Bankless Weekly Rollup Last Week of March 2023
------ 📣 Infura | New SDK for NFT APIs For Devs https://bankless.cc/Infura
------ 🚀 JOIN BANKLESS PREMIUM: https://www.bankless.com/dashboard
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/kraken
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
👻 PHANTOM | FRIENDLY MULTICHAIN WALLET https://bankless.cc/phantom-waitlist
🦊METAMASK LEARN | HELPFUL WEB3 RESOURCE https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
🚁 EARNIFI | CLAIM YOUR UNCLAIMED AIRDROPS https://bankless.cc/earnifi
------ Topics Covered
0:00 Intro
3:56 Markets 5:49 2/3 of QT reversed https://twitter.com/biancoresearch/status/1639004727001358339 17:41 Staking tokens up - April 12 is the date https://decrypt.co/124812/ethereum-staking-tokens-shanghai-upgrade-gets-date 19:14 Arbitrum https://l2beat.com/scaling/projects/arbitrum https://twitter.com/TingHu888/status/1638884726441410561 21:00 How much ETH is lost forever? https://twitter.com/jconorgrogan/status/1637944295746412549
26:50 Binance gets busted https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/8680-23 https://twitter.com/Bonecondor/status/1640376962999787521 https://twitter.com/Bonecondor/status/1640398821153816592 https://www.binance.com/en/blog/from-cz/czs-response-to-the-cftc-complaint-2408916493005890282 https://twitter.com/blockbytescom/status/1640370581949362182
35:18 War on Crypto continues https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/ERP-2023.pdf https://twitter.com/FEhrsam/status/1638247809488150529 https://twitter.com/ryansadams/status/1640511693045346305
43:20 Crypto has its defenders even outside of crypto! https://twitter.com/nic__carter/status/1640494485456003072 https://twitter.com/FinancialCmte/status/1640804417850036227 https://twitter.com/Dennis_Porter_/status/1640144615843188737 https://www.bankless.com/congressman-tom-emmer-tackles-the-war-on-crypto https://decrypt.co/124872/sec-gensler-insists-clear-rules-crypto-already-exist https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1641060548312813570
57:38 ETH 57:45 Polygon ZkEVM launched https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ/status/1640745582644830210 59:48 Consensys launched their zk-rollup Linea https://twitter.com/LineaBuild/status/1640639901292015616 1:00:18 L2Beat introduced Risk Rosette https://twitter.com/l2beat/status/1640302851900465154
1:02:39 Euler https://etherscan.io/tx/0xf69c53b82273764989cdecf75b6daabb0c0bd30b4e659bca080948126c1f992c https://etherscan.io/tx/0xf69c53b82273764989cdecf75b6daabb0c0bd30b4e659bca080948126c1f992c
1:05:39 MakerDAO https://twitter.com/MakerDAO/status/1641106700756213760
1:07:18 NFTs Ticketmaster debuts NFT-gated ticket sales https://business.ticketmaster.com/business-solutions/nft-token-gated-sales/
1:09:56 Microstrategy https://www.coindesk.com/business/2023/03/27/microstrategy-pays-off-silvergate-loan-buys-more-bitcoin/
1:11:07 Nasdaq to launch crypto custody service in Q2 https://twitter.com/watcherguru/status/1639236196894121984
1:11:40 Avalanche C chain out of order for +50 minutes https://twitter.com/kevinsekniqi/status/1638712640242319364 1:12:27 U.S. charged SBF from bribing China https://www.reuters.com/legal/ftxs-bankman-fried-charged-with-bribery-conspiracy-new-indictment-2023-03-28/ 1:13:05 Pause on training AI https://futureoflife.org/open-letter/pause-giant-ai-experiments/
1:16:44 Dune Integrates Chat GPT4! https://twitter.com/DuneAnalytics/status/1640386318000611329 1:18:48 MetaMask is integrating SiwE natively! https://twitter.com/SpruceID/status/1639043625047977985 1:21:00 Kraken partnership with Williams Racing https://twitter.com/krakenfx/status/1640700416156397571 1:22:33 Conduit https://twitter.com/conduitxyz/status/1640731248124637185
1:23:33 Jobs https://bankless.pallet.com/jobs/f39528ec-e381-4c1f-a9ad-907e69ac27bf
1:27:06 Questions from the Nation Bigwiggle501 Goggart RocketPoolster
1:34:18 Takes https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1639621702115049477 https://twitter.com/friedberg/status/1641206963538399234 https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1641270392948944896
1:43:55 What David’s Bullish On 1:46:00 What Ryan’s Bullish On
1:48:25 MEME of the Week https://twitter.com/biancoresearch/status/1639086175721000961 https://twitter.com/Fiskantes/status/1640388198215069699
1:49:44 Risks & Disclaimers
---- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Gary Gensler, tell the principal's office. Can we get Gary Gensler to the principal's office? Wait, I thought he was the principal. You can bring him to another office. There's the principal's principal, which he is now going to. Yeah, so he has been summoned. Bankless Nation, it is the last Friday of March. It's time for, what is it, David? Uh, the Bankless Friday weekly roll-up, where we cover the entire weekly news in crypto, which is always an ambitious endeavor. This week is a medium week, not so bad, so everyone can take a breather. Medium, still a lot of happen, though. So, yeah, we persevered nonetheless regardless of whether it was a big week or a medium week in crypto.
And here we are. You have to, you have to keep going, right? Because you never know which roll-up might be the last roll-up. You just never know. Life is uncertain, David. Uh, a few topics of the week, though. Oh, I got to start here. You're not in your usual place, though. No, I'm background. Different background. I am currently in Montenegro, which is not an ever-a-spot that I ever thought I'd be, to be honest. Wait a second, wait a second. Isn't that the place Doquan was just found, or like late last week, Friday of last week, and you are there, too? I was at the same airport that Doquan was at, like, five days ahead of me.
Yeah, I'm on the hunt for Doquan. That's what I'm doing. That's what I'm doing. People don't know right now whether you're joking or what's going on in the wool. We'll just let the mystery continue. We got some topics of the week. Number one, there is a CFTC versus Binance Battle. Binance getting busted by the CFTC. We're going to dig into that. What else, David? ZK EVM continues. We got two of them this week. Last week, we had one this week. We have Dublin every week. Yeah, every week. So far, they have been doubling every single week for two weeks in a row. And then lastly, Gary Gensler, tell the principal's office, can we get Gary Gensler to the principal's office?
I thought he was the principal. You can bring him to another office. There's the principal's principal, which he is now going to. Yeah, so he has been summoned to testify. Are these the right words in court about his actions against the crypto community? In court? No, excuse me. No, not in court, not in court. In front of the people, which is Congress. Gary Gensler, two face Congress grilling over crypto policy. Gary Gensler will testify before the House Financial Services Committee. So Gary Gensler is testifying in front of the House about his treatment of us. There we go. Those are the details.
I'm here for a good Gensler grilling. I'm here for it. Let's do it. It's a product market fit. Exactly what I want. Speaking of product market fit, we got to talk about our friends over at Infura because they have an API, an NFT API, that I think has some product market fit, David. Tell us about it. This one's for the devs, isn't it? Yeah, this is for the devs. So this is an SDK for an API for your NFT app, if you will. So whether you are, and if you don't know what that means, you're not a dev. So just absorb this knowledge through Osmosis. I'll brute force it into your brain. So Infura has gotten SDK for you, the NFT builder out there, whether you are doing most of the things that NFT contracts do, selling an NFT, buying an NFT, minting an NFT, Infura has got an SDK for you to make that easy for you.
Three smart contract templates to allow you to write onto eight different blockchains and mint NFTs, either ERC721s or 115 tokens, to really expedite the building of your NFT process, your NFT application. There is a link in the show notes for you to get started. You can sign up and account with Infura to get started. Or you could just go to banklist.cc slash Infura. There it is. Well, it will help me chill in NFT. That's another verb that's Austin used. We all will start somewhere, but that's not in specifically the API. Okay, can't help you, Shell. Can help you do everything else though. Click the link in the show notes, guys.
Gotta get to the market, David. What is Bitcoin telling us on the week? Bitcoin down half a percent, which I consider flat. So started the week at 28,000 dish currently or 28,700 currently at 28,420. I have a flat, flat, flat week for Bitcoin. On the week I'll take a flat, how about ETH? Down 2.3% on the week. Start of the week at $1825 currently at $1795. $2.517. I mean, all of this, not bad considering, right? Not considering. You're just on price. Great. Yeah. Uh-huh. Interesting. I think we'll get into that in a little bit. How about the ratio? What's that saying on the week? Also flat? Down 2%.
So 0.063. So I believe the third consecutive week of a down ratio price. Bitcoin still has that strength. Bitcoin with this negative. Yeah. How about total crypto market cap? We want more. $1.2 trillion, $3 trillion, $1.2 trillion. Not too bad. Look, I consider all of this a win in this economic environment. Oh, bear market, right? Just like, hopefully this is not only narrative. Hopefully there was actually real new buyers of Bitcoin in the last, since the last banking crisis. The worst case scenario would be that it was just a sideline crypto traders who had a bunch of stable coins, who then decided to buy on the narrative that real buyers would be coming.
That's what we don't want to be true. What we do want to be true is bankers were like Bitcoin. Okay. I think that's probably still early. I think it's all still the same recycled buyers. But that's how all of these things start. That's the bad news. That's still the bear case. But it doesn't mean that they're wrong right now. And you have to start somewhere and you always start with that foundation of existing buyers who are like, I'm a little scared. I'm going to stable coins and then they buy back in. I think this might be the story as to why David. And this, to me, looks like fundamentals.
This is from Jim Bianco. This is the Fed's updated balance sheet. You can see the numbers here. Now, two thirds of the quantitative tightening has been reversed. So over the course of starting in 2021, all the way to up till March, the Fed had been actually, sorry, from 2022, March of 2022 or so, up till 2023, full year, the Fed had been tightening. They had been destroying assets on the balance sheet, decreasing the balance sheet, I should say. And it went from like $9 trillion all the way to $8.35 trillion. They got $700 billion in decrease in the Fed balance sheet. And then what happened, David?
Then $500 billion came back inside of two weeks. So a nice try, Fed. You guys really did your best. And Ryan, you're saying you said the Fed was able in the last year, again, the interest rates started March 2022. Now we are in March 2023, one year. So we had a good, a good ol' try, a good ol' fashion Fed try. I have a call. A good ol' call to try. We started at basically $9 trillion. So when you said we shaved off $700 billion, we started from $9 trillion. So $700 billion is a lot of money. It's quite a lot of money. We started from $9 trillion. We got down to basically $8.3 trillion. And then in the last, it took us a year to go from $9 trillion to $8.
3 trillion. And now it took us two weeks to go from $8.3 trillion to $8.7 trillion, $7.5 trillion. David, this seems to be the big, kind of good run, Fed. Well, well, there's still some debate here. So a lot of people are still saying, including Ben Hunt, whom we had on the podcast as part of kind of, are the banks insolvent? Is the dollar going to hyperinflate? Says this spike right here is just temporary. You know, he always uses the analogy of like, you inject liquidity right into the heart, right? This is kind of the wake up the patient kind of needle. And then it goes back down eventually.
Whereas biology, Arthur Hayes say, uh, uh, this is permanent. And by the way, this spike, you ain't seen nothing yet. This is going to continue to increase. Biology is like, in 90 days, this is going to be massive. Whereas Arthur Hayes thinks it will take years. Jim Bianco gave us a pretty recent take. I feel like was kind of in the middle. Wait and see, how would you summarize Jim Bianco's take from our episode earlier this week? Jim Bianco is towards the Ben Hunt end of this spectrum. So I would say biology and Arthur Hayes are actually pretty close to each other in terms of their position.
Biology sang 90 days until Bitcoin's $1 million, which is very fast. Arthur Hayes sang two years to $1 million, which is still very fast. Ben Hunt, two years may be a million. A million on the table and two years. Ben Hunt is like, that's complete noise and ridiculousness and actually totally irresponsible. And Jim Bianco is less emotional, I'd say, than Ben Hunt is, but still directionally agrees with Ben Hunt saying that yes, this line that we are looking at on this screen is extremely vertical. We just erased two years of rising interest rates. Think of all the pain in the market that we've had for the last year, excuse me, the year of interest rates.
Think about the pain that we've had. And then we just erased all of that progress from the Fed's perspective inside of two weeks. Jim Bianco says, okay, but this spike that we've had is not systemic. It doesn't mean the same amount of QE and liquidity injection that Stimme checks do. And so this is much more contained, compartmentalized to just the banking sector. And it's not going to leak out to the actual bank accounts of, you know, mom and pop and Joe and Alice, right? And so I think this is actually, and of those four interviews that we did. And Dan, did we really try and get down to the bottom of this?
And I feel like we did with Jim Bianco. Yeah, I feel, I feel Cloture on this, honestly. I went in being like, let's get two sides of the story here. And what we ultimately ended up getting is like four different perspectives, which is actually closer to reality. I mean, things are complicated. Real life is complicated. And so getting all of those four perspectives kind of, yeah, I feel Cloture on it anyway. This is another piece of the macro story here. This is Elf saying the same thing macro Elf that is. It took 215 years for the US to reach 7 trillion in debt. This is he zooming out here. Then it took only 27 months, March 2020, to June 2022, to add another 7 trillion.
215 years to get to the first 7 trillion, David. And then 27 months to get to the next 7 trillion. This is, of course, all of the outstanding debt from COVID. This is the big jump right here, these 27 months. This is the big story, I think, here of like, if you zoom out a little bit, even past the two-year mark, look how large and how fast the Fed balance sheet has actually grown. Yeah, he also have finishers that tweet saying, debt is not a bug of our credit-based money system. It's actually a feature. What does he mean by that? I'm confused by that. I think he's saying central banks are kind of designed to do this.
This is what they do. I mean, this is the nature of compound interest, right? So when you see an exponential curve like that, I don't think it should be totally foreign, but this is happening because, I mean, this, when you inflate a currency at 2% per year, this is actually the same shape of the chart that it would look like. This is certainly more than 2% per year, but this is what happens. Did you listen to, so Ben Hunt's strongest point to me is like, you can have a hard money Bitcoin type of, or Ethereum type of monetary system, because what you lose is credit. You lose the ability to pull social credit together, and that's what a fiat regime brings.
And by the way, he would argue the last 150 years of economic prosperity, everything we enjoy in a modern economy is because we have that social credit. We have that trust. And so he really rejects the idea that we would kind of go back in time and reestablish things. So that's his take. And I think maybe Macroff was saying something similar in debt is not a bug of our credit-based money system. It's a feature, right? How else do you get credit, David, in kind of a hard money, hard asset regime? That's the question Ben Hunt posed. And I understand elements of that. And Jim Bianco kind of echoed that, and he's like, hey, banks actually play, this is bankless.
But banks play a function, did you know? The function that they play is not as a data, is not as a money warehouse, that's kind of stupid. I mean, we can hold our own private keys. We don't have to warehouse our money inside of a Wells Fargo. But the role that they do play is like, small community credit creation. That is a role that, right now, defiant cryptos is not fulfilling. And there is some role for banks in that role. So I understand that perspective, too. Yeah, I think the thought experiment to really understand this metaphor that Ben Hunt was saying was that, say we have a Bitcoin standard, you could have a bank that has Bitcoin deposits that operates on a fractional reserve system.
So they take in 10 Bitcoins, and then they lend out 100 Bitcoins, and then they charge interest rates to get that back. The reason why, so in theory, like you could still get credit in a Bitcoin system, if you had just like a Bitcoin bank that denominated in Bitcoin and did the whole fractional reserve thing, that's technically still possible. The reason why the economics would still be different is that in the Bitcoin banking system, with a Bitcoin standard, with Bitcoin credit, you actually don't have a Federal Reserve, which can mint Bitcoins on the other side to backstop banks if something goes wrong.
And so even in a Bitcoin banking system, you still have much more credit risk because again, if the bank goes and solve it, you have somebody who can print Bitcoins on the other side, which allows for more credit at lower interest rates, therefore more investment in the future, therefore ultimately more debt on the Federal Reserve's balance sheet to happen. Yeah, that makes sense. That's my question. Look at this chart, David. So this central bank chart, how does this chart compete against this chart? Something like this. Crypto-economics. That's a good one. That's a good one. For those connections.
I see you in podcast, like just listening to this. So the Fed balance sheet is obviously spiking up, expanding at a precipitous rate. And I just pulled up ultrasound money, which is Ethereum, supply decreasing. Those charts are inverted to each other. So which do you want to hold? Do you want to hold treasuries in the dollar? Or do you want to hold this thing? That's what I don't think central bankers have fully calculated that now there is another option, a better option. And we do get to have both. Like we want to, as individuals, hold ether because of its deflationary properties and its store of value over the long term.
And as a society, we also want fiat so we can get a home loan, for example. Both are good. Both have their, both have their, I think you can totally have both. Yeah, but I'm not holding this one. I'm not holding dollars, though. I am, well, so like I have a home loan. I have debt in dollars. I love debt in dollars. I love you. Isn't it great? You ever look at your mortgage and you're just like, oh my God, that is just inflating the way. Right. That is getting less expensive over time. Right. Fantastic. Me and my, I've got ether on the other side. Like that is a beautiful symbiosis. For you, it is definitely for me.
I don't know what it does to society. I mean, this is what we're grappling with. This is Chris Berninsky's take on this, on this whole thing, David, which is, he says this, maybe this kind of sums up the discussion we've had. A number of people asking me what I think about in the context of the current banking crisis, regulatory fights, apologies bet, and so on. So here it goes. Current banking crisis is bullish for crypto long run. Short term, we're likely in the eye of the storm, so expect volatility. But the banking crisis has been a monetary-induced policy. Too much, too fast with rate hikes, and will be solved by monetary policy.
Fed and other central banks will drop rates, perhaps even this year as the market is now anticipating, which will allow existing bonds to rally and voila. Banks that are currently struggling will have healthy balance sheets again, in quotes. This banking crisis is also more likely to cause disinflation than hyperinflation in Chris' opinion. Credit is drying up, that's interesting. BTFP isn't the same as Stimme's. Stimme's went straight to consumer spending, whereas BTFP is shoring up bank balance sheets, which is likely to just sit there. But disinflation will give the Fed and the other central banks cover to lower rates.
And that will breed air back into the fire of growth stocks and crypto, turning regulation in crypto, and then he ends with this. As for BTFP, I don't take him literally, but more as directionally alerting people. In this distracted day and age, sometimes you need to do severe things to get people's attention. He's done that. But as I said earlier, I think disinflation from here is more likely than hyperinflation, at least for the coming years. Really interesting take here is, biology was kind of being intentionally mimatic about this. And the bit signal 90 days, a million dollar Bitcoin bet, that was him intentionally kind of being hyperbolic about this.
He said he wasn't doing that. Yeah, I know. He said on the podcast that this is not him doing a marketing stunt. Yeah. Well, so another reason we'll take from Chris and I guess we'll see. We are what, you know, 80 days left, 75 days left. Yeah. Speaking of upcoming dates, what do we got happening pretty soon, David? We got withdrawals happening pretty soon, Ryan. Ether with draws coming. The date is April. What's the date? If you scroll down, I can read it up because I don't have memorized April 12th. April 12th. So LSD tokens are getting a nice little bump in their price because of the incoming Shanghai upgrade.
So this is when we can, as validators, withdraw our ether and ether just gets violently sold into the market and the ether goes to zero, crashes. Yeah. That's what happens next. Well, what do you think is going to happen at withdrawal? It's up or down. Price go up. Number go down. What do you think? Flat. Yeah. Staking tokens going on now. Flat, first flat, maybe for a week, maybe for two weeks, and then people will realize that it was quite literally a bullish unlock in the sense that the stakers aren't dumping their ether because stakers are inherently bullish ether. And then people will realize that everyone that hasn't bought ether in the last month because they're fearful of the staking withdrawal unlock are going to be like, oh, it's over.
And the stakers didn't sell. Well, I'll guess I'll buy back my ether. And then we go. So David, David thinks the unlock will be bullish. It'll be flash on bullish. For a weekish and then bullish, yeah. I don't have a strong opinion on that. So I'll just take yours. Sounds good, David. Tell me about Arbitrum. Are you surprised that my conclusion is that it's bullish? Bullish. Are you surprised about that opinion? I'm not, David. I'm not surprised. Let's talk about Arbitrum though. So they had a token launch. Was that last week? Token went out to the markets last week before it launched. Yes, last week.
It was announced two weeks ago. It was launched. Right, right, right. It's all blurring to me. Arbitrum, total locked value jumped a nice $2 billion. You can see it in the chart. Yeah. On layer two beat. And there's also some reports of airdrop farming. What is this tweet, David? Yeah. So this is a tweet of what looks like just one device emulating what looks like hundreds of devices. And I can only assume processing transactions on Arbitrum. So this is what a modern day airdrop farm looks like. I'm still yet to see an analysis, a report of the farmed nature of the arb airdrop. It's like 600,000 addresses.
We didn't know what percentage of them might be farmed. Hopefully it's low. But you're worried that it might be high. I'm sure the efforts of the Arbitrum airdrop curation, like the criteria pruned away like 90% of at least 90% of the airdrop farmers efforts, but like 90% like they need to have well, it is what it is. Ideally, they were pruning away 100, pruning away 100 is damn near impossible. How close to 100 did they get is the million dollar question? And I have yet to see an answer to that question. How successful were airdrop farmers? We do not know the answer to that decentralized exchanges seem to be recently successful.
This is Hayden Adams tweeting Dex versus centralized exchange. I don't know to say sex. You're not going to say sex. Dex versus sex volume is at an all time high of 25% since the FTX collapse. Pretty incredible. In the back of 20-22. New all time high. New all time high. Decentralized exchanges are crushing it. This is a tweet about, have you ever wondered, David, how much eth is just lost forever as a percentage of it? I actually wonder about that quite a lot. Okay. Well, this is Connor and he's got the answer for it. You want to read this? Thanks, Connor. Connor says, I've categorized thousands of instances of Ethereum typos, user errors and buggy contracts.
Thus far, I found 636,000 ether, about $1.15 billion that is lost forever, and I'm assuming verifiably lost forever, which is about half a percent of these circulating supply. That's a lot. That's not a small amount. That's not a small amount. And you could see where he came up with some of these numbers. The parody wallet bug. That sucks. Yeah. That's almost like 5% alone. That's a good piece of Ethereum. That's a good piece of Ethereum history lore that I bet you a lot of 2021 crypto people don't know too much about. Oh, okay. Why won't you tell them? Oh, God. It's such a crazy story, man. So there was this library of code.
I don't know. This is stretching my developer's technical ability to tell the story, but there was this library code-based library or something, and a junior dev on the parody team was messing around with it, and sent this very infamous message to, I think, inside the parody slacked that says something along the lines of, oops, I accidentally killed it. The accidentally deleted the code library or something, which basically froze the multi-sig for parody. The parody was a consensus client that didn't, how did they get all that ether? That was inside. I thought this was the polka dot raise. Was this the polka dot raise?
Yeah. My memory of this is this is a polka dot raise. They basically put it in a wallet, a smart contract, like a multi-sig type early prototypes smart contract and there was a multi-sig that wasn't the gnosis safe. It was their own custom made multi-sig. Yep. And the bug caused a billion dollars worth of eth now to be stranded there forever and locked forever. So, yeah, the message is, I think I killed it. That is terrible. Unfortunate, but that means 0.5%, which doesn't even include an ultrasound money chart of eth is probably locked forever and it's getting, that's going to increase over time.
Yeah. All right, David, what do we have coming up next? Coming up next. We've got the big news, the week Gary Gensler goes to the principal's office, which, yeah, I'm sure everyone is just, we'd love to talk about that, but first, we're going to have to talk about finance getting busted by the CFTC and we'll give our takes about that, how serious of a deal that is, ZK EVMs, an oil or update, SBF managed to get in trouble again. So, we'll talk about that and more, but first a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible, especially Kraken, our recommended crypto exchange because Kraken has been here for 12 years and I can only assume they're going to be for at least 12 years more if not the entire rest of crypto, which is why if you are unsure about your centralized exchange, perhaps you should sign up with Kraken, there's a link in the show notes.
Here we go. Kraken has been a leader in the crypto industry for the last 12 years, dedicated to accelerating the global adoption of crypto, Kraken puts an emphasis on security, transparency and client support, which is why over 9 million clients have come to love Kraken's products. Whether you're a beginner or a pro, the Kraken UX is simple, intuitive and frictionless, making the Kraken app a great place for all to get involved and learn about crypto. For those with experience, the redesigned Kraken Pro app and web experience is completely customizable to your trading needs, integrating key trading features into one seamless interface.
Kraken has a 24-7, 365 client support team that is globally recognized, Kraken support is available wherever, whenever you need them, by phone, chat or email. And for all of you NFTers out there, the brand new Kraken NFT beta platform gives you the best NFT trading experience possible, rarity rankings, no gas fees, and the ability to buy an NFT straight with cash. Does your crypto exchange prioritize its customers the way Kraken does? And if not, sign up with Kraken at Kraken.com slash bankless. How many total airdrops have you gotten? This last bull market had a ton of them. Did you get them all?
Maybe you missed one. So here's what you should do, go to earnify and plug in your Ethereum wallet and earnify will tell you if you have any unclaimed airdrops that you can get. And it also does PoApps and Mintable NFTs, any kind of money that your wallet can claim earnify will tell you about it. And you should probably do it now because some airdrops expire. And if you sign up for earnify, they'll email you anytime one of your wallets have a new airdrops word to make sure that you never lose an airdrop ever again. You can also upgrade to earnify premium to unlock access to airdrops that are beyond the basics and are able to set reminders for more wallets.
And for just under $21 a month, it probably pays for itself with just one airdrop. So plug in your wallets at earnify and see what you get. That's E-A-R-N-I dot F-I. And make sure you never lose another airdrop. Binance gets busted, David. The CFTC sued Binance over what they say are regulatory violations. This is a press release from the CFTC. What is going on here? Yeah, so the CFTC has filed a civil enforcement action charging CZ and three entities that operate the Binance platform with numerous violations of the Commodity Exchange Act and other CFTC regulations. So this complaint charges that Binance holdings limited, Binance holdings i.
e. limited, and Binance services holdings limited together, Binance. Man, that's a lot of entities and that's not all of them. Operate the Binance centralized digital asset trading platform along with number of other corporate vehicles through an intentionally opaque, common enterprise with CZ at the helm as Binance's owner and chief executive officer. The defendants allegedly chose to knowingly disregard applicable provisions of the Commodities Enforcement Act while engaging in a calculated strategy of regulatory arbitrage to their commercial benefit. Okay, let me summarize that. TLDR, CFTC is suing Binance and CZ on allegations that the company knowingly offered unregistered crypto derivatives products inside the United States against federal law.
Directed to the crypto derivative is like a future or something and they didn't get the CFTC's blessing. Exactly, yeah. Directed US customers to evade compliance controls through VPNs. Poorly supervised its business didn't implement KYC or AML processes and also had a poor anti-evasion program and also they never registered as a compliant futures commissions merchant. And so the CFTC and continuing litigation against its defendants, the agency seeks disgorgement, civil monetary penalties, permanent trading and registration bans, and a permanent injunction against further violations of the CEA and CFTC regulations.
This is interesting, David. This is not a charge of fraud, seems like. It's basically, you did follow the rules. You did not follow the rules. File the paperwork and register for your derivatives products and you didn't do the AML KYC stuff that is required by US financial law, the CFTC. This is not like an SBF. You're running a Ponzi scheme that assets aren't backed type of charge. I don't even think it's the same type of charge that Bitfinex was charged with, which was some of this. Bitmax, excuse me. Bitmax was charged with violating the Bank Secrecy Act, which is a massive deal. So what does all this mean?
What's your take on this? Well, there's some other things in this report as well. There's a link in the show notes to read the report. There are some pretty damning things. And so here's a link. There is a thread. We are looking at one tweet in a very long thread of a summary of this report. And so I'll read this one tweet to kind of indicate the more egregious side of things, instead of just like failing to do KYC and registering. So reading from the report here. Internally, Binance Officers, Employees and Agents have acknowledged that the Binance platform has facilitated potentially illegal activities.
For example, in February 2019, after receiving information regarding a Hamas transactions on Binance, Lim, a Binance executive, explained to a colleague that terrorists usually send small sums as large sums constitute money laundering. So they send small money through Binance because they don't want to send large money because large money triggers the flags. So the colleague replied, you can barely buy an AK-47 with 600 bucks. And with regard to certain Binance customers, including customers from Russia, Lim acknowledged that in a February 2022 chat, the quote is like, come on, they are here for crime.
Binance's MLRO, I don't know what that is, agreed that we see the bad, but we close two eyes. And so the more direct charge that's being made here is Binance was the host of a very significant amount of money laundering, and they just completely were aware of that and just looked the other way, maybe perhaps, obviously, totally willingly. So that's the more damning charge that's going on here. Yeah. And I also don't think that's any surprise to anyone in the crypto industry, like I, I, without any evidence, I totally assumed that that's what's going on. Yeah, it's, it's just interesting. I guess the posture here is, okay, CFTC, understood.
But at the same time, they're going after Binance, they're also going after, not the CFTC, but US regulators, they're going after Coinbase. I mean, we just talked about that last week, like shutting down Coinbase staking the Wells notice to Coinbase from the SEC. And I know that Coinbase is much more thorough being US located on AML KYC acts. So I, you know, I don't know. I understand it. I understand why the CFTC is doing this. What is Binance's response to this complaint? Yeah. So CZ made a response to the CFTC complaint. So I'll just read the first two sentences here. Today, the CFTC filed an unexpected and disappointing civil complaint, despite our working cooperatively with the CFTC for over two years, upon an initial review, the complaint appears to contain an incomplete recitation of facts.
And we do not agree with the characterization of many of the issues alleged in the complaint. Basically, CZ saying, like, they're going to fight back. I'll, I'll assert again, and I'll stay safe without evidence that I, with talking with me and my friends and the, the chats that we have, like, everyone kind of assumes that CZ and Binance was allowing a bunch of money laundering to process through their change. I know a friend, perhaps, that has logged into Binance while under a VPN, while Binance has not been allowing US customers and was still able to trade under on Binance. That is like an open thing that the industry has been doing.
Americans has been doing. We've all known that that's an easy and trivial thing to do. You just use a VPN. I'm just saying, this is what my friend did with use of VPN, and then get in and get out. And like, that's been an open secret that the entire industry has known. So I don't think anyone is surprised that like a bunch of illegal money laundering has been going through Binance. And so the fact that this is happening is like no surprise to me. And I think an inevitable conclusion today is the finally the day. And the bull case for this is that Binance pays a fine. They settle with the CFTC.
And maybe even gets the green light to they can argue some of the things like permanent dismantling or whatever. They can they can fight that in court. But hopefully this actually starts a conversation which makes Binance perhaps more jurisdictionally friendly with US. It's very interesting to me because I guess they because they have the power to do AML KYC checks and because they have sort of the, you know, big, big red button to to ban someone or to allow them to stop logging in that they're now responsible for that, which is very interesting. And as a contrast to like a DeFi protocol, right, which has no control over these things.
So the Uniswap code base, it has no ability to differentiate the money, the identity, anything else. And I guess if you are this this also not only does it sort of push some of these centralized platforms to to button up, which is what you're saying, pay the fee and then button up. I think that's probably the the hopeful outcome that Binance would have. It also pushes things more towards decentralized protocols where no one has the ability to do the AML KYC ban someone, you know, push the button where it's kind of completely open. And you know, the CFTC can't go. I guess maybe they can try to sanction code next, right?
Which is what they did with trying cash. But the CFTC didn't try, but the powers that B did, yeah. Interesting stuff. Interesting stuff. Okay. Two more bits of news on this thread is that in the lawsuit, the CFTC versus Binance holding clearly states that Bitcoin, Ether and Litecoin are all commodities. The implication of this is that it perhaps on an alternative world, the SEC might have sued someone else saying that these things were securities. But the CFTC is saying they're commodities, which is like this is a proxy war between the CFTC and the SEC. Yeah. Right. Yeah. You think Gary Gensler read that was like just pissed off.
I'm sure he read it on Twitter. Yeah. And as mentioned, yeah. David, the war on crypto seems like it is continuing. There was an economic report from the present that came out last week. There had an entire chapter. This was like 90 pages called digital assets, relearning economic principles. It's kind of like, do you mean it's on the world of money and finance? No, no, relearning economic principles is what it was called. There was a, you know, I read parts of this, not the entire thing, but like, it felt like 90 pages of just fun being like, okay, so let me offer you an example. Did you? I skimmed it.
Today, cryptocurrencies don't offer any fundamental value, nor are they a better alternative to fiat money or more effective payment system. Instead, their innovation has been mostly about creating artificial scarcity in order to support crypto assets prices. And of course, the conclusion David the report continues is that the nation's financial infrastructure has the potential to offer these same benefits. They're basically like, yeah, that crypto thing is, you know, a scam, Ponzi's, get rich quick. And we can, you know, what people should be using is our central bank digital currency, our existing financial system.
There is no need for cryptocurrency. It's just a bunch of grifters and scammers. And the real solution that they're looking for is, of course, the Fedcoin, the central bank digital currency. That is the conclusion of this report. Hey, man, water's wet. Sky's blue. You and I are bullish ether and the United States wants you to use the dollar. Like, this is, this is just what it is. I'd, I'd look, it's, is it the United States? It's definitely the White House right now. I will say that maybe there are other factions of government that the power to be in the United States. Yeah. This is Fred Erickson.
15% he says of the annual White House report is devoted to crypto foot. I have a question for you that admirable that you even skim this thing. I have a question for you, though, David, which is something that's been on my mind lately. The last, you know, two to three weeks as sort of the the anti crypto and the pro crypto sides. Some of that argumentation has reached maybe a fever pitch, at least a local high. Do you think the US will ever make it illegal to own cryptocurrency? Like flat out ban, you as a, you as a citizen, you must turn in your crypto kind of executive order 6102. You remember that where FDR banned gold?
Basically, you had to sell it back to the government. An individual American citizen could not own more than some amount of gold. You know, basically melt down your jewelry, melt down your gold and sell it back to the feds. That's what actually happened in the early 1930s. And by the way, that that law was an existence for like 40 years. Didn't get that reversed until like the 1970s. Do you think that could happen with crypto? No, absolutely not. Why do you not think that? Because you have a court of law where you will sue them. It did happen in the United States in the 1930s. And there was a court, there were courts of law.
It's not like the 1930s and have courts of laws. No, no. Exactly. We're in a different society now. I happen to be outside of the United States and if that law ever got passed, I would not be coming back. Well, that's, you know, that's interesting. I haven't read much up on the kind of the 1930s if, if similar gold quarters made that choice. And by the way, that's what they were called, gold hoarders. This is sort of the vitriol, which is basically like, you must hate, you're not a patriot. You're just hoarding. You're greedy. You're defecting from the coordination. This is a public good. We need to all maintain our, our fiat currencies, right?
Exactly. Very, very anti, anti kind of capitalist, anti sort of like do it for the public, do it for the social good. I guess what I'm seeing, David, is similar narrative sentiments starting. She's like Ben's hunt, push back against biology where he's like, you know, you're causing a bank run biology by even saying this and biology is saying, I'm just telling people to get to the lifeboats. Are you, are you against lifeboats? If the ship isn't sinking, you have nothing to worry about Ben. And Ben is pointing at biology and saying, you're causing this. Right. What about kind of the social good of keeping this system intact?
We lose all of these things if everyone flees to the life frapt. I'm seeing the seeds of this, this kind of idea of like crypto hoarders, crypto bros. I'm seeing it. So I don't know why you're so convinced this couldn't happen in the United States. I totally think it could. I put a pull up, by the way, and I asked the question, well, the US ever make it legal to own cryptocurrency. Followers on Twitter said no 60%. Yeah, this is surprising 40%. I just don't know why you think it's not possible. But you're just saying that society has pressed it. I mean, it's certainly possible. But yes, it's a progression of society, it's a progression of technology.
Things were more extreme back then. That was an extreme time in people's life, like pre-internet times. Dude, we had like not seism. That was an extreme time, right? We think we are entering some pretty extreme, not not quite 19 20s, 19 30s level, like late 1920s. But things have gotten a lot more extreme than when I grew up in the 90s. I think we've adapted as a society. I think the internet allows information to spread. It allows us to learn from history faster. I don't think it would be possible for us. I'm reading a bit of history lately. I don't think it would be possible for us to have the 60 million deaths as a result of just a mind virus of communism in Soviet Russia, because if we had the internet, I don't think that that would have been possible.
I don't think that we would have, I think when there's just imperfect information and just the way that the society worked back in those days, I think extreme circumstances were allowed to rise much more than in today's world. I totally think this is possible. This whole scenario, I totally think 60 million, 100 million deaths could happen in the 21st century. But that aside, let's talk about this specifically, which is the US could make it illegal to own cryptocurrency. I think the first step towards that wouldn't be just a flat out ban. It would be basically a choking off of the crypto exchange.
There's other ways to do this. We're already seeing a little bit of that, David. We are one step down that path. And the next step would be like, sure, you can buy crypto on an exchange or an ETF, but you can't withdraw to your, like just take Coinbase, take Kraken, no more withdraws to not. You can still say, it seems much more possible to me. Well, and then it's basically, and then after that, the next step would be if we ever get to this step, would be. And by the way, a bunch of crypto-bro hoarders turn in your cryptocurrency. Yeah, make it sell it to a legal version. Yeah, for sale. You have to exchange it for this ETF version of it.
I'm not, I still find that seems slightly more plausible. I can see this. I still think like this is 10% probability, but like, if shit hits the fan, I'm saying, if it depends on how it's rich, if central banks are actually threatened, as they were in the 1930s, and then the politicians and society sort of rallies around, yeah, we have to be in this together. It's like war times is bad times. You can't leave on the lifeboat, right? Things get worse. If everyone leaves on the lifeboat, I could see it happening, but it could be unbeing pessimistic here. Anyway, I wanted to have that conversation with you.
I'm glad we had that. Yeah, now I didn't know that I had to think about that, but now I do. Let's take this to the courts. Crypto also has defenders, even outside of crypto. So David, you said one of our recourses is the court system. Certainly, the United States does have a court system, and this is a white paper courtesy of Cooper and Kirk, which is a law firm, that is actually, they've previously sued the FDIC and the OCC and the Fed over Operation Chook Point 1.0, which was the choking officer in industries like marijuana industry from the banking system. And now they are alleging in this white paper that the US government is doing the same thing to crypto.
What's the summary of this report? Yeah, they sent a letter to US Congress regarding the clandestine financial war against the cryptocurrency industry urging Congress to hold agencies accountable and propose questions and steps to obtain answers. They are claiming that regulators are using regulatory tools and pressure tactics to prevent crypto integration to the financial system and that it's up to Congress to hold federal banking regulators accountable. Now, Ryan, I was not here during the time in which gold was made illegal, but I would imagine, maybe there was stuff like this, maybe I'm being naive, but this is an example of like the push back that comes very early and very hard by a very engaged community that perhaps I don't think we had way back then.
And so this isn't any action, this is just a letter that is drafted by a law firm, but it is allowing the world, the people of the United States to have foundation to stand on to air their grievances. Yep, it's basically executive branches is kind of forcing this and we have two places we can go to fight it judicial, which is the court system, which is what they're attempting to do and they're also calling on Congress to push back against it. Speaking of Congress, Gary Gensler, he's got to go in front of Congress, is that what's happening? Yeah, Gary Gensler to face Congress grilling over crypto policy is the headline.
So, Gary Gensler is going to testify before testify. Gary Gensler is going to testify. Oh man, getting. Before the House Financial Services Committee, it's Chairman Patrick McHenry has confirmed that this is going to happen. This is going to happen on April 18th and he will face questions over his approach towards the crypto ecosystem. Gary is going into the hot seat. I'm sure he's going to prep for this. There's no way that he isn't like cognizant and intentional about his strategy towards the crypto world. So I'm sure he's going to come with a pre-prepared list of deflections saying something like he's already said is like I just I just look towards the Supreme Court for guidance.
I apply the rules of the securities laws that have been established before me. I'm sure he's just you want to do you want to take a shot every time he says how he tests? Yeah. Oh, I mean, I don't want to die, but but that's a fun game. This is a this is kind of interesting because I have observed this too. There does seem to be increased partisanship over crypto. I would not have said this two years ago. Yeah. You know, one one party was more pro crypto than the other. It seemed sort of about even and both were kind of like almost neutral on it, but that has started to change. What is this tweet that we've pulled up here?
Yeah, this is a tweet from Dennis Porter who is a big corner that we've actually had on Bickness before and he tweets out pro crypto and pro Bitcoin Democrats are lining up to voice their opposition to their own party stance. Democrats are on the verge of driving away their own voters and losing support from this important new voter block. In my opinion, it could cost Democrats to 2024 election. And then there are screenshots of four crypto Twitter personas who are saying that they are perhaps reconsidering their previous democratic base in support of the Republican party. If indeed the Republican candidate was sufficiently pro crypto and I'm sure other facts and circumstances as well.
This is someone saying I have never once voted for Republican president but is considering this. This is also Chris Berninsky and we quoted earlier, crypto is going to be an issue for voters in 2024 and already that is a sign of us winning. But I have also never seen the US govern be so draconian. In fact, so long as it's not Trump, it may cause me to vote Republican for the first time in my life. It's very interesting. I know you have a way in on this too. I have a first green started here. Yeah. Okay. What's your take on this? Yeah. So I am one of the four people that are that it's being screen shot and tweeted out by Dennis and I said my entire family is Democrat.
I was once considered myself a Democrat and now I kind of consider myself just politically agnostic. Great party. Great party. Yeah. That's great way to put it. I was once a Bernie bro because of Hillary. So I'm putting my political opinions out here. Sorry for that. I too would vote Republican for the first time given that it is the correct pro crypto candidate and also the Dems continued on the anti crypto war path. Since I'm here grandstanding about my political opinions, I also followed up this tweet with another tweet saying and that Republican would also have to be pro choice. That's how I what I believe.
And so like for me, my personal political beliefs are that I'll vote on almost a single issue voter for crypto. So long as that candidate is not an insane person, I will vote for the pro crypto candidate. It's definitely if it's definitely making you question, right? Previous political beliefs over this one thing and it could start to cost the Democrats. Is that a popular position in your family, David? No, it is not. And so actually, so the growing back to Chris Berniske's tweet, I shared Chris Berniske's tweet with my in my family chat and because my entire family is like pretty thumbs up about Elizabeth Warren.
And I just said, hey guys, like my entire industry thinks that Elizabeth Warren is super cringe and not treating us with respect and is actually doing the whole emperors wearing no clothes thing because the way she talks about our industry is coming from a place of completely just misunderstanding and being uninformed about things. And it's making our entire industry not just question her stance and information about crypto, but basically her stance and information about any other industry. It's kind of like when you when you understand how the mainstream media reports on crypto and you're like, well, they just got that wrong.
And so is that how they report about everything? Because they're getting threats are wrong. And so what about everything else? I think that's true. Although I will say one thing is just I think people are inherently skeptical of like industry bias, right? Sure. There's like big pharma. There's, you know, the gun lobby, all of these things and big banking and big crypto, that could be a thing. Crypto is not big crypto, but like crypto bros, that sort of thing. To me, this is less about an industry fighting for like its ability to exist and survive. Although that's part of it. To me, this goes far deeper than that.
This is like a basic like American civil liberty to own a freaking digital property. Right. Like this is this, this, something that bodies and values. This is deep the level of like constitutional like this is freedom of speech. This is digital civil liberties. And to me, this is not a about like one kind of party helping and getting donations from crypto or not or getting crypto. This is just like why can't we all rally around this being like core to a Western classically liberal democracy that embodies human values and translates that for the digital age. That's what crypto is to me. I don't know if that's an effective argument on anyone in your family, but that's certainly what I believe.
And this is also increasingly what I think some politicians are giving voice to. So we had Tom Emmer on the podcast earlier this week, David. And I know like you were on at the beginning, you had some internet connectivity and then you were not fully established here in Montenegro. Dude, you should see how fired up he was. I'm looking at the thumbnail, man. Is this a thumbnail from the comments? Yes, I think I saw that face during. He is so fired up. And we talked to him a year ago. So we talked to Tom Emmer a year ago and he's pro crypto in this. This time it was a different Tom Emmer, different politician.
He clearly thinks that crypto is going to, I don't know his motivation, but assume he's just kind of a politician going with the votes and that sort of thing. He clearly thinks that this is a cornerstone of his platform. And I think, David, because he is the whip in the house that is number two, most powerful seat in the House of Representatives, I think this could become a platform for Republicans. Because the Democrats are letting them have it for the Republicans. It's like, this is free real estate. Basically, and somebody's got to go get that cohort of votes and we have got a two party system.
So it's going to be either one party, the other. And by the way, the more one party embraces it, the more the other party has to be like, we're not those guys. Right. So that's just how to stand for that. We don't stand for that. So anyway, I don't know how it's all going to unfold. It's really at his courts. It should be a bipartisan, just American issue, but it does seem like the Republicans are kind of making this part of their platform. And we'll see how that carries in 2024. Right. So when I was arguing with my sister, it is perhaps the leader of my family in the pro war inside of things.
And she was like, yeah, you crypto, you crypto bros, like, you think you don't need regulation. Like, look what happened to crypto in the last year. I'm like, are you serious? We are begging for regulation. And this is this is what this is that you're just touting what Elizabeth Warren is saying. Like she's trying to position us as these like rogue shadowy super coders who don't want at your regulation. And my response to her is like, no, you're doing the same thing that she is, which is misunderstanding and misrepresenting our industry and casting us off as like these barbarians crypto, like gunslingers, anarchists.
Please regulate us. Please. You're going to get clipped by this, by the way. Somebody's going to clip that. Please regulate us, David Hoffman. You were saying clarify before you get clipped on what you're actually saying. So if you can be regulated, if you are a centralized entity, if you are a bank, if you have, if you have, if somebody deposits trust into you, you are in need of regulation. If you are a decentralized protocol that is permissionless and or also aspires to be permissionless, and you need a path to become permissionless, I mean, regulation isn't just like clamping down the gates.
It's also providing clarity in paths forward for crypto protocols to mature. Yes. Absolutely. Yeah. So internet, get the full clip. All right. Don't just, don't just clip David saying, please regulate us. Crypto bro, like screaming from his eyeballs, one speculation. Crying. Crying. Yeah. Right. Well, you know what? Gary Gensler, you'll be happy to know, says, David, the rules are already clear. Gary, this is SEC's Gensler, insisting clear rules for the crypto market already exist. But the regulator says the digital asset industry is rife with non-compliance. You already have all of the rules in front of you.
It's perfect clarity. I've already explained this to you in office hours with Gary. Your problem is you're just non-compliant. That's what Gary says. I can't wait to get me looking forward for you testifying by the in front of Emma, too. What's Emma going to do? Get him, Tom. Okay. This is going on in the meanwhile, David. And this is just a contrast point. Maybe we'll end this section here. The freest country in the world. Okay. What America purports to be is choking off crypto while Hong Kong is opening the floodgates. Do you see this? I am including a Bloomberg article. Hong Kong regulators dozed meetup to help crypto firms with banking.
How you're just talking about like politicians filling the vacuum. Free real estate, free space here is exactly what Hong Kong is doing. Coming out of Hong Kong, can you believe this? Being like, okay, if New York City, the US government doesn't want to be part of this crypto revolution, doesn't want to be sort of a a nexus for finance in this world, then we will be. And I think it's straight embarrassing for the United States. And this is the take that Tom Emmer had, which I, which I share, is America just going to build its future on debt? We're actually going to build something again. That's a question.
And crypto is like a new generation of the internet invitation to go build things here. And what we're doing with these policies and all of the marvelous clarity Gary Gensler is giving us is driving builders off shore outside of the United States. You are not welcome here at crypto entrepreneur. And if we keep doing that, it's not going to be good for the United States. Crypto will be fine. It's just not going to be good for the US. Maybe I'll end it there. What do we got coming up next? Oh boy, that was a while, man. Okay, coming up next. Two more ZKTVM's land on the Ethereum Maynet. We got some good news out of Euler.
MakerDow has a new path for die. SPF gets in trouble amazingly that the guy just can't get, can't stop, can't stop. And then AI training, I'm talking about AI now, is getting called for a timeout. So all of this and more, as soon as we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. Uniswap is the largest on-chain marketplace for self-custody digital assets. Uniswap is of course a decentralized exchange, but you know this because you've been listening to Bankless. But did you know that the Uniswap web app has a shiny new fiat on-ramp? Now you could go directly from fiat in your bank to tokens in DeFi inside of Uniswap.
Not only that, but Polygon, Arbitrum and Optimism Layertudes are supported right out of the game. But that's just DeFi. Uniswap is also an NFT aggregator, letting you find more listings for the best prices across the NFT world. With Uniswap, you can sweep floors on multiple NFTs and Uniswap's universal router will optimize your gas fees for you. Uniswap is making it as easy as possible to go from bank account to bankless assets across Ethereum. And we couldn't be more thankful for having them as a sponsor. So go to app.uniswap.org today to buy, sell or swap tokens and NFTs. The Phantom Wallet is coming to Ethereum.
The number one wallet on Solana is bringing its millions of users and beloved UX to Ethereum and Polygon. If you haven't used Phantom before, you've been missing out. Phantom was one of the first wallets to pioneer Solana's staking inside the wallet and will be offering similar staking features for Ethereum and Polygon. But that's just staking. Phantom is also the best home for your NFTs. Phantom has a complete set of features to optimize your NFT experience, pin your favorites, hide your uglys, burn this fam, and also manage your NFT sale listings from inside the wallet. Phantom is of course a multi-chain wallet, but it makes chain management easy, displaying your transactions in a human readable format with automatic warnings for malicious transactions or phishing websites.
Phantom has already saved over 20,000 users from Giddings GAMD or HAT. So get on the Phantom wait list and be one of the first to access the multi-chain beta. There's a link in the show notes or you can go to phantom.app slash wait list to get access in late February. David, this week, the second ZK EVM just launched. So we've doubled ZK at EVM's in two weeks. This is Polygon's ZK EVM. Tell us about it. So yeah, Polygon's EVM is ZK EVM long-awaited, just shipped to Mainnet. Ryan John Adams, my co-host here, had a fantastic show with Jordy Belina and Mihalo from for Polygon. Jordy, fun fact, previously, I actually love this story because it was me, this is going to be a deep cut of a story.
It was me, Mariano Conti and Mihalo in ETC 2021. I had just come out of my scooter accident if you remember that. Black eye. No, no, just a black eye. I didn't lose anything. Yeah, no, just a black eye. Did you chip it to? There's something you wouldn't do. Yeah, I chipped a tiny little tooth and then it came back. Yeah, I grew back. Yeah, wow. Anyways, so fast forward, like four weeks into ECC, I still had a little bit of puffiness. Anyways, it was me, Mariano Conti, the guy that deployed mate, multi-clateral dye and maker in 2019. We were just getting a beer towards the end of ECC and Mihalo gets a phone call.
He looks at it, steps immediately up and goes and answers it and me and Mariano just continue having a beer and then Mihalo comes back with an overjoyed facial expression and we were like, dude, what was that? And he was like, dog, good news, man, good news. I can't tell you. It was this. It was this. It was the Polygon acquisition of ZK Hermes, which was Jordi Belina's project, which is the man that you see on the screen to the left. And the fast forward to where we are today, this is the culmination of that phone call, of that partnership agreement. And now we have the ZK EVM live on Mainnet.
And so that was what was launched. When was that launched on Tuesday? Tuesday of the day? Yeah. On Tuesday. Eath as the gas token, Matic is the payment to validators. Okay. We've got the full interview if you want to check that out. And the cool thing is how fast and furious these ZK EVMs are now coming. I feel like this is crypto's broadband moment. This is Ethereum's broadband moment, at least. David, we just got our second. But here's consensus coming out and introducing a third. I mean, there are lots of places. Okay. Lena, it's called a developer ready ZK roll up powered by consensus. I haven't investigated this, but they're just coming out of the woodwork now.
We got ZK EVM suddenly. It's March 2023. And we got block space. We got a real cheap block space. You want block space? We got block space. Ether is selling block space. Oh my gosh. Speaking of block space, layer 2B. All right. I love layer 2B because they provide transparency to all of these roll ups that are coming to the market. And as we multiply our chains, it's hard to know what the decentralization and security guarantees are on each of these chains. Did you see this? They added this little kind of pie chart. What are we looking at here? Yeah. So this is a five. There's a think of this like an orange slice for the podcast listener.
So an orange slice with five slices. And each of these slices can be various colors. Gray, yellow, red, and I'm assuming I'm assuming green. Maybe actually we don't see any green yet because nothing's green yet. Actually, no green is possible. Is green possible? This is an orange slice of what? The risk security. Yes. So there's five different like things that all roll ups need to be secure on data availability. Where's the data stored? And can that data be rugged? Upgradeability, validator failure, sequencer failure, and state validation. All roll ups need to improve on this on all five of these things.
And so this pie chart that you can see. Actually, I'm still confused. That's a whether or not. Sorry. There are only three colors. There are is gray, yellow, and red. And okay. Man, they really make gray green. Gray is green. Intuitively, gray is green. Green doesn't exist. Gray is good. Gray is good. Yeah. So there's gray yellow and red. And so you can see the characterization, a snapshot of what the security risks for every single layer to are and what they have to work. Basically, you want your orange slices. You want the whole thing, the whole circle to be all gray. Gray, gray. Can we get this in green?
We and the closest is Arbitram one, which has two orange slices out of five. And yes, you just said orange slices, but there's no orange color. Okay. David is actually talking about the orange, not yellow. I'm worried that people will see like, man, we're totally screwed this up, but we are not editing this out. All right. This is wrong. Unfiltered bankless material. Two orange slices are on. All we're trying to say is go to layer2beet.com. If you want to check in on the risk, you're layer two. That's probably all we need to freaking say. Next topic. Get it out of here. Euler. Good news. David Euler, the exploiter of return 51,000 ETH.
51,000 ETH. 51K ETH. And actually, even more than that, there was another transaction that returned another 7,000 ETH. There was also another transaction that I've returned something like 20 million die. They got 84% of their funds back. 84% of Euler exploited funds are returned. That is, if you had told me that we were going to get 84% of funds back the day it was like, wow, that is unheard of. That's pretty good. Let me ask you here. What are these criminals doing? I wasn't following this story. So like, you go, you hack something. You hack like $150 million. And then you go and a week later, two weeks later, you return 84% of it.
Who does this? Like, what is happening here? So there's two routes. So understanding that my first take on the first exploit was like, man, this is totally North Korea because they immediately went into tornado cash implying that they had no intent on returning the funds. So follow up on the story, and I'll give my take after this, is in a series of messages written into the data of transactions on the Ethereum blockchain, the exploiter says this. Jacob here. I don't think what I will say will help me in any way, but I still want to say it. I fucked up. I didn't want to, but I messed up with others, monies, others, jobs, and others lives.
I really fucked up. I'm sorry. I didn't mean all that. I really didn't fucking mean all of that. Forgive me. And then in another transaction, he says, Jacob, apparently, the rest of the money will be returned asap. I only look after my safety. And that is the reason for the delay. I'm sorry for any misunderstanding implying if we're taking this, if we're taking Jacob seriously, that we are going to be getting a hundred percent back of what we were exploiting funds. So it was either two things, two, one of two things happened, maybe both. One, law enforcement found him and said, Hey, man, you are going to jail.
If you don't return the funds right now, you're going to go to jail for like a big time. If you return the funds only right now, you will only be go to jail for a little bit, something like this, something along this line. That's how it works. That's how it works. It's how it's directly correct. The other one is like he actually felt bad about all of the lives that he damaged. And so he returned it out of guilt. But then he also had an option A there, David. I'm going to go with option A because he, I mean, assuming Jacob's his actual name, he was like, yo, the gig is up. You guys got me. Here's all the money back.
And it's also me doing this. I'm sorry. Here's your money. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Crypto like worst robbers in history. Imagine going like, you know, stealing something from a bank and then like returning a week later, me like, Hey, guys, I'm sorry. I met. I was going through a rough patch. Yeah. Here's the money back. I didn't think of the consequences. I really didn't think about it. I'm sorry. So strange. Well, such as crypto and the good news. Everyone else happened. Okay. Yeah. Maker. What's a new era has begun? Chapter zero. What are we looking at here? We are looking at a promotional graphic.
If you turn on the sound, it doesn't say anything. It is just music. So I actually was trying to get the details of what this announcement means. And then there wasn't too much there. I went into the governance forums. I opened up the links. I looked at what was being proposed. Man, it's make a really bureaucratic. And so they are tweeting out chapter zero. A new era has begun. A governance proposal has passed that ratifies a new constitution, which includes four maker doubt to one, increasingly decentralized the collateral that backs die. And I think the big obvious low hanging fruit here is removing dependence on USDC, but perhaps also for real world assets.
Second, allowing die to free float relative to the dollar. This was an original idea for maker doubt that has kind of been pushed to the background for a very long time now, but now is returning questionable. Also questionable is the timeline on this. I don't know how it like is that this year or were you just saying that we still want to do this? I don't know. And also improvements to the actual governance process of maker doubt. And they also said that they are going to limit real world asset collateral. These are the notes that I have from Christie. Thank you, Christie, who did more research than me.
But man is finding out what this actual announcement is actually really confusing. If someone can summarize this for me, they'll be really appreciative. My high level take on it was they want to go less in the direction of real world assets and more in the direction of crypto native assets because the real world is looking a little anti crypto these days. But probably that's not what they did. Ticketmaster is difficult. This is cool. This is cool. Okay, but I thought ticket master was the villain. And so they jacked up those Taylor Swift concerts. And I resent them being associated with crypto.
But you tell me this is a good thing. If you accepted that face value, which maybe I'm overly optimistic and bullish on humanity, but I will ticket master has launched the ability for artists to offer token gated ticket sales, meaning that a sale can only be unlocked or access with a specific NFT. They've launched a token gated option for special access to concerts and event tickets for eligible NFT holders. And they also have a suite of artist driven tools offering many unique ticketing services, including face value ticket exchange, a program that limits transfer and locks and resale prices at face value.
I don't know if that is done by a smart contract, but in theory, it could verified fan a registration system that filters out scalpers and bots user and and bot users who are looking to acquire tickets for the purpose of reselling and ticket master requests a service that eliminates the traditional on sale rush by allowing artists who sell tickets to high demand shows through a fulfillment and request model during the purchasing process ticket master prompts a user to connect a wallet to verify ownership of an NFT after that is the same buying process. So token gated access to buying some NFTs along with some other equitable tools and services that in theory could all be smart contracts, but it wasn't stated whether they are or not.
And is this a reformation of ticket master? I wouldn't go that far, David. But look, this is a pretty big deal actually ticket master is absolutely massive. These tokens are minted on Ethereum and accessible via Metamask and Coinbase. This is onboarding more people to kind of NFTs. I think in any other like, you know, news cycle or week or like in a world where ticket master was less hated at this specific moment of time, we probably would have led the episode with this. This is actually yeah, huge news in terms of the thing that we care most about, which is like onboarding the world to crypto in Web 3.
Pretty big. I think it's fair to be skeptical about ticket master just by nature what there are and their incentives. And also at the same time, it's also fair to accept that this maybe it's on ticket master, but is coming like verifiable tickets as tokens on Ethereum by someone somewhere. I bet you Gary thinks these are securities. Oh, do you want to ask them? Yeah, come on the podcast Gary will ask you. They're better. Come on. That's that's the only way we can find out. Come to office hours with David and Ryan. Microstrategy. They just bought more Bitcoin. There you go. 6,455 new bitcoins to come to a total amount of Bitcoins of 138,955.
They also paid off a loan that was collateralized by Bitcoin. We tried to unpack it and really understand it. Something else happened, but anyways, micros how's your about more Bitcoin? It was a while. It was a while something about another Bitcoin. David, you didn't want me to include this link, but we had some discussion about it. You know, how much God would be right? If for the record, I told him to not do this. Let me finish. Let me finish, David. Okay. If Microstrategy had purchased Ethraven Bitcoin, rather than $4 billion, do you know how much they would have, David? I'm assuming more, more money.
$6.5 billion. Almost double. There's their section that they had bought Eth and said. David wanted to stress because he told Ryan to not do this. Yeah. And I was like, you know what? I am gas today. You be breaks. Yeah. Try to stop it. YouTube viewers will notice that he typed in the URL instead of instead of pulling it up. This might get cut by readers. I don't know if this will make it, but let's talk about this. The NASDAQ is launching crypto custody service in Q2. The NASDAQ, what are they abandoning stocks, David? Are they looking over their shoulder at the crypto, walking and they're totally abandoning all stocks and equities going crypto only.
That's the news. No, I'm kidding. They're first primarily providing custody services for Bitcoin and Ethereum. This is the top of the rabbit hole of a long list of potential services that they could do. It starts with custody. Kind of cool. Avalanche had an outage last week, what happened? Avalanche, the sea chain was out of order for about 50 minutes, halted the block production, a bug related to blockchain validation. They released an update. This was the second time that this has happened in seven days, which triggered me to make a tweets that caused me to fight with a bunch of Solana and Avalanche people, and that was more or less my weekend.
And David, sorry about all of that. And he takes it all back. Yes. There are some tweets that I could have phrased better. There are some tweets that I could have been more precise. Everything I said, I completely believe. I've never written a single tweet that I didn't believe in. There were a couple, a couple of one or two might be up there. These are those ones. Yeah, except the ones that were released later. The US is charging SBF for bribing China. How much more trouble can this guy get in? Okay. What's happening now with Sandbag been freed? That is the SBF. Sandbag been freed. He is charging with paying $40 million to Chinese officials as a bribe so that they would unfreeze his hedge funds accounts.
Yep. That sounds like a crime, David. Yep. Well, they're frozen for a reason. But I guess it was China that frozen and he paid them $40 million to unfreeze them. All right. Okay. Well, now he's in trouble with two governments, I guess. This is some AI is between usually you don't cover, but I think this is important. This is an open letter to pause all giant large-scale AI experiments. And I got to think that this is maybe not inspired by the bankless podcast with Elisir, but certainly inspired by Elisir himself and his caution and concerns about AI safety issues. Bankless listeners might know if you didn't listen this episode early in the kitchen archive, we had Elisir Yutkowski on who basically he told us we're all going to die because AI is quite literally going to become super intelligent or in the process of becoming super intelligent.
There was no way to keep them aligned with humanity and our ethics and morality. And so that would result in the inevitable demise of human beings. The AI's just basically sort our atoms and do something else with them. So it seems like that's not just him that's concerned about this. This is an entire open letter saying to stop to pause all large-scale AI experiments like stop chat GPT4 is what what I'm reading in this article. No, stop all AI innovation more powerful than chat GPT4. That's the limit. That's the chat GPT4 like armistice like everyone pause everyone stop. So this is the future of life institute, which is a nonprofit organization that works to reduce global catastrophic and existential risk facing humanity, particularly from advanced artificial intelligence.
So this is a petition that you can go sign. It's already signed by Elon Musk, Steve Watson, Gary Marcus, Yosha Bengeo, I don't know, and others. If that is something that you call me, David. Andrew Yang. Oh, wow. Yeah. Wow. That's a max tag mark. Man, oh, you need to read some books by max tag mark. Our mathematical universe. Have you read that? Also life, life 3.0. Great books. Great books. Do you really like these days? What's your take? Are you going to are you going to sign this David? What's your take on this? I don't know. I actually really had to consider that for a moment. I don't know.
And I actually, I'm worried that signing a letter is not going to do anything to stop it. Right. Because this is a mullock problem, right? So like say nine people out of ten agree to sign the letter and pause one defects and one defects. Well, then that one person just gets the lead, right? Or what is the classic mullock problem? Yeah. Well, I will have to say that the LEA's are podcasts that we did. Like I heard from multiple people that it had made waves in the AI community more than it had before. And I think it was important that LEA's are did a non-AI podcast for that to reach new audiences and permeate outbound.
So I think this is not necessarily coincidence that this letter is happening right now. Look, we are not done exploring AI, the AI safety problem. And I think our next, the next stop for for Bangladesh is to get the kind of the counterpoint to LEA's or someone who's a bit more optimistic on AI. So we've got some guests lined up in, because this is what we do April. So expect a deep dive there and those will be a fun piece of trivia. The AI guests that we have recorded. I think we're recording with him next week or maybe the week after a couple of couple of weeks. Yeah, week after spoke at East Denver 2018.
So if you care to find out who that is, there is a little bit of trivia for you. All right, someone will find out. Dune integrates chat GPT4. Wow. Okay, speaking of this, this is the crypto plus AI. Of course, you know, conversation. This is Dune Analytics, fantastic dashboard for coming up almost viewing. They really use it so frequently on the roll up to show data. It's a kind of a complicated dashboard to operate as a not I haven't really dove down how to spin up a board. But I mean, I guess data always uses it. Hildabi uses it. We've used Dune Analytics on the weekly roll up many, many times.
It requires kind of a technical brain to operate. This is what's so fascinating though about chat GPT and why I think it's so hard to stop because like right now it's so damn useful. Could you imagine going to like you and I don't know SQL, not very good with this. We can't construct our own boards. When you love to be able to go to like Dune Analytics and type in like and just give me the number of ETH addresses from date, you know, January to March that steak to eat boom outputs an answer. Like that's what chat GPT4 can do. And it's going to consume all of this public available blockchain data anyway.
And so that's part of the MoLockTrap is how do you stop it? So it's too useful to try to shut down. All the Dune board creators who do like selfless work and create boards for us to view. Like again, like people like Hildabi people like data always. There's a few others. We are now going to be thanking chat GPT4 and their services will no longer be deleted. Sorry guys. Well, look, the bull cases it for them is it allows people to operate on a higher order of rather than constructing the data. You just have to know what questions to ask. Right. Yeah. I think that's easier because I thought it was funny.
Sorry, I'm taking these two seriously because it's the AI topic and it scares me, David. That's cool. By the way, I am an investor in Dune Analytics. I don't think we mentioned this. You and I are both investors in L2Beat. Got to mention this, of course. All of our disclaimers are always at bankless.com slash disclaimers. David Metamask is integrating sign in with Ethereum much more natively these days. What's what's this news? Yeah. So this is Bruce ID the Twitter account as Bruce is basically the studio behind sign in with Ethereum. So sign in with Ethereum is now being so like everyone knows they're like, log in with Facebook, log in with Google.
Metamask is now having like a log in a sign in button and it is integrating with the sign in with Ethereum protocol. And so that is what is being announced here today. Sign in with Ethereum and integrated with Metamask. David, I think we're going to see sign in with Ethereum on more websites including and excluding our website right here. Bankless.com has silently added the ability to connect with your e-thedress. Look at me doing this. Connect your wallet. They're really this way to log in. Metamask our favorite wallet and sponsor ever. Thank you. Connecting with an address. Boom. Sadly, we don't see that part on screen.
Sign in to verify identity. Let's fucking go. There we go. We don't see the Metamask because Zoom doesn't do the screen share for Metamask. Sorry. Right. And then I just signed in. So I linked my wallet with my bankless citizenship. And now I don't have to log in in order to access all bankless citizen content. You don't have to log in with your email password. You do get to log in with your Ethereum address. So when we launched the bankless website, it was unequivocally. One of the most positive responses about the website, like everybody was positive, except for one complaint. Which was that they needed to log in with an email and password.
That was the one, everyone, everything was unequivocally positive. And this one person was like bankless bad because signing in with an email address. And first off, I'll remind you, we're a newsletter. We need your email address. And fast forward, however many weeks ago, we launched this website for about a month ago. Now we have signed with Ethereum. Yeah. It's just actually those like two weeks that took us. Oh, wait, when did we launch the website two weeks ago? Yeah, two weeks, two, maybe two and a half. Jesus. Time is weird. Zoom in. By the way, speaking of zoom in fast, Kraken Exchange just announced an official partnership with Williams Racing.
What's cool about this is there's some way that Kraken has provided for you to get your NFT, potentially on the back of a race car. Yep. This is a partnership with Williams Racing of F1. So this is F1 Motorsports. It's not NASCAR. Not NASCAR. European. Yes. So new horizons, new frontiers for Kraken, if you will. So they have a Kraken logo on a race car. So Kraken is getting a race car. And they have real estate on this race car for your listener, you as you, your NFT could be on the Kraken race car. How do you get your NFT? Do not freaking put your dick butt on the back. Do not shame industry.
I could. I could. Don't. I could do it. I'm asking you not to try. How do you feel about an MFR? He's totally going to try. I feel fine about an MFR. Okay. But not a dick butt. Honestly, whatever you want to do, dude, it's permissionless. All right. I can't stop you anyway. I won't even try. So the details of how to get your NFT on this race car is in this link in the show notes. You put your NFT. I'm assuming this is how this works. You put your NFT into the Kraken NFT platform. And then probably sign up. I bet you that's how that works. There you go. Kraken is a sponsor of Bankless. Thank you.
Also adding layer two support, which we always love. We love that. You can now send and receive stablecoins natively to Arbitrum. There you go. David, some other layer to releases going on. Condo it is a crypto native infrastructure program that allows you to launch a roll up in just a few clicks. I'm pretty sure we predicted this feature would be coming. Like you can now use your token or the OP stack. Yes. Yeah. So the whole idea a long, long time ago was that the OP stack is the ERC 20 token for roll ups. Here we have a startup that is executing on that idea. So that not only is this a release, it's also a raise announcement.
So this is a startup that raises I think $7 million from paradigm. And they are one click OP stack deployment. Man, that is really, really cool. I think it's really cool. Yeah, that's really cool. We're going to have, you know, how it's very easy now to launch your token. And that was revolutionary in 2016 with Ethereum's basically provided a platform for that. Now it's going to be just as easy to launch your own entire chain. So we're going to have an absolute explosion of chains when it's as easy to spin up a website, launch token as it is an entire chain. David, we got tokens. We got chains.
We also got jobs. David, new jobs of the week and I got to do a shout out for a very important role. Bankless is hiring for what do we need here? What we need is someone to edit this podcast that you are listening to right now. We are looking for a podcast video editor slash media operations. So if you are familiar with audio and video editing software, if you've ever edited a podcast before, if you've ever edited a video before, we are interested in talking to you, especially if you live in EST or European time zones because a bankless nation never stops producing content. So we quite literally need a podcast editors across the globe because Ryan and I produce way too much content at all hours of the day.
So that is the job. If you want to work directly with me and Ryan to edit and produce podcasts, please click on the show notes and apply. We got 30, maybe 40 million downloads, I think, on the podcast. We're trying to get to 100 billion and then a billion. I can be a metric. You help us reach here. Got some other jobs going on to rise is hiring a marketing manager, a sales development representative, Uniswap needs a senior product designer, an application security engineer and a senior mobile engineer who's a react native. You can find all of that in more at the bankless jobs site bankless.palette.
com slash jobs. David, what do we have coming up next? Coming up next, we got the questions from the nation. We're going to talk about whether or not Ryan changed anything about our portfolio as biology scared us out of our pants. We'll talk about that as well as who was the first DK EVM on main net and then we got some takes of the week and we got what we're bullish on and then we got some memes of the week. There's more than one meme this week. So stay tuned because both of them are very, very good. But first, I'm going to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible.
Learning about crypto is hard until now, introducing Metamask Learn, an open educational platform about crypto, Web3, self-custody, wallet management and all the other topics needed to onboard people into this crazy world of crypto. Metamask Learn is an interactive platform with each lesson offering a simulation for the task at hand, giving you actual practical experience for navigating Web3. The purpose of Metamask Learn is to teach people the basics of self-custody and wallet security in a safe environment. And while Metamask Learn always takes the time to define Web3 specific vocabulary, it is still a jargon-free experience for the crypto curious user.
Friendly, not scary. Metamask Learn is available in 10 languages with more to be added soon and it's meant to cater to a global Web3 audience. So are you tired of having to explain crypto concepts to your friends? Go to learn.metamask.io and add Metamask Learn to your guides to get onboarded into the world of Web3. Arbitram 1 is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web3 landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitram 1 producing flourishing, DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With a recent addition of Arbitram Nova, gaming and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitram Home.
Both Arbitram 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar and fully EV and compatible. On Arbitram, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees. With Arbitram's recent migration to Arbitram Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit Arbitram.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets and start building your first app. With Arbitram, experience Web3 development the way it was meant to be secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free.
We got the questions of the week. This is a question from Big Wiggle 501 from the bankless citizen discord. After your chat with biology, does your portfolio remain the same? Have you made any changes? I think this is a question to you and I. Did you make any changes after the 90-day Bitcoin bet and our conversation with the biology? I want Brian, you to guess whether I changed anything. No, David, you did not change a thing. In the last, there is the slight probability that you just purchased some more eth is my guess. I would consider that not changing my strategy. You did it. Correct. Yes.
I will say during the biology week, the Bitcoin signal week, I was like, maybe I should perhaps reconsider my position because you don't have any Bitcoin or you have a little bit of Bitcoin. No, technically, I'm short Bitcoin because I have sold Bitcoin for Ether to do my Ether long bet. I think that's short Bitcoin relative to Ether. That's not to the dollar. I don't think you would be short Bitcoin. I would never, ever be short any crypto asset. Ever. God, are you insane? Why would you? I offended. Remember the person that got liquidated shorting Luna while it was crashing? No way. Anyways.
No, I did not change anything. While I did need to take a moment and reflect it in reconsider, I was like, okay, biology is saying this. Arthur hates also saying this. Perhaps this is not the time to have a net short position against Ether versus Bitcoin. I waited until next week to sleep on it and then reassess and I have decided that I will not do anything. So you're still bullish on Ether relative to Bitcoin. So you're still making a bet on the ratio then too. Correct. Doing more. Correct. Well, like I said, that is a 18 plus month long position. And I don't think anything changed. My position has not changed either.
I've been long Bitcoin for a long time. Right. So right after does on Bitcoin. I do. I have not purchased Bitcoin also in a long time. And I will continue purchasing Ether. I think that everything that biology and Arthur say, I don't do this in my mind, but like you can kind of substitute Ether as an asset. I don't think that biology or Arthur fully understand or believe in the monetary premium virtues of Ethereum in a high conviction way that you or I do. I think anything basically that benefits the monetary premium as a story of Bitcoin actually doubly benefits. Maybe I shouldn't maybe claim kind of any sort of ratio, but even more so benefits the Ethereum narrative over the long run.
So I haven't changed. Over the long run. Big emphasis on over the long run. Because I actually will take biology side that and I do take biology side that the banking crisis puts the wind in the sales of the Bitcoin narrative and also the long-term Ethereum fundamentals. But emphasis on long-term, like that doesn't hit until later, but Ryan, that is the long-term perspective that you have that you take. Yeah, it was kind of it was basically it was more confirmation, okay, well, this is what crypto people have been saying for a while and it looks like this is happening. So I haven't changed a thing, but it also was really like already way over way crypto.
So there's not much I could change. I can't get any more bullish. All right. This is a related question though. If you're going to have an IRA for a seven-year-old crypto friend, 70, not seven-year-old, how would you diversify into ETH Bitcoin? So on the older side, in that generation, what would you advise them of 100%. So they have their pool of other assets. And now they want to know, I've got some pool for crypto. What should I buy, not financial advice? But you're having a fight. If I was a financial advisor who would, in theory, therefore give financial advice, which I'm not for entertainment only, then it wasn't entertainment only.
Yeah, so the 70-year-old is an interesting detail because that implies like, you know, end-of-life phase. And so the question is like, how healthy is this 70-year-old are they living like five more years, 20 more years? Like how much? Well, I mean, at that point, you have to start to consider these things, right? And so if we're thinking of five to 10-year-long time horizon, the shorter the time horizon, the more weight I would go to Bitcoin. And if we are thinking that this is a 70-year-old yoga person who still goes on runs, then I would start to shift more towards Ether. So if we're thinking shorter, I would go 50-50 Bitcoin Ether because that is my bias towards Ether.
And then, you know, as soon as we start to hit like 10 to 15 to 20 year-long time horizons, I would start to go maybe if we're doing a 20-year-long time horizon, I would go 80% Ether 20% Bitcoin. Yeah, that's similar to what I would say. And it's interesting you're not saying any other tokens. But like, so it would just be Ether Bitcoin, right? I mean, if they want to hear my shitcoin portfolio, I'm happy to have you to talk about that. 70%. Actually, I would do either 70 or 80% Ether and either 20 or 30% Bitcoin. And I would do that Ether, a portion of that nice, staked Ether. I mean, if you are in your 70s, like how nice is it to have some sort of fixed income asset as well?
So you have the option to kind of sell it as it comes in or keep it. And that is something that that ETH Staking provides and is pretty unique. So I'd definitely overweight on ETH, either 70 or 80%. But I would have some Bitcoin. It wouldn't be 0% for a 70-year-old. I think that's right. Yeah. Okay. And by the way, I say the term shitcoins like endearingly, like I love my shitcoins. I don't think they're shitty. I love term of endearingment. Yes. This is a rocket pollster question. Who really was the first ZK EVM to main net? Who won David? Yeah. So I'll put a metaphor. You know when I did this to my sibling.
You know, when a sibling likes something to claim something. That's kind of what happened with the ZK EVMs. One just stuck their tongue out. Yeah, exactly. ZK sync was technically first be polygon by a few days. I will have to say ZK sync has been around for since 2017, 2018. We were processing getcoin transactions with ZK sync, the first ZK sync rollup, which was a ZK rollup, not a ZK EVM. But it has been around for a while. The fact that polygon is anywhere close to that is like a huge tip of the hat to the polygon engineering team for catching up to ZK sync. But ZK sync was technically first.
There you go. ZK sync was first. My answer would be, and does it matter? I mean, they were three or four days apart. We're getting ZK EVM every week now. I think we're okay. That probably won't matter in the grand scheme of things. David, let's do some takes of the week. You ready? We'll start with yours. Man, this is okay. This is the take that triggered a bunch of fighting out there. So sometimes actually it was just one and another one. Sometimes this is my take. Sometimes I feel banquoise. Us, that's us, right? Should victory lap more often. We ignored Solana, Avalanche, and Tara during the bull market, in which we got our not-friendly label as blind eith maxis.
The thing that happened next was Solana went down 80 percent versus Ether. Avalanche went down 70 percent versus Ether. Luna is basically at zero. More or less for all the same reasons that they would be, that this is unsustainable. This is just in what's invoked the moment. We chose to not cave to external pressure and not cover something that we didn't really understand or believe in. Meanwhile, we focus on layer 2s. Our listeners disproportionately got the OP and Arbitrum air drops compared to other media organizations. That's what we chose to focus on. We also pounded the table across layer 1 bridge risk.
I can't take credit for all of this stuff, but I'm saying that our listeners leaned in towards layer 2s more than Altair 1s and also leaned in to a shied away from cross layer 1 bridge risk. We got a lot of shit in the second half of 2021 because that was not in vote. Layer 2s were not cool during that time. You know what was cool? Altair 1s. You and I had conversations many times. Like, dude, are we out of touch with what's going on? Perhaps in that moment, maybe we were. But this is when we decided that Banclis is making content for things that you and I believe in. Not what other people want us to believe.
And so that choice, I think, has been to the great benefit of our listeners so far and all the choices that we've made about Banclis and the things we choose to talk about and how we talk about them. I would make, again, immediately. Banclis is not perfect, but neither is this industry. And I think if you can scroll down because I don't have my own tweet, I only hope that we can continue this track record. And that was my take of the week. Yeah. I agree with that. And I got to play the role of making sure that we inject some humility into this too. Definitely doesn't mean that we're perfect. And maybe it's the Canadian in me, David, but I have a hard time tweeting a victory lap type tweet.
So I'm glad you do that on behalf of Banclis because if we don't do it, who else is going to? But I will say we're definitely not perfect. But I hope the listeners know that what you hear on Banclis is authentically what we actually believe. And we try to stay as curious and open-minded as possible. We're also not perfect at that. We also have our biases. But I'm actually not against like I think I think you want somebody in crypto to have biases, right? They just have to be biased towards the right things. Like whenever possible, we try to be biased towards Banclis technologies and towards decentralization and towards things and products.
We think are making the world better and are in it for the long-term game. So I appreciate bias as long as it's not like it's long-term oriented bias. And we do try to maintain that here. So we appreciate everyone kind of holding us accountable for these values. I do think at times we've been maligned a little harshly. But yeah, we're going to keep bringing this platform to you guys. And you'll always know that when you come to Banclis, this is what David and I authentically think whether it's right or wrong. And maybe we'll be a little stubborn on some of our convictions. I think that's reinforced that a little in us finding the balance of conviction and yet being open-minded is probably the sweet spot for all investors.
The last thing I'll say on this is, do not expect Banclis to be journalists. We are not journalists. We don't like the dayward. We talk about news, but we are and always have been crypto investors that are on the journey going Banclis and we're just sharing what we're learning here. So yeah, maybe turn that into what Banclis is kind of taken and message. And we also attempt to wear our biases on our sleeves. Like it's not like we're hiding them in like shoving them in the closet. Like I think we're pretty open and transparent about how we're biased. And then I also followed up this tweet with one small more another follow-on tweet saying, I'll be much happier to talk about Solana and Avalanche Rip Luna.
Next bull market after they've completed a full stress test cycle. Meanwhile, gearing up for another round of shit thrown at us during next years, next crop, next cycles crop of new layer ones with a community brand new people new to this base. It does happen every cycle, doesn't it? David, this is a David Friedberg tweet. Cash is now a risk asset is a pretty big paradigm shift. Cash being a risk asset is a big paradigm shift. What's he saying here? Basically, this is talking about the bank insolvencies. Right? So if you hold your money in a bank and that bank is at risk of going insolvent, your cash is now at risk.
The other thing you could do is hold the United States treasuries, but like that's also at risk. And so like nowhere is safe in your dollars. David Friedberg is a co-host of the All-in podcast for those that did not know that. Right. Okay. He's the sultan of science if you listen to it. I also had to take on risk. I was thinking about risk this week. And because there's something I was confused with when they teach you sort of portfolio theory and you go to kind of finance classes in your undergraduate or in business school, they always talk about this term called volatility. And the finance textbooks seem to equate volatility with risk, like they're one in the same.
If an asset or portfolio is volatile, that also means it's risky. I got to say, David, I as just an investor, like practically, have found that that is not true at all. And I think particularly when you look at crypto, this is an asset that is very volatile, but surprisingly low risk. And I don't mean all crypto, by the way, because there are some very risky crypto assets. But in particular, I'm talking about something like Bitcoin or Ether. And so I tweeted this, I consider it a volatile asset. I do not consider it particularly risky. People often mistake volatility and risk. Another way to say that maybe is, Ether and Bitcoin feel more risky than they actually are for me, because they can go down 80%, like 85% relative to the dollar.
That means they're volatile. But if you held, did you actually lose anything? And so going back to this tweet from David Friedberg, cash is now a risk asset, right? For me, treasuries are much more risky than ETH, like I would risk in the real way of it being risk not volatility. Yes. Yes. This is Fiskantisu who tweeted, and I think clarified the point that I'm making volatility becomes risk when one, you use leverage. That's how volatility can increase risk. Or two, your time horizon is short or unpredictable. That's totally how volatility becomes risk. But volatility and risk are not the same thing.
And people, I think, look at crypto as an asset class and confuse those two. The other thing is number three is what I would add to Fiskantisu's tweet here is if you cannot stomach volatility that also increases your risk. If you have a visceral emotional reaction to seeing your crypto portfolio appreciate 5x and then go down 85% or if you don't have convictions, another way to say this, you definitely increase the risk that you are going to hit the sell button. It becomes a much more risky asset. So I don't know if that makes sense to you, but like this is, by the way, what they teach you in business school, they teach you that volatility and risk are one of the same thing.
And in order to decrease risk, you want to decrease volatility, but it does nothing to reduce tail risk. And it hasn't really, that paradigm on the world has not helped me become a better investor in the crypto asset space. I think understanding that paradigm early on when I was getting into crypto and everyone was like, crypto could go to zero. It's super risky. But then you understand the fundamentals of crypto and it's like, it actually can go to zero. It actually, like a buyer steps in somewhere. Right. It kind of can't. And like all of a sudden, like you start to understand and unpack this difference.
There's one thing about Fiskantes. Tweet, I want to change actually a little bit. Number one, if you use leverage, I want to change that to your measure of exposure. So like say, I have $100. If I have $1 of Bitcoin and $99, that volatility of Bitcoin is not a risk. If I have $100 of Bitcoin in $0 and also I need to pay rent and put food on the table, then that volatility does become risk. And then you can also get into leverage and you can leverage $100 into $150 and then that volatility becomes super risky. So it actually isn't a binary about whether you are or are not on leverage. It's a function of your exposure to the asset and your short-term needs.
I think that's a great point and it's totally true. And I'd also say that might come packaged in with the term leverage because in a way, what you're sort of doing is you're leveraging your future ability to pay rent. Sure. You're like, you're watching crypto, right? I guess it's a form of leverage, but yeah, point is completely valid. I got to ask you the question, what do you bullish on this week, David? Okay, so this is a different one this week. This is the permission list 2023 Twitter account, which it's a it's job is to promote the 20 provincialist 2023 conference, which I'm a huge fan of.
I'd love promoting it. It is also Ryan, the best meme account in crypto Twitter that I have been able to find is extremely obvious that a zoomer runs this account and they are making some memes that I have never seen before and they are hilarious new territory new new territory. And so like, it's super zoomer. And I chuckle at every single one. Also, there's a healthy amount of SpongeBob memes, which I'm a big fan of. But this is also dude, even the least funny memes here aren't better than most people's memes. And so I'm my call that my what I publish on is like, I'm just bullish on the memes and jokes that are coming out of this out of this account.
Like, I will say it's I haven't seen this Twitter account do much else other than one promote permission list and to make memes about permission. This is why it exists. And I'm sorry, I'm this is just product market fit. I just love it. I just think it's so funny. Well, well, David's so excited about the memes, which I also am, you know, that conference is coming up. And we're going to be there. I hope the bankless nation is going to be there. That's September 11 through 13th in Austin. Thousands of crypto folks there, it's talking about DeFi, talking about, you know, NFTs, talking about crypto regulatory institutional, everything.
It's a fantastic conference. And by the way, if you are a bankless citizen, you get a discount, right, David? 30% which pays for a year's worth of your bankless membership. Also ticket prices go up every two weeks. I think there's something in the $400. They go up by a percentage, by the way, which means it's exponential. So if you are now interested in getting permissions ticket, you would be who view to go get a ticket earlier. And also if you have subscription. There you go. Right. What do you both run? I look, I really enjoyed the Jim Bianco episode. It was my favorite episode that we put out this week, I think.
And one of the thing that he he said sort of stuck out to me, which we're beginning to see, the beginning of crypto decorate become uncorrelated with the stock market, right? We have we have promised the world an alternative financial system, alternative banking system. And if we are just acting like a risk on asset that is completely correlated with the stock market and it's just a magnified version of holding S&P 500, that's not the ticket. That's not an alternative banking system. And so what we're seeing is, you know, bank stocks down crypto up. That is a good indicator that we are starting to build on this harder path, which is an alternative money system, an alternative financial system.
That's there for you when the central banks and the banking system fail. And that's really as the existing system is as fault lines show more and more as that narrative propagates is that is that truth propagates. Crypto should be showing you should be going up. Right. And it's showing or it's too early to call it by showing early signs of actually doing that. And that that makes me bullish because that means maybe the market is a little bit smarter and that we're not just like a, you know, meme funded meme stock kind of market as that's the way it was acting in the end of 2021 and 2022. This is it feels much more real and substantive than ever before.
So that's what's making me bullish. Yeah. I think not only that as in like crypto now can express itself independently from the stock market, but the other big takeaway I had with Jim Bianco is that the economy, the health of the economy is now being expressed in the stock market, which also has not been true for a very long time. And so the fact that those were divergent is not a sign of health. And the fact that economic strength is now a requirement for the stock market to go up just makes me feel good because that means mainstream and Wall Street are being connected again. So another reason to be bullish about the trad world.
Yeah. There you go. Speaking of Jim Bianco too. He puts out some dank memes himself. The Bianca research he's giving giving the permission to kind of run for their money. This is Janet Yellen. What do we look at it here? So Jim Bianco tweets out Yellen. Yellen, the banking system is sound and resilient. And this is a Photoshop picture of Yellen who's playing the slots at a casino. And let me tell you, it does not look Photoshopped that look. She looks like a lady who could be at this like machines. She looks like she's having a great time. I don't think she's looking at all. She's having a fantastic man.
We also got another one. Second meme from Fiskantes. And this is a SpongeBob meme. So you know David included it. US government says, let's kill crypto by any means necessary apart from total ban and call it Operation Chookpoint. And then crypto. And this is a picture of SpongeBob with like these pincer things that are squeezing SpongeBob made of a sponge around the neck. And you can just see SpongeBob is just like just chilling. I kind of love it. It's just like, yeah, it's slightly giggling because he's a sponge. You know, like crypto is like a river. It just routes around. It's the biggest obstacle and continues.
I mean, the tighter they squeeze though, the bigger crypto gets. This is the problem that centralized institutions are going to have with crypto is like you're proving our point. If you squeeze us, you know, recent disclaimers got to end with this. Of course, crypto is risky. You know, it is. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot. None of this has been financial advice.