In today's episode, David delves into the interesting dynamics between Ethereum and Celestia. While Ethereum and Solana are often seen as the main rivals, Celestia shares similar design philosophies and goals but with notable differences. Is it Ethereum's true competitor? Joining us to help answer that question and much more is Nick White, COO of Celestia Labs.
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🔐 SAFE | ATTEND SAFE{CON} https://bankless.cc/SafeCon
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 5:28 Celestia 2 Years Ago 6:30 Build Whatever & DA 11:29 Celestia Design Architecture 19:15 Ethereum vs. Celestia 22:26 Celestia No Virtual Machine Trade-Offs 29:57 Sharing DA Layers & Blockchain Interoperability 37:23 Celestia Trustlessness 42:09 DA as a Commodity? 54:09 Network Effects of DA 57:35 $TIA’s Role in Celestia Ecosystem 1:01:50 Lightnodes 1:04:57 $TIA’s Moneyness 1:10:20 Execution & Settlement Layers 1:16:46 Cosmos & Celestia & Ethereum 1:21:56 Sovereign Endgame 1:26:42 Closing & Disclaimers ------ RESOURCES
Nick’s 1st Bankless Episode https://youtu.be/bmSU3cZhe3U
Nick White https://twitter.com/nickwh8te
Celestia https://twitter.com/CelestiaOrg
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Point to build whatever is there's no optimal point. It's all like a trade-off curve, right? And Celestia is optimizing for a certain thing. Ethereum optimizes for a different thing. And again, also to tie it back. And that's why they're not commodities because they're just gonna be very different. It's like Ethereum block space is gonna be different than Celestia block space because they make different choices. They're optimized for different things. I think that Celestia just has a different philosophy and that results in a different design. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance.
And today we explore the frontier of Celestia and the roll-up landscape that it wants to bring into the crypto universe. Bankless Nation, there is a paper thin wall between the design of Ethereum and the design of Celestia. These two networks are both designing for very similar outcomes. It's often discussed that Ethereum and Celestia are the biggest competitors out there. But I actually think the reason why these two networks are positioned as big competitors is because the design philosophies of Ethereum and Celestia are just completely opposed to each other. I suggest to you, Bankless listener, that it's actually Celestia that is the real competition to Ethereum because it's made the same choices, optimizing for the same outcome, but with just some few key differences that we're going to unpack here on the show today.
Perhaps this is also why there is a much more friendly relationship between these two ecosystems, between Celestia and Ethereum, because despite being more meaningful competitors, our values are the same. So personally speaking, if Celestia won the game of thrones in crypto, I would actually still consider that a positive outcome for the preservation of crypto values in the Bankless thesis to which I hold dear. And to which other networks I could not say the same for. Today on the show is Nick White, the COO of Celestia Labs, and has been with Celestia from the earliest of days. We had Nick on the show about two years ago, but since then both Celestia and my understanding of it has grown quite a bit.
And also this meme of Tia as modular money has also emerged. And whenever some token presents itself as money in the crypto space, I immediately want to go kick its tires and see where that idea holds up or where breaks down. So let's go ahead and get right into the episode with Nick White from Celestia Labs. But first, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible, especially Kraken, are preferred crypto exchange in 2024. If you do not, have an account with Kraken. Consider clicking the links in the show and also getting started with Kraken today. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world.
Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone, everywhere to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos. With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience.
So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Kraken.com slash banklists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Have you heard about Safe? They're not just pioneers in crypto custody, they're also leading the transition to the world of smart accounts. With Safe, managing your crypto has never been smarter or safer. They've recently passed $100 billion in total value secured and are now deployed everywhere with over 15 supported networks. But that's not all.
Safe is revolutionizing the game with their full compatibility with ERC4337, making embedding wallets super easy to integrate into your daily crypto activities. So, what are you waiting for? Head over to Safe.Global to join over 8 million others in securing your crypto. And while you're there, don't forget to check out SafeCon, happening during the Berlin Blockchain Week, where the future of smart accounts is unfolding in real life. Secure your spot today and be a part of the transition to smart accounts. Click the link in the show notes to learn more and take your first steps towards smarter crypto management.
Celo is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon negative blockchain built for the real world. Driving real world use cases like mobile payments and mobile defy and with Opera MiniPay as one of the fastest growing Web3 wallets, Celo is seeing a meteoric rise with over 300 million transactions and 1.5 million monthly active addresses. And now, Celo is looking to come home to Ethereum as a layer 2. Optimism, Polygon, Matterlabs, and Arbitrum have all thrown their hats in their ring for the Celo layer 2 to build upon their stacks. Why the competition? The Celo layer 2 will bring huge advantages, like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability, secured by Ethereum validators, and one block finality.
What does that all mean for you? With Celo layer 2, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC20 tokens, sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect. But Celo is a community-governed protocol. This means that Celo needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Celo forums. Follow Celo on Twitter and visit celo.org to shape the future of Ethereum. Banclization, I'm here with Nick White, COO at Celestia Labs. Nick, welcome back to the podcast. Thank you, David. I think it's been almost exactly two years since I first came on Banclists.
So I'm thrilled to be back. Yeah, and two years ago, let me tell you, I had much less of an understanding of what Celestia is. I think even we were using lazy ledger as the name for this whole system. And the concept of DA was just very foreign to me. So I'm hoping to do kind of just like a reprise of that same podcast. But your host this time has a lot more knowledge to ask the right questions and take this conversation into the right direction. Celestia has like the project has grown immensely and has really like redefined an entire meta. So A, just like congrats on the success of my man. Like what's it been like over the last like two years of Celestia?
Like give us a peek behind the scenes. Well, it's been a grind. There's been a lot of work happening behind the scenes. People like to call things overnight success or whatever. But really the reality is it started way back in 2019. And it maybe even earlier in 2018 when Mustafa and folks like John Adler or some of the co-founders of Celestia were researching roll ups and L2s, back when no one was talking about them, forming the foundation of data availability sampling and all the technology that now is live and in production and forms a basis of modularity. So it's been a huge amount of effort and work to get where we are.
And I think to us, it was kind of inevitable because these things just make so much sense when you get to the bottom of it. It's like this is the right way to build blockchains. One thing I appreciate about Celestia is that there is a notion of like a logical conclusion of the design construction. Like from first principles, like you can arrive at the conclusion of Celestia. And so maybe we can kind of start there. Like Celestia's motto is build whatever. And I think going into the design construction of Celestia people listening to the podcast will be able to understand like why and how that motto emerges.
But maybe you can just kind of walk us through like the first principles in nature of Celestia, why Celestia, it's a data availability layer. Maybe you can kind of like walk us through just the base foundations of like the theory, the thesis behind Celestia. And why might one be interested in building a blockchain that starts using starts with DA first and foremost to build like at the to be at the bottom of the stack. What does it mean to build whatever and how did you start here at DA? So first, what is Celestia? Well, you can think of Celestia as the first modular blockchain network. And the goal of Celestia is to make it easy for anyone to securely launch their own blockchain.
So you can kind of think of Celestia as an L1 that's been designed from the ground up to do one thing, which is to provide secure and scalable data availability for rollups. And so now to go like I said further, like well, what does it mean to be a modular blockchain? And this is kind of what ties into the build whatever concept. Monolithic blockchains, which is pretty much every blockchain up until the first rollups and Celestia came along, were blockchains where all the functions were combined and coupled into one protocol. And so the nodes in that protocol had to do all the functions of running a decentralized application at one time.
And when you do things that way, you fundamentally have a bunch of constraints that when you take a modular approach where you decouple those functions and break them into separate protocols that are optimized for that and that can be remixed, you get all this, you remove those constraints and you have all this freedom as a developer, as a builder, to build new things that weren't possible before. So build whatever is touching on this aspect of modular blockchains that really removes all the constraints and just blows the doors open and what's possible. So that's really what build whatever is about.
So first of all, you know, what are some of the constraints that get removed? First, scalability in a modular system becomes like is significantly better because you have a really high-performance data availability network at the bottom which provides this very cheap, scalable, secure block space and that's enabled by data availability sampling. Then you have rollups which scale the execution part. So all of a sudden you can have a blockchain that can have really high throughput while still being secure and trust minimized and all the things that we want. And that wasn't really possible before those two innovations.
