Welcome back to the Bankless Friday Weekly Rollup. First up, why Telegram founder Pavel Durov was arrested in France and what it means for the future of privacy. Then, drama at the Ethereum Foundation as they sell $100M worth of ETH. And finally, the latest Wells Notice from the SEC, which company got it? ------ 🌊 KELP | Deposit ETH with Gain today https://kelpdao.xyz/gain/?utm_source=Bankless ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦄UNISWAP | BROWSER EXTENSION https://bankless.cc/uniswap
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle 🌐 OBOL | STAKE ON DVs, SCALE ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/obol
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT https://bankless.cc/toku
------ TIMESTAMPS & RESOURCES 00:00:00 Start
00:02:22 Markets https://pro.kraken.com/app/trade/btc-usd https://pro.kraken.com/app/trade/eth-usd https://farside.co.uk/?p=1518 https://x.com/tokenterminal/status/1828049589305319792?s=46&t=2ZINVXJQKx6xO_6Wiiu_2g https://www.growthepie.xyz/fundamentals/total-value-locked
00:06:23 Rate Cuts Incoming https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/powell20240823a.htm https://x.com/RyanSAdams/status/1829156259062501574
00:08:41 Stablecoin ATH https://defillama.com/stablecoins https://x.com/PayPal/status/1828161802208985462
00:13:14 When Pump? https://x.com/2xdog/status/1826460239090385028/photo/1
00:18:42 Telegram Founder Arrested https://x.com/WatcherGuru/status/1827450423608795287?t=9gT6e4AmQL8qHc5gDA0Rrw&s=19
00:21:01 What Are The Charges? https://x.com/Cointelegraph/status/1828915121823068476 https://x.com/RyanSAdams/status/1828122303047033327
00:24:03 Encryption
00:27:47 Takes On This Issue https://x.com/EmmanuelMacron/status/1828077245606342672 https://x.com/VitalikButerin/status/1827602680388239582 https://x.com/Kasparov63/status/1827819652535489007 https://x.com/NoelleInMadrid/status/1827798993017127243
00:30:45 TON's Reaction https://x.com/ton_society/status/1827753299736674599 https://x.com/ton_society/status/1828446248841441467
00:36:36 Mark Zuckerburgs Letter https://x.com/boblatta/status/1828516974269472936/photo/1
00:39:46 Roman Storm's Battle https://x.com/RyanSAdams/status/1828906357723955378
00:46:34 Ethereum Foundation Sold $100M? https://thedefiant.io/news/blockchains/ethereum-community-rattled-by-foundation-s-eth-sales-and-vitalik-s-defi-hate https://x.com/0xstark/status/1828416178194104342 https://x.com/defiignas/status/1827287094705701318?s=46&t=2ZINVXJQKx6xO_6Wiiu_2g
00:52:26 Does Vitalik Hate DeFi? https://x.com/VitalikButerin/status/1827583576751181961 https://x.com/kaiynne/status/1821020189594669398 https://x.com/RhettShipp/status/1827911788488487047 https://x.com/haydenzadams/status/1828452122385424718 https://x.com/VitalikButerin/status/1828448417585971661
01:01:51 Sony's Layer 2 - Soneium https://x.com/soneium/status/1826832581897126367
01:03:34 MakerDAO Rebranded To SKY https://x.com/SkyEcosystem/status/1828405625828843710 https://governance.aave.com/t/temp-check-buidl-gsm/18775
01:05:47 Trump Harris Debate https://x.com/disclosetv/status/1828505848504819978
01:06:42 RFK Drops Out https://x.com/watcherguru/status/1827059890549862600?s=46&t=iahr7Lh5v08SSM_Ery-bGw
01:07:45 Trump NFTs https://x.com/mdudas/status/1828575205276459258
01:09:29 SEC Threatens To Sue Opensea https://x.com/dfinzer/status/1828791832009953706?s=46
01:12:37 Chainbound Raises $4.6M https://x.com/chainbound_/status/1828047583090016308?s=46&t=dAxCjT2P_GIrJMvMgWIpfA
01:13:22 Most Unattractive Hobbies... https://x.com/nic__carter/status/1827862983034245338
01:14:50 Moment Of Zen https://x.com/songadaymann/status/1828885208227332591?s=46
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Bancle Station, it is the last week of August, it's time for the bankless weekly roll-up. Telegram founder, Pablo Derov, was arrested in France. Why? What are the charges? What happened? And what does it mean for the future of privacy with encrypted messaging apps? Also, does the Ethereum Foundation need to be a little bit more transparent when they send $100 million of ETH to Kraken? And why does Vitalik hate DeFi? Or does he maybe not? We'll shed some light on all of this drama. Also, another week, another nasty gram from our friend at SEC, Gary Gensler. What lucky company is joining the ranks of companies that are in the targets of Gary Gensler and the SEC?
Somebody got a well-snoticed place, your bets, consider which awesome, compliant US-based company is now receiving a well-snoticed place, your bets, think about it, and we'll come back to this later on the show. Also, consider Gary Gensler's feelings on Pokemon cards and NFTs. So you think there are securities? And speaking of NFTs, you know, Trump's got a new NFT program. He's rolling out. It's like the fourth edition of the Trump card. We'll talk about that. And the MakerDowr rebrand into sky is underway, so we will give our takes and all the information about the change from die to USDS and NKR to sky.
Also Sony, introducing their Ethereum layer 2, built on the OP stack, where did this come from? Why does Sony need a layer 2? And also really bad news for men in the crypto dating department, guys, you guys aren't doing so hot. But before we get to all of it, are you guys, I'm Mary, okay, are you talking about it? I don't want to talk about it. I'm talking about it. I'm talking about it. You don't want to be included in that department. All right. Before we begin, we got a message from our friends over at KelpDowr. What are they up to? Yeah, KelpDowr is introducing a brand new product to maximize rewards.
If you're in the business of points farming, yield farming across all of these different apps, maybe just let Kelp do that for you with their new product gain. You can deposit ETH, RSEETH, or other LSTs, you get access to rewards from multiple different layer 2 networks, other restaking platforms, DeFi opportunities with a single click. Maybe you're in the trenches and you would spend like to be a little bit less than in the trenches. Gain from Kelp can do that for you. There is a link in the show notes as you can get started. You also have full control over your assets, you can withdraw at any time.
All right. Shall we get into prices, Ron? Heck, yeah. Bitcoin price in the week. What are we looking at? Bitcoin price, $60,700, up a half a percent. So call that flat currently at $61,000 at the end of the week. ETH price, start of the week, $2,600, down 1% to $2,590, we'll sell us $10. Call it whatever. And on the ETF inflows or outflows, we are actually on inflows as of the last yesterday. So for the first day and two weeks, the first day and one day of inflows, net inflows. We are on a one-day streak, could be also two at the end of today, could be two, the day recording on Thursday. So yesterday, the 28th, we had $5.
9 million of net inflows, $8.4 million into BlackRock, $3.8 million out of grayscale, Fidelity got 1.3 and everyone else is basically selling. I mean, there's no way to sugarcoat this. No way to sugarcoat this. The ETH inflows haven't been great. ETH ETF inflows have not been great yet. So we're still at the... They'll turn it around. I'm still holding that Pope. Still early. It's under a month. Still under a month. Did you check out Bitcoin this week too? It had some pretty red days, like the 28th and 27th this week. Oh, wow. Bitcoin is at a zero-day streak. Yeah. Well, okay. So the last four days, the 23rd, 250 in 26, 200 in 27, 127 out, the 28th, 105 million out.
Yeah. So some rough days. Okay. Maybe those diamond hand institutional buyers aren't so diamond hand, David. Yeah, it turns out it's just all... It turns out all of the ETF buyers are just us in our retirement cars. It turns out that's just how many. Well, thanks to Kraken for those charts. Obviously, we use Kraken Pro and the Kraken Exchange for all of our crypto trading, don't we? And thanks to Kraken for sponsoring Bankless for as long as they have. Let's turn it to Layer 2's for a quick update. Base is absolutely running away with Layer 2's from this metric, which is monthly active user addresses.
So this blue line is base and it is just climbing kind of the only one that's going up. Yeah. Hockey stick growth. What are some of the stats here? Let me see. So... 13.4 monthly million active addresses, up 20% month over month, up 1,300% year over year. That's 13.4 million monthly active is compared to Arbitrum's 3.5. Lenea's 1.3 and Optimism's 1. There's a question of how much of this is like Cible. So Travis Kling asked in this chart, isn't this skewed by Cible farming, industrial grade, Cible farming, airdrop farming, what if I told you 10 entities controlled more than half the wallets? And token time is revised.
That has been the entire paradigm of all address-based metrics. Sure. We've always been like that since I've ever gotten into crypto. We've known this. Yes. And also, the data that we just quoted is from token terminal that tries to screen some that noise out. So the reply here is the above. I did not know that they did that. Yeah. Get old token terminal. They're building behind the scenes. The above chart takes into account unique fee-paying addresses. Does not consider whether those addresses are controlled by one or many IRL entities. So they do unique fee-paying addresses, but like I guess they, you know, they don't always know.
Oh, but they do say, please share a list of the 10 entities, and we'll, uh, disclude them. So they find out. They're calling Travis out, so he's like, oh, so you know those 10 addresses, 10 in the hallway. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's, uh, monthly user addresses, which is one metric. Another though is total value locked. And here, Arbitrum still reigns supreme. They're crushing it. Gargantuan. Yeah. $15 billion in Arbitrum followed by basis six followed by optimism five and a half followed by Blast 1.5. Yeah. Uh, so, you know, another metric to look at. Of course. Where's our friends? Five. Three or two's with a billion dollars.
Mantles could the next one at 1.1 billion dollars. Let's talk about trad markets for a second. Jerome Powell is signaling that rate cuts are all but inevitable. This is kind of what we expected, but he made a speech this week. Uh, and he noted a few things that inflation has dropped from a peak of 9.1% in mid 2022. Do you remember that 9.1%? That was crazy. Yeah. To 2.9% last month. And both are edging close to the 2% target, of course. And he adds this, we will do everything we can to support a strong labor market. So notice that the strong labor market, I think that indicates that they're shifting their focus from inflation to jobs reports and jobs numbers that the labor market.
He also said this. This is a direct quote with an appropriate dialing back of policy restraint. There is good reason to think that the economy will go back to 2% inflation while maintaining a strong labor market basically saying, I'm going to dial things. Back, inflation is going to be fine. And also jobs will be fine. So that's next. That's going to happen in September. It's all but inevitable. I think a lot of macro folks are saying inflation is no longer the thing that you should be looking at with respect to Fed policy decisions. You know, everyone's trying to prognosticate and try to predict what Powell and the Fed are going to do next.
But really the numbers we should be looking at are coming out of the jobs reports. So jobs numbers are now the new inflation, like more important in determining the Fed's next move. So I feel like we might need to incorporate some jobs numbers into this, you know, tradify, update macro section moving forward. So I asked like, you know, like what are the best job numbers to track? So maybe we'll include some of that moving forward. So that's what's happening on the Fed side. Looks like easy money is back on the menu. Also this happened towards the beginning of this week, which is where we saw like some price increases across the board.
Like each got almost up to $2,800 Bitcoin got up to like $65,000. So we saw the price action respond here, like both inequities and in crypto markets. But I think people are like my suspicion is that they are going to cut slowly. It's going to be a slow move, not whiplash because they learned their lesson last time. It's going to be a slow cut. So people got really excited. But then they realized that, you know, okay, it's going to be the easy rate cut cycle era, but it's going to not happen all at once. That's my indication of the market. Anyways, more into the crypto side of markets, stablecoin, stablecoin supply is almost almost at all time high.
It almost grew a whole 1% over the past week to 169 billion dollars, almost there. USDT tether has grown 28% this last year from 91.5 billion to 117 billion USDC grew 44% this last year from 23.8 to 34.4 stablecoin supply to me paints the floor for fundamentals and valuation for all our other crypto assets. As this number goes up in price, to me, the floor price of crypto assets also goes up in price. So just really strong growth out of the stablecoins. Yeah, that's good for defied David, you want to hear a fun fact always. So okay, Warren Buffett, he just, you know, he's been selling his stocks and stacking, you know, dollars basically.
He sold more B of A stock, Bank of America stock yesterday. He has now, now he has about two stablecoin market caps worth of cash sitting on the Warren Buffett Act. That's not a fun fact. That's not a fun fact. That's not a fun fact. Almost 300 billion dollars Warren Buffett has. I thought you were going to tell me he was going to say he had just started buying stable coins for some reason. That is a fun fact. He could convert all of that to stablecoins and tokenized treasuries and middle fund. He could corner the stablecoin market. Okay, here's what an actual fun fact is, PayPal's PYUSD hit one billion dollars in market cap.
Congratulations to PayPal's PYUSD. Well done. What if people don't know what PYUSD is? That's a stablecoin, right, from PayPal. Yeah, PayPal, yeah, PayPal stablecoin. It has doubled. It supplies it into June, monthly active wallet addresses of PYUSD was at 25,000 in July, and it's been up from 9,400 megs, so getting some traction actually mostly on Salona. It went from zero to 650 million dollars of stablecoin supply on Salona in the last three months, which is closing on tether supply on Salona. Apparently, allegedly caused by incentives, a commando drift, and margin-fi introduced boosted rewards for PYUSD, so when you incentivize things, it happens.
But yeah, PayPal, PYUSD, cornering part of the stablecoin Salona market. David, I've heard you're larger in stablecoins. Why are you laughing? Oh, just because you said when you incentivize things, they happen, and I just thought that's brilliant. Also, I was going to bring up the fact, so Nick Carter has told us, and so did Austin Campbell, when we had him on the podcast, by the way, that said it's going to come out later with Austin Campbell. It's a great episode. It's a great episode. More than stablecoins. It was just like about, yeah, how do I talk to the roots? Yeah, how to talk to you, sort of like the, the normy on the street in the US, and you like to explain why crypto is actually good, anyway, that aside, they both have said things like PYUSD, PayPal's stablecoin is actually better in some ways than USDC, certainly not from a little bit.
Better from like an investor protections, consumer protections, point of view. Yeah, and they can explain this better, but it's because it's like segmented in a trust, and so it has the settlement guarantees almost like cash in your pocket. It's like a true bear instrument, and if PayPal goes bankrupt or anything else going like bankrupt, unless the US government literally goes bankrupt, and then we're all screwed, it's redeemable, right? So, which is maybe it's not as clear what would happen in the case of like a circle bankruptcy or something crazy of what would happen to USDC. I think that's some of the additional settlement guarantees that you get with PayPal's stablecoin.
Yeah, to further illustrate that point, like your dollars in your Wells Fargo or your dollars in FinTech PayPal are an IOU, this is how banking works, we know this, stablecoins are better than those banking, in terms of a bankless life, like using bankless tools, it's pure like USDC tether, stablecoins are better because they're one-to-one backed, right? Like there's not risky lending going on in the background, but PYUSD is even better than the typical stablecoin because of an additional like legal protection wrapper and how it becomes tokenized in the first place. Yeah, it's even better according to them than FDIC insured.
It's like dollar in your bank. The most bank minimized stablecoin on existence other than die, which died this week actually became a little bit less bankless, we'll talk about that later. Yeah. All right, so people are getting this point in the episode and they're like another flat week, you know, another bankless roll-up, when pomped David, okay, here's some optimism for you, hunt for green October. So historically, I guess we got to skip all the bankless roll-ups in September, but historically, you come back in October, we're going to be, all right, we're going up in October because historically, the most bullish month for Bitcoin has been October, average price performance, second half of the year, 20% for October.
It's negative 6% in September and then plus 6% in November and then plus 10% in December. So really where you want to be is the back quarter of the year. The last three months of the year is going to be good for crypto. You believe this? I mean, I think so. This isn't like my kind of like charting, but like, I'm not going to disagree with the facts here. Why don't you have a disagree with something bullish, right? Yeah. I'm just looking back at 2017, dude, when I got into crypto. I got into crypto in June, July of 2017 and June, July was 9% and 15% to pretty green months. Where I like got into it in October, October, it was up 50%, 53% in November.
It was up 51% and in December, it was up 45% 50, 350% months in a row. I just remember that time and I was like, so euphoric and just like high on crypto, learning about crypto, like smart contracts and blockchain. I remember the very distinct time in my life, and you think you'll ever feel that you worry again. No, that's a one. That's like, you only get to do call this one. You only get to play Dark Souls for the first time once and you only get to get in crypto for the first time. Yeah, there's only for me. It's only one of you, the first viewing of Lord of the Rings, you know, and then after that, you only get to do it for the first time once a second and they're doing manually, of course, in my case.
David, we got a lot more coming up. So France has accused the telegram founder of helping with organized crimes and arrested Pavel Duroff. So what does this mean for digital privacy? What does this mean for digital rights? Also, there's some drama around the EF Foundation, selling 100 million ether. You were talking about it in the intro, and there's this rumor. There's this idea that suddenly Vitalik hates DeFi, we'll get it all that. Suddenly. Yeah. It just happened out of nowhere. All that and more. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our recommended exchange and the place to get prepared for a Q4 of 2024.
That's going to be absolutely explosive. That is cracking. If you don't have an account, go get yourself an account. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Crackin, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Crackin is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone, everywhere, to trade crypto. Crackin's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks.
And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos. With products and features like Crackin Pro and Crackin NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Crackin.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice. Crypto trading involves risk of loss.
Distributable collective is up and running and is maybe one of the most important collectives that you've never heard of. Opal is bringing distributed validators or DVs to the Ethereum staking stack. Distributed validators allow multiple parties of people running multiple nodes to create a single virtual Ethereum validator. Together, this makes participating in Ethereum consensus more accessible, more affordable, and more inclusive. It is a strict improvement to the Ethereum staking tech stack with collaboration from Lido, EtherFi, eigenlayer, and 50 other entities, and thousands of individuals.
The Opal collective is working to scale and decentralize Ethereum using DVs. And now you can get involved, introducing the Opal Contributions program. Visit opal.org slash bank lists to stake on DVs, either through a partner staking protocol or at home. Earn access to future governance and ownership in Opal while contributing to retroactive funding for projects that are actively decentralizing Ethereum. This is your opportunity to secure inclusion in one of the most important projects working to scale Ethereum's foundation for future growth. Visit opal.org slash bank lists to get started. That's obol.
org slash bank lists. The Uniswap Extension is here. The Self-Custody Wallet created by the most trusted team in DVs, Uniswap Labs, designed to make swapping feel effortless. This extension lives in your browser's sidebar, letting you swap, sign transactions, and send or receive crypto without ever losing your place on the internet. Plus, with human readable transaction messages, you'll always know exactly what you're signing. Navigate a multi-chain world effortlessly with support for 11 chains like Ethereum, MainNet, Base, Arbitrome, and Optimism. No more chain switching or token importing. All your assets are right where you need them to be.
The Uniswap Extension is designed to level up your swapping experience with other Uniswap Labs products as well, easily onboard to the extension using the Uniswap mobile wallet to begin managing your assets across platforms. And take advantage of smooth seamless synergies with the Uniswap Web App. So go and download the Uniswap Extension today by clicking the link in the show notes. Just another way Uniswap is helping you swap smarter. Telegram founder, Pavel Darov, arrested in France this week. Monday this week, Pavel was placed in custody by agents of France's National Anti-Fraud Office. According to French News, this TF1, he was arrested at the airport and was subject of a search warrant for an OFMIN, sounds like some France alphabet agency.
It's an investigative agency which combats child exploitation in France. Okay, so what are the charges? The French judge put Darov under formal investigation in a probe into his, into organized crime on the messaging app Telegram. He was granted bail, which he used on the condition that he pays 5 million euro, reports twice a week to police and does not leave French territory. The charges are out of jail and bail right now. I'm sure that on screen, he looks like he's just right. He can totally afford 5 million dollars. That is not a concern for him. It's like 15 billion dollars net worth. Anyway, go on.
Yeah, he's doing great. The charges, complicity in selling child sex abuse material, drug trafficking fraud, a bedding, organized crime, transactions, refusing to share information or documents with investigators when required to buy law. The French judge said in the statement that Telegram has been used in various criminal cases, but almost entirely ignored judicial requisitions. The French investigation services and public prosecutor offices like the Belgian ones shared a very similar observation. This prompted the Paris Prosecutors Organized Crime Office to open a probe into possible criminal liability of the managers of this messaging service in the commission of these offenses.
This probe began in February. Okay, so what does it mean for Darov now? He's being placed under formal investigation in France. It does not imply guilt or does it necessarily lead to a trial. The only thing that we know is that the judge has considered that there is enough evidence to proceed with a probe, so the probe shall go on. This investigation could perhaps last years or sent to trial or shelved, but that's kind of where we are. This really surprised me. I was shocked. I think a lot of people were shocked by this. We actually had reached out and tried to get Pavel on the podcast, not too long ago.
Apparently, he's a very difficult person to contact. I think because he has these types of security. Perhaps. Yeah, when you're getting probed. Yeah, you don't want to go on a podcast. Did you read? So this is the English translation of the actual letter for the prosecution of Pavel. So I don't know how many there's like 13 or so charges here, at least complicity charges, like complicity and fraud in an organized group, but some of these last ones, you mentioned the child's sex trafficking, child pornography, type things, illegal drugs, all of the sales complicity in those things, not him actively doing it, but because telegram host rooms where people were allegedly doing these things, then he is culpable according to these charges.
And also just generic things like this, David, providing cryptographic services designed to ensure confidentiality functions without proper declaration in accordance with the laws. What the hell does that mean? It just provides, it sounds like they're trying to regulate math is what that sounds like. It sounds like a Gary Gensler just come in and like register your encryption service. What does your lighting for that math? Seriously, providing cryptographic services ensuring only authentication functions or integrity control functions without prior declaration and accordance with the law to use encryption.
What is this? Another charge importing cryptographic services ensuring only authentication functions or integrity control functions without prior declaration and accordance with the law? I mean, this seems like it's more than just like, you know, drugs and you're like money long laundering charges of people, people by the way, not Pavo, but people using his app doing these things. And the charges basically that telegram should be present and monitoring all of the telegram users are cost a billion different users and all of the groups and making sure that this stuff doesn't happen. It also seems like some of these charges are specifically about telegram using some encryption type services.
And it should be told that telegram does not use end-to-end encryption on all of its chat rooms, right? It's not perfect secrecy, it's not perfect encryption. Yes. And this has been a criticism of telegram I think is like pretty valid and like pretty warranted like signal for instance does provide end-to-end encryption. So this means that if you're not know what you're saying inside of signal, they don't do that. Right. So this is a criticism, but yet, but yet when I read those generic charges, right, the concern here is that this seems to be a throw everything at them, see what sticks, and these same charges could be applied to like any messenger app, like a signal for instance.
Anything, anything with encryption, yeah. Yeah. I mean, did signal come in and like register, provide cryptographic services designed to ensure confidentiality, like did they do that in France? Providing cryptographic assurances to services to provide confidentiality. If that was like listed in like this iOS app, like feature button, I'd be like, oh sick download. You like use it. It's, it's scary. It's, I think it's scary. I think that this is like a major sort of war on encryption prong and a lot of people see it as such. Just a little bit more about the architecture of telegram for those that don't use it, much of the crypto industry runs on telegram, like the, I have so many telegram groups.
I use it every single day. It allows for one to one conversations. It also allows for group chats that let's, and also allows for chats that have channels for one to many broadcasting up to 200,000 people compared to the maximum of 1000 for WhatsApp. And so there have been some concerns that you can spread this information this way. And to end encryption is not available for group chats and channels and to end encryption. There is a privacy mode in telegram where you can start a, an encrypted chat, a private chat with you and whoever's on the receiving end, that's me and you, we could do that.
Private DMs. Yeah. Not, not end to end encrypted, but it is, it is possible. But then the default mode of telegram is, I think, I'm, I, the way I think this works is like default mode is actually like they do aren't able to see the contents, like that's planned review. So telegram, the company can or any government agency that's spying on telegram and like requesting their data set and telegram submits it to them can like see all of the chats in telegram basically that's not, you know, like encrypted. So generally my rule of thumb when it comes to subjects like this is that if it can be regulated or controlled, then it should be regulated or controlled.
And this is what differs from signal in my mind where signal has built a structure where they literally cannot see what is going on there on the inside of the conversation. And so in my mind, signal and signal founders are not at beholden to like the activity of the people using their tech platform. If you as a organization can see conversations and like see like image files being sent around and then like it's a child porn, like that's it, that's, to me, that's a different story. How do you feel about that take? Okay. So I think part of that take is reasonable and part of it's not all right.
So here's the part that's not reasonable from my perspective is like, okay, so the answer is just they yank the guy and just like go directly to jail and here's all of these charges. Yeah. Like that's a piece. I'm not going to agree with that at all. And now they're also saying like he hasn't been cooperative in all of these things. So it's just like, I don't know, maybe that this is the last escalation. So you could kind of defend that. But also look, look at the charges, David. Look, some of these are just some of these charges could be directly applicable to what you just said, which is the use case of signal.
And also there's, there's sort of the broader, there's the broader context of this. If you like, you know, step back and look at like the components of a, of a free society, right? We need some sort of chat function between citizens that allows us to share information. There's all sorts of like ignoring the illegal activity. There's all sorts of information that's being shared front lines of the war. For instance, things that get censored in other places, things that maybe the state doesn't want you to say. I mean, in any free society, you need coasters that are like hidden from the eyes of the government.
Like I, I think that that's an important function. And so I don't know if not telegrammed and where. I mean, a billion, basically the inverse of this, basically the government saying, no, some paddle should have had basically a watcher spies inside of every private telegram group inside of its app reporting a legal activity to us. That's kind of the inverse of that. When you say like that, I mean, that doesn't sound like a good equilibrium either does it. So I hear what you're saying and I hear that argument. And also I don't like where this is going is what I would say the trend is not, is not healthy for sure.
Let's get to some comments. So this is the president of France, Macron. He says, I have seen false information regarding France following the rest of Pavel Derov. So there's a lot of bad press. He says in a state governed by the rule of law, freedoms are upheld within a legal framework both on social media and real life to protect citizens or respective fundamental rights. He says, basically, this is the judiciary fully independent. This is not political. This is not driven by France for some sort of political means to arrest him. Here's a funny tweet that we read. Imagine you own a large apartment apartment complex.
France says is a legal requirement for you to put microphones in every room and let us listen. And you say, no, people should be able to have private conversations. And then you become arrested. That is the digital equivalent to what just happened to Pavel Derov. Vitalik, who says, I've criticized Telegram before for not being serious about encryption. But given the info available so far, the charge seems to be just being unmoderated and not giving up people's data. This looks very bad and worrying for the future software and comms freedom in Europe. This is Gary Kasparov with an alternative take.
He says, there's much to learn about Derov's arrest, but my first thought is not dependent on supposition or motivations. He was admitted by Kremlin propagandist telegrams widely used by the Russian bureaucracy and military. So it has been used for acts of war and war crimes in Ukraine. He goes on and says a full thread, but it's basically Derov is not the person you think he is. Don't hold him up as a martyr or hero. And by the way, we don't know. Maybe he was working with like the Russians. Maybe he's a KGB agent, right? There's some of that that's being injected here as well in the conversation.
Like who knows at this point? An interesting tweet from Noel Acheson says, this is not about telegram censorship. It's worse. It's about privacy. Derov's arrest is the latest and perhaps most blatant example today of the role of layers in narrative misdirection. And she makes a couple points here. Authorities want to suppress certain channels and contributors, but reports suggest that the investigation was focused on the lack of moderators. This suggests that the issue is not about censorship, but responsibility. And also second, authorities insist on having access to chats of political activists and military groups so that their intentions can be known ahead of time and their actions diverted.
What's more, it's starting to feel blatant. The authorities don't seem bothered by how this looks. They're counting on the majority not caring as much as long as they feel safe. So kind of calling out the French leadership saying like, this is like this is bullshit. You guys are doing this for your own political like motives. Yeah. And before by the way, we throw France to under the bus, there was also speculation that some of this could be motivated by the US. The US basically saying, hey, like go do this, like who knows what goes on behind closed doors. But the broader point here is like sometimes when you hear moderation, right, that can just be state, speak for censorship.
And so like some of these things are like used one and the same. Telegram has a blockchain. They have a layer one blockchain called ton. What was the telegram change reaction to this? What happened? A ton, a community rallied. Of course, there is a ton society Twitter account, which is like, call it the telegram blockchain community. We've updated the ton coins logo and profile picture across the ton community channels to the global symbol of the digital resistance. The resistance dog, why a dog in 2011, Pablo Darab was ordered to eradicate the post of liberal thinkers and dissidents at his previous company, which was a social media platform in Russia.
I can't pronounce the name. It's called, it's basically the Facebook of Russia in response to this, Pablo posted a picture of his dog refusing to silence anyone on his platform. They, the ton society announced an open letter, many app, they issued an open letter to French authorities requesting the immediate release of Pablo Darab, anyone can sign it on the telegram app and it's a crude 1.48 million signatures so far. So that's kind of cool when you have the distribution to do that. I mean, that's a good point earlier, like, uh, Pablo's history, my impression is always that the Russians were kind of out to get him.
I mean, that's why he had to sort of like free Russia. He became a citizen of France. He made a social media platform in, in Russia, he made a social media platform had to leave Russia in 2011 because if you, if you get too much power in Russia and you're not part of like the inner circle, yeah, if you're not censoring things, like that's a problem for the Russian oligarchy. Like it took a capture power in Russia. You need to have that like approved by the oligarchs. And so I think he was like more or less an outsider, not kind of playing by these rules. And so he had to leave. He now is based in Dubai.
Part of the story was that he was traveling to France with this like, model that was like, babe, like catfished, posting location kind of thing. I saw this. Well, that's the conspiracy was that she was posting like pictures of them. And it had all the geolocation data. And so like she was just like, allowing him to be traced all around France. He was arrested at the airport. So like they were going to get in there anyways. But yeah, the joke is like he just fell in love with his like model who was like, babe, let's go to France and then he gets arrested in France. And there's also conspiracies wrapped in the conspiracy.
Like maybe he intended to get arrested for some reason. Like we have not heard of those. You've not heard that. Okay, like he got a good deeper David. There's always a level deeper. So we don't know yet. Well, we do know back to the the time community and the time chain. Unfortunately, the ton network stopped producing blocks a couple of times. Probably probably down. Completely unrelated. I'm pretty sure this is completely unrelated. Yeah, this was result. Well, maybe it was related in a way. This was the result of network overload caused by high number of dog transactions. Maybe the dog transactions were related to the new like dog insignia.
Yeah, so instant. An important launch on Tom Cobb dogs as a result of the founder getting arrested. The ton of validators took the chain down causing them to to loot consensus took the chain down. So I guess it is related. It is not coming from like this is not a state sponsor. Yeah, yeah, yeah, this is just how do we even know that brand new brand new block chain with, you know, like not perfect consensus. Are you sure about that? I haven't had much Lindy. We could go deeper in the conspiracy because I'm the conspiracy one. I lead us. I lead us down the holes. You don't lead me down the conspiracy holes.
I lead you down the conspiracy holes. Macron, like decided to launch this meme coin at just this time to take time to time network, stop producing blocks. I, one learning lesson from this is like, hey, layer ones are hard. Keeping them up is very difficult, right? I mean, so, you know, like, time is you don't have a spec or a single or a single client block. Hey, now's not the time, David. Let's say that for another week. Let's let's talk about the time. The importance of multi client blockchains is always the time to talk about multi client designs. Well, it's all the more they don't talk about that.
Ton price is down as well on the week as you'd expect. I mean, like not a massive cut. I mean, we're back to 25 percent. Yeah, okay. I mean, that's just like one bad day. It's one bad day. I've seen it. I've seen where it's one bad day. We're back to April. That's where we're back to from a price perspective. I think something that's related to this is the question of like who's next. So I tweeted this out when it was on my mind. Resting Pavel is just a step or two removed from arresting Elon Musk or Mark Zuckerberg or Sam Altman or Tyler Buterin. I said a step or two removed before you think I'm going to hyperbole because there are still some steps that need to be completed there.
But I were getting closer. We're getting into that vicinity and so you can you can Elon on X is like bulletinly pro like pro right pro maga pro Trump anti comola anti Democrats. And then like something like this happens and I'm like, oh, I that makes sense. Well, look at the look at the charges, right? So like you could say I'm sure there's somebody in some dark corner of Twitter is probably wouldn't take long to find that is doing like quote unquote a legal stuff, right? Maybe sharing like images they shouldn't maybe doing like drug deals. I'm sure there are foreign on Twitter, right? Okay, but like there could be stuff that Elon's not monitoring, right?
And if it just takes this, I mean, you have a apology made this point. He's like a manual Macron has a, you know, like population of France of what, I don't know, population of France, we could look this up. I'm going to say 70 million people, something like this. Does he know what's going on in the dark corners of like Paris streets? Is he monitoring that? Or is there a legal activity going on? You know, it's kind of like a network state thing of, is it unreasonable to expect the monitoring, the continuous monitoring of every single chat, every single tweet that's going on inside the platform?
I think that's a, that's a question for like that all open societies need to go, like think about and consider. Anyway, related, but unrelated to this, maybe Mark Zuckerberg sent a zinger to the Biden-Harris administration. My God, this was so good. Okay, so did you read this letter? This is Jim Jordan, the chairman. Yeah, why don't you summarize this for us? This is from Mark Zuckerberg. Yeah, so he was talking, he was reflecting on some decisions that he made in 2020 and 2021 about Facebook and the pandemic and COVID, like well into the pandemic after it had sort of become very politicized.
He said in 2021 senior officials from the Biden administration, including the White House, repeatedly pressured our teams for months to censor certain COVID-19 content, including humor and satire, and expressed a lot of frustration with our teams when we didn't agree. Ultimately, it was our decision whether or not to take content down and we own our decisions, including COVID-19 related changes. We made to our enforcement in the wake of the pressure. I believe the government pressure was wrong and I regret that we were not more outspoken about it. Wow. I also think that we made some choices that with the benefit of hindsight and new information, we wouldn't make today.
Like I said to our teams at the time, I strongly feel that we should not compromise our content standards due to pressure from any administration in either direction. We are ready to push back if something like this ever happens again. Wow. And then he also cited in a separate situation, the FBI warned us about a potential Russian disinformation operation about the Biden family and the lead up to the 2020 elections. That fall when we saw a New York Post story reporting on corruption allegations involving then Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden's family, we sent that story to fact-checkters for review and temporarily demoted it while waiting for a reply.
It has since been made clear that the reporting was not Russian disinformation. And in retrospect, we should not have demoted the story. We've changed our policies and processes to make sure that this doesn't happen again. For instance, we are no longer temporarily demoting things in the United States while we wait for fact-checkers. Wow. I mean, this is hard, right? That's basically like that word that you used earlier, like misinformation, right? That's another, like, state-speak type word, which is like, if they don't like something, it could be misinformation, basically. And so when you start having the nation-state and White House officials telling social media companies what should be censored or like demoted and what shouldn't be, I mean, that's it.
Yikes, bro. Yikes, bro. And it's one thing for the United States to have that happen inside of the United States because I believe in our court system, eventually, to slowly come to like agreement with truth and the constitution. But I have no such assertances for like France. I don't have any assurances that France will do that. He's also, this is also a shot across the ballot, I think, for Mark Zuckerberg, where he's, basically, he's, I think this is I'm done with. Yeah, I'm done with you guys. I'm done with a Democratic party. Maybe. This is what you could interpret this to believe. Like, I'm not willing to play ball anymore.
So like, come at me, bro. Maybe he's saying that as well as part of us. Now he wears a chain and has like sick chugets who say, it's like, you believe it. So you want to believe it. Look, this is the fight that's going on. It's the big one. It's an important one in the digital right sphere. We've got our own Pavel that's happening right now in the United States. This is a court case. We've talked about on Bankless for a while. And I just wanted to bring both Dave and I wanted to bring your attention to it. This is Roman Storm. So you recall, tornado cash developer was arrested out of his home last year by the FBI for deploying open source privacy code tornado cash.
Lots of people in the crypto ecosystem used to protect their cryptocurrency transactions and to make them private. Of course, some bad actors also use this tool as with any tool. It could be used by the good guys and it could be used by the bad guys. This is fundamental to encryption. If encryption is an open source technology that's available to everyone, good people will use it and to protect themselves. And also bad people will use it. That seems obvious. Anyway, you've heard us mention his court case. That's coming up. It's on December, I put the tweet wrong. December the second and Roman real soon.
That's real soon. And unfortunately, I just learned this this week because I knew there's ongoing fundraising for Roman Storm's case. He's basically, it's out of money. He's $2 million short. It costs a lot of money. There's a full budget attached to this. It costs a lot of money to get the S tier legal team to protect him. Okay, like we're talking millions of dollars and he's $2 million short. He's raised like 500k. He still needs $2 million in order to get the S tier legal team on this. This court case, the US versus Storm, will be a defining historic court case for digital property rights in the United States.
It's like going to determine, David, if we have the right to private cash in any form, it's going to determine like even if... It's going to determine whether or not smart contracts can be made illegal by our government. Yes. This is the court case that says that tornado cash is allowed or not allowed. Is the notion of a smart contract able to be made illegal? This is that court case. It just so happens there's this one guy that is either going to go to jail or not based on the outcome of this. But the precedent is perhaps the most critical crucial precedent that this industry has ever had. Fuck Gary Gensler, fuck the SEC's insecurities, we'll find a boss.
This is the final boss. But this is the final boss. There's... This is probably the most high leverage court case that is going to exist has ever existed as it relates to the crypto case. Yeah. And if we don't find it as a community, like hugely disappointed, right? So we're just going to bend over backwards and be like, okay, we'll just have the illegal smart contracts. Well, but do you know what he gets? You know what he gets? If we don't fund this fully is a private attorney, defense attorney. It just randomly signed by like whoever is available, right? Instead of the S tier, like we need to have the...
Yes. We need to have the A team on this in order to actually have a shot at winning this case. Anyway, we'll include a donate link in the show notes. David and I, Bankless has donated to this in the past. We're prepared to in the center. We're going to up it. We're going to up it. Yep. And we'll have more information about this and the weeks to come because like we can't leave this deficit out there. This is the most important thing. This is... It's... I don't want the legal smart contracts. That is antithetical to why I am here. And I know we have like... We have the biggest super PAC ever apparently, like $130 million in the fair shake or however large that is.
Let's get $2 million into Roman storm's defense so that we can have permanently legal smart contracts. That's how I see this. I agree. All right. We have more to talk about, David. What's next? Sony introduced a brand new Ethereum layer 2 called Sonyum. Yes, that's Sony. Perhaps the maker of the TV that you might have in your living room. That's Sony. Yeah, yeah, walk me out, yeah. Trump launched another NFT collection. So we're going to go listen to that and Gary Gensler does his job and takes down another scammer in crypto. Yes, wait. No, just kidding. It's a very legitimate, compliant United States space company that employs hundreds of United States-based employees.
And they just got issued a well-known as Gary. Last time to place your bets about what that company is. Try to imagine it. Think who it is. We'll see if you get it right. But we're going to go ahead and talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. And then we'll be right back. New projects are coming online to the mantle layer two every single week. Why is this happening? Maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer two design architecture since it first started building mantle DA powered by technology from eigenDA. Maybe it's because users are coming onto the mantle layer two to capture some of the highest yields available in DeFi and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the $3 billion mantle treasury in the mantle reward station.
Maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with giving you grants, liquidity support, and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application. Maybe it's all of these reasons all put together. So if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's DeFi apps, click the link in the shown up. So getting started with mantle. Arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications. Arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions.
Arbitrum has the leading DeFi ecosystem strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs, and is quickly becoming the Web3 gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.arbitrum.io. Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitrum orbit chain? Arbitrum orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput. Whether you're a developer, an enterprise or a user, Arbitrum orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum.
Experience Web3 development the way it was always meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Visit Arbitrum.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities. Launching a token? Don't let complex legal and tax issues slow you down. Toku provides specialized support to optimize your launch and ensure that you as a founder and your team and your investors get the most tax-efficient outcomes. The Toku team understands the crypto space inside and out and will ensure your token launch is fully compliant while maximizing tax efficiency. Toku can connect you with the best attorneys if you need them to make sure that you have the best advice and Toku can help to optimize your taxes so you pay the least possible amount of taxes while still maintaining legal compliance.
With Toku's guidance, you can concentrate on building your company while Toku handles the logistics. Token launches don't have to be complicated. Talk to Toku today to get a free initial token valuation. Some backlash to the Ethereum Foundation this week after somebody identified on-chain a hundred million dollars coming from an EF wallet to Kraken, or a lovely exchange, and sponsor. People were like, is the EF about to dump a hundred million eth on us? Like, is that about to happen? Like, what's going on? Where are they getting the money? What's it going to all of these things? So, what's the story?
Where are the concerns here? So this first office is a semi-regular activity. The Ethereum Foundation has ether all the way back from Genesis. They fund things, and they semi-regularly send ether to Kraken, and then they sell ether. Not all at once. They sell it on an as-needed basis so they can distribute funds to a bunch of different things that they have committed to funding. And we're going to go through what those things are in a second. But this happens every now and then. But sometimes they batch send it all, right? It doesn't mean necessarily. Yes. According to what they said. Like, the hundred million is being marked as a watch.
The last time they sent 35,000 ether to Kraken was, however, long ago. And then they have been trickling selling that until now. And then like, oh, we ran out of ether. We need to pay more people. So let's send another 35,000 ether. And then we'll slowly sell that. This is just what foundations do. This is why we have foundations. They pay for support. And I think it has always been since my time in crypto. Like a cry of the Ethereum community. Not that this is happening. I think we're all in support of some of the things that they're funding. It's the lack of transparency of like when or how and where this is going.
It just happens randomly. And then all of a sudden, everyone wakes up and like, oh, we're 35,000 ether. It's got sent to a point. It's like a little bit of a sticker shock phenomenon. I'm like, yeah, whoa. It's that. And there's also cry for transparency. It's just like, uh, where's all this money going to? Yep. Yep. Yep. So I, my Gucci, who's the director at the Ethereum foundation, she tweeted out, this is part of our treasury management activities. The EF has a budget of a hundred million dollars a year, largely made up of grants, salaries, and many of those recipients are only able to accept fiat.
This year, this lately this year, we were advised to not do any treasury activities due to regulatory complications. And so we were not able to share the plan in advance. Also, this transaction is not equal to a sale. They're always a planned and gradual sales from here on out, like I said. So here's Eric Conner, who's been one of the ones who's always asked for eth transparency. He says the lack of transparency from the Ethereum foundation ten years in is both shocking and extremely frustrating. It's really not a lie to ask for simple financial reports or clarity around fund movements and usage.
Anthony Sazano says, I understand that people want more transparency around where the money goes, but it is not just being spent on bullshit. It is being used to further stoward the development of the Ethereum ecosystem and fund many critical projects that otherwise would not get any funding. Let's keep on pushing for more transparency from the Ethereum foundation, but let's also do it in a constructive way that benefits the ecosystem. Trashing the EF for spending $100 million a year, which is absolutely relatively tiny to the Ethereum's $320 billion market cap is not constructive. Okay, so Josh Stark, who is a member at the EF, actually put out a fantastic thread about some of the fundings that the Ethereum foundation does.
And so he says in 2023, out of the total cost of 2023, layer one research and development was 25% of the total cost. This includes grants to external client teams, which is 62% of that 25% and internal Ethereum foundation researchers, salaries, that's 38% of that 25%. This is teams working on cryptography and zero knowledge proofs, execution layer and developer tooling like Gath, privacy and scaling, explorations, solidity, and more. And there's also a new institution section, which is 3537% of that total amount. This is including the Nanomic Foundation, the decentralized research center, the decentralization research center, layer two beats, who we all love, a zero x park who's doing, in my opinion, some of the sickest work in cryptography and smart contracts that we have, shout out to the episode that we did on autonomous worlds, not too long ago, and there's some other things as well.
Layer two research and development applied zero knowledge cryptography, community development, developer platform, internal operations. And so that's all of it. There is a link in the show notes if you would like to get some of this report. And then he said that also there's going to be another report that comes out for the end of November to update all of this. I thought this was a solid answer to kind of more transparency, like here it is. And I think this brought a lot of the concerns that folks had. I think as zooming out to be clear, a lot of the concerns that folks had was like, somebody selling $100 million.
I think so. But like also transparency is valid, but now transparency is so caught the dogs a little bit. This is a wider scope take on the Ethereum foundation. So the EF holds 845 million in ETH, which sounds like a lot, but realize that represents only 0.25%. So 1% of the total ETH supply. Now I see that amount. I'm like, kind of worried about the sustainability. If they're spending 100 million a year, I'm really worried on the other side of this left. This is just a tiny sliver of ETH supply as compared to like other foundations and other ecosystems. We're not comparing all the details of the Solana foundation, the Tezos foundation, the New Year foundation, all these things, which have a much chunkier percentage of supply.
I don't know. My take is the could improve some transparency, but like does a pretty reasonable job in this whole ecosystem. They funded things like Uniswap, David, in the very early days from grants, which wouldn't have been possible. With a $10,000 grant. Anyway, so that's part of the market. People are a little bit mad. That's not the only thing that people got mad about this week. There is also a talk of Vitalik, not liking DeFi, kind of a chance of Vitalik hates DeFi. Where did this come from? I was having trouble actually finding the source of why this became a, like what was patient zero or tweet zero over this.
I think maybe it was Kane Warwick mentioning on steady lads, which is a podcast from Georgia Alexander and company that says that Vitalik discourages and doesn't like DeFi, and that doesn't really support it. Doesn't support DeFi. Then Kane's position, because DeFi is such a critical component of blockchains, which I agree with, the number one thing to come out of a blockchain is primarily DeFi. Also, DeFi is the most and so his position is that if you don't support DeFi, then you're actually against DeFi. Vitalik has in the past been critical of, the way I read these tweets or statements, is that in his personal opinion, he is personally critical of some of these structures of DeFi that we have seen.
Very similar to like his, but do we deserve it tweet about ICOs in 2017 when she was like, what the hell is going on on Ethereum? This ICOs aren't doing anything, and he's like similar, similarly saying that the loans from Maker Ave synthetics aren't like real loans. They're capitalized collateral based loans to help people speculate and gamble. These are not helping low-income developing countries gain access to capital. Therefore, it's only part of this circular economy. He's not interested in it. He's the way I've always, I've always, overbore a strict people. I also have an Auroborist ring that I like, because I love the concept of Auroborist.
He's thinking of sale, yeah. Whenever Vitalik I said this, I've always read this as his personal interests. Many people were ascribing this as the stance of the EF as a whole, and maybe there's no way to parse Vitalik away from the EF. Maybe that's fair. But that's been the stance here. Yeah, I think in particular that term Auroborist was triggering to people, because they're like, yeah, that's crypto. That's money. The entire purpose, that's how we bootstrap things. This was Keynes original tweet that we were referencing. He said, if the only thing propping up your chain for the last five years is DeFi, and the best you can musters be grudgingly tolerating it, you are anti-deFi.
So he wants just more than like, yeah, DeFi is good, and I prefer better use cases. He wants, I think, Vitalik in the EF, like his expectations to have them be overwhelmingly positive towards DeFi, and just being like, it's the greatest thing ever, which like, I don't know. I don't think that's entirely unfair, but there's also like, I mean for us for bankless, the reason we actually started this podcast and this entire movement was because to put the focus on DeFi, we think that is the killer. Going bankless is the killer use case of crypto, but it's not the only use case, and I get, that's fair game, I think, to be Vitalik to have Vitalik be interested in other things.
Anyway, here's another take on the Auroborist thing. This is a retchip. My opinion, you could just as easily say, eth is downstream of DeFi. It accounts for the majority of usage and gas fees on the chain, usage at the primary value driver of Ether. Ether is used heavily in DeFi as collateral. There's also a major value driver for ETH. This is sort of what Justin Drake has said in the past, which is like, ETH is pristine collateral. It's where the whole ultrasound money meme came. I feel like for someone like Drake, who also works at the EF, he is probably more bullish than Vitalik on some of the eth is money and eth is DeFi use cases, though I don't want to put words in his mouth.
Anyway, this ret is making the point that if you remove DeFi from ETH, its value would be 80% less. I also think that's true. Hayden's take is, Vitalik is driven by his interest in values. Personally, I think DeFi is the most important and impactful area of crypto by far. I am not in the least bit upset that he wants to see use cases beyond DeFi, where he asks where the yields come from. It's not his job to pump your backs. DC investor, he also said, Vitalik and many core devs will literally never talk about ETH as a sort of value or as a meaningful programmable money. This has been true since inception.
I think it's tied to public comments on DeFi, yet it is super obvious that ETH must be a desirable sort of value in order for Ethereum to operate securely and proof of stake to which Vitalik responded. If I did not believe in ETH as a sort of value, I would not hold 90% of my net worth in it, which makes I think both you and me, Ryan, more bullish on ETH, as a portion of our bags than Vitalik. That statement from Vitalik makes me also very happy, because I think DC investors had a long history as long as you and I have in Ethereum and crypto. He's kind of right. The ETH is money camp, right? I remember, David, it was like four years ago, when ETH, 2019 maybe, 2020-2019, when Ethereum was still kind of finding itself, and everyone was saying ETH there had no value, it was just a stupid gas token, it was worthless, and there was this growing chance in the Ethereum community.
No, ETH is a monetary unit. ETH is money, right? I remember you at a conference in Israel, I don't even remember what the conference was, but you were actually- It was an ethereal from consensus, yeah. You actually, this is recorded somewhere in the internet archives, probably. You asked Vitalik, you were like, hey, is ETH money? And his answer, this is the kind of the first indication, right? His answer was, if the Ethereum community wants it to be money, then it is money, right? And then I heard that, I was like, great, therefore it is. So that's been like a history of what he said about this.
I don't think he started a Ethereum to create ETH as a monetary asset, but I think he also recognizes its role. So this is why I was so pleased to hear this, why I retweeted it is, this is the clearest I've ever heard him say, ETH is a store of value asset. And by the way, his bags back his belief here, which is 90% of his net worth is in ETH right now. I like this tweet. Yeah. Also, I think the broader conversation here is what is the role of the foundation and Vitalik and their relationship with the application layer? Because to me, Ethereum has always been trying to build in this kind of like intellectually pure true north direction, regardless of what happens on the application layer.
So like people like Cain and maybe like greater Ethereum are asking for a little bit more of like BD and growth out of the things built on the app layer, things like Ave, things like synthetic support. It's all general. It's more just support whatever with that unspecified word. I don't really think there's any specifics offered of like what they're really looking for here. Maybe just better public statements about DeFi, but it's always been Vitalik in the EF's stance to be neutral about what happens on the app layer and not bias any one application over another or any sector over another. And that has always been how I've thought that they would like take a stance towards the app layer.
And I think people these A's are kind of just like we know DeFi is useful. Like we know this is going to this is benefiting your chain. Like why wouldn't you support this? And like I think Solana actually does this well. When we had Kyle on this is what he talked about is just like Mark seller from Ave said that like the EF has never really talked to anyone from Ave. Like what's up with that? And I think the Solana like growth, marketing, DD like go go go mentality would be one that we're like yeah let's let's talk to people, let's talk to the builders and let's help them build what they want.
And I think that's valuable because because that's not what Ethereum is doing, but I prefer what Ethereum is doing, which is building the most credibly neutral open centers of resistance protocol possible because that's how you get as massive massive scalability and social support as possible. Like what if we like what if we started benefiting app layer behavior at the wrong time? Like what if we started incentivizing like the ICO mania when that was happening? Like that would be wrong. And so I've always believed in the stance that the Ethereum protocol should be as credibly neutral as possible.
And it's also not like like all of these like projects, synthetics, maker, Dow, Ave have like insanely valuable market caps with VC investors. Like they have support. They have support. I mean like my take on this is Ethereum's awesome fatalex done a fantastic job. The EF has done a great job as well. Everyone is saying these things because we're kind of in a mood. You know, if you know what I'm kind of like ETH price is low specifically on the ratios and there's kind of a vibe session going on. And so we're all kind of like at each other, particularly on social media. So some of this to me is noise.
By the way, a bank list faced some of this this week as well for that cosmony episode that you mentioned. But you're like I guess spread some of the angst around the EF and fatale. David. This is so this is so funny. We were talking about the hate of the of the community on like fatalex and the EF. And yeah, I think you put out a tweet that was like usually it's directed at bank list. Yeah. And then three days later, we released the class and then it's like it was directed as bank list. All right. We got some more stuff to talk about. This is cool. Sony has a layer two now. Sony is deploying layer two and it's gone to test net.
So when PS5 on Ethereum, David, that was going on. What is this? Okay. Sony, Sony, a public layer two that aims to connect Web 3 with everyday internet services. And so this is back by Sony, the Sony block solutions lab. That's the company. Along with this like merger aqua higher of this Astar network, which is built with a polygon CDK on polka dot. I don't know where that came from. But apparently like this Astar network is going to roll into Sony M and the which is going to be built on the OP stack and eventually will join the super chain. And phase two or phase there's two phases here. Phase one on board crypto people, normal layer two stuff.
But then phase two is on board Sony products such as Sony bank, Sony music, Sony pictures, and so on. Quote, we would like to integrate Web 3 and blockchain technology into Sony's product. And in three years, we would like to on on board not only Sony, but also all enterprises and general apps on top of it. Interesting. I don't think this is just another layer two. Just trying to split the current user base into another chain. But I think they have. It's not like an IP change plans. It sounds like an enterprise IP chain almost. You know, we were talking about this the second two weeks. Did you see, did you see that right after a story released a store, an IP restaking protocol on story got announced?
No. So you can restake your IP. That's actually. I can't wait. That's not podcast. Okay. Sky. This is the MakerDow rebrand. So this has always been a part of the MakerDow end game. The rebrand is finally here. The rebrand is called sky at sky ecosystem on Twitter. Sky, the best and easiest place to get rewarded for savings without giving up control. And so die and mkr is now turning into USDS in sky. So sky is now USDS. This is happening on September 18th. It's voluntary. So both maker and dying is current form. We'll remain in existence as legacy tokens. This is where the stock split of mkr is getting one mkr is getting split into 24,000 sky tokens.
So mkr is going to go from like $2,000 to like $20, 10 cents or something if I did my math right. I probably didn't. And then MakerDow subdows like this spark protocol will become sky stars. So independent decentralized projects will connect to the sky ecosystem. Each sky sky star subdow will have its own governance token manages treasury governance community. One of them is spark. Like I said, I'm going to miss maker. I'm a miss maker. I got my spark start start and defy back when it was called actually not die. It was sigh. Single collateral die. Single collateral die. Now die is going now.
Maker is going. I guess, you know, this guy's cool, but almost maker. But, you know, what's wrong with maker and die, bro? I thought that brand was fine. Their Twitter account got like taken over, right? The maker Twitter account. Yeah, yeah. And some so they they changed it up. If you if you were once following MakerDow on Twitter, you are now following sky ecosystem. They just they just swapped their handle. But then some guy just picked up the empty MakerDow handle. So somebody guy is just his name is not makerDow and it's at makerDow on Twitter. There is one important difference that I would like to highlight.
Die does not have a freeze function, which has been one of the best properties about the makerDow system that I've enjoyed in its battles. It's the most bankless stable coin that exists because there's no freeze function as USDS has a freeze. Does it really? Which is yes. Yes. All right. Well, it's why I don't enjoy it. I will, you know, speaking of disappointment, David, politics. Trump and Harris have agreed to debate on ABC news. So they got the date. It's a September 10th. That's going to happen. My question to you is, what do you think the probability that crypto comes up? Either in the form of a question or Trump somehow injects it.
It is like zero. Zero percent. I ask this on Twitter less than five percent. That's the Sun Twitter. Same question on Twitter. Again, my followers crypto natus. My followers say 46% yes versus 50% 50% 50. Yeah. Yeah. I voted no on that poll. I'm voting yes on this poll. I think it's going to I think you didn't already do this. Yeah. The Biden debate and I lost that one. Remember? Yeah. But so did you did Biden also lost that in a big way. And so I'm hoping to be right on this. If there's a polymarket spun up, David, maybe I'll bet against you. Also in political news, RFK Jr. You guys know this.
It was national media news here. He suspended his presidential campaign endorsed Trump. Of course, RFK Jr. We had him on bank list, very pro crypto candidate, maybe even more pro crypto than Trump. I think who's more. Yeah. He was more pro crypto first. Yeah. I think it came from a place of deeper place in his heart. Yeah. Deeper place in his heart. That makes sense. So I was kind of wondering. I mean, this is sort of in exchange for becoming probably like a cabinet member in Trump's administration where he to get elected. Like what cabinet would he be a crypto czar? Would he be pro crypto? I think he's really gunning for health and human services.
Yeah. Something that helps. Yeah. But it would still be a good thing obviously to have another pro crypto member of the executive branch if Trump gains power. And speaking of Trump, David, you want to make us watch this? Should we watch this? I don't know how long how much of it I can watch, but let's play a little bit of it. Is your favorite president, Donald J. Trump with some very exciting news? By popular demand, I'm doing a new series of Trump digital trading cars. You all know what they are. We've had a lot of fun with them. It's called the America first collection. 50 all new stunning digital trading cards.
It's really something. These cards show me dancing and even me holding some bitcoins. Here's the best part. I'm doing great things for my Trump digital card collectors. First, there's the real physical Trump cards. Purchase 15 or more of my Trump digital trading cards and will mail you a beautiful physical trading card. It's really I think quite something. Each physical trading card has an authentic piece of my suit that I wore for the presidential debate. And people are calling it the knockout suit. I don't know about that, but that's what they're calling it. All right. So David, people calling it the knockout suit.
This is Trump's latest release of the Trump NFTs. That's what's happening. So that was that was real. That was not AI generated as Trump talking about his fourth NFT collection here. Everyone rush to go get them. Do you know how much they cost? He says 99 dollars. But if you spend, he's adding some utility to his movies. For one card. Yes. But let me tell you, if you spend $25,000 in the cards, you get utility. You get Trump utility. You get access to Trump sneakers, Trump cocktail dinner, Trump national golf course in Jupiter, Florida with Trump. It's kind of the Gary V. Play. You know, like I got these NFTs.
And if you buy certain NFTs of a certain amount, then like you can meet me in person and we'll do things together. It's utility, utility to that FTs. Okay. Right. We are getting towards the end of this episode. Every listener who has placed their bets about which the United States company, not everyone. Okay. Not everyone. Like what? 20, 30, 40,000 people listen to these things. Not everyone is on Twitter. At least have them tell us. Maybe less than half of what's Gary doing. Okay. Sorry. Okay. So which which United States domiciled crypto company that's extremely compliant and legitimate has received a Wells notice from the SEC.
You have your last five seconds to think about this. It is Open C. Okay. So Devon Fincer, the CEO of Open C has tweeted out Open C has received a Wells notice from the SEC threatening to Sue us because they believe NFTs are on our platform are securities. Yeah. We are shocked. The SEC would make such a sweeping move against creators and artists, but we're ready to stand up and fight. Cryptocurrencies have long been in the crosshairs of the SECs and companies like Coinbase, Uniswap, Robinhood, App Crackin and Consensus. Wow. That list keeps on growing longer. Has been fighting against the SEC's single track approach of regulation by enforcement.
So well done. Open C. Congratulations on joining the ranks of some of the best and most legitimate companies, United States companies and crypto. Honestly, you guys deserve to be there for some reason. You done well. You're really making an impact and you could tell because you got a nasty gram about Gary Gensner trying to see you. Let's remember what NFTs are. Art, collectibles, video games, Trump cards, domain names, event tickets, all of these are NFTs. Dude, Trump is selling illegal securities. Well, why the way? Do you think there's something to that? Is that why the executive branch and Gary Gensner prosecuting it?
There's another conspiracy for you if you want to go down. It's certainly interesting timing and a terrible look for the Democrats. Not that they needed any more terrible looks. Look at this. DC investor goes, oh, shit, they're selling illegal securities on eBay and he's tweeting a picture of eBay of a magic, the gathering card on eBay. You want to go on this? Two million dollar magic, the gathering card. Yeah, that's more than crypto punks right now. That's a nice card right there. Don't remind me, bro. You remember when Richie Torres asked Gary Gensner whether he's like, what happens if I take a Pokemon card?
Is that a security? And then he's like, what if I tokenize that Pokemon card? He has Gary Gensner this. Is that a security? And Gary was like, oh, facts and circumstances. We don't know how we test blah, blah, blah. I guess he does think that Pokemon cards when tokenized suddenly become securities. This is what this means. Jake Jurinsky, the SEC is fully lost the plot. The idea that a financial markets regulator established in the 1930s would have jurisdiction over digital art defies common sense. And also the SEC's actual authority to do this. Hayden Adams saying what you said, David, which is like, hey, OpenC, welcome the fight.
You're one of us now. Devon Fisner is planning to fight this, which is fantastic. So more legal bills that we as taxpayers are paying for Gary's, you know, senseless crusades to stop you from buying digital art on the internet. That's where we are in 2024. All right. One bankless ventures raise on the week chain bound, raised $4.6 million in a seed round with participation from us over at bankless ventures. What is chain bounds? They're working on software to issue pre-confirmations from staking pools. This is a staking pool like Lido, Rockpool, anything else led by cyberfund, who is the kind of the Lido adjacent venture capital firm.
The idea of this is like you can issue pre-confirmations for layer two to have faster settlement times to the layer one. Also very beneficial for base rollups. The big vision here is to allow proposals to do sequencing. So it's a pretty interesting infrastructure that kind of ties layer one and layer two's together much more intimately, I would say. So congratulations to chain bound for the race. And unfortunately, as we end this episode, David, I got some bad news for you, man. As a single dude in crypto, some, look at this, look at this possibly be some bad data just came out. This is Nick Carter tweeting out a chart of a data around the unattractiveness of male nerd hobbies.
So it's basically plotting which male nerd hobbies are the least attractive to women. We've got a lot on here. We've got video games. We've got comic books. We've got cosplay. We've got magic to gathering. We've got dungeons and dragons. Unfortunately, crypto ranks as the second most unattractive male nerd hobby out there. And it only loses to one, which is Funko. What is Funko? Funko pops. The little Funko pop collectibles things. Dude, I don't even know what that is. Second place. Very unattractive. Well, apparently. You said this is bad news for me, but actually this is just not related to me because this is for nerd hobbies.
Crypto is a lifestyle. And so it's just not relevant. It's not a hobby. Yes, not a hobby. It's more than a hobby. Crypto's life. Yeah, so there you go. I can't believe, though, that it's worse than cosplay, that that hurts. But boys just aren't allowed to have fun. You know, your hobbies are unattractive. I guess you got a date in crypto if you want to get something to happen. David, we got a moment of zen. This is a song a day guy. Yeah, a song a day man. You have some context here because you did an episode while I was out with him. He is a lawsuit against the SEC right now, too, right? What's lost to you?
Highly related to the SEC's Wellesnose versus OpenSea. They are pursuing the SEC for setting the precedent that NFTs are securities, basically. Song a day man releases an NFT every single day of his songs that you could buy it. And because of the Stoner Katz legal case where Mila Kunis and Async Kutcher released their Stoner Katz thing, they had to settle with the SEC. That precedent determines that artistic, you know, creations form in the form of NFT are there for securities. So he's suing Gary Gensler, and he's suing the SEC to break down that precedent. And so of course, since the SEC is now going after the NFT marketplace OpenSea, he makes a song about it.
And you can go buy that illegal security that he may or may not be issuing with the link in the show notes if you are so interested. So Gary Gensler, this is who you're up against a moment is that in just a minute, but when you serve a well notice, this is who you're serving. Gryffto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's certainly not for Gary Gensler, but we're glad you're with us on the bank list, thanks a lot.