Bitcoin is bleeding, STRC is off peg, and Saylor’s “never sell” machine is facing its first real confidence test. David and Haseeb unpack whether Strategy can survive without selling BTC, why Bitmine’s ETH play may be stronger but riskier, and what select token strength, U.S. perps, and Coinbase’s Ethena deal reveal about crypto’s next phase.
---
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
---
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🔮POLYMARKET | #1 PREDICTION MARKET
https://bankless.cc/polymarket-podcast
🧭OKX | TRADE, EARN, PAY to OKX | 120M+ USERS WORLDWIDE
https://app.okx.com/join/USBANKLESS
🦊 METAMASK | DOWNLOAD NOW
https://go.metamask.io/BL-Pod-Download
🌐BRIX | EMERGING MARKET YIELD
🎯THE DEFI REPORT | ONCHAIN INSIGHTS
https://thedefireport.io/bankless
---
TIMESTAMPS & RESOURCES
0:00 Intro
1:37 Saylor & Strategy Confidence Test
https://x.com/zerohedge/status/2061418482344849785
https://x.com/KobeissiLetter/status/2062475802252365980
https://x.com/glxyresearch/status/2062518531128746000
https://x.com/TrustlessState/status/2062499179239215390
13:26 DATs Underwater & Bitmine Preferred Offering
https://x.com/lookonchain/status/2062011412965405059
https://x.com/zoomerfied/status/2062288919853490553
34:19 Major Weakness & Select Token Strength
40:45 U.S. Perps Get Greenlit
53:41 Coinbase Invests in Ethena
57:13 Closing & Disclaimers
---
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to the Bankless Weekly. Rollup is the first week of June and we've got his seat on the show subbing in for Ryan this week as see how you're doing. You're okay it's kind of a rough day but you know hanging in there. Rough day because of the markets. Rough day because the markets I've just seen all the, seen all the bleeding. I mean obviously you know I think it's okay I think it's going to be okay but it sucks to see so many people kind of down and hurting. Yes. Is this different than any of the times in the past? I think what you're saying is like this happens. This is what we go through in crypto.
This is perfect. If you're in crypto, if you've been in this industry for a long time, you know being down 4% in a day is not catastrophic. I think we were feeling a bit of a sentiment reversal. It's like okay we're pulling out of this. It's as if we're going to shake it off and it's like no you're not out of it yet. So I think people are feeling that pain. That's right. We're going to talk about a handful of things on the podcast today is Michael Sailor going to kill Bitcoin. Bitcoin is trading at its 200 week moving average while stretch is trading off of its peg. Sailor is in the middle of a confidence game with a market.
We'll see who's wins. Tom Lee and Bitmind have announced that they're going to issue an equity yield instrument right in the middle of stretch of being distressed. We're going to talk about whether that's a good idea or not. Despite the weakness and the majors of crypto. Some tokens are still very green on the week. That to me is new. So what to make of that. And also the CFTC green lights the first compliant purpose markets inside the United States. Let's start with Michael Sailor. Sailor and strategy sold 32 Bitcoin for $2.5 million. A very small sale. Probably just probing the market seeing how the market digested coincidentally or not.
This is a question that I have for Haseeb is whether this was a coincidence. Coincidentally or not Bitcoin fell by like 17% after the announcement of that sale from $72,000 down to $62,000. It's back up about $63.6,000. Haseeb coincidence. Bitcoin is kind of just doing the cycle thing, but the timing is special. What do you think? Yeah. I mean, clearly not a coincidence since this was announced. I think this was announced on what was it Tuesday that the sale was announced, but the sale happened last week. Yes. And obviously this amount of sale is so small that it's obviously it wasn't the sale itself that was absorbed by markets causing this downturn.
It's more symbolism. It's a signaling. It's a signaling. And the signal clearly has accelerated this, but only since Tuesday, right? And market was coming down before Tuesday. So I think it's it's quick in the pace of the sentiment turning sour, but it doesn't explain the full drawdown that we've seen since Bitcoin kind of recovering to near 80k. Right. Yeah. I'm of two minds. There are some such thing as coincidences, but also I think if you just ignored the sailor thing and just looked at the price chart over cycles, this would look normal. This would look relatively normal, but at the minute you disagree.
Well, look, I'm not a I'm not a TA kind of guy. So I don't know what's a normal or not normal price chart. I'm like, I think it was true that there was a sentiment reversal. People felt like we can't have been shaken out. A lot of retail had already exited the market. And so it's like, okay, now we've, you know, we've taken our lumps and now it's time to re-consolidate and kind of reestablish, okay, how do we feel about the fair value of Bitcoin? I think it's pretty clear. This market is very flows driven right now and very sentiment driven and sentiment. I think, you know, sailor was probably testing the market as you mentioned.
And I think he got the answer he was not looking for, which is that absolutely not you are not allowed to sell. Like you are a big part of the story of why Bitcoin gets to keep going up. And so I think sailor likely has internalized this lesson. I've never pressed that button ever again for as long as you think that he is not, he's his hands are tied and he can't sell. You think this response has told him, okay, yeah, it's fine. Go sell some more. Okay. So here's what here is a possible path that I kind of think was was my base case. So we have to look at stretch. Stretch is trading at 95 dollars, 95.
3 dollars. That's about 5% off of its peg. The market cap of stretch is it's about 500 million dollars off of the market cap. It should be a little over 10 billion. It's trading over at 9.9 billion. We're five hundred and sixty one million dollars below par. I think sailor just needs to take it on the chin and he needs to sell enough Bitcoin to fund the stretch dividends for three years, three plus years to establish confidence in the market. That is a, I can't remember how much that is. That is a sale in the five or six or seven hundreds of millions. And so he needs to sell five hundred six hundred million dollars.
I believe the stretch dividends are like over a billion a year and he has seven hundred million on hand if I'm not mistaken. He needs to puke up enough Bitcoin to establish confidence in stretch and the stretch dividends and make stretch holders believe in stretch. So that stretch returns to trading at a hundred dollars. To me, stretch is a canary and it's telling us that there is a lack of confidence and this is a positive feedback loop in the bad way in the negative direction because people like me are looking at stretch being five percent off. I'm like, oh, sailors going to need to sell Bitcoin in order to close that gap.
Then I'm going to sell my Bitcoin because I know sailors coming in like a train behind me. So I'm just going to get out of the way and I'm going to sell my Bitcoin. And so it's creating a downward, downward feedback, downward spiral. And I think sailors just needs to take it on the chin, make a large single sell of Bitcoin. And that's it. And then he just clears it. But I don't know if he can just do nothing here. So I would take the opposite view. I think what he's learned is that look, I sold nothing. I sold 25 Bitcoin. And this is the reaction of the market. Right. He lost so much more money in his nav because of how much Bitcoin went down from that sale relative to the amount of cash he would need to raise to pay dividend holders, which tells you the way that you raise this money is not by selling that breaks the whole system.
You have lost more than you would have because it conceivably have gained. So now I think the lesson that the market is telling him is no, no, no, no, no, no, no, you got to die with the ship. You do not get to be a prudent financial manager. You are Mr. Bitcoin. Mr. Bitcoin doesn't get to sell. So you want to be Mr. Bitcoin like either one, you got to throw the stretch holders under the bus and say, okay, you guys are going to have to sit on your dividends for a while. I'm not paying any dividends. And you know, they have the ability to skip paying out dividends. The dividends accrue over time.
They actually eventually get paid. But you can miss a dividend. And you know, they have the discretion to do that. The second option, of course, is Duluth stock, right? So go do some ATMs, sell some more stock, dilute the common shareholders so that you can pay the dividend, right? Now, in each of those cases, somebody gets screwed either the common shareholders get screwed or the preferred shareholders get screwed. But one way or another, one of them has to lose because the third category of Bitcoin gets screwed does not work. That does not work. You cannot sell Bitcoin. If you are selling Bitcoin, the whole system breaks.
So I think that's the lesson he's learned. And he's ultimately going to have to choose one of two bad options. Now at the end of the day, Bitcoin is largely fine, which of those two he chooses, right? So the whole industry is large, like, you know, if he screws over the stretch holders, then okay, that removes part of your financing. You can't really, you know, put lever up and go use it to buy more Bitcoin. But at least you're not selling any Bitcoin until, okay, you're, you're, you're, you're solid. We can count on you. You're not marginal sell pressure. But if you, now, if you dilute the common shareholders, then okay, the premium goes down, the nav goes down, and then that really screws over a much larger holder base, but also is, is harder for him to be able to, you know, justify going back above nav in the future and, and getting the whole system running.
So it's, it's genuinely a difficult situation. And when you have multiple, multiple categories of shareholders who are not completely aligned with each other, which you have here, because, you know, he's issued so many different instruments over the years, you're going to naturally have these kind of conflicts where, you know, it's kind of zero sum. Dude, the common shareholders get screwed or the prefer shareholders get screwed. But I think he's learned you can't screw Bitcoin. You screw Bitcoin, you screw yourself. I suppose what I'm kind of advocating for is sailor taking like a pretty drastic move to sell Bitcoin to like shore up the finances, establish establish confidence.
And what you're doing, what you're saying is take an equally hard core move and just like stare the decreasing Bitcoin price and the decreasing stretch price in the face and don't blink and just don't blink and be like whatever we're just not selling Bitcoin. Look, I think the reality is that he has constructed a fantastic financial machine around him. So he actually does not really have pressure to do anything, right? Like these, these assets are so favorable to sailor. The reason why you have these favorable structures is that you don't have to sell in times of distress. Now this looks to me like a time of distress, right?
Like Bitcoin is down. It's, you know, it's about to go below, it's 200 day monthly average. This is the time when that runs in your favor. Is it you can say, nope, screw you? Everybody be quiet. Bitcoin is going to go back up because I'm Mr. Bitcoin, if instead you say, oh, well, I have to be a prudent, you know, yeah, exactly. I have to take care of my stretch holders. Then, okay, well, why did you even set this whole system up to be so favorable and so just so much to give yourself so much discretion to not have to sell Bitcoin in a time of distress? If he's selling Bitcoin at 120, cool, whatever.
You're selling Bitcoin at 60, now you're below your average price, you're realizing losses. I think the market is very, very clear here. You don't get to do that. Try one or the other two or just sit on it for a while and let's hope that the market goes back up and recovers. So do you think, do you think he resumes his never sell your Bitcoin retort in that case? I also think he has been ever wavering from that. I don't think so. I'm sorry, but I do think that he has been chasing by the market and he's learned, look, you like, Michael Scherge now is so much bigger than they were in the past. It's important to understand that they have sold Bitcoin before.
I believe in, what was it, 22 or something? They sold some Bitcoin, but they are at such a bigger scale now than they were at that time. It's such a bigger portion of the Bitcoin market. And this is kind of the end game for Dats is like, once you become big enough, you are the market. Right now, sailor is the market. And if the market itself is voluntarily capitulating, I think you see what the response is for market participants and they just say, look, I'm getting a hell out of the way. I don't want to I don't want any part of this. So now look, it's possible that he does one big fat sale. I don't know that the liquidity is like, it's going to be ugly to try to raise a couple billion dollars in this environment.
But maybe he does one big fat sale and then says, I'm cooling it. No more sales for a long time. That's the least bad way to do it if you're going to do that. But I think it's more likely that he is just going to take the lesson of, you know, don't screw the golden goose, which is don't sell Bitcoin. It ruins the whole story. Yeah. I do take that argument. I did not consider that. I do like that argument. You can also look at the ETFs. The ETFs, this is from Galaxy Research. Bitcoin spot ETF outflows are on a record setting 13 day streak of consecutive outflow. It's one of the most red times in Bitcoin ETF land.
I think the ETFs are probably just right there with it. Why do you think this is because this is just separate from strategy. Obviously it's correlated with Bitcoin price. But ETF holders, whether they're institutions or retail, why do you see so much outflows happening from the ETFs? I mean, look, I have no idea. So I mean, I want to preface with like, look, I'm not a public markets guy. So I'm speaking a little bit out of my depth. But I sort of think a little bit of looking at the ETFs is kind of like looking for signal where like the signal is actually backwards looking, not forwards looking.
