What if the biggest threat to your freedom isn’t a bad decision - but a scoreboard you never agreed to? Philosopher C. Thi Nguyen joins Bankless to unpack how modern life quietly turns values into points: likes, GPAs, net worth, rankings, and performance metrics that feel objective - but often flatten what matters most. We explore what games really are, why “gamified” platforms like social media can be uniquely corrosive, and how “value capture” pulls you from meaning into measurable proxies. Then we get practical: playfulness, reflective control, and “value federalism” as ways to use metrics without letting them use you.
---
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
---
🔮POLYMARKET | #1 PREDICTION MARKET
https://bankless.cc/polymarket-podcast
👑BANKLESS PREMIUM | AD-FREE & BONUS EPISODES
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
🎯THE DEFI REPORT | ONCHAIN INSIGHTS
https://bankless.cc/the-defi-report
💰ICO WATCH | UPCOMING PUBLIC TOKEN SALES
https://bankless.cc/ico-watch
---
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
0:58 “Is this the game you really want to be playing?”
5:45 What counts as a game (Bernard Suits’ definition)
11:38 Bankless “serious games” and the cheating test
16:29 Social media as “game-ish,” not truly a game
21:28 The magic circle and why points get dangerous
24:08 Rotten Tomatoes vs. forming your own taste
33:27 Portability: why metrics flatten nuance
38:15 Value capture: when your values get outsourced
45:52 Plato’s cave: “metrics are the new shadows”
54:12 The outsourcing dilemma: we can’t know everything
1:01:47 Playfulness as an antidote to metric hypnosis
1:12:55 Switching rule-sets: D&D, indie games, and redesigning incentives
1:16:22 Reflective control: using metrics without being used
1:20:21 Two endings: cynicism, hope, and the tradeoff of scale
1:23:38 Value federalism + why "Civilization" makes Thi miserable
---
RESOURCES
C. Thi Nguyen
https://x.com/add_hawk
C. Thi Nguyen’s “The Score” Book
https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/457380/the-score-by-nguyen-c-thi/9780241653975
---
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
CT1 is a philosopher of games. He is the author of a new book called The Score, how to stop playing someone else's game. Tee, welcome to Bancliffe's. Hello. I have no idea what I'm doing. I was going to ask you this in the pre-show, but you know, I'm making a wish to ask it here. Do you know what's amazing? I enjoyed your book so much and I've enjoyed some of your previous writings because so much of what we talk about on Bancliffe, which people think of Bancliffe as a crypto podcast. But what is crypto? It is finance. It is money. What is money? What is finance? It is a game. So much of crypto takes place on another game engine that we call social media, Twitter, X.
It's all games all the way down. And so this is why I feel like there's so much to learn from you actually T. Excellent. You do not have the wrong person. I'm not walking into the wrong room. No, this will be a lot of fun. I want to talk to you about games and social scalability and all of the interrelated things. But actually, maybe the place to start, give us some salience for Bancliffe listeners is the way you start your book. There's a story in the first chapter of your book about someone that I personally identified with and maybe some Bancliffe listeners might identify with as well. This is a student.
She's an overachiever. She's obsessed with her body mass index or GPA. She's the child of immigrants. She, her parents pushed her to get 4.0s through school. She's a competitive golfer trying to get in the most highly ranked prestigious university. Basically, life gave her a set of these scoring systems. And she was trying to optimize for a high score throughout all of the systems that she was engaged in. And what snapped her out of it? The idea that you promote that these things are games. Many of these systems that she's engaged in, the rankings, the metrics. If she could step back and get some distance from them.
If she could start asking questions about these systems rather than just accepting them. She changed her phone background to this concert reminder. Is this the game you really want to be playing? I really enjoyed that because it's a question I think that has some salience for everyone listening. Is this the game you really want to be playing? Why is that an important question to UT? So, God, there's so many ways to talk about this. Maybe the most important thing for me, and this applies both to games, to real games, and to games, game-like systems outside, is the idea that we have a significant choice in the games we play.
We can pick the games we play, we can pick which scoring systems we engage in, and we can pick and fine tune in Taylor, then we can shift and move them around. And I think like, I've been trying to figure out for a while. I wrote this book in part because the student wrote that email after I gave an early talk version of this a lot of this material. And I was trying to figure out what is it about the framing of how I was talking about things. It was really impactful. And I think it's that we know in our hearts that we play games for fun, for enjoyment, for richness, for satisfaction. And then if a game pulls us in, and if we fight all our might to max out that score, and then we end up with misery and sorrow, I think it's really intuitive to think to yourself, like, no, you screwed up, right?
Like, I've had this experience a lot, fly fishing. This is there's one mode of fly fishing I engage in, which is dry fly fishing, which is like very, very difficult, very weird. The point is to get a trout to eat your fly off the surface of the water. It's incredibly beautiful to me. It's incredibly satisfying. It's hard as hell. You actually have to stalk and sneak and like move through the undergrowth and you like see a trout and then you like sneak up on the bank and you cast the stomach at a little cast to like to the trout that you see. There's another mode of fishing. I don't enjoy it. Some people really enjoy it called Euronymphing.
You're basically like bouncing this heavily weighted fly along the bottom. You can't see it. It's kind of exhausting. I find it miserable. Some people love it, but you catch a lot more fish. And one of the things I've been running into a lot of the times is a certain kind of person. I was about to say, dude, and I stopped myself, but I should just say like everybody I met like this is in fact a dude. A certain kind of dude who's like, you got a Euronymph. It's such a better way to catch fish. And then they're like, I hate it. It's like it's miserable. I just don't dry fly fishing is so much more fun, but you got to do it because you catch more fish.
It's so much more efficient. And I'm kind of like, we're letting the fish go, man. This is a game. This is a catch and release date. You go out, you catch some number of fish, and then you let them go and you go home. And what is the goddamn point? And I think like this is there are times when you're forced to do something because you need to survive, but there are other times when we make these choices. And I think like this is the like I think a lot of the times we don't even realize we're making a choice. We think it's forced on us. I think the dude that I think there's a specific guy ran into just miserable on the side of the river just like hating his fishing and thinking he had to do this.
They thought it wasn't a choice. He thought he had to optimize for this particular score. And I don't know, that seems to miss the point of the whole thing. So yeah, that's why it's important to me. I think when we invoke the word game, when so many invokes the word game in a conversation, people's brains probably go straight to something like, you know, chess or video games. We are obviously talking about games in a more expansive fashion than that, like using games as a lens to view a lot of our behavior that we engage in. How expansive can we really get here? Like how far does this really go?
Is it like everything a game? No matter no matter what environment they were in, is it always a game or like, or is it possible to escape games? Like how expansive can we really get here? Right. So I mean, this is this is really important because I don't think everything is a game. I, when I started thinking about this stuff, I was kind of lost about what a game really was. It seemed like really an important concept, but I couldn't get my hand, my hands around it. And so I found this incredible book by Bernard Suites called the Grasshopper. He's a philosopher. He wrote in the 70s. This book is kind of a cult classic.
And in it, he gives a definition of games that I think is incredibly useful because it like points to one specific point of life, but not everything. So this short version or long version, I'll give you the short version first, but I suspect you're going to want the details of the long version. So the short version is that playing a game is voluntarily taking on unnecessary obstacles to create the possibility of the activity of struggling to overcome them. Right. It is. So what a game is is something where one way puts it is in a game, there's always like an easy way to get to the goal. And then we put a constraint on ourselves.
We take, he says like the long way on purpose, right? You run a marathon. There are easier ways to get there. You could not only take a shortcut, but you could call a lift, right? I'm a rock climber. Like you could climb up the front of the rock, or you could go back up the back, which is easy, or you could climb a tree, or you could get a ladder, right? There are all kinds of easier ways to get there. And one of the things Suites is saying is that in games, when we're playing a game, we're trying to hit some goal, but it doesn't count unless we do it under the constraints, right? Like if you thought the goal of basketball was just to pass the ball through the hoop, then logically what you should do is take a step ladder to the court, and then pass the ball through the hoop as many times as possible.
But that doesn't count, right? So the thing that's really important for Suites is whatever the value of basketball is, it's essentially bound up with doing the activity inside a constraint system. So if you believe that, right, then the world just quickly divides into what Suites calls normal practical activity and game activity. In a normal practical activity, there's some goal you want, and you just do as efficiently as possible because all that matters is the goal, right? If you're hungry and you need fish, you take the most efficient means possible, which is actually like a net, or like dynamite, right?
Or, right? When you're, I think people forget about this, but when you're doing this other thing that I do, it's the technical term for an angling. You're not trying to catch fish as strictly as any, by any ways you can. You're not using a net. That's what commercial fisherman use because that's actually the most efficient way. What you're doing is you're trying to trick the fish into biting your fake lure or your bait. You're like, you're engaging with the psychology of the fish, right? Like all angling involves tricking the fish into biting a baited hook or biting a fake lure. That is a much harder way to catch fish.
It's a game because if you're doing that, it's like, so I don't know if you know this, but if you're fishing, I don't know, my mind is not fishing today. If you're fishing and you're reeling in and you get something, and it turns out that you accidentally hooked the fish on the side, it didn't bite the hook, but you just like, it doesn't count. You're like, oh crap. I, the term, I snagged it. It's not, I didn't really catch it because what you're trying to do is a specific tricking thing, right? And what makes it a game is that it matters that you did it that particular hard way. Does that make sense?
And under this, under this, under the shoot description, anything could be a game, but not everything is a game because it depends on why you're doing it. He has this great, by the way, tell me if I'm rambling on too long. This is like a topic on which I could talk infinitely, but one easy example, he says is, imagine two people climbing a mountain together next to each other. One is climbing it because there's some rare medicine at the top that they really want. And the other is a rock climber, right? They're, they're a mountain air. They're, they're engaged in the game of rock climbing. And the way you can tell that one is playing a game and the other is not is if like somebody passes by in a helicopter and says, hey, you want a quick ride to the top than the person who just wants to get there for the medicine, right?
They're like, of course, I just want the goddamn medicine so I don't die. Get me to the top as quickly as possible. And the mountain climber, this is really important. It doesn't matter if they're a professional or an amateur. It doesn't matter if they're doing it for the reward of being the world's top mountain climber. If they're doing it for pure joy, the mountain climber who's playing a game will reject the helicopter because it doesn't count as climbing the mountain unless you did it under a specific set of constraints. Hey, Bancliffe's nation is David. If you're hearing this, that's because you were listening to the free Bancliffe podcast feed.
Did you know that there is a premium Bancliffe RSS feed? The premium feed has extra interviews that I do for my own personal research and just deeper questions that I want answered about the crypto industry, questions that I want to answer so I can be more informed as an investor both at Bancliffe's ventures and also just in my own personal portfolio too. Also, there are no ads which means if you listen to the premium feed instead of the free feed, you'll get about 20 hours of your life back every year because you choose to support Bancliffe directly. So if you're interested in getting extra content all while skipping the ads or you just appreciate what we do here and want us to keep doing it, we'd appreciate it.
If you signed up for Bancliffe's premium and there is a link in the show notes to get started, cheers to a good 2026. Okay, so let's let's test this because I like that definition and I understand it very clearly through the lens of the mountain climber example, but so here are some serious, I'll call them serious games that I play like almost like career games, right? So one is a game that David and I play is maybe the podcast game where we create content, we have a guest subjects we want to talk about, but we also have a scoreboard related to that. Like we have downloads, we have views. Another game that David and I play is social media game where you have tweets and some of them are successful, they get a lot of likes, they get a lot of retweets, some are not so successful and we have social media games across YouTube as well, right?
Like the thumbnail, you can optimize a podcast thumbnail to be more clickable and some thumbnails and titles do better than others. We also have business games that we're engaged in, right? Like revenue, growth type games as we grow our media company. Crypto itself is just like one big financial game it seems like, you know, all the games I played, computer games in my youth almost seem to resemble like the life games that I'm playing now. I mean, it's just about bouncing around and collecting coins, you know, like profit number go up, which of these are games under the suits definition and which of these are like, because if you asked about the podcast, for instance, I don't think that if there was a way for us to generate millions of views in all of our videos and podcasts by cheating in some way, by I don't know, paying YouTube off or something like this or paying Spotify, I don't think we do it.
That wouldn't be fun. And so I guess we're playing a game? Yeah, no, this is that's you've already asked you to question, but like, so first backup, remember that for suits. And I think this is really important. What gaming is is a motivation. And two people can do this, be doing the same activity next to each other. It looks really similar. And what really what makes one a game and the other not a game is their reason for doing it, whether they're whether they're doing it to be involved in the process and the struggle or the essential or whether it's not. And I think you just so I also want to say to read the important that not everything that's a game like is a game.
There's this whole category of game-ish things and I think it's really important that there are a lot of times where we hyper orient towards a scoring system and they're not always games. A lot of a lot of the examples I have in my book are cases where there's a ranking system. There's so much power attached to it and people just zero on the power of eye of that ranking system. There's no other way to get it except by that ranking system. And I'm not I don't think those are games. They're game-ish. They look like games. They might grab on some gaming psychology, but they're not games in this sense.
You answered the question already, which is I mean, here's one way to put it. Think about a video game, right? Like what what are you trying to do with a video? You're trying to get to the end screen. How do you know that it's a game that you're playing into a game? Because they're all kinds of ways to get to the end screen that don't involve going through the game. You could you could you could pack it, right? You could hack the software. You could pay somebody else to play the game for you. Like none of these count because the point maybe that's an easy example. The point is to do it yourself.
And I suspect that there are some people for whom podcasting is not a game because they would do anything to make the number go up. And I suspect for you, we could figure out all kinds of things. So it count is cheating. What if I told you that you could get more of an audience by doing an optimized AI simulation of you who would like hand her perfectly via focus groups and we'd make your numbers go away. Or what if I don't know you were you wanted your social media account to go higher. So you bought the social media company and instructed the programmers to, you know, an example out of nowhere like to like re-change the coding to make your numbers go up, right?
I think if it weren't, right? It doesn't make sense. If it weren't again, you would take any means necessary. And it might not be a game. A lot of these systems, a lot of people respond to ranking systems just because they are incentives are connected to money. They'll do anything they can to make them go up. That's an important phenomenon that's right next to games. But if we can find something that intuitively feels to you like cheating, like not the way you wanted to do it. Like if there's anything I could say where you would be like, I wanted that, but not that way. Like what's in something that's what's crucial to suits is that what a game is, this is something where we care about the method that we did it.
We care that we did it out of this particular talent or using this particular ability, right? You, you, you, you probably care that you get podcast counts by people listening to you talk and you doing the interviews live instead of having an optimized bot create a similar game. Can we talk about social media for a minute? I recall you wrote an entire article about Twitter and it's game of gamification. This is something that many listeners are very familiar with. Crypto is overactive on on social media. Is social media a game? And is it a, is it a healthy game? What are we, what are we doing here?
What really matters for thinking about social media? I think at some point the question of is this a game by that definition I gave is a boring question. That's not okay. But we actually what I actually care about here. What matters is the fact that certain game like things are happening. And I actually think what's really crucial to understand the damage of the gamification of social media is to understand that it's not a game in a really profound way, but it's superficially game like and it motivates us in a game like way. And how is a game like maybe get to that definition? Is it because it has points?
Is it because it has a mechanism? Yeah, I think the the crucial thing that when I'm thinking about social media as a game of five platform, I'm thinking that's because it renders a clear singular pronouncement of how well you did. So the the crucial thing it has is a scoring system. I scoring systems are really interesting to me. So when I wrote my first book about games about my academic book about games in art form, I didn't realize something really crucial, which is that you can have a game without having a scoring system. So I think one way to think about it is that what a scoring system is, is it's something that yields an instant clear verdict that everyone agrees to, right?
Like so if you if we if we play a game, we all agree to a particular scoring system and then the scoring system looks at our activities and it spits out about your point and we know exactly how we did and there's no way to there's no way to argue it, right? So if you're playing like one of the classic German like Euro games that I'm obsessed with, like the game tells you exactly what each sheep is worse than victory points, what each like gold and you just add it up, right? There's no space for argument. One of the important things I think is that real games you have that a lot, but you don't have to have them.
So the example I've been thinking about a lot is like skateboarding before it went pro, before it went official, like if people go to the skate park in order to they can have a game and they can compete even to have the coolest trick, but there's no actual system that guarantees that we'll all agree about the coolest trick, right? Like in fact, you can have this competition, you can you can have at home cooking competitions and you don't actually need to agree and afford it, right? Everyone can come out and be like, right, have a different opinion. That's, fine, that's a that's a possible game.
The thing that distinguishes I think a lot of the more formalized games that we're more familiar with is the existence of a scoring system that says something like we're going to have people jump and then we're going to measure how they jumped on a ruler and then the winner is the person that went higher on the ruler or that says like we're going to do this thing and then every time you like collect a sheep token, you get two points, right? That kind of cleat that kind of clear scoring system is distinctive to board games and that's what I think get to borrowed by social media. The existence of a single, I mean, here's one way to think about it.
In kind of normal communicative life, there are so many different values that we could be judging ourselves by and that we could be aiming for. You could be communicating to be funnier and entertain each other, right? You could be communicating to connect. You could be communicating to learn. You could be communicating to figure things out. You could be communicated, right? That plurality of values means that different people can be judging a conversation in different ways. Like sometimes I've had conversations with parties where it's very clear that the other person is trying to one up me and I was trying to like have an interesting connection and then they think they want the conversation.
I think it was like the worst conversation ever. Like that's completely possible. But if you're on social media, there is a scoring system and if you orient yourself towards it, then you have an instant and complete way to like, you know, instant compare each tweet, instant compare each post, right? And instant compare different individuals in terms of the like follower or subscriber account. So it's that like reduction to a single dimension that then gets quantized so that we can make instant comparisons. That seems, that to me is like this weird, intense feature that is an artificial feature of some institutions and technological systems.
And it's game-ish so you can see that sucked into it and like start relating to it like a game. But there's a crucial massive difference from most games. That crucial massive difference is it's interconnected to the rest of the world. So crucial, I think one of the crucial concepts from a lot of theorizing about games and play is that games are weirdly detached from the rest of the world. There's this concept that in the game scholarship that says one of the things, this is from an anthropologist named Yohan Hussinger and he says in the Bokomoludans, that what games and play are is an activity that occurs in something called the magic circle.
An magic circle is a space in time that's separated in some way from normal life. The way that there's a scholar Annika Weren and the way she puts it is, we've created this meaning boundary where meaning's change. And it, I mean, that sounds fancy, but what it really means is you and I could be, I mean, I could be best friends with Ryan and hate David, but we play basketball and David's on my team and Ryan's the other team and it doesn't matter what my social relationships are. Those are canceled and I am all-in, incorporating with David and trying to destroy Ryan. And then afterwards, it doesn't matter, right?
It would be really weird for people who are on the opposite team to be emotionally hurt that I block their past, right? So another thing that's really important about games is that in not all, but in most games, the points are unattached from ordinary life. So if you, if I, I mean, I mean, this is, I can feel a question back there and I think maybe I'm jumping the gun in the answer, but one quick answer to a lot of questions is in a game, if I go all out and ignore, think about nothing about the point and think about nothing about max, but maxing out my point at the expense of everybody else, then nothing changes in the world when the game is over.
It does not matter if I slayed my spouse or my spouse laid me the thing that makes it okay. I mean, you know, my kids have just gotten to the age where I can play, I've been playing a lot of super smash with my like eight or nine-year-old and so fun. There's, you know, I just, I was selling my class this. I have a class in the policy of games and I was like, you know, it's kind of weird, but it's one of the few ways I guess get to destroy, try to destroy my kid all out. And he gets just like, like, I don't have to protect his you. I can just be like, it's important because I'm really bad at them.
So a platformers are about the same level and I can just try to fuck him up. And that's cool because that doesn't leave the game, right? Right. It's just a game. It's just a game. And on the other hand, if you are social media and the game, the game like thing that people are doing with finances, where they go, whatever Jeff Bezos is doing, right, to max out his score in his activity is not an magic circle, right? I see. Okay. Okay. I think we're starting to see the distinction between games, which are fun, which don't have real world effects and consequences, and which are time-bound to these other game-like things, these gamified things that we play, and quote unquote, in real life.
And both of them do have a scoring system. At least games don't have to have a scoring system, but many of these gamified objects do. Maybe let's talk about, because that's, I think, more the point of your book, The Score. It's like more about the scoring system and all of these gamified platforms and systems that were engaged in, like GDP or GPA, as we talked about. Maybe we can go through this and you can help me to settle an argument with my wife. Okay. So this gets into some marriage counseling here. So one thing I love to do is before we watch any movie in my house is I have to look it up on Rotten Tomatoes and IMDB.
I have to. I have to. Sorry, we can't be friends. Okay. Right. It's like, okay. So let's talk about this. I want to get into the pros and cons of looking it up. I'll give you my rationale. The reason is, look, it's 90 minutes of my life. Maybe two hours of my life. I don't want to waste my time on anything that's like 50% under. And I look at the metrics, like with clear eyes. Okay. It's not just the critic metric. It's also, you know, there's the user rating audience rating. I'll cross reference with IMDB. So it's, you know, a bit more pure. But I'm just like not going to waste my time on a low ranked movie, right?
My wife is like, this kills it. This kills the movie watching experience. Okay. What you should be doing, Ryan, is you should watch movies. You should that you like. And you should form your own opinions. And you shouldn't go into it with some preconceived notion of how good the movie actually is. Help settle this argument and talk about ranking and scoring system that I'm seeing. We could literally spend the rest like five hours talking about this one question. This is actually when I started thinking about scoring systems. A lot of my book is about metrics and bureaucratic and bureaucratic measurements.
But the place I started thinking about it was Rotten Tomatoes and Wine Scoring Systems. And what they, I'm on your wife's side. But why? Why? Tell me why she's right. Okay. Let me, let me, let me, let me, hear this. Let me take a simple pass at it. And then I'll take the big huge pass. So my friend Matt Stroll, who's a philosopher of art, who wrote the beautiful book, White Okay, to love bad movies, has an essay about Rotten Tomatoes. I think it's just, it's called against Rotten Tomatoes. And one thing to note is that he notes, if you think about like, if you ask most of you who love movies to list off great movies by their own taste, and you look at them on Rotten Tomatoes, one of the things you'll find is most of them sit around 50 or 60% because good movies are often controversial.
They're often like a lot of things are incredible, often like push against some people are repelled by like David Lynch movies, right? Incredible, fascinating, weird, provocative. Some people are repelled by them. Some people don't get them, right? So a crucial thing about a movie that's kind of daring or kind of subtle is some people are not going to get it, right? So if you're using Rotten Tomatoes as a measure, what you're going to pick up on, the kinds of movies that do well on Rotten Tomatoes are precisely the movies that are engineered or made so that everyone will get and everyone will get about equally.
So you're not going to get daring movies, you're not going to get subtle movies, you're not going to get provocative movies. You're going to get movies that are kind of acceptable to every taste. So you won't get anything that plunges into a particular taste. This is, by the way, this is, this is, this is different from the question about whether taste is objective or subjective. Even if taste is completely objective, right? A measure like Rotten Tomatoes is going to give you rough. Okay, let me run the case on, let me run the case on social media and then we'll see if this applies to Rotten Tomatoes.
Okay, so here's a case, here's my case against social media platforms, my worry about social media platforms. One measure of how important a communication is is how deeply it strikes people and whether it changes people and sometimes I'm communicating people. Well, here's something I can do in the classroom. I can say something weird and interesting, it falls flat on 80% of the people and like 20% of the people like get it maybe like one one person it like totally moves them. I can see in their face that their their life has been changed at that moment. Now let's say that instead of looking at their faces, I'm interacting with them on a social media platform.
I do a post and most people do not like it and a one person hits like like doesn't register the intensity of their relationship to it. It doesn't register the fact that their life was changed by it. It simply counts one, right? So an important thing about likes on social media is there's a flattening aspect. It only picks up like it only picks up whether or not someone was pro or con and then aggregates. So let me back up. So you're giving me a very suspicious look. So let me try try this. Let's say that your audience is 1,000 people. One one one tweet that you have is kind of slightly clever and a little bit funny and all 1,000 people mildly like find it mildly funny and then forget about it in 20 minutes.
That tweet will probably pick up like a thousand likes or like 500 likes. Madeline, you say something else that's weird and thoughtful and almost no one gets it except two people have their life changed by it. That tweet will pick up two likes. I think what you're saying here is that the metric itself is like boiling all of the variants out of the signal here and it's kind of flattening things and it's one dimensionizing things. And you're probably going to say that same argument applies to my rotten tomatoes and IMDB rankings. So I don't get any of the high variance type movies. I just get kind of the low variance popular mediocre but popular things.
Yeah. This is Matt Strauss point that if you look if you go back and you look at the reviews of like movies that are like generally considered great now. I mean, I'm kind of dodging here because I'm using this like now they're considered great. But if you look back at most of them, most of them were incredibly divided. You had critics exploding like with this is the most amazing thing ever and other people being like this makes no goddamn sense. Like the everything is incoherent and weird and like that. That's when you when you take that to rotten tomatoes, that's going to show up as 50%. Your mediocre crop.
Crim will show up as 50%. But so will that. Okay. I just want to add one thing. Then isn't that just a problem with the metric itself? We could divide the metrics. So do you do your point? Yeah. The metrics are in perfect. I feel like what happened in the year is there's two different games trying to be played. There are the there's the critics game, which is people who watch movies in a particular way that the average member of society does not watch movies in that they're not playing the same game. And like me guessing, hypothesizing why Ryan is trying to watch a movie. He is trying to watch a movie so he can sit down, laugh at some stuff, forget about life, forget about the internet, and like have a good time for two hours and then resume life.
And I don't think he wants to watch a movie that like is like gritty and thought there's a movie I was watching not too long ago called Mickey 17. And it was like I think a critic would love that movie because it was a good movie. But part of that movie I was watching and I was just uncomfortable the whole time because the whole thing was just gritty and kind of difficult to watch intentionally so it's where the movie did a good job of what it was trying to do, which is make me uncomfortable and like, you know, squirm in my seat. And it wasn't enjoyable by any means, by any means, but a critic I think would have enjoyed that.
Nothing about this has to be great. Weird-ass comedies like some of my favorite get busting hysterical comedies also don't do great on Rotten Tomatoes because they only appealed like there's nothing here that says gritty, right? Some of this is just about particularly. But let's let's separate. There's so many things in this Rotten Tomatoes point. Let me separate a few things. There are two questions. One is whether Rotten Tomatoes will accurately give you what you want. And even if it's a funny light experience, the claim is something like no, it's going to steer you towards kind of the average funny light experience and not like the weird peculiar funniest that's that you'll find.
And then there's a bigger point that I think we should shelter a bit and come back to, which is like being worried that you won't develop your own sensibility, right? That you're giving up some profound independence. I'm just going to give names to this because I don't want to forget either because I think these are the two, these are the things I want to talk to YouTube the most. The first one, I'm going to let's call portability. The second one is the value capture stuff that I've been thinking about. So, so let me, let me, let me go, let me, let me, let's do portability first. So here's, let me give you the kind of like stepped back philosophical answer to what, what you're talking about.
So, so you say, and I suspect you're just teaming me up to say this, so thank you. You say, look, shouldn't we just make better metrics, right? Is this a problem of a particular, of this particular metric, couldn't we just improve them? It's true that one of the things I've said is something like, oh, it's, you could shift from like the Rotten Tomatoes metrics to like thinking about the agreement of the critics and the long term, something like that. But I think, I think that's not going to do it. You could do better, but not perfectly and not, especially not in this case, because of the nature of what data is and how data is collected in so far as metrics are based on data.
So when I try to understand metrics, the most, the thing that helped me the most was this book from theater reporter called Trust in Numbers. So theater reporter is a historian who works in quantification culture. And he was trying to understand why people kind of like knee jerkly reach for, he was particularly interested in bureaucrats and politicians. And why they always reach for quantitative justification, even when they knew that quantitative justification wasn't that great. And his answer was to understand what the particular nature of institutional quantification was. So he ends up saying there are two different ways of knowing things on the world, qualitative ways of knowing and quantitative ways of knowing.
And he thinks they're both great at different things. And the problem comes when we don't like find the appropriate and one or balance them against each other, but go all in for quantitative in every case. So he says qualitative ways of knowing are context rich, sensitive, and open-ended, responsive, dynamic, but they don't travel well between contexts because they require a lot of shared background information to understand. So my example for years, you know, a professor is written comments I write on my philosophy majors papers, right? They're long, they're complicated, they're particular, they're responsive to the students, what they're doing, they use a lot of complex like in philosophy language, they use a lot of particular concerts from the class, someone else from elsewhere in the university or elsewhere in hiring won't understand them.
Quantitative ways of knowing in institutions work by identifying a context in variant kernel, and then holding that kernel stable across different contexts. So making sure that everyone collects into the same kernel the same way. So the example here is like letter grades in the university system, right? So an A means about the same thing, a B means about the same thing, a C means about the same thing in every different context. And once we fix that, we can, that information can travel easily, like my really long, complicated, qualitative discussion of a student is not going to be understandable by the business dean or by someone hiring in Silicon Valley, but A, B, and C are immediately comprehensible.
And the reason they're comprehensible is precisely that we've stripped context, high context, high nuanced information out of them. Does that make sense? Yeah, there's a portability tradeoff basically, right? And so somebody asked me about a movie, rather than give them a commentary, I can just say, well, it got 92% on Rotten Tomatoes. It's much easier. It's much easier to display in a UI for, you know, Netflix too, rating all the movies and they can say, oh, this one got, you know, 42% in this one got 89%. Yeah, so that is exactly the view that what you're getting, what quantitative data does and what quantitative data collection does is it trades away high context, high sensitivity and multi-dimensionality in exchange for portability.
This is generally called the portability theory of data. Right. And so I think the same kind of thing that applies to GPA applies to Rotten Tomatoes, right? Like information that I have that I can put down qualitatively, like this student is not good at test taking, but incredibly good at community building and very original, but a little bit sloppy. Like that's all important information, but it gets squashed out into a B, right? A B does not carry that information, but precisely because it's been squashed out, that's what makes it instantly comprehensible and that's what makes it instantly comprehensible and instantly aggregatable.
So the fact you can create a GPA out of many different judgments depends on us having stripped out all that complexity. Same thing with Rotten Tomatoes, right? I got it. Yeah. Could you talk about the second there? So that's portability, the second flaw in metrics and scoring that you identify. And this is a big theme in your book is value captures. So what does that talk about that? So value capture is any case where your values are rich and subtle or developing in that direction. And then you get parked in an institutional setting that gives you a simplified typically quantified rendition of those values.
And then you intake and let take over that simplified quantified version. So like going to school, caring about education, coming out caring about GPA, starting to exercise, caring about health and fitness and coming out obsessed with like step counts or weight or your body weight or BMI or going to social media to connect to people or and becoming obsessed with likes and follows. So my worry about this stuff is that you're outsourcing your values and that part of what outsourcing your values is is that you're not developing a sense of what matters to you. You're accepting a pre-made value system from outside.
And because of the nature of the value systems you're accepting, they're typically thinned out and portable in exactly the way we talked out before. Right? I think one reason that people often become obsessed with something like weight or BMI and I have been this is like in part like personal confession is it's very easy to communicate because it's just like my knees feel better and I feel healthier and I feel happier when I move through this stuff is very hard to cross compare or communicate. Right? I lost 10 pounds is something that every makes sense to everyone and that I can quickly compare like I lost 10 pounds, you lost eight pounds, I did better.
Yo! Right? So one of the worries about value capture is that you are taking on values from the outside and that those values have a particular character and it's this like D nuance decontextualized portable character. But I think the deepest thing underneath and this is the thing I wanted to talk about before was that in value capture cases it's part of the outsourcing means you don't have to figure out for yourself what you care about. I mean so there's this example from actually you laughed I want to know why you laughed. I laughed because I think that's so true actually I think that there's some psychological benefit to considering how well you're doing in your podcast let's say or in your social media feed by the number of likes or downloads that you get or one example and I think part of the reason that is excited to have you on is because you know crypto is very much I mean we deal in in the world of concrete points and numbers right finance in general net worth very easy for people in finance and crypto to just outsource their value to what's their net worth score and they can check this in an app on their phone and you know they either feel good or bad depending on the day and what that number says and it's so much easier than actually like confronting the real challenges in your life or in building up your own unique set of values because this is just what society hands to you this is just what the industry hands to you.
What one way to put it is that things like having a meaningful life, a satisfying life, a rich life, a fun life having good friendships these are all like they're kind of quiet and then other things are very loud I mean I I feel this constantly I feel like I mean some of the stories like some food is delicious and makes me feel good and other food is low in calories and it's really easy to grab onto that right to that number it's really easy to track the success of losing weight which is how like I made myself miserable for a period of my life it's really I just went through this thing I mean I there are moments where like for an academic like me like you've got a job offer and the job offer is from a place that has a higher status ranking on this list of like what the status is of universities and you know I knew that I would be less happy at this other place I knew that the place that I am at which is lower ranked on this official external ranking right I knew I was happier there I knew I loved my colleagues there more I knew I fit in better and it was still incredibly hard to hang on to that super quiet sense of like I mean it's not that subtle like I'm happier I love these people these are like we work well together it's all and then the other side is something like but that place is higher ranked and it's really funny because it there's there's a little quick vision because no one if you are an academic like me it's funny because academics like to pretend that they don't care about this kind of thing because they don't care less about money but every academic knows the relative status of their various department and publications right and if I had made a move to a higher ranked institution I never would have had to explain to anyone my decision you would have been obvious to everyone right because ranking is a very legible transmittable status ranking is a very external comprehensible thing but if I don't make that decision justifying yourself turns seems really hard right one of the things I say in my book the pleasure of games is that they reduce value complexity like instead of having like a billion values to think about and try to measure off the value of like health and work and family and all these things and decide make complex decisions and measure off between these things you there's just one thing and you know exactly how you did and so if you suddenly accept a clear external scoring system for your life like the ranking of university or your net worth or you know your your your military rank or it's like it's wild I think there are a lot of different institutions where they'll make fun of other other places for being obsessed with networks then they have their own internal system I as an podcast with a pastor in a philosopher and the pastor when we were talking about this was like yeah in my church there's an internal leaderboard for baptism rates and we're all competing to like see who gets more baptisms and like he was like I've definitely found myself writing sermons that I find less meaningful but I know we'll get people more of the door and bapt it right and more people baptized right and it's another case where like where the simple I mean this is why the portability stuff matters the clarity of the score when you have an external system that everyone can comprehend and they know precisely what it means and explain exactly how it's connected makes justification to yourself and other people easy and it seems to speak really really loudly I mean this is this is the same like opening sir what's going on with like bro who's on the river who's fly fishing away he hates and is miserable and says he has to do it because he catches more fish because the number of fish seems to be speaking louder than the actual point of what you're doing when I was reading some of your work tea I kept on just thinking of Plato's allegory of the cave over and over and over again whereas like you know maybe just to recap the cave we haven't talked about it while in Nicholas it's like it's this idea this thought experiment from Plato where you're you're in a cave society is collectively inside the cave and then there are the social elites you know the governors the leadership of society they are casting shadows on the wall using the fire that is in the cave and they point at the shadows on the wall and they tell society this is this is reality this is what this is what real it's is the shadows on the wall but really they're the ones making the shadows and then you know the the whole point of the cave is you're supposed to escape the cave and you go out to the daylight where you actually learn what real society is when you are out of the governance of the puppet masters the people casting the shadows the people producing the game and you know reading reading some of your work as like oh like what what he is doing is he is expanding like Plato's allegory of the cave into like this game metaphor where like the game is the shapes of the hands that are that are casting the shadows on the wall like they're you're creating in this environment where you get to dictate what reality is and the whole but the difference here was with Plato's allegory of the cave it was like the the whole point was like it's noble to get out of the cave like you aspire to leave the cave escape the cave and get out into reality and then write your own rules but I think what you're kind of saying is like oh you know at times society really enjoys going down into the cave and creating their own shadows like kind of creating their own game well I think maybe one of the points of like what you're writing is like let's make sure that people know about the cave that they're in but like I wonder if you were thinking about this kind of allegory or this kind of lesson when you were writing some of your work I'm feeling very pleased and understood right now because I actually have on the cutting room floor for this book is a chapter about Plato's cave which has the motto that metrics are the new shadows on the wall I mean here's here's one way to put it that the thing that I'm worried about is that we have substituted for our sense of reality that which can be quantified, metrified and data-fied and that we have put in front of us instead of a sense of well-being or happiness like some legible external tracker and we become convinced that that's the real thing now one thing I want to say I'm not like let me just I'm not saying data is bad I'm not like anti-science I take my antibiotics I believe in science one of the things I think that's really important is that the large scale institutional methodologies I'm talking about this kind of porter portability concept is very good at measuring some kinds of things what they're very good measuring is anything that's context invariant and easy for everyone to pick up on so for example I mean one of the reasons that I mean this is vastly oversimplified but one of the reasons that large scale database methods are good for basic medicine is because being alive or dying that's very easy that that's stable across context similarly bacteria leaving your system right that's stable across context that's exactly the kind of thing that large scale database methods and quantitative methods are incredibly good at capturing they're capturing a real thing and they're doing it perfectly the problem is if there's something that's valuable that's highly variable between context that needs a lot of sensitivity to pick up on right that's going to be the kind of thing that large scale data collection methods that demand portable easily recognizable categories and recognition systems that's going to be the kind of thing that really bad at picking up on this is why like when I think about the kinds of things that we're not going to get good data on I think about things like well being happiness art beauty because not because these things are like ineffable but because they're highly contextually variable elusive of barns is a philosophy of meditation who does a lot of stuff on philosophy of health and disability it's just really great discussion of why I think like health you'll never get a metric on health and the reason is because health is not a context invariant concept so she points out that what health is is highly variable depending on your interests just great example she's like okay you go to a doctor you're like is my knee healthy and she says look what a healthy knee means for a 20 year old Olympian who has four years to train for the Olympics is very different from what a healthy knee means for me right for an Olympian help knee health what really matters is maximum performance over the next eight years long-term pain might be worth it right for me I'm a climber like what knee health means for me is I don't but climb as long as possible so long-termness matters more but you know I'll take some pain it's okay I I wake up my knees hurt every morning that's okay as long as I keep climbing for other people what health might mean is to be to walk pain-free as long as they can right so this is the cup because the concept of health is interest-dependent it's going to vary between people and so no metric will capture it precise precisely does that make does that make sense so then so the oh god how did how did we get or the cave cave I need to go back the cave okay here's the word there's some things that is very that data is a very appropriate method for something the type of context invariant something that everyone can pick up on easily there are other things that are subtle and rich and important that are highly contextually variable and highly dependent on interaction with particular personality or particular specialization metrics won't be good at picking up on that the cave for me is when we start treating as reality only the things that we have metrics and data for treating those as the only real things and then the rest of the stuff falls so in the university for me it's like people will target it's very easy to target student success and graduation rates and if you want to say something like but what about making students are ethical and thoughtful right and you say I want to do an intervention that might slow down slow things down a tiny bit but it'll make students more ethical and thoughtful since I don't have clear metrics for that that like falls off the radar here's something I think I've been thinking about a lot that I think is that might be controversial to some people I think when making public health decisions we often hyper target things involve mortality rates and we don't hyper target things that involve maintaining communities or traditions it's much it's much I mean I'm thinking here about covid responses and I think like there was a period we're earning that debate where mortality was the only thing that mattered and like mental health and communities did not matter and I think part of the reason was that one of these things had a very kind of clear reality in the world of easy accountability and the other was like really it slips through your fingers when you try to get an easy count on it few people in crypto put real skin in the game when they make public top or bottom calls the defi report is one of them the week before the October 10th flash crash Michael from the defi report emailed his entire newsletter saying he's going aggressively risk off and sold the majority of his book from crypto into cash this is when ethos about four thousand dollars and bitcoin was 110 Michael runs the defi report an industry leading research platform built on data cycle awareness risk management transparency and most importantly skin in the game we like Michael at bankless we like his analysis and that's why you hear him on the bankless podcast about once a month and the defi report is giving bankless listeners one free month of access to the defi report so if you're looking for some sharp data driven analysis to make better informed decisions around your portfolio you can learn why and how Michael called the top and what he's doing next all in the defi report pro check it out there is a link in the show notes yeah what what I'm hearing from you is that you know it's all of the games that society plays like using the expansive version of games are like you know we learned how to gamify some things or measure certain things and there's just like a series of games across society that that like people tend to participate in one for example if we're talking about health and fitness is like you know we've really codified down a nutritional label into like a protein carbs fats and sodium and a few other things and we say like you know get make sure you get your points here in the correct way and you know get not the American Heart Association gives these points like a thumbs up and then we where we lose track of his like some of the more nebulous loose ideas of health which is like you know eating food that was grown you know more domestically closer to you from farmers markets is actually also extremely healthy but hard hard to codify that into a game when we have the the allegory the cave hard to make your fingers bend in the right way to make that show up on the wall that's particularly hard to make show up on the wall but we can make you know the points of round calories and protein and fats that those can show up on the wall pretty well and then downstream of that society orients itself around that reality and same thing with like I think we were talking about social media like pretty easy to orient society around which tweet goes viral versus which tweet has the most amount of meaning and so like I one of the down downstream effects of what your book was talking about with the downstream effects of like a really well produced social structure call it a game is like it it's actually very easy to get a lot of people in line with these types of points or these types of optimized outcomes and like you know honestly frankly a lot of society probably appreciates that even though we might call these people sheeple including including myself like sometimes I just don't want to think about like how to escape the cave and like think for myself on a wide variety of topics I really want to outsource my thinking but then there's other like other parts of society where like I actually do want to escape the cave like for us for bankless it's about like personal finance and you know don't live under the shadow of the banks like don't let the the banks be the puppet masters but like I don't know if it's totally socially scalable for everyone to be out of the cave amongst all possible subjects right so this is this is amazing I think like this is so good let me let me back so I think you said to me what you heard in me it's let me say back to you what I think I heard new which is basically I think this is right this is the view the right view is something like one way to put the thing I'm worried about is there's all these things are important in life and then there's a few things that are very easy for people to count together and I mean one way to put is what I'm really thinking about is what's easy and hard to count together some things are really easy to count together because everyone can recognize the lines and some things are very hard to count together because the lines require a lot of sensitivity or nuance or historical experience to count and in the metrified world what what's happening in the metrified world is that all our attention is fixated on the things that are easy to count together right and one of the things that typically squashes out is any kind of value that requires that is highly tailored to you or your sensibility or your experience or your history does that does that does that kind of track when you're saying okay so there's more then do you have this question about but we don't have enough time and I think this is exactly right this is the whole problem we don't have enough time so like the thing that I think we have to recognize is I've spent a long time crapping on outsourcing your deliberations and the other feature is that we outsource all the time because we don't have enough time to do everything this is like time and just like cognitive capacity exactly this is this is the most okay this is the other half of what I think about in philosophy that barely made it to end this book but I think is actually the crucial half the other the other crucial thing which is the essential feature of human of humans right now is the we know human being can understand even close to everything for themselves right humans are the world is vast we have to spend for everything else there's a game yeah so what that means well because like I feel like at least most people are like somewhat at the forefront and at least one domain of knowledge like everyone has some something that they are kind of the best at or at least the best that they know and for that domain for them they're outside of the cave but for everything else that they do for everything that they don't really know that they're not a leading expert in then they just have to collapse down to like the what they think is the best game for them they'll they'll follow kind of the best the the the oh I see the other people are also following I don't think that's exactly right it's close but I want to disagree with one big part of that so I think part of what's going on is each of us has a domain where we are a specialist and we can really think clearly in that domain and a lot of other domains where we trust other people because we have to trust other people we have to outsource stuff all the time I mean you outsource stuff because you don't care about it right I mean I think that's part of what you're doing like I I mean I'm gonna horrify all of you but I don't think about finance at all like I just try like I spent a tiny amount of time I do totally normal I just look at some general ranking and like I'll just put my money in some like whatever mutual fund the people think is right I don't have the time for this look at the expression of horror on your faces I've just like I think it's completely sensible to it's completely sensible for a lot of people to just put in an index one yeah like whatever like whatever like let me find an expert quickly to figure out what to what to do and they will tell me what to do and I think that's exactly right one way to put it is what do you get if you outsource all of your art decisions to either crowdsource or to crowdsourcing via a run tomatoes or to a bunch of experts who tell you the correct things to like like what what does it get you to outsource that right I feel like there's a space where developing your own tastes and finding things that please you is far more important than deference to experts because the experience of art is essentially personal and because I think like developing your tastes is like part of the thing that's the game like here's my real worry I feel like I can think you're cheating if you just let other people push you into the artwork that you like and not cheating because you're bringing some rules like you're cheating yourself because the the thing that is valuable is the thinking through about what's important whether you like things or not and if you just like suck that in from the outside then you're not doing this like beautiful you're giving me that you're giving this dare tell me what you think no I mean I think that makes sense right it's like I I think you're losing yourself in in the I'm back to the fly fishing example you just you're becoming the person that's just trying to get quantities of fish this is also there's an example of people outsourcing all of their thinking to AI or all of their artistic expression to an artificial intelligence and they're kind of losing their ability to think clearly for themselves and like part party your framework is the difference between you know playing games in an achievement sense versus in you know for for the winner the loss versus in a striving sense where it's more about the process yeah tea let's let's talk about this as we start to underline this for folks and I mean I think the initial prompt of really your book the score and where we started this conversation was how to stop playing somebody else's game how to start playing your own game and I think there might be some people listening that get this sense or feel the senses I have it various times I had like a whole burnout episode earlier this year to you where I had to go and assess like what I was doing what objectives I had and really think about the what wealth I wanted to kind of build and what that meant and I think many folks are in that some more position of they feel like they're just playing somebody else's game they're just grinding it out they're not really living they might feel some of the symptoms that we've talked about yeah how do they get out of it how do they start playing the right game I think there was one one idea that you had that spoke to me maybe we could start here is this idea of playfulness so if you're finding yourself in a metrified world where you're obsessing over GPAs and algorithmic scores and likes and retweets and performance reviews and all the numbers earnings reports all the numbers the society throws out for you playfulness is a habit that can help you regularly distance yourself from the scoring systems at play like have some fun is that what that means can you talk about that see okay awesome great thank you thank you for that question that's let me let me let me take a run up to this let me back up and take a run up to this question through I think some other ideas that you might find interesting one of the things that I've really learned from a bunch of philosophers of technology and historians of technology is a is a particular way of thinking about the world where technologies and the systems we engage in have an interest they have a point of view they have something they're doing so one of one of my favorite versions of this comes from a thinker Dennis Woods who thinks about maps and he says that you know maps aren't neutral maps like have a point of view and you can see that point of view from what they show and what they don't show right like the maps we look at most a lot of the maps we look at are there to serve drivers or people moving through but they don't show things like where the soundscape is good or where the environment is good or where the people are friendly right that's because they're built to serve people that are driving or they're built to serve like you know like tax people that are going to tax property owners they're not built for people trying to look for a good place to hang out right does that make sense that like and when we place you can take this is to think that every scoring system also serves an interest right every scoring system is there to guide us to a particular kind of action and I the first thing we need to say and we should have said this a long time ago is it here's something crucial thinking about games to think about games you have to understand that there's a difference between a goal and a purpose so the goal of the game is what you're doing during the game and the purpose of the game is why you play the game for example the goal of twister is not to fall over the purpose is to have fun and you can tell that those are different because you can lose twister and have a great time and your time was well spent right does that make sense so big reason so I mean I think for some people who play there's no difference in goal and purpose and those are people who only care about winning if your goal is to win then the goal and the purpose are the same but for a lot of us the goal and purpose are completely different right in fly fishing my goal is to catch fish my purpose is I think to zen out on the river and like clear all thoughts from my head and have like a completely non-conceptual relationship with nature or like my senses all to know right like I so same thing with climbing right my purpose my goal in climbing is to get to the top of the cliff my purpose is my actual purpose is to get my brain to shut up so I can like have a moment of silence in my head so so again now you think about scoring there's a goal and a purpose what is the goal of the score in a lot of the scoring systems were surrounded by I think we don't think about who they serve and what they're there for there's a really there's a really convincing paper I read about the history of the American grading system they convince me that what grades are for what letter grades are for is not for the student education it's to serve the interests of employers who want easy mode of certification so they can quickly hire people that have the qualifications that they need to do the job I mean I think we can talk a lot more about that probably hopefully it's intuitive that the American grading system doesn't serve the interests of student happiness or even student education it serves the interests of employers looking to quickly hire like someone they can do a job right that's what that scoring system serves one of the interesting things about games is that they're scoring systems not all games are like this but they're scoring systems built to serve you right they're scoring systems built to make things fun or delightful we're enriching or satisfying and I think it's really important that like no one tuned GPA to make it fun or even to make it satisfying right they tuned it for some other purpose purpose someone totally tuned super smash to be enjoyable and delightful and like to create like laughter and hilarity and intensity and enjoy that's enjoyable and a lot of ways but there's like there's an even more meta important point here for games which is not only our games made for people but you can transition between games to find the ones whose which suit you whose purposes suit your purposes right like I I think a lot about which I'm drawn to some weird ass activities like I like rock climbing I like I've been reading to yo-yo lately like modern yo-yo's wild competitive yo-yo's like this super tense world and like it's become clear to me that I like games which are super hard where there's always a harder thing to learn than where I can lose myself an absorption and hit like some non-verbal state where I'm super into like the moment like what I love is this moment where this really hard thing comes into view that I couldn't have before and so running a marathon is really boring to me rock climbing is great because over and over over again when you're rock climbing you're like this climb is impossible oh move your hips this way oh my god I got it or like paint just a little bit more attention to where your thumb is oh I love that and so I can hop games and move between them and find the one that works for me and for me playfulness the best account of what playfulness is comes from Maria Lagones feminist philosopher and one show what she says is playfulness is the spirit of moving lightly and easily between rule sets and normative worlds playfulness is the spirit of not being in a world and treating its goals dogmatically but being able to shift between worlds and shift between rule sets and try on and off different conceptions of how we're supposed to do and what we're supposed to do I think like a really rich relationship with games is about the spirit of playfulness I mean there's there's terrible ways to relate to games you can grow up and the only sport anywhere around you is like football and you hate it but you think you have to play it right that is a very non-playful relationship to a game and a playful relationship is one where you try them on and you see how different they are and then this affords you I think this opportunity to actually reflect on which systems work for you there's um this is I think some of the biggest lessons I've learned from this come from indie tabletop role-playing I think it's incredibly fascinating world because neither of you do tabletop role-playing like dented and dragons I have before but not in depth so there's a super interesting history of people that played a lot of dented and dragons and some people loved it and then some people really found that it wasn't giving them the experience they wanted so there's this little indie world that basically there articulated responses and just and dragons was this just keeps making me tell stories of anonymous murder and I didn't want to tell those stories I wanted to tell like epic character dramas and then they basically realized that nothing in the rules pushed them this early dnd dnd change sits in or nothing in the rules pushed them to do character work or character drama or like family stories it was all about killing things and earning money to make weapons to level up to kill more things and so they changed the rules they built a different rule set so there are all these rules out there now that have these delightful rules that are like think one of my favorite very accessible ones is lady black bird and a lady black bird if you run out of energy points you get them back by having a refreshment scene you know a freshman scene is a quiet moment with another character where you reveal shared backstory so the game just forces you over and over again every time you use up all your energy to invent shared backstory and it forces you to do it whenever you're in trouble and it just like pops out narrative right and it's a different scoring system so one of the interesting things is old school dnd most of the scoring system is built towards like giving people experience points for killing things or completing quests and one of my favorite new systems so lady black bird it gives you experience points for acting in character and it gives you double experience points for getting your team in you into trouble by acting in character right to completely like it's I mean I think like this makes sense like these people are for me like the heroes where they were like even in a game they realized that a game wasn't giving them the experience they wanted and so they retuned it and sad an example of your concept of reflective control yeah this is like the basic control okay so just so talk about that more that is that basically the principle when you you kind of you treat metrics like game rules basically the metrics that the system hands you in your life you treat them as much like much more like game rules that can be changed or modify that you can adopt when useful but discard when they're not useful they no longer serve your serve your values right although I have to say like you know the whole problem is that games are disposable and the metrics are not like it's very hard just be like well ignore finance ignore money ignore like when the world is actually pushing on you and saying like well you have to do well by this metric or we're gonna fire you or kill your department what's the way around that if you're you see if you feel like you're indentured into a game that you have to play it like you have no other option and in some of the you know not true games but the the gamification systems that we mentioned earlier in this episode and some people might feel like hey I like I'm trapped in the wealth game or the keeping up with the Joneses game or whatever I think we have to acknowledge that a lot of the world's scoring systems have a deep impact on us practically and there's no way to completely disentangling ourselves with them but there's a huge difference between knowing that something gives you some useful goods and that you all participate within it in so far as you get the goods you want versus taking it to heart as the I mean simplest example is just like there's a big difference between paying attention how much money you have and how big your retirement account is so you don't starve and have enough versus thinking my goal in life is to max out my money score no matter what right I mean like like I mean it in some sense it's like a super simple thing to say but like I mean I have there are a bunch of things that the world tracks about me as an academic my publication rate my citation rate and it's a completely different thing to be like well I can't keep this job unless I hit this minimum versus my goal is to maximize my publication citation rate any way I can I think if you recognize it as a merely external system then you will as we say play the game to some extent but then distance yourself from it and take control where you can and I think like you know there's some people I mean if the more the the less power you have the more you you can't exert this kind of reflective control but the time I mean by the time you get to I suspect the stage that I'm at and that you're at I suspect that you two like crypto experts are moderately financially independent and you're not about to starve and you can get healthcare if you need it right like if you're at that stage right then you have a real question about whether or not the scoring system of continuing to max out your financial wealth is the one that's valuable to you or whether that is a useful resource that can be used as a background to for some other pursuit Titian does that does that track does it make sense it does yeah I I love it because I think the the message of your book is is one of agency with respect to the games that you play and the scores that you use to measure your pursuits and and your progress at the end of your book tea you have you have two different endings it's like choose your own adventures there's like an A and a B well one is a cynical sad one and the other has a bit more hope measure of hope I I prefer the second I prefer the measure of hope version I I think that the second reflects a bit more agency maybe in the individual than than the first ending maybe what why'd you write two different endings to your book and you like at this whole thing I I feel like very much as I was reading the score I saw sort of the trade offs a world of a landscape of trade offs right the pros in the cons of scoring systems and gamification of everything you some of the pros are wow we've really scaled out society haven't way I mean nation states bring all of these and bureaucracies bring all of these improvements to our net welfare overall and look at the GDP growth and look at post enlightenment everything it's all fantastic and then also the acknowledgment of the costs of that score the one dimensionization almost the the feeling that we're all part of this machine and the loss of purpose the loss of hope but it is a trade off right I'm not sure that I'd want it you know yeah I'm not sure I'd want to go back to you 400 years ago before the metrication of the world right in the way things are but anyway why two endings to the book why are you of two minds on right this whole scoring system we're we're recording this before this book has come out and I'm just super happy right now because I feel like mostly I've shown this book to other people on philosophy so I have no idea how it's going to hit elsewhere and talking to YouTube makes me just incredibly happy because I feel like I keep hearing like the the quiet things I hope would come out and I think the biggest quiet thing that I hope would come out is this trade off because I think the thing that what thinking about this stuff has really convinced me is and I think this is something that is obvious to you because you work in finance but not to me in philosophy because I work in philosophy is the importance of scale that the biggest driving force in what I've been thinking about is what scale does the nature of information collection and what scale does the nature of judgment right the whole point is the bigger the scale and the more we can coordinate on some clear measure the more efficient we are at hitting exactly what we coordinated on and also the more likely we are to miss anything that we're not coordinating on right so if you set up if you I mean the bureaucratic institutional world is so good at optimizing for anything can measure and what what I'm just trying to point out is that there's a cost and it's not that we should give up on institutions I mean I without large scale bureaucracy and large scale data collection I would die to age 11 right I'm an asthmatic with poor health like I would be dead 40 times over without this stuff so I'm not saying go back I am saying I mean you picked up exactly what I'm saying I'm saying that the vast power of scale also comes with this the seductive call to forget that there's anything else outside of what the institution can measure and I'm just trying to say like no there's a trade off no there's other stuff that you've forgotten and know that sometimes it's okay to detach yourself and that there's gotta be what I'm hoping for is the middle ground work and be like yes decide yes to increase GDP maybe not yes to like defining our entire lives only in terms of our network why why two endings I mean I'll give you a simple version there are times when I look at this I'm like this this is terrible this is so depressing the world is so efficient in squeezing out everything good in human and the other time from like no this is just another trade off this is just another trade off thing we just have to be careful about the trade off and I like there's something we should be careful about which is you know going too far in the direction of only metrifying it only recognizing as important what we can measure via large scale institutional data but we can pull back from that so part of it that I'm up to you mind but there's a deeper there's a there's a this is my RT party reason the two endings to the book are kind of my own private glorious joke I know and the joke is this this whole book is about what kinds of external systems tell you what's important versus what kinds of external systems let you find what's important for yourself what kind of external systems squash agency and which kinds of ones permit agency and one of the interesting things to me is that large scale institutional metrics even though they so proficiently looks like look like games are agency squashing machines because they tend towards singular renditions of value that suck everybody in and games I think are agency promoting machines in that they let people jump between different scoring systems and try on different things and towards the end of the book you probably know it's like there's this moment where I'm talking about this stuff and I'm like hey look there's some kind of technologies and ways of presenting things encourage agency and other ones that don't and my example of an agency encouraging so I think there's some earlier in the book I talk about agency destroying cookbooks that just tell you this is the right way to do things this is the perfect muffin this is this isn't the end going to go back to why your wife is right about we're on tomatoes like this is terrible because like you make this thing and it's good but you're never going to explore and find out what's the muffin for you and then there's this other cook bike I'll jockey you really a cook at home where the whole structure of the book is in every recipe there's jox version in Julius version and they're different and then they argue free with each other about why there's this better and there's no conclusion it ends you in an inconclusive choice where you're allowed to try out different ways of making a burger and I think that's agency promoting and it sounds like it gives you space to understand the gap between the two versions and understand why there's a gap there and it's great because it has like it has the authority and it does what cookbooks are good for it it shows you the expertise it lets you imitate them but then it doesn't tell you what you have to do it tells you look here's the version that makes the salmon super crispy and here's the version that makes it super and then you get to try them both and find out what you like and also learn how you can move between them and the two things of the book are supposed to be that and like I don't want to tell people like it would be really ironic if I wrote a book about agency and exploration and did it telling what people people what they should think so I want like the inner joke is that it's just supposed to be my own version of the jocke and julia cook at home like here's a happy ending and a sad ending you choose i'm not going to tell you that's great and the way to get out of this metrification of course is at the local level right you promote this idea of value federalism right where you can make decisions in your own life irrespective of what the system is telling you and what the metrics that the system wants to support and I think that's the the best way to adjust moving forward to you this has been great thank you so much for joining us hey I had just one last question because I mentioned so many times hearing about why do you not like the game civilization the computer game you said it makes you miserable it's one of my favorite games I mean this is this is this is the hope this is the whole point of the board right civilization makes some people miserable and some people happy and that's okay and that means you can play it and I don't have to for civilization for me is like 15 turns of interesting decisions and then a time lost nausea of micro optimization as I do not I just don't like I like civilization is something that I feel like I just lose months to and there are other games I mean rock climbing I've been playing I mean super smash with my kids is like way richer for me than civilization and I think the key point of the book is I guess the dumbest possible message if you like civilization play civilization don't don't that's right don't optimize for it of the game sucks for you yeah make the games you're playing better that that's the message to you thank you so much for joining us thank you thank you civilization gotta let you know of course games are risky crypto is just another one of those games you put in skier that's right play the right games kids but we're headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on bankless journey thanks a lot you