Nic Carter rejoins the podcast to discuss Bitcoin’s second civil war. When did it begin? Where are the party lines drawn? How will it end? Possible solutions? David and Nic dig into all of these questions and much more.
------ 📣SUI | Register for Sui Basecamp https://bankless.cc/SUI-podcast
------ 🎧 Listen On Your Favorite Podcast Player: https://bankless.cc/Podcast
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
💸 CRYPTO TAX CALCULATOR | USE CODE BANK30 https://bankless.cc/CTC
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 7:30 The Bitcoin Civil War 10:32 Defining Side Lines 14:14 No Core Consensus 17:13 Filtering Out Transactions & Expressivity 22:39 Season Two 26:16 Lightning Doesn’t Work? 29:16 Ordinals & Bitcoin L2s 32:49 The Future of Bitcoin Core 35:16 Covenants Explained 37:26 Bitcoin Venture Capital 48:26 BitVM 51:64 Bitcoin Block Philosophy 1:02:10 Bitcoin Expressivity Going Too Far 1:07:36 Bitcoin Ideology 1:10:12 Closing
------ RESOURCES
Nic Carter https://twitter.com/nic__carter
------ Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
I think the technology and the financialization of Bitcoin are intertwined and you can't have one without the other. And as we move into this intermediate term with ETF flows and things like that, these allocators will continue to ask themselves, is there interesting stuff happening on Bitcoin? Why Bitcoin is supposed to be any other blockchain? And just being the only crypto asset with an ETF, I don't think it's sufficient. So we do have to continue to show that there's like actual technological developments happening. Bankless Nation, welcome to a conversation with Nick Carter. Over in Bitcoin world, there is a second civil war forming.
It's been forming for a while. It's always been there. We unpack it here today on the conversation with Nick Carter. But this camp is the filtering camp versus the Bitcoin rationalist camp. There's not really any good names here. These are the monetary maximalism versus the Bitcoin expressivity camp. The Satoshi's only versus the Ordinals camp. Some of these people want to only have Bitcoin, the blockchain be good for BTC transfers. And the other camp is for Bitcoin expressivity, Ordinals, BRC 20s, Layer 2s on Bitcoin. And this has worked its way up to the Bitcoin core part of the stack. We're not going to have hard for the Bitcoin chain.
That's not going to happen. But there are still places where these different philosophies want to exert control. So there's been political fights over what gets merged into Bitcoin core. And overall, there's just been a divide in the Bitcoin community about what Bitcoin can do and what Bitcoin should be good for. Apparently, the very, very radical side of this camp wants to go so far, even to make a filter that filters out Bitcoin transactions that have arbitrary data in them. Anything that's not just a simple raw BTC transfer doesn't go through the Bitcoin blockchain, at least at the surface level, not the actual chain.
I think this is super interesting. And I love the fact that the Bitcoin expressivity side of things, the Ordinals, BRC 20, Layer 2 side of things have crescendoing momentum. And in my opinion, have a date with destiny of success. At least that's where I think things are going. But first we're going to talk about Sui and the Sui base camp, which is an in-person conference in Paris during Paris, blockchain week, April 10th through 11th. So if you are interested in a parallelized layer one delegated proof of stake chain, the Sui base camp might be for you. There is a link in the show notes to get 20% off of your pass to the Sui base camp.
This is the move ecosystem for all the devs out there who enjoy move. This is Sui is like the spiritual successor to the whole Libra project, now turned into a layer one. And so especially if you're a dev who's interested in parallelized new VMs that are parallelized, there's a link in the show notes, so you get started. Nick Carter and I unpack all of these different conversations and his opinions on this thing, where he stands. Nick has been very, very early to rejecting Bitcoin fundamentalism, Bitcoin monetary maximalism, and been a fan and an investor in Bitcoin expressivity, Bitcoin utility.
And so I just wanted to check in with him and kind of peer over the fence as to what's going on in Bitcoin world. Because I think it's been interesting ever since Ordinals came about, and it's only been growing in his interestingness. And so we have this conversation here on the show today with Nick Carter. So let's go ahead and get right into that conversation with Nick Carter. But first, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world class security and award winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world.
Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos. With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience.
So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax obligations for providing token grants to your team? It's no secret that token management gets complicated. Between learning all the legal language and tax obligations in every country that your team is in, token grant management can feel like an obstacle course, but it doesn't have to.
That's where Toku steps in. Toku provides practical tools to handle token grants, allowing for effective oversight of token distributions and payroll tax compliance for employees, contractors, advisors, and investors. They also handle tax withholdings through their real-time tax calculations that can be done by Toku or integrated into any payroll EOR providers in any jurisdiction. Toku is a trusted provider of protocol labs, dydx foundation, mean protocol, and many more. Get started for free and make token compensation simple at toku.com slash bank lists. It's everyone's favorite season in crypto, tax season, and crypto tax is always an absolute headache, especially for all you degenes out there.
But it doesn't have to be a nightmare. That's where crypto tax calculator comes in. The software built for degenes by degenes. As Coinbase's official global tax partner, crypto tax calculator focuses on making complex transactions into easy ones, supporting over 300,000 currencies across Ethereum, Arbitram, Optimism, as well as a thousand other integrations as well. It's as simple as connecting your wallet, pulling in all your transactions, and following the automated suggestions to quickly and accurately calculate your tax obligations. Plus, for all the airdrop farmers out there, crypto tax calculator has your back.
As they are consistently adding support for new and upcoming layer ones, layer twos, and all the airdrops that you're currently farming. 2024 is the year where the degenes do their crypto taxes with speed and confidence. Make taxes this year easy and affordable with crypto tax calculator. Sign up at cryptotaxcalculator.io and get a 30% discount with code bank 30. Click the link in the show notes for more information. What's up, Nick? How's it going? Good, man. Good to be back. I feel like, I don't know how many of these we've done now. A good number. Yeah, you are number two number most frequent bankless podcast guests, but also the instances of where it's just been like you and me going at it is also like creeping up there pretty well.
While I'm honored to be back, I feel like it's been a while. So thank you. Yeah, well, it's because there's like some shenanigans going on in the Bitcoin, the Bitcoin sector. I think there's like a lot, there's a lot to talk about in the Bitcoin world, which like isn't usually the case, but for the last like 18 months or so, like the conversations to be had about Bitcoin are like up only. Are you, are you a Bitcoiner? Do you consider yourself Bitcoiner turning the tables? Do I have to own Bitcoin to be a Bitcoiner? Ah, yeah, I think so. In that case, I'm not a Bitcoiner. Not even one mere Satoshi.
Not even a single set. Yeah. Bitcoin, believe it or Bitcoin, like I think Bitcoin, I believe in the Bitcoin ideology. And I think the Bitcoin, Bitcoin ideology like was extremely precise on a lot of very deep truisms about crypto very early and there's an ideology that I like largely agree with in a lot of different respects. And so in that way, if I can define Bitcoinerism like that, then I am a Bitcoiner. Okay. Big tent. Yeah. So we'll have you. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. But one of the things that's going on recently is like that big tent is like splitting. There's like another Bitcoin civil war like bubbling at a higher level in the stack.
Is that how you would define the landscape at this present moment or would you change those words? Yeah. I mean, it's been going on. Do you think there's been a Bitcoin civil war for years? That's how I feel at least. I mean, between the laser-eyed Uber Maxis and the Bitcoin pragmatists. Yeah. Like, I don't know what any of the camps are called anymore, but there's like basically the fundamentalist or the purist, the light laser-eyed Maxis, if you want to call on that. And then there is like the moderates, maybe, the like, you know, integration lists, the Bitcoin season tours. This is what CK was calling them, the Bitcoins.
Who is the fixed-to-filter camp versus the Bitcoin season two people? Yeah. I think so basically the core divide is like to maybe call them Bitcoin monetarists, like people that think the Bitcoin, the protocol should be only interested in moving around units of Bitcoin versus people that think ought to do other things as well. And that debate has been happening on Bitcoin forever. I mean, like, there was issues with counter-party back in the day, I think in 2013, maybe, if I'm not getting my timelines mixed up, there were debates over opera-turned, Vitalik's reference those in the past. I think he might have even mentioned that as a catalytic moment for him wanting to go the Ethereum direction, realizing that opera-turned was too limited and, you know, whole new protocols required.
So that same debate is happening. And so, like, now, of course, the main concern is ordinals and inscriptions, and, like, can the protocol filter out non-monetary data? Is this spam, does the benefits towards fee accrual to those matter or defuse non-matter? Should there be fees? Is there a security budget question? All these questions are pretty intertwined. And so I would say broadly, like, the debate is that between folks that are interested in Bitcoin being more richly stateful to borrow the Ethereum term, and between the folks that think Bitcoin is just about moving Bitcoin around and pretty much nothing else.
But it's certainly come to the fore recently in particular with ordinals, but we're also seeing that same debate with the Covenants proposal, software, the op-cat proposal, and you're going to see it now with roll-ups as well as those become, you know, something that is a thing on Bitcoin, I think, in the next year. And yeah, so certainly, like, a pretty, like, heated episode in sort of like that debate. I think trying to actually define the line between these two camps has been, like, murky. But I think one, perhaps, definition that gets us, does a lot of work, a lot of good work is, like, does this trend, this Bitcoin transaction have extra data beyond BTC transfers or does it not?
And I think that definition kind of gets us most of the way there. But I heard there was, like, something like drama around this one, coin join protocol, which was about Bitcoin privacy and Bitcoin, kind of like a tornado cash equivalent, just like a privacy tool for a privacy gadget for Bitcoin transfers, which I think even, like, the Bitcoin fundamentalist, the monetary maximalist would say, like, we enjoy those properties. But if you filter out transactions from Bitcoin that have arbitrary data, then you also lose this one coin join implementation. And so even that isn't a perfect definition because the coin join people are enhancing the monetary properties of Bitcoin.
And you wouldn't really clump them into the Ordinals category. But they do need that extra stateful data about Bitcoin in order to run their program. And so even that definition isn't perfectly precise. But I think that that one line kind of gets us most of the way there in terms of determining who's on what side. Do you agree? But I mean, I think it's a silly debate because Bitcoin has always, always had non-monetary data in it literally from the first block, right? I mean, Satoshi put the Genesis block information in there and people have always found ways to put arbitrary data into Bitcoin, including people that are on the filtering camp, they're on the side of filtering.
So loop dash, infamously, in 2011, put Bible verses into Bitcoin. They're still in there. If you look, if you go to an explorer that supports text searching for arbitrary text data in Bitcoin, you can find his verses, I think they, I'm trying to remember exactly what they were. But he ran a mining pool called, I think, Allegias, which I think is biblical reference. And you'll see that in there. I mean, Coinbase outputs always have non-monetary data basically saying which mining pool might them. And people have always found ways to insert non-monetary arbitrary data into Bitcoin even outside of Opp return, like using malform transaction types.
And even very respected devs that have been very influential in Bitcoin, like Andrew Poelstra have made this point, you can't actually really inhibit arbitrary data insertion into Bitcoin. You can maybe try and like, soft fork out the, you know, blob space associated with inscriptions. You can't actually stop people doing it. People find a way to do it. And it's just a matter of like how efficient it is and how useful for operating a node, like how burdensome that data is on node operators. So I find it to be silly. People will use Bitcoin for whatever they want. From my stance, I think it's very useful to have, you know, other transaction types on Bitcoin.
I'm always of the view that we should have like a rich and active, you know, set of different patterns of network usage, whether that's L2s or inscriptions. I think the ordinal thing is great. But I guess a lot of that comes from my view that like having fees and usage is good. And some people would rather preside over wasteland where no one ever moves their Bitcoin, everyone just sits on the Bitcoin. And I guess a lot of people are content with that, but I'm not. Why can't we have both? Because why can't we just have two versions of a Bitcoin node software, one that actually does filter out arbitrary data to satisfy the monetary maximalist to satisfy the fixed the filter camp and then have a different implementation of a Bitcoin node software that does all of the expressive stuff.
Why can't we have both? Bitcoin is generally our skeptical of multiple competing implementations. And I think Bitcoin core is pretty much the only dominant former software. And I think the risk is that it would, there would be consensus issues with multiple implementations. I don't, I'm not that up to date on Ethereum, but I think there's like, it's trending in the direction of one major implementation that people generally use. Am I correct in that assertion or is it so pretty so I went in? There's a new one's conversation here. So like guest dominance is on the execution layer and there's been a very big push to reduce guest dominance down from its heights of like 82 to 83% where it is now at 75%.
So still pretty dominant. But other execution layers are coming online like George Eos from Paradigm is making rust, so rust Ethereum. And that's just on the execution layer on the consensus layer that we have actually a pretty good, healthy state of diversity of four different clients where you need to combine at minimum two of them in order to get over, over consensus thresholds. Yeah, so Bitcoiners, I think the general design philosophy is like there ought to be one major implementation and the significant risk to consensus if there are different ones. So this is a fight over Bitcoin core.
Yeah, in a sense. From what I've seen of the fixed filter debate and I've honestly kind of ignored it because I think there's no chance for the like filtering camp to win here. It's very clear to me that I could win. I think are mostly just talking about transaction propagation and I don't think they're talking about some way to actually eliminate inscriptions in the sort of core protocol like undo taproot or like undo segwit or something I think that would be very far fetched. So then what you might just get is a situation where people email transaction data to minors directly to get it, let's say they did filter out and they made inscription transactions non-standard, you could just email your transaction data to a minor and so you know you wouldn't really eliminate those transactions from the actual ultimate inclusion in the blockchain.
You would just make it more unwieldy to get them in, but people would still do that. And it would create a shadowman pool, which I think wouldn't be good at all. And it would create out of band transactions and things like that. So I don't know, it seems like pretty silly to me the whole thing and I don't think those people have like the critical mass to get anything done here. I do think it's interesting that there are these two different philosophies. Call it the monetary maximalist fix the filter camp versus the Bitcoin expressive camp. I like the word expressive and I think that's kind of like some of the ideology that's being expressed on the like arbitrary data, where like adding more expressivity to Bitcoin is I think it's no coincidence that like Vitalikich pushed out from that early like op-code thing and then goes make literally a fully expressive smart contract platform.
And so we're starting to see Bitcoin land dabble into this. But like who has the incentive to filter out transactions? Is it like why are they so motivated to care so hard? Yeah, I mean, I think they don't want Bitcoin to host like, you know, NFT activity, they don't want to reward those kinds of people and they don't want their node software. I mean, I don't want a lot of things in this world, but a lot of things don't also motivate me to get out of the bed in the morning to go like change the world in that particular state because I don't have the incentive to like, like they can want that.
But why do they fight so hard? Yeah, I mean, I think it's about showing your adherence to the, you know, a specific breed of Bitcoin ideology and like showing how pure you are, basically, you know, like creating that signal and gaining cloud on that basis. But yeah, it seems like they're tilting a windmills and it's big coin virtue signaling. Yeah, effectively. And I don't think there's any prospect of it happening. So I'm pretty puzzled by it, frankly, I think ordinals are great. I think Bitcoin itself is a good host for NFT data or other arbitrary data types in particular because the, you know, blockchain is small.
And so we have like really good assurances that the data is going to be there and accessible, you know, 10, 20 years from now. And, you know, like we've had insertions of this kind of data for a long time and inscriptions just codify it and do it in a pretty, you know, benevolent way from a user perspective. So I see very, very few downsides there. I was hanging out with Alex Adelman and we were talking about just some of the natural incentives that comes with like an expressive layer on a blockchain. I use the example of Bitcoin media, Bitcoin ink, one of the big media companies in the Bitcoin space were one of the first ones to do some ordinals initiative where they like minted an ordinal on the blockchain and that caused that I think was at the very beginning of like one of the schisms, I mean, it's the same schism as you've defined, but the modern schism between these two camps, one, the Bitcoin fundamentalists that like pointed their way fingers at Bitcoin media for playing how dare they play in the ordinal space, but somebody who like me who works at a media company who understands media incentives, I see like Bitcoin expressivity as like a great complement to a media company's business model because expressivity is like drama surface area is like there's things to talk about.
There's content to produce. There is more than just mini like mere BTC transfers to talk about and as like BTC media who is going to be like one of the largest distributors of thought of narrative of content in this space probably loves the aspects that there is like expressivity happening on Bitcoin. There's ordinals, there's NFTs, there's datefulness in its essence and so any sort of media ecosystem around Bitcoin is going to enjoy that because that is a boon to their business. They have more content to produce and I think that is just one shard of which you could look at this. You could also look at it from the VC angle like VCs also will love the expressivity going on Bitcoin because there's this more investible surface area.
So like we have like these ideological motivated side of the camp versus like the actual rational more economically rational agents on the other side of the camp to me is just like well I know which one's going to win here like I know how this story goes. Yeah, I thought it was brave for BTC media to do that and that was a signal to me that the sort of like let's say purist camp which they'd probably identified with more historically throughout the debates like that started well that it always existed in my case like there was a big fall out in 2021 where people got mad at me for investing in on Bitcoin stuff right so that was like part of the Bitcoin civil war so sort of like Bitcoin cold civil war maybe like it wasn't that bad.
So I sort of see fractures even in the purist camp and now they seem very fractured. Now we see big debates around covenants between the purists. We see icing now a realization has set in that ordinals are not going anywhere and descriptions aren't going anywhere. And so I think that camp has been somewhat defanged because reality has just imposed itself on them and they realized well this stuff is actually going to stick around regardless of whether you want it or not. So I see the kind of purist side is very fractured and not very organized, not very coordinated and I think like the Bitcoin season tours whatever you want to call them like the Udi's and Erics of the world like very clear to me that they are in the process of winning or have won already basically.
Why is it called season two? Well I guess the idea is that season one was to do with lightning and the previous big civil war which was the block size war which was won by the small blockers and lightning was the output of that like so much effort went to segwit and lightning. That was one technological theme that characterized Bitcoin from 2015 let's say when segwit and lightning were sort of first theorized to 2023 I would say that was sort of the thrust. Like Bitcoin early days is just a thing people are trying to build and then it's like okay scale ability how we're going to do it. Okay we're going to do this.
There was a period of slumber like relative complacency I would say is Bitcoin core and application developers were just folks on lightning. Now there's been a reinvigoration partially due to ordinals and inscriptions but also due to disillusionment with lightning as the ordained scaling method and it's really puzzled me that lightning has been the focus for so long it's still the focus among many Bitcoin focus VCs among many application developers founders that are building infrastructure on Bitcoin and for core devs like if you look at the core dev road map it's still sort of like lightning focused and season two is just to pose the question hey is there's like something else we could do here you like is it all lightning is that the ordained scaling mechanism are there other ways to do things or there are other things we can do and ordinals and inscriptions I think ordinals were invented conceived of in late 22 maybe if I'm remembering that correctly and that you know they had a big 23 and now is the new season for sure from my seat I see it happening of new altos and eat contemplating things like roll ups so doing what big corners said they would always do which is inherent the best tech from other blockchains let other blockchains experiment make mistakes learn things and then we'll bring it over Bitcoin is now considering or the big winners are considering doing that thing that we said we would do which is inheriting the best technology but it does require making this heretical statement hey maybe lightning is not all it's cracked up to be and that takes a lot and you know obviously people aren't going to be happy with that because we have such a sunk cost both like intellectually and positioning wise in favor of lightning and a ton of capital as well and just developer time has been sunk in a lightning it takes a lot to acknowledge that it hasn't succeeded in the way that maybe we thought it would if looking back we look back at the way we thought about things in 2016 17 you to be kind of brave to to you know stick your hand up and say lightning didn't deliver also because you never want to show weakness but it didn't like look at the stats like at the data like the traction lightning is useful for some types of transactions for certain transaction niches but it's not a panacea and it's certainly not the scaling method that's going to take Bitcoin to the promised land it's not where you know these richly stable transactions are going to occur it's clear to me I think I've relatively good view into this stuff it's time to explore alternatives and I don't think this is a you're not alone here there I think there are people if I'm remembering my Twitter timeline history correctly there are like a little bit quite lightning developers who have stood up and been like hey guys I don't know about this I've been working on this for a while I don't I don't see the path forward here maybe you have more light you can shut on that yeah I mean we gave like we gave lightning the old college try you know what I mean so we passed segway and we fixed some malability bug for lightning we fought this entire civil war and the whole point was hey we don't need to expand the block size we have this alternative thing that we're going to do which is lightning that's going to win a scalability Bitcoin core was lightning focused for the last five years to hundreds of millions of dollars of VC I know it doesn't seem like a lot but for Bitcoin VC it's a lot went into building lightning infrastructure building applications for lightning and as time went on I think we had enough data regarding the usage of lightning and the drawbacks of lightning we learned what some people theorize like I'll actually give Carl Simone credit here I remember him years ago saying hey lightning is capital efficient UX complexity is very significant and that's true basically and like we're investor in lightning companies and I don't mean to denigrate them I think lightning is still useful in certain contexts undeniably but it does I think the time is such that we know now that these challenges are fundamental as opposed to merely contingent challenges where like oh we have an invest enough resources in this we haven't sufficiently explored it now we know now we know that the challenges with lightning are actually fundamental in particular the cost and difficulty of pre-funding a channel that's very unintuitive from a UX perspective the capital and efficiency of a mobilizing capital in the network in order to transact it doesn't adhere to our intuitions as to what a payment network is like and it's very much unlike the way that people transact in blockchain context we know now that these are fundamental challenges that have to do with the actual architecture of the network they're not things that can actually really be designed away and if you look at lightning like that's why probably most lightning transactions today are custodial through custodial wallets as opposed to using lightning itself we know now that retail ordinary users are not going to just use lightning wallets in the way that was maybe intended we know that it's more centralized model there's nothing wrong with that that's how payment systems develop but yeah I think basically we have enough data now to say it has these fundamental challenges let's look at something else and even lightning I kind of categorized this is still a project that was is trying to express Bitcoin it's a payments network it is just expressing it in a payments modality like a payments form factor which counts but now these like season two like innovations are kind of are meaningfully different like ordinals is more about just like data not about BTC transfers it's about data it's about NFTs it's about JPEGs on the chain but then and then there's also some newer innovations going on in the bit VM that is actually layer twos where maybe we can start to bring back the payments conversation the BTC the asset transfer conversation but I see kind of these two not not camps but two different ways of leveraging Bitcoin data one is like the NFT ordinals side of things and then the second one is like the more further out big actual true Bitcoin layer twos is there actually a line there or in my imagining things no but I think the like Bitcoin moderates like myself are supportive of both the creation and fostering of an NFT ecosystem on Bitcoin I think this benefits there and also alternative ways of making Bitcoin payments ways of doing Bitcoin smart contracts right but isn't one more real like the NFT ordinals thing is like undeniably real we have the data like that's that no one's really questioning that but the Bitcoin layer twos still more researchy engineering theoretical correct undoubtedly and bit VM which is the catalytic sort of technologically forward which I am personally very excited about after having spent fair amount of time with Robin the inventor recently that's still theoretical and those projects out there saying they're building on bit VM bit VM barely exists sort of still back in the napkin type stuff and it may exist this year I think it will exist this year but doesn't really currently exist in a meaningful sense but what I know about it is so exciting that I think we can make predictions about the infrastructure the bit VM enables namely I think optimistic roll ups in like sort of a true sense on Bitcoin and so well okay if people are already saying that they're building on bit VM like and you can interpret that is like well you guys are crazy because you're building too far ahead of the curve you're building on top of paperware or you could say like well no you they just see where the puck is going and they're going ahead of it yeah and look we've funded Bitcoin altos like new alternative altos like in 2021 in 23 as well before we knew about bit VM but bit VM is an unlock which is a massive accelerant and it means you can now build an alt too without the requirement of a soft fork which is essential because there is a power vacuum in Cordev there's been a lot of there's been a lot of turnover in Cordev I don't think people don't know about this and the champions that would have historically championed a soft fork are not active for one reason or another so if you're predicating your business on a soft fork is not going to happen for the foreseeable there's very few soft forks that actually appear likely in the next 12 to 24 months so bit VM is great because like it allows us to sort of potentially circumvent that interesting well yeah so what does this mean for the future of Core you talked about how Core has been built like in a lightning centric design or in a lightning direction for so many years and it sounds like that we are thinking about new directions what do you if these new incentives at play around the Bitcoin ecosystem play out as we are watching them play out what do you what do you think about what does that mean for the future of Bitcoin Core Core is pretty undeterred and you know steering Bitcoin Core is like steering an aircraft carrier or frankly that's not even a good analogy because aircraft carriers do move you know they can be stared can stair one Bitcoin Core moves at its own pace which is glacial there's of course a lot of work to make it you know root out bugs and keep it updated with like new operating system developments but like soft forks there's conversations around like covenants but there's a bunch of different proposals so nobody wants to really go to bat for one covenant proposal or another because there's so many and they're worried that they will pick the wrong one so that's caused Jesus okay so wait I have heard that there is a universal consensus that Bitcoiners enjoy covenants except for the filter people it's just like what you're saying is like we need an implementation and deciding on which implementation has no consensus yeah it's like a political consideration whereby people are worried about picking a specific approach to covenants and there's a lot and so people are just waiting to see which one emerges but for one to emerge there need to be champions and the typical champions that we had in prior years around let's say top route or segwit they're like basically retired you know partially due to like Craig Wright harassing all the Cordeves and suing them so I don't blame anyone from stepping back or just due to general PTSD from like dealing with it with you know the activation of top route or segwit like it's very hard to be the center of that I think it's a very emotionally challenging thing so yeah we're kind of in stasis right now with covenants which is weird because most people that are good agree the covenants are important so it's the kind of a like I would say pretty frustrating situation this is probably been the first time the word covenants has been uttered on the bankless podcast so we should probably define what it is can you can you unpack a covenant oh man I would say this is like you asked me what a zk roll up or something hoping you wouldn't I would say a covenant is transaction where you can specify the conditions for the transaction which like sounds very vague but it would allow you to do things like have automatic recovery if you know there's like a transaction which is unusual and maybe you've been hacked and like redirect your funds to evolve instead basically sending the conditions for transaction success initially upfront and my understanding is that unlocks a lot of you know like richer transaction types there's a big debate right now in sort of like the more maxi focused corner of bitcoin around onboarding the global south onboarding hundreds of millions billions users the views the covenants would enable that and so there's like this class argument that's happening whereby people that are anti covenants are are being accused of being classist because the fees would likely be prohibitive without covenants if you wanted to onboard the whole world or whatever even on pro covenants that argument doesn't seem very convincing to me because I think there's a number of different altos in ways you can onboard people without requiring everybody to do sort of L1 transfers like I think scaling through exchanges and bitcoin banks and sidechance like is a valid way to do things so yeah that's like a weird subblock that's happening in bitcoin land right now okay so maybe like reductively covenants are just expressive transactions it fits inside of the expressive category yeah definitely yeah so what's it like being a bitcoin vc these days because kind of for the same way I was talking about earlier like the expressiveness nature of bitcoin is just like surface area for optionality about stuff so I imagine being a bitcoin vc I don't know do you consider yourself a bitcoin vc or just a vc I'm just a vc you know a vc happens to be bitcoin or yeah and a lot of people got it twisted and they thought that I'm a bitcoin vc and I think that I corrected the record on that you know pretty aggressively back in the day yeah but you did it from the perspective of the angry cyber hornet bitcoin max is like fundamentalists who thought you were who thought you were exclusively a bitcoin vc but when it's coming from like more of the ethereum camp and I call you a bitcoin vc I'm just like oh he's a vc who knows all the bitcoin deals yeah so I'm having great time being bitcoin vc or like a vc who looks a bitcoin stuff because there's more stuff to invest in in bitcoin then there ever has been actually like what have been the vc investments in bitcoin historically there is like block stream there is a lot of money there were some custodians or some exchanges miners if you're into that and then there were lightning application infrastructure deals and that was it and some you know some like custody stuff nothing other than the lightning deals nothing none of those categories were about the actual state inside of the bitcoin blockchain that's right they're all about service provision and like ancillary services around bitcoin today it's totally different something has changed there really has been a shift and we're seeing high quality founders that are coming to bitcoin that are newly excited about building new infrastructures on it and I would say specifically new altos from the zika roll up perspective evm compatible altos optimistic roll ups staking like restaking using bitcoin security for other blockchains so we've been like I would love to be more active on bitcoin in prior years I would have love to have been because that would have better aligned like what I care about with my fund but now really almost for the first time there's finally a lot of deals and high quality founders that I feel comfortable investing in where I think the outcomes can be really big as well and very useful to bitcoin so it's pretty much like the best time ever to be a bitcoin VC but specifically one who's open-minded and more moderate a lot of the bitcoin only VCs ironically won't participate in this season at all which I think is a huge mistake but that's fine with me because they're you know that they're occasionally my competition so mantle formerly known as bit down is the first Dow lead web 3 ecosystem all built on top of mantle's first core product the mantle network a brand new high performance a theorem layer two built using the op stack but uses eigenlayers data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one not only does this reduce mantle networks gas fees by 80 percent but it also reduces gas fee volatility providing a more stable foundation for mantle's applications the mantle treasury is one of the biggest Dow owned treasuries which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the web 3 space for mantle mantle already has subcommunities from around web 3 onboarded like game 7 for web 3 gaming and buy bit for tvl and liquidity and on rounds so if you want to build on the mantle network mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone based funding to promising projects that help expand secure and decentralized mantle if you want to get started working with the first Dow lead layer 2 ecosystem check out mantle at mantle dot xyz and follow them on twitter at 0x mantle arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions arbitrum has the leading defy ecosystem strong infrastructure options flourishing NFTs and is quickly becoming the web 3 gaming hub explore the ecosystem at portal dot arbitrum dot IO are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own arbitrum orbit chain arbitrum orbit allows anyone to utilize arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain giving you access to interoperable customizable permissions with dedicated throughput whether you're a developer an enterprise or a user arbitrum orbit lets you take your project to new heights all of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum experience web 3 development the way it was always meant to be secure fast cheap and friction free visit arbitrum dot IO and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities cello is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon negative blockchain built for the real world driving real world use cases like mobile payments and mobile defy and with opera many pay as one of the fastest growing web 3 wallets cello is seeing a meteoric rise with over 300 million transactions and 1.
5 million monthly active addresses and now cello is looking to come home to Ethereum as a layer 2 optimism polygon matter labs and arbitrum have all thrown their hats in the ring for the cello layer 2 to build upon their stacks why the competition the cello layer 2 will bring huge advantages like a decentralized sequencer off chain data availability secured by Ethereum validators and one block finality what does that all mean for you with cello layer 2 gases will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC 20 tokens sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect but cello is a community governed protocol this means that cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard join the conversation in the cello forums follow cello on twitter and visit cello.
org to shape the future of Ethereum yeah well maybe another way to kind of like define the landscape here is that like all those Bitcoin deals that you talked about the miners the service providers the exchanges custodians those are all like exogenous to Bitcoin they're all like looking out at Bitcoin from the outside and one of the things that like one of the reasons why I kind of like skipped over Bitcoin and went straight for the Ethereum world was because like I saw the intern internal internal endogenous side of Ethereum and that just kind of nerds knife to me that something that Bitcoin didn't have like we had internal defi we had our own exchange was called uniswap we had our own money market it was called compound and that internal side of things was just like the exciting thing to me and that's the thing that like Bitcoin has never really had even with lightning can barely really call that internal even though it is about it does have some semblance of like statefulness about Bitcoin but I think really this whole explosion of ordinals the fact that it exploded so quickly and then it's also been followed on by even more akin innovations I kind of think it's just a eludes to like the amount of like latent potential energy there is demand for like an internal endogenous side of Bitcoin that has ever been able to be be expressed before yeah the conditions today are very suitable for that to finally be built like Ethereum has built a lot of this stuff we know now after a lot of these experiments on Ethereum that some of these architectures work like optimistic rollups I think we have enough data to consider that to be like a successful technology we have this hobball of money that's a lot of it's relatively new entrance to Bitcoin focus on ordinals and inscriptions and BRC 20s which is like silliest BRC 20s are that's a proof point to people that people are willing to go through the brain damage of using Bitcoin itself if they think they can make money and a lot of that's capital from the east actually and so that's another catalyst that makes builders think that they can attract liquidity in capital then you have general excitement around Bitcoin with the rally which is more of an ETF thing and the having which I don't think matters but other people think it matters and so there's like a new enthusiasm there's a wealth effect in Bitcoin maybe okay some people that are big big corner is going to be willing to you know do interesting stuff when when these you know applications get built and very importantly there's a disillusionment among lightning among people that are sort of brave enough to make that assertion so those catalysts are coming together to create like a perfect storm basically for actually funding new infrastructures on Bitcoin and getting the capital to make them worthwhile and there have been side chains on Bitcoin in the past like root stocks and sovereign and stacks I would say represented itself as side chain on considers a true side chain but they didn't have the right catalyst so the timing wasn't right the timing is right now and for that reason it's very exciting time in Bitcoin despite you know all the main stuff that I just said about it there's a meme that crispy niskey put out there about Bitcoin which is like Bitcoin is like soap the more you touch it the less you have of it and I saw a retort to that meme which which is like eth is like soap you should probably use it every single day which is like it has a lot of utility and you can do stuff with it and that's why it's valuable and so long as I've been watching Bitcoin Bitcoin has always been just like you know stacksats they humble grow your bitcoins don't touch it you know put in cold storage you know low cost basis no touchy hands off and that's been paired well nicely with like the lack of expressivity up on in Bitcoin up until this point but now like there's a there's a friction there where there's a lot of ordinal stuff and some people are like very happy to go start playing with their bitcoins and start playing in the ordinal's land but in terms of the total market cap of BTC the one trillion dollars I'm gonna still guess it's a large minority of total capital that's like playing in ordinal's expressive Bitcoin land and so in really in order to get this indulgent aside of Bitcoin fully expressed we're going to need to like kind of change the culture of some of that no touchy bitcoins that cold storage deep cold storage bitcoins I mean like we can have both but like there's still like there's still like a cultural divide here a between like the come play with me Bitcoin and the deep cold storage Bitcoin yeah and also the UX of like doing interesting stuff on Bitcoin has been challenging the past but I think that'll change the ordinal's thing has catalyzed creation in new wallets better transactional experiences as well which is really important the major exchanges seem to care about it again they're building like dedicated wallets and tools and things like that they're realigning themselves with Bitcoin so I feel good about it I think the infrastructure is getting there there's a lot of work to do but yeah I think overall it's a pretty good time in Bitcoin what else in Bitcoin world is exciting to you well what else is worth bringing up I mean I think bib VM is is the key thing you know I was writing some internal notes from my team recently about like what I care about and I think bib VM enables optimistic roll ups on Bitcoin under the you know caveat the security assumptions are at least one validator in the set or sequencer whatever you want to call them has to be honest plus miners have to not censor the fraud proves the first both of those caveats I think are fine but this is another conflict divisions Bitcoiners tend to lionize the perfect at the expense of the good and I think etharians are the opposite they will iterate faster and pursue merely very good things and not try for perfect things and a lot of Bitcoiners get lost in these conversations because they look at that assumption that miners aren't going to create a cartel of whatever 51% of hash rate and start censoring and they think well it's not perfect but that's fine with me I know it's I would see I'd be I find it very far fetched that miners would decide to censor fraud proofs if there was an optimistic roll up like first of all it would be very hard to get them any miners together if a pool started misbehaving people could immediately defect to a different pool and miners are structurally long Bitcoin anyway so why would they want a harm Bitcoin I was found that incredibly far fetched the people considered that a show stopping objection so my understanding is that you know Bitfium could be out as early as mid-year and I know that there's a lot of optimistic roll ups that are being built at the moment being funded and being built with the intention of rolling out in 2024 and I think that changes things a lot including from the investor perspective like the Wall Street finance people like main street allocator types that are buying the ETF I don't think we can coast on the ETF like excitement forever like these people care about the technology they don't maybe care enough to like dig into how Bitcoin core works or whatever but they do when they're making their allocative decisions care about the vibrancy of the network and if it's so total ghost town that nobody uses I think they'd be concerned about it they'd be like okay am I just buying like a pet rock type thing like can I really justify this so I think you always do have to show even if it's simply just for optics reasons you do have to show technological development and like a positive vision of the future and a way in which this thing could become a dominant sort of transaction method and a network that people actually use so I think the technology and the sort of like financialization of Bitcoin are intertwined and you can't have one without the other and you know as we move into this like intermediate term with ETF flows and things like that these allocators will continue to ask themselves like is there interesting stuff happening on Bitcoin why Bitcoin is supposed to be the blockchain and just being the only blockchain with an ETF or any you know the only crypto asset with an ETF I don't think is sufficient so we do have to continue to continue to show that there's like actual technological developments happening isn't the internal expressive endogenous side of Bitcoin kind of like the spiritual successor of the big blocker spirit well I was a small blocker and I believed in in that approach I don't know maybe I think the big blockers were wrong in that they felt that merely by adding block space would be sufficient to get Bitcoin to be adopted as a payments network like that was always the argument they made like okay how we're going to onboard millions of people in the global south if the blocks are one megabyte or whatever now they're four megabytes I don't think that was true because I don't think the block size was a constraint at all the constraint there is like is there interesting stuff to do with it you know and I always felt and also the other constraint is like people don't really want to use Bitcoin and transact with for like tax drag reasons and like because people would rather transact with dollars right that's another thing the Bitcoin community has been really slow on the uptake about which is stable coins so I think they were wrong for other reasons and I see like the notion of other altos like roll ups I think that those are actually consistent with like even the lightning philosophy which is execute computation off chain and then periodically sort of batch state and register it on chain like I think that's the best way to do scaling right and I think Ethereum has that in common with Bitcoin frankly and like the Solana vision the monolithic vision is the competitive vision so I tend to think the roll ups and like other types of side chains and altos are still consistent with like the dominant philosophy within Bitcoin but it's going to take a lot of convincing to get the sort of like lightning crowd to sort of agree with that yeah I kind of think the reason why I asked this question is like the big blockers I agree were like wrong in their implementation but not necessarily wrong in spirit and this is actually kind of like my overall critique of Bitcoin as a system and like when we opened up this conversation I was like oh yeah Bitcoin ideology spot on but like Bitcoin the blockchain as a product as an execution incorrect and Ethereum is correct this is like my like high level view of the of this of the system and but like block small blockers I've always thought like have the right ideology the right design for how you build a base layer but then the big blockers are what you want to build on top of that and so the big blocker philosophy to me is just like we can do more with our block space we can do more with our bitcoins and the small blocker philosophy is like we need to preserve base BTC transfers peer to peer at all costs including the costs of like being able to do more with our bitcoins but then of course we have like innovators and you know innovations and progress where we can we can have both if we just have to figure out how to get there and so right now like the bit the small blockers one like we had this we have the small block size on on Bitcoin but the big big blocker spirit is now returning with Bitcoin expressivity bit vm layer 2's on Bitcoin ordinals using Bitcoin for data and now we are seeing like a harmony and alignment between these two philosophies that's kind of creating some sort of like greater than some of his parts which is like all you can see when you see like statefulness vitality vibrancy like you've said VC investment content production coming around to Bitcoin and all of a sudden like this is kind of what you get when you align people's incentives aligned people's ideologies and you can make them both work inside of the same constraints which is just Bitcoin that's a kind of my like landscape definition here yeah I would say like I do pursue that as well and I think the fundamental disconnect is between people that pursue layered scaling as the model and want side chains and you know altos and things like that and between people think that you can just sort of arbitrarily increase the data throughput and that's like the monolithic versus modular debate I guess all the big winners wouldn't call it that and from that perspective I think Bitcoin and Ethereum are on the one camp and then like Solana and Apto's etc are in the other one but yeah I just took Bitcoin a lot longer to realize that there should be more than one scaling solution like the comparison I draw be like the sort of intellectual rot and stagnation that occurred in Bitcoin would be like if Ethereum was still trying to do raiden like if it was just raiden or like percentage of listeners that know what raiden is it's like below 1% raiden was basically lightning network on really yeah you have such little faith in bankless nation we just like never talked about raiden on the podcast before okay okay I don't know that's such a deep cut reference that was a deep cut yeah but think about that like if all of the teeth core dev in the year of our Lord 2024 was still focused on raiden or for another like plasma maybe for instance plasma cash that's probably right yeah so like you just have to iterate and like even leaving all the details aside obviously a system that is adaptive beats an non-adaptive system like that's obviously true like you can't be completely static in a world that changes Bitcoin has endeavored to be static for five to seven years now clearly we need to be empirically driven look at data evaluate whether things were doing our working and change accordingly but we haven't we've been so stubborn we've been very like a priori driven like non-imperial and that's like my main critique of Bitcoiners is they actually reject empiricism a lot of the time they reject data because they view a lot of this data or these observations is like immoral things to say like stablecoins another side of that debate like for years now I've been saying hey stablecoins of traction the in 2020 I wrote a paper called crypto dollars and I said wow stablecoins are doing 30% of all value settle on blockchains and that's going linearly I refreshed out last year in 23 it's now 70 80% all value settle on blockchains is 70 80% of that is stablecoins and so on that basis I said Bitcoin is losing the medium of exchange war right which is true it's a true fact right Bitcoin has actually been displaced is sort of the crypto native collateral it's not the thing people use to collateral is on exchanges anymore it's not the medium of exchange it's certainly lost unit of account battle right you don't quote your positions in units of Bitcoin the way used to right and I went and I said this to the Bitcoin community I said stablecoins are winning what's our stablecoin strategy like stablecoins or the killer app of crypto is Bitcoin going to benefit from this or is Bitcoin usage going to be cannibalized by stablecoins and Bitcoiners said to me they said well actually you need to extend your time horizon like this data is irrelevant ignore the data because you know decades from now people will not use the dollar they'll use Bitcoin to transact with and I said well I don't care about decades from now you know forgive me but I care about today I care about years from now I don't care about some idealized future state that you think will happen but is very indeterminate in which dollars don't exist anymore and everyone has to use Bitcoin because dollars have you know gone they've like exploded or whatever hyperinflated so like that's another conflict divisions which is like I'm data driven I have to be it's my job like we allocate for a living we have to look at where you know the puck is going we have to be dated like reality driven but there's a lot of resistance to that in Bitcoin which is the same resistance to lightning like if you know lightning is a very telling example like the lightning throughput like this big debate on Bitcoin Twitter about lightning right now and the lightning throughput is like at most one to two billion dollars a year in terms of value settled right and you could say oh well you know it's a lot of invitual transactions like it's you know useful for like social media and content monetization applications which is true but the fact is it's probably one to two billion and big owners will say oh you're excluding private channels that's fine but that's not like orders of magnitude more than what's measurable stable coins you probably know this stable coins in 22 settled around ten trillion dollars worth of value that's roughly the same as visa and they're probably gonna do the same in 24 they was a little bit down in 23 10 trillion dollars versus one billion dollars is 10,000 times more 10,000 times more so like how can you not look at that and think to yourself maybe like we missed a trick here like maybe we need to figure out how to harmonize and synergize Bitcoin and stable coins like what's the strategy but there's a general refusal and a rejection of that type of reasoning because stable coins are like immoral or wrong or bad or whatever I will say though some big owners are now coming around to the notion of stables and like those attempts to like bring them on to Bitcoin in various ways but yeah that's like another frustration I have is it's like refusal to be dated driven in the Bitcoin space if I'll put on like my Bitcoin fundamentalist hat which never ever goes on I don't think you own that hat on that hat that's for sure but like isn't there one perspective of like a slippery slope concept here we're like okay we let ordinals in but then we're gonna do layer two's and then if we do layer two's are gonna put stable coins on the layer two's and then if we let if we do those things and we'll do I have to do even more things and then even more things will happen on Bitcoin and then all of a sudden like BTC and BTC transfers are just like a complete afterthought of the Bitcoin blockchain and like why are we even here in the first place what would you say to this philosophy yeah I mean I think there's just like a general fact which is that people prefer dollars for settling transactions for collateralizing positions and that applies to Bitcoin that applies to every other crypto asset for that matter like it applies to Ethereum it applies to salana I think that's just a fundamental challenge that all native crypto assets need to be able to deal with which is dollars are cannibalizing L1 assets there's like what I mean at a kind of a slow rate I mean there's 137 billion dollars of stables and there's what 1.
5 trillion two trillion dollars of sort of like other stuff in crypto but that's just like a fact I mean I think I wrote a piece for you for your newsletter a couple of years ago about this like destable coins threatened like L1 tokens and I think they do I think you've to rise the occasion you have to find a way to make them actually benefit the protocol itself well I'm not asking about specifically stable coins and I'm more asking about like what happens if you let Bitcoin expressivity go too far and it actually like pushes out BTC monitor the monetary maximalism right like it's like a slippery slope of like you know you you let the you let the ordinals in you let the call data in you let the NFTs in then you let the stable coins in then you let the layer twos in and then when does the shit coinery stop like when when do we actually start to enshrine and preserve the sanctity of BTC and BTC transfers they may be if like a Bitcoin fundamentalist was here maybe they would this is like the perspective that they might have yeah yeah I guess like to refin the question it's like is the SOV use case of Bitcoin sufficient or like does it have to have MLE what does it have to be a medium of exchange for it to win many Bitcoiners will say yes I don't think it does I don't think it does like I think SOV is sufficient and I think what you have to do is to find a way to so like first of all none of the shit coinery etc.
interferes with Bitcoin's monetary properties we did not know like random ordinal meme coin that you make makes Bitcoin have more than 21 million units doesn't change the monetary policy that set in stone my view is that that improves the monetary properties of Bitcoin because it creates this fee pressure which is a source of revenue for the miners albeit still a small one which then ultimately replaces the subsidy for like as the form of revenue for miners which is necessary in the long term so I think all activity types on Bitcoin benefit Bitcoin from a monetary perspective because they create vibrancy and fee revenue that enhances the security of Bitcoin so I don't think you can complain about it too much people might say well yeah you are displacing Bitcoin as a medium of exchange I think it's already happened though and I think I have a hard time imagining a world in which Bitcoin is like a very widely employed medium of exchange mainly because like sovereign nations privileged their own currencies over transactions and other currencies so like for tax reasons this is like basically the case everywhere you don't want to be doing all this complex accounting when you're doing a Bitcoin transaction you're like determining what your cost basis is and like doing your tax accounting there and you know this is a foreign exchange risk like if I'm transacting with you I don't want volatility to be like changing the value that I'm transacting in real time so I think we actually need to sort of like a concede defeat on the medium of exchange front and like maybe it'll happen years from now but I don't see it going that direction I see it going in the other action and I think we can acknowledge that the SOV use case is sufficient like gold is not something that people routinely transact in but it's something that people own a lot of right like golds market app is like 11 12 trillion right people don't habitually make gold transactions like so Bitcoin can be a very useful SOV maybe you can issue stable coins against Bitcoin and then unite the both camps that would be one way I would see that you know we can have an SOV in an MOE that's sort of benefits Bitcoin while acknowledging that people aren't going to probably use Bitcoin for transactions that often one thing I do appreciate about Bitcoin the protocol is like how kind of like shouldn't from the hip here it's just like how naked it is it's just like it's an unlike like apto sui salana like all these new layer ones they are all they're all like engineering and technology constructions but Bitcoin is like because it is what it is it's just there's a lot more ideology conversations to be had around Bitcoin it's like a surface area for like ideological conversations of this and this is something that I think is kind of like lost with these newer entrance that came in 2021 and beyond who went straight to the smart contract platform rather than the newer entrance that went to Bitcoin is like they were missing like I think a large part of these like big blocker small blocker philosophy debates and Bitcoin I think really inspires a lot of that it's always been like my biggest interest in the Bitcoin space and definitely why I always enjoy bringing you on and having some of these conversations because I think like understanding some of the the more philosophical reasons about like how these things are built why they're built and who they attract and where they are going I think is like some of the most rich conversations there are to be had in this space yeah the I mean like the ideology is shield but it's also like an autoimmune disorder I think Haasu coined that right so like it's an immune system and it protects Bitcoin from being debased and changing into something totally radically different that's fine I totally accept that but at the same time it's also like very off-putting to a lot of people that are active in the Bitcoin space and these days like people that are building on Bitcoin tend to try and ignore the like excesses of Bitcoin ideology and so I do think that like the more far reaching you know claims made that part of the like Bitcoin you know liturgy or whatever I think they're not negative but I do still acknowledge that there is a strong ideological grounding and and it's probably you're pretty useful in terms of like keeping those those core considerations alive yeah Nick that's been fantastic thanks for joining me today thanks David cheers you