Is the U.S going to be ok?
Mike Solana (no relation to Solana the chain, that’s his name),is the editor-in-chief of Pirate Wires and the guy who broke the Trump Memecoin news.
We brought him on the show today to try to make sense of the current state of politics in the face of the upcoming election, and what it all means for crypto.
Expect to learn why tech has pivoted right, why democrats are cracking down on crypto, why media in 2024 is fundamentally broken and much more.
------ 🎬 DEBRIEF | Ryan & David Unpacking the Episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-the-mike-solana-interview
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/27?referrer=0x077Fe9e96Aa9b20Bd36F1C6290f54F8717C5674E
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦄UNISWAP | BROWSER EXTENSION https://bankless.cc/uniswap
⚡️ CARTESI | LINUX-POWERED ROLLUPS https://bankless.cc/CartesiGovernance
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle ⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT https://bankless.cc/toku
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 7:10 $DJT Memecoin 16:36 Crypto Politics 29:39 Mike’s Perspective on Crypto 34:12 Memetic Wars 37:58 Growth vs Degrowth 43:22 Information Wars 53:35 Social Media 1:01:52 Being Terminally Online 1:14:18 Media in 2024 1:26:30 2024 Election 1:31:15 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Mike Solana https://x.com/micsolana
Pirate Wires Daily https://get.piratewires.com/pw/daily
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
What do I see? I see some like scammy gamblers, which whatever they're saying they're that now. So I like that better. I see a lot of scammy gamblers. I see a handful of people working on things that I think could be really cool and I think that's really nice. And then you still see a bunch of people sort of being dishonest, like looking for a solution to a problem that doesn't exist and pretending they're working on something that doesn't really actually matter and all they really want to do is launch a coin and make some money. And those are my least favorite of all the groups. Welcome to Bankless, where today we explore the frontier of tech, culture and politics.
Maybe some crypto sprinkled into. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless. The guest today is Mike Salana. That was no relation to the Salana chain. That's just his last name. We do discuss that. Yeah, we did. He is the editor of the pirate wires. He's the guy that broke the recent Trump coin news. This is a Donald J Trump and we start the conversation on that interestingly enough. He doubled down on his take that the Donald J Trump coin was actually associated with Trump. So stay tuned for that and why that could be bullish for crypto.
Then we broaden the conversation to a number of other subjects, including why tech has pivoted right, why the Democrats are bad on crypto. How the tech world views crypto? Is it like one giant Ponzi casino to those guys growth versus degrowth and the mimetic wars. The state of media and why it's broken, including social media and is the US going to be okay after the election of 2024. Mike is a podcaster. He's got his own podcast, which it's always just fantastic hosting other podcasters on your podcast because they know how they know how to podcast. It's always a good conversation. He's always got someone to say something useful and I really think his perspective as someone who is just just outside of crypto.
He's savvy about crypto. He knows about crypto. He's not in crypto though, but he's in tech circles. He's in political circles. And so getting his perspective on like our world as well as his perspectives on the future of where all of this whole the whole world is going is just very, very, very useful because he's not a crypto person even though he's pretty close. He's pretty close. And so that's kind of the value I got out of this episode with Mike. David, maybe for the clickbait, we should have titled this the the Salana episode, huh? And then it's just Mike Salana. I don't know, but we'll have some things to discuss.
I'm sure during the debrief, which is available to you if you are a bankless citizen. All right, guys, let's get right to that episode with Mike Salana. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Including our number one recommended crypto exchange, whether you're buying Bitcoin, Ethereum or Salana, that's Kraken. Go create an account. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Kraken. One of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world, Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone, everywhere to trade crypto.
Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles and videos. With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. So check out the simple, secure and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro.
Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be, not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. The Uniswap extension is almost here. The self-custody wallet created by the most trusted team in DeFi, Uniswap Labs, designed to make swapping feel effortless. This extension lives in your browser's sidebar, letting you swap, sign transactions and send or receive crypto without ever losing your place on the internet. Plus, with human readable transaction messages, you'll always know exactly what you're signing. Navigate a multi-chain world effortlessly with support for 11 chains, like a theory made net, base, arbitragem, and optimism.
No more chain switching or token importing, all your assets are right where you need them to be. The Uniswap extension is designed to level up your swapping experience with other Uniswap Labs products as well, easily onboard to the extension using the Uniswap mobile wallet to begin managing your assets across platforms. And take advantage of smooth seamless synergies with the Uniswap web app. So go and sign up for the wait list today and download the Uniswap app and claim your free username to get added to the extension wait list. The Uniswap extension is available later this month to everyone.
Just another way Uniswap is helping you swap smarter. Have you ever felt that the tools for developing decentralized applications are too restrictive and fail to leverage advancements from traditional software programming? There's a wide range of expressive building blocks beyond conventional smart contracts and solidity development. Don't waste your time building the basics from scratch and don't limit the potential of your vision. Cartesi provides powerful and scalable solutions for developers that supercharge app development. With a Cartesi virtual machine, you can run a full Linux OS and access decades of rich code libraries and open-source tooling for building in Web3.
And with Cartesi's unique roll-up framework, you'll get real world scaling and computation. No more competing for block space. So if you're a developer looking to push the boundaries of what's possible in Web3, Cartesi is now offering up to $50,000 in grants. Head over to Cartesi's grant application page to apply today. And if you're not a developer, those with staked CTSI can take part in the governance process and vote on whether or not a proposal should be funded. Make sure your vote ready by staking your CTSI before the vote is open. Bangladesh nation excited to introduce you to Mike Salana.
He's the editor-in-chief of Pirate Wires, which is a media company that focuses on tech politics and culture. I would say very pro tech. I don't know if he'd use the term EAC, but that's a term you've heard on Bangladesh. And it's really pushing against a number of narratives, maybe the the degrowth narrative among others. Also, he is the CMO of Founders Fund, which is Peter Tiel's VC thing. They invest in crypto as well. Mike, welcome to Bangladesh. Thanks for having me. All right, so you must be aware your last name is now the name of a major cryptocurrency. Yes. How do you feel about that?
Yeah. Have you said cease and desist this whole foundation? Honestly, I hate it. It's Salana was it's my name and it was a rare name and it was I owned that name. I was Salana. I signed my essays Salana Salana is an important name. It's my family's name like to have it just taken for me in this way is feels wrong. Weird and obviously, you know, it's it's a word and people can take words. I'm not saying that like I'm going to be sending any cease and desist letters anytime soon. But it just yeah, no, I don't I don't I guess maybe it's partly it's flattering, but God, I wish they chose something else.
I really do. Do you do you own any soul? At least you'd benefit from it. No, I don't. I was a Bitcoin person. Still, I'm a Bitcoin person and but I've kind of stayed out of the I'm interested in could the crypto stuff be on that in the abstract? I'm going to defend people's rights to sort of work in it and trade in it and all of that. But I've got too many hills that I'm presently dying on to take on another. So so I promise that we're going to get to more like intellectual conversations. But speaking of crypto coins that have people's name on them, the Donald J. Trump meme coin, the like debacle that happened last week.
Well, there's been a lot of news. Did you see? Yeah, people are in my DM saying like, no, David, it's not over. Like it's it's going to be it's going to blow up. And so I haven't put my head in since last week though. Well, obviously I broke the news and I stand by everything that I reported. I've spoken a lot on the pyre wires pod. I kind of broke down everything that I know about the coin like there are things that I can that I know for sure. And then there's speculation. So I know Baron Trump was involved. And beyond that, I don't have the insight into the inner workings of the Trump family and what weird things are going on behind the scenes.
I have a perspective which I've shared. But I think the more interesting thing here now is so you have obviously people are speculating on the Donald Trump meme coin. But then you have the polymarket like the the betting markets where people are like, well, there was a question of is the Trump coin real? That was one. Then there was the question of is Baron Trump involved? Both of those because of the UMA protocol have been resolved to know. And while the first one, you know, what is a real official meme coin? That's objective. Really complicated. Like, I don't that's a separate question, I think.
Philosopher is like coming on that one. To the question of is Baron Trump involved to resolve to know on that question is shocking to me. I could maybe understand resolving to nothing like to sort of unresolved like unresolved or I don't know. But it's not possible. Well, then the problem is the protocol like you then the protocol is a problem a huge problem because you're resolving to know on something that I know I know is true. And that the only evidence we have indicates that it's true. But a bunch of anonymous DJN assholes just think the vibes are off. And so they're saying it's not true.
They don't know anything unique. And now people are losing money off of that. Not only are people losing money off of that, but the people voting on the protocol are also voting on polymarket, which feels like fraud to me. And it's a huge like the Trump coin thing is fun. But it is like really sent shockwaves through I would say the sort of decentralized finance community and challenged a lot of assumptions about tools that are still being worked on and have a lot of promise. And I still think there is a lot of promise in this stuff. But this one is really bad. UMA like not only did they come out and not only this happened, they then supported it publicly.
They have employees making fun of people like myself. Um, publicly online over this in my opinion, like very contentious issue that they're just wrong. Again, they are just wrong about and polymarket just announced them publicly. So that is going to be, I mean, that's like a huge sort of just now like within last hour, I would say, uh, breaking story. I feel like we need to maybe back up and set some context who we dove right into the Donald J Trump, like meme coin and like some bankless listeners might not be familiar with this story. So I want to start with kind of like the tweet that sort of set a whole bunch of this off, which is as you said, Mike, the tweet you kind of stand by, which is from pirate wires per conversations.
Trump is launching official token, DGT, on salana, baron spearheading. That's the tweet. And so is that what you're talking about? Like you stand by that tweet. You think that that is an activity that I reported was everything that I reported at the time was accurate. And I've no idea what's happened since I'm not in Donald, like not a member of Donald Trump's family. I imagine a lot has happened since I can speculate and I did on the pirate wires part about what I think kind of maybe went down since then. What do you think? What do you think went down? I believe that baron asked Trump to run the meme coin and to make it the sort of official Donald Trump mean coin.
And Trump said, I love you son. Yes, of course, whatever. And that guy can't do his voice, but someone else better than he can. And I think he didn't think much about it. And Baron got excited. And I do believe that screly was involved. I don't know. I have no sense at all of, you know, whose idea it was or anything like that. I just know that that Baron was involved. I believe my speculation is that Trump said yes, but there were other people maybe even in his family who wanted to do their own version of a meme coin. There was probably some kind of like succession, like internal game gets to do the meme coin.
And I think Baron Trump made a move. And that's what I think. And I think that once the news went public, probably Trump had not clued in a lot of his lawyers. And I think they probably were like, what the fuck is this? And freaked out because it's not too long before an election. And it's a sort of unknown quantity and shut it all down. But there's been no public. Just shut down the exposure, just like the lawyers don't say anything. I think they iced out anybody. I'm not involved obviously in the coin itself. I don't even own any. I don't bet on the stuff. But I think that they probably iced out anybody they were talking to about it and are just putting all of it on pause for now.
It's interesting to me that there's been no public denunciation. I hasn't there. Didn't didn't. There was some announcement from one of the like the Twitter news accounts that said that an advisor to the Trump administration says that they are not involved with the DJT token on slona. Well, the advisor's not involved. I didn't see it. I'll have to look exactly at the Trump administration. I know that advisors advisors back channel didn't and didn't know anything about it. They're totally wrong. If there's an official, if the Donald Trump campaign is officially coming out and saying the president of the United States can confirm that he is not involved in this or whatever, that will be interesting to me.
And I'll have to reassess what I've been saying publicly and provide more insight into what I know for sure. But I'm guilty of being a headline reiner. So I'm going to the details. I haven't seen that. And I've been inundated with anonymous schizophrenic DJs in my mentioned. I'm surprised if they if they had denounced it, I think I probably would have seen that over and over again. Maybe not. I'll have to look at it later. Where does Martin Screlie fit into this? That's why this story is also weird. Screlie was working with Barron in some capacity on the coin. Yeah. Okay. And he's Screlie has heard himself into things.
I don't know. I don't want to say anything about him because I actually don't know the genesis of that at all. I just want to share what I know. Can we can we talk about a hypothetical universe where Trump's advisors lawyers like like, you know, you know, a better sense of the situation didn't actually put pause on this. And like Trump actually legitimized a crypto meme coin. What do you think that world would actually look like? Well, it'd be moving right now. It'd be like, so never go up. And I think that I think that all it would really do is solidify Trump's connection to crypto in such a way as he would have to defend it or be much more likely to defend it, which would be a really great signal for crypto and people heavily involved in crypto to support him even more than they already have been.
It's very clear to me that the Democrats want to shut it down. I mean, you're dealing with people who are animated by socialism and control of the economy. And so obviously it always surprised me that they allowed this to go on as long as they did without going to war for it. Like this fundamentally threatens their ability to manipulate people. And I mean, in fact, that's why Bitcoin was created. Like come on. Like, that's the whole fucking genesis of it. And it's working. And yeah, it's like they're on a natural collision course. Democrats have always been on a natural collision course with crypto.
I'm even surprised that Trump, I mean, Trump's not really like a free trade sort of libertarian type person. He's a populist nationalist. And I was surprised to see him take this up. I think it's just politically very smart for him because crypto is a very increasingly influential contingent of the pop or segment of the population crypto people. And certainly they have money. And they were being demonized. And trust me, they're making a lot of bets like this where he seems to be finding these places where there's really not any downside for him to support them and protect them. But a lot of potential upside, they're just like easy bets for him to make.
And he's been making them. And and crypto is I think the probably the best version of this where it was like, why on I know why the far left once crypto did not exist, but Biden's a moderate like, why does he care? Why is he taking this bet? Why is he going so hard now with so many other things that are failing in his administration and his campaign? It was stupid. And we just saw it to Maul Bowman went down, the crypto people got involved there. I don't really think I think that was bigger than them. I think it was bigger than was it a pack or whatever. I think it was just like people really hated him.
But yeah, this and I want to continue kind of just doing the sit rep on like the state of crypto and politics right now. Like the crypto industry, like we see this, we get see the incoming like 2024 election when we're getting excited, right? We see like both political parties trying to like vie for our love. Like Donald Trump, the Dems kind of pivoted and then like didn't really complete that like, they got scared though. They got scared. Yeah, they got scared committing to the industry. But hey, at least we got the ETH ETF in that moment. One last ETF. Yeah, that's it. Trump undeniably like winning the tug of war over the crypto industry.
But then you have like the pro Trump crypto people who are like FES, like you have to get behind Trump. He's going to support our industry. Then you have like the more like moderate skeptics like leftists who are saying like, well, like he's definitely more pro crypto than Biden. But like it's free real estate for him. He doesn't have to make any like real promises. He just has to like speak the words. And this is kind of like the tension of politics that crypto has. That's like tension of politics period. Yeah, it's like politicians say shit and do they mean it or not. That's valid. I think that if you just looking at the record here, it's very, very, very, silly to think separate from everything else.
It's really, I don't even silly. I think it's like it's almost dishonest to say that you think there's a chance the Democrats could be better on crypto than the Republicans at this point. Not only because of what they've actually done in office, but because of just like the ideology behind both parties, I've never understood conceptually the sort of like the leftist crypto person. I don't understand what that is. To be a leftist to me is like control of the economy, centralization. It's the only way to make leftism work. We're talking about fucking Marxism here. I remember there was a huge wave of press years ago.
Taylor, the rents generated it when she did an interview of this. What's her name? Legion or something. She was like the web three socialist person talking about reading Marxist and shit. We know Legion. We've had Legion on the podcast. Yeah. So she talked a lot about Karl Marx and trying to find some intersection between these things. There's no intersection. Okay. That's like you trying to be cool among the young kids who are like the fucking communist baristas and shit while making a lot of money doing crypto stuff. And it's like that's classic of a certain kind of leftist rich person to be honest, but it's obnoxious.
And it's just not true and ideologically, it's just a lie. Crypto is the antithesis of centralized, the sort of centralization that you would need to make socialism or communism work. It just is. One thing that I'm trying to measure out is a lot of the crypto industry, we say that crypto might just end up deciding the fate of the United States election. We are enough of a cohort that we might be able to sway some swing states. And even Mark Cuban was on, he put on some big tweet saying Gary Gensler and his reign over the SEC might actually cost Biden the election because he represents the policy stance of the Biden administration towards crypto.
I'm wondering if you as being more external to the crypto industry, what your thoughts on our ability to sway this thing or not? How much influence do we really have here? Anyone with money has influence. People say there's too much money in politics. There's not a lot of money in politics. Actually, there's not like comparatively to the rest of the economy or whatever, like people aren't flooding it with dollars. It's pretty easy to make a huge impact with a few million dollars even. You know, 10 million dollars and now you're like a major player in a race, especially if you're talking about regional like Senate races or things like that.
So there's money in crypto. Ergo crypto has influence and should use it. I think that's broadly true of anyone in tech, anyone in business. Like if you need to be involved or you need to stop complaining about the outcomes. Okay, here's the thing I don't understand Mike and maybe with your kind of like tech politics lens, you can you shed some more light on it. But it feels to me, like I don't understand why the Democratic Party is really like doubling down on this anti-crypto army thing. It just feels very much like shooting themselves in the foot. Anti-crypto army. Yeah, okay. So this anti-crypto army is like an Elizabeth Warren thing.
So she launched an actual campaign a year ago and saying, hey, I'm going to lead. I'm the general in an anti-crypto army. She actually, you've seen this, right? You've seen it. I'm going to introduce that story as Elizabeth Warren or Goons because Trump said, I will keep Elizabeth Warren or Goons off of your Bitcoin. Well, actually, there's some truth in that. And this is why it's a self-inflicted wound just because Elizabeth Warren actually stated that like she was going to lead the anti-crypto army, right? And so Lieutenant's like Gary Gensler, the regulatory state, this whole thing has been part of it.
And the Biden administration has largely kind of let them set a White House policy on this. But like, what I can't get my head wrapped around is like, why? Well, because he's old and senile and weak. I just have the energy to keep her off. But what about? So is it that? But even for her, right? Like the Democrats still want to remain in power. They still want money and votes. Do they not? And so they gain nothing by being anti-crypto. Like not even the big banks want to be anti-crypto. There's some legislations. Who is the anti-crypto army? I don't understand. Who's supporting these people? This is why it feels like such a self-owned to me that it's just like not logical from a...
The Democrats have a weird, I mean, so you have also democratic policies on things, for example. And I'm not going to try and have the debate right now, but sort of like trans stuff for kids, like that entire topic, right? You have behind the scenes, the story is just breaking now. Biden's was a Secretary of Health or whatever she is, the general, involved in removing restrictions for procedures for kids, gender affirming procedures for kids, right? Like that is really unpopular. And why would they do that? And there are lots of things like this that are really unpopular, but they do it on the Republican side.
You have a Republican right now who... And I just skimmed, so I don't have... I'm not going to have a thorough breakdown of the report here, but you have a Republican congressman who is targeting IVF, which is like wildly unpopular on both sides of the aisle in America. And this is like the hardcore pro-life side, right? Like at a certain level, both we have two parties. And so they have to make a lot of bizarre alliances and they end up doing things that are deeply unpopular eventually. And I think on the crypto side, it's like you have real Marxists in the Democratic Party, like hardcore leftists who would like to completely control the entire economy.
And getting rid of crypto is a really big part of that. There's the crypto, I actually believe that Bitcoin makes communism sort of impossible right now. So it's a huge enemy of the very far left. So there was a take floating around the crypto world right after we discovered that the SEC was coming to like actually like try and stop the Ethereum network. Like the SEC was going to try and make it either as a security going after consensus. And the take was... It's not just Gary Gensler in this one road campaign. It's not just Gary Gensler trying to climb the political ladder, but it's like the Clinton types and the powers that be in quotes that saw the rise of web to tech empires saw the rise of Zuck and Facebook like Elon and Tesla and like the rise of Silicon Valley as like this center of power that they don't have influence in because they rise to the internet kind of surprise them.
So the internet like kind of quote unquote got away from them and created all these like you know, Loki of power that are outside of like whatever the Clinton types have influence over and they don't want to see that again. And so like one hype that this is just a conspiracy. One potential answer to like who is the anti crypto army is a lot of like the establishment elite that don't want like a new set of like influence to be outside of their control. I'm wondering if that resonates with you or not or where you have any reflection. I think to a certain extent yes, but I think crypto is also interesting in that so many people have exposure to it including elites.
And that changes your perspective on and obviously for obvious reasons as well. Once you've bought a little Bitcoin like you start to think about it differently when it starts to moon and there are people on both sides of the aisle who have done that as well. Which means there's a sort of tension now between the ideology of politicians and the self interest of many politicians which is great. Like let's keep that as tense as possible. I think that there is something to the idea that people saw this empire rising but also why is the most aggressive stuff happening in a in a bear market rather than the crazy exuberance that we saw previously like there was it was kind of quiet during the exuberant period.
I don't know I'm a little bit less I and you see a little bit of this with AI as well where I think that it's like people are going after this stuff now because they didn't do it aggressively enough before certainly you saw that with scooters never scooters in all the cities. Do you guys remember this? There is like the cities that I have populated everywhere yeah. Right so that's mostly gone at this point. They aggressively regulated it up a lot of cities and I think that the aggressive regulation in part was driven because it came fast and hard and it was in part driven by this feeling that among regulators like the worst people alive that they should have regulated more firmly against right share like Uber and Lyft you know they came in and they like broke a lot of rules that should never have existed in the first place like if I have a car I should be able to do whatever the fuck I want with like if I want to drive someone around with my car I should be allowed to do that but they don't believe that and they think that that was a mistake they should have ended that there should have been you know like a politically empowered taxi lobby I guess in every city that they controlled they don't know and it's frustrating and this was like another version of that just like something they didn't have control of that could potentially get away and they preemptively nuked it in hindsight they probably didn't have to it seems like that stuff would have gone away on its own I am sad about that I personally loved running the scooters around but yeah there's like a lot of just in a lot of different technology spaces they're overreacting now because of what they feel as like a a miss on their part okay so so here's the I mean we're talking about like it definitely the the Democrats are like much weaker on crypto and like hostile towards crypto versus the Republicans and the right but like I'm not sure I trust the right either here Mike yeah you should trust any politician so you were talking in terms of right versus left and like that's one framing of it I also have like a you know like the the political compass type framing of it where you have like you know two lines you have the right versus left line but then you have another line that kind of intersects that which is authoritarian at the top and then like a small L libertarian at the bottom right so you know civil liberties types and I know it's less common for somebody being the bottom left quartile of like I respect civil liberties and yet I am on the left but there are a lot of people on the right that are just like authoritarian state as well that's why I agree you're talking like anyone nationally sufficiently nationalist who wants control of the economy is gonna have a hard time with this for sure and this is part of the reason like Trump is better and he's branding himself as the pro crypto president he's he's better than Biden right now but last term he like wasn't he had like a secretary of treasury who in the final days in January you know Steve munition was trying to like do a blanket ban on non-custodial crypto wallets so like how much do you really trust the right on these kind of like tech forward libertarian issues and like should we trust the right are they just like the the better of the evils well first of all okay so I misspoke nationalism is not it it's like the authoritarian thing because there's nationalism and globalism either one of those things can be authoritarian or I think a little bit more liberal and the authoritarian pieces the thing that you want to watch for and there are obviously nationalist right way are authoritarian nationalist authoritarian right wingers and who want control of the economy and whatever else your life can you trust the right you can't trust any politician first of all you can't trust anybody who wants power and yet you also have to be just reasonable about you know the people who are going after this specific thing are there really authoritarian right wingers yes have they done really fucked up things of course um but we'll just look at the landscape here and like who has passed all of the worst legislation and who is right now trying to do it and it's just like very obvious that you don't vote for those people if this is your only issue um and then you lobby aggressively on the right it's just like there's no good answer here because you're like oh can we trust these people it's like of course not that's just democracy but yeah I mean it would be very silly to vote for a democrat I think if if if your only thing is um is crypto and if you are going to anyway I would be willing to bet your only thing is not crypto and you're just valuing other things higher than that than your economic freedom I want to get your perspective uh about like what the crypto industry looks like uh from you from your perspective because I know you're like pretty exposed to it but you're not in it uh so like adjacent but not inside uh and so like uh just from the from the outside in like what what what are we to to you like you like what you look over the fence like we're trading meme coins we're like trying to innovate we're like struggling for adoption yeah would it do we look like a mess like are we legit like how how do you perceive us I think on some level it's like refreshing to see people speaking more honestly about the meme coins because that's what everything was a few years ago anyway and there was a lot of lying about like well this meme coin is going to be essential to like I don't know agriculture and some really ambiguous way and I was just like is it that seems like a fucking stretch in a half um so it's like kind of nicest to people like no I'm just gonna like launch a meme coin associated with Andrew Tate and call it daddy and you're gonna buy it because this beanie baby is really popular and you know cryptographically secure um that is one thing like I guess the the sort of overt trashiness of it I actually prefer uh and then um I think that there are a lot of people who very earnestly are looking to work on you know decentralized finance because they sort of believe in the mission I think that's cool um and they're still figuring out ways to do that I think that Bitcoin has already proved its value and I think that any kind of decentralized cryptographically secure store of wealth is very valuable by itself like you don't even need to justify beyond that so that's cool it's already awesome to me um and then if any of these other interesting sort of hypotheticals play out that could be great too I think that the like sort of decentralized contracts are interesting and I think that uh every time I talk about this problem of vanishing information online people say crypto solves this I have not seen that solution I am interested in that solution if you can actually create some kind of solution there to this idea of like you know literally information just vanishing or being manipulated disturbed remove from the internet you mean we need a permanent record and is this huge flaw in the a life lived online we've abandoned the analog right the last encyclopedia Britannica was published in 2010 the physical encyclopedia Britannica uh people are not buying magazines anymore or newspapers I'm not a fetishist for paper I don't really care about it in that way but they were physical there was right one a year ago if you told me that a mid-century issue of time magazine would be more durable than a blog from 2004 which no longer exists I would have been like that's crazy there's no way the information online is immortal it's never going to go anywhere but that's not true it's vanishing all the time MTV News just pulled their entire archive for the last two decades uh you saw the entire Gawker universe snuffed out like the toast and like weird blogs like that that really matter to millennials but really so like no one's archiving this stuff like the way back machine the way back machine doing pieces of it it's super clunky it's really hard to search and you what it effectively does is it like it cuts you off from your past so yeah there are versions of this and it's just not enough it's like this stuff needs to be alive and at your fingertips and like really easy to sort through and it's not at all um so yeah maybe there's a solution there so I guess what do I see I see some like scammy gamblers which whatever they're saying they're that now so I like that better um I see a lot of scammy gamblers I see a handful of people working on things that I think could be really cool and I think that's really nice and then I you still see a bunch of people sort of being dishonest like looking for a solution to a problem that doesn't exist and pretending they're working on something that doesn't really actually matter and all they really want to do is launch a coin and make some money and those are my least favorite of all the groups sure yeah I agree uh what what are your touch points with crypto like when when crypto like comes across your timelines or your feeds or whatever is it just through Twitter or like where do you actually like view the industry Twitter and then through like friends of mine who are super and colleagues who are like super into it yeah and just like kind of like shows up in chat rooms just because somebody somebody's interested in throws your way like crypto news and stuff like developments and weird things that people were working on but yeah it's okay that's kind of the same but yeah Twitter like it does feel like a slightly different world though to my world like I'm definitely right next to it and there's always overlap but it wasn't until the trump coin chaos that I was like whoa I am suddenly like they're here they're out my doorstep and it's like a whole other thing Mike I consider you kind of like a mimetic warrior at some level right sort of you you've got some memes that you care about and like I also consider you someone who's skilled in this warfare as well and I think I mean we'll talk about sort of media a little bit later and kind of like new media but like I want to focus on on the meme portion of this because in order to like win this movement for crypto there's like a few meme tribes that we belong to right so like we belong to the tribe of pushing crypto versus fiat for example right the tribe of the network versus the nation state the tribe of going bankless rather than being banked the tribe of liberalism versus authoritarianism like what what would you say are kind of your tribes that you identify with these days and like where have you kind of picked the different battle lines and like just in general what do you think are the big mimetic wars that are being fought right now such a good question because they're so complicated and there's so many and I think that in the over the last like 10 years things have become really fragmented and there are more dimensions to the conflict than there have been previously right so I always say that freedom is like my north star like anarcho cap I started my whole sort of philosophical journey as an anarcho capitalist that's when I really like kind of came online so to speak and just read the most and became the most radicalized I mean I've been radicalized a few times in my life but that was one of the big radicalizations that's diminished but it's still my north that that's like a wouldn't it be nice like like we should try and maximize for liberty wherever it doesn't put you into some sort of real danger and sort of threaten the entire project of human civilization so that's the that's the star and that's the guiding that's the guiding light but I would say the things that I find myself fighting for it's like business conceptually technology conceptually the country the nation I'm I am a nationalist I'm pro-America and that's my frame for thinking about international politics for sure it's like this idea that you should so I'm not in the decentralized state camp I believe that states exist and I think that COVID really proved this out like when the physical world around you in your own hometown is crumbling like the decentralized state does not matter at all there's it's I hate to disagree with you guys on and like I just I love the people involved in thinking about it I think it's just like really a it's a really kind of damaging path to take because you're taking a lot of smart people out of the problem of just fixing your local community like what really should be happening is crypto people should be flooding to one place um and leveraging their wealth and influence to shape politics in a more freedom oriented way is what should really be happening not trying to reinvent a place maybe the decentralized state becomes an island utopia somewhere or whatever like you don't have to do all that like anyway if America falls your island utopia is not going to be safe like where is going to be safe if America is over like that's the nowhere safe um so yeah I would say like I would say like my it's yeah it's business technology my country and sort of I have all of those values because of my family that's like I do I care about those things because I think it makes the world the safest and the best for like my nieces and my nephew and my sister I think about and like my mom like those are the people that I think about and so um and all those things have interesting memes that become a sort of field of war for the concept of those things um and that's where I fight this is all really abstract but the meme stuff it's it's it's it's great framing I think I think we've gotten to the kind of the basement level and then we can maybe build up so so one that intersects probably business tech and America is this memetic war that we have observed sort of a growth versus degrowth type of memetic war and I know if you see that if you can weigh in it's certainly part of the crypto battle right anti crypto versus pro crypto made the observation that like in the in the 1990s uh the democrat party under Clinton gore like gore is famously arguing like telling people that he invented invented the internet right yeah like the democrats used to be very pro tech very pro internet and now it's switched into sort of a there's like a degrowth well because the democrats have become less liberal the democrats are no longer liberal that like the whole project the internet was super liberal it was like hippies doing the whole earth catalog and shit leading to like this idea of the free flow information it was an macro capitalist wasn't I mean that was the idea there was overlap between the hardcore libertarians in the left for a long time but they're super authoritarian now and uh not only are they authoritarian in terms of money that's been true for a long time they're authoritarian on social issues as well and controlling your actual life and speech and like it was unthinkable to see a liberal 20 years ago say that the first amendment was problematic you would never ever ever ever hear something like that but I think our politics our politicians our political parties are like someone of a reflection of like they're built on top of the mimetic narrative wars that actually happen like the battle for for hearts and minds that we see some times on like social media and other things and like this this growth versus degrowth thing is enter definitely entered the tech sphere in the form of crypto but like maybe more manifestly in like AI right sort of this uh AI safety thing versus human issue as well that's a dimension I didn't mention I'm glad you brought it up because it's weird it's to me it's just table stakes of course you'd be pro growth um I think a lot of people don't understand that they think of it as like you can be growing or not growing and the more you grow like more money more problems kind of thing um things get complicated run of resources whatever but there is no such thing as like stagnants right it's like you're either growing or you're dying that's what an organism does and it's it's that is what our civilization is doing that's how I look at it and I am pro human existence and so I am pro growth is sort of that simple and then all of these other things that I care about are also just inherently pro growth and um you know there are problems like the question of what if we run out of this resource but that is a problem that we can solve with technology and um more material and then you know I mean eventually you're going to get to a point where you need to like be leaving our sort of world and harvesting new materials and using those and it's like but what if we run out of of that it's like you move on like the universe is very big we're going to be okay so like I guess you err on the side of being pro growth not necessarily too extreme so like how does that manifest yeah I'm 100% well okay but like how does that manifest and say that AI debate so there are some folks out there that just say accelerate accelerate accelerate accelerate yeah like without regulation without sort of breaks just all gasoline on this AI thing we need to outcompete China all the models all the time open source everything get every single person their own kind of like a AI lab on their computer uh yeah what's your take on that because the AI safety people will say yo this shit's dangerous like yeah it's an important meme because they're basically saying it's like when you when you have someone saying AI should be banned it's an existential threat you need to some you need someone to then suddenly your reasonable position is the extreme like no we should do it with some safety protocol now you're the extreme let's say the extreme right of that of that equation the stream left is now shut it down so the EAC people are like no no no no we should max no rules no regulations we should just fucking do anything and now they've expanded the conversation so the moderate position is where we get to be because of the EAC people so they're very important in this conversation and so I I'm happy that they exist um if it wasn't for them we would really just be arguing like how quickly should we be showing down AI uh instead it's more complicated I think that all technology is complicated and I'm not this like I'm not an EAC person I think that technology very obviously poses every new technology poses new challenges that were actually if it's efficiently a new technology then the challenges were impossible to predict that's always happened with ever huge paradigm shift that we've encountered even the internet right now I think that we are just figuring out the what it does socially culturally um politically we didn't know we had no idea like I was saying a moment ago we thought we had no idea that information would be vanishing like this or we thought it everything was permanent was going to be our problem was there was no problem it was abundant information that there are actually several problems one the information was malleable to uh there's too much of it so people have a hard time making sense of the world because it's endless amounts of information so what do you focus on um that makes people feel disconnected from each other right like these are all challenges it took decades to figure out um I don't know about regulations I'm not I'm not proposing any I'm just saying like it's very obvious to me that not every technology is a hundred percent good and it's very conceivable to me that some things might have to be regulated um based on the realities that present themselves inherent of those technologies you you've brought up this uh information disappearing information thing a couple times and we actually just haven't explored that on the bank of this podcast yet I don't know actually and mind familiar maybe you can kind of just give us the the quick download on on on what that is and why you're concerned sure I've written about this a lot um I first started writing about it in 2020 and there was an issue of people changing definitions of things online in the middle of contentious political debates public to political debates uh so there'd be some debate over the phrase like uh sexual preference is that offensive you know and um a a cb the supreme court justice was in her hearing her confirmation hearing and um she used the phrase and uh a Huffington Post writer reported that as highly offensive it was like a cb just used the phrase sexual preference which is bigoted and blah blah blah blah blah and I was like is it I didn't know that uh it's like dated for sure but like is it a it's an offensive sexual I didn't know that so I googled it and uh at first it was not and then as the the new cycle blew up the webster's dictionary changed the definition so I was like that's crazy like that you can just change it changed to say that it was offensive um it had been offensive it was very nerve-wracking to me because nobody has a physical dictionary anymore they're relying on these internet definitions and so if someone controls that then they have a lot of cultural influence that previously they did not you know your your record was what was ever on on on yourself the problem is much broader than that this is like articles change randomly without a notation about it definitions of words change based on whatever thing is happening politically that then determines the debate the shape of the debate Wikipedia is a huge problem and people like well there's a record of the edits or whatever and it doesn't matter most recently we saw this with um the flag that was flying in front of one of the supreme court justice's house it was the green tree flag um that had over the one week where that became a controversy there were more edits to that page than over the proceeding like I think it was like six or seven years I would have to go back I think it was even longer than that because I tweeted out about this I actually counted all all the edits you have a war going on right now that most people do have no sense of whatsoever it's a straight up information war and it's biased completely in favor of one ideological worldview and so that was where I first that's like the the most topical political version of this problem is that like the information is just changing and there's this sort of invisible information war happening that is shaping the the the frame of our like entire politics right now and and culture and whatever else um but then you have this additional problem of things straight up vanishing and so you know all of the old like live journal zanga um my space uh geocities um google nuked like all of these old youtube and gmail accounts like there's endless amounts of information in all of these things that comprised culture online for the first two decades of um of the 21st century that is fading very fast faster than information from a hundred years ago is fading that information is fading um and it's going to be very hard for us to reflect back in 50 or 70 years and um assemble and accurate portrait of what we were at this time I think um and so I think it's a very hard problem to wrap your head on because it's so apps uh it's a very hard problem to wrap your head around because it's so abstract I have a hard time myself and I think about it a lot uh but it is this invisible very important problem facing our entire society right right and it's not coming from any like one central like epicenter there's not like the ministry of truth but it kind of is similar to that I think what was some of the things you're saying is like the the internet is like soft it's like malleable and so like some things as a result of this malleability are like pruning snippets of the internet as they see fit to to benefit them their and their reality and their version of the truth and so yeah I think you're just asking for like literally just a harder version of the internet one that's a little bit just more like uh like structured and less malleable is that kind of like just what you're you're seeking what I'm seeking is to have a conversation about this problem I want people to think about this problem I don't know what the solution is I think that the internet inherently is malleable and so like the technology this is malle uh martial McCleuen talked a lot about this um he posed this very interesting series of topics central to his philosophy is the idea that like most people think that technology is additive you invent a new technology and you know it's it's uh it's the the typewriter okay the typewriter is just as good as the printing press it does everything the printing press does plus a little more so it's like this old thing plus this new thing and the computer comes along and the computers like well it's just as good the word processor just as good as the typewriter is everything that does plus a little more so culture doesn't you know changing it's just growing there's now new things that the old thing could do it's not true at all every new technology the medium that you exist inside of has fundamentally new rules that reshape society completely and the the way that the thing the tools that you use to to build and to communicate alter you entirely the world of the the internet is completely different than the world pre internet which is completely different than the world pre print like fundamental differences they're not additive differences and I think the internet is something that where we are just understanding and um this one aspect of it is new um and so unexplored I think that we actually don't even fully know there are many aspects of the internet the rapid instant global virality is another new property of the internet so rapid viral sharing of any piece of information that could be erroneous or not and have consequences because of the rapid sharing for example COVID okay had you had a virus like that 50 years ago be released from a lab in China what we have seen lockdowns all over the world I don't know I don't think so actually I do know it would not have happened because these controversies would have broken down at different times in different places at a very slower speed and so you would have had a much more sort of diverse set of of of practices that played out now you could say that's bad and everybody had they just you know locked down immediately and starved to death or something like the world would be a better place I don't think so but um I mean that was not possible as my point like these are new properties of the internet and I think this one the malleable piece um in the fact that it's so easy to change information the fact that you know you have to have a conversation now it I've screen I have screenshots of what the definition was yesterday and people like well did you doctor them I have no idea I don't believe you were entering the world deep fakes which adds a whole other layer to this like you are it's very interesting that the very first deep fake controversy that we're having is Biden's press secretary conflating the word cheap fakes and deep fake deep fakes but also using the word deep fake to talk about just um an unfairly edited piece of information but but implying that you know Biden acting very senile in these video clips that Republicans are weaponizing we're not real and so you have someone hiding behind deep fakes rather than using them to attack someone and that is what the future is it's going to be like did this happen or not I have no idea and it's like we haven't even we haven't even figured out the internet shit yet and now we're adding you know generated information online it's super super malleable and like clownish cartoonish that's a different kind of reality that we're living inside of now it's like a dream world and so that's going to affect our culture the impermanence of everything new projects are coming online to the mantle layer two every single week why is this happening maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer two design architecture since it first started building mantle d a powered by technology from eigen d a maybe it's because users are coming on to the mantle layer two to capture some of the highest yields available in defi and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the three billion dollar mantle treasury in the mantle reward station maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with giving you grants liquidity support and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application maybe it's all of these reasons all put together so if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's defi apps click the link in the shown us so getting started with mantle arbitrum is the leading ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions arbitrum has the leading defi ecosystem strong infrastructure options flourishing NFTs and is quickly becoming the web three gaming hub explore the ecosystem at portal dot arbitrum dot IO are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own arbitrum orbit chain arbitrum orbit allows anyone to utilize arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain giving you access to interoperable customizable permissions with dedicated throughput whether you're a developer an enterprise or a user arbitrum orbit let's you take your project to new heights all of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of ethereum experience web three development the way it was always meant to be secure fast cheap and friction free visit arbitrum dot IO and get your journey started in one of the largest ethereum communities launching a token don't let complex legal and tax issues slow you down toku provide specialized support to optimize your launch and ensure that you as a founder and your team and your investors get the most tax efficient outcomes the toku team understands the crypto space inside and out and will ensure your token launch is fully compliant while maximizing tax efficiency toku can connect you with the best attorneys if you need them to make sure that you have the best advice and toku can help optimize your taxes so you pay the least possible amount of taxes while still maintaining legal compliance with toku's guidance you can concentrate on building your company while toku handles the logistics token launches don't have to be complicated talk to toku today to get a free initial token valuation the the impermanence of everything is a problem with the internet today and you talked about disappearing information ability to bias information can we just like double click on media in 2024 and maybe in particular start with social media and then we'll kind of like branch it out for there but like the the internet is really interesting because you know TCP IP like it is a communication protocol that's the thing it does it is not a truth consensus protocol that was kind of left to us individual nodes in the network to figure out what the truth is and have institutions like media help with that now social media has taken a more and more active role in helping society find out what's true and disseminate information yeah the same time I don't know if you feel this way Mike but like social media also feels broken or at least incomplete and now like the newest manifestation of social media it was we were aggregated on a few particular platforms you like one being Twitter we found out Twitter was censoring in various ways and now we're in the stage where like we've got this fractured social media going on biology just tweeted out was like now you have x which is like the center right you have threads which is the the center left you have substacked nodes the center you have mastered on in blue sky and that is like the left maybe you've gab and truth right in crypto circles we sort of forked some of our like a discourse to chat rooms but then also there's an app called farcaster a lot of crypto people hang out on that's like Twitter clone only with decentralized protocols no farcasters are there awesome okay so yeah I'm not super active but I yeah but that's the thing you're not super active because it's hard to be in all these places at once so the fracturing of your state like makes it just hard to maintain anyway what do you make of the health of social media today because it just like it feels broken yeah so I mean apologies right he actually is echoing so I did interview with Jack Dorsey where he broke this down himself this was like month or so ago and he was just like he had left blue skies board because of this problem it was just a super left wing place now and he was reflecting on the fragmentation of the landscape now and his thing is he's super idealistic and I think he really does believe in some kind of totally decentralized version of all of this stuff it's just like increasingly not the world we live in and I don't know the word broken has a connotation of bad I think and I'm not first of all I don't know what's really happening I think no one really does it's still kind of influx there's a lot of chaos right now I think we're in the fog of war right now with social media I mean maybe can I get more precise when I say broken I mean like I feel like media is there to help people figure out for themselves like what's true and for society's sort of reach consensus and in that aspect it feels like social media is broken what one element of this is like Twitter bought accounts like crazy I don't know who's real who's a human in like crypto twitter is sort of front running a little bit of this because there's literally incented bought armies that are like put in place to pump particular tokens or narratives or to like shift the ties recently there's this like this airdrop type of like meta where token projects they give airdrops and if they're not giving enough airdrops to the right people you see simple attacking armies like rise up and say this is a scam give us more tokens right you just like I can't figure out what's real what's not who's a human who's not is just like broken from that perspective I don't know what's true and what's yeah there's no way to tell it's going to get worse but also part of it this is very good because no one ever knew what the truth was about certain topics or things and we were lied to for the whole 20th century this was how in the 20th century every single country became super centralized and I think pretty authoritarian this is how you operate in a wartime like that was huge massive like existential wars were happening so to maintain power like that you have centralized communication and everybody believes a very narrow band of things many of which are not true at all so the internet makes that impossible like if the internet were around during Vietnam that would have been a very very short conflict for America there was no way it would have persisted for as long as it did so in this way it's very good that all of these narratives are challenged and nobody's really agreeing because on a lot of the topics of the day there is no way to agree okay you can see the same exact thing I think about Nick salmon a lot the kid with the Magahat who got yelled at by the Native American and then was laughing and it was like well what's really happening here he's attacking the Native American it's the Native American attacking him people are looking at the exact even when the full clip came out and to me it was very clear that the kids did nothing wrong there were people who were like this is the problem these kids are the problem with America right we're looking at the exact same thing and disagreeing so what is the truth there okay I think there isn't one this is a subjective issue and we've never had a solution to navigating this certainly not at scale building consensus among a family is difficult among a community is very difficult among a world that's not possible that will never be possible there's no way to do it and I think because we were like tribal creatures okay pack oriented creatures we have this desire to come to some kind of broad agreement on everything and we're going a little bit crazy online because the internet tricks your brain into thinking your tribe is this whole group of people now all over the world and you're trying to come to consensus with people who are fundamentally different than you and you never will and that makes you feel like you're going insane so it is easier to manipulate people online than ever before but I think that the fact that we're all questioning everything is just we should be questioning everything you know it's like we didn't question enough 50 years ago I think it's super anxiety inducing for everybody to be in the state of like what the fuck is going on all the time which means probably what's going to happen is people are going to be not online looking for things they're going to be trusting I think influencers are going to become much much much more relevant small groups of people who people trust will just rise in dominance Joe Rogan is already playing this role for people sort of sifting through complicated things and coming to a perspective and you're like well I trust that guy so I'm going to kind of go with that and this is actually what the media was before the 20th century you had all of these warring journals saying all sorts of crazy shit and you kind of just picked the one that you believed in based on vibes like you picked the guy that like that one I guess and then you just trusted him because you can't spend all day thinking about this stuff and weirdly I think that's where like we're it's like this older thing is kind of popularizing again there's another theme here too like you're like apart from kind of like figuring out truth and and that is just like that that out goes that power these things right are very much incented by a advertising business model is some of the crypto web 3 tribe is sort of you know like pointed this out which is it's not like you guys should check out the interview it's on pyre wire totally well Jack he talked about this a lot yeah he points to everything to the advertising model this is the problem with everything um and well for him when it came to censorship he had no choice but to to to to go after this narrow band of things and he was very he's like I'm out of he didn't call himself a victim and he was just like listen I chose for the company to survive we unfortunately picked this advertising uh business model which put me um at the mercy of advertisers who are you know they're motivated by all sorts of things not just uh you know selling as for the new Disney movie or whatever right they had to do whatever they said and that is just what happened um so if you for yourself of that it helps but if you get rid of advertising revenue there's a lot less money in media which is also another set of problems so Mike you've presented some of these ideas that I want to kind of like summarize and throw back to you this is an idea and I have that I want to get your like five check on uh like the crypto industry all all this like crypto tribes like we kind of exist on on Twitter on discord we have like our own little like satellite world uh we've got to like a strong meme game uh we also have like political agendas uh we also have our own like job markets and we also have our own financial markets with all like these tokens that we have um we also have scammers fraudsters decisively humans we also have bots like fake humans trying to pretend to be real humans and like political tribalism and social engineering campaigns we kind of have like everything that society has you're like an Asian market and blade runner where it's like robots walking around and like digital processing yeah like it's all there you have it all but everything is like super concentrated and like everyone's a participant right like everyone's like playing in this kind of this game uh but also like time is sped up 10x that's what just it feel like to be in crypto like time just moves really fast in crypto everything's happening all the time and also there's a lot at stake because we have all these tokens that like we're all invested in and it really matters that like what the outcome is like you kind of also have to play in whatever this game is and like this idea is like i kind of think crypto is like this spearhead of the rest of society and we're not the only ones there's there are other like organizations like communities out there that are also doing this like zoomers on tiktok i would also kind of classify as this because they are being inundated with like AI generated content and so they are like able to discern what AI generated content is and sometimes i'll throw like some AI thing AI meme to my mom and she won't realize his AI so like some other like we're not the only communities doing this but like crypto specifically i think is like front running a lot of social problems like especially like the fake internet the fake human problem uh i think we're also going to see a lot of this play out in the 2024 election where like social engineering campaigns is going to be like can can society handle this but i just kind of want to like present this idea to you that like crypto is as a community as like a corner of the industry is kind of like charging into this future like running headfirst into these very big internet social problems and we don't have solutions yet except for the fact that we're exposed to them and so like i kind of feel like i can navigate the internet a little bit better than the average human just because of the skills that like and we're living in crypto like has produced for me i'm wondering if this kind of like sparks anything and you or any i think anyone sufficiently online it we'll see this and you if you're just like super super super online knowing like i get with you like no one's really prepared but like you're more prepared and crypto by its it's crypto exists it lives online right and then to learn about it you have to be online and like you're you're talking about these huge swings that are happening very fast so you want to be online finding them it's not that like it's crypto that did it it's that being online did it if you're living a non significant non trivial part of your life online you are just now your life is a giant question mark like i yeah i agree like i mean there are people fighting like in my matches not even with me with each other all the time and i'm like i don't know if that's a person i really don't and i think about it more and more like that you just have you seen the chat to you be t-reply guys yet yeah dude those are funny yeah i have yeah and it's like that's wait wait how do you guys know yeah that's a secret question you just read it and you're like i didn't i didn't say i know i say i have question marks now all the time and it's a way to be not true so yeah so i am just living in a state of generally speaking like i have a lot doubt about the kinds of things that are happening around me and if i'm responding to someone it's usually because i think other people reading this might have a question and i'm not really responding i'm not talking to the person am i am i mentioned i'm talking to the other people reading the thing that's live do you have any just like advice for either like like we both work in media for like maybe a young media entrepreneur or a young person who's just like growing up in this world or how to like navigate what this weird world of 2024 be and beyond is just any sort of like perspective you have to offer i think that you want to be skeptical of everything as much as you can but also cognizant of the fact that it's really hard when you're emotionally involved into something to be skeptical um and just acknowledge it like you're a human and you're going to make mistakes and if you're very heated about something that just showed up on your timeline it's hard to advise us because it's so impossible to do in the moment you know i make this mistake all the time but just be aware that you could be just totally wrong about almost anything and um and you have to always just be i mean if a story is too good to be true you have to be asking like is this true if it confirms your biases um immediately and you like really want to share it you should be very concerned if it if it perfectly confirms all of your biases that means in my opinion someone is is trying to provoke you um if it's just too good to be true you know it's like genderqueer teacher with purple hair tells kid to transition or she's going to fail him from class uh where a dread like that's then there's a whole sort of that's too bad yeah curious if you're a certain kind of guy but like my thinking is like there's no way that's true like there's no way that's true one two if it is true how like how deep is that like that's a crazy aberration it seems like probably right like how serious of a problem it is it is if it if it just can really really confirming your biases i think that you have to be very careful i think this advice was always good probably throughout all of modern history but now it's just very important because we live inside of this like raw information feed and um this stuff is just very quick and it happens all the time yeah advice i don't know it's just like it's the fox molder thing just trust no one my advice the uh there's been that meme that will like surface up in like variety of different formats of just like the world has never been the same since like 2016 like 2016 like the world just got more and more chaotic then the some meme will say like yeah it's when like they killed her on bay but that's also just like an internet meme but yeah just the world has gotten weirder and weirder and weirder for like you know coming up on like a decade in a row now and there's just like a fog of war with everything like it feels like we are in an equilibrium that doesn't feel stable like growing up in the 90s in the early thousands that kind of that felt like a pretty solid equilibrium but what do i know that that was my first first rodeo of like first and second decades uh but like the internet is chaotic like Twitter is being chaotic Elon is being chaotic all these platforms are being chaotic we have AI now that's like changing up the game and and this overall like our political landscape doesn't feel like there's an equilibrium there and i'm wondering if you also just to kind of agree with that sentiment of just like they're kind of chaos and if you see like there's like a uh a clearing in the fog of war because to me i just see like fog of war and like what like it's like a normal society looks like on the other side of this like doesn't feel clear to me either normal society because you're you're you're what you're asking is like are we going to go back to something that existed when we had a different technological frame defining our reality in the i think it's like 2014 2015 probably maps with mobile internet penetration and number of hours before it's spending online once you're walking around with the internet and your pocket and everybody else's now society is existing for a non trivial amount of time on the internet the internet the rules of the internet are clownish that's what like the malleable information the rapids pace of of information the ease of deception you're now talking about like a sort of cartoon reality that is shaping culture so our politics didn't get crazy it's not like oh my god how did Donald Trump happen and then now how is like what's her face like uh like um comola like like giggling in a weird way every five seconds and like i can't believe she's a heartbeat away from the presidency like this is clownish clown world type stuff the politics are mapping that the politics are being they're emergent like there was no way to stop this once we started living online because the internet is a cartoon world now our society is shaping to those laws um that will be the future that is it will get more and more clownish it will only get more i think it's like it's sort of less chaotic a little bit because people sort of now understand that it's going to be clownish um so it doesn't hit the same way i think that it did in like 20 certainly 16 17 and then 2020 was super dark it you're like a little bit more adjusted to the clown world but i don't think we're getting rid of the clown world i think the only way that gets rid of it is a paradigm shift a technological paradigm shift that changes the way we interact with the world that could maybe be something like artificial intelligence and some really crazy way that none of us can see really predict right now because it's just very very complex um but i think that's the only thing that changes and i think there's no going back unless you you know get rid of the internet i mean get rid of the internet right so like to hear here's a difficult position just to steal man the case against kind of like some of your your core tenants like i certainly don't think this we're very like protect at bank lists obviously being mean crypto pro pro capitalism you know the property rights this type of thing and generally pro the us but someone hears that that we're living in a clown world and you say uh that this is because of technology because of the internet and who brought us the internet well these corporations that's the business side and it's resulted in in clown influencer politics and uh your position is pro-america and they see america and it's just going in the total wrong direction so how do we go back to the normies out there and say yeah i know like the internet has caused all of this chaos and tech companies have like brought about the internet and brought it into our everyday lives and have been a participant in this chaos and by the way made a whole bunch of money and like now we've got this you know clown politics how do we go back to them and say hey guys you know what the solution is it's actually more business more tech like more entrepreneurship do you see like why there is this this cynicism on the anti like this maybe this explains the anti crypto army maybe this explains degrowth maybe this explains like all of the counter forces that that we're kind of facing in these arguments um well i would first just acknowledge that you're right to feel a kind of way about this it's like there i i am not people put techno optimism on me i don't think i'm techno i'm i'm like i believe in the concept of technology and the concept of business i think they generally track to good things i am not in a dogmatic person about this stuff i think that there are problems that we're not facing because we don't want to face them because we don't want to have this conversation it's like we want to believe that the internet is an unambiguous good but nothing is an unambiguous good especially nothing at scale like nothing that everybody now is using of course they're going to be drawbacks um i think that there is no easy answer here because the easiest answer would just be like some silver bullet argument of like no the clown world's great and it's going to do all of these good things i think that there were drawbacks to not having it like i mentioned before in the prior world it was easy to convince people to do these horrible wars that killed i mean like i forget what the number was it was like millions of of teenage boys were shipped off to Vietnam to die like forced like conscription that is not possible now okay like you're never going to get to the level of consensus at society consensus that you need to do something like that so the prior world of technology led to certain outcomes that were also really fucking grizzly once you created machine guns for example okay like you could defend yourself better but you could have guaranteed that there would be trench warfare and you would have a long protracted sort of world war one situation every technology changes the world in some kind of a way that is not good or bad but complicated and now we're in the internet world and i think the very first thing that we have to do is just sit with these challenges and i kind of come to some sort of consensus on like okay we are in a clown world and now what like we're in a clown world what is that mean how is that presenting are there technological solutions here are there things we could do to make it better what are the good outcomes of that like what are the things that happen that were great like we don't want to throw the baby out with the bath water like i think we have to just be talking about it and and be sober about it and not be a lot about it and also not you know a crazed accelerating you know i think every american should have a nuclear bomb in their basement type person i'm not really on board with that either yeah that's a rational take i can get behind that i think the larger point is maybe just uh tech realism is like more the the bent here is which another point is we can't put the genie back in the bottle like it is what it is like you you can't like delete the internet and go back to the 1990s we'll never live in that world again so let's let's talk about one area that we're we're both focused on so i consider pirate wires sort of the uh the alt media for tech in uh some more ways that you know bankless is like alt media in crypto and so uh we were talking earlier about how social media is like is imperfect has some flaws is going through this anarchy a type phase let's zoom out to media in general so like we've got mainstream media we've got alt media like pirate wires uh there's difficulty sustaining the business model it's hard to like i don't know pay for real journalism and truth finding like what's your take on the state of just media in general not social media but you media in general in 2024 and like the way forward to make it better well it's really bad it's like absolutely i would say like existentially bad like to the point where like whole kinds of journalism could probably will probably end and there are people who will celebrate that who think just like all journalism's bad and like fuck the journalist and it's like i understand that because so many journalists are such shitty people but um it's really important that you know what's happening in your local city hall and there are places all around the country right now that have no idea and local politics sort of shapes your actual day to day reality did not know what's going on is very bad man it's so complicated because the thing that's happening right now is you basically need people to pay you for your content which is great and for me uh pirate wires is we're good to go we're able to do that and i'm able to pay all my employees and we're gonna grow and but there are all sorts of things i cannot do because i'm not making tons and tons and tons of money okay all sorts of things i would like to cover but won't be able to um with the New York Times is able to do is really to sacrifice burn a ton of money to be reporting on some strange i don't know political feud in africa that might have one-off consequences like our second order consequences all around the world really because it's good for their brand they're they're the people who are you know covering everything or whatever um not because it makes money and uh what is this like the future of that i think the times will survive and they'll continue doing a lot of this stuff i think that the influencers will be the other thing and then now reporting on certain topics like we're doing like on tech on like based tech news no one can compete with pirate wires like there's no we don't have a competitor in that in that lane it's a very specific lane like the New York Times could never um and so like you have to go after the giant on on those in those ways and then just grow as best you can from there but there are going to be a lot of things that just are not covered and i don't know newspapers were basically there were companies that had hard defensible lines of distribution they made money for the most part on advertising and then advertising was multi-pronged you had advertisements you had inserts um you had what was the other classifies was the other huge one by the time of the internet most of that had already been like most of the a lot of the average they were already dying and a lot of the advertising had been cannibalized by television um once the early internet before social media came you lost classifies to Craigslist and search and things like this uh and then all you had in the new media landscape in the early 2000s was just straight up advertising so you need to clicks that was a total disaster for media and was the beginning of sort of the end of everything now what you're seeing are people rebuilding old media companies on the internet essentially building back lines of distribution separate from social media they're owning their own distribution via the email and you're like rebuilding this advertising revenue sort of on top of that in addition to that uh but it's just still it's like such with technology as it is the slice of the pie is much much much much smaller um and i think it's like there's not a lot of i don't have a lot of good solutions here all i can say is that like i'm on the front lines like in a in a hard moment succeeding in a way that is sort of closer to the top of the pack and it's like very difficult to do it um and i'm just hoping that that we develop new tools to do it and um i really hope that a i becomes a huge amplification of what we're able to do on smaller teams um i'm really interested in every sort of new tool that comes around uh but it's yeah it's pretty bad right now i think the other than it's kind of good with fragmentation all these different social media things um if that continues which i would love to see there's a there's a world in which they just lose the power the pricing power that they had which was really really really damaging to the whole ecosystem that kind of gets the the question i want to ask i wonder if you have a take on if i imagine a pendulum between like large conglomerates media conglomerates ms mbc like new york time it's like central like the spectrum here is centralization versus decentralization if there's a pendulum like uh that is swinging between one and the other where do you think that pendulum is where you have like large centralized media orgas on one side and then you have like the elan musk vision which is he wants every single twitter account to become like a citizen journalist uh and then you have like uh people like you and i you and us where you have like pirate wires and bankless which are like small independent media organizations with like a committed following somewhere somewhere in the middle probably more on the left side what where do you think it did you think there's a pendulum and uh where do you think we are on that and where's it going i think that there are no real citizen journalists to be honest um there are people talking and that's enough that was enough to do the most important thing that social media did which was throw the curtain back on these huge institutional or at least legacy media institutions and just challenge them fundamentally like you are telling us things that are not true and you do not have authority over the concept of truth you are not able to fact check me okay like you like your opinion is not more valid than my opinion that was really important and is provided that the internet the social internet stays free um you have this very important corrective on these other giants but none of these things are solving the chaotic internet problem in fact social media just amplifies it and so what you're going to have to have are these smaller groups that are growing so once everything weirdly modeled off of the New York Times right like we're talking about building up distribution channels and um you know your own forms of advertising subscription revenue uh you have this new crop of of smaller players that are growing and increasingly influential like you said in the middle uh and i think that they're going to become these really important nodes for sense making of the world it twitter in this chaotic state and all social media really is kind of too chaotic for the average person they're looking to like okay what's this one guy who i like gonna send me in my inbox and that says like everything i need to know that's happening right now um so that will be very important and um i think also increasingly lucrative when you have that kind of a relationship with someone that they trust you that much um you'll be able to make a lot of money and what i'm trying to do with that is like use that money to fund journalism that otherwise would be very difficult for example local politics reporting in san francisco just straight up like what the fuck is going on type stuff uh at city hall or with the crime stuff or like the new mayor who's at of oakland who's um super is allegedly corrupt um like that's what you hopefully do with that kind of with that kind of um influence and i and i think that i do think that influence is really growing yeah i i hope it grows i mean like i'll just tell you it's sort of our story and i i don't know if you have any um advice for someone who's it was thinking about like starting an alt like media uh company maybe maybe the generic advice is like don't do it like be sure you want to like for david and i's story with bankless is we kind of like stumbled into this david was doing a podcast i was doing like a a sub stack and we're basically like man no traditional media is not covering crypto the way it should right it's like you see financial media cnbc and bloomberg and it's just like uh reporting on the wrong projects in the wrong ways like it's just so so like just boomer and out of touch and like not in the weeds so we sort of just develop this niche and then like a sub stack turned into oh we have some people to like write this newsletter and that kind of like grew and we forked off we like accidentally built i think maybe an alt media company but like this doesn't scale to like hundreds of employees very likely it's still going to be like david and myself and probably like a small team to just cover our niche better than anyone else in crypto i don't know if that's like a scalable model i see some similarities in pirate wires and like one thing that's important to us is like we totally have a bias like our bias is is decentralization values like our bias is crypto and like we're unapologetic about that bias i think that might be an important ingredient i don't know if that is really good it buys a lot of people clock as but i'm i always say pirate wires is very biased people like this has got objective reporting i'm like correct like i'm generally pro business i'm generally protect when i go after companies like google it's because i think that they are damaging those things um i think that their policies are bad for the country or the industry more broadly engineers i that's why i that's but that's that that is how that's what builds trust and that is the problem with the 20th century media model is like once we all got online and started talking to each other it was like holy shit we've been lied to a lot i feel like they pretend they don't have any biases or exactly exactly just for why that's the first that's like the original sin of media of 20th century is 20th century media didn't always used to be like this but like the idea of the objective journalist is a myth it's not true people cannot be objective they cannot you cannot even when the the way that you determine what a good story is or an important story what is newsworthy okay that's your bias that is that is you need the bias to tell you what to cover even if you could somehow cover it in a neutral way i don't even know what that would exactly look like or be you needed the bias to tell you that it was important and so to say that you don't have it is just a total lie and everybody knows it's a lie and that's why that is the power of someone like Joe Rogan for example who is just very clear about what he believes and what he's interested in and that's why people connect to him because they've been lied to for so long and people who don't lie and that way are going to grow and grow and grow the danger of that obviously is building up trust and then abusing it which people will do and probably already have done um i think that like you have like i see these influencers blowing up and then like you know by my my token class on how to start a business or whatever like that stuff's really gross and um but but you know they're that kind of stuff has existed forever and the internet's just kind of modeling it's just showing you the new version of this scammy kind of guy that has always existed but yes i think that we are biased i think that's really good i think that is why people like us um i think that it's super narrow and we're able to do it because we both are covering stuff where there are enough people with enough money who care about this thing that's worth it for them to to look at this um i would like to grow beyond what what we're currently covering as well but uh i'm never going to be able to cover like local politics in mazula or something like that's just there's no way i could justify that um maybe one day you know what never say never yeah i'll find a way a i right i mean maybe make it out a little a i for reporters and embedded in every community maybe let's end with this question mike this has been uh really cool i think we've covered a lot of things but just one of your um one of your values uh rather than biases i'll call it a value is um is the United States and uh this is an election year it's a particularly insane election year of 2024 and i guess like my question uh david and i aren't as like uh in the weeds in terms of politics except as it relates to crepto but like we definitely live here and see what's going on like is america going to be okay after this election i do you have any election predictions i i'm not asking who's going to win and who's going to lose but but say that if you want like my broader question is like are we as a country going to be okay i mean it depends on what you what do you mean by okay like are you asking if democracy is going to still exist yeah to to me it's like constitution democracy and also like no civil war would be like a good definition of who's going to fight in the civil war like let's just start there who's fighting in this war is it like this this the sort of angry baristas of san francisco fighting the farmers in napavali like that's not happening democracy what about uh will the far with the extremes the left and the right will they get further apart or will we like move closer together as a society like can we like meld far left and right like relations i like like that's that's nice that would be nice to have my like my question too is like will the republic just hold you know like are we going to be able to just maintain a democracy yeah i mean i i don't really we're talking about two democratically elected presidents and everyone is saying that democracy is failed it's like well both of them won their election and it didn't fail so like our automatically i'm sort of like okay what are we really talking about here it's just it's like very hysterical um it's all like super super super hysterical and i mean people just need to like calm down generally and be a little bit more sober about this i do think that there are huge problems that are new problems i think that the weaponization of the court is really scary to me um i think that the sort of distrust of the court uh the higher court the supreme court is really scary to me because like you have a situation now where people all sort of understand that if you control the supreme court you can just sort of magically do whatever the fuck you want and that is that's like super authoritarian potentially um you know you have the democrats talking about packing the court which is like really horrifying to me uh just like a complete sort of that's like it for me that's like you're taking over the country you've resolved the legislative branch at that point um and there are new things the courts have not ever been this the supreme court has never been this distrusted and um and the idea that a that's not like the alvin bragg case was like really crazy to me i couldn't believe that that happened um but i still think like the thing about america is it's so goaded in terms of like talent and resources and money i often wonder like why are things so stupid here like separately from the internet things are so dumb and so many ways like san francisco is dumb like the politics are really really dumb and the internet didn't do that okay it's like been dumb for a long time um the reason is because we can like it's like we're we just are so good that like the like we can fail totally at politics and still we're better than everybody else um so there's not enough external pressure to fix anything right now that's both good and bad it's like bad news for new infrastructure projects you're never getting high speed rail in california um as long as we don't have like some kind of i don't know california a specific dictator to do it which would i don't know i'm open to it um but like we're also i think democracies gonna exist and uh i think the republican does survive and uh it's like does the republic survive a donald trump presidency it did everything was fine um like i just don't think that there's i think that people freak out about this stuff and it's actually fine i think that we're there are fewer checks and balances to just pure democracy which is a problem like we're becoming more and more of a sort of like i think all of the california style direct democracy is really bad uh you want repper you want to be electing representatives and having them legislate and you want to make sure the courts are not legislating that the courts are um determining what legislate like they're sort of litigating what legislators have have said but yeah i mean this is a lot i'm babbling i i think things are gonna be fine um i don't think there's there's definitely not gonna be a civil war because who where would the the lines even be it's like with your urban core versus ever the suburbs that just seems really silly i think that yeah i think things are be fine i'm glad to hear you say that mike because the civil war would be very bad for our bags i think over here in crypto oh my god well crypto would boom i don't know for sure you need a currency you can trust sometimes we wonder if this is a risk on asset or a risk off asset or like what it actually is and how it trades but uh mike so far it's been both yeah it's been bearish it's been both uh mike this has been great i uh for bankless listeners i consider pirate wires kind of like the bankless of tech so you guys want to check that out it's a pirate wires dot com you can you can and should subscribe there'll be a link in the show notes uh this has been great my god to the daily subscribe to the daily it's like so we have the daily brief at bankless the daily what's the daily give us the pitch for the daily three daily takes technology politics and culture nice very quick well everything you need to know and it's like your portal into the pirate wires universe so do that guys as a follow up i got to end with this of course none of this has been financial advice uh that should be obvious i don't think we we recommended the donald j trump token at all um you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot