Nic Carter is one of our favorite writers in crypto. He's shaped our thoughts on many subjects over the years. He's definitely a Bitcoiner, but is he also an Etherean? What makes Nic tick?
Get to know the person behind the persona in this week's episode of Layer Zero.
------- 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🍵 MATCHA | DECENTRALIZED EXCHANGE AGGREGATOR https://bankless.cc/Matcha
🔐 LEDGER | SECURE YOUR ASSETS https://bankless.cc/Ledger
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING https://bankless.cc/UniGrants
------ 📣 TracerDAO | Perpetual Pools are now Live on Aribtrum! https://bankless.cc/Tracer ------
Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 4:00 Nic Carter & Geography 8:51 What’s Your Deal? Ethereum?? 12:39 Shared Ancestry 20:09 Cypherpunk Values 23:28 Working for Bitcoin 25:54 Countering FUD 28:24 Individualism & Value Supremacy 35:00 Conservative & Faith-Based 42:53 Money God 46:35 Affiliation & Identity 52:48 Mountaineering & Fun 56:55 Memory & External Storage 58:40 What’s Nic Doing? What Now? 1:05:22 Kanye & Closing
------ Resources:
Nic on Twitter: https://twitter.com/nic__carter?s=20 Castle Island: https://www.castleisland.vc/ Nic's Podcast, On the Brink: https://onthebrink-podcast.com/
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Layer 0. Layer 0 is a podcast of unscripted conversations with the people that make up the Ethereum community. Ethereum is built by code, but it's composed by people, and each individual member of the Ethereum community has their own story to tell. CypherPunks understood that the code they write impacts the people that use it. Layer 0 focuses on the people behind the code, because Ethereum is people all the way down, and it always has been. Today I'm talking with Nick Carter, who I don't necessarily think identifies as part of the Ethereum community, but I think he has impacted it all the same.
Nick Carter is a prolific writer and also content producer, and just a general Bitcoiner in the Bitcoin space. He works at his fund, Castle Island Ventures, and also has a podcast, which I listen to the weekly roll-up every single week. It was actually the inspiration for the bank this weekly roll-up. They call it the weekly round-up. Some of Nick's writing and overall content and conversation has deeply impacted the way I think I've thought about this industry. It's thanks to Nick that I began to understand crypto and blockchains as political revolutions rather than just technological ones. In this show, we actually go back even further into the organizational structures of history and talk actually a lot about religion and the comparisons and comparing and contrasting Bitcoin as a religion, and a blockchain as an omnipotent, omnipresent God.
I also talked about the differences between the Bitcoin culture and the Ethereum culture, and I ask if Nick thought that the Bitcoin community generally is a more faith-based one as in they tend to go to church more than other crypto communities out there and Nick agreed with that point. We collectively, him and I, parsed that apart and made some jokes, and then I also asked Nick about, what else does he do? He mountaineers, apparently, and also spends a lot of time in deep thought mode while writing. Overall, it was just a lovely conversation with my friend Nick Carter. Let's go ahead and get right into that conversation, but first a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible.
Living a bankless life requires taking control of your own private keys, not your keys, not your crypto. That's why so many in the bankless nation already have their ledger hardware wallets, which makes proper private key management a breeze. But the ledger ecosystem is more than just a secure hardware wallet ledger is the combination of the ledger hardware wall and the ledger live app. And if you're used to seeing all of your crypto services and favorite deaps all in one place ledger is where you want to be. Not only does ledger let you buy crypto assets straight from the app, but it also hooks into decentralized exchange aggregators like periswap, which makes sure that you are getting the best prices on your trades without your assets ever leaving your control defi never stops growing and the ledger live app grows alongside with it.
So click the link in the show notes to see all the defi apps that ledger live has and stay tuned as more and more apps come online. And if you don't have a ledger hardware wallet, what are you even waiting for? Go to ledger.com, grab your ledger download ledger live and get all of your deaps all in one place. Arbitrum is an Ethereum scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use defi. If you've been using Ethereum for the past 12 months, you probably notice the high gas fees and the slow confirmation times that have been plaguing defi too many people want to use a theorem and it doesn't have enough capacity for all of us.
That's where Arbitrum comes in. Arbitrum is a layer 2 to Ethereum, which means Arbitrum can increase Ethereum's throughput by orders of magnitude at a fraction of the cost of what we are used to paying. When interacting with Arbitrum, you can get the performance of a centralized exchange while tapping into Ethereum's level of security and decentralization. This is why people are calling this Ethereum's broadband moment where we get to add performance onto decentralization and security. If you're a developer and you want to save on gas costs and make an overall better experience for your users, go to developer.
offchainlabs.com to get started building on Arbitrum. If you're a user, keep an eye out for your favorite defi apps building on Arbitrum. Arbitrum has been working with over 300 teams including Ethereum's top infrastructure projects and will be opening up to all users shortly. There are so many apps coming online to Arbitrum, so you may want to pack your bags in preparation for the great migration to the Arbitrum layer 2. To keep up to speed with Arbitrum, follow them on Twitter at Arbitrum and join their Discord. Hey, Nick. What's up? How's it going, man? Pretty good. I'm doing good, man. I just moved.
It's been a lot, but I fished out the cables and we were at the audio, the video, all set up. Am I the first person to get a peek into your new abode? Yes, I believe so. This is the first piece of video content I'm doing from my new place. What inspired the move? Why'd you move? Well, a number of factors, but Miami is kind of a good center for... Oh, you moved to Miami. Yeah, I'm in Miami. So it's a good zone for crypto people. There's a burgeoning community here. The Northeast seemed kind of stale, frankly. And heavily walked down and things like that. And Miami is just a more happening place.
Although it's very hot here right now, so there's downsides as well. I lived in Boca Raton for almost three months right before COVID hit. And Boca Raton, anywhere outside of Miami is not at all like Miami. Miami is its own thing. But Florida felt like there were costs to living in Florida. The Seattle rain that I'm used to is not the Florida rain that you experienced down there. Yeah, there is absolutely torrential rain actually about an hour ago. I kind of just got stuck on the highway knowing it could really drive. I mean, I guess, you know, New York just had like incredible amounts of rain.
So that's not just a, you know, a Florida thing. But yeah, I think it's your question. I mean, we operate remotely now as a consequence of COVID. And so I could operate out of anywhere. And I spent four years in Boston. I figured, okay, you know, try new city. Not to mention, you know, crypto has a very heavy Latin American sort of influence. You know, some of the highest penetration rates in the world for crypto are in Latam. And if you run a Latam business, you most likely have a Miami HQ or Miami office. And so this is another way of getting sort of in touch with that sort of genre of entrepreneur.
Yeah, I kind of had the same exact path, except on the West Coast where like COVID happened after students COVID happened. I wanted to get out of Seattle because I lived in Seattle all my life. So as soon as I was ready, I was like, well, I'm going to go do exactly everything I'm doing. And I moved down to San Diego. So we're both like had our upper corners moving down to the lower corners of the opposite sides of America. That's kind of funny. Exactly. I've some catching up to doing the plant front though. For Florida is a fantastic place to have plants. I know. I know. I brought some of them down.
They were very much neglected and kind of starved of sunlight. So I'm hoping, you know, they're thing we restored. How are you, how are you going to deal with the heat? Are you, are you ready to handle that head on? It's been fine, honestly. I mean, people here just scurry from AC to AC. So they don't spend too much time outside. The humidity is what, as they say, is what gets you. But I don't know. I'm like completely fine with it. I mean, yeah, you get sweaty, but you know, whatever. That's the cost of doing business down here. What about the East Coast resonates with you? You seem like an East Coaster.
Yeah, I don't know what that means, but you seem like one. So Miami is exactly 1,500 miles south by road from Boston. It precisely 1,500 miles. So yes, I did want to stay on the East Coast, you know, my family's here on the East Coast. So I was, I was going to, Miami's like not that far from, you know, DC where like, you know, my, a lot of my family and friends are. So, you know, I figured I would stay on the coast, but just go to the most tropical part. That's funny. So the first question I ever gave to you in a podcast was, what's your deal? And then the first question that Ryan ever gave to you in a podcast was, are you an ethereum?
And so I kind of want to get an update on both of those things. So I think when I asked you what your deal was, it was roughly like two years ago. So like, how would you update your answer to your question, what your deal is? What's your deal as of now? I don't remember what I said back then. What did I say? Do you remember? Yeah, whatever you said, it actually like triggered me a complete like reconceptualization as to what like crypto is. And started to get my mind thinking of crypto as like a political movement more than a technology one. And so you said that like Bitcoin, it just instantiates a lot of values that you have, like the unprintability of money, strong property rights, and a few things of this nature.
That's deeply insightful. Two years ago, me was genius. I don't know about present day me. I think I've lost some brain cells in that time. But that's still my deal. Actually, that's that's that's that sounds quite insightful. I mean, just recently I was thinking about how we keep mistaking technical decisions or what are actually political decisions for technical decisions. I'm sure we'll get into this, but EIP one five five nine. I think it's a great example of that actually. But yes, I think that's still my deal. You know, trying to peek through the sort of opacity and the veil is a decentralization and get to the fundamental nature of these systems.
And you know, kind of like resident enthusiasts to all skeptic all bundled into one. So I think that's still my deal. Maybe I'm more open minded than I was two years ago. So when the intro to the show is talking to all the people that compose the Ethereum community. And when I pitched you coming onto the show, you're like, I'm not sure I count myself to be a part of the Ethereum community. Could you elaborate on that point? Well, I guess it's like, you know, the same way like a theater production, like do you count the guy in the audience who's like heckling the performers as like part of the production?
Like I guess. So like you can hear them from the stage. So that's me like, you know, I'm like sort of adjacent, like occasionally, you know, like making like annoying noises. But you know, I'm not like an Ethereum per se. But some Ethereum's, you know, tolerate me. So that's good of them. And some just write me off as like a hopeless maxi, which I'm not to be clear. But, you know, so let's see. I'm on the sidelines. Would you, do you have resistance to being considered part of the Ethereum community? Would you decline that label if you were given it by someone? Well, an outsider, I mean, that's certainly like in terms of the vent and diagram of the things that I am, like no one would say I'm primarily an Ethereum.
But I've certainly used Ethereum much more than sort of the average global citizen. And we also have invested in many companies that, you know, build on Ethereum and things like that. So maybe I'm just being too pedantic about the distinctions here. You know, maybe, maybe you could allege me to be an Ethereum who knows. Well, I think that when we talk about like the layer zero, if we really want to zoom out, the layer zero goes all the way back to the cypher punks really like they are the layer zero of the layer zero, I kind of think everything. I mean, Hazu said that like crypto culture is downstream of Bitcoin culture because Bitcoin started this thing in the first place.
But I actually think Bitcoin culture and Bitcoin itself is actually downstream of the cypher punks naturally. Like it came out of the cypher punks. So everything is kind of downstream of the cypher punks. And so I think one of the cool things that crypto did for the world is it kind of shattered the identity of a cypher punk into a million different pieces and allows all of us to become like some sort of cypher punk. And as we all know, also know cypher punks are like zealots, right? Like they really believe in what they believe. And so when I see you like endlessly like writing articles, fighting, fun, talking about all the different aspects of the relevant aspects of Bitcoin to the rest of the world.
So I kind of consider you to like a Bitcoin zealot, but it's all related. It's all the same community, right? We're all downstream of the cypher punks. So that's kind of why I'll include you in the community, if you're in community no matter what. Yeah, I mean, you know, it's the same way like, you know, sloths and, you know, armadillos are part of this, you know, same animal kingdom. You know, we do we share a common ancestor. But you know, like I think it might actually be a mistake just to say big coins of the sole heritage to the cypher punks. Like there's a lot of cypher punky stuff, which doesn't have to do, you know, nothing to do with blockchains.
Like Julian Assange was a classic cypher punk. And I mean, you know, he was a big corner. I suppose still is a big corner. But he was more about encryption and, you know, revealing data and, you know, passing data in a sort of a covert way. Like that's cypher punky for sure, but it's not like crypto. And then, you know, actually I was reflecting on this recently. You have to think it's very important to remember the cypher punks. Many of them, so it was a heterogeneous group for start. They were interested in sort of digital cash as in cash like instruments that were natively digital with David Chong, you know, did you cash type things and of course they had different opinions about it.
A lot of it was sort of dollar denominated and the challenge was to build the, you know, anonymous cash protocol and anonymity was an incredibly important part of the cypher punk doctrine. And then Bitcoin, I would say, is actually really, really different from sort of establishment cypher punk thought, right, because Bitcoin has sort of reasonable suit on anonymity, you know, not perfect. And it is a bearer instrument, you know, kind of settles digitally, but it's not really that cash like in that it certainly doesn't attempt to have a stable, you know, stable unit of account or anything. So it's really, really different from the Chameon ideal, right, it's not just an upgraded version of Digi Cash or anything like that.
It's very much, you know, has these ideas and pregnant into it about monetary systems. And that attracted a whole different breed of people, right, so that attracted, you know, like monetarists and like gold bugs, right. So those are completely different concepts, but you know, it was so attractive to them that it sort of took flight. And then, you know, somewhere along the way we forgot, okay, what about fulfilling, you know, the vision of Chame and people that wanted, you know, dollar, stable digital bear assets. And some people have attempted to do this obviously with public blockchains, but there's just not that much emphasis on that, which I find interesting, because if you look at the history of Cipherpunk thought, that was probably, I would say, the primary vision of digital cash would be something more resembling a stable coin.
I know, you know, that might be a controversial idea, but you know, just go back and read the discourse. Right. I would argue that the emphasis on like a cash instrument and anonymous cash instrument was simply confined by the vehicles that these Cipherpunk had at the time, right. Like they couldn't even like imagine a non-state money, because no one could imagine a non-state money at the time. Really, really the thing that Satoshi really invented was inventing the idea of non-state money. And then that, as you said, like that idea is impregnated into Bitcoin. And then I, but I would say that like Cipherpunk values would be like, aha, we no longer, like we, I would say that the desire for like digital cash, that value is a bug.
Above the desire for self-sovereignty and self-independence. And I would say that monetary, a monetary policy that's non-state, that's non-sovereign, it more subscribes to the whole values of being independent than they would care about like the digital anonymous cash. Yeah, it's an interesting question, you know, because Bitcoin gives you independence in this whole other domain, which is monetary independence, you know, which is very important thing, of course, having a non-discretionary monetary system. But it's almost like that idea was so strong that it blotted out this other idea, which was let's, you know, build dollar stable instruments to transact privately online, which was kind of one of those prior ideas.
And, you know, that's an idea, which is important, though, because it's now a matter of public policy, right? And let's say there had been a huge emphasis solely on completely anonymous stablecoins instead of us, you know, whatever synthetic monetary commodities like Bitcoin. We might actually be in a better place with regards to the CBDC discourse, right? You know, like, I don't know what that kind of factual world looks like, but if we had hundreds of billions of super private, whatever ZK snarkified stablecoins floating around, that would still be a net for you win for freedom and sovereignty, for sure.
It's just that the main battle has actually been around the monetary discretion front. So, I don't know, I'm sort of a little bit wistful for that other outcome, which we didn't get. I mean, the private dollars. Yeah, yeah, I know that seems like completely incrementalist, and it's like, well, Nick, like actually we have a bigger like battle fight, which is, you know, destroying central banks or whatever. But private dollars are pretty important, too. Yeah. I would like, I want to get your take on this, is that like, so maybe maybe I'm falling into a fallacy, but I kind of like the fallacy that I'm falling into, is that like whatever crypto values we discover as like a community of crypto people retroactively, we get to say that these are cypherpunk values, like everything is downstream, like whatever values we discover to be valuables, like, oh yeah, these are now cypherpunk values.
Yes, and you know, there aren't actually really that many true cypherpunk floating around. I don't, I wouldn't say I'm one, right? I like don't use PGP, for instance. So, you know, or whatever the new version of PGP is, so, you know, I don't use signal enough even, you know, like I'm not even using the best cryptographic tools we have. So, yeah, I think a lot of people, you know, profess themselves to be cypherpunk and crypto end, but it's mostly branding exercise. And a lot of the original cypherpunk just would completely denounce cryptocurrency. A lot of them have. So, maybe I shouldn't keep this like cypherpunk branding, like, and held in such high regards, but that's kind of like why I want to redefine it, right?
Like, you know, we can use it more expansively because it's such a generally such a positive term in this industry. And I mean, the cypherpunk was just such a small group of people, and so, you know, the culture just changed. And this is a more mainstream movement. So, you know, the question is like, is that label still, does it have semantic content? Is it a useful label? Or should we rebrand the movement and call it something else? Well, one thing that crypto has done is put a public private key into the hands of everyone that uses crypto, and that is absolutely like a cypherpunk thing. Like, now we all have private keys, and we can build on top of that and go from there.
So, like, I don't think cypherpunk would at all argue that that's not a cypherpunk thing. That's true. It was the consumerification of public key cryptography in a way that vastly outstripped. I mean, I think the biggest public key infrastructure before cryptocurrency would have been PGP, I can't think of anything else. And that was, at most, what, 100,000 individuals. And in terms of people that have used a, as they say, non-custodial wallet. Unhosed wallet. Unhosed wallet, yeah. According to the FAADF or whatever, that's how many people do you think that is probably? Well, over 50 million, I would say, like, probably 250 million people have sort of had exposure to the financial assets in some capacity.
But most of that, or much of that would have been in a hosted manner. On hosted, I'm sure it's over 50 million. I mean, you know, how many hardware wallets is ledger sold, things like that? Right. Well, I have at least four of them, so there's that. And Metamask, they have 10 million monthly active now, I think. Yep. Yep. So one of your changing gears here a little bit. One of your articles was Bitcoin at 12, where you illustrated Bitcoin as this, like, cathedral, that many different individuals are helping build. And they all know that they're not actually going to be able to see the ultimate, like, manifestation of this cathedral.
Because it takes hundreds of years to build a cathedral. And so it's still a dedication out of the values of the builders that actually create these things, regardless of whether they get to enjoy the fruits of their final projects. So my question to you is, how many hours a week do you work for Bitcoin? That's a good question. Probably zero. But nothing I do is sort of directly accretive to Bitcoin, I think. Oh, God, I fundamentally disagree with that. Maybe that's because of different perspectives as to what it means to work for Bitcoin. Does making content? Yes. Yes. Peter McCormick works for Bitcoin.
Okay. Well, I don't know. I probably spend, you know, five to ten hours a week writing something. And then, I mean, you know, does funding Bitcoin start up? Yes. I guess. Yes. Yes. Everything counts. Everything counts. Some months I don't. And then, you know, other months I'll do three. I don't know. I can't say I'm a full timer on Bitcoin, but I'll give it at least 10 to 15 hours a week probably. I kind of more or less think that everything you do in your professional life is like working for Bitcoin. Unless I'm missing, I have no idea what it's like to be Nick Carter in the professional life, but like I think like every single podcast that I make and every single article I write is like me working for Ethereum.
Yeah, that's fair. I mean, I think I'm maybe more broad in my focus. I mean, you know, a lot of my time is on stuff like coin metrics, which does like, I don't know, 50 blockchains or something. So some of it is more broad. And you know, like when, like, Siv, Castle Island will fund startups that are just like financial infrastructure for the space at large, whether it's stable coins or, you know, cryptocurrency. So I wouldn't say it's confined to Bitcoin, but yeah, it's in theory, it's all sort of generally useful for Bitcoin and some some capacity. When you were when the whole Bitcoin energy, like, FUD part of the recent history of crypto was going around, I think you were putting out something like how many articles, like a week, like take us through like that whole phase of your life.
Well, that was weird because the FUD somehow reached a crescendo for some reason. I guess it's probably Elon, the Elon fact. But it was like, I like somehow serendipitously or on luckily ended up being situated in the middle of it because I guess I sort of like appointed myself like one of the one of the main like debaters. Yeah, and I mean, I'm sort of glad it's over because it was a lot like, you know, I was like talking to the press like every other day. And it just, it wasn't really sustainable. I couldn't like do my job at the time. And so for the last like two months, I've just been saying no to all press inquiries and all podcasts with the exception of yours.
I did pumps as well because, you know, he's my neighbor now. Oh, really? I didn't know he's not. Yeah, yeah, yeah, his studio is here. It's great. So, you know, people on friends with all like still, you know, do the content, but basically I'm sort of like a little burned out from all that stuff. Although I will say there is one final thing that I've done on the energy question, which is actually more paper and that I think will be really useful for a lot of people should be out this month. So stay tuned for that. But yeah, I don't know how, how many like videos and pieces of content things I did is like an uncountable amount.
Do you like it? Enjoy the limelight of being like a Bitcoin spokesperson? Is that like something that's fun for you? It felt more like an obligation than anything, I think. Of course, it's fun. Like when your star is rising, you know, I'm sure, you know, you felt the same, but it just becomes a grind eventually. And, you know, at the end of the day, like there's only so many hours in the week. And the more time you spend being some sort of like unofficial Bitcoin spokesperson, the last time you can spend on real work, whether it's writing or, you know, like funding startups or anything like that.
Do you think like sometimes I kind of think these like these protocols will lead themselves into their own future. And obviously these are all these podcasts is called layer zero. So it's all about like the people that help these things like direct themselves. But there's also these are decentralized networks. So many different people are building the cathedral in their own specific way, like to some degree, like what can one person do? Do you kind of think that like if Nick Carter didn't exist that Bitcoin would more or less be in the same spot? Or do you do actually see what you do actually moving the needle for Bitcoin?
I think Bitcoin would be absolutely fine without me. So why do it all of it? It was fine before me because I find it interesting. I think, you know, occasionally I have sort of maybe good points to make. But yeah, I think would be completely fine without me. In fact, you know, I haven't done that much publicly in the last month or two. And everything, you know, the blocks kept arriving. You know, like I've noticed that, you know, certain talking points that might have originated with me, like other people just glom onto them and they get a life of their own. They don't need me, you know. And you know, Bitcoin content, like there's an incredibly vibrant ecosystem out there, which, you know, like people will they'll respond to the fight or they'll, you know, like right interesting things and original ideas, like there's no need for me whatsoever.
That's a very big corner answer. Like Bitcoin absolutely does not need me. And I think maybe it's kind of interesting. In the Ethereum world, we definitely fundamentally accepts like the layer zero of Ethereum as in like Ethereum is it's code until it's people. And then like you said before we hit recording, like, Hosie says like it's always the social layer that is the final, the buck stops at the social layer. But Bitcoiners, I don't think want to have that same sort of illustration for Bitcoin. They want it to stop at the code and the code be the thing that propels Bitcoin in the future and no Bitcoin doesn't need anyone.
Do you agree with that perception? That certainly is the view, probably the establishment view on Bitcoin, but I would say Bitcoin also has what I call value primacy. So effectively values that supersede the code, especially in a time of crisis. And so even Bitcoin, the code is merely an encoding of the values, but the values are supreme, especially when there's a conflict between the values and the code. So, you know, with the overflow bug, you know, there are 184 billion Bitcoins or 192 billion, whatever it was, this 21 million. So we're going to revert the code and we're going to sort of engineer a fix to that.
So I don't know what the next instance is going to be where there's a conflict between the implied specification. We don't have one exactly, but between the sort of constitution and then the actual, you know, enforcement of that. But Bitcoin also has the social layer, just it's convenient for people to pretend that it doesn't. The way I've described Bitcoin social layers that the social contract of Bitcoin is to not have one, which implies that there's still a social contract. But like it's still also at the same time diminishes its own role by like, it's like, it's almost like a snake consuming its own tail.
It can get almost all the way there, but it doesn't fully be able to like consume itself. It's kind of like take on the social contract. I mean, it's not just a Bitcoin question. It's any monetary system. Like this is a question that like monetary theorists have puzzled over for decades and decades really just forever. I would say it's like, how do you, as long as you have money, how do you build a monetary system in which the people in control can't tinker with it excessively or you know, like can't, you know, can't change the parameters, especially to benefit themselves. And that's why you, you know, throughout history had these movements to get on the gold standard because the gold standard is sort of this.
You know, at that point, you're beholden to sort of natural law as opposed to the law of man, right? So that's the whole point is that you, you, you know, you, you bind yourself to the mass. You sort of voluntarily tie your hands and you say, okay, I'm going to actually give up power here. But that takes like active management. That takes like an ongoing commitment to the surrender of power. And of course, like the history of the gold center is a history of governments saying, well, you know, actually it would be really convenient if we could get off the gold center for a little bit. The most interesting thing to me is that in, you know, historically the norm was after departure from the gold center, people would advocate to go back on it.
And so you'd have this recognition like, okay, well, you know, we had this like temporary aberration, we went off it. But let's, you know, surrender control once again. And you just had these cycles, you know, on off, on off. And so that's just the same thing that's happening with Bitcoin. But you have to have this ongoing vigilance and this commitment to not changing anything. So you do need that sort of continual pressure. And I sort of worry about what happens if we get extremely complacent and say, well, the code is supreme, whatever. What happens of a decade passes and people like, huh, like, why did we submit to this like particular parameter in the code again?
We should just kind of forget about that. So I do think, you know, it does need a measure of sort of like active vigilance and sort of participation. Hey guys, I hope you're enjoying the conversation thus far. We are about to get into the comparison contrasting of religion and Bitcoin and that whole religious conversation as it relates to our crypto industry. That's what's coming up next. But before we get there, we have to talk for a moment about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. When you shop for plane tickets, you probably use kayak, Expedia, or Google to compare ticket prices.
So why would you limit yourself to just one exchange when you trade crypto? When you make your trades, you want to make sure that you're getting the best possible price on your trade and that you aren't paying high gas costs that you could have otherwise avoided. That's why you should be using matcha matcha routes your orders across all the various defi exchanges on Ethereum, polygon, finance, March chain and gives you the best possible prices without taking any commissions. Matcha has smart order routing that splits your order across multiple liquidity sources if matcha sees that it gets you better pricing trading on matcha is super easy because it pulls the liquidity for me into a single easy to use platform.
Matcha also allows for you to make limit orders on chain so you can set and forget your defi trades and they will go through automatically while you're away. New to matcha is an integrated fiat on ramp so you can purchase crypto directly with your credit or debit card and have that fiat be instantly traded for any token that has liquidity. When you're making a trade, head over to matcha.xyz slash bankless and connect your wallet to start getting the best prices and most liquidity when you trade your crypto assets. Bankless is proud to be supported by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure.
Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum, which is what Ryan and I call a money robot. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. Something brand new in the Uniswap ecosystem is the Uniswap grants program is now accepting applications for grants. We have been saying this for a while and we'll say it again. Dows have money and they are in need of labor. If you think that you have something to contribute to the Uniswap Dow, apply for a grant to Uniswap.
Just look at the size of the Uniswap Treasury. It's almost $3 billion. This mountain of capital is looking for labor. Do you have something of value to contribute to the Uniswap Dow? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a Unigrant at unigrants.org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. That's exactly what we did to get Uniswap to be a sponsor for bankless and you can do the same for your project. Thank you Uniswap for sponsoring bankless. That's super interesting. This active vigilance thing. I don't know if this is true and you'll probably be familiar with this or not.
But the Bitcoin community, generally, I think is a little bit more faith-based than the rest of the crypto world as I'm actually talking about straight up religion here. When you say active vigilance, it reminds me of the part of religion, organized religion where it was your duty to wake up in the morning and remember your faith to God. Before the Renaissance, before it was all about the individual, you're supposed to wake up and remember that you are subject to God and you need to remember to keep your faith. Bitcoiners, and they're very, very strong social dynamics, we all need to wake up and remember that the 21 million hardcap is most holy and we all need to remember that.
There's a reason that Islam means submission in Arabic. Religion is all about submission, of course. You accept that you are infinitesimally small and unimportant relative to the highest power and in Christianity you're submitting to it. It's the same thing. I don't want to push the religion analogy too far because I find it sacrilegious sometimes. Bitcoin is all about submitting to a specific monetary schedule. You have to submit. You can't push it, you can't change it. You're the most important developer, you probably can't really even tweak it even a little bit. There's a sublimity in submission, I think.
If you actually can accommodate it, but if you can't then Bitcoin's not for you. Was I right? Would you agree with me when I said that the Bitcoin community generally is a little bit of more faith-based than the rest of the crypto industry? Yeah, I think so. Bitcoin is more conservative and it's a core value. You have these clustered values. I don't know what the right term is, but there's this sort of thing about society where if you know one belief of a person you can predict the next 15 beliefs. Even if those beliefs are completely unrelated to each other. For instance, one's opinion of sunscreen or seed oils or eating meat.
Those are very meme things. The reason they all map is because those values are all expression of some deep underlying set of beliefs. Am I fundamentally conservative? Not in the political sense, but do I fundamentally believe in hierarchy and stability and keeping things the same or do I believe in progress and shaking things up? Bitcoin is not big sea conservative, but I'd say it's a little sea conservative in that I view it as an attempt to restore the form of a gold standard, not the features of a gold standard, but the environment that the gold standard facilitated. That's why I call it it's a paradox because it's like a technologically progressive, but in some senses you could say it's maybe not regressive, but an attempt to reclaim something that has been lost.
People call it revanchious, like you reclaiming lost territory, and that's the paradox of Bitcoin. It's technologically forward, but it restores more ancient values. That's the idea. That's crazy. That's one of my favorites. If you don't mind me asking, do you go to church? Not currently, but I am religious for sure. I also just moved here, so I need to locate a good one. Someone who's literally never been to church other than touring. How do you choose a church? It feels like if we want to map this onto the crypto world, it's like you're picking a tribe, right? The crypto world is easy to pick a tribe, you generally fall right into one.
How does it work in religion? Well, you're born into it, so you don't typically... I guess so. You don't lay out a map of all the schisms in Christianity. I believe in predestination, but these are the gospels. You don't pick and choose that way. What's your specific denomination? Well, I was baptized into the Anglican church in England. In the US, that would map onto the Episcopalian church. A mean solomani, who's one of my own personal heroes in this space, coin this term, money god. It's simply something that uses control theory or has automated away all of the governance functionalities. On Ethereum, these would be in the application layer, but Bitcoin is itself one instantiation of this.
We've created Bitcoin, we've cast it away into existence, and now it controls us. It's autonomous, and we can't control it, but it determines our lives. It has a monetary policy, a supply schedule, and it imposes those values upon its users. It's subservants. And so, like, do you serve two gods? You know, this actually came up in a debate I had with Francis Coppola, the infamous no-quiner, because she said, as a Christian, she rejects Bitcoin. Because it's, you know, this doctrine of absolutism, but only god himself, only providence is absolute. And I was just kind of baffled by this, but maybe there's something to that.
I mean, you know, like I see Bitcoin as a human institution. It's just we're trying to do something inhuman. We're trying to create an institution that supersedes our sort of base human desire. So in that sense, you know, there's a similarity. But it's not divine. You know, in my view, sort of it inspires feelings of sublimity and, you know, something truly awesome in sort of the baroque meaning of the word awesome, you know, on screen. Yeah. And, you know, you might go as far as to say it's sort of, wow, it's incredible that, you know, such a creation exists. Like this is evidence, you know, of, you know, of something greater than humans.
Like it certainly inspires those kinds of feelings. I'd say a lot of people, but, you know, it's fundamentally a human creation. I believe, you know, I believe that Satoshi was a human. I think you can take this even further, right? Because like some of the properties that are, are fent discovered in good blockchains that are actually like alive ecosystems, like Bitcoin. And I basically only other included Ethereum is that like, well, they're, they're omniscient. They know everything because all of the state that is held in Bitcoin. And so Bitcoin remembers all. There are omnipotent in the fact that like you must comply with the rules of Bitcoin.
There's a few more omnipotent words that if I had, like, if I could think of them, I would, I would. But like, the properties of these things do approach something like the words that we use to describe like actual God. I think at the same part of your brain probably lights up when you think about it. Yeah, probably. Yeah. We might be torturing the analogy a little bit at this point. You know, Bitcoin doesn't make any metaphysical claims. Sure. As far as I know. As far as I know. But you know, like there's a great degree of mystery and, and like intrigue in the origins of Bitcoin, which I've always held up as a strength.
You know, I think it would be, it would be tedious and boring if we knew, you know, what the origin was. I hope we never find out. Well, if we want to hop on to different subjects, let me know. But I'm going to keep going on this for one last little bit. And so like there's the claim that like the story of like the Christian God or the Catholic God or even all religion, more or less. It's like in the same thing as this, this layer zero podcast. It's people all the way down. And so like the Bible was written by humans and was composed by humans to tell a story of like a holy figure. And as somebody who didn't grow up with religion, but then discovered it, discovered how to appreciate it much later in my life.
Like to me, the Bible is just a story of, it's a collection of fables of stories as to how to live like a good life and have good values. But all these stories were composed by people, right? In the same way that like, you know, the Bitcoin is a, is a system of human, that instantiate human values and same thing with Ethereum. Like it can be argued that like, you know, the way that we discovered religion is that like we discovered all these things that are fundamentally capital, capital G good. And then we created like a network around them. And so like these, these concluded while we are definitely like mutilating this metaphor, like it also keeps on going.
Yeah, well, there's, there's like two, I guess, there's like the secular description, the charitable secular description of the Bible, which is it's sort of a set of heuristics that we learned over thousands of years and incorporated into stories. And then, you know, it's, it's guidance of how to live. And then there's, you know, I would say the religious version, which is it's genuinely the received word of God. So I guess I've used that first definition, the metaphor, the analogy probably makes a bit more sense. Although the rules encoded in blockchains are very simple, I would say it's like you have to craft transactions this way for them to be valid.
And blockchains doesn't care about anything else. So it's really just, well, I suppose there's other rules relating to monetary policy and things like that. And that does feel like how the, the 21st century version of religions is right. Look, now we've actually removed the subjectivity from a religion and now we actually have objective properties about these things. If we want to consider Bitcoin and Ethereum a religion, which I kind of do. I don't know. I haven't decided I'm mixed, I'm mixed on the, on the merits of that. I mean, religions not very popular these days in the US like zoomers are mostly agnostic or atheists.
But also it also Bitcoin or Ethereum or crypto doesn't fit into the old categorization of categorizations of religion. It's like very much like a neo religion in the same way like Bitcoin and then Ethereum are like neo nation states. Yeah, I mean, I think my preferred analogy would be a political one. So the nation state one, which you've done a number of times. People feel a religious deal perhaps towards their nation state or their tribe or their ethnos, you know, that we see for history. I mean, people that's probably the primary cause of people living and dying and fighting, you know, becoming soldiers and going to war and things like that.
So again, though, you know, blockchains are not complete in the sense that a nation is, you know, they don't. But, you know, I think that's probably my preferred analogy. Like I can certainly see that, you know, there's a hundred million or so people worldwide that kind of subscribed to Bitcoin nation. I like Balaji's conception. I think, you know, the crypto capital versus the whatever the woke capital versus communist capital. I think that's really, really opt. Yeah, that's funny. I actually just read that like for the first time, like last night. So good timing, good timing for that. I would say that the reason why I frequently use like the nation state to like analyze Ethereum is like what it is.
Whenever I do that, like I also go backwards and say, well, the nation state is just like the next iteration of religion. Well, the nation state now is sort of becoming obsolete too. I would argue. I mean, like if you just look at the crypto community, like you have people that have much, much more in common with each other. Even though they, you know, are it's a global audience fundamentally. Then they have with their sort of fellow countrymen. And that doesn't just happen on, you know, along the line. And I think that's like the truest definition of the metaphors, which is, you know, a congregation of people that are gathering in a certain venue, where that new digital typically identity supersedes the old identities that they sort of had or subscribed to.
And that could be crypto. It could be like trading JPEGs back and forth and discord. So it could be whatever. Like Roblox. I'm not even sure what Roblox is, but I'm just going to say it because I think kids like it. Or, you know, Fortnite or whatever. So like if you were to poll hundreds, zoomers and say, what's your primary affiliation? I think they wouldn't say like American necessarily or like a good chunk of them would say something else. Yeah. I mean, that's always the, that's been the early promises of the internet, right? Is like poll all like-minded people, regardless of their physical locations in the world and regardless of where they are really in relationship to borders, and allow them to meet on the internet and group together according to like, like values and like interests.
And it also just so happens we have this new crypto crypto thing is instantiating specific values upon like internet digital objects that we can all like rally behind. Well, the crypto affiliation is the strongest because it's deeply tribal. The stakes are enormously real. It's financial and nature. So it's a very grown up game, but it's also, you know, very fun and, you know, youthful and, you know, and like, you know, gamified, but, you know, the stakes are incredibly real. So when you manage to not do work and including the work that you do for Bitcoin and the work that you don't do for Bitcoin, whatever you call work, what happens, what happens after you do work?
What happens when it's play time? What do you do? So I try and carve out I would say one week and a month to like go climb a large pile of rocks. Is this like in or rock climbing? Like mountaineering, which includes some technical climbing, but typically you're just hiking uphill. And I like that because it's an excuse to turn off my phone for two to three days. Not that I don't have service typically, unfortunately, you know, it's like hard to get lost anymore. It's like all these mountains, like you think they wouldn't have service, but they do. And it kind of like takes the joy out of it a little bit.
But yeah, I like it because it's an excuse to just turn off my phone and, you know, suffer basically. I mean, that's what mountaineering is. It's suffering at altitude. And so I attempt to do that once a month, but I can't always. But how are you going to do that Miami? There's not many mountains around you. No, I have to fly it. Typically I would fly at West and do okay. Oh, sure. You come out West to go hiking? Yeah, I was, where are you now? You said you're in Southern California? In San Diego, yeah. Oh, it was like in your neck, the woods a few weeks ago. Oh, no shit. Yeah, next time I'll let you out.
But, you know, back when I lived in the Northeast, the mountains were there, but they were all small. Right. The best ones are obviously out West. Like where would you go, cascades, Rockies? I was most recently in the high Sierra. And before that, I did Chasta up in Northern California. That one, yeah. So we're going to try some harder ones soon. Glaciers. If you ever, yeah, anywhere, anywhere on the, on the West Coast, if you ever go mountaineering, like I'm just with you, I want to come. Okay. What do I need to know that that's not just because I'm, I'm, I've done an insane amount of like actual backpacking trips where I put a tent in my backpack.
But like, what do I, what am I not prepared for if it's mountaineering? So that's the essential skill is just being able to, you know, walk with a 40, 50 pound pack. Um, but, you know, if it's, there's snow involved, you have to know how to use crampons and fix them to your boots. Yes. Um, like learning to sell for us with an ice axe is pretty essential. That's easy enough to learn. And then glacier travel, um, on a short rope, um, and, uh, you know, crevasse rescue. That would be like the next skill to learn. But if somebody, if somebody in my troop knows how to do it, do I know how to need to know how to do it?
Yeah. You should know. Yeah. Cause you might have to save them, right? Um, um, and then like anything to do with cold weather, just like gear management, cold weather, camping. Um, if you've done that, you'd be good. Okay. I mean, there aren't that many mountains in the lower 48 that are really going to impair all you. Yeah. This is, this is, this is right on my alley. I'm a big fan of the concept of suffering. I think pain is how you, how you improve yourself. Um, so it's funny that you brought that up. I have a good friend that, uh, he divides fun into like three typologies. Have you heard of this?
Like type one fun type two funds. Like type one fun is just like straight pure hedonic fun. You know, like, I don't know. Like doing croaker or something. Drugs for dopamine. Type two fun is like, you know, it's like actually kind of challenging in the moment. You might not seem that fun. But afterwards you sort of glad you did it. Endorphins type. Yeah. You know, maybe like, you know, running a 10k or something. And then type three fun is just miserable in the moment. Uh, feels terrible. And then I suppose upon reflection, you might be like, oh, maybe I want to do that again. That's where I'd put most mountain air experiences.
Nice. Yeah. Maybe meditation as well. Because whenever I try and meditate, like, I fucking hate it. And then I can't do it at the end. I'm like, I guess that was okay. I'm like the worst tech bro ever. I can't meditate. Yeah. I can't do it. Have you? Okay. So here's something I've noticed ever since, especially, we started happening before crypto. But as soon as it's, as soon as I got into crypto, it got even worse. It's just like, my memory is absolutely shot. And I think it's just because I have so many devices around me that I just used to outsource all my memory functions. And so like, as a muscle, the atrophy is just endless.
Have you noticed anything like this? That's an interesting concept. So as you have more external storage available to you, you just externalize more and more. And then eventually your brain just becomes an index of how to find things. So we've effectively become sort of like cyborgs a little bit, you know, we've uploaded part of our, I mean, I guess that's true. Like you've uploaded part, you outsource some of your consciousness. I mean, like, that's kind of like, you know, we don't remember maps of cities anymore because we've GPS. And we don't remember like trivia or like facts about the presidents because you've a Google.
Exactly. So I do worry about that actually. Yeah. Certainly, like, honestly, I think mentally speaking, I'm at my worst, like I've been on a study decline since high school, like I think high school, me would have just like blown me out of the water when it comes to like any mental sharpness, actual test. Yeah. I think everybody feels like that. I don't know. I don't think it can be reversed. I definitely remember being more mentally sharp, but I'm definitely also much more wise than I ever was. There we go. There we go. There's the trade off there. Like mental acuity, maybe it's not there, but like wisdom is, wisdom levels are off the charts.
Hopefully. That's the trade. That's the trade we all make. Yeah. Okay. So it's the weekend, but you're not, we can't go mountaineering. So what are you doing in Miami this weekend? I'm still trying to figure like, trying to get settled here, there's like a lot of stuff like that. And I'm more generally stuck to do. I would, I'm actually not a big beach person, but I would try and do something outdoors. You probably find a spare weekend. I mean, like the truth is that I reserve my weekends often for writing because I can't get it done. Sure. I can't get into like a deep work, like, you know, non actual work, work phase during the week.
That's when I do probably 70% of all my writing would be on like a Saturday or Sunday morning. Be at relax, go to the gym, like go to the sauna, write, you know, like go to eat, like, you know, really boring stuff, but stuff I can't do during the week as much. Sure. Okay. Do you actually like course light or is it just a meme? I actually quit drinking. So. Okay. If I, if I were to drink, I would drink course light, but I'm much more focused on, on sort of being healthy these days. Well, I have, when I, the way that I get through writing is I just brute force, brute force the writing by ingesting beer.
So we are on offices and to the spectrum there. Yeah, I used to do that. I mean, when I was an undergrad, that's how I wrote most of my philosophy papers, you know, like write trunk at its sober. But yeah, the, I don't know, these days, like you have to try and get yourself into the flow state somehow. And so these days, I don't try and rush it. I mean, I'm not, you know, I'm not on a contract, I don't have to write every weekend or whatever. So I just now, I just kind of wait for inspiration, I suppose. So as, as 2021 is coming to a close with the last quarter remaining here, like what do you, what do you, what do you see on the horizon for our industry and for Bitcoin?
Well, Bitcoin is just becoming much more sort of predictable and like widely understood. You know, things like Cuba passing a Bitcoin law, like that's probably honestly not net good for regular Cubans or Cuban Bitcoiners. But it just cements the notion of Bitcoin as sort of this, you know, like not that interesting monetary alternative. And that's, it's a good for Bitcoin overall, like Bitcoin, like gold, gold is extremely boring, but it's worth 11 trillion dollars. Bitcoin is just going to grow up and we're going to look back at these days with nostalgia and be like, wow, those, like such an exciting time.
So we should be grateful to be living through it, frankly, but, you know, the future of Bitcoin is just going to be this onward march towards respectability and there's nothing wrong with that. It just won't be as exciting in 10 years time. In the near term, you know, I've always kind of been more on the conservative side in terms of, you know, being wary of financial regulators. At this point, I think they've signaled to us that they're going to try something, whether it's treasury, whether it's SEC, whether it's some other agency, there's no doubt in my mind now that there's some reprisal coming from the state.
I think we can survive it. I think it's likely to be healthy, but I think it's also going to be extremely painful. And so I don't know what form is going to take, whether they're going to target exchanges, more contract developers, you know, entrepreneurs, funds, it's not clear to me yet, but it is clear that there's sort of a lot of political capital behind this anti-crypto movement. Now, of course, you know, we're looking at a time of, you know, like relatively rare unity at the state level. You have the president, both houses of Congress or blue. That may not be the case in sort of a year's time after the midterms.
So this might actually be sort of like their shot to, you know, do something extremely harsh, maybe in a year or two, like we'll be in better stead in Washington. But yeah, the, you know, the crypto industry is like what, 60% America based, it's like very exposed to what happens in the US. And so I think it could be like a really, really, really tough 18 months. And you know, I would steal yourself for that. But that doesn't mean that, you know, what we're building is invalid or isn't going to work. It's just we might have to, you know, reimagine what it's like to build these, you know, unsensurable protocols.
And you know, critically examine some of the, you know, the choke points, which is, you know, what they're going to go after. They'll go after things that give them strategic leverage, whether it's stablecoins, exchanges, whatever. And so, you know, it'll be a process of also, I think, learning about what those exposures are. And, and maybe we'll sort of think twice about having stablecoin based liquidity for everything, you know, something like that. What do you think is to add more risk, Bitcoin or DeFi? I think like Bitcoin will like suffer collateral damage just by association. I think like lightning operators would be probably, you know, lumped in with DeFi.
So like if something adverse happens to like DeFi, it would suffer in that respect. It seems to me that DeFi like Dexes would be like a primary target, at least just looking, reading through the lines, like looking at what Gensler's had to say. You know, some of the tone I'm seeing from people that are actually talking to, you know, these officials, it seems to be pretty, pretty down in the dumps as far as I can tell from my position. I don't really have, you know, any privileged information whatsoever. But yeah, it seems like a lot of it would be targeted either at the like brokerage industry or DeFi directly.
Who's your favorite music artist? All time I'm a huge Beatles fan. I love Pink Floyd as well. The Eagles, what's up when more contemporary like Tim and Paula and I'm a big Kanye fan as well. He had a good new album. Yeah. Oh, that's the other more frequent take I've heard as the album's not that good. I haven't listened to it. I liked it. I've been listened to it. You know, it's very like very, you know, Christian in nature, which I like, you know, it's like Kanye's work has been sort of like, it's always like had some like gospel elements, but it's like unabashedly, religious now, which, you know, like I like, but yeah, I actually think there's like some good tracks on there too.
I'll have to give you a listen. Awesome, man. Well, thanks for coming on Layers Zero and let me pick your brain. Thanks David. Maybe you can come on on the brink. Well, you're on there. I've always wanted to, to be honest. So we all. Oh, it's been great, man. All right. Cheers. Thanks, Nick. Take care. Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcasts and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience.
You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops, raffles and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, meet any things and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks, everyone, for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation.