4th Week of August, 2022
------ 📣 Chainlink | Register for SmartCon 2022 with promo code “BANKLESS” https://bankless.cc/smartcon
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🌱 LENS | WEB3 SOCIAL PROTOCOL https://bankless.cc/Lens
🚀 ROCKET POOL | ETH STAKING https://bankless.cc/RocketPool
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
🌉 JUNO | BRIDGE FIAT TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Juno
⚡️ ZKSYNC | THE LAYER 2 SCALING ENDGAME https://bankless.cc/zkSync
----- Timestamps:
0:00 Intro 1:53 UFO Sightings 5:20 Actual Intro
7:50 MARKETS 9:45 Total Market Cap https://www.coingecko.com/en/global_charts 11:15 Biden Debt Cancelation https://www.politico.com/news/2022/08/23/biden-student-loan-forgiveness-repayment-pause-00053299 13:30 Trolley Problem https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FbBIG1vXgAAniu5 17:50 Inflation Pain https://panteracapital.com/blockchain-letter/ethereum-tightening-more-than-fed/ 20:10 Energy Markets https://twitter.com/Schuldensuehner/status/1562771407313915905 21:14 FTX Revenue https://www.cnbc.com/2022/08/20/ftx-grew-revenue-1000percent-during-the-crypto-craze-leaked-financials.html 22:15 Layer 2 NFTs https://twitter.com/blockworksres/status/1560292557975801856 23:40 Hardware Wallets Up https://decrypt.co/107877/crypto-winter-freezes-have-turned-investors-hardware-wallets
Tornado Cash Fallout 26:30 Flashbots Blacklists Wallets https://thedefiant.io/flashbots-blacklists-wallets-tornado 30:20 FTX Froze Aztec Funds https://twitter.com/aztecnetwork/status/1560710567249096704 33:55 Uniswap UI Bans Wallets https://blockworks.co/wallets-banned-by-uniswap-labs-for-alleged-crimes 34:40 Alex Persev in Jail https://twitter.com/skywinder/status/1560655212741685248 36:30 Tom Emmer https://twitter.com/RepTomEmmer/status/1562084891247902721 37:15 Matthew Green https://twitter.com/ryansadams/status/1561887300887482368 37:45 Tether https://twitter.com/Tether_to/status/1562468486886346753 38:25 Layer Zero https://twitter.com/ercwl/status/1561180759146336256
40:00 FEI Fallout https://thedefiant.io/fei-shutdown-uproar 41:45 The Proposal https://tribe.fei.money/t/tip-121-proposal-for-the-future-of-the-tribe-dao/4475
47:15 BITBOY https://twitter.com/DegenSpartan/status/1559516281078190080 49:00 Suing Atozy https://twitter.com/atozy/thread/1562206338293309440 51:20 Community Support https://twitter.com/atozy/status/1562403410791567360 52:20 Drops the Suit https://twitter.com/AutismCapital/status/1562541877689126913
56:40 NEWS 58:30 Merge Updates https://twitter.com/TimBeiko/status/1562418377582419968 1:00:20 Merge Dashboards https://twitter.com/duneanalytics/status/1562021273575751680 1:00:45 Overhyped Merge https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/is-the-merge-overhyped 1:11:15 Uniswap Open Source Development https://app.uniswap.org/#/vote/2/24?chain=mainnet 1:15:50 Nike vs Adidas https://twitter.com/Blockworks_/status/1561666150991335431 1:17:15 Pudgy Penguins https://decrypt.co/107974/pudgy-penguins-ethereum-nfts-pump-83-as-meta-nansen-execs-join-advisory-board 1:18:20 BendDAO Bank Run https://metaversal.banklesshq.com/p/the-benddao-bank-run- 1:21:54 Gary Gensler https://twitter.com/cobie/status/1561809080297177092 1:25:00 Coinbase ENS Integration https://twitter.com/financeguy74/status/1561872288399691777 1:28:35 Swell Launch https://blog.swellnetwork.io/mainnet-soft-launch-announcement/ 1:29:06 Arbitrum Nitro https://twitter.com/arbitrum/status/1561812173793419265
1:29:30 Jobs https://pallet.xyz/list/bankless/jobs
1:31:00 Questions from the Nation https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ/status/1562470760824057857 1:32:00 Merge for Norms https://twitter.com/Yash_WeCan/status/1562472673795457029 1:35:25 More Merge Questions https://twitter.com/YoEdJoCo/status/1562472379313684480 1:36:20 Bullish Layer 2 https://twitter.com/_satyakikc/status/1562651521837600770
TAKES 1:39:11 Unicorn Markets https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1562559417857773568 1:40:00 Good Podcast https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1562569160474824705 1:41:05 Eric Wall Poll https://twitter.com/ercwl/status/1562673861434703876
1:43:25 What David’s Bullish On 1:45:05 What Ryan’s Bullish On
1:48:30 MEME of the Week https://twitter.com/NFTek2424/status/1562809727608066048
----- Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
#ethereum #eth #crypto #cryptonews #btc #bitcoin
No summary for this episode yet.
There's some bad things happening, but also some good things happening. Happy Friday morning to you. It is the fourth Friday of August and David, the special time. What time is it? Ryan, is the Friday bankless weekly roll-up where we cover the entire weekly news in crypto, which is always an ambitious endeavor? Yet we persevere into the frontier every single week, nonetheless, with a cup of coffee, of course. Yeah, I hope you are enjoying your cup of coffee. By the way, David, did you get a cup of coffee? When you went in the mountains, us week, you were in the mountains. Like, what'd you take with you?
Do you enjoy any coffee or any... Yeah, so we had coffee, but then we ran out of water. So we had to like, we had to skip the coffee and walk out of there. Yeah. I guess you need water. Is that is coffee higher on Maslow's higher key of needs? Or is it lower? Well, it definitely makes you lose water. So you definitely, if you're short on water, you got to, you got to skip the coffee. How is the trip, though? Oh, dude, it's super good, man. We were at 5,000, 5,500 feet up, but we're like zero, we started like 3,000, but like we're in Washington, so basically like really close to sea level. You can see the ocean from the top of the mountain.
It was great, man. It was great for me. You also had cell service, I heard, is it checking in? Yeah, so we were so high on the mountain that like, we had sightlines with Victoria, British Columbia. And so we actually were able to get service. And so when I wake up on Sunday, I just like look at my phone to check out the time. And I have like a widget on my front screen that shows me the, shows me the ether price every single year check in prices. Oh, no, I knew it, I knew it. I can't not check prices. It's on my home screen. Like it's the first thing I look at. You can delete it from your home screen?
No, no, I can't. Okay, it's hard to put it into that list. And so I wake up in Sunday morning, like sweet. We're down like 10%, like big ass red candle. Excuse my language, sorry. Yeah, you knew it, huh? It's right after the roll up, too, when we prices were up. So and then we had a crash. But you also saw some like a strange activity while you're there, dude. Okay, so I don't know. This sounds a little conspiracy theory to me. So convinced me. This is what this is what we were worried about. Okay, so it is 946. It's dark out. We're on the top of the mountain. And you know, we're watching a shooting star here or there.
There's a shooting star. There's a shooting star. It's nice, super cute. And then we see this very slow line in the sky. I'm like, wow, that is the slowest moving shooting star I've ever seen. And then it just doesn't go away. Like shooting stars go away like a second or less. This thing we saw it for 90 seconds, maybe a little bit longer. And it was just like this long line. And it had this weird trajectory. It was like, first it was coming down across the horizon like a shooting star. But then it changed direction and started moving toward us. And then we got right over us and it was this line of light.
And as it got closer and closer, it turned from a line to like a series of dots. And then it looks like we were like right below, like, you know, how those planes like trail assigns, like, you know, marry me, Susan or something. Yeah, it was like that, but lights, but who has ever seen those with lights on them? So like, that was okay. So what are you guys thinking there? Like there, there has to be a group of five of you. I know one of the people got to believe you, but I'm a, I feel like a very sane, grounded individual. And I'm like, I don't know. I don't have an explanation for what this is.
This is the campy of playing. I think it's possible. I don't, I don't know. Like it is by definition an unidentified flying object. Cause we didn't know how to identify it. So we were all here, dude, like there's no explanation for what this thing possibly is. Like 30 to 40 dots in a row flying at a uniform. There was no sound, no propeller engine, no jet sound. Like didn't make any goddamn sense. And so we, well, we had service. So we started pulling up Twitter and we typed in like UFO Olympic Peninsula Washington and like 50 other people's videos and photos of the same exact thing. I'll show it up and like people freaking out.
Like what the hell is this? What the hell is this? And then we saw like people also saw in like Albany, New York and like Minnesota. And we're like, what the hell is going on? That's weird. And so this is in the middle of the night, middle of the nine, 46 PM. 9.3 PM, because I have the video like tagged. And then because we're eventually figuring out how it's like apparently it's Starlink launched like 58 new Starlink satellites. And when they launched them, apparently they launched them like ducks in a row. And they, they start very close together. But over time they spread out, but like it took us forever to get there.
And also that's what they say allegedly. Like it's a very, very like coincidental cover up story. And then the next thing that happens is that we see again, exactly 24 hours and two minutes later, when we go back to the cabin, we're sitting out on the beach under the by the campfire. And we see it again, we're seeing it again. It was one of the most like, it's just Elon Musk messing around with it, not aliens. Rich people playing rich people games. I guess. Yeah, I guess so. But you know what? This is, this is not going to become a UFO truth or podcast. I hope David unless you are like, what's the probability now?
You think this was a UFO versus Elon? I mean, I would expect. So when we, we were up there, we were like, okay, we're going to get back to like civilization tomorrow. And like either aliens are going to be here or we're going to have like a rational explanation for this and aliens are not here. And no one has else has had its not Starlink. So like I'm going with Starlink. All right. Well, bankless listener, if you've, if you've heard this story of other information for David to, to feed his alternative ideas, then please send it over to us. But we're going to get to crypto right now first thing on the menu.
Yeah, you remember crypto, the other big conspiracy theory out there. The tornado chill, tornado cash. Just got a little bit colder and bad things happening. But also some good things happening. Maybe a page is turned and people are fighting back. We're going to talk about that. David, what else we covering? TribeDow is shutting down. There's a proposal from the TribeDow team to shut down and call it a day much to the consternation of the tribe community. So we're going to cover that and like how the proposal actually looks like to wind the thing down. And then BitBoy, you know, you know, BitBoy is crypto's biggest YouTuber account filed a lawsuit on a, against another YouTuber who made a video of him talking about him being a scammy pump and dumper.
And then BitBoy files a lawsuit of like citing like defamation and like destroying BitBoy's business. And then all of crypto Twitter, right, and shows up to defend this other YouTuber who's not a crypto YouTuber who made this video about BitBoy. So we're going to cover all of that drama and this and Kobe, who just yeeted $100,000 to help defend this innocent crypto YouTuber. Hi, drama, hi, drama in crypto Twitter this week. Awesome. I think we also have some merge updates. Of course, some coming up from the Ethereum foundation to you. So a date is definitely being proposed. A speaking of dates that are proposed as a date of a conference that's coming up.
Our friends and sponsors SmartCon. This is a conference by Chainlink. This is a crypto web three conference. Look at these speakers, David. This conference is absolutely stacked. I'm a child virtually the past couple of years. This time it's in person. It's physical. You know, I won't be there because it's a physical conference. But everyone else should go. I'm the weird one because who do we got? Let's go into this conference, David. Yeah, we got Eric Schmidt, former CEO of Google. We have Sergei Nazaros, of course, founder of Chainlink. A biology recently had him on the podcast. SBF, Ed Felton from Arbitrum, Stony from Ava, MN from Avalanche and a totally from Salana, Kane from Stendetics.
And so this is the first time that SmartCon is actually in real life. And so previously it's been in virtual every single year. But this is in real life. There is a link in the show notes to get a ticket if you so choose to go and also a code bankless to get a hefty discount if you also want a hefty discount, which why wouldn't you? H hefty discount. This is for you for the bankless community. Just type in bankless and get that discount to a gift from the folks at SmartCon. Thank you for that. All right, David, let's get to the markets today. Bitcoin. I'm seeing some red candles. Yeah, I'm seeing some down.
Red candles. Yeah, right after we recorded the weekly roll up last week. So like when bankless listeners open up the weekly roll up Friday morning, like all of our numbers are all bad. It was all bad. Yeah, it happened like, yeah. And so let's see, Bitcoin started the week at 23,000 and a half, 23 and a half thousand dollars, ending the week at 21.6 thousand dollars, down 8.2% on the week. Oof, oof. That doesn't feel good down almost double digits. And ether, I think, is down double digits, yeah, started the week at 19, 20, ending the week at $1,700, where we are now, down 11.4% on the week. David, what happened to my merge straight, man?
Did it start last week? No, it's fine. It's fine. We're back 14 days. We're back 14 days. Just back in time, 14 days, not a big deal. That's what happens when you're too zoomed too closely to this. But how about the eth Bitcoin ratio? Because that's a, that's a tell for whether an merge season or not. Yeah, we're started the last week at 0.0795 down to 0.0876. So down 1%. But if you look at the chart, like you zoom in, there's basically 0.08 went all the way down to 0.073 and then recovered to where it is now at 0.0787. So like, like went down a lot and then recovered a lot. And so to me, that like pressure, that by pressure to keep the ETHBTC ratio at its like local highs, I think is the merge trade.
That's kind of strange. Like what happened to you? That's merge strength, merge strength. What happened here? Like, why did this happen on Friday last Friday? This big candle down. I don't know. I don't know. Market's going to start. It happens. Market crypto does go down. Did you know? Sometimes on a daily hourly minute by minute basis, you know, it goes up and down. It's what they tell me. Sometimes they go down for an entire year. I'm back to David. Why do we even do numbers, huh, every week? How about the total crypto market cap while we're doing numbers? What is that looking like down from where it was last week?
1.16 billion, excuse me, trillion to where it is now at 1.086 trillion. So down what, what is that, 0.8 trillion on the week? Do you know, David, I remember time in total crypto market cap was $10 billion. Some people remember way like way like sooner than that. But like I remember the days like 2016 when Ethereum was like 500 million to a billion and like Bitcoin was just the big behem, it's so zooming out. This feels a whole lot better. Like $1 trillion. What a success. For crypto, over 90% of these listeners weren't here. That's sorry. But look at these things, you know, like, I don't know, we're back to crypto price.
I came in in June of 2017 and the total crypto market cap was $80 billion. See how silly is that? Now you're at a trillion. Wow. What a success. Wow. It's been very successful. Yeah. And June of 2017 was like kind of like pretty frothy at that time. We were well into the bull market. Yeah. I was just, I was a 2017 top buyer, certainly. Top buyer badge with pride. I think we all were, we've all bought some tops around here. That's how you learn in crypto. But it's talking about some dove studs. You want to talk about stuff a little bit, it's a little bit because some stuff's happening. Biden just okayed a sweeping student loan relief plan as midterm sneer.
That's a keyword as midterm sneer. Of course, right before. Of course. November. But also what's happening here, it looks like some debt forgiveness. Yeah, $10,000 of student debt is being forgiven for anyone who receives less than $125,000. So if you make $125,000 a year or less, you have $10,000 less of student debt if you had it. Just been eliminated. It's gone, gone, gone. They deleted the zero or the $10,000. If you had a Pell grant, you got up to $20,000 of student debt for low and middle-come borrowers who had a Pell grant. So cool. So I, so like, you know, a lot of people have student debt.
So add, like, multiply $10,000 by a number of people who make less than $120,000, $25,000 a year that who have student debt. Like, that's a large number. I don't really, I think there's that calculation in this article, but it's a pretty good number. It's funny, I mean, you just said cool. Some people think cool, and a lot of people who have student debt are like, this is cool. And, you know, you know, some people who don't, but they're just supportive of debt relief are also think this is cool. Some other people don't think it's very cool as well, right? This does remind me a lot of the PPP loans, though, which were loans for businesses.
Some small businesses got the funds. A lot of large businesses got the funds that were eventually forgiven during COVID. It kind of reminds me of that. And it strikes me that, you know, some of the people who got the money are generally in favor of this and people who didn't get the money aren't, right? And so like, it just feels like different constituencies are hooking, finding their way to hook into the money printer, right? And whether it's a good or bad thing, that's kind of beyond the scope of this podcast to consider. But what we are looking at is the money printer continues to go burr, right?
And one, you know, whether it's red or blue, one politician gets in control and rewards their constituency. And then another gets in control of rewards there through tax cuts or debt relief or stimulus checks or that sort of thing. I feel very much like, David, we're kind of losing the credible neutrality of the money printer through this process, though. And that is certainly a contrast with the crypto. David, you've got a meme here. I think this is the classic trolley problem. What are we looking at here? Yeah. So there's two like fights on this debate. There's like people, some people are sad that like they paid back their student loans.
And then then the student loan gets canceled and they're like, well, F, like I shouldn't have paid it back. I should have waited to just get it canceled. So there's like a, I think I thought a funny trolley meme here, trolley problem. And so the trolley problem, of course, traditionally it's there's one person on one track, five people on the other track. If you do nothing, if you don't divert the trolley, the trolley is going to kill five people. And so if you do something, if you divert the trolley by like switching the lever, then it only kills one person. It's a moral question as to like, do you take the action you as a person with agency?
Do you take the action to divert the trolley to kill one person rather than five people? In my mind, you absolutely do that. Even though you then become like a murderer technically, you also save five people. It's like net beneficial. Anyway, utilitarian, utilitarian. Yeah, this trolley, but there's also there's like an infinity number of like red renditions of the trolley problem. So this one, the trolley has already killed 10 people. And if you divert the trolley, it won't kill five people. It will instead kill zero people. And then the person who's like in control of the lever says, but if I divert the trolley now, that would be unfair to the people that has already killed.
I thought it was funny. I thought it was funny, me. Yeah, no, I get it. This is kind of the argument that's like, but you bring up an interesting question, David, about your ethics. I'm curious here. So have you ever played that like trolley problem game where it's like 30 different renditions of the trolley problem? Yeah, yeah. And then they start off relatively like easy, but then they get more and more like hard. Yeah. Okay. So there's like some that are very, very difficult, right? So like you got a baby on one side and then five people over 85 right on the other side and do you flip the switch?
Is it baby or do you let the trolley go kill five 85 year old people? What do you what do you decide in that case? Oh, am I am I on the stands here? Yes, I'm curious as my as my business partner in co-host. I know you're moral ethics, David. Oh, it's so big. You tell Terry and over here. So like the way that I would do this, if I was to do this, like how old are these people? 80, 80 years old. 80 to the 85. So like I don't know what the stats are. But the way I would come to determine this is that if you are 85 years old, what is your expected remaining years to live? And so like if you're expected remaining years to live is like eight, multiply that by five and you get 40.
And then you take the expected remaining years to live of the baby. And if it's greater than 40, then you kill the old people and save the baby. Okay, let me modify that. What if one of these 85 year old people are noble prize winning scientists on the cusp of curing cancer? What then? Oh, if you know they're on the cusp of curing cancer, then you absolutely kill the goddamn baby because that baby hasn't had any. He's sick. I can't believe I was like, if you kill, if you cure cancer, you in like re recreate like David, there's a lot of these problems. All right, kill the baby, Ryan. Kill the baby.
Oh my God. Do it. We're about to get sued by BitBoy or all sorts of different agencies here. Okay, my favorite one, which I think is the one that, okay, the most answers I answered with consensus. But the one that I didn't answer with consensus was, do you kill one human or five sentient robots? What do you do? Well, I've got to represent the AI side. So that's good because I also represented the robot, the AI side. Oh my God. Can we get back to crypto sentient sentience? Who am I to judge? You know, at some point in time, I guess maybe a eyes will be making these decisions for us. That reminds me of our episode with the machine that's coming up to relate the future a eyes of the world.
Please let it be known that if the trolley problem kills AI to like choose to save you, is that rock was ballast, right? You get a lot of use basil. Yeah. Yeah. It broke his vascular. Anyway, deep cuts so far on this. Deep cuts on this roll up. Maybe this will make the cut. Maybe you'll never hear this. Did you know, though? Okay. So we're just talking about Biden, more money printing, of course, more debt forgiveness. That is what it is. Here is a tweet from Jacob Franek who says a fed study finds that 60% of all US inflation over 2019 to 2021 was due to what? A demand for goods thanks to fiscal stimulus and other aggregate demand factors.
Right. What is student loan forgiveness? Is that is fiscal stimulus? Is that fiscal stimulus? Is that increasing everyone's net worth by $10,000? It puts more money in people's pockets, more perceived money. They're more willing to spend on other things, including meme stocks because they're probably millennials and also crypto, right, which is kind of an interesting byproduct, but there's a direct link between the money printing and fiscal stimulus, of course, and inflation, which is a problem, David, because the US is in the process, the Fed is in the process of trying to get inflation under control.
This is a chart from Pantera Capital. And this is showing the real 10 year treasury yield. Okay. So this is if you buy a treasury bond for 10 years, your real rate of return right now, that's the return of the bond minus inflation is negative six percent, right? Negative six percent, which David, would you buy this bond earning negative six percent per year, right? Right. So I feel like there's two rational ways to say yes to that question. If I emberish on the stock market and I think the stock market is going to go down more than six percent, then yes, I would buy bonds rather than have it in stocks, rather than have it in stocks.
Yes. What was the other one? I can't remember the other one is maybe you're the Fed, and you have to buy bonds to keep the entire because that's what's happening. That's the other rational outcome. What's actually happening is they're kind of running out of buyers, right? Because a lot of people are like, this is not a great deal with inflation running so hot. They're buying alternative assets. So the Fed has been buying a lot of bonds historically, of course. Anyway, it's a real quandary. And I think there's a juxtaposition between debt forgiveness, inflation, and also the real return on sovereign bonds.
And you contrast that with crypto. And this is the market we find ourselves in right now. David, there's also some energy price things going on. What's this? Yeah, this is a graph of the cost of a megawatt hour in Euro terms in Germany. I haven't been paying too much to the macro markets, except for like a tweet here and there talking about the commodities markets, which are looking bad and energy markets, which are looking worse. So just let it be known. We don't have time to go into it. And I'm also just not an expert. But energy in Europe is really expensive right now going to the start of the years.
Say, let's just pick an arbitrary point. It's like January 2022. The cost of a Euro megawatt hour was about like 80 to 100 euros for a megawatt hour. We are currently up to 313. So it's 3x in since this start of the year. So energy costs Europe going up. That's bad. And it's going up relative to euros in particular, which is kind of bad because euros are Europe is a next exporter net exporter of energy. So they don't have energy kind of backing their currency. The way Ruples do more on that in the Luke Rahman episode, which I think is a fantastic episode on that that we did. But David, we're talking about money printing.
SBF and FTX is definitely printing some money back in the bull run. It's not printing money if it's revenue. I guess so. All right. So some leaked financial data. How much was FTX making last year? In 2021, first off, before we get to last year in 2020, FTX was making just a measly below $90 million. You know, just below $90 million in 2020. In 2021, they were making over a billion dollars of revenue. So from under 90 million to over a billion in revenue, some insane profit margins, profit all with 27% operating margins. And then not only did they make just a ton of money in 2021, but they also made a ton of strategic acquisitions.
And so they have just like, like Sam Bankman freed an FTX just won the bull market, made a bunch of money, bought a bunch of businesses at a very cheap discounts because all of those businesses were distressed. So FTX really just won the bull market for sure. Yeah, they definitely did. And that's what they're doing by me. So distressed assets right now. David, this is interesting. I think we wanted to include this here because it seems like a layer two season might be a foot. Some more competition for alternative L ones, at least on the NFT side. This is a stat from a mutable X. What's a mutable X doing?
Mutable has passed a Lana in daily NFT sales volume in dollar terms. Now it is the only chain. It's the second chain with the most volume behind the Ethereum layer one. And this kind of just makes sense. Like a mutable is a NFT optimized platform. It's built for NFTs and for trading NFTs. And also with super cheap fees, kind of like Salana. So perhaps eating into Salana's market share, but also Salana overall is down in NFT trading volume. It was between like three and five million dollars in daily NFT trading volume back in June. Now it's down to one million dollars of daily NFT trading volume where IMX has now gone to like one and a quarter million dollars in trading volume.
This is one thing we predicted not sure if we're right on this thesis, but alternative layer ones will find themselves competing more with layer two as Ethereum layer two's than Ethereum directly. Maybe that's starting to play out now. It's also just a big plus one to the modular Ethereum thesis where specific chains that are custom built to do and perform specific activities are going to be better at those activities than monolithic chains who have to like have trade-offs because they want to do everything at once. Right. And here's a plus one to the bankless thesis. So maybe we've learned something this cycle.
As we always learn things, did you know that even in the midst of a bear market, crypto hardware wallets are up, up bigly. Okay. So ledger says their sales recently blew up since the health, the sales he has hacked by 4.5X, 4.5X, Trezer and SafePowl also up hefty sales figures. People are withdrawing their funds from centralized exchanges. They're taking sovereignty of their own crypto, taking their own keys, they're going bankless and they're buying hardware wallets. And that's on the back of centralized exchange failure. This is a good thing, I think. We are learning our lesson and we are getting more people to go bankless.
I'm kind of bullish on this actually, David. Of course. This is, I mean, this is how the crypto industry learns. We learn through pain. So when something bad happens, when everyone gets like a punch to the stomach, they're like, I didn't like that. What can I do to not have that happen to me again? And hardware wallets are definitely a solution. Absolutely. Get more resilient as time goes on. David, got a lot more to cover in the next section. What are we going to talk about? Oh my God. So much first coming up next is the freezing, the chilling effect of the tornado cache. But we also got some thawers on the horizon.
People trying to stop the freezing and thaw things. Am I drawing out this metaphor too much? I don't know, probably. But in addition to that, the tribe down trying to unwind, trying to shut down proposal from the tribe down team to just call it a day with tribe and the community backlash as a result of that. And also bit boy, so is a YouTuber, but the entire crypto community, the entire crypto Twitter community shows up to defend that YouTuber. So we're getting to that drama, which is some juicy drama. And more right after we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that help you go bankless, rocket pool is your friendly, decentralized Ethereum staking protocol.
You can stake your eith with rocket pool and get our eith in return, allowing you to stake your eith and use it in defy at the same time. You can get 4% on your eith by taking it with rocket pool, but you can get even more by running a node. Rocket pool is the only staking provider that allows anyone to permissionlessly join their network of validating notes. Running a rocket pool node is easier to set up than running a solo node and you only need 16 eth to get started. Why would you do this? You're getting extra 15% staking commission on the pool to eat. So your API is boosted. So if you're bullish e-staking, you can increase your API and get some extra tokens by adding your node to the decentralized rocket pool network, which currently has over 1,000 independent validates.
It's yield farming, but with Ethereum nodes, you can get started at rocketpool.net and also join the rocket pool community in their discord. You can find me hanging out there sometimes in the chat. So I'll see you there. Lens Protocol is an open source tech stack for building decentralized social media applications. It is the new era for social media. We all have toxic relationships with our Web2 apps. We want to break up with them, but we can't. These applications own our digital lives and all the relationships that we've made. We need to break through to a new paradigm of social networking applications that we control rather than them controlling us.
Lens isn't a social media app. It's a protocol to let 1,000 Web3 social apps bloom. Lens is a permissionless and transparent social graph that is owned by the user. In crypto, we say not your keys, not your crypto. And on lens, we say not your keys, not your profile. With lens, your followers go with you to whatever social media application you want to use. And instead of being trapped by an algorithm chosen by that app, Lens lets you choose the way you want to experience your social media. All right, guys, we are back more on tornado cash. The more on the OFAC sanctions, of course. As you know, OFAC sanctioned for the very first time, smart contracts on Ethereum, the tornado cash, smart contracts last couple of weeks.
We've been dealing with and talking about the fallout from that here, one of the fallup items. This is in the negative section. There's also some positive things we're going to talk about. But what is this first headline we're looking at, David? So post-merge, a lot of all of the Ethereum clients are going to have this thing called MEV boost kind of plugged into it, like a little bit of a sidecar that's produced by flashbots. And this is something that is first an accessory to the Ethereum protocol, but then later becomes integrated into the Ethereum protocol. Basically, it's a precursor to a proposer builder separation.
And it allows Ethereum stakers to just receive pre-created blocks from MEV boost, from these people called block builders who are building blocks, which are kind of a computationally intensive thing to do. And then these block builders just propose these blocks to proposers, e-stakers, proposers or e-stakers. And then e-stakers take these blocks, and then they just like, oh, I'll take that bit associated with that block, and I'll propose that. This service is going to be created by this thing called MEV boost. But sadly, flashbots has a US centralized entity, and they stated that they plan on complying with OFAC regulations because they don't want to go to jail, like relatively rational.
And so as a result of that, that's one of the big conversations that trigger this Ethereum censorship conversation saying, oh, well, if flashbots is going to be maintained OFAC compliance, or almost doing censorship at the protocol level, and as a result of that, flashbots has accelerated the open sourcing of MEV boost and their relayer so that more people can participate to remove some of that censorship. But the point here is that flashbots as a centralized regulated entity is not going to go toe-to-toe with OFAC, and they will be complying with OFAC. I actually wouldn't necessarily classify this as a tornado cash chilling effect.
I would actually straight up saying like, they would otherwise be in violations. And so you can't really blame them, like I wouldn't say like, no, oh, tornado, excuse me, no. Flashbots people, you gotta go to jail for us. But it's also stuff we don't like. Yeah, definitely. And there's two things for this. One, if you still have more questions on MEV boost or flashbots, go to the episode that we released earlier this week on flashbots. You'll understand all of that. We actually recorded that episode before all the tornado cash stuff happened. So we weren't able to ask the censorship resistance questions.
But if you're wondering how this affects Ethereum's long-term protocol censorship resistance, listen to our episode coming out with Justin Drake this Monday. New Drake dropping. It's so good. Okay, this is our episode. I think we called it Ethereum uncensored and he classifies this problem. The problem of flashbots and block builder censorship as a form of weak censorship attack, weak sensor attack. And so he goes to the difference between weak and strong and shows what the mitigators are. Anyway, fantastic episode. If you're worried, like I am, when you read a headline and you're like, flashbots is blacklisting well as what does this mean?
You've got to do your research. Listen to both of those episodes coming out on bank lists. We could talk a lot more about that, but there's more FTX. If this is actually a tornado cash chilling effect, as in this did not need to happen, this is not, no one is forcing FTX to do this. So there's a layer two, similar to tornado cash in terms of the tech stack it uses. But also different, more advanced in some ways. We talked about a lot. It's called ASTECH. And FTX actually froze a user account who sent coins to ASTECH's ZK money. ASTECH, of course, was not on any OFAC sanctions list. Does use similar technology, it preserves your privacy on chain, it's only in layer two.
And then now here's a crypto exchange saying while it's can no longer, like our users can no longer withdraw to ASTECH. Big problem. Flashing red light. What do you think about this, David? Yeah, yeah, this is like, this is like an unforced error, I would say. Like, if we're going to be in crypto, can we live by crypto values, which is to not censor, like a minimum viable censorship that doesn't make operators of FTX and others go to jail. And so ASTECH, you can just go and use ASTECH right now. You're not violating any laws, you're free to do so. I'm not a lawyer, but I'm pretty sure that's true.
And so the fact that we are banning people that are using ASTECH before, just because it is privacy services is like against the ethos of crypto, we didn't need to do this. Is it bad? Yeah, this is part of the chilling effect. ASTECH also responding by implementing some practical deterrence and measuring their effectiveness. This is a tweet from ASTECH and I understand why they're putting this out there, they want to say that they're doing something, but I don't like it, David. Look at this. I don't like that they have to do it, yeah. I don't like that they have to do it or they feel like they have to do it.
This is all part of the chilling effect. They're doing some IP specific deposit rate limiting, they're looking at people's IP addresses and trying to rate limit how much you can deposit. Nothing else. This has a throttling effect to how many people use ASTECH and the scale of what ASTECH could be. This is a throttling effect for privacy for everyone in the world and massive problem. And let it be known that if you are North Korea or a highly motivated actor, you can get around all of these things, except for the system-wide daily asset deposit caps, which they mean you know no more than 1,000 ether can go into ASTECH on a daily basis, other than that.
It actually just makes it have more friction for individual people like you and me. And it's annoying for somebody like North Korea, but it's not going to stop them in the slightest. David, have you seen that meme of like, there's a guy, there's like a sidewalks? Yeah. Okay. That's like a six inch wide or the six feet long barrier that has no barriers on either side. And it's like banning North Korea. Yeah. And so it's like North Korea is obviously just going to route around all of this as they usually would. So the only group that you're punishing are law abiding privacy-seeking individuals, which is a big problem.
But let's keep moving the data. But it's not ASTECH's fault. That is O-Fax fault. Yeah. Yeah. I get that. I get that. It depends like I think there's a spectrum of how much you react to the chilling effect, right? I don't want. Look, people can't code from jail. We can't do a bit the bankless podcast in an orange suit, right? So like we got to we got to stay out of jail in order to continue this stuff. And yet we don't have to be over compliers either. And so I'm not sure what the line is here, but there is a line here anyway. The fight continues. But what is happening with Uniswap labs? Yeah.
More wallets are being banned from TRM labs, which the Uniswap front end and other front lends used to block band addresses. So 253 crypto wallet addresses over the last month have been banned. They have been claimed to belong to criminals and hackers or interfere with US government sanctions. So DeFi front ends getting harder to use for, well, 253 addresses. And you know, Jake Turvinsky says he doesn't blame organizations for doing this at this point in time. Again, because of the chilling effect. If you want more of the mitigators for front end kind of bands, then listen to that Justin Drake episode.
He walks through all the ways we can solve this as a community. But also David, the developer, Alex Perthsef, who was arrested by authorities in the Netherlands is still in jail, right? Okay. So he's been in jail now, I think for 12, 13 days, and a judge just ruled that he will spend the next 90 days in jail as well until there's a hearing. No charges have been laid. No charges. Why are you supposed to hire a legal defense if you don't have charges? It's unbelievable. How do you go to court without charges? They tried to hit his lawyers, apparently tried to make bail and bail was denied. Again, no charges, right?
It's just like there's, there's the new process. I don't know. I don't know what's going on. Anyway, some people are protesting this as they should be. There are some ways to get involved too. So some people are literally protesting in person. You know, this is my tweet. The judge just ruled that Alex must stay in jail, Alex wrote some open source privacy code to public good. If you bad guys used his code, so they put him in a cage who's next, Vitalik, Tim Berners-Lee, we're going to rest the creator of TCP IP in the internet. So I think we need to get loud as a community. And there are ways to do that.
There's a website called setaluxfree.nl where you can join a sign of petition, join a telegram group, donate in various places, and start to speak out because we at least need to know what he's being charged for. If they don't have a charge, they need to let the guy free because it looks like they're just putting him in jail for writing code. How is that permissible in any free, open, democratic society? Yeah, there better be a real good reason why that guy's in jail, otherwise it's completely ridiculous. And also scary. So protest happening as well. But David, there's also some good news for the story.
The farers coming to the rescue. OK, let's just imagine people with flamethrowers, just like flamethrowing the tornado cache chilling effect. That's what's going on here. So representative Tom Emmer, who we've had on the podcast, tweets out, I sent a letter to Secretary Yellen regarding the unprecedented sanctioning of tornado cache. The growing of the adoption of decentralized technology, we're certainly raised new challenges for OVAC. Nonetheless, technology is neutral and the expectation of privacy is normal. Oh, wow. I like that one. The expectation of privacy is normal. Thank you. Thank you.
And then this is what this guy's Ryan Sean Adams says, thank you for standing up to privacy representative Tom Emmer. But he is not the only tornado cache flamethrower of the chilling effect. Matthew Green, who we've also had on the podcast, he says on Twitter, I made a GitHub organization to republish a fork of tornado cache repositories that were banned following the Treasury's sanction order of the other week. So there's tornado cache code back up on GitHub. New GitHub repository with tornado cache because all that is is open source code. Matthew Green, nice job. Third, tornado cache flamethrower, anti-chilling effect, thar person, tether.
Tether, that's unexpected. Yeah, tether. Tether holds firm on a decision to not freeze tornado cache addresses, awaits law enforcement instruction. So basically saying, hey guys, we're not going to freeze those, but come talk, we'll come talk. Send us a reason, like, give us a court order, they're not falling victim to the overcompliance trap. I will say though, tether has like blacklisted, I think like 10 to 50 times more addresses than USDC has, it's been around longer and it's had a higher market cap longer than USDC. So yeah, asterisk there. Definitely, ultimately, David, as we get into the Justin Drake episode, our greatest defense is the layer zero, right?
And if there is some sort of censored version, OFAC sanctioned version of Ethereum versus an unsensurable original Ethereum, which one of the core devs going to support? Which one is the Ethereum community going to actually develop software for and actually want to use? This is a quote directly from the last core devs call from one of the core devs of Ethereum. He says this. If we allow censorship of user transactions on the network, then we basically failed. This is the hill that I'm willing to die on. We start allowing users to be censored on Ethereum, then this whole thing doesn't make sense.
And I will be leaving the ecosystem. Who's going to work on your OFAC sanctioned Ethereum version? Chills. It's not going to be the core devs of Ethereum. That's for sure. Right. Yeah. That's a really good point. If OFAC wants an OFAC compliant version of Ethereum, they need to build all of that infrastructure from themselves, because no Ethereum core devs are going to be like, OK, yeah, we'll just build OFAC compliance into our censorship-resistant blockchain. Ethereum.gov, baby. Let's go. Let's do it. Build your own blockchain if you want to sanction one. China's doing it. Why can't the US do it?
Yeah. Go do it. This is Marius on the Geth team, Geth, probably the most important piece of Ethereum infrastructure that exists. Bullish. Bullish. I think BullishLayers0, David. Yep. Let's move on to the next story. What are we talking about here? Yeah. So this is the FAY fallout of the FAY doubt. So the title of this article here is that the FAY community is up in arms over the disillusion plan. And so, citing technical financial and future regulatory risks, the team behind FAY says it's ready to call it quits. They make a proposal to the Dow, but that proposal would only partially repay $80 million of the Rari hack, which is now the Rari FAY, for Rari, remember that whole thing.
So Rari Dow, Rari got hacked to $80 million, and there's plenty of funds to pay back these hack victims in full, but according to this proposal, this proposal pays back the tribe token holders, hence this is the tribe team. And only pay back the hack victims partially. At the peak of the bull market, the FAY market cap, the FAY stablecoin, was over $800 million. Now, it's just $140 million, a comment from Sam Cosmani, founder Fracks, says it's a new low for DeFi. So, an important part of this story is that back in May, holders of the tribe token, the entity's governance token, all voted to make the community whole after the Rari hack by repaying the bad debt on behalf of the hacker, but the specifics would be hammered out later.
And then when this specifics were actually hammered out, the team, with the majority owners of the tribe token, the actual centralized team, voted no, and the team said that, well, the original vote was non-binding, since it didn't take place on chain, uff, big lame, big lame. Okay, so going into the actual details of the proposal for the wind down of the FAY Dow, which is coming out of the FAY team. There's three phases, a consolidation phase, a fuse hack repayment phase, and then a final redemption phase. Basically consolidation is just like a liquidity phase, it's like, let's just sell all the assets and get as much as liquidity as possible.
The current account ownership, asset ownerships of the FAY Dow, the tribe Dow, 50,000 state eth, 22,000 eth, that 22,000 eth is going to be converted into die using balancer, that 50,000 state eth because it's illiquid, is going to be distributed to tribe token holders pro-rata because they can't sell that, so they're just going to distribute the state eth. There's 18.7 million LUSD from the liquidity protocol, it's going to be converted to die using periodic trades on balancer or curve, and then so that will be retained by the Dow temporarily, and then they have some other assets, 1.5 million in VEBAL, which is going to be traded OTC for FAY, tribe or BAL, 1.
5 ohm, traded OTC for FAY, tribe or die, and then there's some liquidity, fox tokens, and index tokens, which I mean very small amounts. And then, so after a lot of that staked eth, it's distributed to the tribe token holders, you have FAYs too, which is the fuse hack repayments, which of the remaining assets in the ore, any of the assets that can be converted to die, that 22,000 eth, and also that 18.7 million LUSD, that will be used to, whatever's left will be paid back to the fuse hackers, and then there's the final repayment, which all FAY becomes wrapped die, so if you are FAY holder, you basically become a die holder, tribe becomes redeemable for a pro-rata claim on all the remaining assets, after setting a side die for backing FAY, and then that's basically it.
Well, what kind of sucks about this is it feels like it's like, at least with BlockFi, depositors didn't get a haircut, equity holders got a haircut, and it seems like in this case, the people who are depositing into Rory in this case, which was later merged into FAY, which is like what you're talking about, FAY and tribe is where this is all coming from, they are not getting protected, they're getting protected after all of the tribe equity holders. Yeah, the tribe equity holders are like, I choose to pay myself. Yes, and not the hack victims. Oh, and there was a governance proposal that said that we should help the hack victims, but it's not binding.
It's not binding. No, that was a fake one. So it's just, I'm with Sam, this is just kind of, look, I don't know all of the details of this, so I hazard to talk too much about it, but in general, this doesn't strike me as a good thing or a good precedent to hit, or the right thing. This goes back to our episode with HaSue, invests a protection rights kind of suck, and so do depositor rights. And so it's very much like caveat ematures, like buyer beware when you're doing this kind of stuff. This is something that like, when we take this to like, tradfy, tradfy is better than defy on this particular scenario, traditional equity, equity holders rights, like, DeFi failed here, because we don't have this, like, exactly, yeah, like this is something that like, when we show to Gary Gensler, Gary Gensler is like, oh, this is great, this is good for me.
I get to regulate this more. Yeah. This makes Gary Gensler right, but he's wrong, because he wants to fix it, the Gary Gensler way, which is like, maybe sings on it, but there's more ammo, yeah. Yeah, there's also, it gives him more ammo for sure, but so I'm disappointed with that, like, not with a wind down and them choosing to quit, but I'm disappointed with them not helping the fused hack repayments, but I'm more disappointed, macroly, in like, the class of 2021, David, DeFi builders, I'm not throwing everyone under this bus, but there have been a lot of them, and there have been a lot of DeFi builders that I feel like have abandoned their projects, just like, orphan them.
Things got a little tough, right? It's like going got tough and they folded, yeah. I feel a little bit like DeFi grandpa over here is saying, pack in my day, room, prison, and make room down, didn't quit when they go and got tough, but that's a bit how I feel, I just want to say, rather than calling out some of the DeFi projects that did abandon, founders that did abandon their projects, I just want to give a shout out to all the DeFi founders that didn't, even when the going got tough, and there are a lot of them, I created a thread where the community kind of tagged a lot of people here, and that gave me some hope that, you know, a lot of DeFi founders stayed with their projects, did not choose to abandon.
I mean, ultimately, I don't understand why DeFi founders are taking this shortcut, reputational shortcut, when we're at the very first stages of a multi-decade industry, of like, you're going to abandon your project, like, people are going to remember that. I know I'm going to remember, bankless community will remember, and it might make it a little bit hard to re-enter after you've done something like this. That's all I'll say. DeFi grants over. The sad part is, is that Ether is actually like a lucratively bullish asset that if you exit into Ether, you still get so much upside. So I think that's where a large amount of the incentive comes from.
It's like, oh, if I like abandoned my project, I'll have enough Ether to stake for life. It's the same story, David. We saw this in ICOs, right? A whole bunch of them just kind of did an ICO, and they have asked their project, but then they kept all the Ether, right? But also, I would like, yeah, it's people that like, take money too early, right? That's another problem of DeFi is like we fund people with way too much money way too soon. And they're like, wait, but I just made all the money. Like, what? That was the point. I'm done here. Oh, I know. We've got to work on that for sure. David, next thing though, is the BitBoy story.
Okay. So I don't watch BitBoy at all. I've never seen, I've never seen a BitBoy. I've heard of him by reputation. So let me just say that. He gives some people some context for who BitBoy is. I get the sense that there is a whole another world of crypto YouTube out there. We are barely YouTubers, by the way. If you're listening, if you're watching this on YouTube, we are Godcasters who put our stuff on YouTube. We try our best, all right? We're like, we're not YouTube optimized yet, although we're getting better, right, David? Yeah, we got some stuff better. But anyway, BitBoy was purely crypto YouTube.
And what was he all about? What was his platform? Yeah, he's got an insane following. I think he's got something like over a million followers. I called him, well, I participated in some of this drama. I commented on a DJ and Spartan sweet thread calling him like the Alex Jones of crypto. And maybe we could get the editors to actually play that clip just a small showcase of who he is. He's got this insane setup, like just like a stupid media studio office thing, kind of like how Alex Jones does. And then makes them just like very ridiculous statements about crypto, like the one we're about to play right here.
I want to be very clear on this. The US government is 100% behind the crash of USD. Anyways, very bombastic, dude. And also it totally can completely known for just like dumping on his followers. That's the, I don't want jumping on his followers. Signing deals, receiving tokens, pumping the tokens and then selling the tokens. Like that's just the general pattern. And like I don't know this because I watch him personally. I know this because that's what everyone in my sphere like comments on. And so it's to the point of like, why would I ever go watch BitBoy? Like, yeah. Anyways, so that's the start of the story.
So here is a thread from a Twitter handle tagged Atozi, ATOZY. And he puts out this thread that says, I wish I didn't have to make this thread, but I'm being sued by YouTuber BitBoy crypto for a video I made roughly nine months ago covering how he promoted a project named PAMP, P-A-M-P. It's called LAP. Yeah. Last night, a third server, like somebody who like, I listened to this guy's YouTube video, he got served three different times. And the third person finally actually showed up with the real lawsuits. What? And according to his house, yeah. The first two were just like drafts of lawsuits.
The third one was the actual lawsuit. And so this crypto YouTuber, he made this YouTube video about BitBoy. It was like a journalist like, yo, this guy dumps on his followers. He like promotes, makes promotions. And then these tokens rug. And so like this whole PAMP token like pumped, and then it went to zero after like BitBoy covered it. And I think this is just like one of many, many, many things that BitBoy has covered. And so Ben Arthrong, aka BitBoy says, Erling Mishing, Jr., which is Atozi posted a video on YouTube entitled, this YouTuber scams his fans, BitBoy crypto in November 2021. I'm reading out the details of the BitBoy fired lawsuit right now.
The lawsuit claims a laundry list of offenses in that video, including defamation, inflection of emotional distress, torturous interference with business relations or potential business or potential business relations, violation of the uniform, deceptive practices act, and violation of the fair business practices act. And so this is BitBoy suing Atozi for these things. And also Tozi did was like talk about how BitBoy pumped this token and then dumped the token and doked went to zero. And so what you can see on chain, you can see it all. It's back totally, totally odd. It's not speculation. And so this Atozi person, he's not like, he's just a normal YouTuber.
So he doesn't have the money to fight this lawsuit. So this is BitBoy who makes bajillions of dollars pumping and dumping tokens again allegedly. I'm pretty sure it's true, though. Oh, David's. I'm going to be showing up at our house. Yeah, you're going to see a GoFundMe for another BitBoy lawsuit. Anyways, BitBoy coming in hard with like paying a ton of lawyers to like slam this guy with a bunch of lawsuits that he can't afford. So this crypto YouTuber Atozi spends up this GoFundMe with a $50,000 goal to defend him from BitBoy's lawsuit. And this is when it gets into crypto Twitter. And crypto Twitter doesn't like BitBoy.
No one likes BitBoy, except for YouTubers or YouTube consumers who probably don't know better. And so crypto condom excuse the name. This is actually like a crypto community member. He's pretty good. Says I will be donating to Atozi's legal fees related to BitBoy's lawsuit. If you have the means, I encourage everyone else to donate to scammers like BitBoy are a net negative to the space and should not be supported. If we don't believe our police ourselves, no one else will. And so this is when this GoFundMe starts to actually gain some traction. And then coming up next Kobe tweets out, I'll send $100,000 later or something when at PC.
And then that gets $8,000 likes. And then Toby follows up a little bit later, says scent. And yes, Kobe actually did send $100,000 to this crypto, non crypto YouTuber, normal crypto YouTubers just like Ethereum address. I'm assuming Ethereum address. And so what happens next? What happens next, Ryan? Is that BitBoy drops the lawsuit? And so this is Austin some capital saying hearing BitBoy succumb to social pressure and announced he's dropping the lawsuit. Can anyone verify? And then the next week says yes, indeed. And so here's the clip that BitBoy said where he's on his own like YouTube channel saying I'm dropping the lawsuit.
Okay, where rad is at this point, it has become public. It's become an absolute defaq. We know Kobe gave him $100,000. So, you know, hopefully that money will go to good use. But yeah, so we are going to drop lawsuit 100% and I'm sorry, this became public. Ryan, you want to know my favorite quote from this little clip here? Yeah, give it to me. Where BitBoy says I'm sorry, this became public is what he says. I'm sorry, I was found out to do frivolous lawsuits to allow myself to continue to dump on my followers. Okay, but yeah. David, here's one thing that doesn't connect to me. This feels like, you know, victims keep going back to their abuser.
Why does this why does this person have YouTube views? Why does he have followers? Why do why do people like why do people do subject themselves to this? So like look at the production value of this like of BitBoy, right? Like fantastic production value. No wonder he has a million views. He's optimized the YouTube algorithm. He's played the game. He's got his ads everywhere. He's got his like topics that he's run down. And like this kind of goes back to the heart of like crypto, I think where like there are some projects that like you have these open source developers that just care about code.
They don't know how to market. And then you have other projects which market themselves to the very end. And that's the product and they forget about the actual code development. This is the same thing. It's a BitBoy hyper marketing optimized. Knows crypto to enough extent to when people like, oh, like I would like to know about crypto, I'll go to the most number one followed crypto YouTube channel because clearly that's the best channel. And then they listen to BitBoy crypto who's like, PAMP token, it's going to PAMP. It's in the name. And then he's paid a promotion for that. And then token goes to zero.
And it makes a bunch of money. And then in Washington repeat because people like people these days have amnesia, they forget everything. I would say why do people go back to like their abusive relationship is because people have amnesia, Ryan, they forget. Yeah, I, you know, once commented that crypto, Twitter, crypto in general has the memory of the goldfish. You know, like we just like constantly forget things. But is this also a lesson that if bankless ever gets, if we ever get our stuff together and we increase our production value, people better like be scared. Okay, well, we do plan on increasing our YouTube production value.
David, he's looking back at his studio that he's just built and he's like, oh, what did I just say? Oh, I think we can do both. It just takes longer. You just got to not take shortcuts. Don't take shortcuts. Plus like the bankless community is intelligent. If we ever started, like pumping and dumping tokens, it would be over so fast. It wouldn't even take a half a second to like, oh, like, bankless went evil. They wouldn't, they wouldn't allow us to do that. It wouldn't let us do that. We would not zero so fast. Man, what a story though. That's crazy. My favorite part about this. So since they dropped the lawsuit, like, well, they made a tozi made $200,000 and he says, once I have it confirmed, it's officially pulled, I will be refunding everyone who donated.
And then Kobe says, use my money, my $100,000 to pay for the gas fees for a lot of people, the individual donators. But then also Kobe follows up and says, keep some for a vacation to smiley face. Kobe, good job. Well done. Hey, look, look, both of these lessons, right? It's like the last lesson is like, not take, don't take shortcuts. This lessons don't take shortcuts. Also, I love this, this concept of we can also police ourselves at the social layer too. We need to do much more of that in crypto and call these things out. So good job. A tozi YouTuber. Man, I am so not connected with crypto YouTube though.
This just shows me that I'm just living in a different world. David, what do we got coming up next? Oh my God, so much. Okay, merge updates. We got some merge updates for y'all. Of course, Uniswap is getting a brain. Queue that part of the Wizard of Oz, where the scarecrow says, if I only had a brain, there's a meme on that later. Between Nike and Adidas made $200 million in total NFT revenue. But one of them made a lot more than the other. So we'll get into which one may, which one won the NFT game in 2021. All of that and more. Right after we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors, then make the show possible.
Arbitrum is an Ethereum layer 2 scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Some of the coolest new NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home, while DeFi protocols continue to see increased liquidity and usage. You can now bridge straight into Arbitrum from more than 10 different exchanges, including finance, FTX, who will be in crypto.com. Once on Arbitrum, you'll enjoy fast transactions with cheap fees, allowing you to explore new frontiers of the crypto universe. New to Arbitrum. For a limited time, you can get Arbitrum NFTs designed by the famous artist, Ratwell and Sukoi, for joining the Arbitrum Odyssey.
The Odyssey is an eight week long event, where you can play on chain activities and receive a free NFT as a reward. Find out more by visiting the discord at discord.gg slash Arbitrum. You can also bridge your assets to Arbitrum at bridge.arbitrum.io and access all of Arbitrum's apps at portal.arbitrum.1. In order to experience DeFi and NFTs, the way it was always meant to be fast, cheap, secure, and friction free. ZK Sync is an Ethereum layer 2 network that is pushing the frontier of high performance blockchains that don't compromise on security or decentralization. ZK Sync has combined the power of zero-knowledge rollups in the Ethereum virtual machine, enabling developers to build the greatest Web3 projects possible once we haven't even seen yet.
crypto needs its killer applications to onboard the world, but crypto-killer apps need ZK Sync as a platform to build on first. It's generally accepted that zero-knowledge rollups are the conclusion of crypto blockchain scaling technology. And ZK Sync is leading the charge into the final frontier of crypto economics. So if you're a developer who wants to build your app on a future proof foundation, which gives your users the best UX possible, check out ZK Sync's website at zk Sync.io. And yes, there's also going to be a token, so give them a follow on Twitter too at zk Sync. TTA September 15th.
Not even a date range. Not even the 15th to the 16th. September 15th. Mark your calendar. David, is that the official date? September 15th. That is, well, no, because it's still an official TTD number, total terminal difficulty. So there is no official date that TTD number can hop around, but it's an official TTD number, which says the same thing. There's no new TTD number. The only thing that's new this week is that we have new client software that instantiates that TTD number into the clients. And so as soon as you update your clients, that TTD number goes into your client and then it's hands off from there, that the bell tricks activates and then later is the merge.
The current estimated merge time right now is 6.20am eastern time, Thursday, September 15th. This number has been hopping around. It used to be like 8am, then it hopped around to like 4am, and now it's at 6.20am, but it's looking like Thursday, early morning, eastern time, specific people, and also eastern people, you're probably going to be in bed. But this number will continue to hop around, but you know, zeroing in on Thursday, morning, September 15th. This link in the show notes is a script that actually calculates it based on the current hash rate. So you can always get the update on that.
Even though you know, bank is going to update you on a weekly basis. Yeah, we're going to talk about everything. This is going to happen until it actually happens because, as Dune Analytics says, the merge is coming, you're the top dashboards to follow the action. Anything here we should pick out, I guess maybe a link for people, a resource for people, if they want to follow the merge, there are a ton of dashboards from Dune Analytics where they can see the intricate details of all of the numbers that make up the merge. So anything here to point out, David. Yeah, all six of these dashboards are fantastic.
It's just a nice little command station to sing the merge. I don't really have anyone particular this favorite, but it just has a resource. These are available to you. You know, the bigger question, I think, is there is this rag of a publication, a, you know, a terrible newsletter, terrible, terrible newsletter. That post an article said, why would you ever publish this title of it? Is the merge overhyped? Who published this? Who are people who are not seeing on YouTube? This is bankless. Okay, this is a bankless article. We had our friend, Jordy Alexander. Do you remember Jordy Alexander? So he came out of time when everyone was just so frothy bullish about Tara Luna.
And he took the bear case of the very difficult, at the time, difficult position to take the bear case for Tara Luna at its peak. When was this April? Did we do this March? April something like this, like about a month before the terror collapse, essentially, and Jordy took the position that like, I know everyone's bullish on this thing, but there are a few tail risk events you really should look at. And I think they're fairly high probability. A month later, it's, it's completely beat up. And by the way, a whole but most people, a lot of people coming out of that debate thought Jordy lost the debate.
Yes. They all say that. Oh, yeah, I hose a the other guy to sexually sweep the floor with him. But then if you go back to the YouTube comments, they're all like, oh, like now. Oh, really? If you see the the chart, the chart of viewers on that video, you know, it's the normal curve. And then terror collapses. And it gets another huge bump because people went back and watched it. And so like the four month old YouTube comments are like, Jordy got railed by Jose. And then the three month old YouTube comments are like, oh, Jordy was right. Oh, Jordy got it right. Wow. Jordy was right. But here's this case.
We asked Jordy to write in a ETH bear article for us. ETH merged bear article because Steven and I could have brought ourselves to write that. All right, because we don't actually leave it. But fantastic article. And I think like anytime we have a thesis on something or bullish on something, we'd love to get kind of the counter to that or the the steel man case for why not. And I think Jordy puts in a fantastic steel man case. So a few things, by the way, this is full of fantastic memes throughout the article. But let me try to summarize some of his high level takes and get your reaction to this, David, as an ETH bull, right?
So one thing he says is that yeah, there's these three dragons to the triple happening to the ETH merge bullishness. One is reduced issuance. He says, yep, I understand that. That's pretty bullish. I get it. The second is EIP 1559 burn. And the third is locked staked ETH. Okay. So he's good with the reduced issuance. But he says burn has been down pretty bad. Okay, like look at burn over time. So because block space is in much lower demand than it was during DeFi summer and then later NFT, like the whole NFT boom. And then if you look at like this past summer, David, we're not even deflationary.
No, it's not deflationary. And so what's with your ultrasound money merge money if it's not even deflationary? That's what Jordy's saying. And there's not an indication he says that a positive catalyst ahead that will actually bring this block space demand back maybe goes to alternative layer ones. Maybe it goes to layer two's that don't consume as much block space revenue. So there's that. And then he also chips into the ETH staking rate. And he says it's actually a lot lower than a lot of people are saying. So he calculates the ETH staking rate at steady state in like 2023 to be closer to like one to two percent yield.
So in real terms, in real terms is what he's saying. In real terms. Yes. You stake your ETH and maybe you're getting like three or four percent. But then you have to subtract the issuance of ETH, which is maybe one and a half percent. So you're left with like one to two percent real yield. And he's like no one's going to be super excited about that. And he's calculating this based on a whole bunch of more people will stake. And so the yield goes down. And so maybe you'll get like 20 to 30 million ETH staked in the network. And I can't remember what it is right now, David. But it's like 15 million ETH.
I can't even remember. I shouldn't even say that. But it's a lot less now. And so these are some of his his bear thesis cases for why the word merge won't really matter. What was your take when you read the high level of this article? My high level article is that Jordy is making an argument against an outdated bull case, but like outdated stats. And so he's taking like May 2021 or November 2021 gas price of gas markets. And he's making the his argument that it's not bullish against that. And I mean, we have since then like, look at this. Sorry to the podcast listeners who don't see this. I'm not going to explain this one.
And so he's making like, yes, there was previously more bullish parts of the Ethereum economy. Gas prices used to be a lot higher. Therefore the Ethereum Merd burn used to be a lot more. And it's no longer the case. And I mean, since then we've adjusted the numbers, the yield numbers. Like if we had May 2021 gas prices, like we were looking at like a 15% yield on staking ether. And like we used to say that on the weekly roll up because that used to be the data, but that is no longer the data. And now we've adjusted down to where it is now at like 5.2% without MEV. And maybe perhaps maybe six plus percent with MEV.
But Jordy is taking the frame a slice of data that was in the bull market. And now, but also, and so that's the gas market thing. Now I will say that the ETH supply reduction is was always going to be more significant than the ether burn. Simply just like when you compare those things, there's less ether burn, less ether issued. That's the name of the bulls are bullish on how it's the supply reduction. Right. And so even at these like, even if you take the bear at most bearish gas fees, which is at like seven or eight percent, that goes from 0.43% ether issuance down to 0.2%. So the burn just lowers it by immediately 0.
2%. But it's cutting the issuance down by 50% because they already is so low. And so like that's still the bull case is still strong. And if you go and compare it to Bitcoin issuance at like 1.5% or Salona issuance and avalanche issuance at like six and seven percent, like it's still fundamentally bullish. It's just not ultra uber mega bullish that would have been if we had merged during like DeFi summer, for example. So that's the gas market thing. Did you see this argument? Yes. It's like, you know, one side, steak Death will be locked off the market. Yeah, you're super happy about this. But then you realize the unlock will hang over us for over a year.
Because everyone is essentially depositing their staking. And it's one way. But then there will be this big unlocking event, maybe a year from now. And all of that, you know, 15, 20, 30 million worth of ETH is suddenly unlocked. And his argument is the market's going to price that in ahead of time too. And that makes the case less bullish and maybe bearish. Sure. The market will price it in. But we need to make sure like are all the unlockers going to be sellers? Because I don't think that necessarily so. Like typically we use this word unlock or like investing, like investing unlocks for like angel investors or seed investors that got in at valuations one 10th or one 100th.
And so of the supply of the asset. So like, of course, they're going to sell. It doesn't matter what price it's at. They're going to sell because they're up so much. That's not the case with ETH. Like the average ETH or deposit price, I think is like 700 or 800 dollars. So like the average person is up at 2x. And so like, yeah, maybe it's obviously some people have had their stuff like illiquid for so long that they're going to sell. But I don't really think it's going to turn this into the systemic sell event when the APYs go up to by the way up from 4% up to like 5, 6, maybe 7% if MEP is really strong.
I don't really think they're like we use this term unlocked to be like, oh, investors unlocks are totally going to dump. That's not true with ETH or stakers. ETH or stakers are fundamentally bullish. So that's the whole point of proof of stake is that you reward ETH or holders who want to be long term holders. And so the people that stake their ETH or back when ETH or price was like 300 to 700 dollars. They're the people who are like, yeah, I'm fine with having my ETH or be illiquid for two years, three years, an unknown amount of time. They're fundamentally the most bullish ETH or owners there are because they take the illiquidity of it and they don't care about that.
So they're not likely to be sellers. So I don't really think it's fair to say that like all of these finally we get this big unlocking and everyone runs for the exit so they can dump their tokens. I don't see that happening. Well, anyway, I think we could have an entire episode. Oh, wait, no, I'm not done. We got one more point. We got one more point. And so his last argument is that the yields go down to a super low amount. Can you go to that part in the in the articles that like the if we have something like 30,000 ETH or staked and Ryan Ryan I pulled this up right now there's 14,000 ETH or staked.
If we get something like 30,000 ETH or staked, the issuance of Ethereum goes up because as more people stake, the more ETH or is issued to reward those people, the yield, the per validator yield goes down, but total ETH or issuance goes up. And so that's his argument that like, well, we have increasing actual ETH or inflation in decreasing yields for stakers. And so the yields are actually going to be way lower than people expect. But he's missing the part that the way to get to like 30,000 plus ETH or staked is 16,000,000,000 ETH or comes off the market and begins staking. And so like 16,000,000 ETH or comes off the market and begins staking.
And so he skipped over the bullish part of that, which is that a bunch of ETH or gets locked up. So you can't forget that bullseye. And that is my complete rebuttal of the bear case for the merge. It's not complete. Come on. You know, it sounded like David wants to get on a podcast with George and really hash this out and have a debate. But I also remember what happened to the last guy who did that. So maybe I'll keep the last guy I was defending Tara and I'm defending Ethereum. I do think if there's demand in bank list nation, if you guys are excited about this, let us know. Maybe we'll have a how press plus David plus Jordy plus another bear debate on this.
Maybe we'll get checked made in a scene or something. Anyway, a lot of discussion about this. And I think it's really fun to look at both sides of the argument. David, let's get to this. Uniswap has a brain. That's what you've been saying in the tease to this. What do you mean by this? How is Uniswap getting a brain? Uniswap uni governance voted overwhelmingly at 86,000,000 to 770. So like call it 99.9% yes, to create the Uniswap foundation. We've talked about this that precursors for this. There was a governance proposal and also a sentiment check. But now formal vote token snapshot vote has gone through overwhelmingly in support of creating the Uniswap foundation.
So what does this mean? What are the details of this? The blog post says there is work to do to help Uniswap reach its full potential. The governance process has too much friction. The ecosystem is too difficult to navigate and the UGP Uniswap governance process in its current form is not able to fund the most ambitious and impactful projects. We want to change that. Today we are excited to propose the creation of the Uniswap foundation which has the submission to support the decentralized growth and sustainability of the Uniswap protocol and its supporting ecosystem in community. Today we are thrilled to propose the creation of the Uniswap foundation and then some details scope, team, budget and governance participation scope.
The UF, the first foundation of a major protocol to go through the community governance process will support the protocol's decentralized growth, reinvigorate governance and serve as a protocol advocate. The team behind this is going to be Devon Walsh who will serve as executive director and Ken Eng who will serve as head of operations and they also have a team of 12 behind them. They've got some budget requests as well, $14 million of operating budget to cover a team for three years and $60 million expanded Uniswap grants program budget to cover three plus years. So they are requesting a total of $74 million from the Uniswap Dow which we broken up into two disbursements, a first disbursement of $28 million and lastly in governance participation also requesting $2.
5 million Unis to participate in governance primarily through delegation, through usage of a new smart contract premise called the franchiser and this Uniswap will be revocable by the Dow at any time and cannot be used for any purposes outside of governance. So Uniswap getting a foundation, nice. Okay so one question I have on that David is there's $74 million that's going to fund the Uniswap foundation. Where's that coming from? I would imagine it's got to be like uni token sales at some level from the Dow maybe. Yeah, if not already then future sales. I don't know. I don't know. That's one interesting thing to check into but like am I also understanding that so we have three pieces here.
We have the protocol right Uniswap itself which is not a legal entity or anything else it's smart contract code and then we have Uniswap labs which is the thing Hayden and team are doing that is venture backed that is continuing to buy companies and create tools for the Uniswap ecosystem and then now we also have this Uniswap foundation and their job will be to kind of steward the protocol itself a bit more and I guess grow it. Is that the model here? Yes exactly right and I've looked into the governance proposal it's all coming out of the Uni token yes so this is all funded by the Uni token.
So this will create some sell pressure I think in Uni in the short run. Now they're doing this in chunks like first distribution of 20 million and then kind of the remaining but also you could say bullish on Uniswap getting a brain. Yes that's like that's a bullish. Don't who cares about 20 million dollars of sales pressure that's a blip Uni token is actually pretty liquid. The point is is that Uniswap can be just more organized if you listen to our podcast episode with Hazu these dows need direction and centralization centralization is on a bad word and the foundation can do this. In addition to the two to Ken Eng and Devon Walsh we also have some advisors Jesse Walden from variant Julia Rosenberg from Oak from Orca Protocol Alexis Galba Galba from Open and Hart Lambert from Uma and then they also have already talked about some proposals that they're trying to get done which is building Uniswap in the chiral language for stark net and other things that like I think the Uniswap without a brain just might not have been able to get done.
So I think that is the reason why we should be bullish here is that you know execution execution matters. And if you're curious to why it doesn't have a brain why Uniswap labs is not necessarily that full brain. I think the Hazu podcast is the answer to your question but here's a nice meme. The scarecrow. Yeah. From the scarecrow from Wizard of the Oz even though there's that one song where the scarecrow's cut. It's only had a brain but this one is if I only had a foundation. This is every doubt by the way, a dancer. Okay, this is cool. This is a tweet from Blockworks but did you know David? This is another chart from Dune Analytics.
Nike and Adidas had NFTs last year. Nike revenue was $185 million. Donate them. Adidas was $11 million. But in total, like so Nike absolutely swamped the floor with Adidas. But think about how much money that is for Nike and NFTs. What do you think the cost of these NFTs were? Very little three million and five million. I bet you the biggest cost was legal. 10 million? Yeah. But think about these profit margins. So if you think that large corporations are just going to pass this by, pass up this frame opportunity. You don't understand. Look at that secondary trading volume of Nike and NFTs. $1.
3 billion of secondary trading volume. Crazy. You only have royalties on that. Look at these other brands too. Dolce and Cabana are here. Tiffany's here. Gucci here. Adidas here. Budweiser here. Time magazine here. NFTs. NFTs are just a fad. Never coming back. Look at that data. There's two columns. Primary sales revenue. $93 million for Nike. $92 million in royalties off of that secondary volume. Crazy. Crazy. Yeah. More companies are going to join this and NFT market will be back. I'm sure. But in the short run, we are seeing summer surgeons in some other classic non-corporate NFTs. Pudgy penguins.
Pudgy penguins. Pudgy penguins. I thought they were 10%. I thought they were 10%. As Meta and Nansen Executives join advisory board. Ryan Meta. Facebook. Yeah. Right. You want to hear a funny story, Ryan? Yes. You know when we were talking about how I was moving wallets from a while ago? Yes. Well, I'm also slowly doing that for my NFT wallet and just like getting rid of all these NFTs that I thought were dead. Yes. So I sold my Pudgies literally two days. No, you did. Before this happened. David. Oh, it was it was like perfectly ironic. It's like I sell these things just because like I don't really know what's happening with these things.
These are just some jokes. I would have seen they they're dead too. Yeah. And then like literally like out of nowhere. Like that has the biggest research in so far time. It was like literally the pico bottom. It was fantastic. It was quite you listen to bankless for your NFT alpha every single week. Cause Dave and I know what we're doing. We know we know what we're doing the JPEGs. Do you know we do know a little bit about DeFi and this is kind of a blend of DeFi plus NFTs. This thing called Bendow. Yeah. Which basically like I think of it as maker. It's like it's like collateralized loans backed by NFTs.
So but there was kind of a crisis last week with Bendow. What happened? Yeah. So Bendow NFT liquidity protocol. Of course you can put your NFTs into Bendow and borrow ETH against them. Some of the top NFT pro collections in there. Azuki's, Bordebioc clubs, clone X, crypto punks, doodles, mutinapes and space doodles. And the thing is is that once upon a time Bendow had about 18,000 ETH earlier last weekend and that went down to 15. Not 15,000, 15. Yikes. 15 ETH. It's currently back up to 4,500 as of a couple days ago. But basically what happened was that all of the ether you lend your ETH to Bendow and then you get a yield on that ETH.
Very strong yield. And then that Bendow lends out that ETH to people that collateralized their NFTs. You could get an 80% yield on your and your Ether because they were in such a short supply of Ether because all these NFT collateralization people were borrowing were borrowed up all the ETH. They used all the bandwidth. It's like if compound utilization, if compound has like $100,000 of USDC in it and then there's $98,000, 98% of that USDC is utilized. They're going to jack up the interest rates to incentivize people to pay back their Ether. So what's going on here is they jacked up the interest rates or yields paid to Ether lenders and they also what they did in order to fix this credit crunch they had is that they pass emergency parameters to progressively lower the liquidation threshold from 95% to a new baseline of 70% incoming in September 20th.
So it's going to go from where it is now at 95% to where it will be in the future at 75% or 70% basically like making liquidations more likely to happen. Increasing is like increasing the interest rates. The Bendow if it's like a maker Dow they're increasing the interest rates and making more strict capital requirements for NFT lenders so that they can pay back their loans and get Ether back into the coffers. I will say this is not a failure. This is actually quite the opposite. I would say this is a big success. It's so it was so successful that all the borrowers used up all the Ether and they just had to jack up the interest rates.
The first time the first time a maker Dow had to go through a cycle. Die was trading below a peg and they had to jack up interest rates from like 0.05% to almost 20%. I feel like this is this is the same thing with Bendow. It's like everyone's using the protocol. We ran out of like credit. We need to jack up interest rates so we can like get more money in the system. Yeah, but they almost they almost went insolvent in the process, right? So they they they bent. They didn't break but like they almost I wouldn't call it insolvency. They just had more loans outstanding than they can issue. They couldn't issue anymore loans.
They didn't have more enough money in the in the system. There is a great explanation if you want all the details from William Pester who does know a thing or two about NFTs in Metaversa and you can read through that. Ryan was joking earlier. We don't know shit about NFTs. I think one of the things though David is that Bendow is as definitely learned through this episode is that NFTs are not quite as liquid as maybe they thought they were. So it's one thing if you're selling ethos collateral in a maker type auction because you have to liquidate. It's another thing when you've got like 50 board apes and you're trying to find buyers for those things.
Of course, that's what makes them non fungible and lower liquidity profile in them right now. David Gensler's back. What's he saying now? He wrote a op ed in the Wall Street Journal. I read part of this. It was also pay world. Maybe there are a few choice tweets or choice quotes we can take out of it. But basically his take is there's no reason to treat the crypto market differently from the rest of the capital markets just because it uses a different technology. The facts machine and the internet are the same thing. That was my paraphrase. That's not his paraphrase that in part. But I feel like that's kind of what he's saying.
What are your thoughts on this David? He also made a video on this and basically he's saying like, oh yeah, like crypto markets, traditional equities markets, they're the same thing. Therefore, we should regulate both of them, which is a hot take. But also, you're trying to have your cake and eat it too. It's like you're saying you want to regulate the crypto markets. And therefore, we should treat crypto markets like the traditional equities markets. But then you're also not treating us fairly. And this is what Kobe said when he followed up and says, sounds good. Spot ETF then. Because if Kobe says or if Gensler says, okay, we're going to treat the crypto markets like we treat the traditional equities markets, that means we get spot ETFs.
That's what that means. And so he says like the SEC, according to Gary Gensler, should regulate the crypto markets just like they regulate the traditional equities markets. But then he also doesn't want to treat us like normally. So this is a standard at play. Huge double standard. There's a double standard. But he also doesn't understand that this is a much different technology. It's not like that. It's kind of like covering your eyes and plugging your ears and just kind of ignoring the differences between crypto and the traditional equities markets of which the differences are also vast. These are two different technologies.
It's fax machine versus internet. And I was definitely say that Gary Gensler is playing this narrative game. He knows they're not the same. He used to teach classes at MIT about boxing. So he's doing a PR stunt saying, hey, the SEC is going to regulate the crypto markets because they're the same as equities markets. There's no new magic here. The SEC is going to regulate this. It's just not hard. We can have a nuanced conversation about what pieces are the same because there are parts that are the same as the equities markets and what parts are different. Let's have a nuanced conversation about that.
And let's get some clarity. Mark Cuban had a tweet take two. He says to Gary Gensler who says there's no reason to treat the crypto market differently. Just come in and talk to me. Mark Cuban says, come in and talk to who? Set up an appointment. How? You use in calendar these days since you understand crypto lending and finance is why don't you just publish bright line guidelines? You would like to see and open it up for comments. We don't want regulation, legislation by Wall Street Journal op-ed. All we're asking for at some like just some clear treat us the same like you sign lines or even treat us the same and don't have a double standard very confusing here.
But seriously Gary, I'm on the podcast. I think the best way of clearing all this up is to engage with the crypto community. It's what you should be doing. We'd love to have you on bank lists sincerely. We've had Hester Person. We've had other CFTC regulators on. We would love to have Gary Gensler on pretty friendly. We could talk about this. Give us your perspective. David, you have a take here. The thing is people outside of the crypto industry have noticed Gary's lack of popularity. Also an article that came out in Forbes. I believe yeah, Forbes was titled Gary Gensler colon resign from a writer called Roslyn Layton from the international tech policy.
Not a crypto person. But Gary Gensler is like losing the public support like left and right. And so Gary Gensler got to win hearts and minds and you can do that by coming on bank lists. We don't want you to resign until you tell us what you really think about crypto and we can have a good conversation. First come on bank list. All right, David, do you know Coinbase's ENS integration is finally out in the wild. What does this mean? Yeah, so this is in the Coinbase wallet. I'm pretty sure not the coin normal Coinbase consumer app. But if you are a Coinbase wallet user, you get an ENS name built into that wallet.
So this is a user who's got debanked.cb.id. Interestingly, Ryan, not.eath. Did that catch your attention? There's no.eath. Yeah, but it is actually an ENS integration. And so from the article, it says on a technical level, both cb.id and.eath can be used on multiple networks. We determined that most users associate.eaths.id slowly with Ethereum. And so Coinbase chose cb.id because they want to make easier for people to understand that a user name is not tied to Ethereum and can be used on multiple networks. However, did you know, Ryan, that your.eath name can work in Bitcoin wallets and Litecoin wallets and Dogecoin wallets that is by run by the ENS standard.
And so Coinbase wallet is just like kind of making that a little bit more formal cb.id saying, hey, this can work for your Ethereum address, but it can also work for your Bitcoin address. It can also work for Coinbase. What's happening here? Coinbase is just giving these to all of its users. Yeah. Basically. Yeah. And all of its users who are using the Coinbase wallet. Users are becoming decentralized, either claim your current user name or decline and get a random 20 character user name. So you get your own ENS name. You get one by default. Yeah. That's cool. What is this extension though? The cb.
id. What is this? I think it's just means identification identifier. Yeah, but I know. But like, how are they getting a .id? Is this like I guess I just have something to do with DNS. And this is there's a DNS.id like a.com like a.org. Yeah. So another fun fact of ENS is that it's actually DNS compliant. It also operates with the traditional DNS system. And I think I don't know the details beyond this, but like the .id is a DNS thing. So you can actually Ryan go and type in this into into your URL. It worked. It took you back here. You already had the web page. You just sent me back to the same site.
But it works. So like if you have like this, this also works. Does it? I think that's also works. No, this doesn't work with David Hoffman dot ease. Does it? Debang. No, it doesn't work with David Hoffman dot ease. And that's why and so the .id name is a DNS name. And so that's why I have a deep browser. Exactly. It works in it. It works in your browser. Yeah. But it's not completely decentralized because there's still some DNS linkage there. I suppose. But whatever. Okay. Cool. That's cool. Can better swell. What is swell? Are they another staking provider? Yeah. Staking as a service provider, basically swell is a hybrid between rocket pool and LIDO.
So they have a permissioned validator set, which allows for capital efficiency. But they also have a permission list validator set, which allows for permission lists. And so they they had a testnet launch not too long ago. Now they have a guarded launch coming soon. And so swell network is coming out new staking as a service protocol. We've got to love that competition. That's awesome. Also more competition, of course, in later two world. So just a reminder, now I think there are five days is a five or four days. Five five days. Okay. Five days till Arbitram releases Nitro, which is the next release of Arbitram.
And of course, the TLDR is this is faster, cheaper transactions for you. If you're an Arbitram user, awesome to see later to use upgrading as well. David, speak of upgrades. You have an opportunity to upgrade your job right now upgrade your job. Okay. This is our reminder to you to what, David? Get a job in crypto because it's the most fun place to have a job. Absolutely. That's that's the rule. What could be more fun? Uh, number one job. I'm going to read some out for you. Uh, Missouri. It's looking for software engineer two software engineers, one for media, one for market data, dy dx, backend software engineer, stakefish, a business partner, HR, business partner, stakefish, a backend full stack software engineer, stakefish, front end software engineer, stakefish dev ops engineer, bankless.
We need somebody to run our podcast, edit the media operations boardroom lab software engineer, doubt governance, man to core labs, manager of crypto marketing, bankless needs a thread or a senior newsletter editor, marketing coordinator at bird text protocol. Lots more bankless academy needs a product manager. You can find out more of course. Look at all these from scrolling through them. Probably people that shop boards for all the people that watch the YouTube. I'm aware my dancing is extremely pretty. No one's ever said anything that I've seen, David. Must be great. I can feel it. All right, what's going on next?
Uh, coming up next, we got questions from the nation, which layer two are you most bullish on and why and also how can you explain the merge to normies and also, of course, some hot takes from crypto, crypto Twitter, the meme of the week and also a fantastic moment of Zen coming out from Gabriel Haynes. Uh, it's about BitBoy Ryan. Uh, so all of that coming up and more right after we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. Juno is bringing crypto friendly banking straight into your checking account. With Juno, you can send money from your Juno checking account straight onto a layer two like polygon, optimism, arbitrum, and they have CK sync and stark met support on their way.
You can skip the ACH wait times, you can skip all the gas fees and go straight from your checking account to an Ethereum layer two in seconds. Inside Juno, you can buy and sell crypto with zero dollar fees, and your Juno checking account comes with a metal massacre card that gives you up to 5% cashback on your spending. Juno, it's also giving you $10 cashback on your first crypto deposit and $100 when you set up a direct deposit. This ad just writes itself, so go sign up at Juno.finance slash bankless. The Brave browser is the user first browser for the Web3 internet with over 60 million monthly active users.
And inside the Brave browser, you'll find the Brave wallet. The secure multi-training crypto wallet built right into the browser. Web3 is freedom from big tech and Wall Street, more control and better privacy, but there's a weak point in Web3, your crypto wallet. And most crypto wallets are browser extensions which can easily be spoofed, but the Brave wallet is different. No extensions are required, which gives Brave browser an extra level of security versus other wallets. Brave wallet is your secure passport for the possibilities of Web3, and supports multiple chains including Ethereum and Solana.
You can even buy crypto directly inside the wallet with ramp. And of course, you can store, send, and swap your crypto assets, manage your NFTs, and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps. So whether you're new to crypto or you're a season pro, it's time to ditch those risky extensions and it's time to switch to the Brave wallet. Download Brave at Brave.com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. All right guys, we are back starting with the questions for the nation. Of course, a reminder, if you have a question for Dave and myself, follow bankless on Twitter. That's bankless HQ.
On Twitter, we tweeted out, you can reply to the thread, get your question answered. The first one is from two commas.eth. How do I summarize and explain the importance of the merge and its implications to my more normy friends who ask me about it? We question from two commas.eth. Explain it like I'm five, David. How do you explain the merge to someone who doesn't know anything about crypto, doesn't really care about crypto? God, these are all these so hard. All right, I'm going to go for it. Okay, Ethereum, it's the number two blockchain behind Bitcoin. It's the thing that created DeFi and smart contracts and allows us to do things like decentralized finance stuff, borrowing and lending, trading, etc.
So that's the big blockchain. It's got the majority of all economic activity inside of crypto, created enough teas. It's that blockchain. It's the big blockchain. It's proof of work, which is that thing that consumes a lot of electricity, which a lot of people in the outside world don't like. It's always been proof of work, but it's always wanted to go to this thing called proof of stake. Proof of work works by if you lie to the blockchain, you basically burn electricity for no reason. Proof of stake works that if you lie to the blockchain, you lose your ether. Ether, the native currency of Ethereum, how proof of stake works is that you stake your ether to the promise that you're not going to lie to the blockchain.
If you do lie to the blockchain by trying to add in a false transaction and invalid transaction, you get your ether slashed. So it's kind of like proof of work and that you just lose money, but you lose money a lot faster and a lot more quickly and a lot more money in proof of stake. So generally, the crypto world is like, this is just a better, more efficient way to secure a blockchain. We don't have to consume electricity. We also don't have to have Bitcoin be sold because of proof of work, because of all this electricity consumption. Because there's no electricity consumption, you don't have to issue as much ether to pay for that electricity consumption.
And these takers don't have to sell their ether. So it makes ether really bullish. And how is that? Pretty good. Pretty good. I think it's hard to explain. You know, kind of what I go back to is just like buy $100 on Coinbase worth of ether and then ask me questions as you're curious about it. So it's just like, I feel like, but what if this is the question they're asking about? Then I get them to listen to bank listen and you explain your thing. I think it's like that. Sometimes people aren't interested until they have some skin in the game. They actually have finance. I wasn't really interested as interested in crypto until I own some Bitcoin.
And then I was like, oh, this is cool. Why are the numbers going up and why are they going down? What does this all mean? That's why I actually advocate, like don't dump your entire net worth in here. But like if you want to get into crypto, buy some first. Do it. Step one. Buy some. Just do it. Not financial. All right. That was first question. Let's get to the second. When the merger occurs, this is from Eddie Coates. When the merger occurs, what if anything, well, if holders have to do, will automatically convert or will holders need to sell out of the old and buy into the V2? Thanks, guys.
Bankless podcast is lit. What? Sick, sick, sick, rock horns. Yeah. What do you have to do anything as an ether holder? No. I'm so glad. I'm so glad they answered. The answer is no. You don't have to do anything. You're going to have ether in your wallet and then you're still going to have ether in your wallet. You will actually not notice a thing. The merge is a kind of like a software update. You know, when you plug your phone in and then it just like updates while you're sleeping, it's going to be like that. You're not going to notice it. Not going to notice. And updates like this have happened many times in Ethereum's history and you probably haven't noticed if you've been here for one of them.
It'll just be like one of those. That's if everything goes well. It should go well. But nothing you should have to do. Last question from satkc.eth. Ask the question, which layer two scaling solution are you most bullish about and why? And he lists a few. Starknet, ZK, sick, polygon, scroll, can't help but notice David. All of these have a similar theme and they are ZK EVMs. Yeah. Which layer two scaling solution are you most bullish about as the question and why? I am most bullish on. Yes. They're all great. They're all great. They're all great. Like, okay, I'll give you different reasons why you should be bullish on every single one.
Starknet, apparently, after you're listening to a podcast, I'm about to talk in a sec, this Cairo coding language and this overall the developer support and building out Cairo and accepting updates from developers has been great. So the developer user experience for Starknet has been a lot of adoption. A lot of adoption. Developers love it. First of all, it's the long in a lot of ways. Yeah. And definitely their BD skills are really strong. I think they were the first to market. So, like, Starknet, like, can't not be bullish. ZK sync, Alex and team have been around Ethereum from the beginning.
They're also doing a separate, an EVM compatible strategy with their ZK roll up. They just, like, exude the values of Ethereum. And, like, we've just see adoption of things that, like, exude the values of Ethereum. You would have swap. I would put in this category. And so, like, they just have, like, fundamental Ethereum alignment at their tailwinds. They've been around for a while. They're, like, friends with all the other developers in this space. They're just very well connected. And then, okay, let's go to Polygon. Polygon also has their proof of stake chain, which is a, like, not a ZK roll up, but, like, the most bullish thing possible.
I don't know if this is possible, but if it is possible, it's really bullish, is that their current proof of stake chain just rolls into their ZK roll up. If that's possible, really, really cool. Scroll, the most bullish thing about scroll is that it's got EVM equivalents. They're going for the very hard task of EVM equivalents, which is if you can deploy your thing on the Ethereum layer one, you can also deploy your thing onto the optimism layer two without changing a goddamn thing. And you can also deploy it to scroll, which is a ZK EVM without changing a goddamn thing. Also, really bullish.
Super strong engineering team, though it's a harder problem, right? It's, like, all of these have different strengths. They all have, they're all different flavors. So, like, I like, I like many different flavors, and they're all bullish. They're all bullish. To me, this question is asking, which of your kids is your favorite? I can't answer that question. They're all especially. I feel like you can't answer that question out loud. No, it's true. I have three kids, and I love them all equally. Kids, if you're listening, you guys are fantastic, all of you equally. So start net ZK Sink Polygon and scroll.
David, takes the week. Let's get into them. Take the week. First take here from you. Yeah, you want to read your own tweet? No, I'll read your tweet. Okay, it's better that way. From David Hoppen, my favorite version of the future is the one where global 4x markets are traded on a unicorn theme venue. This is Uniswap. I imagine. Yeah. You think that's real? I mean, I feel like that is actually the most likely version of the future is when like global 4x markets are held on Uniswap. And just like Hayden and like his friend Carl and Vitalik, they just like unicorns. And so they made it a unicorn theme.
And then like, you know, butterfly flaps its wings and all of a sudden global 4x markets are like on this Uniswap traded or unicorn traded venue. I still contend that Uniswap will be the largest exchange in the world, you know, sometime in the next 10 years. Yeah, that's right. I think that is undoubtedly true. But we'll see. And that'll be funny when it is. Also, you have a podcast that you want us to tune into. Yeah, I don't really know where to fit this into the roll up. But here's my hot take. This podcast that I have to listen to is really, really good. This is into the bytecode from Cena.
Great podcast. Very technical. But also does a great job of breaking it down for the listener. And so this is Julian from Argent, Argent and Smart Contract Wallet. And they talked about just a number of things like built wise smart contract wallets need to be the future. Wise smart contract wallets and ZK rollups go really well together, account abstraction, and overall the developer experience of Starquare and ZK sync. And so this is where I got that take that the Starquare team is doing a great job, just like making their developers feel good. So my hot take is that this was a good podcast and you should listen to it.
I've been waiting for Argent to get his legs under, under itself again, because I feel like we haven't yet seen the promise of smart contract wallets. Oh god, not. And I'm hoping that later to use bring that, but we like, we still haven't seen it yet. And there's just such a promise, such a potential there. It's a little bit like layer two is where there's promise and potential, but we just haven't fully seen it realized last take here. This is a poll take actually. I'm sure the poll results here, but let me give you the A, B and C. This is from Eric Wall. A option A. The merge will happen as planned in September.
Vote on that if you think it will happen as planned. B, it will happen, but something big will go wrong, like, proof of work. Miners will refuse to mine the last block. A major client consensus split something chaotic. That's option B or C. It won't happen. It'll get postponed. All right. Before I clicked my answer, which is A, I thought that basically A would be the vast majority. I thought we'd get like 80 or 90%. But it turns out what? What are the results of your data? It is A that got the most votes. 52% of respondents said A, it's going to happen as planned in September without any problems.
Four to 15% of people said show me the results. So 15% of people are automatically off the table. 15% of people said B, it will happen, but something will go wrong. And then 18% of people said it's not going to happen, it's going to get postponed. So if you add B and C together, what do you get? You get something like 33%, 34% of people think that it's either going to get postponed or go wrong. And 52% think it's going to happen fine. And like, okay, so I've accounted for a 95% success rate in my head. And this is accounting for something like a 66% success rate. And so that discrepancy, if I'm right, means the merge is not priced in.
That's my takeaway. That is an interesting takeaway. It's interesting that 18% think it'll be postponed. Bitcoin. It's already been like pushed as an update. It's happening. It's going to happen at this point. You don't even really have C as an option. That's just kind of like, I don't know, I guess if the world is a little bit too late for C. Yes, we have the client software. And yet we have almost 20% of people again in this Twitter poll. But I think it's decently representative of crypto Twitter sentiment saying that it's not going to happen. It's get postponed. And it's like, we have a date.
And the software has been updated. And we're just waiting for that date to be activated at this point. Anyway, I do think that there's some alpha there for us. David, what do you bullish on this week, man? Oh, I am bullish on it. You know that high value production studio that we were talking about? Yes. The BitBoy studio. The BitBoy studio. Well, as BitBoy exits, I hope to enter. And I'm going to turn to the new BitBoy. We are thinking about not totally true on this, but splitting the bankless YouTube into bankless podcasts, which is our long form interview formats weekly, roll-ups, Monday podcasts, live streams, the podcasts that you know and love.
But then also short form bankless, 20-minute long, like a little bit more, just like newbie optimized content. Your boy's got a teleprompter right behind the screen. I got scripts. And so we're trying to make trying to expand bankless into new audiences because there's a lot of people out there with that when they come to YouTube, they go, oh, BitBoy, he's got all the best information. He's trying to steal the BitBoy audience. We're trying to steal the BitBoy audience. And instead of feeding them candy and tokens like out of zero, we feed them. We jump food. We feed them the veggies. And so with some junk food, we're some merge candy.
Yeah. Not high-fructose corn syrup, but you know strawberries and raspberries. Organic junk food. Yeah, organic junk food. Anyways, that is what I'm bullish on right. There's a bankless productions, bankless studio, something. And that's actually aside from like this Joe Rogan, Lex Readman type studio. I've got behind me, which gets finalized and finished tomorrow. And then we're off to the races. All right. Yeah, that becomes BitBoy. That's going to be a new BitBoy as bankless. Wow. Ryan, where do you bullish on? David, you were laughing about this before I hit record. But let me tell you why.
I'm bullish on the Constitution. Here's specifically why. All right. That doesn't sound like it's an overly patriotic because, you know, I'm reasonably patriotic, but I'm not a super patriotic person. But I'm really into like social protocols. And the Constitution happens to be a pretty big one and a pretty important one and a pretty good one, particularly this thing called the Bill of Rights. And you know where I got excited about it was when we were recording with Jake Trevinsky. And basically, the takeaways, all of the OFAC sanctions and developer getting arrested and like restrictions on privacy that we're feeling right now.
What's super interesting is 250 years ago, the framers of the Constitution and creating the Bill of Rights already thought through these things. Like we have these protections. It's a solved problem and it's actually enshrined in the protocol that governs our country. It's like sometimes we get overly afraid of like OFAC. For example, it's like, what if we do this thing? They put me in prison. They're the ones doing the thing that's illegal. They're the ones that are doing the thing that is against the Constitution that's unlawful. Of course, we have to prove these cases in court over time. But like, talk about the First Amendment in the Bill of Rights, freedom of speech, press, protest.
This is code. All right, we've precedent. Legal precedent. That code is protected as a First Amendment right, just like speeches. The Fourth Amendment. No unreasonable search and seizure. This is privacy. If you live in America, you have the constitutional right to privacy. Number five, due process. That means the government can't come and seize your property without due process. That a court saying it's okay without proving that you did something wrong. Digital rights. If property, the government can't come and seize your eth in the US. That is unconstitutional. All of these things. And I think it's a bit on the legal front.
It's a little bit back to getting back to the original protocol of the US, right? This is why actually, I think that some people are like, US is too far gone. It's turned into a surveillance state. All of these things. I think that may be true over the past 40 to 50 years. We veered into that. But if we can have a generation of people and a group of people who take us back to our roots, right? And kind of like the actual social contract this entire country is founded upon, then we can resurface and find our digital rights once again. So it sounds like I'm running for a political platform. I'm really not.
But you kind of are. Crypto is a political movement, isn't it? And I want to make sure that we protect these things. And I am into fighting the fight in the US because I think this is a decent place to fight the fight for digital freedom and for cryptocurrency. Because it's like baked into the social contract, baked into the narrative of the US. So why not do it here? And that's what I intend to do more and more. Of course, it's going to be the Jake Trevinsky's of the world, the coin centers of the world doing it. But like, we're going to help through our platform and education to continue that fight.
Ryan is a bullish on the Bill of Rights. On to lighter matters. How do I get exposure to that? We're going to buy the right before the bridge started. Did we try that? Did we try to buy the constitution? All right. What are we looking at? Me of the week. Me of the week. We have a guy doing like the pre squat and he's looking at one of those like, what do you call those? So the a stack of rocks that are all balanced on each other. And we have like Vitalik and inflation, and then top of that is a recession. And on top of that is Putin and a Fed pivot. Bounce on top of that is a stock pump. Bounce on top of that is SBF.
Arthur Hayes, medium post. The ETH Foundation not selling. Dejan Spartan bullish tweets. Jump capital not selling. And then the ETH merge pump. And we are praying that the aligned rocks here allow us to have a bull market. These rocks are built like a Django castle too. It does not look good. A lot of things have to go right in order for the ETH merge pump to happen is what this meme is communicating. That's right. There you go. David, what are people in tune in store for for the the moment of Zen if they're watching on YouTube? Yeah, right. Okay. So this Gabriel Hayes, he's the guy that's just like always like wrapping and dancing.
And it was a wrap from Gabriel and a song from his wife. And so that is coming up in this moment of Zen right after we get through Ryan's classic disclaimer. Of course, guys, crypto is risky. You got to tell you none of this was financial advice, but we are headed west. This isn't for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot. I don't care about you big boy. No, not even one euro. Y'all that chose the world before that you are.