Last Week of March 2022
------ 📣 CONSENSYS | M·A·C: NFT Collection for a Good Cause https://bankless.cc/MAC
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALED ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🏦 ALTO IRA | TAX-FREE CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/AltoIRA
👻 AAVE V3 | LEND & BORROW CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/aave
⚡️ MAKER DAO | THE DAI STABLECOIN https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
------ Timestamps:
PERMISSIONLESS TICKETS https://blockworks.co/events/permissionless/
0:00 Intro
6:25 MARKETS 6:28 BTC Price 7:31 ETH Price 8:14 ETH/BTC Ratio 8:30 TA Candy https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/is-the-bear-market-over-lite 11:04 $BED https://app.indexcoop.com/bed 11:30 Gas Markets https://dune.xyz/hildobby/Gas 12:55 Top DeFi Lending Protocol https://thedefiant.io/anchor-passes-aave-tvl/ https://defillama.com/ 17:35 DPI is 1st DeFi Index on CEX https://twitter.com/Gemini/status/1508784238488961028 19:40 Half of Germans to Invest in Crypto https://cointelegraph.com/news/almost-half-of-germans-to-invest-in-crypto-report 20:55 100 People vs. 9.75M Users = $40K https://twitter.com/RAC/status/1507189330694967296 23:15 20k Private ETH https://twitter.com/aztecnetwork/status/1508368318138236933
28:50 RELEASES 29:18 Wells Fargo Arena, Now Bankless Arena https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/breaking-wells-fargo-arena-now-bankless?s=w 31:30 Apple Pay in Metamask https://beincrypto.com/iphone-users-score-apple-pay-integration-with-popular-crypto-wallet-metamask/ 32:35 OpenSea Adds Solana NFTs https://twitter.com/opensea/status/1508851483449585670 33:40 Polygon Zk Web3 Identity Services https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/139735/polygon-unveils-identity-service-leveraging-zero-knowledge-proofs 36:00 BNB Chain to Launch Sidechains https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/139409/bnb-chain-to-launch-application-specific-sidechains-to-reduce-network-strain 37:37 Opera Beating Brave? https://blogs.opera.com/crypto/2022/03/opera-web3-polygon-solana-starkex-bitcoin-ixo-ronin-nervos-celo/ 39:05 DeFi Saver https://twitter.com/DeFiSaver/status/150883134852551885
39:37 RAISES 39:50 Sequoia, FTX, A16z $135M LayerZero Investment https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/03/30/a16z-ftx-and-sequoia-lead-155m-round-for-layerzero-at-1b-valuation/ 41:21 Avalanche Another $100M Fund https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/139265/avalanche-launches-100-million-creator-fund-with-grimes-and-web3-platform-op3n 45:30 $5M Seed for ZkLend https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/03/29/delphi-digital-leads-5m-seed-round-for-money-market-protocol-zklend/ 46:25 nfty chat https://twitter.com/nftychat/status/1508517166425034764 https://nftychat.xyz/ https://metalink.com/login
47:37 JOBS https://pallet.xyz/list/bankless/jobs Bankless Talent Collective https://bankless.pallet.com/talent/welcome Great Testimonial https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ/status/1508888147576373249
49:30 NEWS 49:45 Biggest Hack in Crypto History? $600M… 49:55 What Happened? https://twitter.com/Ronin_Network/status/1508828722085867521 50:10 William Peaster Breaks it Down https://metaversal.banklesshq.com/p/analyzing-the-ronin-bridge-hack https://twitter.com/kelvinfichter/status/1508839255996522508 52:30 FTX Deposit https://twitter.com/FrankResearcher/status/1508832517826174989 54:15 SBF Tweet https://twitter.com/SBF_FTX/status/1508839529293176847 56:15 Reimbursement https://beincrypto.com/players-to-be-reimbursed-promise-axie-infinity-team-after-breach/?ref=coingecko 57:30 Can’t Do This Hack on Polygon https://twitter.com/Mudit__Gupta/status/1508882791525724163
1:02:55 ETH 1:03:15 5 Things to Know About the Merge https://twitter.com/trent_vanepps/status/1508478499325202435 1:09:50 Bloomberg Intelligence PDFs 1:11:23 Ethereum Report - Institutions https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1508448302576148480 1:13:40 Misconceptions about PoS https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/4-misconceptions-about-pos-vs-pow?s=w Vitalik on the Road not Taken https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin/status/1508915954570436612
1:18:26 NFTs 1:18:30 Tiffany & Co Buys NFT https://twitter.com/TiffanyAndCo/status/1508149472198549505 1:19:32 Budweiser beer.eth Cans https://twitter.com/budweiserusa/status/1507507766759411712
1:20:35 BITCOIN 1:20:40 MacroStrategy $205M Loan https://www.theblockcrypto.com/linked/139719/macrostrategy-silvergate-loan-more-bitcoin 1:21:22 Change the Code https://www.cleanupbitcoin.com/ https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/news/change-the-code-not-the-climate-greenpeace-usa-ewg-others-launch-campaign-to-push-bitcoin-to-reduce-climate-pollution/ 1:25:10 Counter https://twitter.com/MessariCrypto/status/1500492844758351875
1:26:25 REGULATION / TRADFI / MISC. 1:26:40 Canadian Regulators Crack Down https://twitter.com/ryansadams/status/1507425569310392322 1:27:56 Canada’s Next Leader? https://twitter.com/PierrePoilievre/status/1508535716795531273 1:28:55 EU Unhosted wallets https://twitter.com/paddi_hansen/status/1509536318585454597 1:30:35 Write the SEC https://twitter.com/DanSpuller/status/1509178997858521090 1:32:12 MakerDAO Hooking Up With Traditional Bank https://thedefiant.io/makerdao-bank-deal-dai-loans/ 1:35:20 Maker Panel https://youtu.be/woW1nAWFTEI
1:38:10 TAKES 1:38:30 Epicenter of Digitization https://twitter.com/mikemcglone11/status/1509163605354291205 1:39:30 What Are You in Crypto For? https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/tokbqf/yes_i_am_in_it_for_the_money_and_i_dont_care_what/
1:45:15: How Many Jobs You Got? https://twitter.com/nftnoobbby/status/1509043140325425157 1:45:45 Democratizing Force https://twitter.com/RoninImperial/status/1509293153349734402 1:45:50 The Point of Crypto is to _______ https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1509217719555702786
1:46:50 MEME of the Week https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/is-the-bear-market-over-lite?s=w https://twitter.com/sartoshi_nft/status/1508288792796581892
1:48:15 Disclaimers
Moment of Zen https://twitter.com/kmoney_69/status/1508915008704421890 ----- Not financial or tax advice. Do your own research. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
We can't wait to tell you who put their name on the next Crypto Sports Arena. I'm super excited about this, David. And I know you're smiling too. I know you're excited. I know. I kind of want to skip right there, but it goes in the news section. Happy Friday morning, Banclist Nation. It is the last week of March. Or is it the first week of April? I'm not too sure, David. But I do know one thing. It is time for what? The Banclist weekly roll-up, Ryan. Where we cover the entire news in the last week in crypto, which is always an ambitious endeavor. Yet we persevere nonetheless covering everything that happened in the markets, the news, what's going on, the NFT shenanigans, the regulation shenanigans.
We cover it all here on the Friday, Banclist Weekly Roll-up. Absolutely. Fastest way to get your crypto digest and some hot stuff, hot topics this week. It's going to be a fun week. It's going to be a fun week. Look, we got to talk about more crypto companies putting their names on sports stadiums, OK? Who could that be happening? Who could that be? April 1st, it's happening. We're going to tell you about the biggest one yet. I think this is bigger than FTX. I think this is biggerthancrypto.com. This is the biggest one yet. And we can't wait to tell you who put their name on the next crypto sports arena.
I'm super excited about this, David. I know you're smiling too. I know you're excited. I know. I kind of want to skip right there, but it goes in the news section. It's not the biggest in terms of deals and terms of money deals, but it's the biggest in terms of culture. I was like, I totally agree. With that. Also, one of the biggest hacks, maybe in crypto history, the run-in sidechain, there was an exploit. So, this was a $600 million plus hack. We got to cover that. What happened? What went wrong? Our sidechain is really safe. What does this mean for Axi infinity, of course, because that's the run-in sidechain?
Also, David, there are so many misconceptions out there about two things. Number one, the Ethereum merge. Number two, proof of stake. We're going to lay those misconceptions to rest. We can also talk about traditional finance institutions, waking up to the merge, waking up to proof of stake. Lots of reports there. So, a number of things to cover. I'm excited to dive in. David, before we get there, we should talk a little bit about permissionless. This is a conference. And we are getting closer and closer. I think we're like two months away, is that correct? Yeah. The drum roll for permissionless is getting louder and louder.
May 17th to 19th, Palm Beach, Florida. It's just going to be insanely fun. This is going up to be a reunion of the bankless podcast, and also so many more guests and panelists and speakers, some insane content. All of your favorite bankless, previous podcast guests are going to be there. Justin Drake, Chris Dixon, Nick Carter, Eric Peters, who's a huge in the traditional finance world. We had them on the podcast. Geho from Axi, of course. Jake Stravinsky for all the people who are trying to get downloaded with the legal and regulatory side of the crypto industry, Ryan Selkis, of course, what would a conference be without him?
Donnie from Alve. Just had them on the show. It's going to be the who's who of crypto events, smack in the middle of the year. May 17th to 19th, in Miami, or in Palm Beach, Florida, bankless is throwing a party. I'm going to be there vibing. Ryan and I are going to meet for the first time. The number of things that is going to happen at permissionless is off the charts. There's not even enough time to talk about it here, so you got to get your ticket. There is a link in the show notes to go get your ticket. If you are a bankless premium subscriber, you get 30% off, which pays for your entire bankless premium for the year.
So there you go for that. And you got to come. You got to come. It's going to be a huge event. I'm really looking forward to it. Ryan, I know you're excited for permissionless. Why are you excited for permissionless? All right. I'm excited to meet you, David. That's why I'm going. That's really why I'm going. Well, the conference is cool and everything. But let's finally meet in person. I guess. I hope the podcast doesn't end, does or something like that. David, something else going on. Our friends at Consensus on the NFT side wanted to give the bankless nation a heads up. So on April 10th, it is National Youth HIV AIDS Awareness Day.
And Mac, MAC, the makeup company, is actually releasing an NFT collection. This is going to be powered by Consensus NFT. It's going to be dropping on April the 10th. And it's featuring art by Keith Herring. The cool thing about this, I think, is some of you listening have kind of dabbled around in NFTs. Haven't really gotten into it. But this is an opportunity for the NFT, the first time buyers of NFTs, to get a cool NFT and also support a great cause. Because all of the proceeds of this NFT actually go 100% to support youth impacted by HIV and AIDS. And this is in two forms. So one, the initial purchase price of the NFT.
And then because NFTs are so badass, every resale of that NFT, 2.5%, also goes to the cause of HIV and AIDS and the youth impacted by it. There's three rarity levels. So there's like a bottom tier of like just $25 NFT all the way up to $1,000 NFT at the rarest level, only 25 of those. And all of these, of course, are super scarce. The art is not released yet, okay? It's not released yet. I can't wait to see what these look like. But if you want to partake in this, at least check it out. What you got to do is go sign up. I've got the website in front of me right now, but a quick link to that would be bankless.
cc-mac-mcapital-mcapital-a-capital-c that'll get you there right away. I'm going to pick up one of these, David, because it's a good cause, man. In Vitalex blog posts about legitimacy, he talked about ways that NFT projects can gain legitimacy and it was through donating to causes. We saw this with people, please, there's effort in her NFTs, like some portion of the proceeds going to charity to establish legitimacy. A hundred percent of the revenue is going to this charity. So extremely legitimate, I think, is how the conclusion to sell. Very legitimate. Yeah, and this is cool to see companies partaking in this, too.
So it's also a crypto-saturation story, a lot of wins here for everyone. Speaking of wins, are we getting wins in the market, David? Let's flip to market stuff. Bitcoin price. Any wins there on the week? Yeah, we got some wins. We started the week at $43,000. Hit a high of $48,000 of which it almost was at the time of recording, except in the last hour or so. We tanked. We tanked from $47.5 down to $45.7,000. Still though, Ryan, up 7% on the week, maybe a little bit less, maybe like 6.5%. It's a good week. It was a good week. It's been a good month. It's been a good month. It's been a really good month.
Look at this, and I'll take it. I have to say, the bearish, David, weekly roll up, which people have definitely tapped into and have been teasing me about so far. Some people has painted the bottom. Some people are calling that a top signal, David. I hate to break it to you, man, but... What's a top signal? You mean a bottom signal? The top signal of you, excuse me, bottom signal. Bottom signal of you being bearish. I'm sorry. For the first time ever on a roll up, you were bearish. You go back three to four weeks, and you look at the fundamentals of the macro market, and tell me how it's in how hard it was to be bullish in that moment.
Like, give me a break. It was difficult. Some of us managed to do it, though. Okay, David. Let's talk about ETH price. Hopefully we're going up, too. Are we? Yes indeed, yes indeed. Started the week at $3,050, hit a high of $3,450, up $400 for the peak, but also has kind of retraced in the last few hours here. We always record these on Thursday morning. Thursday, March 31st, down, or excuse me, up 9% on the week, down like two or three percent in the last hour to where we are now. Roughly about $3,300. Ryan, you're showing the Bitcoin price chart. Just have a ride. Am I? Oops. Let me flip that ETH there.
There we go. There we go. Yeah, so chopping around, how to really bullish week kind of retrace a little bit just now, but again, up 9% on the week. Yeah, I was looking at it. I just look at the shape of the chart and it's like, that looks a lot like Bitcoin. How about the ratio? ratio to Bitcoin ratio. Up to about 2.2% on the week, started last week at 0.07, we were up to 0.0717, 2% up 2%. That means I'm 2% more bullish. Yes. That's about right. That's about right. There's also market signal. We got some candy charts to show in the market Monday this week, put a bunch of charts into the newsletter, and there's just this same pattern that you see across the three most important charts in crypto in my mind, which is Bitcoin ether and the ETH BTC ratio.
Starting all the way back to, I guess I think this chart starts, it really gets bullish in the start of 2021, where Bitcoin zoomed from like $20,000 up to almost $70,000. From 70, went down to 36, from 36, went back up to 70, you know, ish, I'm kind of rounding these numbers here. And then after it hit like 69, the high of $69,000, it then went back down to $36,000. But now it is again retracing, bouncing off that bottom. So there's a channel here with higher highs and higher lows over time. This is a one year long channel. And the same channel is seen in the ether price, you're scrolled down to the ether prices.
This is the same thing. It's the same thing. Higher highs over time, higher lows over time, over a really long time frame. This is like an 18 month long channel. But we bounce right off of that bottom. And like if you can just, if this channel is something to take guidance from, like what is the current top of the channel? Like for Bitcoin, it's $75,000. For ether, it's $55,200. And the same channel you can see in the ETH BTC ratio. And so if you scroll down once again, Ryan, you can see, yeah, just a little bit more. It's there too. And so like what happens if the ETH BTC ratio bounces, which it did off the floor of like 0.
06, 0.055 is the absolute bottom, again, higher lows and higher highs. What if it goes up to 0.09? Or the top of the channel is like, hmm, hmm. What happened to bearish data? David, he's nowhere to have seen that guy's gone. Well, like Putin, Putin is absolutely effed. He's got no options. Like Ukraine's fundamentally winning. There's like peace talks. There's peace talks. Like commodity prices are coming down, all of the bearish reasons have dissipated. And so like if you were the person that bought into the fear, congratulations, that worked out for you. Look, my co-host just makes decisions based on the data.
And the data has changed, right? Information coming has changed. Macro looking a bit brighter. I don't know about like the Fed in inflation though. I don't know if that's changed. That data point still feels a little bit bearish. But the question there is does that even matter though? Well, sometimes it doesn't matter. Maybe maybe heavy inflation is actually good for crypto. Do you want to store your value in dollars? Or do you want to store it in crypto assets that have nice channels like this? Let's talk about the bed index. So that's a third. A third, a third. We must be up on the week. It looks like we are.
Bigly. Yeah. Actually, this is up more than Bitcoin and Ether. DeFi won the week this week. Up 11% started the week at $107 ending the week at $128. So DeFi leading the way this week. You ready to call it DeFi season? Oh God. No. I would not ever. Of course. Of course. How about ETH gas? That's always fun to talk about on a weekly basis. We up or down. Yeah. Gas prices are up on the week. And the last week, the average was $22 for the week. We are up to $40. Up to $40. Average gas for the week. So gas markets are up again, which is a bullish indicator. It's always funny to me because I don't know how to feel about gas prices rising because at one level I'm like, oh man, my Ether transactions going up at the same time.
It's also a bull market signal, ETH block space, more valuable, revenue going to staking in the future, bullish for Ether the asset. So I'm always of a divided mind with respect to that. And I think the market is too. Market can't figure out whether high-eath gas prices are good for Ether or bad for Ether. It's like people calling it in either direction. I have to say sentiment. I think market analysis is definitely when gas prices are up, Ether value is going up. I think that's pretty strongly correlated. I think that's a, I think that's, yes. And I think that's a, that's a bankless thesis as well that like on the main chain, gas fees have to continue to increase over time, right?
And transaction fees will decrease in layer two, but they have to continuously increase in on, if you remain it. And that is actually, exactly, thumbs up, yeah, exactly one direction or the other. And that is actually the bull case for Ether the asset when you run the numbers when it becomes a capital asset. Anyway, we'll get to more of that later. But let's talk about some other market news. One is that anchor, which is a DeFi protocol, Monty market, money market, borrowing and lending. So similar to comp, similar to Ave compound or Ave, it just topped Ave, leapfrog Ave with 14 billion in total locked value.
You can see it here on DeFi Lama. So there's Ave, there's anchor, only maker is higher, Lido and curve. Those are the three DeFi protocols that are higher than anchor at this point. And this is all coming off of this terror explosion, this UST explosion, that is a terrorist stablecoin, UST. And of course, the last two weeks we've been talking about how Doecoin and the terror ecosystem is planning to backstop this algorithmic stablecoin, rather than being backstopped by the meme narrative price of the luna token, backstopping it with billions of dollars of Bitcoin. And that process has started with these Bitcoin buys.
I put this tweet out there because I feel like this is a conversation we need to have on bankless, is terror UST the future of crypto money or is it a ticking time bomb waiting to explode? I think those are two sides of the spectrum. Maybe the truth is in the middle, I'm not sure. But I feel like that's an episode we need to have, David. And I think we have some guest line up for that, we're in the process of doing that. So hopefully an episode next week on this topic. Yeah, Wednesday, Wednesday, we're going to figure it out, we're going to get the right guest. We're going to have one bowl versus one bear.
We already had multiple very qualified people, very intelligent people, well informed people to raise their hands saying they want to argue either for the bowl of the bear size. So we're going to pick out the best candidates, throw them into a Zoom together and they're going to fight to see what happened. They're going to fight. Yeah. And so that's going to happen on Wednesday. And you know, just some comments Ryan, like, Dokewan on Twitter has been like, I'm going to call it Icarusing, he's been Icarusing pretty hard and like he's been kind of a bully. Like this has been something that the people have noticed is like Dokewan's being a bully on Twitter.
And it's has been as a function, it seems to be as a function of terror price, Luna price as Luna goes up, Dokewan gets even more confident. I think I think he's Icarusing, man. I think I think this is like, there's so many top signals right now for Tara, but what about it? What do I know? I'm just an eithmaxie. There is a thing called a bowl market goggles, I think, like your price is exploded in the way that it has. It's hard not to let that, you know, make you feel like you have this sense of invincibility. But look, this panelist is for us to really discover this, this bear in bowl markets to understand a bit more about the USC ecosystem, the arguments on both sides.
I'm always worried about algorithmic stablecoins just in general. It's because like all of the past experiments have failed. If I had explosions out of my soundboard, I would have played it by now. They have, right? In various ways and maybe this time it's different. If it is different, let's try to understand how. And I do think that there are models for successful models for algorithmic stablecoins out there. It's just, let's see, I prefer the ones that are maximally trustless when we're doing that and certainly transparent. Anyway, we're going to dive into this and hopefully serve as both sides of the argument for you guys in bank lists so we can all learn together and see if this is Icarus or if this is like the next new thing in this time it's different.
One last comment on this, Ryan Popquist, who was the last extremely confident person on Twitter? Doquan put out a tweet, buy my hand, die will die, as in die from MakerDow. He just wants to have UST be the perfect decentralized trustless stablecoin to dominate the market. So he tweets out, buy my hand, die will die. So Popquist, who is the last extremely confident aggro builder on crypto Twitter to talk negatively about MakerDow? Well, that's got to be Danny Sesta and what happened three weeks later? I mean, I don't know, where is Danny? Where is Danny? I don't know where he is, I don't know where the frogs are.
Yeah, it does, I'm feeling a little bit of that energy, right? Maybe it's different. Look, there are some personalities that are just like that, you know, Elon Musk to the world is actually like building things but we have to see, we want to unpack this a little bit more. Another similarity is that Doquan also has an invitation out in his Twitter DMs to come on bank list, which he has not yet replied to. So there's that. Well, we'll see, DeFi pulse index, the DPI, this is huge, this is huge. This is an index put together by a DeFi protocol called index co-op where big fans of it, DPI is actually part of the bed index as well.
It's an assortment of the top blue chip DeFi assets on Ethereum. It was just listed by Gemini as a coin. So along with, you know, index itself and maple and fracks and some other coins, they are listing the first DeFi index. And I think David, this is the first DeFi index to be listed on an exchange. Pretty big milestone here. Yeah, this is something that the index co-op and just DeFi in general has really been looking for for a really, really long time. It's hard to get liquidity and demand for DPI, the DeFi index when it's stuck inside of DPI, in stuck inside of DeFi, like you have to actually go by on uniswap, which means you have to take self custody of it.
A lot of people want indices products like DPI, but they also want it to be inside of their centralized exchange with centralized custody. And DPI has been around for over a year now and hasn't been able to break into the centralized exchange marketplace for reasons. There is some like risk involved because in theory, like the index co-op can just change everything about the DPI. And so there's some risk involved for centralized exchanges to list this. That's why it's been slow. But finally, we're getting the DPI into Gemini. So hats off to Gemini. Thank you for getting my call. We love you. We love you guys.
And just like, come on. Let's get more going. Let's go. Let's go. Let's go. List them all. I mean, look, a year old, but this does also demonstrate like Lindy effect in indexes right? Like you wouldn't necessarily as an exchange want to list an index product that's like two months old, right? Like 60 days into this thing. You have to give it some time to work out the kinks, figure out what it's doing. And I think DPI has reached that point. So it should be a mainstay, right? Gemini lists it. All the other exchanges are going to have to compete to list it. Really cool that DPI products are breaking in here.
Let's talk about Germany for a second. Almost half of Germans are now invested in crypto. Hats off to Germany, the richest country in Europe. Okay. Yeah. Like I think once you get 50% of your population, and this is like 44%, almost 50%. It's kind of over for anti crypto regulators. It's kind of over because like the people are speaking with their wallets, they're voting with their wallets and they're saying we want crypto. And so if you try to push through anti crypto legislation, you're going to have a much stiffer resistance than when you tried to do that in the first decade of crypto, when everyone thought it was like scam money and only 1% of the population owned it.
So to me, the most bullish thing is for crypto to be understood, as we've said before, but be to be owned. That is super bullish. So easy. Yes. Yeah. Germany and really Europe at large has always been I think a little bit ahead of the curve. So a lot of developers in Germany, so very strong like just community there. So cool. Yeah, that's cool. I wish we could get there in the US. I don't think we're at 50% yet, but this is cool. This might take us there. Stuff like this. This is RAC. Yeah. Grammy award-winning artist Hadamon Bankless before. Do you want to read out this tweet, David? Yeah, he goes.
I've personally made $12.5 ETH, about $40,000, which is equivalent to almost 10 million plays on Spotify. RAC would have needed 10 million plays on Spotify to make $40,000, and he just made $12.5 ETH in his number of drops, if you scroll up around, it'll show up what he's talking about. But his NFT drop on sound, XYZ, May 10th, 100 editions for 0.1 ETH for $310 a piece. And so in addition to royalties on top of that, 2.5 ETH and royalties, this would have taken him 10 million plays on Spotify. Now I, in a huge RAC fan, and I'm actually just, since I already have Spotify up, I'm going to go to RAC on Spotify, and we're going to see how many plays that he got on his number one song, 44 million plays on his number one song.
And so he's got a number of, and he's only had three songs above 10 million plays each. And that took years for him to establish those plays, and he did this in mere minutes. NFT's in crypto, and just tokens, and decentralized trustless, programmatic finance, putting money into the hands of artists. Yeah, this is super cool. He said, he said this to you on the tweet. So yes, 100 people generated more income than 9.75 million users. Let that sink in. This harkens back to our conversation we had, and I would encourage listeners to go listen to it if you haven't with Lee Jen, where she talked about forget the 1000 true fans thing, 100 true true fans can make you for you, and that's easy.
You can have a narrow fan base of the most 100, like the 100 most passionate people about the thing you're creating, completely fund everything you're doing as a creator, because these are sort of like the most passionate individuals who are willing to spend any amount and not just spend this amount, but actually invest this amount in you because they believe in you. This is the power of NFTs in the creator economy, and I think that's what RAC is saying here and demonstrating. And there's also, we did a show with RAC and meet the nation if you guys want to meet Andre, great guy, great music, listen to the music in college, and then also the episodes that we did with Blau also come to mind if you guys are interested in the subject matter.
Super smart guy, both of them, as techs roll up, this is hot, 200, no, sorry, 20k eth in deposits shielded, what is Aztec, why is this hot? Yeah, so Aztec is a layer 2 privacy roll up, it also has a layer 1 smart contract system, but this is, I believe, yeah, this is the layer 2, 20,000 ether is now in Aztec shielded, so that's 20,000 shielded ether as in private ether. This is basically like to take Zcash, the blockchain, but make it into a layer 2, that's basically what this is, and there's a bunch of other smart contract functioning as well. And so, this is like tornado cash, but even better, using ZK technology to have private ether transactions, which sounds like we're going to be needing even more and more as we go into this highly authoritarian future that we kind of see ahead of us.
So remember Ryan last, I think it was last week or maybe the week before, but we were talking about Elizabeth Warren being super cringe when she was asking somebody in congress I'm hearing about, if you have these cross chain bridges, can't you just obfuscate all the ether, and like she was making the point that like crypto is mixing it easy to obfuscate, but like she was getting her details wrong about how like crossing bridges or obfuscation. Anyways, it was super cringe, she was trying to paint an narrative. The thing I'm a little bit concerned about Ryan is like, what she was looking for, she was attacking, she was attacking the wrong source.
What she thinks, crypto, all of crypto is, is what Aztec is building. And so like, this is a regulator's worst fear. It's private layer twos that has complete assurances as to privacy and ownership and payments. So like once regulators get their minds around ZK technology, which is going to take a while, I'm a little bit worried that they're actually going to have some real thought or to fight the situation. But here's the problem, why in the world is it regulators worst fear that citizens actually have privacy on their crypto assets? They don't have access to a list of all of the physical property I own.
They don't know how much cash I have in my wallet, in my physical wallet, or gold bars I might have in a vault somewhere in my basement, okay? But they need to know everything about my digital transactions. This is like, the problem is establishing this as a norm, like an outrage norm that Elizabeth Warren in any politician has no right to be angry about privacy of crypto transactions. We need to like bust through that as a norm. Like it's absolutely ludicrous, authoritarian, and ridiculous that like free private speech in the form of money on the internet would be a thing that's controversial in any Western democratic country.
You don't need to convince me, man. I'm sorry. That was for you. That was for me. I'm not saying that for Baycluses News either, I just needed to say that. You're totally right. That should be the approach. I have zero faith that that's going to be the approach. Exactly. Same here. This is why we need to be active, guys. We'll get to that when we get to the regulatory section. But first, man, we're going to talk about the sponsors, and when we get back, we've got to talk about that breaking news. This is happening, arenas being purchased by crypto companies, we're going to get right into it. Before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible.
Arbitram is an Ethereum layer two scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Over 300 projects have already deployed to Arbitram, and the DeFi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly. Some of the coolest and newest NFT collections have chosen Arbitram as their home. All the wild DeFi protocols continue to see increased usage and liquidity. Using Arbitram has never been easier, especially with the ability to deposit directly into Arbitram through all the exchanges, including Binance, FTX, Quoby, and Crypto.com. Once inside, you'll notice Arbitram increases Ethereum's speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee.
If you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users, visit Arbitram.io slash developer to start building your DAP on Arbitram. If you're a DGen, many of your favorite DAPs on Ethereum are already on Arbitram with many moving over every day. Go to bridge.arbitram.io now to start bridging over your ETH and other tokens in order to experience DeFi and NFTs in the way it was always meant to be. Fast, cheap, secure, and friction-free. The Brave Browser is the user first browser for the Web3 internet. With over 50 million monthly active users, control your digital footprint with built-in privacy and ad blocking.
Inside the Brave Browser, you'll find the Brave Wallet. The first secure crypto wallet built natively inside of a Web3 crypto browser. Web3 is freedom from big tech and wallstree, more control and better privacy, but there's a weak point in Web3, your crypto wallet. The Brave Wallet is different. Brave Wallet is built natively inside the Brave Browser. No extension required, which gives the Brave Wallet an extra level of security versus other wallets. With the Brave Wallet, you can buy, store, send, and swap your crypto assets and it can even manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps, all from the security of the best privacy browser on the market.
Whether you're new to crypto or you season pro, it's time to switch to the Brave Wallet. Download Brave at brave.com slash bank list and click the wallet icon to get started. Avae is the leading decentralized liquidity protocol and now Avae V3 is here. Avae V3 has powerful new features to enable you to get the most out of DeFi, including isolation mode, which allows for many more markets to be launched with more exotic collateral types and also efficiency mode, which allows for a higher loan to value ratios. And of course, portals, allowing users to port their Avae position across all of the networks that Avae operates on, like polygon, phantom, avalanche, arbitrum, optimism, and harmony.
The beautiful thing about Avae is that it's completely open source, decentralized, and governed by its community, enabling a truly bankless future for us all. To get your first crypto collateralized loan, get started at avae.com, that's a-a-b-e.com. And also check out the Avae protocol governance forums to see what more than 100,000 downmembers are all roving about at governance.avae.com. All right, guys, we are back with the releases of the week. This is a hot release, David. It's been a long time coming, Ryan. Look, I feel like we should just maybe get right to the press release here because this just dropped this morning, this morning, okay, for Save April, this morning.
Wells Fargo Arena is now the bankless arena, David. Do you want to read this press release here? Yeah, but the arena for the Philadelphia Flyers and the 76ers is the arena in Philadelphia is now bankless arena. We got it. We got the name. We did it. The bankless arena, okay, first FTX did it, then crypto.com. Now bankless, we are just taking it back from the bank. We didn't care about any other arena, but it was the Wells Fargo arena that their naming rights happened to have ended this year. And so we submitted the bid. We won the bid. It's not the biggest naming rights deal. We don't have FTX money.
We don't have crypto.com money, but you know, we were early to eat. We have some money. And so Wells Fargo Arena, now, bankless arena, sick is F, sick is F. Yep. Last minute bid as well, Citadel CEO Ken Griffin tried to beat us out for those. The internet bid. That was a nail lighter. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. But managed to do it. Guys, all of the details are here for you in the press release that we just published on bankless. So we'll include a link to that. But look, this is more evidence that crypto is here to stay, you know, what should we get next? We got an arena. What's next? Oh God, I don't know.
It's going to hold country. By an island, start with an island. The bankless island. Mm-hmm. Totally worth it. Hey, congratulations, man. Like pass on the back. Thank you to the bankless community and everyone that has listened to bankless and all the sponsors for bankless. We couldn't have done it without you. You know, this is crypto taking over, you know, we're putting our names on places and bankless is next up. Thanks for your response. Thanks for your response. Thank you. It just has a great ring to it. Yeah. I can't wait to see the flyers play. Man, this could be awesome. I love sports.
Anyway, we should we should move on, okay, because that's a big deal. That's a big deal. But there are some other things that are happening in crypto as well. Apple Pay, integrating with Metamask. This is not a super big deal, but it feels like a big deal. Tell us about this. Yeah. So this is an integration with wire, W, Y, R, E, right into Metamask. And wire has this widget that allows you to buy, I think, up to like $500 worth of Ether using Apple Pay. And now it's hooked right into Metamask. So you can now get Apple Pay into Metamask to buy Ether and other tokens straight from your credit card, straight from your debit card using Apple Pay.
And so this is, I think this is going to be especially useful for activities on layer two's because, you know, $500 of Ether on the layer one isn't too useful. But then things like gaming where people don't really care about Ether or Ethereum, but they need to fund their wallet to play games. That's going to be really useful. This has always been wire has always been building forward towards this integration has been this Apple Pay via wire has been a thing for a while. It's just now it's in Metamask. Yeah, it's cool. It's just a greater access to fiat and onboarding that into crypto is awesome.
OpenC just added Solana NFTs this week. And of course, Solana NFTs shot up in price. Many of them, the floor prices have risen for sure. And so you're calling this the best kept secret in Web 3 multi chain NFTs. That is a thing now. And OpenC is supporting them, whether it's Arbitrum, Optimism, Polygon, Solana, Avalanche, NFTs everywhere on all of the chains seems to be the direction we're moving in. Yeah, OpenC has just is just killing it on the execution layer. Kind of a bummer that Solana isn't EVM compatible, right? Because then you have to have an alternative wallet. Like I have my trustless state OpenC account where everyone can go check out my NFTs.
And that's my Ethereum address for my NFTs. But that's a different wallet for my Solana wallet, which I don't have. But if I did have one, it would be different, which is because it's not an EVM thing. But I'm assuming they're eventually going to integrate Avalanche and that will be the same wallet. So things like that. But anyways, OpenC blockchain agnostic integrating wherever there is NFT demand as you would expect. One of the features we were talking about earlier is like, how do we get privacy on the chain? So we're talking about Aztec. This is another interesting solution to privacy on chain.
It's privacy. It's also identity. Polygon just unveiled an identity service that leverages ZK proofs. So this is the ability to check credentials of an individual polygon user without revealing private information. Kind of useful. So I think my take on this, too, is that some of these side chains, like in ecosystems like polygons and these layer 2s, are going to compete by adding on interesting services. So this is like a layer 2 slash side chain adding identity as a service on top of their chain. Of course, Ethereum doesn't have that natively baked into the protocol. Some chains layer 2s might decide to add oracles, for instance, price oracles.
I think this is going to be an evolving landscape of all of these layer 2s and side chains kind of competing on the feature level in order to win against the competition. Because it's a pretty competitive world out there, survival of the fittest. And so everyone's trying to carve out their niche in their area. And I think adding features like identity are one such way to do that. What's your take? Unlocking and solving identity in ways that developers can build on that and build just using that identity primitive is going to unlock so many use cases. Some we already know about, but many, many more we don't know about because we haven't had that unlock yet.
So many people are working on this, polygons working on this, disco.xyz is working on this. And identity as a primitive is absolutely massive. And it's really going to be one of the things that elevates the metaverse to the next level. And this is kind of why some people are starting to meme social summer 2022. They're seeing the writing on the wall as the infrastructure is starting to be built out yet. I think summer is a little bit early, but like social web 3 is on a horizon and it's going to be great. Yeah, it's fascinating to me that all of these features seem to be being built on the execution layer as well.
Like we'll never see an identity service on a theory of main chain. We'll probably never see like a centralized Oracle service on a theory of main chain either, which is, in my opinion, a good thing keeps the protocol based level protocol less complicated B and B, formally, Binance chain. They are launching application specific side chains to reduce network chain strain. So this is B and B chain, which is a side chain, also launching side chain. What's a side chain? Okay. Right. It's kind of a semantic thing, right? It is a side chain, right? And I don't personally see B and B as kind of like competitive with more decentralized, alternate, even layer ones, but even alternative layer ones.
It's like like 21 validators all over your like mostly owned or like somehow carteled by B and by Binance. So effectively, to me, this is a side chain. Some might call it an alternative layer one semantics, but it's funny that they are expanding by launching other side chains. As soon as B and B chain gets congested and demand and in too much demand, they start to become modular. So plus one to the modular blockchain thesis. This is what this is, you know, centralized version of modular blockchains probably has a niche to fill, I guess. That's probably it. I think this is less modular blockchain to me.
Modular blockchain to me is where you're actually like building a stack in modules. This is like a network of monolithic blockchains to me. You're just like straining together monolithic blockchains as side chains. It's a step. It's a small step on this spectrum of modularization towards the modular side, but yeah, it's like one step on a very long journey, right? Why not be a layer too? I don't know. You could do that too. They don't want to bend the knee. They don't like bending knees. Opera taking a giant leap into Web 3. They are adding Salana Polygon, Stark X and others. This is opera, the browser.
It's like a low percentage of market share browser. It's like, you know, 2%. Let's call it browser. But what I love about this is the other Web 3 friendly browser is Brave. And now we have opera and we have Brave, and they're both competing against one another and a race to build features fastest where Google Chrome, just as there is, like, I have all the market share. You have to do anything. I don't, you know, just like the incumbent here and these two operating, these two browsers are like battling it out to be the winner of the Web 3 movement and the change that's happening. Web 3 integrated, Web 3 native browsers has got to be the way forward in the browser landscape.
It can't just be with extensions. And so I think we are on the very beginnings of like a new age of what a browser actually looks like. And like you said, it's just opera and just Brave. And opera is doing things that Brave's not doing. So like opera, kind of like the dark horse crypto, like a dark horse browser, I guess because they were basically in last in terms of market share, they had to kind of do something, but they're doing the right things. So like nice job. Nice job. Do you know, I always thought it would be cool for like a wallet to become big enough to go back in the other direction, like go buy a browser or go build a browser or something like this, right?
And I didn't ask browser, that's a great brand for a browser. That'd be bad ass. I love that. I don't know. Anyway, it's good to see. We're starting to see it. Also DeFi Saver. So this is an app built on maker. They're adding automated stop and loss and take profit options for maker vaults. What's cool here is just, you know, we don't talk about it very much, but on all of the base protocols, particularly once they've been around for a long time like maker, an entire application infrastructure is being built out on top of these things to make the protocols easier. I think we've got something else on maker later in the episode, but it's just cool to see.
Cool. It's important to DeFi more power for the users, you'll have to see it. Rases. Rases for Rases. Rases, some big raises this week. Yeah. A layer zero raise, $1 billion valuations. Yeah, Ryan, I raised $1 billion for my podcast. Did you know? So that's how you afforded the arena. That's exactly right. Okay, so this is a 16z FTX and Sequoia, leading $135 million around for this layer zero thing. What is layer zero? It's a, other than the bankless podcast exploring the culture behind the people behind projects rather than projects themselves, is also a blockchain interoperability network. It's like, it's like, consider layer zero as in like, you know, the subterranean network between blockchains.
It's kind of a semantics debate as whether or so that's a layer zero or just a different layer two. It's a bridge, man. It's a bridge. It's a bridge. But anyways, cross-chain composability layer zero enables developers to build decentralized applications that simply weren't possible before. It's Ali, a general partner at Adrys and Horowitz. But yeah, I mean, if you believe in the blockchain, multi-chain, polychain, interoperability world, this would be right up your alley. This makes a ton of sense. I'm bullish bridges in general, bullish bridges. You know, in our conversation, the Olaf, though, okay, which that episode is coming.
Yeah, unreleased. Not next Monday, but the Monday after this is Olaf at Polychain. He actually, his thesis was that bridges could actually become competitive with layer twos and layer ones and actually host their own applications, which was kind of a novel idea to me, but maybe explains the aspirations for a $1 billion valuation because this is definitely layer two territory now, it's like a $1 billion valuation. We already have a unicorn in the bridge world, which is pretty crazy to see. Yep. Congrats to those guys. Avalanche. They just launched $100 million creator fund with Grimes. That's Elon Musk's, they still together?
I don't know. They're married, right? Okay. Cool. Yeah. They named their kid, hella weird. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. That's all I remember. Anyway. Grimes is in it. It's a Web 3 platform. What's interesting about this story, David? Yeah. So this is a $100 million fund coming out of the Avax token and they are just building out Web 3 social open OP3N, kind of in the same vein as the Web 3 social that we talked about just a second ago, but also on the panel that we had $100 million initiative for creatives to build projects on Avalanche as the blockchain network grosses profile with non crypto natives.
That is the story. I got some takes about the token, Ryan, unless you have it. Tell me about the take. Okay. Mine only first take is like Web 3 socials hot. This has a little bit of, do you remember when EOS, the US platform, voice, right, and they bought like a domain name and everything and they invested millions of dollars. It wasn't $100 million at that time. It was less. Now we're at $100 million. But what do you think this means for the token for Avalanche? Okay. Look at that next paragraph. Named the Culture Catalyst Initiative. The first of these funded projects paid out of the network's native token Avax, right?
So this wasn't a raise. Really? Actually, this was just a token sale of $100 million of the Avax token to fund this initiative. Ryan, do you know the inflation rate for the Avalanche blockchain and the Avax token? Watch, tell me. Because that's hard. It's hard to define that. I've looked in a few places that they don't have figured out yet. According to Missouri, the Avax token is inflating at 26% per year. So that means that in order to sustain its current price, 26% of the value of the market cap of Avalanche needs to be turned into buying demand for Avax to maintain its current price. At the same time, they are selling the Avax token to fund all these development initiatives, you know, investments, investments into the ecosystem.
You know, you got to invest in yourself to grow out the ecosystem. But like I'm just getting flashbacks of the 2017 Ethereum ICO, Mania, where so many ICOs had just stockpiles and stockpiles of Ether. And that is the reason why Ether went from $1,400 down to $90 because so many ICOs had to sell their Ether to pay for taxes just to sell it at all, just to fund their teams. Consensus had to do this to say alive. And so like, I'm seeing the inflation rate of Avax, which if Missouri is correct, at 26.6% and they're doing all of these raises by selling the token and like, that is a lot of selling pressure, bro.
Like, how is that getting absorbed? That's the thing. I think that people need to remember that issuance isn't free money. It's selling pressure. Issuance is selling pressure, ultimately. And at some point that can catch up to you. And so the thing is, like, I guess the main lesson is never, not never do this sort of thing, but make sure when you do it, you're invested very strategic and you've got to return on a capital story. So, but that is a lot of issuance. And you know, some people might say, well, this is the problem with Ethereum. Ethereum never does these sorts of investments. That's why more centralized alternatives like Avalanche and Terra will overtake Ethereum.
I don't know. I don't know if I buy that. I guess we'll have to see what happens. I mean, they can definitely pay developers way better than the Ethereum ecosystem has because of decisions and actions like this and also because they have just a ton of VC backing. If you go look at the Avax price chart, you don't need to pull it up. Like, it doesn't look like there's any selling pressure. Like, it's a bullish looking chart, which is kind of confusing to me. Like, you don't, that is a discrepancy in my mind of the chart looking kind of bullish ish, but there's so much issuance. There's so much inflation is insane.
Yeah. We'll see. Maybe, I don't know. Maybe that kind of thing doesn't really catch up to you unless there's a bare market. It shows up in bare markets for sure. If we're back in bull market territory, they may have a long runway still. Talking about this, Delphi Digital, they just let a $5 million seed round for another money market protocol called ZKLend. This is on, I think. Starkware. Starkware? Okay. Starkware. What's this? I'm assuming it's like an Ava type compound money market borrowing and lending, but ZK on a ZK roll up. So lower transaction fees, higher speeds, the things that we all know and love.
There's got to be some consolidation here at some point in time. Does every single chain, every single piece of technology need its own money market? Or as soon as there are ZK EVMs, then things like Avae, which have been battle tested and hardened and have also been progressing in their own wrap, where our maps can just deploy there too. So lots of competition to be had and you know what happens when there's a lot of competition. Good things happen for the users. That's true. That's true. Okay. Let's talk about this last one. This is a. Nifty chat. Nifty chat. I was actually in on this full disclosure, but they just raised a million dollars.
And Nifty chat is kind of cool because it's basically like discord and chat room meets Web 3 NFTs. So you can like kind of go here, log in your NFT and then you get like, let's say you have a cryptopunk, right? It will pull the fact that you have a cryptopunk and create a cryptopunk specific chat room or like mini discord for you, which is kind of neat. There's another app that does this too called meta link, which I also like, but it's kind of cool, right? It's going to give discord, I think, run for its money, which needs to start adding some NFT features. Remember, they tried to do that and then backed off of it a few months ago.
All right. Yeah. So can I like put on my cryptopunk hat and chat as my cryptopunk and then like rip off my cryptopunk mask and put on my MFR hat and then chat as a different account? Is that how this works? Yeah, and it's the idea is trying to bring these communities together too. So it's like you and all the cryptopunks and if I don't have a cryptopunk, I can't get in. I'm not welcoming the chat. I'm outside the party, man. I don't have a cryptopunk. I don't have a cryptopunk. I do have an MFR, so I can come chat with you there. Jobs time. This is the time of the week where David and I remind you to get a job in a cryptop.
If you haven't already, go get a job in crypto. It's fun over here. It's a good time. We have a good time. It's real fun. It's real fun. We're like, we're buying arenas over here. What? You too. All right, let's talk about it. A few jobs. We're going to read them out because these are hot. A co-founder for an innovative Omni Chain DeFi Primitive. This is ominous. Who is the hire to be announced in Paris? Oh, OK. This sounds too good to be true. Wow. So go check out that job description. Missouri is hiring a blockchain engineer for DAO's. A software engineer for market data. It's going to be hiring an operations manager.
Smart DeFi, a senior product designer. Senior Go Rust Engineer at Syndica. Senior Full Stack Engineer at Syndica. Senior Software Engineer, AirDrop Labs. Product Manager at Nori. Bankless Web Developer for Bankless. A bankless editor for Bankless as well. Community Manager for Bankless Academy. I could go on. We've got Uniswap Labs listings. Ethereum Foundation listings. A whole lot more. Go check out the bankless job board. Here's the thing. So those are the curious. This is actually how I dance in the club. So you'll be able to see that permission list at our party. I can't wait to see that in person.
Look, this job board really works, too. This is somebody from Smart DeFi saying, Bankless was responsible for over 75% of our core team hires across all positions. It's pretty cool. It felt like using cheat codes. You can't leave that part out, Ryan. It felt like using cheat codes. So it's just let me know that the talent that is listening to Bankless is significant. And if you want to tap into some of that talent, the job board is a place where you can, as a talented person, post your resume with a talent collective or as an employer and post your job. There's a link in the show notes. Yeah, very cool.
Let's keep going here, David. Are you ready for news time? Yeah, this is definitely the news of the week, other than the bankless arena. Big news of the week. All right, take a breath with me. $600 million, probably over $600 million. That's like three stadiums this week. That's like three stadiums. Yeah. The Ronin Bridge has been exploited for $173,000 ETH and 25 million USDC. The Ronin Bridge, of course, is a sidechain that Axi has been building out. Responsible, I think, for a lot of Axi's growth over the last 12 to 18 months after it launched, like cheap transactions. But what happened here, David?
Tell us the story. Yes, so this was not a smart contract exploit. This was not a bridge exploit of the actual bridge. What happened here was that this bridge was a multi-sig bridge, which is relatively common. And there was a five of nine multi-sig that controls the bridge. It just so happens that these, the private keys, this was basically a private key theft. So the attacker, the exploiter, found a way into the nodes that actually maintained the keys. So rather than just like having these seed phrases written down somewhere, the way that this bridge maintained, I'm assuming, or at least in the spirit of accuracy, the details are to be determined.
But these are nodes in the cloud. And these nodes, these five of nine nodes, or the validator nodes for the bridge, are verifying transactions, making transactions to make this bridge work. But the private keys are in the nodes. They're in the cloud. And so the attacker was able to get... They're like in hot wallets, basically. Yeah, five of them. And the attacker was able to access the cloud servers, the nodes directly, and just basically get five of the nine multi-sig private keys. So basically, there was no malicious attack. There was no just like smart contract exploit. The attacker just got all of the private keys.
And so then he just withdrew all of the ether and USDC down to the main chain. And so we haven't really seen an attack like that because it's pretty easy to secure that. This is kind of like one-on-one security, I think. Well, people remember the last bridge hack, which actually wasn't that long ago, which was the wormhole bridge hack. And what was that, like $200 million? This is a bridge from Ethereum to Solana, something like that. And that was actually smart contract code hack. Yes, that was a bug. This was not that bad. This was a private keys. This was a private key. The theft of private keys.
This is, we got your private keys, type of hack. So I think a lot of implications from that that we should probably talk about. The first one, Ryan. Pop quiz. Do layer two rollups have private keys? They do not, sir. They do not have private keys. They do have upgrade contracts, which is an asterisk. So there's that. Yes. Well, I mean, this is kind of a lesson, I think, and we'll get to the learning lessons later, but this is a lesson on side-chain security for the crypto ecosystem. Maybe a very difficult lesson to learn. But let's talk about this, too. So hacker goes, steals $600 million. The crazy thing about this is, imagine you're a bank robber, and you go and you steal from a bank.
But what's the last thing you do? Well, like what you're doing, everything you do with that money is like, it's as if you're broadcast on YouTube, live streamed, like whatever you do. So everyone knows what you're doing with the money. We can't get to you, but we know what you're about to do. We can watch it. That's what's happening. And so we can actually see what this hacker is doing with the $600 million. OK, so you're a bank robber. You steal $600 million from a bank. This is what the attacker does next is he deposits all of this, I don't know if all the money, but a lot of this money into FTX.
That's like a bank robber robbing $600 million and going to a different bank and depositing it. OK, being live streamed, I'm thinking, I'm being live streamed. OK, so why did the attacker do this? People have come to the conclusion that this is not just some like novice. Oh, I get to have this money now, I'll send it to FTX and it cash it out. No, what's very likely happening is that the account that it was deposited to in FTX was like purchase, right? It was somebody else's account that they got the password or email address for. So they were able to access somebody else's KYC to account. Fake IDs.
Fake ID, right. And then maybe I don't know what they were doing in there. Like, I can't imagine that they sent it outbound to a bank account because they had to have to send it to their bank account if they want the money. What is more likely happened is they sent it into FTX and then withdrew it from FTX, which made it invisible to the chain, but it made it very visible to FTX. So FTX knows where this money is. And we actually, there was a tweet out of Sam Bank been freed that said, I acknowledge that this is happening. We are investigating and taking action if and where appropriate. So like they're up to something.
It just doesn't seem like a good strategy, though. Like, I don't know, you go steal from a bank and then you deposit it into another bank. The other bank knows, you know, it has your funds for some period of time. Maybe it's been withdrawn, but sort of knows all of your transaction history can like freeze your account, contract this down. I don't know if this is a good way to escape with the money. And that's kind of the flaw, I guess. If you are a black hat crypto hacker right now, it's just like, it's relative, it's not easy to go hack money in crypto, but like, we see these things every week.
This is just one of the biggest. But like, if you're smart enough to hack, are you smart enough to get away with it, too? Get away with the money and somehow withdraw it. We haven't seen many hackers complete that last circuit. No, definitely not. The other very interesting thing about this story that is just a complete curveball, right? And the Ronan side chain was exploited. This hack happened on March 23rd, Wednesday, March 23rd. No one noticed until the 29th, I forgot about that. Six days later, people no one noticed when somebody tried to withdraw, they were like, so I'm trying to withdraw my teeth.
And it's failing. Yeah, and so it's the teeth not there. It's not the bench, it's not the bridge vault anymore. Right, and so people were probably sending teeth into the chain because that was probably fine. But like getting back out, there was an empty vault. Six days, $600 million went missing for six days. Oh, crypto. There's a joke going around Twitter. I think Kobe was the spawn of this joke where he said, oh, yeah, I noticed that the Ronan side chain got hacked. Therefore, I went and shorted AXI. But then the token prompt, and it pumps, and I got liquidated because no one noticed. Right, exactly.
Sorry for the laughter, that's $600 million. A lot of people have lost money. AXI has stated that they are going to reimburse people. I don't know how they're going to do that, but they have stated that that is their intentions. It's always unfortunate when we see $600 million getting lost. This is just a... That is the reason I'm laughing, though, is because I expect everyone to be reimbursed. I mean, AXI has massively deep pockets, and we've seen this before, right, with the Solana wormhole hack. Everyone was just reimbursed. Is this ultimately just coming out of A16Z? Is A16Z footing the bill for this one?
I don't know. Actually, I actually think that what'll happen is they'll get the money back from because the black hat hacker will find it's impossible to actually, and so we'll cut a deal in some fashion or it'll get frozen. I think they'll get their money back, but if not, yeah, then I suppose that comes out of somebody's treasure. Just give $580 million back and have $20 million. It's your life is going to be the same. Black hats, it's easy. Don't be greedy, okay? Congrats. Congrats, you pulled it off. Give it back. Take the $20 million or whatever number you can settle with, and then have a good life.
Well, some people are worried because this is not the only side chain, of course, with a bridge. There are many. One of which is polygon. Yeah. And so this is from, oops, account muted. Chris Black. Oh, it might, I also haven't muted. By the way, polygon is secured by a five of nine multi-sig, just like the Ronin network, he says, and they've refused many, many times to answer any questions about how these keys are secured. Somebody from the polygon team, this is a legitimate concern, okay? If this can happen to Ronin, can this happen to polygon in the same way, why don't you read the response, David?
Yeah, this is somebody who's on the polygon team, so it has actual information about this. C-I-S-O, chief in security officer or something? Yeah, something, I don't know. Says, polygon keys are secured in a very different way than Ronin. All polygon keys are on offline hardware wallets, like a ledger, not on a server connected to the internet, which is the vehicle for the exploit of the Ronin side chain. For that storage. Close storage. Good, how it should be. For that reason, it's impossible to do a Ronin-like attack on polygon, and this person continues in the next tweet. No backup is stored digitally on a device connected to the internet.
Unfortunately, there's no way for me to prove this to you, so you just have to take my word for it. So obviously, just have to take my word for it. It's kind of like a hotline in trustless crypto. We don't want to trust people. It just needs to be the way that it is. But also, we can't have the details of the polygon security mechanism public on Twitter, because then that just informs the attackers on how to do it. So it's appropriate that this is not information that's publicly known, because then that is a risk vector. So in my mind, the current state of polygon security, if it is indeed an offline cold storage wallets, that perhaps not all of the multi-six signers know the locations of the other multi-six signers, that makes sense.
As far as we can tell, the security for polygon is grade A level security. They've done it right, and they're taking it seriously. Yeah. It's got to be better than Ronin, but also, I think there are some learning lessons here, right? And the top learning lesson for everyone listening is side chains do not inherit the security of the base chain. So let me just repeat that for a second. Side chains do not inherit the security of the base chain. So if you move your assets from something like Ethereum to another chain, and if that's a side chain, realize that you are incurring some risk in that move, in that transaction.
You are now in a different security paradigm than you were. And I think this is just like, I'm very careful with what I do on side chains, right? It's like, I know some of the risks, and I'm not going to be like putting my net worth on a side chain or significant amount of my net worth on a side chain at this point in time. And I think at some level the same goes for layer two's. I mean, they don't have the Lindy. So just be careful where you're moving your money and your assets. The second thing I think I took away from this is again, a reflection that is really, really hard for hackers to get away with funds on chain, right?
So like in this case, I don't know that the hacker's going to be able to get away with it. And they really weren't in the wormhole case either. And then the third thing, I don't know if this is a good lesson for us to take away, but it is a lesson that the market's taking away is that if the chain is capitalized well enough, the pockets are deep enough, you got some of that VC money, you got a nice treasury, then when something bad happens, oftentimes people get reimbursed. Is that a good thing? Is that a bad thing? I'm happy for the scenario, but it does set a precedent where people sort of expect to be reimbursed and we tend to become more reliant on this trust dependency here.
Some people say that's a feature, some people that it's a bug, I think it depends. I sure wouldn't want to see that on a layer one chain. I guess on a side chain, maybe that's a compromise that you're willing to make. But I do get worried when everyone expects a bail, starts to expect a bailout. There's a big enough amount of money that's lost where it can't be bailed out. I guess it's appropriate for bailouts to happen in the beginning stages of this whole bridging bridge or ecosystem. As bridges get more hardened, as users get more informed, we would probably simultaneously expect bailouts to happen less and less and less, but we're at the very beginning stages, so I guess bailouts are appropriate.
But we don't know if there's a bailout coming on this one. That's a special speculation. Yeah, it's a promise from Axie, but yeah, we don't know the mechanics of it, so just to wrap up this conversation, just a market chatter, the Ronin token, the RON token, was $2.40 before the hack, and it is now currently at $1.70. $1.70, so down like 30% not that crazy for how big of a loss it was. The AXS token kind of unfazed, really. It's mostly just down four percent, or it's up 9% in seven days, which is a little bit nuts, but it peaked at $72, and then the hack happened, and now it's at $63. Look, this is the market telling us it's not really worried about this event.
Yeah. Market saying it's going to get resolved without big losses, big incident. Yeah, that's a big hack. That's a big hack. All right, let's move on. Let's talk about some Ethereum stuff, David. And I think it's time to clear out some misconceptions here, and we want to do a few misconceptions. The first, there's some misconceptions going on about the merge right now, and we're going through a tweet thread from Trent Van Epps, but I think we're going to focus on maybe five things, five misconceptions of the merge. Do you want to take the first one? Yeah, the first one is that stakers get unburnt fees, and so not all of Ether is burnt in a transaction fee.
It's an in-prope of stake. It's about, it actually doesn't change versus proof of work versus proof of stake. EIP1559 on average burns about 75% of the transaction fee. In the future, stakers will get this 30%, so unburnt fees, tips on the execution layer will be sent to stakers. That's pretty awesome. I don't know that many people know that post-merge. If you stake, you actually get those tips. You get the transaction fees. Passive income. In addition to new Ether that's minted as a block reward, you also get 30% of all transaction fees, which in bull markets can be very significant. Absolutely.
The second thing I wanted to highlight, this is a misconception. A lot of people think that once the merge happens, that they will be able to withdraw their eth from the staking contract. Uh-uh, can't. Not post-merge. Okay, not immediately post-merge, I should say. So staking an eth right now is a one-way ticket. It still will be post-merge. You will not be able to withdraw your eth post-merge. There will be another update that happens. I don't know, this could be three months later, six months later. Six is the end of the summation that I've heard. Yeah. We'll have to see how long it takes, but at that point in time, you will be able to withdraw.
Not immediately. I think there's some pros to this, which is a lot of people are saying, well, post-merge, a bunch of the staked eth is going to get sold. No, it's still going to be locked up. It's going to be locked up. But also keep in mind that when you stake, that eth is going to be locked. It's a one-way ticket, you're not going to be able to withdraw your eth post-merge. So that's the second misconception to clear up. Yeah, the alpha here is that post-merge. There is zero net new Ether introduced into the secondary market. The block reward issuance is going to stakers, which is locked because they can't withdraw.
The fees are going to stakers, which is locked because they can't withdraw. The reason why they can't withdraw is just reduce complexity. One step at a time, this is a very big deal to merge to proof of stake. And so we're just keeping it simple, doing one thing at a time, letting things stabilize, and then merge, which draws will be unlocked roughly six months later in that time. In those six months, the yield on staking goes from like 5% to probably like 15%. And the demand to stake will be 3xed, because the yields are going to be three times higher. And so there's going to be three times more demand to stake Ether, pull Ether out of the secondary market to stake it, and no ability to withdraw for six months.
Bullish. Bullish. I think so as well. Why don't you take the next one? Number three, third misconception. The merge will not reduce gas fees. I think people got this conflated when we started talking about Ethereum 2 versus Ethereum 1. And once we merge, we're at Ethereum 2. That's no longer the case. Sharding will reduce gas fees, but that's later. That is phase two. This is currently phase one, which is the merge. So the merge is not going to reduce gas fees. I'll take the next one. This is just a reminder. I think if you've been listening to banklists, you probably know this. But the ETH issuance is about to drop from 4.
3% in proof of work to 0.43%. That's a smaller number. It's crazy. It's a lot smaller. 4.3% to 0.43%. This is far lower than Bitcoin, like post-havenings. It'll take. To lower the lowest of any blockchain. By lowest of any blockchain, and that 0.43%, a significant portion of that is going to be burnt. That's where we get to ultrasound money, deflationary ETH as an asset. Because if the amount of ETH burnt exceeds 4.3%, then we're in deflationary territory, negative ETH burnt. On the year. So think about that. 4.3% to 0.43%. That is the ETH issuance in the post-merge world. Here, you want to do some comparisons, Ryan.
The current ETH issuance rate, inflation rate, is 4.3%. As you just said, Solana is a little bit above 9% in inflation rate. And Avalanche, as we said earlier, is at 26% inflation rate. Both Solana and Avalanche are proof of stake. But their much higher issuance rate comes from their, the centralized, monolithic blockchains that they have. They have so much throughput that they need to issue a ton of currency in order to secure that very high rate of block space issuance. The more you create block space, the more you have to spend on security, because you have more block space to secure. Because they are very, very high throughput blockchains, because they're centralized.
They have to issue a ton. Ether Ethereum is much more limited in block space, because we want to maintain decentralization at the base layer. That's how you do that. Therefore, it doesn't have to issue as much. So it's as low as 4.3%. The point, though, of why I'm doing this, is that this is comparison, 4.3% of Ethereum, in proof of work mode, in comparison to other proof of stake blockchains. And so when Ethereum joins Solana and Avalanche in proof of stake, it's going to be 0.43% inflation rate on Ether, versus Solana's inflation rate of 9%, versus Avalanche's inflation rate of 26%. These are, we are in different categories.
It's just killer. It's just killer. It's just killer. And that's not including the burn. That's not including the burn. Let's talk about the fifth misconception, and why didn't you do this last one? This is a good one. Running a node post-merge does not require any eth. You can be either a staking, validating node, and you can add transactions to the blockchain, or you can be a listening node. And you can send your own transactions to the mempool via your own node. But you do not, in order to run your own node, you do not need to add any eth to it. It is free and accessible to anyone to run a node.
Do you know this not actually true, Ryan, for Avalanche? I know that I'm trying to not be an East Maxi here. But in order to run a node on Avalanche, you have to be a validator. You have to be a validator. In order to access the mempool and see what's going on in the mempool to participate in it, you have to stake at Avalanche tokens, which is reminiscent to order flow for people that own the shares of the network. It's concerning to me as to the gating of that information away from the public because the public can't run their own Avalanche node. Yeah, I am also concerned about that. But this point is really important because some people say, no, well, it's going to cost thousands of dollars worth of eth to run a node.
No, it's not. It's just costs the hardware. And anyone can run it from a consumer machine. That's, by the way, always been a case. Anyone can run a node on Ethereum today. Just go download Gath and set it up. Dap node or something else. David, you know what's cool about this? These misconceptions is they're starting to fade on the institutional side. Okay, so people are starting to get it. I don't have a Bloomberg terminal or a subscription or whatever is required, but there is now an analyst at Bloomberg who covers Ethereum and he is writing some fire content about Ethereum and there are a few articles that some afforded me this week.
This is one on how Ethereum is transitioning to a global asset. This article absolutely nails it. There's another article on how the DCF model suggests the network asset for Ethereum ETH is undervalued. We just did some episodes with Ryan Alice and others on the DCF model for Ethereum. We did our DCF model with Justin Drake over a year ago. Yes, we did that. We did a year ago as well. Our conclusion was that I think Ethereum might be undervalued. This is what this analyst says too. Conservatively, Ether could be worth 6,100. Well, you plug in whatever numbers in the DCF and you spit something out, but it's sure a lot higher than it is today, depending on the numbers you put in, but like any obvious number, it will be higher.
And then here's an entire Bloomberg article on the merge, how the merge will be a super catalyst. I guess all this to say is the institutions are starting to get it and it's funny to me because we've been talking about the value proposition ETH is a triple point money for like probably two years, I would say like longer than that if you go back, but on bank lists for about two years. And it's interesting to me to see kind of the lag time of like institutions starting to get on board and starting to understand these narratives. This is from our friends at one river asset management and they bought one of the biggest Bitcoin buys in history about a year and a half ago.
It's like they are an institutional hedge fund who is now very crypto focused. This is what they say about Ether. Ether is being transformed into a low risk bond asset. And it is cheap. Remember, Ethereum, the internet bond, remember all those articles we wrote about? Remember what we were talking about? I remember. The largest institutional investors are now saying it, okay? It is increasingly clear, this is a quote, that the future of finance runs on Ethereum with Ether as a reserve asset to the ecosystem. The institutions are now repeating it. The narrative is cementing, still an early set of institutions, but it's out there now.
We did our job. One of the things I've been hammering about is to one of the most underappreciated aspects of proof of stake with EIP1559. And basically Ethereum versus Bitcoin is like, Bitcoin is really hard to value. It's hard to put like numbers and models around demand for Bitcoin. It's just like, do you take it on faith that people value this is really the Bitcoin investment thesis? With Ethereum, you have the issuance rate, you have the burn rate, you have the stake rate, you have like active addresses in DeFi, you have demand for Ether in DeFi. There's so many metrics and numbers, especially when like, first off, the appropriate numbers to actually make a DCF analysis, which is very comfy zone for institutions.
But the sheer number of just things to measure, metrics for Ether the asset, just enabling institutions to be comfortable. It makes it feel like it's in their wheelhouse, which kind of is, and it's definitely one of the most bullish things about Ether is like, you can actually reason about it with metrics and numbers rather than just like, assuming that there's going to be sufficient demand for an asset. Yeah, they're like, oh, yeah, we know bonds, we know equities and we know capital assets. Oh, and this thing performs like a bond, like an equity, like a capital asset. Okay, we can value that thing.
And oops, when we plug it in the spreadsheet, it spits out a much higher price than the price of ETH now. That's what's going on. Look at that, we look at the words that they use. Low-risk bond asset and it is cheap. I know. That's all you need to know. That's all you need to know. I know. Let's keep moving though, because the merch is coming. There's still a lot of misconceptions about this transition from proof of stake to proof of work. And I hope bankless listeners got a chance to tune into our episode with Lynn Alden and Justin Drake. That was kind of a debate on the merits of both sides.
We put together a new row of posts on bankless this week that dives into four misconceptions about proof of stake versus proof of work. And I think this is information that's worth getting out there. Why don't we hit all four of these points, David? What's the first one? Yeah, the first one is the rich do not get richer in proof of stake. This is a common critique of proof of stake is that it's a rich get richer system. And actually, it's completely the opposite. The fact that yield is baked into the asset allows everyone in the world to democratize access to the upside. So there is no difference in rate of return for somebody that invests $1 billion into ether versus $1 million into ether versus $1,000.
Everyone gets the same rate of return. And it actually improve a work. It's actually, that is the actual rich get richer system because of how much complexity and middlemen there are between $1 of capital and proof of work getting translated into $1 worth of hash power. You got to invest in the ASICs. You got to invest in the mining facilities. You got to get the ASICs through the supply chains. You got to have relationships with manufacturers. You got to power your facility. You have to cool your facility. And all of these things have respond to economies of scale. And that means that there's a significant competition around Bitcoin miners, which Bitcoin is really like.
But it is actually indoctrinating that who can invest more capital into proof of work most. So that's a misconception number one. The next one is that proof of stake is equity money and proof of work is commodity money. These are mental models. But in terms of actual definitions, it's not empirical. There are no empirical definitions. So I go through this and I actually make the claim that Ether has both commodity-like and equity-like characteristics. And Bitcoin has mostly neither. And I explain in the article about that. So that's number two. Proof of stake does not give governance powers to stakeholders.
There is a difference between on-chain governance and token vote governance and proof of stake. These are different things. There are systems that have on-chain governance like Tezos and Decred, and Tezos is proof of stake. Decred is a hybrid proof of work proof of stake. But the consensus mechanism and on-chain governance are completely different things. And Ethereum does not have on-chain governance. And lastly, dealing with 51% attacks, how does a proof of work system deal with a 51% attack if the time comes? Basically, the answer is, if somebody can generate enough hash power to 51% attack, a proof of work network, they have enough hash power to do it in forever.
So if the honest miners can't source enough honest hash power to overcome that 51% attack, that proof of work chain is dead, because the attacker has enough hash power to attack it into infinity. This exact opposite thing is true with proof of stake, where if somebody is attacking the proof of stake network, because Ether is registered to Ethereum, unlike ASICs, Ether is actually at a specific Ethereum address. The network can identify who is the attacking address. Where is the attacking ETH coming from? And we can coordinate around a fork to do something about that, whether it's forcibly exiting them from the Validator queue or slashing their Ether.
It's just so much easier to discover and route around an attacker in proof of stake than it is proof of work. So those are the four big misconceptions that I addressed in this article. I did my best to make this extremely digestible, so I highly encourage everyone to go read it if you are trying to get your learn on about why the hell we're doing this whole proof of stake thing in the first place. I think there is a difference between sort of an opinion on proof of stake versus proof of work and which produces a better money. I think there can be some variation in opinion there. But there's also some fact that I think you lay out in these misconceptions, right?
It's like, it's a fact that proof of stake is not more rich-get richer than proof of work, right? And it's like empirically a fact that proof of work can lead to economies of scale that help the rich to get richer. So I think it's important when you're looking at this to like separate the fact versus the opinion. And some of these misconceptions can be refuted just with like, hey, have you actually thought deeply about this and here are the facts as we lay them out. Now, there are some disadvantages with proof of stake versus proof of work, like weak subjectivity. There's some more deeper answers to some of these things, but I don't think these misconceptions actually hold up under any scrutiny.
Anyway, go take a look at that. David, let's flip to some NFT stuff. A few things happened this week. Number one is Tiffany and Company. Apparently, they just acquired an NFT. So Tiffany and Company, Tiffany Rings, Diamond Rings, and NFTs, I guess. This is the same NFT that Budweiser bought. Like, this is one of the rocket ones where you can kind of build your own rocket and each one has their own different brand. This seems so off brand for Tiffany, but you know, the metaverse is weird. So all right, cool. Do you think somebody's like, there's some consultant out there who's like, hey, I have my 10 easy steps to how a corporation can enter the NFT game and like lays out exactly the strategy for what they should buy first.
Can you imagine that? Being that consultant, like imagine this NFT on a PowerPoint is like, all right, like Tiffany, board of directors, like we're gonna buy this NFT for the podcast listeners. This is a kind of a shittily drawn, excuse my language, poorly drawn, hand drawn rocket with different components. Looks like a flash game from like the late, the early thousands and now it's part of Tiffany and Company. Yeah. Well, Nexus, the consultant recommends you buy a cryptopunk or a board ape. That's what you should do next. Or a stadium. Budweiser, they have beer.eth cans. Look at this man. Oh, that's a real can.
