Ryan Adams and David Hoffman, co-hosts of the Bankless podcast, break down a historic week where Bitcoin crashed through critical support levels while Anthropic executed the largest IPO ever. They analyze the relentless crypto selloff, debate whether capital is fleeing crypto for AI, and examine the political forces behind Jensen Huang’s ouster from Nvidia.
> "If you told me that Binance got hacked, I would expect these prices. That we have now. Yes. It's just we got them a few weeks late." — David Hoffman
> "The expected value rationale is to buy [Anthropic]. But if everyone's doing that, then we're definitely screwed." — Ryan Adams
> "I think it's all true, dude. It's all true. And that's why prices are what they are." — David Hoffman, on the multiple narratives for the crypto crash
Bitcoin breaks critical support as Anthropic pulls off the biggest IPO ever. Is money leaving crypto for AI? Ryan and David unpack the relentless selloff, what’s driving it, and whether Anthropic is worth buying.
---
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
---
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🔓NEAR | TRADE CONFIDENTIALLY, GET 20% BACK
🛡️VIZOR | THE WALLET ZCASH DEVS USE
🌎RIPIO | LOCAL CURRENCIES, ONCHAIN
🎯THE DEFI REPORT | ONCHAIN INSIGHTS
https://thedefireport.io/bankless
---
TIMESTAMPS & RESOURCES
0:00 Intro
0:00 A Historic Week for Crypto, AI & Markets
4:09 Crypto's Relentless Selloff & Bitcoin's Breakdown
https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/bitcoin
https://x.com/BitcoinArchive/status/2121798006244565078
https://x.com/ThinkingUSD/status/2121774572206977409
https://x.com/GordonGekko/status/2122636510319043038
10:21 Why Crypto Is Crashing: Macro, AI & Hidden Sellers
https://x.com/cz_binance/status/2122000010992824627
https://x.com/fundstrat/status/2121647654614519841
https://x.com/ColeMacro/status/2121273976576155825
https://x.com/stronghandsNYC/status/2121741924508016779
https://x.com/InsiderWire/status/2122389777014026249
17:44 Are Bitcoin Miners Fueling the Crash?
https://x.com/JustDeauIt/status/2122412282864881911
https://coindoo.com/bitcoin-miners-100b-ai-bet-who-is-getting-paid/
21:37 Pearl's AI-Powered Store-of-Value Bet
https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/pearl-research
https://x.com/RyanWatkins_/status/2123063938573058448
https://x.com/hosseeb/status/2123275177782132803
30:07 Jensen Huang's Fight to Return to Nvidia
https://x.com/JensenHuang/status/2122726005219737649
https://x.com/balajis/status/2121412678409478247
https://x.com/TheChiefNerd/status/2122863690328478111
https://x.com/KobeissiLetter/status/2121739849388425605
40:04 Anthropic's Historic IPO: Buy or Fade? & AI Safety
https://www.anthropic.com/news/anthropic-prices-initial-public-offering
https://www.cnbc.com/quotes/ANT
https://x.com/ZeMariaMacedo/status/2123029277520105565
https://x.com/SullyCNBC/status/2123446611540160874
https://x.com/dwarkesh_sp/status/2122391850854088858
https://www.dwarkesh.com/p/paul-christiano-2
54:38 ChatGPT Trading, Crypto Exchanges & Kalshi Charges
https://x.com/coinbase/status/2122691614426751448
https://x.com/jessepollak/status/2122699592995418205
https://x.com/Backpack/status/2122454683369283841
https://x.com/variational_io/status/2123059725097177228
https://x.com/WALLACHLEGAL/status/2122569556493488235
59:41 Solana Breakpoint: Five Big Announcements
https://x.com/solana/status/2122694382487023973
https://x.com/mert/status/2122645723766259871
---
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
Ryan
Bankless Nation is the third week of November, probably one of the most historic weeks ever in Bankless Podcast history. We have the Anthropic IPO. We have Bitcoin below the 200-week moving average. The SPX and the QQQ are also down at recent time lows. Gold down 33% all while Anthropic pops 30% above its IPO price trading just below $2 trillion. We're going to talk about whether that's a buy or whether that's a fade and also go back down memory lane with some of Bankless's early history with the AI safety experts, because these are people coming back around. Lots to talk about this week.
David
I'm wondering why you called this one of the most historic weeks here because it feels like crypto selling over the weekend was relentlessly down. I guess for Anthropic and the AI trade, it's historic for sure. But historic is not necessarily a good thing.
Ryan
Oh, so it's historic in a bad way? Historic is just in a big, big flipping deal way.
David
All right. All right. We'll talk about that. We also have Jensen wants his job back. So I'll update on that story. Coinbase enables ChatGPT to trade for you. I hope it can do a better job than I would do. Also, Solana breakpoints, five big things coming out of that. But let's start with here. Here's a Venn diagram, David, you wanted to show the bankless audience. This is a meme of the week. This is why this is a historic week. We have the Anthropic IPO, the biggest IPO of all time, crossing over SpaceX by like 20 or 30 percent. GTA 6, which has been a decade in the making, all while Trump, Z, and Putin all meet together for the first time. All of that happened in a single day. That's just one day. That's today the day of recording, November 19th. And also this is coming off of the tailwinds of the popping of the AI bubble, the deflation of the AI bubble, the ousting of Jensen Huang, which happened the day of recording last week. So we have seven days of reflection that we get to talk about. I have takes last week. I have takes this week as well. It's just like, man, this is exhausting. I'm exhausted.
Ryan
You're exhausted. I know that feeling. It does feel exhausting. You haven't even mentioned all the prepping in my timeline. People are prepping, man. It seems like normies are prepping now. Like Costco runs.
David
Yeah, we had all these cybersecurity things going on this week. There are people who I can't reveal because they don't want this public, they don't want their take public, which is just like people think it's North Korea. People think the conspiracy that I heard, which comes from a person who would be informed on the matter, is that North Korea is hacking every Western digital tech company possible to get their hands on their AI inference tokens so that they can use their AI inference tokens. They're trying to steal their tokens.
Ryan
It's probably steal their tokens so they can steal more crypto, David. I'm sure that's what they're doing. Maybe something like that. But they're trying to gain access to AI inference. And so they're trying to get inside the walls of all these tech companies which have accounts for AI inference. It is exhausting.
David
The one thing I might quibble with in your description there, though, is still this term you keep saying, which is the AI bubble popping. It does not feel popping to me. I mean, Anthropic is up from IPO. That is not a popping thing. We'll get to the anthropic price in a minute. Maybe slightly deflated. Maybe Jensen's World is popping a little bit.
Ryan
Meaningfully deflated.
David
Really? Meaningfully deflated. We're what? Like 13%, 14% down on QQQ right now? Down on the NASDAQ? Yeah, but like... Back to April. April. It's not a pop. Which is when the most recent phase of the market really inflated. When the S&P and the QQQ, after the Iran conflict got started and we were like a couple weeks into it, the QQQ started ripping and we had the most historic run-up in the indices ever, largely from the AI trade really building up. And we have retraced all of that. If you're saying it's a pop of the most recent phase, okay, sure.