But almost by definition, if Bitcoin went down, it's because more people sold. And so then people look at the ETFs and say, oh my God, the ETFs are sold. People are moving out of the ETFs. It's like, okay, well, yeah, yeah, they sold. We know that. We already know people sold. So looking at the ETFs and say, well, here, this explains the selling. No, this memorializes the selling. This is a record of the selling. Asking why did they sell it like this, this chart cannot answer that for you. So like, I think the answer largely is that they sold because the price wasn't going up. Because everyone sold to, yeah, and they are.
I mean, I don't have some brilliant explanation. Like, there is a story about, oh, well, the AI trade is sucking up everything. But that's been true for a while, right? So I don't think that's uniquely true right now. I think it's that thing started going down. And so people sold and anything that would not have been explained by the price chart doesn't get a more explained by looking at this. Not to be too barehold, but we just got a look at the debt. Tom Lee is down $8.9 billion on $10 billion of ETH. They have currently $10 billion of ETH. Michael Saylor is down $7.6 billion. He has $56 billion of Bitcoin.
And while stretch is undergoing a confidence test in the market, while it's trading 5% off of his highs, we got an announcement that Bitcoin has filed for a preferred stock offering offering a yield of 9.5%. Interesting timing. I did not know. I was unsure if Bitcoin was going to do this. We once talked to Tom Lee and he was like, I like to keep my options open to do whatever I want to do. Seems like he's chosen a door. He's going through this door. Some doors are going to close as a result of this, but he is doing the stretch style of a yield offering for 9.5%. What was your reaction to see when you saw this?
I don't feel like we know enough. So one, filing to be able to make an offering does not mean that you have to actually do the offering. So he may have, again, kept his options open, wanted to test the market, talked to actual buyers, and then he may decide go no go depending on what the appetite is. Now, that's it. I think actually Bitcoin is situated pretty differently from strategy, because the fact that Ether has a yield, and because Ether has a yield, you can actually pay the yield here by just selling the yield and not selling the principal. And so he doesn't actually have to sell any net new eith in order to be able to fund this in principle, depending on how big it is.
But this is the endgame. This is why you run a debt and get to scale is that you can have these very favorable financing mechanisms that are a lot better than what you and I could get if we wanted to get some leverage on something. We can't offer preferred stock on our crypto buys, but maybe Tom Lee can. At scale, you can't. This was one of my conditions for being bullish eith. The first one is let's increase the eithburn, because if you increase the eithburn, the yield that Bitcoin is going to get is even stronger that way. Without any eithburn, the yield is actually just issuance. It's really just Ethereum taking from one pocket and giving it to another that second pocket is where Bitcoin has all their eith.
But with the burn that yield goes from nominal to real. And that is the strength here that I see happening. The fact that this product can be stronger than strategies is a huge bulk case to me, especially bolstered if we get layer one burn up. But also another bulk case is that Tom Lee can just learn from sailors mistakes. I think sailor, I don't know, he knows more than me, but he really just issued the crap out of stretch aggressively. And now we are starting to look at some of those consequences. I think there's potentially a second to mover advantage that Tom Lee has in addition to the yield mechanism.
I think it's plausible. I buy that story in part. I think, look, the reality is whether you're funding this out of staking yield or whether you're funding it out of Bitcoin sales at the underlying, the difference is really one of narrative as opposed to the underlying mechanics. Because look, if sailor is funding through Bitcoin sales, which I think, like we said, I think he's going to learn that you cannot do that. You have to dilute common stock if you want to pay these dividends. But if you're doing it by selling Bitcoin, the reason why markets revolted is the story. The story is supposed to be buying more Bitcoin instead of selling Bitcoin.
In this case, they bought, let's say, 100,000 eith and then they get some seeking eith and they sell that. That sort of sounds like, oh, you're still accumulating more eith. That's great. In reality, they're still selling eith. Somebody else has to have cash to buy eith in order to make the whole system work. But it sounds better. It does sound better. Exactly. It sounds like, oh, we're still accumulating. The number has not gone down. It's only going to go up. And so I think that is a narrative transformation, not an actual economic transformation because, of course, that's inflation to the totally supply.
But either it does not have a real yield, quote unquote, meaning that it doesn't have a yield paid in external assets. It's not like you're getting dollars by staking eith. You have to get anything. You have to sell the eith. And so at the end of the day, I think these are similar from an economic perspective. But for the debts, it's very clear so much of the flows depend on the narrative. And the narrative is Tom Lee's going to keep buying this stuff. And therefore, it's always going to have a bid. Doesn't matter how bearish the market is, Tom Lee is going to be in there buying eith. And the same thing is true for sailor.
Sailor is always going to be in there buying Bitcoin. It's clear now that ETFs are not up only. They are not a one way ratchet of just accumulating more and more Bitcoin or more and more eith. These debts are that. So I think the story matters. And I do think the story is better for Tom Lee. But it's not impregnable. There is something funky about Tom Lee issuing the yield offering. And then financing that with eith staking yield. The reason why you would issue a yield offering is that so you can hammer the ATM generate revenue to buy eith. But you're selling eith on the other side to pay for the yield.
So like it just seems, I guess the answer here is like, well, doing this thing gives Tom optionality. And he can sell eith when it's beneficial. He can hold eith when it's beneficial. He can sell at the ATM when it's beneficial. And he has those options and he will load balance accordingly. I guess that's the answer. It just feels weird to be selling it out of one pocket and buying from another. Yeah. I mean, obviously it is. Like, why would you do this? Why is it? Why are any of the debts doing this? The answer is because they think number go up. If you don't think number go up, don't do this.
This is not a good strategy. You will not make money the long run doing this for random things. You will only make money doing this if number go up. So this is a number go up game. If number go up, they win. If number go down, they lose. It's really that simple. These guys are taking on leverage. It's very favorable terms to take on leverage. It's not a lot of leverage in percentage terms, but this is leverage. So getting levered only works when number go up. I think Tom Lee needs to rescind his 5% target because he says like, we're going to earn, we're going to buy 5% of the total e-supply. And then we're going to call it good.
To me, that takes some of the energy out of the whole system. If you say you're like, I'm just going to not buy more than 5%. I think you kind of have to say, I'm going to blusherly buy as much as the market will give me. What's yet now? Is there like three something? No, 4.5%. He's pretty close. And they also say that they are going to slow down their e-th purchases as they approach 5%. And so to me, I was like, okay, this is a different game than what strategy was playing. Michael Saylor, Michael strategy is just like, I'm going to give, I'm going to buy as much Bitcoin as humanly possible.
And Tom Lee was saying, yeah, we're going to get 5%, we're going to call it good. And we're slowing our way there because we're at 4.5%. And so there's something dislocated to me about the issuing of the yield offering. And also capping at 5%. I think he needs to say, we're going for 15. We're going for 50%. Yeah, you're not wrong. I do think that it's very likely that, you know, Tom Lee is probably going to reevaluate that 5% number when he gets spending distance of it. And this offering doesn't make a lot of sense if you're slowing down, right? This is a speed up kind of offering. This is a speed up thing.
Yeah. This is a speed up thing. So I think that you are right. I think this is maybe a signal of that is that, you know, look, Tom Lee gets paid the bigger that this thing becomes. He becomes really big. He makes more money. So his incentive is very obvious. Now that being said, it is also true that ETH is actually different from Bitcoin. In that owning a lot of Bitcoin doesn't really impair the coin's properties because, you know, the consensus of Bitcoin is around proof of work. It's not around ownership. Whereas for Ethereum, the, you know, the governance power of Ethereum is actually in staking.
And so if you own a lot of ETH and you're staking it, you actually do exert more control and more power over the network in a way that is potentially somewhat sus. And so I think, yeah, I don't know if this is playing into that equation, but you might be mindful of that. You know, the total ETH stake supply is, what is it? Like 30 something 40%? 30, 35% 30%, 40%. Okay. So it's higher than that. It's higher than that. It's like 40%. Okay. 40%. Let's say, let's assume that's right. Okay. So if he has five, then he's one eighth of the total stake. Yeah. So you have to get to 33% of total stake in order to basically be able to cause a major failure in consensus.
And so that takes you to, what is that? 13%. So that's not a lot of headroom before basically he's breaking the security model of Ethereum, right? Which is this thing cannot get arbitrarily big. And ETH is not as big as Bitcoin, right? So you know, Bitcoin's one and a half trillion. ETH is 250 billion roughly. Yeah. So yeah, it doesn't have one percent of Bitcoin. And Tom Lee has 4.5% of ETH. Right. There's effectively no ceiling on strategy strategy could own, you know, 5% of Bitcoin and still doesn't matter. It doesn't really change anything about Bitcoin itself. But if if if Tom Lee goes to 13%, that's like a two and a half times where he currently is.
Tom Lee is about 10 billion. So if he gets to 25 billion at current prices, then he is now basically kind of in control of consensus. That's weird. That's very weird. That is weird. There is a silver lining to that that maybe you'll agree with me. We you had me on the chopping block and we talked a lot about this that there needs to be an institution, a new institution that fills the vacuum that the EF is intentionally leaving behind. That is pro ETH, the asset pro the financialization of the asset pro number go up pro leading Ethereum to be market competitive with with other blockchains. And I see increasingly bit mine being positioned to take that torch.
Maybe they don't even want it, but they kind of have to because they have so much ETH. So I'm actually of the opinion that it's it's actually a good thing to have an entity that is that is existentially tied to either the asset in its price performance. And also can be aligned with some of the you know Ethereum foundation members that have left the brain drain out of the EF. I think there's optionality there. I don't quite know what's cooking over there, but I could see that actually being quite a good thing for Ethereum despite all the risks that you identified where if one holder has too much ETH, that's kind of such for the network.
Yeah, so I completely agree with you. I very much very much think that they are in pole position to be that economic advocate for easy the asset. That said, like it does put them in this kind of uncomfortable governance position where now they have disproportionate power over the network. A lot of Ethereum stories that it's credibly neutral is that it's you know whatever were worth your resistant blah blah blah. If you have one public company that is the major like the largest steward of Ethereum and has the ability to kind of stop the show if they want to. They say, hey, you know, Ethereum is you know, not enforcing OFAC compliance.
Well, that's not good for us because we're a public company and we're getting subpoenas. So, you know, like there's in principle, I mean, again, I'm kind of scared. I'm going a little bit. I don't think this is likely. And I think it's also possible that that that might if they get into that position, let's say that they start to own a third of the overall stake supply of ETH, right? One can imagine that maybe okay, we're going to move some of that ETH into DeFi to get yield instead of putting it into staking. Maybe instead, we're also going to move it into other stakers instead of the staker that we own.
We're going to move some into LIDO and you know, whatever so that we were not actually directly in control. And maybe even we put it into blind trusts and those trusts are responsible for staking and those, you know, the governance over those are done by third parties or, you know, somebody else entirely that has some kind of nonprofit type structure around it so that and we pledge our ETH there and we don't have corporate governance control over it. Therefore, we are not in control of ETH. I think there's a problem that if they get to strategy levels of success and they blow past the 5% threshold, they do probably have to start thinking about this about, you know, what does it mean when you are now with the EF stepping back with consensus, not really being anywhere near the scale now of what BitMine is and all the other debts being quite a bit smaller than BitMine.
And BitMine now having access to, you know, the bigger levers within capital markets like being able to issue preferred that are stretch style, that may mean that, you know, they just rocket their way to becoming by far the largest single holder of ETH. And when that happens, things might get trickier relatives to what it is today where it's a pure financial play. I think the jury is still out on whether these equity yield instruments are Ponzi's or not, Cammy Russo tweeted out, are these things Ponzi's or not? And my answer was they are not Ponzi's if they are appropriately risk managed and they are Ponzi's if they are not.
I don't know if you have an opinion on this. I think this has actually kind of been one of the major stories of the next few years is like, what are these things and how does the market treat them over time? What do you think they are? I mean, I think it's hard to describe these as Ponzi's. A Ponzi is guaranteed to fail, right? That's why we call it. That's why it's a crime to run a Ponzi scheme. These are clearly not guaranteed to fail. They might fail, but they're not guaranteed to fail. You know, even over a very long time horizon, you know, if Bitcoin, like Bitcoin will probably never be worth a thousand dollars ever again, right?
So if you take a very small amount of leverage on Bitcoin, so say you will get margin call if it goes below a thousand dollars. There's a very good chance that that just continues forever. You have now perpetually taken on leverage and you will never get margin called in the Ponzi will never collapse. Now, if you take on the Ponzi quote unquote, if you take on, you know, 300 percent leverage in Bitcoin ever goes below 65, it's over. Then okay, that that's very, very likely to collapse. And if you just look at the historical wall of Bitcoin, like that's that's a that's a risky proposition. But, you know, if you took that thing when Bitcoin was at 5K, Bitcoin never visited a thousand again.
So, you know, it's, so I think Ponzi not Ponzi is just the wrong frame to be thinking about this, like it's kind of too binary or too simplistic. These are risky bets. The risk is dependent on how you think about the future volatility as well as the future progression of these assets and where the demand floor is going to be on them. I think if you look at, you know, if you look right now, Bitcoin, Bitcoin has no structure. There's no debt. There's no anything, right? This is this would be the first structure that gets added onto Bitmind's capital. So clearly, as is, Bitmind is not a Ponzi. It cannot be a Ponzi.
There's no way to stop them out. There's no way to margin call them. There's no debt. So it's just like a trust, you know, it was GBTC a Ponzi. Obviously not. It's just a big pile of Bitcoin that's trading on, you know, and public markets. So I think the reality is that these things are still mostly just trusts that are trading on public markets. That's like mainly what you're buying, even when you buy strategy, right? There's some leverage, but the leverage is very small relative to the balance sheet. So mostly it's a Bitcoin trust that just moves up and down, you know, relative to nav. So that's why I think calling it a Ponzi is just kind of too simplistic.
Yeah. I think she's kind of going for this beard of the question, which is like, will basically will these things collapse or not? And I do think like if you want to balance risk and be efficient at risk and beyond some sort of efficient frontier, then for sailor and strategy, there needs to be some of these moments where confidence is not at 100 percent. And some of the market actually does think that this is going to fail. And then it doesn't fail. And if you don't, if you never have these moments where part of the market, like shrugs off and be like, I don't want this risk, then actually you're not taking enough risk is like, there's a Goldilocks zone.
And if sailor can find that spot, I think that's actually the efficient frontier of like leverage and risk. I like this argument, although I was not expecting it from you, David. I do like this. It's sort of like if your girl is never a little bit nervous, like you're not, you're not, you're not sort of, you're not putting yourself out there enough. It's like you keep a good relationship. There's got to be a little bit of fear. He's not buying enough Bitcoin. Okay. Okay. Wow. I don't reject this theory. I don't reject this theory. Right. Which does, one of my big questions that I think we'll get answered by the end of 2027 is like, what is the nature of these products?
These like stretch like products with that's appended to them. And to some degree, the answer is that is going to depend on the risk management of the team behind them. Because like, if you if you are overly cautious, well, then you're not a very good that and you've left margins on the table. And if you're too, if you're too risky, well, then you collapse the whole entire thing. But like finding how to have find the correct equilibrium and stay there indefinitely is going to be a little bit of an art that I think that that question will get answered over the next 26. We like the bad boy deaths.
You know, we got to feel a little nervous. You know, we got to feel a hard race every once in a while. Otherwise, you know, it's too boring. Yeah, that's right. That's right. Trading is changing, not gradually right now. OKX just launch trading bots directly inside the OKX app. Grid trading, DCA, arbitrage, you set your strategy once and then execute around the clock. No staring at charts all day, no manual entries, no missing moves while at your sleep. And for the first time, automated trading actually feels simple. But OKX is thinking bigger than just trading. They also launched the agent payments protocol, an open standard that lets AI agents execute full commercial transactions on chain.
The Ethereum Foundation, Uniswap, and AWS are already building on it. And now it's live inside the United States. And new users who deposit in trade can get up to $500 in Bitcoin through the bagless link. The link is in the show notes to learn more, not invest in advice, not available in New York or Texas. $100,000 is up for grabs. Metamask and Ando are giving it away in the Ando trading competition. Five weeks, three tiers, whoever earns the best percentage return in each tier wins the biggest cut. Pick from 260 Ando tokenized stocks, funds, and commodities to swap inside Metamask and let your portfolio do the talking.
If you think you can out trade everyone else, this is your chance to prove it from now until June 18th. Click the link in the description below and opt in on Metamask mobile. Trade RWA's on mobile or desktop to compete, not investment advice. In 2024, emerging markets generated over $115 billion in annual yield for investors, with yields ranging between 10 to 40%. These are some of the highest most persistent yields on earth. The problem, DeFi can't access them. Bricks changes this. Built on mega-eath, Bricks takes emerging market, money markets, and sovereign carry, and turns them into composable primitives you can access straight from your wallet.
While DeFi investors earned 3 to 6% on stablecoins and T-bills, institutions have been harvesting 10 to 50% yields backed by sovereign monetary policy. Bricks connects these worlds with institutional gray tokenization, local banking rails, compliance across jurisdictions, and real-time stablecoin settlement. Bricks does the heavy lifting so DeFi can finally access real collateral, instruction products on top of real-world yield. Even the best carry trades can be within reach. Bricks brings DeFi's promise to the emerging world and brings the emerging market yield to your wallet. Let the yield flow with Bricks.
Some exciting news, we are launching a new podcast to help people figure out the crypto cycle, how to navigate it. The best crypto cycle investor I know, his name is Michael Nado, he runs the DeFi report. This is the guy that sent me a sell alert before the 1010 price drop happened. His cycle analysis has been absolutely on point, I've been following him for years, and this year we started recording weekly podcast episodes. Each one we get into his portfolio, what he's holding, the market structure, entry targets, fair market value of Bitcoin and Ether, and where we are in the cycle, there's new episodes that are released every Wednesday, they're 30 minutes, they're short, they're punchy.
I think this crypto cycle is harder to navigate than most, so let's do it together. Go subscribe to this podcast, search the DeFi report, wherever you get your podcast, YouTube, Apple, Spotify, or find a link in the show notes. There's a new episode waiting for you now. All right, okay, so let's see, the market this week has just been the story of majors being pretty weak, so Bitcoin is down 13% this week, Ether is down 12% this week, XRP and Solana are saying the same thing, but if you go down market, there are some good tokens. There are tokens that have done exceptionally well. I don't know what humanity is, but it is up 120%.
World coin is up 94% this week. That's why it is very similar to World coin. It's like a palm, like proof of humanists through using your palm reading. I see, I see. Okay, so then the AI, human identity tokens are the winners of the week, congrats to them. We got lighter up 30%, Estina, up 11%, hyperliquid, up 10%, Venice, up 9%, Jupiter, up 6%. And so there is never before, if we go back last cycle or the cycle before that, when Bitcoin and Ether were puking, Bitcoin is at its 200-week moving average after following 12%, you know, Ether's 30% below is 200-week moving average. Never before have I seen tokens reaching all time highs and having strength in that same week.
What do you make of this? What does this tell you about the state of crypto? Well, it says a few things. So one, I think you did sometimes see this, but mostly in scam coins, and what's notable is that actually these are pretty legit projects that have been around for a while, and so there's some real price discovery happening here. The second thing, of course, is that there are more and more tokens that are not that exposed to the Bitcoin price, which is, in some sense, is kind of surprising. So take hyperliquid. Hyperliquid recently hit all time highs, although it's pulled back a little bit.
It was in the 70s, mid-70s earlier this week. And for hyperliquid, hyperliquid is exposed to the Bitcoin price because, you know, they make money trading crypto, but more and more of their volume is actually coming from TradeXYZ, which is trading RWA's. And so if more of your narrative, the reason why people are bullish on you is RWA trading, then who cares the Bitcoin's down? Everything else is volatile and everything else is going up. And so it's kind of like you're not that exposed to the underlying Bitcoin price. Same thing is true for Venice, for example. So Venice is a crypto AI project, more AI than crypto, let's say.
And for Venice, you know, their price largely moves in comparison to demand for tokens on their platform. Tokens not being crypto tokens, but AI tokens. So as demand for AI tokens goes up, Venice's revenues increase and Venice goes up. So I think there's a, what you're seeing is that there's more and more tokens that are actually materially diversified out of the crypto market itself, which means that, you know, it's not just that, oh, well, these are all memes and they go up and down together because it's all part of the big crypto meme. What you see instead is that, no, no, no, this market really is quite variegated with respect to what these things have exposure to.
That world coin, I don't know that I can explain to you what's going on there. It seems like open AI IPO or dissipation that seems to be what people are claiming is causing this. So maybe there's a little bit of meme coinness going on with the world coin rally. Obviously, it's been very violent over the last couple weeks as world coin or so now world coin as open AI has announced that, you know, they're trying to go public and obviously anthropic and SpaceX. So there seems to be a bit of an affinity trade going on there and maybe humanity alongside world coin. And then, of course, these Binance life, which is the number four there is literally a Binance meme coin.
So beyond that, I can't tell you what else is going on in this list. It is nice to see that the elites are tokens that I'm focused on, which is hyper liquid, Venice, near lighter and Zcash. Zcash, I think, has pulled back perhaps perhaps the most out of all of those. And that is the one that is not revenue driven. That is more of just like medically paired with Bitcoin because it's the same thing, 21 million units. But like all the other ones are revenue driven. And so to some degree, I'm seeing the industry is just being mature. We have tokens that make money. And if you are making money revenue, even dollar denominated or in nearest case, near denominated, if you are making money, you get to be not dragged down by Bitcoin and the rest of the market.
To me, it's a sign of maturity. I agree with that in part. I mean, DeFi is getting hammered if it's not a Perp Dex, right? So it's not true across the board that, okay, well, revenue will save you. A lot of things in DeFi make revenue, but the multiples are getting compressed. And of course, their revenues are denominated in crypto. So as crypto goes down, their revenues are expected to go down in the future, even if they haven't gone down yet. So I think the story is a little bit complicated. And you know, Nier got hammered today. So Nier is down. It's like, well, I think one of the most down assets today.
So it is a more complicated story. I think part of it is also that, you know, AI tokens are doing well because the entire market is, you know, captivated by what's happening in the AI world. But I largely agree with you. And I should also know where investors and most of the assets that you mentioned. So I'm grateful to see that there are some good projects that are weathering the storm and are able to have decent price expansion during times when a broader crypto market is under threat. But what that may well mean also, it's too early to say, but what would may well mean is that they don't necessarily share the same velocity on the upside.
So I've seen a lot of people saying, like, oh, well, you know, this is how hyper look was doing now. Just imagine how they're going to do when Bitcoin is a market plus. Right. And it may will be that actually people are pricing hyper liquid on revenues. And if they're pricing, I'm going to revenues. If the revenues don't, I mean, you know, it's not that likely that revenues are going to double just because the Bitcoin price goes up because so much of the revenues coming from RWA. So if that is true, may not be true, you know, TBD, let's see. But if that is true, then what you may see is that actually the crypto beta really is actually side, you know, sort of cord and off to these assets that are more crypto native and the less crypto native assets that really have identifiable revenues and sort of growth engines that aren't tied to the fundamental Bitcoin price.
They just don't capture as much crypto bait on the way up either. Did you just call a hype BTC top? I see. I did not. I didn't not call a hype BTC prop. Just pointing out that markets are complicated. Just pointing out the markets are complicated. All right. Let's get into to US perps. The CFTC this last week announced two pretty big things. First, it gave a license to Kalshi for the first Bitcoin perpetual futures contract inside the United States. At the same time, the agency also gave a no-action letter to Coinbase, allowing them to connect to their customers to a perp platform, a different perp platform so they get to be the pipes.
And to this kind of signals, the opening of the gates, the cutting of the ribbon to ensure US perps. And this is partly why I think hype did so well this week. Same thing with LIDAR is like people are just getting really excited about the perps market broadly. And especially when so many platforms, polymarket, Kalshi, Coinbase, Robinhood, LIDAR are just to name the handful that come to mind. Are all just like tromping at the bit to get access to the United States perps market? I think in addition to the stories that I'm collecting, what are the equity yield instruments of the debts? I think the next big story is what happens with the US perp market for the rest of this year and for 2027.
What was your reaction, Hazeeb, when you saw this? I might be in the minority here. I'm actually somewhat skeptical on the domestic perp story. So a few things, I think. One retails not here. And when retails not here, it's kind of like, okay, well, if retails not trading the stuff, then what does it really matter that we offer perps domestically? It's not like people are dying to find leverage ways to trade crypto right now. So it sort of feels like it's a real world asset. That's true. True. Yes. Yes. And so if you're talking about perps on real world assets, a one CFTC has explicitly said that they are not encouraging people to apply with perps for equity instruments or for securities.
So they say particularly perps are really appropriate for crypto works great. Not appropriate for equities, not appropriate for ag products. Why not? Yeah. I mean, presumably ag products because the ag industry kind of controls everything behind the scenes. And then for, there are all these rules. There was a story that I tweeted about where call sheet, they restricted their agricultural related markets to not be tradable on weekends and after APM, unlike every other contract on call sheet, just because the ag industry complained so much. So I don't totally understand why ag hates weekends or price discovery or whatever, but it's very important to them that onion futures have no price discovery after APM.
But for equities, I think for the CFTC, it's very obvious is that they have really, really large stakeholders with a very strong vested interest that they get to go first. So if you're the CME, if you're CBO, you do not want some crypto bros going in and saying great, I get to create totally new financial instruments that trade 24 seven on the weekends and give arbitrary amounts of leverage to retail traders. That is not happening. That despite how crypto friendly this administration is, you are playing the biggest game with the biggest boys when you enter into OK, I'm going to offer derivatives on equities.
So we've seen some products being contemplated right now, but like most these products are not available to us customers, the BTC perp, which was offered here, is obviously very vanilla because the CFTC is kind of like, look, if you want to offer perps on Bitcoin, whatever, what's the worst that could happen? It's already Bitcoin. It goes up and down, whatever. But the reason why they do not want these derivatives to be issued willy nilly on real world assets is the argument that the ag industry always makes is that, look, what if the price is getting manipulated? And then it breaks my business that oil futures are now priced at blah blah blah and it breaks my yield and now I can't plant the season and whatever.
I don't know all sorts of stuff like this that I probably don't understand. But these prices are very important inputs into how all these systems work. And if these prices are just yielded arbitrary amounts of speculation, then there's much more volatility than the line markets and that's bad for real world businesses. So that's the claim that I presume the CFTC would be making. If they reject somebody who says, hey, I want to offer, you know, 50X SpaceX perps. This is like, well, SpaceX is a real business and like, no, you can't do that. Maybe eventually, they will offer guidance about how to do equity perps.
But it's very clear right now, they're not ready to do that yet. Right now, they're only offering crypto perps. I'm talking to Mike Seedling from the CFTC on Monday. So I will be asking him exactly some of these questions. Okay, so great. I'm not a lawyer. I might be totally off on this, but this is my understanding from what I've read. It checks out what what I'm hearing you say is there are people who are just fundamentally bullish, the perpetual as in the instrument. And I don't think you are, you are perhaps also thumbs up on that. That's not what you're saying. What you are saying is something very akin to the banks versus crypto with regards to stablecoin yields where the incumbents just want to make sure that they retain their biggest piece of the pie.
Maybe it's the CME. Maybe it's the existing incumbents that actually offer perps. Maybe they go 24, 7, 365 with perpetuals because the perpetuals are such a fantastic instrument. But they're just going to be the ones to do it. And the status quo is a status quo. And we're not going to see like Coinbase coming in and trading oil futures on perpetuals in that dominate the market. There is no way that Coinbase goes first or that some startup goes first, right? Or the hyper liquid US goes first, like there's just absolutely no way that that's how it happens. Just because of income and see. Absolutely, absolutely.
I mean, we talk about, oh, you know, crypto is such an organized lobby and so on, but like you're again, this is a different scale than what we, you know, the scale of the equity markets and the scale of the commodities markets are much, much, much, much larger than the scale of the crypto markets. So letting crypto bros go and beat up on each other and, you know, go get levered long and kind of go crazy. It's a great sandbox with the perspective of the CFTC to say, hey, let's offer these products domestically. Let's surveil them. Let's manage them. Of course, these are fully KYC CFTC surveils all these markets and can basically pull records on people if they see weird stuff happening.
Like these are not hyper liquid style, you know, load up a privy wallet and just go ham. These are US regulated, you know, DCM DCO platforms that are going to be very closely monitored by the CFTC for malfeasance. That's why they want these markets is they want to bring this activity onshore and under the watchful eye of US regulators. So I think on a just absolute basis in terms of where I expect the trading volume and where I expect the revenues to be. I think in a world where you see coinbase and call sheet and polymarket and all these guys, they said they do launch onshore products. I expect that actually most of the volume will still remain offshore.
Hmm. Go wait, well, go into that a little bit more. So like imagine call sheet, polymarket, lighter, they launch onshore, Bitcoin, ether, V, V, V, all of the crypto tokens that crypto people love to trade. You still think that the dominant trading venues will be offshore. I do. So let me just give you a thought experiment. Okay. There are today some exchanges that will take Americans that are like sort of know to low KYC exchanges, right? They're kind of shady. They're not the exchange, you know, they're not the the really biggest ones, but you can sort of, you know, you put them in my mind to go to the exchange list, go to like number 10, number 12, and go try to make an account there and decent chance you can figure out how to do it as an American, right?
And these are mostly, you know, Chinese or whatever, they're somewhere overseas and they're, they're, you know, say shells or something. And these exchanges will take your money. Okay. You go on these exchanges, you can, you can go buy perps as an American. They are not big exchanges. There's not an enormous amount of demand for people to just go and sling around perps on all these products. And to the extent that if people on Coinbase can get access to perps, the reality is that the, you know, part of the reason why Coinbase stock is down and Robin has stock is down is that people are just aren't buying as much crypto.
And I think there's it probably a large part of displacement from the spot markets into the derivatives markets, because look, people certainly said they're only buying, you know, they're only depositing so much money. Now with perps, you can take on the more leverage, but these products are US regulated, which means they're not offering 50X leverage. They're probably not even offering 20X leverage, right? The most products in the US offer very low amounts of leverage to retail traders. So, I think the fantasy that we have that, you know, what you see on Hyperliquid is going to become available to every American is probably not the experience that we're going to get.
Now, look, I could be wrong. And I think this changes as the market evolves. And as these products become better understood and they get better marketed. And especially if they start being offered to institutions, I think there's there's an argument that institutions might be drawn to the perps market and that this displaces some of the demand for futures and for options and so on. But I think at the end of the day, the idea that launching domestic perps is going to result in this renaissance of demand for all coins or for crypto. I think is a bit of a fantasy. So, look, we're going to see these products soon, if not already.
You know, these products have already been approved. I don't actually know if they're live and trading. Do you know that? They're not. They're not. They're not. They're not. Yeah. Yeah. So, there's a way to trade for Colchee. Right. I would predict that you don't actually see the Bitcoin price move very much once these perps launch domestically. Now, if I'm wrong, that's how you'll know. You'll know that I'm wrong about this thesis because wow, they quit so much incremental demand, so much buying pressure that we're seeing now from Americans. But my guess is that we're actually not going to see much movement once US perps go live.
Yeah. I would agree that actually there's not really much that we'll move Bitcoin price right now. Like we kind of just need to get through some pain, but that is a separate topic and a separate issue. I think the more bull case is that like perps, they grow, they penetrate, they get adopted marginally at the margins. And then in like 2028, people think Bitcoin is cool again. People think it's cool again. And then they go back to Coinbase and there's this six slider mechanism that they've never seen before. And they're like, oh, hi, what can I do here? And then it's a little bit off to the races.
And that's how you get euphoria because it's going to work when people do that early in the cycle rather than late. And then a lot of people are going to make money and it's going to go viral. And then that's how you get the blow off top. That seems to kind of fit the pattern match the cycles that we've seen in the past. Yes. I think that's an accurate or not accurate. It's a plausible picture of how it might go. The other thing to remember too is like, why did we invent perps at all? But perps were not needed for other markets before crypto. So why were perps basically created the way that they are?
There's kind of two answers for it. One, perps are very simple for retail. And that's one big advantage. But the second thing is that we had to create an instrument that works in a system without any credit and without any ability to claw back from people who lost money. Right. In the traditional financial system, we know who you are. There's no randos. We're not going across multiple jurisdictions where there's no way that we're going to be able to get your money back in the traditional financial system. If you go negative, okay, we send you a bill and then we send you collections and we get the money back from you even if you go negative.
So part of why perps evolved and became so popular in crypto was because of the particular market structure of crypto being global and unregulated. So bringing perps domestically, now I do agree that perps are a simple product easy for retail to understand. That's great. But part of why perps thrived is in this environment of being offshore and not having the ability to basically claw back money from people who are deeply read. And the US domestic exchanges don't actually have that set of problems. Otherwise, like, look, perps have been around for more than 10 years. And yet they're not adopted for almost any other market besides crypto, even still, except for the perps that we now have on RWA's.
As a very good point, maybe as you might be alluding to perps are just an offshore thing. They just resonate with being offshore. I do think it's true that they're very simple for retail. And I think that's the real virtue of perps is that it's so simple to just be like, yeah, buy the thing and lever up this much the end. You know, doing that through options, doing that through futures, having a role, you know, blah, blah, blah, you know, CFDs. Okay. There's there's there is just a virtue of this simplicity of perps. And I agree that that's a real thing. But it's really only true for retail. It's not it's much less true for institutions.
Sure. Sure. Last thing has been before I let you go Coinbase bought ENA. That's the token of Athena. On the open market this week and also flagged a new partnership. It sounds like they are going to put in an Athena yield product into their front end kind of as they did with Morpho. What does Morpho do? They just offer Bitcoin back loans. You put up your Bitcoin, you can get a loan. Sounds like they are doing the same thing with Athena. What does Athena do? It provides yield with dollars actually with via perps by going delta neutral. And then they collect something between like four and seven percent.
I don't think we know what the yields will be in Coinbase in the front end. But pretty cool to see another implementation of the DeFi mallet. So Coinbase in the front, Athena in the back giving yield accounts. What was your reaction to see when you saw this? Very excited. So we're big investors in Athena. We leather seat round. So we've known this team for a long time. And we we had a small role to play in kind of bringing the relationship between Coinbase and Athena together. And so it's very exciting to see this actually come to fruition because not everything like this actually does. And Coinbase obviously has been super supportive of things DeFi.
They've always been very forward in adopting things and offering stuff that kind of go into the C DeFi type construct like they did with Morpho. So I think that's awesome. It's important to call out that Athena is evolved quite a bit from the early days. You know, it used to be that almost all their yields came from the carry trade or the basis trade. And that is evolved as the carry trade has really kind of weakened because you know, just the basis is not as strong as it once was while crypto markets are pretty bearish. So I think this is also part of the evolution of Athena and its strategy.
And on some level also part of the evolution of Coinbase presumably. So there may be something in here. We don't know the details yet. And I don't know the details. But there may be something in here that is responsive to the constraints placed on Coinbase via the Genius Act. Or so not the Genius Act, but the the correct act. So clarity kind of revises the Genius Act by restricting your ability to pay yield. But if it's not you paying the yield, you know, not being the issuer. If they're getting yield through some other product, you know, technically that allows you that allows them to get yield.
Even if it's not directly through, okay, the the issuer of the stablecoin paid the yield. So there's a sort of economically equivalent transaction such that they're getting yield. But the yield is being shared between Coinbase and Athena when can imagine. And so, you know, economically, it's not that dissimilar from what it would look like for a stablecoin to pay yield. Now, I don't know if that's what's happening. I'm kind of speculating. But I think there's probably an interesting story on both sides of this partnership. My my reaction was the same. There's specific language that we cannot pass the yield from the from treasury yield treasury yield specifically.
And that's what's happening here. The the yield is completely generative of a net new source, which is inspired by the treasury yield, but it is not the same thing. And so one of the things one of the stories of the clarity act as I understand it is that there is some creativity with how Coinbase can pass back the yield. And this seems like a potentially creative solution. Yeah, it's possible. I mean, so Athena does have some USDTB, which holds a black rock, a little money market on the back end, I believe. But it's also possible that this is being offered to non-Americans or there's different versions of this for if you're American versus not American, because remember the genius act or and or the clarity revision to genius only applies to Americans.
And Coinbase is a lot of non-American users. So you can still pay yield to non-Americans. That's totally fine. Just the Americans can't get the yield from their own government bonds. Thank God for our government protecting us from the yield. I see. This was the first week of June. Thank you for coming in and stepping in for Ryan. Ryan will be back next week. And that has the bankless weekly roll up. I see. Appreciate you coming on and giving us all of your thoughts. I really appreciate you. Cheers. Thanks for having me, sir. Bankless Hation, you guys know the deal. Crypto is risky. You can lose what you put in.
But nonetheless, we are headed west. It's not for everyone, but we are glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot.