Bankless Weekly Rollup 4th Week of November, 2023
------ 🎙️ Tap into the Bankless Premium RSS Feed https://bankless.cc/premiumfeed
----- 🌐 Near's Cost Effective Data Availability https://bankless.cc/near
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
👾GMX | V2 IS NOW LIVE https://bankless.cc/GMX
💲 USDV | NATIVE OMNICHAIN STABLECOIN https://bankless.cc/usdv ------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
00:03:39 Markets https://pro.kraken.com/app/trade/btc-usd https://pro.kraken.com/app/trade/eth-usd https://www.coingecko.com/en/global-charts
00:04:39 CZ and Binance https://www.wsj.com/finance/currencies/binance-ceo-changpeng-zhao-step-down-plead-guilty-01f72a40 https://x.com/jacqmelinek/status/1727055732657246582?s=20
00:08:28 What is CZ Charged For? https://x.com/cz_binance/status/1727063503125766367?s=20 https://x.com/tier10k/status/1727112081361834432?s=20
00:12:44 Yellen's Threat https://x.com/BanklessHQ/status/1727074910370214051?s=20 https://x.com/jacqmelinek/status/1727068905083154619?s=20
00:17:22 Takes https://x.com/SenWarren/status/1727075454258180374?s=20 https://x.com/PapiChuloGrim/status/1727072835842265315?s=20 https://x.com/TrustlessState/status/1727012179780788372?s=20 https://x.com/nic__carter/status/1727090868908396745?s=20 https://x.com/RyanSAdams/status/1727035378371305712?s=20 https://x.com/RyanSAdams/status/1727022257250136447?s=20 https://www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/11/21/binances-cz-and-the-end-of-the-borderless-crypto-company
00:31:23 SEC Attacking Kraken https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2023-237 https://blockworks.co/news/kraken-commingle-customer-funds https://x.com/nic__carter/status/1726742215601394147?s=20 https://x.com/jespow/status/1726862770635936101?s=20
00:38:39 What Does Kraken Do About This? https://x.com/krakenfx/status/1726753079201034466?s=20 https://x.com/jespow/status/1726794688433369290?s=20 https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1726735133435113869?t=SRaRCiQMqLAJgPnBBWwnTQ&s=19
00:44:37 Blast Launch https://x.com/Blast_L2/status/1726747087906464024?s=20 https://x.com/Blast_L2/status/1726747105056989438?s=20 https://x.com/Blast_L2/status/1726747111994351627?s=20 https://blast.io/en/about
00:51:18 Blast Takes https://x.com/matthuag/status/1726794007169392798?s=20 https://x.com/bkiepuszewski/status/1726885938482266589?s=20 https://twitter.com/_Enoch/status/1726789502100795705?s=20 https://x.com/josephdelong/status/1726807950696800717?s=20 https://x.com/buchmanster/status/1727012742031368503?s=20 https://twitter.com/adietrichs/status/1726973122400989520 https://x.com/dankrad/status/1726912734388765067?s=20
00:59:12 Argentina's New President https://www.reddit.com/gallery/17zpatk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pysVxVg9Y28 https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/argentina-readies-vote-likely-presidential-election-thriller-2023-11-19/ https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1726448609871458645?s=20 https://x.com/brian_armstrong/status/1727013818524660197?s=20
01:02:52 Coindesk Sold https://blockworks.co/news/bullish-acquires-coindesk-dcg https://twitter.com/JasonYanowitz/status/1726611872353591392 https://x.com/elitanjourno/status/1726753641363550440?s=20
01:07:28 Optimism News https://x.com/optimismFND/status/1727105321817219488?s=20 https://twitter.com/OPLabsPBC/status/1727007225552748712
01:09:33 Meme of The Week https://twitter.com/alancarroII/status/1727037504119837108
Moment of Zen https://x.com/BanklessHQ/status/1727348869401636953?s=20
----- Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosuresBankless
No summary for this episode yet.
who CZ is going to serve in 18 months, gel time, allegedly. And then also, Binance is only paying $4.3 billion. And then, once that is over, Binance will have the green light from the United States, which is an expensive tax to pay. But that is a hugely good thing for Binance in the very long term. Backless Nation, it is time for your Friday weekly roll-up. We've got a lot to talk about, David. What are we starting with? CZ stepping down from Binance and stepping into jail. And also, Binance paying $4.3 billion to the Department of Justice. Yeah, we got to find out what that means. Also, the SEC is attacking Kraken, the crypto exchange, for the terrible charge of what?
Being a crypto exchange? But also, co-mingling funds? Question mark, what the hell is the deal with that? So we'll unpack all of those details. CoinDesk, crypto's largest, earliest crypto news media company is sold out of Barry Silverts at Digital Currency Group to who we will discuss. Also, blast a new layer two on the scene has caused a bunch of controversy among crypto Twitter and why many people in the crypto industry are kind of just fed up with paradigm to talk about that. And Argentina is getting a new president, a new president elected to Argentina, pro the dollar and pro crypto question mark.
We will unpack all of this and more. We should also say it is going to be Thanksgiving. You know what? I think I said happy Friday morning and this is actually coming out on Thursday morning. So happy Thanksgiving to all US listeners. I hope you have a fantastic time trying to convert your family members into crypto zealots as they ask you, hey, honey, how's that crypto thing going? I hope you have a fantastic reply to them because you are listening to bank lists. So you'll know exactly what to say. And none of it will probably make sense to your family members. As usual. Oh, honey, I heard one of your crypto friends got put in jail again this week.
It's like really bad timing. And David, you're actually on the West Coast over to visit family for the holidays as well. So are they going to be asking you about crypto? Oh, well, they know, they know I'm very deep in the crypto sphere. So they already did. I was home last night. My mom was asking me about it. Yeah, bank lists, longtime bank listeners will know when this is my background, David's home for some holiday reason. This is the home Ryan that I started my crypto rabbit whole journey in. This is where I like was losing blood. I was cutting my fingers on the sheet metal while I was putting together mining computers for Ethereum back in 2017.
Wow. Yeah, that was how many years, six years ago. Yeah, crazy, crazy. Literally started your crypto journey with blood. That's a pretty impressive dad. You have scars on my hands from trying to put together mining computers. Yeah. Right, David, we've got to get into the markets. But before we do, what a shout out. Our friends and sponsors over at near. They've got a new data availability layer. David, tell us about it. The near layer one is also now a data availability layer for Ethereum rollups or rollups generally. And so data on Ethereum is still pretty expensive. World War three resistant block space is expensive.
So the near data availability is 8,000 times cheaper than currently Ethereum data availability. So if you are launching an app chain like in the Cosmos ecosystem or a layer two on Ethereum or a rollup just somewhere in the cryptoverse, well, those are kind of your only two options. Use near for data availability. Near's data availability layer already has some very early partners. Madera by Starknet, Caldera, Fluent, Vistera, Movement Labs, and a few others. So the price of data, Lin Web 3, like all things, is getting cheaper thanks to near. There is a link in the show notes, bankless.cc-flash-near to get started.
All right, let's get to the markets, David. The Kraken charts this week. What are they telling us about Bitcoin? Look at that up line up into the right. I mean, you're Zoom's super far out on the one month, but that is just an upward trend line with plenty of volatility. Bitcoin started the week at $36,000 and ending the week at $36,000 and a half thousand dollars up a little bit, keeping the markets alive. Moving into ETH price also, just looking like a straight line up again with some volatility, starting the week at $2,000, ending the week where we are now at $2,040. The ratio between Bitcoin and Ether a little bit up, but relatively flat and of course, the total crypto market cap, $1.
44 trillion. Blue chips, Bitcoin and Ether up, marginally up, some altcoins down the market cap stack down. But overall, I would say we are floating. We are floating up, I would say. This is definitely bull market territory and thanks to Kraken for providing those charts, of course. No securities traded on Kraken. These are crypto tokens, aren't they, David? We'll get to that story a little bit later, but before we touch on Kraken, let's talk about CZ. CZ, the founder of Binance is out, David. Take us through the story, so how did this happen and what happened over the last couple of days? So the Department of Justice in the United States has actually been investigating Binance for a very long time.
Since 2018, 2019, and it has finally come to a head, finally come to a conclusion. So CZ is going to plead guilty on Friday here in Seattle, by the way, in the court in downtown Seattle, to money laundering charges, as well as Binance is going to pay $4.3 billion. This is a settlement between Binance and the Department of Justice and also the CFTC, the quantity of futures and trading commission, versus Binance. The SEC is not involved here. Yeah, so that's what's interesting about all of this. He said he's going to plead guilty, right? He hasn't actually pled guilty and he's going to be pleading guilty in front of a court in Seattle, which coincidentally, David, that's where you are right now.
I don't know how that ended up happening. You always seem to end up in the funniest places when they're stuck to people to crypto leaders going to court for some reason all the time. Yeah, okay, so he hasn't pled, but they're putting out all of these press releases ahead of that, basically. We already know what he's going to plead. We already know what the fines are. We already know what the settlement actually is. And here's a tweet with some of those details that you just recapped. So Binance has to pay $4.3 billion in fines. Binance is reaching an agreement with Finson, OFAC, the CFTC, and we'll give them $1.
8 billion. That's part of the $4.3 billion. CZ actually made a statement better to ask for forgiveness than permission toward operating in the US. So he's like, oh, oopsie, that was my strategy. And you know, this is how it's playing out. The CZ is also the Brian Armstrong approach. Yeah, the opposite. And then CZ, he's resigning. And he can't operate Binance for three years from the start of the agreement. Interesting though, David, he gets to keep all of his equity. So he can't operate it, but he's not forced to sell any of it. So he gets to realize all of the upside. He is still a hyper billionaire.
I have no idea what his net worth is, but it's multiple billions, many billions. In fact, at one point in time, I think Forbes estimated CZ was like maybe the second most wealthy person in the entire world, like top five. And so he gets to keep all of that. There's also the David talk of some jail. Like there might be an actual Eosentons. Can you tell us about that? So he CZ is going to be released on bail, $175 million bail. And the agency, the Department of Justice, is looking to seek an 18-month sentence for CZ. Now, like, why do we know all of these details? It's because this is a settlement agreement between Binance and the Department of Justice.
So rather than just carry this out even longer, perhaps like CZ avoiding a much longer sentence, perhaps life, this is the terms of CZ. This is the cost of Binance to pay for a clean slate from the United States government. So post this, CZ is going to serve an 18-month jail time, apparently, allegedly. And then also Binance is only pay $4.3 billion. And then once that is over, Binance will have the green light from the United States, which is an expensive tax to pay. But that is a hugely good thing for Binance in the very long term. So he's actually going to jail, though. That's crazy. I wonder if this is like house arrest, if you can negotiate that, or if it's actual jail jail, if it's like, is this kind of like, you know, the white collar cushy jail, or is it Arthur Hayes jail, or is it Sam Bankman-Free jail, like on this spectrum?
That seems to be unclear. Can we talk really quick, David, about what Binance is actually being charged for, though? Like, what crime did they commit? And what is CZ actually pleading guilty to here? I'm sure they would love to go after CZ in Binance for every single thing under the sun, but the thing that has finally come to a head here is allowing, knowingly allowing money laundering and terrorist financing to occur on Binance. Binance famously was pretty loose in the early days about KYC on the exchange. You could just kind of flub your KYC, your VPN. Like, check, I'm not an United States citizen, and then you could just like use Binance.
And so they, and there were reports, remember when the signal chats that came out with CZ and other executives of Binance, they knowingly allowed terrorists to operate on Binance. So they just pretty iron clad proof of this. There's not proof of this. And so it was not only like, they allowed it, but they also knew about it, and they didn't do anything about it. And so this is why the SEC is notably absent from this. This is not child's play of Gary Gensler and his influencer campaign. This is the department of defense, having a problem with Binance allowing for terrorists to funnel money through Binance.
And CZ is like, we're turning a blind eye. And so it's kind of like the highest level of offenses you could make towards the United States government. Yeah, you said the department of defense and they're kind of associated here. It's like the agencies of Finson and OFAC. And by the way, if you're not familiar with what these agencies are, we did an entire podcast on financial surveillance apparatus that you should absolutely check out. But notably, what CZ did not do, and what Binance did not do, it was not an FTX style fraud. Right, okay? So there was not a missing funds from the exchange of billions of dollars.
And by the way, that was rumored earlier in here, at least on crypto Twitter. It's just, oh my God, CZ is doing the same thing that FTX is doing. That's not what these charges are for. And you have to assume that these investigators went through absolutely everything they could. There's no gaping hole on the balance sheet. So it's not that. And as you said, it's not an SEC snafu. It's all about financial surveillance. It's OFAC, it's Finson. It's not doing the AML KYC. This is the statement from CZ. David, do you want to read some of this? CZ tweets out today. I stepped down as CEO of Binance.
Admittedly, it was not easy to let go emotionally, but I know it was the right thing to do. I made mistakes. I must take responsibility. This is the best for our community, the best for Binance and the best for myself. And then he announces that Richard Tang, the former head of global regional markets, is now the new CEO of Binance. And he discusses like the qualifications of Richard and who he is. And then he talks about what's next for him. And I thought this was like a pretty crazy line. I will take a break first. I have not had a single day of real phone off breaks for the last six and a half years.
It's easy. It's been grinding for six and a half years. After that, my current thinking is I will probably do some passive and investing, being a minority token shareholder in startups in areas across blockchain, Web3 and DeFi, AI and Biotech. I'm happy that I will have more time to spend looking at DeFi. I cannot see myself being a CEO driving a startup again. I'm content being a one-shot entrepreneur. On that note, I am proud to point out that in our resolutions with the United States agency's day, do not allege that Binance misappropriated any user funds and do not allege that Binance engage in any market manipulation.
Funds are safe who, which is a meme for safe. With that, I look forward to seeing the new leadership take the reins. Please join me in congratulating Richard on his well-deserved promotion onwards. CZ. So no misappropriation of user funds, no market manipulation, but clearly doing legal activity with respect to financial surveillance laws and regulations that are in the book. We'll talk what this means, like how people are reacting to this and how CZ might be viewed through history. But all of this also came to a head in a press release that the Department of Treasury, and I believe the CFTC kind of stood up at 3 p.
m. on Tuesday, November 21st. And actually, when they announced all of this, some of this news came out ahead of that and some of it was tied up in this press release. And Janet Yellen actually spoke about this. And here she is, addressing crypto specifically. And what I would say is a not-so-veiled threat. Let's listen. And let me be clear, we're also sending a message to the virtual currency industry more broadly today and for the future. If virtual currency exchanges and financial technology firms wish to realize the tremendous benefits of being part of the U.S. financial system and serving U.
S. customers, they must play by the rules. And if they do not, the U.S. government will take action. There it is, David. If you want to play in the U.S., and you are a crypto company or a crypto project, you must play by U.S. rules. Okay, but who is she referring to? Because Binance, okay, got him, the number one exchange. Who's the number two exchange coin base? Extremely compliant. Who's the number three exchange in volume after those two? Kraken, extremely compliant. After that, we have Bybit, OKX, and Kucoin who are Asian exchanges. So maybe this message is to them. But we're now talking about the long tail of volume.
There's no one left. FTX has gone. Yeah, no. Well, she's just saying this in general. David, what I think this is, is this is a statement of like, we're in control, right? Like we're in the driver's seat. Okay, like, let me show you who's boss. Yeah, Ben the knee. It actually doesn't matter what rules we say. And in fact, what the subtext years, we're not even necessarily going to give you clarity on what the rules are. But when we say jump, you jump. We are the bosses here. Else we will shut you out of the U.S. market. And what that means is you're disconnected from the entire Western market, right?
It's like, you're up kind of follow suit. If you shut out, that's the stick that Janet Yellen really carries here. We'll talk about this a little bit more when we get into the crack in case. But you know what is also crypto Twitter found hilarious was the way she pronounced Binance, David. She set the entire time. She must have mentioned this, I don't know, five, six, seven times. Binance is her pronunciation of Binance. So that's like high class Binance. Right. Well, I remember back in 2017 back in 2018, I would, the early days of Binance, people called it Binance all the time. It was like, it was back in the day I mean, people also would say ETH or ETH, people referred to ETH as ETH.
Yeah, but if someone started saying ETH right now, and if someone says Binance right now, it just shows that they either don't care whatever, or they're disconnected. They don't have any crypto friends, that's for sure. They definitely don't. So how big of a deal is this? Let's look at this from the Binance token itself because there is a token out there that is maybe a proxy for what's going on in Binance world, the BNB token. That is down what 12% here on the day? Down 12%. Yeah, so at a fully diluted market cap of $35 billion, we're losing a couple billion dollars of market cap off of the BNB token, down 12%.
But I will also say, like that's not far off from like the regular old market, like right now, like for example, Solana is also down 12% right now. Layer two tokens, like optimism, down 8% on the week, XRP, down 7% on the week. So you can't even really say that the market even reacted to this. It's a little bit of a reaction, but kind of a little bit of a reaction. Yeah, but like 12% in crypto, like whatever, okay. That's fine. Another big question though, David, for Binance or Binance, I should say, is where is all of this coming from? This $4.3 billion, do they have the funds to actually pay for it?
What's this tweet? Yes, so Connor put out a little audit of Binance's crypto holdings from Binance's proof of reserves, disclosures that they publicize because they're cool and they do that. So what reserves does Binance have? 6.35 billion dollars in total assets, 3.2 billion dollars in stable clients, and this does not include any off-chain cash balances or held in funds that they don't disclose. So they will likely be able to pay that $4.3 billion fine without actually having to liquidate any crypto. Wow, they're not on us. So Binance is basically like, oh, $4.3 billion, we'll write you a check.
Here you go. You know, it's like a cost of doing business basically for a company of this size. And honestly, like they probably saw this coming. They probably knew this was coming. You said investigation since 2018. They've been in the thick of it for a while. So let's talk about some different takes. One angle is, what is the Elizabeth Warren anti crypto army take? This looks like I'm like waiting on baited breath. Elizabeth Warren says about this. Do you like victory lab, David? Because I think this screams of Elizabeth Warren doing a victory lap. The CEO of the world's largest crypto exchange pleaded guilty to breaking anti money laundering laws.
This is part of a larger trend of criminal activity in the crypto industry and sadly predictable. She told us all about this in advance. I urge the Justice Department to investigate Binance for lying to Congress. She goes on law enforcement and national security officials need additional authorities and resources to pursue money laundering, sanctions evasion, blah, blah, blah, blah. I'll keep working to pass bipartisan legislation to address the serious and dangerous problem. PS, I was right about Hamas too. I'm not giving you guys any ground. That's not what she said. But I think she's thinking that, David.
This is definitely a victory lap from the Elizabeth Warren camp. Nice dunk. But let's carry this to some banks. So Poppy Trulow-Grim, Twitter crypto Twitter account says, the enforcement against CZ is insane. For perspective, in 2010, Wacovia bank owned by Wells Fargo was shown to have purposefully laundered $378 billion from the Sinola cartel. I think that's a Mexican drug cartel. Yes, it is. Wow. 2004 and 2007. So $378 billion. How much was Wacovia bank find a $160 million? Okay, Liz Warren. Okay, explain that one. Go after the banks who are subsidizing your narrative against crypto. Like, come on.
Yeah, yeah. David, you've got to take about this. So there's another question of what does this mean for crypto in general? Is this bearish? Is this bullish? You say it's bullish. This is David Hoffman tweeting. A Department of Justice settlement with finance is hugely bullish. Finance takes a hit, begins US approval and regulatory clarity moving forward. The whole industry gets further legitimized. So David, you choose to interpret this news as bullish. Why? Do you remember when the Bitcoin was seized from the Silk Road? And then it was auctioned off by the government. Oh yeah. And there was a premium on that Bitcoin because people wanted to buy Bitcoin that was like blessed by the United States government.
If the United States government is selling you Bitcoin, that Bitcoin is clean. And this was back in the days of when just like, everyone was worried about like the UTXO traces of their Bitcoin coming from dirty sources. So people paid like a five to 10% premium on Bitcoin that was clean. So I'm kind of making this same comparison. Binance is going through the trials of the Department of Justice. CZ is paying his debts in 1.5 years of jail time and 50 million dollars fine personally that he has to pay. Binance is paying a 1.4.3 billion dollars to wipe the slate clean. This is what happens now.
Moving forward, Binance now has a clean slate. They have now have a green light of being washed by the government and they are now further legitimized along as they don't do anything wrong moving forward. Yeah. And so going back to like who are the now the biggest exchanges that own over 90% of crypto centralized crypto trading volume, Binance, which is clean now, Coinbase, which is regulatory compliant and Kraken, which is regulatory compliant. So like, come on. Like that is that's just massive tailwinds for crypto skeptics to get onboarded into crypto. Yeah, I'll note that the regulators didn't shut Binance down.
Okay. They let CZ keep is, you know, at $4.3 billion it sounds like a lot, but it's a slap on the wrist. So they're indicating that they want to control these exchanges, not shut crypto down and that is some certainty that has been injected in the market. I think there's another question though here is Binance CZ, good or bad. You know how we all like to put people in, you know, especially in crypto, like binary camps. You're either good or you're bad. It's dark or it's light. This is a Nick Carter take on Binance and CZ. I think we can acknowledge that Binance has been a critical linchpin of crypto adoption globally while also granting that knowingly facilitating one billion in flows to sanctioned entities is extremely bad and not a victimless crime.
So this is Nick Carter saying, it's kind of mixed, right? They did some good things. They did some bad things, not a victimless crime. This is a danger reflecting a similar sentiment. A little sad by the Binance suit, but at the same time it seems relatively reasonable given all the evidence. Binance was shady indeed towards governments as far as I can tell, they did write by their users the true crypto ethos. Maybe the skews a bit more kind of light, which is very interesting. My personal take is say what you want about CZ, he did onboard millions of people in a crypto and he didn't steal our money.
We've had a lot, we've had a lot worse bankers, David. We've had Alex Meschinsky in the space. We've had Sam Bankman freed in the space. We've had the BlockFi people. And the bottom line for me is like, I still probably trust CZ more than US regulators. And I don't know what that says about US regulators or what that says about CZ. So I'll grant that he's kind of like a neutral type of character here. My take is he was definitely a profit maxi. He definitely was sloppy with respect to AMLKYC compliance. He probably cost no risky, risky push limits. Yeah, he pushed the limits, I would say. And he broke the limits, actually.
He broke the limits, it cost him in the end. And but there's also a question of like ethically what do you actually think about AMLKYC, right? I think our posture on bankless has been if you have the ability to block the bad guys, right? Then you should be regulated to block the bad guys. If you are a credibly neutral protocol, it's just it's open for everybody. You have no ability to block anyone. And by the way, the good of credibly neutral protocols outweigh the bad. But finance was not a credibly neutral protocol. It was more like a bank, it was an exchange. And so it should have some type of rule structure, regulation, apparatus, and finance clearly dodged that.
What's your take on CZ? Are you like team CZ good or team CZ bad or do you fall somewhere in the middle? Yeah, I'm trying not to be warped to buy all of the bad people that have redefined what it means to be bad. Like, Sam, they really pushed the limit on what it means to be bad. You know, Alex with Skate Dogwan, Daniel Sesta, just like, I didn't realize how bad people could get. And so like maybe had I come in with more like virgin eyes into this place, I would have been more innocent. More innocent David would have been like, ah, he's not a great guy. He's pretty bad, yeah. He's like allowing flying terrorists financing on his platform, but like, man, like going, I'm about to go to Argentina in January.
Like, they use Binance, dude. They use Binance to get banked. They use Tron on Tether and that's, well, that's not Binance, but it's just like, they use the Binance exchange and the Binance app to send money around. This is also true for Africa. And so, yeah, I mean, like the simple take is like, we support DeFi protocols that terrorists can use. And also the rest of the world. And we believe that this is a net positive outcome in the grand scheme of things. CZ tried to operate under those principles, but he didn't have that same foundation. Like he could have stopped the terrorists. No. And he chose not to.
He was not an internet protocol like TCPIP. All right, he had his own Walt Garden platform and there's some responsibility when you have something like that. David, you alluded to it earlier, but one other question here is, okay, what does this mean for centralized exchanges? And you said, I mean, this is very good for a coinbase. This is very good for a crack in basically because Binance is pretty much stultified in Western markets anywhere that the kind of the US touches or the US influence over shadows. Binance is kind of cut out of that. And it looks like I think to me that US regulators are doing some kingmaking here.
They're slapping around coinbase. We'll talk about it soon. They're slapping around crack in as well. But that will also boost up coinbase and crack in, I think, in these markets. And so that is a massive factor here. I saw one last take to round this out on. I saw this one take from Emily Parker, the end of the borderless crypto company. She wrote this in a coin desk. Basically is saying BitMex was also a borderless crypto company and BitMex got asked like right before the start of this last bull market, I think in like 2020. That was Arthur Hayes' exchange. And it just famously operated like very light KYC AML and just use crypto as payment rails.
And Emily Parker's take is like, well, Binance was the last borderless crypto company. The last pirate bay are the one that you couldn't really stop. Just like skipping around jurisdiction, jurisdiction. Where am I located? Our offices are virtual, that kind of thing. Exactly. So one passage that I liked was we will probably never see another company quite like Binance. Crypto itself might be borderless, but crypto companies may find it increasingly hard to operate outside of legal or geographical boundaries. In the early days of crypto, it seems possible to launch a massive exchange that slipped through the grasp of any jurisdiction.
Those days are gone. And Ryan thematically this kind of lines up with where we see the globe heading like generally. We as a globe are not globalizing. We are Balkanizing. The internet is becoming Balkanized. The walls between China and United States are going up. The walls between Russia and the EU are going up. Walls generally across all domains, digital or physical are generally going up. And I think this fits into that story. And what else fits into that story is underlying Web 3 decentralized, credibly neutral protocols that give no f's about those walls. And so this is the increasing like retreat from globalism, the increasing like strength around borders and also the increasing ripeness for protocols that slip right around those borders.
I think this is perfectly in theme with the thing that we've been seeing over the last five years or so. Yeah, you're right, David. I think crypto exchanges are going to have to be geopolitically aligned moving forward, some axis of power. And they can't be in both camps at the same time. It's further Balkanizing. We had a lot more to talk about, including another crypto exchange that's on the hot seat. The SEC is accusing Kraken of what being a crypto exchange is very different charges here. And also maybe commingling funds. What's up with that? Let's talk about that. Let's talk about that. Did they really Gary?
Yeah, did they really? Come on, Gary. Also, there's a new layer two on the scene. It's called Blast. And everyone is super happy about it. Actually, not so much. There's a lot of controversy. We'll get to those things and more. But first, we want to tell you about the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our number one. Hear this here again. The number one crypto exchange. Crypto exchange, all the tokens, no securities. It's called Kraken. It's called Kraken. In solidarity, right now, listen to this. Go create a Kraken account. Kraken knows crypto. Kraken's been in the crypto game for over a decade.
And as one is the largest and most trusted exchanges in the industry, Kraken is on the journey with all of us to see what crypto can be. Human history is a story of progress. It's part of us hardwired. We're designed to seek change everywhere, to improve, to strive. And if anything can be improved, why not finance? Crypto is a financial system designed with the modern world in mind. Instant, permissionless, and 24-7. It's not perfect and nothing ever will be perfect. But crypto is a world-changing technology at a time when the world needs it the most. That's the Kraken mission, to accelerate the global adoption of cryptocurrency, so that you and the rest of the world can achieve a financial freedom and inclusion.
Head on over to Kraken.com, slash bank list, to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading, involves risk of loss. Cryptocurrency services are provided to US and US territory customers. I pay word ventures, eek, pvi, doing business as Kraken. Introducing USDV, a better type of stablecoin. Currently, billions of dollars in stablecoin yield each year are paid to tether, circle, and other central issuers of major stablecoins. But what if yield could be shared with the protocols that use it? Those protocols, in turn, can decide how to reward their users. USDV shares its yield with a community of apps and developers that mint it.
Every USDV is backed one-to-one by US treasury bills which pay yield. This yield flows out to the community of USDV issuers. So your protocol or app can get paid for helping end users convert other stables into USDV. This works thanks to a breakthrough technology called color trace from layer zero. Without it, it was impossible to attribute users of it token with a specific issuer. But now we can. USDV is live on Ethereum, optimism, arbitrum, and other chains. And it's already available on over 20 exchanges, such as Curve, Bitget, Velodrome, and Stargate. Start participating in the yield from treasury back stablecoins at bankless.
com slash USDV. Introducing GMX, the deepest on-chain futures market to trade Bitcoin, Ethereum, and leading altcoins. GMX is a permissionless decentralized exchange that offers perpetual futures and spot trading, lightning fast trade execution and competitive pricing with the security and self-custody of a decentralized exchange. GMX is live now with V2 bringing new optimizations to on-chain leverage trading. And even more than an improved trading experience, GMX will reward you for just participating. All GMX users can easily set up a referral link. And with $12 million of arbitrum grants being distributed as incentives and over $150 billion in trading volume to date all settled on-chain, GMX is leading the charge in terms of opportunities for defy liquidity providers.
The future is on-chain with your waltz, with your trades, and with your money in your own hands. Try it out now at app.gmx.io. The SEC is attacking Kraken this week. New charges dropped from Gary Thenzler's SEC. I'll read the press release title. The SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered securities exchange, a broker, a dealer, and a clearing agency. Otherwise, I think David, known as a crypto exchange. Maybe you can't do that in America. I'm not so sure. David, tell us some of the details here. What are the claims that are being filed against Kraken by the SEC? So the SEC alleges that Kraken provides a marketplace that brings together the orders for securities and multiple buyers and sellers and thus operates as an exchange.
The only part about that is that they use the word securities. Engages in the business of affecting securities transactions for the accounts of Kraken customers and thus operates as a broker. Engages in the business of buying and selling securities for its own account without an applicable exception and this operates as a dealer serves as an intermediary in settling transactions in crypto asset securities by Kraken's customers and acts as a securities depository and thus acts as a clearing agency. All of these Ryan are normal crypto exchange operations. The only thing that is different here is that they are being flavored by this security word.
Basically saying that hell, all those things that you are doing, all those assets, all those tokens, all those coins are all securities and therefore everything you do makes you a securities exchange. If I'm reading this, David, they of course as usual need to get, they drop to similar suit against Coinbase, right? So this isn't the first time, but they mention a few token what they would call securities. We call these just crypto assets or cryptocurrencies. ADA, so that is Cardano, Algorand, Adam, File, Flow, all sorts of things as usual. But they're basically saying these are all securities.
I know we've got clarity, they don't admit to that, but these are all securities and you've been running a securities exchange illegally in America and they're taking them to court over this. And this Ryan in combination with just the Department of Justice going after CZM Binance, I think is one of the reasons why the long tail crypto assets, the market is down this week, like Bitcoin and Ether relatively unfazed this week, like Ether is actually up, but like tokens are down this week, like the long tail, like Maddox, Solana, Filecoin, like all the ones, all these ones listed here are down. And that's the same thing that happened last time, the SEC did this when they actually named names.
And I think just like these three-letter agencies going after crypto is kind of like rattling the markets and scaring them out of like the altcoin season. So my take here is that, well, okay, well, we'll just kind of see a bounce back on that because that's what we've seen before and there's nothing really new here. Except there is something new, right? In line, 221 of this complaint, there's this co-mingling fund thing that the SEC has accused Kraken of co-mingling funds with its own accounts and customers. So customers, funds are being co-mingled with each others and also Kraken is using customer funds to pay its bills.
And so this is the one thing that's like different and new that like flagged my attention. I was like, yo, what do you mean co-mingling funds? What does that mean? Because that sounds very FTXE. And in the press release of the front of the SEC, they have like all of these bullets that I read out earlier, right? Engages in the business affecting security transactions, provides marketplace, blah, blah, blah. And those are the elicit allegations, but then there's this separate paragraph that's like, oh yeah, and also by the way, they co-mingled funds and they use customer funds to pay bills. Yeah.
It's like, why wouldn't you lead with that? Why wouldn't you put in the bullets? And so like, oh, by the way, they also did this thing. And it sounds like the verbiage that they use sounds very FTXE, right? Just like, you know, co-meat. We all have the trauma, the PTSD of like FTX using customer funds. And that's definitely what they are alluding to in this press release. Okay. So what do they mean? Like they have the statement in line, 221 and 222 of the accusation. Here's what they say. Separately, Kraken treats some fiat and custodial accounts as its own and not the customers. Supposedly because Kraken's customers, oh, Kraken fees arising from the customer's trading, this is true.
For example, Kraken has at times paid operational expenses using funds held in customer custodial accounts. This is another example of improper commingling of funds that increases investor risk, which registers security intermediaries into mediaries are prohibited from engaging. Kraken does not disclose to his customers that Kraken commingles customer and corporate fiat and either customer custodial accounts or Kraken's corporate operating accounts. But once again, what does this mean? Here's how this works. And this is how all crypto exchanges work, Ryan, is that when you deposit your crypto onto Kraken or Coinbase and then you make a trade, that trade incurs a fee.
This is how exchanges make business, trading fees. And so all of a sudden, the crypto that you deposit to them, some of them, some of that crypto becomes the exchanges because of the fee. But because that state is not immediately reflected on chain, well, then all of a sudden, the fee that is collected by Kraken and the customer deposits from the customer is still in the same wallet, it's still in the same address because Kraken's internal ledger in the Ethereum blockchain or like the Polygon layer two or Solana, they don't update that immediately. And so in a one moment of time, there is a combingling of funds because of that discrepancy.
Just a temporary combing ledger, what you're saying. Yeah, this is Nick Carter who's talking about this. So something people don't understand is that there's always cross flow between customer and exchange funds as there's always some overlap due to ordinary latency and operations. Co-mingling is a big bookie man, but all exchanges definitely have some overlap, even if short periods. Even if for short periods. Is this seriously what the SEC is like, they are talking about it as it kind of an add-on in their list of allegations, which lead with securities. But they are like, it seems like intentionally making it sound as if Kraken is running an FTX SBF style scheme.
And really, it's just a technicality in the way the business operations detail. Are you effing serious? So you can imagine Jesse Powell, one of the co-founders of Kraken, how frustrated he is with this. So he falls up to Nick's tweet and says, it's so ridiculous. There's no statutory requirement to segregate. Fees paid our quote, combingled until they are moved out. Extranges can have customer accounts for foreign exchange or whatever, like any other business customer. And for there are reorgs, chargebacks, failed settlements, and bank errors. These are all things that would lead to like a discrepancy in the ledger that needs to be accounted for with time.
So yes, nice. Again, like it's a good little like, good little jazz, good little. They're putting it in the press release. Those allegations will not hold up in a serious court system, right? They're just adding it to like flavor the entire list of collidates here. Yeah, that's absolutely bogus. So the big question here though is, what is Kraken going to do about this? And I'll also like remind folks that earlier this year, David, it was nine months ago, Kraken was charged again by the SEC this time for it's staking service. And at that point in time, it decided rather than go to the court system to all these things, basically the mob boss is coming and kind of collecting, it decided to pay the penalty rather than fight the SEC.
30 million dollars. 30 million dollars. That was nine months ago. Okay, so now the SEC is like, oh, so you're willing to pay. I guess we'll drop some more charges on you. That's what it seems like to me. So what is Kraken going to do, David? So here's David Ripley operating CEO of Kraken, who says we strongly disagree with the SEC claim, stand firm in our view that we do not list securities and plan to vigorously defend our position. Look, yes, as we've seen in court. Gary, the SEC argues that Kraken should come in and register with the agency when there is no clear path to registration, words that we've heard for like three years now, it's allegations are factually incorrect contrary to law and the wrong way to create policy in the United States.
As an industry leader, we will stand up to these allegations and defend the crypto industry's right to exist in the United States. That's right. We believe congressional action is the most appropriate path to resolving the lack of regulatory clarity in the US and will continue to support these efforts to bring clarity and certainty to the chaotic environment that has been created in the US. Saying, Congress, will you please reign in your boy, Gary Gensler? Stop what he's got to. Jesse Powell retweeted this blog post from Kraken and he says, USA's top decel, decelerationist and this is coming out of the backs of like decels now a word that we use to describe anti-innovation in Silicon Valley and tech and crypto.
Okay, so USA's top decel is back with another assault on America. He's calling the SEC and Gary Gensler a decelerationist. The masochists haven't been happy with the beatings that they've been taking in New York. I'll unpack that in a second and are shopping for a different flavor in the regdom in California. Regulatory dominance? Yeah. Wow, this is unhinged. I thought we settled all their concerns for $30 million in February. Now they're back for seconds. The message is clear. $30 million buys you about 10 months before the SEC comes back around to extort you again. Lawyers can do a lot with $30 million but the SEC knows that a real fight will likely cost $100 million and valuable of time.
If you can't afford it, get your crypto company out of the United States war zone. That's amazing. I just love the energy out of Jesse. Like just calling it how it is. It's like they're just back. Extortion. Extortion. Okay. I'll unpack the, the massacres haven't been happy with the beatings they've been taking in New York and are shopping for a different flavor of regdom in California. Is he talking about the ripple case? Well, so all of the cases that the SEC has filed in New York have gotten shut down. The New York courts have said Gary Gensler go home. And so this, this allegation against Kraken was filed in California, which is brand new, clean slate regulatory jurisdiction that SEC is like, hey, California, all you liberals over there, I'm a liberal.
I can say that. You guys, will you guys like please help us take down Kraken? Like New York's not doing it. Like, can you guys help us? Well, they're diversifying their court cases basically. They got a new exchange and they got a new court system in a new state and they're trying to like, they keep losing. But what does it cost them? I mean, they're getting paid by tax funder dollars. It doesn't cost them anything to keep bringing these court cases. Gary Gensler clearly doesn't care what the crypto industry thinks of him. He clearly doesn't care about the legitimacy and credible neutrality of the SEC as a governing entity.
He is here to advance the career and political aspirations of Gary Gensler. So he could drop whatever court case he wants at any point in time and he does not care if he loses. That's what's so insidious. It's such a stupid tax on American innovation and our entire industry. And ultimately, the one in five Americans that actually own crypto. I think David, this man, Gary Gensler, is under his leadership at the SEC. He is a political liability for the Democratic Party. I don't. It's treason. It's treason. He said David goes straight to treason. He's treason. Oh, man. So that's what's going on there.
And it's great to see Kraken pushing back on this absolute sham of a regulator. I guess one thing we have to add at this point, of course, is full disclosure. If you're not already aware, Kraken is a sponsor of bankless. And that's why we picked them. We picked them because they protected users for over 12 years. Gary Gensler has not even given us a Bitcoin ETF in the last 12 years. Kraken has a stellar reputation. They were first to initiate proof of reserves. We believe they are right. And the SEC is time. Haven't lost the dime. However, and I just want to pull this out one more time. Yeah.
Kraken is not doing anything wrong according to the SEC other than trading securities. And the SEC is going to Kraken and being like, hey, you guys are trading securities. But then they list a bunch of securities. And they're not going out to the securities that they issue and say, hey, you guys made securities. They're going to Kraken and say, you guys are listing securities. And Kraken's like, yo, we didn't make these things. And so they're going after the people that aren't responsible for the inception of the alleged securities in the first place. Because they can't actually go and take file coin or salon it to court because they probably don't want to lose that one either.
All they may, they may, yeah, it's still early here, David. Then why aren't they doing it? Well, I bet they, who knows? Who knows what this mastermind's plans are? And the whole point of that section was to tell you that that Kraken is a sponsor. And of course, love sponsor. Love sponsor. And of course, guys, if you want to be extra sure, just don't keep your crypto on any centralized exchange ever. Go, go, bangless. That's also what we encourage. All right, David, are you ready to get blasted, man? Because this is new, there's this new layer too. It's called blast. And it blasted on my Twitter timeline this week.
And there's some controversy about it. I've been busy looking at other things. Can you tell me what this thing is? Blast notably raised $20 million from paradigm. And this is where people's attention gets funneled into blast because paradigm is like dopamine. Dopamine for like the Twitter D gen. It did friend tech. Exactly, they did friend tech, right? And like you're going to see, you're going to notice, they also did blur. And you're going to notice like a lot of blasts cut from the same cloth as friend tech and blur. Like a lot of this stuff. Just like really dialed up. And so introducing blasts, the only layer too with native yield for eth and stable coins.
And so, okay, what does that mean? The TLDR is that if you submit your ether or your stables into the blast deposit contract, they just convert it to lido-staked eth or they deposit it into the MakerDowtee Bill engine. And then your eth balance on blasts just naturally increments up like 0.02, 0.03, over time, as eth-staking does. So it just converts your ether into staked ether on your behalf and then just gives you more ether on the layer too. Same thing with stables. Okay. And so like, I kind of cool, I guess. But that's kind of cool. Yeah, you're depositing everything. Every asset is yielding.
I mean, there's some risk associated with that. So people have to keep that in. Right. Yeah, is it really any different than depositing staked eth or our eth and then minting our eth on a different layer too? Actually, straight up, no, it's not. It's not. It's arguably better UX. Just saves you some transactions. Maybe. Okay. So built by Pac-Man Blur, the Blur founder. And so this is when we started, well, it's not only just cut from the same cloth, it's made by the same founder. And this is where a lot of the financial engineering, financial gamification that Blur pioneered is now being like that playbook is being repeated again.
And also Blur, you know, investment from paradigm. Interesting set of an investors. A lot of the crypto Twitter trade influencer accounts that also, again, that is a playbook from a friend tech where they kind of just like gave the crypto Twitter influencers early access and investment into front tech so that they could like promote the whole friend tech thing. So we're starting to see like a reproduction, a lot of the same strategies. Well, yeah, and we were looking at a tab earlier, David, that actually shows it's not just the e-field and the USDC yield in maker, but there's something called like Blast Rewards.
Blast Rewards. Okay. The longer I keep my funds on Blast, the more you get rewards. You get rewards. Yeah. Okay. On the Blast website, you go to the website, it's Blast. And that's AirDrop is the first tab on Blast. And it's not about this. Unabashedly, I remember when I opened up friend tech and was like, oh man, they made an AirDrop tab. That's bold. And they also gated release with invitation codes, law, friend tech. And so like, you know, you don't have access. You got to get an invite code. If this is where... I mean, but the whole branding, they're leaning into the, this feels very Robinhood, I would say.
Right? They're just totally leaning into, leaning into the degen of like fast money. Like, you know, if it's deposit here, you're earning, you're earning. It's just kind of leaning into that kind of culture. It seems like to me. So what's the problem with this though, David? Why did it... It keeps getting worse. It keeps getting worse. So here's how invites work. And so this is literally from their website. I'm reading a section from their website. How invites work? You get points when you're invites, earn points, you're invites, the people you invite. When they earn points, and then when they're invites, also earn points, you earn points.
You get 16% bonus points, when you're invites, earn points, and 8% when they're invites in earn points. If you invite a whale, you get a lot of points, and you'll move up the leaderboard. So like shout out to the graphic designer who made this last section a square, and not a pyramid. This is a pyramid. This is a pyramid. And so if you are just getting points, if your invites come in on board, and then also if they invite, you get their points too. It's just a pyramid scheme technology. Pyramid scheme for invitation codes, right? Okay, so what is the wisdom of the elders here? We got another pyramid scheme.
What do respected members of the Ethereum community say about this? Right, okay, so remember how they called it a layer two? Well, it's not a layer two. It is a one way deposit contract that is a three of five multi-sick. The layer two launches in Q1 2024. Right now it is like a centralized side chain with a three of five multi-sick that you cannot withdraw from. It does not go backwards. It only goes one way. That doesn't sound great. Yeah. We're wrapping up the risk here. And there's already, at the time this tweet, 30 million, but I think there's more. I don't know. There's a hundred and over.
I only look at 20 million dollars. There's a positive, very, very early in the early days of this yield bearing layer two, which again, I contest the idea that is the first yield. I have my assets on optimism, and I have that in our eth. Does that make optimism a yield bearing layer two? Because it's effectively the same technology. Yeah. Okay, so it's not a real layer two. Here's another take. It's not a real layer two, it's not a really yield bearing. The duality of paradigm. They've raised the bar in terms of technology. Founder, Rheth, Aloy are wonderful. They've won the hearts of engineers I love.
I respect Georgios and think he cares. They've made my life as a lowly application developer better. But my God, the behavior of their investments, I thought blend was awesome, but blur blast. Should be seriously ashamed of launching an L2 in this state. There's not even anything to roll up. It's a multi-sig wrapping a proxy to an unverified contract. It's grossed and no different than people shoveling ether directly to influencer EOAs in hopes of a shit coin allocation. Wow, some condemnation here from a crypto developer. What's your take on this? Yeah, and this is weird. Oh, actually, I gotta read this.
But I can't throw stones, the same poster here. I claimed my airdrop. I bridged two. I'll still keep drinking that garbage. I just wish it didn't have to be this way. I don't know about that lot. If you wish it didn't have to be that way, but you're still participating in the pyramid scheme. It's the most incentives, right? It's the game of occasion. It's the incentives. It's not lost on me that Matt Huang from Paradise wrote that casino on Mars blog post. And in the middle of launching three different casinos. So here's a take from... And the casino is like blur, blend, friend tech. These are all just like gambling platforms.
And so like at some point in time, paradigm was like, you know what? Like we're just going to fund casinos. We're going to fund casinos. That's what we're going to do. We're just going to lean into it. And that's why they've gotten all the crypto Twitter trader influencers on board. This is Joseph DeLong, who just tweets out, did paradigm just turn into a pump and dump sweatshop? Like a pump and dump sweatshop? It's like, I would have called it a casino sweatshop. But yeah, that's like what people are as critiquing is what paradigm is really like what they're investing in. Here's Ethan Bookman from Cosmos.
Remember when paradigm like took crypto off of their website and then they had to read it and they did crypto crypto. Well now it's just like Ponzi, Ponzi, Ponzi. This is not actually what the website is, but this is like the edit, right? So like people on crypto Twitter are just saying like, yo, like kind of gross and Ick. And it's the same like financialization Ponzi playbook being repeated over and over and over again. And here's Dankrad who says, this is a very bad idea. And this is referring to the native yield aspect of it. ETH and liquid staking derivatives are different assets with different risk profiles.
And users should have a choice about which ones they want to use. The same is true for different types of stablecoins, saying that just like, oh, if you deposit your assets into blast and then they swap it out for staked ETH or and make your doubt treachery, it's like, that is a choice that they are enshrining into the quote, quote, quote, later too. As removing user choice. Okay, but so let me push back on that. Is there the possibility, David, you're being a bit puritanical about this maybe, right? So this is Udi, of course, who's always the one to call out. And any hint of, you know, maybe Puritanism or what we might call sobriety, says actually the thing you're calling a very bad idea would actually be more accurately described as a trade off.
Isn't this just a trade off? Dankrad replies and says, I'm not against the trade off, but against misnaming things to confuse users. They can make their base asset form of an LST, but as you call it that instead of ETH, there's an element, David, of like, I mean, are they doing like, are they doing anything? If you don't like the pyramid scheme mechanics of it, just don't participate, right? Sure. I think that's a, you know, a counter to this. It's not, you know, but also I understand the reaction and I think the reaction from the crypto community is just, oh God, another pyramid scheme. Is that all we're offering to the world?
Like we're just kind of tired of this. I certainly feel that way. Like I'm just, I'm done with the roller coaster of like, the exact same mechanic only in this mechanic, it's more a pyramid scheme. That's not really innovation. That's not really going to like change the world. And I think paradigm maybe, and this particular project caught crypto in a moment where it feels like it's just jumped the shark. You know, like we're just kind of done with it. Yeah. And the mood has shifted. And I think paradigm and maybe blast is taking the full brunt of that new shift. Fair or not for this particular project.
Well, they're, they're jumping the shark thing is just like, oh, well, we saw the, the gamification of incentives on blur. We saw the friend tech invite code system work. Let's like put everything that we've learned and just go full casino. Let's just turn, turn it up to 11 on the casino. Let's say outside of things. Yeah. And like to some degree, there are the crypto Twitter trade influencers, the one that's like listed in the announcement. And there's all of that money sloshing around playing games independent from like the innovations in the layer two space. It's not about like any of the optimizations that salon is making.
It's not any of the optimations that the super chain is making. It's just like the casino, the casino on Mars. And so that casino on Mars just happens to be very proximate to more like the EF members, the more the the idealist out there. And that is a friction point. We have like the DJNs right next to the idealists. And now like we're talking about it. And so maybe that's just like, this paradigm is just making this product. And it's not for us, but they just happen to also be in our community. And there's just something weird about just like the duality of paradigm that one blog post, where like Georgios is working super hard to fix like roll up composability, like cross-chain and commercial composability.
He built Russ Ethereum, which Debs love. And so like you have this, just extremely prestigious, hard working, like a bunch of research has had a very hard problems. And then their products are casino ponces. Yeah, no, I get it. I think my biggest issue with this is that it's a multi-sick and not really multi-sick. That's probably my biggest otherwise. Branding is bad. I feel like this same way I feel about Frontec, which is like it's a pyramid scheme. That's what they're doing is their growth strategy. I guess I'm neutral to like not feeling great about it, but I hope to God. This is not all that crypto produces.
Like we got to show the world a little bit more than this. All right, David, we got some more stuff coming up. Coinbase just got sold. We talk about who the new buyer is and whether we should be concerned or not. And also is there a new crypto president of Argentina? But before we get to all that, we want to shout out our friends and sponsors over at Metamask. And if you have not opened the new Metamask portfolio app and all of the updates that are coming your way, go check it out to great place to look at your portfolio. Metamask portfolio is your one-stop shop to navigate the world of DeFi.
And now bridging seamlessly across networks doesn't have to be so daunting anymore. With competitive rates and convenient routes, Metamask portfolio's bridge feature lets you easily move your tokens from chain to chain using popular layer one and layer two networks. And all you have to do is select a network you want to bridge from and where you want your tokens to go. From there, Metamask vets and curates the different bridging platforms to find the most decentralized, accessible and reliable bridges for you. To tap into the hottest opportunities in crypto, you need to be able to plug into a variety of networks and nobody makes that easier than Metamask portfolio.
Instead of searching endlessly through the world of bridge options, click the bridge button on your Metamask extension or head over to Metamask.io, slash portfolio to get started. Cello is the mobile first EVM compatible, carbon negative blockchain built for the real world. And now something big is happening. Introducing the Cello Layer Two. It's a game-changing proposal that's going to bring Cello's rapidly growing ecosystem home to Ethereum. Vitalik has shared its excitement for the Cello Layer Two on the Cello Forum, so has Ben Jones from Optimism. But why? The Cello Layer Two will bring huge advantages, like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability and one block finality.
Which is all that mean, rock solid security, a trustless bridge to Ethereum, and more real world use cases for Ethereum without compromise. And real world adoption is happening. Active addresses on Cello have grown over 500% in the last six months. With the Cello Layer Two, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas using ERC-20 tokens. But Cello is a community governed protocol. This means that Cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Cello Forum. Follow at CelloOrug on Twitter and visit sellow.org to shape the future of Ethereum. Arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications.
Arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions. Arbitrum has the leading DeFi ecosystem, strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs, and is quickly becoming the Web3 gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.arbitrum.io. Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitrum orbit chain? Arbitrum orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput. Whether you're a developer, an enterprise or a user, Arbitrum orbit lets you take your project to new heights.
All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum. Experience Web3 development, the way it was always meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Visit Arbitrum.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities. Javier Malay is his name. David, this is a picture of Javier. He has dressed as his superhero alter ego called General Ancap. The Ancap, I think, stands for NACRO Capitalists. And Arbitrum Capitalists. Yeah, definitely on the skews libertarian, let's say. Have you been following this? A little bit, a little bit. Yeah, I saw this video of him waving a chainsaw around outside of the roof of his car as he's waving the chainsaw saying, we're going to cut out the government.
It reminds me of actually a little bit of our Vivek interview where he's like, we're just going to gut half the government. If there was no chainsaw in the Vivek interview. Vivek has a lot more. This guy is an eccentric character. This guy is like, he's kind of like a rock star. Like, he should have a guitar. And he should be on the rolling stones. Like, that's kind of crazy. He's a little bit crazy. Super easy. He's a big performer, very loud and boisterous. Very like right wing. Elected right wing libertarian is now the new president with 87% of the votes counted. 56 to Malay, 44% to the opponent.
So like, what's his deal? Like, what does he want? Why do people even think that he's like pro crypto? His major narrative is what it's being called economic shock therapy. So he's just going to rustle things up with the Argentine economy. By the way, the Argentine economy, if anyone can solve that problem, they'll get like a Nobel Prize. Cause they at like 100% Argentine peso inflation year over year, like the amount that people like demand for dollars in Argentina is through the roof. So he wants to shut down the central bank. He wants to ditch the peso. He wants to just cut half the government, like slashing spending and then potentially very painful reforms.
And so his first presidential speech, he goes, the model of decadence has come to an end. There's no going back. So this guy wants to shake up Argentina. And I think the question is, there's like the Argentine economic situation is a very large problem. And now we have this very loud and boisterous human promising to shake things up. And is the human able to be as large as the problem? Because some people in Argentina are like, it doesn't matter who is president. The economic situation is so terrible. Like it's one man can't do anything about it. It's a larger problem. It's any bigger than any one man.
Well, apologies take here is that this is the second Bitcoin president. So he congratulated him and there's one clip here where Javier is saying about Bitcoin, what Bitcoin is representing is the return of money to its original creator, the private sector. He also says we have to understand that the central bank is a scam. So not a big central banker. I believe though David, he's not doing the El Salvador at play of like adopting Bitcoin, but rather kind of casting aside the peso and adopting the dollar as sort of the stablecoin. So maybe it remains to be seen how crypto friendly he is, but certainly I would think you would be stablecoin friendly.
Would he not? Yes, stablecoins has got to be in any rational person who's leading Argentina with the intent to dollarize. Stablecoins has got to be on their menu of like first things to consider. The reason why people are calling in pro crypto is because he wants to get rid of one fiat for the more strong fiat in his anti-central bank. It's like crypto viby, crypto adjacent, like there's no concrete plans, but yeah, we're gonna be a crypto country. It's just like we're gonna get rid of our shitty fiat in favor of the better fiat. Well, David, you are going to Argentina pretty soon, right? It's like the beginning of next year.
I believe so. Three weeks and one week in Buenos Aires, two weeks in Patagonia. So I'm gonna, yeah, hang out with a bunch of architized. I'll get there take. Yeah, get some person on the street takes too. David, some other big news this week, CoinDesk was sold. And they were sold to a crypto exchange. This is one of the largest media companies in crypto and they were bought by a company called Bullish. This is the crypto exchange. David, do you remember who Bullish is? And like it's from my distant past, I've heard this name. And it really had to dust off the old like memory addict to get downloaded on this one.
So a DCG digital currency group, also the conglomerate that owns great scale and Genesis and is in a lawsuit with Gemini. They need to raise capital to pay, to fill the hole in their balance sheet, to pay back Gemini and all the other creditors of Genesis who had like a billion dollar hole in it as a result of all the fallout from 2022. So in that end, they have accepted a bid to sell CoinDesk, the 10 year old crypto news company to Bullish, a crypto exchange, where did Bullish come from? Bullish is a subsidiary of Block One, which was launched, a crypto exchange bullish, subsidiary of Block One.
Where is Block One? This is gonna be for like the long time crypto people. Block One is the people that made the EOS blockchain. And so this is, if any Ethereum Pearson is calling like Solana the EOS of this cycle, this is like why we're getting like, some people get like the PTSD of Block One and invoking that. Block One raised a $4 billion 2018 ICO to do this high throughput free transaction fees, EOS chain. And they raised $4 billion in Bitcoin and Ryan, they didn't sell any of that Bitcoin. So that $4 billion in Bitcoin in 2017 to 2018, when they were raising that money, he's worth some crazy amount of money.
Oh, 164,000 Bitcoin. That is more Bitcoin than micro strategy. They have more Bitcoin than micro sailor. Why don't people talk about them? Well, because like on the Bitcoin Treasuries website, it's a treasuries for public companies. And Block One is like this private conglomerate that has this massive amount of Bitcoin that they got from like this very dubious ICO to make this very high-performance blockchain. Okay. And the big question here is, is this good or bad for crypto media? And this is Jason from Blockworks who gives his takes and I think he says it's bad. The Coinbase and bullish acquisition is bad for industry and then he lists some thoughts.
Why is Jason saying this is bad, David? He's basically worried about the conflict of interest between CoinDesk, a journalist company, a journalist media organization, and being bought by a crypto exchange. And he says, this is like NASDAQ buying the Wall Street Journal or like Binance buying CoinDesk. It crushes editorial integrity of the brand. I'd assume every reporter will leave within six months. Now, Jason founder of Blockworks is inside of the media world. And so he would probably would be concerned about this and also perhaps has a bias. On the flip side of things, ELE Tan, who's a journalist at CoinDesk, Fun Fact Ryan, we've had him on bank lists.
I interviewed him, he's one of the few in-person interviews that I did my apartment. ELE Tan retweeted this tweet from Yano and said, how many market-nuking scoops does CoinDesk have to have to prove its editorial independence? Interesting. Yeah, and I remember back in the day, editorial independence was a big problem at CoinDesk. Like the bags of Barry Silvert and the articles that went out of CoinDesk in like 2017 to 2019. We're very, very aligned. That is no longer the case. And I think now I'm willing, personally, to extend CoinDesk the benefit of the doubt. I think they have totally proved to myself themselves to be editorially independent why the founders of bullish are interested in buying CoinDesk is perhaps up to be scrutinized, but anyone inside of CoinDesk, I think totally gets the benefit of the doubt.
Yeah, I mean, they broke the FTX story and ended up costing their parent company everything, DCG everything. They ended up costing this selling of CoinDesk. You still broke it. Yeah, I guess I'll give them benefit of doubt for a while, but you really have to wonder how CoinDesk will operate when it's under new management. So under the previous management, I think they proved that they had editorial independence, whether that continues moving forward or not. But I do think the big signal will be how many of the journalists actually stay. Those with integrity, if they stay and if they feel comfortable operating under new management, that's probably a signal that they're able to maintain their editorial independence.
So I guess for me, it's to be determined, David. Getting into some optimism news, there was this blog post that came out that really got me excited, Ryan, talking about shared upgrades for OP stack chains. So this is a roadmap for some upcoming technical improvements to the OP stack to its main components. This first component focuses on changes that will impact OP stack nodes and node operators in shining a protocol version. That means that anyone using the OP stack for their chain can easily track whether their infrastructure is up to date and in sync with the official latest protocol version as component number one.
The second component of two just simplifies the multi chain contract upgrades with a multi chain upgrade contract. So eliminating hard coded configurations, super chains, all the OP stack chains that are part of the super chain can share one set of implementation contracts and therefore perform multi chain protocol upgrades inside of a single transaction. So one single transaction upgrades, the optimism main net, the base chain, Zora, public goods network, anything that is an OP stack chain that wants to be a part of the super chain can all upgrade in unison. So this is one of many mechanisms that it would take to have to recompose the Ethereum many layer twos into like this one singular system.
There's no one single silver bullet, Ryan for reintroducing composability across Ethereum layer twos. One of my tweets this week, Ryan was the layer two fragmentation on Ethereum is just going to die a thousand cuts. And this one is a very deep cut, I would say. Like single unison protocol upgrades for all OP stack chains that want to be a part of the super chain. Pretty cool. So the governance process to implement this multi chain contract upgrades will crack off in early 2024. Yeah, I think that has been a major criticism of Ethereum and Slayer 2 strategy this year. It's just like fracturing of governance, fracturing of the user experience, fracturing of composability and liquidity.
And so now the story is some of that's true. Actually in exchange for scalability, the story is how does Ethereum stitch it all back together? And I think there's some promising solutions ahead that we'll be talking about in the weeks to come. David, you ready for me in the week, man? I am. Let's do it. All right, happy Thanksgiving to you. And this was the, this was the meme of the week we decided. So what if your crypto friends got in trouble this week? David, we're looking at a picture of an awkward family dinner get together sitting around the Thanksgiving table all of your relatives looking at you and asking you about your crypto friend who got in trouble this week.
And that would be CZ Binance, all of our crypto friends. Right. I'm actually going to be sharing the day after Thanksgiving with CZ because I'm going to go down to the courthouse and I'm going to wait. Wait, wait, wait. Tell us more about that. Okay, so we talked about earlier. You were actually in Seattle. This is just I'm in Seattle right now. I don't know how you do this. Whenever you go to a mall and something bad happens to Gary Gensler, you went to Montenegro and don't want was arrested and don't want to just happen to be there. Now you just happen to be in Seattle and CZ is there. So you're actually going to go to his, he's got a date in the Seattle courthouse at 9 a.
m. Seattle time on Friday where he's going to plead guilty where he allegedly is going to plead guilty. And yeah, he's got to date with the court and I remember I see you're going to shout out. If I can, yeah, I'm going to go watch this. Yeah, I remember going to this courthouse like way back when where I had to like contest a parking ticket, no, a speeding ticket. Yeah, yeah, I've been to this courthouse. Yeah, that's hilarious. All right, guys, we got a moment of Zen for you. If you enjoy how Janet Yellen pronences banance, you will enjoy this, I think, some disclosures, of course. David and I, we are investors and advisors for optimism, big fans of that project.
Also, as we mentioned, Kraken is a strategic sponsor of the show. We are long-term investors, we're not journalists. We don't do paid content. There's always a link to our disclosures at bankless.com slash disclosures. And you gotta know, crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, especially if you deposit in blast. But we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot. It's banance. Finance. Banance. Finance. Banance. And let me be clear. It's banance. Banance. Banance. Finance. It's banance. It's banance.
Let me be clear. It's banance. Banance. Banance. Banance.