SOL is currently trading at an 83% discount to ETH - should it be?
Michael Nadeau is a crypto analyst who can help us answer this question. His approach isn’t technical, he isn’t a decentralization-maximalist, and he doesn’t represent any specific tribe. Instead, he focuses on current on-chain fundamentals like daily active users, fee revenue, and Total Value Locked to provide insights.
In our discussion, we explore why fundamentals matter when analyzing crypto assets like ETH and SOL. We review the data for 2024 to see who’s winning and examine the catalysts for both ETH and SOL. Additionally, Michael shares his price predictions for ETH and SOL this cycle and offers insights on which asset will outperform the other in the second half of the bear market.
------
✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨
------
🐡 PUFFER | CHECK OUT PUFFER UNIFI
https://bankless.cc/PufferUnifi
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙 KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE
https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🛞 MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK
🦄 UNISWAP | BROWSER EXTENSION
⚡️ FUEL | EARN FUEL POINTS
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM
🗣️ TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION
------
TIMESTAMPS
00:00:00 Start
00:02:59 Are Fundamentals Having a Moment?
00:08:59 Solana's 83% Discount
00:12:11 Fundamentals Data
00:17:09 Fees, SOL vs ETH
00:19:52 Fee Generation & MEV
00:22:36 DEX Volume
00:25:31 Stablecoin Volume
00:28:08 Total Value Locked
00:31:49 Core Devs
00:34:50 Value Accrual
00:41:45 The Bull Case For Ether
00:49:22 Upcoming Catalysts
00:57:09 Qualitative Differences
00:59:40 Price: SOL vs ETH
01:04:10 Price Targets
------
RESOURCES
Michael's Report: https://thedefireport.io/research/sol-discount-eth
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
If you get to $1.8 trillion, that's about slightly under $15,000 per coin. For ETH, if Salana gets into that $450 billion range, that gets you above $900. Bangladesh Nation, the price of the sole token is currently trading at an 83% discount to ETHR. The question is, should it be trading at a discount? We have Michael Nado on the podcast today. He is a crypto analyst who can help us answer this question. I think it's a very relevant one for investors. His lens really isn't technical. He's not a decentralization maxi. He doesn't represent tribe A or tribe B. He just looks at current on-chain fundamentals like daily active users and fee revenue and total valued locked of these respective networks to answer the question of what should these assets be worth?
A few things we discuss on today's episode. Number one, why fundamentals matter when we analyze crypto assets like ETHR and Sol? The data for 2024 and who's winning? Number three, the catalyst for ETHR and the catalyst for Sol? Number four, his price predictions for ETHR and Sol the cycle, which asset will outperform the other on a relative basis in the second half of this bull market? I won't spoil this now. You got to wait till the end. And before we get there, get an announcement from our friends over at the staking protocol Puffer. So you probably know Puffer as an Ethereum staking protocol.
Well, now they're doing something even more exciting. They're releasing a roll-up that helps solve Ethereum's layer two fragmentation problems. A problem we've been talking about a lot on bank lists. It's called a based roll-up and it's called Puffer Unify. We are really excited about based roll-up tech. You've probably heard Justin Drake on the podcast, talk about it. How does it work? Puffer Unify leverages layer one sequencing, integrates pre-confirmations from Puffer's restaked validators. So all of that results in benefits like synchronous composability and unified liquidity in Ethereum's layer one.
So this fixes fragmentation. It also features fast confirmations, pre-confirmations, I should say. And there's native yield on your ETH in the form of Unify ETH. So go check that out. Really think that this is the next generation of roll-ups on Ethereum. It tackles Ethereum's fragmentation. And it unifies unified liquidity. So if you want to find out more about Puffer Unify and I suggest you do, go take a look at their light paper. There's a link in the notes. And if you are a developer and you want to build on top of this exciting new frontier, then fill out the form in the show notes and you can get started.
All right, let's get to that episode with Michael right now. Bangladesh nation very excited to introduce you to Michael Nado. He's the founder of the DeFi report. And he writes some of my favorite analysis in crypto. I got to say that because his focus is old-fashioned fundamentals. You know, old school on crypto. So he likes to analyze tokens, crypto assets, like equity as capital assets with cash flows. He also models the demand for crypto assets as money. And he has less of an emphasis on some of the attention metrics, let's say the tension economy behind crypto and more focus on overall fundamentals.
Anyway, it's just a great blend to me of a crypto native knowledge and financial analysis. And I hope the crypto world starts viewing assets. Our crypto assets the way Michael does in his reports. So it's just a solid base to figure out what's real. So Michael, what do you think that gushing intro? I don't usually do that for my guests. But I got to say I'm a big fan of your reports here. That was a gushing intro. I'm blushing a little bit. No, it's great to be here Ryan. First time long time been a fan of the show for a while. So awesome to be here with you. Okay, well, let's open this up with a leading question.
So on the agenda, of course, we're going to be talking about sole versus eth, make it a little spicy for people out there. In particular, you wrote a report called should, should sole be trading at an 83% discount to eth, which is approximately what it is right now at the time of recording, what it is when you publish that report. We're going to table that, get to that conversation in just a second. I want to ask an overarching question to you before we begin, which is fundamentals. Are they making a comeback in crypto and recall the way I just defined fundamentals as, you know, a kind of like cash flows as an equity analyst might view these crypto assets.
We are seeing maker. This is a, this is performance of maker mkr, a token in the, in the, blue chip DeFi token. It's never really received kind of the credit, fundamental and analysts are due. It's, it's had a great year so far. And people are talking about maybe the rekindling of fundamentals analysis. Maybe it's fundamentals crypto, maybe fundamentals are cool again. What do you think is, are fundamentals having a moment? I love to hear this and it is interesting to see this, this narrative starting to pop up a little bit on Twitter. My view on fundamentals is that everything we do at the DeFi report starts with data.
So that, that's always the starting point. Even if it's, even if it's a meme coin, right? I think there's actually fundamentals of meme coins. You can even go in and see how many, what's the growth of token holders? You can, there's fundamentals related to social and what's happening on Twitter and things like that. So fundamentals is a broad, a broad term. And I just think that ultimately, this is all going to fundamentals. For me, the fundamentals are easier to, to sort of wrap your head around, I think, in a bear market. And in this, you know, discussion today, we're going to talk a little bit about Salana versus Ethereum and really what kind of brought me to Salana initially was studying it in the bear market.
I mean, I think that's where there's actually easier to see projects as Warren Buffett likes to say when the tide goes out, you can see who's kind of been swimming naked. And you can kind of see that wash out and you can see what might, might last in a bear market. But I love to see this at the DeFi report we work with some of the data companies in the space that are very focused on fundamentals. We believe ultimately this is where the industry is heading. So it's great to see this narrative out there. Makerdown is obviously one of the projects that has fantastic fundamentals in the space. So that's fantastic.
Yes, it's interesting. Someone ironic that we mentioned is, you know, fundamentals coming back in style as a narrative, which is interesting that does seem to be the way that that crypto markets fluctuate. But what is just the general thesis behind fundamentals? Is it as simple as, hey, like in the long term, that Buffett quote markets are kind of a weighing machine in the short term, he didn't say this, but maybe they're more of a narrative game. But in the long run, fundamentals actually matter. Is that, is it just that simple with respect to why you view crypto assets from a fundamentals perspective that they're important in the long run?
And they will reflect in price over the longest period of time? Yes, it is basically that. But I think that, you know, the market needs to have some sort of KPIs for a relative, you know, valuation. Like I think today, if you look at the crypto markets, like I don't think anybody's making any argument that like crypto assets are trading on cash flows and put ultimately, I believe that is, that is where we're going. Even though we're not trading on cash flows, we do have these like sort of benchmarks in the market. You've got Bitcoin, Ethereum as sort of the two like alpha assets. And then everything's sort of a relative valuation on those two assets.
And so there's always going to be, you know, fundamentals and KPIs that the market needs to understand. I think what we're trying to sort of work through now is like, what are those KPIs? You know, when you go back and study sort of how security analysis came came about, these are really social constructs, right? I think it's important for people to realize that, you know, the market sort of coalesces around a shared set of ideas because we can make sense of them and a discount cash flow. Sort of how do we do this with stocks and equities? Is discount cash flow going to be the thing we do use for relative analysis in crypto?
Maybe, maybe, maybe not. But I believe we are in this process of sort of sorting that out today. So it's funny that kind of the, the meta game here is not only do you have to believe in fundamentals, you have to, you have to get all of the other investors who are buying crypto assets to also believe in fundamentals, right? As you sort of define it. So it's almost like a coordination game, a consensus game. One reason I think to be more bullish on fundamentals, who knows? Maybe not this cycle. But in the months and years to come is tradifies growing involvement in crypto. This is how they're used to viewing traditional capital assets.
And they're going to, by default, bring that lens into crypto. I've actually been super impressed with some analysis I've seen from shops like Vanneck, which like they dive into crypto assets. And it's really, it's from a fundamentals perspective. I mean, you can disagree with the variables. You can adjust them. You can, you like say, those assumptions are wrong. That's all fair game. But the way they're actually coming up with their price predictions and analysis, it's all very much fundamentals based. 100% and there's, there's different fundamentals for different types of assets as well, right?
You don't use the same metrics for, if you're analyzing a basket of banks, as you would for commodities or some other asset class. Crypto is a new asset class. And so you do have, you know, database fundamentals. But then crypto is very social, right? It lives on the internet. It kind of lives on crypto Twitter. So there's all these other nuances that get folded into fundamental analysis and crypto that is unique to this asset class. So the reason I led with those questions is because I want bankless listeners to hear how you think about assets and your approach to investing in general. And I think you're, you're bringing this framing to the conversation we're about to have.
And that's why I think this conversation is so valuable. So you wrote an analysis report. I think you published this last week that kind of caught my eye. I read through this and I think it's a great subject to have an episode on and actually apply what we just heard about fundamentals to two assets that have really been taking a lot of mind share this cycle. So ether and salana and the title of this report is like as it's a good title. Well written made me click right away. Should soul be trading at an 83% discount to ether. So you're viewing this from a market cap perspective and the current market cap fully deluded.
I assume a soul salana is trading at an 83% discount to ETH. And should it be that's the question and you call this a data driven investigation. And the reason I wanted to have you on to talk about this rather than somebody else is because I think you can bring a objective like neutral hey like this is what the data says perspective to the analysis and it's like less tribal in fighting. There's less of this debate between decentralization and centralization. I'm not saying that those debates don't matter. I'm just saying your lens is a little less political I would say and it's a bit more objective with respect to the data.
So high level as we get into the key metrics and analysis. What are you actually analyzing here like what are the core data points that you look at when you look at L1 tokens like ether and salana. Yeah so and this this kind of like comparison between these two L1s in particular goes back to like the end of 2022 and after after the accident we really started taking a hard look at salana and I was comparing salana at that time to like ether back in like January of 2018 and I was seeing some similarities in the data there and really what what I was looking at was like total value locked salana versus versus Ethereum back then I was looking at the number of users looking at the number of transactions looking at the number of developers and sort of the application activity sort of anecdotally looking at where is venture capital money going where are VCs sort of focused and so you know that when I started to see those numbers and salana basically looked like Ethereum in January of 2018 this was in in December of 22 that sort of forced me to go deeper on salana at the time when everybody was sort of punching down on salana and sort of giving up on on the project so that's where it always just sort of starts with fundamentals for me and then there's obviously layers of nuance within crypto and analyzing crypto assets the social layer and the and the sort of nuance there that we layer in but those are the that's kind of the core I guess fundamental analysis here okay and I I want to you'll say something that you said at the beginning of this report which is you used fundamentals analysis in kind of like the depths of the bear market in December of 2022 and it allowed you allowed you to see this dislocation in price so at the time December 2022 like bear market FTX had just like imploded it was the end of the world particularly for salana and at that time salana's market cap was just 3% of ethers in the wake of the demise of FTX so like 97% off the price of ether and so you said you didn't think that was right and you shared a long salana kind of report and since that time salana has appreciated a capture now it's 17% of a theorem so one from 3% relative to ether the asset to 17% and it definitely has been the trait of this cycle right kind of the ether salana ratio has been a good way to do well so the question I think in this report is will that continue will salana continue to build its relative value versus eth so let's talk about the the data the fundamentals data the first is this daily active addresses and if listeners want to go log into like YouTube or Spotify and video you can see sort of the charts that Michael and I are looking at live but this is a chart of daily active addresses of a salana versus ethereum plus ethereum layer 2's so not just ethereum it is salana versus ethereum plus the layer 2's what are we looking at on this chart on the screen here yeah so this is looking like you mentioned I think when you do any type of relative comparisons now for ethereum you need to factor in probably like the top 10 l2's so we do have I think the top 12 included in this report so all the majors and what I'm pulling together here is just we're combining ethereum and we're going back to June of 21 and just looking at sort of the chart between ethereum's growth or salana I mean ethereum's chart looks fantastic right there's there's nothing nothing wrong there what I'm trying to understand is where does salana sit relative to to ethereum and the the combined l2's and and salana really made a lot of progress really over the last six months in this report we were looking at just q2 data for the quarter salana averaged 1.
