4th Week of January, 2023
------ Crypto Tax Calculator | Free Crypto Tax Calculator https://bankless.cc/CTCpodcast
------ JOIN BANKLESS PREMIUM: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/subscribe
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/kraken
UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
EARNIFI | CLAIM YOUR UNCLAIMED AIRDROPS https://bankless.cc/earnifi
----- Resources:
0:00 Intro
4:20 MARKETS 9:00 Inflation https://twitter.com/NorthRockLP/status/1617593771222519811 11:00 Crypto Revenue https://cryptofees.info/ 15:50 Aptos Mooning https://decrypt.co/120009/whats-going-on-aptos-price 18:20 dYdX Rally https://thedefiant.io/dydx-rallies-18 19:00 Optimism All-Time High https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/optimism
24:00 Genesis Chapter 11 https://www.theblock.co/post/204035/genesis-owes-more-than-3-6-billion-to-top-50-creditors 27:00 Gemini Earn Users https://twitter.com/cameron/status/1616298056097624064
29:00 SEC Ban Hammer FTX: https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/2023/lr25617.htm Avi: https://twitter.com/secgov/status/1616531972020469781 Nexo: https://www.theblock.co/post/203983/nexo-pays-45-million-to-settle-sec-and-state-charges-for-failing-to-register-lending-product 34:55 Hester Peirce https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/peirce-remarks-duke-conference-012023
40:20 Kevin Rose NFTs Stolen https://www.coindesk.com/web3/2023/01/25/kevin-rose-says-nft-wallet-with-dozens-of-high-value-collectibles-hacked/ Bad UX: https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1618329248275795968 Behaviors: https://twitter.com/iamDCinvestor/status/1618351192358408194
48:30 Shanghai Shadow Fork https://decrypt.co/119851/ethereum-shanghai-mainnet-shadow-fork-goes-live 49:30 Uniswap v3 on Binance Chain https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2023/01/23/uniswap-poll-shows-80-support-decentralized-crypto-exchanges-move-to-bnb-chain/ 50:30 Wormhole Hacker https://cointelegraph.com/news/wormhole-hacker-moves-155m-in-biggest-shift-of-stolen-funds-in-months https://twitter.com/0x_Osprey/status/1617603687702224897
53:00 Doodles on Flow https://twitter.com/poopie/status/1618271090459160577 https://twitter.com/doodles/status/1618262941287211009 55:10 Pudgy Penguins https://twitter.com/pudgypenguins/status/1618288231552004100 https://twitter.com/cyounessi1/status/1618273523671396354 56:05 Sewer Pass NFT https://www.coindesk.com/web3/2023/01/12/bored-ape-collections-pump-ahead-of-upcoming-sewer-pass-nft-mint/ 58:00 Yuga Arbitration https://twitter.com/flyabstractart/status/1616179578224926721 1:00:30 Porsche NFT Fail https://twitter.com/BcSmithHere/status/1617524649700757511 1:03:00 The Rug https://therug.mirror.xyz/biX_10PO0yD8nN_lN6ctr3tOa2X5CtFonDOtzl80dAY 1:04:05 Peter Thiel Sold BTC https://archive.ph/8XLr6#selection-1985.281-1985.356 1:05:20 Proof of Innocence https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1617999327867338753 1:08:15 Robinhood Wallet https://decrypt.co/119594/robinhood-wallet-metamask 1:10:00 QuickNode https://www.theblock.co/post/205028/quicknode-reaches-800-million-valuation-in-series-b-round
1:10:30 Questions from the Nation https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/subscribe
1:19:00 TAKES of the Week 1:20:00 RAI Mistake https://twitter.com/ameensol/status/1617582677833699330 1:24:50 No Bailouts https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1616536164621774849 1:26:10 Omnidimensional https://twitter.com/trustlessstate/status/1617734657759670276
1:28:00 What David’s Bullish On 1:30:00 What Ryan’s Bullish On
1:32:00 MEME of the Week https://twitter.com/icebergy_/status/1611153750432825350
MOMENT OF ZEN https://twitter.com/Xofee3/status/1618406659659038720
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Kevin Rose has gotten his multi-million dollar NFT collection swiped drained, so that's unfortunate news. We'll talk about that and we'll also talk about how you can protect your NFTs from getting fished, because if Kevin Rose can get fished, you can too. Bankless Nation is the fourth Friday of January, David. What time is it? It's the Friday. Bankless weekly roll up, Ryan, where we cover the entire weekly news in crypto, which is always an ambitious endeavor, yet we persevere nonetheless into the frontier. With coffee, I've already had two cups. How many are you at? Four or five? You know they answer this.
It's always the same. I'm pretty regular. You know, like a regular coffee-drinking old chap is what I am. How's your ember mug? It's pretty good. It's retaining the heat. You use it all the time? This is not an ad. Actually, it's not an ad. No, actually, so what happened is my office is right down the hall from my kitchen, and I would go from my office to my kitchen many times a day to heat up my coffee. The most frequent time you would leave your office is to go do that. Well, but think about it, right? Three different coffee heating cups of coffee times five, it's 15 per day. Anyway, my microwave button broke off, like completely like disintegrated under the pressure of all of the clicks.
So I had to order a 3D printer part. I'm just getting into the microwave of this robot not learning how to like control its own strength and just like snapping off its microwave paddle as it tries to open the door. No, it's going easy on it, but yeah, it just wasn't built for that kind of that kind of pressure. Anyway, we're not talking to microwaves or coffee today. What are we talking about? Topics of the week, David. What are we covering? Topics of the week, Genesis officially filing for chapter 11 that saga is coming to a close. So we discussed the fallout, of course, sadly, in other news, Kevin Rose has gotten his multi-million dollar NFT collection swiped.
Ryan, what else are we going to talk about? We're going to talk about the SEC. They came in with a big old ban hammer this week, Caroline Ellison, Gary Wang, Nexo, a whole bunch of action by the SEC. We're also going to be talking about a fire speech from SEC commissioner Hester Purse. Stay tuned for that. And doodles, migrating to flow, Pudgy Penguins, migrating to Arbitrum Uniswap, migrating to BSC. Is everybody moving from Ethereum, David? We're going to talk about that too. And of course, we've got to remind you to like and subscribe if you enjoy this episode. If you're on YouTube, hit that like button, subscribe to the channel.
If you're listening on the podcast player, then hit subscribe as well. David, before we get into this episode, got to talk for a minute about taxes. And you know, I've always taken the time to talk about crypto tax calculator during the last few weeks. This time is your time. I'm going to hand this to you. What do you want to tell us about taxes and crypto tax calculator, David? Okay, so if you're like me, you majored in a discipline that has nothing to do with money or finance or any and your parents are saying and never taught you about taxes. And so you had to figure it out for yourself because crypto was your first entrance into the world of business and finance and also taxes.
And that probably means you need something like the crypto tax calculator that we are showing on the screen right now because you don't know how to do taxes. And so you use something like the crypto tax calculator, which there's a link in the show notes to go use, to help you sort out your crypto tax nightmare, especially as crypto is getting more complex. First, you have ether, then you got staked ether, wrapped, staked ether on arbitrum that is going to yield farm that is brand new. Well, crypto tax calculator can help you out with all of that. It's got all the layer ones, all the layer twos, many, many defi apps, 300,000 currencies, which I didn't even know we had that many.
And it's as simple as just plugging in your Ethereum wallet, putting in your transactions, and they will do the rest. There's a link in the show notes for 30% off for bankless listeners. That link, that code is bank 30. But if you are a bankless premium subscriber, you get 40% off from a secret code that is in the bankless nation discord. So go there to get your tax off. How do you like that pitch run? That was pretty good. Guys, take it from the psych major, not from the business major. I think you pitched it better than me, my friend. Business majors don't need to tax calculator nearly as much as the psych major.
That's right. And I was too excited about it. That was actually practical advice. Good job, David. All right, let's get to markets then. Bitcoin as measured by dollars. We still measure Bitcoin in dollars. We don't measure it in Bitcoin. Dollar currencies. Let's see, where are we at on the week? Up or down? Big up, almost. Big up again. Big up again. Start of the week at $22,200, up 9.2% to where we are now at $23,000. How are we doing this? This is like three things keep going going up, man. I mean, I'm going to start having to say bear market with a question mark at the end of it. Bear market.
Let's not get ahead of ourselves. We'll talk about that. Well, I mean, it's been three weeks and we're almost double digit. Let's talk, eat the price, too, is that up to? 1530 was where we were last week. We were at $1,600, a hair above, oh, a hair below $1,600. We were above $1,600 a second ago, up 4.5% on the week. So only up half as much as Bitcoin this week. Does that mean Bitcoin gained some ground on the old ratio? That means we are down below 0.07 on the ratio 0.069. So I mean, just noise, brother. Just noise. Do you still have any bets outstanding on this ratio? I think it might be that you see ratio is like that is a multi year long long position.
I'm holding. How are you doing that trade? It's a compound. No, excuse me. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Well, cool. Yeah. So you bet that ratio and holding for the long run. What's your time horizon on that multi year, you say? Two years. Until the lapening. Yeah. Not the flipping. Okay. The lapening, which is what? Double two X Bitcoin. Yeah. Two X Bitcoin in market cap. So maybe even the third lapening, who knows? Okay. So what does that mean? Ethan would have to appreciate by what? He's at 5x. And so if we if we if Bic ether doubles versus Bitcoin, that's the flipping from and then it doubles again versus Bitcoin, which is the lapening.
So that is up four X from current Bitcoin prices is when I will perhaps consider to unwind this trade. Perhaps perhaps. But then you'll feel like it's, you know, only going to go up from there. Yeah, exactly. Like I said, like if ether doesn't stop at the flipping, it starts lapping Bitcoin. That's that's how it goes. Can you imagine the in this industry on the day that that happens? The flipping happens. Can you imagine? It would be the most healthy and progressive thing to ever happen. I don't think it's going to sound very healthy on like your Twitter feed or my Twitter feed when that day happens.
Yeah. But I'll be feeling okay about it. All right. Global cryptocurrency market cap. We above a trillion. Above a trillion and 1.08 trillion dollars. Yes, that's right. That's a lot. That's it. That's a big number. Yeah. And it's pretty big for it. Like are you hearing anybody saying crypto is dead this cycle? Yeah, Jimmy Diamond said it this last week. Yeah. Okay. Well, Jimmy Diamond's been consistently wrong in crypto for the beginning of time. That's right. There's less of that than there was last time around, I think. I mean, there's fewer people saying crypto is dead. Right. And that was one of the best things that died in the 2020 to 2020 bear market.
It was like no one after big crypto, Ethereum, Bitcoin came back from that bear market. That was the last time I heard like it could all go to zero. Like, I'm sorry, Bitcoin cannot go to zero. That won't happen. Same thing, same thing with ether. Like it's just not going to go to zero. I mean, a trillion is definitely not dead. This very much alive. And yet it somehow feels like would we get to last cycle three trillion? Almost four trillion. No, just about three. Just a hair above three. It still feels to me like crypto hasn't had its big one yet. Like it's big, big run up. God. What do you think?
I mean, like if you think of the dot com bubble, for instance, and you kind of measure that in today's dollars, that was something like seven to nine billion. Excuse me, trillion. In terms of the inputs crypto bubbles to shame, yeah. It was real big. I don't think they'll stock market. Yeah. Yeah, I don't think I don't think we're there yet. My mental model for this. And there's nowhere. I'm not going to be able to tell if I'm right on this at all. But just like, okay, so we had the 2013 bubble. We had the 2017 bubble. We had the 2021 bubble. To me, this is like the crypto engine, like tumbling over.
You know, when you have an old car, and it's like the cylinders tumble, and it doesn't start and it tumbles and it doesn't start, every single bubble is like a tumble. But these things are getting bigger and also kind of faster, a little bit TBD. But the idea is like we just start to tumble and tumble and then the engine starts to rev and then crypto takes over the world. Yeah, well, that engine feels like it's revving anytime. It's a load of trillion. All right, let's talk about inflation. What is this chart showing us? Yeah, this is a chart from Hal Press, which is just inflation. Typically goes down as fast as it comes up.
So the headline CPI inflation for 1980 peaked at 50% year over year and then it slowed at the same rate that it went up for the next three years back down to 0.2%. So I asked Hal for a source on this one and he said it's just like national economic data. So it's like pretty, pretty damn verifiable. The take here is that inflation goes down as fast as it goes up, which is while we're still in the early days of data of declining inflation does seem to track so far. So basically, we went up last summer all the way to 9% and if we are kind of on the other side of the peak year, then we can expect of the next 12 months to fall back down to what?
It's a question. This is 2% 2%. That's what happened in 2023. Yeah, I don't know. I mean, are we ever going back to 2% sure question? Well, it's all relative. So like if we if inflation went down to 2%, it would not mean that prices went back to normal. Like eggs are still going to be high prices. The rate of increase is now stable now, which is fine because that is what we need. We're what we are doing with inflation is resetting the denominator and resetting the debt. So like debt is too large and so we had to keep on inflating and interest rates makes the debt too hard to pay for and so what did we do?
We just cut the value of the dollar in like half and now that's so much more manageable. I still somewhat wonder if the new normal is going to be above 2% though. I mean, like it's been 2% for like the 90s, right? Sure. Kind of the existence of most people's adult life. I think that has to be above 2% because we have too much debt. I think the new normal will be like a 3%, 4%. I think that's very possible. We might not get back here too much. Let's talk about earnings in crypto crypto revenues. I love this. We haven't pulled up crypto fees.info in a while. That's why I wanted to put it on our weekly agenda.
I don't know when the last time you looked at this was, but I'm tell us what we're looking at for somebody on the rollup who hasn't seen us pull up crypto fees.info. What are we looking at? What does this tell us? So there are two things that we're looking at here. There's pink and there's white lines on this list of things that generate fees. Pink are applications like Uniswap of a GMX liquidity, white, non-pink, or Ethereum, Binance, Marketing, Bitcoin, or actually like blockchains. So there's different ways to measure this. The Uniswap fees, which are a seven-day average of $1.4 million generated over a seven-day average.
So that's per day. $1.4 million per day over seven-day average is the fees charged by the Uniswap protocol to traders to go to LPs. Top line revenue. Top line revenue. Ethereum and also Bitcoin and also Binance Marchain are like basically gas fees. The fees it takes to transact on the network. Ethereum is making $4 million a day over the last seven days on average. Binance Marchain is the next closest profitable blockchain at $5.5 million a day, followed by Bitcoin at $350,000 a day. Wow. Yeah. It's not zero. It's not zero. Well, let's pause here. Okay. So when you say top line revenue for Ethereum, how is it generating this revenue?
Gas fees. Gas fees. Gas fees. Gas fees. Yes. Okay. So what's it selling? Block space. Block space. It sells you the space for you to put the data into the block so you can do your thing. Because, guys, blockchains, so blocks. That's what they do. That's the thing that they do. And sometimes somehow every single cycle, we seem to forget this. We forget this. So what is the difference between, so look, Ethereum is about $4 million in sales per day. That's how much block space it's selling per day. Bitcoin, $356,000 worth of block space per day. It's actually rate higher than I thought it'd be. That's higher than you thought?
Yeah. But look at the Delta here. I mean, it's over 10x. Yeah, it's over 10x. But that's the smart contract premium. Bitcoin is like, all right, I'll send you big coins. And then I'll also open up a lightning channel. Ethereum is like, what you want? You want to mint some NFTs? You want to mint some tokens? You want to take some leverage? What you want to do? Yeah. It's got more to offer. In other words, the utility or the value of its block space is worth more. Yeah. It's very high. And are there any other layer ones on this? So we talked about B&B, which is that's always been a little bit weird because it's super centralized.
But it is producing revenue. And then what do we have coming in at number four? We have an L2. Yeah. Wow. That's the first time I've seen L2's on here. Optimism coming in at $40,000 a day. Polygon, $39,000 a day. Arbitrum, $1,000, $28,000 a day. These numbers are super low, but we also have to remember they don't have to pay for security by in the nature of layer two design. So coming in after Arbitrum, actually, depending on how you measure it, Solana made less money than Arbitrum yesterday, but it's made more money over the last seven days. I've never thought about it this way, but in a way, like, if you look at a layer two like Optimism, it's kind of like a reseller of Ethereum block space.
Yeah. That's a good way to put it. Because it's basically, it's kind of like, it's taking the Ethereum product block space. It's making it more valuable. It's adding its value on top of it, and then it's reselling that to all the consumer. That's interesting. But the next close is layer one, alternative layer one, Solana with $45,000,000 per day. Yeah, making over the last four. No, no, no, no, 45,000 per day. Yeah, making less money in the last 24 hours, less than Optimism, less than Arbitrum, less than Polygon, yet it also has to pay for security. So the other website that we also go to is MoneyPrinters.
info, I think, and you'll just see the absolute rate of inflation on a lot of things. We could do monolithic layer ones. We will hammer this into your head. Blockchain sell blocks. They also collect revenue. If they sell, if they issue more currency than they collect in revenue, they are inflating, and that's bad for sustainability. Yeah. It's why it's like, here's the thing. I think it was YouTube chat the other day when we were doing a live stream. It was like, why don't you guys talk about these other alternative layer ones, acting as if they should be valued far less than a theorem? I'm like, because of this, go to this site.
Discrepancies. Their revenue is down. They are not selling their blocks. Their product is less valuable than even layer 2s. By definition, their product is to not charge fees, which makes them fundamentally unsustainable over the long term. The product is broken. Anyone can sell a product where you're losing money. I don't understand why this isn't more widely. I don't know, I don't know, too. We're just dumb eathmaxies who don't understand. It's just economics. It's just science. What's going on with the price of Aptos? That's a really good question. Well, do you have any answer? Did you know the fully diluted valuation of Aptos right now is at $16 billion dollars?
I did know that, David. That is deeper than the fully diluted valuation of Coinbase. Remember that exchange that little exchange? It's $12 billion. Aptos for my god. It was $16 billion when I looked at it yesterday at $18.6 billion dollars. Look at this chart. Coinbase, the exchange from 2011 or whatever it got started, is at $12 billion. Who the hell is buying this? I think the inflows are actually coming from Korea. This is a 6x from January 8th. It's going real. It is an empty blockchain. There's nothing going on there. There's some stats here for you, David. The TVL, Total Locked Value, Vanity Metric for Aptos is $58 million dollars.
$58 million dollars. That's with an M. That's less than most DeFi apps on Ethereum. The valuation is $18 billion. The Total Locked Value on Ethereum is $32 billion. That's what the B. The valuation of Ethereum is $196. If you do that math of Total Locked Value divided by fully diluted valuation, you can do. That means Aptos is 53x more in terms of its value in the market than Ethereum. It seems like quite a hefty premium. I'm having trouble understanding why. I'm not one to be so foolish to short anything in crypto because why would you ever short something where there are just apes involved?
You just say, man, is that really an enticing short? You're going to do it? No. I don't even know how. If it was a token on Ethereum, it'd be easy. I don't know. I'd have to go do it in some centralized exchange. But would you do it if you could? If it was trivial for me? Yeah, I'd probably throw some pocket change at an Aptos short. Just for fun. Just for fun with me. Just to say I did it. I just never short things because it doesn't matter if it's the most obvious short in crypto history because apes will liquidate you. Have you ever seen people do these angry shorts? They're like, the market's wrong.
Aptos shouldn't be this high and they just like angry short it and they're just like, they're not right. But it doesn't matter because the volatility still equates them. They might be right like two or three years later. DeYDX is also rallying. The reason why is because they postponed an unlock of tokens. That's basically it. It's a dumbest reason to rally. That's the tokens. It's pretty dumb reason. Do we know that this is true because sometimes people just like to ascribe things? Sure. It does seem like it's true because the news came out where they were like, the unlock will now begin December 1st rather than some other date.
Anyway, when that happened then the price rose. So we're trading right now. Cool. Cool. An unlock. We can just kick that can down the red. But optimism is up to you. You want to talk about that? Optimism is that all time highs. OP token. I'm sure if arbitrum had a token it would probably also be I'm assuming these things will trade in parallel with each other. Optimism coming in at almost a $10 billion network which is pretty damn crazy. It's hard to value these things because like optimism still still still do. What am I looking at here? This is coin get go. This is just this is not fully diluted value.
That's market cap valuation. Yeah. So market cap is the discrepancy between the supply of not much supply on the market. Not much supply on the market. But that's just a function of like how they're just slowly air dropping out their tokens slowly releasing it. Right. So there's a lot of locked tokens. Market cap is something like half a billion but fully diluted valuation is that 10 billion. So it's actually technically not unlike aptos in that there's a very small float and a very high fully diluted valuation. But when you buy these things you need to look at the fully diluted valuation because that is the valuation that you are buying these things at.
If so you're a long-term holder. If you're a long time holder. Yeah. Yes. Yeah. But at least there's real actual innovation and activity like velodrome on optimism is hitting volume all time highs. So there's actually like justifiable. It is kind of it's like in a much more advanced AMM. It's a little bit it's kind of a hybrid between curve and uniswap a little bit but for any token like curve specializes in like two like assets where velodrome is a little bit like uniswap where it's not like a to be assets press assets aren't supposed to be priced on parity. We did an episode with a few months ago and then after we did the episode the price absolutely moond I'm like why didn't I buy it?
Yeah why didn't you David? I died because it's tradition that's why. Yes it's tradition. The number of times I've done a show on something I'm like hmm that's kind of bullish and then I don't buy it and then the show goes out and then the token price it goes up is that that's happened to handful of times. Definitely it would be by the way guys in the case you're listening if there was a purchase of anything that David made prior to doing a show that would be listed in the disclosures on our website. I know also mentioned doing a show and also mentioned at the beginning of the show. So even if David tried to fake pump and dump us he actually couldn't because we have that in place.
Also let's like not what I'm interested in doing. I don't need to do that. You don't want to pump and dump. At least want to hold for the long term and be boring. Exactly. All right what's coming up next we got some non-boring stuff. It got some non-boring stuff. Yeah. So Genesis filing for chapter 11 so that is finally wrapping up. We'll talk about that SEC coming in a hot Ali iceberg the mango market manipulator got charged by the SEC Gary Wang and Caroline Ellison charged by the SEC Nexo charged by the SEC lots of things to talk about and then Hester Perse of the SEC comes and delivers a fantastic speech which Ryan and I just absolutely gushed over.
We'll talk about that and then also a bunch of NFTs migrating, Uniswap migrating to Binance, everyone on the move, lots to talk about. We'll also talk about how to make sure that you don't get your NFTs fished all that and so much more. It's going to be a big roll up after we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make this episode possible especially Kraken who is our strategic sponsor of 2023. Cheers. Kraken has been a leader in the crypto industry for the last 12 years dedicated to accelerating the global adoption of crypto. Kraken puts an emphasis on security, transparency and client support which is why over 9 million clients have come to love Kraken's products.
Whether you're a beginner or a pro, the Kraken UX is simple, intuitive, and frictionless, making the Kraken app a great place for all to get involved and learn about crypto. For those with experience, the redesigned Kraken Pro app and web experience is completely customizable to your trading needs, integrating key trading features into one seamless interface. Kraken has a 24-7365 client support team that is globally recognized. Kraken support is available wherever, whenever you need them by phone, chat or email. And for all of you NFTs out there, the brand new Kraken NFT beta platform gives you the best NFT trading experience possible.
Rarity rankings, no gas fees, and the ability to buy an NFT straight with cash. Does your crypto exchange prioritize its customers the way Kraken does? And if not, sign up with Kraken at Kraken.com slash bankless. How many total air drops have you gotten? This last bull market had a ton of them. Did you get them all? Maybe you missed one. So here's what you should do. Go to earnify and plug in your Ethereum wallet and earnify will tell you if you have any unclaimed air drops that you can get. And also those pro apps and mintable NFTs, any kind of money that your wallet can claim earnify will tell you about it.
And you should probably do it now because some air drops expire. And if you sign up for earnify, they'll email you anytime one of your wallets has a new air drops word to make sure that you never lose an air drop ever again. You can also upgrade to earnify premium to unlock access to air drops that are beyond the basics and are able to set reminders for more wallets. And for just under $21 a month, it probably pays for itself with just run air drop. So plug in your wallets at earnify and see what you get. That's E-A-R-N-I dot fi and make sure you never lose another air drop. We said it would happen last week.
And now it happened. Genesis filing for chapter 11. Here's the story. Genesis owes more than 3.6 billion to top 50 creditors. The papers were released. We got some more data on this. David Phyllisson, what's happening with Genesis? Yeah, Genesis Global Files for bankruptcy protection and the US Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York in the filing. The company publishes a list of its top 50 unsecured claims. So if you are curious about it's a whopping $3.6 billion to its just its top 50 creditors. $3.6 billion it's owed. Are you on that list anywhere, David? No, I'm not. Okay. I think I am by proxy.
Yeah. Well, I think I think you are joined by many, many, many people who are who are that because like again, it turns out yield is just this gravitational black hole. And so all the yield that was created in the last two years ended up flowing back into Genesis. It was the keystone of contagion. So the list of creditors is going to be large. $3.6 billion is owed. Does not say how much they have assets under management. That is not a $3.6 whole as a $3.6 amount owed. They have some amount of money and they're on their balance sheet that they do have. So it's not the whole size. Where's some of the big ones?
Miranda Corp. 151 million. I don't know what that is. Babel Finance. I've heard of them. 150 million. Van Eck, you know, Van Eck. I went to their biggest commercial. I went to their talk a lot too long ago. Well, they're at a lock $53 million. It's a whole big list here. A lot of people affected by this. Genesis is literally at the end of the road here. But okay, so Genesis goes bankrupt, but not DCG, interestingly, which is kind of the parent company of all of this. Yes. So DCG is letting Genesis go into bankruptcy without coming to save it because the hole is probably too big for that to be saved.
For them to want to do that. And so that's also why they are selling coin desk. Did you hear they're selling coin desk because they need to raise capital and like a parent. I heard prices on Twitter of like 25 to 30 million. I would like to that be really corroborated. I think that's just a rumor. But the price, the speculation on Twitter was like the prices that are being offered for coin desk is $25 to $50 million, which is extremely low. I think that's low. But it was how much it's hemorrhaging. Right. Yeah. I know coin desk has a ton of employees. Not be profitable. Yeah. Well, we all thought the block.
I thought everyone was like, oh, the block company like turns out they're not profitable. Yeah. Like anyway, I should imagine having a profitable video. All right. We'll earn, get their money, their users money back. That's a big question. And I know Cameron Winklevoss and Winklevoss have been all up in this. This is Cameron Winklevoss with an update on earn. This is the big question. It means like $900 million. I'm just a billion dollars of retail funds in Gemini earned. We'll investors, I guess investors. Will people get their money back, David? So TPD. So quote from Cameron Winklevoss is that Genesis bankruptcy does not insulate Barry, DCG, or any other wrong doers from accountability said Cameron Winklevoss.
Gemini is preparing to take legal action against Barry, DCG and others for the fraud. So the idea here is that they are saying that fraudulent activity happened. It's outside of Genesis. It's Barry and all of DCG. And so if even if Genesis can't make Gemini earn customers whole, we are going to sue DCG and Barry Silver for fraud to get the rest of the money back. So with the Winklevoss twins continue to be coming in very hot with accusations of fraud. And we will only be able to tell what the truth is after everyone has their day in court. But Gemini twins coming in very hot. This is interesting.
I just ran the Matthew. So $900 million divided by $340,000 earn users according to Cameron Winklevoss. It's about an average of $2,600 per user. So I mean, these are smaller retail types of accounts. And that could be somebody's like savings. They're crypto savings. Hopefully not their life savings. Don't invest more than you could afford to lose and certainly don't lend it out to a crypto lender. Gemini laid off 10% of staff amid troubles, which by the way is not a lot compared to like a crack it. Just in 20 minutes. It's their third round of layoffs in the last eight months. But like 10% is relatively normal, especially when like other like Web2 companies are laying off similar.
Yeah, totally. It's just not just a massive layoff. Coinbase is dumplings. All right. Well, we're going to continue to talk about this as it comes up. But we got more the SEC band hammer. What are they doing? SEC charges Caroline Ellison and Gary Wang with defrauding investors in FTX absolutely no surprise there in the press release. It's charged that Caroline Ellison manipulated the price of FTT by purchasing large quantities on the open market to prop up the price again, which was the collateral that much of Alameda and FTX used to borrow with. Overstated the value of the collateral and the balance sheet led to all of this explosion at FTX and over over a crazy amount of risk exposure.
The complaint stated that Wang created the FTX back door allowing Alameda to divert FTX customers funds and Ellison used misappropriate FTX customers for Alameda's trading strategy. I think as these people go through the process of being in court, we're going to find out how much did SBF actually know because he claims that he had no idea that Gary Wang had the back door between Alameda and FTX. How could he have known that? His exchange and his prop trading desk having a back door with each other. How could he have known? Yeah, impossible to know really. You got to feel for the guy. Caroline Ellison was the former CEO of Alameda, right?
Yes. And then Gary Wang was the CT of FTX. Correct. Basically operating is the same. Very incestuous. Yes. All right. So that's hit number one from the SEC. What about number two? Ali Ellsberg, the guy that manipulated the mango markets on Solana and then took that money over to Ove to try and do a short squeeze on curve or something, but then he got liquidated blah, blah, blah, blah. I think the ACFTC is going after him too, but the SEC charged Ove with market manipulation, which is what he definitely did. Ellisonberg is in federal prison awaiting transport to New York City and the SEC labeled mango token as a governance token offered and sold as a security on the crypto platform mango markets.
So this is perhaps sitting in precedent. What is the mango? The Eason mango markets. I think it's like an Ove. Solana DeFi. It's a Solana DeFi thing. Yes. I think it's like a borrowing lending protocol. Yes. Funny to me is I'm like the headline is this guy apparently stole 116 million crypto assets. I'm like, oh, that's not that much. Holy crap. It's 116 million. What has happened to me? Yeah. Yeah. Like measuring things in the billions for the fraud. Well, he was the guy that tweeted out, we just engaged in an extremely profitable trading strategy and everyone was like, bro, you stole that money.
It's called a set deal. It's called market manipulation and theft. And he tweets about it. He did it out in the open. It's like, it was a very profitable trading strategy. Yeah. Market manipulation is profitable. Do you know when YouTube influencers and stuff and TikTok influencers will literally film the crimes that they're doing? I post it for cloud. This is what this guy was doing. Advertising his big wins. Yeah. And it was in the form of market manipulation. So that's number two. Oh, it's just, yeah, same thing. How about they hit someone else? Next zone. Next zone. $25 million dollars. That's what you see.
Charge. Next zone for failing to register the offer and sale of its crypto asset lending product. It's interest product. Next zone's agreed to pay the SEC 45 million dollars and have ceased the sale of the earned product to US investors. This is why next zone said that they were leaving the US market last December, citing a dead end in talks with US regulators, which is kind of on par with conversations we've already had. SEC charged Gemini Earn and Genesis last week for the same thing. Also told Coinbase. It would sue them if they released Coinbase's earned product as well. And so this is kind of far in line with all the other things that the SEC is doing to be mean.
So I feel like, you know, lots of times, Bankless has a lot of scolding for the SEC. Like, we're like, what are you guys doing? Stop doing like, what are you doing? Can we be mad about some of these actions? I mean, the SEC taking on a market manipulator for the mango token, the SEC taking on the FTC, FDX executives and doing that. I don't know about it next step, but like, even those two, isn't the thing we want the SEC to do is come after like the clear scammers and grifters. Like the BitConnect guy from 2017. Isn't that where we're crypto is basically, hey, we could use some help in these areas.
So I almost feel like I want to praise them for this. We're like, say thank you for some of these things. And yet, David, I'm like, I'm worried to say that because I don't know what the lines of demarcation actually are. And like, it's kind of like, oh, you give them an inch and they'll take a mile sort of thing. And so just, I don't know how to really address this or how to talk about it. I don't know if you have any takes on that. But, yeah, what do you think? My take has been what it's always been, which is if it can be regulated, then it ought to be regulated. If there is a central, low-key of power that the SEC has the ability to apply pressure to and that works, that means that that thing that they're applying pressure to is sufficiently centralized to the point where there is a discrepancy between public market information and private actors, that means there is a principal agent problem.
And so it's a little bit kind of judging after the fact, like if the SEC can apply pressure, then they ought to. But that's just what the nature of decentralization is if they can. No, so I agree with that line, right? I agree with that line. However, like, so I think you almost have to get even more detailed there. Sure. Because that's a guiding principle. But like, how do we know? Yeah. Either scan can be regulated. It is a centralized company. Right. Could be regulated as a broker dealer. Or like, if you're a, for instance, are we going to make, remember that was actual legislation material from SBA?
We should regulate all of the D5 frontends. Do you remember this? I understand that. That's a good point. So how do we do this? I guess one of my takeaways last week was like a breath of fresh air. Esther Purse, who is a commissioner of the SEC, gave a speech at a digital assets conference at University Duke. And this is just exact, like, I don't know how to articulate it the way Hester does, but the way Hester articulates the role of the SEC with respect to regulation crypto is exactly. It's so good. What we want. It's we should be close from this fresh reminder of how things ought to be done by in the nature of why they were created in the first place.
Here's a here's a quote. Hester says, cryptos value proposition depends primarily on the builders of this technology, not on the regulators like me who lack technical expertise and stand on the periphery looking in. What a great posture to the space. Some of these lines are so great. What else you got? My favorite line here was privately designed and voluntarily implemented solutions can be both more effective and more tailored because the people driving them better understand the technology and what they are trying to achieve with it iterating and experimenting with private solutions is easier than it is with regulatory ones.
Moreover, private solutions avoid the systemic risk that comes from an industry homogenizing because everyone has to fit into the same regulatory parameters. Like my drop. Oh my god. It's such a powerful line. It's so good. It's just also the principles of just like frontier innovation always happens when you let the free market do its best. And this is what I've seen not necessarily that CC at large, but Gary Gensler really getting in the way of is just like really pushing back the freedom of the frontier to explore and innovate. Like, yes, we find trouble on the frontier and then we route around it and you're not going to do that, Gary.
She also says this regulatory solutions which tend to be inflexible should be a last resort, not a first resort. I also appreciated David how this speech was also directed to people in crypto said this to us to the bankless audience. I think people who believe in crypto's future should not wait for regulators to fix the problems right regulatory solutions which tend to be inflexible should be a last resort, not a first resort. I said that already privately designed and voluntarily implemented solutions are much better at fixing things than regulators using their inherently coercive power to impose mandatory solutions.
She says later, crypto is about solving a trust problem. How can you interact and transact safely with people? You do not know that is the core of it. Anyway, this whole speech is fantastic and I just like the posture of a regulator really taking the time to understand our industry. What's up? If you go to the footnotes, David. Look at these footnotes here. You're going to bring out multiple bankless podcasts. Yeah. Three bankless podcasts. What's up, Hester? Shout out. Thanks for listening. Taylor Monahan. YouTube video on the brink episode. She listens to all three podcasts we do. That's great.
I mean, this is what we've asked the SEC and our regulators to do is we don't bite, engage with the crypto community. We want the scammers out too. We want your help to do that. Can you take some time to understand to talk to us? Anyway, this speech made us, once again, so excited and so bullish. We reached out to Hester person's office and asked if she'd want to come to the show. I think that's in progress. She said I'd absolutely love to. Hester purse round two. People don't know that the crypto industry have warmly dubbed Hester purse crypto mom way back when for offering the stances that she's been put forth in here.
Also, you know she's a regular listener because she cited our is everything a security episode with Brian Fry. So, you know, she's paying attention. Yeah. Yeah. She actually mentioned the fifth prong of the highway test. Yeah. The speech. Did you read that? Oh, no, I missed that part. Yeah, she did. She she said, and yeah, fifth prong of the highway test. Some people have observed is does the SEC want to regulate this? Right. Which is like this exactly from Brian. I mean, the only prong of the highway test. Anyway, I'm just big listeners. No, we give regulators a hard time sometimes and I think a lot of that's justified.
But we want to call out when they're right and when they're trying to do the right thing. And let's keep in mind regulators are just people. They're citizens. This is a layer zero type of thing. And when they're when they're fulfilling their mandate in like for the people, then I think that's a much healthier place to be. So just hats off to this particular regulator doing this work. And we hope more of them step up and do this and SEC, CFDC, all the government agencies and every jurisdiction around the world. And just to really drive this point home, the reason why we spent time to talk about this is like we talked about, okay, the SEC charged Caroline Ellison and Gary Wang with defrauding investors and FTX.
Uh, yeah, that's good. Uh, charging Ali Ellison Ellison Ellison with market manipulation. Like, yep, that's good. Uh, Nexo for failing to register like the facts and circumstances. It's a black box. We don't really know. Um, but like the point is it's like the SEC, the Caster in this article said, hey, crypto is not a monolith and we need to judge crypto individually about by facts and circumstances. And I think that's how we should approach the SEC, facts and circumstances for every single decision they make. And that is what we are trying to do here. That's right. David, Kevin Rose had a real bad day earlier this week.
Here's the headline. Kevin Rose's NFT wallet with 40 high value collectibles was hacked. This was a fishing scam, David, that drained millions of dollars worth of rare tokens. A lot of very valuable NFTs on this list. What did what did Kevin Lutz in this hack? Yeah. So 40 NFTs, like you said, one auto glyph, which hurts my soul, auto glyphs is such a such a treasure. There's not that many of them. 25 Chromy squiggles, which is the first one. Uh, that's a Chromy squiggle. Yeah. Yeah. Uh, 25 of them, uh, which is the first art block ever created. Uh, one Q, Q L mint pass, which I don't know what that is.
One admit one pass from G money. I've got one of those. Uh, a cool cat NFT, the currency NFT by Damien Hurst, of quantum key, several on chain monkeys. But, uh, it was nice to see that he owned a zombie crypto punk, extremely rare, extremely valuable, and that one was saved. Um, but all the other ones were sadly lost to a fishing scam. Uh, the way that this worked is the fraudulent website. Uh, he proved a transaction, that transaction, bundled up all the, all the NFTs that it was preparing to, to bundle up and then sent them outbound from Kevin Rose's wallet all in one go. Uh, so quite unfortunate.
Sorry, Kevin. That is terrible news. Um, and this is just part of part of the early days of crypto where we still need to work out some of these kinks. This is a problem that only we as an industry can solve. Do you know that line? We say at the end of every show, which is you could lose everything. Uh, basically, this sort of thing can happen. Uh, this was a fishing attempt that got Kevin. Um, this was my take on it, David shortly after it happened. I said, it looks like Kevin Rose just had millions of dollars in assets stolen because he clicked the wrong transaction. And how brutal is that?
You just click the wrong transaction. Imagine if swiping your credit card at the coffee shop, put you at risk for getting your entire bank account drained. I think, David, this is really bad UX. Honestly, it's something that crypto has to fix before it goes mainstream. Some people say there's ways Kevin could have protected himself for this 100% agree yet if he's a bit more careful. And yet he's a seasoned veteran. He's probably kicking himself now. Right. Um, but like this could happen to anyone. Buddy, we know in crypto, like a simple mistake of I am signing a transaction that I think is legit from a wallet where I have a lot of different tokens or assets.
This type of thing can happen. Right. So how do we solve this? Do you do you agree with me that this is up to the crypto industry to solve it? Like it's a big UX problem. There are things that you can do today to make sure that you never fall victim to this. And it's just a matter of taking the extra time and energy to do the thing. DC put out this, this wallet best practice, which I thought was very, very valuable. And also it's really the first two points that I think everyone can do. If you are engaging with a wallet that has a ton of value in it, you should consider that when you do something, the rest of the things in your wallet might be at risk.
And so what DC investor is advocating for in which is a great system is that have people in the NFT world do this quite frequently. You can see people's like vault address in their name on OpenSea. Have a vault address. And what that means is like you put all of your high value NFTs into that vault address. You send it from your hot wallet to your vault address like cold storage, cold storage. Yes. You never ever approve any NFT for sale from the vault address. If you would like to sell that NFT, you send that NFT away from the vault address to a wallet that doesn't have much money in it. And then you approve it for sale from that wallet.
And what this does is that it only approves things to be sold from that hot wallet. So like this is how like if you ever want to sell something on OpenSea or any other NFT marketplace, you have to give a smart contract a approval to access that specific NFT set. This is how Kevin got fished. He said, I'll sell this NFT. I approve what he actually was doing. Not on OpenSea, right? Not on other web sites. Some other fishing website, right. It's probably somebody was like, Hey, Kevin, here's something for free. I don't know if it could be something like this. And so he approved an in bulk all NFT outbound transfers from that wallet.
And then that's more contract to did that. So what you do is that you only transfer one NFT into your wallet that you plan on selling. And then you just sell that one NFT. And then once you're done, you send the NFT back into the vault wallet. So the vault wallet never ever approves any smart contract ever permissions to move your NFT. And so one is literally Fort Knox. And then this hot wallet is the one that you can collect all of your, you know, smart contract STDs is kind of what some people call them. STDs. Yeah. Yeah. So like, have you ever gone to like delegate.cache? For example, this website, the DC Scott, it'll show you sometimes like you load up your wallet and it's like, I've allowed all of these smart contracts to access my money.
Yeah. Like most of the time, smart contracts are safe because they're not owned by anyone. But if you approve a smart contract to access your money, and that smart contract is controlled by someone, they can remove all your money. All right. Well, so let's double click on this. What is delegate.cache? Should people go do this right now? Delegate.cache is a way to delegate a specific authority to have some sort of access to a hot wallet. There's also revoke, try revoke.cache. I think that's the one. That's what you're talking about. Right. Yeah. And that can show you all the permissions that you've enabled for a specific wallet.
Yeah. You can unenable, unrevoke those. Yeah. Yeah. Definitely some things that you need to do as an early crypto native. We're settlers on the frontier here, right? We're basically beta testing all of these things for the rest of the world. And so we get the upside from that. We also get the pain when this sort of thing happens. So you need to protect yourself. It really is the Wild West right now. And I think DC has some valuable ways to fix this. Also though, David, back to kind of the point, it's still really bad UX. It's bad UX, right? We have contract walls. We need smart contract walls.
We need contract walls. And I do think that this will be solved over time, but we're not ready yet. All right. David, what do we got coming up next? Coming up next for the rest of the week. They roll up when with draws. When with draws, Ryan, I would like to withdraw my ether psych nor when I'm taking forever. But I think my wormhole hacker is now the fifth biggest owner of staked ether. And Ethereum NFTs are going multi chain as well as Uniswap going on to Binance crazy. All of this and more as soon as we get to some of these fantastic sponsors that make this episode possible. Uniswap is the largest on-chain marketplace for self-custody digital assets.
Uniswap is of course a decentralized exchange, but you know this because you've been listening to Bankless. But did you know that the Uniswap web app has a shiny new fiat on-ramp? Now you could go directly from fiat in your bank to tokens in DeFi inside of Uniswap. Not only that, but Polygon, Arbitrum, and Optimism layer twos are supported right out of the game. But that's just DeFi. Uniswap is also an NFT aggregator, letting you find more listings for the best prices across the NFT world. With Uniswap, you can sweep floors on multiple NFTs and Uniswap's universal router will optimize your gas fees for you.
Uniswap is making it as easy as possible to go from bank account to bankless assets across Ethereum and we couldn't be more thankful for having them as a sponsor. So go to app.uniswap.org today to buy, sell, or swap tokens and NFTs. Arbitrum 1 is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web 3 landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum 1, producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With a recent addition of Arbitrum Nova, gaming, and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitrum Home. Both Arbitrum 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible.
On Arbitrum, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees. With Arbitrum's recent migration to Arbitrum Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit Arbitrum.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app. With Arbitrum, experience Web 3 development, the way it was meant to be, secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. All right David, when withdrawals, when are people going to be able to withdraw their eith from the beacon shade? Still don't know, but we are one step closer.
A Maynet shadow fork are in full address rehearsal for system upgrades, which has allowed developers to test for flaws of the withdrawal contract. We have done a successful shadow fork of the withdrawals contract for Shanghai. This is one of the last big things that we needed to get done in order to actually do withdrawals on Maynet, so this means that we are still on track for a March, perhaps, delivery of the Shanghai Hard fork that is not official. Do not quote me, but we're looking good. David said March. You can quote me quoting David. Uniswap poll just shows 80% support for going to Binance, BNB Chain.
That is, what is this? I can't wait for the headline to come out. It's like, Uniswap Abandon's Ethereum. We're getting a Uniswap on Binance, so Binance is not a layer 2 on Ethereum, but it is a EVM clone, an EVM fork, which means it's relatively trivial to deploy a Uniswap V3 there. Since Binance actually has real adoption, Uniswap is like, yo, let's go to Binance. So 20 million Unitokin holders voted yes, 6,500 Unitokin, so they're doing it. Yeah, voted no, and so they're doing it. Yeah. Do you care about this? It's not bearish for Unitokin. I think the only thing that's really relevant is for the Unitokin here.
It doesn't put Ethereum under any threat as well. They're not migrating and leaving. They're just adding. It's adding more. Uniswap is on Arbitrum. It's on Optimism. It's on Polygon, and now it's also on Binance. The story on Coinbase, of course, with the Uniswap floaty here. I don't understand this image. It's hard to get images for crypto headlines, man. True, true. Wormhole Hacker moved $155 million in the biggest shift of stolen funds in months moved it, and then also staked a portion of this with Lido. It started doing some things with it. So refresh us on the Wormhole Hacker. It made up with like hundreds of millions of dollars in hacking this bridge protocol.
It's still live on chain. We could track it, of course, moving from place to place, and now they're active again. Yeah. So Wormhole Hacker, third largest crypto hack in 2022. Wormhole is the bridge between Ethereum and Salona, backed by jump. Jump actually filled that hole in Wormhole. They took the hit there to make people a hole again. 120,000 ether was stolen in February 2022 during the hack. So the hacker has now transferred $155 million onto some exchange. Then went on to swap that around in various DeFi protocols. The latest on-chain activity has a 995,000 ether sent to open ocean. I don't know that text.
And then converted into east pegged assets like staked ether and rap staked ether. And then what they did with all of their staked ether is they used it as collateral to borrow 13 million die, which they then swapped it for more staked ether and then wrapped that staked ether again and then borrowed more die. So they are leveraging long on their staked ether. Still a bunch of ether and now they're leveraging it up. So they are now the fifth largest holder of staked ether. Yes. According to you this suite right here, which is pretty crazy. Is this threatening at all to eat a protocol like Lido?
So let's say the authorities say, hey, you can no longer interact. Protocol can no longer interact with this specific ethodress. Why? Because it's a criminal. See, we find out the hacker is like North Korea or something like this. And it makes its way on an o-faxation list, this specific address. Is this threatening to maker? Is this threatening to Lido at all? Yeah. So I put out a suite. Can Lido compensate this east, this staked east? Turned out the answer is no. And I'll go back to what I was saying earlier. If it can be regulated, then it ought to be regulated. And if it cannot be regulated, then it's fine.
And so hackers, like Ethereum doesn't know the difference between a normal good person and a hacker. It's just everyone's free to the equally. And if no protocol has the ability to do anything about that, that's just the way that it is. And you can bet that the authorities are watching these funds move and waiting for this person to slip up so they can nail them in real life, which is fine with me. NFT stuff. Okay. Did doodles just move to the flow blockchain? I think so. Here is a tweet from, I think one of the founders of Doodles, Doodles NFT project. So why did we choose flow for Doodles too?
And he goes on, he states, why? What's the TLDR of why Doodles is moving to flow? They think that they can get better customer user onboarding using the flow blockchain. They think the UX is easier. And so newcomers can just get better access to flow by all the various differences of the flow blockchain. My critique of this is always that like, yeah, of course, things like flow are better or more like web too. And therefore easier for new users because they are web too, because it's centralized. But that's just my. Last time I think that flow is in the context of top shots. And even top shots was kind of named in this tweet.
In fact, the flow founder says, this is how top shots got to 400,000 people, newcomers can create a wallet by signing into Gmail and then buy an NFT with a credit card. It's like, yeah, it's like, it doesn't. Okay. All right. So that, I mean, that is interesting, right? And you kind of wonder if other NFT projects are going to migrate. I've, you know, we've long known that they would migrate off of the theory and main chain, of course. But the big question is, where do they go next? And it seems like the answer for Doodles was flow. I also somewhat wonder, David, if this was subsidized, I know many blockchains, even layer two's, but certainly alternative layer ones essentially subsidized projects in order to kind of move to their chain.
So I wonder if some of that was involved. Here's full letter to the community. Is there any takeaways from this? Yeah, it's just like the Doodles community knows that they're going to offend a certain set of their cohort of their community because, you know, the flow is just, it's just not crypto aligned. It's not crypto native. Yeah, at the same time, as an Ethereum person, we should take this as a signal that our layer two's are not ready to do the things that they will eventually be able to do. And so other layer other systems, ones that are more centralized and have compromised have been able to adopt protocols like this because they can just have better onboarding experience.
That's great. Bring on the competition, right? Sure. Pudgy Penguins is doing something too. What are they up to? Migrating to other ecosystems, such as Arbitrum, Polygon, and BNB. So Pudgy Penguins, using layer zero, which is a cross protocol into communications protocol, has allowed for cross chain bridging for little Pudgies, one of the derivative projects, so that you can find little Pudgies across more walkings. This is a take on all of these happenings from Cyrus Unessi, what's he say? Yeah, he goes, as an eth-maxie, I'm disappointed by this. I love the fissitious self-laviiling of eth-maxies, by the way.
As an eth-maxie, I'm disappointed by this, but every layer two builder needs to read this thread and figure out what type of onboarding and user experience they need to provide if they want to scale into the masses. It's just a fair reason we'll take. It's like, our layer twos are not as polished as compromised layer ones, but they need to be. Absolutely. David, you told me this was big news, but I wasn't following a board and ape community, launched a new collection, apparently, an upcoming sewer NFT pass. What is this? No, it's no longer upcoming. It is released. Sewer NFT pass. It's a game called Dukey Dash, released by Yuga Labs, and in order to access this game, users had to hold a sewer pass NFT that was free for all board-ape or mutant ape holders.
A new NFT that was created, that was claimable by board-ape and mutant ape holders, that I can't remember what the price for one of these NFTs started trading on the secondary market and was definitely non-zero, definitely a good price. The game instructs holders to reach a score above zero, to validate the sewer pass, and then transforms them into a mysterious power source. Okay, the wealth effect from board-apes and Yuga Labs is absolutely insane, because if you are board-ape holder, you got to mint a mutant ape. You got to mint a board-ape kennel club. You got access to the other side mint.
You got the coin, the ape token drop. Now you got this NFT. So a lot of people who are outside like me looking in at the board-apes are like, why are those floor prices so high? How is the ape coin so high? Well, it's because of the wealth effect. Yuga Labs keeps on air-dropping, like so much value to the ecosystem. Yeah, but it seems like the community is really sticking around. It doesn't seem like some of these coins. Yeah, because they're making them rich, dude. But we're in the bear market, and if everybody was leaving, if everybody was pressing the cell button, they would no longer be rich.
It seems like this community is here to stay. Right, because the dividends you get from holding an ape has been, it's paid for the ape five times over. I'm saying I'm bullish on any community that is surviving and thriving in this bear market. And if that's what this community is doing, then it sort of makes me bullish. Not enough to buy an ape, but what else they do? And this is a tweet. The board ape yacht club organization sets a huge legal precedent yesterday for the whole NFT space. What is this huge legal precedent? This kind of went unnoticed, but you brought it to our attention. Yeah, so in the terms for this surapass dukey dash game, there was an in the fine print by minting this NFT.
I believe this says by accepting these terms, you are agreeing to resolve any dispute between you and you glad is through binding individual arbitration rather than in court. So I if I'm reading this and not a lawyer, but they're saying, Hey, by participating this, you remove your ability to take you glad to court for any dispute. And then they also finished saying you also waive any right to participate in a class action lawsuit or class wide arbitration against you got labs. So that's new out of the NFT industry. What's your reaction to this round? I you know, the reaction is obviously before minting, you're going to hit with one of these gigantic terms of service agreements from here moving on.
Yeah, like every every project is going to have one of these to cover themselves. And that makes sense. But it's also just like, okay, well, that's back to the legal system. How many terms of services have you ever read before like clicking your iPhone update or, you know, whatever it is? Yeah, I mean, I cool, I guess. This to me, this is the private market filling in the holes that things like the SEC and the CFTC have left. It's like, they haven't given us any clarity. So teams like you go labs are saying like, Hey, in order to participate, you can't sue us. Maybe it's fine. That's fine for me.
But I'm okay with that. Then covering their ass. And it's not like created a new governance structure for like board eight holders to settle their disputes amongst one another. They're just saying, if you click, if you mint this thing, then you can't sue yoga, which covers them. But I mean, it's like, you doesn't matter what asset, one NFT, if people buy it, and then it goes down in price, if it goes down enough, people sue. It doesn't matter like what the precedent is or like what the grounds are. They're like, I'm going to sue. And so like, this is just you go labs finding a mechanism to protect themselves from that.
And this is the private market, saying like figuring out when there's lack of clarity or lack of investor protections, the people issuing the tokens get to get to determine what the protections are. Yeah. Well, my only take here is, I don't know whether it's good or bad, but I know it's going to be omnipresent from here out. The Porsche NFT collection failed to gain traction. Man, what happened? People not into Porsche NFTs, David? Yeah. So Porsche NFTs, Porsche, or is it Porsche, Porsche release an NFT collection? I think like 10,000 of them for selling at a whopping 0.911 ether permit. And what does the NFT look like?
It is a JPEG of a Porsche. It's a JPEG. Porsche. I love that. David and I don't know for sure. Of course, of course, I'm not a car guy. I don't know if you are. Are you a car guy, David? I've got. Oh, I would love cars. I would love to tell you about my car. I know because I people, bankless listeners know we're huge sports guys, but we've never had the car conversation. Oh, actually, I'm not a modern car guy. I am an old car guy. Just like, it's like your music, right? You listen to like a lot of old guys. Well, since we're talking about it, I'm going to go send you a photo and we're going to talk about my car real quick.
Do I have to do this right now? Yes, you do because you brought it up. David, I drive a 2015 Honda Odyssey. Okay. I'm not that way. Honda Odyssey was the car that I was riding in when I was being driven to soccer practice. There's no shame in that. All right. It's a good car. I'm sending this to you. I'm going to take you from A to B. Guys, I am anxiously awaiting, sorry, for the interruption this roll up. I'm anxiously awaiting David's car picture. Wow, this looks slick. Man, this looks like something old James Bond would right here. Right? Can I find this? Let me. Yeah, right, right. Click it and there you go.
We're going to show the big list nation. Look at that. What is this? That's my, that is a 1972 Volvo P 1800. You still on this? Oh, yeah. Yeah. That's sitting in the garage of my house back in Seattle. In real life at FT, guys. David, I was wondering, I didn't know this. That car has been in my family longer than I have. No way. Yeah. So this is a family, not a family, family car. I have a family car. It's called a hodja. Honestly, I don't know what this is. This is not a family car. It's an heirloom. That's awesome. All right, guys. Well, that was our car talk. So expect to hear more car talk from Banclas in the upcoming episodes.
Actually, that will never happen. What do we got? Next, David, back on track. Of course, the NFT didn't work out. Yeah. There was a supply of 7,500 of them. I think they sold 900 total. Yeah. So they did not flop or did flops. Excuse me. Did flop, huh? They're big flop. Oh, moving on. So made about 1000 ease. David, some interesting news here too. I think you're going to have to have to have those brand brand new headline Trump NFT holders have been air dropped classified intel by Donald Trump himself. Actually, no, that's a rug. That headline brought to you by the rug, which is a product out of the Dow.
This is something I think we're going to try and experiment with. But the rug is a weekly issue of a, it's like the onion of crypto aliens invented Bitcoin, Canadian government sends Ukraine $45 billion of SHIB, chat BT, satire for shit. It is, there are some of the headlines are pretty damn funny. Gemini suspected of being run by one or more evil twins. If you are not paying attention to the rug, there's a link in the show notes. You can collect this post on mirror, by the way. And so moving forward, the idea is that we are going to slip in a rug every single weekly rollup. And we're going to read that that headline at some point in the time.
This was the rug this week. This is the rug. Yeah. Y'all just got rugged. Trump NFT holders air drop classified intel. I think that's pretty funny. That was funny. And tells you the news fan, everyone's getting classified intel. All right. What do we got next? Peter Theo wound down his eight-year-long Bitcoin in March of 2022. So he sold pretty damn close to the top. And a very early supporter of Bitcoin cashed out in March of 2022. You know, not long after being crazy on the Bitcoin 2022 stage, but that's the topic for a different day. He held his Bitcoin for eight years though. It's yours. It's long-term holder.
He made about 1.8 billion. He bought his Bitcoin in 2014, and then just sold it in March at the like good timing March 2022. And then went on a Bitcoin stage and talked about how bullish he was on Bitcoin in later that year. Was it later that year? Was it actually after he sold might have been at the same time. When was Bitcoin Miami? Is it March 2022? Maybe he went David. You think he went to that conference? It's like these people are crazy. And my God, it was in April. It was in April. Yeah. He sold in March and started chilling in April. What was he doing? I'd be a little mad at that if I didn't more.
I mean, if he's going to buy back in at the bottom, that's fine. Like you can't guy-held for eight years. He's held longer than most people should. Yeah, sure. Like sold in March and then went to the conference in April. Oh, Wales. What are you going to do? All right. On releases this week, so somebody built a really cool protocol. I would guess a protocol kind of extension. It's called Proof of Innocence. It's built on tornado cash. I think the best way to think about this is it basically enables a tornado cash user, which of course, David and I are not because we're a US citizen. No longer.
And that would be illegal. I was. David once was. And what it does is it essentially allows you to cryptographically prove that you or your ethodress is not on an OFAC sanction list, even though you've interacted with tornado cash. So the builders are calling this a proof of innocence protocol uses cryptography to do this. I think it's brilliant, David, because of course it is basically OFAC and Treasury, of course, kind of OFAC is an organization under Treasury. There's a sanctions list. And what they did was they blank it, banned everyone from using tornado cash. That is if you're US citizen, you couldn't use it.
And a whole bunch of people said, including us, what about the legitimate uses of tornado cash? Are you saying no one who is an American citizen can have access to on-chain privacy? Are you saying all of us are criminals? And OFAC's response was like, yeah, basically that's what we're saying. Not only that is that probably unconstitutional and possibly on its way to the Supreme Court, there are multiple lawsuits. One, which includes my co-host David going on right now. Now we have a tool that we can use to cryptographically prove that we are not criminals using tornado cash. I think this is magic.
You can view the details if you're interested in this. There's a medium post in the show notes. But my question that the Treasury is basically this. All right, can you un-sanction the code now? Because if we run this tool and basically prove that we are not some of the addresses that you suspect are North Korea or other sanctioned type addresses, that we are just average Americans looking for crypto privacy. Or maybe OR the question to Treasury is, was this really not about protecting us from criminals and terrorists all along? Were you trying to do something else? That's the beauty about this whole thing.
This is a statement of speech. It's not, I don't think it's really about the actual implementation of this code. It's about making a point, which is that now users can access privacy tools while proving that they're not North Korea or any other illicit actor still have their privacy, which is their constitutional right and then prove that they're not a criminal. If OFAC doesn't remove this tornado cash now from sanctioned code, it just proves that it wasn't about North Korea in the first place. It was about making sure that they can spy on us. Thanks to the billers you're building it. Thank you.
Why have we left? Cryptography. Cryptography is both the solution of the problem and the solution to all problems. Yeah. Cryptography maximalist around here. Robinhood has just rolled out a new wallet, a new crypto wallet. They say it's going to be a competitor to Metamask and they plan to onboard a million users this way. David, I think we've got a beta access to this. I haven't had a chance to test it out. Robinhood is very much known for their design. I know we talked to the Robinhood's founder back in the summer and told us this was coming. Now it's finally here. I'm excited to have new wallet entrance on the scene because I think competition will drive better solutions to the market.
This is great to see. You know those Robinhood users are going to be super picky. They're not going to accept gas fees or anything like that. This wallet has to solve that. This is built on polygon right now. They're also going to add support for Ethereum and there's probably a way to get into some beta access. Then I think that will release to everyone later in the year. David, this is a new product from index co-op. What's this? A diversified state, eth index. It's just basically all of the state ethocans inside of an index. That's that. Well done. Some of them are risky. Some of them are less risky.
We've got some names. They're all together. They're all together in one kind of packaged risk model for you. Diversified portfolio. That is defiant for you. David, some raises this week. What's this first one? Centrifuge raised $252 million to add more power to the real world asset revolution, which is a revolution. I'm a big fan of. Centrifuge is the system that helps put debt products on chain loans, et cetera. Been around for a while. Long-term cooperation with both maker and Ave to help take real world assets and put that value of real world assets into DeFi, allowing maker doubts and not just be the central bank of Ethereum, put the central bank of the whole entire world, which is why I'm bullish on it.
We got this as well from QuickNode. Tell us about this. QuickNode, $800 million valuation in their series B, series B raised $60 million. Basically, crypto infrastructure firm providing blockchain development tools. Two record quarters in 2022 and revenue grew over 300% last year, which is, wow, 300% in 2022, Jesus. I know. Pretty amazing. Good to see more blockchain infrastructure funding for Share QuickNode. It's a good company doing great work. Guys, we have some questions from bankless citizens this week. The first one, let's see who is this from. This is from. Denton. Denton. Okay. Denton in discord.
I think we're looking at the question. A question on the staking derivative token, David. I'm going to throw this one to you. Why is there a premium on our ETH that is a staking derivative for rocket pool and a discount on STETH, which is a staking derivative for LIDO? That's the question. Is it purely that our ETH is currently the most decentralized option and less reliant on a single point of failure? If all liquid staking derivatives, LSDs, are eventually one to one with ETH, and what is the benefit of buying or holding our ETH? Essentially, what's the benefit of one over the other? Is there a benefit to our ETH when the gains in staking rewards are essentially cancelled out by the premium pay?
Help us understand these staking derivatives and why they trade with different market prices. Denton's intuition was correct. Our ETH has a premium because the costs of decentralization are always higher. LIDO doesn't have a cap on the supply of staked ETH, because there's no bond from the stakers. The LIDO validates the 29 of them. You can come in and you give them your ETH, and they don't have to put up any bond. That's what the role of the LIDO Dow is. With rocket pool, the far more decentralized option, rocket pool stakers do have to put up a 16-ETH bond. There is a constraint on the supply of rocket pool staking nodes, which limits how much external ETH can come into the system, and that is just the cost of decentralization.
Decentralization tends to be costly, it tends to be slow, and that is why the constraint on our ETH supply shows up as a premium on the secondary market, and the unconstrained supply of staked ETH from LIDO shows up as a discount. It's a little bit like the difference between Dye, which is a little bit harder to scale in USDC, which is quite basic. That's exactly right. What about this follow-up question? What if someone buys our ETH? Is that a good idea? How does our ETH equalize to the price of ETH? Is there some arbitrage opportunity here? If one of our ETHs is 0.01 ether, one ether will net you 0.
99 reether, so you kind of lose 1% ish at that rate, and so what the Denton is asking is like, okay, well, you lose 1% right off the bat. Why would I do this? 5, 6, 7% returns a year. I'm backwards. I'm back like six weeks or something. I have to pay six weeks of my time in order to make up for that. Why would I do that? Well, if you want to go and mint our ether by providing a node, you actually get that 1% premium. Rather than buy it, mint it. Yes. You mint our ETH by instead of buying our ETH on the secondary market, you go to rocket pool deposit your ether, and then you get our ETH in return, and then you can sell that our ETH for a 1% arbitrage.
Now that 1% is not that much, so you kind of have to do this at scale, but that's how you can do that. Same thing with stake-death. If you want to wait until withdrawals, which are coming in March in theory, they'll say stake-death is that 0.98 ether. You buy one ether worth of stake-death, you get 1.202 ETH worth when you can later withdraw, but you are right that essentially the discrepancies between premiums and discounts, and also APIs will eventually net out because of arbitrage. Here's our second question, David, from Danubi, and of course this question is in the bankless discord, which is where bankless citizens hang out these days.
A question about layer 2s. The question starts this way. It seems that every layer 2 starts to create an ecosystem with a different value proposition. So you have DeFi on Arbitrum, and NFT community on polygon is strong, and Optimism has its thing. Here's the question from Danubi. Do you think that L2s would differentiate themselves in the future based on the value of ecosystem rather than technology? So what is it? Is the differentiator between these L2s, is it more on the technical side, or is it more in the community in the set of applications that are on top of them? I absolutely love this question because this question is talking about Ryan, the relationship between culture and code, and that is the thing that I think is the coolest thing about this whole entire industry.
So Danubi, he's onto something. They're onto something that like Arbitrum is super DeFi-focused, Polygons got this NFT community. Our Optimism is really focused on this governance model, and each one of these things has downstream effects on who chooses to do what on each layer 2. So the culture behind the teams, and what the teams decide to build their layer 2s actually shows up in the communities that come to be built on these things. So Optimism is working on this Optimism collective dual token model for governance, which I think is like the longest term most bullish time horizon for what we can do in this space is how can we re-architect human governance?
And so you'll get a lot of the regenerative finance, public goods, focus communities on Optimism. The DeFi ecosystem on Arbitrum is super hot, so you get a lot of the DeFi people. And a lot of this ultimately comes back down to how these different layer 2s are constructed. And so that's one of the bullish cases for layer 2s, is that we have the idea that every single chain is its own city. Some people like LA, some people hate New York, some people want to live in Seattle. Like layer 2s all have their own culture to all facilitate any sort of demand for any sort of niche that needs to be expressed by the people that live on these things.
And so that is how I see layer 2s differentiating themselves based on values rather than technology, even though these things have a synergistic relationship. It's a little bit of both, right? But I do think you're right, over time the technology itself will become the commodity, right? All layer 2s, just in the way that all cities in the real world adopted similar standards around roads and their transportation system and all of these things, not really that much different from Chicago versus New York. But there are some subtle things that are different. I do think all of these layer 2s will collapse on the same best set of technologies.
You can even see some of that now with some of the optimistic roll-ups being like, that ZK stuff. Yeah, we'll implement that when the time is right, not yet, but soon. And I do think it'll all just collapse. And what you have left is kind of the culture. That's what makes Chicago different from San Diego, different from New York City, different from Austin, different from any like, you know, that's the differentiator. So I do think that will become more true over time. And this is why, sorry, finished stuff. I was just going to say, I think in the short run, technology does matter. Sure. A good bit.
And probably more than it will matter in the long, long term. Yeah. And I'll take this one. I want to chill the OP stack. This is something that optimism is building. The OP stack is this skeleton. It's like a build a layer 2 workshop. And so they have all these modules that you can come and combine into a layer 2. And so it takes the best of any layer 2 turns into a module and you can build a layer 2 on it. And so the OP stack is allowing for the expression of any type of layer 2. And if you build it on the OP stack, any sort of layer 2 that is built on the OP stack actually has synergies and composability benefits and just second order positive consequences that allow these OP stack chains to work together, which is what optimism is building for.
Like this massive Cambrian explosion of interoperable layer 2's layer 3's that are all built on the OP stack that allow for different technology to come together to allow for some sort of expression on top. And I'm so bullish. It's so awesome. It's so sci-fi. It's pretty exciting. By the way, I'm speaking of awesome things going on in the community. What you're seeing now on screen is the bankless nation discord. This is where we hang out. We talk about heading west. This is where we head west with bankless citizens, bankless community members. As a group, questions like this get asked all of the time.
David, you are doing something I believe this Friday a special event in the bankless nation discord. Tell them about that. And how can people who are not part of this community join? So, at the time of me speaking, newsletters going out on the bankless newsletter that I wrote is called Ethereum the economic engine, the economic machine. I'm super excited about this article. And tomorrow, which is actually today for the time of listening, listening if you are listening on Friday at 3 p.m. Eastern, we're doing a little Q&A session for everyone that's watched the video or read the article that has questions about the article at 3 p.
m. Eastern. We're all going to be all the bankless premium subscribers, all the bankless nation. It's going to be in the stage in discord. And I'll give a short little monologue about the article and unpack it a little bit. And then we're going to do a Q&A session. And so for anyone that's got extra questions about the article or anything else, I'm sure we'll start talking about whatever. That is happening at 3 p.m. Eastern for every bankless citizen. The other cool thing that happened in the discord this week, we made this channel called RSA slash David Tracking when I want to click on that.
How do we come up with all of the topics for the bankless weekly roll-up? Well, we put them into this channel inside of the bankless HQ discord, the centralized media company discord. And then we've created this relaying channel into the bankless nation. So the bankless nation can keep tabs on what we're up to and making sure we're still working. Somebody can get our information to fork our roll-up and they come up with a different one, a better one. So everything that we talk about, we just take the link from Twitter, from coin desk, wherever it is. We put it into our discord and then that bot relays it into the bankless nation discord.
And then you can comment on that and see what we're going to talk about. It's like you can see what we're going to talk about seven days ahead of time just because we have this carbon clone copy of these two different discord channels that goes. It's like a window into HQ. That's what we're up to. A lot of cool stuff going on here. And if you want to become a, we're calling them bankless citizens. Upgrade a bankless premium. There's a link in the show notes. And what happens is when you join, you get a link to this discord and you can catch David's talk tomorrow that's happening in the bankless discord.
All right, David, we got some takes of the week. Here's the first one from a mean solomani. Eath only rye. That's R-A-I rye was a mistake. The Eath staking yield means that borrowing rye against pure Eath will always have some percentage opportunity cost. The rye redemption rate should almost always be negative to reflect this opportunity cost. Decentralization is expensive. People don't want to pay. All right. There's some context, I think, people should understand before reading this tweet. The context from my perspective is rye was too much to call it a stablecoin. It's not tracking the dollar, but we'll call it a stablecoin kind of a crypto native stablecoin that doesn't have any off-chain value.
So it's completely collateralized and backed by Eath. It uses some control theory to do this. It's sort of the original single collateral die model only fully realized. A mean is he's been in the theorem space for a long time. He's kind of a co-father of this rye protocol, which has been kind of exciting for crypto natives who want like we want our crypto only money, right? This is him kind of waving the white flag and saying like, hey, this method didn't work out. I think that's a big deal because he's been very bullish on rye on prior to this. So that's the context. I guess my question here is twofold.
Why do you think a mean is waving a red flag, the white flag on this rye project? And what does this mean for the future of crypto native stablecoins? Does this mean we'll never get here? Because rye was one of the most promising projects there. And it's just like, look at the market cap, David. It's down to like 8 million or so. So this is like a supply of dye going down from like almost 100,000 or 100 million down to 8 million. And so like man, this isn't working. People aren't using it. Yeah. He actually follows up with a second tweet that has some elaboration. He goes, I tried to do some casual interest rate manipulation to the set, the redemption rate for positive.
Basically, basically he's saying that like rye doesn't work when there's only one collateral and no one wants to take the opportunity cause of using that their ether collateral to mint rye when ethers is going up and up and up and up and up and up. And so maybe was he was he's saying that maybe it works if you have staked derivatives in there instead. Like if you have sce in it or like r eth maybe it works better. Yeah. So he said that the rye team has always been doubling, tripling, quadrupling down on ungovernance as in no governance mechanisms, just pure raw cryptography that makes this system work, which is admirable and very something that we should always aspire to.
But he's saying that they went so far down the ungovernance route that they were never able to swap out ether for something like staked ether or anything else because they made their system so rigid. And so I think the lesson here is like if you like there is some benefit to having human governance, like going so far down the ungovernance. It's ungoverned too soon until you like already for a homeostasis. Right. Or also vacation. Yeah. And that's what happened here. And so basically there's a massive opportunity cost for people depositing if it to back rye because it means they can't stake it.
So it's anything else. So it's a much higher cost of capital and it's just the economics don't make sense. It's also just like typically it's hard to admit you're wrong. So props to a mean I wouldn't be waiting the way I'm going to say like the project I'm working on, we made a mistake. Do you ever made you wrong David? It was last time you admitted you're wrong. Oh no. It depends on the context. I've admitted that we were wrong about the outlay or one trade but I only made it in the short term. I'm still right in the long term. I need to reflect on that one a little bit more. I got one. We admitted recently that we shouldn't have had next so it was a Q four or six weeks.
But also I'll say like we should be able to have centralized sponsors because centralized products. I always like to justify it. When I look the big takeaway here is I'm kind of worried we'll never get sort of a crypto native backed stablecoin. That's my worry. I get fractured some combo of maybe it's just our hybrid options are the only things remaining for us but I think the decentralized enough approach is underrated. Here's my take David. I'll read it out in crypto when our banks fail we don't bail them out. It's more painful in the short run yet more healthy in the long run free market. This is kind of hard to just say coming out of 2022 right because a lot of people got hit by 2022 including us including many bankless and yet there's an element of like that is short run pain but what it did was it detoxified a bunch of the things that were destined to fail anyway and it's strengthening our market rather than the other method that we use in traditional finance to bail out right we didn't have to bail anybody out the companies that were taking undue risk die paid for that risk they paid for it isn't that the way it should be.
I think that's good and I'm hopeful crypto can preserve this sort of thing in the future will be much smarter next time around the appropriate people largely got hit with the penalty for the risk that they took. It's not perfect let me just say it's not perfect but I think bailouts would be far worse. I would totally agree yeah the comfort that is a bailout is toxic towards maturation and growth if you just if you don't have to deal with your consequences you don't ever mature. Here's here's your take David. The bull case for East taking is no longer that Ethereum will be the settlement layer for the internet that's now the base case.
The new bull case for ETH is that it's the security layer for the entire internet. East taking goes from one dimensional to omnidimensional. I think you're talking about eigenlayer here. I guess not correctly. I will not specifically eigenlayer but eigenlayers the one that's pioneering this field of restaking or what I kind of have called omnidimensional staking where you can take your ether and stake it to Ethereum to secure Ethereum but you can also take on additional slashing penalties to secure other things as well and also get a yield for that too and so like what do you want to secure an Oracle you can restake your ETH.
What do you want to secure a prediction market you can restake your ETH. So ether people think like oh yeah Ethereum is going to be the settlement layer for the internet. The yield on ETH is going to be great. I'm going to stake and retire for the rest of my life. I'm claiming that Ethereum is winning that and is going to win that and so that's not the base case for ETH. The new bull case for ETH is that you also get additional yields for other things that you want to use your Ethereum staking for that gives you additional yields and so it's rather than just being ETH is only meant for ETH or staking.
ETH or you can stake for anything omnidirectional staking. I think this new bull case would be and this should be honestly a bankless article at some point in time because I don't think people fully understand this is the idea I mean it kind of transitions ETH into kind of the ultimate story of ETH in some ways because yeah you can use it to bond other entire networks as well yes that's what we're talking about it's like the secure the unit of security for the entire internet and I haven't fully walked through what all that means but I think it's pretty cool. This is why this eigenlayer thing has captured the imaginations of many many many people.
All right David what do you bullish on this week? I'm bullish on this concept which is the subject of my article which is economic equilibrium. So Ryan the history of steam engines was that we figured out that steam has a lot of power and so we tried to harness it for a while and then it would just blow up because we couldn't figure out how to harness it and then we figured out this mechanism called a centrifugal governor which allowed a two hot engine to cool down and a two cooled engine to heat up and then that was this mechanism that allowed this steam power to go into actual productive output created this industrial revolution that we know today.
I am claiming that that same mechanism of control theory the controlling of power is what the combination of EIP 1559 and proof of stake is for Ethereum where when gas fees remember when gas fees were like 600 way like all of that value went into proof of work and we actually just lost that value it expended outwards out of Ethereum with proof of stake in EIP 1559 the Ethereum economic machine can recapture that value put it back into the Ethereum economy and actually like move forward as an engine and so this is the subject matter of my article it came out yesterday for you Friday listeners and it's also why I'm just so bullish on what I'm calling Ethereum triggering the industrial revolution of the internet because all of this energy recapture Ethereum block space goes into the value of ether ether is the dominant collateral in DeFi when the value of ether and DeFi goes up the downstream wealth effect for all tokens and supply of stablecoins also goes up and it's just this recirculating loop of economic activity that makes the internet industrial revolution on its way that's why bullish on that's cool David David bullish on steam engines steam engines from internet steam engines cipherpunk to steam punk Ryan what do you bullish on I'm really bullish on this proof of innocence thing just code that we were talking about that in the show all right and just to recap a fact ban tornado cash so and they said anyone who uses tornado cash is obviously a criminal we have to assume and so what did builders do they developed a way to cryptographically prove that people using tornado cash are not criminals and that's just badass that is like jujitsu against the Thorterians I think the authoritarian move is you can't ban it because bad people will do bad things with privacy right and the crypto builders are out there saying like well no we can use our math and our cryptography to prove without divulging our privacy that we are not the criminals you think we are that's fine bullish on I I just think that cryptography and builders and a community with shared values is always going to be able to fight back using the internet against a Thorterians and against this this further encroachment of our freedom and the reason I'm bullish on that is both because I see it happening that's what the crypto movement is all about and also David because honestly it's our only hope as we transition to this digital era we have to stay one step ahead of the surveillance state surveillance corporations and those that would seek to kind of encroach and control so yeah it's so cool when when we see that sort of thing and then you can kind of put the acid test you can throw it back to them and say like yeah was this really about what you say it was about protecting us from criminals in terrorists or was it about actually you controlling things right and then that's where the the strong community and the social layer kicks in and it's like yeah tell us like show us like that's why that's why we've always thought of bankless and and crypto is more of a social movement than anything else anyway that that kind of thing just makes me bullish because I had no idea this sort of thing was feasible and then just somebody spins it out and it's like yep we released this open source code go ahead and use it extend it if you want and then I could tweet like something to you know Janet yell in the treasury right but like hey can we can we use tornado again because we can prove that we're not criminals anyway it's cool builders always like four steps ahead of uh you know archaic institutions and for all the people that are suing the department of treasury myself included this is just a huge piece of evidence that we get to take to the court and be like I think so look at this look look what look what we can do uh and so like it's a huge boon to all the people that are suing the department treasury yeah very cool all right David team of the week what are the week remember the week boom uh we're at table where this is the scene out of the hangover except all the faces are have been replaced although the wolf pack faces have been replaced by Kyle Davey's of three-year heroes capital we got Sam Trabuco in the bottom left we got Sam Bigman freed rolling the dice we got Doe Kwan uh who was that in the back Barry Silver uh oh of course uh Suzu and then uh in the top right corner uh we got Arthur Hayes wait what happened to Arthur he's doing okay well I mean after after fighting the CFTC and paying a fine I don't think the guy guys in Singapore uh guys not coming back to America uh each one of these things each one of these people have an X over their face they did not make it yeah uh rip wolf pack with 2022 uh that's it for you guys we got a moment then okay we have a moment then this is for YouTube only because it is only visual and this is about the KZG ceremony that is currently going on uh if you do not know what the KZG ceremony is there is a YouTube video interview that I did with uh Trent Van Epson Carl of the Ethereum foundation basically everyone needs to contribute entropy to this KZG foundation and then there's this like period of time where really fun and cool mechanisms of creating entropy are give like kind of art artful ways tasteful ways of creating entropy are also being added into Ethereum to unlock EIP48404 if you didn't understand that go watch the video but here is a very fun and creative way of creating entropy uh to add to Ethereum and that will come after right after Ryan tells you all about how risky crypto is yeah yeah guys it's super risky okay uh you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot