Kirk Hutchison is the Co-Founder of Volt Protocol, an inflation hedged stablecoin built on Ethereum. Kirk is widely known as the gigabrain’s gigabrain when it comes to all things DeFi.
As inflation continues to rise, Kirk couldn’t have joined at a better time. However, Kirk and David dive into much more than inflation.
On this episode, Kirk explains symmetric money systems, self-referential feedback mechanisms, the problems with DeFi today, what Volt is and its future, and so much more.
------ 📣 NOTIONAL | Real DeFi Yield https://bankless.cc/Notional
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALED ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🏦 ROCKET POOL | STAKE YOUR ETH https://bankless.cc/RocketPool
👻 AAVE V3 | LEND & BORROW CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/aave
⚡️ LIDO | LIQUID ETH STAKING https://bankless.cc/lido
🔐 LEDGER | NANO S PLUS WALLET https://bankless.cc/Ledger
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 4:45 What Kirk Thinks About 8:36 Decentral Bank Terms Explained 13:45 What is a PSM? 18:16 The Bankless Thesis 21:20 Fully Symmetric Money System 28:05 Why is Fixed Rate a Problem? 32:12 Self-Referential Feedback Mechanisms 40:45 The Problems with DeFi Today 47:40 DeFi Utopia vs. Dystopia 1:00:55 What is Volt & Its Future? 1:09:25 Governance Token Design 1:13:35 8% Yield to Combat Inflation in DeFi 1:19:20 Closing
------ Resources:
Kirk https://twitter.com/OneTrueKirk
Volt Protocol https://twitter.com/voltprotocol
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
The idea that we're going to today in 2022 create an immutable system that will work forever with no changes is ridiculous. Right? Every system that's ever been made has been changed a lot. Ethereum's a lot different than it was when it started. Bitcoin's a lot different than it was when it started. There's nothing that will work without change and be adopted and used long-term without change. However, you can get it so that the procedures for chains are less subject to abuse. Welcome to Layers 0. Layers 0 is a podcast of unscripted conversations with the people that make up the Ethereum community.
Crypto is built by code but is composed by people and each individual member of the crypto community has their own story to tell. CypherPunks understood that the code they write impacts the people that use it and Layers 0 focuses on the people behind the code because Ethereum is people all the way down and it always has been. Today on Layers 0, I'm talking with Kirk Hutchison of Volt and Volt is a inflation hedge stablecoin. It's a stablecoin that is hopefully designed to restore and retain its value as inflation goes up and up and up which is a very timely conversation. However, we don't actually start the conversation there.
Kirk has been recommended to me by many, many different people from across the DeFi ecosystem with universal consensus about this gigabrain nature of this guy Kirk. In order to meet this guy Kirk and get to know why everyone respects him, I just decided to pull him straight on to a podcast. We dive down the rabbit hole of some very primitive DeFi concepts that we haven't really revisited in bankruptcy for a very long time. This concept of no magic numbers when we design our DeFi protocols. Anything arbitrary in a DeFi protocol is fragile and if it's fragile, it's going to break. We talk about that concept.
He also is very, very attuned to the world of monetary policy and economics and trying to apply the lessons of tradify and economic history into the lessons of DeFi. Rather than this being a more typical Layers 0 episode where I'm actually trying to go into the soul and personality of our guests, this is me just trying to figure out how Kirk thinks and what he's trying to do. And what does what he prioritize and I find a ton of alignment with what he is building, how he's building it and what he's modeling it after. And so I hope you guys follow me down this rabbit hole of understanding Kirk and also understanding volts, Volt and seeing where all this goes when the ecosystem that Kirk envisions for the DeFi ecosystem comes to fruition.
So let's go ahead and get right into the show right after we get to some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. Arbitrum is an Ethereum layer 2 scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Over 300 projects have already deployed to Arbitrum and a DeFi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly. Some of the coolest and newest NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home, all the wild DeFi protocols continue to see increased usage and liquidity. Using Arbitrum has never been easier, especially with the ability to deposit directly into Arbitrum through all the exchanges including Binance, FTX, Quoby and Crypto.
com. Inside you'll notice Arbitrum increases Ethereum's speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee. If you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users, visit Arbitrum.io slash developer to start building your DAP on Arbitrum. If you're a DGen, many of your favorite DAPs on Ethereum are already on Arbitrum with many moving over every day. Go to bridge.arbitrum.io now to start bridging over your ETH and other tokens in order to experience DeFi and NFTs in the way it was always meant to be. Last, cheap, secure and friction free.
The layer 2 era is upon us. Ethereum's layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day and we need bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a layer 2 life. Across is the fastest, cheapest and most secure, cross-chain bridge. With across, you don't have to worry about the long wait times or high fees to get your assets to the chain of your choice. Access are bridged and available for use almost instantaneously. Across bridges are powered by UMA's Optimistic Oracle to securely transfer tokens from layer 2 back to Ethereum. A token proposal is being deliberated as we speak across forum where community members will decide on the token distribution.
You can have your part of across the story by joining the Discord and becoming a co-founder and helping to design the fair, fair launch of across. If you want to bridge your assets quickly and securely, go to across.io to bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Arbitrum or Boba Networks. I'm here with Kirk Hutcherson and co-founder of Volt Protocol and Kirk has been universally recommended me from by a number of people who I know and trust in the crypto space. The word digger brain has been used a number of times to describe Kirk. I don't know where this conversation is going to go but I have a feeling it's going to be a good one.
Kirk, welcome to the show. Thank you so much David. I'm really excited to be here and flattered by the kind words people have said of me. I definitely am kind of a theory cell as far as crypto stuff. I come from a very mechanism nerd, like look into the history, look into all the nitty-gritty of it. I feel very grateful for the opportunity to build and practice that now. That's how I'd introduce myself. Fantastic. Yeah, crypto definitely offers a blank slate for thinkers to begin to tinker. I like that line. Thinker is going to tinker. As a thinker, Kirk, what do you think about? What are the subject matters that you often ideate in your imagination?
Well, the thing that got me into crypto in the first place was like many people in general the idea of censorship resistance, not just money, you know, things like social networks as well. And I took a brief soldier in trying to be a silly dev. I was never a particularly good one, although I gained useful insights by trying to learn that. I became fixated after a while on the problem of scalability in governance and how, you know, if you look at like token governance models today, such as MakerDow, how they decide to tune parameters in the system or add new collaterals, there's quite a bottleneck of attention, you know, the attention of the whole dial at one time is not very scalable.
I'm thinking a lot about that problem, especially in the context of stablecoins. And that's what drew me to fuse and you know, Rory capital and the tribe that ultimately was looking at more permissionless lending markets and thinking, how could you govern deployment of PCB or, you know, lending capacity in one of those markets in a more scalable market based approach. And that was what was my original idea that let was behind bolt. There's been quite a journey since then and a lot of other elements and the scope of the problem for me has expanded into the question of really how can you correctly make a decentralized bank, you know, the fully symmetrical currency and credit markets and everything, you know, all the types of things that people need banks for in a totally transparent on chain way that is governed ideally by markets and not by votes.
Because the votes are where it gets sticky and anything that is like asynchronous decision making, not very ideal for like a continuously running open system. That's why Ethereum or blockchains are so good is that they don't go down or they're not supposed to right there's always always there and it can't be disrupted. So having some of the principles about what makes L1 so good and thinking about can we take that into these, you know, applications and, you know, make further strides in the design is really what I'm obsessed with and how we could. Yeah, I, I've inspired a lot by what exists. I also have inspired a lot by traffic and learning about everything how that works.
And I think that there's a lot to learn as far as building those functions, but not necessarily in the same package on chain. Yeah, I have a feeling this is going to be a pretty brainy and technical show. So I definitely, as we go along, want to take some time to define some stuff to make sure that all the listeners are keeping up with us. You used a term which I have not heard in a very long time, a decentralized bank. Now that that's from a decentralized bank is something. I think, I think I might have made this thing in 2018 when I was first getting into the role of content production and using it to describe make or down.
It was like I understood make or down at the time to be like a version of a central bank as in a controlled interest rates, it had a monetary policy, it had like assets and liabilities, but it was to centralize. And so like, how do you talk about these things? Well, like let's call it a decentralized bank. I mean, never really caught on, but I think as we extrapolate from 2018 to where we are now. I think what you're leaning into is like, there is a more rather than make or down being the decentralized bank, there is the concept of a decentralized bank. And make or down is now just like one flavor of that or one implementation of that.
I'm getting the idea that vault is an alternative flavor of a decentralized bank. But before we go into vault, can you talk about the concept of a decentralized bank? You use some other words that I'd like you to define as well as in a fully symmetric currency. That one left a question mark in my head as well as asynchronous votes. So can we talk about like the model of a decentralized bank for a model and then talk about those two dynamics of a components of decentralized bank, symmetrical currencies and asynchronous asynchronous votes. Can you talk about those things? That sounds great. So if we, I think maybe we should start by just asking about like in a modern context, what is money?
And since pretty much, you know, at least the industrial revolution, money means either a currency issued by, you know, a central bank or maybe a deposit at a bank that issues its own independent notes. And usually this represents some kind of like a hard money value, you know, which could be gold, it could be central bank notes. And there's an understanding that the bank is taking part of that capital and loaning it out, you know, and they have some portion of basically hard money reserves and then they have a loan book. So not everything is fully liquid and they have to manage, you know, the liquidity within the system to ensure the price is stable.
This is what central banks do to bond markets and all that. But it existed with private banks too. And this is, you know, we could get into what is a bank in the gold standard, which is a little different. We won't worry about that for right now. But the idea that users need convenient media of exchange, exchange media. You know, so like you don't want to hold gold bars right you want dollar bills or now you don't want that you want to credit card or debit card. And so users need to deposit their value with some kind of an institution that provides those convenient exchange media. And there's other functions that the bank does as well, which is that different people have different time preferences with their money.
You know, you might have money that you need to spend tomorrow, but then you have money you don't need for five years or whatever. And you're willing to have different levels of liquidity on those funds in exchange for getting some return. And likewise, there's people who need to borrow money. And so those are all the things that a bank does. You know, there's lots of, and along with that, banks also do deals with other banks where they buy and sell these types of debts. And so essentially, and that latter function is what the Federal Reserve and Central Banks have kind of taken over like they control and regulate how the banks can relate with other banks and other various rules.
But even before central banks existed, it's natural for banks to have things like, oh, if lots of people come to redeem from them and they run out of liquid reserves that they would borrow from another bank to get what they need and have those kind of deals in place. And these types of ideas are being brought up in D5 by others as well. Like Seb Ventures from MakerDow, someone I respect a lot. And he posted a blog post describing like a clearing's down where stablecoin issuers could draw credit from each other like using their own stablecoin is collateral when they had liquidity needs, for example.
And I think that these kind of structures can be very informative for D5. So when I think about a decentralized bank, I say, to me, what is the problem with money on chain today, if we look at L1 tokens like Ethan Bitcoin, the problem is that they're too volatile to be short term money. You know, and I don't think that's ever going to change. They could be thought of as the equivalent of like, you know, the highest quality equities right in the future. Or like other, there's other or entirely new ways of thinking about valuation, but they're not exactly the same thing as cash. Now, stablecoins, at the end of the day, all stablecoins basically either depend upon a not necessarily sustainable incentives model or on centralized stablecoins in order to maintain a stable backing.
And there's nothing that it's like a conclusive exception to that that's shown to be highly scalable so far. And we can see clearly the disadvantages of depending on like, I'm not someone who's like a PSM hater necessarily, you know, I it's good that die has the PSM, but it's not good to stay that way forever. And they're working on it, right? You know, like maker Dow is all over trying to diversify out of USDC risk. But can you define a PSM? PSM is a peg stability module and for a simple thought about decentralized stablecoins, you could either be doing over collateralized lending where they're minted against an over collateralized position of eth or other assets, or you could mint it directly against another stablecoin in a PSM, which is a peg stability module.
And not everyone would call it a PSM, but it's the same thing like how, you know, the portion of fracks supply, which is backed by USDC is analogous to a PSM type of operation. And then let's see. So when I think about a decentralized bank, I think that all of these things that banks do, like accepting deposits and loan origination, you sort of, it's going to be very, you can't leap all the way there in one step. You know, these decentralized systems to have the equivalent of the triad fight instantly. But if we start to learn from these, I think it's possible to build a more resilient and decentralized stablecoin systems, especially if like you can, if you can cut out centralized middleman in the right way, you know, like with USDC circle controls everything.
We can see other things like how Lido manages the validators or how MakerDow is looking at them doing direct deals with different entities like bond offerings, those things all can help mitigate counterparty risk. But having a really like to me, it's still done on like a case by case basis, you know, I mean, there's no like clear transparent framework for how MakerDow will scalably decide what kind of real world lending it will do without just relying on like an inside group of experts. And so figuring out decentralized and market based approaches for these things is one of my big goals. And when I said a fully symmetric stablecoin, I guess what I meant is one that has a match between both being able to, um, to match make between those who wish to deposit their capital in the stablecoin system and receive stable value and some yield.
And those who would allocate that capital and the lending opportunities that exist in a way that is fully market based and the rates are derived from the market. And you know, utilizations similar how often compound have utilization based rates. Um, but connecting that into a wider variety of activities, potentially even including real world assets, because I, you know, I am a decent, I say I'm decentralization mostly rather than decentralization maxi because I do think that getting that last mile into the real world is very important. And we can't just if, if, if the best decentralized systems, because they're too purest minded, drop the ball on the last mile and then just let the scams and such go direct to the people.
Um, that is not a good outending. And like when I look at how big like terror and UST got and then look at like how little attention is given to even, you know, the more promising like radically decentralized experiments like rye. Um, I just think that for vault, at least it's one of my goals to really be proactive in that regard, at least. And we can learn from, um, yeah, I like what said at make it out thinks about, you like, there are ways to analyze to get close to the purity of a smart contract through the legal system, not 100%. But, um, like we shouldn't be close minded to the idea that there can be other consensus layers besides one blockchain right and a settlement layers and being in general, the perspective of looking as holistically possible at the, how blockchain can fit into the world economy and in the, um, taking a long term view over five, 10 years, right and how lending markets and capital markets can evolve.
That's all the type and a historical perspective of how they've changed. Otherwise, like, there's been many big changes in the world capital and financial markets in trafi in the last 30 years, 40 years. Um, and so understanding how digitization has affected them and then like looking at the arc of how things will go, um, I think that there's a, I might be rambling a little bit now, but I think that there's a lot of significance to, um, you know, going to the kitchen and stealing the chef secrets for trafi taking the best out of it and then, um, but keeping those robust decentralization and censorship resistance features and, but that's what's like a, you know, it started the camel through the eye of the needle, right.
So you had to be, it's not an easy task, but that's the problem space. Okay. So yeah, there's a number of different rabbit holes that I think just opened up and the first one, I think, uh, at the beginning, you talked about, like, all these different stable coins that we have on a theory of frack style, USDC tribe. Uh, and I think you kind of alluded to how there's not really ever going to be any one single perfect winner of like the stablecoin, uh, systems, but the net results. Once we have what kind of feels like a commercial banking layer of private money. So where we have like the maker Dow making die, we have the, the tribe commercial bank making tribe, we have the USDC commercial bank and doing USDC.
Once we have all of these this commercial banking layer and what I, what I mean by that, just to be super clear, is that in the trafi world, we have the Federal Reserve, which is the bank zero of the whole entire thing. And then layered on top of that, you have the commercial banking layer, the Wells Fargo's, the, you know, JP Morgan's, the Goldman Sachs that have accounts at the Fed, and they trade and market make between each other, but then ultimately everything settles down to the Fed. And I think what you alluded to is that if we do want a fully decentralized bank, it's not going to be maker now that wins, it's not going to be tribe that wins, it's not going to be USDC that wins, but rather is going to be an emergent product out of the interrelationships between all of these things.
And that's when we, when we get the network of those things and these financialization networks between all these stable coins that are mostly decentralized for the most part with the exception of USDC, which is completely centralized. And then at that point in time, we actually do get this like emergent D central bank that unlocks this like bankless future that we're all looking for. Am I on track with this general thesis here? That's absolutely right. It's sort of like, you know, the movie The Incredibles, right? It's like, if everyone's special, no one is, right? Like if everyone's a bank, then no one is, that's the bankless future.
The marketizing access to the kind of powers that banks have. And you know, you can, I expect there'll be many more bank like entities of varying degrees of centralization, you know, from the spectrum of full decentralization, immutable smart contracts to, you know, just circle, but in a different legal jurisdiction and a different, you know, different backing exposure. And I see there being a wide diversity and then having, yeah, the more intern luck network to they are, the more resilient the system can be. And I'm really inspired. I'll show a little bit my favorite living economist George Selgin who has written a lot about like the Scottish free banking era and some historical periods of robust banking networks that did not rely on a central bank.
And you know, there's interesting things to learn from there as far as how they manage liquidity crisis or currency also for the, from a defy perspective, but I think there's, yeah, clear historical and theoretical evidence, the central bank actually generally contributes instability, rather the stability to the system and that a decentralized network will be far superior. Cool. I definitely want to go into that, but also I want to just like double double tap on the fully symmetric money system. I might be wrong on this, but like my, the way that I'm trying to understand this is like if we talk about like Tara Luna, for example, I'm guessing that that is a fully non sync symmetric money system as in it is extremely lopsided.
And it was so lopsided that it collapsed and like with the idea that I see you nodding your head. So I think I'm on the right track here is that like when, when Tara, like Nick Harder had this tweet about Tara Luna that I really liked where he said the day that Tara sold off UST to purchase Bitcoin to have Bitcoin on the balance sheet was the start of the collapse because they took, they, it was a lopsided system. They took away liquidity out of UST to buy Bitcoin in hopes to like, okay, we're going to have this Bitcoin to like defend the peg one day, not realizing that like if you sell UST to buy Bitcoin, you are causing the deep hanging of the UST, you are taking weight away from one side of the market.
And, and you're, you're adding a bunch of selling where you are not creating enough buying. And so with, if I'm understanding like symmetric versus asymmetric monies, it's when there's like there's the in equal buying and selling is like kind of my general understanding for that. And so if we have like money crises, it's because there is an imbalance in money. And so if you, if you are telling me that like the dollar, for example, or the way that currencies generally maintain their peg is being by symmetrical where there's like sufficient market participants on both sides, you have both depositors and creditors, right, you and these things are balanced enough and the markets are efficient.
That makes a symmetric money, which is a, which is for an stable going purposes going to hold its pay. Going to hold its peg if it's symmetric, if it's sufficiently well balanced. Am I on track here? Yes. And, you know, symmetric was was off the cuff. There might be other ways to describe it. But the. So, and of course, Tara had many other problems, but in general, there's a there's a general class of problems we could talk about and it applies to every stable coin that exists today is that there's no such thing as a stable coin whose backing is 100% instantly liquid for dollars. Right. And so what that means is that for every stable coin, there's a condition under which it might trade not at peg.
And for some stable coins, those conditions are extremely remote. For some of them, they are very likely. And the worst failures of peg will always occur when people don't know what's going to happen. And so in the case of, I'll bring in one of the examples from this Scottish banking period. It was a common feature of many, you know, so these banks would issue notes, right, in exchange for gold, you know, gold deposits in the dough. We interact principal redeemable for a certain amount of gold, although the bank was fractional reserve. And some of these notes came to carry what they call an option clause.
And the note said that this bank is either redeemable in gold on demand or from the moment you brought it in payable in gold at a certain interest rate in this much time. And so by putting this clause on the note, the bank notes, it gave people the confidence that at least if they couldn't get their money right away, the bank was solvent and they would get a certain interest rate. And so that also meant that if the bank had a liquidity crisis, those notes converted into bonds and then had a higher value, right. And so it kind of, you can see a similar principle at work to, you know, an offer compound when lots of people want to withdraw their money, you know, the interest rate goes up to incentivize people to close their loans or more deposits to be made.
And so that's like a very responsive and symmetric system and it facilitates matchmaking of those who want more yield and those who want liquidity. And so you can't necessarily guarantee that so we will always hold peg with the system like this, but it should make any discount more rational and limited, right. So if you know, like in the case of die because people know it is over collateralized, even in a case where more than half the die supply had to unwind and they depleted the PSM. It's not going to go that much below peg before people then refill the PSM by arming because they're confident since it's over collateralized.
And so the knowledge in the knowledge of the mechanism by which it would return to peg or the mechanism, the amount of haircut you might take if you need instant liquidity demand, making that as clear as possible and predictable for the participants makes the system more stable. So one of our, you know, things we're thinking about a lot is. If you have a stable coin that has a significant illiquid backing component, let me take a step back if you checked out interest protocol. No, I have not. It's a new kind of compound or all the style market with a native stable coin that was released recently, GFX labs was behind it.
And the idea of a stable coin that is responsive on these kind of same yield curves makes a lot of sense as often compound. But then the question is, if you're going to bring in, let's say, more PSM or real world type of assets or do these kind of, you know, loans or bond stuff that make your dad was considering. How do you do the right feedback between that and the interest rate that you're giving out on the stable coin and how can you. Do a market mechanism also to decide like how liquid the stable coins backing should even be like if you asked me, should the stable coins backing be 99% liquid should it be 50% liquid.
That's not something I want to arbitrarily decide, right? That's something that a market should decide somehow. And you can look at like the fracks collateralization market process, it's something kind of similar like that. And in this case, it would be like not choosing how under collateralized it is, but maybe just how illiquid it is. That kind of idea. Interesting. Interesting. Okay. So just a just a good and define like what makes a good resilience, stable coin, all stable coins that are going to be robust, resilient, antifragile, like a sustainable, have to have what you call symmetric marketplaces as in like a balance, right?
Is that that's part of the definition here. Yes, and this idea of symmetry is really, it's about liquidity. That's what I would emphasize is that there needs to be a two-sided liquidity marketplace and not just like fixed rates anywhere where there's fixed rates or things that are not responsive. There's problems. That's why when MakerDow has to go and manually turn the interest rates, right? That's less than ideal. The curves on often compound are better. The anchor fixed rate was a problem. And we have in fact realized that the idea of pegging vault to a fixed rate of the CPI is also a problem.
Right. Yeah. We'll definitely get into that. Actually, actually, no, let's go down that rebel hole right now. Can you just illustrate why, why is fixed rate a problem? Like we see this right now in the Japanese bond market, I believe where I think there's something like a cap on like the yield of the bond market. They have a yield curve controls of like 0.25%. So they're fixing their whole entire bond market. Can you explain why a central bank would do that? And what problems arise as a result? So central banks generally serve political ends. That's what I would emphasize and that I don't always know why they do what they do because it doesn't always necessarily look like the best idea.
In this case of the bank of Japan, if we just at a basic level of what is the effect of very low interest rates on the economy is that it makes borrowing cheaper. And the reason that they might want to make borrowing cheaper is because there's lots of what you might call zombie companies in Japan's economy that are heavily indebted and don't have strong growth prospects such that if rates rose, they would collapse. And this is the case with the United States economy as well, but it's significantly worse there. So if rates go up, it would lead to significant social disruption. And so that's what they don't want.
But at the end of the day, it's like an incentivized system. It's being propped up by the central bank. They can't keep it that way forever. So oftentimes keeping it that way longer doesn't make things better when you ultimately need to change. And you know, that was the case for terror, right? I mean, the fact that it's unbacked in the first place means it won't work. But even if it wasn't unbacked and if it was instead just like, imagine like we'll offer this 20% yield and then we'll go and like, I mean, even just look at something like Celsius, right? That's a more, you know, if you're like, we'll go off for 8% yield and then we'll go state yeast and it's locked up for a year.
It's like, well, what if they want to get out? And then if you don't have a clear marketplace to sell off your illiquid collateral in some way in order to or give people like a defined haircut on exit and that they knew upfront what it would be, you get panic and bank runs and chaos. Okay. So we're going back to the symmetry thing. Is it the supply of the outstanding dollars for whatever this bank that we're going to talk about, whether it's micro Dow tribe, whatever, the supply of the outstanding dollars needs to be balanced by the available liquidity. So when those things are balanced, is that is that like the symmetry that we're looking for here as in like if there's a if there's like a billion dollars, there needs to be like 10 times more liquidity than a stablecoin that's only a hundred million dollars.
And it's that that's liquidity that is that if there's sufficient liquidity, then the peg will be sufficiently defended. Yeah, to an extent, although I would say, I'm not sure what the right liquidity ratio is, but it certainly does scale with the size of the system. And then the other thing is that there needs to be a feedback mechanism. That's the most important thing is that there have to be when it, like, and this, this happens with, I'll give an example of how fracks works, where there is a feedback mechanism. Like, if I go and, you know, redeem some fracks, I get a certain amount of USDC and a certain amount of, you know, FXS.
And as I do that, the frack system adjusts slightly its preference in the direction of being more collateralized. So as redemptions occur, it will seek to become more collateralized in response. Now, overall, I'm a, you know, a pro over collateralization individual. That's for sure. But nonetheless, you know, we can learn good mechanisms from everywhere. And the fact that there's any system variable that is fixed and can never change, that means that there's probably a market condition in which that's wrong. And so that's the kind of the insight that I've arrived at. And, you know, and needing to change it by a vote is also probably wrong.
Because sometimes things happen fast. And it'll be much more smooth if it can be according to a curve or a market process. Okay, this, yeah, this opens up something I've always been fascinated about in the crypto space. I mean, Solomon, one of my, we're not personal heroes in this space. I say that every single time I bring him up, gave out this line in 2017. I think it was a tweet or on a podcast or something. And he actually doesn't remember saying this. And so he said that he said the line, no magic numbers. And while I was only very young in my like career down crypto, like I understood that line, like into as soon as he said it, like, no magic numbers.
And what he met by that is like, if you, if a human just chooses a number, a parameter, and they just arbitrarily chosen, that is the definition of something that is not anti fragile. It is, it's literal fragility because it's a fixed number. If it's something it's fixed, it's fragile. And so if we are trying to make a censorship resistant human resistant, like long term sustainable financial systems, we can't just be picking arbitrarily arbitrary numbers. It has to be a dynamic system that can respond to the inputs and outputs that are around it, right? And so this is where this is always where crypto starts to look a lot more like nature, more than it does finance.
I mean, it definitely looks like finance, but like it's borrowers property from nature. And so there are a number of systems out there, like you've already talked about the dynamic interest rates of compound and Ave as the utilization of these assets inside of compound and Ave go up, the interest rates go up. And what that means by that is like, if there's, if Ave has 100 teeth deposited into his vaults, people have supplied 100 teeth. And no one is borrowing anything. Well, then the interest rates on that is basically zero, because we wouldn't need to incentivize people to borrow it. As that number goes up, that goes right, it goes up slowly at first, like 10 East gets borrowed so interest rates go up a little bit, 20 East gets borrowed so interest rates go up a little bit.
If we get up to 80 East borrowed out of the 100 East that's deposited, the interest rates that are being charged by the borrowers goes up a lot. Because at some point, if you hit like 99 East that's borrowed out of the total 100 East that's deposited, there's no more liquidity in the system. We got one East left. And so we have to dynamically increase this interest rate to naturally balance out this marketplace and incentivize more deposits or to incentivize people to repay their yield. A similar system, also part of Rai, Rai, the stablecoin is like this governance, it's called a, what is it called?
Based on like control theory, it's like a natural governor. Kirk, can you just talk about this dynamic of like a self-referential feedback mechanism and how it can take us from like a fragile version of finance to an anti-fragile version of finance? Yeah, I think that let me think about for saying about the best way to put it in words. Here's a, I like to give people very concrete examples. So let's think about this. You and I are, you know, we have two avocados between us. One of them is ripe today and one will be ripe tomorrow. And we each have one dollar. So the question is, yeah, or, you know, there's an avocado seller, yeah, present.
How much is the one ripe avocado worth and how much is the unripe avocado worth? It's a good question. How do we decide, right? Because I don't want to over bin on my avocado, right? And so, you know, we get very quickly into the questions of like, how does market pricing work? And at the end of the day, most likely the avocado seller sets a price because he exchanges with many people or who knows what happens? But any system needs some way to regulate. Otherwise, what if, you know, I get word before you that the avocado is there and I run to the store and buy it undercut you. And this is, you know, these kind of examples are what happens when there's like, you know, a liquidation failure in a lending market.
You know, something doesn't happen at the right speed when it could have been sold for the right price, but it wasn't. And so you, even if you do have a, you know, there's always a chance that something could still be mispriced, right? Even if you do have feedback loops. But the, sorry, I'm, I'm generally in my words, I think we need to step one step back and just ask like, what is a market? And if we understand that what a market is in general is like an information system where there's the whole economy and like, how does someone decide what something is worth to them? It's based on their own needs.
And so based on their own needs, they'll pay the best price they can figure out for what they're going to get. You know, I have my income. I have to decide what I'm going to spend it on. And those prices propagate into the economy and the market and they inform the sellers and other things. And it all comes together to be expressed in the prices, which are an information signal. And when you have like a, in order to have a market, you need the ability for the free exchange of this kind of information. And the easier it is for people to, you know, connect economically, the more efficient the market will be.
So running on a blockchain, this 24, 7 global, always online, you know, where anyone can be a market maker or a liquidator compared to these opaque tradfly systems. It's much smoother. And for lending and borrowing, that's why it's the difference between like, you and I'll critique. This is a sample form that I kind of like, but there's one thing I don't like about it, which is LUSD. The fact that it has a fixed fee on minting and no ongoing charge introduces instability into that system. And if the, the fact that it is instead a liquidation only model that's just based on like you have to top up your collateral.
It means that incentives are applied in a more staccato way, you know, like when the liquidation actually occurs instead of a smoothly adjusting rate. And so you can see that like, it means like traders in crypto will often like to look at where the liquidation walls are, right. A lot of people will have their position at that spot. And probably we can do a lot better with like automatically regulating these things like people are already working on like defi saver type of stuff that will automatically adjust your collateralization to be responsive to the market movements, right. So that's another type of feedback that's very beneficial for the users where you don't want to just be like.
Or like even I'll draw an analogy to like uni v3 right it's more of a market of opinions because instead of just being stuck to like oh it's this price and this curve only you can say oh well I'll put whatever curve I want right and it's my opinion. And then I can change it in the future to with flash liquidity provision on different curves. Anything that allows like more granular market choices and also brings people together into like a smooth place where they can all exchange in the market together will make things less risky and better. And this is observed in trad fight to I was just reading a book I got involved in a little defi you know defi slide meets trad fight reading group and the first book of the week was an introduction to repo markets, which I found very well written and talks about some historical perspective of how like.
And just for the listeners are repo market is one of the main types of like quote low risk trad fight yields and banks do it and all kinds of things and it's basically like let's say I'm a stock trader and I have some home depot stock and I want to leverage up on it. I do it over collateralized loan basically just like compound or all the with the bank where I give them you know $100 of home depot stock they give me a $50 loan and a half percent or 1% interest rate and then I go do whatever I want with that I had a short home depot ahead or I lever up whatever my my plans are. And this is a huge you know huge huge market the only really came into existence.
I know that you came market was created in the 90s that's not that long ago and the motive of creating it and like legally allowing it. Because before it was like only banks can do these types of deals and then they made a market where like 90 like firm can do it because their goal was to reduce the volatility in the bond markets and allow people to like hedge their positions in that and it worked and the bond markets grew after that. And so you can see that making a place where people can like trust how the rules work and more people can participate grows the pie for everyone and so that's one of the things that's of course really exciting about D5 when you think look in the long term.
Certainly okay so I think we've talked a lot about some just big ideas right like resiliency through multiple D central banks who got we talked about control theory and how that keeps things balanced if the parameters are tuned right. I want to start to get into some more specific things about like the current state of D5 and the problems you see in the current state of D5 and how we get it to that future that you just alluded to where like the pie is very very big. And so like how do we what why what parts of D5 are preventing the pie from getting a lot larger that are like consuming your brain space like what are the problems that you are working on right now.
One thing you know the central thing that we're working on right now at vault you know directly at the moment is this liquidity management system where you know people may be familiar with the die savings rates. You know so there's a version where people can take their die stable coin and lock it to get yield that used to be some yield on it now it's it's been one basis point for a long time of a who knows that the American maybe we'll go back up. And the idea that a stable coin could be natively yield bearing you know we initially created vault is the idea of the inflation resistant stable coin and a hard target on that US consumer price index inflation peg.
But we've realized of course is that in some market conditions the risk that's needed to achieve a hard target maybe unacceptable it's a magic number and we need to get rid of it. That doesn't mean that you know the goal of the system is still to preserve user value and create a marketplace where that's possible but it's just that sometimes it's not up to me to decide that eight and a half percent interest is the right amount at the right risk level. And so creating a way that risk and interest can be priced by the users is what's key. So we're working on a way to build a compound or a style utilization curve into the stable coin and have concepts of the difference between liquid and illiquid reserves you know the difference between like holding die or fae versus let's say holding.
You know for a very simple example like think about what's the equivalent of USDC for die for vault it would be like tokenized wrapped treasury inflation protected securities you know these some kind of a tradfly inflation head instrument right like let's say there was some tokenized you know thing that we could get for that. So some maybe like you know that's earning 9% whatever so it's like 10% of the PCB is in that 90% is liquid and away for the market to choose how that breaks down you know having all those kind of design features so that's what's our most proximal thing. The other big classes of problems I see in defy today are one the lack of like longer term debt and liquidity management you know most dows or stable coin issuers or on chain it's pretty difficult to get longer term borrow only against a very very narrow range of collateral like each only right and even then the markets aren't very liquid.
So with the ability for a stable coin issuer like maker down to access or give out longer term debt is highly beneficial banks you know can real real bank constructed yield curve and have like a management of the liquidity of the underlying things and so that seems like a powerful area that will have a ways to go still is there's not a huge amount of traction there are some cool projects but nothing that has had like run away product market fit yet. And then the other thing for me is yeah really cracking the governance not I think that token governance is a very thorny thing especially when the more money is involved and so really getting that right and checks and balances in the system is critical so one of the things that we're working on for the next volt upgrade is governance rights to the stable coin holders.
And I was very excited to see the recent light of proposal along similar lines of putting various checks into the powers of the light token on state teeth. And we like that idea like you know ultimately in the vault system the goal is that in some way the you know the governance tokens would be able to onboard new yield strategies or venues and then allocate you know PCV or or choose in some kind of a market how that is directed. But we would like the volt holders to be able to veto or say no to bad decisions you know I don't think it's right to expect stable coin holders to proactively go and like decide should we do this or that you know or like way the merits of a highly non-governance decisions but they should at least be able to say like no we don't want this you know like it's even in governance tokens like maker getting participation from the holders is tough.
So it's not like we expect all stable coin holders to be super engaged in governance but giving them especially the large holders and in a relatively small forum the right to veto negative changes is a great security check so you know thinking about those patterns a lot. Ave is the leading decentralized liquidity protocol and now Ave V3 is here. Ave V3 has powerful new features to enable you to get the most out of D5 including isolation mode which allows for many more markets to be launched with more exotic collateral types and also efficiency mode which allows for a higher loan to value ratios and of course portals allowing users to port their Ave position across all of the networks that Ave operates on like polygon, phantom, avalanche, arbitrum, optimism and harmony.
The beautiful thing about Ave is that it's completely open source decentralized and governed by its community enabling a truly bank this future for us all. To get your first crypto collateralized loan get started at Ave.com that's a-a-b-e.com and also check out the Ave protocol governance forums to see what more than a hundred thousand down members are all roving about at governance. Ave.com. There is a brand new staking feature in the ledger live app today. We all like staking the assets that were bullish on and now you can stake seven different coins inside the ledger live app. Cosmos, Polkadot, Tron, Algaryans, Tezos, Solana and of course Ethereum with ledger live you can take money from your bank account buy your most bullish crypto asset and stake that asset to its network all inside the ledger live app.
Through a partnership with figment ledger also lets you choose which validator you want to stake your assets with and ledger is running its own validating notes offering a convenient way to participate in network validation and it even comes with slashing insurance. Ledger live is truly becoming the battle station for the bankless world so go download ledger live if you have a ledger already you probably already have it and get started securely staking your crypto assets. The era of proof of stake is upon us and Lido is bringing proof of stake to everyone. Lido is a decentralized staking protocol that allows users to stake their proof of stake assets using Lido's distributed network of nodes.
Don't choose between staking your assets or using them as collateral in defi with Lido you can have both using Lido you can stake any amount of your eith to the Lido validating network and receive STE in return. STE can be traded use as collateral for lending a borrowing or leverage on your favorite defi protocols all this without giving up your eith to centralized staking services or exchanges. Lido now supports Salana, Kusama and Polygon staking. Whatever your preferred proof of stake asset is Lido is here to take away the complexities of staking while enabling you to get liquidity on your stake.
If you want to stake your eith, sole, ormatic and get liquidity on your stake go to lido.fi to get started that's lidio.fi to get started. Another thing I learned from I mean so many is that if you remove the ability for one party to bully you around, he called this a rage quit mechanism out of molocked out. If there was a proposal that was going through and it was accepted by molocked out, they would go into implement it in seven days. And if you didn't like that and didn't agree with it, you could rage quit without before that proposal was implemented. And so you would remove the ability for anybody who was a whale to who was governing and controlling governance.
If you just were able to quit, they couldn't bully you around and this check on power always protects the minority and it gives a minority a voice. And so I think that it's an interesting checks and bads like checks and balances is definitely the right word. But also at the same time isn't the goal of this whole bankless future is for having governance minimized things right. And so I think any time that there's a vote, I'll take a leaf out of Elon Musk's book and say he says at any time there's a user input into something that's that's an error. And I'll say the same thing for governance is anytime there's a vote, that's a bug that we need to remove.
And like and I don't know how far we can go down by doing that process over and over and over again, like the bankless the bankless utopia is literally all the way to the point where there are no votes. And and I guess that kind of sounds scary is like no votes like what like we just are ruled by these algorithms and like kind of like so I want to kind of want to go down that rabbit hole where like if we do agree that like the idea is that anytime there's a vote that's a failure. We want to do and we want to establish some like market based equilibrium algorithm that that removes the need to vote.
And we have this future where everything on is devised completely automated is that the actual utopia that we want or does that actually lead us down in accidental dystopia. Well the one so I very strongly agree with them the dangers of of mutable systems. However, I think it's a necessary risk. And so we have to tread the thread the line where it's going to be very the idea that we're going to today in 2022 create an immutable system that will work forever with no changes is ridiculous right now. Every system that's ever been made has been changed a lot. Ethereum is a lot different than it was when it started bitcoins a lot different than it was when it started.
There's nothing that will work without change and be adopted and use long term without change. You can get it so that the procedures for chains are less subject to abuse right. And so that's what you said with like the rage quit right things like like Uniswap will make new versions but migration is voluntary right so like opt in is a great pattern. There's some things for which that works better than others and you have to like you know think about ways that certain like dynamic or lending systems can be safely moved over or and then when especially when there's a question of like protocol control value.
So these questions can get a little interesting of how it will work but I am pretty much in favor of the idea that the smart contracts themselves should be as minimal as immutable as possible and then it should be frequent changes and you know voluntary migrations but also the tools to make that relatively easy and simple. That we're thinking about now as we're looking at some of the next iteration of the vault system you involve is not immutable or fully decentralized today that's certainly the goal but in the first. You almost all defy projects today are controlled by multisix and even the ones that are controlled by token governance you know a small number of whales in the core team have enormous influence there's a few that have really gone the extra mile and attained you know distributed and effective central as a decentralization you can see this when the founder tries to push things around.
They don't work. You know there's only a couple instance like that compared to like L1 projects like a theory of there's a long way to go for pretty much all of defy but I've definitely been reflecting a lot looking at like the things that went too immutable too fast in my opinion and then well let me take one step back once. People just need to be a little more careful launching tokens for things and like launching a token for an immutable thing and then having the team only have like a whatever a few year vest is very questionable in my opinion it's just like at the end of the day the incentives are not there for new versions to be made that use the same token.
So that's kind of a problem but that's almost like separate from these like core mechanism questions that I'm trying to you know that are your problems to figure out but I think that it's important to make sure that incentive alignment is there and in the case of something like maker dowry it's obvious that the incentive alignment would be there even if they were to build a successor to die you know they've already built science seems crazy you think there might be a third one right after side and die but but maybe there could be it who knows and if they did that and build a whole new entire system that was voluntary migration they could do that and they have the infrastructure needed to keep teams working and building on it right and that's like incredibly neutral and trustworthy and you can count on that when it's like everything is built by some kind of a centralized labs entity but they're still try to pretend it's fully decentralized you have to wonder a little bit.
You know throwing a small amount of shade on you I think they're great builders but sometimes it's like you know I just feel a little weird when I see like uniswops labs ventures doing big investments when they need token and it's like holders are kind of in the dark about what's going on so transparency is big for me and that's you like I think transparency should almost proceed decentralization and that first of all like who are these people who are supposed to decide right when you give the tokens out like a theorem is not decentralized in the sense that like all the eithholders have to decide how it works right that would be kind of ridiculous however they are able to opt in or out very readily and the kind of like peers those who can run the clients of the network can all opt in or choose right as the majority consensus of the people who really like care and have skin in the game effectively decides the fate of the network and that's pretty good robust decentralization about as good as you can get and it's very hard in my view to get there with token voting system and so these things need to be thought about very carefully and not rushed into is one of the things that I've been realizing lately is like I think that over the next couple of years we'll see really great governance systems design but we can't expect like expecting products either be fully decentralized at the first MVP or things to be immutable when they first are created will lead to dead ends but at the same time things should not be allowed to scale to excess before they have achieved those goals you know that's one reason that we've done a cap launch on vault and will not be like you know significantly allowing the supply to grow until the core issues are ironed out and it's more hardened as far as changes but I do think it's also there is a need for experimentation and that's where like these debates about like regulation or what should be allowed like there is a great need for experimentation and just freedom and sandbox to do whatever you want but I think there's also a room for industry standards of responsibility and things like I think a big lesson we can draw from this whole market is you probably shouldn't do like uncapped public launches of a lot of types of experimental financial products.
It can lead to trouble now probably shouldn't doesn't mean should be illegal and you know but it's still like it causes trouble and so it's wise to think carefully about you know these are the types of lessons I've tried I think maker Dow again is like I keep point to them is like my golden favorite example of a stable coin assure and like the place to look of maker Dow's culture is if a change is going to happen like it needs to be so thoroughly justified and there's all these stakeholders who are going to weigh in and that bias against change like you know let me tell a little when when rocketry got started in California and like the people who would eventually go on to found JPL were just sneaking outside of Caltech and firing off rockets in the canyons when no one lived around like that experimentation was good it was also good that now like today in the aerospace field there are such strict standards for software security right like far more than for any defy project.
You know I have a friend who worked at JPL and it's like they have entire separate teams working on the tests and the code and the people who write the code haven't even touched the test and at the end it all has to work perfectly right and it's like they have everything so specified and so many eyes on it external firms were like even almost the best in the business it's like oh we had two audits you know by these two big name firms it's like well that sounds great but like when was the last time like of our compound checked. An audit on one of their collateral tokens and what governance changes have been going on like even at this moment there's like a bunch of collateral tokens on offer a compa where if a malicious change went through they could just infinite meant or something and and rug you know there's so many buried risks and so that's why I respect maker to a lot of you like no you like very few collaterals per asset collateral caps keeping them very small getting rid of things so those types of choices and also just a completely open and transparent decision making process.
That's what's so good about DeFi like you can see everything that happens on chain and it's even better if the decisions are all out in the open and so that's something you know it's hard for small projects because at the end there's only so many people who care or understand you know you have to just you know it's a small team who's figuring things out but as things grow making sure all of those. Those rails are laid out and transparency is super huge i'm very i'm going on another little tangent here but i'm very much an enthusiast and proponent although we haven't implemented these things at vault yet of like decentralized front ends and informatics hosting you know like decentralized subgraphs or.
IPFS based distribution of sites you know there's a lot of DeFi products can do to just the simple fact of like making the site a front end immutable link like front insecurity is such a kind of worms to like there's so many things that need to be carefully minded so you after all of the like heady days of the the last year i've definitely taken a long look at like. Just how deep a rabbit hole true security really is and what it means to have a security culture and that you know i really admire like the Ethereum core Debs and their process and so DeFi needs to learn from like these robust decentralized existing orgs i think maker Dow and like all core Debs and they they are the Ethereum culture is really strong and that's what DeFi needs to not get lost in and you know sometimes move fast and break things is good but sometimes the Ethereum instinct of no slow down and.
Contemplate is a good one so i'm contemplate and make sure it's really designed the right way for the long term and decide everything based on the best long term principles not based on short term opportunism or incentives. So i mean i'm 100% in alignment with the other property about maker Dow that I definitely admire is that and this became super obvious right after the terror collapse is that the growth of maker Dow lags demand or at least the the growth of die supply lags demand. Whereas like us t was minted in a growth strategy is like well mid will mint all these tokens so that we can go like do things like mint the tokens so people can have the tokens like mint the money and then all of a sudden like it fell over.
Die supply is the opposite of where like it only grows if there's sustainable long term die demand pushing up the die price in the secondary market creating an incentive to mint new die and so this constraint on how fast this thing grows. Is what makes it and protects it and make sure that it's always going to be stable and so like using these principles same thing with like a theorem block space to right like a theorem block space is so constrained yet it actually has gone literally 10x in supply since 2015 when a theorem first got started. And so like the theorem block space supply has grown 10x but everyone feels like that is this Ethereum scaling is going so slow because if we juiced up the block space supply like it would turn into salon and then crash.
And so these ethos of like constraining growth while we are in a hyper growing environment like constraining growth is probably pretty okay like yo we're going to be fine we're still going to grow. So so Kirk I want to we touch on it a little bit but I want to just like formally go down the vault rabbit hole. Let's start from the very beginning like what is vault and how have you applied all these principles that we've talked about so far in the podcast to building vault. Let me quickly run through like three visions of vault the because there was a time when vault was actually going to be a fork of rye that's because I really admire the controller model and the idea was that vault was going to be a rye fork focused on long tail defy asset lending this is a very bull market idea back when you're getting like 20 to 50% rates and fees you know on the hotel defy tokens and thinking that that would be a very you know effective way to do an inflation resistant stablecoin.
With a floating price but targeting the inflation rate return so offering a lower borrow rate than maybe people were already paying for those long tail assets but more return to the users. We ended up moving away from that just because of kind of the complexity of the rye implementation and it's really made to be immutable and just be a wasn't you know the more scalable and modular thoughts that we were looking for wasn't there although I admire the team and the design of it a lot. So we moved away from that to the die like model right with the the PSM and also you know thinking that lending would be up this major component of it directly showing vault through fees.
And the and what I think is the. The bad part about this model is that like you said the magic numbers you know and I had always intended to make it more market based in various ways but as the market conditions have changed I think we've come to understand that it's not necessarily destiny the on chain yields will always be super high you know they won't necessarily always be more than try to fight yields. And while there are those higher yields out there they require you to move significantly farther on the risk curve and so that's what's inspiring me to think about some significant changes versus the current vote V1 so you'll vote V1 is live today just.
And it is a very fail like stablecoin because ultimately we did not issue any vault as direct that issuance as part of the V1 MVP so it's just minted through a PSM. And realizing that having like in the early stage of the project the team it's not desirable for us to manually make yield decisions especially risky yield decisions right that's the exact opposite of what the DeFi project should be doing and the. Goal is to create a what we have realized we need is a feedback mechanism where the vault holders can say you know this is the um when a vault holder says I either want to hold more vault or I want to get out the system needs to take that information and accept that feedback and say okay vault holders are leaving the system so we need to adjust the rates accordingly or we're minting more vault and there's various things you could adjust like you can adjust the actual yield rate of the vault is earning you can also adjust a mint fee you know so like when there's very very high demand to mint you can do like equivalent of an auction right and you're sexually with this yield bearing type of stablecoin so there's thoughts to think about there like when you are expanding the supply how do you do it and efficiently and as fairly as possible because it will be capped at first and then at what point do you judge it safe to expand beyond the guarded launch but the um I'll just kind of sketch through how I'll envision the next step of vault working which is that.
There will be a you know the system will have a concept of let's say first of all. Let's say there's a stablecoin can have both liquid and illiquid backing so for die the liquid backing is USDC the illiquid backing is the loans of die you know so if you borrow die against east make your doubt cannot redeem that instantly unless they do emergency shutdown they have to wait for you to repay they can jack up their rates but maybe you don't care. And so especially if you think that die is going to go further like below peg or like something's happening like there there can be just being able to change the rates alone just not guarantee that those things will be redeemed and so you can categorize it roughly as liquid and illiquid backing and for vault we're thinking the target liquid backing ratio should be determined by a market process you know this is similar to how frax has a collateralization ratio the vault would still be over collateralized you know by PCV but how that was allocated would be based on this liquid or illiquid reserve at first it would be 100% liquid probably and then just with depositing into other decentralized on chain yield venues whether that's offer compound you know a certain menu of them and optimizing the liquid yield rate and so that liquid yield rate would be like the minimum that the vault holders would earn and then you can say a portion of the funds within the protocol could then be available to go into less liquid or riskier yield venues so that could be as simple as like you know in let's say the protocol is 99% backed by you know or let's say the vault protocol has you know 100 dollars of circulating vault and then they have you know 99 dollars and 7 cents of stable coins and 3 cents or and then like 5 cents of ETH you know like just a tiny percent you know 1% of volatile backing right or it could be that tokenized you know you know yield bearing instrument from off chain or it could be a on chain loan like a doubt to doubt loan a border a bond to a doubt let's let's say a 7% fixed rate loan to a Dow that expires in 6 months and the mechanisms by which that those could be added will also have to be designed and I termed that process market governance is like what I like to say for this whole theme and you know things where I think it's very maybe we can talk a little bit about governance token design I think it's very important that governments tokens have skin in the game along with their decision making so you can look at like a lot of governance today we have kind of tragedy I there's a few common classes of problems I'd say one is tragedy of the comments this is what we see with a curve and other VE style emissions tokens where you know I take the best bribe I can get and I vote for that pool and who cares if that is actually good for the underlying dow or revenues I'm just profit maxing for myself and I capture a spread on how much I'm dumping on the other holders versus how much I'm getting bribed you know so that has significant issues then with just token voting it's like majority rules and if you if you feel like you're part of the majority it's like why even bother especially if it's an unpopular decision and people will know what you're voting for and you have some things that are really cool like for example I like a lot like the of insurance module where of a tokens can put skin in the game voluntarily and opt into it to the seeking module and so you can envision things like what if they could stake but like per collateral token and then that set what the debt ceiling was for that collateral and they put skin in the game for that collateral specifically um and so that pattern in general like more gradiated or like smooth decision making where you could stake to like a certain opinion and consequences and rewards associated with that stance um I believe we'll have more effective results so we have sort of the vision of like vault protocol is almost like an abstraction around a compound or ava where holders put in a stablecoin and they don't really care what underlying stablecoin it's backed by it's kind of abstracted away and the governance token holders borrow those funds and deploy them into yield strategies and they can be liquidated right if they lose capital and there's some sort of a uh a market based system and then there's interplay and that's why I talk about symmetry where the demand from the governor's token holders to go and deploy in certain yield strategies is you know they'll want to go and pursue the best risk adjusted return or as the vault holders will express their requirements as far as how much they need to be paid to keep their deposits in the system you know they'll have this floating curve and hopefully it can all come together symmetrically to offer the um why not hopefully but rather through significant hard work and ongoing effort will come together to um get a fully symmetric stablecoin system that can support a wide variety of different types of like yield activities more than just like I would call onchain repo you know over collateralized secured lending but also have other um types of yield instruments and things yeah the concept of a work token comes to mind and this was a term I remember being thrown around in 2017 about many many uh many many 2017 ice uh I guess I see O tokens yeah I see O tokens I think uh the auger's token was the the first one I heard this classified as a work token where um if you a lot of people just like buy these tokens and like if they buy the right ones and it goes up in price and then they're like yay uh but like the concept of a work token is that you do put it somewhere in the right box and if you put it in the right box then you get the right you get a reward if you put it in the right box and you have to determine what the right box is and so auger as a as a prediction market there would be like an auger market spun up around like the super bowl right and team A would win the super bowl and team B would lose the super bowl and then all the auger people all the auger token holders would come and they would put their rep their REP tokens rep for reputation and they would put it on the side of like team A won the super bowl and then they would collect a small fee from uh the gamblers who were gambling in that market and the gambling would be denominated in like die or eat or something so there'd be a fee and then that fee would be shared by all the rep holders that uh that stakes their rep on the outcome end of a particular event now there's many many many different marketplaces uh and so like rep was utilized uh the rep token was utilized across all these different marketplaces so it's not like every single person was voting on every single marketplace but you would go to the the ideas that you would go to the auger marketplace and then you would just like like stake your rep tokens that you have in the markets that you know what the outcome was and then you would get a small fee uh and like this was a way to get a decentralized oracle onto the system sadly auger never really took off but it made the token holders go do work and it was kind of like governance over the system like auger auger governance says that it like team A won the super bowl and then the token holders would go in and like actually move their assets and the value of their assets uh into this direct box and they would be compensated as a proportion of the amount of capital that they put at stake there and so like if they put if they put the thing in the tokens in the wrong box they would get penalized they would get slashed uh and so if you're on if you're if everyone at 99% of people said team A won but you put it in team B you lose your tokens uh so there's risk there if you choose the wrong side now maybe listeners are like well why would anyone choose team B is obvious that team A won well then we start to get into the more gray area types of prediction markets where the market is actually confused uh and so like there's perhaps something where uh like the outcome of something is is not totally certain and so we need to come to like what what what what does the wisdom of a crowd think uh like uh i can't really think of an example off the top of my head but you could totally exemply think of a an outcome where like it's a kind of up for interpretation like if we're doing the sports metaphor it's like all right was it like everyone just looked at the film was that was that the football players foot over the line or not and like everyone's looking at the film and like everyone's debate like it is over the line it's not over the line it is over the line and then wrote token holders are gonna have to go and vote like is it was his foot on the line or not uh and then maybe like 75% of people say yes it's on the line 25% of people say no it's not on the line uh and then the 25% of people get slashed and the 75% of people get the rewards and then i also get the rewards of the of the are rep tokens that was slashed so you're rewarding all the people for being right and the the reason why i want to go down this rant is rewarding the people for getting it right is this control theory mechanism that we've been talking about where the market info it like has this input and it uses it to balance out the actual inputs of the system uh and so if you're talking about like the vault governance token like uh staking it's it's like yes i believe in this market like this is not going to get rug the yields here are good i'm going to stake my capital here and then the vault system naturally increases the debt ceiling the ability to mint uh and deposit capital into this one particular vault that sounds like a self regulating marketplace regulating low governance overhead stablecoin yield bearing stablecoin marketplace uh am i my own track here you're absolutely on track okay cool uh so but how on earth maybe this is uh going down a different rebel hole but how on earth do you have uh do you find like 8% yield right now uh to combat inflation on defi and that is the realization we've ultimately come to is that it is not my place to decide whether there is appropriate your risk adjusted return at that yield and as we do do diligence into defi yields today in general we conclude that they are mispriced as far as risk you know most defi yields are not enough to justify the the the risk the yield is not enough to justify the risk that is actually present in the system and even well regarded safety five projects have a lot of governance risks or things that could potentially go wrong with them uh and so there's a lot of care and concern that thought that needs to go into um like composability is huge but you have to be careful you're not just composing risks uh and so the that is the central reasoning behind our need to I think move to a floating rate system with the feedback is you know realizing that for me to say vault will always have 8 and a half percent yield um is a dangerous dangerous thing that could lead to the system blowing up and being destroyed under certain conditions and what we'd rather say is that you know in the early stage the team will begin white listing you know certain yield venues on a basis of most secure first you know like existing well regarded defi things and in the meantime be designing these mechanisms by which a decentralized process can onboard more yield venues and we want to you know keep the scale of the system reasonably small like it is now while all these systems get ironed out and then once they're well in place and have been working in production we can scale it up more uh and there'll be a parallel effort I think to look into real world assets and also um not just like purely real world but maybe like what we could call like hybrid um on chain off chain things like um you know you look at maple finance right is an interesting example where it's kind of like quote uncollateralized loans into these market making firms which should be scary to people uh in light of the recent three AC kind of stuff but you know they've they've said everything's fine and I you know not trying to throw shade at them but it definitely is a little spooky to not necessarily know what all of these books of these people are um and so you can envision like maybe a middle ground that's one step more decentralized like there's a special purpose legal vehicle that corresponds to a single borrowing pool right and it has very strict rules about what kind of things to be done with the funds and so I'm interested in both learning about not yeah not saying that vote will internalize in house all of these things too like there's lots of projects going on and I've been learning about the the efforts of other real world asset or um also like on chain native lending or credit market kind of projects and so I think it'll be very important over the next like month or two to um and I think there's oh here's what I should really put it I would really encourage listeners to just look at the fact that there's conversion evolution happening among a lot of stable coin issuers today and if you go look under the hood at what maker Dallas planning and what fractures planning and when I look into my own head of what I'm planning there's a lot of the same things going on of stable coin issuers realizing that you know there's only so much demand for liquidity and on-chain repo markets just to leverage up against east right and you need to be able to do more nuanced type of lending activities whether that's like a long term debt against east like I'm sure there's a lot of people who would like to have a one year long bond on their state East collateral right like that might be a different kind of a deal than I could get liquidated at any time so there's like room for more sophisticated lending markets um and so I'm excited to see what develops there that we can integrate with and also to what extent we need to build things ourselves uh but we really did realize it vaultly like if you're a defi protocol and you're integrating with another protocol their code is your code you know like you need to have read every line um not just on your own but like pair program security reviewed with their team every single line of code uh and you need to do that again every time they have a governance change of any kind and so that's the kind of that's the truth right like that's the type of diligence that ought to be done in systems that's handling you know tens or hundreds of millions of dollars of capital or more and again that's one reason that we're starting small uh you know there's any new project has limited capacity uh and we have to be careful and quality over quantity for integration so we've been doing a lot of deep dives into all of the existing projects and yeah I've had a lot of fun I took oiler protocol for a spin for the first time yesterday um trying to I had my nose to the grindstone for so long on vault it's nice to look around and see what else has been built and exists today so these new yeah oiler protocol and interest protocol are the new on-chain what I would call repo style markets you secured lending the interest me a lot uh of course there's the classics of avant compound uh and then there's the sort of avant compounds style real world asset things like tin lake goldfinch maple finance um so learning more about that whole landscape and where we can fit in but I think that vault will both have its own internal mechanisms and integrate with other platforms uh and i you know maker dad was the same way right where they're looking to build their own internal real world asset stuff they also have D3M's into Ava other markets and so these kind of connections I think will become very robust but they have to be taken their time with and built very carefully well Kirk I definitely appreciate your perspective in emphasizing uh the conservative nature as we build out a brand new financial system for the whole entire world some conservatism and slow moving uh is uh perhaps the right five especially as we are coming down off of a bull market where things only move very very quickly um Kirk if if people want to just learn more about vaults and just follow you and and your other thoughts that you have where should they go yeah um so to learn more about vault you can visit us at vaultprotocol.
io and you'll also find links there to our discord uh and you can find me on twitter or on discord and also on telegram anywhere you like is one true Kirk um you can also uh you know me at Kirk at vaultprotocol.io um yeah always happy to chat about any DeFi concepts and um just answer questions not limited to vault but and also to to learn from others because to me the most limiting part of the whole like pandemic period was just being cooped up in a little box I got out to my first ever crypto conference for East End of Caught and I think that taking getting out aside of our you know crypto Twitter is a bubble and even within DeFi there's little bubbles right and so it's good to go outside that bubble and so I'm working on that a little bit um trying to learn more about like L2 stuff to a vault launched on arbitrum uh recently and I'm working on understanding a little bit more about the security and decentralization like uptime concerns with L2s and how that relates to lending um lots of interesting stuff well Kirk it sounds like you're ever coming in an expert in every single facet of crypto so uh I'm glad that uh I got introduced to you this way by doing the podcast and I'm gonna keep it eye on on what you're up to and and where your brain goes and I think we'll we'll reconvene on the podcast at the later date and time as well thank you Dave but I really appreciate getting the chance to speak with you and um apologies for the connectivity issues on my end um we're gonna have to unfortunately grab my house internet has its limitations well I think we can edit all that out in post so no worries Kirk uh thanks thanks for coming on my man I appreciate it thank you hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend joining our daily newsletter podcasts and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for air drops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me any things and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation