Justin Drake joins the third episode of Layer Zero to discuss coining ‘Ultra Sound Money,’ which sent supersonic waves through the Ethereum community. Unsurprisingly, Justin is a deeply compelling individual with a powerful drive to work hard and pursue individuality.
From Quantum Computing to engineering Layer Zero, Justin’s holistic approach to the space really comes through as we discuss what it means to work for a meme.
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ 🎖 CLAIM YOUR BADGE: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/-guide-2-using-the-bankless-badge ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
💰 GEMINI | FIAT & CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
🔀 BALANCER | EXCHANGE & POOL ASSETS https://bankless.cc/balancer
👻 AAVE | LEND & BORROW ASSETS https://bankless.cc/aave
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING http://bankless.cc/uniswap ------
Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 4:30 Justin Drake 9:05 Coining Ultra Sound Money 12:37 From Layer 1 to Layer 0 15:10 Working for a Meme 24:14 The Purpose of the Meme 27:27 The Gini Coefficient 31:17 Proof of Stake and Distribution 35:22 A New Age Cypherpunk 43:30 Scalability 49:30 ETH and the Dollar 57:13 Quantum Computing 1:00:30 Burning MEV 1:04:19 The Efficiency DAO 1:08:11 Bitcoin FUD Dice 1:15:38 Layer 0 Engineer 1:18:20 Layers 3 and 4 1:20:00 A Workaholic and a Father 1:24:14 Citizen of the World 1:28:18 An Emergent Individual 1:34:15 Closing & Disclaimers
------ 📣 SoRare | Collect and Play! https://bankless.cc/SoRare ------
Resources:
Ultra Sound Money Website https://ultrasound.money/ Modeling Ultra Sound Money https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-sotn-44-modeling-ultra-sound-money The Bull Case for Cryptography https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-moon-math-the-bull-case-for-cryptography Ultra Sound Money https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-ultra-sound-money-justin-drake Justin on Twitter https://twitter.com/drakefjustin?s=20
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Layer Zero. Layer Zero is a podcast of unscripted conversations with the people that make up the Ethereum community. Ethereum is built by code, but it's composed by people, and each individual member of the Ethereum community has their own story to tell. Cypherpunks understood that the code they write impacts the people that use it, And layer zero focuses on the people behind the code because Ethereum is people all the way down. And it always has been. Today, I'm speaking with Justin Drake. Justin, as we all know, is the founder of the ultrasound money meme. And we go through the creation process of the meme itself, as well as how Justin Drake has moved across the different stacks, the different layers of Ethereum, first as an entrepreneur, then as an L1 dev.
And now what he what I call actually a L0 engineer, a memer, if you will, he is tinkering with the layer zero of Ethereum by committing himself to the ultrasound money meme. And so we start this conversation off with what does it mean to work for a meme? This is what Justin Drake considers his current role in Ethereum. He's working for the ultrasound money meme. And not only that, but he's recruiting other people to also work for this meme, which is just like kind of breaks the brain to anyone who doesn't really understand the role of memes and money and markets and finance. But Justin Drake definitely understands that.
We also just kind of overall have an Ethereum technical conversation. It turns a little bit more into a more traditional bankless podcast where we talk about, you know, a little bit more of the code than what I advertise on Layer Zero. But all of that context for, you know, further innovations on Ethereum, staggering shards, putting oracles at the base layer, all this stuff, it actually turns into, towards the end of the conversation, a conversation about Justin Drake, the personality himself, his sort of rebellious nature, his lack of a nation state identity, and also how that is reflected in his kid as well, and how those values are also instantiated in Ethereum.
himself. And so the first two thirds of this podcast is all about ultrasound money and in Ethereum, the protocol, a little bit tech focused, but then it turns into the actual personality disposition of the man himself, as well as his kid and kind of the story of his life and how it relates to Ethereum. So I really enjoyed this conversation with Justin Drake. I really enjoyed seeing the man behind the meme, and I'm pretty sure you will as well. So without further ado, Let's go ahead and get right into the conversation with Justin Drake. But first, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible.
Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. Something brand new in the Uniswap ecosystem is the Uniswap Grants Program is now accepting applications for grants. We have been saying this for a while and we'll say it again. DAOs have money and they are in need of labor. If you think that you have something to contribute to the Uniswap DAO, apply for a grant to Uniswap. Just look at the size of the Uniswap treasury. It's almost three billion. This mountain of capital is looking for labor. Do you have something of value to contribute to the Uniswap DAO? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a Uni grant at unigrants.
org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. That's exactly what we did to get Uniswap to be a sponsor for Bankless, and you can do the same for your project. Thank you, Uniswap, for sponsoring Bankless. Balancer is a powerful platform for flexible automated market makers. Typical AMMs just have two tokens inside of one liquidity pool, which can lead to fractured liquidity across the many pairs in DeFi. With Balancer, you can access the full power of multiple tokens inside of one single AMM, which unlocks an entirely new playing field of possibility. This makes Balancer an awesome building block for so many different use cases.
Balancer pools can make asset indices, but instead of paying fees to portfolio managers, Balancer lets you collect the fees from traders who use your portfolio for liquidity. Additionally, Balancer Smart Pools can be programmed to have properties that change according to predetermined rules, such as changing the swap fee based on market conditions, or even liquidity bootstrapping pools, which can help you launch and distribute your token with day one liquidity. At Bankless, we use a liquidity bootstrapping pool to sell our BAP t-shirts to much success. Balancer V2 brings powerful new features that makes your money work even harder for you.
In V2, idle tokens are capable of generating yield in DeFi without sacrificing liquidity in the pool using Balancer's asset managers. Balancer's vault architecture lets you trade between Balancer pools at a fraction of the cost versus trading on other platforms. Balancer's mission is to become the primary source of liquidity in DeFi by providing the most flexible and powerful platform for asset management and decentralized exchange. Dive into the Balancer pools at app.balancer.fi. All right, Bankless Nation, welcome to the third episode of Layer Zero. Here we're bringing on Justin Drake. You guys all know him as the ultrasound money man, and I feel like I think that's the right place to start off this conversation.
Justin, a fun little story for you. After we recorded our ultrasound money podcast with you, me, and Ryan, And I turned to Ryan, I was like, this is about to change the game like forever. And every single week on the Bankless newsletter, we have like the Market Monday piece, which is like a short little blurb to that. Usually I write it, but sometimes Ryan writes it, sometimes somebody else writes it, but usually I write it. And in the piece, it was the week before we were going to drop the Ultrasound Money podcast that we've recorded with you. uh and in and so i usually write it and then ryan comes in and edits it and changes things up a little bit and in the in the market monday piece i had written uh the ethereum ecosystem the ethereum native narrative will forever change as a result of this podcast and i use some like really like big language and ryan like asked me he he dm'd me i was like are you sure you want to make some like this grand of a statement this grandiose of a statement uh and i was like absolutely absolutely Absolutely, I do.
And he did he did walk me back a little bit, but it turns out that that was exactly right. Like Ethereum as an ecosystem has fundamentally changed ever since the ultrasound money meme really like took storm. And it was it was you know, it was a collaborative effort between many people, but it was really you. So how does that feel? How does it feel to be like the ultrasound money guy that like changed the trajectory of his of Ethereum? Well, I guess, you know, I still think that we're at the very beginnings of the ultrasound money meme. I would agree with you that it has kind of rallied the Ethereum community specifically, but it hasn't grown yet that much beyond the borders of the Ethereum community.
I mean, there was, you know, some brief mentions on Bloomberg and on CNBC and whatnot. but you know I believe the meme will educate a hundred million people and so we're at the very very beginnings of of that I mean how I feel personally I mean the meme has kind of infected me it's kind of taken over my life and in a way you know like in the same way that a virus takes over its host you can think of memes as you know the equivalent of genes that take over their host And I've been taken over by this meme and I'm kind of spreading it to other people and other people are themselves spreading it to other.
I mean, are you like patient zero of this meme? Is that is that what your role is? Patient zero of ultrasound money? Yeah, I think so. But, you know, maybe I'm patient one in the sense that Vitalik had a very, very similar meme before he infected me. His meme was supersonic money. and that you know that was good but it didn't really catch on in the same way i think partly because you know it doesn't reuse the word sound verbatim as we have with the bitcoiners with sound money um so yeah this is kind of interesting you know like just like genes mutate memes mutate as well and you can have um a totally kind of um not non-viral meme with lots of potential that just needs this one little mutation and that changes the game.
I mean, it's a little bit like monkeys and humans, right? We're like 99.9% the same genetic material. It's just these few tiny tweaks that make a lot of difference. So the supersonic money meme came around before ultrasound money, and you're saying it actually mutated into the ultrasound money meme, but you were the mutator, Yeah, that's correct. Basically, we were chatting in a Telegram group and Vitalik was mentioning this meme. I was like, oh, well, it's a good meme, but it didn't really catch on. And then Vitalik was like, hmm, maybe we should try harder to bring it out to the community. And then a few minutes later, I was like, ha, I've got a better version of the meme.
And that point onwards a lot of my time has been just spent you know trying to make this meme a reality i guess um and you know i have a very obsessive um kind of a personality kind of addictive personality like when when i do something i want to do it like right um and really go deep um and you know it's very different from what i was doing previously you know like you know when i joined different foundation. I was doing, you know, crypto economic research, and then kind of, I went deep in the cryptography and, you know, I've done all sorts of other things, but now, you know, I'm kind of doing something totally different, kind of going down the stack from layer one to layer two, to layer zero.
And actually I'd say more and more of my work is at layer zero, interestingly. So for example, one of the things that I've been doing is recruiting, right? That's something that just needs to be done at the FM Foundation. And for some reason, you know, I've been one of the, you know, the biggest recruiters of the research team at the FM Foundation. And yeah, so recruiting, I guess you can think of the ultrasound money meme as kind of being the decentralized version of marketing. And, you know, these two things, kind of HR and recruiting and marketing were things I kind of despise. And I didn't really see myself doing these kinds of roles.
But, you know, in a decentralized context, they're kind of different. And, you know, actually very interesting to dive into these new fields. Yeah, the world of marketing historically has always felt like top down. It's like, here's our brand, here's our image, let's like shove it down your throat. But like in the world of crypto marketing, it's very much of just like an infinite amount of just like A, B tests, A, B, C, D, E, F, G tests to like figure out which one works. And it only ever works if like the world adopts it themselves rather than have it just like shoved down its throat by like trillions of dollars of ad spend.
Exactly. Yeah, there's these algorithms called genetic algorithms where basically you just try tons of mutations and then something sticks and then it just conquers the world. And it feels like, you know, the FM community had a lot of previous failed attempts, you know, that kind of laid the ground. You know, the ground was very, very fertile in the sense that the FM community was trying to find itself and it desperately wanted kind of this meme. And once it found it, it kind of embraced it. And I think that's partly why it grew so fast. But, you know, again, I think it's still a baby meme. It has to grow a bit more.
So from my perspective, you're like a genius cryptographer. Your big brains can code all the things, talk about all the crazy cutting edge technology that this industry has to offer that gets way outside of what I can even comprehend. Yet you are, like you said, going from that, from layer one down to layer zero. Why do you think that you are most suited there rather than back up at the cryptography level? I mean, I kind of have a bit of a founder, kind of entrepreneurial mindset, kind of builder. I just like building stuff. And actually, before I joined the FIM Foundation, I was an entrepreneur of a company.
And you get to do everything as a founder. And I'm kind of this jack of all trades in that sense. and you know I think part of the the reason why I like doing different things is because I'm I guess I'm quite curious and I want to try and understand the the full stack you know when you when you look at computers for example you know it turns out there's like there's like 20 stacks right if you go you know all the way down to the transistor or to the silicon you know all the way up to you know the website there's just so many stacks in between and oftentimes people will focus kind of on maybe three, four, five stacks, layers of the stack.
But I'd much rather try and get a full understanding of all 20 stacks. And I guess this is part of just my personal journey in the Ethereum ecosystem to try and understand every single layer of the stack. Interesting, yeah. And every single layer of the stack has like, it's its own rabbit hole, right? With its own rabbit holes upon rabbit holes. But like we say, like everything kind of always leads back to layer zero. So I think that makes sense that that's actually where you found yourself. Yeah. And actually, if you think of me as an entrepreneur, I was at layer two. So I was trying to make OpenBazaar, which is this decentralized peer-to-peer marketplace built on top of blockchain, such as Bitcoin.
And then I went to layer one and now layer zero. And it's possible that you know once once we're we're done you know shipping eek2 and and and all the the good stuff there then maybe i'll go full circle and go back to layer two and build something cool there and just re-edit maybe we'll go through the cycle like one more time possibly yeah so you said you kind of like work for this meme now as in like it's kind of your your full-time job illustrate that Like how, how, what, what is it like to work for the ultrasound money mean? Yeah. So, you know, we, we have these two pieces of infrastructure.
Like one is, um, the ultrasound money website and the other one is the ultrasound money, uh, Twitter account. And the basic idea here was to try and do things as decentralized as possible. So, you know, try and, and, and get, you know, Different team, you know, different, people to contribute, to join the meme. And I think I mentioned basically the story here, which is that I think it was at the end of the second Ultrasound Money Bankless podcast, I said, you know, I bought this domain, ultrasound.money. I'm looking for a team. And like 10 people came in. And one of the crazy things is that I had to do zero filtering on these 10 people.
All 10 people were invited to contribute. They were all very high quality. And I think part of the reason they were all very high quality is because in order to get to the very end of the second podcast, they had to go through four hours of content. And so only like kind of the most enthusiastic people made it to the end. And actually more people have started to volunteer through the Twitter accounts. They say, oh, we love your movement. We love what you're doing. How can I help? So at this point, there's maybe 15, 20 people who volunteer to contribute. And I think a lot of the work that we do at the FRIM Foundation is coordination.
Very similar to what Danny is really, really good at. And I've tried to help coordinate this team, but also provide kind of the initial impetus and I guess maybe inspiration to get this idea out of the gate. So what kind of talent has shown up at the gates? Is it like dev talent or marketing talent? Is there any sort of through line? Talk about all the skills that has come to the ultrasound money meme. Yeah, so there's quite a lot of dev, so, you know, back and front end, but we have also some non-dev. So, for example, there's this artist, Rodrigo, who just makes awesome, awesome art. And actually, I think one of his pieces was auctioned on the Bankless DAO.
And, you know, this guy just created, you know, this art totally for free, and he had no expectation of financial returns. And, you know, he didn't even really have, you know, expectations of, you know, building much of a name for himself. He was just trying to contribute and do something interesting. You know, at the end of the day, it turned out pretty well for him because he sold, you know, so many copies of his NFT. And then I guess, you know, we've also had in the non-technical field, like someone who I think wants to remain anonymous, who basically is this meme lord who, you know, is behind, you know, a bunch of memes behind the Twitter account.
That's awesome. So how do you have goals? Like, what is the goal of this, like, emergent organization? organization? Like what is the goal with ultrasound money? Like if it's a business and you're an entrepreneur, like what are you, what's on the horizon? What are you trying to go towards? Right. I mean, I think the, the KPI is like how many, how many minds can we infect? And, you know, uh, this is largely kind of an educational thing is like, um, how far can we spread the meme to educate as many people as possible. And, you know, one of the metrics that we track, for example, is, you know, what we call kind of the ultrasound fam, the fam wearing the kind of the bat signal, which is the two emojis, which, you know, you're the grandfather of, which is very cool.
It's pretty cool. I am honored to have that spot. Yeah. And, you know, the fam has been growing, you know, incredibly, you know, we have 3,300 fan members, I think, right now. And it just keeps on growing at a steady rate every single day. And actually, if you want to compare it to other Ethereum memes, it's pretty striking. So for example, there's this other kind of Ethereum meme on Twitter, which is that you're going to use your ENS address as your Twitter name. So for example, Vitalik.if. And so one of the things we did is that we went ahead and scraped all of Ethereum Twitter. So that's about 3 million accounts, including kind of like the 2 million accounts that Vitalik follows.
And we found about 6,500 Twitter accounts within ENS. And so you have one of the most powerful memes, I think, in Ethereum, which is the ENS, which kind of grew to 6,500 over kind of four years. And then this ultrasound money meme, which kind of in just a matter of, you know, four, five, six months grew to over half the size. That's fantastic. Yeah. And so just for the listeners that are a little bit unfamiliar, the ultrasound money fam is if you have the bat emoji followed by the speaker emoji. Does it also work in reverse? Were you also scraping for speaker emoji and then bat emoji or does the order matter?
So there's tons of creativity and there's lots of flexibility. So it turns out there's like three different speaker emojis. There's like one with three lines, one with one line and one with zero line. People also kind of change the ordering. People sometimes kind of put a comma in between kind of open brackets, the vat and people kind of do all sorts of crazy variations like, um, you know, for example, people will use the, the, the dolphin and then the, the, the speaker because dolphins also produce emojis. I mean, I kind of like to keep the dolphin separate for the flippening. Um, so maybe, you know, at the flippening we can, uh, you know, we can all pivot for, for a day or two or a week or two.
Um, and then, you know, people change the, the, actually, I have a regular expression here on my computer, but basically people will swap out the emojis and be quite creative. And people will put it in unexpected places. So for example, people will put the bat emoji in the location, which is something that we didn't scrape. And so now we're going to need to go ahead and scrape that as well. Yeah, yeah. I didn't think I finished my thought, but what Justin is talking about is the ultrasound fam is those that have the bat and then the speaker emoji in their Twitter header, their Twitter name, right?
And so if you are part of like the ENS clan, you have like your name.eth. And then now generally it's followed by the ultrasound money, like, like bat signal, which is the bat. And then the speaker emoji, usually with three lines. And it's interesting to see on the ultrasound.money page, you have all of the top followed accounts that are Twitter accounts that are followed by people who have the ultrasound money meme in their Twitter account. And so like, it's funny to see like Anthony Susano actually recently flipped Ryan Sean Adams as the number one person with the most ultrasound money fam followers.
But I will have to say I have the met of the I have the highest ratio of followers to ultrasound follower fam on there as well. So I would like I would like people to know that. But it's a fantastic way to make a fun little game about just like putting a personal identifier on your Twitter profile, which is like kind of what that Twitter bio space is for. Yeah, I mean, one of the things that we've had is sometimes we've had kind of spam attacks. So like people, like very low quality accounts, like accounts that participate, for example, in a lot of giveaways, add the bat emoji. And so we tried to filter those off.
And one of the simplest and most powerful quality metrics that we found is basically how many FAM members does this account have that follow them? So we call them FAM followers. How many FAM followers do you have? and you know as you can see on ultrasound.money and you scroll down to to to the fam like you can clearly see that these these these when you start uh ranking the the fam members by this like the really the high quality accounts stand out um and and this is true not just for the top fam members but kind of for the whole thing um we all we all know like so what what is the purpose of the ultrasound money mean?
Like, why is that so such an important thing to like dedicate your time to? Right. So I think part of the part of the reason is basically the realization that if Ethereum is not pure technology, right, there's if you want, if you want utility, if you want things like security, if you want economic bandwidth, then the monetary aspect plays a key role. And this is something that I think the devs, myself included, very heavily underappreciate. And so what the meme is trying to do basically is educate people on the monetary aspects of Ethereum. And now, why is this important? The reason it's important is because money is a meme, right?
In order to achieve this monetary premium, this magic meme energy, you somehow need to have coordination across the community. And memes, which are basically just ideas that replicate are ideal for coordination because basically they all program us to think in the same way and so we're in a position where everyone knows that everyone else thinks the same way and so we can all kind of be on the same wavelength and be coordinated around making ETH a monetary kind of shelling point and then as I said once you have this this monetary shelling point and you you achieve high monetary premium, you're in a position where you can provide a huge amount of utility.
And one of the reasons is because you can have very, very high economic security. Basically, it will be impossible even for a nation state to attack Ethereum. And so some of the kind of code is law and immutability and kind of all these nice properties and lifeness and safety have more credibility behind them. But also because ETH is used as collateral money, the fact that the money appreciates unlocks economic bandwidth. And so if you look at, for example, MakerDAO, it's actually in a way disappointingly small. You know, it's only quote only six billion die that are that are out there, you know, especially when you compare it to to a system like USDT, which has 10 times the amount, you know, 60 billion.
And, you know, one of the key limitations is that we need this trustless collateral and we need, you know, a hundred more times, a thousand more times more collateral. And the only way to get a thousand more times more collateral is for the token to gain this monetary premium. So here's a question that I don't think has been asked before. Do you think the existence of the ultrasound money meme has or will impact the Gini coefficient of Ether? That's a hard question to just like come out of left field with you at. Okay, so while you think I'll kind of explain the Gini coefficient to users. The Gini coefficient is just a measure of like the distribution of ether, or any currency, or any unit, ever right and so if you have a strong Gini coefficient I can't remember if the Remember, if the number is high or low, it's a measure of how concentrated ownership over a certain supply of things are.
One of the best things about the Ethereum ICO, regardless of what Bitcoiners will say about it, is that the ICO actually allowed the Gini coefficient of Ether to be pretty strong for an asset that was just birthed. Usually assets that are birthed have a terrible Gini coefficient because they're in the hands of a few. But the ICO was a mechanism to distribute ether into the hands of many, many people, which is really, really important if we talk about the properties of money. It's good to have money distributed because, as we all know, it's easier to get people on board on a particular money if more people have it.
So back to the question, do you think this ultrasound money meme has impacted the future current or state of the Gini coefficient of ether? Yeah, it's a good question. I mean, I think to a large extent, kind of early adopters don't need much more conviction. You know, they already have extremely high conviction. And I think the meme maybe kind of crystallizes, expresses kind of an intuitive feeling that they had and kind of confirms. And so in that sense, hopefully, you know, it might not make these kind of early whales, you know, not want to sell anymore that they previously did not want to sell.
I mean, one of the things that I'm hoping is that kind of the meme brings on many, many more people and especially give them access, for example, to very fresh revenue sources, which will lower the Gini coefficients and in particular, staking. So, you know, with staking, we're in a position where we can really distribute ETH to many, many people. And, you know, one of the reasons is because the barrier to entry to staking is so low that anyone can participate. And the other reason is that the profit margins are very, very high. So basically, when you combine these two, anyone can come in and anyone can enjoy the fruit of staking.
Then basically, this new issuance is kind of going to dilute the existing holders. And I guess another aspect of this dilution and redistribution is basically from those who use the network to the stakers. And the reason is because part of the transaction fees will not be burnt, kind of the MEV portion. And so that is another force towards circulation of funds. Do you think that the concept of proof of stake as it's applied to Ethereum impacts the Gini coefficient or is it kind of a wash and it's just kind of doesn't actually impact it all that much? Tough questions, huh? Right. Yeah. No, these are questions I'm just kind of thinking up on the fly, but I think they're interesting to ponder about.
okay so i mean because you know again for the same argument because because staking is is really open to all and because the the profit margin is so high then then we have this this this this natural kind of redistribution of things. Yeah, it's, it's, it's very, very hard to tell basically, what percentage, like the existing holders will be staking, like one of the policies that we have at the different foundation is that we basically want to be staking roughly, as a percentage, roughly what is currently being staked. So for example, if there's 10% of relief that is staked, then the Affirm Foundation would like to stake about 10%.
And, and, and the reason we we kind of have this this kind of unofficial policy is because it gives us kind of neutrality, we're not, we're not favored, you know, we're not biased in one way or another towards staking. And so, you know, the question is, you know, are these these large holders staking more or less than the average. Um, and, uh, you know, actually, you know, just, just, uh, you know, personally, I'm, I'm staking actually a little bit less, uh, than, than, than the average, so there you go. What's the incentive? Why aren't you staking all of your ether? Like why, why haven't you just aped all the way in?
Um, I think part of the reason is that when you make the sausage, You know how it's made. And, you know, there's a bunch of tail risk, you know, that is difficult to quantify. One of the things that I've been doing at DFM Foundation is trying to build as quickly as we can, basically, a dedicated security team to really harden the beacon chain. So I think we're going to provide a little bit more transparency through blog posts and things like that. But basically, whenever you have new software, especially when you have four different clients and quite a bit of complexity, there's bound to be bugs and vulnerabilities and things like that.
And I think we're in a privileged position with the beacon chain where, as far as we can tell, no attacker has really, like no black hat attacker has tried to break this. So, you know, we have had, you know, quite, you know, significant number of reports from white hats and we've been, you know, fixing and things are definitely getting much, much better. The frequency of reports is going down. The severity of the bugs is going down. It's more and more kind of edge cases that are hard to trigger and things like that. So yeah, in general, security is one of our big goals and we're working as fast as we can to get security to a high enough level where we can actually do the merge.
It would be totally reckless to do the merge if we don't have high confidence in the beacon chain. And this confidence is increasing very rapidly. So I've been asking a lot of questions about Ether, ultrasound money, and Ethereum. And I actually want to kind of revisit the layer zero aspect of this podcast, which is more about you, the individual, but also keeping in theme with the ultrasound money meme. You talked about how the importance of the ultrasound money meme is to secure Ethereum. Right. The value of Ether implies the security of Ethereum. That is good for everyone that's building on top of Ethereum.
Therefore, the role of somebody who's working on the ultrasound money meme, it becomes really, really important. It's like if you are focused on securing Ethereum, you might actually step away from the code and actually start to work on the memes, which is kind of sounds like what you've done. And I kind of think that that is a expansion or an extrapolation of kind of like the original cypher cypherpunk vision. Right. Cypherpunks used to be all about math and code and cryptography, except now the role of what a cypherpunk is with the emergence of crypto economics has expanded into new realms.
It's like unlocked new territory that it comes into. So I kind of think of you, Justin, as like a leading new age cypherpunk. How do you feel about that? That label? Yeah, I mean, it's a very grandiose label and I'm not sure I'd put it on myself. But yeah, I'd agree that the economic aspect has unlocked this new design space. And actually there's these impossibility results. There's certain things that we just can't do with cryptography alone. And so we need to make these concessions. When we have the protocol sync thesis, cryptography and math are like one of the lowest layers you know they're super robust and then you have to have like the more mushy layers which is the the economics but you know having the the these two layers combined like the really hard layer and the the mushy one gives you like these these these superpowers um and uh yeah this this is something that i've i've only you know I appreciate it, I guess, relatively recently.
And I mean, I guess one of the reasons why I'm working at this layer is because there's a little bit of taboo and resistance, I guess, from other technical people. You know, I feel like I'm in a unique position to be doing the work that I'm doing, partly because no one else is really keen to do that work. You know, it's kind of seen a little bit as dirty work. but I kind of see it as very important. We in the bankless world, we often use like the pioneer as a metaphor. It's like, come on, we're all going West, like grab your favorite leader and go West with them. It sounds like that you are specifically trying to be like the pioneer for the other like code and math and technical minded people, specifically trying to like corral them and being like, no guys, like this is the way, this is where we're going.
Like, let's all go westward. Yeah, right. I mean, it's not like I kind of pioneered and completely invented this idea that the memes are super important. You know, like, it turns out that this goes back, you know, even to gold, right? Gold is just, to a very large extent, just a meme. And Bitcoin took it to an extreme, you know, like really emphasizing the memes. and you know I you know in the Bitcoin land there was this kind of this debate should we do small block, big block and I think both sides have very very good arguments you know and I think the big mistake of Bitcoiners is thinking in very kind of black and white is like either one or the other but it turns out that it's both right like we want the transactional utility.
And, you know, how do we get this transactional utility? We get it with scalability, with privacy, you know, with programmability, with economic bandwidth and all these things. But, you know, in addition kind of to the raw transactional utility, you also want kind of the monetary premium and all the memes. And these things are actually symbiotic. They reinforce each other. And the reason is that in order to achieve monetary premium, you need to distinguish yourself in some way or another. And one way to distinguish yourself is basically to maximize utility. If you are the substrate for the Internet of Value and you're settling the world economy, then you become the natural shelling point to become this money for the Internet.
and vice versa you know once you once you've achieved this monetary premium as i already mentioned that provides utility for the utility in the sense that it provides security and economic economic bandwidth hey guys i hope you're enjoying the conversation with justin drake so far coming up in the second half of the conversation we talk about both ether and ethereum's march towards capital efficiency and what that means for the holistic system if we always are going towards more and more efficiency. We also talk about the quantum computing threat as it relates to both Ethereum, but also more importantly towards Bitcoin as the thing that can't really adapt or change or overcome obstacles.
And then we also talk about what Justin Drake thinks about the current state of the layer zero of Ethereum and also where he thinks it's going to develop into the long term and where he hopes it develops into the long term. We also talk about layers three and layers for what those are and how they relate to the layer one and the layer zero. I thought that was a particularly interesting topic of conversation and there's a call to action to any graphic designers who are interested in in illustrating this concept in a in a actual design that we can actually look all look at. So there's that. And we also talked about Justin Drake's kid, and also Justin Drake himself and his lack of identity with any one specific nation state or any one specific culture and how that is a result of how he grew up and how that relates to what he works on on Ethereum.
He has a distaste for politics, yet we all know that governance is a part of this thing. So we parse apart those details. We also talk about Justin Drake's non-laptop related hobbies and turns out he likes to tinker on the piano. And even that has something to talk about as it relates to Ethereum. So I hope you guys are enjoying this conversation. The second half of the show, in my opinion, is even more fun than the first. So let's go ahead and get right into it. But first, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange.
I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got into crypto in 2017, and it's been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys and sells. Gemini is available in all 50 states and in over 50 countries worldwide. And on Gemini, there are markets for over 30 various different crypto assets, including many of the hot DeFi tokens. And it's one of the few exchanges that has liquid die markets. Gemini just launched their Earn program, where you can earn up to 7.4% interest on 26 various crypto assets. If you're tired of paying fees in DeFi, or you don't want to worry about DeFi exploits, but you still want to earn interest on your crypto assets, Gemini Earn is the product for you.
Another product I'm stoked to get my hands on is the Gemini Crypto Back credit card, which gives you 3% cash back on all of your purchases, but paid to you in your preferred crypto asset. When I get my Gemini credit card, I'm going to make sure that I get my cash back in ETH. So whenever I buy something, I get a little bit of ETH bonus back to me at the same time. You can open up a free account in under three minutes at gemini.com slash gobankless. And if you trade more than $100 within the first 30 days after signup, you'll be gifted a free $15 Bitcoin bonus. Check them out at gemini.com slash gobankless.
The Aave protocol is a decentralized liquidity protocol on Ethereum, which allows users to supply and borrow certain crypto assets. Aave version 2 has a ton of cool features that makes using the Aave protocol even more powerful. With Aave, you can leverage the full power of DeFi money legos, yield, and composability all in one application. On Aave, there are a ton of assets that you can supply to the protocol in order to gain yield and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have supplied collateral here you can see me borrowing 200 usdc against my portfolio of a number of different defy tokens in eth i'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than the stable interest rate option but i could choose the stable interest rate option if i wanted to lock in that interest rate in permanently v2 also features the ability for users to swap collateral without having to to withdraw their assets, trade them on Uniswap, and then deposit them back into Aave.
With Aave, users can do this in one seamless transaction, saving you time and gas costs. Check out the power of Aave at aave.com. That's A-A-V-E dot com. After having our first and second podcast with you, the first being Moon Math, all about cryptography, and the second being all about ultrasound money, My mind has actually kind of become convinced that like the only viable crypto economic system is a smart contract enabled system, which promotes utility and actually promotes like the reasoning for using the thing in the first place. And then also proof of stake, because it's also the system that requires the least amount of operational costs to secure.
And so I feel like if we go in through and we're living in a simulation and we run through all the possible simulations, we will end up at a smart contract proof of stake system every single time. Do you agree with that? So it turns out there's like some technical reasons as to why, for example, smart contracts are not necessarily fully required. And the reason is because once you have the data availability layer, and once the blockchain has one single functionality, which is the ability to verify snarks, you can do everything because you can do ZK rollups. But, you know, I guess that's just a minor technical detail.
Is that also the future of Ethereum in your mind? Is that where we're going as an ecosystem? I think it's definitely possible. The reason is that in the short and medium term, we're taking this roll-up approach. And I believe that the long-term winners are going to be the ZK roll-ups. But one of the problems with Ethereum, which is one of its greatest strengths, but also one of its weaknesses, is the EVM. The EVM has so many, many quirks and it's arguably badly designed in many, many different ways. And each of these ways are not a deal breaker, but there's like a laundry list of 200 issues with the EVM and they start to add up.
And so one of the things we've been looking into is like, is there a replacement for the EVM? And it turns out that once you have snarks, you can basically have arbitrary VMs. And this is something that we're starting to see. Like, for example, Stockware came up with Cairo and kind of their own VM. And then, you know, like there's the Matterlabs. They have their own zk-sync. And so in theory, at least, you can take any VM, for example, Wasm, and then you can snarkify it. and then you can start running it on the EVMs simply by verifying the snarks. And so this has actually two advantages. One is that you get the scalability of ZK rollups.
You just have to verify one single snark, which is very, very cheap. But the other advantage is that you get to escape the EVM. It's kind of this wormhole Right. That allows you to go explore a different portal into a different VM. Right. Exactly. So I think this is definitely a possible future. One of the things that we're heavily considering is basically if and when we have a VM, which really stands out, for example, is really, really snark friendly, meaning that it has very, very good performance in this snarkification world. And it has all sorts of other advantages. maybe it's more dev-friendly like Wasm, or maybe it's more friendly to formal verification, or maybe it's more friendly to optimistic approaches, or whatever it is, then we can take this awesome VM and kind of enshrine it at layer one.
So that could give us various advantages like a natural shelling point to avoid too much fracturing of the ecosystem. It could provide lower latency. It could maybe provide better security guarantees. It could provide maybe performance optimizations. There's all sorts of things that get unlocked once you're happy to enshrine a VM. But I think at this point in time, we're very, very happy with the situation we're in where we have the EVM. Okay, it's not perfect, but it's the natural shutting point for all smart contracts way beyond Ethereum. And so there's this very powerful network effect. DVM is good enough in the sense that it unlocks all these parallel worlds that you can go explore through snarkified VMs.
And then maybe in the more distant future, we can enshrine a really awesome VM. Maybe have one instance running per shard or something like that. So I know that there's a small ideological debate going on between, I think, you, Vitalik, and a few other of the core Ethereum contributors about like the long-term expressivity of Ethereum. I remember you once upon a time submitted an EIP to instantiate the ETH price at the protocol level. And then also in our episode, our first cryptography moon math episode, you talked about like staggering all of the shards so that there's one shard, making it finalizing every like one second.
So you actually get really quick finality over time. And so like you seem to be looking towards Ethereum with kind of like a high touch approach. Let's just turn this like machine that we have into the most like decently complicated, well-oiled, like fantastically like capable machine where others, I think Vitalik is more in the camp of just like, let's just make it what we need and then stop touching it. Do you see this as a future issue that some of the core Ethereum contributors are going to have to like get into a table and like discuss about what they want to do Or, or where does this story go?
Yeah. So just a couple of things, like one is that, uh, you know, the, the stacker rig is something that this, this consensus on, I didn't know that. I'm going to go. Yeah. There's something is likely going to go ahead with, um, I mean, actually there's, there's, there's, I think much more alignments than, than, than you kind of portrayed it there. Okay. I think everyone wants maximum simplicity and basically just build what's enough. And so I think everyone falls into the Vitalik kind of camp and philosophy. I think the real debate is, you know, what do we really need? And like one of my heuristics, I guess, is that if you can't do it at layer one, we should very, very seriously consider doing it at, if you can't do it at layer two, very seriously consider it doing it at layer one.
And trustless oracles is, it turns out to be one of those things. Like as far as I know, there's no really like fully trustless way of doing oracles at layer two. Like the best that we have is Chainlink. And, you know, while Chainlink might be kind of good enough, in the short and medium term? Is it really kind of the long-term technical solution that we want to power stable coins like liquidity and stuff like that? I mean, I think the answer is maybe it's good enough, but it's not a convincing answer. And so on the other hand, we don't want to enshrine all our calls on the one that doesn't make any sense.
And so really what you want to be doing is you want to look at this kind of this long tail and you want to you want a solution with like kind of 1% of the complexity that gains you 80% of the value. And I think if we were to enshrine one single oracle, it would probably be kind of the ETHUSD price. And it turns out that you can kind of leverage the basic security assumptions that we're making at layer one to get an oracle with very, very similar security assumptions. And so if you're using Ethereum, you don't have to pay more in terms of security assumptions if you want to use this oracle. Whereas if you're using Chainlink, now suddenly you have two assumptions.
One is you're paying the platform of Ethereum, but you're also paying the platform risk of Chainlink. How would the US dollar price of Ether actually become instantiated in the protocol? What's the technical process behind that? Right. So one way to do it, for example, is with committees. So we have this, for example, this honesty assumption in a theorem where we assume that, you know, half the stake is honest. And what we do is that we sample committees which are large enough to be statistically representative of a wider population. And then these committees of so-called attesters are going to go vote on various things.
And we basically assume that if the majority of the committee members vote on something, then that's reflective of the wider population. And it's kind of true. And so we could have these committees basically vote on what they think is the price of US dollar. I mean, the big problem here is that basically the price of ETH in US dollars is subjective. and and and kind of one of our design goals is to be kind of world war iii resistant right and there's kind of some of these edge cases where like there there is legitimately a definitional question as to what the usd is so for example in argentina there's kind of um there's the kind of two market rates for the argentinian peso there's kind of i forget what it's called but like blue market and black market or whatever um and so if you're if you're in a situation where you know the the us economy goes crumbling there could be a lot of chaos and we don't want this kind of chaos around the us dollar to be a systemic risk for for ethereum right um there's also the topic of just like the us dollar is an arbitrary anchor in of itself right like the choice to include the dollar is also subjective in the first place so i think maybe maybe the big debate behind this thing is It's like, do we even include subjectivity into the layer one at all?
Right, exactly. Like the simple approach, the purest approach is to say just no subjectivity whatsoever. But yeah, I mean, if you look at a deterministic virtual machine, it's extremely powerful, right? It's too incomplete. It has everything, but actually it doesn't have all the superpowers that you want. And more specifically, it doesn't have the oracles. Now, there's various types of oracles that are very, very familiar to a computer. Like if you take a phone, for example, it's aware of things like what is the time. It's also able to gather randomness. It's also able to pick up the temperature or whatever.
Now, in the context of, you know, decentralized finance, for example, and the Internet of Value, knowing what the time is, is very important. Having access to randomness is very important. And the blockchain being aware of its own price, I would argue, is also very important. I mean, we are definitely improving in terms of these oracles. So, for example, EIP-1559 gives us an oracle. more specifically, it gives us a base fee oracle. So basically the block devm is aware of itself as to how valuable its block space is. And I think we need to- In Ether terms, yeah. In Ether terms, exactly. And so the more we have like these really important oracles, I think the more complete the devm will be.
Interesting. That's a fantastic. Are there any other like parts of like the Ethereum future roadmap that is are kind of like up for debate as it comes to like high touch versus low touch styles right um i mean i i think one thing that we have a kind of consensus on is that we need to do a quantum upgrade this is not negotiable i mean some some people will say oh and i mean this is a diminishing population but some some people will say quantum computers will never arrive they kind kind of skeptics. And our position is that even in that scenario, which is not the consensus within kind of quantum physicists, that we still need protection against quantum computers.
And the reason is because that blockchains are meant to be these ultra conservative pieces of infrastructure. And, you know, we need at least kind of 10 years of heads up in order to do all the upgrades, because these things are very, very slow to upgrade, especially if in, let's say, five, 10 years, Ethereum has a $10 trillion market cap, it is going to be especially difficult to change it. And so this is one of the actually high touch kind of things that we need to do, like taking out the guts, the cryptographic guts and changing them for post-quantum cryptography could have quite big consequences.
In terms of where there's still kind of debate, I mean, one of the big ones which we talked about is basically, do we want to enshrine a VM other than the EVM? And I'm leaning towards yes. And part of the reason why I'm leaning towards yes is that um you know the the power of innovation is is is so huge and we've only just scratched the surface in terms of vms that are custom designed for blockchains um and you know we've also just scratched the surface in terms of vms custom designed for snarkification and and and for more verification and things like that and so i'm i'm optimistic that uh you know in in five, 10 years time, the EVM will look completely outdated and it will kind of be kind of, it will kind of be stupidly obvious.
There'll be this natural shelling point that, yes, this is, this is like 10, a hundred times better. And we should just all adopt, adopt this new thing and, and shining it at layer one will, will help achieve this, this, this shelling point. I mean, another thing that you, you brought up is, you know this this this this idea of a parallel universe where um you know proof of stake is a necessity because it's the most economically efficient eip 1559 is a necessity because it's the most economically efficient um and it's it's it's definitely possible that we'll find ways to be even more economically efficient than we are today and like um one um one possible way to do that would be to find a way to burn the MEV.
Now, this is kind of an alpha leak. I don't know when your podcast will go out. Three weeks. Okay. So in three weeks, it will definitely be published. So basically, we have this kind of MEV intern, which we hired kind of three months ago. And it's quite possible that he actually cracked MEV, which is a huge... That's a massive statement. Cracking MEV? Yeah. Yeah, yeah. So basically... That's like stuff that dreams are made of. Oh, yeah. Kind of totally out of left field, he came up with this super simple kind of genius idea to basically do what's called MEV smoothing. So the big problem of MEV is that it's highly volatile and spiky.
And this spikiness basically is a liability for the security of the consensus layer. And so if you can smooth out the MEV, suddenly it starts becoming very similar to issuance, right this grade a fuel which you can be you can rely upon and it's kind of injected at a constant rate and so basically his idea is when you produce a block like all the mev shouldn't go to the block producer it should actually go to all the validators that help get this block on chain namely the block proposer and all the committee members that are voting to include that to basically attest in a position where actually the MEV is spread out, is kind of smoothed over the whole committee.
And so, you know, that actually turns MEV from a liability into an asset, right? From a security standpoint. It just turns into staking yields, right? Yeah, it turns into something very, very similar to issuance. So MEV today is already staking yields, but it's like highly volatile yields. And this volatility basically incentivizes reorgs and forking and very nasty things. Once you're in a position where you smooth things out, then it's kind of really the position you want to be in to maximize security. And so another consequence of this idea is that potentially we could burn the MEV. So we'd be in a position where the protocol kind of has some knowledge, you know, very similar to this Oracle idea, right?
the not only is the evm aware of the base fees but it's also aware of how much muv there is because it's capturing it and spreading it to the whole committees and so we're potentially in a position where we can burn the muv and so we could take kind of the the ultrasoundness as it were to the next level where um you know right now like the the data suggests that the the fee burn is about 70%. So of all the fees, we're burning 70%. Well, maybe we can burn this extra, you know, 30% as well. So we can approach 100% of the burn rate of transaction fees. Yeah, potentially. I mean, I don't want to oversell this right now, because it's still kind of early research.
But yeah, at least the aspect of turning MEV from a liability to an asset seems very, very promising. And there'll be an e-research post coming soon. And this kind of speaks to the DAO nature of Ethereum. The word DAOs are kind of misused when we talk about them nowadays, like bankless DAO, Uniswap DAO, not a DAO, just a digital organization. The only two DAOs that I think are truly functioning at this point in time are Bitcoin and Ethereum. Those are the DAOs as in the they are decentralized, and they're autonomous, and there's some emergent bottom up organization. And like the the direction of the Ethereum DAO tends to always go towards efficiency, right.
And so if you're telling me that we like, we're working towards efficiency and security, and this is just another innovation that we've been able to unlock that lens towards that idea. And all know that like d5 is on a relentless march towards capital efficiency of the assets that finds that find themselves inside of d5 and so like and so like going back to that like if we run the simulation over and over and over again the block the crypto economic system that makes it that you discover the right whatever we call it ethereum or whatever name we want to to name this in these different universes the number one thing that you will find inside of every simul every uh trial of the simulation is that each economic system gravitates towards efficient maximum efficiency every single step of the way yeah absolutely i mean another way to rephrase that is just trying to absorb innovation as much as possible um and i think one of the the killer features um of ethereum is uh you know kind of turing completeness is this this awesome innovation sponge right and the reason is that you can you can build any program you want on on the EVM.
But yeah, like the other aspect of this innovation sponge are, you know, the throughput from a data standpoint, you know, we're improving that greatly with shouting. There's also the economic security aspect, which we've talked at length, and we're improving. And then there's also the monetary aspect, which we've talked at length. And it turns out that in each of these four directions, we're just making incremental progress and we're very, very open to absorbing the innovation. And I think that's partly kind of, I think one of your previous questions was where, for example, is there disagreement within DEF?
I think that there is some disagreement as to when Ethereum will be considered kind of done. Like my kind of gut feel is that we've only had 13 years of blockchain innovation and there's at least another 20 years of very, very fruitful kind of exponential kind of innovation. And that, you know, most likely Ethereum won't be kind of totally done, you know, anytime soon. And, you know, the quantum threat aspect, one of the good things about it is that it's widely accepted. And so even the Bitcoin has kind of accepted, kind of the ossification maximalists will accept it. And so it's, I think that might be kind of one of the last times where we do it.
So if we assume, for example, the quantum computers will arrive in 30 years, or let's say 25 years, then in, in, in, let's say in 15 years, um, this will be kind of our last chance to get all, all the good gadgets that we want. And thanks to this, this kind of forced massive revamping of the system because of quantum computers and external ice age, if you will. Yeah. Um, right. Exactly. You said that even Bitcoiners tend to accept the quantum threat. But Nick, have you heard of Nick Carter's FUD dice? Oh, yes, yes, yes. I love his FUD dice, yes. But he has quantum computing on the FUD dice. Yes, absolutely.
Why are they on the FUD dice if you say that Bitcoiners are generally accepting of the quantum threat? Yeah, okay, interesting. I think the reason why it's on the FUD dice is because Nick Carter is myopic. And the reason that he's myopic is that he only thinks kind of 10, 20 years into the future. Like, you know, another kind of similar issue is the low issuance. Like, OK, low issuance is not really a big deal. You know, we'll just kick the can and we'll think about it in 20 to 30 years. And, you know, I think that that attitude is actually OK if you're happy to embrace innovation, because basically you're saying if there is some massive innovation in the next 20 years, which is very, very likely because we live in this exponential innovation world, then we can just go grab the fruits and do the upgrade.
But, you know, you can't have this this this relaxed attitude if you say that, you know, whatever was created on day one is what we're going to have for the rest of time. I mean, when I say that quantum is accepted, it's like I don't think the stance of the Bitcoin technical community is that quantum computers will never come hence it's not a threat i think they they do acknowledge that they will come um but the reason why they consider it fud is because it's you know it's it's so far in the distance and and in that sense they're a little myopic interesting to me if you put uh quantum computing on the flood dice and you think that bitcoin bitcoin can overcome that via technological changes like you're committing to a hard fork would you agree with that assumption yeah i mean you can do all sorts of crazy gymnastics with soft forks you know if that's the technical distinction that you're you're putting forward um so you know soft forks and hot forks are not too dissimilar and from a capability standpoint but yes like some sort of massive fork that radically changes bitcoin yes um and not just from a technical standpoint it's it's also fundamentally a social thing why is it a social thing the reason is that there's lost coins and we need to decide what to do with these lost coins like part of the the bitcoin ethos is we're not going to do any kind of rescue and actually this is very very similar to the dao The problem with the DAO was that you had one single entity, the DAO attacker, which had control over, let's say, I forget what it is exactly, but let's say 10% of the supply, like a huge amount of the ETH supply.
And here, it's basically would be a similar situation. A quantum attacker, which could be a single entity or maybe a small handful of entities, could have control over 10% of the Bitcoin supply, this 10% being all the lost Bitcoins. And it's interesting because, you know, if the Bitcoiners are going to be kind of intellectually consistent with the past observations, they would reject the idea of confiscating these coins and just destroying them. They'd say, oh, no, code is law. And, you know, the Bitcoin script was cracked. And, you know, we just need to run the scripts as they're programmed.
And 10% of the supply is going to go to this quantum attacker. But of course, you know, this is just impractical, especially if you want to be like, you know, money for the world economy. If you're going to have $100 trillion of monetary energy stored in the Bitcoin network, it's kind of inconceivable for a single entity to have $10 trillion. You know, kind of half the size of the M3 supply of the US dollar or something. It doesn't make sense. Yes. Interestingly, it would go all of those 10 percent of the bitcoins would go to a single entity that would have the maximum amount of like like hashing power, which is kind of like equivalent to a proof of work.
Right. But instead of going through the actual proof of work route, you're just you're just running proof of work through private keys. Right. Now you're just doing it with quantum computers, which is interesting to think about how like the other way to get a bunch of bitcoins is to like maximize your computational compower but now it's just in a in a quantum uh field i mean yeah you're right it's kind of stretching the analogy but yeah it's interesting points but yeah it's no it's around it's round about proof of work unintentional proof of work yeah not intended proof of work but if you take your comment literally there's actually this is a very deep observation which is that proof of work is broken on the quantum computers.
If you have sufficiently advanced quantum computers, then proof of work is essentially broken. And so, one of the long-term ideas of how Bitcoin is secured is basically you have these ASICs, Moore's law is broken, so that that is basically equivalent to proof of stake, where you have a fairly homogenous distribution of these ASICs. And it turns out that this vision is going to get potentially disrupted by quantum computers in the sense that all the ASICs will become worthless from one day to another. and you have to go through the same growth phase and maturation phase that we've gone through.
So in the traditional silicon world, there's been four kind of maturation phase for proof of work. We've got one from CPUs to GPUs to FPGAs and then ASICs and then kind of the end of Moore's law kind of ASICs, I guess five phases. And then as soon as you change the paradigm, you know, in this quantum paradigm, then suddenly you go back to almost the genesis from a security standpoint where proof of work is, just like Satoshi was the only miner at the very beginning, at the very beginning of this quantum era, there's going to be a single miner. And yes, there is going to be the difficulty adjustment and things like that, but your decentralization is basically going to go down to zero.
Yeah, it's just going to be a complete reset of the entire proof of work system, right? It's going to start from day one again. Exactly, yes. And Bitcoiners will say this is fun because maybe one of the observations is that you need quantum computers, which are potentially much more advanced than the ones that can break the private key. So, you know, it's maybe an extra 10 or 20 years after these first generation quantum computers. But, you know, it's still very much a possibility that they will come and reset the proof of work. I want to pivot the conversation back to layer zero. So you used to be a layer one engineer, and now I kind of view you as like a layer zero engineer.
So with thinking into the long term about the layer zero of Ethereum of this community that we're all part of, do you have any like long term projections or wishes for the layer zero of Ethereum? What do you want it to turn into? Interesting. I mean, you know, I really like the layer zero of today. I think the Ethereum community and culture is just so great. And I think there is a risk of dilution, right? As soon as you grow, then you might dilute. But there's potentially a way out, which is basically abstraction. Like if we're in a position where many, many billions of people can use Ethereum without without even knowing that they're using Ethereum, then they'd be in, they'd effectively be at layer two, but they're not at layer zero.
You know how I said that, you know, we're going full circle basically between layer zero and layer two, because it's kind of people on both sides, but actually these are different people. Like you can be part of the community and not a user and vice versa. You can be a user and not part of the community. So I think the ideal scenario is basically where the layer zero grows very significantly, but the quality stays very high. And I think there is actually a possibility to do that. And basically the filter is geekiness or intellectual curiosity. very difficult to get into ethereum if you're not very multidisciplinary and intellectually curious um and so you kind of the in a way the the the barrier to entry is maybe relatively high and that could be kind of a filter and then everyone else who just wants to use ethereum for its utilitarian values can just use it without understanding and so i guess it's very similar to planes like everyone uses planes but i guess the plane community like the ultra geeks who knows how every single button in the cockpit and how the engines are made in the jets and things like that.
That's probably a very special community, which is relatively small and pure in that sense. It seems to be that with that perspective, the whole purpose of Ethereum is to let a a thousand layer zeros be born on top of layer two, right? So like infinity layer threes, if you will, just infinity communities built on top of layer twos, which are built on top of layer ones, which were built on top of the Ethereum community, which is like the layer zero. I see what you mean. Okay, so tons of communities built on top of layer two. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Each one with its own sets of values and principles, which they're allowed to choose from because Ethereum allowed them to choose from the full set of all values and principles because that's the value and principles of the layer zero.
Yes, I like that. I mean, maybe we could call it layer four. And the reason is because in my mental model, kind of layer three is the service layer, right? So you need all this middleware between kind of the, the, the smart contract and the user, um, that was just kind of layer layer three. And so for example, Coinbase is layer three, right there, there, they're kind of connected to the blockchain. They make deposits and withdrawals and also things, but they provide this, this, this service. And then I guess layer four would be the, the, the, the, the communities that are built on top of that.
Whoever, if there's anyone listening who wants to turn this into a graphic, Especially if you're in the bankless DAO. I'll tip 5,000 bank to whoever's in the bankless DAO who wants to turn this into a graphic so we can deliberate about this on Twitter. Justin, I want to go into a little bit more detail about what you get up to. I'm sure like many people in the Ethereum world, you're more or less a workaholic. And so you're probably in front of your computer, like, I don't know, anywhere between six and 18 hours a day. But when you close the lid of your laptop, like what happens next in your life?
Like, what do you go do? Right. So that is correct. I am a workaholic, which is great in the sense that I love what I do, but it definitely has downsides in terms of health, for example, and just friendships outside of work and things like that. But, you know, I do have a family. So I've been married for six years and I have a young kid. And, you know, I guess a lot of my time is just being a parent, you know, just spending time with my kid, dropping him to school and teaching him, you know, stuff. Like today, for example, we were flying a quadcopter. You know, I'm at my parents' house. and like kind of teaching him, you know, what goes into a quadcopter.
For example, the fact that the specific quadcopter that we have has a GPS and it uses GPS so that if there's a bit of wind, it doesn't drift away. It kind of stays where it is. And so I explained to him that basically there's these, you know, satellites that every second produce a pulse. And then all these different, you know, satellites are slightly, the pulses come at slightly different times. And then the GPS chip will kind of analyze when the pulses are received. And then using that, it can determine its position. And so, I guess it's just distilling a lot of the complicated technology that I've enjoyed learning kind of on my own and passing it on to my son.
Is he a technically inclined individual? Does he like all the... I I mean, all boys to some degree love gadgets. What part of like Justin Drake, the cypherpunk, do you see in this kid? How old is he? He's six. Six, okay. So yeah, he's, you know, I mean, maybe every parent will say that, but he's pretty sharp. And he's capable to appreciate many different things. like at one point he was he was really into mathematics and I think partly because of mimetic desire you know like I you know someone told him that I studied mathematics and then he wanted to do some mathematics and then like but now it looks like it seems like he he he's he's moving on like no now he's really into art and and crafty things and and stuff like that he's also very much into languages.
So my family is kind of extremely international. So like, I, I, to kind of illustrate this, I say to people that I was born in the UK from a British dad and an Argentinian mother. And then we, we lived in China and I'm also Italian by, by, by blood. And you know, my, my wife is Russian and she speaks Japanese, which is what she studied at university and so he he's kind of inherited this this this international aspect um you know through through learning all sorts of different languages um so he has one for example grandmother who's who speaks to him in french and then another grandmother who speaks to him in russian and then i speak to him in in in in english and and and stuff like that with and he really appreciates uh i guess the you know being read you know books in different languages and uh yeah that is hilariously appropriate for somebody who's like working on the layer zero of ethereum to have like a such a diverse background of culture that like you don't actually have one specific culture that is like the most resonant thing with ethereum that i can actually think of yeah and i've kind of I've almost lost this nation state identity in the sense that I don't even speak a single language without an accent.
So I lived roughly half my life in France, from one years old to 14 years old. And when I was 14, I guess I would consider myself kind of French. And then I went to live in China and then I came back to the UK and I studied there and I've spent 14 years now in the UK. And, you know, I can't really say that I feel like I'm a true Brit or a true Frenchie. I'm just a citizen of the world, I guess. And this is even more true where, you know, I adhere to, I guess, the bankless nation, right? This is my nationality. and I also try to detach myself from the nation state I feel it's a very early idea but the idea of network state from Balaji is just so mind-blowing and this is something some sort of a meme I want to contribute towards maybe in 20 or 30 years I could see myself trying to build a network state with all the infrastructure that we're building today.
Yeah, well, I think with this massive like regulation conversation that has arisen lately, like it's only going to accelerate the desire for people to have the options to opt out of their like nation state identities. Like I would never, I don't really consider myself like a patriot. I don't fly the United States flag. And I think a lot of younger generations resonate with that inside of the United States where like being a proud supporter of America is like no longer cool for a large part of the population and we're kind of looking towards online identities to like find to fill that niche right to fill that void right um i mean i personally really dislike politics and i try to minimize it in my life um and you know i think governance is is a fundamental part of layer zero but what i what i like about blockchains is this govern governance minimization right so you know it it could be argued that governance has you know in the lifetime of a firm only really kind of stuck its neck out you know in in a big way once which was for the dow um you know let's hope that this this these kind of events don't happen very often and ideally just just just this one time and really try to to to minimize the decisions that the humans have to make and maximize the the just the autonomous programmable you know inspectable whatever um i think i think it's very very telling that when we talk about it at the nation state level we call it politics but when we talk about it at the crypto economic level we call it governance which is like the governance has a purpose politics is a game and everyone hates politics but uh governance is like it's like this the the chores like just you got to brush your teeth you got to fold your laundry you got to do your laundry you got to participate in governance but if we can minimize governance it's just like minimizing all the chores that we have to do every single like week of our lives yeah absolutely um and i think governance kind of highlights the utilitarian aspect of it right we want to do upgrades upgrades are fundamental because we live in this in this exponential world and also because we need to fix the various bugs um whereas you know as you say politics is just it's just become a kind of a show really right right i mean a meat space show yeah depending on every every person has their interpretation of politics and it's generally always negative um okay so going back to my original question like when you close your laptop and what you get up to uh but excluding your family say justin justin drake has some like alone time some justin some justin time what is what's justin time look like okay um i mean one of the things that i that i do is uh improvise on the piano really so shit um so you know i i used to take uh you know a piano lesson so when i was younger but uh you know, I kind of find it constraining to have to adhere to what's written on the page and the specific notes.
And so, you know, at one point I was like, you know, I just want to do my own stuff. And I think creativity is one of the things that, you know, I do a lot in my daily job and, you know, I guess it makes sense to try and reflect that in the music. But yeah, So it took me some time to basically have the confidence. You know, at first I was just playing random notes. It was kind of a genetic algorithm, right? I was playing these random notes, but then suddenly I started making patterns. And then I started making kind of these small snippets. And then now I'm in a position where, you know, I can go on the piano and just improvise for hours.
do you have you uh do you connect those dots between like your uh lack of interest of being aligned to a nation state which is generally like a top-down ideology to like your lack of interest of being taught how to play piano and rather your desire to like be more creative and improvise do you connect those two things at all or or or any other like aspects of your life that fit into that pattern no yeah absolutely i've i've always been a little rebellious um you know even in the french education system like the the french education system is very very top down and rule driven and kind of bureaucratic and whatnot and uh i i just uh very naturally just went against the the the the the rules i mean i mean sometimes you know i had a teacher which would kind of embrace this aspect of me so you know there was this story where i mean it's a little oh shame to say it but basically there's uh the my my teacher as i had in kind of in in middle school and my brother asked like was there any kind of genius in in your in your class uh so he has a teacher and the teacher said no no there was no one and and then she said oh actually maybe that i did have one genius but only in one specific domain which was the mathematics and that that was, you know, me.
And, and the reason she thought I was a genius is because I was, I'm not, I'm not, not, not really a genius, but the reason why I gave the impression that I was a genius is because whenever there was a math problem, I would solve it in a completely different way than the way I was taught. So basically it was kind of a roundabout way. And, and the teacher didn't really understand what I was doing, but she always said, Justin came up, always came up with the right answer, but kind of the wrong method. And she kind of embraced that and was fine with it. But a lot of other teachers in the French education didn't like it so much.
And so that caused a little bit of tension, I guess. It's really interesting to connect this. Again, this podcast is called Layer Zero. And so we have this like non-nation state identified rebel who likes to be creative and route around problems to discover the right answer like too many of these things are lining up with like how uh ethereum and crypto economic networks like operate at scale at large like throughout the layer ones and and the layer twos and like part of my goals with this podcast with layer zero is to like discover the ways that like the dna of of humans and the neurons of humans relates to the code that we write uh and so i'm seeing a massive like direct one-to-one connection with like kind of the the stories that you're telling me and how like these, this whole entire industry is like built upon.
Yeah. I mean, I'll say that I also have kind of a, a bit of a hacker mindset. You know, I try to find the vulnerabilities. I try to find the cracks. I try to take a route which no one expects and is kind of hidden. And you know, I, I'm kind of the proudly have a kind of a $1,000 bounty for, for reporting a pretty bad Google Chrome vulnerability that could basically allow an attacker to basically take screenshots of your desktop remotely. But I also kind of use this hacker mindset in research, right? Because in research, oftentimes you have a problem and it looks like there's some sort of impossibility result, like you can't do something.
And the way that you escape impossibility results is kind of by redefining the problem or redefining the assumptions. You really don't want to take for granted things that other people took for granted and basically relax the problem in very subtle ways where suddenly you open up a design space. And so, yeah, this is something that I like doing is kind of taking something where people seem stuck. You know, they're not they're no longer making progress. They thought about it for a long time and they believe it's impossible. And then kind of coming in with fresh eyes and saying and a new perspective and saying, actually, if you tweak your your viewpoint just a little bit, there is a way around it.
interesting fantastic well Justin Drake it's been a wonderful time having you on layer zero and I hope this is not the last time that we hear we talk about this and all these subjects and I hope to have you back for more fantastic thanks for having me cheers hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a Bankless Premium subscriber to get the most out of your Bankless experience.
You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless Premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings, and weekly roll-ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the Bankless Nation.