I thought that was Photoshop. No, that's a real can. I think it's one of those. I don't know where you can get these. Okay, this is an NFT beer fest. So I don't think they're cranking these out of their factory. I don't think you can go to your supermarket and buy these, but they do exist. Beer.eth, king of NFTs, Budweiser, going all in with their.eth address, right? If I saw a beer.eth on a beer can in like a local like supermarket, I would just absolutely die. That would be way too cool. It might actually get me to drink a Budweiser. Oh my God, it says the king of NFTs on it. I know. That's great.
That's great. Oh, there's a GM badge. There's a GM badge right in the middle. Where? Yeah, right in the center. That's great. Just well done. Whoever is doing it well. Budweiser is just killing the NFT game. They totally are. Totally are. Putting craft beers to shame, okay? Just crack open a bud. Bitcoin stuff, okay? Macro strategy. Macro strategy. Macro strategy? Yeah, Macro strategy. A $205 million loan to do what to buy Bitcoin. I saw this title and I was like, who is Macro strategy? It's a typo. Well, it turns out it's a subsidiary of microstrategy. It's Michael Saylor again. He's here. He's got a subsidiary of microstrategy.
And when they asked him what we should name it, Michael, he said macro strategy. And he's using that to buy more Bitcoin, of course. Dollar cost averaging in. It's the perfect name. It's the perfect name. It's Michael Saylor living up to his total chadness. $205 million on a loan or the Bitcoin. I do still think that'll pay off for him. Let's talk about this. There was a campaign that launched this week called Change the Code, not the climate. You've heard Bitcoin fuels the climate crisis, but did you know a software code change could clean it up? Wow, that sounds enticing. What can I do? How can I upgrade Bitcoin and get rid of the environmental waste?
Is that a way to do that? This is the campaign. Estimates show Bitcoin uses more electricity than all of Sweden. I mean, at a surface level, this is super damning, right? Bitcoin alone could help warm the planet by more than two degrees. I hope to see the details on that one. Bitcoin is resurrecting fossil fuels. A software code could change it, could fix it by 99%. Why aren't they doing it, right? Like at a surface, if you're kind of mainstream, if you're sort of an army, you already don't like crypto because you don't own any, you've heard some bad things. And you read this, you're like, this is terrible.
I hate Bitcoin. This is the campaign that is being pushed out. And guess who's funding it? In part, Greenpeace, of course, EWG, but also, Ripple, the Ripple Foundation. Oh, those bastards. Yeah. Ripple is in on it. If anyone has ever thought that Ripple has been a friend to the industry, like, think again. OK, well, give me your take on all of this. What do you think about this? OK, so when I was reading that, I was like, wow, this feels like it's coming from somebody who knows something about the industry, right? Like a Bitcoin, Maxi's would point this and be like, because it labels Ethereum.
Like, why isn't Bitcoin doing proof of stake like Ethereum is? And it's like, oh, this is like a probably interpreted as like a narrative attack against Bitcoin by Ethereum. It turns out it's Ripple. Wow, I didn't know that. Yeah, it's Ripple. My take on this is that it is really, really probably spinning a lot of narrative. And it's probably way more not true than it is true. For sure. At the same time, the rest of the world is totally ready to hear this. The narrative just resonates with people. It's slammed so hard. And so even if it's wrong, I'm conflicted on this, because like, if Bitcoin was, what Bitcoiners would believe it to be, a lot of this stuff could actually become true.
Like imagine if Bitcoin was a $100 trillion network, and it's still proof of work, it would be consuming an absolutely insane amount of energy. And so that is true. What is not true is that there's any amount of evidence that Bitcoin the network is putting is increasing the average global temperature. There's no evidence to that. And so this is really just a narrative campaign. Oh, God. It's just like, this is God damn bastards. God damn it. It doesn't, it doesn't look. It doesn't show like the totality of the picture. Like the drying industry, just like drying your clothes, it consumes more electricity output, the entire industry than Bitcoin has in this existence.
It's just stuff like this. Benchmarks, you don't really see. It's not telling the full story. It's, you know, can you just click a button and upgrade a software code to reduce Bitcoin's energy used by now? No, you can't. It's not how this works. It's not Bitcoin is resurrecting fossil fuels. Maybe in some places, but like in others, it's incentivizing actually a green usage. Photo usage. Yeah, so this is ridiculous. But here's the thing. I guess when you're thinking about the narrative battle that we're all fighting, I'm just, we just talked about proof of stake. I'm very glad that crypto proof of stake does not have to fight these types of battles.
Yeah, it's one of those things where like I'm very frustrated with Ripple for doing this, but at the same time, like, yo, Bitcoiners, this is your fight to fight. Like, good luck. We, you know, Ethereum has six more months. Yeah, I don't know, three more months. I mean, we'll see. To fight it. I guess. It's not even fighting it, though. It's just like, we're gonna switch. Okay, so here's a great tweet out of Missouri. Here's what I was saying with tumble dryers. Look at this. This image is a little fuzzy, so I'll read it out. Carbon emissions of Bitcoin compared to other industries. Bitcoin, 41 million tons of CO2 per year or something, gold industry, 122 to Bitcoins, 41.
Global banking, 130 to Bitcoins, 41. Tumble dryers, 53 to Bitcoins, 41. So do you, do you wash your clothes? Yeah, do you dry your clothes in a dryer because you are producing more or consuming more energy than Bitcoins? You don't have to. Yeah. Aviation industry, 1,982 to Bitcoins, 41. So like, what are we really being concerned about here? Yeah, I think there's some takes here, of course, but again. You remember the leave Brittany alone memes? Like leave Bitcoin alone. Yeah, there's an element of that for sure. But also Bitcoiners, good luck. Nick Carter, which is the best for you. Wouldn't want that job.
Yeah, no, that's a hard thing to defend proof of work. I think over the next decade for sure. But we have other battles to fight in the regulatory front. And I think one of the main battles that everyone in crypto should be concerned with is this attack on our bankless wallets, on non-custodial wallets. Here's the fight that Bitcoiners don't have to fight. But they should also, yeah, well, they don't, I guess. Well, they do. Like, Bitcoiners want, they're even private key access, of course. I guess so. Why was it only mainly referred to DeFi? But yeah, this is super, this is super important, okay?
So last week, a Coinbase user in Canada sent me this letter and this is an email rather from Coinbase. Starting on April 4th, Coinbase will introduce some changes required by Canadian regulators, specifically, when he sent crypto to another financial entity or money services business, then transactions over a hundred, oh, sorry, a thousand Canadian dollars, we legally require you to ask for the information about the recipient of that transactions, their name and address. Boom. This is like the question I have. So this is first on the menu, MLKYC, they want to know who you're sending funds to if it's over a thousand dollars.
But what's next on the menu? Just disable withdraws to crypto while it's all together. Like they could very easily do this. This is a nexus to do this with crypto banks, essentially. And my concern is that governments, like the Canadian government, want to trap crypto into the existing financial prison system that we have, digital financial prison system, this panopticon, where they get to monitor all of the transactions and with a click of a button, they can shut them down. That is not a good system. There's not the bankless decentralized finance money for the system that we were fighting for.
I think some Canadian politicians, to be fair, are pushing back on this. So this is one, his name is Peter Pooley-Ev. I think, Pooley-Ev, I think. This guy has a good shot from what I've been told at becoming Canada's next leader in Canada's conservative party. I'm not sure what a step that's true. But look at this campaign. Let's make Canada the blockchain capital of the world. This is going to be the new division in politics. Are you pro or anti-crypto? And it's going to be the incumbents who are already politicians. This is going to be anti-crypto and it's going to be the newer politicians.
They're going to be pro-crypto. And this doesn't break down and left and right. I mean, like I've heard a progressive candidate in the US wrote a fantastic editorial piece on why the left shouldn't brace Web 3 and brace crypto this week that I read to you. So that's a counter for us. But the EU as well. They're coming down against unhosted wallets. This is just a breaking today, I believe. What's happening here? Yeah, the tweet says that's from Patrick Hanson. The econ and LIBE committees, I don't know what that is, of the EU parliament voted in favor of the FTR compromises D&E that crack down on unhosted wallets.
Entire regulation drafted to be voted on later today, but we'll certainly go through breakdown of the vote and more updates in this thread. Basically, the EU voting to basically control unhosted wallets, the restricting withdrawal to unhosted wallets. God, the unhosted wallet thing. That's basically like, is your wallet custody by an institution that has an address? I don't like that, they don't like unhosted wallets. It's such like a nanny state thing. Like, oh, you need to have a wallet that is taken care of by somebody else. Like, no, I don't, I can host my own wallet. That's kind of the point of crypto.
Exactly, it's, yeah, it's a terrible situation. So this hasn't gone through yet, but I'm not sure the process for which this sort of thing becomes a law in the EU, but it's on its way. And another example of kind of a regulators and government officials not liking unhosted wallets and the battle that's ahead, Patrick Hansen, ends it like this. This information comes straight to the EP. I will share an official link overview of the vote here, ASCP. We have lost the battle, that's this, but this is far from over. So there's still some steps in the process through which we could get something like this shut down.
But you could see it, right? I'm last week we're talking about some of this talk in the US from Elizabeth Warren, wanting to do similar types of actions. Now we're seeing it in Canada, we're seeing it in the EU as well. This is the SEC who has come up with this very expansive definition of the term exchange. And it's very unclear what in exchange actually includes. Like is it code? Is it a non custodial wallet? Is it something like uniswap something in DeFi? The language that they're trying to put in place in a proposed rule in the US is very unclear. And so they've asked for comments. I think there's maybe 20 days remaining, 30 days of comments.
This is some action we can take is actually to comment against this. We'll include a link in the show notes where you could tell the SEC don't create more uncertainty for DeFi. But the language around what's in exchange and what's not is incredibly unclear. And I think it's also unclear by design. So we don't know if this is more of the same kind of energy of rejection, non custodial wallet, but it sort of feels like it. And in all of these places, I almost feel like the boat's kind of leaking and people in the crypto industry are like, where's the leak? We're just trying to bail it out. We're just trying to get the water out of the boat.
And we have to do this on a weekly basis. Like they're just kind of wearing us down. There's always a something that's trying to slip by and get past. Yeah, the number of things that they can do is probably more than we can probably patch the holes for. So the solution for this has always been to build our way out of it, which is what we are doing. Germany, 50% with crypto. That's how we do this. That's how we do this. What's this story, David? In good news, MakerDow is hooking up with traditional bank, what's that mean? Yeah, so MakerDow is really innovating in ways that other organizations are not.
And they're taking this very real world approach of getting real world assets into MakerDow through a combination of just like LLCs and trusts to custody, real world property, and then have that these loans be using the MakerDow system, loans generated against these real world assets. No one else is doing this. And it's one of the most bullish things about MakerDow that no one really understands. There is controversy about MakerDow as in like it's kind of like the banked version of DeFi, but I would contend that it's actually quite decentralized in the model that they are doing this. But there is so much value out in the real world and the only organization that is going after that to put that into TVL inside of contracts is Maker.
So you go to like something like DeFi Lama and you look at like Awe, it's got Ether and Unity tokens and Link tokens inside of its balance sheets. Only Maker has real world property, real world real estate, inside of its vaults with die backing it. Or no, backing die. So like it's in a league of its own and Maker is in my mind one of the most underappreciated things in DeFi. This is kind of, I think your words are like, it's a back end for banks. What's cool about this is this small bank based in the suburbs of Philadelphia. It's a 151 year old community bank. So not one of the big ones, not like a Wells Fargo or in HSBC.
It's just kind of a community bank, local community bank. They are trying to put $500 million in assets inside of Maker so you could lend and borrow against that and that would be collateral for some basis for die. So it's creating some innovation for some of these credit unions and banks that are much smaller and it's sort of a bridge for these banks to DeFi, which is really cool. So yeah, I think this is a counter force against all of the regulatory scrutiny and pressure is just like, hey, look at the value that we can drive. The efficiency we can bring to our financial markets. These small banks are able to use these DeFi protocols and provide benefits to the world.
And this is in stark contrast to like the algorithmic stablecoins of the world, which are kind of backed by a fractional reserve backed by nothing to some portion of them or aren't fully backed. This is a direct in my mind, the equal and opposite force for that, where it's backed by extremely real things. And that $50 million loan that this HPV bank is asking for, that there's going to be something, there's going to be a steep fee with that. Like the risk of the real world assets is going to come with a Maker Dows ability fee and a TBD on what not number is, but that's $50 million, which the MKR token is going to get burned as a function of that stability fee.
There's going to be some sort of interest rate on $500 million, and it's going to go to burning MKR. That's kind of cool. I'm just excited that we get to see all these experiments play out, right, as I've long said with Maker. And so we will be covering all of this and more in a live stream happening two day Friday for the listener. Maker Dows, like I said, I think is one of the most underappreciated things, because of the existence of the centralized foundation of Maker Dows, they haven't been able to market themselves in the way that other organizations have. So we're giving three DOW members a chance to give the most bullish case for Maker DOW and MKR that is happening as a live stream, 9 a.
m. Pacific, 12 p.m. Eastern time today, Friday, as you are listening to this. So if you want to hear the case, so why Maker DOW is so fundamentally bullish, we're going to hear it from three DOW community members who are bullish MKR. I think you should ask him if DOW Quad is going to kill DOW. I think I will. Guys, we will be back with the raises of the week, but before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. If you're trying to grow and preserve your crypto wealth, optimizing your taxes is just as lucrative as trying to find the next hidden gem. Also IRA can help you invest in crypto in tax advantage ways to help you preserve your hard earned money.
Also crypto IRA lets you invest more than 150 coins in tokens with all the same tax advantages of an IRA. They make it easy to fund your alternative IRA or crypto IRA via your 401k or by contributing directly from your bank account. There is no setup or account fees and it's all you need to do to invest in crypto tax-free. Let me repeat that again. You can invest in crypto tax-free. Diversify like the pros and trade without tax headaches. Open in alto crypto IRA to invest in crypto tax-free. Let's go to altoiray.com slash bankless. That's a-l-t-o-i-r-a.com slash bankless and start investing in crypto today.
The layer two era is upon us. The era is the layer two ecosystem is growing every day and we need bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a layer two life. Across is the fastest, cheapest, and most secure cross-chain bridge. With a cross, you don't have to worry about the long wait times or high fees to get your assets to the chain of your choice. Access are bridged and available for use almost instantaneously. Across bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens from layer two back to Ethereum. A token proposal is being deliberated as we speak in a cross forum where community members will decide on the token distribution.
You can have your part of a cross's story by joining the Discord and becoming a co-founder and helping to design the fair, fair launch of a cross. If you want to bridge your assets quickly and securely, go to across.to to bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Arbitrum, or Boba Networks. MakerDow is the OG D5 protocol. The MakerDow produces dye. The industry's most battle tested and resilient stablecoin. Using Maker, you don't need to sell your collateral if you need liquidity. Instead, you can spin up a Maker Vault and use your collateral to mint dye directly. With Maker, the power to mint new money is in your hands.
The Maker protocol is extremely hardened and operated by one of the most experienced dows in existence. They've been here since the beginning. They've seen it all and so you can mint dye with the assurance that your collateral is safe. Soon, Maker will be present on all chains and altos. So minting dye can take place on oasis.app, zaryon, zapper, or any other D5 protocol that you use. Follow Maker on Twitter at MakerDow and learn from the oldest and most resilient down existence. All right, guys. We are back with the takes of the week. This is from someone on the institutional side. Mike McGlann, he says, what?
Why don't you read this out, David? Yeah, demand is increasing, supplies declining, and the Ethereum's position at the epicenter of the digitization of finance and money. So just further price appreciation, Ethereum, the denominator for NFTs, and the top platform for tokenization is becoming the collateral of the internet. This is a good take, this is nothing new to bankless listeners, but the cool thing about this is this is coming from Tradify. That's why we're talking about this. This is a Tradify guy, Mike McGlann, who's at Bloomberg, 46,000 followers on Twitter. Probably none of those followers are the same followers that we have on crypto Twitter.
Those are brand new followers. And we got Tradify people speaking bankless language about Ether, people are waking up. Tradify is waking up. Bankless quoting Bloomberg, quoting bankless. That's exactly right. That's exactly right. Let's talk about this. This is a Reddit thread that I ran into this week and something about it resonated for me. So it was this, or at least caught my attention. Yes, I am in it for the money. I don't care what people think. Cryptocurrency from the perspective of a male in his thirties. That's the title of the post. The poster goes on to describe the conditions today.
There's no wage growth, no prospects in many countries, constant financial crisis that keep hitting and hitting us from all sides. Now inflation is gonna melt our savings. That's if we're lucky enough to have savings in the first place. Education system that's a joke in most countries, crippling debts, high cost of living, rents going up and up and up and so on. Crypto for a lot of us is the only way out. The only way to be able to afford a house or flat in the future. So yeah, you bet I'm in it for the money and I don't give a damn what people think. Priority number one for me is to provide for my family.
What do you think about this? I'm in it for the money. 100% that's why I'm in crypto. It's because there's no better way to get money for someone who's like early in their life. Like all of the other opportunities have been already extracted. What do you think about this take? Oh God, I could talk about this for hours. He talks about so many things and I'll just reiterate them. No job prospects, constant financial crises, new inflation, melting savings, crippling debts, high cost of living, rents going up. So yeah, he needs to be about the money. But the system that is creating all of these things is a result of the centralized, captured financial system that we are leaving and the reason why crypto works is because why crypto number is going to go up and why this guy's going to make money is because crypto is fixing all of those problems.
One of those problems is not having any money. One of the best use cases of crypto Ryan is number go up. And so that is the first thing that solves so many people's lives with crypto. Number go up is the most freeing thing possible. And so being in it for the money is the bootloader to talk about everything else about crypto. Crypto's not here to make you rich, it's here to set you free, but in order to be free, it really, really helps to be rich. And so that is like the first step. And so once this guy finally gets rich off of crypto, he's going to start to realize that the, and this is what Kevin O'Walky talks about with regenerative crypto economics.
The reason why crypto works is because we're all in it for the money. And it's instead of the old banking system, the old government system, the old institutions capturing us, everyone being here in it for the money is actually enabling for these systems to work. Bitcoin is secure because people are greedy and they need to, they need to mind Bitcoin. Ethereum works because people are greedy and they want to stake as much ether as possible. The systems, these democratized systems where everyone wants to be greedy and for a number to go up is how this industry is powered. There's why there's energy in dals, there's why there's energy in Ethereum, there's why there's energy behind the uniswaped out.
This is why crypto works. And so this is always the first step in people's journey into integrating into crypto. First you're here for the money, then you get the money and then you understand the values behind how this industry is powered. We've got to get you wealthy before we get you healthy. That's God. Why did I say all of that? Look, man, it's like, this is the first step to freedom, right? You said, we said before that crypto is a journey towards freedom and you can't have financial freedom unless you have some level of financial independence. But the thing is, I think the important thing to remember is sometimes we've said it before.
Decentralization is kind of a luxury for the wealthy, right? It's like, I think decentralization hopefully becomes more important to people over time. But at first, the way you got into crypto, the way I got into crypto, it was very much about like, how is this an opportunity to achieve some level of financial freedom? And it's totally fine if you're in it for the money, at least at first. Just don't stop when you have the money, right? Keep going. For everyone else, lend a hand downward. Don't pull up the ladder, help other people. Decentralization is a public good for everyone that keeps this system free of corruption and cancer and corrosion.
And that's definitely what we need. So it's almost like, David, my expectations are higher for people who know better and have been in this industry for a long time. And a lot of when we get a little bit maybe preachy onto decentralization, it's not talking to people who haven't made it in crypto yet and are just trying to get wealthy. It's talking to people who are here already wealthy and like, no better. Know that if we don't create systems that are sustainable in the future, there's no future for this industry and it won't do the good capital G that we think it can. The way that you said that where you're kicking the ladder out as you go, that's a really important point.
And that's why after you get yours, it's important to reach your hand down and pull someone else up with you. And a way to do that is to promote decentralization because that is how these systems are going to generate wealth for our kids and our kids' kids. So this guy needs to focus on getting as much money as possible because like he said, his number one concern is providing for his family. Once he's done that, he can consider it has the luxury to consider more things. And it's going from number going up on Bitcoin and Ether because these assets are decentralized to turning into promoting centralized systems is a kin to getting yours and then shutting the door behind you.
So that's why once you get yours, you got to promote values. There you go. How many jobs you have in crypto? This is great tweet. I love this tweet. The three in web three stands for three full-time jobs that's the tweet. Hey, what do you think? How many jobs do you have? You can work for 50 Dows. There is no limit as to what you can do. And sometimes when you work for multiple Dows, you can do work that is doing work for multiple Dows at once. Really blurring the lines between what's job and what's not a job. Yeah, we tell you to get a job in crypto. We're not telling you to be less busy. I mean, this will be more busy when you get a job in crypto.
That's a good point. That's a good point. All right, proof of stake will go down in histories. One of the most democratizing forces of power that has ever been invented. I feel like I read that from someone this week. Great quote. David, that's yours. Whoever said that is a genius. Just complete genius. What's that genius mean by this quote? Yeah, Ryan, earlier you tweeted out this week and you flashed on the screen, what is the entire point of crypto? What is the point of crypto? And I said, pushing power to the margins. So what we were just talking about with decentralization, the way that crypto works is over the long term.
The structural balance of crypto is stable. So that future generations do not feel disenfranchised. And the way that we do that is we push power into the individual who are always at the margins. You've got the institutions at the center. You've got the individuals at the margins. Crypto is here to put power at the margins. David, I think we're going to skip what we're excited about this week. Because I know we're both excited about the same thing. Yeah, I know. It's super obvious. Yeah. Have a bankless arena. I've always wanted my name on an arena. But I think I'll settle for bankless's name on it.
It's way better. It's way better. So let's just jump to the meme of the week. And there was a lot of meme fodder this week that we could get into. But this is the one we chose. Because this is with the iconic Will Smith slap Chris Rock week that kind of shook the world. I woke up to this on Monday and I was like, wait, what happened? It was crazy. Can you believe that happened for so long? Yeah, no, that was a surprise. That was a surprise. It was a little bit refreshing. Here's some just like good old classic Hollywood drama. Slapstick. Don't promote violence. But like, if I have to choose between the drama of the week being Will Smith slapping Kevin Rose and Russia invading Ukraine.
I'll go wait, wait, Will Smith slapping Kevin Rose. Oh, excuse me. Sorry, Kevin Rose, who's the guy that got slapped? Chris Rock. Chris Rock. I don't know why it's a Kevin Rose. That's funny. Nothing to do with Kevin Rose. Yeah, a little bit more lighthearted of drama in the news for this week. It's not like this meme is of Bitcoin slapping the shit out of the bear. Bear market's over. So that's why this meme in the week. And Ryan, you have a fantastic caption. I'm going to swear here. So cover your, cover your kids ears. Keep my coin out of your fucking mouth. I can't believe you said that at the Oscars, man.
It's hilarious. Guys, that's it for the weekly rollup. I hope you enjoyed. We're going to get to the moment of zen. Stumpin' you got to stick around for. But of course, got to end with our disclaimers as usual. None of this has been financial advice. Bitcoin, ETH, and DeFi. They're all risky. You could lose what you put in. But we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bank list journey. Thanks a lot. Yo, hey guys, you guys spoke with NFTs? Hey, what's up, man? Yeah, we're building right now. We're really just bridging the gap between Web2 and Web3.
Oh, I'm building. We're really just bridging the gap between Web2 and Web3. We're building. Just hanging out with my boys over here. They're speaking. I'm not speaking because I'm just busy building. Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks.
If you're interested in crypto, the bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders. Ask me anythings and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation.