Today Jake Chervinsky is back on the podcast to discuss Tornado Cash developer Roman Storm's court case and its implications on DeFi and the crypto industry. Could DeFi be made illegal in the United States? Are DeFi developers going to be prosecuted if criminals use their code? Is it just DeFi? What other sectors could be at risk? The answers to these and many other questions are discussed in today’s episode.
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT https://bankless.cc/toku
⚡️CARTESI | LINUX-POWERED ROLLUPS https://bankless.cc/CartesiGovernance
🦄UNISWAP | BROWSER EXTENSION https://bankless.cc/uniswap
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/75?referrer=0x077Fe9e96Aa9b20Bd36F1C6290f54F8717C5674E
------ TIMESTAMPS 0:00 Intro 4:44 Roman Storm’s Case 12:52 Is DeFi at Risk? 18:20 The Ruling & Its Implications 21:29 Money Transmission Explained 25:52 Roman Storm’s Arrest 30:54 Are All DeFi Protocols At Risk? 36:17 Prosecution of Privacy 43:11 What This Ruling Means & What’s Next 48:41 Best & Worst Case Scenario 53:11 Other Sectors At Risk 57:35 Other Cases 1:03:48 Totalitarian Nightmare 1:08:21 SEC Updates 1:12:00 US Election 2024 1:17:30 Geofencing 1:23:21 Are We Winning & Conclusion ------ RESOURCES
Jake Chervinsky https://x.com/jchervinsky
Jake Chervinsky’s Tweet https://x.com/jchervinsky/status/1839412423096467753
A Practical Guide to Geofencing https://variant.fund/articles/practical-guide-to-geofencing/
Defend Roman Storm https://juicebox.money/@defend-roman-storm
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
This is, in my view, for the first time the United States government saying the developer of an open-source and mutable smart contract protocol should go to prison for how someone else abused that protocol even though there was nothing to do to stop it. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier internet money and internet finance. This is Ryan Sean Adams, David's out today, so I'm here to help you become more bankless. Pretty hard to go bankless if they make it illegal to go bankless. On Friday, September 26th, a US judge ruled that, quote, control of funds was not necessary, end quote, for money transmitter laws to apply to the tornado cash developer, Roman Storm.
This is a court case I'm referencing that we've talked about a number of times on bankless. If you're not familiar with it, we get into some of the details in today's episode. The question I had when I heard about this was, did they just make DeFi de facto illegal in the United States? The development of DeFi? This is a terrifying precedent regardless. And it really begs the question, do all DeFi developers become criminals if criminals use their code? Are DeFi protocols now unregistered money transmitters? And what would that mean? Is the Department of Justice waging a war on money laundering?
Or are they trying to wage a broader war on privacy and all forms of decentralized crypto? Crypto lawyer Jake Trvinsky is our guest today and he shed some light on all of these questions. We've called this tornado cash case the most important case in history so far of our fight for crypto freedoms. I think I'll answer questions like, can code be sanctioned by governments? Can crypto developers be arrested at the whim of an enforcement official? That's what's at stake in this case. This case and others like it is not just about our right to financial privacy, but that's important and that's part of it.
But it's about our broader right to develop and run software and preserve our civil liberties in this digital age. Liberties that I'm afraid are starting to erode. We're in the expert hands of Jake Delplus navigate this. The episode today was sponsored by our recommended crypto exchange Kraken. If you have not created an account and gotten started, go do it. There's a link in the show notes today. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world.
Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles and videos. With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience.
So check out the simple, secure and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Launching a token, don't let complex legal and tax issues slow you down. Toku provides specialized support to optimize your launch and ensure that you as a founder and your team and your investors get the most tax-efficient outcomes. The Toku team understands the crypto space inside and out and will ensure your token launch is fully compliant while maximizing tax efficiency.
Toku can connect you with the best attorneys if you need them to make sure that you have the best advice and Toku can help to optimize your taxes so you pay the least possible amount of taxes while still maintaining legal compliance. With Toku's guidance, you can concentrate on building your company while Toku handles the logistics. Token launches don't have to be complicated. Talk to Toku today to get a free initial token valuation. Have you ever felt that the tools for developing decentralized applications are too restrictive and fail to leverage advancements from traditional software programming?
There's a wide range of expressive building blocks beyond conventional smart contracts and solidity development. Don't waste your time building the basics from scratch and don't limit the potential of your vision. Kartezi provides powerful and scalable solutions for developers that supercharge app development. With a Kartezi virtual machine, you can run a full Linux OS and access decades of rich code libraries and open source tooling for building in Web 3. And with Kartezi's unique roll-up framework, you'll get real world scaling and computation. No more competing for block space. So if you're a developer looking to push the boundaries of what's possible in Web 3, Kartezi is now offering up to $50,000 in grants.
Head over to Kartezi's grant application page to apply today. And if you're not a developer, those with staked CTSI can take part in the governance process and vote on whether or not a proposal should be funded. Make sure your vote ready by staking your CTSI before the vote's open. Bankless Nation, very excited to introduce you. Once again, to Jake Chavinsky, he is probably Bankless's favorite crypto lawyer on Twitter. As evidenced by the number of times he's been on the bankless podcast. And he's here once again, he is the chief legal officer at variant fund. He's on the board of the DeFi education fund.
And we're here to talk about a very big case, a very important case that is going on in the US right now. This is the tornado cash case. But first of all, Jake, welcome to Bankless. Thanks for having me back. Ryan, great to be here. Do you need to say your typical legal disclaimer since I've had you on enough? I know that this sort of needs to be said, yes. Yes. And thanks for prompting me, because sometimes I forget. And then halfway through, I have to stop. So yes, I am a lawyer. But nothing I say here is intended as legal advice. So don't do or not do anything just because I talk about it here.
And if you do need counsel, feel free to reach out and I'm happy to make a recommendation. There you go. Jake is a fantastic lawyer, but he is not your lawyer of Bankless Nation. So just remember that. I want to start with this tweet. So this happened on Friday, the 26th, there was a ruling in the Roman storm case. And at the time, I didn't know the significance of that ruling, but that's that's why I invited you on the podcast really talk about this ruling. And you tweeted this out, Judge Fala, her ruling denying Roman storm's motion to dismiss the indictment is an assault on the freedom of software developers everywhere.
This will go down in history as a perversion of law and a travesty of justice. And it will go down on appeal if that's what it takes. Strong words, fiery words, they're Jake. You are one who, you know, your voice on encrypted Twitter generally is is very rational, very, very moderate, very considered, I would say. So to hear these fiery words coming out of you is was like a kind of a wake up call for me. Can you give us the context? Why did you tweet this out? And what happened on that Friday, September 26th? Happy to do that. And I appreciate your kind words. And I really do try to be as reasonable in my, my public statements as possible.
And, you know, often there are very lab voices on either side of an issue. And, you know, in this case, I'm not just blowing hot air. I think that Judge Fala's ruling on the motion to dismiss the indictment in the criminal prosecution of Roman Storm, one of the developers behind the tornado cash protocol is really a dangerous precedent to set for not just crypto, but for open source software development generally. So maybe let me start by giving you the procedural posture where we are in this case. And then we can get into what Judge Fala rules last week in her oral ruling, not written ruling on the motion to dismiss.
That sounds good. And one thing I want to say about this, we'll talk about this case, the Roman Storm ruling as kind of the thing that's most recently happened. There are a series of cases that are kind of tied together in this tornado cash case. Some in the US, some outside of the US, we might touch upon some of the other cases. The Roman Storm one is probably the largest going on in the US and the most significant going on in the US right now. There's almost a tornado cash versus the governments around the world like meta case because it's a series of cases that are all tied together. But okay, let's get into the Roman Storm case, the 26th, September 26th, and the ruling that was made.
So can you talk about the background for that and TS up here? Yeah, happy to do that. And also we can step a little more meta than that even and talk about just sort of the global battle for privacy as well because that's really how all of this sort of fits in. But to zoom in first on the Roman Storm case, the government decided, when I say the government, I mean the Department of Justice, which enforces the criminal law in the United States, decided to indict the developers behind the tornado cash protocol. So that includes Roman Storm on three different criminal charges. Conspiracy to commit money laundering, conspiracy to operate an unregistered money transmitting business, and conspiracy to violate IEBA, which is the law that creates all of the sanctions rules in the United States.
