Last Week of June, 2022
------ 📣JUNO | Crypto Friendly Banking https://juno.finance/bankless
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🚀ROCKET POOL | ETH STAKING https://bankless.cc/RocketPool
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦁BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
🌴MAKER DAO | DECENTRALIZED LENDING https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
🔐LEDGER | SECURE STAKING https://bankless.cc/Ledger
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 5:10 Markets 5:15 BTC Price 5:35 ETH Price 6:55 ETH BTC Ratio 7:05 Crypto Market Cap 7:50 FED WATCH 8:00 Who’s to Blame For Inflation? https://ritholtz.com/2022/06/inflation-blame-15/ 11:58 How’d We Get Here? Dan from Pantera https://panteracapital.com/blockchain-letter/the-feds-twin-policy-errors/ 15:10 WSJ: Rising Interest Rates Will Crush the Federal Budget https://www.wsj.com/articles/high-interest-rates-will-crush-the-federal-budget-inflation-debt-spending-costs-recession-economy-11656535631
20:00 3AC Meldown Continued 20:22 Crypto Hedge Fund Three Arrows Ordered by Court to Liquidate https://www.wsj.com/articles/crypto-fund-three-arrows-ordered-to-liquidate-by-court-11656506404 23:55 Voyager $660M Unsecured Loan https://decrypt.co/103892/voyager-digital-issues-three-arrows-capital-default-notice 29:49 Three Arrows Capital Liquidation Ordered in British Virgin Island https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/06/29/three-arrows-capital-liquidation-ordered-in-british-virgin-isles-report/ 29:55 Su Zhu’s Yacht https://twitter.com/AutismCapital/status/1540001243795542018 31:25 Vitalik Subtweet
33:19 BlockFi 33:22 Where it Started https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/06/16/blockfi-liquidated-three-arrows-capital-report/ 35:25 FTX Seeks to Acquire BlockFi https://www.theblock.co/post/154929/ftx-blockfi-deal-sources 35:30 New Morgan Creek Bid https://blockworks.co/blockfi-has-a-new-bidder-in-morgan-creek-report-says/ 40:15 BlockFi Is Pursuing Plans to Go Public https://www.coindesk.com/business/2021/07/22/blockfi-is-pursuing-plans-to-go-public-even-as-regulators-close-in/ https://www.theblock.co/post/155069/ftx-walked-away-from-celsius-deal 42:15 4 Big Takeaways https://www.theblock.co/post/154681/a-leaked-investor-call-revealed-morgan-creeks-bid-for-blockfi-here-are-four-more-big-takeaways-from-the-call
43:30 Grayscale Sueing the SEC 40:35 SEC Rejects Grayscale’s Spot Bitcoin ETF Application https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2022/06/30/sec-rejects-grayscales-spot-bitcoin-etf-application/ 45:35 Michael Sonnenshein Didn’t Like That https://twitter.com/Sonnenshein/status/1542311510055292928 45:45 Grayscale Sues SEC https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2022/06/30/2471737/0/en/Grayscale-Investments-Initiates-Lawsuit-Against-the-SEC.html
52:10 NEWS 52:30 MakerDAO 52:42 Controversial MakerDAO Governance Vote https://twitter.com/labsGFX/thread/1541488156909912065 https://vote.makerdao.com/polling/QmWYajMq#vote-breakdown 54:22 Post-vote Thread From Hasu https://twitter.com/hasufl/status/1542196610775629824 57:03 Lido Voters Reject Growth Limit For ETH2 https://thedefiant.io/lido-rejects-self-limiting/ 57:25 Hasu Co-authored a Proposal for Lido stETH Governance https://twitter.com/hasufl/status/1535275167177490438 57:30 Proposal https://research.lido.fi/t/ldo-steth-dual-governance/2382 59:20 Arbitrum Odyssey 1:00:25 Odyssey Paused! https://twitter.com/arbitrum/thread/1542159105946787840 1:01:15 Dune Analytics Data https://dune.com/springzhang/arbitrum-odyssey-event-tracking 1:03:39 Optimism’s TVL Doubles https://thedefiant.io/optimism-layer-2s-surge https://l2beat.com/ 1:05:00 Merge Watch 1:05:10 Sepolia on July 6th https://twitter.com/sassal0x/status/1540352501605490689
1:05:30 NFTs 1:05:35 NFTs Down Down Down https://dune.com/hildobby/NFTs 1:06:00 ENS.Vision https://www.ens.vision/market https://dune.com/makoto/ens
1:06:45 BITCOIN Michael Saylor’s MicroStrategy $10M Purchase https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/06/29/michael-saylors-microstrategy-purchased-another-10m-of-bitcoin-over-past-two-months
1:09:19 REGULATION China Covid Bankrun Stoppage https://twitter.com/NeerajKA/status/1541397028089073664
1:11:58 MISC Horizon Bridge Hack $100M https://twitter.com/harmonyprotocol/status/1540110924400324608 North Korea https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/06/29/north-korean-hacking-group-behind-100m-horizon-bridge-hack-report/
1:13:10 RAISES Digital Wallet Maker Dynamic Raises $7.5M a16z https://thedefiant.io/dynamic-wallet-fundraise/
1:14:08 Jobs https://pallet.xyz/list/bankless/jobs
1:16:30 Community Questions 1:16:52 L2 vs Cross L1 Bridging Risk https://twitter.com/miner89r/status/1542272305627283466 1:20:38 Best dApps to Get Started https://twitter.com/kangaman_gus/status/1542179373070970881
1:23:48 TAKES 1:23:51 Why CeFi is breaking https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1542284015796895744 1:24:50 Ryan Follow Up https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1542493426687541250 1:25:50 And You’ll Be Happy https://twitter.com/aubreystrobel/status/1541509159455277058 1:26:34 Internet Security https://twitter.com/kobigurk/status/1539140832615440385 1:27:22 Ethereum Rollup vs. Cosmos https://twitter.com/bkiepuszewski/status/1541065105634385922
1:28:55 What David’s Bullish On 1:30:09 What Ryan’s Bullish On https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1542504457140707341
1:35:20 MEME of the Week https://twitter.com/jackniewold/status/1539939621848727555
1:38:20 Disclaimers
1:38:43 Moment of Zen https://twitter.com/functi0nZer0/status/1542571158905786368
----- Not financial or tax advice. https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
DeFi markets performed flawlessly, transparent, on-chain. It all worked. We did the same liquidations that the CFI lenders did, except DeFi didn't screw anyone over. It actually performed exactly as it was supposed to, it's because our regulations are based in smart contracts. So the SEC and other regulators could view DeFi as part of the solution here. Hey, Bankless Nation, happy Friday morning. And happy fourth week of June. This is the last week of June. We got a lot to cover here, David. I'm fresh back from last week. I did get COVID last week. I wouldn't have any tests and fun, but also got COVID.
So I'm a little bit under the weather, so I'll try to meet the coughs, David. But how you doing, man? Your new place looks great. Yeah, thanks, man. Doesn't the brick look pretty good? I got some big plans for what's going on behind me in the future. Yeah, what do you think in some NFTs? Got a little bit of NFTs, but more than that, more than that, Bankless Studio. The plans for Bankless Studio is underway, more on that later in the show. All right, we'll say that to the T's at the end, but we got some hot things to cover, some big things to cover. I came back and I feel like I'm, you know, I left kind of shaking my head a little bit, and I came back and I'm just like, still shaking my head, like, what a mess.
Last week was a complete mess again. I think the theme of the episode today, they were all up today, is Crypto Contagion. Once again, it's continuing to propagate. But we've got a few stories where we're going to chase down. What's the first one, David? Yeah, we're going to recap the dust that is settling around the three-hours capital meltdown. We've done this a few times before already, and the dust continues to settle. We were finally starting to get some clarity, although there's still much more clarity needed. So we're going to go through all of what we is beginning to shake out as the final part of the story of three-hours capital.
And then that bleeds right into the story of BlockFi, again, the same stories that we've been covering. But because three-hours capital was related to BlockFi, we got to cover the settling of the BlockFi issue as well. BlockFi, where it was previously raising at basically a $5 billion valuation about a year ago, is now being valued between $25 million. Those are some differences between those numbers. That's down bad. But then that bleeds right into the third big story of the week, which is that racecale is suing the SEC. And all of these stories are related to each other, one just flows right into the other, which brings us back to the theme of this whole entire market, which is contagion, contagion, contagion.
And it really, Ryan, all kind of comes down to the GBTC discount. And so we're going to walk the viewers, the listeners through, how all of these things are tied together, how one rogue venture fund that everyone thought was Chad's, was connected to this GBTC-gayscale trust, which is an inferior product as a result of SEC regulation. Whose fault is the bear market? Well, that's a lot of people's fault. But we can definitely name some names. And so we're going to cover all those stories. All right, we're going to be naming names for you. Is that what you want? In the bear market, guys, for us to talk about things that people did that were just straight up dumb?
Because that's what we're going to do in today's episode. I think we have to camp on that to learn from our mistakes, hopefully. Also, wanted to tell you about our friends at Juno. Juno is a crypto bank, OK? But it's not like all the other banks in that it has remained solvent. And actually, this is kind of a bank account that I think of as DeFi's best friend, because they are so crypto native and so defy native. David, what kind of things does Juno provide in a bank account? Juno, I think pretty much has the world record for the fastest connection between your checking account and an Ethereum layer too.
So Juno, it's like your new financial services, crypto enabled financial services. You can get a checking account with Juno. And you can go from your checking account to Polygon, Arbitrum, Optimism. And then they've also are working on their stark net and ZK syncing integrations as well. So that's already mind-blowing. Checking account to layer two in seconds. You can also swap your money for crypto assets, with zero fees. We love that. And you can also, in your on Juno, a checking account, get 6% on your USDC, or 3% on E3, or 3% on BTC. And so the crypto enabled checking account for the future of the world, the address writes itself.
Yeah, absolutely. And you may think, hey, why are the bankless guys so many go open a bank account? But we're literally telling you to go do that, because this bank account is so crypto native and crypto enabled. And look, you're never going to get rid of your bank account. There's always going to be a place for the banks. But this is what a Neo bank really looks like. It's completely connected to the crypto world. And there's no borders. You have seamless transition between both. So no, you guys probably want to get started. You can head on over to the link in the show notes. And when you do, there is a $10 back reward on your first crypto deposit.
And also $100, when you set up a direct deposit, because once again, you can actually get paid in crypto through Juno as a service too. So go check that out. Juno.finance, slash bankless. All right, David, let's get on the markets report. So what are we looking at with Bitcoin price this week? We're down and it looks like, yeah, it's one of those weeks. Like, yeah, it's down every single week, isn't it? Start of the week at $20,500. We are currently at $19,000. There's a few dollars above $19,000, down to 7% on the week. Oof. That does not feel good to be below $20K. That's definitely bare market territory.
It's getting chilly down here in the cold. How about ETH? What are we looking at on the seven day here? Yeah, ETH started the week at $1,100. We are currently at $1,026, down 6.7% on the week. Oof. Flirtin' with that triple digit. I saw triple digits this morning. Yeah, we got a little bit of that. I saw it 999.99. I was like, wow, that's a number. That sucks. That's a bad number, huh? ETH. Not for buying. How deep is the cut here? How deep are you going? Oh, god. You want to make some calls? I mean, I think we're going to have plenty of three digit buying opportunities. Maybe not plenty, but there will be numerous buying opportunities.
There were three times, I remember being able to buy $80 ETH in 2018 to 2020. This is the second time that I've seen triple digit ETH. So count them, like two times. There you go, guys. It's look, if you're bullish on the space as we are, and if you're bullish on ETH and some of these other assets as we are, this is an incredible opportunity. I'm not saying that we're going to go up overnight, but I am saying that probably over the next weeks to months, maybe years, I don't know. We'll probably be one of the few triple buying ETH opportunities. If not the last one, we ever see. But who knows?
I mean, quote me on that later, after I'm right, don't quote me on that. I'm trying to bear for it. Forget I said that during the bear market. To Bitcoin, the ratio, what are we looking at this week, David? It's basically flat. We're at 0.054. That's where we were last week, so no significant change. Not going down, though. And total crypto market cap, we down to? We're down on that one. Yeah, we are at a clean $900 billion in crypto market cap, down $50 billion in the last week. $50 billion in crypto market cap used to be noise. That's not noise anymore. We lose $50 billion in the market cap.
That's what is that? That's two and a half percent. Do you know, it's still funny, though, less than a trillion dollars. No, it's $2.35, that's five percent. But less than a trillion dollars, right? It's like, you know, the dot-com boom got to like three trillion in the big dot-com boom. And if you do like inflation adjusted, that's more like 10 trillion. So like, you know, crypto did what? Two trillion, three trillion. It's market cycle. It's market cycle. Not that big compared to like the internet or the dot-com boom. Oh, three trillion. Yeah, exactly. Now we're back under a trillion dollars.
But let's set some context here because, David, I know we're going to do a lot of macro episodes. And I think it's worth talking about macro for a minute. Our friend, Kyla, this week mentioned in her newsletter, a meeting that happened at the ECB, the European Central Bankers, where all of the central bankers got together, and they had a big conversation. And essentially, as Kyla says, they were like, wow, the entire economic regime is shifting from blow inflation to whatever this is. Whatever this is is definitely high inflation, new paradigm. And Jerome Powell is actually quoted as saying, we understand better how little we understand about inflation.
What? This is what Jerome Powell says. And it's kind of head smacking, right? Because you're just like, you have one job, Jerome Powell. And that is to like look at the historical context for this thing. He said that out loud. I'm pretty sure he did, David. And so your job is to literally understand what inflation is. This should have caught no one by surprise. In fact, there's a lot of things that the Fed could be doing. That's not to say, though, David, that the Fed and Powell are the only ones to blame here, OK? Sometimes all of the blame going around for inflation. People are like, oh, it's Trump.
People are like, oh, it's Biden. They'd be like, oh, it's the war, Russia, and Ukraine, it's Putin's fault. Everyone wants to blame someone. And the reality is yes to all of the above. It's all of their fault. There's a lot of collective fault. This was a post that I read this week that lists 15 things that inflation can be blamed on and justifiable reasons for each. Number one, COVID, number two, Congress, number three, President Biden, the CARES Act one, number four, President Trump and the CARES Act one and two, number five, consumers who overspent, number six, consumers who shifted to goods, as part of COVID, number seven, the Russian inflation of Ukraine, number eight, just in time delivery, supply chains, number nine, Fed monetary policy, number 10, wages and unemployment insurance, number 11, home shortages, number 12, semi-conductors, automobiles, price go up, number 13 corporate, profit seeking, number 14, tax cuts and infrastructure, number 15 author of this post, even added crypto.
Why is it our fault? A little bit funny. They just said a lot of people made a lot of money on crypto and then they bought things in crypto and drove up the prices of other things. Yeah, but I would say. I would say about the equities market too. There was more money made in the equities market than crypto. I don't feel that blame at all. I'll take one 15th of the blame, I guess, whatever. But the point here is the broader point is it's not any one thing, David. It's like a whole bunch of things that are causing where we are right now with inflation. And it seems like the central bankers are still not quite sure what to do with it all.
Right, right. I would summarize between all of those things. It really boils down to globalization because globalization made a pandemic global very, very quickly. It also is responsible for our supply chains, our very fragile supply chains. And then also a Russian invasion of Ukraine that also has global impacts, just because we have a global network. So we're super global. So I think like five to seven of those things could fall under the globalization category. And I think also five to seven of those things could fall under the fiscal irresponsibility category. My printing category. Money printing, payments for infrastructure that is probably, there's a bunch of corruption in the United States, no surprise there.
So between globalization and fiscal irresponsibility, I think is two thirds of the blame, I would say, for all these things. And then you got a war. Well, that's globalization, though, right? Because then the war impacts supply chains, impacts oil, blah, blah, blah. Sure, sure. So there's the bumper sticker. Globalization, money printing, and war caused, caused inflation. And, too, don't have that. And crypto. And those crypto bros. Forget about crypto. It's Bitcoin's fault. Yeah. Well, you know what, I read a great, probably the best thing, article I read this week was actually a letter from Dan at Pantera and we've had Dan on the podcast in the past.
He's really good from a macro perspective in particular. And he was talking about the big blame. Maybe he would say like more like two thirds itself is actually on Fed policy. So he would, he would wait what you just said. And he would probably agree. But I think he would wait things more towards Fed policy decisions, at least exacerbating all of the inflation that we were about to have. And two things, the Fed did wrong. Powell, for some reason, and the Fed and the central bankers around the world screwed this up in a big way. Number one, they kept rates low for too long. We should have been raising rates a year ago, David.
That was clear. That was clear inflation. Right? It's a transitory inflation. So it's number one. That's happening at times in the past. But like that's one issue. But the second issue is even bigger. They've been manipulating the bond market, OK? First time in history, this has happened. If you look at some of these graphs from the Pantera report, you can see, look what the Fed bought. $3.1 trillion in bonds, buying a whole bunch of mortgages and Dan makes the argument that when you have an interest rate of 2.3% in the US, and when home prices are raising or increasing by 20% year over year, the Fed is basically daring you not to buy a house.
In fact, don't just buy one house. Buy two or three if you can, because it's all cheap money that the Fed is effectively giving you. So by manipulating the bond market and stepping in on the housing side of things and the market side of things, the Fed just pumped this thing up way beyond levels that we've ever seen, probably historically. And so we've got a lot of over-evaluation to get through. And Dan actually says he doesn't think that this is going to be fixed until a few things happen. One, housing inflation goes negative, either that or unemployment rate goes up by 2%, so we're in a recession that, possibly.
Or core CPI gets closer to 2.5%. Core CPI is not total CPI, it's CPI less energy and food. And it's about 6% in the US. Or the Fed has unwound the majority of all of the mortgage manipulation that it's been doing. And an important thing to take a look at is, this is kind of a US problem, all right? The average core inflation across our peers, Japan is 0.8%, France is 3.2%, Canada 5.7%, Germany 3.8%, the average 3.4%, the US is 6%. No coincidence that we also printed the most amount of money for stimulus checks. We also gave out the most amount in unemployment and stimulus checks, and I'm surprised, we also have the highest inflation.
100%. So this has to make its way through the system. And you have to wonder to you, this is something that you picked out this week. The Wall Street Journal is talking about this in a different way than they've been talking about it. What are we looking at here? Yeah, they give the headline, rising interest rates will crush the federal budget. And like the conversation here is that if we raise interest rates and send our economy into a recession, not only is that a recession for the American economy, our own government can't pay its own debts. And so like the federal government is too indebted to suffer high interest rates.
But also if we simultaneously, that's a problem. And then if we send our own economy into a recession, where's all the tax money going to come from to pay off the debts? So like in 2022, you know how much, like the IRS, the Treasury is gonna receive in capital gains tax in 2022? Like nothing, basically, no capital gains. It's going basically to zero. So like they're not making any money on capital gains, they're gonna be able to make less money on just like other things, because overall when the economy is down, the economy is the thing that they tax. And so if we have a recession in, like they have no inflows to pay their own debts, meanwhile the interest rates are going up because that's what we're doing to fight inflation.
And so the Wall Street Journal, and it's important to note that the Wall Street Journal is saying this, because like it's an extension of, like the some parts of the world are just extensions of the state. There's arguments that like the tech sector is just a surveillance arm of the state. The media sector is just like a media arm of the state. If you want to put this into your conspiracy hats on, the Wall Street Journal is very close to the state, right? And so like when the Wall Street Journal is saying like, hey, we need to defect from the policy of the Federal Reserve and say, hey, if you guys keep on raising rates, you're gonna kill everything.
It's important to note like where this source is. This is just like one person's opinion in the Wall Street Journal, but I mean, it was published by the Wall Street Journal. Yeah, and you know what, this is the, this is the thing I think we want to find out. And I want to find out, Dave, and we have a lot of macro people coming in the podcast in the next couple of weeks, right? Like Lynn Alden's coming back. Who else, Luke? Luke Grommon? Yeah. Grommon, we also have Travis Klingon as well. Like, we have like so many different macro commentators who are gonna give us the question. I want to find out is, okay, so you have people like, Dan from Penterra saying, the Fed's got to raise rates, like four to five percent.
And the fact that they're talking about like half a percent or you know, 0.75 percent raise is laughable because they're already like months behind. And so they need to raise it to like four or five percent. Oh, is you have that? And then you have a conflicting kind of conversation going on saying, the Fed can't raise rates or else the US won't be able to pay its interest payments any longer. So how does they skit result? Is a big outstanding question for me that I want to ask some of these macro brains on bankless. So, bankless listeners, stay tuned for that. Lot of conversation coming up. The answer to that question, probably is the answer that the whole entire market hinges upon right now.
Like whether we are in a bear market or a bull market or like a recession, depression or revitalization, depends on the answer to that question, I would say. Totally great. Guys, we got some more stuff coming up. Three years capital. We're dead. I've got some things to say, Ryan. David's going to go through the full story. And he knows that he's been doing his research here. Also, BlockFi lent three years capital, $1 billion. Oh, BlockFi is suffering in this as well. This is the crash of the crypto banks. And lastly, we're going to talk about the grayscale assuming the SEC what that's all about.
We'll get back to these topics when we come back. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Rocket pool is your decentralized Ethereum staking protocol. You can stake your eth in Rocket pool and get our eth in return, allowing you to stake your eth and use it in DeFi at the same time. You can get 4% on your eth by staking it with Rocket pool, but you can get even more by running a node. Rocket pool is the only staking provider that allows anyone to permissionlessly join their network of validating Ethereum nodes. Setting up your Rocket pool node is easier than running a node solo and you only need 16 eth to get started.
You get an extra 15% staking commission on the pooled eth that uses your node to stake. You'll also get RPL token rewards on top. So if your bullish eth staking, you can boost your yield by adding your node to the decentralized Rocket pool network, which currently has over 1,000 independent node operators. It's yield farming, but with Ethereum nodes. You can get started at Rocket pool.net and you can also join the Rocket pool community in their discord. You can find me hanging out there sometimes in the chat. So I'll see you there. MakerDow is the OG DeFi protocol. The first DeFi protocol to ever exist even before we called it DeFi, MakerDow produces die.
The industry's most battle tested and resilience tablecoin. Using Maker, you don't need to sell your collateral if you need liquidity. Instead, you can spin up a Maker Vault and use your collateral to mince die directly. With Maker, the power to mince new money is in your hands. And there's something new in the MakerDow ecosystem. Every time a new MakerDow is opened, the owner can claim that po-out, which contributes funds to one tree planted, an organization with ongoing global reforestation efforts. Creating a world where digital participation and the health of our environment can live side by side.
Soon, Maker will be present on all chains and layers to bringing the biggest and best DeFi credit facility to everywhere there is DeFi. So follow Maker on Twitter at MakerDow and learn from the oldest and most resilient down existence. All right, guys, we are back and to start with the crypto contagion. The three arrows capital melt down. The story continues into this week. Here is a story from the Wall Street Journal. Crypto hedge fund, three arrows capital ordered by court to liquidate. David's gonna go through all of the details, but just a little bit of background on this. Three arrows capital is absolutely massive during the bull run.
10 to 18 billion, maybe assets under management. It's still kind of unclear, but a whole lot of money and a whole lot of prestige through this group. And now there's a complete meltdown. David, what's the story here? Like what take us through the timeline of what happened? Now that we have seen the fallout from some of this, we get to start to peer inside the black box that is three arrows capital. And all of this really started and this behavior started at the very beginning of the bull market. For those that were here around the beginning of the bull market, the Grayscale GBTC trust, the GBTC is one to one towards Bitcoin, but not, there's no redemption window.
And this is because we cannot have a Bitcoin ETF because of the SEC, they had to make a trust out of things. And so you could come to the Grayscale GBTC trust, you could deposit one Bitcoin, you would be issued one GBTC share, and then six to 12 months later, you were allowed to liquidate that share on the open market. This is for credit investors only. As the bull market got underway and institutions did not have Coinbase accounts or FTX accounts, they used the Grayscale trust to gain access to Bitcoin. And since they're not one to one redeemable, since there's not a credit window, the Grayscale GBTC trust could have a premium.
I think the premium got as large as like 148% as in like one Bitcoin was, one GBTC share was worth 1.48 times a Bitcoin, when it should trade at par, but it doesn't because it's not need to. So it's a nice arbitrage, it's a 48% arbitrage right there. If you can take the six months ill-equated window. So here's what three rows capital would do. They went out and borrowed as much Bitcoin as possible from the market to turn it into GBTC shares to milk this premium. They would borrow Bitcoin from some source and they would put it into Grayscale six months later they would have this like 48% like arbitrage and that number would fluctuate.
Because the thing isn't even would never go away, right? It was so persistent for so long that that's what people thought. But then even the most average person will, like yeah, if there's a premium, people are going to milk it and through those capital were the people milking it. The thing is Ryan, they weren't selling their GBTC to capture it on premium, they were giving it to, they were using it as other collateral. So it starts off by three rows capital borrowing as much Bitcoin as possible, as much Bitcoin as the market would lend to them from any lender facility possible, which is where this contagion starts.
And so they put all their BTC that they are borrowing into the Grayscale GBTC trust to get GBTC back. And then they start using that GBTC as collateral to borrow stablecoins. So they're now borrowing stablecoins based on their GBTC. And they started to invest in order to try and get the alpha, try and get the premium to start to pay their, some of their loans back for borrowing Bitcoin in the first place. They invest bigly into Terra, we all know what happens there. They bought a bunch of vested AVACs tokens. Well, I mean, AVACs is down bad and they're probably still investing anyways. And they started to take more and more capital from wherever they could get it because they also have like loan and interest payments to get back, right?
They get a $660 million unsecured loan from Voyager, which is a crypto exchange, not a lending facility, but somehow they convince Voyager to give them a $660 million loan, unsecured loan. They get a billion dollar loan from BlockFi over- over-clateralized. I believe the numbers were some combination of Bitcoin and also GPTC shares. We'll talk about that later on. So they get a billion dollar loan from BlockFi with a 30% over-clateralization. So like a $1.3 billion in side of BlockFi, they get a $1 billion loan and they go and speculate on the market with that. They get caught up in the staked-eath trade, like trading the merge, thinking that the merge is gonna happen, like everyone's gonna buy into Staked-Eath, but then instead of the merge happening, the markets go down bad because of Fed risks and like their staked-Eath, instead of being worth one-Eath, turns into being worth 0.
96-Eath and they can't redeem that because that's how Staked-Eath works in the first place. And so also like, there's a legal stuff happening too. And so the Singapore Central Bank just gave three arrows, Accentures, Accentures, I don't know what that means actually, three arrows capital for alleged misleading and false disclosures and there's evidence for this going around on Crypto Twitter and in throughout the markets. There's evidence that they falsified records, two lenders in order to access more capital. So the fraud, basically, they committed fraud so that their balance sheet could look healthier so they could get more and more loans out from other people.
And there's also public reports that three arrows capital allowed other trading firms to use their account on crypto exchanges to trade through their account, right? Three arrows capital, they had billions of dollars, they could negotiate with crypto exchanges to like, hey, charge us less fees on your exchange because we're gonna put a bunch of volume there and we don't wanna pay those fees and the crypto exchanges are like, yes, totally, you guys put all this volume through our exchange. We'll totally charge you less fees. And then three arrows capital, let other people put money into their account to trade on their account on crypto exchanges so that these third parties could access less fees as well.
You know what that is, Ryan? That is an unlicensed prime brokerage with Brank Secrecy Act and wire fraud. That these are criminal cases. And then there's also representation that they, there's also evidence that they represented OTC desks. They had relationships with other entities and other OTC desks that they didn't in order to like, presume some legitimacy to other OTC desks. So they start off with this like very normal, like I'll just borrow Bitcoin to get this GBTC tray premium. They never sell, they never manage their risks. They instead of, instead of closing their risks, they just open up more loans on those risks.
Then they somehow like give this crypto Twitter brand about themselves that they're huge chads who make a ton of money. And so people will lend them even more money. They took money in from DeFi Treasuries, who like DeFi Treasuries, like they raise $50 million. They're sitting on it. They don't need to go get yield during the market. So somehow Thuros Capital Commencement just give us your treasury and we will give you like this percentage. Meanwhile, they probably like stick it into something like Terra and get 20%. And then that thing goes to zero. So like a bunch of DeFi Treasuries are down bad down to zero because they trusted Thuros Capital to give them the yield.
And so like not only did they like, they are the one of the sources of contagion because they borrowed from Voyager. They borrowed from BlockFi. If they didn't borrow from Celsius, they are one degree away from borrowing from Celsius. Well, what's crazy about this is like, this is the point retail, it starts the lending to Thuros Capital without knowing it. So if you're putting funds into BlockFi, right? And you're generating some sort of yield, you were effectively lending to Thuros Capital. Now this is an overcladderized loan, right? Of course, so people think that's super safe. But we'll talk about why that wasn't so safe with GDPC a little bit later.
But I think the important point here is, it wasn't just institution to institution, this became a retail phenomenon when you're depositing funds into these crypto banks like a Blockfire Celsius, you're actually giving some funds to Sue and the Thuros Capital team. And that truth is rampant throughout the industry, right? Like Voyager, a crypto exchange, not a lending desk. Customers would come and deposit their money into Voyager Exchange to do normal exchange stuff and Voyager lent that money out to Thuros Capital. So Thuros Capital is at the center of the contagion. They are the contagion, Ryan.
They had their tentacles in every single entity that would ever lend the money, either overcladderized or undercladderized. And so it almost doesn't matter where retail entered the industry, money flowed into Thuros Capital because they took every single lending opportunity that they could and maxed that account out. That is crazy. Does this blow you a lot? It feels like they just made all of the new mistakes in like one market cycle. They just did them all. It's like, check the box. I'll think that the GDPC trade goes on forever. I'll get into Tara and see if I'll do this East Staking trade, expecting some sort of timing on the other side of this.
I'll do the Altlayer One trade with Avalanche and all of these other things. They're just checking the boxes of all of the mistakes a newb would make to lose their money during the bull market. Right. And they made such a staggering amount of money during the upside of the market. Part of that was on the backs of if they borrowed it and then it works in bull markets. And then they lost it all in the bear market. And so I can't remember where I heard this quote from, but the venture firms or hedge funds that do extremely well in one cycle aren't going to be around it for the second cycle. Because if they were levered up on the way up, they're also levered on the way down and they don't make it the second time around.
So having two strong performance on the upswing means you're getting liquidated on the downswing. That's definitely what happened. You want to see the cherry on top of this whole entire saga around. Yeah. Give me the suzu has a $50 million mega yacht as being seized. I can't remember what the name of this yacht is, but it's something like internet meme. This is a triple-decker yacht that suzu put a down payment on. Somewhere in like, I think it's the British Virgin Idolins or somewhere who has also made a court order to liquidate three hours capital. That's where three hours capital I believe is domiciled.
Anyways, yeah. So this is something that suzu still has. Is this like $50 million? Yeah, it has a down payment on, which is absolutely crazy. Absolutely crazy, absolutely brutal. And it sounds like the authorities are stepping in. Nation States, British Virgin Islands are ordering the liquidation. So the collectors are coming probably for that yacht as well. I would imagine all the assets are going to get liquidated. This is not a matter of like three hours capital going under and like we're not seeing three hours capital again. This isn't happening yet. This is still in speculation phase. But this is a criminal enterprise.
This is a criminal enterprise. Well, Kyle Davies and suzu are in my mind. I am not a lawyer. I do not have insight to these things. Do not listen to me. They are criminals on the run. Yeah, it definitely is starting to seem that way. And unfortunately, it's cost the crypto market a lot in this cycle, including retail. This is a tweet from Vitalik. What are we looking at? This is not him way in on the whole controversy. But I think he's maybe being a little subble here. He's being a little snarky. A little snarky, for good reason. Vitalik says that there are far more honorable ways to burn $50 million to impress people than buying a super yacht.
They burned way more than $50 million by the way. Like becoming a giggle and grants matching partner. Here is the matching partners for our current round. So if you want to look around in the space and look, who is still capitalized and capitalized to the point of donating to public goods, it's the people in this graphic. We got unlock protocol. We got the graph. We got radical. We got Aragon Project, Zora, Figment, ZK Validers, Cello, Urine Finance, ENS Domains, Protocol Labs, Chainlink. Sorry if I'm not writing all these polygons there. These are the people that are so well capitalized that they are still donating money to public goods.
Nice job, guys. Yeah, there we go. And you know what? This is just, I hope this is part of the cleansing process of getting rid of the excess of greed and leverage and margin that was going on during the bull market. David and I aren't celebrating the downfall of three hours capital. At least I'm not, maybe David is. A little bit. No, he's not, but like, it's, this had to end. This whole spirit of like DGN, short-term, traders dominating, like this had to end. And we had to get back to the fundamentals of what we're actually building in this industry. And so I feel like from that perspective, this is the hard medicine, the crypto industry, and everyone in the crypto industry has to swallow because the stuff we were doing in the cycle, and by we, I don't mean bankless listeners necessarily, but collectively the industry was not sustainable, was not healthy, and had to stop at some point.
And so better now than later, right? And I think this is a healthy thing. Well, let's talk a little bit about BlockFi because the contagion has spread to BlockFi. You said they had a one of the contagion. Yeah, they had a $1 billion loan outstanding to three hours capital, but it was collateralized by $1.3 billion or something to that effect. How does this even happen? How does the contagion spread when you've got a collateralized loan to BlockFi, David? How does this spread into BlockFi's potential bankruptcy or insolvency right now is what it's looking like? Well, so $1.3 of over-collateralized loan for a $1 billion loan, that's sure.
But crypto prices went down by 60 or 70%. And through this capital didn't have any money to top up their loan. So that $1.3 billion in collateral was probably below the $1 billion loan that BlockFi gave to Eros Capital. Well, my understanding is BlockFi, there was like, there was like a $1 billion something alone, right? That BlockFi had with Eros Capital, they would lending them. And they had, you know, call it $1.3 billion over-collateralizedation of that. A whole chunk of that was Bitcoin. And that could be collateralized as prices go down. BlockFi is going, sorry, that could be liquidated.
As prices go down, BlockFi is going to liquidate that entire position. And my understanding is they did. But another chunk of that of the $1.3 billion that was supposed to collateralize this loan was actually actually GDPC. And that is not liquid in the same way that Bitcoin is liquid, right? And so my understanding is that's really where BlockFi has gotten hung up on the GDPC collateral that was not worth what it seemed like it was worth in the market. And that's the part that really, you know, punched him and knocked him out. I mean, there's other things that BlockFi was probably doing from a risk perspective, but this was certainly a big one.
And has led what to BlockFi, it's... There's a fire so. Purchase talk? Yeah, what's going on there? Yeah, there is a tug of war. There is a race to acquire BlockFi. And so this is a race between Morgan Creek Digital, which already has a bunch of BlockFi equity to begin with, and then also FTX. So FTX gave BlockFi, I think, a $200 million like Credit Revolving Door, like Facility, I think, a couple of weeks ago. 250 million, yeah, credit agreement. And so like that allows for users to withdraw their money. As far as I know, users can still withdraw their money. And that comes off of like a credit agreement with FTX.
And I think what that means is that FTX has the ability to purchase FTX shares from the equity holders at, like, basically from what BlockFi was previously valued at, basically free, like at this current valuation, BlockFi is valued at $25 to $50 million, which is an extremely low number. It's basically wiping them out. It's basically you're taking all of the equity holders of BlockFi, whether that's the founders or employees or previous investors like Morgan Creek, you're wiping them out. But what FTX was doing here is placing its debt to BlockFi as more junior to depositor debt. So that means you're kind of like protecting depositors.
So if you're a regular user and you had deposited funds into BlockFi, you want to make sure you're going to get that money out. And you want to get that money out before an liquidation event, FTX gets its money out. And so that was the benefit that this was providing. And I actually think it's, it's lottable that BlockFi is trying to look out for its users. Maybe they're also trying to just prevent, like, criminal charges or something like this, right? So maybe it's not all kind of moralism here. Maybe they're actually trying to protect themselves here. But depositors getting protected in this scenario is a good thing.
It's not clear that that's what's happening in Celsius. It seems like depositors are probably going to take some haircut when the Celsius dust settles. And so that at least was good about FTX. But then Morgan Creek is like, why should BlockFi only be worth $25 million? Like this is somebody coming in and basically exalping BlockFi when they're down and they're trying to raise some emergency capital to value the company at a higher amount and provide that $250 million injection. I think that valuation, if Morgan Creek deal goes through something like $500 million. So far higher than the FTX deal.
Right. But like you said, that puts the equity holders current and new equity holders at BlockFi above depositors. So this is not only a tug of war between FTX and Morgan Creek. This is a tug of war of who gets, who gets like bailed out first, I guess is maybe the moralism. I don't know all of the details of the Morgan Creek and what position it puts depositors in. I think Morgan Creek is trying to also protect depositors. That's not clear to me. But yeah, I guess there's a lot of dust distilled settle in the BlockFi case. But in good news, I actually had some funds. I know that I confessed two weeks ago that I had some funds on the Celsius.
Again, Ryan likes to try everything. Ryan tried some centralized lending lenders, including Celsius, Nexo, a few others. Just a small amount of funds, right? Because you got to keep an eye on those crypto banks out there. You got to keep an eye on it. You're not looking good for my Celsius deposit, all right? But I was actually able to withdraw for BlockFi in the last few days. And so that's at least a good sign. That's a stress test of some sort. They're not freezing accounts yet. So it doesn't seem to be as bad a position as Celsius is. I have a BlockFi credit card too. I hope that's going to be OK.
What do you think, David? Well, if it's a credit card, it's probably going to be fine. There's a really good article out of the block that really summarized these whole things, saying, for big takeaways, from all of it, from a leaked investor call, kind of recapping what we've already said, BlockFi is currently being valued at less than $500 million. If the FTX deal goes through significantly less than $500 million, we're talking about $25 to $50 million. If the Morgan Creek deal goes through, maybe it's around that give or take. Morgan Creek Digital says BlockFi is the loan to three hours. Capital is $1 billion.
And the collateral on three hours capital loan was $2.30 Bitcoin and $1.30 GBTC. During the call, yes, FTX, the FTX deal gives the firm the option to buy BlockFi, but not if Morgan Creek can get their first. And then, of course, obviously, more layoffs, maybe in the works at BlockFi. It's kind of what I would expect. But, Ryan, I would like to take this opportunity to go backwards in time about one year to June, 2021, when BlockFi was on the verge of going public. Right when the SEC came into BlockFi and told them that they can no longer accept new customer deposits in their existing lending products.
And BlockFi fought them on this. SEC wanted them to close their existing lending product products. BlockFi fought them on this and said, hey, we just won't accept any new inbound, but current customers get to be grandfathered in. That's the settlement of that whole thing. Can I just... BlockFi then... Can we just say, like, is the SEC saving the day here? I mean, like... Not doing that. They weren't wrong about this, were they? They weren't wrong. No, not at all. And so, at the same time, BlockFi wanted to go public. And so it was going to raise $500 million on their Series E, which would put them at $4.
7 billion valuation. $4.7 billion valuation a year ago. 12 months. One year ago. Fast forward to today. BlockFi is on the... On the market for $25 to $50 million in valuation. Oof. Yeah. That's down bad. And it's unfortunate that retail has been involved. And again, it's people depositing into BlockFi. You see the crypto contagion. BlockFi issues some loans to 3 years capital. 3 years capital goes bust. And eventually that flows back to retail, right? This is the problem. I think this is a great contrast point with... DeFi did quite well during all of this. A lot of lending going on in DeFi. And when crypto goes down 70% to 90%, right?
A lot of the CFi lenders are caught, like, insolvent. And yet DeFi unwinded very gracefully with a highly efficient market. We're going to get more to a take on that in a little bit, but it's quite the contrast point. The juxtaposition is just so clear. Exactly. It's so clear. And as a quick fun little side quest before we go on to the next thing, the SEC thing, there was an article out of the block that states that FTX was interested in making a deal with Celsius, kind of in the same way that they're making a deal with BlockFi. But then they looked at Celsius's balance sheet and they're like, oh, no, no way.
We're out of here. So declined buying Celsius once they took a look at their balance sheet, which is not a good sign. Allegedly, according to a source, Celsius has a $2 billion hole in their balance sheet. So no one would like to take responsibility of that one. David, did you see that meme? It was like a person reaching down to someone's hand and they're in the water and looking like they're drowning. It says FTX and it's like, I'll help you. And Celsius is the person drowning in water. Then the person goes down under and it's only the hand. And the FTX caption is like, oh, you're too deep, see you later.
Sorry. It's kind of like, it's kind of what's happening. I mean, Celsius is in a far worse place than BlockFi was. And so we're kind of seeing the quality of these crypto banks right now, right? We have some that are still left standing. Nexo is still left standing. Juno, what you talked about earlier, they're still left standing. Coinbase is fine. They're going to be totally fine. CZ Binance, they're actually like buying things. FTX, they're buying things right now too. FTX is all of the great position right now. They're in a great position anyway. So OK, what does the GDBC thing have to do with all of this?
We've mentioned it a few times. And grayscale is actually suing the SEC. They are the creators of the GDBC product. Can you explain what's going on here for us, David? Right. And so the GDBC discount is something like 30 to 35% at the moment. As in, the GBTC is worth only 70% of what one Bitcoin is worth. And a lot of GDBC is a product that you can get in your retirement account, right? Retail can buy in their retirement account, because we don't have an official ETF in the US. We have to use products like GDBC, which is a trust. Right. And it's like almost inarguably an inferior product. It's a post to represent one Bitcoin.
Yet it's only representing 70% of one Bitcoin. And there was like a six month illiquidity lockup period for accredited investors between when they deposit Bitcoin and then they redeem their GBTC. So like a lot of capital lockup, a lot of capital efficiency. During a time where crypto markets go down like 75% on average, there is a discount, a 30% discount on GBTC and illiquidity lockup phase. When people need the liquidity the most, this trust model sucks it all dry. And it's no fault of grayscale at all. It's the SEC's fault because the SEC won't let them turn this into an ETF. And so the SEC rejected grayscale's bought Bitcoin ETF application, which from all the commentators like Jake Stravinsky and others that I'm aware of, say like there's literally no reason why the SEC should deny this.
This is totally above board. They should accept this. But for some reason, people just got the feeling that the SEC was going to deny it. And so the day that the SEC said that they are denied the grayscale conversion of the trust to an ETF. Michael Sondinstein tweets out, we're filing, we filed a lawsuit against the SEC dollar sign GBTC, ticker sign GBTC, $15,000 likes, which is a big, big number. And so they also released this PR report that talks about the details and I select there. Grayscale investment initiates a lawsuit against the SEC. We're going to court. Crypto, it's taking the SEC to court.
And everyone I think in my opinion should be behind this conversion of the trust into an ETF because it would immediately restore 30% of capital that should be there in the GBTC token. And it would allow a one-to-one redemption window between GBTC and Bitcoin. So many people would get much more liquidity. So many people would become much more capitalized in a time and a place in the market where people need it the most. So statement out of a grayscale says, the SEC is failing to apply consistent treatment to similar investment vehicles and is thereby acting arbitrarily and capriciously in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act in Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
There is a compelling and common sense argument here and we look forward to resolving this matter productively and expeditiously says, grayscale. Take him to court, grayscale. Go do it. Look indirectly, the SEC cost retail a lot of money because of this market inefficiency. Now I'm not saying like Susu's actions and block fives risk actions caused all of this, but I am saying that there is an inefficiency in GBTC and the Bitcoin spot price that doesn't actually need to be there and wouldn't be there if the SEC just allowed grayscale to convert it to an ETF. And so it's just kind of an example of like sometimes regulators in the SEC are helpful to the industry, right?
In a way it's like, okay, we have a centralized lending provider. We need some regulation. We need some windows into that. We need some auditing. We need some insight into that, okay? So there should be a role for regulators in looking at Celsius in depth and looking at block fi in depth and making sure that they're on the up and up, okay? That's one thing that we could benefit from. By the same token, we also want from the SEC an ETF for retail. So why can't you get rid of help us with the things we need to help with as a crypto industry? But then also give us the things that will protect retail that we need, like an ETF.
Give us a safe space to play. And of course, like this kind of silence on DeFi from regulators and almost hostility towards DeFi, an undue hostility towards DeFi and it's kind of a TBD. We don't know if we're gonna allow that or not, right? When DeFi is part of the answer to this, right? DeFi markets performed flawlessly, transparent on chain, it all worked. We did the same liquidations that the CFI lenders did except DeFi didn't screw anyone over. It actually performed exactly as it was supposed to is because our regulations are based in smart contracts. So the SEC and other regulators could view DeFi as part of the solution here.
And they're not quite there yet. I'm hopeful it gets resolved, David, but like I just feel like anything with regulators is kind of a double-edged sort because we want you guys here to help us with the scams and the clear things that we need help with where retail is getting screwed over. But we don't want you to say the whole thing is off limits and hamper the entire industry and try to shut it down and get it out of the US because part of the reason we're doing these things is because we are routing around dumb regulation that doesn't work for the people. That's my rant on the SEC tape. Love it.
So going back to the market section where we talked about like the 15 different sources of inflation, like here's a source, here's like the fault four sources for the contagious in the crypto industry. We had like irresponsible centralized lenders, both unsecured and secured. We had Theros Capital taking advantage of that. We had an inferior product out of grayscale with the GBTC trust, again, to no fault of their own. And an SEC unwilling to work with this industry to provide clarity or allow this industry to move forward in a way that protected retail investors and allowed these markets to do efficient and orderly clearing of liquidations.
Like the SEC, which is their mandate, got in the way of that. So like this contagion of crypto, the reason why it's so big, is like three or four different interwoven reasons. Like some degeneracy culture, like the same reasons of like defy people, like talk crap about CFI stuff is like black box, human folly, like you can't manage stuff, so you let the code do it. And then because of that inferior stuff, you have like Theros Capital who like exploits every single possible like way to get money out of it. Like yeah. Congratulations, that is the bear market of the last six months. That's a full context.
We're all on the hook for it. It's a lot of blame to be shared across all groups doing this. David, we got more to cover man. We're going to talk a bit more about maker's defy governance, the biggest maker proposal in history. Most controversial. Also an update on Arbitram Odyssey. This is their latest update and what's going on there. Guys, we'll be right back. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. The layer two era is upon us. Ethereum's layer two ecosystem is growing every day and we need layer two bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live in layer two life.
Across is the fastest, cheapest and most secure cross chain bridge with a cross you don't have to worry about high fees or long way times assets are bridge and available for use almost instantaneously. Across is bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens between layer two's and Ethereum. Across is critical ecosystem infrastructure and across V2 has just launched. Their new version focuses on higher capital efficiency, layer two to layer two transfers and a brand new chain with Polygon, all while prioritizing high security and low fees. You can be a part of a cross's story by joining their discord and using across for all of your layer two transferring needs.
So go to across.to to quickly and securely bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Polygon, Arbitrum or Boba Networks. There is a brand new staking feature in the Ledger Live app today. We all like staking the assets that we're bullish on and now you can stake seven different coins inside the Ledger Live app. Cosmos, Polkadot, Tron, Algarine, Tezos, Solana and of course Ethereum with Ledger Live, you can take money from your bank account by your most bullish crypto asset and stake that asset to its network all inside the Ledger Live app. Through a partnership with Figma, Ledger also lets you choose which validator you want to stake your assets with and Ledger is running its own validating nodes, offering a convenient way to participate in network validation and it even comes with slashing insurance.
Ledger Live is truly becoming the battle station for the bankless world. So go download Ledger Live. If you have a Ledger already, you probably already have it and get started securely staking your crypto assets. And we are back. Long time bankless listeners will know that MakerDow holds a very close place in my heart. I think it's a very cool project. There was the most contentious, most controversial governance proposal over MakerDow just happened. The highest amount of all MKR showed up to vote. And it was neck and neck up until the very end. Here's GFX Labs putting everything into a nice summary.
30% of all token supply voted, which is crazy to think because like so many MKR are scattered around like all of DeFi, 30% of them are showed up. Voting was neck and neck up until the last two hours. The vote was to add a new core unit to oversee the Dow's onboarding of collateral assets and also form a specific framework for growing the protocol. This core unit also came with a hefty price tag. Basically, the framework was a little bit more of kind of like a constitution, a constitution-ish about what MakerDow needs to do, where it needs to go, the direction it needs to go in. And it was a pretty big turn off of its current path.
And so unlike most governance votes, two distinct sides developed, those who wanted to see more organization and control-voted yes, which is like the Trad5 VC real-world assets camp. And then the nose, which are like the kind of the core MakerDow community, opposed the price tag and didn't really like the specific direction and wanted to continue with Rune, the founder of MakerDow's end game plan. That's the name of a post that he wrote. And so after the dust settled, it ended up being that the Trad5 and VCs did not make the proposal. They got outvoted by about 15%. So the MakerDow decided to go with a continued end game plan.
But the idea here is that there's a tug of war going on over MakerDow and no one thinks that this is over. And so after this, Hazu actually put a very interesting thread together about his vision for the future of MakerDow. Hazu was on the yes side of these things, like the Trad5 and VCs side of things. And I know Trad5 and VCs are generally heard as a negative term, like abstaining your opinions on that word in this particular context because these are crypto VCs, have opinions. Hazu puts a tweet out that says, I just proposed a series of simple governing changes to MakerDow that address many problems that exist in governance today.
This includes a general lack of vision and strategy as well as low accountability for Makerholders. Hazu has been thinking a ton about Dow governance lately. And so he puts these like this proposal into place that basically like streamlines governance because there are so many things that's going on with MakerDow that everyone has to vote on all the things. And there's no just like, there's no centralization of decision making. Basically, like it's really taken the Dow at heart. So like he puts these vision strategy tactics and implementation categories together and promotes like three different ideas that just streamlines all of these things.
And so if you are into the world of Dow governance and like on the frontier of that, pay attention to what Hazu wrote. We're gonna get on the podcast soon. But basically, there's a very controversial MakerDow vote, pulling MakerDow into two different directions. And while this new direction did lose, I don't think it's gonna be the last time we hear from this. Well, I do think it's healthy, honestly. I think the two directions are kind of healthy, right? So it sounds like VC investors are just like, hey, we want more accountability. And our method for solving that is like, let's install a core unit, a new management team effectively, some more centralization, right?
And here's the community saying, no, everything's good. We have a plan. Let's keep going in the direction we're going. And this is a healthy tug of war, I think, because like the other reality is everyone who owns the MakerToken does have another vote beyond this governance vote. And that vote is just to sell their MKR tokens if they no longer believe in the direction of the project. And so any investor in MKR tokens can do that at any time. And anyway, it's good to see. I do think sometimes communities bear on the other side of the whole decentralization debate too much. And they're like, no structure.
All structure is bad. All leadership is bad. Any kind of token mechanic that increases the value of the token is bad. And that is obviously not the right choice either, right? It's like, I would love to see a bit more investor action in something like the UniToken, for example. Like, I would love to see it there. Anyway, let's turn on that fee switch. Yeah, exactly. I think it's all healthy and makes us to see how this all plays out. But it's playing out transparently in real time. Here's another governance vote from Lido. What's going on here, David? Yeah, this is not the end of the Dow governance saga, also related to Hazu.
There was a proposal from the Lido Dow to itself to say, hey, should we cap ourselves? Should we limit how much ethers in Lido? Because ethers is like dangerously close to passing a threshold that would allow Lido to have undue control over the entire Ethereum network. I wouldn't actually be surprised if that limit has already been passed. So Lido submitted a governance proposal to itself saying, hey, should we like cap ourselves? Should we prevent more ethers from being deposited so we don't grow too big? And surprise surprise, 99.81% of Lido said, no, we should not cap ourselves. Which makes sense.
Lido is not going to say, I think that we should make less money because our product is too good. They're not going to say that. And so Hazu, again, co-authored another proposal for Lido-staked eth governance, which I think is really innovative. And I think it is a model that we can take out for other doubts. And so the idea here is that Lido governance will stay Lido governance, but staked ethholder's Ryan, will get the ability to veto any Lido Dow proposal. So they don't like staked ethholders don't get to say, yes, they don't get to submit new proposals. But if a new proposal is submitted by Lido Dow governance and the Lido Dow governance says yes, then staked ethholders can come in and say, no.
That's really cool. That's really cool. That's really, really cool. Yeah, so like they say to the whole holders, get one tool, which is, no, you get to veto. Vita power. Which, right. And so I think that's great. I think that's really cool. That's really smart. And that's the kind of evolution, which I'm most excited about in kind of Dow governance, there's new ideas, like Hossu's idea here and to see how that emerges. No surprise though that Lido would vote to self-limit, right? In fact, the original proposal, I mean, I don't think anyone was calling for a self-limit. Even the Taluk was not talking about a self-limit.
He was talking about race fees after you have a certain percentage of market share. So even the original proposal seemed kind of like constructed in a very binary way. That was a little bit weird. But of course, token holders are going to vote in their own self-interest. David, let's talk about some layer two stuff too. There are two stuff. Odyssey from Arbitrum. What is Odyssey? And what happened with it this week? Right, so Arbitrum Odyssey is basically this journey around the Arbitrum ecosystem where you would go and do some things and you would get some NFTs. The first week of the Odyssey was Bridge Week.
So you Bridge onto Arbitrum and you would get an NFTs if you did that. And so they were going to go from Bridge Week into App Week, which is going to be the remainder of the Odyssey, like Weeks 2 through 8. But as soon as App Week got started, like Arbitrum got congested. Because so many people came onto Arbitrum during Bridge Week. As soon as I started doing App Week stuff, they got congested. And that's because a lot of the applications that was in this first week was like heavy computation stuff. There was a lot of, what was the app that was being used? It was GMX, which are perps and leverage, which just requires a ton of computation.
And so like simple St. Transures on Arbitrum, that's not going to clog the network. But as soon as you do computationally heavy stuff, that will start to clog the network. And so they are putting the Odyssey on pause until they release Nitro. And once they get Nitro back, once they get Nitro online, and they get the Arbitrum layer 2 updated to this new update, then they're going to resume the Odyssey, and the Odyssey shall continue. I asked some of the Arbitrum folks, give us some numbers on what the scalability of Nitro. And they said, a nice easy, easy to interpret number of seven Ethereum.
As soon as the Nitro update is on online, Arbitrum is going to be about seven Ethereum's. And like all of the layer 2's, these updates are just the beginning. And so going to where Arbitrum is now, which I think is two to three Ethereum's, going up to seven Ethereum's, nice big jump. But then there's also, again, EIP4488, that increases the scale as well. And so there's also some crazy numbers that we have. There's a Dune Analytics page, which I'll have you pull up, Ryan, which just showed the sheer magnitude of people that went on to Arbitrum during week one, 250,000 new bridges, at least bridging addresses, that happened on Arbitrum.
So 250,000 addresses went on to Arbitrum in seven days. And that wasn't congested at all, just, again, because simple transfers are totally fine. So can I ask you, David, did they just pause the Odyssey itself, right? They didn't pause the network or anything like this? Oh, God, no, no, no. Network is doing just fine. The congestion's not even here at this point. They just paused their marketing program, basically, because they were like, oh, too much too soon, we wanted to play Nitro first, which is going to 7x their network. So that's the reason why the pause. Why are people doing this for worthless NFTs, David?
I mean, OK, so the simple take is that if you get all the NFTs, you'll get all the air drops. So these are like participation NFTs, right? Participation NFTs. It's so obvious that I'm kind of skeptical on it. It's like, yeah, like Arbitrum, obviously, we're going to give you NFTs. You can be on a list of people who got the NFTs. It seems so obvious. Dude, eth is obvious right now at the merge. I think that's what's totally going to happen. Again, none of this is, we don't know anything from the Arbitrum team about any of this. But what's really nice about this is if they're giving out NFTs for real things that people are doing, they get a pretty clean white list of actual individuals doing real things in the network.
Well, not if you don't have to farm it, though. Do people just farming NFTs instead? Right, farming NFTs, that's a concept. I bet they'll find a way around that. But it gives a nice base of additional data to differentiate for a future air job, which it's got to be happening, man. It's got to be happening. Well, Arbitrum token is coming for sure. I've been trying to figure this out, Ryan. What is the Arbitrum token going to be called? ARB, or ARBI, or something else? ARB? ARB? ARB is kind of a cool name. Like, ARBs, it makes me feel like ARBs. It's like ARBs. ARB is cool, though, because it's like an ARbitrosh.
You're right. ARB, what is the optimism? OP, it's just OP, right? Yeah, which is, I think, super hot. Could be AR. AR? ARB is OP. That's okay. God. I don't know. We'll have to see. I think I do think optimism won the name debate, or the name fight, but. OP is nice. That's just my take. OP is pretty hot. Okay, speaking of both of you. They're going up, too. Trading activity surges on optimism's layer two as total-locked and value doubles. David, this is a layer two beat. Look at this optimism now, number two, ahead of dy dx in terms of total-locked value on the roll-up. The number two roll-up behind Arbitrosh, which has $1.
96 billion. It seems like the recent OP air drop has helped in terms of getting more value locked inside of this platform. Also impressive that this is happening during a bear market. So, roll-ups continuing to do well, even despite a bear market. Any other takes here? I wonder if the minus 11% flowing out of dy dx is a reaction to their dy dx chain, or if just people are scared in the bear market, so they're not trading leverage. I don't know. Could be. I'm tempted to say it's kind of noise for now, but that's going to be one to dy dx. No longer going to be on L2-B, David. He's out about that.
Right, yeah, this is going to be L1-B. Yeah, L2-B isn't L1-B, yeah. By the way, guys, we had an episode with Antonio where they talked about earlier this week. They talked about their transition to an app chain for a layer two. You go listen to that episode. I have some thoughts coming out of that episode. I have some thoughts. We'll share them all here, but in the weeks to come, maybe we'll share some of those thoughts. But anyway, great episode. If you want to hear their rationale for doing this. Eat stuff, merge stuff. When merge, David? Well, I still don't know. We still don't know. We still don't know that the July 6th is not when the merge is happening.
That is when they said, pull the test net merge is happening. And so that's coming up. That is the second of three test nets that we must get to to get the actual merge. The second one is happening on July 6th. It's going to be live streamed on Anthony Sisono's daily way, or maybe the East Dakers. It'll just be a whole entire event. So that's on the horizon. That's good. Another dress rehearsal down. David's picking him down though. NFTs have been down pretty bad. If you've looked at the price of your JPEGs lately, but it's not going to give you any comfort, okay? I love all my JPEGs. I don't look at the price.
Yeah, okay, yeah. It's just, David's just here for the images. He's here for the art, okay? So NFTs, USD volume, it's back to like 2021 levels, like early 2021 levels. Right. Down pretty bad. But there is one bright spot in the NFT economy, and that is dot in things. Yeah, that's names, yeah, that's names of them. Outperformers right now, especially the three digit numbers. Some crazy, crazy sales have happened in the last three days. 003.8 got sold for 83.5. Eight, eight, eight, eight. Got sold for 38.5. Zero, zero, three, seven. Got sold for 30.5. 383 got sold for 27.5. Ryan, porno.eth. Got sold for 184.
eth. So ENS names are hot right now. Yeah, hotter than Sam.eth, which only came in at 100.eth. So of course Sam. Porno's got you beat Sam. Sorry. But yeah, look at these numbers, man. May was like the biggest month ever. For ENS. And June looks like it's going to be strong too. So pretty impressive. All the while, Michael Sailor continues to dollar cost average into Bitcoin. In the bear market, he hasn't stopped. It's probably a better time to actually buy the Bitcoin at this point in time. But he just purchased another $10 million of Bitcoin. David, are you getting concerned that like Sailor owns too much Bitcoin at this point?
Like he's got to be close to 1% of the entire Bitcoin supply. OK, 1% is 210,000, and he's got 130,000. He's still got a ways to go for 1%. The only thing I see when I see Michael Sailor buying more Bitcoin is like, dude, you spent all of your ammo at the top. That's not dollar cost averaging. He's just putting in his fuel at this point. Expand your time horizon, the top of what? Not the top of the decade, OK? Just a local top. It's just a local top, my friend. Oh, god. You can't time these things. You've got a dollar cost average. A kind of a useful website. Ryan, you might want to pull this up while I talk about it.
It's Bitcoin Treasuries.net. And so this can just show you people, and the treasuries of people around the world and how much Bitcoin they have and what they bought it out. The cost basis for micro strategy is basically $4 billion. They've taken $4 billion USD and bought it and bought Bitcoin with that, which is currently valued at today's dollars at $2.4 billion. So they have lost $1.5 billion on their Bitcoin trade. They have down 40%. And then you can see how much of the $21 million they have. They have $0.6. Dude, that's not bad. I've been down worse than this. 40% or $1.5 billion. Definitely the former.
All right, I've been down worse than 40%. I do think that I know people are making fun of them now. I do think this trade is ultimately going to pay off really well when you zoom out. And the capital he's getting is basically free. It's a publicly traded company. It's taking these loans at very low Fed interest rates. I know that's not what micro strategy should probably be doing directionally. They're business analytics firm, but it's probably going to pay off for them. I still think this. I just see that $10 million is a drop in the bucket on their $2.5 billion position, which started at $4 billion.
You should have saved your ammo, dude. Oh, yeah. That's what everyone says, right? You can't tie me things in my life. I mean, I'm also. Sailor, I still support buying this to myself, too. Don't get me wrong. Keep buying the dip, Sailor. Maybe you could reverse things for us. David, this is a tweet from Nourage from Coin Center. And just the crypto industry's attention to this. I thought this is an interesting story. Chinese officials are using the COVID health code system to stop a bank run. They turned all would-be withdraws codes red before they could get to the bank, effectively, unpersoning them.
So what was happening in the banking system in China, what's been happening, is rather than suffer a bank run where individual citizens were going to the bank to try to withdraw funds, the banking system would just give them a COVID code, a COVID red code. You are a COVID positive, you cannot leave your house. Exactly, cannot leave the house. And effectively, X communicates you from the social system, but also the financial system. So cutting off your bank access that way in order to prevent a bank run. This, my friends, is very terrifying. This is scary. This is the reason we can't have the nation states in control of the banking system and in control of the money supply.
And with the a bureaucrat's ability to just press a button and eliminate you from the economy, why to stop a bank run? Like, who knows? Who knows what the why will be in the future? Maybe because you have different political persuasions. Maybe you voted a different way. Maybe you've said something publicly on TV. This is very terrifying to me. And I think I am most alarmed that countries in the West are actually embracing similar capabilities. This is what a central bank digital currency, this is actually the power that that gives. They wouldn't even need to deem people as COVID positive. They would just skip that step and just go straight to, like, no, you can't have your money.
There's a quote from this article says, the news about the health codes has gone viral on China's social media platforms. Sooner or later, this sort of thing is going to happen to all of us wake up people one user wrote. National pandemic prevention policy has been reduced to a private weapon, said another. This is the height of expansion of power, ideological decay, and evil influence. Oof, oof. Guys, I'm coming to a CBDC near you. The end of the decade we're only going to have two types of money. There's going to be state surveillance, controlled money, and there's going to be free money. It's all going to be digital, free money.
The only free money available will not be cash anymore. It will just be crypto. So you got crypto and centrally controlled money. And those are the two options. And this is why we need to preserve crypto as an option. You hear that from us every time on bankless. David, there was a bridge hack this week too. We got to cover that real quick. What happened? Yeah, harmony to Ethereum bridge. $100 million was stolen in another bridge hack. I mean, we've been here before. Ryan, you want to know who was behind it? Who? North Korea. North Korea. It was North Korea. Yeah, so once again, North Korea hacked a bridge and now has all the money, does not look good when half of this industry is hacks end up in North Korea's pockets.
Oof. You know, it was interesting in our conversation earlier this week with Matthew Green, how he said he was having conversations with the US national defense. And they were like, hey, how can we come help the crypto industry to prevent hacks from these happening? Because every time North Korea goes and hacks something, they get more funding for their government to go, I don't know what they'll do whatever they do. Nuclear weapons or something like this. So it actually becomes, these hacks actually become a national security risk. Interestingly enough, crazy angle on that. You said layer two, prevent nuclear war.
Is that a fair take? Yeah, it might be a stress statement. It's a stress statement. There's something there. Maybe there's a future article, David Hoffman article. Digital Wallet maker dynamic raises $7.5 million good to see a raise still coming through in the bear market. Anything special about this one? Yeah, this is something that, for those that pay attention on the crypto Twitter, Nick Carter and Castline Ventures raised put money into this round. And Ethereum Wallet that has digital identity features baked into it. And he got absolutely hounded by the Bitcoin community, like the cyber hornets, just because from their culture, you don't touch anything that's not Bitcoin.
And so Nick Carter, the blasphemous, sinning Nick Carter, touched something Ethereum. And now he's being like xx communicated from the cyber hornet culture. Just a small peek into the window of Bitcoin Maximism. Did you read his post? Bitcoin Maximism is dead, his bank rates. No, I haven't, but I feel like I could already know it. Yeah, I think he's over it, man. He's over Bitcoin Maximism, for sure. As am I, as are you. Always have been. Still, even in a bear market, this is an incredible time to get a job in crypto, because crypto is still hiring. There was a lot of money created and raised during the bull market.
And good firms are still hiring. Here are a few firms. I will read them out, read them out, and their job opening. Number one, Alliance style. CTO, Alliance style software engineer, Alliance style, is also looking for an executive assistant. Go check that out. Auto space is looking for a solidity engineer. Abstract Ventures, a front end engineer. Boolean Labs looking for a founder and Web 3 for their Web 3 community analytics platform. And a CEO, that's a big one. Bankless was still looking at Twitter specialist resumes. Blockchain capital wants a research engineer, a swell network, a tech lead.
Go check out all of those roles. There's so many more jobs, boy. So many more. That's the place, bankless.palette.com slash jobs. Guys, we'll be right back. Come back with hot questions from the bankless nation, as well as some hot takes from Twitter. We'll get right back to that. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Arbitrum is an Ethereum layer two scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Some of the coolest new NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home, while DeFi protocols continue to see increased liquidity and usage.
You can now bridge straight into Arbitrum from more than 10 different exchanges, including finance, FTX, QOB and crypto.com. Once on Arbitrum, you'll enjoy fast transactions with cheap fees, allowing you to explore new frontiers of the crypto universe. New to Arbitrum, for a limited time, you can get Arbitrum NFTs designed by the famous artist, Ratwell and Sugoi, for joining the Arbitrum Odyssey. The Odyssey is an eight week long event, where you complete on-chain activities and receive a free NFT as a reward. Find out more by visiting the discord at discord.gg slash Arbitrum. You can also bridge your assets to Arbitrum at bridge.
arbitrum.io and access all of Arbitrum's apps at portal.arbitrum.1. In order to experience DeFi and NFTs, the way it was always meant to be fast, cheap, secure and friction free. The Brave browser is the user first browser for the Web3 internet, with over 60 million monthly active users. And inside the Brave browser, you'll find the Brave wallet. The secure, multi-chain crypto wallet built right into the browser. Web3 is freedom from big tech and Wall Street, more control and better privacy, but there's a weak point in Web3, your crypto wallet. And most crypto wallets are browser extensions which can easily be spoofed, but the Brave wallet is different.
No extensions are required, which gives Brave browser an extra level of security versus other wallets. Brave wallet is your secure passport for the possibilities of Web3 and supports multiple chains including Ethereum and Solana. You can even buy crypto directly inside the wallet with RAM. And of course, you can store, send and swap your crypto assets, manage your NFTs, and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps. So whether you're new to crypto or you're a season pro, it's time to ditch those risky extensions and it's time to switch to the Brave wallet. Download Brave at brave.com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started.
Question time, questions from the nation, a tweet goes out of the bankless Twitter account every single Wednesday and it says, what question do you have for Ryan and David? Let us know, we'll talk about it. Every time I put these agenda together in the mornings, I go and check out all the hot questions and I grab some of the hottest ones that everyone seems to want asked. So we got two of them this week. Dan Scott says, does bridging ether, to a layer two have similar risks as bridging ether to an alternative layer one like Solana or avalanche? Ryan, you want to take this one? Sure, I would say it depends.
It depends on the bridge that you're using. But one benefit, if you're kind of like individuals, one benefit that a roll-up has versus an alternative layer one is it has a trustless, immutable bridge that cannot be destroyed, okay? So it's a bridge that works regardless of any security dependencies on the chain itself, on the layer two itself, right? So if you're picturing kind of bridges in your mind, the other bridges routes around to layer two's and to alternative layer ones, these bridges can be destroyed. These can be like, these can crumble. These can fall if some of the security assumptions on the other chain go by the wayside.
But a roll-up always preserves a bridge where you can always withdraw your funds back to Ethereum. And that is why a roll-up is a roll-up because it doesn't have dependencies that are external to Ethereum for your security. So there's always that bridge, but there are some bridges you can take to these chains that are also like multi-sig and don't have those same security assurances. So you have to be sort of careful and cautious as far as which bridge you're using to transmit your funds onto the layer two. I think there's a decent amount of like semantics confusion that goes around here when we bridge from like one layer one like Ethereum to another layer one like Slon or Avalanche.
There's no actual bridge being built. There's not like something you go across and you transport your ether from one side to the other. You put your ether into one contract on Ethereum and then somebody else on the Slon or Avalanche or other layer one application is looking and observing that contract and say, oh, they submitted some ether here. I will mint them in the IOU on the other side. So it's a little bit more like a teleporter and like you have a central operator teleporting you with an IOU and if the teleporter breaks your IOU on the other side is worthless. With a layer two on Ethereum, there is something like like a canonical bridge, a cryptographic bridge that has much stronger assurances that doesn't actually have to operate on like what is usually a multi-sig.
And so you have just an extra layer of risk removed because the layer two bridges, they don't have to make their own independent blockchain. They are giving up their independence in the name of security and having an actual, like it's still not an actual bridge because at the end of the day, the metaphor breaks down. But you have like a strong cryptographic assurances that the bridge will always be there and if the bridge isn't there, then the whole network's not there. So like Slona can go up and stay up. Ethereum can go up and stay up and that bridge can go down. But on a layer two, if the bridge goes down, the whole network is going down, right?
And so the layer two network on Ethereum cannot stay up while the bridge is down, that doesn't work. So there's a bridge of last resort on the L2s. And so it's less risky because I guess the short answer bridging to a layer two and that is essentially the point. Okay, so here's another question for us, David. What are some of the best dApps that you can recommend to help beginners start living a crypto native life, a bankless life, David, what do you recommend? Yeah, I put some of my favorite sound. First, if you're going to go into the world of the bankless nation, if you're going to go into the metaverse, you need a name.
You need your new metaverse name. And so you've got to go get an EMS name. So just like how you when you sign into Instagram, sign into Twitter, what happened? You make a new handle. When you're going into the metaverse, you need an EMS name. So go get an EMS. Point out somebody got point out, maybe not that one. So once you get your metaverse name, I think the next coolest thing you can do is you can take some of your ether, you can put it into MakerDow, and you can literally mint money. That is the cool thing about crypto. You can mint money. And then you can take that money, like put one ether into MakerDow, like make sure you're measuring the gas fees, put one ether into MakerDow, mint some dye, put that dye on a layer two, and then you've done like some really cool stuff.
And that's what I would say where I would start with. I think that's great. I think that like the path to going bankless is like number one, you have to start taking custody of your own keys, right? So it's the move from an exchange to actually taking custody of your keys, whether you're doing that in a smart contract while it's like an argent or something, a hardware device, like ledger, or for small bits of money, maybe meta-mask, something like that. You have to go through that step. But once you're on the other side of that, I think about still like the money verbs that we've talked about, you know, so often, like what are the things you want to do with your financial life in a typical banking system?
Well, one thing you want to do is like save your money and invest. And I can think of no better investment, my friend, and saving mechanism for the long run. It's going to be volatile in USD and ups and downs. Then something like ETH, okay? And maybe after that, a basket of some other tokens. But you definitely want to have ETH that you don't spend. All right, you also need some ETH for gas, but ETH that you don't spend. So that's like a store of value type use case. And then once you have that payment use case, stable coins are amazing. Dude, I could send money to anyone in the world for like fractions of a penny, okay?
And like it can be any amount of money. This is so freeing and so cool. And it's something that you should learn how to do. Whether you're using USDC or DAI, having some stable coins in your crypto reserves is kind of cool. Then you can use something like pool together, which is like a fun DeFi savings type tool. It's a really interesting starter application in DeFi. Go check that out, pool together. And you can deposit your funds, actually save your money. They have a lot of, it's called the no loss lottery. They have a system that rewards various people based on the pool size. It's really cool to just check it out.
It's a good first app. If you're lending and borrowing, Abe is fantastic. And then trading, of course, like go check out Uniswap. So we got storing value, basic payments, savings, lending and trading. And that's a good place to start, because you just knocked off like five of the different money verbs that you're gonna need for a crypto native bankless life. From there you can do all sorts of other things, but that's where I would start. David, let's get to some takes of the week, man. So here's a take from you, my friend. This is all about C5 versus DeFi. I say, C5 lenders are blowing up specifically due to the properties of centralization.
They're black boxes. You gotta trust them to withdraw your assets and they're subject to human folly, human decision making. Not only now do DeFi lenders have fewer competitors, because like a few of them have blown up, but their competitive edge is now proven and legitimized, C5's fragile, non-sable, DeFi's robust and stable. And so I think it's that last line. DeFi has fewer competitors, because all the C5 things blew up. They blew up because of the properties of centralization in the first place. So now like, not only do they have less competition, but their differentiation is justified and proven out in the market.
And I think that's awesome. I totally agree with you. And you know, I think another lens on this, something I tweeted out is for regulators. And I said that regulators around the world should be watching DeFi protocols closely to congratulate them, all right? Because DeFi provided a fair, orderly and transparent drawdown during the 70 to 90% downturn we've just seen. Well, the C5 peers went bust. You want to regulate crypto. DeFi is crypto regulation. Self-regulation on this tweet said, yeah, it's effectively what a smart contract is. It's regulations written to code. That's what we're doing.
That's the whole point. The EVM is the regulator for DeFi. We are like, that's the whole thing that makes it what it is. Exactly. Smart contracts are simply self-regulating and self-enforcing themselves. And this is where regulators can lend a hand, is maybe they need some smart contract auditors on their team. Maybe they want to spin up some transparency dashboards. This is where DeFi can use your help, not to say that we're getting rid of all DeFi. Anyway, I don't know how many regulators listen to bankless, but that's our message to them. Here's another take, David from Aubrey. What's she saying?
Yeah, Aubrey. The first time we got Aubrey taken here, she goes, S-B-F will own everything and you'll be happy. Why is she saying this? Because S-B-F is like buying up everything. He's like the lender of last resort. He's like trying to buy FDX. They provide a credit window for a bunch of other things. S-B-F and Alameda and all these people that were capitalized during the bull market and had a lot of stables are now looking at some pretty sweet deals right now. I don't think this is a fair tweet, David, because CZ is going to own at least some of this, too. CZ. Not just S-B-F. CZ, too. We're having CZ on the podcast tomorrow, so we're going to ask him about the CZ of Binance, of course, and so forth.
Today for the listeners, actually, it's probably going on right now as you listen to it. Oh, sure. OK, I'm listening to the roll-up. I really like this take. I really like this take. This is a kind of a snarky way that also is really educational as to how optimistic roll-ups work. Kobe Gurcam says, the security of optimistic roll-ups is based on the fact that people will, with great zeal, strive to prove that somebody is wrong on the internet. This is how a fraud-proof works. If you do something fraudulent in an optimistic roll-up, you can get away with it, but the way that security of these optimistic roll-ups work is as soon as somebody is doing something fraudulent, somebody is out there going to prove that.
And so security of optimistic roll-ups, based on the fact that the internet people like to prove that other people are wrong, and if they do, they get rewarded. So that is a little quick lesson in how optimistic roll-ups are secured. Everyone becomes an auditor. That's the model we're moving towards. This is TakeFromBarteck.eth. Being in a Ethereum roll-up is like having the strongest army in the world securing your estate. Becoming Cosmos Chain, you are now protected by your token holders. Unless you use interchange security and upcoming feature, in this case, which case you pay atom holders for protection, I think this is probably background commentary on DYDX's movement from a StarCware roll-up to its own app chain.
And I know you and I commented on this after the show. We have a ton of respect for Antonio as a builder. It's built something phenomenal with DYDX. But it also seems like it's going to be a lot of work for them to spin up everything necessary for a layer one chain. And kind of the analogy to me is like, you want to start a butcher shop. And so you're founding a country in order to do that. I was like, well, why not just park your butcher shop in a country that already exists? Because then you need to spin up your own app. Yeah, military, tax code system, and money system, and monetary policy, and defense network.
It seems like a lot less work. And I think it is. And so this is a comment on that. I do think that there's obviously room for all sorts of chains to spin up. But what they are spinning up is sophisticated nation-state type of economies. And I think that's more difficult to do than some people assume. I think that's exactly right. And I think that is the loss of the takes. Ryan, should we get into what we're excited about? Yeah, what are you excited about? Be bullish on it. Do you see this awesome brick background behind me, Ryan? I do. I do. It's amazing. It looks like you got a ton of room there.
Right. Look at all this space. And my desk isn't in the middle of this space. Let's see if I can zoom out. It starts off as a blank brick background. But it's going to change in the future. And I'm not just talking about me putting up my NFTs on the wall. That's what people are envisioning. I'm sure they're going to change. I'm sure they're envisioning. It's going to change. Bankless Studio is going to become a thing. I got some plans. I got some plans. Live studio for live podcasts. That's what you're talking about, right? This is what this means. Yes. Yeah. I did a show with Julia from Orca, not too long ago.
And we were very awkwardly on the same couch as I interviewed her. And then I looked at the YouTube comments. I was like, well, that needs to change. So this is the change. Bankless Studio. It's going to be awesome there. I'm excited to come up there one time with you. Yeah. You'll do your layer zero. I'll get you on it. No, I was going to say I want to get you on a layer zero. That's my podcast, bro. I know. I got an interview. Who's going to interview you? That's a good question. Anthony Susano interview you for layer zero. It's got to be me. Yeah, that's right. That's right. Ryan, what are you excited about?
I'm excited, I guess, about the overconfidence of bears right now. Here's something I tweeted out. When prices go up too fast, people get dumb. Of course, that's true. But when prices go down too fast, people also get dumb. And I'm seeing a lot of the dumb sentiment now, David. Just this morning, it was cruising around reddit. The amount of threads, this was an R-slash gaming of NFTs with the dumbest idea ever. Haha, crypto bros, get wrecked. You guys suck. Crypto so useless, it's a scam. All of this noise is going on. And detractors and critics are absolutely gleeful. And what they don't know is we've already been through this three or four times.
Exact same people, not the same people necessarily. Exact same sentiment, maybe different set of actors. Crypto is dead. And I think the overconfidence of the bears actually makes me optimistic that we are closing in on a potential bottom, all right? Now, this could still last a very long time. We're still talking months, potentially years. I don't know how long it's going to last. But I'm starting to hear that overconfidence that feels very much and sounds very much like bottom type of talk. And I think it'll persist for a while, but it's actually making me bullish to hear the same patterns that we've seen so many times in crypto start to play out in the sentiment right now.
So just curious, when prices go up too fast, people get dumb. When prices go down too fast, people also get dumb. And what scenario do people not get dumb? I think when there is a sweet spot of sober time, do you know, don't you feel like this in every market? The sweet spot was probably for me for this cycle around was probably like sometime 2020, early 2020. If I summer? Yep, and I think late 2019 into 2020, I feel like we had six months or so, maybe nine months of just the sweet spot, where things were happening, the builders were building, the market sentiment was like rational. So the end of the bear market.
Basically, and that's the sweet spot. And then I start to hate my life again. I hate my life. I hate my life now when things are like irrationally bearish and everyone's like, you're such an idiot. You have a crypto podcast. But then I also hate like the market, I don't know, three months ago, six months ago, when you're like, you know, this terror thing might not be sustainable. And I was like, you loser, you're so dumb. You're heath maxi, like I hate that side of it too. So we only get rest during like this eight month period, I don't know, six to nine month period, maybe in between these two cycles.
And that's when the market is less dumb. I think I talked to how I experience it. I think I talked about this last week with Anthony when you were on your little AI vacation. But like my mom would text me every now and then saying, hey, I met up with like Linda. She said, like, hey, how's Dave doing? Is Dave doing all right during the crypto crash? And like, I've gotten these texts like three times. Like is David okay, like they know I've been in crypto since 2017. I'm like, can you guys please go look at the chart? Please tell him, I'm like, hey, I'm hiring a Bangladesh if they're looking to get a chart.
Well, no, tell those people to go look at the chart. Like either at $1,000 anyways. But just like, yeah, it's just like so frustrating. It's like, they don't really ask if I'm doing okay when ether is about $4,000. I don't hear anything then. Mom, David's mom, don't be concerned about David until ether's like double digit, okay? Then you can start, say that then I might not be okay at that point. I might not be okay. But bankless listener, we think you are going to be okay. This is all going to be okay. Ryan, you said at the end of 2019, start of 2020 was when you felt like most rational and like just the best in the crypto market.
Like that was the era in crypto. And I was thinking about this earlier. That was the era in crypto where all the people that stuck around during the bear market, that's when all the people were like, yo, wait, the bull market, it's on. That's what happens next. Like people that stuck around during the bear market, they identified that the bull market was started in April of 2020. Like we knew this, everyone had the conviction like yes, the bull market's back on. Like it's on baby. And the only way that you were able to know that was if you rode through the bear market. And so the people that rode through the bear market, were able to ride the bull market from Genesis at in like April of 2020, when Ether was $200 to $300, Bitcoin was like $6,000, $7,000.
And then they rode those things like, and then retail figured out that the bull market was on sometime in like middle of 2021. So if you ride through the bear market, you have a one year head start in a bull market that generally only lasts about two years. So like that's your offer. That's your advantage. It's exactly where you want to be. And that is the reason you don't leave during times like this when prices are down. The reason you stay is exactly for that reason. Totally. All right, David, let's get to the meme of the week. So what are we looking at on the screen? I'm seeing a whole bunch of bulls here.
This is a sad bulls, though. This is one of these called the Dungeons and Dragons like disposition charts or whatever. So you got like lawful good, neutral good, chaotic good, you know, lawful evil, neutral evil, chaotic evil. So for the listeners, podcasts, I'm sorry, this is going to be kind of hard to explain. And the lawful good corner, we got good old USDC being the lawful good. Like everyone likes USC stable coins. They're all stable coins. Everything on stable coin, yeah. And the neutral good, top center, and we got die. It's neutral, it's $1 good. And then we also have chaotic good for fracks.
The algorithmic 85% backed algorithmic stable coin that has admirably held its peg, nothing wrong there. Coming up in the neutral camp, we got the lawful neutral of the actual US dollar, the fiat in your bank account, the cash in your wallet. In the true neutral corner, we have the curved three pool, the tether, die, USEC, curved three pool. And the bull, every single one of these has a bull that's colored, the color of the stable coin. And this bull happens to be both green for USEC, excuse me, blue for USEC, green for tether, and yellow for die. So true neutral, it's the curved three pool. Chaotic neutral, we got MIM.
Didn't that one go to zero? I don't know. I don't know, I don't know, I don't know. And then in the evil row, we got the lawful either, which is ETH evil, which is tether, it's lawful because it's actually $1 redeemable for $1, but it's evil because it's a black box. We got the neutral evil, which is USDD, the tera fork on Tron that somehow is maintaining its peg. And then we also have Chaotic evil in the bottom right corner, which is UST, tera USD. With also, if you notice Ryan, Mike Novigrat's wolf tattoo on the arm. That's crazy man. I definitely agree with the bottom row, I think. And particularly the Chaotic evil being USD, but also this Tron stable coin, man.
Like, this gotta be next to go. Yeah, like Justin Sun, I can't believe the audacity of this. I'm gonna spin up a stable coin a month before UST, and it's gonna be elbow-backed, same kind of mechanism as Looney USD. And like, that is not okay. And if you're in that, like, be very, very careful. Yeah, it's a game of trouble. I'm not listening to Bankless though. Yeah, that's probably true. I saw a post that talks about how Justin Sun had plenty of capital to backstop the USDDD, D-Pegging, and D-Pegged down to 94 cents. But he wanted it to D-Peg more, so he could buy it at like a cheaper discount.
So dumb. This is terrible. Justin Sun is a central banker. No, thank you. Give me, give me, give me Bitcoin. Guys, of course, none of this has been financial advice. It never is. Crypto is risky, so is ETH, so is Bitcoin, so is all of it. You could lose what you put in definitely, but we are headed west. This is the frontier, it's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the Bankless journey. Thanks a lot. We're not five. So I can ship, get on board. So why is, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me. Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to Bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence.
We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a Bankless Premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless Premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anything and weekly rollups, where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content.
Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation.