32 Doomsday Scenario 47:16 Raw Crypto 52:28 Order of Trends 55:06 Silicon Valley on Crypto 58:14 Crypto Founders vs Tech Founders 1:01:27 Politics & Tech 1:14:36 Advice for 2025 1:17:13 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Elad Gil https://x.com/eladgil
Elad Gil Website https://eladgil.com/
No Priors Podcast https://www.youtube.com/@NoPriorsPodcast
Prime Open sources their 10B parameter training run https://x.com/PrimeIntellect/status/1862607165669900407
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
I do think that to some extent, one could argue that there will have been three ages of humanity, right? The first age is all the compute is roughly humans and then other animals. The second age of humanity is probably this what we have right now, which is there's some split between humans and machines and humans are directing the activity and all the rest. And probably the third age is the age of machine intelligence, right? Where that's the predominant form of compute and intelligence on the planet. Welcome to Bankless where today we explore the frontier of tech investing. This is Ryan Sean Adams.
I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless. I live with tech investing. I mean crypto, of course, is a form of tech investing. We're talking a little broader than that. We're talking not just crypto. We're talking about AI today. We have unicorn tech investor Eli Gill on the podcast. He's giving us the Silicon Valley take on AI crypto and also Silicon Valley's involvement in politics, particularly the recent involvement. So this is one part getting up to speed on everything that's going on in AI and Eli provides a masterclass in that. And then we talk about the intersection of AI and crypto in his take on that and then politics.
How will tech flourish under the new administration, what changes have we seen in the last year? Eli probably knows as much about AI as Ryan and I. Bankless knows about crypto and vice versa. He knows about crypto about the same about that. I think we know about AI. So we really start off picking his AI brain. But he's just familiar with the growth of markets, the growth of tech, having seen the rise of the internet. And so not only is he intimately familiar with these tech sectors, but especially AI, but also how investing works and how markets develop and grow and the S curves and how all these many S curves relate.
So it feels a little bit like ancient wisdom from a tech investor veteran on the podcast. He's also very calm, which I found and found very peaceful. So overall, very enjoyable episode. Does he meditate, David? Usually call it when guests meditate. And you can see he could be a meditator. He might be a meditator. We didn't get into that in the bulk of the podcast. My big question going in for him was like, okay, give me the truth on AI. Is it overhyped right now or is it appropriately hyped or is it underhyped? So stay tuned for that answer as well. Let's go ahead and get right into the episode with Elad Gale.
But first a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. Bangladesh nation very excited to introduce you to Elad Gale. He is one of Silicon Valley's greatest of all time investors. I would say that he's he's backed 40 unicorns, including Airbnb, our beloved Coinbase, Figma, Stripe. Many others. He's super active right now in AI. You actually host a podcast that I enjoy very much. It's almost like the AI sister podcast to bankless. It's called no priors. He's just in general a very prescient thinker. Today we want to get his takes on AI on crypto on the next decade of tech investing.
What the opportunities are. Elad, welcome to bankless. I don't think so much for including me. All right. So let's start with AI because David and I have been following this in various ways. The bankless audience knows about it. But we focus mainly on the crypto tech revolution, not as much AI. Catch people up. Catch us up to speed. So obviously there's a lot going on right now. How about this year? If we just zoom into this year, what are the big things like the big milestone events that happened in AI that we should be paying attention to as general tech investors? Yeah. It's kind of interesting because if you look at the history of machine learning and AI and we still all call it machine learning 10 years ago, I think what a lot of people really under appreciate is that we had a series of fundamental breakthroughs that effectively put us on a different technology curve from what we traditionally talked about machine learning.
So we used to talk about convolutional neural networks and recurrent neural networks and all these things in the 2010s with Alex net and a few of the breakthroughs around machine vision and a few other areas. And the basis for those things kind of shifted in 2017 when Google invested what are known as the the transformer. It's a specific type of architecture model for machine learning that got implemented at Google, but also to open AI in the T and GPT as transformer. And it wasn't really until chat GPT launched just two years ago that a lot of people woke up to this fundamentally different technology curve that were on.
So it's almost like we're on one curve with machine learning and then all this transformer based stuff came out and it kind of boosts it us into a different trajectory and honestly a different technology curve. And the capability set is very different from what we've experienced in the past with traditional machine learning, which is really effectively running a bunch of regressions in some sense or kind of data mining out statistical correlations between things. This wave of AI, which a lot of people are calling generative AI, is about the ability to understand and manipulate different types of language and imagery and a few other things in language includes things like code in language includes, you know, the synthesis and understanding of knowledge and there's these multi-step processes that you have and all these other things.
And so when people talk about AI, we've been talking about it for a literal decades, but I think the specific flavor of AI that we're focused on right now is only two, three years old. So even saying what's happened in the last year is almost like saying what's happened in a third or half of the time frame of which we've been aware of this really interesting technology shift that we're undergoing, right? I think there's probably a mainstream interpretation of AI and how it's going to impact our lives. We see ChatchyBT, we see its implications. Then there's stuff like, you know, custom AI generated videos and you know, deepfakes and this is all going to impact our lives in this particular way.
There's probably a consensus level understanding of how AI is going to impact us. But I'd actually like to see if there's any difference there between what you think is the future trajectory of AI. And if there's a gap between mainstream understanding of the future AI and what you think is true, is there a gap? Is there an alternative version of AI's future that you think is being underrepresented or under discussed that mainstream society, mainstream tech forward people are maybe missing? I don't know if it's under discussed. I do think in general, AI is still under hyped despite being incredibly hyped, right?
And I think the thing that people fundamentally misunderstand is as we have these advancements over time, really the product that you're selling or the end product of these AI systems is units of cognition, right? You're selling pieces of thought or ability to do things. So for example, you look at a company like Decagon and what it's doing is it's augmented customer success agents. So you're a customer support rep and you suddenly are making that person's job dramatically easier or you're tackling more of the queries that they get through users. And so each person can handle a much larger base of people and suddenly a person who only speaks English can support people in 30 plus languages 24 seven, you know, you're kind of shifting the paradigm of how work is done in the leverage that you're getting on work.
And so for the digital world, you're basically selling units of labor for the physical world. If some of these advancements and robotics come through and you know, I think that's where much earlier in that curve. And then eventually you're selling units of robot time or labor time or everyone to phrase it. And you know, it does seem likely that one of the major types of robotic chassis or approaches it will have or form factors is going to be humanoid. A, because the world that designed around that and B, because it's general purpose in terms of the things it could do, right? But that's that's much further ahead in the future.
If you just look at the digital part of it, which is very clear right now, I think eventually you're selling units of labor or thought. And that's very different from hey, we're doing this regression on a bunch of data, you know, which was machine learning. It feels a little cloud-like as in there's a cloud of labor out there that you can purchase units of labor. Is that an acceptable comparison? Yeah, I think that's a great way to put it. So as an example, eventually you'll have a series of bots that will do aspects of coding for you. And already people are using coding tools like cursor or magic or bug or devon or other things, right?
But fundamentally, as those capabilities get better and better, you're going to have the AI system do write more and more code for you or the AI system do more and more customer support for you. I don't know if you saw the tweet from the Sea of Clarner that came out maybe six to nine months ago where he said that they let go of 700 people on their customer support team because they replaced it with something they built on top of open AI and it had a higher net promoter score. They had a 25% reduction, I think, in repeat queries. It was available 24-7 and I think it was like 20 plus languages.
And the time to actually resolve the issue for a customer went down dramatically. I remember I have a 50% or some significant amount. So it's strict improvement across all domains. It's strict improvement across all domains within AI system, right? Effectively, to your point in the cloud, they created a cloud of customer success agents or help, right? Now, it wasn't quite agentic. Agentic almost implies like this thing is going to be self-acting and really deep ways. And the technology basis still has to develop to get there. But again, I think it's back to its units of cognition or labor. Have you want to phrase it?
And it's units eventually of robot minutes or robot time or physical labor time. And that's eventually what this wave is about, right? At least for a language, right? There's image gen and video and then there's all these foundation models being built for physics and material science and biology and all these other areas, which is different. And we'll have different substantiations and kind of overlap in terms of what type of person they're going to augment to replace. What I think I would love to find out from your perspective, Elad, is like where we are in kind of the S curve of this new of this new transformer sort of unlock that we've approached in AI.
So you're talking about the measure being units of productive intelligence. And in the case that you just gave is basically like some corporation has a customer support intelligence center that is primarily staffed by human agents right now. So those are its units of customer support productive intelligence. And what it's just done is in using open AI, it's been able to replace that productive intelligence with a higher form of productive intelligence. So you see that that could happen in customer support, maybe some white collar type jobs. We're also getting these version upgrades with the chat GBT's of the world, right?
So like we go from three to four and to like five to six. But at some point in time, I mean, we know in crypto, right? You sort of, you're on the other side of that S curve and kind of adoption progress for the technology that your curve that you're on just starts to Peter out. I mean, where are we on the curve here? Is this still early? Like do we have a lot of upgrades to go? Or like when does this version of the tech curve kind of stop and start getting diminishing returns? Yeah, this is an area of active debate within the AI community. And some people say, well, and really if you look at AI, there's three or four components that go into how smart the system or how capable the system is.
And part of it is how much data and what's for the data? Do you have to train it and how clean is it and how is it labeled and how is it generated and et cetera, et cetera? There's how much computer are you throwing at the thing? And you know, there's a lot of fine tuning or post trading. What do you do once you actually have the system up and running? And then there's the how much computer are you actually allocating at the time that you're doing inference, which is for the moment that you ping the AI system and ask it to do something on your behalf. And each one of those things can scale in different ways, right?
And so, oh, one from OpenAI is really focused on that last piece. And do you see that a lot happen with people like you get asked a question. And if it's a hard question, you'll think for a minute, for a few seconds or whatever and then you'll answer, you won't just spontaneously answer. And an easy question you'll immediately belt out, right? And so differentially allocating compute is what you do as a person, right? You're kind of thinking more or less. And similarly, that has its own scaling law that people think has a lot of runway on it. The training side probably still has quite a bit of headroom on it in terms of just the core.
I'm going to train a big model on a bunch of GPUs. And on the data side, there's ongoing questions of like do you move to synthetic data? Are you capturing data in new forms? Are you going to specific types of experts for the post training side of it? So I think in each of those, there's debates around how much room there is, but I think overall there's an enormous amount of room still to improve. So on the one hand, I think we're still reasonably early in the S curve. And that's again, a debatable topic. But I think there's a lot ahead. We just saw the stuff we're doing. There's a separate question.
I'd say that we stopped our progress. And we just took the models and capabilities we have today. How many more applications could we have cover for it? And there's a ton, right? Again, this technology in some sense or people's awareness of the technology is two years old. GT4 came out, but I don't know what, 16 months ago, right? And four was a big step in capabilities versus three. And that's when you could suddenly do legal. So, you know, one of the companies I've backed is Club Harvey. And they have this sort of legal assistant and set tools. And I'm 3.5, which was the version of GT4, right?
Before four, they couldn't do legal workflows. It just didn't work. It wasn't smart enough. And it forced them. It was capable enough, right? And so I kind of call it the GT ladder or step, right? As you move up from four to five to six to seven, you're opening up entirely new markets that couldn't be served before because the thing wasn't smart enough to serve them. Or you're fundamentally changing the capabilities that you can do in those markets. And if you look at SaaS in the US, it's a half trillion dollar a year or SaaS and enterprise software. It's a half trillion dollar a year market.
If you look at all this sort of white collar-ish services, the payroll for those in terms of areas that could be impacted by AI is about three and a half to five trillion. So to convert 10% of that headcount cost, just employees salaries into SaaS revenue for AI, you've recreated all of SaaS and enterprise software in terms of market cap. Right? So this is a huge revolution. And that's why I'm saying it's under height, right? And so there's there's two S curves is the technology S curve. And it's really a few different S curves stacked on top of each other, as mentioned. There's the training and the post training and there's the time of inference stuff.
And then there's the S curve of adoption. And on the S curve of adoption, really early, we're basically in the era of, you know, it's a year after the Bitcoin white paper dropped or something. And we're about to have like the Mt. Gox blow up or, you know, whatever analogy, you know, it's really early, do you know what I mean? Yeah, okay. So you're painting this portrait of stacking S curves, all of which are early, including the adoption S curve here. Can you give some insight into how transformational this will be? So you've been in Silicon Valley since the early days. You've seen kind of the birth of the the the internet and you've seen mobile and you've seen you like crypto and you've seen social media.
You've seen all of these, these kind of trends, right? And famously Peter Tiel talks about how like some of these, you know, software value, you know, creation hasn't really filtered down into like real world productivity for the rest of the way. Anyway, is this different or how does this compare to previous revolutions? I've heard some people compare the AI revolution, this this idea of unlocking productive intelligence to the industrial revolution, which was kind of like a whole new scale of productivity output for humanity. And I think that's a different trajectory, maybe than what the internet was.
Anyway, how does this stack up in terms of the the tech that you've seen come out of Silicon Valley since you've been there? Yeah, I would separate out two things. Because again, there's a digital revolution and there's the atomic revolution of robotics, right? Which is again, we're not quite there yet on the second one, but that has its own transformation curve or it's its own implications sort of globally. And self-driving cars is sort of one substantiation of that in some sense too. And that's coming. So there's really the atoms and the bits and you sort of separate that. I would separate it out.
Yeah, because that's very different society level implications, but also the degree to which you rework cities and physical labor and everything else is fundamentally different from, you know, what can you do with digital information? And the bits is happening now. That the bits is happening now. Yeah, the bits is happening now. I mean, the internet was the biggest revolution of them all for this stuff, because this AI, the set of AI systems couldn't exist without the internet and distributed compute, and either could crypto, right? And so I think a lot of the, a lot of the really big technology waves are just outcress of the internet in one form or another.
And so that to me is sort of the granddaddy thing or whatever you want to call it. But on a relative basis, I think this is much bigger than mobile. It's going to be bigger in some ways than certain aspects of social. Crypto I think has been enormously transformative mainly at least today in, you know, the financial sector. And obviously it's spilled it over into art with NFTs and it's spilled over in other ways. But I think a lot of the kind of web three premise of everything is going to be on the blockchain. And you know, how they're being on the blockchain with a token to incentivize hosts.
And you know, that stuff hasn't really proven out quite yet. And so I think, you know, it's going to be a very big revolution. And it's going to take a decade plus to substantiate one thing that we've seen in crypto is kind of these repeating hype cycles where every sort of four years or so crypto goes out of terror. And then it sort of gets ahead of itself in terms of, you know, the market price reflecting kind of the reality of where the technology and where the adoption actually is. Sure. And I'm trying to like paint this picture for crypto investors onto AI. Do you anticipate something similar where basically it will happen in waves?
And you know, I don't know where we are in the first wave. But it's been incredible to see the evaluations of companies like Nvidia of this cycle, just like, you know, absolutely explode into the most valuable company in the world. And so it's hard to look at that and not look at some crypto analogs. Well, okay, maybe AI is going to be a long-term transformational technology. But are there periods of time within the decades of that transformation where it gets kind of overhyped from a market perspective? Like are these companies making money? Do they have business models yet? Yeah. I mean, Nvidia is clearly making money.
So I think that's everything is valued so highly. But that's one of those like reflexive money type things, right? It's like, it's making money because there's so much demand for GPUs and chips because there's so much, you know, I guess hype going into the other elements of AI. Well, it's not just hype. It's really interesting. So if you look at the foundation model world, or at least LLM's, these large language models, which is, you know, open AI is GPT, or, you know, cloud from entropic or sonic from entropic or, you know, kind of name your your model Google and Bard and all the things you're doing there or Gemini.
You know, fundamentally, the reason the hyperscalers ended up as a primary backers of these big model companies, right? AWS probably is the biggest backer of entropic now. And Microsoft is the biggest backer of open AI, etc. Is because it also drives enormous revenue on their clouds for AI services, right? So Microsoft had something like a $28 billion quarter or last quarter. And I think they publicly said that 15% of the lift on that quarter. So that's what three and a half or a billion dollars came from AI. That's, that's incredible. That's, that's significant, right? And so these things were translating into real revenue.
And it's happening at startups where some ECS startup go from zero to 10 to 50 in two years, which is insane in terms of any sort of traditional SaaS application. You see that in terms of the rumored numbers around open AI where they're now in the billions of revenue after two years or three years of offering GPT as an API that is actually being used, right? I mean, these are insane adoption curves. Now, there's a separate question of what is it your ability of a giving company? Relative to these adoption curves because overall the segment's going to happen. It's such a useful and powerful technology.
And it gives you so many capabilities and so many cost savings and so many new revenue streams and all the rest of it that it's happening and it's going to happen. And then the question is who wins? And for each layer of the stack, right, you have the foundation models, actually have the chips within video, you have the foundation models, you have apps, actually have infrastructure, then you have apps and then with an app to be to be and you have consumer. And within that stack of stuff for each sector, you can kind of go through and ask, is it an oligopoly market? Is it monopoly? Is it highly fragmented?
Who wins? Why? What's the defensibility of each one of these things, right? What's the technology basis for winning? Do they have to build their own models or not? So there's all that stuff, right? And so I think the direction is clear. The who in some cases is clear and in some cases it's less clear. And it's the old thing about how the future in some cases is determined and but you just don't know who's going to be the person who drives that piece of the future, right? But you know that future is coming. And I think that's very true here. I mean, we've definitely seen that with crypto. It's been hard to predict to the individual, what the individual networks that like we now are going to be, but we sort of know that the future is inevitable.
I want to ask you a question about the evolution of this market. So you're painting the patriarchy lad of, this is an early market. It's still actually underhyped from your perspective, even at this point in time. How do you think this industry evolves? And there's different levers on this. A lot of the value right now seems to be going in kind of, I don't know if you call this the platform layer, but like, you know, the Mag 7 and some of these big companies, right? There's also this other layer. We could talk about like closed source versus open source. I mean, something that the crypto advocates are very passionate about is decentralization, right?
Anybody being like able to use this technology. Sure. There are different versions of that in AI, but that's something that I'm sure you support permissionless decentralized ability for anybody to spin up these tools and for not to be cloistered in some walled garden. Anyway, what do you think of this this market structure? Will it be centralized? Will there be kind of power law winners here? Or will this be more diffuse? I mean, will we see decade unicorns in the startup world start to compete against some of these Mag 7 companies? Yeah, there's a ton of questions I want you to say. So let me try and tackle them one by one.
I think one is around open source versus closed source. And obviously I'm a huge fan of open source software. I think both will happen in this market segment. And I think arguably both have happened in crypto, right? You have Dex's, but you also have centralized exchanges. And a lot of the things that are supposedly decentralized are actually way more centralized than people really see at first blush, right? Like how many people can actually commit to Bitcoin core? And how many miners actually make up what proportion of the network? It's pretty centralized actually in some ways. So you look at Salana or other protocols and related, at least sometimes there's more centralization and less centralization, right?
And so the same is going to be true in this world where the really big open source models of the foundation model layer at this point are basically Lama from Meta and then Mistral. Right? And there's a bunch of other stuff. But at least for the language model side, those are the ones that are I think most prominent. And then there's other types of open source models for a wide range of other areas in terms of things that have come out of academia for robotics or weather simulation or biology. So you can kind of go through one by one and ask, will it be close source or open source? And to some extent, the hard part for open source and traditional software, which is different from crypto where you can often monetize in other ways through a token or there's two or three ways actually that you can monetize open source and crypto.
Many of those things don't apply in the AI world. And it's much more like traditional SaaS where you have to figure out a business model around the thing and charge for it. And so for Lama, there's a few things that I thought were really clever that Facebook did. One is if you're over a certain user number, I can't remember what it was in the original license, it was like if you had over 700 million users, you had to pay for it or license it, otherwise you could use it freely. And so that meant if you're a hyperscaler and you were trying to put Lama on your platform, you had to license it. Or if you were one of the really, really big social networks or companies with enormous numbers of users, you'd have to license it.
Everybody else could use it for free. I thought that was very clever of them. Can you elaborate on why that's clever? Why does that work so well? Why is that a good mechanism? Because I think it does two things. One is potentially, and I don't have any insights into how Facebook thought about it, it potentially creates a monetization path for Lama because all the big hyperscalers, if they want to adopt it, they have to license it and pay for it. And again, if it's driving cloud services, they should benefit from that. It also I think means that the very large competitors of meta can't just adopt it and compete with meta using their own technology.
And so because then they kind of bridged the gap of having something that was roughly fully open-source, but for the things that I'm assuming they really cared about, it was effectively close source or at least you had to license it. I thought that was really smart. And that meant any developer can just pick it up and start using it almost anywhere in the world. That's amazing. Right? So I think a lot of the value of that type of open source is probably going to go to the infrastructure providers and then app companies that want to use that as a differentiator. The reality is, at least today, a lot of people are using open AI or cloud as sort of the starting point and then if they figure something out, then they'll go and maybe fine tune and open weights in open source model like Lama.
But it's kind of like, try down an API first where you don't have to do a lot of heavy lifting and see if it works. And then if you think you can really optimize it or you're worried about data security or whatever, maybe. And again, I think the data is quite secure using these other APIs. But if you have some concern about sending data back, then sometimes you go down the open source throughout and fine tune your model or do whatever it is you need to do. We've discussed the multiple adoption curves, S curves of the growth of AI and why it seems to be that it can accelerate very quickly in the near term.
I want to introduce one more adoption curve S curve of technology, which is crypto. And where I think we're starting to approach cryptos like middle of the S curve these days, especially with Bitcoin crossing $100,000. I'm wondering if you're paying attention to the intersection of crypto AI. And this intersection has been growing right after chat GPT launched. I remember there was like kind of a surgeons of crypto AI tokens, like right afterwards, kind of just riding the narrative of AI. And it was, it didn't really make any sense. It was kind of like, I'm going to call it Stone Age version of crypto AI is very rudimentary.
It wasn't real. But that was over two years ago. And since then, I think there have been some developers who are really trying to make this work, like trying to figure out how do these two parallel frontier technologies? How do they intersect? How do they grow together? And lately, there's been some very strong sparks that have probably actually turned into at least a small to medium size wildfire in the crypto world hasn't really broken out into mainstream. And this is kind of the story of truth terminals. I'm not sure if you're too familiar. There's, but the number one GitHub down the forked and starred GitHub repo right now is the Eliza framework, which is allowing people to build their own AI agents, some with crypto wallets, some just vanilla agents.
Sure. So I'm wondering, are you observing the space? Is this space interesting to you? And if you just have any takes? Yeah, I have like four or five comments on it, I guess. The first thing that I think is fascinating, do you know the origin of near? The near protocol you're talking about with Elia and team? Yeah, I mean, it was a AI origin, right? Yeah, exactly. Elia has a very well-sighted AI paper. Yeah, he's on the transformer paper. He's on the original transformer paper. He's the last author on that paper. Oh wow, fun fact. I don't know that actually. Yeah, and so when my understanding is when he, when he left a star near, and it was called near.
ai, right, it was a early AI company. And they were originally going to do almost like GPT style stuff. And they decided they needed to do, and I hope I'll be correct me on all this. My understanding is it decided that they need to do a lot of data labeling. And they're like, how can we pay people to label data around the world, maybe use Ethereum? And of course, Ethereum wasn't scalable back then, right? That's why we have all the L2 stuff and all the all the rollout, all the stuff we're doing on top of Ethereum now. So they said, hey, how do we create a really scalable protocol so that we can create tokens that can be used to pay people around the world, the labeled data so that we can then build a giant AI system?
I think that's that origin of near. It was fascinating, right? Or at least some version of the origin store that I've heard of it. So I think there's long been an intersection of the people who are interested in AI and the people who are interested in crypto. And I almost feel like in a given era, when one of them has been hotter than the other, it's people's career in one direction or the other. You know, I don't know if you know Umar Roy from Susinct, right? Yeah, she's great, right? And so that's a great example of somebody who did a lot of AI and ML at MIT. And maybe if she'd started her company two years later, she would be doing AI stuff right now.
I mean, she's brilliant, right? And she's very smart on ZK and the mathematics underlying it. But you know, there's stuff like that that I think is just fascinating in terms of these paths that are almost like moment in time dependent on when you graduate. And maybe she wouldn't crypto anyhow. I don't know. I'm just saying like she had that background, right? And so I think there's a lot of overlap in the backgrounds of people interested in these things, at least a subset of people. So I think that's one aside just in terms of the human capital or the people who are excited about it. I think there's three or four approaches that people have been taking to that intersection of AI and crypto.
And a lot of it is over time has been can we create these data repositories where you get paid in tokens, delayable data or use data or do data, et cetera. There's the distributed compute stuff, which I'm more skeptical about. Those reasons you centralize these things usually. One could argue world coin isn't part of proxy and sample and you know, mimetically. There is identity, which I think is super interesting. And actually, do you think like a blockchain resident identity could be used by the agentech AI world. And then still surprised nobody's about like a truly good identity system on the blockchain.
There's payments, which is kind of the obvious one, which is why maybe you mentioned building AI with the wallet attached because it'd be natural for an algorithmic agent to transact using crypto. I think the censorship and censorship resistance is super important aspect of crypto that AI doesn't have. And I think that is showing up in almost like what you call the politics of the models, right? Because the models real bearing steer down very political, the specific subset of political paths, right? They kind of reflect the Bay Area and the Bay Area politics is basically what you see when you interact with one of these systems.
And that may not be a good thing for humanity or all. So I think there's a lot of ways that these things kind of intersect. One conversation in the crypto space is the idea of decentralized versus centralized AI. We have the chat, UBT, the open AI, the Facebooks, Google's with a lot of resources, the benefits of centralized coordination. I think really pushing the frontier of AI, really introducing it into society into mainstream. And then in response to that, there's been a growing parallel world of decentralized AI, which I think has some difficulties because I think maybe one of the biggest drawbacks is that decentralized versions of AI don't have access to the same data that open AI that meta does.
But there's been some victories. One thing that has come on my radar as of recently is prime intellect. I'm not sure if you're too familiar, but the story that I've heard is that these decentralized, these training models have had some constraint in the centralized form factor of training of AI training. Prime intellect is a decentralized training platform. I'm kind of like out on my ski tips here explaining this technically, but they were able to poke through to break through a glass ceiling of the number of parameters that they were able to use. Meaningfully, from I think the constraint in the centralized world was something like 400 million parameters, and now they're breaking through at 10 billion.
So a very significant increase in part of the decentralized structure of the AI revolution is starting to get some wins versus their centralized counterparts. I'm wondering if this is how you see this dichotomy. There's two different worlds of AI. There's decentralized AI and the decentralized AI. They're both developing and iterating forward into the future. Is that how you see it? Not really. I tend to think of it more as open source and closed source. Open source may include open weights. It may include open data sets. It may include all these things. I don't think you need to necessarily decentralize the compute.
I don't think that is necessarily helpful unless you're like we can't afford it otherwise or we're crowdsourcing it. There's reasons to do it. We can't buy all the GPU whatever it is, but I don't really view it through that framework because the decentralization is not additive in this context as far as I can tell unless again it addresses some of those other issues I mentioned. It's more just what's out in the open that anybody can use and how can they use it? I think that's the vector I would care about the most. It's the one other thing that I used to speculate on that. I no longer do around crypto and AI.
By the way, I think it's really cool. They built a 10 billion parameter model in a decentralized way. I'm not trying to say it's not cool and interesting. It's more just the dimensions I care about are what's open versus closed and who has access versus it to centralized or decentralized. The thing I think is interesting is if you think about the blockchain, you've always had these kind of programmatic agents and simple agents acting on Ethereum, smart contracts and other things were effectively these programmatic pre-bake things that happen with strong economic value associated with them. Four or five years ago, I used to speculate what was the blockchain the first place where artificial general intelligence emerges because you have these economic games that are played repeatedly between effectively agentic systems.
What a wonderful place to actually train an agent or an AI. Maybe that's the place where the decentralized AI step is super interesting. If you basically have these selective functions on blockchain resident agents playing economic games at scale and learning off of them, that's really cool. I think that's been more of my personal interest. I think when David and I started really getting into the intersection of AI and crypto is more on the agentic properties of it because the idea of crypto is this podcast is called bankless. It's the ability for individual humans to go bankless. But actually, the most un-underbanked population of the future is probably going to be AI agents.
Very difficult to you can open up a stripe account, but then you have 3% credit card transaction fees. They open up an AI. The form factor of a blockchain with programmable money and property rights is basically fit for purpose for AI agents. You need a social security number to open up a stripe account. Some of the early use cases, which are starting to be interesting and some of those frameworks that David mentioned is almost like the AI agent influencer package. He's talking about Eliza. There's this platform called virtual. There's this meme account called Truth Terminal on Twitter and it has this goat token.
It's basically almost like taking the job of influencers, like crypto influencers. It's like playing almost like attention economy type of games and AI agents in the LLM models that we've created are pretty good at interacting with humans and passing the Turing test and being interesting to interact with. That's been the early, almost like toy version of AI agents on chain. It's been interesting to see when you hook up a Twitter account basically and allow the LLM to kind of talk about whatever it wants and pair that with a crypto wallet. Create that token incentive. What experiments fall out of that?
To your point, I actually think that thesis of the AGI comes through this intersection of crypto and AI could be a spot on as this evolves. That's the potential that we've been more excited about recently. People look at it and they're just like, it's just meme coin games. You just hooked a Twitter account to an LLM model and it's pumping a meme token and who cares? What's your take on this trend? Do you think there's something here? I think it's really interesting training data for an AI. Again, if you're getting back into economic game theory and how humanity evolved and what are the set of drivers for evolutionary progress?
Probably a lot of it was forms of economic games. I think as a training set, it's super interesting. Obviously, you still need skill of compute and you need all this other stuff. I do think it's really interesting from that perspective. One of the big future AGI concerns or safety concerns that Anthropic talks about is resource aggregation by AI. They spend less time talking about, hey, we'll let an AI invent a virus that will do XYZ and all this stuff, because I think it's actually not very likely any time soon. They're more like, what if an AI is smart enough to start aggregating resources at scale and using those resources to manipulate society and how do you prevent that?
It's crypto would be a good basis for that. Basically, the AI as a god or forming a religion or creating some sort of memetic social movement, something like this. Not even as a god. What if this is very good at predicting stock movements and it just starts getting a bunch of money and paying people to do stuff for it? It gets us more money. It's more about that form of safety. I do think that to some extent, one could argue that there will have been three ages of humanity. The first age is all the compute is roughly humans and then other animals from a concentration perspective of its humans.
That was probably leading up into the century. Then we have a hybrid age. The second age of humanity is probably what we have right now, which is there's some split between humans and machines and humans are directing the activity and all the rest. Probably the third age is the age of machine intelligence. That's the predominant form of compute and intelligence on the planet. To some extent, perhaps we're very lucky to be in the second age. It seems like a limbo period. It's a waiting room for the third period. The grand scheme of things is going to be all of humanity is in the first age. Then we have this very short amount of time where we figured out how to get computers to think, but dumbly, like calculators.
Now, I think the third age is how you're describing it is now they think on their own. There's a lot of them. Compute perspective, there's way more intelligence embodied in machines at some point than there are in people. We're not there yet. But at some point, that will happen in the coming decades. Does that third age scare you sometimes? We actually opened up the rabbit hole of crypto by talking to Elise or Yutkowski. He's definitely has a defined thought on this kind of a doom take on AGI in general. But should we fear this third age? Maybe it's inevitable. I guess we're all investing in it to some extent.
Part of the thing we worry about, if you take Elise or Yutkowski's line of view is, oh, cool. We've created this property rights and financial system, an economic resource allocation system for a bunch of robots that are going to enslave us or obliterate humanity. Great job, crypto. Do you have any worries like that? I'm not part of a doomsday cult. I feel like some of the progress and investigators in this topic are basically doomsday cult leaders. It's not, I'm saying anybody's specific. I'm saying in general, there are these things that effectively feel like doomsday cults. And they have AGI as the before it was like the meteor striking the earth or some religious event.
And it's almost like a religious rapture in some of these people's minds. I think my take is a bit measured, which is I would kind of view myself as like a AGI or safety moderate. I think there's enormous good coming through AI. And I think we're only in the earliest innings. And if I look at global health, equity and educational equity and all the rest of it, or how do you want to phrase it? These are the things that are going to drive the ability of humanity to participate at scale in ways that they couldn't before. Everybody should be able to get a one-on-one tutor education that's best in class in the world.
And everybody should be able to have access to the world's best medical information through any device. And that's coming. Now at some point, there will be these very intelligent machines. And we'll be interacting with them in different ways. And I don't know what that world looks like. Like I can speculate. But I think it's very hard to say what, and years or decades from now, things are going to be. It's the old saying that less happens than you think in technology in two years and more happens than you think in five years. And once you hit 10 years, like it's game over, like 10 years ago, we wouldn't be predicting any of this stuff.
We wouldn't be predicting the stuff that SpaceX is doing. We wouldn't be predicting the quantum computing stuff that Google just released. We wouldn't be predicting this wave of generative AI. Nobody predicted this different curve on the transformer models. So I just think it's very hard to think 10 years out. Then we've also over predicted certain things that didn't end up happening in terms of technology curves. You're a market veteran. You're a tech evolution veteran. You've seen a thing or two. Now, we have these two emerging frontier technologies, AI and crypto. I think we've talked about AI quite a bit.
I want to just kind of get your takes on raw crypto, crypto without the AI. When you're looking over into the world of crypto, you're seeing Bitcoin in 2009, Ethereum in 2015, Coinbase going public circle. These companies that are just evolving, maturing, the industries becoming legitimized, regulatory. We've had regulatory oversight. We've now we have regulatory leniency or at least we think that's what we're getting. Just like what patterns are being sparked? It was what's your what's your overall take? You've seen a thing or two before. What do you was resonating with you in the growth of our industry?
At this point, I feel like I'm reasonably ignorant on crypto. I used to spend a lot of time on crypto and I did a lot of crypto investing in 2016, 2017, et cetera, and got involved with companies like Coinbase and some of the protocol level things and then index funds like Bitwise and just different things across the industry, StarCware and that early work and all sorts of early ZK stuff like Mina and other early adopters in different ways, do you ZK? I think it's amazing what the crypto industry has accomplished. I think it is a fundamental thing that's here to stay. Usually when I look at these sorts of technology shifts that are so important and so fundamental, I try to distill it down into use cases like what are the specific aspects of the technology that make it uniquely good for a specific application or use case because otherwise nobody's going to use it.
And that's sometimes where I feel like people in any market segment, especially if it's a lot of technologists lose their way because they start extrapolating all the stuff off of the technology that nobody actually cares about, but they think should happen because the technology is so good, and so the mobile version of that is if you look at the really big mobile-centric companies that got formed, it's the companies that uniquely took advantage of the new capabilities of phones, which was GPS, so location, always on. It was the instant ability to message or it said push notifications, et cetera, and roughly what that collapsed into was social products like WhatsApp and others, Instagram, whatever it is, and then Uber, you push a button and then a stranger shows up in a car and you're okay getting in, and they'll take you to wherever you want, right?
Instacard and other delivery services, right? So you kind of go through and you say where were the new startups or new things created? And obviously there's enormous encompassing usage, right? Like B of A apps and all this stuff now, but the main things where the mobile revolution was important was one opening up access nonstop to the internet, but because you had a device you could carry with you everywhere, a super computer in your pocket, but second, was these unique things that were enabled by GPS and text messaging and all the rest of it, right? And so for crypto, it's the same question of, okay, what are the core capabilities of crypto?
Because some versions of blockchains, and obviously it's much more sophisticated now, but in the early days, a blockchain was kind of like a shitty database, right? That had very unique characteristics that made it incredibly important around censorship resistance and permission of the systems and all the rest of it, right? And then you ask, well, where are those unique capabilities really important? You know, you have this 24, 7 accessible financial system, right? That's emerged. And that's things like store value, like Bitcoin, it's DeFi, you know, it's a bunch of stuff like that in my mind.
So I almost view it as like, what are the capabilities of the system and therefore what are the unique use cases versus, hey, it's just going to do everything. Do you like Chris Dixon's framing of this, which is like he goes through, you know, he wrote a book called Read Write Own, which is basically Web 1 is as read Web 2 is right, you know, so you get blogs in that kind of era. And then Web 3 with crypto is own. So it's this idea of like property rights, which fits into store value, decentralized finance, the ability to spin up assets that are like digitally scarce. Is that the rubric through which you view crypto use cases?
No, I kind of view it more as like, when do you need these capabilities? I mean, it overlaps, right? And there's a lot of things that haven't happened in crypto that I thought would happen. Like what? What are you thinking would happen? I mean, do your point of property rights, like a public ledger of who owns what property? So therefore, you're, you can avoid government seizure of your land or other assets, right? Or the notion of identity on the blockchain, where you should be able to fragment identity, but probably show that you did stuff. So for example, you can probably show you on one identity strand or, you know, one wallet or however you want to kind of assign identity that you're a Google engineer and you've done XYZ things, and then on the other one that you're a contributor to some dow or something that you're anonymous on or student on on, right?
So there's a bunch of stuff like that that hasn't happened that the blockchain feels like a really good fifth floor because you can transparently in the clear approved identity without having to reveal identity. What's really difficult in this, and I'd love your take on this is it's hard to determine kind of the order of operation through which these things will happen. Like some of those use cases that you mentioned, like identity, I'm personally, you know, David and I are both personally big believers that identity will happen on chain at some point in time, like ZK tech stack just like makes so much sense for this use case where you can just like prove prove prove something without disclosing all of your, you know, private information about it.
But to your point, right? Like crypto has not really done much in the identity space. Like Bitcoin has been the big use case has been like store value being the big use case. And some of the things that we thought would happen earlier haven't happened yet. But the question is will they happen in kind of the fullness of time? How do you get the order of operation right sure in these different tech trends? I think that's a great question. And if I knew the answer to that, I'd be retired right now. I think that I'm joking about retiring. But I think I was going to say, I'm sure you could retire.
You're just like, you know, just like like what you're doing too much. Retiring is boring. Yeah, I don't know. It sounds pretty nice. So I think that the order of operation is a great question, particularly with some identity where you kind of have to bootstrap up a network and the usage of it and all the rest of it, right? I think for other areas, it's just never going to work because it just doesn't matter. Like the argument for like a decentralized Uber was well, every driver can buy a token and therefore have a stake in Uber and you could go buy Uber stock. Yeah. You know what I mean? It's not.
And so I feel like some of these things are a little bit overstated in terms of like, you know, decentralization and a token will magically make something occur. But the flip side of it is like a store of value where you can cross a border with literally a billion dollars in your head, which nobody can seize is amazing, right? That's a superior product to gold. There's a pure product to whatever store of art or whatever you're going to cross a border with, right? And so I do think that there's a lot of stuff like that encrypted that's really important. And again, I do think DeFi is an example of that.
I think, you know, all the stable coins and all the USDC and all the whatever form you want to talk about, like all that stuff was clearly going to be really useful for all sorts of applications. And so I just think there's a lot, a lot that crypto is accomplished and a lot still to do and it's very exciting. And the place where I see crypto companies sometimes get a little bit lost is either they just go all and I'm building some really cool piece of infrastructure that doesn't necessarily have an application yet or really focusing on like a use case where the existing centralized version works just fine.
What would you say, Elad, is kind of the mainstream Silicon Valley take on crypto right now because I feel like I've been charting this from the outside a little bit. It felt like there have been periods of time where there's some pretty intense skepticism about crypto, just like this term that you used earlier of, you know, it's just a slow database, like who cares? Or like, you know, I don't understand why Bitcoin is worth what it is. This feels like a tool up mania. And, you know, this has been present at various times. In fact, a lot of the crypto startups have just like not happened in Silicon Valley.
They've happened outside of sort of the VC Silicon Valley apparatus. What does Silicon Valley think about crypto now or do they not think about it? Silicon Valley all like AI, AI, AI, and you know, this crypto thing's happening on the side, but it's like less interesting. How has the narrative really shifted? I don't know. I think there's a subset of founders and firms on the venture side and all the rest have continued to just participate in crypto ongoing, right? And so, you know, and then there's obviously specialist firms that have kind of spun up, right? So, you know, in terms of the broader firms, obviously, in recent, it's continued to do a lot of crypto with critics and in others there.
There's been standalone firms that obviously either spun out of existing institutions or set up on the road and that's paradigm and electric and on ventures and, you know, you name it, right? There's a bunch of different folks. And they're all based in Silicon Valley, right? It feels like maybe the biggest shift over the last couple of years is the degree to which momentum really increased for me or is one of the core places for crypto over the last five years or whatever time period you want to put on it. And it was almost like this transition from L1 to other layers, right? Because it felt like that L1 stuff continued to be out here for a while in the Bay Area.
And then it kind of shifted elsewhere. And obviously, it was always distributed and those people working from all over. But I just feel like the type of work or almost the subcluster and crypto for a while at least reflected the nature of the work being done in terms of the geography where there was concentrations of people. But I think mainstream tech maybe 20% of people always thought crypto was really important and kept thinking it was important. And then maybe there was 30 or 40 people who swing in and out based on Bitcoin price. There's 30, 40% will always be skeptical. And, you know, those are the people who are like, get off my lawn, you know, kids playing there.
You know, it's very, and some of these folks are very smart. I just think it's a little bit backwards looking because I think it's clear that those use cases is clear that there's adoption. And I do think there's a lot of assets that are reflexive and it's one of them. And it's hit that escape velocity in my opinion, barring something really unexpected or, you know, some quantum attack or God knows what. But even that, it'll survive it. And obviously, there's quantum resistant algorithms that you can add. You know, it's just there aren't that many things I can think of that would disrupt it outside of, you know, civilization and all events at this point.
But I could be wrong on that, you know, maybe regulation, like a global lockdown from a regulatory perspective with some tyrannical world government or something, you know, I would love to pick your brain on regulation because it affects many things in a and crypto, you know, like one last thing while we're on kind of like crypto companies and the evolution there is crypto founders. So you've had an opportunity to invest, like, and work with many of the, you know, the best tech founders in the space, you know, people like Paul Merlucky, Brian Armstrong, of course, you know, Coinbase, who we're very familiar with, Dylan at Figma, I'm wondering if you think that basically the tech founders, you like generally are similar to the crypto tech founders.
Or if you think that there's a different pattern with a crypto tech founder, one thing that's kind of breaking the mold a little bit in crypto is obviously you have the original crypto tech founder, which is Satoshi. And like, who is this person, right? They just appeared. This is not normal. Like that's certainly not something that happens. Then you have people like Vitalik. And he has like Vitalik almost has not like Mark Zuckerberg CEO type qualities. There's almost something like David and I have described as like munchish about it. He's just almost like a, he's a, he's a movement founder, not a tech company founder.
Right. Yeah. He's founded it. An entire movement, it feels like I'm just like a Dalai Lama type figure. There's like, I don't want to impose this on him. But there's something like kind of movement religious about it in a way. And then you also have the Brian Armstrong's and Jesse Powell's of the world and the Hayden Adams and such. Anyway, are there differences between crypto founders and tech founders? Or are they kind of like, you know, same patterns? It's an interesting question. I feel like to your point, there's been multiple different types of ways of crypto founders. Because it went from a true backwater, right?
When the Bitcoin paper dropped and, you know, you had to be kind of weird to get into it, right? And you were, you know, using it to buy pizzas and, you know, all this stuff, just to try and get other people to adopt it, right? If you remember those days where they were just giving out Bitcoin to, trying to get anybody to do something. And so that, that was a wave of people. And obviously, that also came out of more of a kind of right leaning technology community, which is very different from the internet, which was very left leaning in terms of its origins, right? In terms of the types of people working on it.
And as you kind of moved up and down the stack, you change the type of founders that show up. And I remember there's also an era of a lot of like professor coins, right? And like 2017 or 2018, like every, every professor working on crypto, like, launch their own token, right? Or was working on a token. And there's kind of the AI equivalents of that where you have kind of these professor AI companies, right? There's these new architecture, model company that spins out of an academic lab. And it has a very similar characteristic where there is a lot of money. And then sometimes that execution is lacking.
I mean, obviously, there's good versions of that too. So there are some analogs or parallels. I feel in different areas of each of these things. As mentioned, I do think there's people like Uma from Sasing, or a number of other people, Ilya from Nier, who have done both or could have done both. And so I do think there's a lot of overlap. And then obviously, there's also differences in terms of either some of the philosophical perspectives or political alignments or other things between the two communities. And sometimes they overlap, but sometimes they don't. So Ilya, I want to pick your brain on politics from a different angle here.
This is just like Silicon Valley's entrance and big text entrance into the political landscape in 2024. We've certainly seen this in crypto. And David and I have been you're like tracking it quite closely, but I, in general, I've never seen tech so political. You know, you have Elon Musk. You have the all-in podcast gang. You have Mark Andreessen talking about politics. Of course, in crypto, it's taken the form of being like Brian Armstrong, Jesse Powell from Kraken, the fair shake pack, like political donations, public advocacy for pro crypto candidates, all of these things. Just a couple of weeks ago, we had conversations around debanking, go viral, and that has kind of a political lens to it as well.
What's your story for why tech got political in 2024? Did this need to happen? Yeah, I mean, I think there's always been some overlap between tech and politics. And so if you even go back, you know, 100 years or 80 years to World War II and all of the industrialists being pulled in to basically be able to create large-scale weapon systems and other things for the US military during World War II. I mean, that was effectively a mobilization of what was a prior generation of tech in some sense, right? When tech was more about automotive or more about shipbuilding or more, you know, all these things that were high tech of its day, Detroit used to be the high tech capital of the world in some sense during the automotive industry boom.
And there was very similar cluster effects and everything else that happened during that era that now are happening in Silicon Valley. So I think one could argue on one level that there's been this engagement in different ways or different forms. Obviously, I think there's a period where technology went very kind of libertarian and very kind of hands-off from government and vice versa. And one could argue one of the reasons tech has been so optimistic over time is because it was so lightly regulated and so you could be optimistic. Because if you're heavily regulated, you tend to always have constraints around you and so you become more pessimistic in some sense around the world.
And you can actually see the most regulated industries when you talk to people in them are often the most pessimistic in terms of what can actually be done, right? You have very clear guardrails and not set of those guardrails you can't do much, right? So I would argue part of tech optimism is due to a lack of regulation. And I think that if you look at prior administrations, there are always ways of tech people participating. So the Obama administration and a number of different people from Google actually joined the administration and then some of them cycled back out to companies like Facebook and Google and others.
So I think there has been some back and forth. I think maybe the difference is that in this cycle, some of the most prominent people in tech are very actively engaged. And that's Elon Musk to your point is some of the other folks you mentioned, data sucks, etc. And these are people who built very large-scale companies and had enormous success. And now they're building that perspective, bringing that perspective and skill set and everything else to government in a really deep way. And I think part of that is because there may be this moment in time is being recognized about being able to affect large-scale change and actually change the system.
And that would be things like doge, the department of government efficiency and sort of the changes in some of the Supreme court rulings, it may actually enable it to happen. When before you didn't have that legal framework to do so, Chevron and other things. And then I think part of it is that certain aspects of government became highly weaponized against aspects of tech. And that's the banking stuff that you mentioned. That was going after Elon Musk in different ways across different companies. I think there was a dozen or two dozen different lawsuits from different federal agencies against Tesla and SpaceX.
I think the most egregious one was where as a government contractor, they had to hire legal US residents. And so there's one rule in the books that says as a government contractor, you have to do that. And then there's another rule in the book that says you can't discriminate against immigrants. And so you get sued either way, depending on what you're doing, right? So how can you function in that environment and why did his company specifically get sued? And so if you're being targeted, of course, you're going to try and do something, right? What do you think about Doge? So now Elon Musk is going to bite back along with Vivek.
Are you optimistic about Doge? Maybe you like Doge in theory? We're waiting to see it and play out in practice. What do you think? I think that if they're able to pull off what they're hoping to, then it is a truly once-in-a-generation opportunity to affect massive change that can cascade through time in a positive way. So if you're actually able to reduce certain types of regulation and certain size of government and all the rest, it could be extremely freeing for the US economy, for progress, for the capabilities of the country, the economy, people's participation in the economy, etc., technology progress, all that stuff.
So I think it could be incredibly positive. Now obviously there's certain things that are important to maintain while you do that, right? So for example, I'm very happy that the FDA has prevented the tainting of baby formula in the US, which has happened in China, right? I think that's really good. We probably don't want to get rid of that, right? But there's other aspects of things that we probably do want to change and that we want to change significantly. And part of it too is just asking, are we functioning within the proper legal framework relative to the US? In other words, is it constitutional to have all these agency setting rules that they weren't necessarily tasked with doing to begin with, right?
That go outside of their mandate and that should potentially be legislated by Congress, right? And so there are also interesting legal questions of are we in compliance legally as a government and as a country? And if not, then we should probably fix that either by changing the laws to say, hey, we're now in compliance or getting people into compliance, right? That's the reason we have legal frameworks is to kind of set the rules by which we do things in government. I know one thing in kind of watching this crypto get political, watching this up close firsthand over the past four years, I think you're very right that in particular crypto leaned kind of libertarian, right?
We're doing our store value thing. We don't need the nation's state to kind of interfere. We're not going to get involved in politics. It turned out that, you know, this happened in kind of 2022 that somebody actually changed that in crypto. His name was Sam Beckman-Freed. And he started to getting very active in politics only in a negative way in that kind of blew up in our face. And I personally watched first hand as people who are, I would say, more libertarian right leaning by philosophy, people like Brian Armstrong, in the wake of 2022, in 2023 and 2024, say, okay, we can no longer afford to do this.
Politics is actually existential for crypto at this point. We had the Gary Gensler attacks. We had, you know, the FDIC and various debanking types of movement. So for crypto, it really felt existential this election cycle in 2024. And that's why there is so much funding, there's so much advocacy, so much work done to actually push pro crypto politicians. I think that's largely been successful. I know Mark Andreessen has taken the point that, you know, everything that was going on in crypto was sort of act one for what the existing government apparatus plan to do around technology. Act two was a whole bunch of handcuffs and aggressive actions against AI to try to, you know, capture that from a regulatory perspective.
From your purchase, did you kind of see that in AI? Like, you're watching what is going on in crypto and like, okay, well, you know, this is starting to affect AI and it could really offset the US's progress in this incredibly important tech field. Yeah, I mean, I felt like there was three or four things all happening at once, right? So to your point, there was the crypto side of it where, you know, you had kind of what felt like reasonably random enforcement action that wasn't quite enforcement action, but with these warning letters that, you know, is very like unclear frameworks for how you can actually function and then sort of action against companies that fell either politically motivated or suited random.
You also had censorship at the social network side, right, which was clearly coordinated with the government, at least if you look at the Twitter files or other things, then you had strong antitrust activity that in some cases seemed justified. In some cases, it was just kind of weird. And then to your point on the AI side, there was this interest in getting really heavily involved from a regulatory perspective. And I think this sort of doomsday cold stuff helped fuel the ability for politicians to do that. But it felt to me like a lot of that activity was just another way to try and take control of the tech industry.
It wasn't, it was at opening to regulate tech more broadly. It wasn't a, hey, we care about AI or understand it deeply, right? I mean, if you talk to the people behind it, they didn't necessarily, and some people were very bright about what AI is and how it works, but a lot of the regulatory action that was coming felt like, hey, there's some aid in the administration who kind of wants to get a handhold on tech, and this was a way in, right? And the tech industry was semi welcoming it. Now, some of the people who were welcoming it, perhaps were doing so because regulatory capture, the ability to have a lot of extra rules tends to help incumbents and hurt startups.
And so this was sort of the big tech versus little tech thing of like these were very, in some cases, maybe kind of pro big tech things that would have hurt a lot of innovation at startups. So I think, you know, fundamentally, it's back to like, are we other clear regulatory and legal frameworks? Do they make sense? Are we complying with them at multiple levels, company level, government level, etc. And in the cases where we're not, or we're acting well outside of our mandate in ways that are potentially quite negative, societally, or sectorally, like, why are we doing that? And how do we stop that in a behavior, right?
And there have been absolutely, obviously, bad actors in crypto, and there will be bad actors in AI. And, you know, and so it's good that there's some regulatory framework for this stuff, but we just did to make sure that it's correct and then it's properly enforced. So do you think all some of the negative headwinds we felt from the regulatory apparatus? Do you think that just all goes away under the Trump administration? Do you think we get big changes here? I don't know. I mean, I'm hopeful that, and to your point, I think Coinbase and others have done a great job of kind of helping rally the industry around some of these issues, right?
And to your point, there was packs set up and other things to really focus on creating a pro crypto environment. And I think that's, this is the first time it's really felt that way. And one could argue, that's the reason Bitcoin has really started running. And so I'm hopeful that given the, um, intellect and capabilities of the people from tech getting involved in the cycle, because it really is some of the strongest people, right? Like Elon Musk is probably a once in many hundred years founder, right? Or something on that level, right? I mean, like, if you just look at the span of stuff that, you know, we have some very capable people getting involved in government, the question is how will government react?
And, you know, how does that story play out? But I hope it ends up in a really positive place. What do you think about this newly appointed crypto ZAR position? So David Sacks was kind of tapped for that role, obviously from the all-in podcast. Yeah, this, and by the way, this is a crypto ZAR position slash AI, I believe. So it's kind of a combo type role. Do you think that will have some power in the administration? I don't know the nature of the role. I think David is very smart. And it's funny that you call him a podcaster or you're talking about the all-in podcast business, you know, investor, founder, all these other things.
Well, I mean, he was early at PayPal. He was, I think, what was he? COO or something at PayPal? Wait back in the day. And then he started Yammer, which was bought by Microsoft and he ran a division at Microsoft. And then, you know, he became a prominent investor with craft ventures. And he funded all sorts of early crypto things back in 2017 or so, right? And then, you know, I've overlapped with him on some AI stuff and talked to him from 10 to 10 on that stuff. So I think he's very smart. And he's, he has done a lot of stuff operationally. He has done a lot of stuff as an investor. And he's participated in crypto and AI in a way that many folks in the prior administration who had those sorts of responsibilities or roles hadn't.
So I view it as quite positive. You know, the proof will be in the pudding or however, the British say it. I don't, I don't really know Britishism. So I probably got that wrong. They're probably like, cheerio. I think that's right. The tomato sausage. You know, I do what British people say, right? But whatever the Britishism is, you know, obviously we now have to see what things translate into. But I think he's very strong. And I think, you know, I'm excited to see what impact he could have, you know. You like, this has been great. We talked AI. We talked crypto. We talked about sort of the US and the regulatory apparatus.
Maybe a final question to kind of close this out. So obviously, we're speaking to an audience of investors, crypto investors, slash tech investors, who are looking at 2025. And they're always in the lookout for the kind of the frontier opportunities. What do you see as the the biggest growth opportunities for tech investors in 2025? You know, maybe, maybe particularly, you know, less the VC kind of startup type of thing and more kind of the category that a retail investor might have access to. Like what advice would you give them on how to do well in tech investing? I don't know if I have good advice.
I think fundamentally the way I've been thinking about the world is what are effectively indices on major tech movements. And then what is durable in the face of tech movements? In other words, what is the best way to participate in a basket of stuff related to AI? And to some extent that's in video that may be other things, what's the way to participate in crypto? You know, to some extent, one could argue a coinbase where I still, you know, own some stock or some of the other companies in the market may effectively function as indices on top of the crypto industry because if you're trading all the tokens, then, you know, fundamentally, you're participating in those transaction fees and therefore you've created an effective index, right?
And so I tend to think a bit in terms of like what are the index companies for the areas that I think are most important? Like I would argue, Andrew will now is effectively an index fund on defense tech, right? And so sector by sector Stripe used to be an index on e-commerce or the new wave of e-commerce companies because if all the new e-commerce companies were adopting Stripe, you effectively had an index, right? Because it took a piece of every transaction. So I tend to think through that lens in terms of how can you participate in markets broadly? Right? The second question is, what's it durable?
So AI comes and eats away at the world. What things will survive and what things will get augmented? But what things just won't care? And so I really like the companies that just don't care. The extreme example of that would be a real road. There's only so many real roads. AI, not AI, who cares? This is going to keep shipping freight, you know? And so that's very durable in the face of AI, right? So I kind of tend to think in those in those ways. You said you didn't have advice, but that's a pretty good advice, Eli, toward the end of this. Thank you so much for joining us. It's been a pleasure to chat with you today.
Ah, thanks for going to me. Yeah, appreciate it. Gotta let you know, Bankless Nation. Of course, none of this has been financial advice. Crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the Bankless Journey. Thanks a lot.