In other words, transacting or facilitating a transaction with a sanctioned party, in this case, the Lazarus group in the DPRK North Korea. And the reason the government took such an interest in the tornado cash case is because, as we all know, and as we were all able to see, thanks to the transparency of a public blockchain, tornado cash did end up being used as a mixer by some bad actors in the space. Even though the vast majority of the use of tornado cash was ordinary people who just wanted to protect their privacy on chain. And in the course of the prosecution, as a defense lawyer would do in basically any case, Roman Storm and his counsel filed a motion to dismiss the indictment.
And the industry really showed up to support that motion to dismiss. So I co-authored an Amicus brief, along with Amanda Tumanelli at the DeFi Education Fund, arguing why that motion should be granted, Coin Center filed an Amicus brief, the Blockchain Association, and many others. And in essence, the argument on a motion to dismiss an indictment is, even if you accept all of the factual allegations that the government makes in the indictment, those facts do not add up to a crime. And the core of the argument in the tornado cash case for Roman Storm is that he is not credibly accused in the indictment of actually committing those offenses, conspiracy, ticket money laundering, or operate an unregistered transmitting business, money transmitting business, or violate sanctions, nearly because he wrote code that he put onto a blockchain that operates in an autonomous and self-executing fashion, and then was abused by bad actors after the fact without his personal involvement.
So that was essentially the argument that was made in the motion to dismiss the indictment, and we can dig more into the details there. But just, yeah, go ahead, Ryan. It seems like a clear-cut argument. I mean, is it a pretty clear-cut argument? Is there precedent around this? Well, you would hope that it would be a clear-cut argument that individuals should not be held liable for the bad acts of some other third party that they are not actually participating in. But in this case, it does get a lot more complicated for a couple of reasons. What the government did in the indictment, at least in my personal opinion, is they really conflated the ways in which storm was involved in the tornado cash protocol.
They make a bunch of allegations about what storm had done, including writing the immutable smart contracts that comprise the tornado cash protocol, but not just that. They also alleged that he was operating a website, right? You can go learn about tornado cash online. He was operating a user interface, or at least was making updates to a user interface that people could use to access the protocol. He also was involved in creating a relayer network, which was a separate off-chain system that allowed users to better protect their privacy when they use tornado cash. But the government admits in the indictment that the core of the tornado cash protocol, the pool contract that people actually use in order to get privacy, and that North Korea was using in this case, were not in Roman storm control.
That's why the argument was he can't be committing a conspiracy to commit money laundering if he literally could not conduct the transaction that constitutes money laundering, because that transaction is literally out of his control through an immutable smart contract protocol. The same issue for operating an unregistered money transmitting business, which we should get into this a little bit later, has been pretty well-defined already, not by the Department of Justice, but by thin sand over at the Treasury Department, and the way they define this type of business just doesn't sync up with how the Department of Justice described it in the indictment.
This is a key piece here, because I want folks to see this case as I'm now starting to see it post this ruling, and even before, is because this isn't just about tornado cash. It's far broader than that. It's not even just about privacy. It is that, but it's also far broader than that. What you just said is did Roman storm have control over an immutable smart contract is pretty key, because everything that we are building in DeFi is an immutable smart contract, at least the purely decentralized things are. So you think of like the Uniswap Protocol. It's a non-custodial smart contract that has some funds inside of it, but it's outside of the bounds of the developers of the Uniswap Protocol.
It's immutable, it's on chain. They don't control it. They can't access it. They cannot moderate who puts funds inside of the Uniswap Protocol. That's been true of Uniswap V1 all the way to V4 today. So this is broader than just privacy. It's certainly broader than just tornado cash. This is about all of decentralized finance, isn't it? Because a lot of this hinges upon this idea of, you know, did Roman storm, was he responsible for the non-custodial smart contract deployment, essentially a DeFi Protocol that he published on the Ethereum blockchain. Is that about right? What have I gotten wrong in that description?
I think you're absolutely right. And maybe a few thoughts about this. One is this really strikes to the heart of what we are trying to do in DeFi. The purpose of DeFi is to create decentralized systems that do not rely on trusting a single centralized third party in order to operate or in order for users to get access to them. The second that you reintroduce a centralized intermediary with control over a smart contract in a traditional Web 2 finance kind of way, then you're not doing DeFi anymore, at least in my opinion, right? You're losing all the benefits of resilience and transparency and trustlessness and permissionlessness that is at the heart of what we are trying to build in this industry.
And if you go all the way back to 2013, so let's go back in time to sort of the beginning of the analysis of this particular regulatory issue. The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, which is a bureau of the Treasury Department that enforces the anti-money laundering laws, recognized that this nature of a public blockchain, its decentralization and its permissionlessness, was intention with the Bank Secrecy Act, which essentially says if you are a financial institution and you're processing transactions on behalf of customers, then you have some anti-money laundering compliance obligations.
You need to monitor those transactions. You need to do KYC, no your customer, identify who all your customers are. You need to identify suspicious activity. You need to report that to the government. You need to have internal controls to make sure that you as a company are following all of those rules and a number of other types of compliance obligations. Now in the context of a decentralized smart contract protocol, there is no way to identify the users of the protocol. There is no financial institution that can comply with those obligations. But in the very early days, when folks were still wrapping their mind around what is a blockchain-based business, there were questions about whether a centralized exchange should be treated like a financial institution under the Bank Secrecy Act.
And thankfully, FinSN was maybe the only agency at any point in time to give clear guidance about when compliance with the Bank Secrecy Act was necessary. And they explained if you have control over user funds, if you are a money transmitter under their regulations, meaning you accept funds from one party and transmit funds to another party or another location, while you're a money transmitter and you have to comply with all those regulations. And over the course of years from 2013, all the way up to 2019, FinSN continued to give guidance about when actors in the crypto industry were or were not money transmitters under their regulations.
This all came to fruition in 2019 guidance that summed up FinSN's entire view on this issue. And the 2019 guidance is probably the most referenced regulatory guidance of anything in crypto. It's something that all of us for the last five years in DFI have looked to to understand, do we need to KYC users of this system or not? And in my view, the 2019 guidance makes very clear that an immutable smart contract protocol is not a money transmitter or rather the developers of that protocol are not money transmitters by virtue of developing the protocol and do not need to register with FinSN. Nonetheless, here comes the Department of Justice in this criminal prosecution.
And their argument is we are not bound by treasuries guidance. You all in the industry may feel like you've been following what they told you to do for the last five years. That may satisfy them, but not us. And even if you are not in violation of the Bank Secrecy Act, nonetheless, you may be violating the criminal law and you may have to go to prison for it. So that's what's happening in this case. So that's essentially what they're saying about tornado cash. And that's why the stakes are so much wider. The stakes are potentially all of DFI in the United States. So can you get us to the, and just to clarify my understanding of this, Jake is like in the ruling, maybe we'll get to the ruling that happened on that Friday and September in the ruling, the judge by saying that Roman storm had responsibility that tornado cash and his development of tornado cash was essentially a money transmitter, right?
Then de facto, is she not implying that all DFI protocols, potentially smart contracts could be money transmitters or like was this just tied to privacy? Anyway, let's get to the actual ruling and what the implications might be. So what happened in the ruling on the 26th? Yeah. So as I said, in the motion to dismiss the indictments, there were many arguments, but the crux of the argument was Roman storm was not operating and unregistered money transmitting business because what he was doing, offering a website, offering a user interface, writing the original code, working on the relay network, that is not money transmission because he was not accepting funds and then transmitting funds on behalf of any other person.
He never had custody over user funds. He didn't have control over the protocol. And the judge basically said that is not my interpretation of the law. My view of the law is a person does not need to have control over user funds or custody over those funds in order to engage in money transmission. And you know, it's very important to note, first of all, that motions to dismiss indictments are very rarely granted. So in a sense, it's not surprising that storm lost the motion. The standard is extremely difficult to meet. Courts are very deferential to the government. They basically say, well, as long as the indictment sort of hints that there was a crime, as long as the language of the statute, the alleges and offence is somewhere in the indictment, then more or less this can go to trial.
But Judge Filo went way beyond just saying, this indictment is at least sufficient to move on to trial. She actually made a holding on the legal issue that control is not necessary to engage in money transmission. And she sort of steps back and does what I think is a bit of a slight of hand that the government does as well, which is to describe tornado cash as a whole as a service. So she says that Roman Storm was offering a service that was the tornado cash protocol, but she doesn't engage at all with the details about what that service actually might be. And I think we could all agree that storm was offering some type of service.
There was a business here, there were ways in which he was being compensated for that business, but the business was not the business of money transmission. And that's something that Judge Filo, at least in my opinion, just didn't engage with in the ruling. Okay, so can we talk about this term money transmission? Because we were talking a lot about this, this court hinges upon the judge's definition of what money transmission actually is and who's a money transmitter and who's not. We'll talk more about that. But why is that even important? So say I'm a money transmitter, Jake. Does this imply some level of responsibility, like culpability, a set of things I have to do?
Why is money transmission so important here? Yes, that's a great question. And this might get a little bit in the weeds of the law, but hopefully the listeners will appreciate understanding a bit more how these different statutes play together. Exactly to your point, if you're a money transmitter, then you are a type of regulated financial institution under the Bank Secrecy Act, which is that law that the Treasury Department FinCEN enforces. As a money transmitter, you have to go register with FinCEN, you have to KYC, all of your customers or users, you need internal controls, you need to designate a compliance officer, you need to do all kinds of reporting and record keeping under the Bank Secrecy Act.
So being a money transmitter imposes a lot of compliance obligations on you under Title 31 of the U.S. Code, which is where the Bank Secrecy Act is. Totally separately from that, you also could be subject to criminal liability under Title 18 of the U.S. Code. That's where all the criminal laws are that the Department of Justice enforces. And Title 18 makes it a crime, specifically under Section 1960, to operate an unregistered money transmitting business. So the way that ordinarily, we would think about this before the Department of Justice recently took a different position is, if you're a money transmitter, but you don't register with FinCEN, you've committed two separate violations.
Number one, a civil violation under Title 31 of the Bank Secrecy Act, the Treasury Department might enforce that violation against you. And number two, a criminal violation under Section 1960 of Title 18, then the Department of Justice might come and prosecute you criminally. But we all assumed that this was all or nothing, right? You've either complied with the law or you've not complied with the law and violated both of those different statutes. Here, the Department of Justice is saying, that's wrong. You can be in compliance with Title 31, following all of Treasury's guidance, and nonetheless being engaged in money transmission as we differently define it under Section 1960.
And that, frankly, breaks my brain. I don't know how an industry could possibly operate when we can't follow the guidance of the Treasury Department, which is tasked with enforcing this type of statute. So you said it's, is it Title 18? Title 18 is the criminal code, yes. That's the criminal code. And this is what Roman Storm was explicitly charged with, among other things, a violation of Title 18. You said, that is a criminal charge. So when you talk about criminal charges, right? So I mean, we're talking about what jail time, like what are the penalties for this type of criminal charge? Yeah, the potential penalty for operating an unregistered money transmitting business under 18 USC Section 1960 is five years in prison.
And you know, he's also accused of violating Section 1956, which is the money laundering statute. You know, you could tack on more years for that. And then there's also the sanctions violation, which again, all hinges on essentially the same general allegation that Storm is liable for third party misconduct that he could not control at the time that it took place. So these charges stack too, right, Jay? You know, it depends on sentencing, you know, often if there is a conviction for more than one charge, the sentences end up running concurrently. So you could get three five year sentences, but you don't serve 15 years, you know, you serve the five minus some for good behavior.
This is all stuff that gets worked out and sentencing, but we are talking about the liberty of a software developer. You know, this isn't just a question of whether there could be a fine for a company or whether the business can continue operating. This is, in my view, for the first time, the United States government saying the developer of an open source immutable smart contract protocol should go to prison for how someone else abused that protocol, even though there was nothing you could do to stop it. It's actually wild. Of course, we don't know all of the facts and all of the evidence will come out in the court case and that court case will go to trial December 2nd.
So I don't think either of us are here saying like we know all the facts and all of the evidence of this case. But can we talk about the circumstances through which Roman Storm was actually arrested? So someone hearing that might be well, but we live in a reasonable society. Okay, Jay, yeah, these laws are kind of on the book, but like using things like, you know, DeFi developers could go to jail and they could be like criminals. That's not practically how the US works, right? I mean, we are a country of innovation. We support developers and entrepreneurs. But can we just talk about the circumstances by which Roman Storm was was actually arrested?
So he was a privacy DeFi developer, right? Deployed tornado cash. We've already talked about some of the other activities that that he did in association with this deployment. My understanding, Jay, because he was actually arrested from his house somewhere in Washington state in the like early hours of the morning. I don't know if he had a family there, but like in front of his family, it was like literally arrested. So this wasn't the case of like, Hey, you're getting some warnings and we'd like you to comply and you need to do XYZ, like, or else, it was suddenly the FBI, a SWAT team's at his house and yanking him and like taking him into custody is is that accurate?
Because that's what I seem to remember from this. Well, I remember the same report. I don't want to scare people too much, right? I don't want all the DeFi developers listening to this to think that men and windbreakers are going to show up at their door at 6 a.m. tomorrow and put them in handcuffs because I don't actually think that that's what's likely to happen. And I don't want to scare anybody too much. But first, we don't know whether there were conversations between the Department of Justice and Storm or others at Toronto cash or their council before there was an arrest. Frankly, it would shock me if there was no contact at all and doors got kicked down without any warning whatsoever.
So I think that that's an unlikely result. Although indeed, if the government does decide to make an arrest, they usually don't tell you way in advance because they're worried that you're going to forgive. And especially in crypto, where there may be some risk of flight, I think the government tries not to let folks know in advance that there may be an arrest. But I think if I were to steal man the government's case here, not the case on the facts, but in terms of how they're operating, let me give at least my most reasonable interpretation or what I think that someone working for the Department of Justice would say if they had the freedom to actually discuss this, which by the way, they don't.
So we don't really know what's going on behind the scenes. I think what they would say is we are not coming after all of DeFi. And we are certainly not coming after all open-source software developers. That's preposterous where reasonable people let me understand the world operates on open-source software. We are going after people who are building tools that are being abused by our geopolitical enemies, by brutal dictatorial regime North Korea, which none of us should be supporting in any way. And we are only doing that because we know that the developers, and again, this is what they would say, it's not my view, but they would say where we know that the developers are aware of that illicit use of the technology that they built.
And nonetheless, despite that knowledge, they are continuing to profit from their work and they're continuing to try to improve it, and they're not doing anything in their power, and there are some things, potentially in their power, to do, to try to stop that type of illicit use. But no one else needs to be worried about this. We exercise prosecutorial discretion. And if you are trying to work with us to stop the bad guys, then you don't have to be worried about men and women breakers coming to your house at 6am tomorrow morning. That is, I think what they would say. My response to that is that's a nice thought.
We're not here in crypto to trust the government to do the right thing. In fact, we're here to build technology that stops bad actors, whether they're in government or anywhere else, from exerting their outsized influence and power to take advantage of other people. And even if we think the government is making good decisions now, I think everyone could be worried about what a next administration looks like, no matter what side of the political aisle you're on, and whether there could be some abuse of prosecutorial discretion in the form of selective prosecution, where the government decides we're only going to go after people we don't like.
And we're going to interpret the law so broadly that there is no more rule of law. The law is if we don't like you, we're going to come get you. And to me, that's what this legal precedent sounds like, as the Department of Justice is describing their authority to prosecute software developers under section 1960. I mean, it's a little bit like, you know, trust me, bro, enforcement. And that's that's what's so concerning about this because like you don't know who is on the other side of that enforcement. I'm that that's not how the legal system works. That's not how the US is supposed to be designed.
We should have a set of civil liberties that protect us from like this kind of enforcement. Let me ask kind of a questions maybe somewhat of the elephant in the room. So this DeFi protocol was was targeted for privacy use cases. And your point, the vast majority of its transactions were just people simply trying to preserve their their privacy when interacting on chain. So chains like Ethereum, of course, Bitcoin, et cetera, they don't have privacy native to the layer one. So if you want that, like any level of privacy without some third party seeing how you transact, you know, the way I might pay you $100 bill and you and I don't have to tell anyone.
It's not recorded anywhere. It's not on a public ledger. We want that to maintain that cash level privacy. Then tornado cash was an avenue to do that. Lots of people in the US and crypto use this as just like a tool, including my cohost, David Hoffman, by the way, he's a part of another like tornado cash related loss that we could we talk about later. But anyway, the elephant in the room is of course, student in a cash was built for privacy. There are other DeFi protocols that are a bit more general, not necessarily privacy, but like a automated market maker, right? Say like a uniswap, for instance.
And of course, the uniswap labs front end can implement whatever they want as far as, you know, future KYC future screening. They can, you know, de list assets. They can do whatever they want. But the code itself that operates any of the uniswap protocols, right? Is immutable on chain any other third party could spin up an interface. You don't even need an interface. You could trade tokens using kind of like command line firmware type stuff without a user interface. And there is nothing stopping any quote unquote bad actor from and I should acknowledge North Korea is absolutely a bad actor like acknowledge the national security concern here.
Like understand that piece of it, right? What we're talking about is the legal precedent, the sets. But anyway, any actor can participate without the developer's permission. And so how does that, like, why, why should this stop at tornado cash? Why does this not filter down into all of the other DeFi protocols? Is there some sort of argument about proportion of like elicit bad actor use? Or is that what the judge is implying? Or is that the entire problem that this is also vague at this point? I think that's exactly the problem. And if you look at the criminal statute that storm is accused of violating operating an unregistered money transmitting business, there's nothing even in there about illicit financial activity or at least it can apply even if there is no illicit activity whatsoever.
So if you take the government's theory at it on its face, I do think you could apply it to any number of other types of DeFi protocols. Now again, the government is going to say that's not their intent. And their real goal and the purpose of these statutes in the first place is to give them authority to root out bad actors and money laundering. Ah, they want the flexibility here, right? That's exactly right. And Judge Philae in her oral ruling even said, you know, sure, technically speaking in the past, money transmitters have had control over user funds. But I don't see that as being necessary under the statute.
And I have to interpret the statute as being flexible to keep pace with novel ways that people are trying to abuse the financial system. So she's sort of admitting that she is expanding the law in a new way, but that the law is intended to cover new types of conduct. So the government will have the authority that it needs to after illicit actors. So I do think that this is a concern for everyone else that more so though than the legal analysis. And this is so often the case with crypto because laws and regulations are so vague and hard to understand when you apply them in a decentralized permissionless environment.
The question is not with the law says the question is one of practical risk and practical calculations by the government what they want to go after and what they don't. And when they look at something like Uniswapa decentralized exchange protocol that itself does not provide privacy. In other words, there's really no way to use something like Uniswap to obscure the source of funds. All the transactions are going to get traced. And so you can't launder money because you can't stop the government from tracing transactions through the protocol. The government basically says, yeah, we can trace this stuff.
So we don't really feel like we need to characterize this as an unregistered money transmitter. It's when you have privacy that the government says, we are not comfortable with this. And many people have noted, so this isn't my thought, but if cash, which of course is totally private, we're invented today, the government would almost certainly not want to allow it because they want to surveil all of our transactions all of the time. That's how law enforcement works in the modern world. And they are not going to give that up easily just because we built technology that doesn't require centralized intermediaries in order for us to transact at a distance.
This is so interesting. So basically in theory, this judges ruling, and we'll talk about the significance of this judges ruling because this judge does not get the last say on this issue. I mean, per your tweet, and it will go down on appeal if that's what it takes. You think, ultimately, this will be struck down. But let's say this judges theory holds. Then she's basically saying, if you're a developer deploying an immutable smart contract, and a third party actor uses that or does something, that code, you might be a money transmitter, and you might be prosecuted under Title 18 1960 under criminal charges.
But practically what you're saying is the US government apparatus and the DOJ and everybody is kind of looked at this issue. They're not, I mean, used Wopsman operation for a long time. DeFi has been out there for a very long time. I mean, you've been in this industry for as long as anyone, Jake, I mean, looking at these issues, and they're not knocking down DeFi developers' doors and arresting them. And it's because we have this maybe uneasy impasse in that our layer ones and DeFi itself are transparent or not private. And so they've kind of like not prosecuted it in the way they're coming after tornado cash, where they are targeting is when privacy, when there's a layer of privacy, when they can't see in the transaction itself, who the source is, that's what they're most worried about.
And so that's where we get the ire of the US government. I guess that's kind of the, the trust me, bro, is like you're kind of trusting that the DOJ is not going to come after any of our other DeFi protocols, just because they're not private, because they're public. And so we have this uneasy impasse where they have all of these powerful analytic tools and they can, you know, trace, they essentially get their AML KYC anyway. It's just in the background where they can track all of these transactions. It's another quip that I think is somewhat true, is like along with cash being illegal if it was proposed today.
I think if Bitcoin had privacy on like the base layer of Bitcoin, or Ethereum had privacy on the base layer of Ethereum, I don't know that the governments around the world would have allowed it to propagate in the way that it has. And I sort of view that as a practical matter. It seems to be when there's immutable smart contract code and privacy combined. That's when you face the full might of the financial surveillance like government apparatus. That's what they really don't like. I think that spot on and very well said. And you know, I should add, you know, I have friends at the Department of Justice.
They're very good people, right? They want to do the right thing. They're working for the government because they believe in what they're doing. And we should be grateful that they're there because we do need them to go after the actual bad actors. And I do think, you know, one way to put it is trust me, bro. But another is to say they are trying to make good decisions about how they wield their prosecutorial discretion. The problem is what we want to see is for them to go after the actual bad guys, the people who are engaged in criminal conduct, not the people who are building neutral tools that can be used by ordinary people for totally reasonable and legitimate purposes.
We want to protect privacy, right? Privacy is guaranteed to us by the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution. I for one still really like the Constitution. The Bill of Rights, my favorite part for sure, the Fourth Amendment, probably my favorite amendment, maybe after the First Amendment. The Fifth is pretty good too. And the Fourth Amendment as well. But you see what I'm saying, right? We have to balance the very reasonable goals of the folks at the Department of Justice to stop illicit activity and protect people to genuinely protect us from bad actors with our civil liberties. What we cannot say is we will abans in privacy entirely because that will make it easier for the government to hunt down the bad guys.
Because what that leads to every single time you see the rise of an authoritarian government anywhere in the world. And we have so many concerns about authoritarianism now here in the United States, no matter where you are in the political spectrum, is the first thing they do is they take advantage of their control over the financial system and over the criminal justice system to go after their enemies, their political enemies. And if we interpret the law this broadly to give the government this much power, we have to be very worried about how they will use that power next. New projects are coming online to the mantle layer two every single week.
Why is this happening? Maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer two design architecture since it first started building mantle DA powered by technology from eigenDA. Maybe it's because users are coming on to the mantle layer two to capture some of the highest yields available in DeFi, and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the $3 billion mantle treasury in the mantle reward station. Maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with giving you grants, liquidity support, and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application.
Maybe it's all of these reasons all put together. So if you're a dev, and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto, or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's DeFi apps, click the link in the show notes to getting started with mantle. Uniswap wallet is officially the preferred wallet of bankless, and it's the one we use anytime when we want to transact on chain. Whether you're on your browser or on the go, Uniswap wallet makes it easier than ever to swap anytime, anywhere. Use your wallet to transfer funds directly from the top centralized exchange and tap thousands of tokens across the deer, and over 10 other chains like based, arbitrum, and optimism.
Uniswap wallet delivers deep liquidity, fast execution, and reliable quotes with zero gas swaps through Uniswap X. And when it comes to security, you can rest easy knowing it's backed by Uniswap labs, one of the most trusted teams in DeFi. Their code is open source and independently reviewed, so you know it's protected. So why wait, download the Uniswap wallet today on Chrome, iOS, and Android, and don't forget to claim your free uni.eth username directly in the mobile wall, start swapping smarter with Uniswap. The arbitrum portal is your one stop hub to entering the Ethereum ecosystem. With over 800 apps, arbitrum offers something for everyone.
Dive into the epicenter of DeFi, where advanced trading, lending, and staking platforms are redefining how we interact with money. Explore arbitrum's rapidly growing gaming hub from immersed role-playing games, fast-paced fantasy MMOs to casual, luck battle mobile games. Move assets effortlessly between chains and access the ecosystem with ease, via arbitrum's expansive network of bridges and on-rits, step into arbitrum's flourishing NFT and creator space, where artists, collectors, and social converge and support your favorite streamers all on chain. Find new and trending apps and learn how to earn rewards across the arbitrum ecosystem with limited time campaigns from your favorite projects.
Empower your future with arbitrum. Visit portal.arbitrum.io to find out what's next on your web3 journey. Okay, can we talk about this ruling itself? So the ruling has some, you know, terrible implications, let's say, for non-custodial DeFi tools in general, particularly privacy, but not just privacy. How binding is this ruling? Like, where do we go next with this type of thing? Yeah, so great question. And the answer is it's not binding. And not only is it not binding, but Judge Phila decided not to issue written opinions. So all we're ever going to get is this transcript. And that means a couple things.
Most importantly, for the lawyers out there who will understand this, it means the opinion won't go on less law, which is the main research database that people use to look for precedent that is persuasive, even if it's not binding. So this is actually going to be pretty hard for people to find. You could say that was intentional, that she didn't want the opinion to be cited. Although, frankly, very few orders on motions to dismiss indictments get written up as written orders. So it may not be that no worthy that she decided not to write it up. The sort of downside of her not writing it is that the transcript is pretty, it's pretty vague.
You know, she didn't give us the deep reasoned analysis that you would ordinarily get from a written opinion. So as you know, Ryan, when, you know, we get orders from judges, including, frankly, from Judge Phila on some of the SEC's cases, right, motions to dismiss and motions for summary judgment. There are very long dozens of pages, lots of case citations, very deep and detailed explanations of what the basis of the ruling was. We're just not going to get that here. And in a sense, that's a blessing for us in the industry because it's not that likely that the next judge confronted with a similar set of facts or a similar legal argument.
We'll go to Judge Phila and just say, well, she already comprehensively dealt with this issue. So I'm just going to cite her and defer my judgment to hers. I think that's a really positive thing. Then there's the fact that this order itself probably doesn't get appealed on its own. What happens next is the case goes to trial. And the trial is currently set for early December. I think it's December 2nd. And from everything I can see just looking at the public docket, it seems like the parties are on pace to go to trial in December. Now, obviously, who knows what will happen at trial? There will be weeks of testimony and evidence submitted to a jury, like 12 Americans who are, you know, peers of storm will get to decide, did the government actually meet its burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that storm actually committed these offenses?
And what could happen is the jury could say found not guilty acquitted. And that would be the end of the entire story. There would be no further discussion of any legal issue. The case would just disappear. On the other hand, if storm is convicted, the jury finds that he committed one or more of these offenses, then you will have an appeal. And the appeal could be about any number of issues that came up during trial, including things having absolutely nothing to do with any of these issues around money transmission or government authority, right? Evidence that was submitted that shouldn't have been or, you know, things of that nature.
Also, what would likely be challenged is not the order on this motion to dismiss, but rather jury instructions that Judge Fala will give to the jury, explaining to them what the law is to help them decide whether storm is guilty or not guilty. So we're going to get more over time from Judge Fala that will be challenged. And in all likelihood, this will ruin on the motion to dismiss just gives us a sense of how she's going to continue interpreting the law going forward. And this judge is the same judge who's going to be presiding over the kind of the main case that happens in December and you're nodding your head, yes.
And the instructions she gives to the jury, will they be instructions that like, you know, about this non-custodial versus custodial issue? In other words, she kind of, you know, slant the jury to say, hey, still a money transmitter, you know, even with non-custodial. So you have to factor that into your analysis. I mean, in other words, can this really sway the jury towards one interpretation of the law? So often that is what happens. We don't know what the jury instructions will look like, how many of them there will be, what issues they will be on. And the process of figuring out jury instructions involves both of the parties.
So at some point, Judge Fala will ask both storm and his council and also the government, what jury instructions do you think that I should give? You can imagine, or guess at least, that the government is going to want very strong authority in the jury instructions. They'll want her to instruct the jury in order to find a violation of section 1960. You do not need to find that Roman storm had control over user funds, et cetera, et cetera. And often, judges do sway a jury in the way that they give instructions. But there's no way to know that right now. For all we know, Judge Fala will decide, I don't need to give a jury instruction on this issue.
I think it's totally clear all on its own. The jury can just read the statute. And if they have a question, they can also send questions as they are deliberating. So, you know, this really is a long process that goes on leading up to the trial in pre-trial motions practice and then also throughout the trial and then also as the jury is deliberating. Wow. Okay. What's the worst case scenario that could happen for D5 for crypto coming out of this case? And what's what's kind of the best case scenario? I mean, at this point, the best case scenario for D5 would be an acquittal because I think if the government just loses this case, even if there's not a legal reasoning that they get as to why, that would be a strong rebuttal to their attempt to regulate this industry through criminal prosecution of software developers.
So without a doubt, that's the best thing that could happen for D5. I'll throw in a bit of a pitch, if you don't mind, that the best way that listeners can help Roman Storm get an acquittal is to support his defense. And hopefully Ryan, you and I will tweet out or otherwise publicize links where people can make donations. Good lawyers are expensive. And Storm does need more funding in order to make sure that he has the best representation. You know, it's crazy here, Jake. So we have been talking about this and tweeting it out. In fact, Bankless has donated to this cause. I've heard from a number of people who are actually afraid of donating to this case.
I mean, that gives you a sense for kind of the chilling effect that this type of case kind of brings. And I don't know if these fears are rational or not. I mean, regardless, it is causing a chilling effect. You know, it's not illegal to donate is what I would say. There'll be a link in the show notes. And if you care about these issues, then well said by Jake, this is what we need to do. Okay, what is what is so that was the best case scenario that's acquitted? What's what's a worst case scenario? Yeah, so I'm just exactly to your point. And this is quite sad. I think in the worst case scenario, Storm would be convicted.
There would be an appeal on this issue that we're discussing whether there should be some control requirements under the definition of money transmission in the criminal code that could go up to the second circuit court of appeals. In a worst case scenario, they would affirm, meaning they would have validate judge fails ruling that control is not necessary. Circuit courts write opinions, a circuit court opinion going the wrong way on this issue would be binding in the second circuit. So the next time the government brings a case in the southern district of New York, the judge would be required to follow the second circuit's ruling.
Perhaps there could be appeal up to the Supreme Court. You know, we're now talking many years down the road and the Supreme Court doesn't take a whole lot of cases, especially when there's only one circuit court opinion on the issue, they usually look for cases where one circuit court has said one thing and another circuit court has said another thing. So everyone is aware that different parts of the country, the law is different and the Supreme Court is trying to resolve that split. We wouldn't have that, I think, in this case. So it's hard to imagine Supreme Court review. Also, unlike some of the other cases we tend to bring to the Supreme Court, or at least want to in the crypto industry, where the Supreme Court is very suspicious of the administrative state and its authority that where the court is limiting the ability of the SEC, for example, to assert its jurisdiction, the Supreme Court tends to be much familiar to the government in cases involving national security and law enforcement.
So it's hard to put together five Supreme Court justices who would side with us on this issue. If, in fact, the second circuit has decided that control is not necessary under Section 1960. So worst case scenario, this does become the law of the land. And like you said, folks are afraid to build immutable smart contract protocols in the United States without being told by their lawyers. If you want to build this, you have to put KYC into it before you launch it. I think that's the protocol itself, not just the user interface, into the protocol itself, right? That's what a lawyer would say if control is not necessary, if that becomes the precedent.
I mean, I do think that's the implication here, right? And I do wonder if there are going to be some conservative lawyers out there who even hear what Judge Fala just said and started advising their clients, you can't launch a decentralized permissionless smart contract protocol because even though you don't control it, it still might be a money transmitter. So you have to do KYC literally on chain, which I suppose could be theoretically possible somehow. But if that's what we're doing, it's not defying any longer. And I don't think it's what motivates any of us to be here. Wow, control not necessary.
Can I ask briefly, this would seem to have implications beyond crypto. Of course, this is a crypto focused podcast, but we're talking about code that's published in some way, in an open source way, and a bad actor using this code. I mean, does this have implications for like AI, let's say, like AI models and AI generation? I mean, where does this kind of thing stop? I think it has vast implications outside crypto. I think, you know, even before we get to AI, just think about what money transmission means. If it doesn't require control or custody of user funds, is my internet service provider, a money transmitter?
Because I used the internet in order to use a defy protocol. Does Tom Cassney to register now with the government and start tracing all of my transactions? So I think that even in the scope of money transmission, this is very dangerous. Even before that, Jake, I think of in being an eth validator. I mean, what is that? You're certainly processing some transactions, aren't you? It's part of this. Absolutely. Absolutely. And, you know, thankfully, again, FinSem, in its guidance about money transmission, is always said, miners and validators are not money transmitters. But you have to wonder if the Department of Justice is going to say, well, they're not Title 31 money transmitters, but they are Title 18 money transmitting businesses.
And I just, I don't know how crypto could survive in the United States if that were the case. But to your question outside crypto, we are dealing with this again, core issue of when a software developer is liable for a third party that misuses software that they created without their knowledge and without their participation. AI can be used for anything, you know, whether it's getting information or whether it's a future world of AI agents, where all of us are using some type of AI agents to go out and do things for us on the internet. Well, is the creator, the developer of the AI agents going to be liable for everything that anyone does with that agent just because they built the neutral tool?
Again, I don't think we can have in modern digital worlds if the government gets to target literally anybody they dislike just because they are interpreting the law this expansively. Anyone they dislike and even if you just say, well, it's only it's only the privacy sort of case. Well, I guess my question is like, how about somebody who develops some new encryption algorithm, you know, ZK Snarks or, you know, RSA encryption? And this is certainly used in, you know, privacy context. It's open source code. Are they on the hook for how North Korea might might use their encryption software? And it's crazy to imagine that, but if you go back to the 90s and you go back to the crypto wars, right, not the cryptocurrency wars, the photography wars, long before we were building on blockchains, that was the fight that was happening in the 1990s.
The government was deeply suspicious of and not accepting of end to end encryption on the internet. They wanted to treat encryption as munitions. And it really wasn't until commerce came online that the government backed off of that perspective. And there are a lot of people who are now in crypto who were fighting that battle back then who will explain this a lot better than I can. But it wasn't that we convinced the government, hey, encryption's okay, you don't have to worry about us having private communications with people on the other side of the world. It was that businesses showed up and said, hey, we need to take credit card payments on the internet.
And there's no way we can do that if we don't have widespread encryption. So back off. And that's what got the government to back off. And I think the best hope and I say this all the time in so many different contexts, the best hope for crypto to overcome some of these concerns about the risks that that decentralized public blockchains pose. And let's be honest about this, there are risks. There's no question about that. But the way we overcome the risks is that the benefits are so much greater that there is no way to deny the advancement of the technology. And that's why my hope for anyone who's listening to this right now, if you're a builder, keep building, build consumer apps that are undeniably valuable that everybody wants to use.
And that's going to put us in the best position to win not just the court battles, but the policy battles in Washington, DC, because that's where this is ultimately going to get sorted out. Make it so useful, the authoritarians can't turn it off, right? It would be disastrous for them to turn it off. Okay, so that's just one piece of the rolling most significant piece. Let's just drive by a few other related tornado cash cases. So there was a case ongoing in the Netherlands, which was one of the, I guess, co-founders of tornado cash, Roman Storms co-founder. It's a Roman Persev. And Alexei Persev, excuse me, there's another Roman involved here too, but Alexei Persev was the background on that case.
I believe he was actually convicted in the Netherlands. That's going to appeal, but the case did not work out favorably for crypto and defy in that situation. Do you know what the latest is there? Yeah, so there were three developers of tornado cash, three main developers, Roman Storm, Roman Seminoff, and Alexei Persev. And all three of them are being pursued for criminal charges somewhere in the world. Persev was arrested and charged in the Netherlands, and he already had his trial and unfortunately lost the trial and was convicted for essentially similar allegations. And I'm not a Dutch lawyer, so I won't even try to explain what Dutch law was.
But I do remember reading the reports and the court's opinion, which sort of sounded like the worst imaginal version of what we're talking about now. That Persev was liable for, and it wasn't even about North Korea so much as it was other hackers and cyber criminals was liable for helping them wander money just because he had been involved in designing this protocol. And the way the opinion read was sort of like privacy itself is a crime. And the only reason you would want privacy is in order to do something criminal. So the fact that he knew he was building a privacy preserving protocol means he was doing this with some criminal intent.
Now here's the good thing as I understand it about Dutch law. Persev has an appeal and unlike in the United States where an appeal challenges a ruling on a very specific narrow issue. In the Netherlands and appeal is an entirely new trial. And since the original trial, Persev has gotten a new counsel and the industry has also realized how serious this is. And there's a lot more support from those in the industry to try to help him get a better results on the appeal. So I'm not sure exactly what the date is, but that is coming up pretty soon. And we should be watching what happens in the Netherlands as well.
Another related one, Preston Van Loon versus I believe it's the US Treasury maybe, but correct me if I'm wrong here. Now this is from the other side of it. So we're not talking about tornado cash developers. I believe we're talking about someone a user like us and we happen to know Preston he's in crypto circles. He's a core dev. But I believe this is from a user's perspective for tornado cash, though you may be described the details and what the progress is with that case and how it relates here. Yeah, sure. So what we've been talking about so far is the government's attempt to attack privacy preserving protocols by charging individual software developers with some type of crime.
The case you're talking about Van Loon has to do with a totally separate way the government is coming after privacy, which is through sanctions. And you may remember the first time that we started hearing about government skepticism of tornado cash was not a prosecution of the developers it was a decision to sanction the protocol itself and to say that he was unlawful for any person in the United States to use the tornado cash protocol. So that is an infringement at least in my perspective of our rights to use that software and the challenge that that Preston Van Loon and also his co-plaintiffs and also David who is a plaintiff in a very similar case in Florida.
The argument basically is the government does not have the authority to sanction an inanimate piece of software, right? And not to get too deep into the weeds of IEPA and the sanctions laws, but essentially the type of sanctions that OFAC, the Office of Foreign Assets Control at the Treasury Department, which enforces the sanctions laws used in order to go after tornado cash, requires them to prove that what they are sanctioning is a person or the property of a person. And what the government said was, tornado cash is an entity that can be treated as a person. And the protocol is the property of that entity, tornado cash.
And the plaintiff's argument basically is there is no such thing as an entity called tornado cash. You can look at various people who are involved in the protocol, offers a front and interfaces, holders of torn governance tokens, etc. But they are not an entity that is offering a service that can be sanctioned. And the protocol itself is a set of immutable smart contracts. It is literally by definition not the property of anyone because nobody can control it. And therefore OFAC lacks authority in order to sanction tornado cash as a protocol. And here's let me give you a bright spot because this is actually a really positive thing.
There was unfortunately a bad decision in the district court in that case in Texas. I heard about this. Van Loon lost. And the court basically said, this is national security and the government kind of gets to do whatever it wants. And sure if they say tornado cash is an entity, then fine sanctioned. There's a lot of that going around. I got it. It's yes. It's not the rule of law. It's the rule of vibes basically. I'm not doing justice to be opinion. It was obviously a reason to opinion written by the judge. There was an appeal to the fifth circuit. And there was an oral argument in the appeal maybe a few weeks ago.
And the government got roasted by the panel of circuit judges. It sounded very much like the circuit judges did not believe the government's argument did not believe that tornado cash was a sanctionable entity did not believe that an immutable smart contract was property. And so we're all waiting with baited breath but hoping that we get a good ruling from the fifth circuit on this issue. What would it mean if the government could just sanction code sanction like GitHub repose, I suppose, or just like sanction like Ethereum addresses that are connected to smart contracts. I mean the effect of it with tornado cash is that it's illegal to interact.
If you have an Ethereum address in a wallet and you interact with that tornado cash, it's on the OFAC sanction list. So you are in violation. So don't do this at home kids. That's the current status. But beyond tornado cash, where does this precedent kind of leave us? I mean to me, it's a totalitarian nightmare. I mean basically what you're saying is whatever the government doesn't like, they come up with a reason why no one gets to use it. And again, you don't have to be on the left or the right of the political spectrum to imagine how this could play out. You could have a government that says providers of health care services for women are engaged in criminal activity using software.
So we are going to sanction health care databases that allow those types of clinics to track how they are providing health care services for women, right? Or you could have the government say we think that firearms dealers are engaged in criminal activity. So we are going to sanction the software that they are using on websites to display firearms that they have for sale or something like this. It really is when I say a totalitarian nightmare, it's at the end of the rule of law and the beginning of the rule of whatever the person in power happens to think at that time. Right. Okay. And it will like even if you just constrain this precedent to just smart contract code, right?
Anybody for whatever reason could suddenly add a DeFi smart contract to the OFAX sanction list. And that just makes it de facto illegal for the US to use it. So you're you're most beloved, you know, DeFi protocol say a uniswap is just picking on you swap because it's so large. I mean, suddenly one day that smart contract, one version of uniswap, maybe the non AML key KYC versions of uniswap that have been present, you know, like since its inception, that gets added to an OFAX sanction list at the whim of somebody in this dark mysterious, you know, like Washington DC apparatus, then it's just illegal.
Right. And what you would hope is there will be some guardrails around when they make those decisions. And indeed, they couldn't just pick a piece of software and say, this is illegal now. They would have to make sure that they are not making a decision that is arbitrary and capricious. Oh, right. It turned out we talked about a whole lot in crypto, right? And we talked about this a little bit in the context of tornado cash as well. You know, why is tornado cash quote unquote bad enough that it is, you know, on the table for sanctions? And this raises questions about how much illicit activity is enough illicit activity that the Treasury Department gets to sanction it?
Is it 50% is it 30% is it 10%? How do we know if those numbers are right? How much illicit financial activity is going through it decentralized exchange protocol or lending protocol? It's not zero because it's never zero. Look at the traditional financial system. It's certainly not zero. Well, that's the point. That's the point. If we were doing arbitrary and capricious, I mean, if you were to sanction the banking system, there's a massive amount of money laundering and sanctioned violations that goes on the traditional banking system. You don't see these types of actions. You don't because the government has enough authority over those banks and other financial institutions to feel comfortable that they can.
Number one, surveil transactions and number two, censor transactions. And for that matter, number three, exclude unfavorable people, right? Disreputable people or people who they believe shouldn't be allowed to get access to the financial system from accessing those financial institutions. They don't have those things. Well, at least they don't have two of the three. They have transparency on public blockchains. They can see what transactions are happening as long as there's no privacy, but they don't have censorship and they don't have the ability to exclude people from getting access. If you take away that first piece of it surveillance as well, that's when they say we are no longer comfortable with this technology.
We're going to use every tool that we have available to us to go after it, whether it is prosecuting individual software developers or sanctioning code or passing new rules like the Treasury Department has tried to do in order to expand their authority so that they can stop people from launching permissionless protocols in the future. I think everything that we've described, Jake, you and I have talked about this before. You've been on Beggars talked about this. This whole class of problems around control, not necessary, non-custodial versus custodial privacy, surveillance, all of these things.
This is sort of the final boss of crypto getting through its regulatory past. There are some mini bosses that we also have been fighting and speaking of arbitrary and capricious. Let's talk about Mr. Arbitrary and Capricious over there. We got to touch on the SEC really quick. A lot swirling there. Not as critical, I would say, is the other issue that we talked about. I just have full confidence that we're ultimately going to be able to defeat the arbitrary and capricious leadership at the SEC. Maybe that happens soon, hopefully, or maybe that takes some time to play out. We had Graywell, who is, I believe, a prosecutor at the SEC.
He is now leaving, given marching orders under mysterious circumstances. I don't know if you have reflections on that. We've the SEC trying to appeal its ripple case. Why are they trying? I know why they're trying to do that, but give it up already, guys. We have Coinbase versus SEC. What are some of the highlights that you would kind of mention on our boss fight with the SEC? Yeah, well, first I'll say I totally agree with your framing that the big boss, the ultimate boss in the end is this challenge to state authority over the financial system. Financial markets regulation is obviously very important as well, but I think we spend so much more time talking about the SEC and the CFTC and so little time talking about DOJ and Treasury.
I think it's great that we've had that conversation. What's the latest with our friends at the SEC? Gerber Graywell was the director of the enforcement division, so he's sort of the one who was in charge, much more so than Chair Gensler on a day-to-day basis of the SEC's campaign of harassment and regulation by enforcement. The chief attack dog, wasn't he? I mean, really, you know, in the end, it's the director of the enforcement division who's making these decisions about which cases to bring. So I think he gets credit, we'll say, euphemistically, for what the SEC has done the last few years, he announced, or at least the SEC announced just recently, that he will be stepping down.
They only gave nine days of notice before he stepped down, and there is no replacement in line for taking over. It's going to be, you know, an acting deputy who's going to be in charge now. That's a little bit weird. I have to say, not usual for that to happen. We could try to read some, you know, fun things into it and say that it's, you know, a sign that we're winning the battle. I would love to think that's true. I think the reality probably is, it's a political decision. I'm guessing that he wanted to leave his post before the election, you know, after the election, if he left, it may look like he was either being fired or being forced out.
He probably was hoping that there would be a replacement, and I'm imagining, again, speculating, it'd be very hard to find a lawyer who wants that job right now, doesn't seem like a really fun position to be in. So maybe they just couldn't find someone and he decided, you know, he waited long enough and he wanted to get out of there. But it is actually nice to see, frankly, the beginning of turnover in leadership at the SEC from the folks who have been persecuting the industry for so long, it's not to say we're going to see an immediate change in SEC policy, but it is just a nice reminder that chair Gensler and his crew are not here forever, and we will be here longer than them.
So we just have to outlast them. I think that's a really important thing to keep in mind. Do you have any takes on the timeline here? Do you think the election changes this if it goes one way or the other? You know, Trump said he would fire Gary Gensler. Like he explicitly said that, and as you have takes on that, just seems from a, if Trump wins, and it's a coin flip at this point at the time of recording, if Trump wins, Gary Gensler's time has got to be like numbered in days. I would think, or maybe this is all bluster. I'm not sure you're taking on that. And then if Kamala Harris wins, what's, you know, does Gary have a future in that administration?
Yeah. Well, I think it's very unpredictable. I'll give you my best speculation and what the conventional wisdom is. And the conventional wisdom is that a president Trump would essentially immediately solve the financial markets regulatory issues by putting Republicans in charge of the SEC and the CFTC who would take a much more reasonable view on crypto regulation. And you know, whether that's Hester Perse taking over his chair, although I think she maybe doesn't want that job as much as we would all love her to have it, or Commissioner Ueda or someone else. I do think that a Trump administration would very likely and very quickly solve a lot of the issues that we have over at the SEC.
Although, you know, I'm one to be skeptical of campaign promises, no matter where they're coming from. So I think the proof always remains in the pudding. A president Harris, I think, is really quite unpredictable. My view is that she has essentially decided affirmatively that she doesn't want to take a position on crypto, that it's not to her benefit. You can see her running a campaign that is very focused on the middle class and populist messaging. It is not her political advantage to start talking about financial markets regulation really wouldn't fit in with the platform that she's pursuing.
And I think what that means is she and her campaign have decided to just basically not engage on this issue. I think again, the conventional wisdom is and this does make sense that we should expect that a Harris administration would be more of the same from a Biden administration. But honestly, that's not necessarily true. And she hasn't made a couple of statements here and there. Most recently, on a at a speech at an economic club, I think in Philadelphia, where she talked about how she wanted to support blockchain technology and remain dominance in that area. That's sort of the minimum viable statement you could make to not say, I'm going to keep trying to destroy this industry.
So to go to work all that much. But I do think there's an opportunity either that she would pick someone to run the SEC who doesn't come from, let's call it the far left progressive Warren camp of the Democratic Party. And rather might come from a more moderate wing of the party that's not necessarily extraordinarily permissive, but does at least want to balance the interests of innovation and business in the United States with the interest of consumer protection and investor protection. So I think we could hold that hope for that. We also could imagine an SEC chair who is selected totally irrespective of what they think about crypto and we could just sort of get lucky and get somebody who has a different view on crypto.
I still think that crypto is idiosyncratic enough that folks aren't getting selected for leadership roles because of what they think about crypto. One thing that Dave and I have talked about is the ultimate tell for Kamala Harris will be because she's barely acknowledged crypto and when acknowledging it incredibly tepid in any statements. But the biggest tell that we're looking at, I don't know if you agree with this, is who she surrounds herself with in the administration. So who her administrative picks are, it's not just SEC of course, but it's also some of the architects behind this other thing that we don't have scope to talk about, but just like the operation choke point, the FDIC, all of these other agencies kind of choking off the crypto industry from the begging system.
If she picks those, you know, if the folks responsible for that in her leadership roles in her White House, that does not bode well at least from my perspective. You think that's about right? We should be watching who she surrounds herself with. Or do you think all of these people might get a change of heart under Kamala Harris administration? Can that happen? A change of heart. I love phrasing it that way. Look, there's a couple ways to look at this. The first is personnel is policy. And so if you're choosing personnel who have taken these types of positions before, that is an expression of what her policy is going to be.
And I think you're right. She's selected some folks who have been at the heart of some pretty damaging policy initiatives for the industry. On the other hand, personnel follows what their boss tells them to do. And I think we shouldn't underestimate the willingness of elected officials who are responsive to their constituencies to change their minds when their constituencies change their minds. And so I don't think the fact that she's picked folks who have been sort of on the other side of this issue before means they have to stay on the other side of the issue. It just means we have our work cut out for us.
Again, to build products that people want to use and then to explain why those products are so important to the United States, to our economy and to our national security, to those elected officials in DC so that we can very incrementally make progress. And that's what we've been doing in DC for years. And we're going to keep doing that no matter who's in charge of the government. There's so many other case in the SEC, of course, we could talk about because, you know, that director of enforcement was certainly busy. I think that's out of scope today. And actually, I think, I don't know if you agree with me, Jake, but sort of feels to me like the Gary Gensler SEC regulating crypto by enforcement reign.
He's kind of peaked. We are now pushing back. We are now going to win. We're winning the court system. It's just like we've seen peak flood from the SEC with respect to crypto. And I think we're going to continuously erode all of those things and actually win this over. So we don't need to spend too much more time talking about it. Maybe one other item I wanted to talk about before we wrap this up and close with some thoughts here. You wrote a fantastic geofencing paper, which is kind of interesting. And if we connect all of these cases of, you know, we've got the the tornado cash case and that boss fight.
We've got the SEC court case. We've got other things going on with the CFDC and saying, I mean, you are you are very busy, my friend, as a DeFi crypto lawyer. Let's let's just say that. Geofencing is how a lot of users experience it. And so I go to a website for a particular air drop, let's say, or to interact with a particular DeFi exchange or protocol. And I'm hit. If I have a VP, if I have, you know, an ISP resides in the US as a US resident. I'm hit with a star. You cannot access this page. You cannot do the thing you were trying to do list of band countries. And it'll be like, you know, Iran, North Korea, and the United States of America, right, which is just like not kind of the club that I see myself as a US citizen.
You're like belonging in. But this has been incredibly frustrating for users. And it all stems from this lack of regulatory clarity. I mean, if you're a project in the US and you have some sort of token, you have some sort of exchange because we have no idea what the laws are that we we can't open it up to everybody. So can you talk about Geofencing just as a practice? And I know at variant, you give some advice to even, you know, some of the US based projects or even outside of the US, what their practice should be with respect to Geofencing. Just in general, what have you learned on this topic?
For sure. And like you said, at variant, I spend a lot of my time working with founders of a really stage crypto startups to figure out what is their legal and regulatory strategy going to be with the help of their own council. And we get a lot of questions about Geofencing because like you said, it's really hard often to figure out how do we comply with whatever a US regulation says we have to do in order to launch a product or service? Or how do we change the product or service in a way so that those compliance obligations don't apply? And I would say in almost every case, the goal is not to abandon the US market.
Like you said, it's really frustrating has a US person, you know, myself included. There's some really cool new crypto thing. I want to check it out. And I get Geofencing. And what I noticed before deciding to write this paper, along with my deputy general council, Dan Barabander, is that folks in the industry were making really bad decisions about Geofencing. You know, a lot of people were geofencing products and services that it wasn't clear why they needed to be Geofencing. There was no reason why as a US user, I couldn't access that type of product or service. And then some people who had products or services that were clearly not complying with US law and cannot be complying with US law.
For example, some margin, leverage, or derivatives protocols that, you know, frankly, the CFTC has absolute authority over that type of product. And there's really just no way to register with them. There's really no hope other than to Geofencing. Those products are not going to go fast. Yeah. Look, it is really sad, but as a founder of a company, you have to make intelligence risk adjusted decisions. And so what we wanted to do is help people understand, number one, when should I be Geofencing? You know, make sure people aren't Geofencing products that they shouldn't be so they can take advantage of the US market if there's no reason why they shouldn't.
And then more importantly, if they should be Geofencing, how do they do it the right way? Because a lot of times you see a Geofencing. And then Geofencing is basically what is your IP address? And that is the only part of the Geofence. And if you go to the CFTC and you say, I was blocking IP addresses, isn't that good enough? They're going to say, no, that's not good enough. You know, welcome to an enforcement action. So it's really important to figure out how to Geofence properly if you're going to do it. And I would encourage anyone out there who's thinking about Geofencing to take a look at our paper and see some of the best practices and explanations that we give about how to try to do that effectively, obviously with the help of your own lawyer.
It's sad that we actually have to do that, you know, I'll say. And hopefully this is only temporary until we get some more regulation heading our way and legislation heading our way that these Geofences can be removed. But I mean, some of these Geofences, like to your point, they just seem so pointless and silly because any DeFi user who's based in the US, and I could say this because I'm not the lawyer on the show, I mean, like we all know how to use a VPN, okay? So I mean, like it's, you almost have to in this day and age. And the enforcement actions aren't coming to individual users, of course.
Like, could you imagine if the SEC or CFTC came to individual users and said, no, sorry, you were, you were to like Gary Gensler has not gone that far, though I wouldn't put it past them if you give them another few years. So a lot of people just use a DeFi with a VPN. And it's a pain that we have to do that. But I mean, I guess that's the current state of where we are in the lack of regulatory clarity. Well, I'm not going to comment on that any further than the paper, including the section that we wrote on VPN blocking and how to do that if you need to. Yeah. Um, let's just zoom out and close this up, uh, Jake.
So first of all, thank you again for for being with us. And I, you know, we'll, we'll see how this, um, Roman storm tornado cash case goes. That's on December 2nd for everyone paying attention at, at home. And bankless is going to be doing some coverage, of course, as that's ongoing. Just zooming out. How are we doing overall? Like how is, are we winning or are we losing? I'm not entirely sure how to assess this. Ask me any given day and I might feel one direction or another. But if you zoom out, look at 2024 and the progress that we've made and what, the all the work that's still to come, how would you assess that?
Are we winning or losing? Um, we're winning. I'm going to say that hit a full throw it away. I think we're winning. I think of this as a war with many different fronts. And if you think about the various issues we've talked about, you know, the financial markets regulatory issue on one front, you know, the SEC and the CFTC and others, the elicit finance and national security issue, another front, the banking and potential regulatory issues. Like you said, choke point, which we didn't have time to get into. Maybe some other day right another front. At any given time, we're making progress, pushing forward in one front, maybe losing grounds and another.
I think exactly as you said, we're doing an extraordinary job of fighting back against the SEC and the CFTC. I honestly feel pretty good about where we are with those issues. I think we've got pathways to do business in the United States, even though the SEC doesn't want us to, because we are right on the law and they are wrong and we have the courts to back us up. I think on these elicit finance issues, this is sort of the big boss. And I think that the industry is just now starting to understand and hopefully will better understand having listened to this conversation that we're losing ground there, that we are at a point where law enforcement and the intelligence community and the national security apparatus are perceiving the technology that we are building as a threat to their authority, even though that is not how we intend it, even though we want them to be able to do their jobs and go after the bad guys and win these types of geopolitical fights, they are not that happy with technology that they can't control.
And we need to think a lot harder about what legal arguments, what policy arguments, and also frankly what types of technical arguments, right, types of technical projects we can build to get more of an advantage on that front. So I think we're winning. I think we can do it. I think it will take all of us working together and as always Ryan, you know, thrilled to talk to you about this and hope that folks will come away with a better understanding of how important this issue is. You know, the only set of actors that crypto is bad for is totalitarians. And so from that perspective, hopefully the United States, you found it on principles of freedom, freedom comes to realize this and starts exporting this to the world.
I guess just lastly Jake, what gives you optimism just in general about this fight? The founders, honestly, you know, like I said, I spend a lot of my time working with mostly very young people who are very passionate and very optimistic and are building the coolest stuff I have ever seen in my life. And I really think when you when you think deeply about what this technology can empower, when you think about what the internet is, how young it is, right, when I grew up, it was the very beginning of the internet in the 90s, right? Look how far we've come in in so short a time. But if you imagine the internet 100 years from now, 200 years from now, I just cannot envision that internet existing only at the mercy of very large tech companies that have centralized control over everything.
We live in a digital world. As you guys always say, and I'll leave it to you to say the direction that we're all going, but the direction we're going is for us to own digital assets so that we can live real full and fulfilling digital lives. And I just don't think there's any way that that's going to stop. Well, let's talk about that direction as we close. And thank you, Jake, once again, for joining us, some action items. Donate to the Roman Storm case, the link in your show notes to do that. Also, Jake's geofencing paper that we talked about will include it there. But the direction we're headed in is west, as always, crypto is risky.
You could lose what you put in, but this is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot.