Is Canton a real blockchain or a new kind of capital-markets operating system?
Digital Asset co-founder Yuval Rooz explains why Canton prioritizes privacy as “need-to-know” information sharing and a federated “cantons” design that still allows atomic cross-canton transactions without bridges.
We unpack the two-tier architecture (edge validators + super validators that stitch cantons together and validate the public Canton Coin) and what that means for governance in regulated finance.
Plus: DTCC’s tokenization pilot starting with U.S. Treasuries, and why CC fees are USD-denominated with a burn/mint mechanism designed to track real network utility.
------
🎬 DEBRIEF | RYAN & DAVID UNPACKING THE EPISODE
https://www.bankless.com/podcast/debrief-is-canton-even-a-real-blockchain
------
🔮POLYMARKET | #1 PREDICTION MARKET
https://bankless.cc/polymarket-podcast
👑BANKLESS PREMIUM | AD-FREE & BONUS EPISODES
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
🎯THE DEFI REPORT | ONCHAIN INSIGHTS
https://bankless.cc/the-defi-report
💰ICO WATCH | UPCOMING PUBLIC TOKEN SALES
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
0:57 Canton Origin
8:02 Vitalik’s Post
14:15 Canton Philosophy
24:19 Canton Architecture vs Competitors
34:27 RWA Property Rights Debate
38:17 Canto Super-Validators
50:39 Canton Critiques
56:56 Decentralized vs Open Finance
1:02:16 Are Decentralized RWAs Possible?
1:07:04 Is Canton a Real Blockchain?
1:14:20 Canton Metrics
1:22:17 DTCC Relationship
1:25:27 Canton Token
1:30:43 Ethereum vs Canton in 2030
1:31:55 Closing & Disclaimers
------
RESOURCES
Yuval Rooz
Canton
Omid Malekan vs Austin Campbell Professor Debate
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-h-PeUOvDw
RWA Analytics
https://app.rwa.xyz/
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
The second you have the world real, world, unfortunately, you open yourself to censorship resistance by the issuer. Doesn't matter that you put it on a decentralized infrastructure. And Ryan, David, do you guys use stablecoins? Yeah, of course. You do? Well, the issuer is of those stablecoins pretty confident having the smart contract, a feature that allows them either to freeze your stablecoins or to, in some cases, even burn them out of your wallet. So what does it matter that it runs on a permissionless infrastructure? I mean, there are reasons why it's good that it runs on a permissionless infrastructure.
But you're not getting what Vitalik is putting in his post. Bankless Nation, we are here with Yuval Ruiz. He is the co-founder of Digital Asset, which is the parent company behind the Canton Network, which is a subject that we've got some questions about today here on the show. Yuval, welcome to Bankless. Yeah, great to be here. I think my first question, and I think you probably watched me react to this when Ryan was telling me about the Canton Network on the weekly rollout. That was the first time that Canton had ever been invoked on the show. Where did Canton come from? Because all of a sudden, there is a multi-billion dollar network on the scene with some pretty impressive BD partnerships, and I had no idea.
So where did Canton come from? Yeah, so first of all, thank you again for having me. I'm really excited. And funny story, I was driving in Canada in the snow while listening to your end of year recap. And I have to say, it meant to be, because there was one point where you were talking about stocks. And then you said, well, in the beginning of the year, we're going to talk. And just before you said that, I was about to pause, stop the car, and take a note to talk to you guys about that. And then you said, oh, we're going to be talking to you about. I was like, that's perfect timing. But we're not the parent company of Canton.
But we'll talk about that in more detail. But long story short, I started my career at Citadel then moved to DRW trading, which owns Cumberland mining. And I was fortunate enough to help start their venture team that are on 2012. And my co-founder, Eric, helped start Cumberland at DRW. And we started looking into this space very early on. And we had a thesis very early on that everything will move on chain. And I think that to us, what it meant is that in order to move everything on chain, you need to solve for privacy. Well, this is already at around 2015-16. The reality, and this is our view, and time will tell if we took the right approach was that to move financial services on chain, and we can talk about what we mean by that, is going to take time.
And it's not something that can happen overnight. And it requires really careful thinking about what is the problem that you're trying to solve? Who are you trying to solve it for? And what is needed to do that? And the approach we took was an extremely conservative approach, which was build the technology tested actually within world gardens, do not launch a network. And I'll explain in a second why. And only after you prove the underlying mechanics of the architecture, and kind of like, what does it mean to build decentralized infrastructure that can allow for all types of financial services?
And again, we can talk about what that means. In more detail, only then we actually start thinking about the coin economics. How do you launch the network? So start working on Canton in full speed around 2016, had the first version of Canton in 2020. Between 2020 to 2023, it was a lot of different tests of Canton, different throughputs, different use cases. And it's only in 2023 that we actually launched a network and the US, under Gansler, it a fair launch. And that's maybe just the quick intro to what we've done. That's also kind of the surprising thing. So I think maybe what might have been funny to you when you heard me react to the existence of this $3 billion network that I had never heard of, is that well, he would also started it almost a decade ago.
And you were doing all of this work prior in closed doors behind closed doors. And then you're doing the token thing last, which is when a lot of the crypto natives pay attention because like, oh, now it shows up on CoinGecko. So now it's like real to us. But nonetheless, a lot of work have been done behind the scenes at least. Yeah, and listen, I think, hand on heart, it was a pretty hard decision in 2017, not to do an ICO, really hard decision because it was extremely enticing. I mean, yes, I mean, you know, but we can talk a lot about maybe Vitalik's post from two days ago, which I actually think is an incredible post in a very positive way to be clear.
Our view was that we're trying to launch something that will run different types of financial services in 2030, 40, 50 years. And doing the ICO in 2017 seemed to us like a very short term kind of solution to a problem that we were not ready in our opinion to kind of tackle. And as a result of that, we decided not to. And even in the pre-mine era, we decided again, we were not ready. And again, I think that it's taken us quite a lot of time to really think about what is the right way to take this to market. And again, time will tell if being patient and really learning from what the industry have done well and not so well, you know, there are advantages to, you know, coming last, there's also disadvantages.
And we can, you know, explore both. Hey, Banclist Nation is David. If you're hearing this, that's because you were listening to the free Banclist Podcast feed. Did you know that there is a premium Banclist RSS feed? The premium feed has extra interviews that I do for my own personal research and just deeper questions that I want answered about the crypto industry, questions that I want to answer so I can be more informed as an investor both at Banclist Ventures and also just in my own personal portfolio too. Also, there are no ads which means if you listen to the premium feed instead of the free feed, you'll get about 20 hours of your life back every year because you choose to support Banclist directly.
So if you're interested in getting extra content all while skipping the ads or you just appreciate what we do here and want us to keep doing it, we'd appreciate it. If you signed up for Banclist Premium and there is a link in the show notes to get started. Cheers to a good 2026. Few people in crypto put real skin in the game when they make public top or bottom calls. The DeFi report is one of them. The week before the October 10th flash crash, Michael from the DeFi report emailed his entire newsletter saying he's going aggressively risk off and sold the majority of his book from crypto into cash.
This is when Ethos about $4,000 and Bitcoin was 110. Michael runs the DeFi report, an industry leading research platform built on data, cycle awareness, risk management, transparency and most importantly, skin in the game. We like Banclist, we like his analysis and that's why you hear him on the Banclist podcast about once a month and the DeFi report is giving Banclist listeners one free month of access to the DeFi report. So if you're looking for some sharp data-driven analysis to make better informed decisions around your portfolio, you can learn why and how Michael called the top and what he's doing next all in the DeFi report pro.
Check it out, there is a link in the show notes. Yeah, I think for the rest of this episode, we really want to explore basically, maybe part of the reason we hadn't heard about Canton until now, but just to give some context in terms of why we're having you on today. So David and I are just curious explorers of everything that happens in crypto. There's a lot of noise out there, occasionally there's some signal. We see Canton with these big relationships it seems like. So on that role of the David was talking about that that's our weekly episode, it was there was Adline, the DTCC, which I'm told settles quadrillions in assets every year.
This is the settlement layer for the largest securities network in the world that the world has ever seen, of trillions of assets. And they selected Canton network as part of their trial. So it's like, wow, that's big. And I showed the price chart to David and there's this token called the CCToken. This is actually on chain, that's the Canton token. This morning there was news of JP Morgan coin actually deploying to Canton as well. If you go to real world assets rwa.xyz, you see Canton in the standings as far as a network that has some real world asset issuers. And so we got to figure out what this thing actually is, because it's bizarre to be doing podcasts in the space and not to actually know.
So I think part of this is just us coming with an open mind and trying to figure this thing out. Maybe actually that's good framing. So you mentioned the Vitalik tweet. And for there's not familiar, Vitalik put out a tweet this week. I assume you'll all this is what you're referring to. It basically gave a direction, a North Star, let's say, for Ethereum and the Ethereum network. And this long post, I'll paraphrase it. It basically Ethereum exists to provide freedom. It's a freedom maximization tool. That's its end goal. It's never going to be the fastest chain in the world. It's not going to do all of the things that a tradfied might wanted to do, but it will do something that's crucially important, which is maximize censorship resistance, decentralization, and provide sovereignty and freedom to anyone who deploys an application on top of it.
You said you really liked that post. Talk about why, why'd you like that post? And what resonates with you about Vitalik saying that and how does Kanton fit into the story here? Yeah, listen, I think the reason why I like it is because it's a very honest post. And I think that that's something that this industry, I wish was more focused on, is really focused on. Listen, we're trying to solve a problem. This is the problem. This technology is extremely unique. I think it has very different applications that can be used. We as humans like to put frameworks because it's easy for us to grasp concepts, right?
So we created these terms of decentralized and permissionless and open and all of these terms, which are good terms, because we need to find frameworks how to kind of discuss different topics. But clearly, there is a lot of shades of gray in the world of openness, decentralization, censorship, resistance, like all of these things. And the reason why I like Vitalik's post, it is very honest around what is the North Star Ryan, as you say, of Ethereum, which is very noble. I actually see a lot of merits in it. And it actually explains, at least as the reader, what is Vitalik trying to solve? And I don't know if Vitalik controls Ethereum, I don't think he does, but at the end of the day, he is the creator and as a result, create good guidance.
But I think that the reason why I like it, also for selfish reasons, is because I head of this podcast, I was going to say, he's trying to solve a very specific problem and the post was very clear about that problem. I think that we never came and said we want to replace Ethereum. That was not the mission statement of what we were trying to do. Our view was that as we were looking at Bitcoin and even then Ethereum, we actually felt that the technology has an opportunity to make financial services more competitive, more accessible, and more efficient. And I think that that's the problem that we're trying to solve, and therefore comparing us to Ethereum is not really relevant, because we're not, at least, at least again, when I read that post, are not trying to solve the same problem.
So a lot of times people will say decentralization, and permissionless, most important features in the world. And I do think that they are important features, but then they will say, but RWA is the most important opportunity out there. And I'm like, okay, but the second you have the world real world, unfortunately, you open yourself to censorship resistance by the issuer. It doesn't matter that you put it on a decentralized infrastructure, and Ryan, David, do you guys use stablecoins? Yeah, of course. You do? Cool. Okay. Well, the issuers of those stablecoins are pretty confident having the smart contract, a feature that allows them either to freeze your stablecoins or to, in some cases, even burn them out of your wallet.
So what does it matter that it runs on permissionless infrastructure? I mean, there are reasons why it's good that it runs on permissionless infrastructure, but you're not getting what Vitalik is putting in his post. You're not getting that ultimate right freedom from corporations. It's just not happening. And therefore, I just think that if I go back to the post again, it's like to me, you know, what I was hoping to discuss here is what is the mission of what we're trying to solve. And as a result of that, we had to take design decisions that are aligned with that problem. Maybe we could talk about those design decisions in a minute.
I'm so far, I'm not sure that I've heard anything that I drastically disagree with, actually. I don't think David or myself would say that a USDC, stablecoin, a tether issued by a centralized authority with, you know, the ability to kind of revoke and censor the smart contract. We wouldn't say that is max-bankless, of course, that particular asset. Nor really any real world asset that we've seen. There are crypto-native assets where that might be true. And then there are real world assets. And I guess by the nature of what you're saying, real world assets aren't the max-censorship-resistant, max-freedom type of technology that Vitalik is talking about.
At least on the individual level, maybe the platform that an asset issuer deploys to, if you're thinking, maybe that's different. So, so far, I don't object there, but I guess maybe that depends on how far you want to take that. So, is your implication you've all that, therefore, Ethereum is a bad place to deploy real world assets relative to alternatives, say, an alternative like Canton, or, you know, an arc like a chain from circle or a tempo from, you know, Stripe, is that what you're saying? No, not at all. But it's a good question. So, my only point is that as long as we are in agreement, that the second you have an issuer, you are exposing yourself to restrictions beyond the permissionless world.
That's it. I mean, the second you are putting your trust in an issuer. And by the way, that issuer doesn't have to be literally an issuer of a stable coin. You could take all the different issuers of tokenized stocks in many cases. It's really like a derivative. It's not really the stock. But you are putting your trust, Ryan, or David. I think I can't remember who you used because I was listening, but you were saying, here, look, I bought on my favorite super app. I bought stocks while we were talking. I was David. It was Ando, was the issuer of tokenized Google. Yeah, I mean, again, you're taking counter-party risk.
You are putting your trust in a company that actually is holding. So, my point is that's also the product that I'm buying. So, when I buy Google equity, I am placing my trust in not just Ando, the issuer of said equity, but I also Google who is the issuer of the security in the first place. So, the product I buy is already trusted to begin with. Exactly. That's kind of my point. And therefore, the question is, what is the problem now that you're trying to solve? We're already in agreement, I hope, that the second that we move from pure crypto assets. And to me, again, an Ando token is not a pure crypto asset.
Ethereum is a pure crypto asset. Right? The point is a pure crypto asset. The second you move, you are effectively giving up on some of these pure intentions that Vitalik have put in his post. And then the question is, okay, well, if we're going to, you know, relax some of those features, well, then you're starting to move into kind of like an optimization problem. And what I mean by that is we started asking ourselves, well, if we think that there is a massive tam opportunity in RWA's, what are some of the things that we think we have to solve for in order to get massive adoption? Okay. And again, I am trying to explain, we're moving away from this pure world.
And the first thing already in 2015-16 that we said would be privacy. And I don't want to conflate privacy with anonymity. To me, privacy is the ability to share information on an ethno basis. If you sign a contract, you remember in the confidentiality clause, it will say it's the parties to this contract that knows about this contract. You are allowed to share it with your lawyers, with your accountants. And then it has like these special clauses. If you got subpoenaed by a court or by a regulator under those special circumstances, you can reveal it to them. That to me is privacy. Because I can see the contract.
I can see the content of the contract. And in special situation, I'm even allowed to share that information with others. Anonymity is slightly different, which is nobody gets to see the information. And again, for us, this is don't take this as me saying anonymity bad, privacy good. It's again, it's a design decision that we said, if I want XYZ by-site firm to start managing their equity portfolio, their fixed income portfolio, on Canton privacy, not anonymity is critical. If I want JP Morgan to do payments on Canton privacy, critical anonymity, not going to work. That's again, a design decision.
We can be disagreed on, but that's kind of one of them. The second thing, and I think this is, you know, maybe where we're going to start becoming a bit more critical, start becoming a bit more controversial, but hopefully not, is we believe that the laws of physics do not agree that you can run all of the world financial services on a single ledger. That's our view. I'm happy, I'm happy to, to, you know, have conversations, and what I mean by that is when you think about Ethereum, some of these other ledgers, effectively all transactions go through a single consensus mechanism. And as a result of that, it really forces the design to do a few things.
First of all, take a lot of the activity off-chain because there's a lot of activity that why would I run it through the most expensive database in the world? And by the way, when I say that this is not an insult, it's a very expensive database because it gives you very unique features and worth paying for those transactions. But that means that a lot of transactions are not, they don't live to that level of importance, and therefore let's do a lot of things off-chain, which to me is a bad outcome as a result of that because of what we're trying to do. That's one thing. And then second of all, the reason that it, you know, it's not good is because it will eventually create what, in my opinion, happen in Ethereum.
And I think that a lot of the L2s will say they are a good thing for Ethereum. I personally think that they were a bad thing for Ethereum. Because in my opinion, if you are an asset on one L2, you are not composable with another asset of another L2. You have to use solvers, you have to use bridges. And let's just hopefully agree that solvers and bridges are not the value proposition of blockchain composability. And as a result of that, rather than creating like a really nice model of a global composable world, which is in my opinion, the whole value proposition of blockchain, you have effectively bifurcated an incredible ecosystem, which in my opinion is not a good outcome.
So by the way, the reason for the name Canton is really this idea that the world is first of all not homogeneous. It's actually heterogeneous, different applications, different geographies, different use cases, have different requirements. So if you think of a lot of our R&D, most of our R&D is in Switzerland. If you think about the Swiss federated system, they all have their different cantons. They don't even spell Canton the same way in every place. If X rates have different rules, but when you take a train, you don't feel like I'm going from one country to another. I'm still in Switzerland, right?
So the idea was, can I actually create something not to be mistaken with L2s, but look similar, this idea that I can create all of these different cantons that have different requirements when it comes to privacy, when it comes to accessibility, when I can have very, very open configuration on all of those different things, but at every given point of time, if I wanted to compose a transaction across different cantons, I can do that atomically, no bridges, no solvers, and I effectively get a user experience as if I am on a single layer one. Just by the way, the technology that we're using to do this podcast takes the same architecture.
We use the internet, we call the internet a single internet, as if it is a single network, but it's not the internet is a protocol that actually connects multiple networks together. So Canton kind of draws a lot of kind of inspiration from that, and that's really, I would say kind of like, from a technology perspective, some of the major kind of design, the economics and the tokenomics is a whole different. We can talk about the language. There's a lot of different minutiae and what are the complexities that privacy also create that I wish we didn't have to deal with, but there are challenges as a result of that.
Yeah, I think we've been just kind of talking about the contours of the different philosophies around Canton network versus I think probably what our listeners are more familiar with with Ethereum and other public permissionless chains. I do want to kind of just dive actually straight into that conversation and make some of these things a little bit more tangible in concrete. Kind of as I understand it, Canton has done some pretty solid BD work to win some business with things like the DTCC, and as I understand it as I'm guessing, so there have been some architectural choices that Canton has made in order to make these partnerships work.
And I'm wondering if we can kind of just go into what are the big properties or features or differences about the Canton architecture that somebody would make note of that's meaningfully different from a public permissionless blockchain like Ethereum. What are the things that are worth highlighting? This is very different than some of the philosophy from Ethereum. What should we talk about first? I'm sure there's at least a handful of them. Yeah, I would say that the easy one, the easy one is privacy. To be honest, I would say that privacy is probably the easy one. I will mention a point that is not necessarily technical design but actually a governance design feature that is I think just as critical.
I think that we want to envision a world where there's no regulation and everybody just get along together. And then the rubber hits the road. We see avid protocol fights. We see swap and the reality is that governance is just as critical. So if you are the DTCC or you are any one of these large financial institutions, whether we like it or not, honestly, like this is not about my personal opinion, but the reality is that the DTCC, given the fact that they do actually sit on $100 trillion worth of assets, are extremely systemically critical to the U.S. economy. And as a result of that, they are highly regulated.
And as a result of that, it makes their life very complicated. Running the DTCC is not a trivial task. We can say that they can do a lot of things better and they probably could, and I don't think that they would even disagree with it. That being said, they do actually have quite a serious responsibility on their shoulders. And I think that as we launch the network, and this is again, you know, looking back and saying, I think earlier David, I was saying to you, like, hey, patients might have been the right decision or not, but one of the things that we looked at throughout the years is governance of these networks, right?
And I'll give, I think it was in your episode, you were talking about quantum resistance with Bitcoin. And I think you guys said, no, no, they should definitely start looking into it, right? And I think that was the same episode that I was listening to. And it's a great point. I mean, at the end of the day, these networks have to evolve. There's no way, even we working on something for 11 years before launching it, I can promise you, we did not get everything right, not even close to that. Yeah. I would say Ethereum philosophy is largely in agreement with that. Ethereum has always been rough consensus, but the only blockchain that, as I know it, that can't upgrade because it's so incredibly radically cyberpunk is Bitcoin.
And also on privacy as well, Ethereum in the long-term roadmap does actually intend on being a private blockchain in a pretty cyberpunk fashion. And so I'm not sure if these are the things that I think are really differentiating Kanton's philosophy from some of the other... I didn't mention it. I didn't mention it. I was mentioning the Bitcoin, but my point for us governance and the ability for people that are putting significant bets on the network and want to run systemically critical infrastructure, want to know that there is governance of a network and of a code base that they can see evolve and improve at a pace that adheres to the fact that they have these responsibilities.
Definitely, again, I took that example with Bitcoin. Sure. And then that's the most extreme. And then you have all shades of gray in terms of smart contractions. Definitely evolving. It started as a proof of work. It's no longer a proof of work. It has done improvements over time. The question is, what is your governance model? So we launched the foundation in the US under the Biden administration. And we said, well, the people that understand where the puck is going from a technology perspective are the crypto-native companies. And they are critical to have them at the table. And at the same time, you need to get the traffic organizations that, again, I'm not here to say, should we get them on chain or not?
We are trying to do that. That's what we want to do. And if you want to do that and you want them to use your technology, you have to get their perspective. You have to understand what are the daily problems that they deal with. You need to understand what are bank holding regulations. And what does that mean? Does it mean that there's any impact on the features of your technology? So I think the governance of Canton have been another very helpful component in the choice. And then scaling, scaling, and then the last thing that I would say is, again, when you launch your own Canton, you have full sovereignty and control over your Canton.
What I mean by that is, think again back to the design of the internet. You know, if a country outside of the US said, hey, we want to block LinkedIn for whatever reason, they can do that. You still use the same internet protocol, but you have sovereignty and control. You have, you know, you have the same protocol, but you have sovereignty and control over your Canton. In a public permissionless network, you do not have that. And as a result of that, you have to do a lot of things off-chain as redundancy. I'll give you an example. There was the sui hack, if you remember. I can remember what was some kind of a protocol and everything.
And, you know, the reality of that hack is that hacks are bad, right? People lose money, not a good outcome. And if you remember, they decided to kind of fork and kind of reverse the hack. But I think what did they prove? Well, they proved that blockchains are not immutable. Immutability is a social construct. Can I just say one thing on that? They prove that some blockchains aren't immutable, where some blockchains are much less immutable than others, or some social contracts are much different than other social contracts for blockchains. Would you agree that's true? Yeah, I agree that that's true.
But as long as Ryan has used stick to the fact that it's a social contract, and not a guaranteed, and that's kind of where I go back to the design features that I don't think in today's world, a regulated institution top tier regulated institution would be able to go to their regulator as of right now. And maybe that will change in the future as of right now. And be able to say, I'm choosing this chain because they have a very strong social contract. I don't think that they would be able to convince a regulator. We're going to put our books and records. We're going to forget about, try to fire off chain books and record.
We're just going to put our books and record on that because they have a very, very strong social contract. That's just a personal view that I have. And I don't, again, and this is while agreeing with you about certain chains have a very strong social contract. But at the end of the day, it's not a technical design. It's a social contract. And that's the difference. That's just the reality. So when you even look at some of the announcement recently on native, native equity on chain, you write, read the fine detail. You always still have to have an off chain redundancy in case that social contract or something else breaks.
So our view, and this goes back to kind of where we were a while ago, is by wait a minute, anyway, you're taking risk on the issuer. Anyway, you are exposing yourself to censorship or something that they can do to you. Then why not actually give a very strong technical guarantee that said issuer has full sovereignty and control over their ledger. No third party can fork their ledger. And by doing that, they can actually do everything on chain, nothing off chain. So again, it's not trying to say this is bad, this is good. We're just saying, hey, you've already put a lot of trust in the issuer.
Why wouldn't you just actually then also technical capabilities of them saying, great, I can actually have full sovereignty and control over my ledger. And now I will let it interoperate or be composed on a fully permissionless infrastructure. Maybe Ryan, I have a question for you if you don't mind. This is for you to ask me questions. Would you say that layer two that have a centralized sequencer is permissionless? Is it public? Is it private? Is it open? And have a centralized sequencer running by one company? Yeah, I think the thing that a layer two when designed, it's not quite a binary. But the thing a layer two does when it's designed, it reaches kind of stage one, stage two maturity.
Is it gives users a specific set of property rights? Particularly the property right to be able to withdraw their assets at any time. And so the centralized sequencer, the operator, can't freeze those assets. Now they could still censor grief attack in the short run. But even with kind of a properly designed L2, you can kind of get around that. So the thing that is preserved in a layer two design is Ethereum grade or close to Ethereum grade user property rights. I think if your argument is that well, real world assets already sacrifice property rights to say the DTCC or to the nation state or to circle as an issuer, such that it's all overkill anyway to try to preserve property rights for real real world assets.
That's only necessary for crypto native assets. Then I think I maybe partially agree I have some reservations. But it reminds me of a debate that we actually had between two professors on this exact subject. And I'll throw you that episode after this one will include in the show notes for any listeners. But it was Omeid and Austin Campbell. And basically Omeid said, no, real world assets do require decentralized permissionless blockchains. And Austin said, I don't see why that should be the case. They don't at all. They went on for an entire hour about this very issue. There's a great debate.
And I think both of them had valid points. But I could see your it seems to be the case that you're making. Yeah, you're falling on the Austin Campbell side of the argument, which is. Hey, like once you already have real world assets, then you don't really need to like max preserve decentralization and property rights. Because you've already given that up in the first place. Yeah. So by the way, I 99.99% agree with what you said. The only slight distinction is I don't think you give up property rights. I think what you're doing is you're giving up potentially short term inconvenience. That again, Vitalik's approach is saying should never happen.
What I mean by that is if I hold something at the DTCC, it's legally mine. I have full property rights over it. But I am exposed to DTCC freezing at doing something. And if I think that they've done it in an illegal way, I have all the rights in the world, unfortunately, though, to resolve it outside of on chain. That's my point. So I haven't really gave up property rights, but I'm taking operational risks with respect to this asset. I did. Even then, with the DTCC example, you still have your legal property rights, but those legal property rights are conveyed to you by the operating system of the United States of America.
And it's legal framework. And for a pure crypto native asset, it's outside of even the United States of America's jurisdiction, right? It's super national. It doesn't have a jurisdiction on any nation in the planet. That's the entire idea. But my point is an RWA on an L2 will subject you in my opinion on a centralized sequencer to the same risk with the DTCC. You've all I know in the Canton architecture, there's something called a super validator. So it seems like there's a two-tier architecture in the network. And we've seen this architecture in other ecosystems before like Dash famously has nodes, but then master nodes.
They have like master nodes as a little bit more power and control. Can you define what a super validator does as opposed to just a regular validator? And like what privileges does a super validator have? Yeah, so the unfortunate of finding different names for different things. So here's where privacy becomes tricky. So when you want to do, and I'm taking maybe a bit of a sidetrack to explain. So there are certain things that there's an approach that using encryption you could solve for privacy. There's all kinds of regulations. Again, whether we like them or not, they exist that would say, hey, David, if I took your personal information, I encrypted it with the best encryption in the world.
And I send it to Ryan. I have invalidated your privacy. That's it. And I'm going to say, well, but Ryan cannot decrypt it. And they would say, well, not today, but potentially in a year. Maybe if Ryan sends it to his Chinese friends, they will decrypt it today. Like the reality is, I have given your information. Maybe it's not readable today, but it's readable in tomorrow. And the reason why this side story is important is because the approach we take for privacy is that, David, if you and I do a transaction on Canton, Ryan will never have the zeros and ones associated with this transaction on his note.
It will never even make it there. And therefore, what we're trying to say by that is that the validators, not super validators, and we'll get to the super validators in a second. It's the nodes at the edge. They are the ones that actually do the validation on the business logic of a smart contract. It is not the super validators. The super validators in the case of Canton do two operations. One is they are the validators of Canton coin, which is a fully public remissionless asset. It's a crypto asset. It has no issuer. So those are and everybody gets to see all those transactions. That's one.
But the second thing that the super validators do is they offer effectively that trustless, permissionless, decentralized composability layer. So think about them as kind of like the post office on steroids. They see a transaction. They give you a guarantee that all the counter parties to that transaction will have that information of that transaction delivered to them. They have no idea what they have delivered, but they give you that guarantee. So the super validators are those that run kind of the glue as we talked before that stitched all the Canton's together to give you kind of this one ledger experience.
And they also validate the Canton coin transaction. That's what they do. Now the super validators on Canton are can vote for protocol changes. There's there needs to be super, super majority votes to do those things. But that's that's how the what the super validators technically do on Canton. Can I be a super validator? 100%. How do I do that? So the way the way that we decided so if you if you look at most of the so so for let me take a step back. So the super validators get paid as part of the tokenomics and we should talk more deeply about the tokenomics that get they get paid for doing their work.
Now in a lot of in a lot of chains to become like a super node or whatever you have to stake a lot of money. We don't do that in Canton. We actually don't so I'll give you an example. And by the way, maybe it's an offer right now. So if bankless wanted to become a super validator, we would actually love that because our view is that becoming a validator is a commoditized product. It's at the end of the day what we mean by a commoditized product is think about bankless like you have to interview people you have to do marketing you have to think about your business. Where being a validator or being a minor is not it's not free you have to do something but at the end of the day you run servers.
And as a result of that the approach we took from a go to market perspective was we much rather the super validators being people that have contributed positively to the network. And what I mean by that is I can write tomorrow a proposal to the network to say I think bankless could be one of the biggest growth engines to the network. And we're going to agree that they're going to do things together with us. And as a result of that, I want to nominate them as a super validator to the network. That's it. And so I cannot I cannot be a validator to the network unless I get approved by the other super validators.
Yeah, no different validators on every network can censor other validators. I don't know about that one. The whole idea of the Bitcoin or Ethereum or even. Yeah, not so long. But like Bitcoin or Ethereum is like you know you can just add yourself to the network. You can either be a node and and here transactions and rebroadcast transactions or you could be a mining a minor and add blocks to the chain. It sounds like adding blocks to the canton chain is is permissioned by approving other validators in the network. So all Bitcoin miners run Bitcoin cash consensus. No, they made a decision that they don't want to do that part of them and they decided we're not going to look at those transactions.
I don't think you can equate the Bitcoin fork wars to a enshrined property of voting for approval for adding a new network, new a node to the network. Right now I can go add add my node to the Bitcoin network to right now during this podcast. But you see David you you are not you are now making a distinction of because it's a code versus a governance thing of the network. The outcome is the same. I decided that a group of people decided that they want to change the code. The group of people decided that they want to change the code and a certain group of people said no we don't. And they forked as a result and now you have Bitcoin cash and you have Bitcoin right like Bitcoin cash forked off of Bitcoin.
Yeah, yeah and Bitcoin but actually the Bitcoin just declined that update and is is what it has always been. I guess my point my point is that again you're back David in my opinion to the world of social contracts. Yeah, yeah. My favorite thing my favorite thing to be like yellow Bitcoin was about is like yes I agree that Bitcoin doesn't have a social contract. The point social contract is to not have a social contract. But yes, ultimately at the end of the day there is governance over all of these systems. But the decision to formalize it and put it as code formal code in the system versus allowing it to operate at a higher level is a very important distinction for how this network manifests down the road.
Yeah, and the governance I would add the governance surface area for something like Bitcoin, less or so for Ethereum but even Ethereum is very slim and there's only kind of the binary choice of is this existential enough for us to fork yes no if so we fork. Yeah, listen, listen at the end of the day I'm by the way I'm not disagreeing it is very different and I'm not trying to actually minimize it's important. But here here I'll take it I'll take it to step further we think that if anything canton actually allows right the whole idea of of blockchain and everything was democratizing finance and allowing everybody to participate.
The average person on the street cannot become validator on sui or on salana. We're actually if someone thinks that they can add value to canton as small as they are and now you could look at the super validators on canton these are small crypto firms that actually added value from early days and participated didn't have to stake tens of millions of dollars which to me is not very accessible. So I'm not I'm not here to debate that it's not significantly different it is factually as you kind of state a David but again it comes from a different place we want. The super validators those that run the consensus on canton are going to be those that are aligned with the network not because they state a bunch of dollars but actually they because they put blood sweat and tears into the network and as a result of that we think that the network should reward them back for that.
One concern that I have with this model is like I agree that it's admirable to allow people to enter the system regardless of the amount of capital that they have and well you know if you need thirty to each can be prohibitively expensive for some ultimately at the end of the day you can still. Stake three ether and receive the same rewards as somebody who takes thirty two or three hundred either so at least that is equitable nonetheless. One worry that I have is that if we are voting for inclusion on super validators you've all when I asked you like can I join can I join the network tomorrow what I kind of mean is like can I the amorphous individual who might exist in Africa or Australia or Asia can I.
The individual join the network and to me that answer is no because you have to get approved by the governance body and ultimately at the end of the day when you allow for formalized governance of who can validate the chain versus not what I start to get worried about is like oh well. Somebody with friends and influence and knowing the right people in the right telegram group can probably get involved with the network much better than somebody without any of those things and so that is a different vector of privilege if you're like one one side of the concern like you need an exorbitant amount of capital to stake Ethereum to participate Ethereum that's one.
Drawback of Ethereum but like a drawback of something with formalized voting is like oh well this can just become a cartel of insiders allowing only their insider friends to get into the network David I'm I'm sorry I was trying to study we were talking about super validators we're not talking about people joining the network. So yes super validators with I'm assuming super validators are the ones that have the rights to publish the blocks correct yes that's what I mean okay but that's not to join the network and participate on the network to be clear anybody anybody can do that and again go through the list of super validators they are not all DTCC like Goldman Sachs like companies is there is there a published list of super validators.
100% I'll edit what we'll add it to the if you are some who are some let's see you have that are not like the big the big the big players even the big players any of them. Yeah sample size okay so you have copper brawn braille trade web broadridge DRW digital asset trying to think about I'm trying to give you some names that that you wouldn't even know because they are. You know ferrement kill figment republic zero hash chain link I mean I can I can keep on going so you know so you've all I'm not even sure that I share the concern that David has around super validators because I'm not. From everything we've discussed so far I don't think the canton network is trying to compete with an Ethereum or Bitcoin for the crypto native freedom maximizing self sovereign type use case to begin with and so I will you know the apples and orange thing comes to mind you can't compare apples and oranges I always say well you can compare fruit and so but like I'm not even sure if.
If canton is a blockchain is the same is even in the fruit category the way say a Bitcoin or a theorem or like even even sui for that matter I understand like I don't think sui is competitive with a Bitcoin or a theorem I want to run through some of the work crypto native reaction that I've heard with with a canton and I haven't taken a. A horse in this race because I don't really understand what's going on but I'm seeing a lot of crypto natives react very strongly against canton as if it is coming to kill a theorem or replace a theorem or Bitcoin or it's an erosion or a compromise with our crypto native decentralized values so this is a poster on Twitter.
Cyp.eath and says why canton is the antithesis of crypto values and why it's definitely not the only chain with privacy it claims to be a public decentralized chain but is run by super validators that need to be vetted and approved a permissionless dag with no globally verified state it claims privacy but reject ZK as black box claims verifiability but you cannot replay or audit full transaction history claims super validators can't censor but regular validators can only observe shards claim self. There's a possibility compatibility that everything is meaningfully permissioned it claims neutrality but is a surveillance machine as a side note the token distribution is 75% held by the team and early investors so no public verifiability it's not censorship resistance not credibly neutral it's not forkable as no real privacy I'm not even asking you to respond to all of those claims I'm sure.
If you could have the find contradiction that tweet would be one big contradiction okay but I'm not even sure if that's important at all because given that what you're saying is hey we already start with the premise which is Austin Campbell's premise and that debate I was referring to earlier if we have a real world asset and the real world asset its property rights are secured by the DTC and the United States of America. And if you take that assumption you don't really need a max decentralized chain for real world assets thus the Canton network make some trade offs on that domain like is that what you're saying because if that's what you're saying I don't understand why the crypto natives and cypher punks why their feathers are so ruffled.
It's just seems like because it's a surveillance machine but you can't see anything I mean like it's just like it's just so contradictory within itself that it's not even worth a my opinion responding to it and this is I'm actually there are some good anti you could look at someone that I was going back and forth with yesterday I'm actually very much in favor of being kind of like very open because like I said we haven't gotten everything right. But who are the good critics were you going back and forth with just curious I don't know his name but I can find I can find yesterday we were having back and forth because I see you on my timeline once in a while and you do go back and forth with these people and I'm just like sometimes I enjoy the conversation and I'm not sure exactly what's going on.
Next time but but but here's here's my only challenge to to what you said Ryan is the following when it comes to an asset you are opening yourself to the censorship or let's just say the issue we're doing certain things that you wish they didn't. Where I think I have a disagreement and this is important is that canton network as a composability layer is public permissionless meaning no one if I didn't do anything wrong with my DTCC treasuries and you didn't do anything wrong with your USDC no one no one can prevent us from composing that run. That's the only that's the only disagreement that I have with you is that that composability layer what the super validators are running is a trustless permissionless place where everybody can come and participate.
Now you could say to me that the super validators can censor transaction and decide that they don't want to allow you to compose and I would say we're back to the conversation I have with David these are all the social contracts that technically speaking. The validators on a theorem could if they were able to coordinate something decide to censor one party if they all came together and decided we're not going to accept packets from David technically speaking zero probability likelihood but technically speaking possible right. So again I'm not going back to that specific thing but my point is when it comes to the asset that's the only thing that we give issuers of asset much stronger guarantees about sovereignty and control over the their assets it's that composability layer that no single entity control and can censor so as long as I meet the requirements of the smart contract.
And what am I allowed to do with them and how am I allowed to interact with them I will be able to compose a transaction in a trustless decentralized manner trustless decentralized manner that that's where we get into the semantics of what do these words mean a little bit what I'm thinking of is the dichotomy between something we've talked about at bank lessons inception which is like there's decentralized finance and then there's also open finance and sometimes these things are conflating. And I put something like Canton more in the open finance kind of track that's what you're maximizing so the ability to compose transactions you know the bill you know some of the permissionless nature of it.
It's more on the open finance side and I don't mean by the way transparent so obviously privacy is preserved in your setup but it's less maxing on things like decentralization but maybe you can answer the meta question here again about the some the crypto natives who have their feathers ruffled. Another is a crypto lawyer Gabriel Lex node on Twitter if you see them and he says this. This is some back and forth with him he says Canton is the establishments last best chance at co opt in crypto and perverting it to lock in their monopolies and he is quote to eating a Nasdaq super validator participation.
I guess governance form post so this presumably is the Nasdaq and they're saying hey we want to be members of the Canton network we want to do the we want to submit our application to be super validators to to governance and for vote. And some of the game he's saying that this is the establishment co opting crypto and and trying to lock in their monopolies and this again this is a common sentiment that I'm seeing among some of the crypto native. What's your what's your meditate why are they bothered by this can I give you my answer can I can you tell me like. And I and I reminded you in the beginning right after you announced that I'm coming what was your announcement right after me you remember how everybody was excited the JP Morgan issued a money market fund on Ethereum.
Like if if if Nasdaq just came out with a PR saying hey we're going to do everything on Ethereum and we are going to run validators and we're going to do saking do you think that Gabe would have. Posted the same question no you're saying bag bias you're saying there's some tribalism in bag bias and that's fine but but that's not not in bankless but that that post my we never have bag bias. But by the way that's fine it's all good but but again I'm to be honest I have to say I really really I think this conversation was one of the better ones that I had and to be honest it shows that you guys came prepared.
But again I you know we're trying to solve a very specific problem and you know you could say that a lot of the crypto natives on and X are varying I will tell you there's some fairly large crypto native funds that are bag holders in canton. And at the end of the day at the end of the day the question is do you believe that our approach our go to market is capable of bringing more financial transactions on chain you know there's this thing in crypto. So that I actually find a bit interesting which is everybody talks about how's this technology is going to free us from intermediaries. Come on that's not an honest statement all that this technology is doing is creating new intermediaries I have to say that a lot of the intermediaries here into intermediaries that have been created in crypto are even more centralized than the ones that they're talking about removing to be clear.
And I'm not going to get into names there's no point that being said the reason why I really like this technology is that it removes the barriers and the codes around competing with the old intermediaries. That to me is exciting not because I think it's going to by definition disintermediate and remove the old guard. But it will say to the old guard either improve and offer better products to your customers or someone else will take you out. I agree with that. Yeah but that's it marginalizes intermediaries and it reduces the take rate that intermediaries are able to have and it's a check on power on intermediaries.
But I think a lot of people would say it's pretty directionally congruist with saying remove intermediaries. Yeah but just to be clear a defy protocol is an intermediary. Sure. And the governance token that governs my position in AVE is a counterparty to me if we want to really expand what an intermediary is to include a smart contract that has governance. And my only point is I honestly like where I have a lot of a lot of room to have these back and forth for example Ryan and David. I'm actually I understand that we don't see eye to eye on a lot of different things and I'm not saying that in a negative way.
But it's a very at least it comes from a hey I'm starting with a different set of assumptions or things that I think the world should go or what I am trying to accomplish and we end at something rational aligned with it. I'm still actually honestly struggling to find what we might most disagree about because so far I've maybe found a handful of partial disagreements but I haven't been able to put my so so long as a Canton network is acknowledging the trade offs that it has made versus something that is maximally decentralized like a Bitcoin and Ethereum. That seems fine to me and and a position to take which is like hey real world assets don't necessarily need the four to five nines of Ethereum level decentralization.
So here's an alternative it's called Canton that also seems fine to me maybe I want to frame the critiques from crypto natives the people like like Gabriel they were just mentioning. And let's remove bag bias from the quit let's say that's not in play at all okay let's say there's no tribalism actually in play let's say there's some values bias and let's say a crypto native maybe some like Gabriel genuinely thinks it would be better for the world to actually bypass the DTC in some way and to have an actual tokenized equity that's disruptive of all of the existing institutions and that that is best done on Ethereum.
And he is supporting say Ethereum or pick your other you know your crypto native your max decentralized crypto native network because he believes in that value. Do you think that that is a rational argument for why real world assets on something that is max decentralized. It's rational but it's not practical there's a line the US that says that equities in the US cannot be permissionless they cannot be a bearer instrument. I mean I don't I don't know I don't know and I think David you called it out on and that's the point where you said we got to talk to you for like full circle. I mean I don't this is why I keep on coming back you can have a permissionless asset on Canton.
You could you could design it if you wanted to. My point is the Canton token is a permissionless asset right the Canton token is like as similar to Ethereum or Bitcoin right. You could have a permissionless I guess my point is we are trying to maximize real world assets on Canton with regulated institutions because that's where the deep balance sheet is and this is where most of the usage is that's what we're trying we're trying to bring on chain capital markets. That's what we're trying to solve for so the reality is you're not allowed to have a bear you know a bear equity token as of right now in the US.
It's just not possible right and and and and that's just a reality will there be derivative products on Canton that are permissionless that try to mimic the return of US equities probably. But that's not a US equity you know I give this example David when you buy on I don't know if if I don't know your age but like there was a time where going and being invited to the AGM of of Berkshire was the hottest thing. So what you would do is you would buy one share. To actually get the invite because you're a shareholder right I don't think you get the invite if you buy on the finance right I don't think you are recognized by Berkshire is a shareholder and again this is not this is not a stab at on the on the has done something incredible.
But it's solving a different problem it's like hey a lot of people around the world maybe Ryan to give point do not have the freedom to access exposure to Berkshire have the way right and they are enabling that and that's admirable it is it really is it's a good thing it's a good thing for the world. Well Wellington is not going to hold it because part of their thesis is hey if I'm top four shareholders on a cap table not only I want to be invited to the AGM I want to make all kinds of very important votes with respect to how to manage that company. And that's again a different problem that is being sold that's why I'm saying it's not it's not that it's you rational to have that value it's not practical with what we're trying to solve and that said that's just a very a very different again it's a big and I and that's my point I don't understand the point about taking stabs at it.
I don't think you're going to see a post by me trying to say that we are we have been able to create what the theorem have failed to create it's just not true here you have me on the record it's not true. It's not our intention and if anything I would love for canton and a theorem to collaborate because I think that there's very interesting things to do together. First it's just a past time of crypto to debate about ideology and how ideology shows up in architecture and so it's just one of the things that we're doing here I think one of the reasons why canton is ruffling feathers with some of the hardcore cyberpunk people is.
You know that when we created Bitcoin when we created a blockchain a public permissionless blockchain we created something completely net new that not only could you do the old thing of like create a asset but you could also do these new things these new properties smart contracts. You know public permissionless stuff you know the individual I got ideologically inspired by a theorem when I was running a mining computer in my dad's bathroom when I was thinking like yo I'm processing global transactions in my bathroom that's pretty cool no one's ever done this before. And I think a lot of people like me and other crypto natives when they look at the architecture of canton and they see the words super validators and then somebody on a podcast asks you who are the super validators and you list off a bunch of company names not.
Average Joe who's running a a validator from his star link in the middle of Idaho which there's there's somebody on the a theorem network who is literally doing that all of these things are like no no no these are the old things we have the old companies the old Delaware sea corpse that are validating the network that have the ability to make transactions that I don't I can't add to the blockchain and these are just all the old things that they're using the new technology to upgrade the old systems which I think we all agree definitely needs to get upgraded like Coinbase has this whole whole slogan as upgrade the system and I see that's what canton's trying to do is like trying to take can't upgrade the system but is doing it inside of the confines of the old rules which doesn't feel very like rebellious or inspiring or inclusive of the individual to participate is like oh let's let's stay inside of the old rules so like equities they need to have equities can't be bear assets so let's make a blockchain that doesn't even bother with bear assets as like a core promise and let's actually bend the whole platform to kind of sit inside of the container of the of the old world and I and the world and we're ultimately in the same industry and so individuals like me and other like cyberpunk Maxis are just place next to you and that's kind of I think the source of friction here is like we're in the same space we're in the same industry and it was different when canton was you know working behind closed doors working with his partners but now it's got a token page on coin get go and for some reason that matters that places it alongside of all the other blockchains that are also on coin get go right and now you guys are you guys are advertising on block works which has a crypto native audience so it's one thing to have the architecture be highly congruous with securities laws and traditional finance needs and the rules of governments and doing it over there where JP Morgan's quorum is I don't even know where JP Morgan's quorum is it doesn't have a coin get go page but it's somewhere way over there and it doesn't bother me but now like you're in our you're coming into our world you're doing the block partnerships around the coin get go page like all this kind of stuff and so there's I think that's why you have to contend with some of these very deep questions is you have the old style architecture but you are marketing it to our industry where we value the cyberpunk maximum of Bitcoin and Ethereum and that's going to be a recurring theme I'm guessing in your life because you're trying to penetrate into the crypto native world which has a certain set of values which doesn't resonate with some of the architecture of canton that's kind of my diagnosis right now yeah so first of all I would say that I had to bet that if I had to put polymarket bet on do you listen to music on Napster or Spotify I'm pretty sure that I can make the right bet of where you listen to music and you know my point is I don't think that canton is the old guard architecture I think that I've listed a few names there are dexas with privacy the trade rap Bitcoin and rap Ethereum on canton so I mean pretty sure that it's not the old guard that is doing that I can tell you that a lot of crypto natives love the fact that now they can move Bitcoin and Ethereum without everybody front running them by the way so I actually don't think that we only service the old guard that system was not designed to conform to US equities laws it was designed to enable use cases that have to comply with it and that's very different I mean again I think that the approach of most crypto to today have been a very binary view it's not that this is how technology is designed this is how the world should operate and they have almost kind of become like this vertical solution I'm integrating a social contract and a world view into the technology and if you don't believe in my social contract contract and my social view then you're wrong and honestly to be honest on maybe on a personal level I think that that's a bit a bit a problem more generally speaking in the world today that it's like this tribalism and it's like this binary view you either are 100% here or you're not right like you were a liberal until you decided that you know certain you know genders cannot play in certain sports and now suddenly whoa you're all the way to the other side and I don't know how I brought that topic here but my point is that canton does not take hey let's copy paste the old architecture it is trying to be very pragmatic that there is very interesting things like defi there's very different there is a very interesting business models and use cases that are very crypto native that would love and I think you would agree with me to bring the old guard balance sheet to take advantage of them no different than how middle was celebrated how benji was celebrated when any old guard firm comes into all of these crypto native they celebrate it from here till tomorrow i like it's the big deal and by the way it's rational it makes sense they do sit they could actually enable quite significant transactions so i'm not sure i agree with you that we have just copy pasted the old architecture i totally understand why people are upset with us i'm i'm i'm okay to to you know to take the heat about it but like come on i mean us us advertising on block works i mean like a set i mean we have dexas that are being used by d gens that want to trade with privacy i actually don't think that that's a bad thing you know you've all help me understand one one app one dashboard i've been looking at a lot in kind of the real world asset you know generation that that we're living through is rwa dot xyz and so this list all the different networks and some of the value of rwa's on chain real world assets of course canton network is showing here you guys are listed quite high there is two different sections in the real world asset league table one is distributed networks of which a theory of this number one and then be in b chain and then salon and stellar many the names that listeners will recognize and there's another category that's not distributed it's called represented and so canton is in the represented category along with other what i kind of think of as real world asset you know a chains like providence which we haven't talked a lot about on back list but then you have zk sink era over there what are they trying to get at and then another question on real world assets the website is you canton it shows represented asset value of three hundred and eighty billion on this website of real world assets which is a lot but it's all from broadridge dr which i've no idea what that means this is all for me and i worry a little bit that some of these metrics are gamified or they're not categorized completely well help us make sense of this sure so first of all if you don't know who broadridge is if you ever receive the letter to do a proxy vote on an equity it was probably delivered to you by broadridge so i vote on all of my proxy votes every time so they are a small company that is running the back office and middle office for 70% of the US fixed income market so it's they they they do important things there you know they're not necessarily like always in the news it's not like front and center but they they do process and manage a big chunk of the US US market you know you say that three hundred billion dollars is is a big number and it is a big number but actually when you look at the global global repo market on a daily volume perspective it is about i think today ten and a half to eleven trillion dollars every day only in the US it's five and a half trillion dollars every single day okay that's that's what it is so three hundred billion dollars right is not even ten percent of that it's close it's impressive but it's not that so what broadridge have done is they move treasuries on canton the ledger is the legally binding position and they are processing three hundred plus billion dollars of collateral movement on canton now if people think that we gamify the numbers i understand because if you had your you know eyes on crypto numbers right and that's what you're measuring yourself against so many this number comes and i totally understand why that would seem like that but that's like like three hundred eighty billion is bigger than all the stablecoins on public crypto networks again big number so so just just so again if if if you think that we we forget about we because digital asset have nothing to do with publishing these numbers but you can go and look i can remember what is the market cap of broadridge but if if i recall it's let's say around thirty billion dollars or something it's publicly traded you can go and listen on quarterly earnings to tim gokey right and if you think that he talks about canton in his quarter quarter learnings and about dlr i think we were talking about rational it is not rational to think that a CEO of a thirty billion dollar company would gamify numbers to get some attention on a website for what benefit like for what forget about that argument we use not we but like let's say us as an industry and yes i know maybe i pissed off people that i'm now putting us me in our industry but at least you see david i listen but but think about like do we use oracles we do and it goes back into the rw a conversation that we had well guess what we do trust those sources of data that publish it why don't we do it now because the number is big like that's why we don't trust the number like that to me is not rational and again like i try to approach these things unemotionally i can recognize why suddenly when you see a number like this you're like what the hell like what is going on for ten years we barely scratched the surface suddenly like one name puts three hundred billion dollars and i'm just saying like go listen to the quarterly earnings it's a publicly traded company i find it to be highly highly not logical to assume that a publicly traded company will risk their reputation just to get some street street cred on a website that's my view right and you know that's that's the number and by the way that number is going to get bigger is going to get bigger quite significantly and what you will see and by the way this is the double edge sort of privacy is that we plea the customers or the people that build on canton please publish the data out of your products.
So you're going to see other numbers there's seven life insurance companies that are issuing life insurance policies and the newties on canton i mean i'm going to start publishing the numbers and the values of those contracts and again people will say we're liars but i'm say yes your life insurance companies are also liars but you're going to see more people that have been building project on canton starting to publish the stats and that's the difference and i think i think maybe. Now Ryan if i kind of circle back to why i think people are annoyed we took a very different approach we felt that unfortunately it took us this long to build the technology but i think that one of the things that is unfortunate in my opinion in crypto is that crypto created so much noise before nothing was built.
Right we mentioned eos just think about it like we we just kept on coming up you know with vc's backing us and going like we're going to change the world and we're going to do this because look i have some scientists from Stanford that came up with a you know proof of monkeys type of consensus and as a result of that you know we're going to do xyz and we decided now we're going to build stuff we're going to onboard assets we're going to onboard companies. And when we have something real to show we're going to show it right we're not going to come up with futuristic you know like i i responded yesterday on trip and on and x to the founder and CEO of the founder of polygon look at their numbers that's incredible that's real stuff you can only admire when people do real things so.
So i accept the criticism i understand suspicion but i'm just trying i'm listening i'm giving you my version of it is we decide to build stuff we decide to decide to take it into production we launched a network and now we're going to go full steam ahead and we're going to show all of these partnerships all of the relationships all of the assets that have been built and all of the application and expect more to come. I want to actually go back to that you gave me that transition the what we were talking about which inspired this podcast on the the weekly rollup show was the the announcement that canton network is one of the dcc's first pilots to tokenize securities and so.
December 17th dcc announces a partnership with digital asset that's that's the company behind canton network to enable the tokenization of dcc custody assets on canton starting with a subset of us treasuries now i think every single blockchain under the sun. Is trying to get tokenize assets on their chain right now that is the meta that's the game and i don't know if dcc the dcc has any other blockchains that it's working on a pilot for but that makes me very interested in this because i want tokenize securities i want tokenize securities to go on chain. Can you talk about just how that relationship was fostered and what we can expect out of that.
Announcement in 2026 it says starting with us treasuries but like i just kind of want the s and p 500 what are we going to get this year out of tokenize securities on canton yeah so so let me let me start and be very clear the dcc is a market neutral. financial financial market infrastructure so what's important for me to say here in front of the we have no exclusivity canton is not going to be the only network that they do this on. We were very fortunate to be the first but we're not going to be the last i at least at least. That i don't have that kind of a guarantee that i'm the only one and i expect that that based on you know customer demand and opportunities there will be others that's just one second of all i mean you know i can only i can only discuss what what was shared which is treasuries you know my hopes is that equities you know will be there as well.
Actually to be honest when you start thinking about the dcc they also sit on munis and corporate bonds and other assets the hundred trillion is not just the equity market it's you know a pretty sizeable portfolio of assets so my hopes is that all of them because it's not just. trading but i think david what you're going to see is the next generation of ETFs and other products that are natively on chain so to me that's extremely exciting having these assets you know that's you know we've been. working and knowing the dcc for a very long time again we've been trying to bring capital markets and if you try to bring capital markets like i said you go to where.
The balance sheet is where the concentration of assets and the dcc if you could describe a capital markets black hole meaning all masses centered there the dcc is it they are the biggest by far just to give you a sense i think that the europeans are in the thirty to forty trillion just to give you a sense of the magnitude. In terms of size so you know we've been we've been working and talking to the dcc for a very long time and like i said have been very fortunate that they selected can't on first. Now one asset that's not settled by the dcc is the canton asset itself so this is the ticker is cc and.
This is i you tell me this looks like a relatively new asset the price tried at least he goes back to november it looks like on the on the screen i'm looking at it's worth over five billion dollars at the time of recording. And i i'm wondering what role the cc token has in the canton network and then also what's kind of the the valuation. Behind it i understand you can't necessarily get into investors mindset that this is the bait we have about all new crypto native assets is well are they money they store value are they should they be. Value does a utility token or by the revenue they produce discount cash flow that type of thing what can you tell us yeah so.
To me on a personal level what one of the things that really got me excited about crypto is that back to to allowing allowing others that historically couldn't is that if a network becomes kind of a backbone. Of financial industry or subset of a financial industry historically. The common person you know the three of us wasn't able to own a share of that of that infrastructure and and really what crypto showed. Is that you could actually create financial model where everybody can actually participate now that's just ownership. But the value in my opinion and again the value in my world of a smart contract net chain.
Is the utility that gets generated on it and i think that i think i think i think also you to start talking about it in some of your podcast is like. There has been too much too many promises and not many deliveries of what i would say real cash flow businesses. With an exception of a few i'm not saying that there aren't any we mentioned a very impressive business there are businesses but for the most part. I would say that there haven't been really long you know sustainable business models that came on chain and therefore my belief is that long term. Gravity and physics when meaning if you're not going to be able to actually drive utility through your network it's goes to zero long term that's that's my my personal take.
And and as a result of that what we're trying to do and we've talked for an hour and a half is is about what we're trying to optimize as much utility different asset classes different use cases. Canton coin is a utility that is being used to pay for those transactions and one thing that we have done different is that. The utility is denominated in us dollars and again. The reason for that is that we believe that if you're a large institutional player that is going to put a significant piece of your business. Whether we like it or not or we should think that we should start adjusting our currency to be denominated in it is a very interesting conversation at the moment it's not and and and CFOs and.
And controllers do projections in us dollars or fiat it's just a reality so the amount of canton coins that you burn. Are always denominated in us dollars so as canton coins rallies you would have to pay less canton coins for a transaction. But there is a mechanism in canton which is called the burn meant which is effectively says if if you don't burn enough where the price is effectively the chain is very inflationary which should correct the price. Down to where is the right equilibrium of the current utility in the network to the valuation of the network if that makes sense. So if if the price starts depreciating but utility stays at the same level the network effectively becomes deflationary and hopefully you become you get an upward pressure.
And and really over time the reason why we we decided that is because we said if we don't if we don't bring utility to this network we think that the market cap of this network should go to zero that's our view. Which is very counter to how some of the networks that I would say don't even process a hundred thousand dollars of fees a year you know have some crazy valuation to me that is not good for our industry it creates a false dichotomy of what we're trying to solve so. Canton coin is a utility to pay for transactions the transactions are denominated in US dollar and there is a burn meant equilibrium to try to bring the price or the market cap of the chain.
To some kind of an equilibrium value compared to the utility that runs on the network. You've all this has been great thanks for joining us I feel like it's accomplished the mission of fact finding of what the canton network actually is I hope that. A lot of listeners understand it the way I understand it now you know your ideology why you're doing this made me the last question to close us out so the year is 2030 what's a theorem doing and what's canton doing. Man why didn't you send this to me in advance. So so you know I think that in 2030 what we're going to see is that defy on a theorem does it atomically from assets that have been you know minted on canton and that freedom and access to asset could be interoperable between those two networks.
I think that you're going to see a theorem continue to build upon I think that you will see certain elements of privacy gets introduced in different different forms and I think that canton will be driving you know not 300 billions but potentially a few trillion of dollars of settlements every day. Well I'll have to leave it there you may have ruffled some feathers with the final answer but we'll save that for x. You've all thank you so much for joining us will talk to you soon this was awesome thank you. Bankless nation got to let you know of course none of this has been financial advice crypto is risky so stratify crypto you lose what you put in your headed west this the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot.
you