3 million active users which is about half of what salana ethereum plus all of those l2's are doing today so so it's it's doing quite well a few things I noticed from this chart too and ether and the l2's are in purple and salana is in in pink and you say here now it's about 50% of Ethereum and the top layer 2's from a daily active addresses perspective one question I just want to get out of the way is do we know how much of this is like civil activity or like bot activity between the different networks and like how does that factor in at all to the analysis yeah so Artemis does a good job with this they do have civil detection now with with some of their data you know there's definitely a lot of civil activity and and bots my my view on this is you know those things pay fees so I don't I know there's this narrative that if it's a bot it's like not real but like it's over I think over 60% of trading and tradify is coming from algorithms it's like bots are taxpayers too exactly so they're users they are users and I don't really sort of parse them out I still think there's product market fit if there's something using the tool paying fees to do so so certainly plenty of bot activity on on salana but again they're paying fees so yeah and we should remember the definition of a user here is like an active address and of course a bot can have multiple addresses a person does have multiple addresses as well but that's what we're calling a user almost think of it as like a bank account an active bank account here what one other thing I mentioned I noticed from this chart though is if you compare this back to the last bull cycle in 2021 2022 salana was actually higher in terms of daily active addresses than a theorem not by a little by a lot now yeah like what what do you make of this so like we're looking right now if you just look at the last you know 18 months or or or two years or so it you kind of look in the chart and you're like wow salana is really on the tail of a theorem the layer two is really catching up but if you go back to 2022 and kind of like the the mania of the bull market salana was actually higher I don't know from the chart it looks like it was like just a good you know 2x maybe 3x higher than a theorem at the peak in terms of daily active addresses so from that relative benchmark it's actually not doing as well as it was previous cycle yeah no that that is interesting and I think that was happening really sort of at the peak of last cycle or actually almost sort of after like the actual crypto markets had had peaked and right before sort of terrelluna and everything that kind of came came thereafter to me there's a lot of signal there like you know I I sort of watched salana last cycle did not invest in it was sort of just this new shiny thing and trying to figure out if it was real or not and typically what you know I see and I tend to like to sort of wait I put this in the report as well like I like to kind of wait and observe and look at data and kind of just watch the markets and then wait for those dislocations but you could see that there was something here with salana and then you can see those users just come off like basically after FTX and there was basically a restructuring of the whole blockchain and they've since reemerged but there's usually some signal when there's hype there is some signal and then I usually sort of wait and look for the fundamentals in the pair market so let's talk about the next fundamental which is one that I am quite fond of we are quite fond of that bankless and that is fees because something we repeat often is what do blockchains do blockchains sell blocks and fees represent block space that has been purchased so we're looking at a chart of soul versus eth and layer two's again the fees on these networks and I think eth is represented in purple and salana in pink yet again throughout this report and the summary here of this chart is in Q2 salana did 151 million in fees that's 27% of Ethereum and the top layer two's can you explain this chart and actually I was kind of maybe not fully understanding this chart itself because it looks like you know you're saying that the summary that salana did 27% of Ethereum and the top layer two but it looks like on the chart the the pink the salana is higher than the purple my misreading this chart and like what is it saying there's two accesses there's two there so that's what's going on there it's just the chart if you if I only used one excesses then you're not going to be able to tell the difference because Ethereum is still much higher yeah so Ethereum is still much higher here this chart is a little bit misleading but it was the best way to show salana's growth in kind of the last six months okay and yeah so really what's what's happening here is you can see the the pink line is salana even when you showed that chart that showed the users really jumping up last cycle on this chart you can see the fees there there as well but certainly not as expressive as the users and but we can see the fees really spiking up I mean last cycle salana was doing something like 20 million transactions per day and stuff but it was the fees were so low there was really really like thousands of dollars on the day right it was really like I felt and like you know Ethereum is doing just orders of magnitude more here but we've seen that gap close so now you know if you just look at the queue for performance salana was about 27% and a lot of this is MEV now we're seeing on salana as well so you can just kind of see it interesting to me that fees are rising on salana the whole narrative has been that the fees are going to stay super cheap we'll see we may see in this in this bull market that salana you know we'll see when fire dance or gets gets introduced as well but there could be bottlenecks on salana that the same the same process that he went through and we're going to see if that starts to play out later later in this cycle fees is a fundamental that I like and I respect because it represents like the taxpayers on the network it's like real activity because they're willing to pay something for it so it's um I love it because it's relatively simple resistant I want to ask you about the compilation of the fees because there are two ways that blockchains can generate fee revenue right um the first is just selling the space within a block and the second that's one source of the revenue and the second is selling the ordering of the transaction in in the blockchain itself and so you referred to MEV earlier that's the second category it's kind of like you're paying for priority ordering in a given block and getting your transaction and so you're either paying to get your transaction in ahead of everybody else or you're paying for the ordering of that transaction what's the different compilation in terms of like fees my impression has been that um salana is doing like quite a large amount of its fee revenue on the MEV side of things that is the ordering side of the transaction how is that different than how Ethereum is generating fees today yeah I haven't looked at this super recently but it was over 50% and a lot of this is running through you know Gido validators currently which can share that MEV with with people that are validating um you know there's an interesting view here that like some people have this view that all fees should sort of collapse towards you as you know layer one blockchain sort of get commoditized you know as they should um and really sort of the the value of a cruel mechanism is going to come through MEV in the future it's really all about priority access to block space and this is basically how it works in in traditional finance today there's no fees to trade um and everything comes from ordering transactions and value that can be extracted during that process um so we'll see how how that starts to to like hand out um with Ethereum we're starting to see this with layer two's post EIP4844 transaction fees have dropped significantly um we put together this quarterly report on Ethereum that this is sort of the story of Ethereum from from last quarter is that EIP4844 significantly reduced fees at L2 and that that's now impacting L1 um we'll see if that starts to sort of that new supply of block space at ultimately gets backfield in the future here um but my view is that you know MEV is probably the main thing in the future for how these things are monetized so this is going to be interesting and this kind of gets into the different design strategies of Ethereum versus Salana whereas Ethereum has outsourced so I'll say some of its execution kind of the the ability to order its blocks to layer two's Salana has done none of that so it gets to retain all of this MEV so there's some interesting like questions to how long are you on MEV in general across these chains and and how will that shape up that that factors into the analysis but let's get to the third fundamental which is Dex volume so we're looking at Dex trading volumes on Salana versus ETH and the L2's yet again and Dex volume has been pretty impressive Salana did 108 billion in Dex trading in Q2 so that's 36% of Ethereum and the layer two's a much different story than last cycle where like just the volume was not there what do you make of this chart yeah I think this you know basically shows that DeFi was basically non-existent on Salana you know just even a couple years ago and and most of this activity is now happening on on Jupiter and if you look at if you just compare Jupiter where most of the trading is happening today or most of the user activities happening compare that to Uniswap the the users are Jupiter's doing about 90% of what Uniswap is doing in terms of active users so I think that's where most of this this volume is coming from and you know at an aggregate level Salana's still significantly below what we see from from Ethereum and the L2's combined here but this is this is interesting to me I use Jupiter now when I'm buying and selling assets you know on Salana rather than Coinbase I find the user experience to be to be really nice you can avoid sort of the the bridging and a lot of the sort of UX challenges that Ethereum still has so this is something I'm watching to see if there's a potential for retail to potentially on board to Salana you know or it's more of that happening in this cycle versus going you know directly to a Coinbase or centralized exchange so we'll see we'll see how that plays out do you have any takes on the kind of the compilation of these traders and the assets that they're trading so I think there is the impression that Salana's activity is maybe a bit more retail let's say a bit kind of you know like lower in terms of transaction size for trade but like more people and it's the asset compilation is like heavily meme coin right now it's other assets certainly but meme coins have had a massive boom on Salana and that's got to account for a good portion of this Dex activity do you have any takes on the compilation differences between the networks definitely more meme coin trading on Salana this is all you know purely speculative bull market type of assets that are being traded on Salana there's quite a bit of stable coin activity which which which we'll get to as well but yeah I think that's you know to me the the sort of signal here is that there's a lot of velocity you know Salana has always had much lower sort of TVL than what you see on a on Ethereum but the velocity has always been higher smaller amounts can be transacted I think this comes back to the Salana user experience fees are low a little bit easier to use so people can play around and just trade memes at very small volumes things like that so I think I think that's kind of what we're seeing play out in this in this data okay since you brought it up let's talk stable coin volumes this has been super impressive in Salana there's just basically nothing in stable coin activity you can't even see in the charts last cycle this cycle it's quite a different story so you say here the summary is in for Q2 Salana did 4.
7 trillion in stable coin volume so it looks like it outpaced Ethereum stable coin volume and again this is back to kind of the velocity type of take right so we'll get into TVL later and that the like the amount of stable coins on Salana but from a velocity perspective these are big numbers huge numbers huge numbers this is like pretty under reported I was pretty shocked to see this number and this is coming from Artemis Artemis has fantastic stable coin data but yeah I mean it it's really all happening over the last six months or so we saw it really kind of peek out in Q2 we'll see where that number goes I mean 4.
7 trillion in a quarter is absurd this this is not you know these are not like peer-to-peer payments and e-commerce and things like that this is mostly happening on taxes on Salana so keep keep that in mind but that is just a really big number right there 4.7 trillion and we'll see we'll see how that plays out but to your point it's really the velocity the ability to you know I think a Salana user is transacting many more times a day than your typical Ethereum user today this is 2x by the way that 4.7 trillion is 2x that of Ethereum and the later two is over the similar time period you put a footnote here saying you're not concerned about the fact that a large percentage of this trading activity or sorry the stable coin activity is related to meme coins and bots and algorithms you say why it's estimated that more than 60% of trad five volumes algorithmic I guess that's the point you were talking about earlier in the episode bots are people too bots are taxpayers and so like why discount them when you're doing this type of analysis that's how I view it and you know I know like you know Salana has been focused on like creating like the NASDAQ you know on a blockchain and to me you got to you got to try that out you got to have some sort of like minor leagues before the big leagues and we're seeing you with meme coins in speculation today but to me the signal is that is happening and it's happening at high very high volumes so so bots are people too and memes are assets too is kind of like the this Salana narrative here let's talk about this chart which paints a different picture than I think all of the other charts so far which have been like very bullish Salana this this paints a bit more nuance into the story here this is a chart of total value locked and this is again Salana versus a theorem plus the the layer twos and you can see this kind of chart over time it's interesting by the way that in purple a theorem the layer twos it's not up to all time highs of previous cycle so we got a way to go but the the the pink shading the area under under the purple here in pink which is Salana TVL is just like not exploding the way the other metrics are exploding in fact it's it's about approximate in terms of like you know you can kind of see this i eyeball this relative to what it was doing last time as a percentage of of TVL on a theorem the layer twos so Salana average 4.
3 billion of TVL total locked value and slayer twos or you know assets under management I suppose me that's a more tradify explanation which is 7% of the a theorem of a theorem in the top layer twos so 7% so TVL is showing a different story here what do you make of this I think this shows a lot of this is telling me like eat the fact that you have way more eat locked and defy on a theorem just tells me that the Ethereum ecosystem is much more mature and much more further along and if the asset is a more capital efficient asset I would say that then sold currently part of the reason for this I think Ethereum started as a proof of work blockchain and so and it's Salana started as proof of stake and if you look at those sort of stake rates between these two networks it's like 80% on Salana and it's like 27% and that's come up from basically nothing over the last few years on Ethereum and so you have like this lot of soul basically from the original validators that is just locked up and it's not really making its way into to defy just yet I know Salana has made a lot of attempts to get with like with staking solutions in different ways try to incentivize people to pull that pull that value and get it get it into defy that's that's really where this has to go for Salana to really get that number up I think but I think the big takeaway is that just you know that it's a different interesting east starting as proof of work and also just being a much more mature ecosystem today yeah it's also interesting maybe a quick side quest here is like when I when I always hear the the tribal infighting it oftentimes if if your team Salana you'll take the perspective that a TVL doesn't matter it's a made up metric right if your team Ethereum take the perspective daily actives are all fake like meme coin volume decks like trading all of those fundamentals don't don't matter when you look at kind of a holistic picture and you're not just taking one fundamental into account you're taking multiple fundamentals into account does that tell a better story here like where is there one fundamental that's more important than another like do you take them all into account equally like of the metrics so far which are the most important ones towards valuing this asset uh yeah it's definitely I think putting all the ingredients together to sort of paint that picture and then there's office we we certainly look at other stuff outside of just the on-chain data as well and that's more like the intangibles of kind of what you see with community and what you see on Twitter and things like that um I mean I think the biggest signal is always like what are people paying for so that's like probably number one always um looking at users as well knowing that that's a proxy like there's certainly people with multiple wallets and things like that and bots um I think fees is always number one and then you kind of layer in the other the other ingredients there after it's like if you're making cooking a meal um you probably if you're not a vegetarian you probably want some meat in there first that's probably your fees and then you layer and a few other uh spices and ingredients as well um so that's kind of how I how I think the analysis if you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams then head over to crackin one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world crackin is on a journey to build a more accessible inclusive and fair financial system making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto crackin's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks and there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way along with a whole range of educational guides articles and videos with products and features like crackin pro and crackin NFT marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience so check out the simple secure and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro go to crackin.
com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be not investment advice crypto trading involves risk of loss the uniswap extension is here the self custody wallet created by the most trusted team in defy uniswap labs designed to make swapping feel effortless this extension lives in your browser's sidebar letting you swap sign transactions and send or receive crypto without ever losing your place on the internet plus with human readable transaction messages you'll always know exactly what you're signing navigate a multi chain world effortlessly with support for 11 chains like a theory main net base arbitrage and optimism no more chain switching or token importing all your assets are right where you need them to be the uniswap extension is designed to level up your swapping experience with other uniswap labs products as well easily on board to the extension using the uniswap mobile wallet to begin managing your assets across platforms and take advantage of smooth seamless synergies with the uniswap web app so go and download the uniswap extension today by clicking the link in the show notes just another way uniswap is helping you swap smarter introducing fuel the purpose bill operating system for ethereum rollups fuel is revolutionizing the ethereum ecosystem with features like paralyzed and state minimize execution cross chain interoperability and native account abstraction plus supports walls of all networks ensuring you can use fuel no matter where you store your crypto but that's not all you can join the fuel point program today to earn points unlock rewards and qualify for future incentives as fuel marginous towards main net fuel points are off chain points earned by completing on chain actions that positively contribute to the growth of the network and holding fuel points can automatically qualify you for a future network reward so don't miss out on the fuel opportunity click the link in the description below to get started fuel points are here go get it okay and here's one off chain analysis let's say that you included in the report is core developers core devs on soul versus eth and this is eth plus the l2s again it looks like okay so salana averaged 59 active core devs i guess you're looking at get hub repose not sort of thing and seeing commits and that would be in q q2 again this is a full q2 analysis so that would be 11% of ethereum and the top layer 2s it looks like it has definitely grown since like the early days of salana 2018 it's not quite at the the highs it was previous cycles or anything you you divine from this metric yeah i mean i will just just say that this is coming from token terminal you're right it's looking at get hub repose and this is core devs only so this is only people that work directly on salana versus directly on on ethereum so it's not factoring in the ecosystem devs the all the apps and protocols within the ecosystem if you looked at that data and i probably should include it in here it's about 30 almost at 30 salana's at about a third of what you see on on ethereum total but yeah from a core dev perspective i think you kind of i think in general you're you if the ecosystem is really developing the core devs should don't need to grow that much right you need a lot of activity at the beginning to get things stabilized but ultimately you should see that the development coming from apps and protocols around that that kind of core community and i think we're seeing that with salana and we're certainly seeing that with ethereum you can see the ethereum chart just continues to go up into the right so we're seeing it in both in both areas to me what i'm looking at with developers is like a red flags right like if i'm seeing you know other metrics that look good or there's a lot of speculation going but then you look at devs and there's like a few devs on the project that's that's more of a red flag to me and that's kind of what i'm using this this metric for but no red flags on either side i would say okay so let's just summarize the the fundamentals the the data driven analysis we've just done so on q2 q2 performance salana now has 50% of ethereum users you like as measured by daily active addresses 27% of ethereum fees 36% of ethereum decks volumes 190% of ethereum stablecoin volumes 7% of ethereum tvl and 11% of ethereum core developers and of course the context for this report and the market conditions right now is salana trades at about an 83% discount to ethereum at this point in time so that's some of the qualitative analysis that that goes into this i don't think we're quite ready to get to the conclusion and your take on the conclusion but that's that's maybe the the fact so far in the summary so let's talk about the next section right so we've got all of these on chain fundamentals that we've just gone over let's talk about value accrual and there are some differences in terms of how the networks are now architected with respect to value accrual so there's you know like something i think investors need to to really get through their heads is to think about this space you can create a whole bunch of value there's value creation it doesn't necessarily mean you're able to capture that value in an asset so an example i always like to give is like in the early days a peer-to-peer predical like a a bit torrent or something like this or a Napster in the early days created a whole bunch of let's call it value right like it was awesome i could like listen to mp3s and college and like all of these things that's highly valuable but was not able to capture that value in an asset as as part of a a business model so when you look at like fundamentals behind assets it's not enough to see value creation happening you also need to see the asset actually accruing that value so with that stead what are the similarities and differences between sole the asset and its ability to capture value versus ether so i think the big difference here and yeah thanks thanks to that intro that's that's fantastic and i see this all the time by the way i think bankless creates a ton of value for like the entire like crypto ecosystem so that just want to throw that out there a lot of these L1s benefit from media and crypto you know i think the biggest difference here between these two ecosystems is you know ethereum is building itself out as this like modular tech stack and so you know when a user comes into an l2 they're transacting they're paying a fee to that to the l2 sequencer you know today that is just going to these these l2s and their sequencers and then there's a settlement fee also that gets paid down down to ethereum so if you're an eth valedator and you're holding the eth token that's sort of you get that you know percentage of the pie today it's getting there's a piece that's going to the l2 with salana because they are building it out so far in a monolithic tech stack you the the valedator itself is capturing 100% of that there's no l2 that's sort of a middleman in there that's capturing some of these economics and so i think that's the primary difference here you know i don't know i'm not i'm not convinced that salana won't need l2s you know at some at some point here i've you know had conversations with founders in salana that have told me that there's a chance that they're going to need an l2 because they've already run into some bottlenecks so we'll see how that plays out but so far today it's cleaner on salana in terms of the value of cruel to that to that token in general the two assets themselves i would say are building out very strong network effects i think eth has the strongest network effect of any asset in crypto and i think sole is probably number two today so let's talk about this in a bit more detail because i think this is like the crux of some of the conversation i think part of the reason ethereum has had so far a lackluster performance in the bull market relative to salana is this architectural decision that it's made that it thinks will be long-term beneficial but in the short run it's basically and like you might not put it this way but this is the way i've been putting it it's outsourced its execution layer to other chains layer two's a salana has not done that it is taking is not sharing with others right the sole token is the recipient of settlement and execution and all of the fee capture of block ordering and block sales like related to that go to the sole token whereas ethereum has said nope we're trying to scale and maintain its version of decentralization and so with that design constraint we're going to be a recipient of the of the settlement fees but execution that's going to happen in arbtrum it's going to happen in optimism that's going to happen in a zk roll up and we're going to give up that revenue model now the belief for the the ethereum folks is that that will pay dividends later in the future so it's a more credibly neutral settlement layer it's not competitive now with other player ones in the in the same way it used to be it's kind of like the the base layer for settlement it gets to export ether as monetary assets inside of all of these layer two economies that are springing up and it gets to maintain it's like decentralization its version of decentralization but that seems to me is like a bet for sure and also a long-term play but that's what's happening right now and is a key difference between these assets you have any reflections on that yeah no I think that's exactly what's happening it's it's making the market a little bit confused and I think this is something ethereum is going through you know right now and if you look at the data from q2 it's an interesting time to be looking at ethereum data because we're seeing the impacts of eip484 and that plays into this story because ultimately what that did is like open up this like massive amount of supply of block space and my view here is that and if you look at any past you know technology movements when you open up a glut of supply it gets fail it gets backfield and that what what's causing it to be backfield is new entrepreneurs new developers coming in and building new things and I sort of view that as like we're in kind of like this this is the broad ban moment for for kind of ethereum in the interim it looks a little funny because ethereum's fees are down L2 fees are down and so it's starting to look much more competitive as well and investors have to decide am I am I putting my money in an L2 am I putting it in eth you know you're potentially diluting value capture for for eth and we're in this sort of confusion right now ultimately I do think this plays out and because of the network effects with ethiasa it's potentially going to capture value accrual happening throughout the tech stack with restaking potentially capturing value from these L2s as well and other protocols so I do see that story playing out and I'm actually bullish on that on that story but in the interim I think it's it's a little bit confusing for investors that is a fantastic story in the long term we'll have to see how it plays out like a part of your reflection is it's not playing out that way right now in the on-chain fundamentals right and so like what it looks like is oh my god ethereum just like cannibalized itself and it's now just taking all that juicy fee revenue and because it decided not to scale or scale via execution layer 2s it's just like outsourcing ads giving that away and like why would it cannibalize itself that's what it looks like right now snapshot of time in you know at the end of q2 2024 and it almost looks like a bad decision from a fundamentals perspective but let's talk about some maybe the bull case for ether in this section in terms of value accrual versus the soul token a few things I want to check with you so I think that the ethpool would say there's the long running assumption that the execution layer is kind of the commodity here actually and that's going to have not much of a moat and that there will be other incredible execution layers that spring up and go fight salana essentially for execution so theorems over here with settlement it's that you know like the only player that's really doing that well and then execution wars will be a severe will be harsh like have you seen the the telegram you know daily active addresses it's absolutely insane and it's getting like to salana type levels and so all of the rollups on a theorem will go fight that battle with with salana and you know you've got you know rollups like base with the power of coin base behind it fighting for execution against salana so that will be a commodity game what do you think about that you like that counter to value accrual for for soul the asset I think that I think that's fair I definitely think that's fair and I one of the things that I think is very bullish for a theorem also here you mentioned base like coin base there's a relationship there and coin base is very focused on the Ethereum ecosystem 100 over a hundred million you know accounts signed up on on coin base so I think that's pretty interesting I've been looking at potentially what Robinhood may start to enter and it looks like they are going to be focused on on Ethereum they've got a deal now with Arbitrum to potentially allow the Robinhood wallet users to interact via Arbitrum I think that's going to bring users into DeFi so you know there's definitely a story here a bullish story intact for ETH and you know we'll see we'll see how it shakes out salana needs these types of stories I believe salana is trying to be Nasdaq on the blockchain you know a lot of the rear world asset narrative what block black rock is doing also happening in the Ethereum ecosystem so you know there's there's plenty of competition to play out here Michael did you get a chance to watch that Anatolia versus Justin Drake debate that that we had a few weeks back I've seen yes I have I don't think I've watched it full just yet but yes it was a great episode and yeah I did I did tune into sections of it one of the themes from that which was incredibly interesting is in something that we can't like we don't have evidence to verify like part of my my challenge to both Justin and Tully was like make a prediction and let's check back in three to five years and see who is right and that will sell it right that's where we said but like Justin's perspective as the Ethereum bull was that salana is making some short-term decisions that are centralizing it with respect to you know like MEV will centralize its monolithic design will centralize like block production so this is a bad bad foundation to host layer twos to be a credibly neutral monetary asset to preserve censorship resistance to preserve the properties that actually make crypto corruption resistant and those properties like the market discounts and undervalues in the short run but in the long run they matter a lot and isn't that the point of crypto to maintain corruption resistance and be censorship resistant and immutable and no rollbacks and all of these things what what do you think of of of that argument because I think that the salana camp would say hey like you're just trying you're co-opting this word decentralization you're giving it a theorem-specific meaning salana does have decentralization and here's how but what do you make of this yeah there's no question that I think Ethereum is more decentralized it's cheaper to spin up a node on on Ethereum it's more expensive the hardware requirements are are more on salana so I think there's no question here that Ethereum is more decentralized I I think Suslana at the same time is sufficiently decentralized with the number of validator clients that they have the sort of geographic dispersion of those clients I am not as technical as Anatolia and Justin Drake debating these these concepts certainly and I think they're very healthy debates I'm always happy to see these types of debates in the market it's not something that I am looking for a sufficient decentralization myself and it's also in line with just like my ethos and like why why I'm in crypto but from an investor perspective it's not something that I'm really factoring in just yeah but I I think that's fair that you know you do need to be thinking long term here and and you know there could be potential issues that I'm unable to see currently but let me run an idea by you and see if you kind of like coast on this but like I guess my theory is that all of that all of the trade-offs and all of the decisions that that are being made by each respective network will in the fullness of time play out in the fundamentals so you will see it reflected in on-chain revenue so for example if you know users leave Solana because they're getting like sandwich attacked on the transaction because MEV is centralizing or the validators you like take control and kind of like distort the economic so they're receiving some like proceeds and kind of like diluting everyone else or just like corruption happens the various things happen yeah over the long run that will result in less activity on Solana less fee generation you know like it basically attends to play out in the long run if on the other hand none of this manifests and Solana proves itself sufficiently decentralized for the use cases that users want and there is lots of activity on it well that will play out in the fundamentals as well so like might take here as like a little bit of a fundamental I'm a decentralization like lover but I also live in the real world of investing and I do like fundamentals matter a lot so I'm kind of a fundamentals maxi my take is that like the debates are kind of temporal and a little bit silly like it'll all play out in the fundamentals in the very long term what what say you to that I think that's fair and there's something to be said here to like the users are users going to care we care the people that are in crypto early certainly care but do the normies and the people that are actually actually going to be using these things in the long run do they actually care you know we can get into like the privacy conversation as well and all this data is public today so there's a story there but yeah I mean to me like you know when I hear Anatoli and Justin debating or debating a lot of these topics I'm just looking for like is there some is there some red flag that I'm unaware of because I'm not even all these technicals yeah but I think you're you're right that like this is going to play out the market is always correct it is quite kind of how I think of this and it is going to play out in time one thing that's sort of interesting to me with Salana that I haven't fully reconciled is the fact that jump crypto which is like a market maker you know in crypto one of the largest ones is the developer of the fire dancer you know validator and like you know Anatoli talks about you know bringing lowering latency on blockchains and allowing it so that nobody can sort of front-run you we're seeing all this MEV on Salana you have a market maker developing the the next iteration of the validator client you know that that's kind of concerning so I think to your point like there's some stuff that needs to be worked out here as well yeah I raised my eyebrows on that although the salonables tell me it's it's going to be open source where it is open source and so everyone can kind of audit it and check I still haven't kind of gotten to the truth there but you know the fundamentals hopefully will be the reflection of of you know like what actually plays out in the best decisions so speaking of fire dancer a client let's get to some upcoming catalysts for both networks so Salana you do mention the fire dancer client as an upcoming I guess short to medium-term catalyst so there's something that's going to play out in the next like six to 12 months so what do you see as the core catalyst me let's start with the fire dancer the core catalyst for Salana yeah so so this is we just mentioned you know this is being developed by jump crypto open source so you know anybody can kind of jump in here and also participate in the development you know the big thing here to me is just the redundancy of the blockchain and having this like single point of failure because you know Salana has one validator client so I think that's the most important thing here and then this you know sort of gives Salana like over time that sort of lindy effect once if fire dancer goes in and it never has another you know point where it sort of needs to be shut down the blockchain then you know the market starts to forget about these early days when Salana had these issues you know Ethereum had issues earlier as well maybe not shutting down the blockchain but it had other issues that because it's continued to sort of run and validate transactions over a really long period of time the market just forgets about it so there's a chance that that's going to start to play out on fire dancer what does that mean or the you know for this like real world asset narrative is black rock going to start to sort of pay more attention to Salana because they can see that it's more secure it's been around for longer you know that's sort of the signal potentially that comes out this plays out over a multi-year period I think but that's kind of what I'm looking at with with the fire dancer client there how about blinks let's talk about blinks what what are those and why are they a bullish catalyst for Salana yeah so blockchain links this is like very similar to what we saw like on Forecaster with with Forecaster frames it's basically bringing like a web 3 wallet experience right to the browser within social media so blinks are something that you can do on Twitter currently we may see this start to pop up more on other social networks but it basically allows you to like do stablecoin payments and things like this like right in right in your browser you know I could see this starting to sort of really pick up later in the cycle potentially if we get into one of these like hype mania's again where people are sharing all kinds of these links they're probably gonna look kind of scammy and toy like and potentially pumping meme coins and things like this where you could send it you know you could have influencer sharing links right on Twitter and it goes right to Jupiter and you can make a trade and buy the meme coin right from your Twitter your Twitter feed so we may start to see stuff like that later later in the cycle that's what I'm looking for with blinks but in the long run um potentially changing like you know the consumer consumer behaviors e-commerce potentially impacting things like that there's some other catalyst we don't have time to get into but deep in uh it's carved out a special place on on Salana also there's some stuff going on in social let's flip to the other corner though with upcoming catalysts for a theorem the first is something that my god I hope this is the last week we will go uh without an ethereum ETF but the ethereum ETF uh that is a major catalyst let's talk about that for for a second so that is a catalyst on the ethereum side of things if Salana gets an ETF it's kind of like a hail marry pass like you know who knows when it'll happen but ethereum is just like about to get an ETF we saw what it did for bitcoin and he takes there okay this is huge um and this definitely factors in to sort of how I'm thinking about how this cycle is going to play out um you know I expect the ETF to potentially surprise people uh I know a lot of the sort of experts over at Bloomberg and you know I've been watching sort of what they're projecting out there I think somewhere in the 10 the 20 percent range of what the flows that that bitcoin got um you know I'm sort of thinking it might surprise people a little bit and I just think the narrative for eth which is still largely misunderstood I think but just this idea that it's sort of this open source app store there's a cash flow um you know the the the ETF is not going to allow staking initially so there's going to be no yield there but I just think that like the addressable market for ethereum is to me and this has always been my thesis is much larger than bitcoin um and we may start to see this start to become realized once the smart money or the the big money on Wall Street starts to really kind of understand uh ethereum we have this flagship quarterly report we put out ethereum investment frameworks so I'm hoping that gets a little more traction um now that the ETF is here but you know I just think that ethereum has a very compelling story for Wall Street and it could surprise people once this thing starts to start trading well let's add to that story of real world assets you listed as a catalyst you've got black rocks bittle fun tokenized treasuries uh the bulk of that activities is happening on ethereum this is kind of like the the serious assets are on ethereum type of take but uh tell me about that as a catalyst for for ether yeah so I just think you know I always try to like make sure I'm understanding all the incentives that are at play you know you've got ethereum you've got black rock you know you know with this ETF coming I believe they're going to want to sort of legitimize ethereum for putting you know financial products on the asset and so they've already you know they already tokenized uh money market fund on ethereum I'm expecting to see more of this I'm expecting to see Larry think once the ETF is trading going on CNBC more talking about you know all the benefits of putting these assets on on jane this is you know this is like the real use case for crypto is putting all these assets on a blockchain creating efficiencies you know making these markets more liquid and I think black rock totally gets it you know we can talk about it on crypto twitter and amongst ourselves all we want it's a totally different story when Larry thinks on CNBC talking about this stuff so I just think there's a chance that ethereum starts to get that flywheel going where you get the burned eth the narrative is driving price which is driving more burned eth and potentially we see like a pretty in a period where eth just outperforms everything I'm looking for that potentially later on in this cycle we haven't as well had retail come aboard yet but once they do they'll probably be coming aboard via an exchange and then uh being routed by someone like coinbase to go on chain and to use the base platform so you list coinbase and base as a layer two it's a fast growing L2 of course salon has an execution layer has had many years uh of doing this including an entire uh bull cycle we have not yet seen base in a retail bull cycle and you think that that could be a major catalyst for ether as well I think it's yeah I think it's another catalyst um we've seen similar not similar levels of memecoin trading and stuff on base but there's certainly plenty happening there there's a lot of volume the fastest growing app on basis uniswap which is kind of interesting competitor to coinbase in some ways um so yeah I think base is another another big catalyst and also just coinbase facilitating the migration of their users on chain lastly let's talk about qualitative differences and then we'll get to kind of like what all this means and we'll answer the question at the beginning of the episode uh you list a few qualitative differences and this is kind of like uh you like opinion base of course but user experience right now it's better on salana I think people would say hey it's also going on layer two's but then you like the counter would be yeah but it's all fractured across all the layer two's and Ethereum has had a major kind of like which layer two do I use like uh from a devx perspective and a fragmentation perspective and also the difference here is salana is kind of centralized it's a VC funded it's almost like a silicon valley type of team you you go to like you look at the salana events and it looks a bit more like a you know like an apple type uh you know that that that has that flavor in that feeling versus Ethereum it's just kind of like I was like Linux it's a little like open source a little app hazard and uh you know like lastly maybe I'll add something uh some of the feedback I was hearing from ETHCC is that um the Ethereum community feels also fractured on the social layer so not only do you have fractured user experience but you have some of the layer twos that are kind of fighting and it's like what's the cohesive Ethereum community this cycle right there's some question uh as far as that goes whereas salana has a simple message like sole apps sole token go up we're really excited about meme coins but they can unify around kind of like the shared state uh in a bit of a different way anyway what do you want to reflect on in those qualitative differences I mean I think you said it pretty well I mean I think um from my perspective as a user and crypto like I do find myself using salana a little bit more just because of this just the wallet experience and the the not having a bridge that that is my view is that's going to get solved on a Ethereum with with account abstraction and it's just a matter of time and it may end up coming through um stuff like Robinhood and stuff that start integrating with with Ethereum so we may see them we need somebody who's a really good interface developer come in and sort of sort of fix some of those those challenges I do think it does get solved but right now it's better on salana and yeah there's just some you know fascinating differences I think Ethereum has sort of the Bitcoin sort of ethos very decentralized if you're BlackRock if you're Larry Fink and you're trying to figure something out on Ethereum like are you calling uh who you calling um I think there's like a direct line somewhere at salana where you can speak to someone and they're and they're going to help you and there's a little bit more organization I think just with developing uh the developer community and things like that so um we'll see we'll see how that shakes out so let's the moment we've been waiting for let's answer the questions see where this leaves you at the end of the report so the question was should should soul be trading at 83% discount to soul and recall some of the stats we mentioned earlier in the episode so back in November uh 22 salana was trading at 3% of the Ethereum's market cap the market has said that that's not that was not not correct to now it's at 17% of the market cap but that's still 83% of the like off uh in in terms of uh the market cap so what's your answer to that question should it be trading at this discount relative to a Ethereum at this point in time and what do you see on the horizon for the next like six to 12 to 18 months so um the conclusion is that that number's still too low so I think that is actually going to get sort of re-rated higher my my view is that it could go up to like 25% or so in this cycle so we're at 17% now of a Ethereum and you think that it could go up to 25% correct and this is you know this is just pure speculation not financial advice or anything and and and and and I I'll share that in my personal portfolio I haven't sold any eth for soul I did I did add to so add to salana but I never never sold never you know convert I think a lot of people have done that in this cycle where they've sort of taken their eth and gone gone into soul but no I think the way I see this playing out is with this ETF I think eth is going to have a period of sort of outperformance here and I'm looking for salana to sort of outperform later in the cycle when potentially we get this like you know all coin rotation so I think this is going to be interesting Ethereum has typically been sort of the outperformer in the latter stages of these cycles now that you have a new you know market participant as in Wall Street buying those ETFs could could change just a little bit but yeah the take here is that Ethereum has a great run my sort of base case for where this is all going and I use the $10 trillion market cap for for all of crypto and that would sort of follow a similar growth pattern that we saw from the 17 top to the 21 top muting in a little bit for you know just a larger market cap but if we get to that 10 trillion mark you know I usually sort of pencil and Bitcoin gets to 40 percent of it or so Ethereum in the last few cycles has gotten somewhere between 40 and 50 percent of Bitcoin's market cap so you potentially get to like a therium at around 1.
8 trillion market cap and then if salana is 25 percent you're getting somewhere in that you know between 400 and 500 billion market cap so it's getting sort of to where Ethereum got in the last cycle it's kind of where I see this this shaking out but you know that's not saying salana is going to flip Ethereum right Ethereum is growing Bitcoin is growing they're all growing I just think that salana is going to slightly outperform in this cycle and there's a chance that you know if you look at the performance of some of these alternative layer ones in last cycle you know cardano and some of these things did did better than Ethereum so there's a chance even if you go farther down the list there could be our performance on on sole as well so yeah and if you know I guess if crypto history repeats there definitely will be some outliers that just like pump and do absurd things but likely without the fundamentals to back them up like it doesn't always happen that way okay so you are slightly overweight sole relative to Ethereum but you you don't go as far you don't come like close to thinking that salana is going to flip in Ethereum this cycle then it's it's kind of like 25 percent maybe a little higher is kind of the top layer in terms of percentage of market cap that's exactly right I don't see it flipping I think in the fullness of time Ethereum flips Bitcoin and we'll see there's going to be the battle here between salana and and Ethereum my view is that we ultimately get like four to five of these like major L1s and like there's three that I think are investible and that's where all my research is focused currently we'll see how that sort of shakes out between the smart contract platforms but I'm not calling salana to flip Ethereum in this in the cycle so you are overweight ether relative to Bitcoin and overweight overweight sole relative to ether it's very interesting this has been great Michael thank you so much for for guiding us through this just curious maybe at the end if you could translate some of those market caps you know like into price I don't know if you could do that math on the on the spot or you maybe have some of this memorized so you mentioned a 1.
8 trillion dollar eth you just like do the math what was the price of ether this cycle look like and and similar for the sole token if we hit those numbers yeah so and a little more context so about 77% of the market cap today is in like the L1s so you can that's another factor here but yeah if you get to 1.8 trillion that's about look slightly under 15,000 per coin for for eth like the peak and again this is forecasting a 10 trillion market cap if salana gets into that 450 billion range that gets you above $900 per sole you know I sort of have this scenario analysis sheet that I work off of you could say okay maybe the market cap only gets to 8 trillion and then do it from there you could say well maybe eth actually outperforms Bitcoin and it gets even higher than the 1.
8 maybe sold as low so you can kind of you know toggle it as you will but I think these are sort of the base case if we see this you know a strong second half of this this bull cycle so that last if I just want to press you on that for a second so your base case is around 10 trillion which is like a full bull cycle like you know it's kind of a repeat of the last bull cycles you know for your cycles I've been historic there's also kind of like the the bad news case like the bad scenario here like what if this time it's different Michael what if this time you know the the bull gods kind of skip crypto because they're very very excited about AI right now you know they pivoted over to Nvidia stock and like AI and crypto doesn't get the cycle it's had previously what's the probability or chances of that in your mind or you just like betting on kind of like similar cycle you know we'll get to the kind of Raul Paul's banana zone and like we'll figure this all out yeah I mean I will say that crypto is like has this incredible ability to like express human behavior and I always sort of root myself in this and like there's people that have this view and they always overthink like oh retail got hurt last cycle they're not going to come back and like to me it just fails to understand human behavior and like once the number starts going up like I've already seen this anecdotally with you know my family members reaching out to me and asking me what assets to buy when I told them you know 12 to 18 months to go to be interested so I just think it's going to play out again this is even more interesting this cycle because you have like Wall Street I think they're going to have the same promo that that retail has had as well I'm not worried about AI you know stealing the narrative or anything like that I just think this is human behavior don't bet against humans just doing human things and so I do think we're going to have another cycle I think it's going to play out similarly to the past you know they've always sort of peaked in Q4 so we've got a ways to go potentially in this one and you know there is like the other side of this that like well markets are rational then like people should be front running this and that like it can't possibly play out that way but it continues to do it I think Rao Paul does a good job with like his like banana zone analysis and like liquidity cycles and how all this plays in but I just think it's all setting up with the election cycle with with global liquidity the Fed may start cutting rates here into Q4 so I just think it's all setting up and don't overthink it just don't overthink it yeah don't overthink it because you're not so much betting on crypto maybe for the cycle view of things you're betting on human psychology which like fundamentally just doesn't change I will tell you anecdotally Michael a few weeks ago I got my first text from a family member saying hey I was talking to this guy about XRP at a party what do you think of that so yeah this the trickle has started let's end it here Michael one last thing can you shout out where people can access the DeFi report you also have a podcast so you do some of this analysis and podcast forums where can folks find out more about the resources that that you have in the content you're putting out we share all our research through the DeFi report.
io so people can go there and access the podcast also all the written research and I'm on Twitter at just do it and also on LinkedIn as well so yeah thanks for having me on Ryan this has been fantastic amazing got to end with this of course bankless nation you know none of this has been financial advice we don't do that on bankless uh entertainment only and you know crypto is risky you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot Arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications Arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions Arbitrum has the leading DeFi ecosystem strong infrastructure options flourishing NFTs and is quickly becoming the web free gaming hub explore the ecosystem at portal.
arbitrum.io are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitrum orbit chain Arbitrum orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain giving you access to interoperable customizable permissions with dedicated throughput whether you're a developer an enterprise or a user Arbitrum orbit lets you take your project to new heights all of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum experience web 3 development the way it was always meant to be secure fast cheap and friction free visit Arbitrum.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities launching a token don't let complex legal and tax issues slow you down toku provide specialized support to optimize your launch and ensure that you as a founder and your team and your investors get the most tax efficient outcomes the toku team understands the crypto space inside and out and will ensure your token launch is fully compliant while maximizing tax efficiency toku can connect you with the best attorneys if you need them to make sure that you have the best advice and toku can help to optimize your taxes so you pay the least possible amount of taxes while still maintaining legal compliance with toku's guidance you can concentrate on building your company while toku handles the logistics token launches don't have to be complicated talk to toku today to get a free initial token valuation new projects are coming online to the mantle layer 2 every single week why is this happening maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer 2 design architecture since it first started building mantle DA powered by technology from eigen DA maybe it's because users are coming onto the mantle layer 2 to capture some of the highest yields available in defi and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the $3 billion mantle treasury in the mantle reward station maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with giving you grants liquidity support and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application maybe it's all of these reasons all put together so if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's defi apps click the link in the show notes to getting started with mantle