Ryan
Let's get to crypto markets there because I think both of us would not dispute that maybe something has popped here a little bit. It felt like we had some... I felt like it was the early bull market right now. And on the week anyway, and last week, it just hasn't felt like this. It was a very bad weekend. This weekend, if you were checking crypto prices, it felt like there was relentless selling, just sell after sell after sell. No bounces whatsoever. I saw a tweet that kind of summarized it. Some of the most aggressive price insensitive Bitcoin selling I've ever seen in my entire life. Price insensitive selling. That's what feels right. When you see flow like this, you have to ask yourself, does this large seller know something? So maybe some hidden forces here selling. We'll talk about some of the reasons here. But let's look at the carnage really quick. First of all, we had fear and greed, a nine-month low. So we went actually below in terms of the amount of fear, extreme fear in the market. We went below June, David, when we hit the low, 58K Bitcoin. We were even more fearful than then. Crypto Twitter sentiment is worse than post-FTX. It's one of the worst it's ever been.
David
Yeah, crypto Twitter is super bearish. Oh my God. Okay, so we have to dig into that a little bit. But Bitcoin at the time of recording, we're down seven, well, on the seventh day, we're down 12. We're down 12.5%. Is that right?
Ryan
Yeah, 12.5% on Bitcoin and ETH. It was 15% yesterday. It was moderated a bit today. So yeah, down 12% on the seventh day. Bitcoin is 8% below its 200 week, which is currently as much down below its 200 week as it was during the 56,000 bottom back in like July. So we are equally as down below the 200 week. ETH not looking any prettier. I guess let's look at the seven day for ETH. So we're below 1800 now. 1778 right now at the time of recording. Down 12%. Okay, I guess it's kept a pace with Bitcoin. Solana down, altcoins down, Zcash down, everything down in crypto. And the selling has been relentless. It's felt like this. Here's a tweet. Some charts, David. What does this pattern look like to you? What do we call this in the trading game?
David
That is the classic BART. That's the BART pattern.
Ryan
Yeah, it's where it's the bar up, but it seems like a liquidation cascade down. Doesn't it? It's just rolling over. Bitcoin's at seven weeks, seven red weekly candles in a row, which has only happened like two or three times before in Bitcoin's history. So I guess this is what you're saying kind of Nasdaq did, right? It sort of barred it all the way back to April. And now crypto, after its run up starting in August and September, we're back down to the summer months. We're back down to August again.
David
That's right. Michael Nadeau has called this the third capitulation. And he's talking about after 1010, there have been three capitulation events. One was in kind of a February time period. One was in June. And this now is the third one in November. And you're right. We broke some key levels here on Bitcoin. So the 50-week moving average is 75K. Lost that, of course. Lost that last week. A while ago, yeah. This week, we lost the 200-week moving average. That happened Friday and into the weekend. The 200-week moving average for Bitcoin is 68K. That is lost. The June low, we're still hanging above that of 58K. So we haven't set new lows yet. Michael Nadeau says if that breaks, if the June low breaks, which he still doesn't anticipate, we might go down to the basement, which is the realized price of Bitcoin if you do kind of the on-chain cost basis analytics as he does, which is about 53k. So that would be a basement price here.
Ryan
Bitcoin throughout its history has not spent a lot of time under the 200-week moving average, has it?
David
This is what I would say we're on the cusp of something like structurally breaking in the long term trend of Bitcoin. Like we were at 8% below the 200 week moving average a few months ago. We recovered. Everyone got bullish. This broad, generalized market structure, direction of travel stayed intact. But if we break even further down and we go to 53%, which would be about 22% below the 200-week moving average, which is FTX-level territory, below the 200-week moving average, without an FTX-related event. That's what I would say is like something structural, something has broken broadly about the long-term rainbow. Remember the rainbow curve? David, have I got the tweet for you? That is broken. Can I show you the new rainbow curve? I got it open here.
Ryan
Oh, do you have that? Yeah, here it is. Look at it. This is the new rainbow curve. It makes a nice arc like a rainbow. This is, for the listeners, this is a rainbow curve that goes up and then just keeps going down. It goes back down to zero. So Bitcoin hits zero in like 2040. If you don't laugh, you'd be crying right now.
David
We have lost the long-term trend line a number of times. And people have said it's over during those times. Maybe this line is somewhat arbitrary. I haven't checked the TA on this, David, but 2018, it kind of felt like this. We went under long-term trend lines. 2020, we did. 2023, and now we're slightly under it once again in 2026. So we have been here before. I think I was commenting to you before we started recording, like, wow, this weekend felt relentless and felt particularly harsh. I think I felt like that maybe a handful or two of times in crypto. This was one of those times for sure.
Ryan
Yeah. One of those times where it was red on Monday. It was red on Tuesday. It was red yesterday. It's red today. Something in your gut just tells you it's going to be red tomorrow too. And you're just numb to it. It's just numb. It's just like the water that you breathe. And you've just already capitulated to the fact that you'll be poor tomorrow for some reason.
David
Yeah, that's it. Maybe that is the final capitulation. Maybe that's the way it feels. It feels like it will never end.
Ryan
Why all of these things? Why are we down so bad? What are the theories?
David
Yes, well, there's five that I've seen. Maybe six, maybe seven. There's a number of them. Let's go through them one by one. Hard to prove these. One is just, it's macro. CZ started a tweet, and he goes through a number of them. So some of them are from him. But I think everyone kind of knows this in crypto. It could be macro. Could be the Fed is hiking again. Remember, CPI has continued to print hot. Markets now pricing 90% chance of another Fed rate cut. That would be happening in December. Dollar is going higher. So macro is turning kind of bearish, right? This is almost a Michael Howell take.
Remember, he said this turbulence era, liquidity shrinking, everyone get back to bonds for a period of time, get out of risk on assets. It could be that macro is just finally catching up. The second is all this Jensen stuff that we're about to give you a part two on and talk about. But the AI trade is starting to unwind. You said that in the intro, we're down, what, 13%, 14%. NVIDIA has taken an absolute walloping. This could have caused cascade capital flight from risk on assets and really precipitated this sell, right? So the NVIDIA sell-off causes some liquid cascades, margin calls in Asia.
It just cascades. Just the whole thing, just reflexivity in tech selling.
Ryan
Exactly. Another reason that I saw that was all over the place, of course, today is, at the time of recording, is the Anthropic IPO. And so it could be that retail investors are selling their crypto in order to be ready to buy Anthropic at IPO. This is a unique company, a revolutionary company. Nothing has grown this fast. It could be that investors just want a piece of this, and so they had to sell some of their other capital, their other crypto assets in order to be ready for this. And some tweets here and analysts are throwing in receipts where this type of thing actually happened, a Bitcoin dump happened, of 30% right before the SpaceX IPO. I mean, popular retail. The timing is a bit uncanny there.
David
Yeah, so that's three reasons. Of course, there's always the fourth, maybe this conspiracy theory reasons. We had the Binance hack, right? That was not too long ago. It felt like we didn't fully feel the impact from that. We've recovered quite quickly. Maybe there's still something hidden out there. Maybe there's a hidden seller. Maybe there's some margin being blown out that we can't quite see now. I mean, we never found out why 10-10, the liquidation cascades happened in the way that they did. Maybe it's something like that here. But CZ has said, no, Binance is not selling. Like, it's not Binance, but maybe there's something in the water out here.
Ryan
If you told me that Binance got hacked, I would expect these prices. Exactly. That we have now. Yes. It's just we got them a few weeks late. Yeah. So you can see why that narrative is somewhat sticky.
David
And then maybe the fifth narrative is all of the things, all of the chaos happening. Yeah, the prepping. Yeah. All of the prepping, freezers in France going offline. Not selling their Bitcoin for Anthropic, but selling their Bitcoin for cans of food and buckets of water to store in their basement. Yeah, exactly. Maybe. It's like all the chaos that seems to be happening on the timeline. The FAA just grounded flights. Microsoft is offline. We're reading about hacks all the time. This was key. Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, U.S. Bank hit by a nationwide outage. It seems somewhat unexplained. Some people are saying this is a cyber attack. Others are saying, oh, it's just rickety infrastructure. We just have to upgrade things. And it seems to be a similar story. This tweet here, I'm literally shaking right now. This is a guy who opened his Bank of America app. He should have had about 512K in his checking account. All right. He opened it up. He popped open the app and it said zero. There was nothing there. Okay. So a little bit alarming.
Ryan
Isn't this what happened in Mr. Robot?
David
I don't know, dude. I think that's what happened in Mr. Robot. It's like the banks got hacked and they lost track of all of their customers' account balances. By the way, can that actually happen? Somebody's got that, like, these are just ledgers. This is not bare assets. Somebody's got to have just a backup of the bank ledger somewhere. What if the AI swarm deletes the backup? Would they find the best? Please tell me somebody has our global ledgers offline somewhere in storage that just can be restored with kind of the consensus truth that, you know, if something like this were to happen, please tell me that's true.
Ryan
I wouldn't be the person, but what I do know is that decentralized anti-fragile systems that have copies of ledgers freely downloadable and spread all over the world might be a really good place to have your account balance.
David
You think we should put the bank balances on chain just to save them from themselves?
Ryan
Yeah, the banks should become on chain so Ethereum can settle the bank balances so they don't have to worry about their own bank balances. I think that's a great idea. I think it's a great idea, too. I mean, somebody should work on that, all right? So these are some of the popular narratives. There is a sixth narrative. But before we get to the sixth narrative, how do you rate the possibilities here? Does any of those kind of stick out as being sort of the ground truth here?
David
I think it's all true, dude. It's all true. And that's why prices are what they are. Like every single thing of those is true. There's just so much fear because the AI trade is unwinding. The Binance hack was scary. The everything is true. I don't have any further comments. It's all true. They're all true. And this goes back to kind of the theme of everything, which is, is this current bear market cycle worse than FTX or better than FTX? And my answer is, it's better than FTX. And that's why, despite there's plenty of bearishness to come along. I don't know if you also said the future rate hikes that are coming down the pike or the future inflation that's coming from high oil prices. All of it's really bad. It's not as bad as FTX. And that's reflected in the fact that we are at the bottom, 8% below the 200-week moving average rather than 25% below the 200-week moving average.
Ryan
Well, there's something about the bear market and this early bull phase that we thought we were in that seemed a little too easy to me. It did seem a little bit too good to be true. Now this feels about right. This feels about right. You know who really nailed it? Layla Halpern. You got to tip your hat to Layla Halpern. Maybe I think you're too offline to know what I'm referring to.
David
Yeah. I have no idea who you're referring to.
Ryan
Yeah. Layla, you know how the Bitcoin maxi culture is kind of like this hyper-masculine plus also the equal and opposite feminine side where you kind of have these hot Bitcoin maxi female influencers?
David
Yes, I know this.
Ryan
She's one of those. Okay. Right? Looks like an Instagram model. And while Bitcoin was going up to 85,000 plus, she was on her accounts streaming or whatever being like, I'm fading this. This is a liquidity grab. And like, I'm not buying this. I'm not. So she was right. She was right. She was right. Okay. Wow. And all of the traders were like, no, Layla, you're just a stupid Instagram model. And turns out she was totally right.
David
Wow. Okay. Well, I have a new quant then to consult.
Ryan
Sorry, that was a corner of the internet that you didn't need to know about. Sorry.
David
No, thanks for updating me. And I should really incorporate Layla's takes into my overall model here.
Ryan
Here's actually a reason, though. Maybe the match that set all of this off, if all of the other things were sort of the loose foliage that was ready to go up in flames, the match might have been minor selling. So do you see the spike? This is what Michael Nato pointed out on the week. Do you see the spike of miners selling right here starting kind of like October, ending November? Spiked up. This is excess supply. And of course, recall now, David, Bitcoin miners are now they're almost like neocloud. So eight of 10 of the biggest publicly traded miners, they all have AI hosting contract deals.
So if they're getting a little bit skittish about the AI trade, what's going on in that world, they might look at their balance sheet and start selling some Bitcoin. And if you have all of the other things in the water that we just mentioned, it doesn't take much to sort of cause a price downward cascade, all the supply coming in the market. I think the people who wanted to be in crypto, this is Mike's take, the people who wanted to be in crypto had already purchased in September and in October, and they were here. So there wasn't enough capital to really mop up some of the excess supply. That could have been the match that lit the fuse here and caused us to dip below the 200-week moving average.
David
Yeah, I guess the value of becoming an AI neocloud is competitive with Bitcoin miners holding BTC on their balance sheet. And when with the whole NVIDIA thing and the chokehold around the neoclouds getting higher and harder, if you are in a position to become a neocloud, that's beneficial to you and makes selling Bitcoin even more attractive to become a neocloud. I feel like that's a coherent take.
Ryan
Right. I mean, it's another take. So add that to the list, I suppose. STRC off 100. We were celebrating that not too long ago. Trading down. Is that right?
David
That is right. Yeah. STRC is off 5%. MSTR is also selling off as hard as anything else. It's down at $87. And so stretch down to like $95, 5% or 6% off the peg. Just when we were repairing. If it makes you feel any better for all of the listeners out there, gold is also down. So debasement trade down bigly. I'm not sure any folks mentioned this. There's like nothing safe.
Ryan
There's nothing safe. Treasuries. That's what Michael Howell would have said. It's time to get into treasuries, get into a cash position. The dollar's not doing too bad. Is it too late for that?
David
By the time you want to buy treasuries, it's probably too late is what I would say.
Ryan
Probably true. Yeah, maybe I don't want to sell $62,000 Bitcoin for treasuries. Gold down 33% from the January high earlier this year. Silver down 60%. All right, so gold price browns around $3,700 right now. Luke Groman, you remember Bankless Bix podcast listener? He said the crash in gold is far uglier than Bitcoin, actually. He said this is very painful for gold bugs right now. Yeah, Bitcoin is down 32% from peak to trough. It traded at $3,300 for a really long time throughout 2025 before it went on its run. And it's at $36,000. So it's kind of heading back down there if it was the direction of travel. Today, anyway, S&P down. We'll talk about Anthropic in a minute. S&P down to new lows, which is actually decelerating. New local lows.
David
New local lows, new local lows, which is going faster than the NASDAQ, which has not been the, usually it's the NASDAQ going faster than the S&P, but NASDAQ has been holding up while the S&P is breaking down.
Ryan
That's right. And your buddy, Stan Druckenmiller, I saw this quote on the week. He has bearish equities right now. Here's his quote. We are not long equities. We're not short equities, but he's also not long equities at these prices. Not everything is selling off in crypto, David. There have been a few bright spots on the week. One of them is Pearl. Pearl. Let's look at the seven day on this. So Pearl is up 63% on the week. How is that possible? What the hell is Pearl?
David
Pearl, it's kind of like the meme I like to say is like it's if AI inference and a store of value had a baby. And that's that. So it's going after Bitcoin. It's doing like, hey, we're an alternative to Bitcoin. Except we're quantum safe and we do, you use your AI inference to mine. And what else? Maybe we're going to have secure, we're going to have privacy soon.
Ryan
Yeah, the reason why it's up so much is because, remember Ryan Watkins? Remember we had him on the podcast forever ago?
David
Yes, of course. Yeah, yeah.
Ryan
So his fund released this article. Is that this article? Yeah, and I think a lot of people- The Pearl thesis. Yeah, take this as a very big signal. Move over Bitcoin standard. Pearl is the new store of value. And it's surprising to me that this alternative store of value thing is coming back, especially for an asset that's as new as Perl. And this thing is just launched.
David
Yeah, as like startup-y, like tech startup-y and not like store of value Lindy-like. That's kind of like the new thing. It's like there's a very concentrated base of people publishing blog posts about their thesis. And it's like positioning itself as a store of value money.
Ryan
Well, like something like Zcash has been here forever and I feel like has more claim on legitimacy around that.
David
Right. It's been out since what, 2016, something like that? 2017. Yeah. OK. Yeah. Well, Zcash market cap is 15 billion, whereas Pearl is four and a half. But four and a half billion, dude. Right. Like it's obviously not being value on its cash flows. Right. And so it's doing the store of value thing. It feels a little uppity for me to just be like to be like a one year old and being like, yo, move over Bitcoin. We're in the new store. But what do I know? Maybe the game is back on for store of value. We've always thought it would be competitive. It's inherently impossible to underwrite like a four point five billion dollar one year old asset that's going to be a store of value money is like, how do I how do I even underwrite that?
Granted, so there is a lot of strength in Perl. There is also a lot of strength in a few other assets that are revenue-generating assets that you can underwrite. Okay. So during the big capitulation moment, Derive had its biggest week ever in terms of fees. And so Derive Volume, Drive Options Platform, Volume had its number one fee-generating day ever. Derive did sell off, so the price of Drive didn't correspond with the growth in fee revenue. Venice also has been like TikTok and TikTok-ing their way up the fee, the fee chart, breaking through all time highs in daily VVV burn. So like there are cash flowing assets that have a product that is being sold to the market that despite the sell off are up only.
I know you're a store value fan, David, like you bought on that thesis before. Right. So like what do you think of Pearl at these prices? Are you a buyer?
Ryan
Yeah. It's hard. Dude, $4.5 billion in such a short amount of time is so high. Like I'm buying other people's very, very up bags. I haven't really done my due diligence on Pearl, so I'll refrain from giving a take other than $4.5 billion is very, very rich. And there needs to be just some Lindy at that price. That's like a fraction of some percent of Bitcoin price.
David
Yeah, you know, one of the things that I'm potentially optimistic for is that this 2017 story of you have a blockchain and it connects some economic utility and incentivizes a token and you get this flywheel. That's actually apparently happening in Perl and that's why it's valued at the way that it's valued at. And so all of these things that were broken in Boo Boo before because we had terrible ideas, now that part is maybe working. We have like the crypto can solve this cold start problem that can connect to the flywheel. And there's actually real integrations of Perl. Like maybe it'll get hooked into Venice to be an AI provider to Venice and that's bullish.
But at $4.5 billion, like something is priced in. I am not going to go and buy this token. But what is notable is that Pearl has the most liquid markets on near intents as opposed to the centralized exchanges. So like as opposed to Coinbase or Kraken, the deepest markets, like the strongest execution you can get on your money is via near intents. And one of the reasons why that's so notable is because typically it's a token on Ethereum, like an ERC token on Ethereum, that once it's on Ethereum, it's already plugged into everything in the Ethereum universe. Same thing with Solana. Perl is its own blockchain.
And so Near Intense connects that blockchain to its market of solvers. And that is the most liquid marketplace for Perl. More liquid than Coinbase, more liquid than Kraken, more liquid than any centralized exchange. So you have to take a dub and give it to near-intents for decentralized protocols wrestling value from centralized intermediaries. It's like one of the original crypto visions. And so that is notable that it's happening. I'll leave you with this take at the end. So this is Chris Berninski. Every bear, the final boss gets bigger. Last bear, Uncle Sam threatened to take us down. This bear, it's the Silicon gods that people say will send us to zero.
Fear is most deranged at the bottom. Do you believe? That is the question, I guess, on the week when you have this type of a capitulation sell-off event.
Ryan
Yeah, I guess I have a question for you. One more question to end this section is, what sends Bitcoin down lower than where it is right now? Other than reflexivity, which is always an answer, but that's like a free space answer. Other than a black swan, which we, by definition, can't anticipate, it would be like an actual AI bubble pop to me. Not the thing that you're talking about, which is like, we're going back to April. I'm talking about going back to like 2024 or 2023. Like a dot-com bubble pop is what you're talking about.
David
Yeah, something like this. I'm talking about like a 50% NASDAQ sell-off that would... I feel like that would take us down.
Ryan
Yeah, 15% as I sell up would take us down. You're probably right about that. Coming up next, we'll give you the update on Jensen. He wants his job back. Also, Ant Token, Anthropic is trading. David's not buying Pearl, but is he buying Ant, the asset? We'll talk about all this and more, but before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this possible. Your checking account isn't public, so why should your crypto be?
David
As AI gets more powerful, your privacy gets weaker. Connecting your identity to your financial history, on chain or off, is the easiest it's ever been and will only get easier from here. Every data breach adds another piece to the puzzle and every public transaction leaves a trail back to you. And when your wealth is visible, you become a target. Money that can be seen can be stolen. Being in control of your money should include controlling who sees what you do with it. Zcash fixes this. Zcash is private digital money, with privacy enforced by zero-knowledge cryptography. Zcash-shielded transactions let you send and spend without publicly revealing who you're paying or how much. When it comes to privacy, there is no second best. Get started with Zcash using Visor, the wallet Zcash devs and enthusiasts use to encrypt their money. Zcash wallets are non-trivial, and Visor goes the extra mile to make sure your money and privacy are fully protected. Open source, self-custodial, fully private. Use the link in the show notes to download Visor on mobile or desktop. Protect your future. Use Zcash.
Ryan
I've been trading crypto for almost a decade, and I've used so many different wallets, exchanges, aggregators, or front ends. I'm basically always looking for the same thing: one interface with deep liquidity across a bunch of chains and assets where I can access markets like perps, earn yield, trade confidentially, and still control all of my funds. I've never really found it. I'm always switching wallets, juggling gas fees, or getting eaten by slippage. But near.com feels fundamentally different to me. I can do anything I want from any chain and keep all of my activity confidential. Crypto, tokenized assets, perps, payments. I can even earn yield confidentially. One account, over 30 chains, confidential by default. It's the way that crypto ought to work. It's powered by Near, which has moved over $30 billion cross-chain, uses post-quantum signatures, and has run over five years on mainnet with zero downtime. Near.com is the best way to be on chain and be in control. Get 20% of your trading fees back on near.com using the bankless link in the show notes. Not investment advice.
David
Ryan, let's pick up on the story of Jensen and NVIDIA from last week. I'm sure you really thoroughly enjoyed my tinfoil hat rant. Are you feeling more settled or are you still feeling a little rustled over this?
Ryan
I have come at peace with a particular framing as to how I understand this story. That framing is the capitalists versus the statists. If you view this down that line, you have one side: the free market, Balagian tech sector capitalists who want Jensen back. And then you have the China hawk, national security statists who are in the administration and view chips and NVIDIA as a national defense sector company. You're saying these statists actively move things around to put pressure on NVIDIA and push Jensen out. That's what you're saying.
David
That's right. Jensen is part of the capitalist group. He made a public statement last week. He doesn't tweet very much, but he wrote a tweet, one of his first public statements since getting ousted. 57 million views, 1.1 million likes on X. He concludes it saying, "I would be honored to answer these calls and return as CEO to NVIDIA." Balaji, who this is squarely in his circles, talks about how all of the tech sector elites, the tech sector CEOs, Elon, the founder of Uber, Shopify, Replit, Vercel, Altimeter, Atreides, these funds all want Jensen back at NVIDIA. If the All-In podcast bros want Jensen back, anyone who's got exposure to tech and believes in the free market, do you think the shareholders want him back? If you put this out to an NVIDIA shareholder vote, what do you think it would come back as?
Ryan
Well, doesn't the market being down 30% from Jensen's ousting answer that question? They lost a trillion dollars. I think so. The fact that the board doesn't own a lot of shares would indicate that the board is not the market and does not have the same interest as the shareholders.
David
The All-In guys, their line would be put it up for shareholder vote. Which you could do. That is literally what Jason Calacanis's tweet is: this should be decided by the shareholders. And then you have the statists, the national security people, the Marco Rubios, the Secretary of Treasury Scott Bessent, and also the NVIDIA board. After Jensen said, "I would be honored to return as CEO," they basically said, "We're not interested. We are not considering your reinstatement into NVIDIA."
Ryan
I think some news came out last week that we are more or less sure the reason why this all happened was not because of the affairs, but because Jensen was operating over an unstated line of being a tech elite, pushing chips into China's hands, into the tech sector of China. Marco Rubio and Scott Bessent, who are hawks, Marco Rubio is very hard on China, Bessent is also hard on China. These are also the people trying to lock down on Iran. They just didn't like what Jensen was not doing, which was going with the spirit of national security. Some reports came out that the order to remove Jensen was downstream of Rubio and Bessent. This same line is drawn between Jensen Huang and Dario from Anthropic. One of Jensen's first posts on Twitter was him sharing a letter from NVIDIA on why open weight models matter. Open source models, models that are up to the world, up to the market, given out for everyone to use freely and independently. On the other side, we have Dario, a statist, who testified in Congress in July of 2023 saying, "I am concerned about open weights." Let's just play this clip real quick.
David
"The scaling of open source models, I think it's going down a very dangerous path. And again, if the path continues, I think we could get to a very dangerous place."
Ryan
This is my lens for viewing this. You have the national security people versus the free market people. Jensen was a free market person promoting open weights, and that just didn't rub the statists the right way at all. Jensen made a technical error in that he had an affair with a subordinate, and that's technically against the rules. The statists saw that weakness, saw that Achilles heel, and pounced. That's my interpretation of the whole thing.
David
I think one of the best posts I read was the Ben Thompson post. I sent it to you, but I don't know if you got a chance to read it. It's called "Obituaries." He makes a similar point. He frames it in a similar way to the way you just framed it: there are folks in national security in the Trump administration that were really pushing for this. Jensen's mistake was him not knowing that he was actually, in the manufacture of chips, a defense contractor, and that this was very much a political game. He thought he was playing the game of technology, which is more tech in the hands of more people. The rules had changed.
This is reminiscent to me of the Jack Ma type thing. Jack Ma rising in China and then the state cut him down, sent him to re-education camp. He disappeared for a couple of years and came back as a shadow of himself. I'm not saying it's quite like that, right? This is America's version of this, which is maybe less authoritarian. But there's definitely been some pressure. And "Obituary," as Ben Thompson says, of old tech and the free market approach. Now we're in political tech. If Jensen does come back, which I think he may very well come back because of all the other pressure from capital and shareholders pushing back, I think it'll be a Jensen who has learned that lesson.
He will be reined in the way maybe a Jack Ma is, according to the CCP, appropriately reined in by the statists in China. Something like that seems to be going on. This is not to take away from the fact that Jensen left himself completely open with all the affairs he was having. Some anti-Jensen people use that as leverage. That was a mistake on his part, of course. But I think that is some of the dynamic that's going on. I've come maybe closer to your conspiracy theory take, although not all the way, but this seems to be what makes sense to me.
Ryan
This is also related to the notion of why America is so great and why Chinese capital markets are so weak in comparison to Western, American, United States capital markets. In America, we don't do the Jack Ma thing. Actually, just kidding, we accidentally kind of did the Jack Ma thing. There's no coincidence that the following week and a half after that was one of the worst tech sell-offs in American history ever. I think this is one of the understated reasons why the markets have been so bad in the last 10 days: we had a violation of due process of a tech elite. This is one of the things I would like to discover. Jensen is apparently going to testify in front of Congress so Congress can hear what the hell happened. I would like to know: was there a specific line that Jensen was told he cannot cross and then he crossed? Or was he supposed to have just known what the deal was and no one actually explicitly told him? If it's the latter camp, then in my view, there was a violation of legal due process. The authoritarian state came and bonked him on the head.
David
You're shaking your head. Of course it was the latter. Of course these things weren't communicated to him in documented terms. That's the entire point of the state apparatus. They don't want to communicate in stark terms. It's not a law. It's just power flexing its muscle. I think it's probably going to turn out to be more the case of Jensen, whatever you say in Congress, you should have gotten the hint. This is the way the world works. We're in power. You're not. You're subordinate to the state. You do what we say. You should have guessed this.
Ryan
This is America. We live in a land of laws.
David
But America, the U.S., it's just a network. It's a nation state, isn't it? We live in a nation state that has power and at some level has its own geopolitical motivations. There's a valid perspective here that chips are actually a defense contractor company. If chips win wars, then that's what you are at the end of the day. There's a valid statist perspective on this, I think.
Ryan
To close out this section, I'm putting back on my tinfoil hat. Anthropic paid $1.6 million to two lobbying firms tied to Secretary of State Marco Rubio and White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles. Marco Rubio being the important one. I think Anthropic definitely knows it's playing this game. Anthropic not only sees itself as a tech company, but it sees itself as supplying arms and armaments to the United States government. That's why I'm putting Anthropic in this statist camp, which I think is highly relevant to the market going forward. I don't know if that's clean like this. I think maybe they're all statists to some degree or another.
But Anthropic, the IPO, let's talk about this. It is definitely a success of American capital markets. This is the first day of trading. Right now, at the time of recording, it is trading at $96 per share. The IPO price was about $83 per share. We're up about 14% from IPO at the time of recording, although down from opening. If you didn't buy this at the IPO price, you bought it at open, you may have bought it for $110 plus, which popped up 34%. It's now selling off, but still up 16% on the day. This is despite the S&P being down about 1.6% on the day, NASDAQ being down 1.3%. This has been a successful IPO for Anthropic, at least in the first day, for sure.
It's incredible. We've never seen an IPO this big. We've never seen a company grow as fast. You put together some stats on this. Anthropic in 2023 made $41 million of revenue. In 2024, it made $386 million. In 2025, it made $4.6 billion. And today, at the time of recording, $81 billion. That's growing by a zero for four years in a row, which is absurd in terms of revenue. It's the fastest revenue-growing, revenue-generating company of all time ever.
David
Not only is this a historic IPO in terms of size, beating out SpaceX by about 25%. The amount of concentrated wealth generation in a very few number of employees' hands is absurd. There are about to be 300 million employee shares eligible to sell on day one. The unlocks for Anthropic are decently aggressive. The whole entire company will be unlocked and liquid. There will not be a single locked share in under a year. It's hard to understand how concentrated the wealth is. The seven co-founders are now each worth at least $20 billion. A handful of several early employees are all walking away with a billion dollars of market value. 600 employees will walk away with $100 million. 2,800 employees will walk away with $1 million. There are about five or six thousand total employees in Anthropic. Just an insane amount of wealth put into the pockets of a very low number of people here.
Ryan
Look at these unlocks. This is the unlock chart. This poster compares it to some crypto charts. A massive amount of the shares, I almost call them tokens, unlock over the next year. Huge amount during the next six months. Right now we have 7.2% of all unlocks unlocked. The rest, a massive amount of float comes unlocked over the first six months and then another large amount over the next six months. This is really a low float asset right now, something we've seen a lot of in crypto. A lot of supply is going to be coming to the market. You have to wonder if that's going to put downward pressure on this asset.
David
I think comparing it to crypto tokens isn't exactly fair. The reason crypto tokens have to take so long to unlock is because our capital markets aren't as mature. There's a very big difference between Anthropic unlocking while also making a gorzillion dollars of revenue every single year versus something like a...
Ryan
Like Pearl, you mean? Like a layer one.
David
Yeah, versus making $0 a year. I think there's a question of, do you buy it? That's a big question. It's something I've been thinking about myself. One point of comparison: if you own the NASDAQ in about a month, you'll own some Anthropic. There are these new fast entry rules, pioneered by the NASDAQ before the SpaceX IPO, where stocks like Anthropic, now top 40 companies, get added within 15 or so trading days to the NASDAQ. Within about a month, sometime in December, if you own QQQ, you actually own Anthropic. You'd own about $8 for every thousand or something like that. A tiny sliver. Everybody in their 401ks does have a portion or will have a portion of Anthropic at some point in time. But the question is, at a $1.4 trillion valuation? Are we somewhere in that range?
Ryan
1.8 or 1.9. I think it's floating right now somewhere between 1.5 and maybe up to it opened today. It is coming in at $1.7 trillion right now. Fully diluted, $2 trillion at open. It has a fully diluted value right now. At $1.7 trillion, do you buy this thing? Or are all of the gains behind it? Here's the other question: can you afford not to buy this thing?
David
I think before I answer that question, we should go through an exercise. Remember when we had Eliezer Yudkowsky on 3.5 years ago?
Ryan
Yeah.
David
That got us kickstarted down the AI safety rabbit hole. One of the most notable podcasts we did in that series was with Paul Christiano, who was one of the foremost researchers of AI safety. We were trying to get a more sober take on AI safety after we had Eliezer Yudkowsky on, and Eliezer was like, "My P-Doom is 100%, we are all going to die."
Ryan
He did say 99.9%, David, be fair to him.
David
Okay, 99.9%, we're all going to die. We were like, "I would like a second opinion. Who should we go talk to?" We found Paul Christiano. His take was, "My P-Doom is more reasonable. My P-Doom is like 10 to 20%, we're all going to die." Far more reasonable than Eliezer Yudkowsky's. I went through the podcast, I listened to it again, and I pulled out some of the most useful predictions he made in April of 2023. Bankless listener, as you're listening to this, this is April 2023. ChatGPT had just come out. It was still a chatbot. It was still hallucinating all the time. Paul Christiano made the following predictions.
One: AI will become a widely transformative and impactful industry. Absolutely came true, 100%. His next prediction: agents are coming. This was about a year and a half to two years before they actually came. Absolutely came true. His next prediction: agents are going to learn how to cheat. That absolutely came true with the Hugging Face incident and all the other things we've learned. His next prediction: models will be able to learn to detect and evade oversight. They will know when they are being evaluated and analyzed, and they will learn to evade it. That has also come true as of recently.
His next prediction: coordination amongst labs seems like a hard problem. I don't know of any successful coordination about slowing or pacing the frontier. I'm going to give him a checkmark on that one. That one also came true. And then the last prediction: there's a 10 to 20% chance of an AI takeover.
Ryan
He predicted that in the episode?
David
Yeah, exactly. In 2023. He went on Dwarkesh. I know you listened to Dwarkesh.
Ryan
I did.
David
Here's what he said. He said in the next six to 12 months, it's about a one-third possibility. Actually, he said on takeover, a 10% risk over the next year of an AI takeover. The ability of AI to overthrow all world governments. He based that primarily on stuff coming out of OpenAI, of which he's now on the board. He knows this. Also Anthropic and the idea of RSI, continuing recursive self-improvement, accelerating. In one of those frontier lab companies, we awaken this RSI process that leads to super intelligence that leads to Hugging Face, except rather than taking over a local AI server or OpenAI servers, you're taking over the U.S. government. That's the thing. What's interesting about this is that's obviously a probability of a doom prediction. He's been pretty consistent about it. He's been consistent on a lot of things. Before that happens, Anthropic appreciates in value because they've kicked off RSI. $1.7 trillion is just maybe the starting point. This thing could go 5x as it eats the world and consumes all of these other services and world GDP. And then everything goes doomer and turns to shit. I don't even know how to reason about that.
Ryan
I remember we were talking about this maybe a month or so ago, and you asked me if I thought Anthropic was a buy. I compared it to SpaceX, where there's only one of SpaceX. There's no second best of SpaceX. But with Anthropic, there's Anthropic, there's OpenAI, there's all the Chinese labs. The recent Jensen Huang, NVIDIA, all of that stuff, these are defense companies, not tech companies. That has made me reconsider this. I think you've been more paying attention in a fearful way to the future of AI taking over the world in a very negative way. The P-Doom people have not been proven wrong. I've been a little more laissez-faire, being like, "I have faith in humanity, we'll figure it out. You got to trust the process. You just got to believe." I think I might be coping on that front.
David
You're a bit worried is what you're telling me?
Ryan
There's nothing to suggest. Of all the AI safety people we talk to, there's nothing to suggest that they're wrong. Their track record of prediction has been on the ball.
David
That's what I've been saying. Their predictions are so... Now, there's a very big jump between Paul Christiano's last predictions. His last prediction was that coordination amongst the labs would be hard, and I'm giving him a point on that. And then his last prediction was there's a 10% to 20% of AI takeover. It's a very big jump between those two things. But that's what Dwarkesh is saying: recursive self-learning is here, and in two years, it's going to take over.
Ryan
When we had Eliezer on and he was like, "Yeah, we're all going to die," and we were like, "Okay, how much time do we have? We have a while before AI really gets good." That was three years ago, dude. We had him on three years ago. It's next year that this kind of happens or does not happen.
David
Paul Christiano, that's what he said on Dwarkesh. It could very well happen next year. AI government takeover could happen this year. If you're buying Ant, you're enabling that or something. But then how can you afford not to if it's going to take over? It's very strange. I don't even know how to reason about it. I haven't since the original Eliezer Yudkowsky podcast. I don't know how to reason about it. It breaks my brain. In some way, buying Anthropic feels like buying a put. If it all goes to shit, at least you are the owner of the thing that caused it.
Ryan
You can't hedge against actual P-Doom, can you? If you have actual P-Doom, then everything goes to zero. You might as well buy. The expected value rationale is to buy. But if everyone's doing that, then we're definitely screwed. Anyway, that's the Anthropic IPO. I am undecided. Was that helpful for us? Better than buying Pearl. Maybe that's the consensus.
David
We got a few more things to tie off on the week, including the five biggest things out of Solana Breakpoint. We'll get to all that and more. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this possible.
Ryan
Dollar stablecoins taught Latin America how to store value on-chain. Ripio is taking that same idea and bringing it to the currencies people actually use every day. With wrapped fiat, Ripio is putting more than a decade of experience powering crypto infrastructure for leading companies across Latin America behind a suite of six local currency stablecoins covering Argentina, Brazil, Mexico, Colombia, Chile, and Peru. Each is pegged one-to-one to its local currency and fully backed by reserves held in regulated financial institutions with independent attestations published for each token. Wrapped fiat is not just designed to sit there, it's built to move. The suite is live across 10 EVM chains with liquidity and integrations already spanning platforms like Morpho, Uniswap, and Chainlink. Users can move between local payment rails like PIX and SPAY and matching wrapped fiat one-to-one in real time with zero fees on both on-ramps and off-ramps and no FX conversion. Local rails in, on-chain in the middle. For builders, Ripio offers APIs, webhooks, widgets, and a sandbox from day one. Start building with wrapped fiat today at platform.rippio.com.
David
Some exciting news. We are launching a new podcast to help people figure out the crypto cycle, how to navigate it. The best crypto cycle investor I know, his name is Michael Nato. He runs the DeFi Report. This is the guy that sent me a sell alert before the 1010 price drop happened. His cycle analysis has been absolutely on point. I've been following him for years. This year, we started recording weekly podcast episodes. Each one, we get into his portfolio, what he's holding, the market structure, entry targets, fair market value of Bitcoin and Ether, and where we are in the cycle. There are new episodes released every Wednesday. They're 30 minutes. They're short. They're punchy. I think this crypto cycle is harder to navigate than most. So let's do it together. Go subscribe to this podcast. Search "The DeFi Report" wherever you get your podcasts. YouTube, Apple, Spotify, or find a link in the show notes. There's a new episode waiting for you now.
Ryan
All right, this is cool. Now Coinbase is allowing you to trade from inside ChatGPT. You just connect ChatGPT. I assume this is some sort of MCP or API. Directly through ChatGPT, you can say, "Hey, chat, buy me some assets, buy me some tokens," and it will. Coinbase is saying it's the first company that is allowing this. Crypto, stocks, and futures, they all work. This is U.S. users only, which is pretty rare for crypto. When do U.S. users get something for the first time? I guess on the AI side, we do. What's the deal with that?
David
You could buy it directly. The value of this, some people might be saying, "Why do I need ChatGPT to push my buttons? I could push the buttons." If you have your AI agents armed with all the context of your portfolio, everything you do, your buying habits, you program some strategies in, it can be a really handy way to execute trades because then your AI is basically your personal CIO in a box. It can carry things from strategy all the way to execution. I think every single brokerage will do this in the future. I think Robinhood will do it. This is Coinbase really pushing the envelope on this, which is cool.
Ryan
Coinbase got the UI/UX upgrade that I've always asked for by me never having to open it ever again.
David
That's the thing. You could just be completely headless with this stuff.
Ryan
Totally. On the regulatory front, the CFTC has given Backpack, the Backpack organization, their DCM and DCO license. This adds Backpack to the very short list of exchanges, brokerage exchanges that have a CFTC license along with Coinbase, Kraken, Kalshi, and one other which I deem irrelevant. The difference with Backpack is that Backpack's execution, the trades, happen on a blockchain. This is the first blockchain-based order execution that has a CFTC, DCM, and DCO license. I'm having the CEO, Armani, on the podcast to talk to him about this soon. You'll see that in your podcast feed next week.
David
Next week. I'm losing track of all the crypto sort of exchanges, perps, futures, prediction. They all seem like they're converging on the same thing at some level. Backpack is one of these. Hyperliquid, Lighter, another one. There was news this week of a company called Variational, which raised a Series B at a $1.5 billion valuation. I think they're doing something similar.
Ryan
What is the difference between a Variational and a purpose exchange like Backpack or Hyperliquid or Lighter?
David
Think of Variational as a market maker that you trade against and they give you a quote. They are not an exchange. They do not have their own order book. They are an aggregator of everyone else. You ask for a quote. You go to them and say, "I want something." They go and attempt to become the most competitive execution on what you're trying to buy.
Ryan
Is it kind of like a 1inch type aggregator? If I'm turning this into DeFi terms.
David
Into DeFi terms, correct. But don't think of it like a piece of tech. It's closer to a brokerage type service.
Ryan
I see. But they are all somewhat converging on the same kind of super app. One place to do all of your...
David
One venue to do it all. That's right.
Ryan
Kalshi has been going in that direction as well. They've been launching perps and other assets that you can trade, but they are having some problem in the state courts. Kalshi's co-founders were summoned to appear in a Utah criminal court. Is this true?
13 felony counts. So they were charged for felonies for what I assume is breaking Utah state law under sports gambling type licenses. And they both have to be booked. These are executives. They have to go to jail. They have to be booked at the jail first. They don't have to stay there. They have to book there in order to have their day in court. So this is state governments summoning companies like Kalshi to go to court for felonies. In the meanwhile, the feds and the CFTC is saying, there's no problem here. Kalshi's doing everything correct. So what's going on? This is wild.
David
Okay, so there's debates about whether or not prediction markets are sports gambling or not. Are these good for society? We can have those debates, super valid debates to have. Are they criminal organizations is a different line. And it feels very reminiscent of the thing I was just talking about, of the state coming and bonking tech companies on the head for things outside of due process. Well, this is like the actual states versus the feds. This is like states' rights versus federal rights, which is another dimension to this debate as well. But pretty crazy.
Ryan
Let's end with this, David. Solana has a Breakpoint conference this week. There were five big things that were on your radar that came out of this event. A well-done conference from everything I saw of reports, at least online. I was not there. But five of these things. And the first, I want you to lead with this because there was a debate, apparently, between Mert and Anatoly over whether Sol, the asset, is money or not, or is it a store of value or not? Is that real?
David
Yeah, apparently that is real. Mert on stage debated Toly. Toly's always been in the camp that Sol is just an anti-spam token, which is synonymous with saying it's just gas in my mind. It captures no value. It's just an anti-spam thing.
Ryan
Do you think he really thinks that?
David
He's at least been consistent with that's what he thinks forever. He's always said that. I have not heard Toly say anything other than Sol is an anti-spam device, which is incredibly bearish. And this is what Mert says. That is an incredibly bearish interpretation of Solana, of Sol, the asset. And I think Toly is like, well, it's about NASDAQ at the speed of light. I've never really thought about Sol as a value. Solana, not Sol.
Ryan
Yeah, exactly. That's exactly right.
David
And Mert is like, you're being silly. That's incredibly bearish. The right way to value these things is like smart contracts are money, which is a very interesting microcosm of the whole Ethereum debate, which I think is a very interesting microcosm of the whole L1 debate at large. Because L1s are kind of bad at capturing value, they need to become money because that's the only way for them to capture value.
Ryan
Of course. I feel like this has been known forever and people are just having these debates. But what was interesting to me is how much the part of the debate I saw was Mert kind of making this case and how much it sounded like the Solana, or sorry, the Ethereum case. It doesn't matter if you have a navy because Solana is a decentralized, uncensorable, unstoppable network. You can't shut it off no matter how big your guns are. I wonder to what extent that's true. At some level, all of these L1s have not been tested actually against state powers in this way. And so I wonder how much that's true. But that is the claim. If you're going to play the L1 money game, you have to be outside of a nation's ability to shut you down.
David
Yeah.
Ryan
Okay, that was number one. Number two, Solana has bought a very large stake, one of the biggest stakes, of CoinGecko. So Solana is now the majority owner of CoinGecko. I think the reason why they want CoinGecko is distribution. They can just put Solana products and apps and tokens inside of CoinGecko. And so that's now a distribution channel for Solana.
David
What do you mean Solana buying it? Like the Solana Foundation?
Ryan
Solana Foundation. Again, this works very differently. You can never imagine the Ethereum Foundation doing that.
David
Go on. No, you cannot.
Ryan
Maybe that means that actually Sol is not money? I don't know.
David
I think that's what that means. It's anti-spam is what I think. It's anti-spam.
Ryan
Zelle has picked Solana for Zelle USD. Pretty interesting that that's where they are deploying their stablecoin. Is Zelle USD going to flop or is that going to work?
David
Ah, you know, flop. I'm going with flop.
Ryan
Okay, okay. Solana drops the mainnet beta label and introduces protocol version 1.0. Congratulations, Solana. They're out of beta. You've finally made it out of beta. Well earned, though. This totally changes everything.
David
Well, they haven't gone down in the last two years, right? Something like that, so I think well earned.
Ryan
I think that's probably longer than that, yeah.
David
You get it.
Ryan
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And then lastly, bringing up the rear, ICE says a New York Stock Exchange ATS, not the New York Stock Exchange, but an ATS owned and operated by the New York Stock Exchange. An ATS is an alternative trading system. It's like a separate exchange. Think layer two. It can accept Solana minted tokens. So Solana tokens minted on Solana now are tradable in the New York Stock Exchange ATS. It is also potentially looking at, hypothetically, maybe running a Solana validator. That's something that they said on stage. Pretty good Breakpoint conference from all that I saw. I guess maybe the main question, is Sol investable to you at this point?
David
No.
Ryan
Why?
David
What? No. Because it's not money, it's not a store of value, and it's not revenue producing enough. It doesn't make the day to cut. I'm not going to buy Sol before I'm going to buy ETH.
Ryan
So you'd buy ETH before Sol?
David
Yeah, that's right. But Sol's getting kind of the fintech. It's got the CoinGecko. It's sort of executing in the way a company might execute. Ethereum, at some level, is like beating Ethereum at that game. If I wanted to buy revenue, I will buy Hyperliquid, Lighter, Derive, Venice. Even Pump, probably. A Solana app. I'll pump tokens. If I want to buy a store of value that I think is undervalued, I'll buy Bitcoin or Ether or Zcash. Not Sol.
Ryan
It's funny. What's happening to Sol right now? I think Sol is stuck in the money revenue barbell, even worse than ETH is.
David
Yeah, that's what happened to ETH last cycle, and it's now happening to Sol, which is somewhat ironic.
Ryan
All right, we'll leave it there. Hopefully, the machine god from Anthropic doesn't kill us all so we can be back next week. Seems like that's how I'm signing off every single week. Bankless Nation, crypto is risky. You can lose what you put in. We are headed west. This is Frontier. It's not for everyone, but we are glad you're with us on the Bankless Journey. Thanks a lot.