That's the first thing, scalability. You don't have to worry about the throughput and congestion and all those kind of things and get dedicated block space basically because you're running your own chain. The second thing is that you get to mix and match the different components so that you can actually choose the kinds of features that you want your chain, your application to have. So you can choose different data availability layers with different properties, different trade-offs, you can choose different execution layers like you don't have to be just in the EVM or the slotted VM. You can choose any kind of VM or build your own custom execution environment.
You can choose various kinds of fast confirmations like sequencing schemes that have different trade-offs or different kinds of mempools that have MEV tooling or privacy enabled features. And so all these different pieces can be, you can control the economics of your chain as well, which is really important because you can all of a sudden, instead of giving all the value back to the L1 that you built your application on, you can actually capture some of the value that you're creating as the application builder for yourself and for your community and your network. And so it's all those kind of things that as a builder open the door wide open to what you can build.
So build whatever is like, whatever you can imagine, you can build. And we want to explore and encourage the exploration of this design space because ultimately, how we get from where we are to where blockchains and Web3 are used on a daily basis worldwide is by app builders experimenting and showing us what's possible. Because ultimately, a lot of people also say, like, oh, well, modular blockchains are just a bunch of infrastructure without real users or real applications. And so it's like, you guys are just really just, I don't know, it's kind of like a, I don't know, you guys aren't actually thinking about the end product or like the real users, right?
But really, modular blockchains are about that. And it's about experimenting and unlocking new capabilities that I think are going to be the key to figuring out how blockchains become useful, you know, for the rest of the world. But baked into, there are some of the opinions in the Celestia model. There are opinions in every single layer one. And so I kind of want to like define what the opinions are of the Celestia design architecture. First and foremost, like modularity, of course. But like, first and foremost, I think like the Celestia model is opinions that there will be many, many, many, many blockchains.
And in fact, it's trying to encourage the growth of that. And what do all blockchains do is that they need to provide like assurances and verification about their state externally so that the world can verify the state of all of these blockchains. And so like, you know, every single blockchain like with that we've had from the beginning of time has some sort of just like node set internally like like coin has nodes. Bitcoin has nodes, Ethereum has nodes, you know, pick your blockchain. It's got some nodes doing some verification. And that verification is some sort of data and all these nodes are verifying the data of the state of some particular chain.
And so Celestia's opinion is that like, hey, like we will be the place where that data is posted. We call this data availability. That's what Celestia is providing to the world. And there's some sort of like opinion that like data availability is like at the bottom of the stack because in order to have verification of all of these blockchains, we need to verify the proofs, the state proofs of all of these different chains. And so like, I think one of the opinions of Celestia is that it's a multi-chain world. There's going to be infinity different chains. And actually like, not only was there, we can actually encourage that.
And we can actually support more and more chains by actually doing one of the, one of the jobs that all chains have, which is the verification of the state. And like whether you're in Ethereum layer two, and you are posting your fraud proofs or your blobs to blob space, it's kind of doing the same role. Or to the Celestia data availability is like there is proofs, there's statements about the state of all of these chains. And you can post them on Celestia in order to like get the security of people able to verify the state of all these things. And so this is something that's like, this is just fundamentally true about crypto.
This is not something that Celestia invented. This is something that Celestia discovered and is now optimizing for. And so when I hear like kind of the build anything model or the excuse me, the build whatever motto is, to me, it's like Celestia is providing this like space for blockchains to do something that they all must do, which is allow for the verification of their state, except the difference is Celestia is just being this one central place to kind of like all of these proofs to be posted, which helps more and more blockchains kind of like manifest. That's kind of like my attempt at explaining this.
How would you riff on that? That was great. I mean, there's so many things I want to say following that. One is, so Celestia is the most minimal blockchain that you can build. Because when you go down to first principles, all that you need to build these trust minimize applications is some form of ordering, which is consensus, you need to figure out like what are the order of the inputs to this state machine, right? Because every application on a blockchain is a state machine. It's a computer. And you're trying to make sure that everyone can verify and arrive at the same state. So if you want to be able to all arrive at the same state, you need to agree on what's the order of the inputs to this state machine?
And you need to know, first of all, what are those inputs in the first place? And that's data availability. That's data publishing is maybe a better way to put it. You need to know everyone that's participating needs to be able to see what's actually happening, right? But then the actual state machine and the execution of the verification of those transactions doesn't have to live on the layer one on that chain. It can be run sort of client side or on a different layer, a layer two, like a rollup. And so that's really the insight. So when you think of things that way, one way to sort of tie this back to build whatever is when you're layer one, your base layer is that minimal, you're kind of, you know, you're basically providing the maximum expressivity for the other people building on top of it.
Because you made the most minimal amount. Right. And so we're taking some opinion out of the layer one to allow for all of that choice of what that opinion is to be made by all of the layer two's on top of sales. Exactly. Yeah. And like also to talk about monolithic blockchains, right? Like Salana or whatever. It's sort of a one size fits all models. Like let us make the choice for you. We know it's best. All of the opinions. Yeah. Exactly. We're the experts. We have the best execution. We have the best. This and that. And just like build on us. And we'll take care of it for you. Now that I think there's there's validity in that.
But I think that the vast majority of the opportunity is in this space of giving expressivity to developers and app builders because they're smart. They know what they want. Right. There's no one size fits all. Everyone has a different style. Everyone has a different size that fits them. It's anyway. And then another thing about when you make the block salesman or maybe one analogy that could help people is that. It's sort of like. Like a refined sort of commodity. We can also touch on this like refined oil or something that's like now been processed into something new. Like a value added product versus something that's raw and unrefined.
Like a pure just a pure like just got it out of the ground resource. And so block space that has an execution layer embedded in it to me. Like if whether it's on a theory and base layer of salana and a monolithic chain. Is a refined sort of value added like already transformed good. You can't take it back into the raw form that easily. I guess you can like in the theory we can just like post blobs. But that. Layers not actually built for that where Celeste is optimized just for. Massive scale of the raw block space, unrefined block space. And then you can go and like take however much you want.
Basically purchase it from the protocol and refine it to do the thing that you want. It can be jet fuel. You know, maybe you're running it like a SVML too and you want to go really fast. So you refine the block space. The crude oil into jet fuel or maybe you're just like, hey, I just want to you know, everyday EVM chain. Turn it into gasoline to put it into your car. I don't know. It's that kind of mentality. Yeah, I totally under I see that pattern. And I know you read the an article that's going to come out this week on bank list. What I call like Celestia in this. There's an an axis here on size of blocks and sophistication of blocks.
A sophistication being like basically is there a virtual machine in the blockchain? Or is there not? In a theorem in Celeste actually occupy opposing corners here where the Ethereum layer one is a small block chain. We have like small constrained data with a virtual machine. Whereas Celeste is the opposite where it is unconstrained as in the layer one can support like massive size, massive capacity, blobs. But it doesn't have a virtual machine because that's one of the opinions that it allows. It pushes up to the higher layers to the layer, too. Interestingly, even though we occupy like kind of opposing corners here, we've taken like the opposite trade offs.
There's still a lot of like shared values and shared like philosophy here like easy to verify clients. Like even though Celeste is like kind of a big a big block chain. Since all the blocks are like simple because they're all unsophisticated. There's no virtual machine. There's no computation here. It's so trivially easy to verify, which is also one of the goals of Ethereum. Maybe even Celeste is like even more easy to verify than Ethereum because Ethereum you have to actually redo computation to verify it. But like also at the same time, both are interested in like producing this layer to design space.
Maybe it corrects me if I'm wrong, but I think like kind of the main difference between Ethereum and Celeste, especially now that Ethereum has 4, 4, 4, it has its own blobs space, whereas Celeste is like only blobs space. So the only difference between Ethereum left and Celeste is that Ethereum retains its virtual machine at the layer one. Whereas Celeste just like has no virtual machine. It's like just post your blobs. So any other differences that we should parse out or is that kind of just like the main one? I think that I really love that diagram by the way of like, and I like that way of thinking about a sophisticated, unsophisticated and big blocks and small blocks.
And I think that basically Celeste really believes in yeah big unsophisticated blocks. Or I like to say big lazy blocks that are because when you, as you add sophistication, what happens is it becomes more difficult to verify. If you have state and execution, then the transactions that come through like all of a sudden to run a node and verify the chain, you have to have a bigger machine that holds that state that actually processes those transactions. Whereas the point of Celeste is that because of data availability sampling, and the fact that it has no execution, you can run a light node. You can run on your phone.
It requires almost no bandwidth and no compute and very little storage. And yet you can basically have the assurances verification of a full node. And when you start to add execution and state, the more state you have and the more execution you add, the worse and worse that becomes basically like you lose that ability. And it becomes heavier and heavier to run a node that has like fully verified the chain. So in Ethereum's case, obviously it started out as a monolithic blockchain. And it's been extremely successful. There's been so much application. There's so much state. And that's the value of Ethereum, right?
There's so much valuable state and applications and logic on Ethereum. And now Ethereum, and so it's actually pretty, I mean, it's way cheaper than running a salon of full node, but it's actually relatively expensive to run an Ethereum full node and fully verify the chain. Now adding the sort of sidecar of data availability through blob space and eventually like full dang charting kind of like gives you this sort of like dual system of like you have a sort of monolithic state full execution environment with this like more modular, very like specific big, big unsophisticated blocks thing. So it's kind of this amalgam, which I think has some trade-offs that are actually good and are different than Celestia.
It's just like, so I think there's similarities. Like you can think of like Celestia is very similar to like when dang charting is fully live. But Celestia will never have this like full state full at one because we just, we want to be as minimal as possible because we think that, you know, we want to preserve, like if, as soon as you have that stable at one, every roll-up that launches on top of you has to pay attention to that and run a full node of that whole execution. And we don't want to, we want to be as light as possible for the roll-ups ability on top of us. Right. And Celestia as a platform for sovereignty is something that definitely comes to mind here, which is exactly what you're talking about, right?
So because Celestia pushes its virtual machine to the higher level, there's no, there's no virtual machine on Celestia. And so all roll-ups must, must make their own opinion about like what kind of virtual machine do they want? Can you talk about that trade off in like what properties that give Celestia based roll-ups that Ethereum based roll-ups don't have? Whereas like Ethereum, Ethereum based roll-ups are also free to choose their virtual machine, but there's something different about the fact that the settlement layer for Ethereum roll-ups all uses the EVM. Can you talk about the difference in this model?
This is such a great question and a great segue because, so I really think this is one of the philosophical differences potentially between the Ethereum, Ethereum's approach to modularity and Celestia's. Now first of all, as a disclaimer, Celestia also believes in settled roll-ups, but we also very bullish on sovereign roll-ups. And the thing is when you take the Ethereum approach where you have this- Is a settled roll-up and Ethereum roll-up? Is that a smart contract roll-ups? A roll-up that settles to another chain and has to, it's a fork-choice roll and the canonical chain is determined by a bridge contract on another chain.
It's also a very controversial topic as well. If you will remember a year ago, there was months of discussion and debate on this. Anyway, so Celestia roll-ups don't settle to Celestia because Celestia isn't a settlement layer. And so they settle to themselves. They are their own layer one. Whereas what you're saying is settled roll-ups are a hub of final settlement, which is the Ethereum layer one or any other smart contract chain. Yes, well, but you can still run a settled roll-up on Celestia. There's no reason- It's just that Celestia does not want to be a settlement layer. And there's no way it could settle to Celestia.
It could settle elsewhere. That's not Celestia. Yeah, including another roll-up on Celestia. Right. Yes. Exactly. We can unpack all that. It gets a little confusing. Yeah, that was right. I also want to say that Celestia doesn't have any means of settlement right now. But we are adding, going to add a way, and one of the downsides of this is that there's no way to bridge Tia as a token in a trust-minimized way up to roll-ups without some form of settlement. But we have a plan to solve that. We can talk about that later. Anyway, we just put three pins and three different conversations, which I'll want to come back to.
But keep going. Anyway, okay. So when you are Ethereum, right? Ethereum lands of like roll-ups. Starting back in 2020, when they were first getting proposed, was this idea of, we want to extend the throughput and the functionality and the users and the assets, and all these things of the L1 itself. Ethereum has this rich ecosystem of users and applications and liquidity and stuff like that. We need to scale that. So the mental model of the original fight, just to really extend that. Both Arbitrum and Optimism were fighting over which one is more Ethereum equivalent, because they are trying to literally blur the lines between the layer one and the layer two by being exactly the same as Ethereum and having this very natural continuation.
This was the genesis of the Ethereum roll-up landscape here, just to add on to what you're saying. Exactly. And so when you start with that mental model of what roll-ups should be, there's sort of subordinate, like, you know, add-ons to the scale of the layer one, you kind of, you have just different assumptions about how they should work and what they should look like. And you see that everywhere in the Ethereum L2 ecosystem, my opinion, most of them are just running the EVM. Most of them, also pretty much all of them settle down to Ethereum. I mean, that's a whole point of building an Ethereum is that there's users and assets and all that stuff.
But they make those assumptions in their design that they basically need to be, they need to have this bridge contract, and a lot of them have it baked in, that's like the bridge contract is sort of like the source of truth for their roll-up. And so that's what you can think of as like this, like a non-sovereign roll-up, like a settled or smart contract roll-up. Now, Celestia comes at it from a very different angle, which is more sort of from the cosmos, sovereign chains interpretation of what rolls are. In our minds, there's actually no reason why roll-ups need to settle to another chain at all.
They are actually their own blockchains in their own right. They just happen to run, it's like a virtual block chain where they run on someone else, some other chain's block space. So they borrow, they pay to use a block space of another chain, and that's it. But there's no reason that they need to actually post like a proof to another chain to be able to determine the canonical chain for themselves. And so, now there's, but there's reasons that they might. Like obviously, and this is also, there's a whole spectrum of like, if you start bridging to other chains, do you lose sovereignty? I happen to have my own opinion there, which we don't need to get into.
But that's sort of like the big difference. And where Celestia is right now, is actually helping a lot of Ethereum L2 chains, still like scale by using Celestia DA, while still settling to Ethereum, right? And then we do that via this data availability bridge called Blobstream. We're rolling that out also, we deployed it on base and arbitrum. But like, you can still tap into an external data availability layer while still being able to settle to another chain. There's a security tradeoffs there, which is that that bridge contract now makes an honest majority assumption on the external DA layer.
And so it's not as good. If you are ultimately carrying about, you know, Ethereum is my settlement like root of trust for like the liquidity and everything, then, you know, Ethereum DA is sort of a gold standard, because that is more secure from that lens, from the lens of the bridge. But as, you know, our belief is that like, we're still so early in the development of blockchain, that eventually like, it's going to become like, there's like, roll ups and like, the successful roll ups are going to become so big that they're no longer really necessarily, they have to be tied to anything. They can stand on their own legs, and basically like all the liquidity and users and things can be native.
And so I think that's sort of like, we're thinking like, that's the end game of where this stack goes. And so we want to build for that. And also just I guess philosophically, we believe that these applications, these communities that are building and using these roll ups should have control if they want to of their own chain. Because like when you settle to Ethereum, ultimately if something happens, and there's a hack or something like that, in order to change anything, you have to like change the bridge, because the bridge is a source of truth, but you can't fork your bridge unless you fork Ethereum.
And so you end up kind of like, stuck essentially, you're embedded within the Ethereum social consensus and social contract, rather than being on your own thing. That was a long rant, and there's a lot to talk about, but I was out there. I think maybe just one pattern I'd like to elevate. The idea when I got into crypto in 2017, then honestly, there's always been this idea of like, it's a multi-layer one universe. It's a multi-blockchain universe. There's going to be so many blockchains, blockchains everywhere. And then as a result downstream of that meme, a lot of like interoperability chains surfaced, like chains that are trying to connect other chains, some are like bridges, like in the 2017 world, there's like A on network, which is like this one chain that would connect other chains.
There's a blockchain that connects to connected blockchains. And there's been this whole entire sector of these interoperability solutions that would solve the interoperability problems of blockchains with another blockchain. And those of all that whole entire sector hasn't really taken off yet. But the same opinion of like, hey, there's going to be a bajillion chains. Is not the less held by both Ethereum and Celestia. It's just like there's this main one difference of like, instead of like adding a third chain to connect two chains, instead these two chains are just using the same sort of like shared resource being DA.
And that is actually the thing that actually allows for two blockchains to actually talk to each other without having like this intermediary third chain that does that one, this like one global service. Riff on that for a second. Like because like this is kind of the evolution of like the money, many chain world. Absolutely, I'm so glad you brought that up because that's something I wanted to talk about earlier, there were so many other things to mention. So that the why does it make sense to share a data availability there? Like why does it make sense for this like base layer of security like Celestia to be data availability?
And the reason is that data availability, it makes sense if we're living in a world where there's tons and tons of different chains, it makes sense for them to share the same DA resource for a few different reasons. One is exactly like you said data availability, there's actually like an impossibility result and interoperability for blockchains, which states if you're not able to verify the other chain's data availability, you cannot have a trust minimize bridge with them. And so if you want to have these chains be able to interoperate with a high degree of fidelity and security and economic bandwidth, you need that they need to be sharing a common DA layer.
Right? Now, is that just because like you reduce, you just reduce trust assumptions if we all make the same trust assumption? We all agree to use Celestia as the place to, so like on from the Ethereum side of things, right? Like a role optimizer use Ethereum DA, Ethereum for settlement, which can be expensive, or it makes an all different choice. It'll make the choice to have an additional security assumption, which is using an external third party DA provider, which is what Celestia is. But if we all make that same external choice, then that same external trust assumption is better for all of us, and we're all making the same trade off.
And so that trade off actually kind of becomes more secure because more people have made it. Is that what you were saying? Sort of, it's a wind even call it a trust assumption. It's sort of like, well, this ties into the idea of light nodes which I was talking about earlier, right? Which is that, okay, so how does blockchain interoperability really work under the hood? Well, specifically when you're trying to do it in a trust minimized way, what you do is you need your blockchain, blockchain A, to verify the state of blockchain B, right? Like if I'm gonna, if you're saying I bridged these tokens or I did certain action on blockchain B, that I want to trigger to mint my tokens here or do some action here, right?
I need to actually, this blockchain A itself needs to be able to verify that that actually happened. Now, the way that we do this currently, in the most trust minimized way, for example, like let's say IBC, is that these two different chains, they run what's called a light client of each other, which is the same thing that certain users run, like you can run a light client on Bitcoin or whatever, and what that light client does is basically verifies the signatures of this other chain that the block producers, and it says, okay, all the block producers signed off on the state, therefore I'm okay to trust it and do, you know, mint these coins and whatever.
Now, the problem with that is that a light client makes an honest majority assumption on the other, the validator set of the other chain. If this chain decides to go rogue and sign some, you know, arbitrary state, this chain has no way of defending itself. And so that's what I mean. It seems that both chains are secure when they might not be, but it assumes that they are. Well, it's, yeah, specifically assumes that the validators are secure and not going to, like, corrupt, get corrupted. The problem with that is that, like, if a rational validator, if I have a certain amount of stake at, you know, value at stake, if I sign, like, invalid state, I get slash for that, right?
But if the amount of damage I can do to other chains that I'm bridged to is a higher, like, amount of money I can steal is higher than, like, I may as well do that, right? Or like, it becomes rational, the rational choice to do it. So in this world where interoperability is based on light clients, which even to this day, like, most interoperability is not even based on light clients. Like, light clients is better than 99% of other interoperability. But even in this world, you have this problem, right? And the way that, okay, one, and tying it back to data availability, I hope I'm not losing the listeners, is that, now, if we want to do this in a trust-minimized way, what we could do is instead have this chain, post an actual proof, or use proofs, rather than just, like, a multi-sager, like, you know, sign, like, a signature set, it can post, like, fraud proofs or ZK proofs of the state to this chain.
Now, the problem is, and we all know that, so that's a big step up in, like, the security. However, there's still another attack, which is a data withholding attack, which is this chain, post it state over there, and then, but it never actually publishes the data behind that state transition. If this chain is not able to verify that all the data is available in this chain, then it can, again, break the bridge and steal all the money, right? So now, you're sucking this thing of, like, okay, well, in order to have two chains, have totally secure interoperability, which is proof-based, not, like, validator signature base, honest majority-based, fully trust-minimized, they need to verify that each other's data is available.
So now, listen to you, like, okay, well, it makes sense for us to post our data to a common data availability layer. Now, before data availability sampling came along, that didn't really make any sense, because ultimately, if every chain posts its data to the same DA layer, that DA layer just gets bigger and bigger and bigger, and now everyone is burdened with having to download more and more data. So every chain now has to do way, like, more work. It basically increases linearly with the amount of, like, the amount of chains and the amount of transactions. With data-village sampling, all of a sudden, you make it sub-linear, so that we can actually share a common DA layer without increasing the load on the other chains.
So now, you can have this interoperability, fully trust-minimized, without an actually scalable system. Okay, and this conversation all kind of spawned with Celessia as a platform for sovereignty. So, sovereignty yet, yet, trustless, composability. Is it trustless? Or is it just like, we call it trust-minimized? And is it an end-of-one trust assumption? Something that I learned very early on from Mustafa and never used the word trustless. Because there's no such thing as trustless. There's no such thing as trustless. There's always some assumptions baked into these things. But you want to be as trust-minimized.
And the most trust-minimized that we know how to build so far is basically having some kind of execution proofs with those ZK or frog proofs with some form of, with data availability guarantees, with data availability sampling. Or if you want to, you can just download all the data. And that's that way you're fully secure and you're not making any assumptions. Now, the reason why tying this back to sovereignty or why does it make sense to share a common DA layer first of all is an interoperability thing. And I guess why I kind of already covered it. Before, yeah, before data availability sampling, like it didn't make sense for chains to all, like, couple this.
But you also get this shared security of the consensus as well. Like if you're also deriving consensus from the underlying DA layer, you don't have to have your own consensus network and your own proof of stake system. It can all be kind of within one proof of stake system. And the good thing about consensus is that it's extremely scalable because all you're doing is just voting. Like, consensus is actually one thing that is inherently makes an honest majority assumption. There's no way consensus is a subjective thing. It's not an objective like an oval. Consensus is honest majority. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
Whether it's proof of work, it's like you're assuming that, like, the majority of the miners are not going to, like, go back in time and start mining a different, like, you know, uncle chain and proof of stake, you're assuming they're not also not going to sign conflicting blocks, essentially. But the beauty of sharing this common DA layer is that you don't have to spin up your own chain from scratch. So all of a sudden, you can have consensus and data availability, which is the root of the security of your chain, out of the box. And you can pool all those resources together rather than duplicating the effort and fragmenting the security.
Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network. A brand new, high-performance Ethereum layer to built using the OP stack, but uses EigenLayer's data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one. Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle.
Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 on board, like Game 7 for Web3 gaming, and buy a bit for TVL and liquidity in on-ramps. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle. If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led Layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. Launching a token? Don't let complex legal and tax issues slow you down. Toku provides specialized support to optimize your launch and ensure that you as a founder and your team and your investors get the most tax-efficient outcomes.
The Toku team understands the crypto space inside and out and will ensure your token launch is fully compliant while maximizing tax efficiency. Toku can connect you with the best attorneys if you need them to make sure that you have the best advice and Toku can help to optimize your taxes so you pay the least possible amount of taxes while still maintaining legal compliance. With Toku's guidance, you can concentrate on building your company while Toku handles the logistics. Token launches don't have to be complicated. Talk to Toku today to get a free initial token valuation. Taking self-custody of your crypto is one of the most important things you can do on your bankless journey.
It's also one of the hardest things to get right with huge consequences if you don't. If you want help going bankless, talk to Kasa. Kasa helps you take custody of your crypto assets so you don't have to wonder whether you're doing it right. Kasa is a one-stop shop for doing self-custody the right way. With Kasa vaults, you can hold ether, bitcoin, stablecoins, all with one simple app and multiple keys for the ultimate piece of mind with a support team to help you every step of the way. But it doesn't stop at self-custody because even though crypto is forever, you are not. We all plan on making life-changing wealth in crypto but with Kasa's inheritance products, life-changing wealth can elevate to generational wealth.
For your kids and your loved ones who don't know anything about crypto. With Kasa, you won't lose your private keys and you won't accidentally take them to the grave either. Click the link in the description to get started securing your generational wealth. One of the big conversations around Celessia is the notion of D.A. Data availability as a commodity or not. Some people will look at the market cap of T.A. and be like, well, that doesn't make any sense because what are they doing? They're selling a commodity. The price of D.A. the cost of D.A. are going is zero. The economic sustainability of selling D.
A. is just not a very good business. But I think we've already opened up how Celessia is just more than just a seller of D.A. Which is the network effects around many roll-ups, many, many, many roll-ups, all leveraging Celessia for D.A. And especially that sub-linear relationship with more roll-ups using Celessia for D.A. And how scalable it is. And so technically infinite amount of room for Celessia to fit many, many roll-ups who can all have this logically concluded, minimized ease of verification of other chains, giving you a maximum level of interoperability with the retention of sovereignty.
And all of this happens because of there's a common layer here. So maybe D.A. is a commodity, but that's not all what Celessia is. Celessia is more than that. This is my intuition of where this conversation goes. Maybe you can pick it up and run with it. Yeah, absolutely. I'm glad that you're talking about D.A. as a commodity because this is one of the takes that I hear the most, which I think is the most shortsighted or just misguided, basically, because again, if you think about it, right, do you think that, for example, any EVM block space is the same? Like, is block space on Ethereum, L1, versus like Tron or like, I don't know, even let's say Arbitron, right?
All like block space, all block space is like differentiated in some way. They have different features. And just I think people just think like, oh, well, data availability, it just sounds like, oh, I'm just putting my data somewhere and like, you know, it could be anywhere. So like, it's trivial to just spin up more data availability. But the reality is that data availability is just another name for block space. It's just unrefined block space, but it has all the same properties of block space in other contexts. So like, if you, unless you think that literally all block space is a commodity, then you should not think that DA is a commodity.
And I think there's a lot of others. Like, one way I've heard kind of this express, this idea expressed, but someone, I think someone in the Ethereum community uses analogy of like block space as a building material, right? And so this is another way of like explaining this, is like, not all block space is made the same. Not all DA is made equal. In the sense of like, there's block space or data availability that's flimsy, and then there's block space and data availability that's very strong and robust. And like, what, you know, if I'm a builder and I'm building a, this whole, the whole point of blockchains, right, is to have this shared state in a trust minimized way.
And if I'm building my application, and I choose certain building materials, like something that's flimsy, I say like particle board or something like, like the house I'm going to be able to build or the tower or whatever is going to be like, just frankly, not very sturdy, right? And maybe that's okay for your specific thing. But for the, the majority of like use cases and like the, the real essence of what makes blockchains useful, you want something that's very sturdy, like steel that you could just like, you could build like a tower, like in the social scalability of that is so much greater.
So it's like, it's kind of like this, this building material, analogy is one way to think about it. And the Celestia's goal is to be the most sturdy, trust minimized, and yet scalable DA. So it's like, so it's cost effective. It can also might think like, well, okay, if it's, well, if it's made out of steel, you know, it's going to be more expensive than if I bought just like plywood or like particle board or something. And it's like, yes, absolutely, it will be. Like if you want to just use DA on AWS, S3 or something like that, go for it. And it's going to be cheaper, obviously. But you're going to pay for it in other ways, right?
But the goal of Celestia is like, maybe, okay, this is maybe a good thing. Like, okay, maybe Ethereum, wax waste right now, right? It's like steel. It is like the most, it is like insanely secure, like like so many people running nodes, like all these, you know, different features. Celestia is perhaps non-estirty yet for now. But it's, but it's cheaper. So maybe you think of it like, you know, you know, you know, you know, but it's, but it's cheaper. So maybe you maybe think of it like carbon fiber. I don't know if carbon fiber is like actually cheaper than, definitely not cheaper. Okay. Never mind.
That's a bad analogy. Imagine something that's like, not quite as strong, but cheaper to build on. And still, it's extremely sturdy. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I'll think more about what the specific analogy could be. But that's the way to think about it. It's not a commodity. Now within each block, like within Celestia, like box space is kind of created equal. So you could think of it as a commodity within like all Celestia specific block space, all Ethereum specific block space is a commodity. But then you even have Ethereum breaking out its block space into like execution block space and DA block space.
Right. And also you can think of it like, well, top of block is actually more valuable, more valuable sort of like part of the Ethereum block space. Because there's MEV to be extracted at the top of the block. So anyway, that's just sort of me. My rant of like, this is not a commodity. And like, you know, we can, we can talk more about specifically the network effects around block space and DA generally, which I believe are there. There's another sort of like element of this conversation. Yeah. I see two pillars of this conversation. The one that you were just talking about right now and then the second one, which you just identified, which is just like, what are the extra features that come alongside of a shelling point where everyone's using the same DA layer and like how can like a platform like Celessia or any other DA platform like, how can they maximize network effects, which is, which is one part of this like DA as a commodity conversation, which I want to definitely want to get to, but I still want to hang on the first one for a second.
Because I don't, I don't think what your opinion was actually directly attacks at the heart of like the whole DA is a commodity meme. Like block block space is also a commodity like to your point. It's definitely a commodity. But like block space is less commoditized, whereas think DA is very commoditized. As in like, you can like Ethereum produces block space, the Ethereum layer one produces block space at a very specific rate. And so it's producing this commodity. But in this very constrained fashion, which is actually where Ethereum block space gets its value from, the fact that it's so constrained in its supply and production, whereas Celestia, as like the big block, unsophisticated block chain, actually can like expand the supply of DA very readily to host infinity chains.
And so like because there's no fundamental constraint on literally the supply of DA, we can totally compare and contrast Celestia DA with all the other DA providers. And we can say like, well like Celestia is just like the best. It's like the best product. It's the best quality out of all the DA. But it still doesn't like address a point that like Celestia can also massively expand the supply of data availability when needed to sell it to all the rollups that are purchasing it. And so I think that's where kind of the meme of like, DA is a commodity comes from. Yeah, here's maybe a better, to reply to your point, maybe a better analogy is like, there may be Ethereum block spaces like diamonds or some kind of rare mineral where it's like precious metal.
Disapply is so limited and you have to do a lot of work to like get it out of the ground. It's insanely secure, like you know diamonds are like the hardest thing in the world, right? Like you're not going to break it. But like you know, it's just difficult and the supply is fundamentally constrained, right? And what Celestia is actually more like steel, where the ingredients to make it are very cheap and accessible and so it's very scalable, right? But it's still a great building material. It's not maybe it's not as strong as diamond, but you can still build in, you know, really, really good things out of it.
And ultimately like, what Celestia wants to, like what, like okay, we were never going to, if we want to reach web scale for web three in blockchains, we can't do a building out of diamonds. We're going to, we need to have steel or something like that to build all these different things. And so that's why we fundamentally believe that like we, that could constrain supply of block space is a blocker to actual adoption, right? And, and there's, and now you're thinking like, okay, well, if it's totally unconstrained, then there's no, like, how do you price it? The price is like a race, race to zero.
And that's also not the case. Like the price just needs to be higher than the cost to produce, to produce it, right? When I'm, if I'm a steel manufacturer, it's like what I rather, like I could sell like a thousand, I don't even know what you call those. Like, you know, it's bars of steel. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Beams of steel, at like a, you know, a thousand dollars a piece or it could sell like a million of them at like a hundred bucks a piece or something like that. You want to, it's better to have a low price point, but sell a lot. Like that's how, that's how we're going to actually make these systems work in the real world.
And that's what Celeste wants to do. Rather than trying to constrain supply and drive the price up, it's like, have the price be low and accessible to anyone and just, you know, sell a lot of it, basically. It's like economy of scale is sort of like the, the underlying goal. Yeah. All metaphors like, sadly break down until this work, kind of like these, these like economic resources are like metaphors are kind of like, imprecise. But I think like, the measure is like, both Ethereum and BlockSpace and Celestia Blobspace are both like renewable resources, but Ethereum constrains its supply and Celestia maximises the supply.
And so like Celestia re-grows its block space very, very quickly because like, that's kind of the nature of Blobspace as you can actually prune it. And so like, its ability to re-grow more Blobspace happens at a very high rate and is also interested in growing it, growing like renewing its resource over and over and over again, faster and faster and faster, where Ethereum is like, yo, like, really, really put a damper on how much new commodity that we are producing because that's just what the nature of Blobspace is. Yes, exactly. Yeah. And just a quick thing on like the pruning part, right, which is that data availability is different to data storage.
So like, people get mixed up and they're like, oh man, well Celestia doesn't store its data beyond, you know, 21 days, I think that's what the pruning threshold is. But the reason for that is that data availability is about publishing and not about storing. Right. And those are two different things that sort of like, you know, like a newspaper publishes data and distributes it around the world. But you don't expect them to have the copy of, you know, the newspaper from three weeks ago, like, you know, when you go back and check it because it's like, well, I already did their thing. If you need it, there's copies of that newspaper everywhere.
Just go, or go to a library and pull it out because the libraries are storing it. And libraries, more like a storage. Anyway, that's a, a small aside. Yeah. Right. It's not, it's not the newspaper's job to retain the knowledge, like humanity does that in other places. And so, the knowledge remains, but the newspaper is decay. Exactly. Yes. Okay. Let's get into the, the other pillar of this conversation, which is like the specific network effects around Celestia DA or any sort of DA layer that generates network effects because this is the, and I think we've kind of talked about it so we're actually kind of rehashing part of this conversation.
But just like, it's one thing to talk about, say, DA is a commodity or not or it's actually a precious material. But really, the separating factor between, like, one DA platform's quality of their DA and others is largely, it's like shelling point as, like, a settlement network for DA. And so, like, we've already talked about, like, when, if we're all, if robots are all using the same DA layer, call it Celestia, there are, like, tailwinds. Maybe we can just kind of run through that conversation, a little bit more formally, one more time about, like, the nature, how the quality of DA changes when everyone uses the same DA platform.
Yeah. So, the, one of the main ones which we've already covered while just recover quickly, is that, if ever, like, the more, more roll-ups, the more chains are using a specific data availability layer, you get this shared security property, basically, which is, is, you can have, first of all, you share the same, like, root, sort of consensus and ordering between the blocks. And you don't, and you have this, like, shared sort of proof of stake network at the, at the base, right? And then, more importantly, potentially, is the fact that you share this common data availability root. And there's actually, in Celestia, there's this, it's what's called the data root.
And if everyone's verifying the same data root, then they get this privileged access to each other's state. And they can have these trust-minimized bridges that allow them to have, you can really have this high fidelity, high economic bandwidth, interoperability between these chains, which, I think, is going to be vital to achieving the actual, like, value proposition of what blockchains are supposed to be, right? And because, as soon as you sort of, like, bake, if you want to now, all of a sudden, you're on this DA layer, you want to talk to this other, chain on a different DA layer, or that's own sovereign chain, whatever it is, you end up, now you're having a down to your trust that has all these limitations and security implications, that right now, we might not really care about, because we're such, like, where we are as a space is so, like, peanuts, compared to where we want to be, like, fast forward 20 years, right?
Like, it's the same as, the internet, like, people thought, oh, whatever, it's email, blah, blah, blah. Literally, now, everything runs on the internet. That's where I believe Web 3 is going, and except, instead of just, like, data and information, it's going to be, like, the value. It's like, everyone's livelihoods, you know, whatever next, like, the next iteration of central banks are, and, like, the whole global financial system, is going to be on these things. It's not going to be a joke. It's going to be, like, well, I actually want to stay within my zone of, like, if I go outside of this trust minimized zone, I'm actually taking a risk, and there's going to be a limit, like, obviously, people will take that risk.
I'm not saying that, we're going to be these isolated islands. They will be bridging between these, but it's going to be constrained, by those trust assumptions, baked into them, and that are just inherent to the nature of watches, as far as we know, with this impossibility result. So, like, there's going to be this privilege, there's going to be, like, I would say, like, a natural sort of, like, like, pooling, slash, aggregation, consolidation, around specific DA layers for the, for the chains that really need trust minimized interoperability with each other. That's one. Mm-hmm. Okay. Beautiful.
And I want to get into the conversation of Tia, the tokens roll in the Celestia ecosystem. So, of course, like Tia gets the economic security, gives the economic security to the Celestia ecosystem, basically, basic proof-of-stake principles. I don't really think we need to define proof-of-stake here. But, like, what is Tia's relationship with the roll-ups that build on top of Celestia? Like, how does, how do these relationships, like, emerge in, and progress? Yeah. So, Tia is, basically, first of all, the proof-of-stake token at the root of the network. It's also the token that people use to pay for block space.
So, whenever, if you want to, you know, if you're running a chain on Celestia, you're going to need to pay Tia to the underlying layer to purchase the block space. And the, the fee, basically, is proportional to the amount of data that you want to consume. So, it's actually more similar, but the fee market is more similar to Bitcoin, which is, like, a byte-based, like, fee model, versus Ethereum, which is, like, gas-based. So, that's another interesting, difference there, because there's no execution, there's no gas. And it's linear. Is it linear to, to bytes? So, bytes go up by one, gas, or price goes up by one?
Or is there, is there, there's like a base fee, and then there's, like, it scales up as you consume more data beyond that. But, I think, Tia, ultimately, there's, like, nothing, other, there's nothing stopping it from being used as a gas token for execution layers built on top of it, which actually could be very useful, similar to what roll-ups use for ETH, you may not want to issue your own token to do gas. If those roll-ups, operators, and folks using it, are already posting data to this lesson, it can kind of make sense to just have that also be Tia, because it kind of aligns the cost of execution with, like, that the same sort of unitive account, essentially, between the DA and the execution.
So, there's a lot of reasons why that could make sense. And it can also be, that I've learned from David Graber's book that first 5,000 years and also like one of the ways that we understand money emerges in the first place is that like some governments have some control over some piece of land and then they say, hey citizens, we are going to protect you and you are going to pay taxes. Oh, also you're gonna pay taxes in this unit of account, which is our currency that we issue. And so go do commerce with each other, generate revenue, we charge you in taxes in this unit of account and because you have to pay taxes in this unit of account, that unit of account becomes the money of that like particular domain.
It's like it's just a very like understood way in which money emerges in a particular landscape is that people just use the money that they are required to pay taxes in. And in taxes in this particular, like Web 3 context is just like what it costs to pay for the resources that are required to make your blockchain work. Exactly, you know that book is something that I remember I bought it at one point and I was like, I'm gonna read this book and I just could not get through it. It's such a good book, man. I know, I know everyone says that I got a, I, it's on my list. Anyway, that's a great way to think about it, I think.
And then similar to Ethereum, Tia can be used as like in DeFi, it can be used to price NFTs and also in the future, potentially people could build sort of restaking type functionality to, to, to theory, to sorry, to Celestia. So I think there's a lot of actual parallels frankly between like Tia as a token and eth as a token. It's just like very, they're like, they have very similar like uses or potential uses like Ethereum is obviously way further along in terms of like distribution and you know, it's actually actually people like pricing NFTs and doing all these things like in Tia's case is still very hypothetical, but there are people that I'm aware of that are, that are building these kind of things and so we'll, we'll see how it plays out.
And that, and I think that's, that's one, I don't know if we were already off the topic of network effects but there's a couple other ones that I think are, are kind of interesting to go into if that's, before that's something that we have time for. One other interesting network effect around data availability specifically and this is, is light notes. And so, something that we didn't talk about is that in order to have this ability for the, the block space to scale, but in a trust minimized way where it's still verifiable, you need to have a certain minimum number of light nodes that are sampling the data.
If you don't have that minimum number of light nodes, the, the assumptions that allow you to, to call that block space trust minimized collapse basically. And so, the interesting thing is that when these, you know, networks get really, really big in the future, if you wanna compete and have that much throughput, that much block space that you produce, but still have this very sturdy trust minimization like steel property, you are gonna need to have a ton of light nodes out there in the world. And bootstrapping that, getting light nodes distributed, getting users and different people entities all around the world to run these light nodes is a fundamental thing that you can't just like snap your fingers and be like, okay, all of a sudden I have, you know, 10 million light nodes all over the world sampling my chain.
So, I think that's another really important part of this that like, you can't just replicate, you can't just fork, you know, Celeste or some other DA layer, just like you can't fork Ethereum. It's like, yeah, okay, fork Celeste and run in your basement, but no one cares, and it's not trust minimized because you don't have all these, these things that are fundamental to making that possible. And then I think the last one is just, you know, integrations, and this is not necessarily like, at the protocol layer, but just if you think about it, you know, the modular stack, as much as we want things to be like puggable, the reality is, I think we're still pretty far from that.
And right now, to integrate different kinds of DA layers and different tools, like the amount of tools and tooling and integrations you have with execution layers and shared sequencers and all those things, is actually a very fundamental sort of network effect of like, if I'm building a new modular component, where am I gonna choose to build it on first? Or what is my priority gonna be when I'm launching it? It's like, okay, well, I'm gonna go to the DA layers that have the most, you know, users and other integrations as well. And so like Ethereum, everyone's like, everyone immediately built, if you're building a modular thing and it doesn't like touch Ethereum, then you're like, what are you doing, right?
Yeah, and I think, yeah. Yeah, exactly. And so it's like, well, who's that, who's really gonna, like that's your main user base? Like without an Ethereum integration, it's kind of like, well, you know, no one's really gonna care. And I think that there's a similar sort of path here where there's like, ultimately gonna be a limited number of DA networks that these builders are gonna wanna support and continuously like battle test and like upgrade and like maintain these integrations with. And so I think there's kind of a consolidation also at that layer. Okay, so I accidentally truncated this conversation and you brought us back to it, which is just like the network effects around the Celessia ecosystem.
But I also think that also bleeds back into the money conversation because like, what is money? It's just like network effects. It's just network effects. And so like some of these network effects, like many, many, many more like clients, I think are like loosely affiliated with the moneyness of Tia, but affiliated nonetheless, which is just like there's some sort of like security and money are go hand in hand. Like you don't have money without security. And so many, many, many, many light clients produce a security for many, many more at more chains, which kind of just like fosters some sort of like emergent breeding ground for like Tia as money.
Like no one can ever force money to become a thing. It's like kind of this bottom up adopted thing as a result of just like the correct context. And I think what you're saying is just like, when many rollups use the same settlement DA layer, when many light clients are securing all of these rollups, all of a sudden like we are fostering a lot of the ingredients that one would require in order to like allow for money to emerge. And I think you're continuing, the continuation of that is like, well, naturally Tia is the most logical thing to like leverage as money inside of the modular role of ecosystem.
Is that kind of the thought process? Yeah, that is the good way to summarize it. And one thing that I didn't mention is that there is actually a blocker to that future currently in the way that Susty has designed. Because without execution or without like settlement, I guess there is actually no way currently to bridge Tia in a trust minimized way to the rollups on top of it currently. And so now Tia is getting bridge there, but it's using IBC or hyperlain or like all these non-trust minimized options, right? And like that kind of sucks because if you think about like Ethereum, one of the great things for like the eth L2s is that they have a canonical bridge that is like in theory as secure as Ethereum itself.
So when you're bridging Ethereum up into those rollups, it's like the purest, like that eth is not compromised. It's like almost as close to native eth as you can get, basically. That's a release, yeah. Exactly, that's a very good way to put it, love that. And so Celestia right now does not have that ability. And that was, we chose that because we thought, at the time we were like, we would, like there was the only solution we could think of was basically to add execution to Celestia in order to do that. So you could have a smart contract that verifies the rollup. But that would add state and all these problems.
So we were like, how can we do this? How can we add this functionality of being able to have a trust minimized bridge to rollups without adding complexity on state and all the, like adding baggage and weight to the L1. And we came up, most of us wrote this forum post on Celestia Research Forum. I don't know, maybe over a year ago, which is basically like describe this idea of having a snark account or a ZK account at the Celestia base layer. And essentially what it is is, you know, normally, you know, it's basically a stateless way of having a bridge to other rollups and like an execution minimized way of doing it.
Where normally an account on a chain, right, it has an address and a private key. And if you sign a message, if you have a signature, right, the valid signature of a certain transaction, if it matches that address, then the chain will execute that transaction, right? It will consider it valid. Now, what you can do, and this is a vast oversimplification by the way, but it's just trying to get the message across, a ZK account is essentially instead of like the public key essentially, you have a ZK program, like a commitment to a ZK program. And if you provide it a valid proof, rather than a valid signature, that some execution happened on the ZK program, then it will carry out that transaction, which could be like, you know, moving Tia to another address.
So all of a sudden, with this thing, you can have an arbitrary sort of like, it's kind of like a, I wouldn't say in shrines ZK rollup, but it's sort of like as you can have a ZK rollup that can settle to Celestia, and that rollup can be like just uses a bridge essentially to get Tia up into that thing. But you can also interestingly, likely build more interesting things, like potentially restaking and stuff like that. And so this is something that we're still designing and speccing out. People are interested. We have a working group. We have a very active CIP process. So Celestia improvement proposals process where there's a lot of really like gigabrain people much more than me who are like designing these kind of systems.
And I'm excited about that because I think that is the key to unlock this ability. And in a way that stays aligned with Celestia's values of like we try to be minimal as possible and not burden the rest of the rollups with like all the state and execution, right? So is this feature, is this inside of blob space or is this kind of like making a new lane just to kind of enable this one particular feature? So Celestia is execution minimized but it still has execution. We actually thought originally one of the designs was like, okay, actually we'll just have all the execution can be just a rollup on top of Celestia.
But turns out you do need a minimal amount of state for like proof of stake and doing all that and all of that. And so kind of like a chance to be can change, right? Yeah, exactly. So they're exactly, that's a very good analogy. So there is execution Celestia, but it's as minimal as possible. So basically all it is like staking related things and transferring tokens and you, and that's it. So this just adds one other feature to that state variable state machine which is like, hey, we can have these ZK accounts where you can verify ZK program on the Celestia base layer and that can add all this like rich functionality on top of it.
Okay, so this is kind of like Ethereum started out with a very from Celestia perspective like a heavy weight execution layer and it's always been that way. That's what Ethereum does. The Ethereum layer one does execution. Recently in Ethereum land, we added 4844, which is like a pretty lightweight data availability side car where Celestia is like the heavy weight DA provider, like DA champion of the world. And now is adding a very lightweight execution module inside and like, yeah, I don't think you like the word and trying, but like kind of like built into the Celestia layer one itself, in order to like kind of like converge back to like the Ethereum model, which has execution on the layer one and now is adding a DA, whereas Celestia is DA, now is adding a light little like execution module.
I see like a ton of convergence here. I would agree, however, it's really important, right, that people get the message that Celestia's not trying to be a settlement layer and to the difference right between having this ability to bridge and verify something on Celestia base layer and being a settlement layer is like, there's no way to issue tokens on Celestia. There's not even a way to bridge tokens down. There's no way to represent other tokens on Celestia. So Celestia is not a liquidity, like a lot of settlement layers are like, okay, we'll verify your proofs and we'll have this pool of liquidity and users and whatever, and you know, that's one of the value propositions.
And Celestia is not trying to do that. Celestia very, very distinctly does not, on ever be a settlement layer. We just want to be purely DA. It's just adding this because we think it will be useful for the bridging part and potentially some other interesting things, but not for settlement. So I think that's, that is sort of the difference, but you're right, that there is a little bit of convergence. But Celestia, again, it's like, what's the minimal amount of things that we can do to provide the maximum amount of exclusivity and functionality and adding ZK things is one of those things that makes sense for us on the trade-off.
Interestingly, Bitcoin, a lot of people want to do the same thing to Bitcoin. And you know, it's because, you know, that diagram of sophisticated, unsophisticated, like both Bitcoin and Celestia have very unsophisticated block space. And in Bitcoin, people want to build these L2s, but there's no way to, they have the same problem. There's no way to bridge the Bitcoin up. So they want to add a ZK output. Obviously, this is going to take a lot longer to ship on Bitcoin then on Celestia. But I think it's just the last point on the settlement thing. One of the reasons why Celestia doesn't want to do settlement is because we have this vision of scaling any ecosystem and being fully, like, you know, the Switzerland of DA essentially and be very agnostic to any ecosystem.
So like, obviously, most of the chains using Celestia right now are Ethereum L2s. But in the future, as there's more Bitcoin L2s, we're going to provide DA to Bitcoin L2s. When there's, you know, there's a lot of cosmos chains that are now thinking about using Celestia. Some of them already using something called roll chains. So like every ecosystem, now base and arbitrarment, they're going to have their own L3 ecosystems that can use Celestia. So we're trying to be this like underlying very thin minimal layer that encompasses as much and can service as much of the ecosystem as possible. And that's really, and as soon as you start to, you know, do settlement and try to like, if you like, compromise is your ability to be that credibly neutral, just like, maximally minimal settlement layer or sorry, DA layer.
So that's the difference. And like, yeah, I think there's a lot of other DA, like for example, eigenDA is very Ethereum centric, right? So like, would a cosmos chain or Bitcoin chain use it for DA is unclear. So like, or like Ethereum DA has all opinionated with, you know, this very heavy settlement, like execution layer that attached to it. So like, would a Bitcoin roll up, use Ethereum for DA? Probably not because of all those things. So like, that's one of the core value props of like, the reason why not to go to settlement because so many people have been like, whoa, you guys should do settlement or whatever.
And we're like, no, that's like very short-sighted in our opinion. Just to be clear, this whole like ZK thing that we were, the Slesi is like, trying to figure out how to add to it's chain. It is settlement, not on the Celestial layer one, but it is like cross Celestial roll up settlement. It's like a settlement module that is a service to other roll ups, or that settlement doesn't happen on the layer one, but it does facilitate settlement as a module. Is that correct? Yeah, if facilitate settlement specifically for Celestia, the Tia token, it's specifically a module for the Tia token. Well, you can control an account on Celestia with that, that can transfer Tia or do different things with Tia.
But it's not a settlement, again, you can't take tokens from that roll up and then bridge them down to Celestia and then bridge them to another roll up, if that makes sense. And I think another part of this. It's specifically, the opinion here is it's elevating Tia the token as a first class citizen. We already is a first class citizen, but it's really elevating Tia the token as a first class citizen of its roll up landscape. Yes, exactly. Yes, okay, which is where we get to the whole meme of Tia's modular money, right? Yes, that's part of it, exactly. Yeah, okay. Okay, so one thing that I'm optimistic that Celestia brings to its own ecosystem, the Cosmos ecosystem, I categorized Celestia inside of Cosmos, the Cosmos ecosystem, the Cosmos idea, what is Cosmos?
It's this idea of producing super sovereign chains. That's a great notion about Cosmos, but I've always thought it's like, it's going to be unconstrained, pretty constrained as an idea, because Cosmos, it's like two goddamn, like it's too much of an anarchy to really coordinate and scale, because all these chains are so massively focused on sovereignty that they can't collectivize, they can't coordinate, they can't band together, because they're also goddamn focused on sovereignty. And so Celestia seems to be the minimum amount, the absolutely lightest amount of compromises on sovereignty, which do exist, although they're extremely minimal, to allow for some sort of like shared coordination layer for this like Cosmos idea, Cosmos meme to proliferate, whereas like, hey guys, use the same layer for a DA, maybe perhaps consider using Tia as money, but like Tia is this one platform inside of the Cosmos ecosystem that I actually see becoming like a shared resource by all these independent Cosmos chains that actually produces some sort of like coordination in these chains, which I have always considered the Cosmos world to have lacked.
Great way to put it. I would say Celestia shares a lot of philosophical roots with Cosmos. It also, frankly, is built the base chain is built with Tendermint or now Comet BFT and the Cosmos SDK. So there's like this deep root in Cosmos, but I think Celestia's vision and value prop is like quite different. So Celestia is definitely part of the Cosmos community, but I think it's something sort of to its own in a sense. And I actually, I think of Celestia as sort of the perfect middle ground or marriage of Ethereum and Cosmos. That's sort of the way that I think about it is because it's exactly what you said, which is we do believe in the idea of app chains and sovereign chains.
I think Ethereum is now also moving more towards the direction of app chains. App chains and sovereign chains, but we also believe in shared security and coordination that some of the things that Ethereum provides to its things which the Cosmos ecosystem as it currently is does not have. And so Celestia's role is like you said to be like this minimal coordination layer and sort of like shared security layer for whatever kind of role if you want to build whether that sovereign or settled. And ultimately, we're just, we're unimpededinated. Like yes, I frankly believe that in the long term, just technically more and more chains will be sovereign because I think I believe that settlement and settlement layers will become less and less important as chains get more and more abstracted.
And actually my view is that in a long term, execution becomes commoditized. Because if you, like I'm running my application on your role up or on your shared layer, all of a sudden when role ups are a thing and bridging becomes like trivially easy, it's just like oh well, as soon as I want to, whenever I want to, I'm going to just spin up my own execution layer and migrate there. And there's very little cost or downside to doing that. And so all of a sudden it's like, it doesn't matter, but the very from from skip, which is like a Cosmos oriented interop like chain abstraction project said this the other day, which I thought was like just really expresses as well.
It's like in the long term, it's going to matter less where you build as compared to what you build. And we're in this world where the first thing you ask someone when they're like say like I'm building an app, it's like, oh well, where are you building it? Are you building on salana? Are you building on Ethereum? Are you building it blah blah? And maybe that will make venture judgments based on your answer to that. Exactly. And I think maybe there will still be a component of that of like which DA like trust zone are you building on, right? Because that there is actually a reality of like, in the future that that is a hard boundary that is just set by the technology that will still matter.
But in terms of like, are you building on like X EVM chain within this trust zone or Y chain over here, won't matter. It's like wherever you're building, it's all part of it. Like you could, you could just like, it matters more what you build. It's like well, what are you building? Because you will have access to all that liquidity and users and that the flow of that will be so much more seamless and liquid essentially in the long term future. And that's why sovereignty like settling and being rooted in some other chain is going to be less important. Because like, like rollups will be able to stand on their own to, to feet basically and be sovereign.
Nick, this is, this is really great. I really love this construction mainly because I think it's extremely parallel to Ethereum with just like very small divergences. I really think the difference between like the Ethereum landscape and like what Celeste is building towards is really defined by like this very marginal difference of like how sovereign are your rollups. Whereas like Ethereum's rollups are very sovereign, right? Like you can pick your virtual machine, you can pick your block space, you can build an app chain, you can like make something brand new. Like you have a lot of freedom in the Ethereum rollup centric roadmap here, but like it just makes one more opinion about like, well, you use the Ethereum virtual machine on the layer one for settlement, which is an opinion that Celeste does not have.
And making Celeste your rollups, like more, I will call it like marginally more sovereign because like Ethereum's rollups, like I said, they're already very sovereign, but Celeste is like, well, no, no, no, a little bit more. Like literally up to the theoretical maximum of sovereignty while still preserving like this base layer of shared resource, shared interoperability, which is like this Celeste platform. So like I actually think there's a really in the end game for both ecosystems, there's actually like a pretty marginal difference as to like what each one is building for. And it really comes down to like how sovereign are each other's respective rollups.
Do you agree with that? Yeah, I think that that has an element of truth to it. And I think that obviously if you were Ethereum, and you had all this rich state and all this stuff, that approach makes total sense. And I think the difference is that Celeste is starting from scratch, and so we have the ability to basically, well, first of all, actually, we had this disadvantage or rather not the privilege, we're not in the privileged place of Ethereum, which has all that state and users and things like that. But it's also super power in that if you start over from scratch, it's like, well, and you were really building for the long-term, long, long, long-term end game, right?
How would you design a blockchain? And like Zucki, apparently, I heard him say that when he read the laser that you write paper and heard about the project, that used to be what Celeste was called, he was like, oh, you guys are building the last blockchain. That was sort of the phrasing he used. And that was also my feeling when I read the paper in 2020, was like, holy crap. This is so forward-thinking. And I feel like if you play out the various ways that blockchain's evolve, this optimizes for the end state the most of any design that I've seen. And now, to be clear, that could be wrong. We could be wrong about a lot of different assumptions.
We make in fact, we're guaranteed to be wrong about some things. And ultimately, there's going to be always different trade-offs. And this also comes back to build whatever, is that Ethereum makes different trade-offs. And that's a good thing because what we want is more optionality for builders. So like, building on Ethereum right now is actually very appealing and great. And it will probably continue to be despite this trade-off of like, well, Celeste has like very minimal with no settlement and Ethereum. It does have settlement and has state, has execution. Like, the point to build whatever is there's no optimal point.
It's all like a trade-off curve, right? And Celeste is optimizing for a certain thing. Ethereum optimizes for a different thing. And again, also to tie it back. And that's why they're not commodities because they're just going to be very different. It's like, Ethereum block space is going to be different than Celeste block space because they make different choices. They're optimized for different things. And yeah, and that's great. So yeah, I think that like Celeste just has a different philosophy and that results in a different design. Well, Nick, this has been fantastic. This is exactly the episode that I wanted to record.
So thank you for coming on and sharing the perspective on Celeste and I wish you the best one, man. This is really cool. Thank you David. Yeah, I mean, I'm just all fired up now. This is awesome. You asked the best questions. You have great analogies. I kept finding myself being like, oh, damn, that's a really good way to explain it. So thanks for having me. Hey, that's what we do here on Bankless. We are people who do analogies and it's kind of like a one thing. Awesome, my man. Bankless station, you guys know the deal. Crypto is risky. You can lose what you put in, but we're headed west. This is the frontier.
It's not for everyone, but we are glad you were with us on the Bankless journey. Thanks a lot.