Bankless Weekly Rollup 3rd Week of May 2023
------ 🚀 AIRDROP ALPHA 🚀 https://bankless.cc/Alpha
------ 🚀 Consensys Diligence Fuzzing https://bankless.cc/diligence-fuzzing-pod
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK LEARN | HELPFUL WEB3 RESOURCE https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
👾STADER LABS | ETHX LIQUID STAKING https://bankless.cc/Stader
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/Toku
🎮IMMUTABLE | GAMING ECOSYSTEM https://bankless.cc/Immutable
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
------ Topics Covered
0:00 Intro
2:55 MARKETS 5:00 ETH Staking Update https://www.theblock.co/data/on-chain-metrics/ethereum/cumulative-eth-deposited-to-beacon-chain-and-validators Monitor: https://validator-queue-monitoring.vercel.app/ 7:00 Macro Market Trends https://www.cnbc.com/2023/05/15/paul-tudor-jones-says-the-fed-is-done-raising-rates-stocks-to-finish-the-year-higher-from-here.html 11:20 Liquidity Drying Up https://twitter.com/ramahluwalia/status/1657924211770380290 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbr8965IYfo&t=3830s 13:30 The Bore Market https://twitter.com/sassal0x/status/1656857007385894912 14:50 The Promise of Crypto https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1659177889428914177 16:30 Layer Two Activity https://l2beat.com/scaling/tvl
21:30 What Happened to Ethereum? https://twitter.com/0x_Osprey/status/1659019122548830209 24:40 Client Diversity https://clientdiversity.org/#why 27:15 Not a Monolith https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1657316158729494528 29:30 Block Reorgs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkMjcqVEARc
33:15 Is Ledger Safe? https://www.ledger.com/recover 36:30 Ledger Comms https://twitter.com/Ledger_Support/status/1658892462440456192 40:10 Canceling Ledger https://twitter.com/oklahodl1/status/1658580508320620546 https://twitter.com/0xfoobar/status/1658460603831263232 https://twitter.com/Mudit__Gupta/status/1658368265687556097 https://twitter.com/hosseeb/status/1658740433361702913 43:25 Did They Do Anything Wrong? https://twitter.com/0xfoobar/status/1658965272416452609 49:00 Redundancy https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1658788949165322242
51:00 Coinbase vs the SEC https://twitter.com/MetaLawMan/status/1656737447756038177 53:30 Gary Speaks https://twitter.com/ROCKilroy/status/1658206561125146630?s=20 55:00 Summary https://twitter.com/milesjennings/status/1658515975170555904
58:00 Nike Dot Swoosh https://www.swoosh.nike/location 1:01:10 Optimism Bedrock https://twitter.com/optimismFND/status/1658202279147601921 Polynya: https://twitter.com/apolynya/status/1658312190577836032 1:04:05 Worldcoin OP https://worldcoin.org/blog/announcements/worldcoin-commits-optimism-superchain-vision-ahead-mainnet-launch 1:04:55 Lido v2 https://twitter.com/LidoFinance/status/1658195242149879824 1:05:20 PayPal MetaMask https://metamask.io/news/latest/metamask-and-paypal-all-you-need-to-know-about-buying-eth/ 1:06:30 On-Chain Cease & Desist https://twitter.com/zachxbt/status/1659078481228058624 1:08:00 DRC-20s on Dogecoin https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/transactions-btc-ltc-doge.html#3m Doge Maxis: https://twitter.com/938433911/status/1657961759322562560 1:09:45 EU MiCA Just Passed https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2023/05/16/digital-finance-council-adopts-new-rules-on-markets-in-crypto-assets-mica/ 1:11:00 Do Kwon Bail https://www.theblock.co/post/230575/do-kwon-bail 1:12:15 Sam Altman Congress https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ/status/1658498249727307776
1:19:00 Questions from the Nation
1:25:00 David’s Shirt https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1659182411467350016 1:26:40 Abandoning Wallets https://twitter.com/0xDesigner/status/1658851890803744768
1:28:00 What David’s Bullish On https://imgur.com/vlEaQMG 1:29:25 Permissionless Spaces
1:30:15 What Ryan’s Bullish On https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1658660759352614914 https://twitter.com/MetaVsGaming/status/1658687862269771777
1:36:40 MEME of the Week https://twitter.com/MinisterOfNFTs/status/1657793552808656900 https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1657879440146444288
1:37:15 Moment of Zen https://twitter.com/linusekenstam/status/1657083568231702528
---- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Is your ledger safe or should you throw it down the toilet? Ethereum, it's got a finality outage. Is it safe or should you also throw it down the toilet? We don't know. Bankless Nation, it is the third Friday in May and it's morning time on Friday or afternoon time. Actually, it's not. It is 4.40 p.m. All right, well, it's morning for me, David, and I can't wait to have you on the East Coast, but you're still in Montenegro. But okay, this intro is going long. We got something to tell them. It's time for the what? Bankless Friday weekly roll-up where we cover the entire weekly news in crypto, which is always an ambitious endeavor, yet we persevere nonetheless into the frontier.
It's going to be a long one today, so I'm speaking fast. All right, that's good. Let's keep up that pace, David. Topics of the week. Did we just get rugged by Ledger, the hardware wallet? Or is this just mob season on Twitter? Is this Ledger getting canceled? That's number one. What else are we covering this week? Ethereum's non-finality event. Is non-finality an event? did ethereum break or is it working as intended we'll talk about that and more and gary gensler continues to be in the hot seat nice uh bedrock world coin dogecoin plenty of things to talk about there but bigly most bigly nike's dot swoosh program a program that no one is paying attention to which might be the coolest web 3 metaverse thingy thingy that got released that everyone else is just ignoring because we're we're busy canceling each other on twitter that that was it was canceled week for sure uh maybe some of it justified though we'll get into uh we'll get into the story definitely the bankless cancel ship was uh was justified a little bit fuck those guys all right let's uh before we get in let's talk about fuzzing do you want to spend a minute talking about our friends and sponsors over at consensus because they want you to know you should be fuzzing right now if you are not fuzzing david what does this mean what am i talking about?
So ConsenSys has a new diligence tool for all the people who write code. So it's an audit grade security tool that serves as an automated way to find code vulnerabilities. If you know what fuzzing is, then this is for you. If you don't know what fuzzing is, then this isn't for you. And so if you are working to write code without having to host your own infrastructure, no writing of complex tests, blah, blah, blah, blah, diligence fuzzing is a system to test your code that is built by ConsenSys. So you can layer on additional security in addition to your regular audit. You can also use ConsenSys' diligence fuzzing.
So this is ConsenSys' message to you. Go fuzz yourself. Did you just come up with that on the fly? Are you kidding me? Yeah. So in order to go fuzz yourself and your code, there's a link in the show notes. You could fuzz for free too. It's free fuzzing on Vanquish this week. You can do it by yourself. Fuzzing all by yourself for free. Can you beat that? Well, let's get to the markets. Enough of this fuzzing talk, David. What are the markets telling us this week, starting with Bitcoin? It's flat. $27,300. Start of the week, end of the week. It's flat. You put the same number twice. I'm looking at the agenda here, which I print out, by the way, every week.
I print out so I can look down on paper. 27,300 is the start and you have the current 27,300 it can't be I know those are the same but like really I mean give or take a few dollars but you just rounded it huh you just like it's flat how do you know it's that season you can check I don't know I'm just trusting you every week I don't even look at I barely look at this even though the charts are beautiful thank you crack and pro for these charts I barely look at this I just hear you tell me numbers each week what is the ETH price? 1820. It was 1820 seven days ago. It's 1820 today. It's a flat week.
You know what? Something suspicious about these numbers. You just copy and pasting, I think. ETH Bitcoin, the ratio? Flat. Are you serious? Why do we even do markets anymore? Okay, whatever. And Bankless Nation, please open up your price checker apps. Open up your Kraken app on your phone and check the price currently because it might not be flat. Who knows? Yeah. Verify this for me with Don't trust. I'm sure this is, for most Bankless listeners, this is the first time they'll be checking prices this week, by the way. They just wait until we prompt them to check prices. People actually listen to the Bankless podcast in order to hear about the crypto prices.
They don't know the prices until we tell them. It's a global source of truth for them. We'll tell them the market cap of crypto then while we're at it. We're coming in at a whopping $1.18 trillion. So I think we are up $60 billion from last week, marginally up. so okay some shit coins got pumped if bitcoin is flat and ether and flat but the total market cap is up david you can't you can't call the rest you can't call everything non-ether and non-bitcoin shit coins david i just really i think i just did i know and i feel like i should cancel you for that for saying that god uh beacon chain eth supply it's all-time highs up it's up the same flat We're continuing to go up.
Okay, so this chart is all-time highs. How much ETH do we have deposited? 18.5 million Ether. Yeah, so if you zoom in real close, I think this is one of those charts where you can click and drag and it'll automatically zoom in and we can get real close. I can get you the month. We can settle for that. Yeah, 18.5 million Ether is deposited onto the beacon chain. It is going up faster than it has ever gone up before. Man. Which is pretty cool. A lot of people were wrong about this. They said post withdrawals, it would be going down and it's not going down. It's going down. Well, it went down for not even two weeks.
It went down for like 10 days. So here's a cool new website. I mean, actually it's really boring. It's actually a very boring website. But it's still- Yeah, it's not. The information is cool. Yeah, but there are five lines of text here. The most boring website I've ever seen. Yeah, so this is ethereum2.0 validator queue, validator hyphen queue hyphen monitoring. God, I'm not even going to read that. There's a link in the show notes. It basically tells you two things. It sucks, honestly. I'm sorry to whoever made this website. It's supremely useful. It is basically a tug of war between the depositors and the validators, and it tells you who is winning that tug of war.
So pending validators on the entry queue is at 55,000 pending validators. 55,000 pending validators. If you want to make a new validator, it will take you 731 hours to get through that line. If you are a validator who would like to exit and stop being a validator, it will take you, drum roll, four minutes. Four minutes? Four minutes to exit. If I want to leave, it only takes four minutes. But if I want to get in, it's like the best nightclub ever, man. Yes. It's just the line just keeps getting longer. 731 hours to get into the nightclub and four minutes to exit. Man, people really want to be on the beacon chain.
They totally do. Wow. Well, congrats, Ethereum, for that. All right, let's talk about some other market news. David, I think the big question this week in the markets is where are we in the cycle? You just kept talking about flat. And I feel like that's a pretty good description. But let's start the highest level. What is the Fed doing this week? And can the Fed actually declare victory on their interest rate rises? And are we going to stop doing that? This is Paul Tudor Jones, who is a billionaire investor, manages a hedge fund, is someone the traditional finance markets respect on that question.
Here he is on CNBC. I want to know what you think about this, David. Here, I'm going to play it. I actually want you to react a little bit to this Austin Goolsbee interview and some of his comments. I'm curious where you think interest rates will go, should be. What do you think? I think they've done hiking. I'm so glad I don't have his job because listening to these guys try to not say what they really want to say and what they really think. What do you think he really wants to say? All he wants to say, we're done, we've gone too far, and enough's enough. That's what he wants to say. He just can't say that because he's new on the board and he has to follow the chairman.
But that's what he wants to say. And what do you want to say? I think he's right. I think they're done. You think they are done? Definitely, I think they're done. I mean, they could probably declare victory now, because if you look at CPI, it's been declining 12 straight months, 12 straight months. That's never happened before in history. So there's a strong downward arc to inflation at the moment. Two-year break-evens are under 2%. Clearly, they have to be governed by trailing 12-month inflation. But if we get to the here and now, you can see that inflation to a great extent has been run out of the market.
Now, does that mean that we're getting ready to imminently cut? No. But you got to think of interest rates a bit like chemo. So chemo, chemotherapy, chemo is poison. Interest rates with the kind of amount of sector-wide debt that we have between private consumer and the government, we're probably at levels where we've typically hit a recession in the past because of the interest tax on the economy. So we're at a level that historically has really slowed the economy and historically has kicked off a recession. I think it's just a question of what goes on, David. And then he talks about equity markets and he says this on equity prices.
I think they're going to continue to go up this year, but I'm not rampantly bullish because I think it'll be a slow grind. But he thinks equities end the year higher than they began the year. So what's your take on all of this? Can the Fed declare victory? Are they done? What do you think about Paul Tudor Jones and his takes on this market? Well, first and foremost, Paul Tudor Jones is way smarter than me and way more informed. So take that take all my further words with with that um he said cpi is down for 12 months in a row yes and core cpi is not and that is the bigger deal and the more important one and that is such an obvious fact that i'm sure paul de tudor drones has something to say about that response however to say that like oh yeah inflation 12 months in a row is down like that's not the whole story.
The issue is also up a lot. Yeah. Right. And so the last time I checked, which was not too long ago, it was six weeks ago. Core CPI has not had not reversed. And that is the bigger story that I've thought. And so in order to have a more informed take, I would need to go back to the core CPI numbers and compare that to what Paul Tudor Jones is saying. But Paul Tudor Jones is like smarter than me about this interest to high interest rates as as chemo. And I guess that means like debt is like cancer or like uh i don't know meme stock markets are like mal-informed investment poor capital allocation is in is cancer yeah that is the cancer you have to cut out of the system anyway um the fed is done raising rates now is the message i think you might be right on that core message but that brings us to the crypto markets and this is uh something we talked about last week david and maybe we want to put more flesh on this because last week a theme was liquidity is drying.
It's a desert out there because liquidity is drying out in crypto markets. This is Ram, who's been a previous guest on the Bankless podcast now a couple of times, who has some great insight on this, on liquidity and crypto. What's he telling us? So I believe Ram is actually following up with what we were saying last week in the market section, because in our Telegram channel with him, he was like, hey, really good points about liquidity, which I usually don't have good takes about macro markets. Except that one, I was like, Like, okay, I think I'm right about this one. And then he comes in and follows up.
And so here's what he says. Crypto markets liquidity has dried up significantly. These are the consequences of a lack of a crypto bank settlement layer, Silvergate and Signature. Market makers need a way to settle instantly with counterparties. So here's the part that we missed last week. Silvergate and Signature had SEN, SEN, and SIGNET, their interbank instant settlement layer between banks that market makers would use. And so in crypto, the problem was seemingly solved with SEN and SIGNET. a market maker can enjoy instant settlement. One benefit is not having to type capital on many exchanges or waiting several days or funds to clear.
Lack of instant settlement hurts capital efficiency. The banks intermediate these transactions. They confirm tractions and validate sufficient funds, just like the blockchain. And so what he's saying is that, yes, all the reasons that we talked about last week are reasons why there's liquidity leaving the market and also the specific products that these crypto banks made in order to satisfy crypto market makers called Cignet and Send, and Send Transfers. And so these specific products are missing now from the market because Chokepoint choked them. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, the settlement infrastructure for crypto was operating behind the scenes, almost like a private sidechain or a private blockchain, and it was settling all these transactions.
And this is no longer the case. Yeah. We had Ram on the podcast to talk more about this, and I would encourage folks to go listen to that if you already haven't about the U.S. banking system and the crisis that we've seen recently. So this is the part of the market, David, we've been calling the apathy market. We've gone from bear market, where that was obvious, to bore market, right? From bear to bore market. And this is how Anthony Sassano puts it. I love how the entire market has been bleeding nonstop for like a week now, and crypto Twitter's pretty much dead silent about it. Clearest sign I've seen so far that we're now firmly in the time-based capitulation part of the bear market.
time-based capitulation. That's the part of the bear market we're in says Anthony, what does he mean by that? Uh, he means that now it's boring. And so, uh, time-based capitulation. So the excitement is over even when like prices are going down and like there's blood on the streets, at least it's still exciting. Uh, so Anthony is saying is like, well now like all we've bled all of our blood, like we got nothing left to bleed. We all, the excitement has left the market. Now, now we just have to wait this one out. That term capitulation though. Um, he means like people give up in the board market.
Don't they? They capitulate. They're like, ah, it's not moving. Like it's not going up. It's not going, it's, it's going to go down forever. Crypto numbers, the numbers aren't even going down. If it was going down, it'd be exciting. Now it's just flat. They sell. And so they sell, they capitulate in this type of market. That's the market phase that we're in right now. As if on cue, David, I just saw this this morning from the Economist. Here's the headline. I've read the whole story, but it's kind of summarized in the headline. The promise of crypto has not lived up to its initial excitement.
A crypto finance revolution looks further off than ever from the Economist. That's a bearish sentiment headline. This is the apathy market headline. You're going to see a lot of these in the weeks and the months to come. And it's up to you if you want to do the time-based capitulation part or you want to hold through this to the other side. But I got to tell you, man, there's nothing new under the sun. We've done this a few times now in crypto. Like I've seen these headlines before. So you know what this means to me? What? The bear market is half over. I totally agree with you. Yeah. I totally agree with you.
We are now in 2019. 2018 is over. 2019 has started. The true convicted people will watch the innovation happen and learn to be excited about that, even if it doesn't mean the prices are going to do anything. And they will learn to be excited about that. And then the prices will return and then the bear market or bull market will start. And then you actually won't, if you were like me, you won't know what you're really in for with a full bear market, starting from the low, low prices that we're currently at. Anyways, that's how it happened last time. Happy 2019, everyone. I mean, it's just 2019, but it's 10 X, right?
I remember like, uh, 2019, Heath was saying it in the hundred to like two 50 range forever over and over and over. Well, what are we right now? What is the equivalent? right like just you know 10x that a thousand to two thousand that's like a hundred to two like it's so crazy dude it's like it's out of zero the crypto gods are giving us yet another opportunity my friend if you're here you probably see it um this is a chart that i do like looking at though total locked value in layer twos this is on layer two beat of course this hasn't changed a ton of course we've got arbitrum number one 5.87 billion in optimism coming in but look at this activity chart so this is the number of um transactions yo look at that zk sync era all right immutable x wow we got that's actually the first time we've seen chains be equivalent to ethereum throughput that's pretty cool yeah immutable x for people who can't see this on screen immutable x number one with a seven day increase of 250 percent and um transaction throughput higher than ethereum mainnet zk sync up almost 200 as well over the last seven days getting to uh equivalency of ethereum mainnet transactions per second and if people are like uh i thought layer twos are supposed to be faster than ethereum ethereum layer one is clogged it is as fast as it's ever going to go yeah immutable x zk sync these are zk rollups these are not clogged people just aren't using them enough yeah but we have equivalent amount of usage of these things as ethereum so it's cool and then like if you aggregate it all together which is this red graph an aggregate man we have not been reporting on this like i think the last time we talked about this a scaling factor of combined layer twos was like 2.
4 we're up to 3.7 so layer twos are doing 3.7 times as much economic activity it's an all-time high in economic activity on layer twos economic activity in transactions per second not total value nuances but still yes uh economic activity of transactions yes transaction yeah transaction volume and what was interesting to me is um these are both zk this is both zk technology not optimistic technology the immutable and that's right so good news all right we had a lot more to talk about david what's coming up coming up we got to talk about the big news of the week. Is your ledger safe or should you throw it down the toilet?
Ethereum, it's got a finality outage. Is it safe or should you also throw it down the toilet? We don't know. Bedrock on optimisms coming to main net. Say hello to DRC20s. You remember what DRC20 is, Ryan? Dr20? Okay, I don't know what this is now. I don't know. Yeah, well, I'm about to tell you. So we're going to get to all of this and more as soon as we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible, especially Kraken, our preferred exchange for 2023. If you do not have an account with Kraken, consider getting one in the show notes. Here we go. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry, the place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade.
On Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data, and lightning-fast trade execution, all inside their spiffy new modular interface. Kraken's new customizable modular layout lets you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs. Visit pro.kraken.com to get started today. Immutable is at the forefront of Web3 gaming, on a mission to bring digital ownership to every player, offering the world's best games and game development platform.
Immutable lets game builders and players focus on great gaming experiences. So build your next Web3 game on easy mode with Immutable's leading full stack Web3 gaming platform. It's built in UX features like the Immutable Passport are designed for games to scale to the next billion players coming to Web3. With Immutable, players can sign up with an email, pay with a credit card and experience a frictionless purchase flow inside of games. So discover your next favorite game and explore a network of 150 games building on Immutable, including such titles as Gods Unchained, Guilds of Guardians, Illuvium, Embersword and Metalcore.
So join Web3's largest ecosystem of games and players. Build, play, and connect at immutable.com. Introducing ETHX from Stater. ETHX is a liquid staking token designed to maximize rewards all while securing Ethereum. With Stater, you can run an Ethereum node with just 4 ETH, which is 85% lower capital and 35% higher rewards versus solo staking. Stater has a multi-pool architecture with permissionless and permission node operators to enable decentralization and scalability. Stater has extensive experience in building liquid staking protocols on six proof-of-stake blockchains and is trusted by over 70,000 stakers.
Stater has partnered with over 40 leading protocols to bring DeFi utility to their liquid staking tokens. Stater is actively building integrations across the Ethereum ecosystem to bring the same great DeFi utility to the EtherX token. With a million dollars of SD token rewards in DeFi, force EtherX users. All of Stater smart contracts are audited by at least two independent cybersecurity auditors and have multi-million dollar bug bounties currently live. So go to staterlabs.com slash ETH to sign up and get access to the Stater staking protocol. What happened to Ethereum last week? David, after we recorded last week's roll up, there was a hiccup and then there was a second one on the Ethereum network.
What happened to Ethereum? Can you give us the details? Yeah, so Ethereum blocks stopped finalizing for about 25 minutes, and then the second non-finality event lasted for about over an hour. And so what does finality mean? Blocks are still processed. Transactions go into blocks. Blocks are still sent around, but they are not being finalized, as in they are not having the last line of security locking those blocks into the chain. So blocks are still being added to the chain, but they are not being permanently embedded under the full weight of proof of stake yet. And so this is an interesting nuance.
And so we did a show with Preston Van Loon and Terrence from Prismatic that will be able to explain this deeper. But just at a high level, every single validator does attestations. And so there was a large amount of attestations due to the increased number of validators because so many new stakers are coming online. there is increased requirements between bandwidth and also computation. And so a bunch of attestations are being sent around and that overloaded a number of validators and excuse me, a number of clients. And so Tecku and Prism released software updates pretty quickly that strengthened and fixed this part.
And then all of a sudden we were able to return to finality. And then we had a unique lesson learned about how Ethereum works and a contingency patched. And so that's the TLDR. How would you add to that? I think that's a great... So Ethereum didn't go down. This wasn't an outage, as we've seen with other networks like Solana, which was a straight outage. Transactions couldn't move forward for like hours at a time in some cases. This was a temporary halting of finality, which is different. I wouldn't even use the word halting if we wanted to be super precise. We did not achieve finality, but nothing is halted.
Right. Right. And so some people were saying that like Ethereum broke in this case. Some people. And some people. Can you believe it? Like some people even tweeted that out as a headline and then explained it in the details of the body of the tweet. But we're not precise about that. But Ethereum didn't break in that sense. In fact, this is kind of a demonstration of its resilience. If you want all the details, go to the episode that we just did with Preston and Terrence. But I think this showcases the value of a multi-client architecture for 100%. Exactly. Okay. So Prism and Teiku had this problem.
Lighthouse, no problems whatsoever. So Lighthouse, like, I don't know, Ethereum's working fine for me and I'm doing my thing. And so Ethereum's just going to keep on going because I'm going to put Ethereum on my shoulders. It's also, it also demonstrates kind of the blend of proof of stake that Ethereum is, which is kind of the priority of liveness. So Ethereum doesn't go down. It can be delayed, but it does not go down in the same way that other chains go down when they prioritize safety with proof of stake. So David, let's take a peek at client diversity. I didn't know there was an entire page about this, but clientdiversity.
org. There's an entire page about everything in Ethereum. All right, so what are we looking at here? This looks like some charts on distribution of two types of clients, consensus clients and execution clients. How would you explain this? Yeah, okay, so two kinds of clients. One is consensus clients, aka beacon chain clients, and then execution, which is the actual processing of transactions. Nuance there, but also really important. Consensus clients is the beacon chain. So we got Lighthouse, Prism, Tecu, Nimbus, Lodestar. These are what we previously called ETH2 clients. And so Lighthouse and Prism equally have about 38%, followed by Tecu with 16%, followed by Nimbus.
And so it was Prism and Tecu that had the shared bug. And so that's actually one of the unique properties about a non-finality event. When a non-finality event happens, you actually know that it is a bug that is shared by multiple clients, which is a serious thing. And that is why this is an event is because there is one bug that multiple clients had. So it showed up in Ethereum. If this was just one client, and say if it was like Nimbus at 6.5%, and Nimbus had a catastrophic client that just broke every single node, you wouldn't notice it. Not only would you not notice it, you would still actually get finality because Nimbus is only at 6.
5%. At Lighthouse, if all Lighthouse clients went down, you would not achieve finality because it would get to below 66%. And so because Lighthouse has 38.2% of all nodes, Lighthouse has enough clients that we would get below that two-thirds threshold. And so Prism at 37 and Teiku had this bug, but Lighthouse and the other clients held the system up. And so this is the importance of client diversity. and also again why when there's one bug in multiple clients that is when client teams wake up and start fixing the problem immediately which is what Preston and Terrence and other people across the client teams did thank you for your service and so this is just a quick lesson in client diversity and while multiple clients had the bug call it a bug the rest of the clients kept Ethereum up So like think of it like Atlas holding up the world, right?
And every single client is an arm. And the strength of the arm is related to the share of nodes that they have. How's that for an explanation? Multiple armed Atlas. Yeah, totally. And the cool thing is building a new arm is permissionless. So you can always build a new arm because it's... You want to build a new arm? No, I'd rather talk about people who build arms. Yeah, it seems way harder to actually build arm. This is a take from David Hoffman. ethereum in quotes is a composition of diverse and distributed components none of which are individually critical to ethereum components can and will fail but the chain will continue this downtime non-event illustrates this perfectly single client systems are weak and fragile fast systems cannot hold a distributed set of components since more components require slower systems to maintain consensus fast chains minimize components and therefore maximize fragility i think you are saying here, David, that this event showcases the design decisions that Ethereum has made, which is to maximize liveness, to maximize resilience, to not go down at the sacrifice of some other things, right?
Ethereum is not the fastest layer one from a transactions per second perspective. It is a slow chain. Tell me more about this. Yeah. So the slowness of Ethereum, the decentralized nature of Ethereum allows for more components, more clients to be a part of the network. And the idea here is that Ethereum is designed, intentionally designed, so that components will fail and Ethereum will continue because Ethereum is not one thing. What is Ethereum is a question, not an answer. And so if you go back to the client diversity page, like what is Ethereum? Well, it's 38% Lighthouse, it's 37% Prism, it's 16% Teiku, and those numbers are in flux.
And there can be other nodes that come online or other valid clients that come online. And so Ethereum as a system just needs a majority of these things to work. And even if a majority of these things don't work, that actually doesn't take down Ethereum because it only takes down one component of Ethereum, which is finality. That's only the cherry on top of what makes a blockchain a blockchain. And so like these considerations have been deeply considered by the ETH researchers out there. And so the actual fact that this happened and Ethereum didn't stop and then also naturally recovered quickly, along with the help of some superstar client teams, it just shows the resiliency of the system at large.
This is a question from the Bankless Discord from AlexRowe.eth that I think is relevant here. In light of Ethereum recently, in quotes, breaking, is this too soon? Can you explain block reorgs? It sounds like a reorg could cause chaos, but each block produced is susceptible to it for two epochs, I believe. Is this not a huge risk? Can you explain block reorgs in the context of this? Yeah, so blockchains are a chain of blocks that go one by one by one. And sometimes, due to the construction of a blockchain, we pick a new header. And so maybe two or three blocks are added to the chain. and then actually because of the mechanics of the chain, it goes backwards like three blocks for whatever reason.
This happens in Bitcoin every now and then, like not too long ago, there was like, I think like a 10 Bitcoin block reorg, if I'm not mistaken, maybe not that much. But the idea is it's possible. And so the joke here is that like, everyone was freaking out about Ethereum not having finality for like over a little bit over an hour. Do you know when the last time Bitcoin has had finality, Ryan? No, I don't. 13 years ago, because Bitcoin doesn't get finality. Yeah, it doesn't get deterministic. It doesn't get deterministic finality. It's like economic weight, probabilistic finality, of course. Right, so rolling back the Bitcoin blockchain back to block zero is technically possible, and within the rules of the Bitcoin system, it just costs a lot.
Ethereum, because of the innovations of proof of stake, achieves finality in six minutes. And then if you want to go backwards in time more than six minutes, it takes, you are provably going to slash two thirds of all staked Ether. In the event of non-finality, this is when there is susceptibility to block reorgs. And so that is the risk here. That is why this is important because we are no longer having our massive wall of capital slashing to protect a reorg event. And so while there are other penalties, there's not like the big penalty. So it is a risk. And this is why when Preston and others saw that Ethereum mainnet wasn't having finality, they didn't just say, oh, okay, we'll just wait.
No, they got up and fixed the problem. But that's because Ethereum has a culture of maximum security. And so, yeah, the risk for a reorg doesn't just, there's more and more nuances there. I think one other thing I would say is it can sound like without Terrence and Preston waking up or client teams waking up and fixing the problem, that Ethereum would never have finalized. It still would have finalized. It still would have finalized. That's the point. What would have happened is this client distribution would have changed. A whole bunch of validators would have switched over to Lighthouse. And the network would have rolled on.
So this is not a case where this was reliant on the client devs to like pop up in the in the middle of their day and like wake up from their like naps. Preston was literally almost going like for a nap at the time and like fix it. It would have resolved itself as well. They just restored the resilience back to the network. They did it faster. So when parts in parts of Ethereum are not doing their job, they get penalized. There's like producing an invalid block and then you get slashed and that's the big one. But if you're not also doing your job, you get penalized in a minor way. And the idea is like as soon as, and this is actually did start to happen, when there isn't finality for enough amount of time, the sources of non-finality start to get penalized marginally, and then a little bit more, and then a little bit more.
And then eventually they get penalized so much that the actual, the network starts to return to consensus because the people that are producing, helping produce finality are not getting penalized. And so the system is naturally finding an equilibrium because that is what a good crypto economic system does. There's a much better explanation if you just listen to the podcast. There it is. It's right here. It's right here, guys. If you want to use this apathy market to level up on your Ethereum knowledge, this is a good time to do that. David, speaking of level ups, Ledger Recover, all right? Was this a level up for Ledger or was this a big mistake?
The question on people's minds is, is Ledger safe this week? That is the hardware device that we're talking about. And give us the context for this, because it all started when Ledger decided to announce a new product called Ledger Recover. Take us there. So Ledger introduced a new product called Ledger Recover, which lets you recover your seed phrase using your ID, which for the normies of the world was probably they're like, nice, great, love that. That's what I'm used to. If I'm if my bank account like I can't access it, I'll just show them my ID and they let me in. That's normal. For the crypto hardliners out there, you understand the risks associated with that.
That has new risk assumptions that triggered a lot of the crypto. Shivers up your spine when you see this. Exactly, yes, right. We don't want nation state IDs to be our recovery process. So the way that this works is that you subscribe to this Ledger Recover through the Ledger Live app. You go in and make an account and then go through the ID verification process. On your device, after pin verification, you will ask to initiate a recover backup process. So you ask your own device, like your device has to, Hey, do you want to do this thing? And you're like, yes. Um, so after you consent to that, the ledger takes your seed phrase that's inside of the ledger, shards it into three, encrypts it, and then sends it outbound to these three custodians of your sharded private key.
One is ledger to our, uh, alternative custodians in different parts of the world. And then these are the people that you go show your ID to, to, in order to get your seed phrase back. So it is a way to, if you lose your seed phrase, use your ledger, your nation state ID can get you your seed phrase back. Again, it makes sense to a lot of people. And so that is kind of this new product that I think will make sense to a lot of people who are not in crypto. I think prescient bankless listeners can understand where people started to get concerned. The idea here is that people, including myself, always assumed that your private key cannot leave your hardware wallet because that's the point.
And so I'll nevermind the fact that it's sharded and then encrypted and then sent into three different spots, which is probably a very secure way to do this. The fact that it can do it at all is new information for a lot of people. And so if you can- That's the idea. That's the idea. The idea of software being able to pull out your seed phrase, pull out your private keys is just like very concerning because that is the point of a hardware wallet. You don't want anyone to be able to pull out those private keys without you knowing about it. And so the idea is like, okay, well, if you can do it securely, what's stopping you from doing it insecurely?
and so this is like okay you can shard it encrypt it but you can also just do it in plain text and that is theoretically possible the fact that it's theoretically possible is like the new information so people on twitter got very upset because this is like a perceived rug by ledger and then also i'm going to add on that ledger comms was not the most not the greatest about this so here's a tweet that people really didn't like which was technically speaking it is and always has been possible to write firmware that facilitates key extraction. You have always trusted ledger not to deploy firmware, whether you knew it or not.
Technically the truth, but oof, as a PR statement, oof. Well, you say oof, but this is the, this is the actual truth. So, so just describing like you have to opt into the ledger recover service. Yeah. Like of course. Right. And so, um, you, And you also have to opt into a new upgrade of the Ledger firmware. New firmware, right. Which if you have Ledger, a Ledger device of any kind, you probably have already done not only once but multiple times in the past to get security updates, to get new feature unlocks, that sort of thing. So you have to do that. And lastly, you actually have to click a button on your Ledger device.
Really important point. in-person consent anytime a seed phrase or the private keys are actually leaving the hardware wallet. So there's kind of like three steps here, right? And most people will not do the recover service, right? That's kind of a total trust ledger thing. Most people will also want to continue to upgrade their firmware, all right? But there is this like fallback of unless you physically put in your pin number in the ledger interface and click the check mark button, it will not send your seed phrase externally from the wallet. Right. I think that's an important consideration here in this, in this, this whole kind of mess, but, and yet still people are uncomfortable with the idea that a firmware upgrade, um, can maybe put in an errant message or something, or could somehow well the idea is that we are now people are now realizing that we are one firmware upgrade away from a key extraction type of firmware that that's right in the worst case scenario you just approve any transaction and because it was a malicious firmware upgrade from who knows where that fake transaction the next time you you press the check mark button that you're in your private keys outbound right so that's that people thought that that was not possible but it turns out to be possible and now because we are in mob season on twitter uh ledger has been absolutely mobbed by this and so this is now just talking about like the social drama uh should we go to this tweet david this is a video and i actually this this twitter user has me blocked so i have to open hilarious hold on oh oh that is a ledger being hit with a hammer oh oh it's broken wow that's what it looks like inside.
Oh, it's in a fire pit now. It's going in a fire pit. Oh, we got a blowtorch. Oh, we got a guy blowtorching a ledger. Oh, that ledger is toasty. Oh, that ledger's dead. Bye-bye seed phrase. Wow. Yeah. Well done on the toast job, though. Yeah. Okay. I get it, Ryan. We can stop. I hope that guy backed up his seed phrase. are people you know doing other things with this this is the only one I saw about it and I actually I saw it linked in discord or someone like are people like putting it in blenders and running over it with their cars and you know the typical let's go on we'll talk about this at the end let's go to the next we have to go through the twitter mob part of this agenda and then we'll go all right all right so here's another tweet from Fubar let's let's read this stop using ledger hardware wallets migrate away from them immediately they've shown nothing but gross incompetence and wild misunderstanding of their own purpose and now they've publicly admitted intentionally backdooring their own proprietary hardware.
Stop using Ledger. Ooh, big words. Intentionally backdooring their proprietary hardware. That's interesting. Okay, let's keep going. Okay, so these tweets are in order from most extreme to more reasonable. So now we're starting to get into the more reasonable side. Here's Munit Gupta who said, Ledger just released a new update for Nano X that allows social recovery of your seed phrase and encrypts your seed into three shards, sends it to different entities, and then it can reconstruct your seed from your post ID verification. It's a horrendous idea. Do not enable this feature. Now that is a take that is talking about how you actually have the option to not do this, which again, understand is only half the issue, but you can opt out of this.
Let's go to the last take of this whole series, which I think is the most reasonable take, which is Hasib, which of all the people drawing a big hubbub on Twitter was actually helpful here. And so he goes, yesterday I freaked out about the revelation that Ledger could spit out your private key with a firmware update. Yet I noticed the smartest people were not freaking out. Was I missing something? I spent the evening educating myself and now I'm in the nevermind is fine camp. So then he continues and goes, my initial mental model is I thought Ledger secure enclave was like Apple secure enclave, a box that has private key lines in which I can only sign things, but the keys can never leave the device, but it's not.
Firmware can exfiltrate the private key, oh God. And then he finishes and says, this take is actually nonsensical. This cannot be how it works because ledgers upgrade. Most people's instincts are like, wait, why even? I don't want my hardware to wallet to ever upgrade, but ledgers upgrade to support evolving blockchains. Ethereum now requires BLS signatures. There's Solana, Near, Aptos, all this new stuff, new signing algorithms, new key derivations, all this fanciness. Aside from Bitcoin, every single blockchain evolves. And so the point here is that the secure enclave in your ledger has always actually been software.
It is a hardware wallet, but there is software inside that secure enclave. And the point that you said earlier that everything actually doesn't necessarily fall back to the Ledger hardware wallet, but it does fall back to you pressing approve. That is the actual remaining part of the Ledger. That is the hardware of you hitting that approve button, not the secure enclave itself. And so this is the new reality that, by the way, has always been the reality. And if we as an industry were more informed about this, there wouldn't be this mob attack. posture that's the security posture you've always accepted when you've purchased a ledger device to hold your private keys and some people are just now aware of that right yes and so uh are we is this where we get into our takes okay are we are we ready for so this has been like the us doing a trying to do an objective job of reporting it i'm ready to give yeah and i will say uh we we talked to you um charles the chief security officer on bankless um i think uh if you're interested in hearing from at least the Ledger side, how this works and what went on, you can listen to that episode.
We tried to be as objective as possible, but I think people come to the roll up for some takes too. And I would be interested in hearing your takes. What are your takes on this episode, David? My takes are Ledger did nothing wrong. It was the crypto industry's collective misunderstanding as to how a hardware wallet works. Here's all of the blame that I will place on ledger there is the narrative and the marketing that your private key cannot leave your hardware wallet and there's two different ways to interpret that there's it can't leave the hardware wallet because the firmware up to this point has not allowed it and then there's the it can't leave the hardware wallet because the hardware doesn't allow it maybe ledger benefited by that gray area and meant the software version but but got the benefits of the hardware version maybe that's the and that has been their comms mishap for years now of advertising, maybe being able to double dip and say like the hardware wallet will not allow your private keys to leave the wallet, but not saying that that's because of the software, the firmware that we upgrade.
And so maybe that is their- It wasn't clear. That's their bad. But Ledger is frustrated because they've been here in crypto helping people go bankless this entire time. And now Ledger is being canceled from what appears for them to be like no good reason. Like you guys install firmware updates. The trust model is completely the same as it's always been. And y'all are just like learning about this for the first time. And so I think that coming to that conclusion has actually not been that hard. And so now my final take, Ryan, is I am actually disappointed in the people who have taken the opportunity to jump into mob mentality about this and cancel culture so quickly and make viral videos of them smashing their ledgers with a hammer and a blowtorch just because they know they're going to get a bunch of likes because it is currently in vogue to cancel Ledger.
So that is my set of takes. Jeez, that take is going to be pretty damn unpopular this week, David. I think the mob mentality is coming after me next. Come at me. That's what I believe. Ledger did nothing wrong. I think that you say nothing wrong is your summary, and yet you also said they did something wrong. They could have done something better, but I understand the error. This is where I come down on things. And I think I largely agree with what you said, but I want to put a fine point on what you said. So this is also from Foodbar. This is a tweet from Ledger from November 15th, 2022. Hi, from Ledger, the Ledger account.
Your private keys never leave the secure element chip, which has never been hacked. The secure element is third-party certified and is the same technology as used in passports and credit cards. A firmware update cannot extract the private keys from the secure element. A firmware update cannot extract the private keys from the secure element. Okay. Here's what I'm saying, David. I think that is technically true from what I understand, unless you hit the approve button. Okay. Yes. So you could read this tweet and be like, yes. However, by not making it emphatically clear that you are still a nefarious firmware update from Ledger away.
From Ledger, you're trusting them to not snatch your private keys. I think that there's a little bit of an omission there, or at least a little bit of a communication mishap. So that's what I'll say. The other thing I'll say, David, is I actually think this could have happened no matter what they did from the comm side of things, right? It was just the time in the universe where we decided to take a week and completely torch Ledger, all right? It's like, I get that. Now, what they can do in terms of moving the industry forward is they can choose to open source their firmware, elements of their firmware.
So let's take this. Yes, the reaction was probably extreme. Yes, there's a lot of people who didn't know. Yes, this was Ledger's misunderstanding and their target market and like, well, you just pissed off your core group through this comms. Yes, all of those things. And now how do we move forward? I would be supportive and call on Ledger to open source as much of their firmware as possible or to explain if there's pieces why they can't open source it, explain why. I think that could be the path forward because that's the best that we can really do. So what do I plan to do here? I'm not like going and torching my, you know, any ledger device i own um i plan to continue to use it but i've also always had redundancy different setups like don't just depend on one provider have ledger get a trezor if you want grid plus is a fantastic hardware wallet we've had them on the podcast before and i think they do a fantastic job on this still even with grid david you're still one firmware update from being screwed by Grid Plus, all right?
But if we have redundancy here, one thing that Grid Plus, I believe, is doing is open sourcing, moving to open source, more of their firmware in Q3. I think that's a positive step. It's good pressure on the industry to do it. I also think, let's zoom out, big picture, okay? Seed phrases do kind of suck. They kind of suck. And Ledger was trying to make that less sucky for normies. That is a noble effort. We want more people on the bankless journey. we don't just want to be like the crypto gold bugs here and so we got smart contract wallets we have npc technology that to me is the way forward so i also think that ledger made some mistakes but i agree with you it's not i don't know why we're choosing this week to cancel ledger so hard like just learn from it and then use whatever security posture uh you prefer for your private keys i've got i've got a take for you ryan and it actually ties these two stories together.
These two stories being Ethereum's multi-client design philosophy and Gnosis Safe. And so Martin Koppelman says, whatever wallet you are using that actually holds your keys, it's never a bad idea to use at least two different ones and combine them into a safe. And so I retweet this and I say, this is the same philosophy as Ethereum's multi-client design strategy. If one client fails, you have redundancy with orthogonal alternatives. The overlapping risk space of multiple strategies becomes minuscule. Okay. So, so you got a ledger, you got a, a, a lattice, a grid plus lattice. And so you also have a MetaMask and you do a two of three.
And if ledger rugs you, it doesn't matter because you need grid plus and MetaMask to access your Gnosis safe. Say MetaMask rugs. Well, you got your grid plus like two of three. And so this is the same security philosophy. That is how Ethereum multi-client design works. But since we have smart contracts and multi-sigs, which is a completely different realm, we actually can completely mitigate any risk whatsoever. So once again, solved by smart contracts. I agree. And that's just a very sensible reaction and security posture. I will say though. Oh, wait, I shouldn't burn my ledgers. No, you shouldn't.
But even in that, David, like smart contract risk on the safe wall, do you know what I mean? Like you're not going to get out of risk in this space. We're going west and crypto is risky and we're on the frontier at this point. That's right. Like, come on. Yep. Yep. I think that the moment I'll start to get concerned about this is if I hear of a firmware update that's been pushed and someone gets maliciously hacked, right? Yes. So far, all of this has been hypothetical. This is why I never install firmware updates first. I always let other people go first. Tell me first. That's a great security trick.
Let others go first. Yeah. Let others go first. Right. All right. Enough of that. So let's get to the SEC this week and more grilling of Gary Gensler, I guess. This is big, though. Absolutely massive. This happened late last week. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has just filed a brief in the Coinbase versus SEC case calling out the SEC for acting unlawfully in the digital asset space. This is the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, not the Chamber of Digital Commerce. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce represents all U.S. businesses in the United States. They have a massive presence in D.C. Metal Lawman says this is a big deal.
He says the U.S. Chamber is highly influential, and they represent companies across all industries, not just the U.S., and the brief opens with this. As it stands today, nobody knows for certain which digital assets, if any, are securities under federal law. Could not have put it better ourselves on a weekly roll-up. I think this is a big vote of confidence for Coinbase in what they're asking for from the SEC. It continues and makes three big points. Regulatory uncertainty is killing innovation in the U.S. The SEC is destabilizing the digital assets regulatory environment, and the SEC is violating constitutional due process and fair notice rights.
Basically, the chamber is declaring the SEC actions are not just harmful policy. They are unlawful. They're not just bad. They're illegal. which is great. The court will give these arguments advanced by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce serious attention. And like Ryan said, this is the largest, most influential business organization in the U.S., has just declared that it stands with crypto, represents the interests of more than 3 million businesses and organizations throughout the country, from small businesses to global corporations. Dope. I love that. These are great words. Did you see? So, David, this same week, SEC just responded to Coinbase's petition.
And you recall that petition we were talking about a week or two ago where Coinbase was asking the court to require the SEC to respond just yes or no, a simple yes or no, to whether it will undertake rulemaking for our industry. That's all they had to do was respond yes or no. You know what they responded with, David? Oh, boy. Here, tell me. 36 pages of legalese. I skimmed this. it just amounts to we don't have to if we don't want to that's my non-legal summary of this thing this is what paul graywall chief of legal at coinbase said today the secs responded to coinbase's petition asking the court to require sec to respond just yes or no the secs answer a resounding maybe uh resounding go fuck yourself basically sorry that's what they said so david maybe that was why Gary Gensler was so defensive this week when asked at a financial conference whether the SEC has provided sufficient clarity to crypto.
Here's what he said. Okay, can you comment at all on the dispute with Coinbase about rules on crypto? And why doesn't the SEC want to publish rules for that market? Because Tom, the rules have already been published. And to make it quite direct. This is a field that is in operating largely non-compliant. Our agency has put out rules about what it is to be an exchange, what it is means to be a broker dealer, what it is means to be an advisor or custody assets, and how to register a securities offering. Those rules are in existence and there's nothing about a new technology that makes it non uh he goes on i'm sick of hearing this but basically gary's rules are already clear right and again on the back of this he's doubling down on that well the chamber of commerce said that he's being illegal by doing that i like that he's in this situation right now david yeah so here's myles jennings from a16z lawyer lawyer at a16z sec come in and register coinbase we'd like to register sec you're not allowed.
Coinbase, why not? SEC, the rules are clear. Coinbase, the rules don't make sense. SEC, the rules are the rules. Can they be adapted? Yes, but we don't like your industry. But you've adapted rules before. No, we haven't. You approved our IPO. No, we didn't. Yes, you did. We're going to sue you. For what? Wouldn't you like to know? Yes. Too bad. You should have registered. But we would like to register. I bet you do. Can you tell us how? No. That is exactly what happened. Wow. That's a really long tweet. Good for him. Yeah, that's really good though. All right, David, what do we have coming up next?
Meanwhile, while crypto is eating itself and Gary Gensler's hot seat gets even hotter, Nike has built the most legit Web3 metaverse platform ever. WorldCoin is coming to optimism. Sam Altman testified before Congress and urged lawmakers to regulate AI. Bitcoin or Dogecoin, it's the same picture. So much to talk about, but first I want me to talk about these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible, especially MetaMask, who's helping you learn about all the jargon that Ryan and I don't have time to explain on the podcast. Sorry about it. But if you want to go learn all that jargon, there's a link in the show notes to go check out MetaMask Learn.
Learning about crypto is hard. Until now. Introducing MetaMask Learn, an open educational platform about crypto, Web3, self-custody, wallet management, and all the other topics needed to onboard people into this crazy world of crypto. MetaMask Learn is an interactive platform with each lesson offering a simulation for the task at hand, giving you actual practical experience for navigating Web3. The purpose of MetaMask Learn is to teach people the basics of self-custody and wallet security in a safe environment. And while MetaMask Learn always takes the time to define Web3-specific vocabulary, it is still a jargon-free experience for the crypto-curious user.
Friendly, not scary. MetaMask Learn is available in 10 languages with more to be added soon, and it's meant to cater to a global Web3 audience. So, are you tired of having to explain crypto concepts to your friends? go to learn.metamask.io and add Metamask Learn to your guides to get onboarded into the world of Web3. has a decentralized sequencer set, eliminating the risk of downtime and censorship on the network. And because Mantle implements multi-party computation nodes, layer one settlement execution is shortened from seven days to as low as just one or two. Mantle is the first layer two built by a DAO and is backed by one of the biggest DAO treasuries in the world, BitDAO.
Mantle already has sub-communities from around Web3 onboarded to help the growth of Mantle, like Game7 for Web3 gaming or EduDAO for the world of DeSci and Bybit for TVL, liquidity, and on-ramps. Check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. Nike's .swoosh platform is a brand new platform that Nike is rolling out to consumers. Not for us. This is not for us. So don't judge it because it's not for us. And if you're not a Nike, if you're not a sneaker head, this might not be for you. But it's a .swoosh platform. I think it's an allusion to .eth, but Dot Swoosh is the home of Nike virtual creations and community hub for Dot Swoosh members.
So they are creating like kind of like loot boxes, boxes of merch, virtual merch. So they have their OF1, our force instead of air force, you know, air force ones, but our force also OF1 collection of Nike virtual creations inside of an OF1 box. So OF1 create collection starts with each OF1 box comes in two forms, classic remix or new wave. Classic remix boxes contains an Air Force One inspired by Air Force One collections from 1982 to 2006. These are NFTs? These are NFTs. Well, I mean, these are digital collectibles, actually. Yes, virtual though. Virtual, yes. I'm not sending a box with sneakers to my house.
But I think if you are a sneakerhead who's collecting Air Force Ones from 1982 to 2006, you know exactly what they're talking about. The New Wave box features a brand new next generation reaching Air Force One that takes inspiration from 2007 to the present and even into the future. Scattered across both boxes are co-created Air Force Ones from our year, your Force One winners. These are all, so this is like a digital scavenger hunt collection for sneaker heads who like to collect. And not only that, but they have a swoosh ID, which secures your place in the dot swoosh community where you can meet members, collect virtual collections, get exclusive access to physical and virtual collections.
and then you can also co-create with Nike. And so what are collections? They are sneakers, apparel, accessories, other collectibles that you can use in games or other immersive experiences. Some Nike virtual creations will unlock benefits for you in the physical world, such as in real life products and exclusive events. Wow. Okay. No mention of an NFT though, which is kind of cool. And so you will get a wallet. They won't call it a wallet. You will have your wallet custody by BitGo, which is fine for this use case. Don't cancel Nike, Jesus. And the thing is like, you will buy these things with a credit card and you will buy digital assets with a credit card.
Guess on what blockchain, Ryan? It's not going to be on Ethereum. I know those are too high for this use case. Tell me. Polygon, on the Polygon blockchain. Where else would it be? I mean, they're getting the big ones. It could have been Flow. It could have been Flow. When I was looking at this, I was like, oh, is this going to be flow? Well, there you go. So, and the good news about Polygon is, of course, it has a future direction to become an Ethereum layer two as well. And you can take that asset and put it back on Ethereum if you want to. Speaking of layer twos, David, what's happening in the Optimism ecosystem?
Optimism is getting its Bedrock update. So Bedrock is coming down on June 6th. Ooh, that's D-Day. Never mind. an upgrade that will require two to four hours of downtime for OP mainnet. Once upon a time, I was a World War II history buff. Okay, so Bedrock will bring a 50% reduction in protocol fees. So optimism fees are getting cut in half. It's also going to make it easier to contribute to client diversity. So the OP stack getting an upgrade, improve the security and resilience of the OP mainnet bridge, will increase the minimum diff between OP mainnet and Ethereum, that Ethereum equivalent that we know and love, and also sets the stage for the super chain to enable more and more OP chains.
So that world, that super chain, that all those OP chains, every time you hear the world, hey, this is an OP chain or built on the OP stack, it helps that thing become a little bit more composed. So this is the first major protocol to Optimism to be voted on and approved by Optimism's token house. Interestingly, this will require two to four hours of downtime for OP mainnet, which is actually, I think I haven't seen that before for a layer two actually going down to start back up again um i'm sure that's going to cause some drama when that day comes and zooming out this is plenia speaking about i think ethereum's modular scalability strategy a standard chain one like ethereum that's 1x a fast chain i would assume that's a monolithic chain like a solana 10x fractal scaling 10 000 x this is why fast chains have only offered variations on the apps described nine years ago in the Ethereum white paper.
To explore the next frontier at scale on chain games, we need fractal scaling with thousands of chains. This is kind of alluding to what Optimism is doing with Bedrock and the idea of a layer three types of chains. Yeah, yeah. I think the whole idea of like, hey, we're going to scale by juicing up our monolithic chain in the future, that will just be an anachronism. As in, it'll just be like, hey, remember when like the crypto industry tried to scale with layer one chains that were juiced? like eventually we're watching layer twos get faster. We're watching the super chain gets composed. And so the super chain, fractal scaling, hyperscaling, these are all the same terms.
Yeah. And so like, we're going to watch and it's just going to blow people's minds about how fast these things can actually get. It's just going to take some more time to get there. David, how come we've never talked about this? I didn't know you were a world war two buff, man. Oh yeah. Oh yeah. So am I. Yeah. Oh, I know. I have read so many freaking books. What's your favorite World War II book? There's a book called D-Day. Yeah, I remember that one. It's been a while. It's been like 10 years since I've been sort of like deep into it. Would you compare our collections? Mine's Band of Brothers.
History? History podcast? You down? We could do like a World War II history podcast. You do a history podcast. Forget the food thing. I'll do a food podcast. It'd be great. All right. Tell me about WorldCoin. What are they doing? It's coming to Optimism Mainnet. So actually not an OP stack, although I think they have expressed plans to make an OP stack in the future. For now, WorldCoin. What do you mean by that? They're using optimism code. WorldCoin, yes. And so they will use the OP mainnet for WorldCoin, the coin. I think they also might use it for WorldID. Eventually, we did a podcast. I did a podcast.
Actually, you weren't there. With Sam Altman and Alex Blania from WorldCoin about the WorldCoin vision. I'm seeing a lot of world coin chatter start to heat up. So I think this is going to be a reoccurring conversation throughout the Twittersphere. Eventually they will have their own OP stack chain. For now they are putting their infrastructure on OP mainnet. More Sam Altman in this agenda too. Before we get there though, Lido, they just released withdrawals, I believe. That's right. Lido V2 enabled withdrawals, a bunch of other upgrades as well, along with a router. I couldn't find very many stats.
I think there were some big withdrawals from Lido, but that's what you would expect. And they were very temporary and very short-lived. The tug of war in the side of the smaller microcosm of Lido is TBD. I think Lido's going to be doing just fine. You know what's really cool too is the increasing amount of PayPal and Venmo support, at least in the US, for crypto. This is integration of PayPal and Metamask where you can just buy in Metamask, in your Metamask wallet, you can just buy crypto using PayPal. So you select PayPal, you choose the amounts, you tap it, and you've just purchased some ETH.
And this is also cool. You can also buy and send crypto from PayPal. So you buy your crypto in PayPal and then send it to Metamask. This is very big. This goes into the DeFi mullet thesis that we've been talking about so long, which is like, man, millions, hundreds of millions of users of Venmo and PayPal across the world. and all of them now have a way to onboard directly to a bankless wallet in something like MetaMask. I just think that is absolutely massive and worth celebrating. By the way, I think we're in touch with their team. Yeah, we're talking to them today about a future podcast episode.
Yeah, we want to see what they're up to. The podcast episode is going to be so easy. Like, hey, what's your guys' DeFi mullet look like? Yeah. Do you think they're going to understand that question? Well, that'll be the screener. They don't come on the podcast and let's say they understand that question. Okay, so here's something that happened pretty cool. This is a tweet from ZachXBT. He tweeted out, wow, both pump and dump meme coins, Nyan meme coin and Grumpy Cat coin were sent cease and desist letters on chain. So a cease and desist letter was turned into a JPEG, an NFT and sent them to the deployer address for these pump and dump coins from law firms.
Does that work? Does that work? Does that count as a cease and desist letter? I don't know. Have you received that letter if it's on chain and posted publicly? I don't. It's on the blockchain, bro. They do call it a wallet. I mean, I send it to your wallet. I send it to your address. I send it to your vault. Is this legally valid? It's in your custody. Well, yeah, but I get spam tokens sent to me all the time. It doesn't mean I look at those. There's a difference when no one tweets at me about my spam tokens. They definitely got tweeted about this because this is what this tweet is. if I put a cease and desist in your mailbox and I leave it in your mailbox, but you never open your mailbox, have you received it or not?
That's a big question. I think it's equivalent. So the cease and desist letter starts with May 17th, 2023, Kia Carmen, attorney at law, to the persons with wallet addresses listed below and all collectors. Attention, 0XDAE2D95, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. So like attention wallet owner. That's funny, man. That's funny. Okay, are you ready for this one, Ryan? I'm going to carry you through this one. Yeah, what's this? Say hello to DRC20's tokens on Dogecoin. So Dogecoin daily transaction volume climbed to a lifetime peak after the launch of DRC20 token standard, a new mechanism that allows the issuance of tokens on the Dogecoin blockchain.
650,000 transactions on Dogecoin on Sunday, briefly crossing both Bitcoin and Litecoin transactions before falling back down. and so ryan this is hilarious because the next part of this story is a bunch of doge fundamentalists not being happy no yes there are doge maximalists out there yeah so so not despite this increased uses of dogecoin people in the dogecoin community have said that this has led to network congestion that moves away dogecoin's aim of being used as an everyday currency the drc20 dogecoin community should stop this shameless hype, wrote one Dogecoin community member on Twitter.
Everyone should probably focus on the transactional currency use case, said another. High fees and network congestion are valid concerns for any blockchain that may lead the network to becoming expensive, slow, and for everyday users, dampening adoption plans. Does this sound familiar, Ryan? Oh my God, that's amazing. Are these people serious though? I thought Dogecoin was always a parody. Is this actually a serious crypto tribe? I don't know how to answer that question. And why DRC20s? I mean, maybe the better question is why not? Of course, there were going to be DRC20s. So we have an Ordinals on top of Doge, and now we have two camps inside of Doge.
It's like, get your stupid pump-and-dump tokens out of my extremely serious and legitimate global currency. That's the Will Smith slap to the face right there. Okay, in more serious news, Mika out of the EU has passed. Mika, they say Mika. Mika has passed. We saw this coming, right? Yeah. My summary of this is we did an episode on it with a bunch of panelists who know a lot more about it than you and I do. It's a B-minus, they say. And here's a take from one of the panelists that I'll quote. The EU never knows when to stop. This is the big but part. It's like, we got some good B-minus legislation.
That's good. But the EU never knows when to stop. MICA may be a B-minus, But the AMLR and Data Act and DAC8 is with the council. All are bad for crypto, and there's even more coming after that. So before anyone throws a we're moving to Europe party, they need to consider that things never get better in the EU. The regulation only gets heavier. So that is the fear on the back of this. And before you start celebrating, let's all move to Europe because it's better than the US. It is right now. The US doesn't have any clarity on crypto. though, just look in the pipeline of other things that might be coming down because I don't think the EU is done.
That's the what's the opposite of a silver lining? It's the opposite of a silver lining. All right. Lead lining. Yeah. Lead lining. Speaking of lead linings, Doquan is said to be released after Montenegro court accepts a four hundred and thirty six K bail. And we'll compress Doquan's getting out, David. Yeah. That's going to hang. Yeah. So I'm not too far away from from So the capital of Montenegro, Podgorica. God, that's taking me forever to learn how to pronounce. Is where he is. That is about an hour away from where I am. So under conditions of bail, Quan and Terra executive Han Chan-jan will be under surveillance and prohibited from leaving their apartment.
Yeah. You setting up the interview? Would you interview him? Would you talk to him? Yeah, sure, I'd interview him. Just be like, why'd you do this? Like, how has it been? Is that the question I would lead with? I think my first question is, do you feel guilt? Do you feel guilt? Yeah. Are you sorry? Yeah, are you sorry? But maybe that's too moralistic. Maybe she's just like, in order to get him to open up, you have to have the question of reflect on the last year and just leave it so open-ended. Right. So he can get a peek inside the mind. What do you want people to hear? Yeah. Because you can't corner him.
He's already cornered. Yeah. Anyway, that's not going to happen. But let's talk about regulation of a different type that we don't usually talk about. But while they're talking about crypto regulation in the US, really AI regulation is heating up. So what happened this week? So Sam Altman had to testify before Congress. And so we've seen this before. We've seen Web2 employees. We've seen Zuckerberg. We've seen the SBF testify before Congress. Sam Altman's turn. And so he actually urged lawmakers to regulate AI in specific ways. So he testified before the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Privacy, Technology, and the Law.
The hearing touched on the risks that generative AI could pose to society, how it could affect the jobs markets, and why regulations from governments might be needed. There's a useful clip, I think, that we should play. And last, I don't know if I'm allowed to do this, but I will note that Sam's worst fear, I do not think, is employment. And he never told us what his worst fear actually is, and I think it's germane to find out. My worst fears are that we cause significant— We, the field, the technology, the industry, cause significant harm to the world. I think that could happen in a lot of different ways.
It's why we started the company. It's a big part of why I'm here today and why we've been here in the past and we've been able to spend some time with you. I think if this technology goes wrong, it can go quite wrong. And we want to be vocal about that. We want to work with the government to prevent that from happening. but we try to be very clear-eyed about what the downside case is and the work that we have to do to mitigate that. Interesting response. Sam Altman, of course, he is the CEO of OpenAI, the creators of ChatGPT. What's your take on that response? I did a podcast with him on last Sunday, so six days ago, about WorldCoin, so a different subject.
Prior to this, I think I had an internal bias. I'm very aware of my biases, I'd like to say. I had an internal bias if I really wanted to not like Sam Altman why? just like kind of reptile tech bro reptiles a little bit of that we came out of the Eleazar podcast being like oh man this is going to take us over the world and then it's irresponsible for other CEOs of AI companies who are falling victim to the Moloch trap who are accelerating this thing so they are being irresponsible and so and then I like I listened to him answer Lex Friedman's question about AI alignment and I thought that he just man he just deflected the hell out of that one he asked he asked questions in return it was like well what do you think yeah it's like until I'm like man Sam bro look what's about to happen here and that and lately I have seen him in addition to the podcast and kind of seeing the human there I think I've seen him to tackle this alignment problem head on.
And I think the CEO leaders of these AI companies are also going to be the very likely solvers of AI alignment, if anyone. And so I think I'm cautiously optimistic that Sam Altman is not just a good guy, but a potential, God, I hate to say this word, hero in the fight of AI alignment. That is my optimistic, rosy colored glasses scenario. Plenty of other scenarios can play out, but I am hoping the best in Sam Altman and I'm starting to be okay with depositing, um, some trust there. I think his name will be, um, front and center will become a household name. If it hasn't already, that's how important this is.
I, uh, it always makes me uncomfortable, David, to be put in the situation of having to trust heroes and having to trust people. I will say that. And I think it's probably the case that we may never know what Sam Altman's, intentions actually are. We'll have to judge it by his actions. I mean, there is a more nefarious like case you could make, which is just, yeah, I'm going to put on this face in front of Congress and regulators say, come in and regulate me in order to like establish and entrench my own sort of power so I can help shape the regulations. Like there's like, remember SBF was doing a little bit of this.
Do you know what I mean? You just don't really know is the thing. And I, and he could be an incredible person. I have no idea. He could also be an SBF. We also have no idea. And it's just, I hate that we have to trust, but I don't think we do. I think we need to find ways to sort of verify and find other ways rather than relying on the human beings in this ecosystem, kind of put AI in the right direction, but interesting nonetheless, more to come. I'm sure on that, David, what do we got coming up next? Coming up next, we've got questions from the nation. We've got three of them this week. I think there's some great questions and then some pictures.
We're going to look at some pictures because that is going to be some, both some takes of the weeks and, uh, what Brian and I are excited about. And there is also a moment of Zen for the YouTube people. It is a video only moment of Zen. It is the most impressive of AI artificial generation of image video. Oh my God. It's so cool. You got to go watch it because it's actually really related to what Sam Altman was testifying about. Anyways, all of that's coming up and more as soon as we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. Hiring people worldwide, paying them in crypto, providing them access to benefits, it all is so complex, but it doesn't have to be.
Complying with labor laws, payroll rules, tax obligations, and crypto regulations in every country that you employ someone is difficult, time-consuming, manual, and costly, and it's drawing more and more attention from regulators and governments. But there is good news. Toku is here. Toku is the first employment and compensation platform for the crypto industry that makes this easy. Toku helps you hire employees or contractors and pay them in fiat or crypto legally, compliantly, and with all the taxes handled in over a hundred different jurisdictions. So whether you're an early stage company with just a team of two, or you're an enterprise with 200, Toku has a solution that meets your needs.
Toku is already working with the leading companies in the space, Protocol Labs, Hedera, Gitcoin, and many more. So transform your employment and token payroll operations with Toku. You can reach out to Toku at toku.com slash bankless or click the link in the show notes. Arbitrum One is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web3 landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum One, producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With the recent addition of Arbitrum Nova, gaming and social dApps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitrum home.
Both Arbitrum One and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. On Arbitrum, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees. With Arbitrum's recent migration to Arbitrum Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit arbitrum.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app. With Arbitrum, experience Web3 development the way it was meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free.
Questions from the nation this week. this one from thebigsalad.eve. Man, I love that E&S handle. Would it be possible for Ethereum to use MEV as partial gas refund to users? Would that be possible, David? So not only is that possible, but that is an explicit strategy that a number of startups are going after right now. Actually, this is one of the benefits that I think that Bankless Ventures has because we actually get to learn more about what's going on in the frontier and be educated about the frontier and be able to relay that information here on the podcast. There is a very decently saturated market of people that are trying to connect the circuit between transaction origination and MEV back to transaction origination.
So like transaction from the wallet, if you do a DeFi thing, it gets picked up by an MEV searcher bot, which makes another transaction, which goes into a bundler bot, which goes into a block builder, which goes into a block proposer, AKA ETH validator, who ultimately connects the MEV. But then there's a possible way where wallets who ultimately are the originators of transactions, aka the source of MEV, can be paid for their deal order flow, which we generally think of as toxic. But if that deal order payment for deal order flow goes back to the transactors for transacting in the wallet, there is a way where we can connect MEV to people who are making transactions as, yes, a gas-free fund.
So if your transaction produces MEV, your wallet might pay for that in some particular way. And so that is a thing that is being built by a handful of startups in this world. You know how when you use a credit card, you get like points, hotel points, or gas points, or discounts back? It's same, same, except this could be even better. Yeah, because it's ETH. I bet that'll be all sorts, it could be ETH, but there, yes, there could be all sorts of different models on top of this that Wallet's built. And the cool thing is crypto can pay you to spend and to transfer, to use crypto transactions. I think that's definitely coming.
All right. Here's a second question here about Bitcoin. Bitcoin has a history of legitimate and illegitimate hard forks, the most important being Bitcoin Cash. Well, we remember that. Whose central point was the network's block size? Bitcoin won that fight versus Bitcoin Cash based on choosing decentralization as the North Star, keeping one megabyte block size. The question is, if a hard fork is on the menu and thinking that Bitcoin's North Star is decentralization, which option is objectively more decentralized? a chain with or without ordinals. So I guess this is the idea, David, the questioning of whether Bitcoin might fork into two different options, one chain with ordinals and one chain without ordinals.
And the questioner is asking, which is objectively more decentralized? Can you imagine this future and help us make sense of this question from Abram CR? Yeah, so my podcast with Eric Wall, who actually is coming on next week with Nick Carter, actually, so we're actually gonna talk about some of these things. Eric Wall on the card next week. I'm excited about that one. He made the very strong argument, which I'm on board with, that the ordinals blockchain is the more decentralized blockchain. But I kind of want to ask, answer a slightly different question, which is, is Bitcoin going to fork? Because there is going, there's a growing civil war happening, a growing division in the tribes of Bitcoin.
There's, you have the non-ordinals and ordinolers and then the ordinolers. Oof. and so that is a new tribe the new internal tribes of bitcoin and now they are fighting for power and the last time this happened was the bitcoin cash versus bitcoin camp and so does this create a division strong enough to fight over a fork of bitcoin and my answer to that is i don't think so i think this this is fighting over social power who is at the helm of this ship can't really steal the ship because it's bitcoin but it's who who is the bigger bitcoiner and who are the bigger Bitcoiners? Who are the bigger, better Bitcoiners?
And right now, like Bitcoin Media, which runs the Bitcoin 2023 conference, which is going on right now, that company, it's actually more or less the bankless of Bitcoin. They are similar in vibe, very thesis driven, perhaps very biased. I would call them very biased. They are the Bitcoin fundamentalists of the Bitcoin camp. and they are starting to make ordinals content in the same way that you and I enjoy smart contracts and tokens because they are interesting and they're good to make content about and therefore benefits the bankless business model because our business model is content. Bitcoin media is also finding ordinals as a way to produce content because it's interesting and gets reads and clicks and likes and all that kind of stuff.
And also all of the people that I know and trust like Eric Wall and Nick Carter are also like, ordinals, good. and so I think that's gonna win David that's gonna win in the social air is my hundred percent it's more like people like Ponzi's we saw this in Bitcoin last week and so I think this should the power the pendulum power has shifted towards the ordinal of people yeah but you know what they're gonna want David they're really gonna want those Ponzi's to prop up their bags because anything a bit pointers like it's like number go up for Bitcoin that's funny it is because that's a mechanism that aetherium has that Bitcoin just doesn't which is like Like, okay, you have a Ponzi.
That's sort of annoying because it's making my transaction fees high. But then we go and we look at ultrasound.money and we're like, oh, look at all the ETH that was burnt. And then ETH holders are happy again. Well, Bitcoin ordinallers, maybe call them rather than small blockers. Maybe they're just useful blockers. Smart blockers. Maybe that's the tribe. Smart blockers, there. We got small blockers versus smart blockers. The smart blockers of the Bitcoin community don't get that benefit. Sorry. It's just not as fulfilling, I guess, if you want number to go up on Bitcoin. But it does pay for security, which is, I mean, marginally, but not zero.
The public good. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. All right. Let's get to some takes, David. Here's the first one from you. This looks like a picture and I think you're wearing the t-shirt. Tell me about this. Oh, yeah. Oh, I haven't talked about this yet. I'm going to look at the t-shirt. I got a t-shirt. David's shirt. Tornado cash. Symbol. I helped violate international sanctions and all I got was this lousy t-shirt. Okay. So this t-shirt is nothing new under the sun for the people that are inside of the conference circuit, but I haven't gotten one yet. And I would like to say, not only have I violated international sanctions by receiving 0.
1 ether from the dusting attack, I also sued the department of treasury over it. And so this, this t-shirt fits extra well. Yeah. And so wearing that to the congressional hearing or I guess Supreme court case. Yeah. And so like Amin Soleimani, who like made this t-shirt gave me this t-shirt. And so I I thought, of course I'm going to take a picture with Amin. But then I was reflecting on this picture, and some people have probably mentioned me, mentioned Amin Soleimani, I mentioned him on a handful of podcasts. But I wrote this longer tweet, which I think kind of solidifies what this picture means to me.
And so I say, this might look like a picture, but to me it's so much more. Amin has been a personal hero and mentor to me throughout my Ethereum journey. Without Amin, Ethereum would be all rainbows and unicorns, but no claws or teeth. Amin taught me the importance of thinking adversarially what's at stake and what's at stake if we do not think that way he was also my first big guest on my podcast before Bankless POV Crypto back when I was absolutely no one and I follow up and say I would not have the balls to sue the Department of Treasury without the knowledge and leadership that Amin has shown this industry so thank you Amin for the lousy t-shirt I appreciate that that's really cool David it's heroes in real life here here's a take from 0xdesigner onboarding the next billion users with words how the term wallet is psychologically limiting Web3's growth potential and the case for abandoning it killing the idea of wallet David rather than connect wallet, just connect I don't know if I totally agree with it but 0xdesigner bringing up some interesting points that maybe the thing we should be calling this thing, the mental model we should be using is more like an account because sure it's a wallet in some cases but usually when we're talking about finance, right?
Sometimes if you go to the social case, it's a profile or it's an identity. If you go on the art case, not really stuffing an art piece in your wallet, are you? It's more like adding it to your collection. If you're in the gaming world, this account is actually like inventory. If you're music, it's library. And so maybe we should start reframing this away from wallets and making it more generic, calling this connect, calling this an account instead. an interesting point, I think, at least. Yeah, I think that makes sense because we always talk about the future of the internet is like sign-in with Ethereum.
So like Facebook account, Spotify account, all of these things that there's a sign-in button. It's just an account. And the idea is that Web3 just replaces Web2. That makes sense to me. David, what are you bullish on this week, my friend? I got another picture. It's us. This is a picture of us at Permissionless. Do you know when? This was the night we had our party. right yeah yeah the bank was part of that permissionless also one year ago as of today no way that was a year ago as of today a year ago as of today wow the first time we met was at this conference and the only time i will add haven't seen you since it's been a year since i've seen you were that like when uh when we did that were you like oh i might not like this guy in real life like he's just like what if i don't know he smells bad what if the vibes are off And so, uh, there, so we, you came up to when we met for the first time at the Airbnb, uh, it was like five minutes until we had our company meeting.
And then we, uh, we opened up the door, gave you a hug. And then I was like, uh, now what? Now what? Do we continue the podcast? Yeah. Yeah. And I was like, Oh, thank God we had the meeting to like, kind of get the ball rolling. talk outside of this format outside of the screen format yeah that's funny i think the first meeting i think i'm first meeting too we had i had like the laptop in front of me too and i feel like i was like talking to you through the laptop as well where we also you were also like right next to me as well yeah you couldn't couldn't look away from the laptop uh so i guess i'm bullish on another year yeah i'll see you in september i'll see you in september man september permissionless but the other thing i'm bullish on slightly related uh is we're actually going to have this twitter space uh with uh the blockworks guys uh the other dads by the way for the bankless listeners out there for who don't know internally to bankless the employees call uh me and ryan dads and so the blockworks founders jason and mike are also called dads apparently uh and so we're having a dads and dads chat uh ahead of permissionless just uh company media company in web3 to media company and Web3.
That is a Twitter space that's happening on May 31st, I think. When is that? 12 p.m. Eastern time. And so if you want to see just two groups of founders talk about media companies and Web3, we are bringing questions for Jason and Mike and they are bringing questions for us. No way. I didn't know we were doing that. Yeah, we're doing that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So that's going to be a fun time. It's going to be an hour of just like banter and stuff like that. I like the block work team. Yeah. All right. Ryan, what do you blush on? So before I answer that question, let me just say this week felt really exhausting.
Like, I guess maybe emotionally draining. So Bankless HQ, our Twitter account, put out a tweet headline saying, Ethereum broke again, and then went through a thread. And the thread actually had some really good content. Like, I think it was largely accurate. The headline was off. The headline was a bit of hyperbole, I think. I think when our editors published it, they were thinking like, oh, yes, maybe it's satirical. Maybe it's just kind of capturing attention so people will read the rest of the thread. An innocent mistake in my mind, right? And this happened on a Friday afternoon. And I was kind of logged off.
I was enjoying Mother's Day. My parents were in town, that sort of thing. And David, when I logged back on on like Sunday, my God, it felt like the entire like we're used to getting attacked in all sorts of ways. But this was a little bit different because it felt like in tribe, a lot of, um, people we thought were like part of the, you know, the bankless community that we've contributed a lot to, we're just lighting us up and torching bankless for doing this. I'm saying that we've transformed into like click, clickbait media. And, uh, yeah, it just got really negative. And I've been through these negative things before, as I know you have, but I don't know why this one just hit me.
Maybe it was kind of like apathy market, board market kind of hit me at the wrong time, like last straw type of thing. I don't know what it was. Um, we tried to apologize, but when you're being like sort of mob attacked like this, um, you know, sometimes there's nothing you can do. There's nothing you can do anyway. So, so I posted this and I said, maybe it's the bird app talking, but I'm feeling sad right now. Um, I described this as a low point. Um, I was just feeling that way when I posted this. And this is a totally self-indulgent like Venter type of tweet. You're allowed. These are valid.
The takeaway was like, is that a valid use of Twitter? The takeaway for me was like, why I was sad was because a bear market needs to be time where the crypto community bands together and fights common enemies. Like we got them, Gary Gensler and crew, like we got all these common enemies. We build up, we support each other. So why are we so determined to eat our own? And I said, guys, I don't know how we can expect to solve this coordination thing if our friend enemy barometer stays maxed out to mercurial and unforgiving. This isn't about bankless. This is about all the good ones who've been burnt out by the negativity and pitchforking in crypto.
Anyway, I tweeted this, a total event tweet. And David, the reaction from, I think, the silent majority community of bankless listeners was just so powerful. Okay, so I know the reason you do this because it's the same reason I do this. Um, the way my kind of energy gets filled up is when I hear from the community, like when, when I know that we put out a piece of content that really helps someone learn something that means something to them, that kind of like educates them, that, that benefits the world. That's, that's why I do this, right? If it starts to feel like the content we put out is just not doing that, it's totally energy depleting.
Or if it starts to feel like that the content that we put out is like harming people or like causing negative value to people, that's when I'm just like, why am I doing this in the first place? Anyway, the reaction on the back of this was just stuff like this. This is a dartinian.eth. You guys changed my life. Thank you. Don't listen to the haters. You gents have been inspiring me since November 2020 to be bankless. I've been traveling the world for over a year because of y'all. The world needs you and your channel. You guys represent passion, honesty, intellect, and honor with the Web3 space.
You're the cornerstone to this foundation and we need y'all to know it. And then he posts this picture of himself. In Machu Picchu, wearing a bankless shirt. This is so awesome. Anyway, it's just like, I feel like even the segment is somewhat self-indulgent, but let me just say, as a content creator, this is the type of stuff that gets me excited about creating more content and doing more. This kind of stuff. It wasn't just this response. There's a ton of responses. My DMs, tweets, all sorts of things. I guess maybe more broadly, I want people to know if you're in crypto, you're probably engaging in social media.
It maximizes for toxicity sometimes. It maximizes for outrage. and they say this all the time, but like Twitter's not real life. Right. And, um, yeah. And I guess I just felt that this week and it's so easy to get caught in these, these bubbles of, of social media kind of silos where you lose sight of that. But, um, yeah, Twitter's not real life. So what am I bullish on? I'm bullish on the bankless community. I'm bullish that, um, people continue to listen, uh, to this episode. I think we're doing a, an okay job and, um, I, you know, Appreciate everyone who's tuned in to this point. I think this last line that he wrote, d'Artagnan.
eth, you've inspired me to be a builder and I humbly have been grinding in the background as a pioneer, like y'all, helping to create the foundation of our new digital economy. I think the main reason why I do this, Ryan, is that Ethereum, the idea of Ethereum, the idea of permissionless technology, sovereign individual technology, came to me in a time where I kind of needed it most in my life. I found Ethereum when I was in a dark spot and it allowed me to distract myself and then it allowed me to build a platform for myself and then it allowed me to see the world of self-actualization and agency.
And I think the subtext of Bankless has always been something like this. And when I see the silent majority of builders out there who listen to Bankless and follow us along on this journey, who have used Bankless to see in Ethereum, the thing that I saw and that we see in Ethereum as scaffolding for self-actualization in the world, this is like, oh yeah, I'll take the hate. That's why you're here. I'll take the hate every single day of the week. It's worth it. Yeah, it's worth it. 100%, 100%. That's cool. I think you said it even better than me. Guys, so we appreciate you. Thank you all Bankless listeners, even the silent ones.
We appreciate you guys. David, meme of the week. What are we looking at this week? So this is the I prefer the real blank meme for Nat. Meme for Nat. And it's the first one, Doge. And then the guy says, I prefer the real shit coin. And then it's Pepe. And then he goes, I prefer the real shit coin. And then it's the dollar. And then the guy goes, perfection. But I've manually added one more layer, which is the real actual shit coin is this $1 trillion coin. So if the dollar is a shit coin, the $1 trillion coin is a trillion times more shitty. that hasn't been minted yet but the moment it is yeah wait for it yeah wow all right christened disclaimers of course as weird as the internet is crypto is always weirder and it's more risky you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot