1st Week of November, 2021
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ 📣 DHARMA | Trade on Polygon! https://bankless.cc/dharma ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
💰 GEMINI | FIAT & CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
💧LIDO | DECENTRALIZED STAKING https://bankless.cc/Lido
👻 AAVE | LEND & BORROW ASSETS https://bankless.cc/aave
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING https://bankless.cc/UniGrants
------
Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro Permissionless: https://blockworks.co/events/permissionless/ Bankless Discount: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/discount-to-permissionless-2022
7:00 MARKETS 7:22 BTC Price 7:41 ETH Price 9:14 ETH / BTC Ratio 10:10 DeFi Action $BED: https://www.indexcoop.com/bed 13:19 Layer 2 https://l2beat.com/ 15:05 Ultra Sound Money https://ultrasound.money/ Fees: https://twitter.com/evan_van_ness/status/1453939554172301314?s=21 20:40 Market Cap https://assetdash.com/
24:00 RELEASES 25:10 ENS https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/the-ultimate-guide-to-airdrops 32:10 Maker x stETH https://twitter.com/nomos_paradox/status/1453793036865982464?s=21 35:30 Crypto.com leveling up https://twitter.com/froggyfrogster/status/1454181118807351310?s=21 40:05 Phonon by Gridplus https://twitter.com/PhononDAO/status/1453822451436113924?t=CtbsGJIyI3ejIIirzm9UdA&s=19 41:47 DAO Masters https://www.daomasters.xyz/ 42:55 Ronin DEX https://twitter.com/AxieInfinity/status/1456161289722548225 43:46 Optimism Upgrade https://twitter.com/optimismPBC/status/1455645114269724675 45:28 ‘Standard Oil’ of Crypto https://www.wsj.com/articles/digital-currency-group-wants-to-be-cryptos-standard-oil-11635764400 47:51 Metaverse Fund https://www.theblockcrypto.com/linked/122856/firm-backed-by-alan-howard-winklevoss-twins-closes-100-million-metaverse-fund 51:22 Sandbox Raise https://www.theblockcrypto.com/linked/122936/crypto-sandbox-93-million-softbank 52:58 Jobs https://pallet.xyz/list/bankless/jobs
54:00 NEWS 54:48 Facebook Meta https://about.fb.com/news/2021/10/facebook-company-is-now-meta/ 1:02:15 Nike https://twitter.com/joshgerben/status/1455225423411953671?s=21 1:04:22 Microsoft https://blockworks.co/microsoft-ceo-the-metaverse-will-bring-real-world-into-any-digital-space/?oly_enc_id=9918E2523689A0T 1:04:55 Reddit https://twitter.com/iamRahul20x/status/1455950490366263301 1:09:32 Quentin Tarantino https://www.cnbc.com/2021/11/02/quentin-tarantino-to-offer-seven-uncut-scenes-from-pulp-fiction-as-nfts.html 1:10:26 NFT McRib https://twitter.com/chriskatje/status/1455154519491416064?s=20 1:11:32 Matrix NFTs https://twitter.com/jordanlyall/status/1455544585732640775?s=21 1:13:18 China Yes NFTs, No Crypto https://blockworks.co/chinas-tech-giants-yes-on-nfts-no-on-cryptocurrencies/?oly_enc_id=9918E2523689A0T 1:14:31 CryptoPunk Flash Loan $500M https://twitter.com/scott_lew_is/status/1454952085611589634 1:17:23 Aaron Rodgers https://www.coindesk.com/business/2021/11/01/nfl-star-aaron-rodgers-gives-ringing-endorsement-of-bitcoin/ 1:18:14 Coinbase Borrow https://twitter.com/coinbase/status/1455664736687722500 1:19:06 Stablecoin Report https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2021/11/01/biden-administration-to-congress-put-stablecoins-under-federal-supervision-or-we-will/ 1:21:33 China Digital Currency https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1456257274087763979?s=20
1:23:00 TAKES 1:24:30 NFT Breakfast https://twitter.com/zeneca_33/status/1454599139803779076?s=21 1:25:58 L1 Traffic https://twitter.com/ercwl/status/1454331785668608002?s=20 1:28:52 Play the Metaverse https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1455160580843712519?s=20 1:31:13 A Wallet is a Profile https://twitter.com/ohhshiny/status/1455270402788405254?s=21 1:32:14 Wikipedia https://twitter.com/trustlessstate/status/1455548002114879493?s=21 1:33:31 Never Seen a Bear https://twitter.com/ryansadams/status/1456001806992031755?s=21 1:37:46 Robots Use Ethereum https://twitter.com/ameensol/status/1456115235769647110?s=20 1:40:54 Gender Equality https://twitter.com/mdudas/status/1456285472326623242?s=20
1:41:31 What David’s Excited About 1:43:14 What Ryan’s Excited About
1:47:59 MEME of the Week https://twitter.com/niftynaut/status/1454142514487861251?s=20
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
hey bankless nation happy first week of november david what time is it oh it's a friday weekly roll-up time because like always it's always a crazy week in crypto and so we are going to roll that week up in the friday bankless weekly roll-up david you're on the road right now you're in new york city nft nyc that's a nft conference how's that going man what's the vibe been like uh i actually don't know because i never went to a single nft conference event i've only been going to the peripheral satellite events and those have been absolutely fantastic uh we'll talk a lot about a lot more at the end but uh yeah i listened to the famous wu-tang album that got bought by pleaser dow oh my god man how was it at this uh i mean i wasn't i'm not really the biggest wu-tang fan okay uh the first song pretty good next two songs whatever did people like it the wu-tang people really liked it and then there's like the fourth song that had this great like trumpet riff and the whole entire room was just like five into that song is this by the way is this playing off the same like this is a cd right it's compact yes it's a cd yeah okay it's like what happens if that thing gets scratched okay so it is scratched because martin freaking screlly used it as a coaster he used the cd as a coaster so he scratched the shit out of the face sorry uh yeah dude it's why would he do that because he's an that's his brand is he's a villain yeah let's see it's it's literally just a the perfect level of me a villain so it has some like uh i guess some scratches in it does uh the track skip try to remember it sounded great yeah no like and the the acoustics in the room were phenomenal yeah yeah overall it's been it's been a great week seeing seeing a lot of people like like always at all conferences that i i only see online but got to see them in uh in real life uh met cammy russo in in person so that was great chatted with her for a while uh yeah always always a good time at the crypto conferences are people feeling like bullish on nft still is like i mean it's been a phenomenal year it's got to be feeling bullish right but what's the vibe people were people were just like oh guys is this the top remember in 2018 coin desk where we had the lambos outside of the conference like there's like toppy conversations going on but there have been toppy conversations going on in crypto for like i don't know a year now conversations in like for nft specifically like march or april remember and you know people felt like and then there was kind of a lull and then it came back even stronger i don't know what's your personal take on this yeah apparently at the conferences there are a lot of people like pitching terrible nft ideas yeah i heard some some person was trying to pitch somebody else about um supporting uh afghan women oppressed by the taliban using the stellar network like when's the last time you heard about the stellar network ryan like oh like things like It just doesn't make any sense.
Yeah. That always happens. There are some weird shenanigans going around. Apparently, that was closer to the actual NFT conferences, not the satellite events. So I didn't get the full face of that. But there was a number of parties, like the audience party I was at and a few other related NFT events. I didn't recognize a single person. It was extreme. That was a common through line of all the friends that I've known in crypto for the last few years. Different crowd. A lot of us, completely different crowd. Wow. brand new brand new people and we have a take to talk about yeah we do have a brand new people that are just no one is familiar with like getting into into the world for the first time yeah i feel like that's especially true of nfts anyway guys we have a fantastic show for you today on the roll up we're talking about a few things first of all facebook with the name change pulling a prince on us actually not changing their name to a symbol but uh facebook becomes meta what's up with that a pivot into the metaverse also some airdrops coming your ways if you are a dot eth have a dot eth domain ens we're going to talk about that also there was a crypto punk that sold for 500 million dollars not mine sadly half a million that wasn't yours no that's right david would sell his crypto punk i was that you know gonna ask that but we talked about that a few roll-ups ago you would sell for 500 million dollars i would sell for 500 million dollars i would and uh you know if there's any takers out there mcdonald's with the mcrib nft that doesn't feel toppy at all does it quentin tarantino as well we mentioned that the matrix releasing nfts as well and reddit with the biggest web3 pivot ever we're going to cover all of that in more on the weekly roll-ups as you know this comes at you every friday morning we try to pack as much the week in crypto into your mind as possible david before we get into the main show gotta talk about a couple of things the first is this permissionless conference tickets okay this is a big d5 metaverse conference that we are putting on next year with our friends at blockworks website's just been updated the tickets are now released there might not be any left i gotta i gotta warn you so tickets were released maybe a little earlier this week and i'm not sure if they're going to be left by the time you listen to this uh every two weeks could they get they get released every two weeks.
It's always a new cycle. Yeah. Yeah. Batch release. So if you didn't get it this time, get them next time. But the thing is they increase in price every single two weeks. So you want to get them early if you can. I think the price now is 418. When we started, the price was $15, $15 and 59 cents. You might recognize those digits. 1559, but now it's 418. Okay. This is just going to keep going up. If you are a bankless subscriber, of course, a premium member, you need a discount on this, a 30% discount. What's the value of that? It's a hundred and something dollars, a hundred and whatever. It also keeps on going up.
It keeps on going up as well. So make sure you catch that. The speakers are going to be hot. The tracks are amazing. David and I are helping to plan all of this. So check out that conference. Also, another thing to check out is the Dharma Wallet. David, you want to tell them about Dharma Wallet? Yeah. Dharma Wallet is the easiest way to get you and your friends into the world of crypto into the world of defy uh if you guys have gotten into crypto without dharma you probably went the route of sending your money to coinbase or gemini which takes a while takes like seven days then you have to buy ether send that to your to your metamask or your ledger and then if you want to go on to polygon you got to send it to make an l1 transaction to polygon then you need to get gas on the polygon network that's a whole mess then you have to prove the old days the old days but no longer for because the dharma wallet will do all of this for you in just two to three minutes.
You can connect with your actual bank account with Plaid, which again, it's just like logging into your bank account. And then you can send money into the Polygon network. It's a smart contract wallet. It's connected into Polygon and they have a ton of cool features. So it is the fastest portal to get fiat money into the world of crypto where it belongs. So download Dharma, no gas fees. There's a link in the show notes. And I believe that if you sign up with the link in the show notes, you'll get airdropped $50 worth of ether on the Polygon network to get your life on an L2 started. So go check that out.
Yeah, you got to make a purchase. But if you make a purchase above $500, you get $50 in free eat on Polygon. So check that out using the link in the show notes. All right, David, you ready to get to it, man? Yeah, let's do it. Market time, market time. Let's talk Bitcoin. What are we doing? Bitcoin had a flat-ish week, up a little bit, up a little bit. Started the week at $60,000, which was the low, hit a high of $64,000 and currently at $62,000. So up roughly 4% or 5% on the week. Good job, Bitcoin. 4% or 5%, not too bad. But ETH, another story. All-time high week for ETH. A few all-time highs were hit this week.
I feel like celebrating every single one of them. Where are we right now? And what was the all-time high, David? Yeah, ETH started at $4,200. The new all-time high of $4,675 was hit a little bit more than 24 hours ago, roughly 36 hours ago at the time of recording. We are currently clocking in at $4,485. Next milestone is 5K. I feel like that's coming right up. But are we up? How much are we up on the week? We are up 15% on the week. It looks like we dipped a little bit before I wrote that number down. So maybe about like 13% or 14%. Why? Do you think this is like the Facebook meta news? Not to front run that.
We're going to talk about that in news a little bit. But do you think there's a metaverse story connected here? Or do you think this is just the market kind of catching up to what ETH should be? There are so many stories about what ETH should be. There's NFTs. There's the metaverse. There's DeFi. There's scaling. There's the merge. Ultra scalable Ethereum. Like people are getting their heads wrapped around that. There's so many stories to tell you to tell why this number is going up. And, you know, a lot of stories means a lot of reasons for a number to go up. I still think it's low, to be honest.
I still think the price of ETH is undervalued even at these prices. But you guys know that if you've been hanging out with Bankless for any time soon, we are ultra bullish on this asset. The listeners are like, we know, guys. It's like, shut up already, okay? We know. We already have our bags packed. All right. ETH Bitcoin ratio. What is that looking like, David? Yeah. Again, three green weeks in a row for the ETH Bitcoin ratio clocking in at 0.0734. four uh and so ever since the bitcoin etf the bitcoin ether ratio has done really really well uh and again the has it has not spent very very little time higher than this especially in the last six months but also definitely ever wow david are we getting close to we're getting close to like the two year three year maybe yeah all-time high for the ratio exactly yeah so that's a lot a lot of people i know i know anthony sezano pays attention to this ratio a lot and like i know He's like waiting for that to break through.
He's frothing at the mouth. Yeah, he's like, just don't tweet, don't tweet, don't tweet. Yeah, this is one to continue watching. But this is also an indicator, I would say, of the continued crypto bull run, right? If this ratio is gaining steam, then it means bull run in full effect. This is another bull run indicator. But dude, wait, this number is way down today. Total locked value in DeFi. I'm going to go with it. That's a bug on the DeFi pulse. Yeah, this did not happen. I'm going to go with a broken graph. Oh, you know, actually, you know what that was? Go down to Aave. That might have been a lot of people withdrawing from Aave.
No way. Yeah, because Aave is number two now. Aave had that bug exploit, which got fixed, so nothing bad happened. But a lot of people pulled funds out of Aave. This happened from November 3rd to the 4th, right? And we went down $105 billion to $87 billion, for those of you who can't see on the screen. Yeah, I'm going to go with that's a bug. It does feel like a bug. But so let's call it, we're still above, I think we're still above a hundred billion. Let's say that. That means we can make up these numbers, right? We want it to be over a hundred billion. So therefore it is this week. How do you feel like it should be, Ryan?
I feel like this should be a trillion to be honest, but you know, I'm going to be conservative on today's episode. We'll wait. We'll bide our time. How about the DeFi pulse index? This is an index of the top DeFi tokens, the blue chips, as it were, up or down on the week. Up, up, up on the week. Finally, the DPI had a great week this week, up 9% on the week, started the week at $330, ended the week at roughly $375. Signs of life, David. Are you liking that? Some signs of life here. How about this? Ether has way more signs of life than DPI. So we're still going down on the DPI to ETH ratio, huh?
Yeah, yeah. This has been a sad story. I mean, it put a little bit of a bottom. again not a bottom bottom but like hit 0.078 uh climbed up to 0.085 but again it is a nice linear slope down but just remember folks david reminded us last time if you swap out those defy tokens for another set of defy tokens and retrofit the data then david was still right about this ratio exactly right never david's never wrong that should be the takeaway here uh not defy season yet or at least it's more ETH season than it is DeFi season. So to the extent that remains the case, this ratio continues to drop a little bit.
But let's talk about the best of all worlds, which is the BED index, Bankless BED index, that is Bitcoin, ETH, and the DPI all inside one token that's a third, a third, a third. What are we looking at on the week? Yeah, BED had a good week because it is the best uh index in all of defy started the week at 172 hit a new high of 192 currently clocking in at 181 overall up uh how much percent on the week uh i don't know five percent five percent call that five percent so guys of course you know you can get into bed get with this index it's a simple purchase go to the index co-op.com website slash bed and uh purchase that it's actually up 60 percent over the 90 days in terms of a close to 60 percent uh in terms of um you know the 90 day increase in this index so it's starting to get closer to being sort of a staple type index of the crypto markets which is awesome to see all right let's look at layer two beat as well this tracks how much value is locked inside of true layer twos those are chains that are backed by the economic security guarantees of the ethereum network david just added a cool one billion in the past week from last week to this week, getting close to $5 billion.
Pretty crazy. Clocking in at $4.93 billion, up 21% on the week. Arbitrum up 20% in total value locked in layer twos. Optimism clocking in at plus 85% on the week, almost doubling the value locks in optimism. A lot of cool things are happening on optimism. Optimism breaking through that $500 million dollar level so congratulations to the team also loopering clocking in at a doubling and 98 off of i think speculation because something to do with a game stop and loopering integration they did make some key hires of right yeah yeah so that's that's interesting and also my again my one equity uh in that i don't that my the one thing that i own that's not crypto gme stocks doing very well by the way it's all related isn't it it's all it all comes back to crypto So what's cool about this, I think, is particularly with Arbitrum and Optimism, we're seeing this growth without a token incentive, right?
So we're seeing so many other layer one communities, different layer ones, not Ethereum, giving away like millions, hundreds of millions of dollars in token incentives to come yield farm on their chains. And Optimism and Arbitrum are not doing this, and they're still getting like massive growth week over week. So that's good to see. wait till they dial up the tokens if they ever do we'll see what happens there um also ultrasound money eth is becoming ultrasound money and just passed a big milestone what is that david three quarters of one million ether has been burned as of this week 761 000 ether that's more ether than i have closing in on the one million ether mark a little bit more huh just a little bit, just past David's bags here.
This is cool too. I wanted to actually correct this because I think I said that last week, I think I said that ETH had 10x the transaction fees over the past seven days of Bitcoin. And I was actually wrong. And someone reminded me of this. Ethereum actually had 100x the transaction fee revenue of Bitcoin over a seven day period of time. So I was like, you know, 10x off on that number. I knew it was a lot bigger. But over the last seven days, look, man, Ethereum had 50, almost $50 million worth of transaction fee revenue. And back to what we said last week, what do blockchains do? Blockchains sell blocks.
This is their transaction fee revenue. And I guess a year ago, two years ago, it was like a fight between Bitcoin and ETH. Like every day, it's like, who's kind of going to have more transaction fee revenue? Here's Bitcoin, a very distant number on this chart, not even a million dollars in transaction fee revenue over the past seven days. So it's super interesting to see, right? The thesis for Ethereum has always been, you make block space more valuable, then the asset becomes more valuable. And of course, EIP-1559 kicked that into high gear so that there's this immediate feedback loop. But it seems to be the case that this is happening.
Revenue numbers going up for Ethereum block space. Any other takes on this, David? Yeah, there is a direct connection between the amount of fees your blockchain collects and the soundness of the money. And if you have not yet learned how to articulate that association, there's a ton of stuff to go and read on the Bankless newsletter letter. Ultrascalable Ethereum, ultrasound money with Justin Drake, tons of things. So make sure you understand the relationship between blocks-based demand and soundness of the money. It's a really important concept. The only one that's closest is Binance Smart Chain.
and I don't even know what they do with their numbers. It's wash trading. Let's talk about this too. Last week was actually the first week that Ethereum actually had negative issuance, David. And we've seen some milestones on this ultrasound money thing in the past. In fact, the first day, I remember an individual block. It was the first day or the first two days after EIP-1559, an individual block that had negative issuance. I remember being really excited to see that. Like it's happening. But now we're hitting all of these milestones. Talk about this for a minute. Yeah, yeah. I think it was like just a couple hours after EIP-1559.
Everyone was scraping the block, Etherscan trying to find the first ultrasound block. Yeah, that's right, that's right. It took people a couple hours. And then I think just a couple weeks later, we had our first ultrasound day where the full, or no, just a couple, yeah, a couple weeks later, we had our first ultrasound hour where every, all the blocks over the hour were ultrasound they're burning collectively more ether than was being issued a couple weeks after that we had our first ultrasound day 24 hours of uh more ether being burned than was being issued we have now hit our first week of total issuance going down rather than up due to ether burn and so at some point we're going to be repeating this but it's going to be a month and then at some point it'll just be every month moving forward into the future uh ryan are we seeing the current limit of the ether supply right now like that could that could be happening as of this week the total supply of ether capped out that is a possibility that's true i mean uh justin drake when he put some numbers on this predicted this in april he's he thought that ether supply would never get above 120 million and i don't know what the total supply looks like but but you're right we're looking at it right now the total supply is 118.
2 million so over under on do we ever hit 120 million what do you think oh under yeah i definitely uh under for sure because this isn't even getting started yet okay once the merch happens so like we're maybe six months away for that it's over it's done it's gone right so a reduction of four percent this is an immediate reduction of four percent annualized issuance so we're going to be ultrasound month every single month every year i wouldn't be surprised if we start to get ultrasound decades david under our belts with this i mean we'll see what this looks like as soon as we hit the merge it's just ultrasound now and for forever yeah so it's just it's just a race to get to the merge unless you think block space ethereum block space is going to drastically decrease in demand is there any world where that happens i i don't think so and there's a there's a take that we have later to talk about what happens when you increase the block space available people just use more of it and so like even with charting we're going to increase the amount of block space available people are just going to use more.
They're going to transact more. And that's the thing. It's not even going to be humans. It's going to be other chains that are actually using this block space and being secured by it. Absolutely. There's no coincidence that we are breaking all-time highs this week, and that this is all-time high week, and then also ETH burn ultrasound week as well. That is not a coincidence. Bull markets bring in fees. And so really, this is a game of, are we in all-time high season? Are we in bull market season? Are we out of the crab season, and we're just going to keep on yeeting into new all-time highs if that's true then we might actually be in ultrasound territory now and for forever if that bull market can carry us into the merge like that's that's a possibility yeeting into all-time highs yeeting into the bull market so what we're doing right now i love it yeah top assets by market cap this is all top assets by market doesn't have things like gold but it has things that you can like use generally trade on exchanges so number one of course actually not of course i'm surprised to see this the top asset in the world worth 2.
5 trillion dollars for the t is microsoft now no longer apple it's microsoft actually then after that it's apple and google and uh then some like oil and gas companies amazon etc all the way down to number seven is bitcoin bitcoin is the seventh largest asset in the world that you can buy on an exchange of this type right behind tesla yeah right behind tesla well that's interesting and then right ahead of facebook and then if you keep scrolling past berkshire past navita uh nvidia uh you get to ethereum at number 13 almost breaching into the top 10 assets in the world that's pretty cool to see yeah ether is within striking distance i think it's just like something like 12 or 15 more percent which is just like hey that's just like one good week away from becoming a top 10 global asset.
So you got to love this. It's going to be exciting to watch. You think Jamie Diamond's looking at this and being like, oh, I'm number 14 and Ethereum just passed me. Now it's over for JP Morgan. It's like, I was wrong about crypto. I don't think he's saying that. Probably not, but maybe he should be. And along with the rest of the banks, even Visa is behind Ethereum at this point, which all makes sense because Ethereum is a network of networks. It is a global settlement layer. It is a monetary system. It is a money. It is not like all of these other things, aside maybe a little bit like Bitcoin.
I think they'll continue rising in the charts. David, that's it for the markets. And we've got some hot releases coming up for folks. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Bankless is proud to be supported by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure. Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum, which is what Ryan and I call a money robot. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy.
Something brand new in the Uniswap ecosystem is the Uniswap grants program is now accepting applications for grants. We have been saying this for a while and we'll say it again. DAOs have money and they are in need of labor. If you think that you have something to contribute to the Uniswap DAO, apply for a grant to Uniswap. Just look at the size of the Uniswap treasury. It's almost $3 billion. This mountain of capital is looking for labor. Do you have something of value to contribute to the Uniswap DAO? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a UniGrant at unigrants.org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go.
That's exactly what we did to get Uniswap to be a sponsor for Bankless, and you can do the same for your project. Thank you, Uniswap, for sponsoring Bankless. Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange. I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got into crypto in 2017, and it's been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys and sells. Gemini is available in all 50 states and in over 50 countries worldwide, and on Gemini there are markets for over 30 various different crypto assets, including many of the hot DeFi tokens. And it's one of the few exchanges that has liquid DAI markets.
Gemini just launched their Earn program where you can earn up to 7.4% interest on 26 various crypto assets. If you're tired of paying fees in DeFi, or you don't want to worry about DeFi exploits, but you still want to earn interest on your crypto assets, Gemini Earn is the product for you. Another product I'm stoked to get my hands on is the Gemini crypto back credit card, which gives you 3% cash back on all of your purchases, but paid to you in your preferred crypto asset. When I get my Gemini credit card, I'm going to make sure that I get my cash back in ETH. So whenever I buy something, I get a little bit of ETH bonus back to me at the same time.
You can open up a free account in under three minutes at Gemini.com slash go bankless. And if you trade more than $100 within the first 30 days after signup, you'll be gifted a free $15 Bitcoin bonus. Check them out at gemini.com slash go bankless. All right, guys, we are back with the hot releases of the week. The first is this, ENS, which is the Ethereum name service. You might've seen those dot eths all over Twitter. You might have a dot eth yourself that is registered to the ENS, Ethereum name service. Well, now ENS is issuing a token. They are doing an airdrop to all holders of .eth accounts.
What's going on here, David? Yeah, yeah. So we need to, when I was talking to Brantley even forever ago, he was always saying like, they would receive money from selling the ENS names. Lots of money, right? Lots of money, tons of money. And like they consider themselves like a public goods, right? Not a private company. They don't want to be a private company that is just like operating what is a core function of the Ethereum system, which is .eth names. And so they've been sitting on all of this ether, not knowing what to do with it. not knowing how to structure this company. And then the whole DAO revolution starts.
And I think it's just very, very obvious that the .eth side of Ethereum becomes community-operating, community-governed. And so what's so fantastic about .eth names is that it's so easy to identify who has them. And so they just airdropped some, or they will be airdropping some ENS governance tokens to .eth holders. And so there are some different parameters as to how much you are getting. you are getting one if you own a .eth you are getting double that if you actually linked that .eth name to an actually Ethereum address then you are also getting a multiplier based on how long you've actually had that linked and so if you have linked your ENS Ethereum address and you've done it for a long time you might get some nice airdrops coming your way soon hell yeah man that means if you've been listening to bank lists when we started talking about ENS addresses back in 2019 and we created tactics on how to actually register them and set them up correctly, then you will definitely get this airdrop, which is super exciting.
137,000 accounts.eth holders, which is great. One important note though is they're not rewarding like squatters in this mechanism, right? So if you bought like, I don't know, 100 names and you're just sitting on them, You're not getting any amplifier for owning more .eth names. Is that correct? That is correct, yeah. So if you bought 100 ENS names and you're just sitting on them, you didn't link them to your Ethereum address, you are just getting one share's worth of an airdrop. And so it's unique addresses that linked their ENS name to their Ethereum wallet for amount of time. I think it's a great mechanism.
There's a link in the show notes if you want to check out more details on that. Overall, 25% of the total airdrop will be given out to 2.eth holders. 25% will go to the ENS contributors, and then 50% to the DAO community treasury, which I really like that model. This is – Kevin Iwaki shared this model and put this idea in my head where it's 50% for the past and then 50% for the future, right? So everyone who's worked on the project so far, so 25% to the airdrop, 25% to the team, and then 50% to the community treasury, which goes and funds the future DAO, right? actual people that want to start the DAO.
This is super cool. I think this is one of the ones I'm most excited about since probably Uniswap. And the reason is because of such a large distribution. I mean, there's so many .eth holders, so many ENS users. And so this is getting out there. But like in general, they kind of had to go down this path, right? Because they had a multisig, they had a treasury, and they had a small set of individuals who were really responsible for that multisig. I don't know, it was like seven to 10 members of the Ethereum community who had access to that multisig. And of course, it requires some majority of owners to sign off on transactions.
But this turns that multisig over to the DAO, over to governance, over to the users, over to the community. It's a very Web3 concept, and it's super cool to see. So we are actually having Nick and Brantley from ENS on our State of the Nation on Tuesday. I think more details will come early next week on how you can pick up this airdrop. Of course, if you are a Bankless Premium member, we dropped the Ultimate Guide to Airdrops last week. And if you did, number, let's see. Number 20? Number 16. Number 16. 25 hypothetical potential. We're not sure if they're going to airdrop, but you might want to check them out in case they do.
Sort of opportunities. Number 16 was Ethereum Name Service. had some folks ping us earlier in the week and be like, oh my God, I'm glad I saw that. Registered a .eth domain, got started on it. Now I'm eligible for that airdrop. So bankless premium members get that. We will include a link in the show notes so you can check that resource out. It's evergreen. 24 more on this list, potentials. So take a look at that. You can be damn sure that every time an airdrop happens, we will be reminding you that this airdrop guide I mean, I'm just saying, it's just like, why not go... Do your homework. Do your homework.
Why not get free airdrops, folks? Like, why not just put in some effort? Crypto pays you to learn about crypto. So take the extra step here. Anyway. Before we move on, there are a couple more dynamics about the ENS DAO now that I think are worth pulling apart. DAOs inherently have like a funding problem at Genesis because like they just mint a token. They don't really have any money yet. that's not true with with ens they have that very large stack of ether from all of the ens sales and so the ens dow is going to have a very large treasury of ether behind it and so they are going to be able to fund themselves right off the bat they the ens team is giving all of that ether to the dow so that's pretty cool i don't know how much that is i'd forgot about that too but it's like it's got to be a lot because um when we said the dow has a lot of money all of that money is an eth as you said so when you register a dot eth domain you're paying for it in eth and if you paid for in ETH back in like 2018, 2019, that ETH is worth a heck of a lot more in dollar values than it's like your $5, your $10 to register is now a 10x from that, right?
So I'm sure it's a substantial treasury. Yeah. And then the other side of this is that the ENS team, they never raised anything from any funds at all. Zero funds own ENS, right? Like this token was just born. uh no there were no vcs no no one backing it and so it's going to be one of the coolest i think it's gonna be one of the coolest launches uh top top 10 launches top 10 launches top 10 launches sounds like another bankless blog post but this is like yeah the distribution is great i'm excited about this one the way i was with uniswap so anyway next week more details on that uh let's talk about this maker governance just onboarded lido's staked eth that's st eth as a collateral type.
It's really cool because staked ETH is kind of like treasuries and T-bills are to dollars, right? It's sort of like, you know, you take your dollars, you put it in a risk-free asset, which is a treasury. And the reason it's risk-free is because the US government can always pay you back. Why? Because they are the mint. Of course they can print more money and always pay you back. So it's called risk-free rate of return. That's what staked ETH is, or it can be. It does have some risk. The risk with the staking provider, like Lido has some risk on it. So there are various forms of staked ETH. But anyway, it's really cool to see staked ETH tokenized and available as collateral.
So you can get a loan against it. You can start to use it as a composable money Lego inside of the DeFi economy. Any takes here, David? yeah this is uh this is a it's just a great integration it's a great collateral but this is a first step of a very very large story which is eventually all eth is all eth inside of defy is going to turn into staked eth inside of d5 because why wouldn't you well you could have two collateral types eth and staked eth one stays the same and one goes up like five four or five six percent a year and they're both equally liquid and they're both equally liquid that's the difference right so like with the t-bill it's like it's locked up but you can't do anything with it like your money is kind of parked inside of that instrument you can't you know do very much with at least an individual can't do very much with it but with this you could do anything in the defy economy that you could do with any erc20 and that's exactly right and then this is the really the important story here is there's going to be a network effects competition for this staked ETH derivative token, right?
Coinbase as a centralized staking as a service operator, probably going to release Coinbase staked ETH as a secondary currency. Any staking as a service operator, in order to compete with all the other ones, they need to generate liquidity on their staked ETH token. So they will all generate the staked ETH derivative token. Who can get their staked ETH derivative token integrated into DeFi the best is going to win. And so like, because monies have network effects. And so this is a competition that all staking as a service providers are playing in this game. Rocketpool also has REath as well. And so it's really nice to see these decentralized, committed to decentralized versus the centralized ones start to make those moves before the centralized companies do.
Yeah, the collateral types I'm going to support most are the ones that are the most decentralized. Yeah, the most trustless forms because those are truly the most risk-free forms. and in the best interest of the network. And that's specifically the bull case for RocketPool and RE. This RocketPool is trying to be the most decentralized, technically risk-free that there is. Lido has done a few compromises to get there, but they are still committed to decentralization and they just want to go to market first, and that's how they have done that. Both of those are far superior than anything a centralized staking as a service company could offer.
When launch, RocketPool. Come on. Come on, guys. Yeah. Let's see you soon. Let's get this going. This is really cool. Look at this. Release from crypto.com. So we think of the crypto.coms of the world as like crypto banks. So there's sort of infrastructure that sit on top of chains. They are now supporting direct deposits and withdrawals to and from Arbitrum, a roll-up. We said this was going to happen. It's starting to happen. Crypto.com. I believe they were in the top five or something apps in the Apple iTunes. This is Google Android I saw. This is the Android App Store. Top five apps. So crypto.
com has a ton of customers and consumers, and now they are enabling layer two fiat withdrawals. This is fantastic to see a much needed bridge into these ecosystems. Any thoughts here, David? yeah there's going to be another race between all of these centralized companies to figure out how can they drop their users off onto much more user-friendly environments we asked brian armstrong the same question on the podcast that comes out on monday uh brian armstrong on the podcast monday by the way uh and so such a good episode oh my god it was really good yeah uh and so like all i'm every single exchange needs to be playing this game right now and figuring out how to and it's not that hard just do it just put it on the side chain allow users to withdraw it like what i don't get why this is so hard yeah shyla buff me man just do it just do it just do it right now okay exchanges and look we're going to support you if you do right the exchanges that i care about it's like this is a conversation we had with brian armstrong just to tease that episode a little bit more by the way premium members get that tomorrow or today if you're listening to it But we asked him the question of like a couple of questions, I guess, related.
One was, do you regret not building Coinbase chain? Was the question we asked him in the podcast. His answer to that was phenomenal. The other question we asked is Binance is building a Binance chain, right? FTX is really partnering with Solana. It feels very much like most exchanges are playing this Web2 game. like they onboard you to crypto and then they try to lock you into an ecosystem that they control right this is like like the facebook we've seen this before uh and then we kind of asked brian armstrong are you going to be the crypto bank that's going to build on open credibly neutral protocols that was the question we posed to him for the answer to that question you'll have to stay tuned to the podcast coming on monday but it's such a good answer and it's so worthwhile Anyway, I think very much the crypto banks and exchanges will be competing, and hopefully they're competing for consumers in a very Web3 way that is positive, building on top of credibly neutral open infrastructure.
Layer 2 is one essential layer in that stack, and so maybe we see Coinbase support for Layer 2 next. Ryan, I actually saw Brian Armstrong last night. You did? Yeah, he was there. Yeah. And so, again, so we were, I saw him yesterday, the day before we were recording with him in Zoom. And so I go up to him like, oh, hey, hey, Brian. And he looks at my name tag and the name tags. Okay, this is going to be an NFT NYC story. When you were in line and somebody was filling out your name tag for you, they were asking you like, what is your, what was your AIM screen name? Not your name. What was your AIM screen name?
And mine was Blackjack Davey. So like I go up to Brian and I say, oh, hey, hey, Brian. Like, hey, it's great. It's great to meet you. And he just, he looks at me and then looks at my name tag. I was like, oh, hey, Black Jack Davian. Like, no, Brian, it's David from Bankless. Oh my God. We were just recording and it took him a while. Like it's a loud party. It took him a while to connect the dots. But yeah, you know, he did not recognize me at all. Well, the other thing, it was funny though, because we were joking with Brian on the podcast. We were like, he's like, look, we've hired so many people.
I've done bars. Number is like 150 people. I don't even know the employees that we hired on Coinbase. So yeah, it's hard. It's hard when you meet so many people, like for that facial recognition software to keep up and like remember and put names with faces. And it's difficult. But crypto conferences, there's the running joke that is just so impossible. And like, I will never knock him for not recognizing me because I do the same thing for so many people. Why don't they just... We've met like three times. Like I recognize people in the digital world by their Twitter avatars, honestly. Yeah. It's like that is more recognizable to me.
And I know some people change their Twitter avatars a lot, so that throws me off. But anyway, digital games. Let's talk about this next one. Running Phonon. What is this? This is a product by Grid+. What does it allow you to do, David? Yeah, Phonon is, I guess, this new kind of primitive that is being built by Grid+. Grid+, again, has the Lattice hardware wallet. And what they have done is they have made what they are calling a Phonon transfer. Now, the details for this as to how this works, I do not know, but I know the gist. And so the gist is that they sent Bitcoin, 100 satoshis of Bitcoin from one GridPlus hardware wallet to another GridPlus hardware wallet, not using Bitcoin, using the hardware.
And so basically it mimics the properties of cash. It's like if I were to actually be able to give you, go and hand you physical Bitcoin, it's like that. And so Bitcoin was sent over the internet from one hardware wallet to another hardware wallet, but not using the Bitcoin blockchain. And this also works for Ethereum too. And so we are now able to mimic the properties of physical cash and then also send it over the internet, but not actually using the networks. It's pretty crazy. Yeah, so like trustless, bare assets, and private too. Privacy is really important because I can just DM you some bytes of data in this Zoom chat, and those bytes of data will be like a Bitcoin, 100 satoshis of Bitcoin, right?
And you can go redeem it. All of this sounds magic, and I don't know how it works, but it sounds super interesting. And I know GridPlus is very much in the cutting edge of hardware wallets, like the most secure enclaves possible, which is super cool. I feel like I want to learn more after this, David. And if you want to learn more, there's a link in the show notes to check out some of the technical details of this. Also, DAO infrastructure tools. Man, where do you go? Is there one place you can go where you can see all of the infrastructure tools available for you? Now there is. It's called daomasters.
xyz. And you can look at all of the tools that are required to spin up a DAO. Discord, of course. MintGate, Gardens, OpenLaw investing, recruiting, marketing fundraising, payroll, community management all of these various tools in one place, kind of cool to see this is all the infrastructure I wish I had in 2017 2018, oh I wish I'd like to make a token and then I was like how to mint an ERC20 token oh it's gotten so much better I've always wanted just like drag and drop push button Ethereum smart contract infrastructure and this is that and not only that but a bunch of infrastructure around that infrastructure too so this is that golden age of infrastructure right now it's gotten better but it's still going to get so much more yes like better like better it's like it's going to be another 10x a year from now in terms of the tooling we'll have so um stay tuned for that guys also stay tuned axi infinity continue to crank it out they just uh released on their ronin side chain something called Katana, which is a DEX for AXS tokens and SLP tokens tradable with ETH.
David, what's going on here? Yeah, Axie Infinity, famously the Axie Nation, has their total entire GDP on the Ronin sidechain, but it didn't have a DEX. And so if you wanted to swap stuff, you would have to take it back to Ethereum. So they just built their own DEX on the Ronin sidechain. So it's like Axie Infinity Nation's got its own New York stock exchange natively on their side chain uh and so that's probably a huge upgrade for all the axi infinity players out there that don't have to go back to ethereum to start using uh the defy there god look at this video man these axes are so cute the cutest creatures i've ever seen uh digital creatures that is optimism what are they doing equivalence we talked about that a little bit next week but they're releasing that as a release in probably just like seven days or so that's exactly right optimistic Ethereum coming to optimism itself.
They're upgrading their own system, going into EVM equivalents. They release a fantastic blog post. If you want to understand EVM equivalents and AlphaLeak, you do. You do want to understand EVM equivalents. So go check out that blog post. It puts it into really simple language. There is a fundamental difference between EVM compatibility and EVM equivalents. EVM equivalents allows optimism to ride the network effects of Ethereum. All the infrastructure tooling, the dev tooling, the node tooling, everything that's already been built out just gets to be immediately repurposed for Optimism. And that is their big competitive advantage.
So congrats to the Optimism team. We're going EVM equivalent in just about seven days. Yeah, it's really interesting because I think the real chain wars are actually going to be the chain wars between Layer 2s that will need to carve out their place and carve out their niche. And I feel like our optimism's take is we are going to be the most Ethereum aligned roll up of them all, basically. So other roll ups might adopt, you know, other technical implementations. They might even go to other chains. But optimism is really aiming to be an extension of Ethereum, which is a really neat niche. And it's something that I expect they'll be able to carve out quite successfully.
David, let's move to the raises of the week every week in crypto. There's always a massive amount of raises. We can't cover them all anymore, but we do try to cover some of the big ones. This one's different, though. Yeah. So what is this? DCG. This is Digital Currency Group. So Barry Silbert's firm, of course, you might know many of his products. Coindesk is one of his products. Another one of his products is GBDC and all of the Grayscale funds that you might buy in a brokerage. All Grayscale. Yeah, Grayscale. The thing. Owned by DCG. Yeah, exactly. The whole thing. So what are they doing here?
What's this raise? Just raising a casual $700 million. Okay. Yeah. $700 million at a $10 billion valuation. All right. Well, this is the second largest. Yeah. This is the second largest crypto raise ever. I actually don't know what the first is. But I mean, this is just absolutely massive. Naturally, SoftBank is behind this because they have all the currency in the world. So yeah. Congratulations to Barry Silbert. this is absolutely massive raise. Weird headline though, I think. I don't know who gave them this moniker. DCG wants to be crypto's standard oil. Standard oil? We don't want standard oil.
We don't want robber barons in the crypto industry. That's a little weird. Yeah, I don't know where that's coming from, but whatever, metaphors aside. Quick facts about Barry Silbert. He was originally super supportive of Ethereum Classic for some reason. he put a ton of ethereum classic on on his treasury i don't know why uh also he's also previously this is no longer the case from what i've gathered but there was a conflicts of interest between coinbase and digital currency or coin desk and digital currency group because they didn't put up a firewall between the news uh arm and the fund arm of the same company uh so that's some eyebrows over overall like a what is it called um a conglomerate i guess is what this is it's an empire the dcg is an absolute massive standard oil it yeah it doesn't not fit right yeah and they're definitely raking cash i think they've done a lot for crypto adoption i'll totally give them that uh and uh yeah i think overall they're they're they're healthy they're a good actor.
I think they definitely skew a bit more banker, old world, Bitcoin maximalist type. But still, I mean, this is all part of the adoption story. And I mean, wow, $10 billion valuation. That's got to raise some eyebrows. SoftBank jumping in as well. This is another one that's pretty big. The firm backed by Alan Howard, which remember, he's the massive hedge fund manager that is also backing Eric Peters' firm. We talked to Eric Peters from One River Capital Management a couple weeks ago on the podcast. Anyway, they just closed a $100 million investment in a major metaverse fund with our friend Andrew Steinwald, who a year ago, about a year ago at this time, came on the Bankless podcast.
Andrew has his own podcast, had his own firm. It was a very small firm at the time. And I'm going to butcher the name, David. Can you say the name for me? Yeah, Sofirmion. Sofirmion. Okay, thank you. Sofirmion. And at the time, he was on a podcast with he and who was it? Jake? It was Jake Berkman. Jake Berkman. And he basically gave the pitch for NFTs in the metaverse. And he was like, guys, you're not going to believe us when we say this, but NFTs are going to be bigger than DeFi. and we'd just come off of DeFi summer and it felt like very much like both Brian and I were like what? get out of here eventually you know in 10 years or something sure I did believe him but I thought it would take a longer time for it to play out and to be fair he probably did too well he definitely thought it did not happen it happened way faster than he thought it would okay so now his firm just got a hundred million dollars in funding his fun so congrats to andrew congrats to the people preaching you were right we were wrong and like um i think a lot of the people who were right about nfts and the metaverse a year ago are now reaping the rewards on this side it's like market validation now you get 100 million dollars in your fund go invest for us so congrats andrew steinwald the um and his entire team and congrats for being right on the thesis.
It's really cool to see. Yeah. And again, like believing in NFTs before there was any real market validation about them, right? CryptoPunks were still like below two ether, right? Like there was no excitement about NFTs. They were just a concept. Yeah. And he believed in it before anyone was actually bullish on anything about NFTs. You know what? Something really gets me excited, gets me going is like investors with conviction, okay? There are so many people on YouTube and I feel like in Twitter, some of these are traders, self-proclaimed traders, but some of these are like crypto influencers and like investors in the space.
And they don't really invest with any conviction. They don't really have a long-term thesis. They just play on whatever's popular in the narrative, right? Three months in, six months in, okay? I hate that. Like, it's just not, it's not something that I gravitate towards. Like, I like the Andrew Steinwalds of the world. I like the Olaf Carlson wheeze in 2013. I like the Brian Armstrongs in 2012 who are like, oh, I see what this can become. I have conviction. When everyone else is going in a different direction, no one else believes, I'm going to put my flag in the ground. I'm going to build something cool.
And I'm going to invest in this space and build in this space with conviction. Those are my favorite people in crypto because all of them are playing long-term games. and you should go and follow what they do at every single step. And I think Andrew is one of those people. Have we said enough good things about Andrew? I wonder if he's listening. Andrew, we like you. All right, what's next, David? What's this one? Sandbox. Yeah, this is the company that Snoop Dogg is associated with. So that's how Snoop Dogg came into the world of crypto, partnering with the Sandbox metaverse-type, avatar-ish, second-life-type game.
It hasn't been opened yet, but you can build stuff on it so far. Just raised $93 million again by SoftBank. So SoftBank really injecting a ton of cash into this space. Yeah, they just raised a couple months ago $140 million. I don't know what the valuation is. This particular article doesn't say. It's got to be unicorn status already. Building on Ethereum, which is interesting. I know you've taken a look at the tech. You think it looks cool. but i think a lot of this um comes off of the the facebook meta pivot right facebook the biggest social media fifth largest company we're just looking at that in the world is now pivoting to the metaverse and sandbox has a sand token um has that how what has that done on this news uh it's done some things yeah some big so yeah it's been hanging around like 75 cents and then as soon as the Facebook MetaPivot just went from 75 cents to like 3 plus dollars and then at the same time it also raised 93 million dollars so good tailwinds for this sandbox company.
Jeez, market cap close to 3 billion dollars and this is just a leg up. We've seen that ever since the Facebook announcement and a lot of anything that is classified as the metaverse as a token that's a narrative that is happening in DeFi tokens right now. Another narrative that doesn't get old is the narrative of... Get a job. Getting a job in crypto, of course. This is the time when we remind you that there are all sorts of fantastic job opportunities in crypto. All of these fantastic protocols and companies are hiring. We have a bankless job board where we try to consolidate as much as possible some of the coolest opportunities.
This week, head of growth at DexGuru, a technical lead at Daftly, incorporated an accountant at Smart DeFi, product manager at Smart DeFi as well, head of Ethereum research at Immutable. David, you had Immutable on the podcast earlier this week. Also head of tokens, community manager at Dexable, a lead engineer at Hats.Finance, community manager at eAgronim. Did I get it right this week? Yeah, nice job, nice job. That was like four weeks in. Also, I don't know if that's correct, but that's just how I do it. Okay, that's how David has always said it. Also, they're looking for a CTO eAgronim, senior backend engineer smart defi blockchain technical cto interim role at merit community manager argon founding blockchain engineer at highlight oh my god i'm almost out of breath senior software engineer popcorn and a community lead at popcorn as well i rattled off just the top ones that i could list but there are dozens more on the job board sign up for that and make sure you check this weekly for opportunities in crypto that could fit your skill set yeah as these raises have come in in the last few weeks that we keep on talking about raise after raise after raise that's what there's no wonder there's so many jobs available on the job board we just raised 700 million dollars we're digital currency group i think we need to hire some people to spend that on they gotta be doing some of that right where else is the money going with all of these raises yeah that's that's where it's going folks all right david let's get to the news the big one of the week is the Facebook metaverse pivot.
They're changing. They're rebranding. No longer Facebook. They are now called Meta. That is the company name. That is the ticker symbol. That is the meta.com website. A social technology company is what they're saying in their press release. David, what's happening here? I like this little graphic where they have like WhatsApp, Facebook, Instagram, all of their products, and then it forms into the M of the meta. Basically, I think we talk about this a few times where like sometimes people start building stuff and they don't know what explicitly what they're building towards until they actually get there so i think the idea here is that facebook has been building out parts of the metaverse in different little pieces like you know the for the facebook was like the first virtual online social media thing that really took the world by storm it was the first iteration of you know v1 metaverse uh add in Instagram, add in WhatsApp, add in all these social elements.
Now with Oculus VR, I think this pivot makes a ton of sense. They are already making virtual online experiences in different silos and now they're just branding this under the single umbrella. Also doing a fantastic job of aligning their branding with the metaverse, which is getting just absolutely a ton of attention as a word, even though no one still knows what it actually is. I feel like we know what it is. We do know what it is. We have some direction there. Yeah. But I mean, obviously, like, there's basically nothing that Facebook and Zuck can do that has positive light on it. Like, sure, you can call it the metaverse.
I'm going to call it the Zuckverse. It's the Zuckverse. Well, deservedly so. I mean, they have, it feels very much like use their command and control to abuse users in the past. Maybe abuse even ecosystem participants. Countries, entire countries. Yeah, it does feel like Zuck deserves, maybe Facebook deserves a lot of the flack that they get. But Chris Dixon pointed out in our podcast, like he is one of the only original big web two founders that are still actively involved in making bets and managing their companies, right? It's just kind of Zuckerberg, I guess, Jack Dorsey, and Zuckerberg, but like the Google founders, you know, they're gone.
Microsoft, of course, like they're gone. All of the original big tech companies are mostly gone. I guess Bezos is still there. I don't know why Dixon didn't include them. But it enables somebody like Zuck to make a big bet. And that's what this is. This is a big bet on the future. It's going to cost a lot of money for them to get here into the metaverse. And there was so many different takes on this, right? So like one take I felt like was the political take, right? Maybe political Twitter was very much like, oh yeah this is just zuck trying to deflect from this bad pr right everyone hates the name facebook so now you're becoming meta okay you know whatever um i think crypto twitter much of crypto twitter saw this as a co-opting of crypto a co-opting of the metaverse yeah okay you're trying to duplicate our thing but just make it decentralized or centralized centralized um brian armstrong's take was interesting which he was very much like um you know zuck knows what he's doing he's smart he's founder-led uh he actually believes that someone like like i think i do maybe you do too david that this is going to force mark zuckerberg and facebook to build on top of crypto right because like in the metaverse where do you get your property rights layer we can't have meta facebook be the property rights layer of this entire economy this universe that we're building So where does that come from?
Well, it has to come from NFTs, tokens, settlement on systems like Ethereum. So maybe this is actually just Zuckerberg kind of capitulating and being like, okay, I'll build my universe, right? I'll own the front end, but I'm going to build it on this open standard, which is crypto. And maybe that's a super bullish thing for crypto. What's your take on all of these things? yeah i i i'm gonna go with occam's razor here i don't think there's much of a crypto story here at all um i i think this is just about because there was a video i saw of um the whole like presentation of the pivot and what they were going to do with it and everything was cut out for it except for the words experiences and so it's just zuckerberg saying experiences experiences experiences over and over the word experiences was built into this thing i truly think it's more more of web 2 stuff less about crypto property rights nfts stuff like that and more just literally about like it's a big pivot into oculus into vr into the online social experiences uh and so maybe like maybe the crypto part does come but i don't think that's the specific strategy that's being communicated here it could be wrong yeah no i i think there's some truth to what you said I just think the reason it's bullish crypto is because I think many people in Silicon Valley...
No, it's more than that. So many people in Silicon Valley, if you ask them what their... We have a different definition of the metaverse than them, okay? If you ask them what their definition of the metaverse is, it's experience. It's augmented reality. It's virtual reality. It's this new realm that you can go to, okay? The crypto definition of the metaverse is strong property rights. It's self-sovereignty. It's like the difference between New York City, a neighborhood where you can own private property and set up commercial shops and business, and Disneyland, which is an experience. And where are you actually going to set up?
Yeah, it's manicured. Where are you actually going to create a real organic digital universe? It's not in Disneyland. You don't build a house and raise your kids in Disneyland. okay and that if the metaverse is going to be a human experience if it's going to be a real organic thing then it has to have property rights it has to feel real it has to like live so that's why i'm kind of of the mind that yeah zuck thinks it's about experience maybe because that's the only hammer in their tool belts but what this really is about is like they can build the front end on top of this thing, I don't care.
They'll be forced to settle on top of crypto money systems and crypto property rights systems. So that's why I am, I guess, bullish. And I do think that there is a crypto story here underlying, even though they don't see it yet. Sure. Yeah, I do like that take. You said that they think it's all about experiences and we think it's all about property rights. And I will say when you have property rights, you also have the culture come out of the property rights like crypto punks bored apes like property rights about those things and that is also experiences and those experiences are vibes that i've been feeling all week here at nfc nyc and you're not going to be able to that's a bottom-up vibe not a top-down experience and so that is the difference it's it's it yeah it's it's totally right and it's like back to what we were talking about it's like let's make the internet weird again the internet is like boring and sterile and not weird.
Let's make it weird again. I think that's what crypto is doing. Nike's getting in on it too, dude. There's no risk in Disneyland, but there's a bunch of risk in NFTs. There's no risk in Disneyland? You can't kidnap to Disneyland, huh? It is locked down. Very secure, very safe. Nike is heading to the metaverse as well. They are filing trademarks in the metaverse and they are hiring metaverse designers. So here's an interesting thought for you, okay? It's like all of the growth for the mega brands, particularly the premium luxury brands, is going to be growth in the digital product space rather than the physical product space over the next 10 years.
Remember when we had Cathie Wood on? We were like, well, for the banks, they could start doing more in crypto, but it would just be such a marginal small part of their business because they're so large. And she was like, oh, that's where you're wrong. Chris Berninski said this too, because it's not about the proportion of total revenue. It's about the proportion of future growth. So all of the other business lines could be stagnant. And if you have 90% of the growth on the digital side, on the crypto side, then the banks are going to start taking notice and capitulating. I feel like that's going to happen with brands too.
It's like Nike, you've got all this IP, you've got all this fan base, this brand equity, all these athletes. how are you actually going to grow your revenue over the next decade and the massive amount of growth is going to come from digital products rather than physical products so they're going to start piling in david that's what i see here yeah and the whole facebook pivoting to meta i think there's a lot of a lot of companies behind the scenes doing virtual goods metaverse type things and this is just again going to turn this into an absolute rat race of who can be the most metaverse the fastest these are awesome shoes by the way what are these like virtual nikes they look awesome i would i don't get it i want these i want these what in my life nikes yeah have you ever seen my shoes i have never seen i have never seen you can see the bottom half of me i uh it's weird when i do i'll show you my shoes sometime i do have a pair of nikes uh not that cool though um yeah i i said this take but that's the take the the virtual goods are going to dwarf the physical goods before long microsoft getting in on the action too microsoft ceo it's the biggest company in the world apparently uh the metaverse will bring real world the real world into any digital space so they are going all in they plan to introduce 90 new services and updates in three major areas including the metaverse you can absolutely expect us to do things in gaming of course they said no no surprise there they own the xbox so are they just going to fast follow facebook into this thing david yeah yeah everyone everyone everyone's going to the metaverse we're all going to see you there see in the metaverse what's reddit doing david this is super exciting this is uh an engineer who just joined their team going to the metaverse um three words he says decentralize period social period media what does this mean this is huge okay reddit is i think Reddit is on the cusp of perhaps one of the biggest pivots of all time, from a Web2 company to a Web3 company, not just a little bit, but going heads first.
So we know that Reddit has always been curious with Ethereum. They had the Reddit scaling bake-off competition forever ago. Arbitrum won it. And so Reddit is now using Arbitrum to scale out NFTs and tokens inside of the Reddit platform. And so this thread and the writer of this thread has the ultrasound money icons in his handle. Just want to throw that out there. Oh my God. And so he makes a fantastic thread. So let's go through it. Your karma points will soon be tokens. Think community-based decisions, forking subreddits in disagreements, which is, oh my God, that's so cool. That's so amazingly cool.
First off, like incentivizing good content via valid contributions. That's amazing. But also a very dark part about Bitcoin's history and crypto's history at large is that the Bitcoin had a civil war inside of the R-Bitcoin subreddit. And they forked it off into R-BTC and R-Bitcoin because there was this – I can't remember his name. But a mod subreddit that was like silencing anyone that wanted big blocks and only forced small blocks. and there was a massive, massive civil war that ultimately created the block-sized wars, the fork wars, right? And it was just a conspiracy and espionage. It was crazy back then.
Some of the stories, Griff Green told me some of these stories in the Layer Zero. And if we can just figure out how, like how we fork our blockchain, we can just fork our subreddits with more instantiated assets inside of them that go and have governance votes and allow the communities to have voice, that is amazing. And that's exactly what DAOs do and tokens do. And so I think what this could become is one of the coolest things of all time. The thread continues, Reddit has 500 million monthly active users. When we all pull this off, we will onboard 500 million Web 2 users into Web 3, and then there is no going back.
We are all going to make it. And then he just continues saying, crypto culture things. It's time to take back control, make the internet truly open and break free, give us each ownership of everything. And so I think this could be one of the most groundbreaking pivots of all time. Yeah, I do too, David. I'm super bullish on this. Like we said in the last episode, Reddit actually has, they don't monetize their user base very well, right? And maybe that's because they don't really prey on their user base the way other social media platforms kind of do through advertising, through like mining them for all of this information.
It's a bit more open, bit more free, but as a result, it's not as profitable. Well, this gives them incentive to jump into Web3 first because they don't have to cannibalize a large existing business model. There's just opportunity. They don't have much to lose. There's just opportunity on the other side. And the thing is the technology is here too. So this thread goes on to say, Reddit has partnered with Arbitrum, which you mentioned, created our own separate instance of Arbitrum. Community points for two subreddits. 80,000 users are already on RinkBee Testnet and our Arbitrum network. So remember Arbitrum when we had them on?
They have Arbitrum 1, which they're rolling out, which is live right now. But Arbitrum doesn't have to be just one roll-up, okay? You can use the Arbitrum code and create your own roll-up. And that's what Reddit is doing here. They're just forking. They're creating a separate instance of a roll-up that all settles on top of Ethereum. So super exciting to see an engineer talk about the technology being ready for this too. Overall, this is just ultra bullish. Web 2 companies becoming Web 3 companies. They have everything to gain. As Chris Dixon said, Web 3 is ownership. He actually quotes him in this thread.
And I mean, man, Web 2 is great. Web 2 is peaked, man. I really feel like that. Absolutely. Is this the Wall Street? New York Times. New York Times says they are hiring a crypto and fintech reporter. Must be able to explain what Web3 is. Apply here. New York Times. Look at that. Getting in on the action too. Also going Web3. Everyone's going Web3. Everyone's going to the metaverse. We're all going there. They want to talk about it anyway. So super cool stuff to see. David, let's talk about some NFT action. You saw some of it. Lots of NFT action. This week. Yeah. What's this Quentin Tarantino thing?
Yeah. Quentin Tarantino, seven uncut scenes from Pulp Fiction released as NFTs. So he was at NFT NYC on a panel with some of our fellow community members, a coin artist, G Money, Quentin Tarantino, all sitting in chairs together talking about NFTs. That's a big name getting into NFTs. So NFTs, like got another one. Yeah, got another one. What's your favorite Quentin Tarantino movie, by the way? Do you watch any? Oof, oof. I was not prepared for that question. um i i can i defer to next week yeah yeah go watch a few and we'll talk about it next week go watch inglorious bastards jay go and chain is a good one that's a good one yeah oh no it's jay going change it's jay going change uh that's mine that's my answer yeah totally it's easy for me i love that movie um all right let's talk about the mcrib david mcrib is issuing an nft okay uh top signal um global adoption new paradigm it's it's top top signals all the way down um yeah it's just like a rotating like trading card but it's a mcrib uh mcrib has this like cult following mcdonald it's a pretty big deal that mcdonald's is releasing an nft of a mcrib uh again just legitimizing the technology like hey someone's gonna buy it have you ever eaten a McRib?
I have never eaten a McRib. I've never eaten a McRib. Do you know what it's made out of? Because I don't. I've heard it's made out of a bunch of BS that I don't want to know. So it's not an actual rip. And like the ripples in it are not actual like it's not an actual rip, right? Like it's just a synthesized rib? Fake rib. Well, I'll probably enjoy it more in NFT. Real NFT though. Real NFT. That's great. Alright, well I don't know if we peaked or not but McRib is on the blockchain, so that's great. How about The Matrix, dude? Actually, yeah, let's skip to that. We'll get back to this. The Matrix, the new movie coming out, they are actually issuing NFTs as well, right?
PFP NFTs? Profile picture NFTs. A hundred thousand of them, which is crazy. On a sidechain, right? On a sidechain, yeah. On an Ethereum-linked sidechain. Not a roll-up, just a sidechain. It's called Palm. but yeah 100,000 profile pictures for the matrix avatar is this the new style of marketing it's like oh yeah it is yeah it's like oh our movie's coming out let's try and get everyone to wear our avatars as the movie gets released if people get hyped about it yeah that's pretty cool and the numbers here you pointed out david 100,000 that's big for crypto right because usually these pfps are like 10,000 or something is pretty common but like that's pretty small for all of the movie goers who see the matrix right what are the box office sales and millions of people that go and we'll see it box opening weekend it's pretty small and it's it's very easy for them to release this digital nft merchandise i wouldn't be surprised in the future david this is successful every single release we're certainly seeing last week we talked about disney getting on it every single movie release you're going to see nft digital merches merchandise that you can purchase on top of this too here's like a possibility that i could see happening you know how twitter is integrating verify verifiable nfts yeah well what if you get an airdrop for verifying your matrix nft and having it on your profile picture for like two weeks because they want you to do that to market the movie and if you do that and like market the movie then you get an airdrop after the fact like imagine those games that could be played i mean marketers are going to come up with basically every every sort of iteration of what you're talking about david yeah i could totally see see that playing out um what's interesting too is uh in china the tech giants are saying yes on nfts but no on cryptocurrencies right we sort of seen this in the u.
s where web2 companies are like we're not going to do crypto payments that's a little scary but nfts oh yeah easy let's add some features you know tiktok twitter all of these things we're seeing that in china also yeah yeah from i think about this from a regulatory perspective like it's the same thing like no get the currencies out of here by nfts like sure whatever yeah sure we're not threatened by that we're not threatened by your jpegs by your axi it's a trojan horse oh my god that's what i was about to say it's the biggest trojan horse it's the biggest because without cryptocurrencies nfts actually don't work yeah like did you know nfts are actually secured by the cryptocurrencies on the chain right like that is the security mechanism the value of cryptocurrency that is a security mechanism for nfts and if they're not secured by a cryptocurrency then they're not nfts They're just entries in a centralized database.
So tricked you. We tricked you guys. By adopting NFTs, you are adopting cryptocurrencies, maybe without knowing it. So thank you very much. The NFT rug pull. I love it. Let's talk about this. Was this a rug pull or what? There was some CryptoPunk that sold for $500 million. It's the Bloomberg article. $500 million. For FYI, I think the biggest CryptoPunk sale ever was something like $7 or $8 million, something very, very high, but not $500 million. So what the hell happened? Turns out this guy wrote a smart contract, guy or girl, unknown person, wrote a smart contract that when the smart contract would receive the Ether, it would immediately send it back.
And so what happens is this guy put his CryptoPunk into a smart contract, borrowed a flash loan from Aave, just borrowed all money possible, And a flash loan lets you borrow all the money that's in the vault so long as you also return it in the same transaction, which is why you actually don't have to put up any collateral to do a flash loan. So this person just borrowed $532 million to buy a CryptoPunk. Once in that same block that CryptoPunk was bought, the contract returned all the money. So this person basically bought their own CryptoPunk for themselves. It wasn't a sale. It's like a wash trade kind of thing.
It's a wash trade, right? But they did set the all-time high sale of a CryptoPunk ever. And so what happened was that the CryptoPunk bot that goes out, the notification that a CryptoPunk was sold, one bot goes out and says, somebody bought a CryptoPunk for $532 million. Everyone started freaking out. It's not even that cool of a CryptoPunk. What the hell is going on? And then they realized that this guy just made a circular loop and it caused a bunch of storm. But yeah, it's a good meme, good joke, good riff. Now we're all talking about it. Yeah, that's the thing. we're all talking about it and uh we're all getting educated on flash loans because this one person i don't know who this is ryan uh patrick uh kerlin he says who the hell gives out 532 million dollar loan to an individual even for an instant who does that and then scott lewis is like uh the ethereum virtual machine does that it's magic that's how we do it and so what just happened do it with code yeah this guy wash traded it wasn't a real sale right but like these numbers, the amount of money that we're talking about gets headlines.
And then those headlines further propel this conversation and mainstream to start learning what flash loans are, what Ethereum is, what NFTs actually are, and what this transaction was really about. So kind of cool, kind of genius, I guess, from a PR perspective. Ryan, since you're the tax optimizer between the two of us, is this a taxable event? oh my god i don't even oh now you just ruined the rest of the episode i'm gonna be thinking about this the whole time in taxes no i mean if you're moving from uh one wallet that you own to another wallet you own it's not a taxable event there you go tax optimizer answer for the week thank you sir no taxable event david you can do that it's fine check with your cpa i know this is financial advice tax advice bitcoin stuff uh man quarterbacks sure do love getting their payment in bitcoin this is nf nfl star aaron rogers he is uh of the green bay packers he is getting some of his salary in bitcoin what's going on yep it's not not not the first time that that's happened some nba players have also done this some people just want to be paid in bitcoin uh and i've players like they have a lot of money right and so they like to they like to play in the money games too they play in the markets but and they like crypto markets just saves you a step i guess rather than buying bitcoin you get paid in bitcoin you don't have to do that step good marketing you still have to pay your taxes in fiat unfortunately but you know that's true yeah they won't be changing that anytime soon coinbase that's why they want to be paid in bitcoin so they can just like get it immediately you know yeah i i guess so yeah um i i see that you know i guess i'd rather to be paid in crypto in a lot of cases.
Coinbase is doing Bitcoin loans now. So the SEC shut down Coinbase Lend, right? Well, threatened them and Coinbase decided to withdraw. But Coinbase Borrow? That's what this is? That's okay? So what is this product, David? What's it doing? Yeah, well, famously, you can't do DeFi on Bitcoin. That's not what Bitcoin is for. You can take your Bitcoin onto Ethereum and then do the DeFi stuff there. Or now you can also take your Bitcoin to Coinbase and get your loans, your Bitcoin collateralized loans from Coinbase. And this is kind of how we've always said Bitcoin is going to like scale out as a currency.
It's going to use crypto banks and that's what's going on here. So $1 million loans from Coinbase on your Bitcoin collateral. Yeah, that's cool. It's interesting that they can borrow, but they can't lend according to the SEC regulations. It's completely nonsensical. One half of BlockFi, but we talked about that with Brian Armstrong too. You can listen to that on Monday. um what is the biden administration doing next they might be putting stable coins under federal supervision uh if you don't do that to congress biden administration says we will we will do that um what uh what's your take on this message coming to me this is relatively sensical sensical regulation yeah what i got from this is that the stable coin issuers need to be regulated as banks that makes sense the other thing that's also really nice about this is that biden is saying hey congress hey legislators the people that were elected please do legislation which i like way more than the sec which i did not elect to impose regulation what about this or we will part though david yeah or i think it's by or executive order which like yeah okay yeah they might do it anyway yeah um but also it's congress so like don't hold your breath like congress doesn't go very fast Yeah, it doesn't go fast at all, especially these days.
Jake Trevinsky, I think, had his take here. He's a great crypto lawyer. He's been on Bankless many times. There's lots to pick apart in the new stablecoin report. This is a report that was put out, I believe, by Treasury, I think, that's kind of related to that headline that we just read. But the TLDR of this is basically Congress has to act in order to enact the new legislation. And so I think what the Treasury is saying is basically like, hey, we'd like to do some things, but we really can't unless Congress acts. And Jake's point is like prompt action from this Congress on anything is unlikely, let alone on something like stable coins.
Like, this is not that big of a deal on the congressional agenda. They can't get any of the main initiatives passed that the Congress wants to get passed. Are they going to do anything with Staplecoins? No. So this is kind of a, I guess, a sigh of relief for people in the industry who are worried about some harsh action being taken against Staplecoins. That might be a bit, you know, we talked to Brian Quintenz. He talked about, like, Congress is either doing, like, not enough or, like, way too much. And so you got to watch that pendulum swing. And that was the worry that suddenly they would get draconian on stable coins and do way too much.
It doesn't look like that is likely, at least at this point, according to Jake. Yep. Agreed. Yeah. Very cool. David, let's talk about what China's doing. China is continuing to roll out its central bank digital currency. Did you know 10% of China's population now has a digital wand wallet? Yeah, that's crazy. Big moves. that's way more like there's not 10 how many 10 of people inside the united states play with crypto how much how much do you think people play with crypto inside the united states um well coinbase has 30 65 million um customers i guess some of that's worldwide so yeah 10 to 15 let's call it that okay okay well anyways no one's touching the united states central bank digital currency so if uh you know the united states would like to latch on to the success of defy they could actually be China in this, but I'm not holding my breath there either.
Yeah, they really should. I put out this tweet meanwhile in the US. Back to our favorite screenshot here. Congressional hearing. Cryptocurrencies, what are they good for? That's what the US is still debating while China is rolling out a central bank digital currency. Alright guys, we are going to be right back with the takes of the week, but before we do, we want to thank the fantastic sponsors who made this episode possible. The era of proof of stake is upon us. Proof of stake systems like Ethereum, Thank you. the network transaction rewards. Do you have 32 ETH and want to stake it to Ethereum, but running a node sounds intimidating?
Or maybe you have less than 32 ETH and you need to pool your ETH with others so you can access staking yields. Lido offers a solution for both. Simply go to lido.fi, choose which assets you want to stake, and deposit them to the Lido validating network. Lido is working to make sure proof of stake stays as decentralized as possible, and is committed to decentralizing its own validating network to eventually become a completely permissionless protocol. So if you want to stake your ETH, Terra, or Sol and get liquidity on your stake, go to lido.fi to get started. The Aave protocol is a decentralized liquidity protocol on Ethereum, which allows users to supply and borrow certain crypto assets.
Aave version 2 has a ton of cool features that makes using the Aave protocol even more powerful. With Aave, you can leverage the full power of DeFi money Legos, yield, and composability all in one application. On Aave, there are a ton of assets that you can supply to the protocol in order to gain yield, and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have supplied collateral. Here you can see me borrowing 200 USDC against my portfolio of a number of different DeFi tokens and ETH. I'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than the stable interest rate option, but I could choose the stable interest rate option if I wanted to lock in that interest rate in permanently.
V2 also features the ability for users to swap collateral without having to withdraw their assets, trade them on Uniswap, and then deposit them back into Aave. With Aave, users can do this in one seamless transaction, saving you time and gas costs. Check out the power of Aave at aave.com. That's A-A-V-E dot com. All right, guys, welcome back. We are here with the takes of the week. We go, we search the Twitter sphere. We search for all of the great takes that are happening in crypto this week. We try to dish them out to you. This is the first one. David, you want to read this out from Zeneca once again.
He made it last week, making it this week too. What's his take? Yeah. Zeneca says, on the calendar year of NFTs, we are still having breakfast on January 1st. What he means is if you take all of NFT lifetime, the whole entire progress and development in the stories of NFTs, we are just eating breakfast on the very first day. Basically, he's saying nfts have a long long road runway ahead of them have you ever seen like you know that reminds me of you it's like the the lifespan of of humanity and if you like project like the entire history of the universe uh and make that a calendar year then how long would humans be alive it's something like some sort of pico second like it's like nothing so it's nothing yeah we're very early not quite there but maybe we're just still on day one of nfts um david what's this take from eric Wall.
Yeah, Eric Wall says making a high throughput L1 to reduce gas costs is a bit like making a making a road wider to reduce traffic. In reality, the wider road makes people think, oh, I can take my car to work now instead of commuting. And then boom, traffic reclogs, it takes exactly as long as you took to get to work as it did before. And he is quote, retweeting Kyle Samani, when somebody was asking, hey, can like Solana do roll ups too? and yeah sure of course Solana can do roll-ups but the point is like if you can do roll-ups why do you scale the L1 right and so it's just what Eric's saying he made a great thread about this is that it doesn't make any sense to both scale the L1 and the L2 because you're putting an L2 which is really really really scalable scalable on top of an L1 which is also scalable but also not decentralized and so what he's saying is like Kyle Samani is saying like oh yeah Solana will eventually have to go to roll-ups because it'll eventually congest.
Kyle said that, which goes against the whole entire point of why Solana exists in the first place and is just being like, hey, we can just use penetrative pricing, cheap gas fees to undermine Ethereum. And then we're going to be the thing that goes to roll-ups because we totally know that we're going to be congested in the future. That's a total pivot, by the way. That's a total pivot because the entire purpose of chains like Solana, monolithic chain design, was high throughput on layer one so that you wouldn't need rollups. Why? Because the advocates of Solana would argue in rollups, you lose composability, right?
You lose this kind of atomic DeFi to DeFi sort of transaction ability. And so you need massive amounts of throughput on the monolithic chain on the layer one. And this is a pivot from that, a departure, a change, a 360, a, I don't know, sorry, a 180. Like, what else is this? I mean, it doesn't make any sense to me either. And Eric Wall is, I think, rightly calling it out. I think there is a path, as we said before, for the Solanas of the world to move into the roll-up design. And it's like twofold. Either you become a roll-up on top of some other highly economic consensus layer, like an Ethereum or something else.
So you become the execution layer or you move to become more decentralized over time. And you become a bit more Ethereum-like and you prioritize rather than scalability on layer one, you prioritize decentralization a bit more and security. And then in which case you're just kind of following Ethereum toward the path that it's taking. So this is what we've been saying, right? With the Ethereum ultrasound network, modular blockchain kind of thesis that we've been putting out there and others like Pauline and I have been putting out there too. That's exactly right. Well, let's talk about this. I read a letter earlier this week because Metaverse was all the rage, right?
You know, Zuck and Facebook moving to the Metaverse. What does this mean? And this is like an investor letter that said, oh, hey, if you're an investor and you want to play the metaverse the thing you should do is go buy facebook and go buy roblox all right it's so crazy to me that people still think that the metaverse will emerge from this old world that it will emerge from like one old capital formation tools like stocks and like two um old web 2 companies that don't really get it it's like folks the best way to play the metaverse is to buy ETH. It's to buy the property rights layer of the metaverse.
So if you believe the thesis that we believe, which is this entire metaverse thing has to be backed by strong settlement guarantees, strong property rights, like actual digital scarcity that's open and incredibly neutral. You're buying things like ETH. You're buying things like Bitcoin. You're buying the banking layer of this new economy, which is DeFi. You're buying Web3 type things. You're buying crypto money things. You're not buying Facebook and Roblox. My God. I mean, you could buy those things. They're not terrible. It's just like, why would you allocate capital to those old things when you have this new thing?
That's how I see it anyway. And so I just, it was just like a connection is people think, oh, the metaverse is hot and they really don't know what to buy or what to invest in in the space. And I think once again, the answer is really it's crypto. Yeah, 100%. And we haven't talked about this angle a lot lately, but Ether is one of the most fantastic indexes of what Ethereum is. And if you read our Metaverse Emerges article or our Metaverse podcast, everything when the Metaverse is built as a property rights layer, everything ultimately converges on Ether. And you finished this up with exactly what I was about to say.
ETH is Metaverse money. That's the whole thing. yep absolutely that is the whole thing and i don't think traditional investors and traditional media get it yet so that is a an opportunity to front run of course we're still the ability to front run the metaverse now uh david do this take uh it's really good from twitter yeah this is funny the first company to call it a profile instead of a wallet will win if you still think it's a wallet you don't understand its capabilities this is just lending itself to like you know your ethereum address is more than just like, you know, the place that you store your money.
It's your metaverse identity. It is your web three identity layer for the world. My davidhoffman.eth connects to my specific Ethereum address. And that is, you've called this before, my passport into the digital nation, into the metaverse. So it's not, these aren't wallets. These are profiles. I love, I love these small little paradigm shifts like that, right? Like wallet is a really good mental model, but also profile. Self-sovereign identity is a really good mental model. And I think that is starting to emerge in crypto as well. Hey, these things aren't just places where you can store assets.
These can actually be like the ability to log in with an ETH address is a real thing. Really cool to see the decentralized identity narrative taking form some more. David, this is your take. Why don't you say it? Yeah. Facebook's metaverse is Encyclopedia Britannica. Ethereum's metaverse is Wikipedia. And this is just basically saying, hey, Facebook is going to build their own metaverse, their own Disneyland, and they're going to invite you into it. Ethereum's metaverse is everyone's going to contribute and put their pieces of the metaverse into this larger and growing and open and free, larger metaverse, right?
And so this is just a fundamental analogy that we always use in the free and open source software world. Like, why did Wikipedia win? Well, it allowed anyone to write for it. yeah i think it's the difference between like like the united states versus um disneyland right it's like you couldn't fit the united states inside of disneyland could you yeah but like disneyland has to rest on something like the united states right so it's like facebook's metaverse really is going to be an app on top of this larger metaverse uh that that we think it'll be the disneyland version of the metaverse yeah exactly exactly right um it'll it'll still be there and people can go there people can visit they're just gonna be in the metaverse yeah it'll just be in our metaverse and it'll be the metaverse inside of the metaverse the disneyland metaverse yeah i don't think it's it's just not that complicated it's just like facebook is an app on the internet it is not the internet right it's just that um here's a scary thought i was thinking about this earlier this week as bullish as i am devon you know i'm bullish right and you know i don't think the the bear market is coming anytime soon i think we've still got a run in us but it is a scary thought to me sometimes when i see all of these token thoughts Probably close to 50% of people right now have never seen a bear market.
They don't even know what that looks like. Their only experience with crypto is, oh, I buy the thing and the number goes up. Oh, and it doesn't really matter what I buy because anything I buy, the number goes up. Right? And like, oh. JPEGs go up? Yeah. Okay. Everything goes up. All right. And some things just go up faster than other things. And so what do I want to do? I want to get in the, the, um, assets and tokens that go up the fastest, right? These are like little babies in crypto. Like, and I don't mean that in a condescending way. I'm just, they're so new. They're like newborn babies and they've never seen the real shit.
Okay. They haven't really like until you've been through a bear market and like everything gets tested, your conviction gets tested. all of your theses get tested and you've seen kind of the recovery of that the other side you don't really know what you own so many people like your friends and family people you like go to thanksgiving with they many of them will probably own some crypto but very few of them probably know what they own or why they own it right so this is actually a little scary to me A little concerning because, you know, bear markets can come. And then what happens when people don't have conviction in the things that they bought and they start to see a 20%, 30% decline?
They're going to head for the exits. And then it's going to make it worse, right? It's going to make it worse. It turns into a feedback loop, yeah. That just struck me. I guess like at some point in time, you get a certain amount of people who buy in and they don't really know why they bought in. and then it kind of like there's a tipping point reached where like something bad could happen right i guess that's what speculative bubbles are at the end of the day absolutely you have any thoughts yeah one of the guts that i that i try and listen to is like the um euphoria pain like spectrum like sometimes i'm like oh it's been a while since i felt any pain i've been feeling a lot of euphoria like uh lately like that usually means that pain's like around the corner yeah You don't get to be in markets and don't feel like both.
You get equal amounts of pain and equal amounts of euphoria. And there's been a lot of euphoria lately. And you can definitely tell that in how many strangers there are at this NFC NYC event. A lot of these people are just here for the first time. And they've been coming in when the times are good. There are very few people that have felt pain. So does this worry you, sir? Are you worried right now? Are we getting a little long in the tooth in this run? The thing is, like, I always leave room for a new paradigm. And so, like, I think, like, all of the pain that the collective crypto community felt during 2018, 2019, like, it's that meme of the army man protecting the sleeping child from the knives and the swords and the grenades and stuff.
I think maybe there's a world where we took that pain and shielded the 2020, the 2021ers from having to worry about that because we built all the infrastructure in the bear market. I think the other thing is once you go through a bear market, you're not worried about the next one anymore. It's like, what's the worst that could happen? I was making so many jokes this week. about like oh yeah all all the crypto people that i met in 2019 2018 like a lot of us are like gosh the bear market was nice like it was quiet back then like it was quiet good time to make friends good time to start things good time to build right and like if you didn't leave in 2018 2019 are you gonna leave in the great bear market of 2024 no it'll still be a bull market to us Exactly.
Anyway, I just, you know, it's something I'm thinking about. And again, I don't think this is imminent personally, but you never know. And markets can certainly turn in a hurry, at least in the short run. David, this is a means taken. It's actually a riff on the Reddit thread that we were talking on from that engineer who just recently joined Reddit. What does the mean say here? Amin says, the end users of Ethereum are no longer individual humans. It's roll-up dev teams building ecosystems. Let 1,000 roll-ups bloom. Ethereum as a civilizational trust anchor. And Ethereum is specifically talking about the Ethereum L1.
He's saying the end users of the Ethereum L1 are no longer individual humans. And Amin Soleimani, he's one of those guys that memed Moloch into existence. And this angle of Ethereum as a civilizational trust anchor is so great. And so Reddit, when it uses Arbitrum to scale all of its stuff, the entire universe of Reddit comes and settles on Ethereum. And that is why Ethereum is a civilizational trust anchor because it's not just Reddit. It's going to be everything. It's on a roll-up, settled by Ethereum, secured by Ethereum, allowing coordination to happen. So great take. Yeah, I really like that take.
And also let 1,000 roll-ups bloom, right? A roll-up can be whatever you want it to be. And this is Reddit creating its own roll-up. super cool i have actually a question for you david this is something i've been thinking about recently so let's assume as we are that the main chain is completely occupied by roll-ups in the future right so like large pools of capital that are settling on ethereum that means gas fees are not going down on ethereum mainnet anytime soon transaction fees on roll-ups will go down in the future but gas fees on mainnet will not does this mean there could be a lot of nfts like stranded on Ethereum in the future, right?
And I say tokens too, but NFT specifically because some of these are pretty, some of them can be very low value and they cost more to trade. Has there been any talk at NFT NYC, that sort of thing? No, no, I haven't thought about that, but that is a good point. I do believe that L1 gas fees are up only. And so damn, NFTs, a lot of cool stuff might get stranded on the L1 simply because it's just not viable to get it off there. It's something I'm going to think about some more. But yeah, anyway. Also, when Amin Soleimani says, let a thousand roll-ups bloom, that should be in stark contrast to what Kyle Soleimani was talking about when Eric Waltz retweeted him and talking about like, oh yeah, if you add more lanes to a road, the road just gets congested.
The way you add more lanes is you add more roll-ups because they're separate roads. More roads? Anyways. More roads rather than one super big road? Make more roads on the L2. That's what the L2s do. That's where the extra roads go. roads and bridges and all sorts of things uh this is scott lewis take ethereum isn't going to be a consumer facing blockchain for all that much longer that's what he means on the main chain right specifically so i was asking that question about nfts on main chain it's always been it's always been ethereum's plan to be in the background it's not supposed to be in your face it's supposed to be invisible just like tcpip uh and if ethereum hides behind these roll-ups that's perfect that's where it's supposed to be.
Yeah. You don't even know. Like it's DYDX. I mean, this exists in practice. You don't even know you're using Ethereum. David, you did this take. This is from NFT NYC again. Yeah. Somebody tweets out, the pro of being a woman at an NFT event is that there are no bathroom lines ever. And so Mike Dudas, who I actually met this week, great to meet you, Mike. He goes, crypto bringing equality to bathroom line waits. I experienced this for myself. I had to wait behind like seven other dudes to go to the bathroom while like the ladies room had no one in there that's funny maybe another push for this like unisex gender neutral bathrooms edge right it's like this even things out anyway um okay david before we get to uh what what you're excited about actually we're about to get to what you're excited about so let me just ask you what are you excited about this week uh yeah tell me well i've teased it throughout all of this roll-up but nft nyc was great i met cammy russo there i met her in person so i thought that was funny it's nice in crypto we're like you know you know defiant bankless like we're not we're not the same we're not different but yeah friend some friendly competition there like she's got a great newsletter we've got a great newsletter she's got a great podcast we've got a great podcast but in crypto like it's all love it's all love so it got to me uh cammy russo that was fantastic like i said met brian armstrong got to uh shout out to the pleaser dow family which we call ourselves a dow but we're really a family uh even though i'm like the least active member of the team.
But like, you know, hanging out, listening to the Wu-Tang album, it's like, I keep on chilling in real life events. Maybe Ryan will come to one one day. Maybe one day. Maybe. Definitely next year, okay? The culture and vibes are really, really great. And again, you got to find your clan. You got to find your community. Find your people. There's somebody, the first ever crypto event I ever went to was ETH Denver 2018. I met two people there from the Brave team. Luke and Jenny. I saw Jenny for the first time in four years this year here in New York. So that was pretty cool. Yeah. Like again, the crypto world, the longer you're here, the more it feels like family.
It's really cool too. A bunch of people shared values as well. And I'm glad Kami probably recognized you unlike Brian Armstrong, right? But I see your AIM username, uh aol username there blackjack davy so i understand yeah it's a totally different shout out to jack white and the blackjack davy song that i named myself that's awesome man ryan i think i just got a tease about what you're excited about so tell me too quickly but you know this okay um bankless dow the dow punk kind of um project that spun out of bankless dow had an nft drop and that happened last friday it was awesome dude it was just really fun i uh I mean, you know me, look, I'm into turtles, okay?
But I haven't jumped two feet into the whole NFT game. So this was the first time I got to experience a whole NFT minting from the ground up. And what was cool about this was like, this really started with the community first. So there was a culture and community for DaoPunks. And what is that culture in the community? It's like a bunch of people who want to say, F the nine to five, right? Like we want to self-organize in these new capital structures and social structures and work for DAOs full time, right? This is about going bankless, which of course we are fully into bankless culture and saying like no to the establishment.
This is about going west. And so a lot of this culture and these values were really imbued in these DAO punks. uh and uh so i minted some nfts and then i purchased a few nfts um like on the on the secondary market and again i don't do this a lot so it's just really fun man and i love the nfts all of these are going to be uh actual uh physical merchandise too so this is the bridge of the real world and what i saw in the community was you know not a lot of shilling not a lot of like what's the floor price checking, not a lot of like, it was just a very long-term kind of thinking, new vibe, new culture, right?
Very sustainable culture. Sustainable culture. And you talked a lot about like, what's a DAO? It's all about like flow. It's all about like the vibes of the DAO. And I think I felt that in a, in a, in a cool way. And you know, tying that to NFTs is cool. So what do you think of my collection here? Not too bad, right oh i oh i love it ryan yeah yeah i'm trying to pull up mine right now but i don't think i'll be able to do it in time i was trying to wow you you've got some good ones wait some good ones okay so i mentioned these two look i minted this one and that one right which are great they're great but like i really wanted a um i wanted one of these either crypto natives or a shadowy super coder and i wanted one specifically with like a bankless bankless box and um so anyway i i found somebody in the dow channel who's willing to like just you know sell me one that wasn't posted in the market so i did that and then i also bought this which is a great one yeah it's like you know it's rare it's um got this interesting skin uh it's a creative number 35 anyway it's really fun i know you had a lot of fun too so do you have yours can i pull yours up yeah i just sent you my my nft address in the chat so if you want to put paste that into open c it'll take you there because i i also like mine one of the cool things and cool things like like you said in the discord felt very sustainable felt really great oh there it is trust the state okay yeah uh and like uh the thing is like i made a joke in the discord like these dao punks are going to simultaneously be with zero and also infinity yeah because no one wants to sell oh someone sold me one oh i got a new one oh the which one the oh these ones bottom one yeah the pjs yeah ultrasound summer oh dude these are pjs this is ultrasound summer yeah that's a good one man that was another one top of my list but yeah tell me about which ones did you mint uh i minted the left to the top left two the ones with the orange backgrounds yeah and then the the other three that i bought um i i offered a guy 3.
5 eth and a trade on one of the crypto or dow punks that i already had and he was like no man like i i it would be really nice to have that eth but uh it just it meant it was two two sentimental value like and i i had this conversation like three times like another person's like no like i i that's a nice offer but like i want to give it to my wife uh and so like no one's telling me the dao punks that i want right i have a list of a few others that i'd love to get but i'm just not seeing them on the on the secondary market and offers aren't going through this is uh this is probably my favorite in your collection here that's my that's my bankless ninja i call that my v for vendetta dao punk because he looks like he's about to hack a bank yeah that's awesome this one looks good too that looks like that one's super cool yeah anyway look i guess i'm down the nft rabbit hole now like you know i guess turtles was kind of my my first experience with the doubt punks you know i got some like a few other things but um yeah i'm glad the turtles are in the rear view mirror ryan hey i haven't sold a turtle i will look it's turtles will come back okay david but you know gotta give it a rest after dressing like turtle last week all right i hope listeners are ready for the meme of the week let's finish this thing out meme of the week what is this from nifty nod david yeah he says can't see it any can't unsee it anymore and we have netflix google meta instagram and if you are looking at this it very clearly spells out ngmi as in not gonna make it now i think netflix might have got some uh collateral damage here i don't have any problems with netflix uh i mean it was an end we needed an end okay we needed an end but yeah all these web 2 companies not gonna make it i'm just not gonna make it that's awesome definitely the meme of the week i think maybe the meme of uh the next era the next decade we'll have to see what happens um of course guys none of this has been financial advice eth is risky defy is risky you could lose what you put in all of crypto is risky but we are headed West.
This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but thanks for joining us on the Bankless journey. exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you Want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders Ask me anything's and weekly roll-ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation